Climate Change, Health, and Disasters - What's the Connection? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03Hello, my name is Caleb Dresser and I'm
- 0:06an emergency physician and serve as
- 0:09co-chair of the Wadom Climate Change
- 0:11Special Interest Group. I'm going to be
- 0:14sharing a couple of thoughts over the
- 0:15next few minutes about how climate
- 0:17change is connected to disaster and
- 0:19emergency medicine and we will explore
- 0:21some of these topics in future webinars
- 0:24as well. Let's get started. First of
- 0:27all, what is climate change and how does
- 0:30this relate to human activity and the
- 0:32field of disaster and emergency
- 0:34medicine?
- 0:35Let's start with what we've been up to
- 0:37over the last few hundred years. We've
- 0:39been burning coal, oil, gas, and we've
- 0:42been changing use of the planetary
- 0:44surface. For example, reducing forest
- 0:46cover and increasing certain forms of
- 0:48agriculture. All of this has led to
- 0:51emissions of greenhouse gases. These are
- 0:54things like carbon dioxide and methane
- 0:56and other gases that act to heat trap
- 0:59heat around the earth. This is a graph
- 1:02from a mountaintop in Hawaii over the
- 1:05past several decades showing the
- 1:08increasing levels of carbon dioxide in
- 1:10Earth's atmosphere.
- 1:13This is of concern because carbon
- 1:15dioxide, methane, and other greenhouse
- 1:17gases act to trap heat. They prevent
- 1:20infrared radiation from escaping into
- 1:23space. And so when you put more carbon
- 1:25dioxide, methane, and other greenhouse
- 1:27gases into the atmosphere, that
- 1:29essentially acts as a blanket around the
- 1:32planet that insulates the planet and
- 1:34leads to rising temperatures. We have
- 1:37already seen an increase of around 1.5
- 1:41centrade as of the time of this
- 1:43recording. The exact number depends a
- 1:45little bit on how you add up the math,
- 1:47but suffice to say, the planetary
- 1:49temperature is increasing and has
- 1:51already increased quite substantially
- 1:54over the past several decades. If we
- 1:57look ahead using computer models, what
- 2:00scientists are seeing is a very high
- 2:02probability of continued increases in
- 2:05global temperatures. How much that
- 2:08increase is? Well, that depends on
- 2:10future and present day decisions about
- 2:13greenhouse gas emissions policy and ways
- 2:16to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
- 2:18globally.
- 2:20Where this starts to become really
- 2:22concerning from a health disaster and
- 2:25emergency standpoint is that planetary
- 2:28warming increases the risk of a wide
- 2:31variety of hazards occurring, increases
- 2:33the intensity of some hazards and can
- 2:36create situations in which threats occur
- 2:39in new environments where they were not
- 2:41previously seen. Some of these include
- 2:44heat waves which are becoming more
- 2:45frequent and intense across much of the
- 2:48planet. long-term changes in biomes
- 2:51which can affect the distribution of a
- 2:53wide variety of both animals and plants
- 2:55and also pathogens, wildfires, long-term
- 2:58changes in sea level which is rising
- 3:01globally and a wide variety of other
- 3:03impacts.
- 3:06In terms of how we know this, there is a
- 3:08lengthy scientific record at this point
- 3:11to help us understand Earth's climate
- 3:14today in relation to Earth's climate for
- 3:17many, many years in the past. to share a
- 3:20couple of illustrative examples. These
- 3:22are graphs from the British Antarctic
- 3:24Survey, which has performed ice core
- 3:26drilling in Antarctica and been able to
- 3:29look back hundreds of thousands of years
- 3:32by analyzing the characteristics of gas
- 3:35bubbles trapped in the ice. And what
- 3:37they see here is that today's carbon
- 3:40dioxide levels are the highest that they
- 3:43have been in their entire time series
- 3:45going back almost a million years. And
- 3:47today's methane levels are also the
- 3:50highest they have been in the past
- 3:52800,000 years. This is concerning
- 3:55because when you look back at that same
- 3:57record, you see that there is a pretty
- 4:00clear correlation between higher levels
- 4:03of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere as
- 4:05inferred from those little air bubbles
- 4:07in the ice cores and higher temperatures
- 4:10as inferred from anal analysis of other
- 4:13trapped gases in those same ice cores.
- 4:16This lines up with our understanding of
- 4:19the planetary system based on a wide
- 4:21variety of other science. And so at this
- 4:23point today, we are looking at a
- 4:25present- day situation where we are well
- 4:28outside historical bounds and a future
- 4:30in which we can expect that we will
- 4:33remain outside those historical bounds
- 4:35and very likely will move further away
- 4:38from our historical experience over the
- 4:40last almost a million years.
- 4:43There are a wide variety of implications
- 4:46of climate change for health. Some of
- 4:48these are disaster related, some are
- 4:50not. This is a helpful image from the US
- 4:54CDC that was released a number of years
- 4:55ago which explores some of the
- 4:58categories these fit into ranging from
- 5:00disaster related issues for example
- 5:02injuries and fatalities from severe
- 5:04weather to very long-term changes in
- 5:08food security perhaps resulting from
- 5:11changes in the viability of agriculture
- 5:13resulting from changes in temperature
- 5:15and rainfall patterns in various parts
- 5:17of the world. So this is a large
- 5:19complicated field and when it comes to
- 5:22thinking about the disaster and
- 5:24emergency medicine aspects of this there
- 5:28are a few different issues we need to be
- 5:30thinking about. I've situated these
- 5:33within the larger context of human
- 5:35activity leading to climate change. And
- 5:38if you look at what climate change is
- 5:40doing to hazards we are concerned about
- 5:42in disaster and emergency medicine in
- 5:44many settings it is increasing hazard
- 5:46frequency exposure and intensity.
- 5:50It's also leading in many settings to
- 5:52longer hazard seasons or even erratic
- 5:56timing of hazards that is different from
- 5:58historical patterns as well as in some
- 6:01cases overlapping hazards. For example,
- 6:04tropical cyclones that occur and are
- 6:06immediately followed by a dangerous heat
- 6:09wave in the setting of large widespread
- 6:11infrastructure damage and power outages.
- 6:13That one-two punch of overlapping
- 6:15hazards is also of great concern in our
- 6:18field. All of this adds up to increasing
- 6:20risk. And in a future webinar, we're
- 6:23going to look at how we think about risk
- 6:25in disaster and emergency medicine and
- 6:28how climate change can be relevant to
- 6:31our understanding and future assessment
- 6:32of risk in this field.
- 6:36For today though, we're going to go
- 6:37through just a few of these hazards and
- 6:39connect some of the dots between our
- 6:42understanding of the impacts of climate
- 6:44change from a science standpoint and
- 6:45then what this means for disasters and
- 6:48disaster and emergency medicine. Let's
- 6:51start with severe storms and flooding.
- 6:53At a very big picture scale, climate
- 6:56change means that more heat is trapped
- 6:59on the planet. That means more energy is
- 7:01available to power weather systems and
- 7:04that can contribute to more intense and
- 7:06severe weather. In addition, warmer air
- 7:10is able to hold more moisture. So as a
- 7:14result, when hotter air takes up
- 7:17moisture over a lake or an ocean, it has
- 7:20more potential to create heavy rainfall.
- 7:23Together, this means that we are seeing
- 7:26more intense storms and more intense
- 7:29cloud burst events where large amounts
- 7:30of rain falls in a short period of time.
- 7:33This map on the right is from the United
- 7:35States and this is based on historical
- 7:38rain gauge data. This is not a model.
- 7:40This is simply adding up historical
- 7:42weather data showing a dramatic uptick
- 7:45throughout much of the country in the
- 7:48amount of very heavy precipitation
- 7:51that's occurring over time compared to
- 7:54say 40 or 50 years ago.
- 7:56When we look at hurricanes, we see
- 7:58something similar. Again, there's more
- 8:01energy available in the planetary
- 8:03system.
- 8:05Hurricanes, also called tropical
- 8:06cyclones or typhoons, feed off of the
- 8:10warm sea surfaces in the subtropics.
- 8:14And so more temperature, high
- 8:16temperature water creates a situation in
- 8:18which there is more potential energy on
- 8:20which these storms can feed. That may be
- 8:24contributing to higher wind speeds and
- 8:26more risk of rapid intensification.
- 8:29This is also in occurring in the context
- 8:32of warmer air where these storms can
- 8:34thus dump larger amounts of rain in a
- 8:36short period of time and also occurring
- 8:39in the context of sea level rise which
- 8:41means that when storm surge occurs it's
- 8:43happening on a higher baseline sea level
- 8:46and thus there's increased risk of
- 8:47coastal flooding. There's also some
- 8:50science showing perhaps a reduction in
- 8:53the transllocation speeds of some of
- 8:54these storms i.e. the rate at which the
- 8:56whole storm system moves creating a
- 8:59situation where a uh city that is
- 9:01exposed to one of these storms may
- 9:03experience impact for a longer duration.
- 9:06And there is some evidence in some ocean
- 9:08basins that the locus of maximum
- 9:11intensity i.e. the point in the storm
- 9:13track where it is most severe may be
- 9:15moving toward the poles thus exposing
- 9:17areas that do not have as much
- 9:18historical experience with hurricanes.
- 9:20This is an evolving area of science and
- 9:23there's a lot to read about here and
- 9:24it's important to understand what is and
- 9:26is not known. The IPCC's uh most recent
- 9:29assessment report has a helpful summary
- 9:32of this literature and the level of
- 9:33confidence in some of these statements.
- 9:37When it comes to heat, the data is at
- 9:39this point quite clear and quite
- 9:41concerning. We are seeing increasing
- 9:44heat exposure. We are seeing more
- 9:47intense summertime heat waves. The
- 9:48heatwave season is also longer. Again,
- 9:52here is data from the United States. And
- 9:53again, this is not a model. This is
- 9:56simply adding up temperature records
- 9:58from weather stations over the past
- 10:00roughly 60 years. And what we see is
- 10:04more heat waves in most cities and we
- 10:06see a longer season in which they can
- 10:08occur. This is concerning because heat
- 10:11is a potentially lethal hazard and it
- 10:14becomes particularly dangerous when
- 10:16people are exposed to it and don't have
- 10:18a way to get out of it. For example,
- 10:20they're working outdoors or they perhaps
- 10:22live in a home where they don't have
- 10:24cooling. And so this combination of
- 10:26higher temperatures for longer as well
- 10:29as exposure of populations that are not
- 10:32necessarily used to dealing with heat
- 10:34and do not have cultural or social or
- 10:37architectural adaptations in place is
- 10:40creating a lot of dangerous heat around
- 10:42the world. This in turn in settings
- 10:45where people have access to air
- 10:46conditioning often leads to increased
- 10:49air conditioning use. And if the power
- 10:52grid is unable to sustain that increase
- 10:54in demand can actually contribute to
- 10:56risk of power outages which further
- 10:58increases the risk. There is a lot of
- 11:00work going on on understanding the
- 11:03implications of heat in the context of
- 11:05climate change as well as adaptation
- 11:07approaches to deal with this.
- 11:10When it comes to wildfire, we are also
- 11:12seeing increasing concerns around the
- 11:15world. This has been seen on most
- 11:18continents that have historical
- 11:19experience with wildfire. And there's a
- 11:22combination of factors here. Some of
- 11:24this is about hot, dry summertime
- 11:26conditions. The type of conditions that
- 11:28can support wildfire ignition and rapid
- 11:31spread. And so when you have hotter
- 11:33conditions and potentially increasingly
- 11:36erratic rainfall during summer months,
- 11:38that can create a tinder box and high
- 11:40risk of fires occurring. On the
- 11:44background of this, it's also important
- 11:45to recognize that in some settings, the
- 11:47growth of fuel for fires during
- 11:50wintertime months, which are sometimes
- 11:51rainy, for example, in many chaparal
- 11:53areas, may mean that wintertime rainfall
- 11:56is actually contributing to the growth
- 11:58of fuels that increase risk of larger
- 12:01blazes in the summer or fall. So, this
- 12:05is obviously concerning. Um, in addition
- 12:08to the obvious dangers of the wildfires
- 12:10themselves, it's worth pointing out that
- 12:13simply trying to prevent them creates
- 12:15its own disaster and emergency
- 12:17management complexities. For example,
- 12:19decisions to turn off power grids to
- 12:21prevent sparks during very high-risisk
- 12:23conditions may help prevent wildfires,
- 12:26but may also put individuals who depend
- 12:28on electricity for medical devices,
- 12:30refrigerating insulin, or other key
- 12:33medical activities that may put them at
- 12:35risk. And so figure out how to manage
- 12:37that risk and balance that is a very
- 12:39important question. Smoke is also a
- 12:41major concern. Smoke from these fires
- 12:43can travel long distances and affect the
- 12:47respiratory and cardiovascular health of
- 12:49people far distant from the wildfires
- 12:51themselves. And finally, after a fire
- 12:55has occurred, often landscapes have far
- 12:58less vegetation, far less in the way of
- 13:00plant root structures to hold soil in
- 13:02place. And so the risk of flooding and
- 13:05in some settings landslides following
- 13:07wildfires actually goes up as well. And
- 13:09so we see this compounding and
- 13:12sequential escalation in disaster risk
- 13:15that we need to understand and be
- 13:16prepared to manage.
- 13:18Finally, drought is a longer term
- 13:22concern as well. Um erratic rainfall and
- 13:25rising temperatures mean that there are
- 13:27many places around the world that are
- 13:29having difficulty with rainfed
- 13:31agriculture or with availability of
- 13:34water in reservoirs. All of this can
- 13:37contribute to poor growing conditions
- 13:39which has obvious implications for food
- 13:41security particularly in settings where
- 13:42small holder agriculture is very
- 13:44important to the economy as well as for
- 13:46livelihoods. And there can also be
- 13:48feedback loops here where as you see
- 13:51less rainfall, there may be increased
- 13:53reliance on irrigation which can
- 13:55contribute to soil salinity and
- 13:57long-term create further damage to
- 13:59cropping system yields. All of this
- 14:02again creates long-term risk that can
- 14:05contribute to food insecurity and even
- 14:07complex humanitarian emergencies.
- 14:10So in summary, we are in a situation
- 14:12where ongoing human activity including
- 14:15burning fossil fuels and land use change
- 14:18is leading to rising global
- 14:20temperatures. And these changes in
- 14:22Earth's climate are contributing to
- 14:24increasing disaster risk through, as we
- 14:26just discussed, a wide variety of
- 14:28mechanisms. How do we address this?
- 14:30Well, one approach is climate change
- 14:33mitigation, which means reducing
- 14:34greenhouse gas emissions and greenhouse
- 14:36gas levels in the atmosphere. that will
- 14:38help prevent the worst possible futures
- 14:41associated with climate change. But we
- 14:44also need climate change adaptation,
- 14:46which means taking steps to prepare for
- 14:48the impacts of climate change. So when
- 14:50they occur, when the heat wave occurs,
- 14:52when the tropical cyclone occurs, we are
- 14:54prepared, our institutions are prepared
- 14:56and our societies are prepared for these
- 14:59impacts. Both of these at this point are
- 15:02necessary and are complimentary
- 15:04together.
- 15:05At this point, we in disaster and
- 15:07emergency medicine are facing climate
- 15:10change. This is a reality we have to
- 15:11engage with and it will have increasing
- 15:13relevance as its effects intensify.
- 15:15We'll explore some of those specific
- 15:17effects, some of those hazards, and some
- 15:19of the ways we can deal with them in
- 15:21future episodes.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Climate Change, Health, and Disasters - What's the Connection? by WADEM, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,390 words across 380 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.