Come veniamo influenzati ogni giorno senza saperlo con Giuliano Trenti, esperto di Neuromarketing — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Our brain loves immediate gratification
- 0:03. We have a whole series of structures
- 0:07within our brain that are automatically
- 0:10activated by what we like, which
- 0:13promises us future gratification, and
- 0:15this creates within us a desire to
- 0:18satisfy this type of reward sensation,
- 0:21and the more immediate it is, the
- 0:24better. Giuliano, um, if you had to
- 0:30tell someone who doesn't know you what
- 0:32you do for a living,
- 0:35what would you say?
- 0:37Well, I like to define myself as a
- 0:39researcher. Um, I study daily, uh,
- 0:45let's say the most advanced knowledge
- 0:48concerning both the functioning of the
- 0:50human brain and, uh, behaviors, so I'm
- 0:52talking about neuroscience and
- 0:54behavioral science. Uh, applied to
- 0:58business ends with a mission that I
- 1:02feel is personally very relevant. This
- 1:06mission I feel is to make available
- 1:09scientific knowledge that is already
- 1:11available or that is created in the
- 1:13laboratory, because we actually have a
- 1:16research laboratory with
- 1:17electroencephalograms, skin conductance
- 1:19, eye tracking, and a whole series of
- 1:22other technologies where, uh, we use
- 1:24them to conduct actual scientific
- 1:26research and therefore discover things
- 1:29that are then useful for better
- 1:30understanding people's behaviors and so
- 1:33on. Because this scientific knowledge
- 1:37is still, uh, often relegated to
- 1:40insiders and people who perhaps do the
- 1:42job of research at an academic level,
- 1:45but which then tend to be particularly
- 1:47limited in terms of practical transfer.
- 1:51M
- 1:52Knowing what the potential impact this
- 1:55type of knowledge has on the day-to-day
- 1:57management that a company can implement
- 2:00, both towards external customers (so
- 2:02we are talking about external
- 2:04neuromarketing) and towards internal
- 2:06customers (so we are talking about
- 2:08neuroscience of employee motivation, we
- 2:11are talking about leadership, we are
- 2:13talking about organizational dynamics)
- 2:16with the goal of generating great
- 2:18motivation, a great desire to move
- 2:20towards goals. Well, the impact you can
- 2:25have with this knowledge is really
- 2:28spectacular, and it is a great shame
- 2:31that, uh, much of the knowledge that is
- 2:34part of the field I deal with is not
- 2:36yet common knowledge.
- 2:39I'll give you an example. In 2023, we
- 2:43did a study, a very simple survey on
- 2:46managers and entrepreneurs in Italy,
- 2:49interviewing a hundred of them taken at
- 2:52random and discovering that almost 80%
- 2:56of those interviewed don't even know
- 2:59that this discipline and this knowledge
- 3:02exist and are applicable within the
- 3:05reality of any company. discipline in
- 3:09terms of neuromarketing,
- 3:10neuromarketing, but also the whole part
- 3:12of neuroleadership, that is,
- 3:14neuroscience in the company, behavioral
- 3:16science in the company. M
- 3:18the vast majority of managers and
- 3:20entrepreneurs don't even know they
- 3:22exist. So, when we talk about, I don't
- 3:27know, Kahneman and Tversky, these great
- 3:29fathers of behavioral science and
- 3:31behavioral economics, whom I truly met
- 3:34in the early 2000s at university when I
- 3:36was a student at the Faculty of
- 3:38Economics at the University of Trento,
- 3:41and, I don't know, if I talk about
- 3:43Richard Thaler, also a Nobel laureate,
- 3:45or other people who have made fantastic
- 3:48contributions to our understanding of
- 3:50what influences human behavior, in
- 3:54Italy. Well, it's as if, I don't know,
- 3:57all of this knowledge hasn't permeated
- 3:59into society yet.
- 4:01Yeah. But so, what is neuromarketing? I
- 4:04mean, if you had to explain it to
- 4:06someone who has no idea what it is and
- 4:09maybe isn't even an entrepreneur, why
- 4:12do you think neuromarketing concerns us
- 4:15all?
- 4:16Well, I like to define neuromarketing
- 4:18as marketing, but without the fluff.
- 4:20Okay?
- 4:21Why? Because, in essence, it consists
- 4:25of using scientific methods that
- 4:29measure either brain activity, nervous
- 4:32system activity, or other types of
- 4:36parameters related to, I don't know,
- 4:39eye movements or other things, with the
- 4:45intent of understanding what people
- 4:48really want and how to ensure that what
- 4:51you offer to the market can actually be
- 4:55of interest to the people being
- 4:58targeted, and it is science.
- 5:02Do you have any examples? A practical
- 5:04example, uh, look: we are currently
- 5:06working on a few projects where the
- 5:09most, let's say, recent one that comes
- 5:11to mind—because today at 11:00
- 5:13there's a presentation my colleagues
- 5:15are giving to this client—where, well
- 5:17, this study we are conducting has the
- 5:20goal of understanding if a potentially
- 5:22revolutionary business idea in the real
- 5:24estate sector has real market potential
- 5:27or not. And one might say, "Well, damn,
- 5:31surely the people developing this
- 5:34technology and these great innovations
- 5:36know if this type of innovation can
- 5:39have a space in the market?" And the
- 5:42answer is, well, yes, they have
- 5:44assumptions,
- 5:45but since they are prudent people and
- 5:48they know that in today's market more
- 5:51than 60%of the products and
- 5:53technological services offered end up
- 5:57failing,
- 5:58they take precautions by going out to
- 6:00understand how people react to the type
- 6:02of proposal they are being presented
- 6:04with. So, the idea is basically this:
- 6:07you do a sort of check to see if what
- 6:10you're proposing actually hits on what
- 6:13people want, and isn't just an exercise
- 6:16in style that gratifies you, the
- 6:19creator, but that when you present it
- 6:22to someone who should ideally
- 6:24appreciate this type of offer, it
- 6:26actually has a chance of success. Look,
- 6:31this is really important because in so
- 6:33many cases I hear people say that
- 6:35neuromarketing is something done to
- 6:38manipulate people and somehow instill
- 6:40hidden desires and rummage through
- 6:43people's thoughts. That is nonsense of
- 6:46the worst kind.
- 6:47Hmm.
- 6:48Because, let's put it this way: if a
- 6:51person's intent is to manipulate others
- 6:53, the knowledge useful for manipulation
- 6:55is widely known, because it has to do
- 6:58with lies, trickery, blackmail,
- 7:00psychological pressure against people,
- 7:02and using, in short, the entirety of
- 7:04human knowledge with the specific
- 7:06intent of altering your perception of
- 7:09reality and making you believe in
- 7:11things that don't exist, so that you do
- 7:13exactly what someone else wants. And so
- 7:18, for example, if we talk about
- 7:21manipulation, we can't forget, in my
- 7:23opinion, the fact that if you, as a
- 7:26human, are bombarded for months with
- 7:28fake news and information that isn't
- 7:31true, but which you trust, that false
- 7:34information you trust effectively
- 7:36modifies your perception of what is
- 7:39true and what isn't. And starting
- 7:43precisely from this alteration of your
- 7:46perception of reality, they can
- 7:48certainly create desires, opinions, and
- 7:51attitudes that some bad actor can then
- 7:53exploit. But this is not neuromarketing
- 7:56. Hmm.
- 7:58The essence of neuromarketing lies in
- 8:01trying to understand what people really
- 8:04want and organizing one's strategies to
- 8:07offer people something that makes them
- 8:10happy with what they are spending,
- 8:12generating opportunities for success
- 8:15and business growth for those who enter
- 8:18the market.
- 8:20Yes. So, let me give you a few examples
- 8:22to see if I've understood correctly.
- 8:25The first example that comes to mind: I
- 8:28enter a supermarket, and the first
- 8:31thing I do—this is now everywhere in
- 8:34the world—is see the fresh produce
- 8:37section, like pre-cut fruit, maybe
- 8:39ready-made soups, and so on.
- 8:44Seeing the vegetable section, and then,
- 8:46well, the aisles move around a bit.
- 8:50Near the checkouts, there are always
- 8:52little snacks or chewing gum, mints,
- 8:55batteries, and so on.
- 8:58Second example: there are brands that
- 9:02have particularly recognizable taglines
- 9:05, like McDonald's, "I'm Lovin 'It," or
- 9:09like Coca-Cola. There are brands that
- 9:13even have little jingles, and there are
- 9:15brands that really leverage the sensory
- 9:18side of marketing. So, I don't know,
- 9:21Coca-Cola. Just seeing a Coca-Cola ad
- 9:25every now and then makes me thirsty,
- 9:27even though I don't even like Coca-Cola
- 9:30. I mean, I know perfectly well it's an
- 9:34unhealthy product, that it's full of
- 9:35sugar, especially the regular one, so
- 9:37I'm not exactly a fan, yet I see
- 9:39something activate in my body. Mm-hmm.
- 9:42Third example, social media.
- 9:46I keep getting bombarded by the same,
- 9:49uh, the same ads until, at a certain
- 9:51point, almost at the moment when I'm
- 9:54tired, I see the umpteenth ad for a
- 9:56brand that might interest me;
- 9:58eventually I give in, I buy it, and I
- 10:01say, "Oh well, I need this, maybe I
- 10:04deserve it, it's been a hard day, I'll
- 10:06buy this." Mm-hmm.
- 10:09In which of these examples does
- 10:11neuromarketing play a role?
- 10:14Uh, just to really understand if I've
- 10:17actually grasped the concept, uh, both
- 10:20in the physical aspect, and in the
- 10:23communication aspect, and also in terms
- 10:26of, let's say, presence on specific
- 10:28customer targeting channels and so on.
- 10:33Well, let's say it plays a role in all
- 10:36the examples you gave, um, because
- 10:38fundamentally the question that
- 10:41applying these methods to marketing
- 10:44tries to answer is: "What is the best
- 10:47way to package either the store, or the
- 10:50ad claim, or the social media ad, or
- 10:53other things, so that they succeed in,
- 10:56um, obtaining the desired result?".
- 11:00Which usually, as a desired result,
- 11:02it's important that it combines the
- 11:04satisfaction of the person who ends up
- 11:07buying with the possibility of
- 11:09implementing something that is also
- 11:11profitable. So, in the case of the
- 11:15store, it makes me laugh because today
- 11:18stores can be seen as true open-air
- 11:20laboratories, where, um, you can really
- 11:23do a lot to make the shopping
- 11:25experience as fulfilling and satisfying
- 11:28as possible and simultaneously
- 11:31profitable for those who implement it.
- 11:35Look, the sweet spot of neuromarketing
- 11:38lies precisely in finding the meeting
- 11:40point between what you offer and the
- 11:42fact that what you offer is profitable
- 11:45and makes people happy about having
- 11:47made a certain type of choice, of
- 11:49experience. Let's take a practical
- 11:52example. Yeah, in the case of
- 11:55supermarkets, as you mentioned, it's
- 11:58true that, especially in Italy, when
- 12:00you walk into a store, the first part
- 12:03you experience has to do with
- 12:05vegetables, fruit, produce, prepared
- 12:08items, and so on. And why is that
- 12:12important, anyway? Because all the
- 12:15elements related to the beginning of an
- 12:17experience someone engages in have a
- 12:19much greater impact on the mind
- 12:21compared to later elements. This is due
- 12:24to an effect called the primacy effect.
- 12:26Primacy effect. Okay. What does that
- 12:28mean? Well,
- 12:30it basically means that everything we
- 12:32see at the start of an experience
- 12:33carries more weight in our memories,
- 12:35our perceptions, and so on, compared to
- 12:37the elements that follow. And for those
- 12:42who do research, this is a very
- 12:44insidious effect because, for example,
- 12:46if I have a client asking me to test
- 12:48packaging variants for, I don't know, a
- 12:51wine, a drink, or maybe a detergent,
- 12:53and I don't randomize the order of
- 12:55presentation—meaning I don't make the
- 12:58order in which stimuli are shown to lab
- 13:00participants random—what I observe is
- 13:03that, systematically, the first one I
- 13:05show is the one that gets the highest
- 13:07rating.
- 13:09You're kidding! Absolutely not. And you
- 13:11can see it clearly in the data, to the
- 13:13point where, let's say, you have five
- 13:15elements, packaging 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,
- 13:16right? You say: "Okay, I won't change
- 13:19the sequence between the various
- 13:20participants," and you have 30 people
- 13:22coming into the lab, and the sequence
- 13:24is: they see 1, then 2, 3, 4, 5.
- 13:25Systematically, you will see that the
- 13:27product perceived as the best and most
- 13:29appreciated is always the one you
- 13:30presented first.
- 13:31But why? Because at the beginning of an
- 13:35experience, our sensory receptors are
- 13:37much more vigilant, and we are much
- 13:39more involved, much more alert at the
- 13:41start of an experience. And you can see
- 13:45this perfectly when we test commercials
- 13:48in the lab. You can see that people, at
- 13:51the beginning of a spot, any kind of
- 13:53broadcast, or a podcast, or even for a
- 13:55client (we tested the effectiveness of
- 13:58online events intended to persuade
- 14:00C-level executives or entrepreneurs,
- 14:02etc.), where purchases of hundreds of
- 14:04thousands of dollars for software and
- 14:07much more are made. You practically see
- 14:12that in the initial arousal levels you
- 14:14measure in people doing the experiment
- 14:16in the first 10 to 15 seconds, or in
- 14:18the very first moments of the
- 14:20experience you're proposing to them,
- 14:22they are much more engaged compared to
- 14:25later moments, and this is a
- 14:26physiological variation that you can
- 14:29measure. It's not just a purely
- 14:32psychological and mental matter, no.
- 14:34It's a physiological correlate that you
- 14:37can see in the data, which is
- 14:39systematic and predictable in human
- 14:41experience. I'll give you the example
- 14:44of supermarkets because it's truly very
- 14:46, very interesting. One of the things
- 14:48that was recently discovered, and if
- 14:51anyone is listening who deals with,
- 14:53let's say, arranging store layouts
- 14:56within a shop or, I don't know, in
- 14:58other areas. Placing flowers at the
- 15:02beginning of an experience can
- 15:03influence the overall shopping
- 15:04experience in an even more significant
- 15:06way. How come? I can explain it to you
- 15:10with a little game.
- 15:12Go ahead.
- 15:12If you think about, if you imagine
- 15:14seeing some flowers, okay?
- 15:16Yes.
- 15:16What is the first thing that comes to
- 15:18your mind? It gives me a feeling of
- 15:21serenity and a good smell, fragrance,
- 15:24cleanliness even.
- 15:25Very good. That is exactly the type of
- 15:27thoughts that flowers usually trigger.
- 15:30In some cases, they also have to do
- 15:33with the concept of love, because
- 15:35flowers are given on certain types of
- 15:38occasions, or in some cases, flowers
- 15:40give this sense of romance, of, in
- 15:42short, of generally positive emotions.
- 15:47It’s called the priming effect: the
- 15:49mental trigger sparked by flowers at
- 15:52the beginning of a shopping experience
- 15:55is able to alter our level of, let's
- 15:58put it this way, emotionality. On
- 16:01average, this type of exposure to
- 16:04flowers can lead people to make a few
- 16:06more purchases during the shopping
- 16:09experience, but not because people are
- 16:11being manipulated—because one might
- 16:14say, "Well, you put them there on
- 16:16purpose so it forces me to buy." No, no
- 16:19, what happens is that you feel better,
- 16:21you are doing better, you are more
- 16:23serene, and when you are generally a
- 16:25happier person, you tend to have
- 16:26purchases that are more facilitated
- 16:28because you are a bit more impulsive.
- 16:31One of the things I often tell related
- 16:33to this is linked to the fact that
- 16:35people, I think, notice how their
- 16:37wallet thins out a lot during holidays.
- 16:40I don't know if you've ever noticed
- 16:41this.
- 16:41Yes, yes. You tend to spend more. When
- 16:43you're happy, you tend to spend more.
- 16:45Absolutely, yes. The levels of serenity
- 16:48and happiness that you carry with you
- 16:50are often good predictors of how well
- 16:51—how well in quotes—you spend, in
- 16:53the sense of how much you are willing
- 16:55to spend. And this is crucial because,
- 16:59paradoxically, having a population—
- 17:02speaking on a macro level—that is
- 17:04happy, serene, confident in the future,
- 17:07and has, let's say, a fairly high level
- 17:11of inner well-being, often feeds into
- 17:13the aggregate demand seen in markets
- 17:16and, paradoxically, creates wealth for
- 17:19everyone at a macroeconomic level. So,
- 17:24it is in these things that
- 17:25neuromarketing is interesting because
- 17:27it tells you: look, if you want to make
- 17:28your customers a bit happier, put some
- 17:30flowers at the entrance. Sure,
- 17:33create a welcoming environment, perhaps
- 17:35—and this is another study—put a
- 17:37bit of lavender or vanilla scent
- 17:39outside.
- 17:41Because these are all scents that act
- 17:43on the emotions at an unconscious level
- 17:45and provide a bit more happiness, a bit
- 17:48more serenity; and so, paradoxically,
- 17:50what we try to do is make the shopping
- 17:52experience and the purchase of products
- 17:54and services as pleasant as possible,
- 17:57to make the people who make these
- 17:59purchases happy. Hm.
- 18:01But you can also act in reverse. What
- 18:03do you mean by in reverse? One of the
- 18:05studies I'm most fond of that we
- 18:08conducted in our laboratory concerns
- 18:11inducing behaviors related to saving
- 18:14money, keeping it in one's bank account
- 18:17to invest for the future, and so on. So
- 18:20, you don't make me spend so that I
- 18:23invest.
- 18:23Yes, exactly. I try to nudge you to
- 18:26take care of your finances,
- 18:29being careful, with a higher level of
- 18:31awareness, of the money you are
- 18:33spending and giving a correct—in
- 18:35quotation marks—emotional value to
- 18:37income and expenses.
- 18:38Yes.
- 18:39And it's a fantastic thing, it's
- 18:42something that can truly bring mega,
- 18:45ultra-happiness into people's lives.
- 18:48But how do you do that? There are a ton
- 18:51of ways to manage this, but one of the
- 18:53perhaps most trivial but effective
- 18:55things we've seen is that just when a
- 18:58person logs into their online banking
- 19:00system
- 19:01Yes. and sees the balance in their bank
- 19:04account. If the balance is displayed
- 19:07with physically very large numbers,
- 19:09okay? The perception that follows is
- 19:12linked to having a lot of money. If,
- 19:15instead, you make that number rather
- 19:17small, what happens is that people have
- 19:20a perception that the amount of money
- 19:22they have in their account is a bit
- 19:24lower, and from there comes the, let's
- 19:26say, feeling of perhaps being a little
- 19:28more careful about how they spend their
- 19:30money,
- 19:31or even the color you use or
- 19:33So, regarding color, especially if you
- 19:36really want to overdo it, what happens
- 19:40if you put the figures related to
- 19:42expenses in red and in a larger size?
- 19:47What happens is that people say, "Wait,
- 19:49wow, I'm spending—I mean, I realize
- 19:52how much I'm spending and maybe even
- 19:54where I'm spending it, so I can manage
- 19:57my expenses with great awareness."
- 20:00Because we are now immersed in an
- 20:03environment where the stimuli to, let's
- 20:06say, spend our money and try to gratify
- 20:09ourselves in some way are enormous, and
- 20:12even the use of credit cards or online
- 20:15shopping has introduced, uh, a lower
- 20:17perception of the pain, in quotes,
- 20:20associated with spending, which makes
- 20:23spending a little bit easier. Now there
- 20:26is also the possibility of paying in
- 20:27installments. In short, there is a
- 20:29whole world of attempts that companies
- 20:32make with the intent to try to sell
- 20:34more, but which on the other hand can
- 20:37lead people to not fully realize how
- 20:39much they are spending and, above all,
- 20:42where they are spending. And this is a
- 20:45subject that is very close to my heart
- 20:47because, as my grandfather used to tell
- 20:49me, everyone in the world earns money,
- 20:51and in some cases, they earn a lot of
- 20:53it. Yes.
- 20:54It's just that you don't realize where
- 20:56you are spending it.
- 20:58And what makes all the difference in
- 21:01the world in defining how economically
- 21:03prosperous a person's life can be
- 21:07is exactly how you manage this money.
- 21:09Yes.
- 21:09Whatever you earn. Sure.
- 21:11I mean, I often hear people who, uh,
- 21:18try to manage their finances as best
- 21:20they can, etc., but maybe when they
- 21:23find themselves facing situations that
- 21:25have to do with today's common
- 21:28behaviors, they don't realize that
- 21:30maybe at the end of the month they have
- 21:33literally burned through 300 or 400
- 21:35euros every month on happy hours and
- 21:38meals out. And if someone already earns
- 21:43, let's assume, 1,500 euros a month,
- 21:46that means they are allocating almost
- 21:4830%of their income to behaviors that
- 21:51are certainly gratifying in the
- 21:53immediate term, but that can be totally
- 21:56compromising in the long run. Because
- 22:00if you say, "Well, I have one happy
- 22:01hour a month, or 2, 3, 4, whatever it
- 22:02is, that's fine." But then, when at the
- 22:04end of the year you sit there with a
- 22:06calculator, you say, "Wait, what did I
- 22:07spend on happy hours this year?" Tell
- 22:09me I spent 5,000 euros
- 22:11on happy hours,
- 22:12okay? And I've done it for 10 years,
- 22:15that's already 50,000 euros?
- 22:18It's because they are habits, right? I
- 22:20don't know if I answered your question.
- 22:21Yes. So, then, um, what about this
- 22:25thing regarding induced needs, right? I
- 22:27mean, for example, the reason we spend
- 22:30money on drinks, rather than maybe on
- 22:32medical check-ups, just as an example,
- 22:36is that perhaps, I mean, what is
- 22:38happening inside our minds, why we are
- 22:41much more inclined to do one and not
- 22:43the other? And another question, you
- 22:47said something that really struck me,
- 22:50that so often we don't realize how much
- 22:53we spend and what we spend it on. And
- 22:56in fact, this is a topic that I think
- 22:59concerns us all, because so often one
- 23:02says "Well, I bought it because I felt,
- 23:05I had this need that was induced in me,
- 23:08I mean, it's not that I really needed
- 23:11it, but
- 23:12I felt a bit like a victim of marketing
- 23:15or, you know, I constantly see this
- 23:17thing in front of my eyes, I see that
- 23:19everyone has it, so I think, you know
- 23:21what, I'll buy it too."
- 23:23What is happening? And how can one
- 23:25protect oneself from these situations?
- 23:27Well, it's a massive topic that I will
- 23:30try to address in its main points. So,
- 23:33the point I would start from is the
- 23:36following. Our brain loves immediate
- 23:39gratification. We have within our brain
- 23:43a whole series of structures that are
- 23:46activated automatically in the face of
- 23:48what we like, which promises us a
- 23:51future reward. And this creates within
- 23:55us a desire to satisfy this type of
- 23:59sensation of reward, and the more
- 24:03immediate it is, the better. However,
- 24:08we are human beings, so there is this
- 24:10activity that appears within us that
- 24:12has to do with some structures
- 24:13involving the limbic system, the reward
- 24:15circuit, and many other structures. But
- 24:19as human beings, thank heaven, we have
- 24:21frontal lobes that can somehow regulate
- 24:23the instincts we feel within us. How
- 24:28does this regulation of instincts
- 24:30happen? Well, this is a massive topic,
- 24:32because there is a whole series of
- 24:35evidence telling us that there is a
- 24:37genetic component linked to whether a
- 24:39person knows how to manage their urges
- 24:41and instincts effectively. And there is
- 24:45also a whole series of demonstrations
- 24:48having to do with the possibility that
- 24:50this ability to better manage one's
- 24:52emotions and impulses can be learned,
- 24:55either from the environment one is in
- 24:57or through specific paths. For example,
- 25:01when we talk about emotional
- 25:02intelligence, the types of activities
- 25:04addressed often concern the regulation
- 25:06of one's own emotions, the postponement
- 25:08of gratification, and many other things
- 25:10. So it can happen that, by virtue of
- 25:13the continuous bombardment of stimuli,
- 25:16I feel these impulses within me and.
- 25:20One of the aspects that I think, uh,
- 25:24needs to be focused on very, very, very
- 25:27, very clearly is linked to the
- 25:30conformity we have regarding our peer
- 25:34group; because, in many cases, the
- 25:37desire to satisfy a certain need is
- 25:40particularly strong, especially if the
- 25:45purchases made have to do with proving
- 25:49to ourselves and others that we belong
- 25:52to a certain social group. Let's take a
- 25:55practical example. Uh, before we were
- 25:58talking about, uh, happy hours. It is
- 26:00very easy, in theory, to say to
- 26:03yourself: "No, no, look, let's do this:
- 26:05I'll manage my finances better, I'll
- 26:08decide to regulate the amount I spend
- 26:10on happy hours, pizzas, or dinners and
- 26:13things that have to do with hedonic and
- 26:15immediate gratification, but which on a
- 26:18purely economic level are perhaps not
- 26:21the wisest choice," right? It's easy to
- 26:25say, but when you find yourself there,
- 26:27you say, "Okay, look, I have my group
- 26:29of friends and every day the meeting
- 26:31point is let's meet at such and such a
- 26:33place to do X. Ah, let's meet there in
- 26:35the evening to do Y." Does one of these
- 26:37types of social occasions involve
- 26:38expenses? And it's hard to say, um, no,
- 26:43what do I do? Am I the only one who
- 26:46pulls back when my entire reference
- 26:49group has that type of lifestyle? What
- 26:52do I do? Do I raise a flag and say, "
- 26:54Hey guys, no, I've decided that from
- 26:56today I'm a conscious consumer and so
- 26:58I've decided to regulate this.""You
- 27:01guys go ahead, go ahead and talk,
- 27:03knowing that I'll be the only one
- 27:05missing, and so I'll become the
- 27:06laughingstock of the group against whom
- 27:09you'll vent all your desire to, as it
- 27:11were, uh, assert your lifestyle to
- 27:13which I've decided to no longer belong.
- 27:15" Yes, these are complex dynamics.
- 27:19Yes, shopping online has become so
- 27:20normal that we often do it almost
- 27:22without thinking. The process is simple
- 27:24, fast, automatic. But there is one
- 27:27thing that few people know. Behind many
- 27:29of our purchases is a company that
- 27:30works to make everything easier, both
- 27:32for those who buy and for those who
- 27:34sell. This company is Shopify, and that
- 27:36is precisely why Shopify is the number
- 27:39one checkout in the world. If you have
- 27:41an online business and want to offer a
- 27:43truly seamless shopping experience for
- 27:45your customers, go to shopify.com/360,
- 27:47all lowercase, and activate the trial
- 27:49for $ 1 a month. Where, in my opinion,
- 27:52without wanting to be too paternalistic
- 27:56, uh, is the reflection? The reflection
- 28:00is to understand what the balance is
- 28:02between today and tomorrow, because a
- 28:05mountain of studies has highlighted how
- 28:08one of the main predictors of success
- 28:11in people's lives is the postponement
- 28:13of gratification. If I were to tell the
- 28:19people listening to us what one of the
- 28:22most important things to do is to take
- 28:24care of yourself and try to have a
- 28:27prosperous, happy, healthy, and rich
- 28:30life, however much that term may mean
- 28:33many things. Well, a key element is
- 28:37precisely the ability to postpone
- 28:40gratification, therefore sacrificing
- 28:42something today in favor of a better
- 28:45tomorrow. And this, however, you learn
- 28:49from childhood. Mm.
- 28:52And if you were raised in an
- 28:53environment where certain habits were
- 28:55present, especially in money management
- 28:57, where certain cultural principles
- 28:59were present, etcetera, etcetera, it's
- 29:04hard in adulthood to turn things around
- 29:08. But also because, if we talk about
- 29:12pure economic wealth and therefore talk
- 29:15about access to goods and services, in
- 29:18a person's life there are basically
- 29:20three major decisions that can impact
- 29:23their economic status, and these
- 29:25concern: one, housing. They tell me
- 29:30that living under bridges is a bit of a
- 29:31mess, so one of the big expenses in
- 29:33life is deciding on a home.
- 29:35Home, rent, buy, don't buy, where you
- 29:38go to live, etcetera. And with the real
- 29:41estate situation that exists today in
- 29:43Italy, it's a disaster,
- 29:44right? It's a slaughter,
- 29:45it's a catastrophe. I mean, it's one
- 29:47thing to say, "Ah, but they pay me
- 29:48little, they pay me little." Okay,
- 29:49those are the salaries. Very well, you
- 29:52obviously have the responsibility to
- 29:54move forward in life by having skills
- 29:57that have great market value. But if we
- 30:00reason based on the average Italian
- 30:03population, the prospect, let's say, of
- 30:05buying a home, which seems to be a must
- 30:08in Italy, eh, and if you want we can
- 30:11talk about that, right? Because there
- 30:14is still a social component linked to
- 30:17saying, "Ah, look, I'm renting, so I'm
- 30:20basically a poor wretch destined for
- 30:22the worst fates in human life," because
- 30:25there is still a component of
- 30:27judgmental devaluation in Italy very
- 30:30often linked to those who decide not to
- 30:32buy a home, and yet, well, if someone
- 30:35says, "Okay, look, eh, at the very
- 30:38least I have to assume that if I want
- 30:40to buy a house, I will have to allocate
- 30:44at least 55-60%of my household income
- 30:47to this type of thing, and perhaps for
- 30:49even 25 or 30 years." Well, that means
- 30:53already accepting that you are getting
- 30:55yourself into trouble in an extremely
- 30:57violent way. Wisdom dictates that
- 31:01usually credit institutions that work
- 31:04with principles that ensure mortgage
- 31:07repayment can be sustained, tend to be
- 31:10very happy to lend money for a home
- 31:13purchase when the mortgage payment
- 31:16somehow reaches around 30-35%of the
- 31:19household income. Okay? One could say:
- 31:24"Well, we both work, we have a good
- 31:26salary, we're around 1600, 1700," or
- 31:29who knows, one earns 3,000 and the
- 31:31other earns 1,000, anyway, we have a
- 31:34certain type of income and assuming,
- 31:37let's say, € 3,000 a month as a
- 31:39household, eh, maximum € 900 a month,
- 31:42okay? Because this type of amount
- 31:47guarantees me that in the long run this
- 31:50expense is sustainable,
- 31:52okay? Because you have to live, after
- 31:54all, okay? And so, I mean, I pay the
- 31:56mortgage, but I don't buy groceries,
- 31:58fantastic. I don't think that's the
- 32:01best strategy. Um, but the awareness of
- 32:06these facts which are, so to speak, the
- 32:08daily bread for those who work in a
- 32:11financial institution, for those who
- 32:13deal with economics, well, we need to
- 32:15prepare more people. But not because we
- 32:18need to teach people to make money with
- 32:20trading etcetera, I mean financial
- 32:22education very often starts with
- 32:24families.
- 32:25I mean, because you say that, eh, the
- 32:27credit institution, I mean there is no
- 32:29education on savings, I mean, is that
- 32:31what you're saying?
- 32:33No, I'm saying that the fact that
- 32:36people know that if you buy a house,
- 32:38the ideal would be to have a situation
- 32:40where the mortgage payment value is
- 32:43around 30-35%of the household income.
- 32:46Well, that is not mainstream
- 32:48information.
- 32:49Okay. Okay. I believe
- 32:52one should know it. Eh, just as it
- 32:53would be very, very important to know
- 32:55that I say this with full awareness,
- 33:01the financial instrument with the
- 33:04highest absolute return that a person
- 33:07can turn to for their own good with a
- 33:10long-term horizon is called a pension
- 33:16fund.
- 33:17Okay?
- 33:17And one says "But how is that possible?
- 33:19Why doesn't everyone suggest that I do
- 33:21this?""Why do they propose that I buy
- 33:23ETFs, these other things, etcetera?" Eh
- 33:24, the answer is very simple, because
- 33:27you don't get immediate gratification.
- 33:30Those who propose it to you earn very
- 33:32little, but you, as the interested
- 33:33party, are the one who risks earning
- 33:35the most in absolute terms. And think
- 33:37that you risk earning so much that the
- 33:39State actually prevents you from
- 33:41putting in more than, if I'm not
- 33:42mistaken, € 5,000 a year or something
- 33:44like that. And you say, "But why would
- 33:46the State even go so far as to prevent
- 33:49me from putting so much money a year
- 33:51into this thing?" Because the tax
- 33:53benefits associated with having a
- 33:55pension fund are insane. It means I do
- 34:00something I always explain, and guys,
- 34:01if there are any financial advisors
- 34:03listening to this right now, for
- 34:05heaven's sake, explain it yourselves
- 34:07because I’m tired of having to
- 34:08explain it in my courses where I talk
- 34:10about neuromarketing and things like
- 34:12that. It's true, insurance companies
- 34:16call me, they call my team, they call
- 34:18me to train their sales force. I have
- 34:23many banks that call me to conduct
- 34:25training to explain to their lovely, um
- 34:28, financial advisors and finance
- 34:30experts how to effectively propose
- 34:32various types of financial instruments.
- 34:37So there is a huge need for people
- 34:39capable of explaining how to take care
- 34:42of one's own savings.
- 34:44Yeah, look, this second communicate, eh
- 34:45.
- 34:46Yes, yes, truly super delicate. Exactly
- 34:48. You were saying,
- 34:49let's say Virginia says, "You know what
- 34:51? This year I'll open a pension fund
- 34:54and put 1,000 euros into it," okay? I
- 34:56know I won’t use them right away,
- 34:57I'll need them in the future. Right,
- 35:00I’ll need them in the future, so
- 35:01it’s not an immediate thing. Okay? If
- 35:04I put, if Virginia puts 1,000 euros,
- 35:07the following year, when Virginia files
- 35:10her tax return, she is entitled to
- 35:13receive back a very, very substantial
- 35:16portion of the payment she made. Let's
- 35:20assume in this specific case, maybe the
- 35:22most conservative case, that you have a
- 35:2420%income tax rate. Okay? Suppose, okay
- 35:28? By putting in 1,000 euros, the
- 35:31following year you get 200 euros back
- 35:33in your tax return as a return on your
- 35:34investment. So what does that mean?
- 35:36It's as if you had invested 1,000 euros
- 35:38and received 200 back in return. It
- 35:41means you had a 20%risk-free return
- 35:44that year. I mean, you are certain that
- 35:48those 1,000 euros will generate a 20%
- 35:50return for you. But wait, what I’m
- 35:54doing is an absolutely theoretical case
- 35:56, because if you already had a, let’s
- 35:59say, 43%income tax rate, guess how much
- 36:02you’d get back? Exactly 43%. So, for
- 36:07heaven's sake, right? This is money you
- 36:10set aside and say, "Well, I'll act as
- 36:12if I never had it," okay? But you're
- 36:14not throwing that money away; that
- 36:16money is taken, invested, and you'll
- 36:18find it
- 36:20after n years, and it will be a
- 36:22fundamental crutch for the future, and
- 36:23in case you need dental care, a first
- 36:25home, etc., there are a whole series of
- 36:27ways to get it back, be able to use it,
- 36:29etc., but if you don't do it,
- 36:32Okay, delayed gratification beyond
- 36:34housing, what were the other two
- 36:35choices? Transportation,
- 36:37okay? So, cars,
- 36:39the car or how you generally commute to
- 36:42work, and well, it seems trivial, but
- 36:45moving around costs m
- 36:48m
- 36:48and it costs a lot. So, deciding
- 36:51whether you live near where you work or
- 36:54work from home, whether you buy a new
- 36:57or used car, etc., to consider—cars
- 37:00are the best way to burn through money
- 37:02in such an illogical, irrational way.
- 37:07I’m quite a car enthusiast, so I say
- 37:09this to myself before telling others,
- 37:11but I have a whole series of
- 37:13justifications for my choices that I
- 37:15won't go into here, but the car is the
- 37:18best way to disintegrate your net worth
- 37:20,
- 37:20so it’s better to use car sharing,
- 37:22use public transport,
- 37:25people can do what they want, but let's
- 37:27put it this way: I believe the choice
- 37:28of car or means of transport should be
- 37:30carefully evaluated. Okay, this seems
- 37:33like an excellent message to convey,
- 37:34because the idea of flaunting your
- 37:37income to people you don't know and
- 37:39whose envy you seek because you’re
- 37:42trying to show things that aren't there
- 37:45, etc., is really one of the worst
- 37:47choices you can make.
- 37:49Okay? Third thing: travel and
- 37:52entertainment. The hedonistic component
- 37:56of our lives must absolutely be
- 37:58nurtured, but without wanting to be
- 38:00patronizing at all costs, it’s
- 38:02obvious that if you put 25-30%of your
- 38:05income into travel and various forms of
- 38:07entertainment every year,
- 38:10Yes. Eh, you are making a choice that
- 38:13is perhaps worth putting into
- 38:15perspective. I say this with the
- 38:19astonishment of someone who still
- 38:22observes today that many people—whom
- 38:25I don't judge—decide to take many
- 38:28trips and are even willing to take out
- 38:31loans for travel. I have nothing
- 38:35personal against this. Something
- 38:37technical. We were supposed to talk
- 38:40about neuromarketing, let's talk about
- 38:41economics. But that’s perfectly fine,
- 38:43but also because the mental aspects
- 38:45tied to this are fantastic.
- 38:47You say: "I want a trip," that's great,
- 38:50I have no objections. I only have one
- 38:53caution, which is the golden rule for
- 38:55the financial prosperity of any person
- 38:57or company, which is: expenses you make
- 39:00in the short term, so, I don't know, "I
- 39:02want to pay for a nice dinner at a
- 39:04starred restaurant," that's fine, but
- 39:07what sources are you using to fund them
- 39:09? With your current income, that is,
- 39:12with short-term revenue. Okay? I mean,
- 39:15I have my salary, I have € 200 left
- 39:18over from the month's pay, I decide to
- 39:20spend these € 200 of my salary on a
- 39:22Michelin-starred dinner. All right, no
- 39:26problem. The problem arises if, when
- 39:29you go to have that Michelin-starred
- 39:31dinner, you don't have that money and
- 39:33you borrow it from the future.
- 39:35So what happens? You take on long-term
- 39:37debt, you take out a loan. So,
- 39:41technically, if you decide to finance a
- 39:44trip—which is an expense with
- 39:46immediate short-term gratification—
- 39:49with a long-term source, a loan, that's
- 39:52where the trouble begins. Look, the
- 39:56main indicator of a crisis that you can
- 39:59see from any company's balance sheet is
- 40:02linked to the fact that you see
- 40:04long-term funding sources increasing
- 40:07while long-term investments are not.
- 40:11Because that means you are in a state
- 40:13where you are taking out loans to pay
- 40:15employee salaries and to cover current
- 40:18expenses.
- 40:19Current ones. Okay. It's a very simple
- 40:22thing, but if I decide to get stuck in
- 40:24these situations where I don't see the
- 40:27fact that I'm taking money from the
- 40:30future to finance today, well, it could
- 40:33be that the levels of purely economic
- 40:36well-being—for heaven's sake, because
- 40:39well-being is something else—uh, can
- 40:42be very affected. And what is the bug?
- 40:45It's immediate gratification. Mm.
- 40:47It's this great desire you have to
- 40:50obtain pleasure today,
- 40:52right now,
- 40:53rather than taking the long term into
- 40:55account. Earlier, at the beginning, you
- 40:59said...you gave an example that really
- 41:02interested me: that of a company that
- 41:05wants to validate products or services
- 41:07it wants to offer, so to understand if
- 41:10it's actually not just an exercise in
- 41:13style, but if it meets a concrete, real
- 41:15need. How, how do you do that? I mean,
- 41:19let's even imagine I'm an entrepreneur
- 41:21who wants to
- 41:23start my own company, whether it's an
- 41:25innovative product or even if it's
- 41:26something standard, so I want to create
- 41:29my own line of perfumes. Mm.
- 41:31How do I figure out if there's room, if
- 41:34it's an idea that actually has a future
- 41:36, a foundation? I mean, what is it that
- 41:38you are doing?
- 41:39This, this, this question would require
- 41:41a series of lectures to be addressed. I
- 41:43will try—I'm not joking because it's
- 41:45a fantastic, very interesting topic,
- 41:48but one that would need to be explored
- 41:50a bit more. I will really go into uh,
- 41:54into giving a rundown of the
- 41:56possibilities. So, It depends a lot on
- 42:02how many resources you can invest in
- 42:05studying this and on the type of
- 42:08evaluations to be made depending on
- 42:11whether you are targeting the mass
- 42:15market or, uh, targeting other
- 42:17companies, so we are talking about
- 42:21business-to-consumer or
- 42:23business-to-business. So, in an ideal
- 42:26world, let's imagine having all
- 42:28possible resources in the world at our
- 42:29disposal. Therefore, let's assume we
- 42:32are a large multinational where
- 42:34investing is not a big problem, as long
- 42:36as there is a return.
- 42:38Well, the main path would be the use of
- 42:40magnetic resonance imaging, meaning I
- 42:42take a sample of people who resemble my
- 42:45target, I bring them into a nice
- 42:47laboratory with a nice MRI scanner
- 42:49inside, and using a very advanced
- 42:50system, I record the brain activity
- 42:52that a person experiences. While they
- 42:57are observing packaging prototypes,
- 42:58communication campaigns, product
- 42:59concepts, or millions of other things.
- 43:04And when I see that some specific areas
- 43:06are activated in people's brains with a
- 43:08sufficient number of subjects
- 43:10activating these areas,
- 43:12which areas
- 43:12in particular? The most famous and
- 43:15perhaps the most important one is
- 43:16called the Nucleus Accumbens,
- 43:19Which is the area that mediates the
- 43:21pleasure we feel as people and also has
- 43:24to do with motivation; it has to do
- 43:26with our learning and, essentially,
- 43:29there is a substantial body of
- 43:31literature today that tells us that
- 43:33when you subject people to an MRI brain
- 43:36scan in front of a product, a marketing
- 43:38campaign, or even a crowdfunding
- 43:41project, or even a piece of music, and
- 43:44even point-of-sale advertising that you
- 43:46place next to products. Well, if you
- 43:50see that a certain number of people
- 43:52activate the nucleus accumbens when
- 43:54exposed to a product and all the other
- 43:57things we talked about, then the
- 43:59probability that that specific type of
- 44:01stimulus you are presenting will later
- 44:03have great market success is very high.
- 44:06But there you are measuring the fact
- 44:08that those people like it, right? No,
- 44:10you are measuring, at a purely implicit
- 44:13and unconscious level, the creation of
- 44:16the impulse to desire that thing.
- 44:18Ah, okay.
- 44:19And it's something that is not mediated
- 44:21by rational aspects, and this is a
- 44:23fantastic thing. Meaning, if you have
- 44:26the same people you are measuring and
- 44:28ask them to tell you what they like or
- 44:30not, the statements people make to you
- 44:32often do not correspond to the activity
- 44:34of the nucleus accumbens; and there is
- 44:36a fantastic amount of literature where
- 44:38you can see that the activity of the
- 44:40nucleus accumbens is highly predictive
- 44:42of the success of the initiatives you
- 44:44then put in place, while the statements
- 44:46or the choices people make...and mind
- 44:48you, these are the same people, okay?
- 44:53People's statements and the choices
- 44:54they say they want to make are not
- 44:56predictive of success. In other words,
- 45:00it means that within a person, desire
- 45:02mechanisms activate automatically
- 45:04without being rationalized, and these
- 45:07mechanisms are predictive of success;
- 45:09but people are not aware that they are
- 45:11triggering these types of mechanisms,
- 45:14and when they state what they want to
- 45:16do or indicate possible options, these
- 45:18statements and choices are not
- 45:20predictive of actual market success.
- 45:25How do I, how do I go about activating
- 45:28this nucleus? How? I mean, how do I
- 45:31create this drive for desire? You don't
- 45:35—let's put it this way: the wisest
- 45:37way to answer this question is as
- 45:39follows: you don't create it, the
- 45:41person creates it within their own mind
- 45:44, primarily due to their cultural
- 45:46exposure and the learning they have
- 45:48developed. Paradoxically, it is not
- 45:52something you trigger; it is something
- 45:55you find as a trigger for the things
- 45:59you are presenting. Let me try to
- 46:01explain myself better. It's not that if
- 46:03you have a—let's say you have a
- 46:05product, let's say a detergent, okay?
- 46:08You say, "Okay, I'll do an MRI," great,
- 46:10and you see that a certain group of
- 46:11people reacts with a beautiful
- 46:13activation of the nucleus accumbens
- 46:14when you present this detergent to them
- 46:16. "Does that mean you've created desire
- 46:18for that detergent, right?" It means
- 46:22that the detergent meets a desire that
- 46:24is already there and that was created
- 46:26through culture, exposure to learning,
- 46:28and even, in part, genetic aspects and
- 46:30so on. But it's not like you created
- 46:34something extraordinary just by
- 46:37presenting the detergent. No, you are
- 46:39discovering that something is already
- 46:41there in people
- 46:42that there is a need of this kind. Okay
- 46:44. Eh,
- 46:45and that's because the vast majority of
- 46:48the elements that influence desire
- 46:49mechanisms have to do with cultural and
- 46:52learning aspects.
- 46:54In particular,
- 46:56I wouldn't want to bore you too much
- 46:58with this, but there is a structure
- 46:59called the Ventral Tegmental Area,
- 47:01which is the basis of the reward
- 47:03circuit and acts as a real radar that
- 47:05is constantly searching for rewards.
- 47:09And when the environment, or the
- 47:11experiences a person has, makes this
- 47:13area understand that a certain type of
- 47:16behavior leads to rewards, this area,
- 47:19puff, signals it and keeps it as a real
- 47:22memory, so that from then on, every
- 47:24time I encounter that stimulus that I
- 47:27know predicts the possibility of
- 47:29getting a reward, I, paff, will
- 47:33activate the desire mechanisms and feel
- 47:35the desire and motivation to move
- 47:37toward that type of thing. Let's take a
- 47:40practical example. I am a child, I am
- 47:42born into this beautiful world. Well,
- 47:45one day I smell something in the
- 47:47kitchen, fantastic. I don't know what
- 47:49it is. My ventral tegmental area is
- 47:52there, and it doesn't really react to
- 47:54this smell. This smell is a delicious
- 47:57smell of chocolate. Okay. I don't know
- 47:59if you're passionate about chocolate.
- 48:01Yes, yes. I love chocolate, but the
- 48:03child doesn't know it's chocolate, so
- 48:06it might be that mom or dad or whoever
- 48:08says, "Hey, taste this little piece of
- 48:11chocolate." I have two children, and
- 48:13I've seen this happen firsthand. When
- 48:17you give a child a piece of chocolate
- 48:19for the first time in their life, the
- 48:22organoleptic reaction they experience
- 48:24upon tasting it isn't always pleasure.
- 48:28It doesn't always generate pleasure the
- 48:30first time because chocolate has a
- 48:32particular flavor, and the flavor of
- 48:34chocolate isn't something particularly,
- 48:36shall we say, natural— "natural" in
- 48:38quotes—but inside the chocolate there
- 48:40are substances that go on to trigger a
- 48:42nice release of dopamine. These types
- 48:45of substances therefore generate a
- 48:47pleasure response that, poof, is
- 48:49intercepted by our beautiful ventral
- 48:51tegmental area. And what happens? A
- 48:55memory is created tied to the fact that
- 48:57, from then on, when you smell
- 48:59chocolate and know it's chocolate and
- 49:02there's the possibility of having that
- 49:04kind of thing in your mouth again, this
- 49:07"click" is created—this mechanism of
- 49:09activating motivation and desire; and
- 49:12from there is born what is essentially
- 49:14a kind of, uh, desire for chocolate
- 49:16that didn't exist before and that was
- 49:19shaped by experience.
- 49:21Okay? So, how is it that I create
- 49:23desires, in quotes, inside people? It
- 49:25is in this way. Is there only one
- 49:27company in the world that could have
- 49:29enough resources to shape people's
- 49:32desires by virtue of the experience it
- 49:34exposes them to, the culture it exposes
- 49:36them to, and so on? The answer is
- 49:39probably no. With a small asterisk. Why
- 49:43this asterisk? Because, if I think
- 49:46about the fact that Coca-Cola became
- 49:48what it is also by virtue of the fact
- 49:51that it continued to bombard for
- 49:53decades, uh, the Western population (
- 49:58but not only) with messages where the
- 50:01brand is associated with happy moments
- 50:03like family parties and so on; and not
- 50:05just that, but also with Christmas.
- 50:09They tell me, I don't know if it's true
- 50:11, but they tell me that Santa Claus
- 50:12even seems to be an invention of
- 50:14Coca-Cola. I haven't found the sources
- 50:16that explain this thing here, but they
- 50:18say that there is this type of thing. I
- 50:20don't know if it's true. Well, it is
- 50:22evident that the continuous and uh how
- 50:29should I put it, persistent exposure to
- 50:32content that makes you understand that
- 50:34a certain drink is present in happy
- 50:37moments—and you're exposed to these
- 50:39concepts from birth—well, it creates
- 50:42some kind of memory inside us.
- 50:45and this can create associative
- 50:46mechanisms that lead us to be
- 50:48particularly influenced by brands and
- 50:50much more. So, for example, a brand
- 50:53like Coca-Cola identified a real need
- 50:56and then reinforced it through these
- 50:59mechanisms, right?
- 51:02They leveraged, let's put it that way,
- 51:04the real need—in quotes, if we want
- 51:06to define it that way, although we can
- 51:08delve deeper into needs later—the
- 51:10real need is joy, happiness, convivial
- 51:12moments, social interaction,
- 51:15okay?
- 51:16Which, in itself, is rewarding for
- 51:18human beings.
- 51:20Okay? And you say, "Okay, that
- 51:23situation works better, or is just nice
- 51:25, also because my product is there."
- 51:28Mhm.
- 51:28So, I'm not saying my product is
- 51:30indispensable for that situation, but I
- 51:33am saying, "Look, when there's that
- 51:36party, that nice, pleasant moment, etc.
- 51:39, if this product is there,"
- 51:41you
- 51:42you enjoy it to the fullest.
- 51:44Yes. Eh, if I didn't have an MRI, so if
- 51:47I can't see...mhm, because for me, like
- 51:50, the best way that comes to mind to
- 51:53actually understand if something might
- 51:56be liked or might be useful is to run
- 51:59surveys, to use questionnaires. But you
- 52:03said that many times the answer someone
- 52:04gives isn't the real one, so how do I
- 52:06figure out what...
- 52:08Well, let's start sliding down, let's
- 52:10say, the slope of super-hyper-ultra
- 52:11reliability. In second place, you would
- 52:15put laboratory experiments—that is,
- 52:17controlled situations where you measure
- 52:20how people react to your presentation.
- 52:25By using, in a somewhat advanced and
- 52:27clever way, certain mental mechanisms
- 52:29as proxies for the reaction elements of
- 52:31the nucleus accumbens, the reward
- 52:33circuit, and many other things, you get
- 52:35very close.
- 52:37Okay? It's not exactly the same thing,
- 52:40but you get very, very, very close and
- 52:42you can understand so, so, so much
- 52:44about the potential. Third thing: I
- 52:48love all the systems linked to startup
- 52:50development, where you use the real
- 52:53world as a true laboratory, meaning
- 52:55there is nothing more real than reality
- 52:58itself. Yes. So, uh, like some lean
- 53:02startup systems, or whatever they're
- 53:05called, what's better than creating
- 53:08your project, establishing its
- 53:11fundamental features, and really trying
- 53:14to put it out there using actual
- 53:17potential customers as a feedback tool,
- 53:21where the parameter to measure as a
- 53:24predictor of potential real success is
- 53:27people's actual willingness to pay?
- 53:30That is: I present something to a
- 53:33person, it doesn't even have to be
- 53:35created yet; it's important that I know
- 53:38how to describe it to a potential lead,
- 53:41but describe it knowing that my lead
- 53:44cannot imagine things I am not stating.
- 53:47This is a fundamental issue. Meaning,
- 53:50it is important that I package my
- 53:53proposal with all its features as if it
- 53:55had already been created, okay? I don't
- 53:58have to develop anything other than its
- 54:00description.
- 54:00Okay?
- 54:02Then I go, I look for subjects who, in
- 54:04my opinion, are potential customers,
- 54:07and I offer this solution with the goal
- 54:09of seeing if these people, once I
- 54:11explain this type of project, these
- 54:13types of features, etc., are actually
- 54:15willing to sign something that tells me
- 54:17: "Yes, I'll buy it for this amount."
- 54:21What is the key aspect? It's seeing the
- 54:24person's actual purchasing behavior,
- 54:26knowing that if someone tells you, "Yes
- 54:28, yes, I'm interested." It's not enough
- 54:31.
- 54:31Mh.
- 54:32It should be "Yes, I'm interested."
- 54:34What's next? Ah, look, it requires X
- 54:37resources. Okay, are you willing? Yes.
- 54:41Are you willing to write me something
- 54:42to the effect that when it's ready
- 54:44you'll buy it, maybe even give me a
- 54:45deposit,
- 54:46a letter of intent.
- 54:47Exactly. Or even a down payment, like,
- 54:49"Look, I'm asking for 10%of whatever it
- 54:51is, and there you go. Okay? If the
- 54:54answer is yes, okay, and you have' n '
- 54:57yesses, one after another, linked to
- 54:59similar subjects who have the same
- 55:02types of needs that you can effectively
- 55:05fill well, that is a powerful signal.
- 55:08Only,
- 55:10you need to put yourself in a position
- 55:12to invest time and resources to
- 55:14actually connect your proposal with
- 55:17potential buyers. And this is where the
- 55:19magic happens. Because you can have the
- 55:23best product in the world, but in many
- 55:25cases, you don't know who is actually
- 55:27willing to buy it, and the world is
- 55:29full of business cases like this. I'll
- 55:32share one that is publicly available on
- 55:35the web so as not to, you know, breach
- 55:37the secrets of my clients. It seems
- 55:42that in the early 2000s, a huge
- 55:45multinational was developing a molecule
- 55:47that was actually the only one in the
- 55:50world capable of destroying odors in
- 55:52environments. In environments. So, a
- 55:56molecule that once sprayed into a room
- 55:58was totally non-toxic to life forms,
- 56:01therefore completely harmless, and
- 56:03which could simultaneously disintegrate
- 56:06any odor present in the environment.
- 56:08Okay? A revolutionary technology. One
- 56:13might say," Well, a business idea like
- 56:14this, who wouldn't be able to sell it?
- 56:16"I mean, you're the first in the world;
- 56:18those who deal with neuroscience and
- 56:20behavioral science like I do know
- 56:22perfectly well that something like this
- 56:24definitely has enormous potential. But
- 56:27there is a major problem, which is the
- 56:30following: since it is something new,
- 56:32people on average react to something
- 56:35highly new with an emotion of fear.
- 56:39Terror. I don't know if you're aware,
- 56:44but the Wright brothers, who invented
- 56:46the airplane, took, if I'm not mistaken
- 56:48, 8 years to sell the first airplane to
- 56:50someone, because the fear of the new is
- 56:53often much greater than the benefits a
- 56:55person can imagine from the purchase.
- 56:58The marketing department in this
- 57:00multinational had to get to work to try
- 57:03to introduce this new product to the
- 57:05market. And the first type of market
- 57:10development they imagined was based on
- 57:12the fact that people wanted to remove
- 57:15odors from the environment—I mean,
- 57:17it's obvious. So, who do you target?
- 57:21People who feel the need to remove
- 57:23odors from their environment. So they
- 57:26do the whole project, they do the
- 57:28market research, they do everything,
- 57:31they launch the product, it arrives in
- 57:33supermarkets, it lasts a month, and
- 57:35then sales go to zero.
- 57:38Oh god,
- 57:39zero. Okay. And I'll let you imagine, a
- 57:43project like this isn't a project that
- 57:46cost € 200, okay? We are talking
- 57:49about tens of millions between
- 57:50communication, development, and
- 57:52everything else. Well, so after a month
- 57:55, sales completely stall, at which
- 57:58point the folks in the marketing
- 58:00department, given that they sensed they
- 58:03would probably soon have to look for a
- 58:06new job, got to work saying," Wait,
- 58:09okay, we got something wrong, what? "It
- 58:13wasn't, wasn't, wasn't, wasn't, wasn't
- 58:14known. They went to research it, and
- 58:16what did they discover? They discovered
- 58:19that their own pre-launch ideas had
- 58:21conditioned the entire development of
- 58:23the research because instead of trying
- 58:26to understand what people actually
- 58:28wanted in association with that product
- 58:30, they had conditioned the entire
- 58:32framework of the study based on the
- 58:34assumption that it was a given that
- 58:36people wanted to remove odors from the
- 58:38environment.
- 58:40M.
- 58:40And what was seen later in the data? It
- 58:43was seen that they hadn't even remotely
- 58:45noticed that people who live in very
- 58:48smelly environments don't smell those
- 58:50odors because they are sensory-adapted
- 58:52to them. Let's take an example. Let's
- 58:55imagine living near, really near a
- 58:58pigsty. Pig farms are fantastic places,
- 59:00but admittedly, on an olfactory level,
- 59:02they are a bit challenging. If I live
- 59:04in those situations, after, if I
- 59:06remember correctly, 15 days, our
- 59:08sensory bulbs realize that that type of
- 59:11smell is part of everyday normality,
- 59:13and what do they do? They tell the
- 59:16brain, in very complex ways without
- 59:18getting into the details," ignore this
- 59:21smell, "and you no longer smell it, and
- 59:23therefore you no longer feel the need
- 59:25to have a system that removes the odor.
- 59:28Sema, what should they have done in
- 59:30your opinion? What they did
- 59:31subsequently: approaching the market in
- 59:33a pure way, saying," Okay, we have this
- 59:35product. "
- 59:36Yes.
- 59:36Good.
- 59:38In what situations would you use it?
- 59:40Take it, use it, see what benefit it
- 59:42gives you, and tell me if you'd be
- 59:44willing to buy it again, and under what
- 59:46conditions—not in theory, but in
- 59:47practice. What did they see? They saw
- 59:51that the only people who were actually
- 59:54willing to spend money and buy it again
- 59:56were people very attentive to cleaning
- 59:59their homes, people who were looking
- 1:00:02not just to remove odors, but to ensure
- 1:00:05that, once the cleaning was done, the
- 1:00:07scents in the house were perfect. Mmh.
- 1:00:12So, a sort of search for the icing on
- 1:00:15the cake, to avoid the risk that if
- 1:00:18someone walked into the house after
- 1:00:21cleaning, there would be even the
- 1:00:24slightest chance of bad smells. And
- 1:00:27there, bam, everything changed, and the
- 1:00:29product was a planetary success and is
- 1:00:31still on the market today.
- 1:00:32Crazy. Anyway, this, in my opinion, is
- 1:00:36one of the most difficult phases in the
- 1:00:38life of a startup: validating the
- 1:00:40problem and then finding people who
- 1:00:43actually need that product or service.
- 1:00:46Sorry if I'm smiling, but as a former
- 1:00:48startupper,
- 1:00:49mh.
- 1:00:50I see myself 100%in all of these things
- 1:00:53. You should know that, um, I work in
- 1:00:56neuroscience, mainly applied behavioral
- 1:00:59sciences in the first part of my
- 1:01:01journey, and then more on the
- 1:01:03neurobehavioral side, so that's been
- 1:01:06since 2007, and I can assure you that
- 1:01:09at the beginning of my journey, when I
- 1:01:11would go around telling people what I
- 1:01:14wanted to do—I was 25—the vast
- 1:01:16majority of people around me looked at
- 1:01:19me like I was crazy, okay? And I would
- 1:01:22then say," But, but wait, but... "" I
- 1:01:25have the data, I have the research, I
- 1:01:27mean, there is science behind these
- 1:01:28things; it's not like I just made it up
- 1:01:30. "And I had some major industrial
- 1:01:33groups that believed in my research, to
- 1:01:36the point that I was lucky enough to be
- 1:01:38a researcher driven by the results of
- 1:01:41some studies I produced, uh, very young
- 1:01:43, and that were really very interesting
- 1:01:46things. And I had very large companies
- 1:01:49that financed my presence in the lab
- 1:01:51because I was discovering things that
- 1:01:54didn't exist. Um, when I later created
- 1:01:59my own company, I assure you that
- 1:02:02finding a business model was not
- 1:02:04immediate. Sure,
- 1:02:06because I thought that once I’d built
- 1:02:08this beautiful research lab with all
- 1:02:10these ultra-technologies inside,
- 1:02:12everyone would flock to do research in
- 1:02:14this field because the benefits
- 1:02:16associated with these types of studies
- 1:02:18are so evident that even a blind person
- 1:02:21could see them. And I am still waiting
- 1:02:24for that to happen. I mean, after 6
- 1:02:28months of the company's operation,
- 1:02:30where essentially expenses were higher
- 1:02:33than income, I had to look myself in
- 1:02:35the mirror and say," I think there's a
- 1:02:38problem with the business model. "
- 1:02:41Something clearly isn't right.
- 1:02:42No. And figuring out how to turn the
- 1:02:45situation around, I did it by doing
- 1:02:47exactly the things I just finished
- 1:02:50telling you about. mh
- 1:02:53discovering that my entire setup—from
- 1:02:55service offerings and business model to
- 1:02:58communication—was way off the mark.
- 1:03:02But when I saw where it was off, and in
- 1:03:05what way, using the methods that are
- 1:03:08part of my profession—which I
- 1:03:10obviously applied to myself, as well as
- 1:03:12to my clients, but applying them to me
- 1:03:15first as a startuper—I could see how
- 1:03:18far off I was in aligning my proposal
- 1:03:20with the desires of the other side.
- 1:03:23When I realigned my communication and
- 1:03:26my business model with the desires of
- 1:03:29my potential clients, we started
- 1:03:31working.
- 1:03:32So, imagine having a person in front of
- 1:03:35you who is starting their own business,
- 1:03:37who perhaps has an entrepreneurial idea
- 1:03:39, right? And this person says," Alright
- 1:03:42, I want to validate it, and I also
- 1:03:43want to validate it, as you were saying
- 1:03:45, in the real market because I can't
- 1:03:46afford to do all these other things. "
- 1:03:48Beautiful, fantastic, wonderful. The
- 1:03:51first thing I would say to this person
- 1:03:52is," I'm with you, believe in it, keep
- 1:03:54going, don't give up. "I mean, now I
- 1:03:57realize I might seem a bit unhinged,
- 1:04:01but really: when I see someone, or when
- 1:04:05someone comes to me with fire in their
- 1:04:10eyes and the desire to try to do
- 1:04:13something, but in a polite, passionate,
- 1:04:17kind, yet energetic way, I really do
- 1:04:21what I can to help. And some of my best
- 1:04:26professional experiences involve people
- 1:04:29who started from scratch, where I
- 1:04:32personally helped them develop their
- 1:04:35ideas and they reached good levels of
- 1:04:38success. Um, I really see the power of
- 1:04:44science at work. Mh mh.
- 1:04:46Because in so many cases it can truly
- 1:04:48change people's lives.
- 1:04:50In any case, the first thing I would do
- 1:04:52is tell them: go for it, but be careful
- 1:04:55. Okay. And, it’s great that, as
- 1:04:58Steve Jobs said, it’s certainly
- 1:05:00important to be hungry and foolish,
- 1:05:02right? Stay hungry, stay foolish. Only,
- 1:05:06I think that Steve Jobs, when
- 1:05:08addressing startuppers, could have
- 1:05:10prudently added one phrase. A phrase
- 1:05:13that basically means yes, but don't be
- 1:05:16stupid—I mean, keep calm, because
- 1:05:18creating a company is a marathon, not a
- 1:05:20sprint. So validate the business, but
- 1:05:24put yourself in a position to know that
- 1:05:26everything could go wrong, not because
- 1:05:28we have to be defeatists, but because
- 1:05:31we must be realistic. The chances of
- 1:05:35success are there, but it's not a given
- 1:05:38that they are so clearly in front of
- 1:05:40you that you can understand how to fit
- 1:05:43into the context where you'd like to
- 1:05:46operate. So, calm, cool-headedness, and
- 1:05:51caution, but with determination. Let's
- 1:05:54go. Okay? If that's the discussion, you
- 1:05:57start by saying," Okay, who could your
- 1:05:59client be? "What is so special about
- 1:06:01the solution you are offering that can
- 1:06:03change their life? What are the pains
- 1:06:05that it removes for them? What are the
- 1:06:07types of benefits that one can obtain?
- 1:06:10And above all, let's gear up to create
- 1:06:13a project that has a beginning and an
- 1:06:15end with a clear proposal. Let's
- 1:06:18validate it, let's go see how people
- 1:06:21respond to these proposals. And yes, in
- 1:06:24some cases, if there are no resources,
- 1:06:27you can do it by putting yourself out
- 1:06:29there to sell directly or trying to
- 1:06:32sell this type of solution directly to
- 1:06:34the market without embarrassment, also
- 1:06:37because one of the things I really want
- 1:06:39to repeat for the umpteenth time is the
- 1:06:42following. As a startupper, the number
- 1:06:46of people in Italy who were totally
- 1:06:51unknown to me, and who, once they met
- 1:06:55me working to create my own company,
- 1:06:59equipped with a smile,
- 1:07:03kindness, passion, grit, listening
- 1:07:08skills, and a desire to work. Okay? The
- 1:07:12amount of people who appeared in my
- 1:07:15life out of nowhere and wanted to help
- 1:07:19me on my path without wanting anything
- 1:07:22in return is enormous. And I can assure
- 1:07:25you, dear Virginia,
- 1:07:27that Italy is full of people like that.
- 1:07:33Forgive me if I take a second to say
- 1:07:35this, but the number of people in Italy
- 1:07:39who move with politeness, persistence,
- 1:07:42passion, grit, kindness, and
- 1:07:44determination is still very high today,
- 1:07:47and just as high is the number of
- 1:07:50people who respond very favorably to
- 1:07:53those who act in this way. I can tell
- 1:07:57you that just recently I've been
- 1:07:59following n-projects of even very young
- 1:08:02people who are reaching photonic levels
- 1:08:04of success that no one talks about. But
- 1:08:07why? Not because these stories don't
- 1:08:11exist, but because these people are so
- 1:08:14busy doing their jobs that they aren't
- 1:08:16there waving it around, saying:" Yes,
- 1:08:18look, a real case of a client of mine,
- 1:08:21I have a client who are two guys who,
- 1:08:23in their own small way, at 27 years old
- 1:08:25, have brought home something like 260
- 1:08:28million euros in investment for their
- 1:08:30business idea in Italy. "M
- 1:08:34in Italy, eh, they do complicated
- 1:08:35things with computers,
- 1:08:37okay,
- 1:08:38but um in Italy, and look, they say
- 1:08:41it's an exception, but go and see all
- 1:08:44the stories of Italian companies and
- 1:08:46people who are doing fantastic things
- 1:08:49that aren't talked about, because these
- 1:08:52stories are good for everyone.
- 1:08:55Beautiful. Yes, yes, beautiful indeed.
- 1:08:58It's just great to know that in the
- 1:09:00dark, in the gloom of a world that
- 1:09:02seems on the brink, there are—and
- 1:09:05there are many—people who are doing
- 1:09:07great.
- 1:09:09Incredible thing. So, keep going.
- 1:09:11Second thing, uh,
- 1:09:13test the model.
- 1:09:14Test the model. How do you test the
- 1:09:15model? By going directly to the market.
- 1:09:18Yes, look, if there are some resources,
- 1:09:20you can get by with a technique called
- 1:09:22decision-making process analysis, where
- 1:09:24you figure out which mental mechanisms
- 1:09:26are associated with the purchase and
- 1:09:28which can be predictive of success.
- 1:09:30Okay?
- 1:09:31Okay.
- 1:09:32Uh, it's not an extremely demanding
- 1:09:34thing, but a few thousand euros for
- 1:09:35this type of research
- 1:09:37are needed.
- 1:09:37Yes, yes, yes, yes. They are necessary.
- 1:09:39But if you don't have them, it doesn't
- 1:09:41mean you have to say," Oh, God, I'm
- 1:09:42desperate. "" No, no,
- 1:09:44get to work. Get moving, get mentored,
- 1:09:47look for mentors, look for someone who
- 1:09:49can help you, look for entrepreneurs
- 1:09:50who see what you're doing and who try
- 1:09:52to give you a hand as well. Even if
- 1:09:54they expect you for lunch, and during a
- 1:09:57lunch or dinner you’re there for 2
- 1:09:59hours talking with these people, and
- 1:10:01they tell you how they see things, how
- 1:10:03they don't, how they could help you,
- 1:10:05who they know in that sector for you to
- 1:10:07talk to, introducing you to this person
- 1:10:10or that, etc., you have to move
- 1:10:12delicately and kindly because these are
- 1:10:14very busy people. And they certainly
- 1:10:17don't have time to waste, they have
- 1:10:19time to invest in people who move with
- 1:10:22kindness, politeness, and passion, and
- 1:10:24who have a passion for doing something.
- 1:10:27One thing I always suggest is to watch
- 1:10:30the beginning of the movie The Devil
- 1:10:32Wears Prada,
- 1:10:34where there's this fantastic girl who
- 1:10:37goes to an interview and says certain
- 1:10:39things: "I would pay to have someone
- 1:10:41come to me for a company interview and
- 1:10:44tell me those things." I would be
- 1:10:46What is it that she says?
- 1:10:49Well, she introduces herself saying "
- 1:10:52I've done this, I've done that," etc.
- 1:10:54The other person, if I’m not mistaken
- 1:10:56it's Meryl Streep, snubs her quite
- 1:10:58brutally saying "Ugh, how awful,"
- 1:11:00etcetera, etcetera, and when she's
- 1:11:02rejected, she says, "Look, that’s
- 1:11:04fine, just know that I'm here, I have a
- 1:11:06great desire to work here, and I learn
- 1:11:08very, very quickly. If there's anyone
- 1:11:11bright who can lend a hand, I'm here."
- 1:11:13Beautiful. Um,
- 1:11:15to this day, I haven't done an
- 1:11:17interview like that one yet. But
- 1:11:21Giuliano, what are cognitive biases, or
- 1:11:23rather, what are cognitive biases and
- 1:11:25what are the most common ones? So,
- 1:11:29cognitive biases are a whole series of
- 1:11:32automatic and unconscious reactions
- 1:11:35that develop within us to certain types
- 1:11:40of communicative stimuli that reach us,
- 1:11:43or to situations we find ourselves in,
- 1:11:46which tend to make our choices distant
- 1:11:49from the choices of a perfectly
- 1:11:51rational agent. That is, if I were to
- 1:11:55take the behavior, quote-unquote,
- 1:11:56presumed of an artificial intelligence,
- 1:11:58which is perfectly logical and rational
- 1:12:00, and compare it in those situations to
- 1:12:02the behavior of a human being, well, I
- 1:12:04would find a significant distance. This
- 1:12:07is because in our minds there is a
- 1:12:10whole series of mental shortcuts linked
- 1:12:15to our evolution as a species and of
- 1:12:20communication mechanisms between brain
- 1:12:22areas. that lead our behavior in some
- 1:12:26cases to be far from that of a
- 1:12:28perfectly rational agent, and in a way
- 1:12:31that is tends to be predictable. What
- 1:12:34does that mean? It means that by
- 1:12:37analyzing the situations in which a
- 1:12:39person has to decide, if these
- 1:12:41situations include biases, you can
- 1:12:43predict the choices and behaviors of
- 1:12:46the vast majority of people. And these
- 1:12:50biases have been studied for many, many
- 1:12:53years. No, the topic of cognitive
- 1:12:55biases isn't new, although, I don't
- 1:12:57know, apparently in Italy it seems to
- 1:12:59be. A brand-new topic, but it's really
- 1:13:03fascinating and curious. Um,
- 1:13:06which ones are the most frequent?
- 1:13:07Well, the most frequent—the first
- 1:13:10thing I'll tell you is that there are
- 1:13:12hundreds of cognitive biases currently
- 1:13:14known in literature.
- 1:13:16Okay?
- 1:13:17So knowing them all is a bit tough.
- 1:13:19Let's say that, at number one, among my
- 1:13:23, uh, subjective preferences as a bias
- 1:13:26very, very, very present in people's
- 1:13:29lives, there's the confirmation bias,
- 1:13:33which is the bias that tends to
- 1:13:36activate within us when, in the
- 1:13:38environment we are exposed to, we go
- 1:13:42looking for confirmation of our beliefs
- 1:13:45, rather than information that
- 1:13:49disproves our convictions. Let's say
- 1:13:53that confirmation bias is an insidious
- 1:13:56enemy within us because it tends to
- 1:13:58give more value to information that
- 1:14:01confirms rather than disproves our
- 1:14:03ideas. And it's a bias that also leads
- 1:14:07us to interpret ambiguous data as data
- 1:14:11in favor of our opinions, and it's a
- 1:14:13disaster. Look at the error I was
- 1:14:17telling you about earlier regarding the
- 1:14:19case of the air freshener, the odor
- 1:14:21eliminator.
- 1:14:22Yes. Ah, that was a confirmation bias.
- 1:14:24It’s totally confirmation bias,
- 1:14:25because what do you do? You direct the
- 1:14:28entire development of your idea based
- 1:14:30on your beliefs because you go looking
- 1:14:33for confirmation of what you believe to
- 1:14:35be true.
- 1:14:37Okay? And it's a bias that, for
- 1:14:40startupers—if there's anyone watching
- 1:14:43this nice podcast or listening—it's
- 1:14:46terrible, because look, don't hate me,
- 1:14:48listeners, but graphic designers,
- 1:14:51creatives, musicians, and startupers
- 1:14:54don't tend to work; they give birth.
- 1:14:58What does that mean? It means that when
- 1:15:01these individuals often find themselves
- 1:15:03creating their own businesses, the
- 1:15:05moment you go to them—even based on
- 1:15:07data—and say, "Well, maybe there's an
- 1:15:13opportunity to make a small change so
- 1:15:15that this could be more successful." In
- 1:15:19many cases, it's as if you were beating
- 1:15:23someone’s child that has just been
- 1:15:26born, saying, "Oh!""Oh, you're telling
- 1:15:30me to change something I created with
- 1:15:32so much sweat and effort, putting in a
- 1:15:34mountain of work, etc., because in my
- 1:15:36opinion..." There, we’ve already
- 1:15:38stopped talking,
- 1:15:40okay? And it's a shame, because if we
- 1:15:44know that this is a type of tendency
- 1:15:46linked to the fact that our mind is,
- 1:15:49quote-unquote, protecting us from the
- 1:15:51pain of admitting that we are wrong or
- 1:15:54that we could be in error, well, the
- 1:15:56whole conversation changes a lot in my
- 1:15:59opinion. Yes. Usually, those who
- 1:16:02approach entrepreneurial projects,
- 1:16:04design projects, and many other things
- 1:16:07in a much purer way, free from
- 1:16:09expectations and preconceptions, um,
- 1:16:15tend to perform better.
- 1:16:17mh
- 1:16:18Quite simply, but why? Because they
- 1:16:20make fewer mistakes.
- 1:16:21I mean, we are all fallible in some way
- 1:16:25, and the idea that a human being
- 1:16:27cannot make mistakes is really more of
- 1:16:32a curse than anything else, right? So,
- 1:16:35knowing that
- 1:16:37you might make a mistake, the antidote
- 1:16:39to these types of errors is admitting
- 1:16:42that it can happen and putting yourself
- 1:16:44in a state where you say, "Okay, wait,
- 1:16:47let's move with a bit of caution." I
- 1:16:49have my own convictions, but let's do
- 1:16:51this, let's see what the world tells us
- 1:16:53, right?
- 1:16:55And being at least a little open
- 1:16:57to evaluating what the world tells us
- 1:16:59can be interesting. So, number one on
- 1:17:01my list is confirmation bias. Wonderful
- 1:17:04.
- 1:17:04Then there are all the social effects
- 1:17:07linked to conformity, social proof, and
- 1:17:10the bandwagon effect, which are
- 1:17:12ultra-present in our lives, and some of
- 1:17:15these are even fundamental in
- 1:17:18determining the success of new
- 1:17:20technologies, new types of products and
- 1:17:23services. In particular, for those
- 1:17:26listening, if anyone wants to delve
- 1:17:28into the topic of the so-called
- 1:17:30crossing the chasm, there is a book by
- 1:17:32Geoffrey Moore on this subject called "
- 1:17:35Crossing the Chasm." It can be
- 1:17:38incredibly useful, because in many
- 1:17:41cases technological innovations do not
- 1:17:43succeed because of the benefits they
- 1:17:46offer people, but also, and above all,
- 1:17:49because of the type of social
- 1:17:51mechanisms they are able to trigger in
- 1:17:53the population, where there is a sort
- 1:17:56of club of people who are the first to
- 1:17:59adopt these new technologies, etc., but
- 1:18:02who don't just have the role of early
- 1:18:04adopters, but also the role of true
- 1:18:08evangelists for this technology or this
- 1:18:10new solution.
- 1:18:12And this can really change the life of
- 1:18:14anyone who has an entrepreneurial
- 1:18:15project.
- 1:18:16Meaning, what are you saying? That
- 1:18:18the ability to manage the social
- 1:18:21aspects of new technology adoption
- 1:18:23determines its success or failure.
- 1:18:26Okay?
- 1:18:27Because, tendentially, the concept of
- 1:18:30new rhymes with dangerous in the human
- 1:18:34mind. True?
- 1:18:35And so if you launch a project of yours
- 1:18:38that you have reflected on, birthed but
- 1:18:41not created, and you say, "Yes, I'm
- 1:18:43launching it, fantastic." And now
- 1:18:46everyone is going to see why I am
- 1:18:48better than Google. What did I just
- 1:18:49hear? And I made n super cool things,
- 1:18:51etc., and don't you see how many
- 1:18:53advantages are in there? Yes, okay,
- 1:18:56great. That's part of the game. The
- 1:19:00other part is finding a core group of
- 1:19:02people who are happy to use your
- 1:19:04technology, product, service, whatever
- 1:19:07it is, but who aren't just customers;
- 1:19:09they are also willing to act as
- 1:19:12evangelists for this new technology.
- 1:19:15Because, if this process of literal
- 1:19:20social diffusion, from peer to peer, of
- 1:19:22the benefits of the technology isn't
- 1:19:25triggered, the probability that this
- 1:19:27new technology, new project, or new
- 1:19:29service will meet an absolute economic
- 1:19:31disaster is quite high.
- 1:19:33An
- 1:19:35and there are a ton of other biases; I
- 1:19:36won't stand here and tell you all of
- 1:19:37them. If you're interested in this, go
- 1:19:39ahead; there are piles of manuals you
- 1:19:41can draw from. I also wrote a book
- 1:19:45called Applied Neuromarketing, where I
- 1:19:48talk about them extensively, but a book
- 1:19:51that is very, very, very dear to me is
- 1:19:54the beautiful—with all the' s 'sounds
- 1:19:57that nature gave me—book by Dan
- 1:20:00Ariely titled Predictably Irrational.
- 1:20:04It's a fantastic book; read it, it's
- 1:20:06really beautiful, beautiful, beautiful,
- 1:20:08beautiful.
- 1:20:09Let's make a note of that. A study by
- 1:20:12Iyengar and Lepper demonstrated that
- 1:20:15supermarket customers
- 1:20:18when faced with 24 types of jam, were
- 1:20:20intrigued but bought very little.
- 1:20:22Yep.
- 1:20:23Conversely, with only six options,
- 1:20:25purchases increased by 900%.
- 1:20:28Nice stats, huh? Fantastic.
- 1:20:30What is happening in our heads? Ah,
- 1:20:33look, this is a delicious topic. Will
- 1:20:36you allow me to approach it from a
- 1:20:37perspective, if you like, a bit fresh
- 1:20:39and based on some publications I read
- 1:20:41some time ago? So, this is a fantastic
- 1:20:44study where it was shown that the
- 1:20:46simplicity of the choice process—that
- 1:20:49is, the fact that a person's
- 1:20:51decision-making process doesn't
- 1:20:53encounter too many purchasing options
- 1:20:55along its path—subsequently
- 1:20:57facilitates the so-called adoption or
- 1:21:00purchase of the proposal; it is widely
- 1:21:02demonstrated. In other words, people
- 1:21:06tend to have much less trouble saying
- 1:21:10yes to a proposal when the set of
- 1:21:13options they are exposed to is very
- 1:21:16simple. So, six options is much simpler
- 1:21:20than 24 different types of options. But
- 1:21:24here too it is very interesting to note
- 1:21:27that in this set, looking at the actual
- 1:21:29data from the research you are
- 1:21:31referring to, it is fascinatingly
- 1:21:34interesting to note that yes, it is
- 1:21:36very true: with six jams instead of 24,
- 1:21:39er, types of jam, I apologize,
- 1:21:41compliance, therefore acceptance of the
- 1:21:44proposal, increases dramatically. It
- 1:21:47goes from 3%to 30%; so, out of 100
- 1:21:50people with 24 jams, three say yes.
- 1:21:53Meaning they buy some, okay.
- 1:21:55Yes. Out of 100 people in the first
- 1:21:58case, in the experiment data, they
- 1:22:00measured it, if we want to calculate a
- 1:22:02percentage, out of 100 people three buy
- 1:22:04, and those who buy are only those who
- 1:22:06wrote on their shopping list "I want
- 1:22:08jam".
- 1:22:09Ah,
- 1:22:09so the persuasive capacity of the
- 1:22:12display layout is zero.
- 1:22:13Zero. Okay.
- 1:22:14But why? Because the choice is complex.
- 1:22:16I mean, how can you choose between 24
- 1:22:18possible options? Which is the best one
- 1:22:20? The moment I, as a human being,
- 1:22:22struggle to understand which is the
- 1:22:23best, I stop choosing. And Amazon and
- 1:22:26all the tech giants have known this for
- 1:22:28years. In fact, I don't know if we want
- 1:22:31to try it live, if you are listening,
- 1:22:33go and search for a 52-inch TV on
- 1:22:36Amazon. Amazon probably has 78 billion
- 1:22:39different options for 52-inch TVs on
- 1:22:42the platform, but it only presents you
- 1:22:45with 78. Okay? And each one is nicely
- 1:22:49stuffed with cognitive biases, like the
- 1:22:51one recommended by Amazon and so on,
- 1:22:53because
- 1:22:53that is a cognitive bias, "recommended
- 1:22:55by Amazon." The price.
- 1:22:56Yes, eh. I am transferring trust to you
- 1:22:58, right? It's as if you were to ask who
- 1:23:00is one of the most important
- 1:23:01neuromarketing experts in Italy? It's
- 1:23:03so-and-so. This person literally
- 1:23:06receives a recognition of authority,
- 1:23:08trust, meritworthiness, and so on.
- 1:23:12Meritworthiness, I don't know if that's
- 1:23:14a word in Italian, but let's greet our
- 1:23:15friends at the Accademia della Crusca.
- 1:23:18Ehm, and in essence, yes, it influences
- 1:23:21you in a fantastic way, it's a huge
- 1:23:23bias, but it presents you with seven,
- 1:23:26not 78 billion, okay? And based on past
- 1:23:30behaviors, a ton of other things. In
- 1:23:34the case of six jams, however, out of
- 1:23:37100 people, 30 buy, so there is a
- 1:23:39massive increase in persuasion, but in
- 1:23:41the data it is fascinating to see that
- 1:23:44the number of people who go toward the
- 1:23:47stand is higher when there is a great
- 1:23:49variety of choice. So what does that
- 1:23:52mean? It means that in influencing the
- 1:23:55process by which you approach
- 1:23:57purchasing options, the multitude of
- 1:24:00the range of choice is an attractive,
- 1:24:03very interesting element. But when you
- 1:24:06then arrive at the point of choosing,
- 1:24:08if the context is too complex,
- 1:24:10you back away. I mean, I should create
- 1:24:12a curtain, and at a certain point, as
- 1:24:14soon as you get close, zoom.
- 1:24:16But look at what Amazon does. Amazon,
- 1:24:17Amazon, has known about this for years.
- 1:24:20That is, if you have a retail store,
- 1:24:23and I say this to everyone listening,
- 1:24:25the main predictor of the number of
- 1:24:27people who walk through your door is
- 1:24:30the expectation of the vast selection
- 1:24:32you have inside the store.
- 1:24:35Yes.
- 1:24:35Okay. If you know that inside a store
- 1:24:38there's a huge range of choices, the
- 1:24:40likelihood of you entering, even just
- 1:24:41to browse, is very high.
- 1:24:43Yes. I don't know if you've seen, I
- 1:24:46don't know if Chinese bazaar chains are
- 1:24:49very common in Milan too.
- 1:24:51Yes, they are,
- 1:24:52they are. No, there are several in
- 1:24:54Trattino. Oh, in my experience, not one
- 1:24:56of those ever closes. One of the
- 1:25:01reasons is precisely the fact that in
- 1:25:03these places you find everything from
- 1:25:06toothpaste to fitness equipment,
- 1:25:09household products, toys, fishing gear.
- 1:25:13Yes,
- 1:25:14and dog food, but also clothes, things,
- 1:25:17etc. Sure, you don't go in with an
- 1:25:19expectation of high quality, but you
- 1:25:21know there's such a vast selection
- 1:25:23there that, if you need...as happens to
- 1:25:25me, eh, the kids at home ran out of
- 1:25:28colored pencils and you say: "All right
- 1:25:30, boom, I'll go to the Chinese shop,
- 1:25:32I'll find something." Okay? This is to
- 1:25:37say that if you communicate your vast
- 1:25:39selection to the outside of the store,
- 1:25:41the probability that people will come
- 1:25:43to see it is much higher. But when I'm
- 1:25:45inside, what do I do? I bombard you
- 1:25:47with 84 types of different toothpastes
- 1:25:49because they exist, right? Six at most.
- 1:25:54Crazy.
- 1:25:54Six at most. Watch out, though, this
- 1:25:58topic of the simplicity of the choice
- 1:26:00process has been widely investigated
- 1:26:02later because when there is a
- 1:26:04scientific publication like this that,
- 1:26:06let's say, launches a very provocative
- 1:26:08theme, there is an entire scientific
- 1:26:10community that says: "Really? Did you
- 1:26:14really measure this thing? Come on,
- 1:26:16let's check if it's true. And they
- 1:26:19start replicating these studies in N
- 1:26:21types of circumstances, etc. Well, you
- 1:26:24should know that it seems it's not
- 1:26:26exactly six, as a number of purchase
- 1:26:29options, that is the best possible
- 1:26:31number, because there are studies that
- 1:26:34somehow challenge this principle, while
- 1:26:36still maintaining the general idea that
- 1:26:39as the complexity of the choice process
- 1:26:42increases, people tend not to choose.
- 1:26:46This is quite, uh, let's say, clear.
- 1:26:52It's not truly unequivocal and clear
- 1:26:54what the optimal number of options to
- 1:26:56present to a person is. I mean, six is
- 1:26:59fine, but does that mean seven ruins
- 1:27:01everything? Mm. No, but where are 8, 9,
- 1:27:0712? Mm.
- 1:27:09And based on the publications I’m
- 1:27:12aware of, humans actually seem to
- 1:27:15handle about ten options.
- 1:27:1810. Okay.
- 1:27:20But let's put it this way, I think
- 1:27:22it’s wise to keep in mind the
- 1:27:25principle of having a certain range of
- 1:27:27choices, but not too complicated, and
- 1:27:30ideally close to five or six options.
- 1:27:34I have one last question for you. Um,
- 1:27:37is there a book, a person, or perhaps
- 1:27:41an idea that has had a major impact on
- 1:27:44your personal and professional journey?
- 1:27:48Just one.
- 1:27:49Yes.
- 1:27:49Oh, my goodness, look, allow me to
- 1:27:52mention at least three names,
- 1:27:55or books too. Mm. Well, I absolutely
- 1:27:59have to mention my mentor, let's say,
- 1:28:03and my guide in the world of research,
- 1:28:06who is Luigi Mittone, m
- 1:28:07m
- 1:28:08he hasn't written many books, he has
- 1:28:09produced many scientific publications,
- 1:28:11but he’s the one who wanted to and
- 1:28:13was able to guide me into the world of
- 1:28:15research, and I owe him so much. Um, he
- 1:28:18is a university professor. Eh,
- 1:28:20could you recommend any books or
- 1:28:22writings? What is it that he passed on
- 1:28:24to you? More than manuals, he taught me
- 1:28:27the beauty and the complexity of
- 1:28:30scientific thought, true scientific
- 1:28:34thought. Conducting a randomized,
- 1:28:37controlled experiment, with all the
- 1:28:40necessary rigor, managing to create new
- 1:28:42, valid, and replicable knowledge, is
- 1:28:44one of the most complicated things a
- 1:28:47human being can do. We just talked
- 1:28:50about this field by jumping straight to
- 1:28:53the conclusions, but producing
- 1:28:55knowledge—that is, doing experiments
- 1:28:58—is complicated, it is extremely
- 1:29:00complicated. It’s not impossible, but
- 1:29:03you have to know how to do it. M
- 1:29:05and the training I was exposed to
- 1:29:08within the economics department and the
- 1:29:11CEL laboratory was rigorous but
- 1:29:13fantastic. Okay. And there are really
- 1:29:17many professors who have currently
- 1:29:20moved up to Full Professor, like Matteo
- 1:29:23Ploner and others, to whom I am devoted
- 1:29:26because they truly guided me throughout
- 1:29:29this journey with great ability and
- 1:29:32with an elegance of thought, a
- 1:29:34refinement that I have rarely found
- 1:29:37elsewhere.
- 1:29:40But some favorites. Number one, Robert
- 1:29:43Sapolsky. Robert Sapolsky, crazy.
- 1:29:45Oh, my goodness. So, read everything
- 1:29:48you can find by Robert Sapolsky,
- 1:29:50everything.
- 1:29:51So, the book,
- 1:29:52I mean, tell us a bit about what Robert
- 1:29:55Sapolsky does, so...
- 1:29:56Robert Sapolsky is one of the most
- 1:29:59influential, I believe, neuroscientists
- 1:30:02and experts in human behavior and also
- 1:30:04ethology, which is a very strange thing
- 1:30:07.
- 1:30:08What is ethology?
- 1:30:09It's the study of animals in their
- 1:30:10natural environment.
- 1:30:11Ah, okay. Yes, he studied baboons,
- 1:30:13right? And other species too, uh, but
- 1:30:17he is a fantastic person. You can even
- 1:30:21find his entire behavioral neurobiology
- 1:30:24course he gives at Stanford for free on
- 1:30:27YouTube.
- 1:30:28Yes, thanks. Look, it's something, but
- 1:30:32he is a super cultured, likable,
- 1:30:34well-prepared person, excellent at
- 1:30:37explaining things, has great oratory
- 1:30:40skills, and is exactly the kind of, if
- 1:30:42you will, myth, the kind of role model
- 1:30:45I have for my profession. Okay?
- 1:30:48I mean, he is really
- 1:30:50your
- 1:30:51who I would like to become, okay? Um,
- 1:30:54come on, tell us just one last one.
- 1:30:56Eh, another one, this one really
- 1:30:59changed my life, his name is Jordan
- 1:31:02Peterson.
- 1:31:02Jordan Peterson.
- 1:31:03Jordan B. Peterson is a former
- 1:31:05university professor who taught at the
- 1:31:06University of Toronto; he is one of the
- 1:31:08most influential psychologists in the
- 1:31:10world. Many people don't like him,
- 1:31:13especially those people who don't delve
- 1:31:15deeply into what he says. There is a
- 1:31:18book he wrote," 12 Rules for Life, "
- 1:31:21which has been widely criticized and
- 1:31:23which, however, contains things of such
- 1:31:26depth, Virginia, that if I told you
- 1:31:28about them, I would get emotional. If
- 1:31:33there is one person who has been able
- 1:31:36to influence, thanks to his studies, by
- 1:31:39gathering a whole series of ways in
- 1:31:42which a human being can live their life
- 1:31:45better, strengthen themselves, aspire
- 1:31:48to a healthier life, and manage to be,
- 1:31:50quote-unquote, happy. This is
- 1:31:54absolutely that person. I don't know if
- 1:31:56you've read anything of
- 1:31:57No, no, now I'll
- 1:31:59He is truly a person who has been at
- 1:32:01the center of a whirlwind of turbulence
- 1:32:04or criticism and so on for a very long
- 1:32:07time, but I invite you to look into him
- 1:32:10because he has a clarity of thought
- 1:32:12that is exactly the clarity of thought
- 1:32:15that was transmitted to me at the
- 1:32:18department when I worked at the Cel,
- 1:32:20which is: I am able to recognize that
- 1:32:23scientific clarity and it is of total
- 1:32:26beauty. Being a clinical psychologist
- 1:32:30himself, his soul as a scientist and
- 1:32:34clinical psychologist, put together,
- 1:32:37manages to convey messages with a
- 1:32:40vibrant power capable of truly touching
- 1:32:44the soul of a human being in a very
- 1:32:48deep way and giving a light, a sign, an
- 1:32:51encouragement of amazing value. And he
- 1:32:55is really a person I am very, very fond
- 1:32:58of.
- 1:32:58Giuliano, thank you. This was an
- 1:33:00incredible conversation. I think that,
- 1:33:03well, I've never done it, but I'll do
- 1:33:05it for the first time. Eh, I think
- 1:33:08there is a need for a part two. I mean,
- 1:33:11because there are, in my opinion, the
- 1:33:13more we talked, the more questions came
- 1:33:16to my mind, so, um, write to me in the
- 1:33:18comments if you are listening to us on
- 1:33:20YouTube or Spotify, so we can try to
- 1:33:22invite Giuliano back, because I think
- 1:33:24there is so much more. And thank you.
- 1:33:28Wow, really.
- 1:33:29A few years of experience. Crazy, truly
- 1:33:31crazy. And anyway, let's see. I hope to
- 1:33:34have you back.
- 1:33:35Thanks to you, Virginia, a pleasure
- 1:33:36speaking with you. Actually, sorry,
- 1:33:38excuse me if I did most of the talking.
- 1:33:39There we go.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Come veniamo influenzati ogni giorno senza saperlo con Giuliano Trenti, esperto di Neuromarketing by Virginia Gambardella, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,004 words across 2,232 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.