اين شخص كل نبوت محمد را به فنا داد — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02This video is based on an article in
- 0:04Arabic written by Walid Fikri, a
- 0:06prominent Arab writer and critic of
- 0:09Islam. We have translated this article
- 0:15into Persian and created this video for
- 0:18you, our esteemed audience, based on it
- 0:20. When Muhammad claimed prophethood
- 0:29among the Arabs and insulted the elders
- 0:31of Mecca and their beliefs, a group of
- 0:33educated Arabs with historical
- 0:35knowledge accused him of merely
- 0:37repeating ancient myths in an
- 0:38incomplete form. They even claimed that
- 0:48they could narrate these ancient
- 0:50stories more completely and better.
- 0:58Greetings to you, dear audience, and
- 1:00welcome to the Fact Studio channel. One
- 1:07such person who challenged the
- 1:09self-proclaimed prophet with his
- 1:10knowledge and literacy, and repeatedly
- 1:13mocked him, was a man named al-Nadr ibn
- 1:15al-Harith. Al-Nadr ibn al-Harith and
- 1:22his historic statement, "These are
- 1:24nothing but ancient legends,"
- 1:26demonstrate a wisdom and knowledge that
- 1:28may one day become the best religion
- 1:30for humanity. Perhaps a generation will
- 1:37come that respects what al-Nadr ibn
- 1:39al-Harith did and builds a statue to
- 1:41honor him. Who is al-Nadr ibn al-Harith
- 1:45? He was one of the renowned
- 1:47intellectuals and thinkers of the
- 1:49Quraysh at that time. His role in
- 1:52defeating and thwarting Muhammad's
- 1:54mission in Mecca is undeniable due to
- 1:56his profound mastery of the culture,
- 1:59knowledge, and history of ancient
- 2:00civilizations. This is what drew
- 2:05Muhammad's ire, and at the first
- 2:07opportunity, he had al-Nadr ibn
- 2:09al-Harith killed in a cowardly manner.
- 2:13In that era, anyone who could read and
- 2:15write was considered a scholar. But how
- 2:21could one man read, study, and know all
- 2:23the ancient myths like al-Nadr? Al-Nadr
- 2:29ibn al-Harith was one of the greatest
- 2:31intellectuals of his time in Quraysh;
- 2:34he traveled to Roman, Persian, and
- 2:36Najran lands, learned their sciences,
- 2:38and knew their myths, stories, and
- 2:41history well. While Muhammad was
- 2:46spreading his message and promising his
- 2:49followers gardens of Eden with pine
- 2:51trees, maidens with swelling breasts,
- 2:53immortal youths, and abundant wine and
- 2:55honey, he was simultaneously using
- 2:57methods of intimidation and terror. He
- 3:03threatened his critics with a sadistic
- 3:05god who would roast the deniers and
- 3:07regrow their skin so they could be
- 3:09tortured forever. To validate his claim
- 3:15of prophethood, Muhammad recounted
- 3:17stories from Jewish, Roman, and
- 3:19prehistoric myths that Muslims recite
- 3:22every day today. Most of these stories
- 3:26were confusing and incomplete by the
- 3:28time they reached him. Therefore, to
- 3:31address the gaps, he added some of his
- 3:33own imagination to them, combined some,
- 3:35and completely altered others. But the
- 3:41story of the defeat of Muhammad's claim
- 3:43against al-Nadr ibn al-Harith and the
- 3:45proof of the falsehood of his
- 3:47prophethood dates back to Mecca, before
- 3:49his nocturnal flight to Medina. The
- 3:55story begins with the first contact in
- 3:58Mecca, where Muhammad claimed
- 3:59prophethood and invited the Meccans to
- 4:02join him for 13 years before his
- 4:03nocturnal escape. During those 13 years
- 4:10, according to all Muslim historians
- 4:12and biographers, Muhammad's followers
- 4:14numbered fewer than 100, most of whom
- 4:17were poor and destitute. A question may
- 4:21arise: why?
- 4:23The answer is that he could not
- 4:24convince anyone with reasoning and
- 4:26logic. Therefore, he promised the poor
- 4:29a second life after death. Paradises
- 4:34filled with rivers of honey, an
- 4:36unlimited number of beautiful virgin
- 4:38women with prominent breasts, alcoholic
- 4:41beverages, and luxurious houses and
- 4:43palaces—all free, effortless, and
- 4:45eternal. How could a poor person who
- 4:50doesn't have a morsel of bread to eat
- 4:51not be deceived by this promise? Nadr
- 4:56ibn al-Harith was the first of the
- 4:58Quraysh who, upon hearing Muhammad's
- 5:00claims and the verses he recited, said:
- 5:02"Muhammad's words are mythological
- 5:04legends that have been told to him
- 5:06imperfectly." After Nadr said this,
- 5:11Muhammad revealed verse 15 of Surah
- 5:13Al-Qalam. "Idha tutla 'alayhi ayatuna
- 5:17qala asatir al-awwalin," which
- 5:19translates to: "When Our verses are
- 5:22recited to him, he says,' Legends of
- 5:24the ancients. '" This verse directly
- 5:28addresses Nadr ibn al-Harith after he
- 5:30had labeled the verses of the Quran as
- 5:32legends of the ancients. Nadr ibn
- 5:39al-Harith would tell the Meccans that
- 5:41if these stories Muhammad tells are the
- 5:43criteria for prophethood, then he too
- 5:45could claim prophethood, because he
- 5:47could tell stories that are more
- 5:49complete, more beautiful, and more
- 5:51meaningful than Muhammad's. Due to his
- 5:57extensive travels and his high literacy
- 6:00and knowledge, Nadr had studied the
- 6:02legends of various cultures. And he was
- 6:05well-informed about them. Nadr ibn
- 6:08al-Harith even declared that he could
- 6:10write poems or structured literary
- 6:12prose texts that were hundreds of times
- 6:14better than Muhammad's incomprehensible
- 6:16verses. Unfortunately, the writings or
- 6:22poems of this great man never reached
- 6:24us because he had checked Muhammad so
- 6:26thoroughly that, at the first possible
- 6:29opportunity, he ordered his execution;
- 6:31if anything remained of his work, it
- 6:33was surely destroyed. You will learn
- 6:39later why the Prophet of the Arabs,
- 6:41when he took Nadr captive during his
- 6:43early banditry at the Battle of Badr,
- 6:46ordered his execution, unlike other
- 6:47captives who were released in exchange
- 6:50for ransom. This act of Muhammad
- 6:55characterizes someone who claims to
- 6:57have come from God to guide humanity,
- 6:59and whose followers call him the
- 7:00messenger of peace and friendship. It
- 7:05is a great pity that everything Nadr
- 7:07wrote during his lifetime in opposition
- 7:09to and criticism of the Muhammadi Quran
- 7:11has been completely destroyed by
- 7:13Muslims. Just as the satirical poems
- 7:18written by various poets about Muhammad
- 7:20at that time were destroyed. In this
- 7:24way, Islam became the founder of a
- 7:26method that continues to this very day.
- 7:30Khalid ibn al-Walid would burn and
- 7:32destroy all the writings that were
- 7:34composed against Muhammad. Therefore,
- 7:38burning the books of thinkers became an
- 7:41Islamic pastime that continues to this
- 7:43day. The story begins with Nadr wanting
- 7:48to test Muhammad in front of all the
- 7:50people of Mecca. In a challenge, he
- 7:55asked him to prove his claim of
- 7:56prophecy. Muhammad, who claimed to be
- 8:02clever, fell into Nadr's trap because
- 8:05Nadr was an educated man, aware of all
- 8:07the stories and myths of other nations,
- 8:10and knew well how to trap frauds and
- 8:12liars. Nadr ibn al-Harith and Uqba ibn
- 8:18Abi Mu'ayt prepared three questions to
- 8:20test Muhammad's claim of prophecy.
- 8:24Muhammad, due to his connection to
- 8:25revelation, should have easily answered
- 8:28these questions. The first question:
- 8:32What is the story of the young men who
- 8:34went into the cave, the People of the
- 8:36Cave, and how many were they? The
- 8:42second question: What is the story of
- 8:44the man who traveled around the globe
- 8:46and reached the east and west of the
- 8:48earth? Dhul-Qarnayn; the third question
- 8:52: What is the spirit? Explain to us
- 8:55about the spirit. Muhammad asked Nadr
- 9:00and the Meccans for two days to bring
- 9:02the answers to these questions. Often
- 9:07in such times, Muhammad would go to
- 9:09Waraqah ibn Nawfal, Khadija's cousin,
- 9:12who was a wise man, fluent in Hebrew,
- 9:14and, according to some historians, the
- 9:17high priest of Mecca. He had studied
- 9:23most pre-Islamic religions and myths
- 9:25and possessed vast information. The
- 9:30next day came and went without Muhammad
- 9:32fulfilling his promise. The following
- 9:35day also passed, but Muhammad did not
- 9:37come. The third and fourth days passed,
- 9:40yet there was no news of Muhammad.
- 9:44Muhammad had asked for two days to
- 9:46prove his prophecy and answer the
- 9:48questions. But now fourteen days had
- 9:52passed and there was no sign of him.
- 9:55After fifteen days and much searching,
- 9:57Muhammad returned with the answers to
- 9:59the questions. But first, he had to
- 10:03make an excuse for his delay. Muhammad
- 10:07explained the reason for his delay as
- 10:09follows. When he promised to answer the
- 10:11Meccans the next day, he had not said "
- 10:13Insha'Allah"(God willing). This
- 10:16justification appeared as verses in
- 10:18Surah Al-Kahf. Surah Al-Kahf, verses
- 10:2223-24: "And never say of anything,' I
- 10:25will do that tomorrow, 'except [when
- 10:28adding],' If Allah wills. '" Is the
- 10:32reason Muhammad did not come at the
- 10:34right time because he did not say
- 10:35Insha'Allah? Interestingly, from that
- 10:40day on, believers have held that if
- 10:42they do not say this magical phrase,
- 10:44what they are waiting for will not
- 10:46happen. Muhammad's answers to the
- 10:50questions. The answers came in the form
- 10:54of verses that Muhammad revealed as
- 10:55being from Allah. First question: How
- 10:59many people were the men of the cave,
- 11:01the People of the Cave? The answer,
- 11:06Surah Al-Kahf, verse 22: "They will say
- 11:09,' There were three, the fourth of them
- 11:11being their dog, 'and they will say,'
- 11:13Five, the sixth of them being their dog
- 11:16'-guessing at the unseen.""And they
- 11:21will say,' Seven, the eighth of them
- 11:22being their dog. '""Say,' My Lord is
- 11:26most knowing of their number. '" Allah
- 11:30himself did not know the number of
- 11:32people in the cave; therefore, he chose
- 11:34a trivial and worthless answer that was
- 11:36unconvincing and did not specify a
- 11:38definite number. You see, the verse
- 11:43that Muslims call the word of Allah is
- 11:45nothing but ignorance, confusion, and
- 11:47evasion of the audience. Whereas the
- 11:51answer to this question is quite simple
- 11:53. State the exact number of people, and
- 11:56that is enough. Perhaps 3, 5, or 7.
- 12:01This means that after a 15-day delay,
- 12:03Muhammad had not come up with a
- 12:05decisive answer, and whoever had helped
- 12:07him had provided confusing and
- 12:09inaccurate information. Is it not the
- 12:13case that Gabriel brought the verses
- 12:15from him? How is it possible that Allah
- 12:18would not provide a clear and
- 12:20convincing answer to solidify his
- 12:22messenger's position and defeat his
- 12:23enemies? The interesting point is that
- 12:27in the same verse, he tells Muhammad: "
- 12:30Say, my Lord knows their number." If He
- 12:33knows their number, why does He not say
- 12:36it directly without riddles and evasion
- 12:38? The story of the Companions of the
- 12:43Cave is a fictional tale created by a
- 12:45Christian clergyman in the 6th century
- 12:47AD as an educational sermon, which
- 12:49spread across vast regions of Europe.
- 12:54From there, it reached the land of the
- 12:56Arabs through merchants. This story is
- 12:59neither real nor logical, yet Muhammad
- 13:02narrated it in the Quran as if it were
- 13:04from Allah. The second question was
- 13:07about the man who traveled from one end
- 13:09of the earth to the other, or Dhu
- 13:11al-Qarnayn? Muhammad's answer was
- 13:14similar to the previous question. Vague
- 13:17and unclear, without providing any name
- 13:19. Muhammad provided the answer in the
- 13:22form of verses in Surah Al-Kahf. Verses
- 13:2783 to 86 of Surah Al-Kahf state: "And
- 13:29they ask you about Dhu al-Qarnayn; say,
- 13:32' I will recite to you a report about
- 13:34him. '""Indeed, We established him upon
- 13:39the earth, and We gave him from
- 13:41everything a way.""Until, when he
- 13:45reached the setting of the sun, he
- 13:47found it setting in a spring of dark
- 13:49mud, and he found near it a people." We
- 13:53said, "O Dhu al-Qarnayn!""Either you
- 13:56punish [them] or you take a good course
- 13:58concerning them." In these verses, the
- 14:02man's name was not mentioned, and
- 14:04Muhammad escaped a precise answer with
- 14:07a ridiculous story, leaving the
- 14:09companions, biographers, and Quranic
- 14:11exegetes struggling to this day. The
- 14:16legend of Dhu al-Qarnayn, or the man
- 14:18with two horns on his head, is a
- 14:20Syriac-Akkadian myth in which Alexander
- 14:23the Great was always depicted with two
- 14:25horns on his head. The story of the
- 14:28spring of mud or darkness is also part
- 14:31of that same legend. When Alexander
- 14:34went toward the sunrise and saw the sun
- 14:36rising from the sea. There is also
- 14:40another mythological figure named
- 14:43Naram-Sin, the grandson of Sargon of
- 14:45Akkad, who has stories about Gog, Magog
- 14:47, and the dark spring. In fact, the
- 14:51original source of this legend is
- 14:53unknown. But the fact that the Quran
- 14:56copied it from the legend of Naram-Sin
- 14:58is an unavoidable issue. Among Islamic
- 15:01traditions, there is a Hadith. It goes
- 15:05like this: Abu Dharr said, "One day at
- 15:08sunset, I was in the mosque. He said to
- 15:12me,' O Abu Dharr, do you know where the
- 15:14sun sets? '" I said, "God and His
- 15:18Messenger know best." He said, "It goes
- 15:21and prostrates beneath the Throne of
- 15:23God." These are the words of Allah
- 15:26Almighty: "And the sun runs to its
- 15:28resting place." Why do biographers and
- 15:32narrators of Hadith struggle so much to
- 15:34justify this story? Because in reality,
- 15:39there is no physical place where the
- 15:41sun sets or rises from. But to avoid
- 15:47answering, Muhammad, with the advice of
- 15:49his teachers, was forced to copy this
- 15:52story imperfectly, and to this day, all
- 15:54translators and commentators struggle
- 15:56to fix this error. The third question:
- 16:01What is the Spirit? The answer: As
- 16:04usual, Muhammad gave no clear or
- 16:06understandable response. Muhammad, who
- 16:12claimed prophecy from God and
- 16:13communication with Him through the
- 16:15angel of revelation, provided this
- 16:17response to a simple question,
- 16:19regarding verse 85 of Surah Al-Isra: "
- 16:21And they ask you about the Spirit; say,
- 16:24' The Spirit is of the command of my
- 16:26Lord, and you have not been given of
- 16:28knowledge except a little. '" Yes, the
- 16:33Spirit is from the command of your Lord
- 16:35; but did your Lord not tell you what
- 16:37the Spirit is? Imagine asking an
- 16:41astronomer who has spent his whole life
- 16:44studying stars, "What is a solar
- 16:46eclipse?" And he says, "I contacted
- 16:49Allah, and Allah said:' Say, a solar
- 16:52eclipse is from the command of my Lord,
- 16:54and you do not have much knowledge. '"
- 16:57Have you ever heard a more ridiculous
- 16:59answer? Yet, Shiite and Sunni Islamists
- 17:03shout that Muhammad amazed all the
- 17:05polytheists of Mecca with his knowledge
- 17:07, and there was no question he could
- 17:09not answer. But they still opposed him
- 17:14and went astray because they did not
- 17:16want to accept the truth. Yes. Now,
- 17:20since there is no representative from
- 17:22Mecca and Islamists dominate the field,
- 17:24they can tell any lie to the followers
- 17:26of Islam. But the verses of the Quran
- 17:30alone speak volumes about many of these
- 17:32issues. In short, after 15 days of
- 17:36absence, contrary to the promise he had
- 17:38made, Muhammad offered weak and
- 17:40unacceptable answers. These three
- 17:45simple questions leveled Muhammad's
- 17:46entire claim to the ground. The number
- 17:50of the Companions, the true nature of
- 17:52Dhu al-Qarnayn, and the nature of the
- 17:54Spirit. In this debate, Muhammad faced
- 17:59a heavy defeat against the Meccans,
- 18:01especially against a learned man like
- 18:03Nadr ibn al-Harith, and his claim of
- 18:05prophecy faced a great challenge. This
- 18:10very issue caused the failure of his
- 18:12claim of prophecy in Mecca and the lack
- 18:14of people joining his new religion. As
- 18:19in the 13 years of claiming prophecy in
- 18:21Mecca, and especially among his own
- 18:24tribe, the Quraysh, fewer than 100
- 18:26people—mostly runaway slaves and the
- 18:28poor—joined him. This issue caused
- 18:34Muhammad to have no chance of success
- 18:36in continuing his path, leading him to
- 18:38think about fleeing to another place.
- 18:44The end of Nadr ibn al-Harith's life at
- 18:46the hands of Muhammad showed the
- 18:48unimaginable hatred of a man with
- 18:50unbelievable complexes. Someone who
- 18:55introduced himself as a prophet and
- 18:57messenger of the God of the worlds to
- 18:59guide humanity, but in practice was
- 19:01unable to prove his claim. Now, a
- 19:06person had fallen into his hands as a
- 19:08captive who, by asking just a few
- 19:10questions, had rendered all his claims
- 19:12void and worthless.
- 19:17Nadr ibn al-Harith was a great man who
- 19:19fought to destroy the superstitions and
- 19:21ignorance that Muhammad had brought as
- 19:23a gift for the people of Mecca. Years
- 19:29later, bandits commanded by Muhammad
- 19:31blocked one of Abu Sufyan's caravans in
- 19:34Badr and stole all the goods and items
- 19:36of the caravan.
- 19:39Nadr ibn al-Harith
- 19:41was among the 70 people of Mecca
- 19:43accompanying the caravan who were
- 19:45captured by the Muslim bandits.
- 19:49Therefore, Muhammad ordered that the
- 19:51captives be released in exchange for
- 19:53the payment of ransom by their families
- 19:55and relatives. He also stipulated that
- 20:00captives unable to pay the ransom could
- 20:02be freed in exchange for teaching 10
- 20:04Muslims how to read and write. But
- 20:08among the captives, Muhammad
- 20:10Nadr ibn al-Harith
- 20:14and Uqba ibn Abi Mu'ayt aside, treating
- 20:16them differently from the others, and
- 20:18ordered their execution. The order to
- 20:23execute these two men only proved
- 20:25Muhammad's sense of inferiority and the
- 20:27suppressed complexes of his defeat in
- 20:29the debate with Nadr. Muslim
- 20:32biographers have written that
- 20:34Nadr ibn al-Harith
- 20:36after being captured, said to the
- 20:38prisoner next to him: "I swear by God
- 20:40that Muhammad is my killer; for he
- 20:42looked at me with eyes filled with
- 20:44hatred and death." Then Muhammad
- 20:48ordered Ali ibn Abi Talib to kill Nadr
- 20:51ibn al-Harith. Ali was the person to
- 20:57whom they assigned killing duties,
- 20:59because he had no mercy for others and
- 21:01in fact played the role of Islam's
- 21:03executioner.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of اين شخص كل نبوت محمد را به فنا داد by Alt Facts Studio, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,784 words across 440 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.