YouTube2Text

Como ENCONTRAR o seu PROPÓSITO DE VIDA? - com Mario Sergio Cortella #112 — Transcript

by Como Você Fez Isso? · 11,885 words · 1,896 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00How to find our purpose.
  2. 0:02The idea of purpose is always striking.
  3. 0:05The word purpose itself means that
  4. 0:07which I place ahead of myself, in order
  5. 0:09to pursue it. Exactly what makes me do
  6. 0:12what I do. And when you say, how?
  7. 0:15That's the key question for things to
  8. 0:18happen. But so that they don't happen
  9. 0:20in a distracted, alienated way, as I
  10. 0:23mentioned, robotically, the "how" needs
  11. 0:26to be preceded by the "why." Purpose is
  12. 0:28not a gift reserved for a few, it's a
  13. 0:30daily construction. He dedicated his
  14. 0:32life to translating philosophy,
  15. 0:34education, and ethics into people's
  16. 0:35daily lives, helping millions to think
  17. 0:37better about who they are and where
  18. 0:39they are going. In this conversation,
  19. 0:41he reveals how to find purpose amidst
  20. 0:42the pressures of the modern world,
  21. 0:44without ready-made formulas, but with
  22. 0:45lucidity and depth. Today's guest is
  23. 0:47Mário Sérgio Cortella.
  24. 0:49Someone might say: "I'm lost, I don't
  25. 0:51know what to do, etc." I say the
  26. 0:53following: "Become necessary to someone
  27. 0:55." If you and I find ourselves lost, we
  28. 0:58must find one another by being
  29. 1:00necessary to someone else. To those who
  30. 1:03do not know where they are heading, any
  31. 1:04path will suffice, right? Now, if I
  32. 1:06understand that I need to become
  33. 1:09necessary to other people, then I begin
  34. 1:12to find my own path. Everyone, would
  35. 1:15you like the possibility of following
  36. 1:19an episode of 'How Did You Do That?'
  37. 1:22here in our studios? You have noticed
  38. 1:24that for a few episodes now we have
  39. 1:26been receiving an audience here in our
  40. 1:28studios, and it is a very cool
  41. 1:30experience. We keep receiving many
  42. 1:31messages from you wanting to
  43. 1:33participate. How do I manage to be
  44. 1:34there? Well, it works like this: if you
  45. 1:37fill out this form, the team is
  46. 1:39constantly selecting some individuals,
  47. 1:41because there are thousands of people.
  48. 1:43It is not possible for us to know
  49. 1:44everyone; we would love to do so, but
  50. 1:46it is impossible because the 'How Did
  51. 1:48You Do That?' community is gigantic and
  52. 1:51we are very happy about that, but you
  53. 1:51might have a chance. community is
  54. 1:51gigantic, and we're very happy about
  55. 1:51that, but you can have a chance. So, if
  56. 1:54you want that chance, click on the form
  57. 1:56and fill it out completely. "The
  58. 1:58information helps the team get to know
  59. 2:00you better, sometimes selecting which
  60. 2:02episode best suits you, if you're
  61. 2:04selected. And obviously, fingers
  62. 2:05crossed, and I hope that one day you'll
  63. 2:07be here, but I really hope so that we
  64. 2:09can always stay connected here. So,
  65. 2:10message delivered, click on the link
  66. 2:12below, fill out the form, and now let's
  67. 2:14get back to our episode. Hey everyone,
  68. 2:18welcome to another special podcast. How
  69. 2:22did you do this episode? I'm very happy
  70. 2:24because I'm hosting someone I admire
  71. 2:26very much. It had been a long time
  72. 2:28since I'd met him in person, the first
  73. 2:29time I had the opportunity to interview
  74. 2:30him. It was wonderful. So, as you saw
  75. 2:33in our opening, I'm hosting him, Mário
  76. 2:35Sérgio Cortella. Applause for our
  77. 2:37professor Mário Sérgio Cortella.
  78. 2:40Professor, I'm very happy. That's
  79. 2:41great. I'm happy. One of the good
  80. 2:43things is that people are happy when
  81. 2:45they're with us.
  82. 2:47One of the good things is being happy
  83. 2:49with the people we're with. So, if we
  84. 2:51combine both sides, then it can only be
  85. 2:54happiness.
  86. 2:55And It might seem a little redundant,
  87. 3:00right? But I always bring up how you
  88. 3:02did it. It starts with a" how, "
  89. 3:05right? We did some research, and the
  90. 3:06most searched word on YouTube today is"
  91. 3:08how, "right? People are looking for a
  92. 3:11purpose, a direction.
  93. 3:14And bringing you here, professor,
  94. 3:17there's no way not to bring up how to
  95. 3:20find our purpose, right? Especially
  96. 3:22this generation that's coming, they're
  97. 3:24questioning many things, right? They're
  98. 3:26searching a lot, but I think it's part
  99. 3:28of humanity to ask ourselves, right?
  100. 3:30What do I want, who am I here for,
  101. 3:32where am I going, what makes me happy,
  102. 3:34what is happiness? I think it's so
  103. 3:36important that we bring up these points
  104. 3:38from time to time, because it's not
  105. 3:40very automatic for us to stop and think
  106. 3:42about these things.
  107. 3:44I have a book that is titled Why We Do
  108. 3:45What We Do.
  109. 3:46Hmm. And this book deals exactly with
  110. 3:48that. That is, with some of the
  111. 3:50afflictions we have to have in our
  112. 3:52daily lives. And the word is affliction
  113. 3:54itself. It's what makes you...Move,
  114. 3:56bother. A person who has no idea what
  115. 3:59the purpose of what they do is and why
  116. 4:02they do it, has a robotic, automatic,
  117. 4:04alienated life, therefore, they run the
  118. 4:07risk of having a disposable life, right
  119. 4:09? In that sense, the idea of" how "has
  120. 4:12to be preceded by" why, "right? After
  121. 4:15all, the idea of" how "is linked to the
  122. 4:18world of technique, of practice.
  123. 4:21Science deals with the" hows. "Uh-huh.
  124. 4:23Right? Philosophy, which is my area,
  125. 4:24deals with the" whys. "Philosophy is
  126. 4:26not a practical area, right? When, for
  127. 4:29example, after finishing a conversation
  128. 4:30with you," how are we going to do this?
  129. 4:32", you won't be able to move a power
  130. 4:34plant, create a more structured
  131. 4:36business, put a product into action,
  132. 4:38because that's not the field.
  133. 4:40Philosophy is an abstract area whose
  134. 4:42central direction is thinking about the
  135. 4:44" whys, "right? And one of the good
  136. 4:46things is that when you talk about" how
  137. 4:49"and you used the English expression"
  138. 4:51no how, "
  139. 4:52we also add to philosophy, in addition
  140. 4:54to" no how, "which is exactly the idea
  141. 4:56of" how to do it, "another...The notion
  142. 4:58, which is in French,
  143. 5:00is the same word, just expressed
  144. 5:02differently in the language, which is"
  145. 5:04savo fé, "right? Savoir-faire in
  146. 5:06French means know-how, and in English
  147. 5:08it means to know how; both have the
  148. 5:10same meaning. But" savier "has greater
  149. 5:13flexibility than" savier, "something
  150. 5:16more closed off. A person who intends
  151. 5:19to act, to do, to build, to construct,
  152. 5:21to undertake, must add the notion of"
  153. 5:24nohal, "that is, technique as that
  154. 5:27which is efficient, which accomplishes,
  155. 5:30but also" savo fé, "understood there,
  156. 5:33right, as a certain flexibility.
  157. 5:35Therefore, I return to the point, the
  158. 5:38idea of purpose, it is always
  159. 5:40significant. The word itself, purpose,
  160. 5:43means that which I put forward, right,
  161. 5:45to seek
  162. 5:46that which I put forward."
  163. 5:47Adiante pró "in our language has,
  164. 5:51right, a preposition." Pró "means I
  165. 5:54put before,
  166. 5:56right? Therefore," proposition, "in the
  167. 5:58case of purpose, is that which I put
  168. 6:00forward. And in that sense, that's
  169. 6:02exactly what makes me...Doing what I do
  170. 6:04. And I really like to remember one of
  171. 6:07the authors, I've been quoting him, I
  172. 6:10even put it in a more recent book, one
  173. 6:12of the authors I've read the most in my
  174. 6:15life was Mark Twen, a great 19
  175. 6:17th-century American writer, a reference
  176. 6:19in world literature and in the United
  177. 6:22States,
  178. 6:22right? I read one of the most decisive
  179. 6:25works for my mind when I was 12 years
  180. 6:27old, called The Adventures of Tom Soyer
  181. 6:29and Huckleberry, The End, both of them
  182. 6:32were remarkable things. Well, although
  183. 6:35Mark Twen was born on November 30, 1835
  184. 6:40, therefore already approaching 200
  185. 6:44years ago, 190 if we take the year 2025
  186. 6:48, he
  187. 6:49also had a concern with this issue and
  188. 6:51he has an expression that I use
  189. 6:53frequently and I'll bring it up here.
  190. 6:55He said:" Two are the most important
  191. 6:57days in your life. The day you were
  192. 7:00born and the day you discovered why. ""
  193. 7:02Ah,
  194. 7:03okay. The day you were born doesn't
  195. 7:05depend on you. The day you discover why
  196. 7:09depends on you. Of course, he uses a
  197. 7:12term, which I don't particularly
  198. 7:13appreciate, but I understand the
  199. 7:15English-to-Portuguese version of '
  200. 7:17discover,' because 'discover' implies
  201. 7:19that something was already there. You
  202. 7:21went there and just removed the surface
  203. 7:23, you discovered it. No, you create,
  204. 7:25you invent, you work. I wasn't born
  205. 7:27ready, right? In that sense, there's a
  206. 7:30whole path. And when you say, 'how?'
  207. 7:33That's the key question for things to
  208. 7:36happen.
  209. 7:36But for them not to happen in a
  210. 7:39distracted, alienated way, as I
  211. 7:41mentioned, robotically, the 'how' needs
  212. 7:44to be preceded by the 'why.'
  213. 7:47And then we think, and many people have
  214. 7:49a lot of challenges with this, right?
  215. 7:51Why do you think that purpose, for many
  216. 7:53people, is a challenge to find, to
  217. 7:55define, because you think that
  218. 7:57autopilot, this lack of questioning,
  219. 7:59this lack of stopping and questioning
  220. 8:02the 'why,' not just focusing on the '
  221. 8:04hows,' you see that this
  222. 8:06is a comfort, it falls, a... "It's more
  223. 8:08convenient to just follow a pre-written
  224. 8:11script, right? Obviously, it's a choice
  225. 8:14, isn't it? There's a great young
  226. 8:16French Renaissance philosopher. He died
  227. 8:18very young, and at 18 years old, he
  228. 8:21wrote a book with the best title I know
  229. 8:23to typify some of the times we live in,
  230. 8:26including embracing an algorithmic life
  231. 8:29, right, where you end up being driven
  232. 8:31by something you have no understanding
  233. 8:34or control over, you and anyone else,
  234. 8:36including me, right? In that sense, his
  235. 8:39name is Étienne de Boici,
  236. 8:41and the title of the book, look how
  237. 8:43great, uh, is a discourse on voluntary
  238. 8:46servitude.
  239. 8:47Wow!
  240. 8:48Voluntary servitude, because there is a
  241. 8:50servitude that you cannot escape
  242. 8:53because you are subjected to it.
  243. 8:56Someone imprisons you, commands you,
  244. 8:58orders you, threatens you, and you
  245. 9:00either lose your life or, to stay alive
  246. 9:03, you need to be obedient. But there is
  247. 9:06a voluntary servitude, one of them,
  248. 9:08which is exactly the voluntary one, is
  249. 9:11when you or I choose to follow
  250. 9:13something that doesn't give me
  251. 9:14responsibility and, therefore, doesn't
  252. 9:17Give me suffering or guilt too. One of
  253. 9:20the most enjoyable things is when you
  254. 9:22don't have to decide at certain times,
  255. 9:24right? I say," Cai, let's have lunch
  256. 9:26today after the recording. "Or," Okay,
  257. 9:28where do you want to go? "Then I say,"
  258. 9:31It's up to you. "That" it's up to you "
  259. 9:35gives me immense relief when I say,"
  260. 9:37Because the choice is yours, and if the
  261. 9:39choice is yours, if there's any kind of
  262. 9:42turbulence, the responsibility is also
  263. 9:44yours. "
  264. 9:44Uh-huh. In that sense, some people have
  265. 9:47difficulty thinking about purpose
  266. 9:49because they imagine, on a large scale,
  267. 9:51that thinking about purpose means
  268. 9:53having to seek it.
  269. 9:55Uh-huh.
  270. 9:55And if you have to seek it and you
  271. 9:57can't, right, there's some
  272. 9:58responsibility in that. At that moment,
  273. 10:01in some circumstances, for many people
  274. 10:04it's easier to have voluntary servitude
  275. 10:07, including because if they don't
  276. 10:09succeed, they might say," See? Look,
  277. 10:12look. Nobody helps me, nobody does
  278. 10:15anything, nobody provokes anything,
  279. 10:17right? "That classic dangerous phrase,"
  280. 10:19Oh, how awful, someone has to do
  281. 10:21something,
  282. 10:23right? "So, this idea suggests a bit of
  283. 10:26comfort on one hand, and on the other
  284. 10:30hand, some difficulty in remaining
  285. 10:33silent, right? You know that it's only
  286. 10:36possible to think about purpose if
  287. 10:38you're also able to remain silent,
  288. 10:40because reflection on purpose is
  289. 10:42internal; it's not offered to you by
  290. 10:44someone.
  291. 10:44Uh-huh.
  292. 10:45Because if someone offers me a reason
  293. 10:47to do something, it's not a purpose,
  294. 10:49it's an order,
  295. 10:50right? It's a command. If you tell me
  296. 10:53now," Take this glass of water and pour
  297. 10:55it over there, "that's not a purpose.
  298. 10:57Purpose is something I have when I sit
  299. 10:59here, where one of the things I want to
  300. 11:02do is what I will do. But if I were my
  301. 11:04purpose, it would be to spill water on
  302. 11:06things, right? Now, a command, an order
  303. 11:09, an instruction is different from
  304. 11:11purpose. Purpose is something from the
  305. 11:13inside out. You choose it, right? When
  306. 11:15someone asks what your purpose is,
  307. 11:17right? A person who gave me an order
  308. 11:19doesn't ask what my purpose is. She'll
  309. 11:21say:" Your purpose is...
  310. 11:23and that's not purpose, right? Order,
  311. 11:25it's command, it's instruction, right?
  312. 11:27As I said before. In that sense, some
  313. 11:30people prefer a little more comfort,
  314. 11:34right? And in that sense, the
  315. 11:36willingness to serve someone else's
  316. 11:39purpose, right? It's always calmer,
  317. 11:42more peaceful. And silence is what
  318. 11:45leads us to reflect, right? It's no
  319. 11:48coincidence that the symbol of
  320. 11:50philosophy in classical Greek antiquity
  321. 11:52was the owl, because the owl is a
  322. 11:54nocturnal animal, it has a notion of
  323. 11:56being more silent. The owl's hoot isn't
  324. 11:59a loud noise, right? It has wide eyes
  325. 12:02and therefore seems to be thinking more
  326. 12:05than speaking. In that sense, it's a
  327. 12:08good capacity, right, that we bring.
  328. 12:11And when we bring these two words,
  329. 12:13purpose and success, the correlation,
  330. 12:16because you can have success without
  331. 12:19following your purpose, purpose is the
  332. 12:22path to success. The correlation of
  333. 12:24these two things.
  334. 12:25Uh, in current times, I suffer today
  335. 12:27from something that probably also
  336. 12:29victimizes you, because I am someone
  337. 12:31better known for... "Because of social
  338. 12:33media, of the activities, right? I get
  339. 12:35imitated a lot.
  340. 12:36It's true.
  341. 12:37There are two types of imitations of me
  342. 12:38. One is humorous, funny. I love it,
  343. 12:41because my way of speaking, my vocal
  344. 12:43fingerprint, it's very distinctive. I
  345. 12:46created a way of pronouncing words, of
  346. 12:49enunciating speech, that ends up being
  347. 12:52imitated. There are even imitators of
  348. 12:54me on television programs, and one of
  349. 12:56the nice things is that it's a tribute.
  350. 12:58It's true.
  351. 12:58But there's a type of imitation that
  352. 13:00isn't imitation, it's falsification.
  353. 13:02And today, with the use of artificial
  354. 13:05intelligence, every day I come across
  355. 13:08profiles that simulate my voice,
  356. 13:10simulate my image, and make me speak
  357. 13:12content that isn't mine.
  358. 13:15Hmm.
  359. 13:15In the beginning, the image is mine,
  360. 13:17then there's a synchronization with
  361. 13:19what I'm saying—before there wasn't
  362. 13:22that possibility, now there is. I'm
  363. 13:24here speaking because it's very good to
  364. 13:26be here in this conversation—but the
  365. 13:29intelligence makes me say something
  366. 13:31else with content that isn't mine. Well
  367. 13:33, what is the...My refusal? It's fake.
  368. 13:36Uh-huh. Second, it's authentic. Third,
  369. 13:39it doesn't bring me success. Even if it
  370. 13:41were successful and well-liked, because
  371. 13:44it's not mine, it's
  372. 13:45not authentic.
  373. 13:46Yes. Every
  374. 13:46now and then I meet people, because
  375. 13:48some of these fake profiles make me
  376. 13:51talk about religion. I even understand
  377. 13:53this area because I worked, you know,
  378. 13:55for 30 years in the field of religious
  379. 13:57studies, but it speaks to me, makes me
  380. 13:59speak religious messages. I could do it
  381. 14:01, but I'm not the one who does it.
  382. 14:03Uh-huh. And every now and then I meet
  383. 14:05people on the street walking or in the
  384. 14:07mall or at the movies or on the
  385. 14:08sidewalk. And so, look, my family prays
  386. 14:10with you every day early in the morning
  387. 14:13in that daily speech of yours, which is
  388. 14:15one that we go to the profile, take
  389. 14:17down, another one appears and so on.
  390. 14:21What can I say? Thank you. I would be
  391. 14:26thanking someone for a compliment that
  392. 14:27I don't deserve, because it doesn't
  393. 14:29belong to me. I tell the person:"
  394. 14:31Nonsense, it's not me. "" That's a
  395. 14:33pointless insult.
  396. 14:35Uh-huh.
  397. 14:35I can't lie, but I also shouldn't put
  398. 14:37the person in an uncomfortable position
  399. 14:40. And the phrase I use is: 'Have you
  400. 14:42thought about that?' "" Right? Because
  401. 14:44that's an open, generic phrase. I'm not
  402. 14:48saying yes or no, but my irritation
  403. 14:51comes from the fact that someone
  404. 14:53attributes merit to me that I don't
  405. 14:56have.
  406. 14:57Why do I see this as a path? Because
  407. 15:00success is only true if it's
  408. 15:02meritorious, that is, if I have merit
  409. 15:05in achieving it. Otherwise, it was just
  410. 15:08discarding other people. It was just
  411. 15:10leaving aside those who should have
  412. 15:12gone along. My life motto in my office
  413. 15:15with my group is: we don't do just any
  414. 15:18business.
  415. 15:19Wow!
  416. 15:19Right? We don't do just any business.
  417. 15:21Then I go back to another point.
  418. 15:23There's a career success, a material
  419. 15:25success, a patrimonial success. There's
  420. 15:28a vital success. That is, what do I
  421. 15:32desire? What is my main purpose? I've
  422. 15:35been saying this frequently and I'll
  423. 15:36reiterate it here. Why do I do what I
  424. 15:39do? What I do, I do so that I have
  425. 15:42success and achievement. And what is
  426. 15:44success for me? What is my measure of
  427. 15:47success? I won't have a chance to find
  428. 15:49my measure of success through a... "The
  429. 15:52reason is that my measure of success is
  430. 15:54that on the day I'm gone, nobody will
  431. 15:56say" good riddance. "How can I avoid
  432. 16:00hearing that? Because I won't be there,
  433. 16:02but just imagining that I need to make
  434. 16:05an effort so that on the day I leave,
  435. 16:07nobody will say" good riddance. "In
  436. 16:09that sense, that's the metric of
  437. 16:12success for me. If, along the way, I
  438. 16:15accumulate assets, have entrepreneurial
  439. 16:18structure, have the capacity for
  440. 16:21presence, and all of that doesn't
  441. 16:23prevent someone from saying" what a
  442. 16:26pity "instead of" good riddance, "then
  443. 16:29yes, I've succeeded. In that sense, if
  444. 16:33you ask me, how do I say it? By doing
  445. 16:36what is meritorious, honorable, and
  446. 16:39therefore, decent in that sense. That's
  447. 16:42the main purpose.
  448. 16:44There are many people who don't like to
  449. 16:45talk about death, right? To think about
  450. 16:47death, for me it's not a threat, it's a
  451. 16:50warning,
  452. 16:50as it's a fact, okay? It's a concrete
  453. 16:53thing, right? As a great thinker,
  454. 16:56Terezinha Ron, who is also a
  455. 16:58philosopher, says:" Dying is not the
  456. 17:00opposite of living, dying is the
  457. 17:02opposite of being born, right? "" To
  458. 17:05live, life has no opposite, "she always
  459. 17:07says, right?
  460. 17:08That's very good. To die as opposed to
  461. 17:10being born. As we are evidently marked
  462. 17:12by mortality, and I will say:" Thank
  463. 17:15goodness, because if we mortals weren't
  464. 17:18, we would leave behind much of what we
  465. 17:21have to do, right? In fact, it would be
  466. 17:23almost unbearable. You weren't born yet
  467. 17:26, right? But Borman made a film a long
  468. 17:28time ago called Zardos with Shang
  469. 17:30Connery, which is a science fiction
  470. 17:33film,
  471. 17:33okay?
  472. 17:34It's a dystopia, right? A negative
  473. 17:36utopia in which a group of humans,
  474. 17:39using a crystal—this film from the
  475. 17:421960 s—manage to achieve immortality.
  476. 17:46And after 500 years, that group can no
  477. 17:49longer bear immortality. And for that,
  478. 17:52they want someone to break the crystal,
  479. 17:55but because of the organization they
  480. 17:57created, none of them could do it
  481. 17:59because there was a prohibition. The
  482. 18:01crystal wouldn't break if it were one
  483. 18:02of them. And it is necessary that
  484. 18:05mortals who live outside of there be
  485. 18:07called to do it. "I'll give a huge
  486. 18:10spoiler because almost no one will
  487. 18:12watch it, or already has. And Chan
  488. 18:15Conner is a group of people who are
  489. 18:17mortal and who are called, in quotes,
  490. 18:20barbarians. And he manages to break the
  491. 18:23crystal. When that crystal is broken,
  492. 18:26the entire community becomes mortal
  493. 18:28again. And one of the most beautiful
  494. 18:30scenes, because it uses the second
  495. 18:32movement of Beethoven's seventh
  496. 18:34symphony, the scene is marvelous. The
  497. 18:36barbarians, in quotes, the knights pass
  498. 18:39by with their weapons firing and the
  499. 18:41people perishing with joy. Because
  500. 18:44after all, 500 years, right, all the
  501. 18:47time, the same coexistence, the same
  502. 18:50pace, like an eternal Groundhog Day,
  503. 18:52the spell of time, right, that leaves
  504. 18:55you, right, in a strong condition. Then
  505. 18:58I return to a point, Dialen, 90 years
  506. 19:01old, he says:" I'm not afraid of death.
  507. 19:04I not only don't want to be there when
  508. 19:06it happens, right? But the biggest
  509. 19:08thing is to imagine that death is not a
  510. 19:10threat, it's a warning. That's
  511. 19:12very good. That's very good. Uh, that's
  512. 19:16caution. You don't have all the time in
  513. 19:19the world to not be an idiot, an
  514. 19:21imbecile, arrogant, petulant. You need
  515. 19:24to build yourself in a different way.
  516. 19:27In that sense, mortality is a guide for
  517. 19:30us, right, in that field as well. Of
  518. 19:32course, right? None of us intends to
  519. 19:36perish in agony.
  520. 19:37Yes. That's why our great dream is a
  521. 19:40good death, euthanasia, using the Greek
  522. 19:43term,
  523. 19:43right? But life itself, if it didn't
  524. 19:46have a movement of sensation, we would
  525. 19:49enjoy and appreciate it less. You said
  526. 19:53at the beginning that you were happy I
  527. 19:55was here, I said I was also happy to be
  528. 19:58here. Both things are true, but
  529. 20:01happiness only exists if it is
  530. 20:03continuous. You And we're only happy to
  531. 20:05see each other because we're not
  532. 20:07together all the time.
  533. 20:09It's true.
  534. 20:10Because happiness also comes from
  535. 20:12absence. I have immense pleasure in
  536. 20:14drinking this water that I'm about to
  537. 20:15drink because I'm thirsty. Thirst
  538. 20:18fosters pleasure. If I had the
  539. 20:20obligation to drink six glasses of it,
  540. 20:22to have a medical exam, I wouldn't
  541. 20:24appreciate it, right? We can only say:
  542. 20:28"I'm happy because she's absent, right?
  543. 20:31" If she had an endless presence, there
  544. 20:34would be no enjoyment. The best thing
  545. 20:37in the world is to eat with appetite,
  546. 20:40not with hunger. Don't confuse hunger
  547. 20:43with appetite. Hunger is the absence of
  548. 20:45food and causes desperation. Appetite
  549. 20:47is the expectation of food and desire,
  550. 20:49right? That's why, when you really want
  551. 20:52to eat something, you could eat
  552. 20:54something else; you don't lack food, it
  553. 20:57immensely increases the taste when you
  554. 20:59savor it. It's already been seen that
  555. 21:02those who like beer, right? Every now
  556. 21:04and then I take the first sip. This
  557. 21:08isn't beer, nor does it need to be, nor
  558. 21:10should it be, right? But the first sip
  559. 21:12is masterful, the second is delicious.
  560. 21:16By the third, the fourth, you become
  561. 21:18just an intermediary between the bottle
  562. 21:21and the toilet, right? So it's just a
  563. 21:24passage where you don't have it, right?
  564. 21:28Uh, you don't feel like it. A person,
  565. 21:30for example, who is an alcoholic,
  566. 21:31doesn't experience pleasure,
  567. 21:33right?
  568. 21:33They have a dependency. Uh-huh.
  569. 21:35Right? That's why there's a difference
  570. 21:38between pleasure, happiness, exuberance
  571. 21:40, and the condition of not being able
  572. 21:43to break free. And I come back to this
  573. 21:45point. We have life and need to value
  574. 21:48it, because we are inevitably losing it
  575. 21:51. Oh, you brought up a hook, I'd really
  576. 21:55like to hear your perspective, because
  577. 21:57I recently saw this study that in the
  578. 21:59age of social media, human beings have
  579. 22:01never felt so alone. It might seem
  580. 22:04crazy, right? In an age of tools for
  581. 22:07interaction, human beings have never
  582. 22:10felt so alone. Ah, and I believe that
  583. 22:13happiness, that's why I'm bringing it
  584. 22:15up, is very much tied to the quality of
  585. 22:17the relationships we have. And people
  586. 22:21have never felt so alone. So, it's safe
  587. 22:23to say that we've never had a moment of
  588. 22:26such unhappiness.
  589. 22:28How do you look at this?
  590. 22:29Two things. The first is that being
  591. 22:32alone isn't being lonely, right? A
  592. 22:34person who feels alone or considers
  593. 22:36themselves alone isn't necessarily
  594. 22:38lonely.
  595. 22:39A lonely person is someone who doesn't
  596. 22:41have anyone to rely on,
  597. 22:42who feels abandoned, left behind.
  598. 22:44Yes,
  599. 22:45right? A lonely person is someone
  600. 22:47you're...I'm sometimes alone.
  601. 22:49Uh-huh. At home, when Claudia goes out
  602. 22:51or travels or has another activity, I'm
  603. 22:53alone. It's not always bad to be alone.
  604. 22:55What's bad is
  605. 22:56being lonely. That's
  606. 22:57true, isn't
  607. 22:58it? That's why loneliness is bad, right
  608. 23:01? The ability to be alone, or to be
  609. 23:03alone at various times, is good for us.
  610. 23:05Uh-huh.
  611. 23:06When you take care of yourself, the
  612. 23:08famous "mm, my time," right? My time,
  613. 23:11of course I'm going to do it now, right
  614. 23:13? I'll never forget that during the
  615. 23:16pandemic, in the initial phase of a
  616. 23:18necessary, longer isolation, Claudia
  617. 23:21and I stayed together and we counted
  618. 23:24the days 110, 120, 130, every day,
  619. 23:26right? 24 hours together. That's why we
  620. 23:29established between ourselves that
  621. 23:31during the 24 hours of the day there
  622. 23:33would be two hours where we were alone,
  623. 23:36each in an isolated corner. It wasn't
  624. 23:38forbidden to talk, but it wasn't
  625. 23:40necessary to do so. So you could also
  626. 23:42have a little bit of, you know, density
  627. 23:45, presence, individuality. Why am I
  628. 23:47saying this? I understood what you said
  629. 23:48.
  630. 23:49We are in a moment where we live out
  631. 23:52loud,
  632. 23:53the connections are continuous.
  633. 23:55That's true.
  634. 23:55The need for availability is continuous
  635. 23:58. And at that moment, of course, right,
  636. 24:00never, as you recalled, never has there
  637. 24:03been so much approximation that has
  638. 24:05left us more distanced from an atomic
  639. 24:08point of view and closer from a
  640. 24:10molecular point of view, right, in
  641. 24:12terms of technology,
  642. 24:13right, as corporeality, we are
  643. 24:16distanced
  644. 24:18in terms of proximity, right, in terms
  645. 24:20of bits, we are touching. Yes, because
  646. 24:24a portion of this technology has
  647. 24:26replaced the need for proximity, right?
  648. 24:29You start with what I've joked about
  649. 24:31for years. One of the most magnificent
  650. 24:34diabolical inventions of humanity was
  651. 24:36the microwave, right? Because it
  652. 24:38immensely facilitated our lives and
  653. 24:40allowed us to have a meal, which was a
  654. 24:43moment of closeness, each in a corner,
  655. 24:45in a family. Yes.
  656. 24:46For example, until 30 or 40 years ago
  657. 24:48in Brazil, when microwaves didn't yet
  658. 24:51have such a significant presence, if we
  659. 24:53were to have lunch at someone's house
  660. 24:55today, we would have to heat up all the
  661. 24:57food at once. Uh-huh. Uh-huh.
  662. 24:59And therefore, the meal had to be
  663. 25:01shared.
  664. 25:01Uh-huh.
  665. 25:02Well, not anymore. We've also had a
  666. 25:04technological advancement that has
  667. 25:07changed what happened 40 years ago–if
  668. 25:09I wanted to listen to music at home,
  669. 25:11everyone would listen with me because I
  670. 25:14only had one stereo. Yes,
  671. 25:16it had to be adjusted to a level that
  672. 25:18was audible. Today, each of us listens
  673. 25:20wherever we want. Imagine a crowded
  674. 25:23subway car in São Paulo, everyone
  675. 25:24listening to different music. You don't
  676. 25:26know what the other person is listening
  677. 25:28to, or what they're watching. Whenever
  678. 25:31one of us wanted to watch a TV program,
  679. 25:33we had to watch it, share it, decide,
  680. 25:35and negotiate a consensus regarding
  681. 25:37what was to be seen on the television
  682. 25:40set itself. Exactly.
  683. 25:41The lower cost of technology meant that
  684. 25:44each of us could first watch programs
  685. 25:46wherever we wanted, on our own platform
  686. 25:48, in our pocket or in our room,
  687. 25:51right? Second, it was no longer
  688. 25:52necessary to do it together.
  689. 25:54All this facilitating technology has
  690. 25:56removed the need for physical proximity
  691. 25:59, right? Remote work, working from home
  692. 26:02, right? He created conveniences in a
  693. 26:05circumstantial situation, but when he
  694. 26:07follows through, you know, for me to
  695. 26:10ease my longing for my grandchildren,
  696. 26:12today all I have to do is make a video
  697. 26:15call. But that doesn't take away the
  698. 26:18smell, the playfulness, the touch. So,
  699. 26:20for example, at home, when my children
  700. 26:25were teenagers, we would have one week
  701. 26:27out of every four weeks of the month
  702. 26:29without microwaves.
  703. 26:31No microwaves. And each of us had to
  704. 26:32make an effort to come and eat together
  705. 26:35, wherever we were. One of the day's
  706. 26:37meals was mandatory together, either
  707. 26:39lunch or dinner,
  708. 26:40because that's when you talk, laugh,
  709. 26:42argue,
  710. 26:43get into trouble, and
  711. 26:44get to know each other.
  712. 26:46Another thing we did
  713. 26:48that made things easier, because this
  714. 26:49isn't a rejection of technology, it's
  715. 26:51using it in a way that it doesn't
  716. 26:52possess us. True.
  717. 26:54After all, the name we gave to
  718. 26:56computers in the 1940s was server.
  719. 27:00That's true.
  720. 27:01And so, if it's a server, let it be a
  721. 27:03server, right? I'm not the one who's a
  722. 27:04servant.
  723. 27:05Yes.
  724. 27:05Right? Another thing we did every
  725. 27:08Saturday afternoon was get-together–
  726. 27:10they were 10, 12, 8 years old. From 4
  727. 27:13PM to 6 PM we listened to music
  728. 27:15together, sitting on the living room
  729. 27:18floor, each picking songs for the other
  730. 27:20according to our age. Two songs that
  731. 27:23you liked, we would all listen to them,
  732. 27:25then retire them, because that created
  733. 27:28an interactivity right at your point of
  734. 27:30departure. Technology has made things
  735. 27:33so much easier. I still use the
  736. 27:35microwave, but I don't just use the
  737. 27:37microwave. I still listen to music, but
  738. 27:40I don't like listening alone. There are
  739. 27:43wonderful experiences. I'll never
  740. 27:46forget them, right? In 2025 I was with
  741. 27:48Cláudio at Deown, right? And we went
  742. 27:51to see some performances, one of which
  743. 27:54I had never seen live before, Ivete
  744. 27:57Sangalo, 60,000 people singing, dancing
  745. 28:00, everyone gathered together, not
  746. 28:02harming anyone, people together to
  747. 28:05celebrate, to sing, to party. Well,
  748. 28:09that replaces that. I can listen to
  749. 28:11Ivete Sangalo, if I want, on my mobile.
  750. 28:14I can just switch and start. Of course,
  751. 28:16I can use streaming, right? I can use
  752. 28:19it, I can,
  753. 28:20but not always. It's
  754. 28:22not that technology should be left out,
  755. 28:24it needs to be used in a way that
  756. 28:26doesn't make me feel like I'm
  757. 28:28voluntarily subservient to it. And
  758. 28:30that's my daily motto: they won't
  759. 28:32algorithmize me. That's it.
  760. 28:34That is, I choose. Of course it makes
  761. 28:36things easier. It's nice when I go to a
  762. 28:38website to look for a product and from
  763. 28:40then on, for 10 years, it will click on
  764. 28:43my screen every time so that it...But I
  765. 28:46don't want that. I need mechanisms
  766. 28:48where I can say no. And then you called
  767. 28:50and said, "But wow, we've never been so
  768. 28:53connected and yet so distant." Yes,
  769. 28:56because part of these relationships is
  770. 28:58very superficial. Uh-huh.
  771. 29:00Right? I simply, if I don't feel like
  772. 29:04having more contact with you, I
  773. 29:07disconnect you, right? I cancel you, I
  774. 29:10erase you, and then it's easy. I don't
  775. 29:13have to go talk to you, say, "What
  776. 29:16happened? Check it out." Wow, I don't
  777. 29:19even need to remember your birthday
  778. 29:20anymore. I have a system that alerts me
  779. 29:22, and I don't need to think of a gift
  780. 29:25for you, right? I can't just go there
  781. 29:27and choose, I can't give you a virtual
  782. 29:29gift, and then you choose yourself. I
  783. 29:32disconnect, and at some point, when you
  784. 29:35look, you're alone in the desert, right
  785. 29:38? And in that sense, being alone and
  786. 29:41being lonely are different things. And
  787. 29:45we do have paths of solitude that are
  788. 29:48stronger, right? That's why you and I
  789. 29:51like being with people,
  790. 29:52we like the stage, we like teaching,
  791. 29:54right? We like presence, right? There's
  792. 29:58something called an active audience.
  793. 30:01For example, in this conversation of
  794. 30:03ours, there will be, and there is, a
  795. 30:06virtual audience that isn't here, but
  796. 30:08is connected virtually, and there's a
  797. 30:11group of people here, an active
  798. 30:13audience. When I'm watching a football
  799. 30:15match, I'm not playing, but I'm
  800. 30:17participating.
  801. 30:18I feel emotion, I feel movement, I feel
  802. 30:20the crowd. The same applies to physical
  803. 30:22presence. What we can't do is imagine
  804. 30:25that we no longer need physical contact
  805. 30:28. Paulo Freire said that the "dirtiness
  806. 30:30" of the world was necessary, in his
  807. 30:33Pernambuco way of speaking, the "
  808. 30:35dirtiness" of the world. That is,
  809. 30:37people bother, people have a smell,
  810. 30:40people, in general, sometimes disturb,
  811. 30:44people caress, people welcome. This
  812. 30:48form of gentrification, not
  813. 30:50gentrification as it's done in urban
  814. 30:53planning, gentrification, is necessary.
  815. 30:56After all, when Michelangelo wanted to
  816. 30:59represent human presence, he painted
  817. 31:02God and Adam almost touching fingers on
  818. 31:05the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. You
  819. 31:09look, you're not sure if it's Adam
  820. 31:10creating God so he won't be alone, or
  821. 31:12if it's God creating Adam so he won't
  822. 31:14be alone. It doesn't matter. Then they
  823. 31:16sneeze and reproduce that scene in E.T.
  824. 31:19, right? And when they touch their
  825. 31:22finger and it lights up, the whole
  826. 31:24cinema goes...When I saw it at its
  827. 31:26release, on December 25, 1982, I went
  828. 31:31to see it in a cinema that no longer
  829. 31:33exists in the city of São Paulo: Cine
  830. 31:36Comodoro. It was a Cinerama, huge lines
  831. 31:38to see the premiere of E.T., which many
  832. 31:41people saw on TV, others on streaming,
  833. 31:43others on CD, others...it doesn't
  834. 31:45matter. But the scene, when the boy,
  835. 31:48Elliot in the film, and E.T. touches
  836. 31:51his finger and it lights up, the whole
  837. 31:54cinema goes like this: "Ah, that,
  838. 32:00that's the sound that wards off
  839. 32:03loneliness. When I meet someone and I'm
  840. 32:06desperate or desperate, I need immense
  841. 32:08help, someone puts their hand on my
  842. 32:10shoulder, someone looks at me and says:
  843. 32:12'Do you need anything?'""Ah, this 'a'
  844. 32:15isn't an 'a' of giving up, it's an 'a'
  845. 32:20of welcoming. That's why the only way
  846. 32:24to face loneliness is to keep using our
  847. 32:28little fingers. This is the digital
  848. 32:31aspect that matters. It's the finger
  849. 32:33that touches
  850. 32:34and the light turns on. People,
  851. 32:36applause because this one was really
  852. 32:38good. I mention this because I also
  853. 32:41watched ET. That scene with the little
  854. 32:44finger really
  855. 32:45moves me.
  856. 32:46There are two scenes that I always
  857. 32:47remember, right?
  858. 32:49Uh, that are brilliant, the one by
  859. 32:52Spielberg that pays homage to
  860. 32:55Michelangelo in the Sistine Chapel, in
  861. 32:58the creation scene. And the other is
  862. 33:01the flight of the bicycles.
  863. 33:03Yes,
  864. 33:04right? Because I was there in the 1200-
  865. 33:08seat cinema. São Paulo had 1000-seat
  866. 33:11cinemas. 1200 when it was that big.
  867. 33:13It's there on the corner of Paulista
  868. 33:16and
  869. 33:16Augusta, where the Conjugo Nacional is,
  870. 33:18there was a cinema, the Cine Astor,
  871. 33:20which later became a bookstore, etc. It
  872. 33:22was a cinema of..." 1200 seats. It's
  873. 33:24very different watching a movie with
  874. 33:261200 people than watching it with 80.
  875. 33:28Uh-huh.
  876. 33:29Right.
  877. 33:29Especially because the movie theater
  878. 33:31was huge, and the other theaters were
  879. 33:33too. Of course, we became more isolated
  880. 33:36, but you see an adventure movie with
  881. 33:381200 people sitting and jumping in
  882. 33:40their seats, right? It was very
  883. 33:42different. Now, what I'm saying isn't
  884. 33:45nostalgia, it's longing. Nostalgia is a
  885. 33:47longing that hurts. Longing alone is
  886. 33:50the kind where you smile just
  887. 33:51remembering having lived through it.
  888. 33:53Well, uh, the scene where the movie
  889. 33:56theater did, oh, is the one with
  890. 33:59Dedinha, but there's the scene where
  891. 34:01everyone claps, 1200 people get up
  892. 34:04there on Christmas Eve, right? Right on
  893. 34:07Christmas, it wasn't even Christmas Eve
  894. 34:08. It's when they're escaping on the
  895. 34:11bicycle, escaping from science, from
  896. 34:13the police, right, from detention, from
  897. 34:15imprisonment. When you imagine there's
  898. 34:18no way out, because they reach the edge
  899. 34:20of a precipice and are going to be
  900. 34:22captured, the Bicycles take flight,
  901. 34:24that beautiful moon in the background,
  902. 34:26the cinema applauds, because why would
  903. 34:29a human being think that bicycles fly?
  904. 34:33When you start to think that bicycles
  905. 34:36don't fly, you perish, you park, you
  906. 34:39retreat, you give up, right? Without
  907. 34:42imagining a madman born in Minas Gerais
  908. 34:44, in a city that today bears his name,
  909. 34:47Santos Dumont, who believed that it was
  910. 34:50possible for something heavier than air
  911. 34:53to fly. Not something lighter, because
  912. 34:56the lightest thing flies, but you don't
  913. 34:58have control over it. Uh-huh. That
  914. 35:00something heavier than air, like an
  915. 35:03airplane, could fly. He dedicated part
  916. 35:06of his life as a purpose to making
  917. 35:09something heavier fly. He had to be
  918. 35:13crazy in a positive sense. He's a
  919. 35:14beautiful madman, right, like Raul
  920. 35:16Seixas. He's that person who thinks
  921. 35:18bicycles fly, that it's possible to do
  922. 35:21things, that it's possible to create a
  923. 35:24vaccine, that it's possible to
  924. 35:26undertake an activity, that affection,
  925. 35:28sharing, fraternity are possible. That
  926. 35:31it is possible, yes, that the day I For
  927. 35:34me, you know, nobody should say, "it's
  928. 35:36too late." That word, you know, for
  929. 35:42purpose, to seek, to find, you have to
  930. 35:44have that impetus, right? How do you
  931. 35:47believe that we are able to refine our
  932. 35:50inner impetus, right? Once Cris
  933. 35:52Junqueira was here and she said a
  934. 35:54phrase that I take with me wherever I
  935. 35:56go, which I found very cool. She says,
  936. 35:58"Man, I can teach people a lot of
  937. 36:00things, except 'are you interested?'""
  938. 36:02Yes, of course.
  939. 36:03Being interested is something internal,
  940. 36:05right? And how can someone listening to
  941. 36:08us explain it?
  942. 36:09I talked to you about this in another
  943. 36:10conversation we had, something I'll
  944. 36:12bring up again because it's in my book
  945. 36:13called 'What is Your Work?' where I say
  946. 36:15that motivation is a door that opens
  947. 36:17from the inside.
  948. 36:19Wow, that's a lot, isn't it? Motivation
  949. 36:20is a door that opens from the inside
  950. 36:22out. Sometimes people ask me, as they
  951. 36:25should ask you, 'Do you give
  952. 36:27motivational speeches?' I say, no, I
  953. 36:29give stimulational speeches, right? To
  954. 36:32give a motivational speech I would have
  955. 36:34to do something impossible, motivate
  956. 36:35someone. And there's no way to motivate
  957. 36:38a person. You can stimulate them, you
  958. 36:40can encourage them, you can provoke
  959. 36:43them, summon them, but you can't
  960. 36:45motivate them.
  961. 36:46Uh-huh.
  962. 36:47Because the engine, that is, the one
  963. 36:49that drives the action, is from the
  964. 36:50inside out.
  965. 36:51I can't put it in you. What I can do is
  966. 36:54create conditions for you to clarify
  967. 36:57what you need." Motivation. I can
  968. 36:59create conditions for you to refine
  969. 37:01what motivates you. I can structure
  970. 37:04movements that give you more tools so
  971. 37:07that what motivates you becomes more
  972. 37:10than just a mere desire and intention,
  973. 37:13but a practice. Fair enough.
  974. 37:15But I can't motivate you in that sense.
  975. 37:18Someone can build what is purpose. I
  976. 37:22can be someone, looking from the
  977. 37:24outside in my teaching activity, who
  978. 37:27stimulates this condition, who leads
  979. 37:30you to reflect, who leads me to reflect
  980. 37:33, but to make you do something without
  981. 37:35you having the internal perspective,
  982. 37:38there's no way. I can order, as I said
  983. 37:42before, I can command, I can also, I
  984. 37:45cut you, like you at various moments in
  985. 37:48life, do things that weren't in my
  986. 37:51purpose. People who tell me, you've
  987. 37:54heard it yourself too, I love my job,
  988. 37:56but I hate my job. Uh-huh.
  989. 37:59I love my job and I hate my job. Uh-huh
  990. 38:01. There are several moments in life
  991. 38:04when anyone has to do things that
  992. 38:06aren't in their purpose, that, without
  993. 38:09being indecent, they accomplish the
  994. 38:11task. That is, they carry it forward
  995. 38:15and It has to be transitory. I always
  996. 38:18remember the example of people who, in
  997. 38:21order to survive, pay the bills, to
  998. 38:24earn a living from a sustenance point
  999. 38:26of view, have to do things that aren't
  1000. 38:29their life's objective. So they know
  1001. 38:32that it's a transitory movement. While
  1002. 38:35they're there, they understand that
  1003. 38:37this episodic movement is temporary,
  1004. 38:40that they're building the conditions
  1005. 38:43for what will come later.
  1006. 38:45This means that while they're in this
  1007. 38:48movement, they can't lose sight of what
  1008. 38:50will be their strongest purpose, but
  1009. 38:53they also can't discard or downplay
  1010. 38:56that moment because it's collaborative.
  1011. 38:59Uh-huh. Several things I've done in
  1012. 39:02life within my ultimate purpose helped
  1013. 39:05me get there, right? And in this sense,
  1014. 39:08there are two steps
  1015. 39:10we can take to help people. While
  1016. 39:12living this, learn as much as possible,
  1017. 39:15even if this isn't where you want to
  1018. 39:17stay forever. But while you're here,
  1019. 39:20don't lose the opportunity to learn.
  1020. 39:23Second, don't lose sight of what the
  1021. 39:25next step is. The Chinese say, and I
  1022. 39:27really like to quote a Chinese proverb,
  1023. 39:29that nobody knows. If it's Chinese and
  1024. 39:31I invent it as I please, but that's
  1025. 39:33Chinese. The Chinese say: "Eh, after
  1026. 39:36that mountain there are more mountains.
  1027. 39:38"
  1028. 39:39Yes,
  1029. 39:40after that mountain there are more
  1030. 39:42mountains. It means that it's necessary
  1031. 39:45to have perspective on what lies beyond
  1032. 39:47. Augustine of Hippo, a stupendous
  1033. 39:51medieval theologian and philosopher,
  1034. 39:53whom many call Saint Augustine. He, you
  1035. 39:56know, someone who was from the 5th
  1036. 39:58century, right, he died in 430,
  1037. 40:01therefore he's far from us in terms of
  1038. 40:04time, but he's close. He pointed out
  1039. 40:06something that I like to revisit. He
  1040. 40:08said that within a prison, within a
  1041. 40:11cell, you sometimes have two prisoners
  1042. 40:16in a cell, one spends all his time with
  1043. 40:18his head down looking at the ground and
  1044. 40:21the other looks out the window, even if
  1045. 40:23it has bars, he keeps looking. It's a
  1046. 40:27matter of motivation. What moves me to
  1047. 40:31keep looking outside and thinking about
  1048. 40:33the day I get out? Unlike what moves me
  1049. 40:37to stay grounded, looking at the ground
  1050. 40:40, saying: "There's no way out, oh
  1051. 40:42heavens," Oh life, oh pain. "What leads
  1052. 40:45someone to have a perspective of
  1053. 40:48surrender and submission, or another
  1054. 40:51person who has a perspective of
  1055. 40:54overcoming, of going beyond, is what
  1056. 40:57motivates them. Can I motivate them and
  1057. 41:00then conclude once and for all? No, but
  1058. 41:03I can stimulate them, I can provoke
  1059. 41:05them, I can make them think about it.
  1060. 41:21That is, take into account what I am
  1061. 41:26saying, not because I am the one saying
  1062. 41:29it, but because it may have some
  1063. 41:31relevance for you to perform better.
  1064. 41:34But again, motivation is something that
  1065. 41:37opens from the inside out.
  1066. 41:39Quick pause in the episode. Look at
  1067. 41:41this. 78%of you watching this episode
  1068. 41:44are not subscribed to the channel, and
  1069. 41:47you are going to miss a lot. Sometimes
  1070. 41:49that specific episode you did not see
  1071. 41:50contained exactly what you needed to
  1072. 41:52hear. So, for now, just subscribe to
  1073. 41:54the channel so you don't miss anything.
  1074. 41:57I'm sure you'll be the biggest
  1075. 41:59beneficiary of this, okay? So, click
  1076. 42:02now, subscribe, and you'll make sure
  1077. 42:04everything reaches you, alright? So, go
  1078. 42:08back to the episode, subscribe, and
  1079. 42:11keep watching. Who would you invite for
  1080. 42:16coffee? It doesn't matter if they are
  1081. 42:18dead or not. If you had the chance to
  1082. 42:21get together for coffee, who would you
  1083. 42:23invite to talk about what? Because
  1084. 42:26coffee usually goes with a conversation
  1085. 42:27, right? We usually have coffee.
  1086. 42:28I would have many people to invite who
  1087. 42:30have already passed away,
  1088. 42:32but I would like to invite for coffee
  1089. 42:35someone who is alive and very much
  1090. 42:37alive, who will be 82 years old, which
  1091. 42:40is Kiss Richards, right? The one who
  1092. 42:43founded the Rolling Stones with Mick
  1093. 42:47Jagger, which in 2025 marks 63 years. I
  1094. 42:52would like him to explain two things to
  1095. 42:54me. First, how he continued to live. He
  1096. 43:00is the negation of science. Everything
  1097. 43:02that science affirms about a living
  1098. 43:04being, he negates by continuing to live
  1099. 43:05. The second thing, how is it that in
  1100. 43:091966, when I was, look, 12 years old, I
  1101. 43:12heard for the first time on the radio
  1102. 43:15in Londrina a distant song from the
  1103. 43:18British world called" I Can Get No
  1104. 43:21Satisfaction, "but with a guitar solo,
  1105. 43:25with a riff that he created? I wanted
  1106. 43:28to understand what he did to make that
  1107. 43:33happen, how does a guy do something
  1108. 43:37like that while having coffee with him,
  1109. 43:40and he's probably sober now, it would
  1110. 43:42be coffee he was going to drink, right?
  1111. 43:45Him having coffee with me, him telling
  1112. 43:51me about it. I have many people, living
  1113. 43:54or dead, but of the living, so as not
  1114. 43:56to leave anyone out of the list, it
  1115. 43:58would be exactly, wouldn't it, Kiss
  1116. 44:01Richards?
  1117. 44:06And you?
  1118. 44:07Me?
  1119. 44:07Yes. Oh, wow, professor, the question
  1120. 44:13was for you, professor.
  1121. 44:15Yes, but now I'm returning the question
  1122. 44:16.
  1123. 44:17How do you open this? It's open, look.
  1124. 44:19Here.
  1125. 44:20Oh, it's a thermal mug.
  1126. 44:22Oh, I can't cry, okay? It has to be...
  1127. 44:31And it can't be people who make you cry
  1128. 44:33. I said it here once, but I won't
  1129. 44:43repeat it, that I said Jesus.
  1130. 44:45Yes,
  1131. 44:47man. Let him lose physically, right? So
  1132. 44:51we can talk to him all the time. But I
  1133. 45:00would invite Paulo to have a coffee,
  1134. 45:04since I just finished watching his
  1135. 45:08movie.
  1136. 45:08Ah, Paul the Apostle.
  1137. 45:10Ah, Paul the Apostle.
  1138. 45:12His letters are amazing, Paul's letters
  1139. 45:15. And from what I've read, he wasn't
  1140. 45:18very good at communication, but he was
  1141. 45:20a great writer. From what I understand,
  1142. 45:22he was educated, right? Yes.
  1143. 45:24Because he was part of the Jewish elite
  1144. 45:25.
  1145. 45:26Exactly.
  1146. 45:26Therefore, he had studied Greek, which
  1147. 45:28was the language, right, of those who
  1148. 45:30were schoolable at that time. Which is
  1149. 45:32why,
  1150. 45:33you know, Jewish religion is a religion
  1151. 45:35without theology in its origin. Uh-huh.
  1152. 45:38What is theology? It's the theory in
  1153. 45:40relation to a religion. Uh-huh.
  1154. 45:42You have a religion as a practice,
  1155. 45:43which is what Jesus did,
  1156. 45:45right? He called disciples, but none of
  1157. 45:47Jesus 'disciples were schooled.
  1158. 45:49Yeah,
  1159. 45:50right? They were fishermen, they were
  1160. 45:52farmers. None of them. If a school is
  1161. 45:55hard to have today, imagine what it was
  1162. 45:56like back then. Christianity was born
  1163. 45:59as a religious practice. It was Paul,
  1164. 46:02who didn't know Jesus, who would give
  1165. 46:05Christianity a theological concept.
  1166. 46:08That's true.
  1167. 46:09In fact, Paul's letters were written
  1168. 46:12before the Gospels. In the Christian
  1169. 46:16tradition, when you pick up a Christian
  1170. 46:18Bible,
  1171. 46:19the letters come later,
  1172. 46:20after the Gospels.
  1173. 46:21But in historical time, Paul's letters
  1174. 46:24precede the Gospels by 40 or 50 years.
  1175. 46:27The Gospels are a later writing.
  1176. 46:30Of the 27 books of the Christian Bible
  1177. 46:32in the New Testament, Paul's letters
  1178. 46:34are those that bring the highest level
  1179. 46:37of reflection and concepts.
  1180. 46:40And all the letters that Paul produced
  1181. 46:42—because there are many attributed to
  1182. 46:44him, but they weren't his, which the
  1183. 46:46Christian world now knows and
  1184. 46:47recognizes—
  1185. 46:48all of them deal with behavior, conduct
  1186. 46:51, coexistence, and ethics. By the way,
  1187. 46:54just out of curiosity, I think you know
  1188. 46:56, the city of São Paulo is called São
  1189. 46:58Paulo because it was founded on January
  1190. 47:0025th.
  1191. 47:00Uh-huh.
  1192. 47:01And in the Christian tradition, January
  1193. 47:0325th is the day that Paul stopped being
  1194. 47:05a persecutor of Christianity,
  1195. 47:07stopped going after those who followed
  1196. 47:08Jesus and started to join him. Uh-huh.
  1197. 47:10And I liked your idea about Paul, I
  1198. 47:12think it's brilliant. I would also call
  1199. 47:14Jesus into the conversation, but for
  1200. 47:16another step, uh, so that he could
  1201. 47:18transform it into wine. And then we
  1202. 47:25could mix these two movements,
  1203. 47:27coffee with wine.
  1204. 47:28Exactly.
  1205. 47:30Professor, I want to ask you a question
  1206. 47:32. It's because we talked, you talked
  1207. 47:33about technology, about the microwave
  1208. 47:35thing. I was going to ask you this
  1209. 47:36question. Do you believe that with the
  1210. 47:40advent of artificial intelligence,
  1211. 47:43people have to be careful? Because if
  1212. 47:47you have a question about anything, you
  1213. 47:50take an AI, you ask a question, but so
  1214. 47:53that you don't lose the capacity for
  1215. 47:58thought because AI is a transfer of
  1216. 48:00thought, right?
  1217. 48:02I know. It's
  1218. 48:03thinking for you. And I believe that
  1219. 48:06our mind is a muscle to exercise, for
  1220. 48:08example, how are you using artificial
  1221. 48:11intelligence? Which one do you know?
  1222. 48:14We've been
  1223. 48:14using it for a long time in various
  1224. 48:15ways. But looking now at generative AI,
  1225. 48:17which is the one that's most directly
  1226. 48:19present now, because it's also the
  1227. 48:21artificial intelligence that does
  1228. 48:23autocorrect when I'm typing on my cell
  1229. 48:25phone, right? It's what allows me to
  1230. 48:27pause a movie when I'm streaming, etc.,
  1231. 48:30etc. It's been in our daily lives for a
  1232. 48:33long time, but now there's one that can
  1233. 48:37be an agent, therefore, do things for
  1234. 48:40me and guide things and can also
  1235. 48:42clarify things. There's an issue
  1236. 48:45regarding AI that I use very frequently
  1237. 48:47, which is the assistance with
  1238. 48:50repetitive tasks, the assistance with
  1239. 48:53things that could take too long. For
  1240. 48:55example, I've been using my personal
  1241. 48:57computer to write for decades. There is
  1242. 49:00an autocorrect system on my personal
  1243. 49:02computer, inside the application I use.
  1244. 49:05I've always used it, where it would go
  1245. 49:07there and identify words that were
  1246. 49:09written incorrectly. This was already
  1247. 49:11artificial intelligence.
  1248. 49:12Yes.
  1249. 49:12This was 20, 30 years ago.
  1250. 49:14Yes.
  1251. 49:14What I don't want from artificial
  1252. 49:16intelligence is for it to take away my
  1253. 49:18autonomy. What do I want from
  1254. 49:20artificial intelligence? That it has
  1255. 49:23automatism.
  1256. 49:24True.
  1257. 49:24That is,
  1258. 49:25that it does what I would have to do,
  1259. 49:28does it better, but quickly saves me
  1260. 49:31from having to do it. I don't want it
  1261. 49:34to do it without my decision. I want it
  1262. 49:37to be automatic and not autonomous.
  1263. 49:40Uh-huh. That's
  1264. 49:41where the choice is mine. It obeys, it
  1265. 49:45is a servant. I
  1266. 49:47am not the servant. Uh-huh. In this
  1267. 49:49sense, I think that when we have the
  1268. 49:52possibility of an instrument in our
  1269. 49:55daily lives, it is necessary that we
  1270. 49:57always take care in relation to it. I
  1271. 50:01mentioned at another time the case of
  1272. 50:03Saint Dom Pedro II, some say I find it
  1273. 50:05difficult to believe, Saint Dom Pedro
  1274. 50:07II took his own life in the city of
  1275. 50:09Petrópolis, where he was. Some say it
  1276. 50:12was because he became immensely bitter
  1277. 50:14about what he invented along with his
  1278. 50:17American brothers, the W brothers, each
  1279. 50:19in the place where the airplane was
  1280. 50:21built, that the fact that it was used
  1281. 50:24as a bomber embittered him to such an
  1282. 50:26extent that he became depressed. Uh-huh
  1283. 50:28. It doesn't matter
  1284. 50:29if the story is true or not. What
  1285. 50:31matters is that anything
  1286. 50:34created by humans can have multiple
  1287. 50:36purposes. Obviously, if I surround
  1288. 50:40myself well, the use of the airplane
  1289. 50:42will always be beneficial. Uh-huh.
  1290. 50:45It can be harmful, of course. I can use
  1291. 50:48a knife, right, to share a piece of
  1292. 50:50bread with you and we both eat, and I
  1293. 50:53can use it to take the bread that's in
  1294. 50:56your hand.
  1295. 50:57That's true.
  1296. 50:58Obviously, it's not the knife that
  1297. 50:59decides. Well, I don't want artificial
  1298. 51:02intelligence to be a knife that decides
  1299. 51:04for itself, right? It can't choose, I'm
  1300. 51:07the one who chooses. And I need to
  1301. 51:09choose carefully. In this sense, one
  1302. 51:13thing that is powerful is that we
  1303. 51:15should be able to exercise caution with
  1304. 51:17what fascinates us. There's an initial
  1305. 51:20phase where artificial intelligence, in
  1306. 51:23the last two years or so, has instilled
  1307. 51:26in us an immense desire to simulate
  1308. 51:28things, to make waves and cuts, to surf
  1309. 51:31, you know, to use filters on photos.
  1310. 51:34Uh-huh.
  1311. 51:34Then it gets tiring because there comes
  1312. 51:36a point when it's not yours anymore.
  1313. 51:38It's like
  1314. 51:38when you were a child, within computer
  1315. 51:41systems, you had some applications to
  1316. 51:44draw automatically. You'd
  1317. 51:46draw a ball, and it would add the
  1318. 51:47colors.
  1319. 51:48Yes.
  1320. 51:49First of all, that didn't generate,
  1321. 51:50right? It didn't generate great artists
  1322. 51:53on the planet, did
  1323. 51:54it? Secondly, it didn't prevent great
  1324. 51:55scientists from emerging. Just like I
  1325. 51:58saw the other day, a wonderful argument
  1326. 52:00arose when someone asked:" Don't you
  1327. 52:02think that games which feature violence
  1328. 52:04do a great deal of harm to children? "I
  1329. 52:07said," Yes, a part of it does, "the
  1330. 52:09person said," a part of it does, but
  1331. 52:11you have to remember that they don't
  1332. 52:13have the power to completely shape
  1333. 52:15minds, because otherwise we would have
  1334. 52:18the largest number of plumbers on the
  1335. 52:20planet, because the most popular
  1336. 52:22computer game, Mario Bros., is exactly
  1337. 52:24about a plumber. "And we don't have
  1338. 52:27hordes of plumbers all over the planet,
  1339. 52:28right? Therefore, the argument is
  1340. 52:31plausible. On the other hand, I use it,
  1341. 52:34why don't I use it? To write for myself
  1342. 52:37. Why? Because I enjoy writing, just as
  1343. 52:42I enjoy cooking. Claudio and I cook for
  1344. 52:45ourselves. We enjoy making it. When I
  1345. 52:48finish making a dish, I get pleasure
  1346. 52:50not only from eating it, but from
  1347. 52:52having made it. It's my work, right?
  1348. 52:54When I finish writing a text, I use AI
  1349. 52:56to correct it, to research, to look up
  1350. 52:59some things, but not to write for
  1351. 53:01myself.
  1352. 53:02But that's because my activity is
  1353. 53:03writing. If I needed her to show me
  1354. 53:06which flights are leaving now, you know
  1355. 53:08, to Rio de Janeiro, what the price of
  1356. 53:11each one is, if she could find the
  1357. 53:13cheapest one, if she could pay for me
  1358. 53:15while I do something else, like, for
  1359. 53:18example, chat with you, go ahead. What
  1360. 53:21I don't want is for her to decide where
  1361. 53:24I go, but for her to help me get there,
  1362. 53:27how wonderful.
  1363. 53:28Oh, marvelous. Pause for Cortella,
  1364. 53:30ladies and gentlemen. Professor, for
  1365. 53:33the last segment, then I have the final
  1366. 53:34question, which we have a moment when
  1367. 53:36the audience will ask.
  1368. 53:37Great.
  1369. 53:38Audience asks.
  1370. 53:39First question, production? Bruno.
  1371. 53:42Where's Bruno? Bruno, your question.
  1372. 53:45The most purple microphone in this
  1373. 53:46country is yours. Go ahead.
  1374. 53:48Hello, professor. Hello, Caio.
  1375. 53:49Hello. In these times we are living in,
  1376. 53:52where groups are increasingly claiming
  1377. 53:55absolute truth, how can philosophy help
  1378. 53:57us improve our conversations without
  1379. 54:00becoming enemies of each other?
  1380. 54:02Very good question. Rosa, Bruno, he
  1381. 54:04once wrote a short story with a special
  1382. 54:07title: it's called" The Third Bank of
  1383. 54:10the River, "which is almost an
  1384. 54:12impossibility, but it makes us think
  1385. 54:15that we shouldn't assume that because
  1386. 54:18someone thinks differently from me,
  1387. 54:21that person is wrong, or, conversely,
  1388. 54:24because I think differently from them,
  1389. 54:27that I am right. It's necessary to
  1390. 54:29bring knowledge closer together. In
  1391. 54:31that sense, one of the most dangerous
  1392. 54:34things is having what is called
  1393. 54:36relativism. Relativism is like that,
  1394. 54:38anything goes. I think this, you think
  1395. 54:41that, great, that's your thought. Life
  1396. 54:44would become and will become impossible
  1397. 54:46if each of us assumes that we have a
  1398. 54:49truth and that this truth is valid. I
  1399. 54:51saw Gabriela Prioli one day, who is a
  1400. 54:54great law professor, attorney, and
  1401. 54:56writer, doing something I thought was
  1402. 54:59brilliant, Bruno, in order to show it
  1403. 55:01to someone who was doubting what I am
  1404. 55:04saying here; That is, the person stated
  1405. 55:06:" I think what I want, my truth is
  1406. 55:09what matters. "
  1407. 55:11She convinced him in the following way,
  1408. 55:13saying:" Interesting, isn't it? You've
  1409. 55:15lost quite a bit of weight now, huh? "
  1410. 55:17And he said:" No, I gained weight. "She
  1411. 55:19said:" No, I'm telling you, you didn't
  1412. 55:22gain any weight, you lost weight. "He
  1413. 55:24said:" Ah, but that's not me. I didn't
  1414. 55:26lose any weight, I gained 5 kg. "She
  1415. 55:28said:" But I don't think so. "He said:"
  1416. 55:30But how can you not think so? That
  1417. 55:32clashes with reality. "She said:" So
  1418. 55:34that's what I'm talking about, right?
  1419. 55:36Therefore, the idea that each person
  1420. 55:39has their own truth is very strange. An
  1421. 55:42intelligent person is one who knows
  1422. 55:44they don't know everything and doesn't
  1423. 55:46know everything they know alone. That's
  1424. 55:48why this is a dangerous time. Finally,
  1425. 55:51since this sometimes leads to hatred,
  1426. 55:53it's worth remembering when he said' an
  1427. 55:55eye for an eye, 'that at some point
  1428. 55:57we'll all be blind. So it's a choice. I
  1429. 56:01don't want to be algorithmized, neither
  1430. 56:04so that I think only I know, nor so
  1431. 56:07that I think I know nothing. I want
  1432. 56:10what I know to be useful to me and to
  1433. 56:12other people, and what I don't know I
  1434. 56:14should seek out, right? In that sense,
  1435. 56:17it's dangerous to imagine. There's a
  1436. 56:20classic saying:' Beware of a one-book
  1437. 56:22person. 'Beware of a person who has
  1438. 56:25only one book as a reference, because
  1439. 56:28they generally become fanatical. That's
  1440. 56:31why, Bruno, this is the way.
  1441. 56:33Very good. Very good. Very good. That's
  1442. 56:35a very good one, huh? Beware of a
  1443. 56:36one-book person. Wow, that's a very
  1444. 56:38good one. Very good. "
  1445. 56:39That's good.
  1446. 56:39This is very relevant in religion,
  1447. 56:41because there are people who use their
  1448. 56:43form of reference—which is a right,
  1449. 56:45right?—as if it were the only thing
  1450. 56:47that has validity, and that's a risk.
  1451. 56:49Just out of curiosity, the word fanatic
  1452. 56:51comes from temple. Fanos in Latin means
  1453. 56:53temple. So, originally, the word
  1454. 56:55fanatic refers to someone who, having a
  1455. 56:57religion, thought that no other
  1456. 56:59religion had validity.
  1457. 57:00Uh-huh.
  1458. 57:00It's interesting, a notion of
  1459. 57:02exclusive-exclusive fraternity, right?
  1460. 57:05So caution is needed.
  1461. 57:06Very good. Very good. Next question,
  1462. 57:08production.
  1463. 57:09Roberta.
  1464. 57:09Roberta, where's Roberta? Come on,
  1465. 57:11Roberta. Directly from the purple
  1466. 57:15microphone,
  1467. 57:16directly from Belém do Pará, huh?
  1468. 57:18Maranhão.
  1469. 57:18The truth
  1470. 57:19of Maranhão, where
  1471. 57:20one of our greatest poets, Ferreira
  1472. 57:23Goulart, was born,
  1473. 57:24who said:" It's not enough to be right
  1474. 57:26to win the battle. "It's
  1475. 57:28not enough to be right to win the
  1476. 57:30battle.
  1477. 57:31It's an honor first. An honor. I'm
  1478. 57:32trembling all over. Well, professor, I
  1479. 57:36wanted to understand your point of view
  1480. 57:38regarding merit. We know that today
  1481. 57:41there's so much talk about...
  1482. 57:42Meritocracy, we're in our own work
  1483. 57:43environment here and everything. So,
  1484. 57:45what's your point of view on this?
  1485. 57:48Starting from the point of view of
  1486. 57:50differences, without ignoring the
  1487. 57:52differences, and what would this issue
  1488. 57:54of self-esteem be, and are we really
  1489. 57:56deserving it, or what is self-esteem
  1490. 57:58talking about,
  1491. 58:00Roberta? Two things. First, let's start
  1492. 58:01from the end. There's a difference
  1493. 58:03between self-esteem and self-deception.
  1494. 58:05Self-esteem is when I value what I have
  1495. 58:08that is positive, but I can't transform
  1496. 58:10what I have that is positive into the
  1497. 58:13only way to be positive and the most
  1498. 58:15positive that exists. And therefore,
  1499. 58:18the others are secondary. There are
  1500. 58:20parents today who, instead of
  1501. 58:22introducing self-esteem to their
  1502. 58:24children, lead them to self-deception.
  1503. 58:28A boy is playing soccer and then he
  1504. 58:30goes around saying," Cool, you're the
  1505. 58:32man, that's great, you're the best. "
  1506. 58:34When that's not true, that's deceiving
  1507. 58:36someone. In fact, it will lead the boy
  1508. 58:38to imagine that he doesn't need to
  1509. 58:39train anymore, that he doesn't need to
  1510. 58:40do anything anymore. I've been a
  1511. 58:41teacher for 51 years and I've always
  1512. 58:43had this because it's my profession.
  1513. 58:46Saying," Look, this isn't good, fix it,
  1514. 58:47do it another way. "Imagine you give me
  1515. 58:49a reflection. I say," It's wonderful
  1516. 58:52when it isn't. "Ah, but you can't say
  1517. 58:54it's not good. Yes, I can. What matters
  1518. 58:57is how I approach it. I say," Look, you
  1519. 59:00are capable of good things, but this
  1520. 59:02one you just did, to be even better,
  1521. 59:04you need to change the way you do it. "
  1522. 59:06That's why, of course, self-esteem
  1523. 59:08isn't self-deception. Meritocracy is a
  1524. 59:11difficult conversation when we confuse
  1525. 59:14equality with equity. Forget it.
  1526. 59:17Equality means everyone has equal
  1527. 59:19rights. Equity means everyone has the
  1528. 59:21conditions to exercise equal rights.
  1529. 59:23Uh-huh.
  1530. 59:24When there is equality without equity,
  1531. 59:25there is no equality. I'll give you an
  1532. 59:27example. Four people, you, me, Caio,
  1533. 59:31and Bruno. Let's now compete in a race
  1534. 59:35in a pool. 100m sprint, okay? Shallow
  1535. 59:39because the pool is shallow so we don't
  1536. 59:41drown those who are shorter. 100m
  1537. 59:43freestyle. The pool is the same, the
  1538. 59:46water temperature is identical, the
  1539. 59:48distance is equivalent. The judge will
  1540. 59:50evaluate us using specific criteria,
  1541. 59:52and we jump into the water. You might
  1542. 59:55say," See? Meritocracy, right? Everyone
  1543. 59:57is on equal footing. "No, because what
  1544. 59:59matters is before jumping into the pool
  1545. 1:00:01. One of us has trained, the other is
  1546. 1:00:0472. The other person has difficulty
  1547. 1:00:07with the water. You can only talk about
  1548. 1:00:11meritocracy if people have equal
  1549. 1:00:14conditions beforehand, that is,
  1550. 1:00:16schooling, opportunity, circumstance.
  1551. 1:00:19One last example of this: I studied at
  1552. 1:00:22a public school on Rua da Consolação,
  1553. 1:00:24in the capital of São Paulo, called
  1554. 1:00:26Escola Marina Cinta, which is still
  1555. 1:00:28there today on the corner of Rua
  1556. 1:00:30Antônio de Queiroz. We were four
  1557. 1:00:33friends who spent a lot of time
  1558. 1:00:35together, we played, we went out to eat
  1559. 1:00:37something together. Me and three others
  1560. 1:00:40. Me and Edu, my friend, were children
  1561. 1:00:43of well-off parents, we had trips with
  1562. 1:00:46our families, we had a place to study
  1563. 1:00:48at home; That is, we had a small work
  1564. 1:00:51table, a place to keep our things. We
  1565. 1:00:54didn't have outside jobs, we were just
  1566. 1:00:56students. And the other two, one of
  1567. 1:00:58them worked at the corner bar and the
  1568. 1:01:01other worked as a doorman in a building
  1569. 1:01:03, you know, on Vanandava Street. We
  1570. 1:01:06took the same exams, the professors
  1571. 1:01:09were the same. The evaluation criteria
  1572. 1:01:12were identical. Why did Edu and I get
  1573. 1:01:15higher grades? Because before taking
  1574. 1:01:18the exam, no matter how much those two
  1575. 1:01:21dedicated themselves, how much they
  1576. 1:01:23studied, they had limitations. When I'm
  1577. 1:01:27evaluated based on a condition that I
  1578. 1:01:29have that's better than someone else's,
  1579. 1:01:31there's no merit. What counts as merit
  1580. 1:01:34is when we have identical conditions.
  1581. 1:01:36This means, and I conclude that effort
  1582. 1:01:39is not a value. Of course it is. It's
  1583. 1:01:41no use for me, Cortella, to have
  1584. 1:01:43parents who helped me if I didn't seek
  1585. 1:01:46it out, if I didn't go after it, if I
  1586. 1:01:48didn't go, you know, seek out that
  1587. 1:01:50effort, if I just sat and waited, it
  1588. 1:01:53wouldn't come. But meritocracy that
  1589. 1:01:56only deals with equality, without
  1590. 1:01:58working with the notion of equity, is
  1591. 1:02:00not meritocracy. At that point it is
  1592. 1:02:04exclusion, it is putting someone out.
  1593. 1:02:07After all, look, I'm white, of European
  1594. 1:02:11descent, I'm educated, right? I have
  1595. 1:02:14light eyes, I fit the profile to
  1596. 1:02:16succeed even in an interview. Why do we
  1597. 1:02:20have so many people of African descent
  1598. 1:02:23or poorer people in public sector
  1599. 1:02:26activities like health and education?
  1600. 1:02:29There are no interviews, it is a public
  1601. 1:02:31exam without interviews. Where do you
  1602. 1:02:33have interviews? I have no doubt that,
  1603. 1:02:36however much the person tries not to
  1604. 1:02:38make a discretionary distinction
  1605. 1:02:41between me and a Black person,
  1606. 1:02:46structural racism is on their side.
  1607. 1:02:48It's more or less like me talking to
  1608. 1:02:50you. I say:" Which team do you support?
  1609. 1:02:52"He says:" I'm a Corinthians fan. "I
  1610. 1:02:54say this:" Ah, in my family, a good
  1611. 1:02:58part of them are Corinthians fans. I'm
  1612. 1:02:59a Santos fan, I'm a
  1613. 1:03:00Palmeiras fan. That's it. My wife is a
  1614. 1:03:02Palmeiras fan. I've been laughing a lot
  1615. 1:03:05, but quietly, right? Why am I laughing
  1616. 1:03:07quietly? Because my team is, you see?
  1617. 1:03:10The championship is the same, it's a
  1618. 1:03:13matter of merit. In a dispute, like
  1619. 1:03:15what happened in 2025 between Palmeiras
  1620. 1:03:18and Flamengo in relation to the
  1621. 1:03:20Libertadores, who had merit? They both
  1622. 1:03:25reached the final. Who won? Who scored
  1623. 1:03:29the goal? Who put in more effort?
  1624. 1:03:32Watching the game, I remember that game
  1625. 1:03:34, it seemed like Palmeiras put in less
  1626. 1:03:36effort
  1627. 1:03:37than they should have.
  1628. 1:03:39Well, saying that's wrong, it's not
  1629. 1:03:41fair, right? Well, if you have someone
  1630. 1:03:44who has to win, the idea of justice
  1631. 1:03:47takes on another level. That's why,
  1632. 1:03:49again, Ferreira Golar, it's not enough
  1633. 1:03:52to be right to win the battle.
  1634. 1:03:55Important question. Important
  1635. 1:04:00conclusion.
  1636. 1:04:02Pedro, Pedro's last question.
  1637. 1:04:04Pedro.
  1638. 1:04:06Pedro, go ahead.
  1639. 1:04:08Good. Good day, professor.
  1640. 1:04:09Hello. In a social aspect, does society
  1641. 1:04:13shape the individual, does the
  1642. 1:04:15individual shape society, or do both
  1643. 1:04:19create and complement each other?
  1644. 1:04:22Interesting, Pedro, because this is a
  1645. 1:04:23question that came up one day. A
  1646. 1:04:24good question
  1647. 1:04:25by a Genevan philosopher, born in
  1648. 1:04:27Geneva, now Switzerland, named
  1649. 1:04:30Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Rousseau has a
  1650. 1:04:32work, a book called Emile, which is a
  1651. 1:04:34book about education and formation, in
  1652. 1:04:36which he seeks to conduct an experiment
  1653. 1:04:38. And Rousseau had a phrase that,
  1654. 1:04:41translated more directly, was like this
  1655. 1:04:43: "A person is born good, society
  1656. 1:04:46corrupts them; a person is born good
  1657. 1:04:48and is corrupted later by society."
  1658. 1:04:51That is, everyone at birth is good in
  1659. 1:04:54desire, in intention, but then little
  1660. 1:04:57by little they are distorted, right?
  1661. 1:05:00They degenerate. And Rousseau conducts
  1662. 1:05:03an experiment on how you educate a
  1663. 1:05:06child who, when formed outside the
  1664. 1:05:08social group, preserves their purity,
  1665. 1:05:11but he only does the experiment
  1666. 1:05:13literarily and not in practice, right?
  1667. 1:05:16Forgetting, and the work is good for
  1668. 1:05:18provoking us, but forgetting something
  1669. 1:05:21decisive. There are two movements,
  1670. 1:05:23right? I'm born, right? Already with a
  1671. 1:05:26possibility of things, but it will
  1672. 1:05:28depend on the circumstances I find
  1673. 1:05:30myself in, for example, right? Until I
  1674. 1:05:33was 10 years old I had never watched
  1675. 1:05:35television, because in my city there
  1676. 1:05:37was no TV until I was 10 years old.
  1677. 1:05:39It's not that there wasn't one in my
  1678. 1:05:40house. What did we do at home at night?
  1679. 1:05:42Given that there was no TV, we talked,
  1680. 1:05:44um,
  1681. 1:05:45listened to the radio and read, we read
  1682. 1:05:47together. I wasn't born with this
  1683. 1:05:50ability, but I was formed in a
  1684. 1:05:53circumstance, but I was born with a
  1685. 1:05:55good capacity for vision. This is
  1686. 1:05:57genetic in me. As you can see, I'm not
  1687. 1:05:59wearing glasses now
  1688. 1:06:01and I don't use contact lenses, right?
  1689. 1:06:03And I haven't had surgery. Now, for
  1690. 1:06:05someone who read at night, in a time
  1691. 1:06:07when lighting wasn't so crucial, having
  1692. 1:06:09good vision genetically favored me. I
  1693. 1:06:12have something that favors me in what I
  1694. 1:06:15do. I have a good ribcage and my voice
  1695. 1:06:17is good for teaching, for working in
  1696. 1:06:19radio, for podcasting, for scolding my
  1697. 1:06:21children and grandchildren,
  1698. 1:06:23right? In that sense, it's no use being
  1699. 1:06:25born with a good voice if I don't have
  1700. 1:06:28the opportunity to develop it. It's no
  1701. 1:06:31use being born with a talent, to use an
  1702. 1:06:33old term, for painting, a better
  1703. 1:06:36spatial vision, if I don't have the
  1704. 1:06:38circumstances that will favor it. In
  1705. 1:06:40that sense, I think it's reciprocal.
  1706. 1:06:42I'll use the technical term now. The
  1707. 1:06:45genotype, that is, what comes with me,
  1708. 1:06:47meets the phenotype, which is what's
  1709. 1:06:49outside of me. Both things influence
  1710. 1:06:51each other. And one day I asked Dr.
  1711. 1:06:54Draudio Varela, in a...I was
  1712. 1:06:56interviewing him, in a conversation, if
  1713. 1:06:59he, with all the experience he's had—
  1714. 1:07:02brilliant, wonderful, a good person,
  1715. 1:07:04right? In the old Carandiru prison in
  1716. 1:07:06São Paulo, where he met so many people
  1717. 1:07:09(they were there separately), he asked
  1718. 1:07:11if he believed that some people were
  1719. 1:07:13born evil and couldn't be corrected.
  1720. 1:07:16And he said that he didn't think anyone
  1721. 1:07:19was born evil, but that he believed
  1722. 1:07:21many of the people he had met couldn't
  1723. 1:07:24be corrected, that is, there was no way
  1724. 1:07:26to remove that condition from them. I
  1725. 1:07:29was very sad that day, not with the
  1726. 1:07:31doctor, but with that possibility,
  1727. 1:07:34because as an educator, my job is to
  1728. 1:07:36help shape people and to shape myself,
  1729. 1:07:38one of our strongest beliefs, that is,
  1730. 1:07:41intentionally, is to believe that
  1731. 1:07:43everything has an alternative, that no
  1732. 1:07:45one will be lost. But there are two
  1733. 1:07:47movements, right? Guimarães Rosa
  1734. 1:07:50brought this up, Machado de Assis
  1735. 1:07:52himself brought a reflection that I
  1736. 1:07:54translate as follows: it is not the
  1737. 1:07:56occasion that makes the thief, the
  1738. 1:07:58occasion only reveals him. Very good.
  1739. 1:08:00The decision to be a thief or not
  1740. 1:08:02precedes the occasion. From this point
  1741. 1:08:04of view, there are two movements.
  1742. 1:08:06Therefore, it's necessary to address a
  1743. 1:08:09person's living conditions and, on the
  1744. 1:08:11other hand, take into account what is
  1745. 1:08:14atavistic in them, what comes from
  1746. 1:08:16their personality and other things, but
  1747. 1:08:19it's a very difficult question that
  1748. 1:08:21science struggles with quite a bit.
  1749. 1:08:23Perhaps your generation, given that you
  1750. 1:08:26are younger, will find an answer that
  1751. 1:08:28mine and everything that came before us
  1752. 1:08:30hasn't yet found. Applause for you,
  1753. 1:08:33Professor. What a wonderful episode,
  1754. 1:08:37huh? That's
  1755. 1:08:38great.
  1756. 1:08:38Wonderful.
  1757. 1:08:39But it's just that, that's why it's
  1758. 1:08:40good. That is, it doesn't happen
  1759. 1:08:42continuously.
  1760. 1:08:43It ends
  1761. 1:08:44this. It's the episode, right?
  1762. 1:08:46And as a final question, I wanted you
  1763. 1:08:49to answer for the whole group that has
  1764. 1:08:52that expression of, "Wow, I'm kind of
  1765. 1:08:55directionless, I feel lost,"
  1766. 1:08:58right? I keep getting that question
  1767. 1:09:00when I open my inbox on Instagram.
  1768. 1:09:02That's a classic, I get a lot of
  1769. 1:09:03questions. What do you do? Caio, 40, I
  1770. 1:09:06don't know what to do. I'm lost. I feel
  1771. 1:09:09for these people that they are
  1772. 1:09:12experiencing this discomfort.
  1773. 1:09:15There's an American philosopher. In
  1774. 1:09:17Brazil, we don't have much American
  1775. 1:09:19philosophy, but one of them was born in
  1776. 1:09:22Boston. That made his life easier
  1777. 1:09:24because he studied at Harvard later.
  1778. 1:09:27His name is Waldo Emerson. Ralph Waldo
  1779. 1:09:29Emerson. We call him Emerson in
  1780. 1:09:31philosophy. He's from the beginning of
  1781. 1:09:33the 19th century. He has an expression
  1782. 1:09:36that I always recommend. Someone says,
  1783. 1:09:38"I'm lost, I don't know what to do,
  1784. 1:09:40etc." I say the following: "Follow
  1785. 1:09:41Emerson." He said: "Become necessary to
  1786. 1:09:44somebody."
  1787. 1:09:46Become necessary to somebody. If you
  1788. 1:09:49and I happen to be lost, it is
  1789. 1:09:51necessary that we find ourselves by
  1790. 1:09:53becoming someone who is needed by
  1791. 1:09:54another human being. And I can't be
  1792. 1:09:57necessary only to myself; I have to be
  1793. 1:09:59necessary to other people. In that
  1794. 1:10:01sense, a person will find the greatest
  1795. 1:10:04ease on this path if they become
  1796. 1:10:06necessary. If they are useless to
  1797. 1:10:08others, they will be useless to
  1798. 1:10:10themselves, right? Therefore, it's a
  1799. 1:10:12person with a life without purpose,
  1800. 1:10:14right? One of the strongest and most
  1801. 1:10:17difficult things is precisely when you
  1802. 1:10:19and I find ourselves lost. That's why
  1803. 1:10:23the Cheshire Cat tells Alice, when she
  1804. 1:10:25asks where this road goes, he tells her
  1805. 1:10:28where she wants to go. She said, "I
  1806. 1:10:30don't know, I'm lost." He says that for
  1807. 1:10:33someone who doesn't know where they're
  1808. 1:10:35going, any road will do, right? Now, if
  1809. 1:10:37I understand that I need to become
  1810. 1:10:40necessary or necessary to other people,
  1811. 1:10:42then I start to find my way, right? At
  1812. 1:10:45that moment, does that pay off from a
  1813. 1:10:47monetary point of view? Not necessarily
  1814. 1:10:50. And how do I support myself, right?
  1815. 1:10:53Well, if you have the ability to seek
  1816. 1:10:55what makes you necessary to another
  1817. 1:10:58person, your sustenance will come,
  1818. 1:11:00right? Because nobody fails to turn to
  1819. 1:11:03those they need.
  1820. 1:11:04Yes. Right? In that sense, even the
  1821. 1:11:06philosophy that my activity, which is
  1822. 1:11:08considered by many people to be useless
  1823. 1:11:10, isn't it? It's something that until
  1824. 1:11:12recently, when someone wanted to tell
  1825. 1:11:14another that they weren't doing
  1826. 1:11:15anything necessary, they would say, "
  1827. 1:11:16That's something a philosopher would
  1828. 1:11:18say." So, one of the enjoyable things
  1829. 1:11:21is even philosophy; technology has
  1830. 1:11:23created something magnificent. Despair,
  1831. 1:11:29boredom, tedium, questions about life.
  1832. 1:11:34And then, who came was locked in her
  1833. 1:11:37room, that old aunt who, imprisoned,
  1834. 1:11:40called philosophy. Then they called her
  1835. 1:11:43in, from there to the street, and then
  1836. 1:11:45to the podcast.
  1837. 1:11:48Applause for Professor Marachar de
  1838. 1:11:49Cartela. Professor, we have a gift for
  1839. 1:11:53you from Cafenar, our sponsor. Okay,
  1840. 1:11:56there's the...
  1841. 1:11:57and it will be taken,
  1842. 1:11:59the super...there's the koala, there's
  1843. 1:12:01the
  1844. 1:12:02Paranaense, the
  1845. 1:12:04sublime, right, sublime, right,
  1846. 1:12:05marvelous. So, first I want to thank
  1847. 1:12:08you for your participation. It was
  1848. 1:12:10stupendous, a word you used a lot,
  1849. 1:12:13stupendous
  1850. 1:12:14all the time.
  1851. 1:12:15All the time. For those at home, all of
  1852. 1:12:17Professor Maro Charles Colotará's
  1853. 1:12:19social media are in the description.
  1854. 1:12:21Obviously, I'm sure you've already been
  1855. 1:12:23impacted by some of his messages, but
  1856. 1:12:24if you don't follow him on any platform
  1857. 1:12:26, this is the invitation, it's
  1858. 1:12:28wonderful. And final considerations, a
  1859. 1:12:30final message for everyone.
  1860. 1:12:32Never, ever wait to say it's too late
  1861. 1:12:37for me. Never. I want that on the day
  1862. 1:12:42we don't meet again, you'll be able to
  1863. 1:12:46say how much I miss you, how much I
  1864. 1:12:48miss you. This applies to me and to you
  1865. 1:12:52. But there's a piece of advice I'm
  1866. 1:12:54giving because it applies to everyone,
  1867. 1:12:55and to me too. And it applies even more
  1868. 1:12:57in the world of technology. My
  1869. 1:12:59grandmother Rosaria, and I'll say this
  1870. 1:13:01everywhere I can. My Italian
  1871. 1:13:04grandmother Rosaria used to say: "
  1872. 1:13:06Anything you can't turn off, don't turn
  1873. 1:13:08on."
  1874. 1:13:10Wow!
  1875. 1:13:13Or can I say a Chinese proverb?
  1876. 1:13:15Invented.
  1877. 1:13:16Say it.
  1878. 1:13:17This one isn't invented. The little
  1879. 1:13:19Chinese one is: never try to ride a
  1880. 1:13:22tiger because once you get on, you
  1881. 1:13:24can't stay on and you can't get off. So
  1882. 1:13:28there's only one decision to make. Ride
  1883. 1:13:30or not. This applies to technology and
  1884. 1:13:32artificial intelligence. Never try to
  1885. 1:13:35mount or ride a tiger. Once on, you
  1886. 1:13:37can't get off or stay on. There's only
  1887. 1:13:41one choice: to ride or not. Okay,
  1888. 1:13:44ladies and gentlemen, you who are
  1889. 1:13:45following our episode, please share,
  1890. 1:13:47comment, like, and follow the channels
  1891. 1:13:50as you have done so. It's a pleasure to
  1892. 1:13:52meet you every week for enjoyable,
  1893. 1:13:53productive, and intelligent
  1894. 1:13:54conversations, with the great goal of
  1895. 1:13:56contributing to your projects. Until
  1896. 1:13:58next week. God bless you and goodbye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Como ENCONTRAR o seu PROPÓSITO DE VIDA? - com Mario Sergio Cortella #112 by Como Você Fez Isso?, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,885 words across 1,896 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.