YouTube2Text

Contentment may be the most radical choice you can make | Jonny Thomson — Transcript

by Big Think Clips · 4,287 words · 248 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00You know, there are a whole range of different  disciplines within philosophy. There is logic,
  2. 0:03there is epistemology, there is political science,  there is aesthetics, the theory of beauty. But
  3. 0:09I've always thought that philosophy is at its  best when it's talking about people's real lives,
  4. 0:12about how to live well. There are philosophers  through a whole range of traditions across
  5. 0:17different countries, different time periods,  who do talk about the good life, but for me,
  6. 0:21the ancient Greeks embodied that. The ancient  Greeks made an entire deal of the good life.
  7. 0:27And it's there in stoicism and Aristotle and  Epicureanism and and cynicism. And so I think
  8. 0:31that philosophy should help us steer our lives.  My name is Jonny Thomson. I'm a writer. I'm a
  9. 0:37columnist at Big Think and I run the mini  philosophy social network where I explain
  10. 0:41philosophical ideas to millions of people.  [music] I'm the author of the upcoming book The
  11. 0:45Art of Enough where I explain Epicureanism and  teach everybody how it can apply to our lives.
  12. 0:52Thank you for watching Big Think. If you'd  like to support our work, we encourage you
  13. 0:55to join our members community. As a member,  you'll receive our quarterly print magazine,
  14. 1:00a beautifully designed collection of the  ideas and interviews that matter most.
  15. 1:04Big Think is for curious people who want to  take deep dives into big ideas. To support
  16. 1:08the media you want to see in the world, go to  bigthink.com/join. And now back to the interview.
  17. 1:17The four things you actually need to be happy.
  18. 1:21So I'm writing a book called The Art of Enough,  which is an exploration of Epicureanism. Now
  19. 1:26Epicureanism is an ancient Greek school which  is contemporaneous with stoicism. And stoicism
  20. 1:32has enjoyed the philosophical limelight for  a very long time. The likes of Ryan Holiday,
  21. 1:37Tim Ferriss, Massimo Pigliucci, they've all  explored stoicism and many people have enjoyed
  22. 1:43what they've had to say. And that's for good  reason because stoicism is a very sophisticated,
  23. 1:48deep and historical philosophy which has many  links to cognitive behavioral therapy and many
  24. 1:56effective psychological treatments and what  we call pro tips and self-help tips. Now I
  25. 2:02have written a book about Epicureanism because I  actually argued Epicureanism is the philosophy we
  26. 2:08need for our time. Now in my book I argue that  we need four things to make us happy. And these
  27. 2:16are four things that you find in Epicurus's works  and some of them overlap with Stoicism and some of
  28. 2:21them are different in a lot of key respects. The  first is introspection. We all need to know about
  29. 2:28ourselves. The Oracle of Delphi had an inscription  above the entrance which said know thyself because
  30. 2:34the ancient Greeks were well aware that if you  don't know about your motivations, if you don't
  31. 2:38know what matters to you, if you don't know what  you value, you cannot make good life decisions.
  32. 2:44And so the first section of my book is about how  we can introspect well. And the Epicureans would
  33. 2:49argue that we can do this in two ways. The first  way is what they called parrhusia which is honesty
  34. 2:56or frankness. So it involves sitting down with  a close friend. It involves sitting down with a
  35. 3:02diary or looking yourself in the mirror and giving  yourself the space and the time to meditate in
  36. 3:08the philosophical sense. You need to reflect on  yourself. What gives me pleasure? What is making
  37. 3:14me anxious? Keep a mood diary. As you're walking  about the day, what is it which is making you
  38. 3:20upset? What is causing what the Epicureans call  tarache, which is mental distress? Because you'll
  39. 3:26need that introspection to feed into the second  section of the book which is known as intention.
  40. 3:31The Epicureanism and Stoicism and all the ancient  Greek philosophies are intentional deliberative
  41. 3:36philosophies. You have to wire all of that  information about yourself into your rational,
  42. 3:42forward-thinking, life-crafting processes. And  Epicureanism is different to Stoicism in a key
  43. 3:50respect that Stoics and Plato and Socrates and  Aristotle often like to use the word logos. They
  44. 3:56talk about our rationality as our logos. And the  word logos has always had slightly metaphysical,
  45. 4:03possibly even supernatural connotations that  our logos is an otherworldly skill that allows
  46. 4:09humans to bridge two sides of the kind of like  metaphysical divide. Whereas the Epicureans never
  47. 4:14viewed rationality in that way. In fact, they use  a word called logismos instead, which is more like
  48. 4:20deliberation. And it's something you see also in  the animal kingdom. In the book I talk about the
  49. 4:26hermit crab, for example. The hermit crab is a  crab which will occupy a certain shell. And then
  50. 4:31at some point in its life, because it grows or  because there might be predators or because of
  51. 4:35other environmental conditions, it has to make  a decision. Should I stay or should I go? That's
  52. 4:40deliberation. That's logismos. And so I argue  in the book that humans are no different to
  53. 4:45hermit crabs. It's on a different scale. It's  possibly more sophisticated. We have more data
  54. 4:49to wire into the deliberative process, but  ultimately the same thing is going on. So
  55. 4:55once we've worked out the things that are giving  us pleasure, giving us joy, giving us happiness,
  56. 4:59and also worked out the things which are causing  us anxiety, causing us pain and distress,
  57. 5:04we then need to do what's called life crafting in  the psychological literature. And this is where we
  58. 5:10sit down and we decide where we want to be, what  we want to look like, and what we want our life to
  59. 5:15look like, and we work out how we can get to that  point. We have to be intentional about things. If
  60. 5:21something is making you anxious, if every time  you go onto your phone you're scrolling you're
  61. 5:24scrolling you're scrolling and you come  away feeling tense, your shoulders are up,
  62. 5:28your fists are clenched, your blood pressure is  up, you feel angry, why not get rid of the phone?
  63. 5:34Be intentional about it. Recognize that this thing  is causing you pain and get rid of the thing that
  64. 5:38caused you pain. Epicureanism is always a very  common sense philosophy in that respect. The
  65. 5:44third section of the book is about connection.  Epicureans are finally tuned to the idea that
  66. 5:49we all need to be around other people almost  all of the time. We need to love and we need
  67. 5:53to be loved. The Epicureans would live in these  things called ho kepos, which translates as the
  68. 5:59garden. They live in this garden community. And  they'll be surrounded by their friends all of the
  69. 6:03time for two reasons really. The first reason is  what we talked about in the introspection section,
  70. 6:09which is that having a good friend is important  to knowing thyself. Because when you sit down
  71. 6:14with a friend and you talk about issues in  a philosophical mature way, you will uncover
  72. 6:20parts of your being that you can't access purely  by introspecting on your own. And it's for this
  73. 6:25reason that talking therapies are so important  and so valuable. I firmly believe that everybody
  74. 6:31should do therapy, but I don't believe it needs  to happen in a therapist's chair. I think we need
  75. 6:36to find a good friend, a good relative, somebody  that we love, and somebody who loves us, and we
  76. 6:39need to have deep and important conversations to  understand who we are. That's the first reason.
  77. 6:45But the second reason is obvious. Our friends make  us happy. We enjoy being around our friends. We
  78. 6:50get pleasure from sitting around the pub table or  the bar table, going walking or playing netball or
  79. 6:55doing whatever with our friends. They give us that  sense of joy. But they also give us the deeper joy
  80. 7:00that comes with security. That an Epicurean would  define a friend quite differently to how Aristotle
  81. 7:06would define it in his famous distinction between  three different types of friends. Aristotle in
  82. 7:11his Nicomachean Ethics said there are ultimately  three different types of friendships. The first
  83. 7:14are friendships of pleasure who are fun. They're  like fireworks friends. They are good for a night
  84. 7:19out. They will go drinking with you. They've  always got a funny gag or an anecdote to share,
  85. 7:25and you probably call them up if you want to have  a good time. Those are the first types of friends.
  86. 7:29The second type of friend is what Aristotle calls  friends of convenience or useful friends. So there
  87. 7:34might be a gym buddy or somebody you carpool with.  They are colleagues you work with, and they are
  88. 7:40often friends because they occupy a certain time  and a certain space in your life. Now Aristotle
  89. 7:44says the third type of friendship, the best type  of friendship is what he calls good friends,
  90. 7:50and these are friends who want you to grow. They  want you to become the best version of yourself
  91. 7:55to satisfy what the Greeks called telos or your  your purpose. And so they are always encouraging
  92. 8:00you. They're always saying, go on mate, you  can get that job. They're always saying, go on,
  93. 8:03you could push a little bit harder on that set.  And they're always saying that you should not do
  94. 8:08that thing because it is wrong. They're saying  you should do that thing because it is right.
  95. 8:12Because the key thing about a good friend is  that they want you to be virtuous. They are
  96. 8:17always helping you to develop your key virtues.  Epicureans all that's all true. That's all great
  97. 8:22and we all need all three types of friends. But  what Epicurus is saying is that there is a fourth
  98. 8:28type of friend as well and arguably they are more  important than each of those. Epicurus says that a
  99. 8:33true and a good friend is one who will always be  there to pick you up and to take you in. Because
  100. 8:40life is hard. Life is full of blustery winds and  choppy seas. And you need to know that you have
  101. 8:46a port to which you can sail to when the winds  pick up. You need to know that you have a door
  102. 8:52to knock on in the long cold night and you need  to know that you have a friend who will take you
  103. 8:56in and say there's the bed, there's the fridge,  see you tomorrow. Because that's what friendship
  104. 9:00is for an Epicurean. And because Epicurus would  then say that if you know that, if you know you
  105. 9:05got the friend that you're back, you go about  your day-to-day life more confidently. It's an
  106. 9:09insurance policy. You can take that risk. You can  do that thing because you know that somebody will
  107. 9:14be there to help you. When I talk about this,  I often talk about it in reference to what's
  108. 9:19known as [ __ ] you money. [ __ ] you money is a  concept where when you can, as quickly as you can,
  109. 9:25you should always put away a bit of money so that  you can say to someone [ __ ] you. It might be a
  110. 9:30boss who is asking too much of you. It might  be a partner who is asking too much of you or
  111. 9:36it might be a situation where you want to escape,  but you always have that pot of [ __ ] you money.
  112. 9:41And what Epicurus is saying is that friends are  the ultimate form of [ __ ] you money. You can
  113. 9:45be bold, you can be brave, you can go about your  life courageously because you know you have that
  114. 9:50safety net. And the fourth and final section of my  book is commitment. So in the intentional section,
  115. 9:58Epicureans and the Stoics well would say that, you  know, every life has its own flavor. Every life is
  116. 10:03a little bit different. What you find happy and  what you find gives you pleasure and what gives
  117. 10:09you anxiety will be different to me, but what  they also say is there are certain set rules
  118. 10:13that apply to most, if not all, human beings.  Epicureans say that we can get maximal happiness,
  119. 10:19maximal pleasure in life and minimal pain,  minimal anxiety in life by committing to
  120. 10:24things. They will say that you need to read fewer  books, but read them again, uh watch fewer movies,
  121. 10:30but watch them better, have fewer friends,  but see them more often, say fewer things,
  122. 10:36but choose your words more carefully. And they  say this because they make a distinction between
  123. 10:41two different types of pleasure. They talk about  kinetic pleasure, which is I broadly map it onto
  124. 10:48dopamine and that kind of feel-good high of yeah a  night out watching a firework display, skiing down
  125. 10:52a mountain or um having sex, eating nice food,  all of those kind of things are kinetic pleasures.
  126. 10:58But there's also what they call katastematic  pleasures, which are settled pleasures. And I
  127. 11:03often describe it with the fireworks analogy. I  say that if you're going to a fireworks display,
  128. 11:08you see all of the reds and the blues and wow,  amazing. And that's a kinetic pleasure. You get
  129. 11:13that wave of happiness as you're in that fireworks  display. And that is great. But then the fireworks
  130. 11:20will stop and then all of the crowds will go  back to their cars and all of the smoke from
  131. 11:25the fireworks will go away. What you're left with  then is the night starry sky. And the Epicurean
  132. 11:31is saying that the greatest pleasure in life is  not the fireworks. It comes when you look up at
  133. 11:36the stars and you take a deep breath and you enjoy  that moment. So you need to commit to now. So the
  134. 11:42final section of the Epicurean book is about  commitment. So recognizing that what you have
  135. 11:46in your small patch of land, your small group of  friends, the hobbies, the passions, the interests
  136. 11:52that you have are enough for you. And that's why  the book is called The Art of Enough. I've always
  137. 11:58had a a a long inclination that philosophy is best  when it's useful. Philosophy is at its best when
  138. 12:05it's a form of introspection, a form of therapy.  You know, there are a whole range of different
  139. 12:10disciplines within philosophy. There is logic,  there is epistemology, there is political science,
  140. 12:15there is aesthetics, the theory of beauty. But  I've always thought that philosophy is at its best
  141. 12:19when it's talking about people's real lives, about  how to live well, how to live good lives. And you
  142. 12:24know, there are philosophers through a whole  range of traditions across different countries,
  143. 12:28different time periods, who do talk about the good  life. But for me, you know, the ancient Greeks
  144. 12:33embodied that. The ancient Greeks made an entire  deal of the good life. And it's there in stoicism
  145. 12:39and Aristotle and epicureanism and and cynicism,  whatever. And so I think that philosophy should
  146. 12:45help us steer our lives. So I've always been  slightly inclined to that. Now running parallel
  147. 12:51to that is a is is a slight narrative within  certain philosophical wings where happiness is
  148. 12:58viewed either as a nonsense term, that happiness  doesn't even exist, that happiness is something
  149. 13:03maybe fleeting and accidental that you recognize  in hindsight and let's not talk about it. Or
  150. 13:09which is I associate that with nihilism, that  that happiness isn't a thing anyway. But also
  151. 13:14there's there's a pessimistic strain, which is  that life is suffering. Life is going to always
  152. 13:18be miserable, that happiness is not a thing in  itself. Now I disagree with both of those. I
  153. 13:24think that most people watching this, most people  hearing me now, have experienced happiness. They
  154. 13:30know what happiness means. It's a real thing. It's  a real feeling. It's a real what psychologists
  155. 13:34call affect. But also I believe that we can all  align our lives and position our mindset in such
  156. 13:42a way that we can experience and enjoy more  happiness. Now if those things are both true,
  157. 13:48the next question to my mind becomes how? How can  I align my life and how can I change my mind to
  158. 13:53experience more happiness? And so then I went  into the literature. I found out who was saying
  159. 13:58what about happiness. And in fact I got a video  on Big Think where I lay out what I think as the
  160. 14:03three pillars of happiness across all of these  various different philosophies. And as I was
  161. 14:08researching for that, you know, I was deep into  my stoicism and I was looking for a philosophy.
  162. 14:13I was looking for somebody just to come along  and say to me, happiness needs to feel good. I
  163. 14:19needed somebody to say to me that happiness  is when you are not worrying about your job,
  164. 14:24your health, your loved ones, whatever. It's just  feeling contented in who you are and where you
  165. 14:28are. And I just really couldn't find that easily  until I found Epicureanism. Epicureanism starts
  166. 14:35on the basic principle that there is only one  good and one bad. The only good is pleasure or
  167. 14:40happiness or joy, and the only bad is anxiety,  pain, suffering. And I just think that's so
  168. 14:47brilliantly clear. It's so brilliantly basic that  yes, it gets more complicated from there. It gets
  169. 14:53more complicated in what gives us happiness,  what gives us pleasure, what gives us joy,
  170. 14:56what gives us anxiety and pain. But by and large,  I just love this notion that we are essentially
  171. 15:03steered by these two strings, you know, the pull  of pleasure and the push of pain, the carrot and
  172. 15:07the stick. And so I dug into Epicureanism and I  found it to be a incredibly rich and incredibly
  173. 15:15deep and profound philosophy that has been much  maligned by history. The Stoics maligned it first
  174. 15:22because there was always an ancient rivalry, and  I don't begrudge the Stoics for this. You know,
  175. 15:26we'd all do it. If there's a rival school who  are trying to attract students, you would try
  176. 15:30to slander the opposition because you want to  get those students. You want your philosophy to
  177. 15:34look the best. So they were always maligned by by  the Stoics because they differ on a a few fairly
  178. 15:41niche and parochial philosophical differences,  I I would say. But then they were maligned by
  179. 15:45the Christians after that because Epicureanism  is a godless philosophy. They weren't atheists,
  180. 15:50and they did believe there were gods, but by and  large they were irrelevant to our human lives. And
  181. 15:54they say that we can be happy by our own efforts,  that human rationality, human intelligence, human
  182. 16:02philosophy and friends and the material world is  enough to give us happiness. And of course, that
  183. 16:09didn't work with the Christian idea of grace, the  idea of beatitude, that you can only find joy and
  184. 16:16happiness and completion in the idea of God. And  so the Epicureans were forever slandered by the
  185. 16:22Christians because they were a godless philosophy,  but then you see pockets of them emerge throughout
  186. 16:27history. You see it popped up again in Erasmus  and you see it in Thomas Jefferson. And obviously
  187. 16:33I'm trying to bring it back to the masses today  because I I feel as though it's been maligned
  188. 16:37for too long and that we need to go back to our  roots, our evolutionary roots, our basic roots
  189. 16:43and actually try to position our lives in such a  way that we can enjoy it more. In the middle of
  190. 16:50last year I was interviewed by a lovely man on the  west coast of America and we were having a good
  191. 16:56chat about philosophy. We were talking about this  and that and Kant, Descartes, Plato, whatever and
  192. 17:01stuff. And then we got to the question of meaning.  And he started to ask about the meaning crisis and
  193. 17:09he started to ask me what gave me meaning in my  life. And it became clear as the conversation
  194. 17:16was evolving that this lovely man was trying  to convert me. It became clear then no matter
  195. 17:21what answers I gave well I get meaning from being  around my friends. Ah, but they'll die, you know,
  196. 17:28and they might leave you. So they really give  you meaning? Okay. Uh, I get meaning from being
  197. 17:32around my kids, you know, when I'm playing with my  children I I'm I get great meaning. He said well,
  198. 17:36you know, is that really enough? And so it became  clear to me that he was angling for a particular
  199. 17:42answer and the only answer was one which involved  God or a deity or some kind of afterlife that for
  200. 17:51this particular person meaning could only  be satisfied by um religion. And of course
  201. 17:58if you are trying to sell or trying to argue  for a godless philosophy such as Epicureanism,
  202. 18:04you're never going to satisfy that criteria.  So the question I I often have is what do you
  203. 18:09mean by meaning? Or in modern corporate speak,  what is your success criteria? What can I say
  204. 18:15to you to satisfy the question what gives you  meaning? Obviously my friends aren't enough,
  205. 18:20obviously my family aren't What is it that I can  say which will stop you asking the question? And
  206. 18:25actually, I think that this is a deeper problem  with the word meaning. And this isn't new to me,
  207. 18:31I should say. A guy called Thomas Nagel wrote  about this in his book Mortal Questions,
  208. 18:35where he talks about absurdity. Absurdism is a  philosophy associated with Albert Camus, where he
  209. 18:40says that humans are a meaning-seeking creature in  a meaningless world. That we're constantly asking
  210. 18:46answers of the universe, but there are no answers  to be had. It's a cold and indifferent universe
  211. 18:53replying to our questions. And Nagel in that  paper asks the important question, I think. He
  212. 18:59says where well, what would give you meaning? Like  let's say for example that I told you that we are
  213. 19:03actually being bred by Martians um who want to eat  us when we die. Does that suddenly give your life
  214. 19:10more meaning? What if I said that I could give you  immortality? You could live forever. Would you now
  215. 19:14suddenly have more meaning? The meaning question  is an unsolvable question. And so what I say in
  216. 19:19the book and what I do actually think is true that  we are suffering from something that people call
  217. 19:25the meaning crisis, but actually I would argue, as  a man called Daniel Cox who argues it and and the
  218. 19:29man called Richard Reeves talks about it on Big  Think, that rather than a meaning crisis, I think
  219. 19:34we do experience a connection crisis. That we do  lack meaningful relationships with our neighbors,
  220. 19:42our village, our community, our humanity even. We  are lacking that meaningful connection because of
  221. 19:51a whole host of things. And it goes back to the  whole like you know your life should be occupied
  222. 19:55in this in the in a house and then of course the  internet and then COVID. I do think we are lacking
  223. 20:00a connection crisis and that's importantly  different because it's an empirical question
  224. 20:05then. Meaning is so vague. It's an unfalsifiable  hypothesis. You lack meaning. Whereas a connection
  225. 20:10crisis, okay, who are your connections? Where  can you find connections? How can you make more
  226. 20:16connections? The question becomes empirical and  then I think it becomes solvable. I I we can do
  227. 20:21more things. We can spend more time around  fewer friends. I think we can, as a society,
  228. 20:26invest more in these third spaces. We can  appreciate um community a lot more. Because in
  229. 20:33my experience and from what a lot of the evidence  seems to suggest, for Jonathan Haidt, for example,
  230. 20:37in his book uh the Happiness Hypothesis, says  that, you know, happiness comes down to three
  231. 20:41connections. Connection with yourself, connection  with each other, and connection with the wider
  232. 20:45world. So I think there is empirical proof to what  I'm saying here, but in my experience, whenever
  233. 20:51I'm around my friends, my closest friends at  their house, dinner party, or in a pub, or we're
  234. 20:56going for a run, or we we I like to I like to go  cycling, we're cycling together, at no point do I
  235. 21:01think, what's the meaning of this? At no point do  I think, oh, you know, this is so insufficient for
  236. 21:06me. This is so inadequate. I wish there were more.  And likewise, my young children love miniature
  237. 21:12steam trains. And in Oxford, in Cutteslowe Park  in Oxford, every second Sunday they um have a
  238. 21:18miniature train, a miniature steam train, a puff  puff puff steam train. And I'm sitting on the back
  239. 21:22and my eldest is there, my youngest is in front,  and we're going around this miniature steam train,
  240. 21:27and at no point do I think, oh, what meaningless  rubbish this is. I am supremely happy. I'm
  241. 21:33supremely contented in who I am because I'm  connected to my family. I'm connected to my
  242. 21:38friends. And so I think the meaning crisis  question is an unfalsifiable one. Now,
  243. 21:43of course, if somebody says to me that meaning  can be satisfied if you do XYZ, then fine, do
  244. 21:47that. But in my experience, if somebody's angling  about meaning, they aren't asking that question.
  245. 22:01Four times a year we print a magazine worth  putting your phone down for. Big Things
  246. 22:05Premium Print Magazine is built with custom  artwork and expert insight from the world's
  247. 22:09biggest thinkers. No AI slap, no rage bait,  just big ideas for curious people. Support
  248. 22:15the media you want to see in the world. Go to  bigthink.com/join to become a member today.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Contentment may be the most radical choice you can make | Jonny Thomson by Big Think Clips, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,287 words across 248 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.