Communism, Trump, and Leaving the Left | David Horowitz | POLITICS | Rubin Report — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:05is it just me or his internet culture
- 0:06the trolling the outrage and the endless
- 0:08hate starting to eat itself this
- 0:10election obviously brought out the worst
- 0:12in almost everybody from real people to
- 0:15Twitter eggs and Anime avatars people
- 0:17are constantly attacking others online
- 0:20and saying things that they would never
- 0:21dare say to someone's face in real life
- 0:24the really scary part of this though is
- 0:26in the words you guys know I love Free
- 0:28Speech but there seems to be no bottom
- 0:30to this hole of anger just think about
- 0:32your Facebook and Twitter feeds for a
- 0:34moment are they enlightening interesting
- 0:36and bringing joy and goodness to your
- 0:38life or are they an endless Cascade of
- 0:40Rants and RAV psychotic ramblings
- 0:42endless fighting and non-stop virtue
- 0:44signaling I'm going to go out on a limb
- 0:46here and guess that for most of you the
- 0:48answer is the latter not the former and
- 0:50yes there are also a lot of baby
- 0:52pictures on Facebook which can be quite
- 0:54annoying what I think is most
- 0:56interesting about our constant state of
- 0:58bickering isn't the obvious fact that
- 1:00the internet can bring out the worst in
- 1:01all of us but that it seems to me that
- 1:04this Behavior and the reaction to it is
- 1:06now bleeding out into the real world I'm
- 1:08slammed with emails every day in which
- 1:10people explain to me how they're
- 1:12suffering real world consequences for
- 1:14what they post or even what they don't
- 1:16post online people are getting fired
- 1:18over tweets losing friends over Facebook
- 1:21posts and God only knows what's
- 1:23happening on Snapchat but perhaps worse
- 1:25than all of this is the chilling effect
- 1:28that this state of outrage has on the
- 1:30rest of us this is why I've said it
- 1:32before and I'll say it again the biggest
- 1:33threat to free speech is that we are
- 1:36actively silencing ourselves not that
- 1:39the government is silencing us the
- 1:41threat to free speech isn't just that
- 1:43protesters are violent at a Milo event
- 1:46it's the trickle down effect that that
- 1:48has now they're violent at events for
- 1:51people like conservatives and
- 1:52Libertarians such as Ben Shapiro and
- 1:54Charles Murray but of course it won't
- 1:55stop there either eventually they'll
- 1:57come for liberals too while at the same
- 2:00time plenty of other people who just
- 2:02won't want to deal with the threats
- 2:04simply won't accept invitations to speak
- 2:07in the first place the outrage machine
- 2:09will just dull us all down to the point
- 2:11where we won't share any original
- 2:13thought because we just won't want to
- 2:14deal with the repercussions this is
- 2:16exactly what's happening with Trump
- 2:18right now the mainstream media and the
- 2:19Twitter Brigade Go Bananas every time
- 2:22anything happens the result is that
- 2:25people won't be able to gauge the proper
- 2:28outrage if he does do something that
- 2:30truly warrants it yes he eats his steak
- 2:33with ketchup while it is well done that
- 2:35sounds horrible to me but you've got to
- 2:37deal with it remember the boy who cried
- 2:40wolf well now we've got the media who
- 2:42cried Trump you think I'm being alarmist
- 2:44here well do we seem more politically
- 2:47correct or less politically correct than
- 2:495 years ago what about 10 years ago do
- 2:52you find yourself censoring yourself
- 2:54more or less now than you did even last
- 2:58year who is forced ing you to censor
- 3:00yourself is it the government I don't
- 3:02think so I bet you need only look in the
- 3:04mirror and guess what this creep of
- 3:07stifling speech for fear of being
- 3:09ostracized isn't going to magically
- 3:11reverse itself we have to proactively
- 3:14fight it and we should have started this
- 3:16a long time ago take a minute and think
- 3:18about our current television programming
- 3:20could All in the Family arguably the
- 3:22best sitcom in television history with a
- 3:25bigoted yet lovable Archie Bunker
- 3:28possibly be on network tele Vision today
- 3:31the beauty of Archie was that we all
- 3:33know someone like him whether that
- 3:35person is white brown or blue only
- 3:37through seeing these people poking fun
- 3:40at them and showing the shortsightedness
- 3:42of bigotry can we change our society to
- 3:44be more thoughtful and decent for
- 3:46everybody even when I watch Seinfeld
- 3:49with all of its quirky racially based
- 3:51characters jokes about gays women and
- 3:52everyone else I think that the
- 3:54authoritarians will come for the show
- 3:56about nothing which was really a show
- 3:58about everything one day as well well it
- 4:00won't be the government kicking Jerry
- 4:02and the crew off the air it'll be the
- 4:04next generation of social justice
- 4:06Warriors upset about the episode where
- 4:08George wanted a black friend or where
- 4:11Kramer wouldn't wear the AIDS Ribbon or
- 4:13the ones with characters like Ping the
- 4:15Chinese delivery guy or Baboo the
- 4:17Pakistani restaurant tour beyond the
- 4:19outrage machine there is another
- 4:21nefarious layer here which is a whole
- 4:23group of people who get off on the
- 4:26outrage itself this is the group of
- 4:28people who react to anything and
- 4:30everything so to get clicks and
- 4:32ultimately money from our constant state
- 4:34of outrage so when Pewdiepie makes a
- 4:37stupid joke about Jews as he did a
- 4:39couple weeks ago the bigger reaction is
- 4:41from those who want to capitalize on the
- 4:43moment rather than those who are
- 4:45actually outraged by the joke itself
- 4:48then the mainstream media gets involved
- 4:50with the Wall Street Journal writing
- 4:51about the incident which subsequently
- 4:53LED Maker Studios to end their contract
- 4:56with Pewdiepie this destructive force
- 4:58will take any one down who has moved up
- 5:01too far the YouTubers attacking
- 5:03PewDiePie wish they had his 55 million
- 5:06subscribers and the Wall Street Journal
- 5:08sees how his influence believe it or not
- 5:10is now dwarfing their
- 5:12own as online culture gets woven into
- 5:15every facet of Our Lives it's vital we
- 5:17all pick up and choose our spots when to
- 5:20fight and when to be outraged if we're
- 5:22outraged at everything then we're
- 5:24outraged at nothing if we spend all day
- 5:27online trying to find enemies well then
- 5:29guess what enemies will present
- 5:31themselves making some intellectual
- 5:33point over an opponent has value but we
- 5:36have to be careful that the value isn't
- 5:38because of the retweets and the
- 5:40favorites it Garners I'm sure I could be
- 5:42better at some of this myself by the way
- 5:44especially on Twitter trolls are always
- 5:46going to troll but those of us who want
- 5:48to change things for the better have to
- 5:50actually be better ourselves final
- 5:53thought I was a guest on the Alex Jones
- 5:55live show last week as some of you may
- 5:56have seen I'm not even fully familiar
- 5:58with Alex beyond the little bites I see
- 6:00of him screaming and generally going
- 6:02nuts that said the guy has a huge
- 6:04audience and is clearly influential as
- 6:06mainstream media crumbles and online
- 6:08media Rises as I've said before this
- 6:11comes with both positives and negatives
- 6:13but regardless the fact is the guy is
- 6:15talking to a huge amount of people
- 6:17immediately when I got the request to be
- 6:19on the show I thought that I shouldn't
- 6:21do it because of the ton of hate that I
- 6:22was about to get then I realized that if
- 6:24I didn't do the show I would only be
- 6:26holding myself Hostage to the very same
- 6:29ideas which are silencing so many other
- 6:31people right now so I did the show with
- 6:33no preparation or Advanced questioning
- 6:35and Alex let me say what I wanted to say
- 6:38well I got the usual hate from the usual
- 6:40haters just for appearing on the show I
- 6:42also know that I got some of the ideas
- 6:44that I care about to be heard by his
- 6:46large audience now maybe some of them
- 6:49will come here and learn more about the
- 6:50issues that you and I care about if
- 6:52you're one of those new viewers welcome
- 6:54I don't yell as much but I think you'll
- 6:56dig it around here but for the record I
- 6:58do not believe that a secret group of
- 7:01lizzard people are leading a shadow
- 7:02government which is trying to undermine
- 7:04our freedoms obviously it's actually a
- 7:07group of frog men led by Pepe and
- 7:09they're actually a bunch of Freedom
- 7:10Fighters good luck to us
- 7:12[Music]
- 7:16all joining me today is the author of
- 7:18several books and the founder and
- 7:20current president of the David harowitz
- 7:22Freedom Center David harwitz welcome to
- 7:25the Ruben report thank you Dave what are
- 7:26the chances that you ended up being the
- 7:29president of place called The David
- 7:30harwoods Freedom Center that is that is
- 7:31incredible I I actually fought that name
- 7:33but but my board said uh I had I had
- 7:37named it the center for the study of
- 7:39popular
- 7:40culture as a as a leftist I thought it's
- 7:43a very hard to
- 7:44attack a center for studying anything
- 7:48let alone just but conservatives see the
- 7:51word culture and they think left so that
- 7:53and it was just confusing so they made
- 7:56me I said you got to put your name on it
- 7:58so so here we are all right so I don't
- 8:01know in the years that I've been doing
- 8:03this show that I've read anyone's bio
- 8:05and found it more interesting than your
- 8:07bio it was at least not someone that was
- 8:09born in the United States I thought it
- 8:11was just there's so much richness there
- 8:13your Evolution politically it has a lot
- 8:15to do with some of the things that you
- 8:16write about about going from the left to
- 8:18the right and all that um so I want to
- 8:20start with your history first your
- 8:22parents were communist card carrying
- 8:25card carrying not Communists like the
- 8:27Communist that kids that think it's cool
- 8:30today talking old school these are these
- 8:32are people who are part of a a vast
- 8:35International
- 8:36conspiracy orchestrated by Moscow um my
- 8:40parents my my I don't think my mother
- 8:43ever got a traffic ticket they they were
- 8:45very middle class not break the
- 8:47law um but they did hide an East German
- 8:52communist in the basement who the
- 8:54government wanted to
- 8:55deport how did he get to your basement I
- 8:58have no idea I was very very
- 9:00young did you know there was someone
- 9:02down there I mean did you know something
- 9:04was going on deer was his name I forgot
- 9:06the last name his brother was the mayor
- 9:08of East
- 9:09Berlin okay um but um yeah they were
- 9:15very
- 9:16conspiratorial um they never refer to
- 9:20themselves as Communists only as
- 9:22progressives even then because it wasn't
- 9:25a dirty oh it was very dirty it was a
- 9:28dirty word popular healthy period but um
- 9:31because this anti-American left very
- 9:35subversive ready to work with the our
- 9:38enemies so you know a horrible
- 9:41totalitarian dictatorship were
- 9:45effectively
- 9:46quarantined we lived in a kind of ghetto
- 9:49where you couldn't say what you what you
- 9:51believed and that for a Democrat or with
- 9:55a small D for a liberal minded person
- 9:58that doesn't seem right but it was
- 9:59actually
- 10:00healthy given the Cold War at the time
- 10:05so so so what did it mean at you need to
- 10:08have a stigma on people who hate this
- 10:10country and we we've lost that
- 10:12completely so so we'll get to that part
- 10:15CU that really sort of that gets to the
- 10:17evolution part of where you're at now so
- 10:19we were stigmatized and uh but what did
- 10:21they believe like what did that actually
- 10:22mean if you said you were a communist in
- 10:25you know we're talking the 1940s now I
- 10:28nothing my my mother was a registered
- 10:30Democrat um I don't think anything
- 10:33different from certainly not the
- 10:34Democratic party of today although then
- 10:37I mean when Roosevelt was President they
- 10:39were all happy Democrats when
- 10:42Truman um declared that uh America would
- 10:46defend free peoples fighting for their
- 10:49freedom against the Soviet Union they
- 10:51all defected that formed the Progressive
- 10:53Party which was run by the Communist
- 10:55Party yeah and then around 1956 if I'm
- 10:58not mist and all the information comes
- 11:01out about Stalin and then that sort of
- 11:03right that was my way I was 17 at the
- 11:06time and that was my kind of Awakening
- 11:09that everything that the William Buckley
- 11:12who we hated the right that the right
- 11:14said the Right Said Stalin had killed 7
- 11:17million people he actually killed about
- 11:1940 million um and we said was this was
- 11:22all anti-soviet lies the Soviet Union
- 11:25was a a paradise of the future everybody
- 11:29equal everybody working everybody happy
- 11:32all lies but we my community believed
- 11:36them and then kushev came along with
- 11:39this gave a secret speech that the
- 11:41Israeli mosad smuggled
- 11:43out and it just it blew up my community
- 11:47that there were divorces in our that we
- 11:51knew of uh over people dividing over the
- 11:53cruise Trevy Port people felt betrayed
- 11:56they had lived a lie and other people
- 11:59felt you know you continue you go on and
- 12:02they defended it yeah and that that made
- 12:05marriages untenable
- 12:08yeah right you think it's tough now for
- 12:10marriages when people are going I love
- 12:12Trump I hate Trump but but that's that's
- 12:14that's Earth shaking stuff your whole
- 12:16narrative yes so I came into the when I
- 12:20went to college I mean
- 12:22my mission self
- 12:27self-developed um was to rescue the left
- 12:31from
- 12:33stalinism um I still believed in this
- 12:36future where every you know Common uh
- 12:40government ownership of the means of
- 12:41production and equality and everything
- 12:45um and so I I was a fervent new leftist
- 12:49I was one of the actually one of the
- 12:51creators of the new left I was at
- 12:54Berkeley um we published a magazine
- 12:57called wuen branch and uh
- 12:59but by the end of that decade it was
- 13:01clear the left was a totalitarian force
- 13:04it couldn't it it was
- 13:07supporting you know whatever was the ma
- 13:10maoists they were maist ma killed more
- 13:13people in Stalin um and uh so you saw
- 13:18that change from what you thought was
- 13:20something decent you saw that basically
- 13:22anything related to authoritarianism
- 13:24would be sort of pieced into this my my
- 13:27most I had two serious ious deviations I
- 13:30had a nuclear family and everybody else
- 13:33was living in communes or whatever
- 13:37um but the more serious one was that I
- 13:39read books so
- 13:42I I I remember when Billy A's uh was
- 13:45elected vice president when the weather
- 13:47people took over SDS this is a a a
- 13:51college senior he boasted that he hadn't
- 13:54read a book in a year I was horrified as
- 13:56a leftist by that statement
- 13:59um but what was so his argument was what
- 14:01I'm not being programmed by these people
- 14:03no but they no was an irresponsible twit
- 14:07I mean it's you know came from wealth
- 14:10very you know privileged uh I have I
- 14:13have nothing good to say about Billy a
- 14:15but by saying I I haven't read a book in
- 14:17year who is he how is he trying to
- 14:18impress Somebody by that he trying to
- 14:19imp well because the books are written
- 14:22by the ruling class or what what did
- 14:25Mark say the ruling ideas are the uh
- 14:28ideas of ruling class completely false
- 14:31how would you explain our universities
- 14:33today Marx is full of crap I mean that's
- 14:35the first thing you have to yeah well
- 14:37we'll get to our universities don't
- 14:38worry about that but wait a minute the
- 14:39first one you mentioned there was you
- 14:40came from a nuclear family and that was
- 14:42then a problem I had a nuclear family
- 14:44yeah oh you had your own nuclear family
- 14:46at that time okay but you also came from
- 14:48a nuclear by the end of the decade I had
- 14:50four children yeah yeah so why was that
- 14:52a problem for them because they want uh
- 14:54they didn't I wasn't expelled from the
- 14:56left I I I was
- 14:59um well what happened to me was that I I
- 15:04I edited ramp Parts which was the
- 15:07leading it was the biggest magazine of
- 15:08the left and a Hollywood
- 15:12producer producer of easy
- 15:14Ryder um was a
- 15:16big uh funer and sponsor of the Black
- 15:20Panther Party and he he introduced me to
- 15:23huie Newton because he wanted me to take
- 15:26Eldridge Cleaver had been on our Mast
- 15:28head uh and Eldridge there was a war it
- 15:31was basically a black panther party is a
- 15:35a street gang and uh this was a contest
- 15:39for leadership um so he
- 15:44um he introduced me and I I got involved
- 15:48raising money for the Panthers I raised
- 15:50for a
- 15:51school um I was very impressed they had
- 15:54a lot of children and the panther party
- 15:56was a mix there were you know genuinely
- 15:59good people and there were
- 16:01gangsters um and the good people
- 16:04impressed me and uh one of them was
- 16:06running the
- 16:07school a school and they were jammed
- 16:12into a uh Brown Shingle House in uh in
- 16:17Oakland I mean they they had
- 16:19double-decker beds from one wall to the
- 16:21other wow for the kids so
- 16:23I um I thought this Hollywood producer
- 16:27would give me the money but it it didn't
- 16:29turn out that way but I
- 16:31raised I think it was
- 16:33$125,000 which a lot of money in those
- 16:35days and bought a
- 16:37church a Baptist Church in East Oakland
- 16:40that had been overtaken by the uh inner
- 16:43city was a white Baptist Church and I
- 16:47and I I signed up the check um I created
- 16:50the Oakland Community Learning Center of
- 16:53501c3 to house the school I'll never
- 16:56forget the uh the minister said to me as
- 16:59I handed him the check I hope you're not
- 17:01going to turn this over to the Black
- 17:04Panthers or the Nation of
- 17:07Islam did he know who that you were
- 17:09working with them at all at the time
- 17:11with the Black Panthers he had no idea
- 17:12so he was literally joking to you like
- 17:15most of the left today I had no idea who
- 17:17they were the Panthers MH um but anyway
- 17:22I've told this story in a radical son my
- 17:24autobiography anyway in in uh 1974 I
- 17:29recruited the bookkeeper my bookkeeper
- 17:32at ramparts to do the books for the
- 17:33school because I believed our own
- 17:36propaganda that the government was
- 17:38racist and that they would shut down the
- 17:40Panthers if they didn't keep the books
- 17:44which was ridiculous I mean look at
- 17:46Jesse Jackson look at Al Sharpton I mean
- 17:48he's a huge tax Vader yeah and he's
- 17:53walking the streets because he's
- 17:54Progressive in Black he's
- 17:56protected um and in December 1974 uh
- 18:01Betty disappeared and by the time the
- 18:03police fished her body out of San
- 18:05Francisco Bay I knew the Panthers had
- 18:07killed her I had been interviewed by the
- 18:09police they explained to me lots of
- 18:11things very difficult to hire to dispose
- 18:14of a body unless you have an
- 18:17organization and then it's not so hard
- 18:19you have safe houses and this and that
- 18:22um and so when that happened um I was
- 18:26personally devastated I mean I was in
- 18:29the same place my parents were being
- 18:31embarrassed by the cruise d report
- 18:34something I swore that would never
- 18:36happen to me
- 18:38um and I I I'm curious were your parents
- 18:40around at the time yeah my mother was
- 18:42very they were worried for my safety as
- 18:45they should be I was threatened by
- 18:46Elaine Brown who was the head of the
- 18:48Panthers and is alive today um toasted
- 18:53by the Atlanta Journal Constitution and
- 18:56uh funded by actually conservatives uh
- 19:00often not always to speak on college
- 19:04campuses um she was the head of the
- 19:06party uh wait why would conservatives
- 19:09fund her now has she evolved I forget
- 19:11that what's the name of this a big
- 19:12Orange County Foundation they gave her
- 19:14$10,000 to speak at uh I can't remember
- 19:18it was UC Santa Barbara h i with the
- 19:21students there informed me now because
- 19:25uh uh conservatives in this country are
- 19:28are are well-meaning
- 19:29uh liberal-minded people generally
- 19:33especially the ones with money um give
- 19:36you the benefit of the doubt I mean
- 19:38here's a black person claiming that
- 19:40America is an oppressive country oh sure
- 19:42here has some
- 19:46money
- 19:47anyway
- 19:49uh I was personally devastated I was
- 19:53clinically I would say clinically
- 19:54depressed for seven or eight years I me
- 19:57I wake up in tears every morning I felt
- 20:00responsible for having recruited Betty
- 20:03uh her name was Betty Vamp patter the
- 20:05woman who was murdered she was a mother
- 20:07of three
- 20:08children
- 20:10um the ideology is so pernicious that on
- 20:14the way to the to Betty's funeral her
- 20:17daughter who worked for me and was I
- 20:19don't know if she was 19 or 20 at the
- 20:21time I tried to warn her I mean I was
- 20:23afraid for my children but I said I
- 20:26think the Panthers killed your mother
- 20:29and her response was no they're good
- 20:32people so so I set out then to
- 20:37warn when I had sort of assimilated all
- 20:42this uh I I'm my mission was to warn
- 20:46other
- 20:46people and that's how I know that Barack
- 20:49Obama is a communist all right so wait
- 20:52let's let's pause before we jump to to
- 20:54modern day because everything that you
- 20:56just described there was why I thought
- 20:57your bio was so interesting cuz you grow
- 20:59up with Communists you know I didn't
- 21:01know about the guy I I didn't know about
- 21:03the guy in the basement but you I mean
- 21:04you you are firmly on the left your
- 21:06whole first 40 some ideas I was a Marx I
- 21:09wrote a book called Empire and
- 21:11Revolution which the left used right so
- 21:13leftist communist Marxist I mean so yeah
- 21:17Paul Berman for
- 21:18example
- 21:20um said of the of my book that it was
- 21:24like a I don't know what he said a
- 21:25handbook a Bible of for the for the left
- 21:29before he called me a
- 21:31renegade for leaving the left right
- 21:34right so that's so you're you're a hero
- 21:37but the second you now change now of
- 21:39course if you deviate from the Party
- 21:41Line This is what political people don't
- 21:44realize political correctness is a term
- 21:46that mousy dong the greatest mass
- 21:48murderer in human history invented to
- 21:50shut people up it's the party line if
- 21:53you deviate from the party line they
- 21:55throw you into the cold yeah all right
- 21:58so now
- 21:59let's Flash Forward unless there's
- 22:00something major or shoot you right so
- 22:03they first they silence you then they
- 22:05shoot you and you know uh so unless I'm
- 22:07missing something I think we can Flash
- 22:09Forward now to around 85 which is really
- 22:11when you then right um what happened was
- 22:15when this happened I was writing I I had
- 22:19um left ramp Parts with Peter ker who
- 22:23was my
- 22:25buddy uh and it was Peter's idea that to
- 22:29write a a a dynastic
- 22:33biography uh the The galsworthy Saga was
- 22:36on PBS at the time or so it was a
- 22:40generational Saga so I was in the midst
- 22:43of writing a book on the Rockefellers
- 22:45which became a bestseller and then we
- 22:48were asked to do a book on the
- 22:50Kennedy which came out
- 22:52in
- 22:551985 and uh in 198 and and uh
- 22:59at when it came out it was a number one
- 23:01New York Times
- 23:03bestseller and uh the Washington Post
- 23:06the editor of the Washington Post Sunday
- 23:08magazine called
- 23:09me to pick my brain about young Joe
- 23:13Kennedy it was a congressman and he said
- 23:16what have you guys been doing I oh you
- 23:18won't believe this but Peter and I just
- 23:20voted for Ronald Reagan and neither
- 23:22Peter and I had talked before casting
- 23:25that boat wow oh that's a good story you
- 23:28want to WR it so our story was better
- 23:30Ron than red but he renamed it lefties
- 23:33for Reagan right so then and that's when
- 23:35the knives came out and Peter said to me
- 23:37at the time I just show you how deep
- 23:41the current rot the fake news
- 23:45is um we were Front Page New York Times
- 23:48MH both books both the Rockefellers and
- 23:52Sunday times and the New York Times sets
- 23:54the standard for all the media they even
- 23:57reprint print the reviews but
- 24:01um and when our article came out on we
- 24:05voted for Reagan Peter said to me our
- 24:09literary careers are over wow I said you
- 24:12must be joking I me so you really had no
- 24:15idea IDE even though you knew some of
- 24:18the tactics OB but it was exactly right
- 24:20that was the end I don't my last 20
- 24:23books have the New York Times They
- 24:26noticed one and called me a relic for
- 24:28using the word
- 24:30communist it was just a squib right so
- 24:34even though you knew all the tactics
- 24:36that could be coming down your way and
- 24:37the way you'd be treated I've never been
- 24:39a realist about that that's so you so
- 24:41that's it you just weren't a realist in
- 24:42your own even though you saw you had
- 24:44such a history of seeing what would
- 24:46happen yeah not that parents than
- 24:47communism black p I can never believe
- 24:50that people um can be you know so
- 24:53ideological and so duped and I should
- 24:55know yeah I think I'm suffering from a
- 24:56little of this right now when I'm the
- 24:58rubbers meeting the road with me at the
- 24:59moment of of this kind but what was it
- 25:02about was it something about rean or was
- 25:04it really about Mand Reagan yeah it was
- 25:08uh this happened earlier um I bumped
- 25:11into into the parking lot of the
- 25:13Berkeley Co-op uh which is a supermarket
- 25:17that was we everybody liked because it
- 25:19was a
- 25:20Cooperative um when uh Rolling Stone
- 25:24actually published a story that Peter
- 25:26and I did on the weather the Weather
- 25:27Underground
- 25:29telling the truth about it um and
- 25:33uh this woman I knew met me in the
- 25:36parking lot she said David you know
- 25:37people really hate you
- 25:41now truth about these crazy terrorists
- 25:45is what they were who got people
- 25:48killed and they hate you now they hate
- 25:50you they hate me for for saying the
- 25:53truth about it yeah but but what was it
- 25:55about Reagan also that then they hat in
- 25:58the way they hate Trump yeah it was the
- 26:00same kind of
- 26:03hatred they pick out they just hate it's
- 26:06it's because he's he's not one of
- 26:09us it's it's very visceral yeah is that
- 26:13what it more than anything ironic for
- 26:15the media he's not one of them you know
- 26:16he was an act and you
- 26:18know I don't
- 26:20know the the
- 26:22Trump phenomenon and problem is a little
- 26:25different but it's it's not all that
- 26:27different I mean Reagan was an actor
- 26:30that they looked down on that
- 26:32um you know um vanon Mei wrote a
- 26:36pamphlet called the uh an essay which is
- 26:39a pamphlet called the anti-c capitalist
- 26:43mentality why do academics um hate
- 26:48capitalism why are they so left and the
- 26:52answer is because they feel Superior to
- 26:55businessmen and here's Trump the
- 26:56businessman MH uh businessmen are
- 27:00yahoos they have no respect for what it
- 27:03takes to build a billion dooll Empire
- 27:06for them it's all theft or something
- 27:09underhanded it's it's theft or it's
- 27:10crony capitalism or something Reagan was
- 27:13like that he was an actor how dare he be
- 27:15pres we're so much smarter than he is we
- 27:18should be running the country so
- 27:21intellectuals I think it was about
- 27:22intellectuals generally they don't they
- 27:25they feel that they're smarter than
- 27:26everybody else right cuz they haven't
- 27:28actually created for the most part so
- 27:30they have to sort of elevate they want
- 27:32the P they think the power should go to
- 27:34them and I learned very early when I was
- 27:37still a leftist when Jack Kennedy was
- 27:39assassinated and Lyndon Johnson became
- 27:42president I was living in England and of
- 27:43course Europeans looked at on Americans
- 27:46from the beginning of the Republic but
- 27:51um LBJ he had the LBJ cufflinks and the
- 27:55LBJ children and the LBJ dog dos and the
- 28:00you know so they they just thought he
- 28:03was this is a yahoo this is a you
- 28:07know and Johnson was much smarter than
- 28:10Jack
- 28:11Kennedy he he went to East Texas State
- 28:14teachers college but he imp he
- 28:17unfortunately he put in place the Great
- 28:19Society which is an albatross on
- 28:22America's neck has been for low these
- 28:26this half century but but he was smart
- 28:29he knew how to get it through Congress
- 28:32and Jack Kennedy couldn't get any of it
- 28:33through yeah and now Congress barely
- 28:35works so that's why when Trump came
- 28:38along I I wasn't one of these never
- 28:41trumping inside the Beltway snobs
- 28:44although some of my my good friends went
- 28:47down that path okay so you you have this
- 28:50this final Awakening you write this
- 28:52thing then a year later I think in ' 86
- 28:54you wrote why it was it why I left the
- 28:56left I wrote and I say look I as I say I
- 29:01I I I was personally threatened by
- 29:03Elaine Brown um and then in a I have the
- 29:08tape of the phone conversation which she
- 29:11said if you if you should get run over
- 29:15David really I'm I'm I'm going to be
- 29:18your best friend because people will say
- 29:20I did it something like that I mean it
- 29:22was a nak a threat um so I was
- 29:26afraid uh I fed to Kate Coleman who
- 29:30wrote an article for a now defunct
- 29:33leftwing
- 29:34magazine uh it's called the party over
- 29:37about the criminality of the Panthers
- 29:39which I had discovered by personal
- 29:42investigation
- 29:45um uh but uh
- 29:49uh I forgot well get getting to the
- 29:51Village Voice piece oh The Village Voice
- 29:54yeah so I finally in 1986 which is it's
- 29:58a decade later I wrote a piece why I am
- 30:01not no longer a
- 30:03leftist and uh and referred to this I
- 30:07did not name The Killers but I did refer
- 30:10to the murder and the pan that the
- 30:12Panthers had murdered her and
- 30:16um Paul Burman wrote this piece uh about
- 30:21the Renegade harowitz the intellectual
- 30:23life and the Renegade harowitz that was
- 30:25a vicious attack mhm and uh he had me at
- 30:28the end of his piece cheering on sua who
- 30:32was a psychopath that was a contra in
- 30:36Nicaragua whom I hadn't even heard of
- 30:38when he called me he said in Hart his
- 30:40cheering wakes up the next morning
- 30:42cheering sua so basically you you went
- 30:44off the reservation officially with this
- 30:46article and then you had said the knives
- 30:48were already out no it was with the
- 30:50Reagan article yeah with the Reagan
- 30:52article was the this one was this is
- 30:54right this is right at the left right so
- 30:57this was a what it was a year later
- 30:58right I think it was 85 and ' 86 so a
- 31:00year later so the knives were already
- 31:01out and then this was like sort of the
- 31:03final door on that's right and that's so
- 31:051986 87 that's like 30 years ago is that
- 31:08what it is something like that in 30
- 31:11years my work has never been taken the
- 31:15work the the ideas my arguments with the
- 31:18left why I'm no long I wrote a long
- 31:21essay on on leaving the left um and why
- 31:25I left it uh
- 31:29never uh responded to the nation made
- 31:33one stab at it but not a very good
- 31:36one on the other hand there's like
- 31:38100,000 attacks on me on the internet
- 31:41from leftist so it's not like they don't
- 31:43think that I need to be refuted they
- 31:46think it's just more effective to
- 31:48pretend he well if it makes you feel any
- 31:49better right before we sat down I was
- 31:50scrolling my Twitter feed and some
- 31:52article was written about me where they
- 31:53referred to me as a right-winger and
- 31:55then got a few other things incorrect
- 31:56about me and then my own audience
- 31:59actually started attacking them on
- 32:01Twitter and then they they didn't issue
- 32:03a retraction but they changed the
- 32:04headline at least and change one other
- 32:06thing which of course is not
- 32:07journalistically uh sound but I guess
- 32:10maybe I'm picking up some of the well at
- 32:13first it hurts but eventually you you
- 32:15get to be liel proof they they liel you
- 32:18so much that it just seems ridiculous
- 32:20more than anything else it's just lazy
- 32:22lazy and ridiculous well you you know
- 32:24I'm an easier Target than you are
- 32:27because I vowed when I left the left
- 32:29that I was going to talk to the left
- 32:31address them in the same way that they
- 32:33address everybody else though oh I talk
- 32:36to them nicely yeah you
- 32:39very very hard to demonize I'm sort of
- 32:42easy so when you see you you had some
- 32:46nice things to say about me when you sat
- 32:47down and when you see someone like me
- 32:49that's understands the title of this
- 32:51book that understands your journey and
- 32:53all that do you think I was just even
- 32:55though obviously we have 30 some IDE
- 32:57years between us that I was just late to
- 32:59the game and picking up what was going
- 33:01on here or do you think something also
- 33:03happened in the last couple years with
- 33:04the
- 33:05left two things first of all starting
- 33:09with the McGovern campaign that's when
- 33:11it started the Communist left
- 33:14infiltrated and took over the Democratic
- 33:17party um I mean Tom
- 33:20Hayden who is no longer with us uh was a
- 33:24cynical
- 33:26anti-American lying
- 33:29radical uh and he was given the medal of
- 33:31freedom by Bill Clinton um uh he was a u
- 33:37state legislator in the state of
- 33:39California you can still see his work
- 33:41whenever you see prop 65 that warns you
- 33:44about the bad effects of chemicals and
- 33:48your whatever oh yeah it's everywhere
- 33:49here in
- 33:51La um but the Democratic party took the
- 33:55left
- 33:56in the
- 33:58the anti the anti-American
- 34:02totalitarian and I would say racist left
- 34:04I will explain that more later but
- 34:06racist left was taken into the bosom of
- 34:09the democratic party in the Clinton
- 34:12Administration and with Obama they got
- 34:14one of theirs in the White House okay so
- 34:17let so let's pause there for a second so
- 34:19when I hear you say that about the
- 34:20Clinton Administration that's hard for
- 34:21me to picture because those eight years
- 34:24were
- 34:25basically I don't think we saw a lot lot
- 34:27of what we're seeing right now so what
- 34:29what am I missing well you missed the
- 34:31you didn't know the personalities uh
- 34:33from one um I've written a uh let's put
- 34:38it this way I think back to the Clinton
- 34:39Administration very fondly still that
- 34:41things were basically they were terrible
- 34:43that they were basically first of all
- 34:45let's let's Bill
- 34:47Clinton's was is not an ideologue in the
- 34:49way that Hillary Clinton is Bill
- 34:51Clinton's idology was
- 34:53Mah it was his
- 34:55ideology and but that you would argue
- 34:57that's probably a Saving Grace then in
- 34:59this corruption is far better than
- 35:01communism
- 35:03yeah if it weren't for the corruption of
- 35:06the clintons Bernie Sanders would have
- 35:07been a
- 35:09nominee um that's a great quote there
- 35:12did you just quote corruption is far
- 35:13better than communism that's a good one
- 35:15it is it is because you you can deal
- 35:17with it doesn't have the ideology that
- 35:19sweeps people along with it Bill Clinton
- 35:21domestically was a fairly Centrist uh
- 35:25you know I don't have too much to
- 35:26quarrel with him
- 35:28there uh uh on foreign policy was
- 35:32terrible absolutely terrible the World
- 35:34Trade Center was blown up in uh
- 35:371993 uh by Ramsey Yousef he intended to
- 35:41kill 50,000 people or 200,000 to top of
- 35:45one of the towers on the other the bomb
- 35:47is fired it wounded a thousand people it
- 35:50killed six Bill Clinton never visited
- 35:53the
- 35:53site dismissed it as an individual
- 35:56criminal act when it was inspired by the
- 35:59blind Sheik who just
- 36:01been um Osama Bin Laden we should have
- 36:05been stopped in the 90s before the World
- 36:08Trade Center was I I can go I've written
- 36:11a lot about this so Bill but in the case
- 36:14of that in the case of the the First
- 36:15World Trade Center bombing so what do
- 36:16you think was going on then in Bill
- 36:18Clinton's head when so this happens he
- 36:20never visited what is what's the
- 36:22ideology there that would lead him to
- 36:24that it's an interesting question I wish
- 36:26we had a um one of these Democrats on
- 36:29and you could ask them the question um I
- 36:33I'll try to get a former Adra just to
- 36:36skip ahead uh in this book I've written
- 36:40big agenda I I lay out what I think is
- 36:43going on that that uh the Democratic
- 36:46party is now a racist
- 36:48party uh if you use the the phrase
- 36:51people of color is a racist phrase
- 36:54identity politics is racist and it's
- 36:57anti American the fundamental American
- 37:00idea is that we're all creatures of a
- 37:05Divinity or maybe Nature's God whatever
- 37:08Jefferson wrote there um and equal in
- 37:13the eyes of our creator therefore we
- 37:15should be treated equally by our
- 37:17government and we have rights that are
- 37:20inalienable that government can't take
- 37:23away so it's all about individual
- 37:26freedom and most most importantly
- 37:28individual
- 37:30accountability when I was a kid in in
- 37:32public schools we
- 37:35always uh there was this phrase
- 37:38regardless of race color or
- 37:41Creed um an American is somebody who
- 37:45doesn't look at your Origins We're a
- 37:47nation of immigrants that way don't look
- 37:49at your origins of course if you come
- 37:51from a terrorist
- 37:54country we maybe we should have a
- 37:58a little betting process yeah
- 38:01um identity politics is the opposite
- 38:05what the left seeks the we are in a
- 38:07civil war situation now um and the
- 38:11reason is the reason it's so
- 38:13irreconcilable is that the left believe
- 38:16is a is racist it believes in a racial
- 38:18hierarchy so if you're the right skin
- 38:21color which is dark you go to the head
- 38:23of the line for admissions to college
- 38:25you go to the head of the line for job
- 38:26you go to the head line for a promotion
- 38:29you go to the headle line for almost
- 38:31anything everything's not diverse enough
- 38:34so we'll take
- 38:35anybody um so what would you say to the
- 38:37people that would say well white people
- 38:39had it good for a long time and and yeah
- 38:41and white people bad things and they did
- 38:44good things and one of the good things
- 38:45that white America did was to liberate
- 38:48the slaves people forget that we
- 38:50inherited
- 38:52slavery uh this is how I made myself
- 38:55notorious in the left by coming out
- 38:57against reparations for slavery 137
- 39:00years after the
- 39:02fact um America inherited a system of
- 39:05slavery slavery existed I learned this
- 39:07from Orlando Patterson who is a black
- 39:10left of
- 39:11center um sociologist at Harvard who's
- 39:14written prizewinning books on slavery
- 39:17and
- 39:18freedom slavery existed for 3,000 years
- 39:22nobody ever said it was immoral not
- 39:24Jesus not Moses not Aristotle
- 39:27until a white Christian males in England
- 39:31led by Wilbur Force said it's immoral
- 39:34and an American slave owner Thomas
- 39:36Jefferson wrote it into the birth
- 39:38certificate of this country that all men
- 39:41are created equal in a given right to
- 39:44Liberty by their creator within 20 years
- 39:47the slave trade was ended um the reason
- 39:51that America didn't initiate a Civil War
- 39:55in 1776 to free the slaves one of the
- 39:59biggest reasons was that England would
- 40:02have come and just retaken the colonies
- 40:04and reinstituted
- 40:06um slavery anyway and within a
- 40:08generation or a little more given in
- 40:11those days people lived shorter
- 40:13lives uh at the cost of uh
- 40:16350,000 Union Soldiers we liberated the
- 40:19slaves and liberated them throughout the
- 40:22hemisphere so black people Americans can
- 40:26be very proud proud of their Heritage um
- 40:29you know it's it's a human Heritage so
- 40:32it's got a lot of bad spots but you look
- 40:34at any other country in the world and uh
- 40:37forgive me lepus for saying
- 40:39this this one is the
- 40:42best what other country du Asians get in
- 40:45boats and risk their lives to get into
- 40:48you think they're coming here to be
- 40:49oppressed right I mean everybody
- 40:51everybody wants want to be here and then
- 40:53the funny thing is this at the same time
- 40:55you go to watch some of these protests
- 40:57and the people that are screaming about
- 40:58how racist and evil and patriarchy and
- 41:00all this stuff they're also the ones
- 41:02calling for open borders they want
- 41:03everyone to share in the horror that is
- 41:05well just destroy the country as anybody
- 41:07with any sense knows so how it's all but
- 41:09let me just say yeah the left is is it
- 41:15it's owes whatever ideas it has to Marx
- 41:19it's the Marxist Paradigm of the
- 41:21oppressors and the oppressed and it's an
- 41:24economic it begins as an economic and
- 41:26they've layered on race and gender um so
- 41:31but the fact is what determines a
- 41:34country's Prosperity is culture not
- 41:38classes it's culture America has a great
- 41:41culture we take in I one of the things
- 41:44we do is we take in brilliant people
- 41:46from all over the world and uh give them
- 41:49freedom to innovate other countries copy
- 41:53our Innovations Israel is the same way
- 41:55it's why they hate it
- 41:58because they're bringing in people from
- 42:00all over the world giving them
- 42:01opportunity BR but but also it's the
- 42:03freedom yeah people do not appreciate
- 42:06freedom in this country obviously since
- 42:08we our universities are now totalitarian
- 42:11institutions I can't go to a university
- 42:13without bodyguards yeah and that's been
- 42:17true for the last 15 years I've been
- 42:20physically attack if I didn't have
- 42:23bodyguards and if the university didn't
- 42:24put in place security I could never get
- 42:27through a speech yeah and I'm not alone
- 42:29it's any conservative no it's all
- 42:31virtually any conservative and it's and
- 42:32now it's moderates and this is fascism
- 42:35and it's it's totally embedded in our
- 42:38University system yeah do you make a
- 42:40distinction between sort of the leaders
- 42:42who really understand the stuff that
- 42:44you're talking about so the people who
- 42:46who are the leaders of this leftist
- 42:48movement versus the the bulk of the
- 42:51people who I think are following along
- 42:54without bad intentions like when I see
- 42:56all these kids who I you know I mock
- 42:58them on Twitter course people go to
- 42:59demonstrations to get laid
- 43:02Yeah Yeah you know and people are
- 43:04gullible and they don't think and they
- 43:06can't put two and two together the
- 43:09phrase I didn't want to skip this people
- 43:12of color is a racist phrase It's not
- 43:17English do we say here's a box of
- 43:20crayons of color it's French that's the
- 43:23way French people speak Purp or whatever
- 43:27they say yeah so it's a completely
- 43:30ideological construct what is its
- 43:33function well let's look at the Mexico
- 43:37two main ethnic
- 43:39groups the descendants of the Spanish
- 43:42conquistadors who slaughtered the
- 43:43indigenous Indians and the descendants
- 43:45of the indigenous Indians when they
- 43:48cross the border they're both people of
- 43:50color therefore they're oppressed both
- 43:51of them the
- 43:53Conquistadors and the indigenous people
- 43:55they're oppressed they deserve special
- 43:58sensitivities and special privileges
- 44:01maharajas in India are people of color
- 44:05beheaders in raqqa are people of color
- 44:09who aren't people of color white people
- 44:11yeah white people are evil bad this is a
- 44:14most this is this is the racist ideology
- 44:18of our time is it also lacking in
- 44:21several other ways I mean for example
- 44:22you could take American Indians uh
- 44:25people who've moved here from India or
- 44:27their grandparents moved here from India
- 44:28or you could take Asian people of
- 44:30virtually any nationality and they don't
- 44:33count in this leftist thing because they
- 44:36economically well the Indians haven't
- 44:39yeah the Native Americans I'm sorry I
- 44:41that was a
- 44:42ridiculous now I'm gonna we're not going
- 44:45to edit that out because I don't believe
- 44:46in that but that was an completely
- 44:47idiotic statement I me I meant American
- 44:50Indians from India who moved to America
- 44:52not Native Americans correct yeah
- 44:55correct Chinese the Japanese American
- 44:57Indians not Native Americans thank you
- 44:59for that's correct I just ruined my
- 45:01course they don't like success minor you
- 45:05you don't don't look over your
- 45:07shoulder there's only arrows there's
- 45:09only arrows
- 45:11coming um Indian joke right there yeah I
- 45:14mean the the
- 45:17left is is pathetic intellectually they
- 45:21don't have an argument so they have to
- 45:23purge those groups because those groups
- 45:25yeah that's why they have to shut you up
- 45:26because they can't deal with your
- 45:28arguments it's really simple
- 45:30straightforward and and it so invaded
- 45:32our literary culture the last two
- 45:34national book awards were given to
- 45:36racist tracks won by tanahi coats I can
- 45:40never remember the title um was it just
- 45:44a rank racist coats uh what what
- 45:49inspired him to write the book it's
- 45:50about how evil America is but how how
- 45:54was the murder of his friend not the
- 45:56murder
- 45:57the killing of his friend by a policeman
- 45:59in
- 46:00Maryland it turns out as he tells you
- 46:04that the policeman the policeman accused
- 46:07uh the Dead uh his dead friend of trying
- 46:10to run him over with his
- 46:12car the policeman is black so how what
- 46:16does coat say he was thinking white now
- 46:19if that isn't the purest racism yeah and
- 46:22this one now it's called stamp from the
- 46:24beginning it's a semil literate book
- 46:27that that it I mean that that they have
- 46:29lowered their
- 46:30standards so dramatically as
- 46:33a it still shocks me because these are
- 46:36intelligent people that people who give
- 46:38the awards but I should know better um
- 46:41but it opens with uh the police
- 46:44shootings of criminals in the last year
- 46:48which were totally distorted by black
- 46:51lives matter and other leftists into
- 46:54cops gunning down unarmed black these
- 46:57were predators and who did they pray
- 46:59pray on they prayed on black people
- 47:02Freddy gray I
- 47:04mean you know you could go on uh I can't
- 47:07even remember the names a guy in
- 47:09Ferguson
- 47:10um they're criminals who pre on black
- 47:14people but this guy has them as innocent
- 47:17blacks who are gunned down by racist
- 47:19cops so at the opening of his book which
- 47:21is which he has called the definitive
- 47:24history of racism in America he's
- 47:26exposes a liar and he won a national
- 47:28book award so our institutions have been
- 47:31just generally corrupted yeah so what is
- 47:35by This Racist ideology of the left so
- 47:38for a lot of people hearing this I think
- 47:39a certain amount of people hearing this
- 47:40are going to go yeah I get it see you
- 47:42don't talk quite like this which is why
- 47:44I think you're much harder to uh I'm I'm
- 47:47I I want to see you with a uh a
- 47:50so-called liberal I don't call them
- 47:52liberals cuz they're bigots yeah well
- 47:54I've had many Progressive progressives
- 47:56on this show and I treat them with the
- 47:57same respect that I treat anybody else I
- 48:00I my general rule is I don't find that
- 48:02Bering somebody or belittling them but
- 48:05yeah as I say I made this vow 30 30
- 48:08years ago that I was going to berate the
- 48:11left I was going to take hey hey LBJ how
- 48:14many kids did you kill today I actually
- 48:17when I was still sort of leaving the
- 48:18left I thought about that statement a
- 48:21lot saying let's see if I were a
- 48:24prisoner of war and I was in a room with
- 48:27my captor would I rather it was LBJ or
- 48:31hoi Min and it was a
- 48:35no-brainer so that's part of it is that
- 48:37you just constantly say the worst thing
- 48:39about your intellectual opponents
- 48:41because there's no end here that you
- 48:43just just constantly say anything to you
- 48:47and that's why I love Milo CU he just
- 48:49throws it right back in there face and
- 48:52that's what really needs to be done
- 48:53these people need to be embarrassed
- 48:55although I probably beond embarrassment
- 48:58yeah I I mean uh ABC
- 49:01News Stephanopoulos is sitting there
- 49:03with Katrina abon who who whose entire
- 49:06life has been spent apologizing for
- 49:09defending and uh advancing communist
- 49:11causes the hell is that that's
- 49:15ABC that's how far gone this country is
- 49:18so are all the answers then for you on
- 49:21the right or do you have frustrations
- 49:23with the right because I think right
- 49:24before we started we only talked for
- 49:25about 30 seconds think you said
- 49:27something liberal i' I tried to
- 49:31um no I mean I I I you know what did I
- 49:37oh I I took on the leaders of the
- 49:40religious right um
- 49:43over uh Mark R rasc uh was the governor
- 49:47of Montana and was the chairman of the
- 49:49RNC met with the I think it's called The
- 49:52Human Rights Association which is a gay
- 49:55group and he
- 49:57addressed them or whatever met with them
- 50:00and he was denounced by Paul wrick and
- 50:04very well-known leaders of the religious
- 50:06right and I wrote an article I saying
- 50:09that um a political party is not a
- 50:11religious movement or shouldn't be and
- 50:15uh it's the job of the RNC chair to
- 50:17reach out yeah and and so forth and I've
- 50:22never been an opponent of gay marriage
- 50:24and I you know I could go on and on yeah
- 50:28and you you mentioned before that
- 50:30abortion although you you're not a fan
- 50:33to say the least but you are pro-choice
- 50:35right so no I wouldn't describe myself
- 50:37as pro-choice I I I um and it's been a
- 50:42long lifetime of rethinking this issue
- 50:45when I grew up uh abortions
- 50:50were uh illegal after the third
- 50:54month and we know a lot lot more now and
- 50:59medical techniques well well we just
- 51:01know a lot more about fetuses um and you
- 51:04know there they're if you think about it
- 51:06they're children from conception I mean
- 51:08I just it's not an argument there's a
- 51:11person
- 51:12already um you think from the moment of
- 51:14yeah and the woman it's not about the
- 51:17woman's body
- 51:18alone uh you know I I think the fathers
- 51:23are involved as well but certainly
- 51:25there's a child there
- 51:27so you know the argument against it is
- 51:29you want to bring a kid into the world
- 51:31that's going to have a absolutely
- 51:33miserable life because it's a wrong
- 51:35parent at the wrong time you know and I
- 51:37I I think the energy should be spent
- 51:40on finding ways to take care of of
- 51:43children that their parents aren't able
- 51:45to take care of it's a very vexed
- 51:48problem yeah and I
- 51:50don't I've I've confronted uh
- 51:53right-wingers actually within the
- 51:54Heritage Foundation debate
- 51:57you know who said it's murder I said
- 51:59well if you think it's murder then you
- 52:01should be demanding the execution of
- 52:03every mother in America is that an
- 52:04abortion and if you don't it's a much
- 52:06more complicated problem so that's kind
- 52:09of where I am what was his response to
- 52:11that and shut him up that that gets him
- 52:14real quiet well that's why the abortion
- 52:15one to me is is one where I think very
- 52:18good people on both sides of this are
- 52:20just struggling with it's because it
- 52:22almost is coming down to the basic
- 52:23questions of life and it is but but you
- 52:26can't discuss basic questions in our
- 52:28political atmosphere not with the left I
- 52:31me the left wants to convert everything
- 52:32into a morality play where they're right
- 52:35how much of this is culture did you see
- 52:37that change too that it's just I know
- 52:40you're saying the culture is the most
- 52:41important thing but when did it go from
- 52:43like I I was thinking even this morning
- 52:45left started taking over the
- 52:46universities in the 70s now they they've
- 52:49got the K12 schools as well um and you
- 52:54know I conducted a was five or sixy Year
- 52:58campaign to try to get a an academic
- 53:00Bill of Rights really a student Bill of
- 53:02Rights that students have a right to a
- 53:05professional education and in a
- 53:07democracy that means that they uh
- 53:10professors can express their opinions
- 53:12but they have to present the opposing
- 53:14sides of controversial issues in a
- 53:16fair-minded way and I was attacked from
- 53:20one end of the country the other is a
- 53:22torada and a th controller was very
- 53:25liberal and I did it all out of their
- 53:27own documents there's a very famous
- 53:30academic freedom statement that was
- 53:32drawn up what's the Thought control part
- 53:34of trying to get more thought in there
- 53:36don't you know it can't be logical with
- 53:38the
- 53:39leftist this is the a these are
- 53:43stalinists I mean I debated them across
- 53:45the country they gosh I mean they they
- 53:48put me through the ringer but you know
- 53:49like I say you get to a point where
- 53:51you're liel prooof because they've
- 53:53libeled you so much that it does doesn't
- 53:55have but they fought it tooth and nail
- 53:58and for example I had
- 54:01praised uh in all of my speeches this
- 54:04it's is a 1915 statement on academic
- 54:07freedom by the American Association of
- 54:09University
- 54:11professors and the Penn State still has
- 54:14as it AC or had as its academic freedom
- 54:17provision the statement that the
- 54:19obligate the it is not the place of a
- 54:23professor in a Democratic Society to
- 54:25indoctrinate his or her students
- 54:28therefore they must present Divergent
- 54:31opinions in a fair-minded manner that's
- 54:33a paraphrase of it and I praise that and
- 54:36so the head of the aaup Carrie Nelson
- 54:41made it a personal crusade to get that
- 54:43ripped out of the Penn State academic
- 54:46freedom provision the so the so-called
- 54:48liberal person right wanted now this to
- 54:51be removed he's atist Carrie he actually
- 54:54I mean he's defended me in some so he's
- 54:57like an
- 54:59un whatever he's not quite of a
- 55:03doctrinaire but but he did The Faculty
- 55:06sent it there ripped it out and took out
- 55:08explicitly the thing it's not the place
- 55:10to indoctrinate the students yeah do you
- 55:12find when you when you meet people maybe
- 55:15some young people that are waking up to
- 55:16some of this stuff that once they see
- 55:18one piece of it that the rest of it
- 55:20crumbles very quickly because I see this
- 55:22because I saw it happen with myself
- 55:23obviously and I and for me it's still
- 55:26unfolding process I think and that's why
- 55:28I I'm happy to have these conversations
- 55:30but I see it happening with other people
- 55:31now I get emails every day people be
- 55:33like one little thing happened and then
- 55:35l two months later I now believe
- 55:38everything that Steve Miller says it was
- 55:40guns that's what turned him from a
- 55:42liberal into a
- 55:44conservative um I have uh somebody who
- 55:48who who writes occasionally from front
- 55:50page my website uh who who heard me
- 55:54speak in Camden New Jersey and I pointed
- 55:56out as I as I do in my book big
- 55:59agenda um every inner city of any size
- 56:03is 100% controlled by the Democratic
- 56:06party and progressives it has been for
- 56:0750 to 100 years including Camden so
- 56:11everything Milwaukee Atlanta Chicago all
- 56:13these plac all the Killing Fields St
- 56:15Louis Baltimore right um everything
- 56:18that's wrong in the inner cities that
- 56:20policy can affect Democrats and
- 56:22progressives are responsible for once
- 56:24you see that it's all over
- 56:27and then there are people out there
- 56:28screaming that it's he wasn't even
- 56:30President we we had this I here's a left
- 56:34this
- 56:34mentality when Peter ker and I wrote the
- 56:38uh this bestseller around the kennedies
- 56:40we found ourselves in a green room of uh
- 56:44Good Morning America sitting and there
- 56:47were only three people the other person
- 56:48was William F
- 56:50Buckley and was dead silence in the
- 56:53room and uh the reason
- 56:57that Peter and I were silent as we is we
- 56:59we had no idea who Buckley was we just
- 57:01knew we didn't want to be nice to a
- 57:05fascist that's what the left called him
- 57:07a fascist so we don't want to be nice to
- 57:08a fascist so Peter broke the ice by
- 57:11saying my mother is a big fan of yours
- 57:13and then we found out from Buckley who's
- 57:15a very gracious human being um that he
- 57:19was silent because his son had just uh
- 57:22written a very critical attack on a
- 57:25Kennedy book that was another one that
- 57:26came out and he didn't know if it was
- 57:30ours uh there but the lack of Civility
- 57:33of the left it just it's so it's fascist
- 57:36that's what it is and it there's there's
- 57:38no way I mean the only response you can
- 57:41have is one like Milo just go in their
- 57:44face otherwise I just shout you down
- 57:47yeah there is a an Incredible video that
- 57:49I saw a couple years ago of you at
- 57:52University of San Diego I think and a a
- 57:56young Muslim student gets up very
- 57:58articulate with a head scarf yeah and
- 58:01she At first she opens by thanking you
- 58:04for coming and saying she's that
- 58:05sarcastic diversity of thought and if
- 58:08people can watch it we'll link to it
- 58:10below so people can actually watch the
- 58:11video there's a twang of sarcasm in it
- 58:13or or it was either sarcasm or she was
- 58:15trying to butter you up before she went
- 58:17for the kill uh can you explain the rest
- 58:19of what happened there so that I don't
- 58:21then edit it she cuz it's falsely
- 58:26accused the Muslim Students Association
- 58:29of being a front for the Muslim
- 58:30Brotherhood which it is and
- 58:33Hamas
- 58:35so and and we had distributed a pamphlet
- 58:37showing this um so I instead of arguing
- 58:43with her about whether the Muslim
- 58:45Students Association and students for
- 58:47justice Palestine they're both Hamas
- 58:49fronts Brotherhood fronts uh instead of
- 58:53arguing with her I just decided to cut
- 58:55to the chase I said will you condemn
- 58:57amamas as a terrorist organization and
- 58:59she
- 59:00said uh you want to crucify me I said
- 59:05come I don't know how how I respond to
- 59:07comeing in and she said well if I don't
- 59:10condemn Hamas then I will be arrested by
- 59:13the Department of Homeland Security this
- 59:15is how delusional these people are so I
- 59:18changed the question and I had done this
- 59:20at other campuses so I knew what sort of
- 59:22to expect I said let me put it to you
- 59:25this I'm a Jew and the head of hisbah
- 59:28says he wants us Jews to gather in
- 59:30Israel so he won't have to hunt us down
- 59:32globally for it or against it she leaned
- 59:36into the microphone and said for it and
- 59:38she was defended afterwards by the
- 59:40Muslim Students Association the whole
- 59:43left they're genocidal they want to kill
- 59:46the Jews when she said that I suspect
- 59:49you were not shocked as insanely
- 59:51shocking as that sounds no because I had
- 59:54it I and you see Santa Barbara I asked
- 59:57the same question of the head of the
- 59:58Muslim Students Association and he said
- 1:00:01it was too complicated a question for a
- 1:00:03yes no answer right genocide is too
- 1:00:05complicated he was smarter than she was
- 1:00:08right hers was just like hers was just
- 1:00:10showing you what they think and what
- 1:00:11they want so all right so let's let's
- 1:00:14shift to to Islam then
- 1:00:17um I I've been talking about it and I've
- 1:00:20tried to bring on I've brought on
- 1:00:21liberals to talk about it I've had you
- 1:00:23know very measured people like Sam
- 1:00:25Harris quote pupes I've had aan her Alon
- 1:00:28who talks about her own personal
- 1:00:30experience enemies of the left people
- 1:00:33who are Majid noaz who's a Muslim Harris
- 1:00:35is you know he's still a leftist liberal
- 1:00:38yeah he's he's a liberal he's a liberal
- 1:00:40whether that I I I don't want to speak
- 1:00:41for him I don't get him into any extra
- 1:00:43trouble um but I've had my point is that
- 1:00:46I've had plenty of people thought of as
- 1:00:47liberals or on the left discuss it they
- 1:00:50get hate from the left then I've had
- 1:00:51people more on the right talk about it
- 1:00:54such as Lauren Southern and Ben Shapiro
- 1:00:57and some others and of course they're
- 1:00:59going to get a certain amount of hate
- 1:01:00for it how do you gauge how much of a
- 1:01:03problem this actually is at the moment
- 1:01:07the problem being the problem being
- 1:01:09Islamic
- 1:01:10extremism or VI or whatever you call it
- 1:01:13I think Islam is a a problem I no
- 1:01:17rational person could not look at Islam
- 1:01:19and say it's a not a problematic
- 1:01:21religion it preaches hatred against all
- 1:01:23other religions it sanctions
- 1:01:26uh there's just a series of quotes from
- 1:01:28the Quran sanctions murder beheading of
- 1:01:33infidels which is what we are um the
- 1:01:36prophet Muhammad has said has said that
- 1:01:38the day of judgment will only
- 1:01:41come when the Muslims fight the Jews and
- 1:01:44kill them when the Jews hide behind the
- 1:01:47rocks and the trees and the rocks and
- 1:01:49the trees cry out oh Muslim there's a
- 1:01:51Jew hiding behind me come and kill him
- 1:01:54yeah talk not only not
- 1:01:58repudiated by organized
- 1:02:01Islam uh but it's
- 1:02:03repeated um Yousef Al karwi um said as
- 1:02:09much the Holocaust was a punishment on
- 1:02:12Egyptian
- 1:02:13TV and he is the Imam the leading Imam
- 1:02:17not
- 1:02:18only for the Muslim Brotherhood but fora
- 1:02:21abedine Hillary's right hand that's her
- 1:02:24Imam that the the Holocaust was God's
- 1:02:27punishment of the Jews for their
- 1:02:29corruption and it will come again uh
- 1:02:32this time Allah willing at the hands of
- 1:02:35the Believers he's a genocidal Nazi is
- 1:02:38kadai and he's the mm of Hillary
- 1:02:41Clinton's rightand and Deputy in charge
- 1:02:44of Muslim Affairs for the state
- 1:02:46department yeah it's a big problem not a
- 1:02:49little one yeah so Keith Ellison is the
- 1:02:52Muslim Brotherhood uh candidate uh is
- 1:02:55now the number two guy in the Democratic
- 1:02:57party he only missed by 13 votes yeah
- 1:03:00how could the Democratic party Embrace
- 1:03:02this and Tom perz is no better but at
- 1:03:04least Ellison has an open record uh you
- 1:03:07know uh of of being in bed with the
- 1:03:10Muslim Brotherhood being supported by
- 1:03:12them and being a faran Jew hater and
- 1:03:15America hater and white hater come on
- 1:03:19what happened to the Democratic party
- 1:03:21yeah I mean and the faran stuff is
- 1:03:22amazing because even in the last couple
- 1:03:23days I don't follow faran verified
- 1:03:26Milo's not on Twitter anymore but I was
- 1:03:28looking at farrakhan's Twitter feed or
- 1:03:30something got retweeted into my feed I
- 1:03:32mean it's all God will destroy America
- 1:03:34hate all the Jews hate white people and
- 1:03:36he was for 11 years a spokesman for the
- 1:03:38Nation of
- 1:03:39Islam and you know people they have to
- 1:03:43repudiate what they did that this is
- 1:03:45this is why I say Barack Obama is a
- 1:03:47communist he was raised by Communists
- 1:03:50he's his whole political career until he
- 1:03:53became United States Senator was in the
- 1:03:56Communist left uh I mean I know these
- 1:03:59people
- 1:04:01um if you are part of a movement that
- 1:04:04you know is evil the first thing you
- 1:04:06want to do is warn other people about it
- 1:04:08especially when it's so deceptive it
- 1:04:10talks about social justice and all this
- 1:04:13crap anyway no well I mean that's but he
- 1:04:16hasn't so that's how you know what his
- 1:04:18allegiances are and when you asked me
- 1:04:21about the
- 1:04:22U this was earlier in our conversation
- 1:04:25about
- 1:04:26about why why is the Democratic party so
- 1:04:29soft on Islamic
- 1:04:31terrorists they're people of
- 1:04:35color that has to play a big role and
- 1:04:38first thing you do is oh we have to
- 1:04:40understand if they're killing people it
- 1:04:42must be because we did
- 1:04:44something very sick yeah what is that
- 1:04:47self- flagellation that so many people
- 1:04:49in the west have it's guilt I mean
- 1:04:52Shelby steel has WR guil of success
- 1:04:54Shelby steel has written a book called
- 1:04:56white guilt yeah it'll bring down our
- 1:04:59our great
- 1:05:01civilization if it's not you know and we
- 1:05:05haven't talked about Donald Trump which
- 1:05:06is the subject of my book yeah okay so
- 1:05:08let's I think is I think if we have an
- 1:05:11antidote he's he's it so you really
- 1:05:14believe that that Trump and that you
- 1:05:16know I was going to say a second ago
- 1:05:18when you were talking about uh you know
- 1:05:20fighting the roots of Islamic extremism
- 1:05:22I mean Bannon from what I understand
- 1:05:25seems to be the architect of that that
- 1:05:28he's a good guy Steve bennon
- 1:05:30yeah so you don't believe him to be an
- 1:05:33anti-semite or hell no first of all the
- 1:05:36chief evidence there's two evidence
- 1:05:39given that Steve Bannon is an
- 1:05:41anti-semite one is a disgruntled wife in
- 1:05:44the middle of a divorce proceeding in
- 1:05:46custody case who said who claimed that
- 1:05:48he said that Jewish children are
- 1:05:51whiny which well may well be the case if
- 1:05:54you you know the the whole ritual of bar
- 1:05:56mitzvah you shower a 13-year-old with
- 1:05:59tons of money and give him an audience
- 1:06:02of adults okay so they might be a lot to
- 1:06:05deal with they might be whining who
- 1:06:07knows right um but that's certainly not
- 1:06:10um
- 1:06:11juting um right regard even if even if
- 1:06:15say it that's not you'd have to big deal
- 1:06:19fighting with that wife that over the
- 1:06:22kids and when they go to school and
- 1:06:23maybe the school was very expensive is
- 1:06:25an expensive School the Archer School
- 1:06:28the other evidence is an article that I
- 1:06:30wrote I gave the title to uh Bill
- 1:06:35Crystal Republican spoiler Renegade Jew
- 1:06:38uhuh so people who haven't read the
- 1:06:40article I read the article I did not
- 1:06:42find anything anti no he Renegade
- 1:06:44because he he's going to return hum
- 1:06:47abedine and Ben rhods who was the
- 1:06:50architect one of the architects of the
- 1:06:53Iran deal back to Power
- 1:06:56it's a death nail for Israel I mean what
- 1:06:58they've done eight and not to mention
- 1:07:01the United I mean it's not Iran isn't
- 1:07:03powerful enough to destroy the United
- 1:07:05States but its leaders do chant lead
- 1:07:07chance of death to America that's what
- 1:07:09they believe why if Franklin Roosevelt
- 1:07:13gave nuclear weapons to Hitler what
- 1:07:15would we call them Obama is an American
- 1:07:18traitor and that's because he's a
- 1:07:20communist and always has been and always
- 1:07:22will be so I know enough people are
- 1:07:24going to watch that and go wait a minute
- 1:07:25but the deal says that they can't get
- 1:07:26nukes but you would say Well it mean
- 1:07:28expires it expires there one it expires
- 1:07:31two what he the effect of the deal was
- 1:07:33to lift the sanctions bring Iran back
- 1:07:36into the community of Nations he gave
- 1:07:38them
- 1:07:38$200 billion dollar 200 billion 100 well
- 1:07:43I forget all the payments and there's no
- 1:07:47controls but even if there were controls
- 1:07:50why would you bring them out of
- 1:07:51isolation now Iran is running over the
- 1:07:53Middle East they over through the
- 1:07:55government in Yemen you know which is
- 1:07:58why we now are losing American lives
- 1:08:01there come
- 1:08:02on anyway so so that's why I thought
- 1:08:05that Crystal and I didn't attack Crystal
- 1:08:08during during the
- 1:08:10campaign you know look I you
- 1:08:14know I can see Donald Trump I can see
- 1:08:17why he upsets some people yeah I can see
- 1:08:19how in my view the
- 1:08:22exaggerated you know the whatever the
- 1:08:24fears the you know I don't think for a
- 1:08:27second that he's anti-mexican or bigoted
- 1:08:30in any way um and it you know and I'm
- 1:08:33I'm one of those people who says well
- 1:08:35look he's been in public life for 30
- 1:08:36years he didn't become a racist until he
- 1:08:39was running against a Democrat For
- 1:08:41Crying Out
- 1:08:42tears I so I but I I could see uh how
- 1:08:47people would get been out of shape
- 1:08:48during the
- 1:08:49campaign but once he's the
- 1:08:52nominee then it's him or Hillary and if
- 1:08:55it's Hillary it's haa abedine I mean
- 1:08:57it's you know the whole anti-israel crew
- 1:09:01so you can sympathize then with Bill
- 1:09:03Crystal's intent so Bill Crystal who
- 1:09:05wanted conservatism all you know what's
- 1:09:07thought of as real real conservatism to
- 1:09:10live forever these are relig these are
- 1:09:12these are people treating Politics as a
- 1:09:14religion if you don't refer to the
- 1:09:17United States as a constitutional
- 1:09:18republic you're not a conservative if
- 1:09:21you don't use the phrase limited go
- 1:09:23limited government he never said said
- 1:09:25that that that that's not look what he's
- 1:09:28doing now I mean he's cutting the
- 1:09:30government in a
- 1:09:32big so they'll be I mean it's just crazy
- 1:09:35he won me over this way I mean I was
- 1:09:38nervous about him through the campaign
- 1:09:39because you don't know uh you know this
- 1:09:42is his first Venture into politics I
- 1:09:44don't I don't know I'm I'm not nervous
- 1:09:46about him anymore although I think he'll
- 1:09:48disappoint me on some things but he won
- 1:09:51me over in the first debate here's a guy
- 1:09:55he's never been a a a political
- 1:09:57candidate before he's on a platform with
- 1:10:00uh 12 of uh you know the top Republicans
- 1:10:04in the country it's in front of I don't
- 1:10:07remember it's 30 million people or
- 1:10:09whatever it is and the fir and he gets
- 1:10:12the first question because he has the
- 1:10:13highest percentage in the polls and it's
- 1:10:16not a question it's an attack from Megan
- 1:10:19Kelly you called women fat pigs slobs
- 1:10:23and
- 1:10:24dogs and and he says oh that was just
- 1:10:26Rosie Odon I said this guy is a guy they
- 1:10:29can't
- 1:10:30intimidate because the political
- 1:10:32correctness is a party line as I said it
- 1:10:36comes from ma it's a like a Communist
- 1:10:38Party Line it shuts you up there is no
- 1:10:42other Republican Under the Sun who on
- 1:10:45national TV this time in front of 50
- 1:10:47billion people would have looked Hillary
- 1:10:48Clinton in the eye and said you're a
- 1:10:51liar and a crook even though she's both
- 1:10:54if it were a man they would say it why
- 1:10:57be because it's this gigantic double
- 1:11:00standard it's Politically
- 1:11:03Incorrect to say anything critical about
- 1:11:06a woman this is ridiculous if that's the
- 1:11:09case they shouldn't be in politics now
- 1:11:12the left will just take out that phrase
- 1:11:13shouldn't be in politics but you can't
- 1:11:15be protected and at the same time
- 1:11:17pretend to be strong you know it's
- 1:11:19interesting how pricious some of this
- 1:11:20stuff is because I'll even see sometimes
- 1:11:22if if if a man attacks me on Twitter not
- 1:11:24that Twitter are that important but I'll
- 1:11:26immediately defend myself and come back
- 1:11:28and I've had a few instances where women
- 1:11:30have and I've just ignored it because I
- 1:11:32don't want to attack a woman and I know
- 1:11:33that's my own then that's it's just my
- 1:11:36own reflection of what I'm you know
- 1:11:38we've all been schooled in that and then
- 1:11:40there's penalties you have to think
- 1:11:42quickly about what the consequences are
- 1:11:44how do you it so that desire to punch
- 1:11:47back or to not be held hostage by
- 1:11:49political correctness or all that stuff
- 1:11:51would you argue that that is far more
- 1:11:52important than any of his political
- 1:11:55totally
- 1:11:55that that's what once I saw here's a guy
- 1:11:59who the Democrats can't intimidate look
- 1:12:02I I use this phrase in my speeches
- 1:12:04whenever I see a republican square off
- 1:12:06against a Democrat it looks to me like
- 1:12:08Godzilla versus Bambi because the
- 1:12:10Republic the the Democrat is going to
- 1:12:13call the Republican a racist a sexist a
- 1:12:15homophobe an islamophobe and the
- 1:12:18Republican will call the Democrat a
- 1:12:21liberal who's going to win that argument
- 1:12:24so this is a bul
- 1:12:25or and I love the way they they call
- 1:12:28Trump a blitz Creek the Democrat Blitz
- 1:12:31Creek uh we have a tradition in this
- 1:12:33country it's sacred to a democracy of a
- 1:12:36honeymoon for an incoming president it
- 1:12:38says there's a peaceful transition of
- 1:12:40power it says we're all part of one
- 1:12:42Community it says we're going to see
- 1:12:44what you do and then we're free to
- 1:12:46criticize you and the remedy is the next
- 1:12:50election Trump didn't get 7 seconds he
- 1:12:53didn't get confirmation hearings he got
- 1:12:54a witch
- 1:12:56the and this is another example of how
- 1:12:58political correctness Works uh Jeff
- 1:13:01sessions I've known him for 20 years one
- 1:13:04of and I've known a lot of senators one
- 1:13:06of a handful of the most decent human
- 1:13:08decent human beings in the Senate a
- 1:13:11champion of civil rights this was an
- 1:13:13attorney general in a deep south St
- 1:13:16State who prosecuted the K clux Clan who
- 1:13:18desegregated the schools and there's
- 1:13:21Elizabeth Warren calling him a racist
- 1:13:23and then violating Senate rules to
- 1:13:26repeat calling him a racist and when
- 1:13:28she's told to shut up they say oh
- 1:13:31they're silencing another
- 1:13:33woman yeah that's how effective
- 1:13:35political correctness is it just to be
- 1:13:37clear for people that didn't didn't
- 1:13:39follow that whole thing she was reading
- 1:13:41other people's words which isn't
- 1:13:42technically allowed in the Senate so
- 1:13:44that she was doing something that she
- 1:13:45wasn't allowed to do by their own rules
- 1:13:47then everyone turned it into happened to
- 1:13:49be a letter from ketta Scott King that
- 1:13:51she was repudiated what happened was uh
- 1:13:54in Alabama there were there were three
- 1:13:57blacks who who's uh were defrauded of
- 1:14:01their voting rights because they were in
- 1:14:02opposition to three other blacks who
- 1:14:05were nacp corrupt officials that's the
- 1:14:08whole case and and uh sessions didn't
- 1:14:12know how to defend himself the first
- 1:14:14time he was up in the 80s I mean this is
- 1:14:15a thing Republicans are not used to
- 1:14:18fighting back they used to getting out
- 1:14:20of the way as why wouldn't you if people
- 1:14:23are calling you racist sexist
- 1:14:25to so it's obvious to me that that stuff
- 1:14:28is not working as much anymore so then
- 1:14:31my last question that that is amazing so
- 1:14:34the words aren't but what I now think is
- 1:14:36we're going to see more violence because
- 1:14:38they've been pinned into a corner where
- 1:14:40everyone that they're against is a Nazi
- 1:14:41and a racist and all those things we
- 1:14:42will see violence so I I suspect we're
- 1:14:44going to see more violence but my last
- 1:14:46question to you is with this Evolution
- 1:14:50with with now the first Republican as
- 1:14:53you're saying with Trump that's not
- 1:14:54going to take it
- 1:14:55it what what's the good path now like
- 1:14:58what if you could see something good
- 1:15:00coming out of these next couple years
- 1:15:02what is that
- 1:15:04path you know I I am uh Antonio gromy
- 1:15:09once said that
- 1:15:10um the Revolutionary for the
- 1:15:14Revolutionary must have pessimism of the
- 1:15:17intellect and optimism of the will and I
- 1:15:21think he stole that from
- 1:15:23somebody um
- 1:15:25I can't I can't remember who but I think
- 1:15:27he did it it's in Wikipedia well if it's
- 1:15:30in Wikipedia definitely stole it from
- 1:15:32somebody I
- 1:15:34um yeah I I you know my head will tell
- 1:15:38me that nothing is good is going to come
- 1:15:40and I'm you know and you can see I mean
- 1:15:42there's so many so many problems
- 1:15:47of you know as I pointed out in in in my
- 1:15:50in my book big agenda the left the
- 1:15:53Democratic party uh it's a totalitarian
- 1:15:56party now it lied to get obam carian
- 1:15:59lied about you can keep your doctor lied
- 1:16:02about you can keep your plan and it and
- 1:16:04its mission was control it's an an
- 1:16:07incredible assault on individual Freedom
- 1:16:12the government tells you you have to
- 1:16:14have insurance the government tells you
- 1:16:16you have to have you you have what are
- 1:16:18they four packages this is the kind of
- 1:16:21insurance you have to have and the
- 1:16:23government gets all your health
- 1:16:26information that is a totalitarian
- 1:16:29threat right there but Republicans
- 1:16:32they're lame why aren't they saying that
- 1:16:36so replacing Obamacare is obviously um
- 1:16:40you know as as we're speaking
- 1:16:41Republicans are all in
- 1:16:43disarray
- 1:16:45um I don't know I don't know what's
- 1:16:48going to happen um Trump is fairly
- 1:16:51isolated you have all these conservative
- 1:16:54idiots like Crystal um and MC Mullen
- 1:16:58gunning for him um Republicans marched
- 1:17:02to their tune of their own said it
- 1:17:05drummers all the time they're
- 1:17:08individualists I was amazed when the Tea
- 1:17:10Party came in and and held a
- 1:17:12demonstration in Washington before that
- 1:17:15you couldn't get three Republicans to
- 1:17:17March together because they look at each
- 1:17:19other and say what are we collectivists
- 1:17:21so so does that then I already said it
- 1:17:23was the last question but we'll keep
- 1:17:24going for a little bit so there's that
- 1:17:25though so when the Tea Party organized
- 1:17:27and the Tea Party was gaining momentum
- 1:17:29everyone was saying there were these
- 1:17:31redneck backward gun nuts and in fact
- 1:17:33they were very decent people who cleaned
- 1:17:35up after themselves left it's just
- 1:17:38destructive nobody was hurt there was no
- 1:17:41violence cops fascists when people start
- 1:17:44referring to the left as fascists and
- 1:17:46not liberals then I'll say okay we're
- 1:17:49winning now it's not right now it isn't
- 1:17:52happening they go on they like I say I
- 1:17:55mean it's corrupted our culture it's
- 1:17:57corrupted our
- 1:17:59schools uh it's just very very bad but I
- 1:18:03think you know I I my faith is in Steve
- 1:18:06Bannon and Steve Miller these are two
- 1:18:09fighters and Trump and Trump understands
- 1:18:13instinctively that when you get attacked
- 1:18:15you attack back and throw them off well
- 1:18:18I I have this phrase that I I picked up
- 1:18:21from Chris Lane who's a democratic was
- 1:18:24in the New York York Times an article
- 1:18:26about him uh a democratic strategist but
- 1:18:29he he stole it from Mike
- 1:18:32Tyson which is everybody has a game plan
- 1:18:35until you punch them in the
- 1:18:37mouth and the Democrats have a massive
- 1:18:40punch in the mouth for Republicans
- 1:18:41calling them
- 1:18:42racists and uh Republicans have to come
- 1:18:46back and call Democrats the Democratic
- 1:18:49party is the party of racism it's the
- 1:18:51party of racial categories it's the
- 1:18:53party of identity politics it's the
- 1:18:56party of the inner cities it is a racist
- 1:18:59party it is also and I love this what
- 1:19:02what Trump said in the was in the second
- 1:19:05debate he turned to the cameras and said
- 1:19:08you have to understand Hillary has
- 1:19:10tremendous hatred in her
- 1:19:13heart and what he was referring to was
- 1:19:15the basket of deplorables which she
- 1:19:17named she identified all of her
- 1:19:20opponents or whatever half the same
- 1:19:23thing um
- 1:19:25are racist sexists homophobes
- 1:19:27islamophobes xenophobes you name it and
- 1:19:30he's raised them up there isn't a
- 1:19:33conservative or a deviating liberal who
- 1:19:37hasn't been in an argument with a
- 1:19:39so-called liberal who hasn't been called
- 1:19:41a racist a sexist a homophobe so in a
- 1:19:43way that was a gift the Democratic party
- 1:19:45is a party of hate that's what they run
- 1:19:48on everything they're doing now is is
- 1:19:52hate invent conspiracy theories with the
- 1:19:55Russians I mean this from a party whose
- 1:19:58candidate turned over 20% of America's
- 1:20:01uranium reserves to the
- 1:20:02Russians I mean how do you deal with
- 1:20:05that the only way in politics you have a
- 1:20:079sec sound bite just go for the
- 1:20:11jugular well I hope but I don't want you
- 1:20:13I I I like your style I want to see if
- 1:20:16we can convert people that way yeah well
- 1:20:19I think interesting I think
- 1:20:21interestingly people are being converted
- 1:20:23on both sides because I think what's
- 1:20:24happening is I I know for sure that I've
- 1:20:27helped a lot of progressives realize
- 1:20:29what true liberalism is and at the same
- 1:20:31time I think I've had and I know that
- 1:20:33I've gotten a lot of more conservative
- 1:20:36people to realize that not all Liberals
- 1:20:38are bad and I think that's where most of
- 1:20:40us actually are I know that that's good
- 1:20:42I don't want to take anything away from
- 1:20:44you but I I found when I came into the
- 1:20:46right I conservatives are generally very
- 1:20:49decent people M and when I criticize the
- 1:20:53um religious right leadership I had
- 1:20:56different reactions um from things like
- 1:20:58the family research Council I had people
- 1:21:01in my
- 1:21:02face the blood vessels popping screaming
- 1:21:06at me MH um and I had people who were
- 1:21:09very supportive very Christian um in
- 1:21:12that way and I also had this experience
- 1:21:15in the 2008 I was at the Moral
- 1:21:18Majority uh Ralph reeden invited me to
- 1:21:20come down to
- 1:21:22Atlanta and uh the woman who who who who
- 1:21:26was my connection there and a Moral
- 1:21:28Majority member I asked her I said well
- 1:21:31if John McCain gets a nomination will
- 1:21:33you vote for him and she said
- 1:21:35yeah so you know people what the what
- 1:21:38the religious right needs to understand
- 1:21:40is that there's religion and then
- 1:21:41there's politics and religion is about
- 1:21:44saving your Immortal soul and if you
- 1:21:47mess with the devil you endanger it and
- 1:21:50in politics you make packs with the
- 1:21:52devil all the
- 1:21:53time it's about getting into office and
- 1:21:56trying to practically change some things
- 1:21:59yeah and one thing that I wanted to talk
- 1:22:01yes to talk to you about that I just
- 1:22:03remembered it's a home studio so we can
- 1:22:05keep going go ahead go ahead is this
- 1:22:09um why is the why is the left and now
- 1:22:13so-called liberalism why are
- 1:22:15progressives
- 1:22:17totalitarians and the answer is that
- 1:22:21they it's it's a crypto
- 1:22:25religious uh
- 1:22:29ideology it's modeled on Christianity
- 1:22:32the world is a fallen Place although
- 1:22:33they never use that the world is an
- 1:22:36oppressive place it's Injustice rules
- 1:22:39but there will be a
- 1:22:41Redemption and we are the
- 1:22:43redeemers that's the danger we have to
- 1:22:46re and then you see it all the time we
- 1:22:48have to remake Humanity so it fits our
- 1:22:51model of the
- 1:22:52Redemption that's why there's so if only
- 1:22:55Bernie was in we have to Outlaw we have
- 1:22:57to Stamp Out racist sexist homophobes
- 1:23:01people who we disagree with yeah Milo we
- 1:23:05can't let him
- 1:23:08speak time to what is more the only
- 1:23:11difference between that and an actual
- 1:23:13totalitarian state is if they had the
- 1:23:15power they would execute Milo he'd be in
- 1:23:18a gulag or he'd be dead yeah do you
- 1:23:20remember there was a line a couple years
- 1:23:21ago that Oprah who and I basically like
- 1:23:23Oprah and back Oprah I'd be happy to
- 1:23:25have her on the show of course when she
- 1:23:27was talking about the you know this
- 1:23:28older generation and some of their
- 1:23:30backwards ways of thinking and she said
- 1:23:31well we just they just have to die I
- 1:23:33remember thinking like even if what
- 1:23:35you're saying some that yes there might
- 1:23:37be you know studies show that younger
- 1:23:39people are generally more liberal and on
- 1:23:41the social issu they not more liberal
- 1:23:43they're less older blacks are liberal
- 1:23:46that's why Oprah doesn't like them oh
- 1:23:48that all right so well that sort of fits
- 1:23:50everything else that you're saying but
- 1:23:51but my point being that when she said it
- 1:23:53it sounds so nuts to me because one day
- 1:23:54if you just if you take that logic to
- 1:23:56its end guess what one day the young
- 1:23:59people are going to want all of you dead
- 1:24:01when you're old because it just will
- 1:24:03it'll just keep going can't try to make
- 1:24:05sense out of it but it is it's the
- 1:24:07reever it's the actually the reverse
- 1:24:10older blacks
- 1:24:13um are not as racist as younger blacks
- 1:24:16racism is pervasive now I mean this is a
- 1:24:20very Politically Incorrect to say but I
- 1:24:23think it's pretty obvious racist uh
- 1:24:25pervas racism is pervasive in the black
- 1:24:28community and especially among younger
- 1:24:30people who've been to schools and
- 1:24:32told that their all their problems come
- 1:24:35from White
- 1:24:36races very bad you
- 1:24:40know the 50s were much better times in
- 1:24:43this country so I think I only got a
- 1:24:45half answer then before you said my head
- 1:24:47doesn't have a lot of Hope something to
- 1:24:49that effect about the future but what
- 1:24:51about your my head well I'm I I'm an
- 1:24:54optim missed by jeans I don't know how I
- 1:24:56am I just am I you know I I phrased it
- 1:25:01in a book I wrote you know I when my my
- 1:25:04head is in conflict with my heart I
- 1:25:06follow my heart so I'm I'm going to
- 1:25:08fight till I
- 1:25:10drop as though there's a going to be a
- 1:25:13positive outcome but uh you know there's
- 1:25:17um what was his name skipio
- 1:25:20Africanus was a Roman
- 1:25:22general who burned
- 1:25:24Carthage and when he saw Carthage Going
- 1:25:28Up in Smoke he
- 1:25:30wept because
- 1:25:33the classical view was that all it's all
- 1:25:36cyclical Empires rise and fall societies
- 1:25:39rise and fall and this idea of progress
- 1:25:43is one of the really bad ideas that the
- 1:25:46Jews gave to us the idea of there's a
- 1:25:49Promised Land although maybe Moses
- 1:25:52didn't mean it in a way that left this
- 1:25:54mean it but that idea of a
- 1:25:56progress is the
- 1:25:59problem can't redeem the world can't be
- 1:26:02fixed why can't the world be
- 1:26:04fixed because the root source of all
- 1:26:07social problems is US
- 1:26:10individuals so you can maybe it you know
- 1:26:14it's it's very hard to take one
- 1:26:16individual who's gone off the de end and
- 1:26:19bring them back yeah but you know modest
- 1:26:23it's you know this is the oldest thing I
- 1:26:25was a volte 10 your own garden you can
- 1:26:28make the space around you maybe a little
- 1:26:31bit more Humane you can help an
- 1:26:33individual but you can't change the
- 1:26:37world well on that note I sense we could
- 1:26:39do a lot more so we'll have to do this
- 1:26:41again okay we'll see may you know we'll
- 1:26:43do this how about we do this one year
- 1:26:44from now and we'll see if I've
- 1:26:46Incorporated some of your T Optimist I'm
- 1:26:49an optimist I'll be around next I I
- 1:26:52can't help it I'm old enough to know
- 1:26:54that that that will be you know a
- 1:26:56blessing you're you're 78 years old how
- 1:26:59do you look so good uh your makeup
- 1:27:02that's all the makeup no I saw you when
- 1:27:03you walked in come on what's the trick
- 1:27:05uh I don't know I I have a great
- 1:27:08marriage wonderful wife um I tried to
- 1:27:13balance the political with the you know
- 1:27:16real real life stuff my animals I all
- 1:27:20these dogs I
- 1:27:22love um yeah I don't know and it's also
- 1:27:26in the
- 1:27:27jeans all right one year from now we
- 1:27:30will do it again and for more on David
- 1:27:32you can check out his new book big
- 1:27:34agenda president Trump's plan to save
- 1:27:36America and visit Hartz freedom
- 1:27:38center.org
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Communism, Trump, and Leaving the Left | David Horowitz | POLITICS | Rubin Report by The Rubin Report, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,583 words across 2,102 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.