Church Committee Hearings FBI Ops against MLK 1975 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00concern that you need to have with the
- 0:01exercise of secret power as we learn
- 0:04about the work of the church committee
- 0:0540 years ago now from November 18th 1975
- 0:09here is senator Frank Church the
- 0:10committee chairman opening up a hearing
- 0:12on the FBI and its abuse of power there
- 0:16has never been a full public accounting
- 0:18of FBI domestic intelligence
- 0:21operations therefore this committee has
- 0:23undertaken such an
- 0:27investigation its purpose is not to
- 0:29impair the FBI's legitimate law
- 0:31enforcement and counter Espionage
- 0:33functions but rather to evaluate
- 0:35domestic intelligence according to the
- 0:37standards of the Constitution and the
- 0:40statutes of our
- 0:42land if fault is to be found it does not
- 0:46rest in the bureau
- 0:48alone it is to be found also in the long
- 0:51line of Attorneys General presidents and
- 0:56congresses who have failed who have
- 0:59given power rather and responsibility to
- 1:03the
- 1:04FBI but have failed to give it adequate
- 1:07guidance Direction and
- 1:10control information is a powerful
- 1:14Resource One of the FBI's most
- 1:16significant features is its system for
- 1:21efficient
- 1:22processing filing and retrieving of the
- 1:27data it
- 1:28gathers the potential dangers in this
- 1:31system are
- 1:33obvious today we are here to review the
- 1:35major findings of our full investigation
- 1:37of FBI domestic intelligence including
- 1:40the coel program and other programs
- 1:43aimed at domestic
- 1:45targets FBI surveillance of law-abiding
- 1:48citizens and
- 1:50groups political abuses of FBI
- 1:53intelligence and several specific cases
- 1:56of unjustified intelligence operations
- 2:01these hearings have one overriding
- 2:04objective the development of sufficient
- 2:07information for Congress to legislate
- 2:09appropriate standards for the
- 2:12FBI after the Senator's opening
- 2:14statement Schwarz and Smothers began
- 2:16their presentation of the FBI
- 2:18irregularities detailing the broad
- 2:20surveillance activities of the bureau
- 2:22mainly in the 1960s and giving some
- 2:25notable
- 2:27examples in the area of
- 2:31uh what they characterize as the new
- 2:33left uh an example of the
- 2:37overbath of the requirements for
- 2:40information laid on the field can be
- 2:43found in the document that's at
- 2:4513-1 of your
- 2:48books and in this document the director
- 2:51of the
- 2:52FBI issued an instruction to all Special
- 2:56Agents of the bureau as to the kind of
- 2:59information
- 3:01that he wanted them to collect and
- 3:03report on now the number of items in the
- 3:07report uh are in letters from uh a
- 3:11through R and numbers under each one of
- 3:14those
- 3:15entries I will just refer to a couple of
- 3:20the specific examples of what the FBI
- 3:23agents are required to report into the
- 3:25field in the area of finances who are
- 3:28the so-called angels for the group in
- 3:31the area of Publications describe all
- 3:34the
- 3:35Publications in the area of
- 3:38religion the policy of what the
- 3:40organization relating to its approach to
- 3:43religion and any vehement statements
- 3:45made against religious bodies by leaders
- 3:48conversely any statements of support for
- 3:50the movement by religious groups or
- 3:53individuals uh in the area of political
- 3:56activities any and all political
- 3:58activities in which so-called new left
- 4:00leaders are involved and details
- 4:04relating to their position taken on
- 4:06political matters including efforts to
- 4:07influence public opinion the electorate
- 4:09and government
- 4:10bodies in the area of
- 4:13Education all information concerning
- 4:15courses given together with any
- 4:18educational outline and together with
- 4:20what is the assigned or suggested
- 4:22reading in the area of so-called social
- 4:25reform all information on activities in
- 4:28connection with demonstration aimed at
- 4:30social reform whatever that may
- 4:33be uh in the area of Labor All
- 4:36Information including all activity in
- 4:38the Labor
- 4:39Field with respect to the public
- 4:41appearance of leaders the identity of
- 4:44any leader who makes a public appearance
- 4:46on radio and television and who appears
- 4:48before groups for example labor church
- 4:51and minority groups and in connection
- 4:53with such appearances the identity of
- 4:55the group sponsoring the speaker and a
- 4:58succinct summary of the subject matter
- 5:00discussed in the area of mass media
- 5:03influence of the new left on mass media
- 5:06and any indications of support of the
- 5:09new left by the mass media a wholly
- 5:12comprehensive listing of everything
- 5:15those people thought or did on any
- 5:18subject you can imagine they're having a
- 5:20concern with uh taking the as a next
- 5:23example of the how the uh intelligence
- 5:29desire
- 5:30seeks
- 5:32out information of uh
- 5:36scarcely relevant to subjects that we
- 5:40had thought the bureau was concerned
- 5:42with in the area of women's Liberation
- 5:44report after report about meetings of
- 5:47women who got together to talk about
- 5:49their problems now how the bureau got
- 5:51this information is not entirely clear
- 5:54but it's apparently by informants so we
- 5:57have informants running all over the
- 5:58country checking up about what
- 6:00housewives are talking about in their
- 6:02efforts to decide whether women should
- 6:06have a different role in the
- 6:08societ uh a reports on particular women
- 6:11who said why they had come to the
- 6:13meeting and how she felt depressed
- 6:14sexually or otherwise reports on such
- 6:17important matters as the release of
- 6:19white mice by women at a um protest
- 6:23demonstration uh reports on such other
- 6:25important matters as the women's
- 6:27Liberation movement is in interested in
- 6:30zapping the Miss America Pageant at
- 6:32Atlantic City by protesting uh the
- 6:36standards and and well whatever they
- 6:39protest in Atlantic
- 6:41City and
- 6:44good my favorite example uh in the
- 6:47Baltimore women's Liberation movement in
- 6:50a document which was sent not only to
- 6:52the FBI this one's at tab 5.4 not only
- 6:56to the FBI but to three military
- 6:58agencies for some reason a document in
- 7:02which there's a long discussion of the
- 7:04origins aims and purposes of the group
- 7:06its location its pamphlets and in
- 7:09concluding on the purposes of the group
- 7:12comes up with such important findings as
- 7:14they wanted a purpose and that was to
- 7:16free women from the humdrum existence of
- 7:18being only a wife and mother they wanted
- 7:20equal opportunities that men have in
- 7:22work in society and so forth nothing to
- 7:25do with violence nothing to do with
- 7:27these labels of subversion extremis M
- 7:30and what's the conclusion on the
- 7:31document quotes will continue to follow
- 7:34and Report the activities of the women's
- 7:35Liberation movement not all of the
- 7:37information collected by the agency was
- 7:40stashed away in some musty file much of
- 7:43it was turned over to White House AIDS
- 7:45and much of it was used for political
- 7:47purposes there was an indication in the
- 7:4864 Democratic Convention that violence
- 7:51May erupt and the bureau was called upon
- 7:54to supply information regarding the
- 7:57potential for violence uh assumingly
- 8:00both on a federal level and to assist
- 8:02local law enforcement
- 8:04officials in addition to
- 8:07that after infiltration of various
- 8:11groups the challenge plan of the
- 8:14Mississippi um to the Mississippi
- 8:17Convention the plans of those who were
- 8:19challenging the official
- 8:21delegation uh were developed by the FBI
- 8:24and
- 8:25submitted uh to the White House through
- 8:28a White House Stafford
- 8:31the plans
- 8:33of Dr King the plans of core the plans
- 8:36of Snick with respect to activities at
- 8:38the convention were also
- 8:41communicated both as they related to
- 8:43efforts to disrupt as well as general
- 8:46political strategy at the
- 8:48convention this was accomplished really
- 8:51through a complete infiltration of these
- 8:54groups and when it became apparent as in
- 8:57the case of the Mississippi challenge
- 9:00that it might be politically expedient
- 9:02to have some information to discredit
- 9:03the group the FBI provided that also by
- 9:07providing some bookkeeping data on the
- 9:10organization and its funding
- 9:15sources we see the same kind of
- 9:17unofficial dissemination
- 9:20occur after the critics of the warrant
- 9:23commission begin to
- 9:25surface and the White House is a bit
- 9:28concerned about these persons who are
- 9:31criticizing the Warren Commission the
- 9:34FBI is directed here to gather
- 9:36information on those persons information
- 9:39which extended to their personal lives
- 9:42indeed down to an including sex
- 9:46activities the name check
- 9:50process was often used as a basis of
- 9:55getting a clearer fix on people who had
- 9:57began to criticize
- 10:01Administration in several cases we've
- 10:05identified news correspondents and major
- 10:08networks who apparently at one point or
- 10:10another earned the White House's ir and
- 10:12was were the subject of name
- 10:15checks the number of reporters from
- 10:18major
- 10:19newspapers many of the names there pop
- 10:23up immediately after Revelations or
- 10:26accusations about misconduct or the
- 10:30activities of the White
- 10:33House we even got to the point where the
- 10:36name check
- 10:37process was used as a basis to gather
- 10:41the views or information on private
- 10:44citizens who have objected the Vietnam
- 10:46policy and this information was
- 10:48subsequently distributed to persons who
- 10:51may be in a position to point up adverse
- 10:54information in the individual's
- 10:56background this took the form for
- 10:58example of going to political figures
- 11:01and saying to those figures if you have
- 11:04an occasion to comment upon so and so
- 11:06you might want to have this
- 11:09information we will talk a little more
- 11:11about that when we come to cointelpro
- 11:15activities the youo in a political Arena
- 11:18virtually covered the Spectrum in one
- 11:21case we will produce information
- 11:22regarding the FBI's reported efforts to
- 11:26influence the Speaker of the House
- 11:28regarding a prom civil rights figure
- 11:30using information that have been gained
- 11:34through various investigative techniques
- 11:36and accomplishing this unofficial over
- 11:39lunch kind of
- 11:40dissemination a footnote on the 1964
- 11:44Democratic Convention a technique which
- 11:47was used there was the Furnishing to the
- 11:50FBI of false press credentials by one of
- 11:52the major networks which the FBI then
- 11:55used in order to insert itself as a
- 11:58bogus
- 12:00newsman into legitimate discussions of
- 12:04political persons and protest groups and
- 12:06acquire information concerning their
- 12:09plans pretending to be a reporter uh and
- 12:12in fact acquiring it for the purposes of
- 12:14the bureau and transmission to higher
- 12:18authority now turning to co inel
- 12:22Pro
- 12:25cointelpro is a abbreviation of the
- 12:28words founder intelligence
- 12:32program
- 12:35cointelpro is the name for the effort by
- 12:39The Bureau to destroy people and to
- 12:42destroy
- 12:43organizations or as they use the words
- 12:45disrupt and
- 12:46neutralize and in pursuit of this goal
- 12:49FBI agents used a wide range of weapons
- 12:52disseminating misinformation creating
- 12:54animosities and generally spreading
- 12:56Havoc among the target groups
- 13:00one of the
- 13:01other techniques
- 13:04utilized was to
- 13:07destroy the job or family life and
- 13:10family life was a
- 13:12particularly opportune Target in bu
- 13:15bureau's
- 13:18View and played on some fairly tender
- 13:22sensitivities without mention of the
- 13:24name reflected therein if you look to
- 13:26tab 9-4 of your books
- 13:29you will
- 13:31see the bureau's
- 13:34report on a co-intel pro
- 13:37effort against a white
- 13:42female who was involved as an officer in
- 13:45what is defined as a local black
- 13:47activist
- 13:50group the way to discredit or neutralize
- 13:53this
- 13:54leader was to take attention away from
- 13:58activities of the Group by creating
- 14:00another kind of
- 14:02distraction the distraction read as
- 14:05follows Dear Mrs
- 14:10blank look man I guess your old lady
- 14:13doesn't get enough at home Mr blank I'm
- 14:16sorry letters to her husband or she
- 14:19wouldn't be shucking and Jing with our
- 14:21black men in action you dig like all she
- 14:25wants to integrate is the bedroom and US
- 14:28black sisters ain't going to take no
- 14:30second best for our men so lay it on her
- 14:33man or get her the hell out of light it
- 14:38signed a soul
- 14:41sister particularly effective technique
- 14:45as reflected by the memorandum it did
- 14:47succeed in distracting her uh Bureau
- 14:50agents were told to attack the new left
- 14:54by disinformation and misinformation and
- 14:56I will give you six quick examp examples
- 14:59of what was done pursuant to that
- 15:02program the was a body called the
- 15:04national mobilization committee to end
- 15:06the war in
- 15:07Vietnam at the time of the Democratic
- 15:10National Convention in
- 15:121968 the that body attempted to obtain
- 15:16housing in Chicago for demonstrators who
- 15:18would come to the convention uh the FBI
- 15:21local office in Chicago obtained 2117 of
- 15:25those forms and filled them out with
- 15:27fictitious names and addresses of
- 15:29persons who purported falsely to have
- 15:32houses in which the demonstrators could
- 15:34say uh the tactic had its designed
- 15:37effect uh because according to FBI
- 15:41documents the persons who went out to
- 15:43look for these houses made quotes long
- 15:45and useless Journeys to locate the
- 15:47addresses and the effort to find housing
- 15:50was canceled and what effect that had
- 15:52upon the attitude of the persons who
- 15:53were there in Chicago and what
- 15:55contribution that made to what happened
- 15:57thereafter I suppose we'll never
- 15:59know the precisely the same tactic and
- 16:02program was carried out by the bureau
- 16:04with respect to the 1969 presidential
- 16:07authoriz inauguration where they again
- 16:10filled out false housing forms to
- 16:12confuse and disrupt efforts by persons
- 16:15coming to Washington to find places to
- 16:17stay during those same 1969 inauguration
- 16:21ceremonies the Washington field office
- 16:23of the FBI discovered that persons who
- 16:26were attempting to coordinate and
- 16:29control the
- 16:31demonstrations there were Marshals and
- 16:33this committee has examined in executive
- 16:35session Mr Eagle Crow who was
- 16:38responsible uh for coordinating law
- 16:40enforcement at that demonstration uh and
- 16:43he has told us that the marshals of the
- 16:46demonstrators were a very useful and
- 16:49helpful group of persons in order to
- 16:52keep the demonstration orderly now what
- 16:54did the FBI do they found out what
- 16:58citizen band was being used for
- 17:00walkie-talkies and they used that
- 17:02Citizen band to supply the marshals with
- 17:05misinformation and pretending to be a
- 17:07unit of the national mobilization to end
- 17:09the war in Vietnam countermanded the
- 17:12orders issued by the uh
- 17:16movement in 1967 there was a rally in
- 17:19Washington protesting the Vietnam War a
- 17:23newspaper in New York City indicated
- 17:26that its contribution to uh this rally
- 17:29was to be
- 17:31the um symbolic Act of dropping flowers
- 17:36on the Pentagon and the newspaper put an
- 17:39ad in the newspaper asking for a pilot
- 17:41who could help them do that the Federal
- 17:43Bureau of Investigation answered the ad
- 17:46and it kept up the pretense that it was
- 17:48a genuine pilot up to the point when the
- 17:50publisher of the newspaper showed up
- 17:52with 200 lbs of flowers and there was no
- 17:54one there to fly the plane the most
- 17:57dramatic testimony today involve the
- 17:59surveillance of Martin Luther King the
- 18:01committee staffers has described in
- 18:03detail attempts to discredit and to
- 18:05destroy King to try to turn his
- 18:07followers against him even to find
- 18:10another Idol for black Americans Martin
- 18:13Luther King was and is a national hero
- 18:16to Millions but to Jay Edgar Hoover he
- 18:18was a dangerous man who would wreck the
- 18:21country by January of 62 Mr Hoover has
- 18:25already typed Dr King as no good
- 18:30Hoover is particularly Disturbed
- 18:34after in 1963 it became clear
- 18:38that the concept of
- 18:42nonviolence was gaining adherence a
- 18:45inherence to
- 18:46be uh made even more clear by the time
- 18:49the March on Washington came
- 18:53around this development of the concept
- 18:56of nonviolent confrontation or
- 18:57nonviolent Pro test were seen as a
- 19:00threat to law
- 19:02enforcement and something the bureau was
- 19:04indeed unhappy
- 19:06about this was aided
- 19:09apparently by what the bureau regarded
- 19:12as Dr King's direct attacks on Mr Hoover
- 19:17and the
- 19:18bureau and the public controversy was
- 19:21pretty much fullblown at the time in
- 19:261963 when
- 19:29the Mr Sullivan who
- 19:32should be able to give us some
- 19:34assistance on this
- 19:35matter communicates to Mr Hoover a
- 19:39plan for dealing
- 19:42with Dr Martin Luther
- 19:46King quoting from a
- 19:49memorandum the plan here is to
- 19:51completely discredit Dr King by quote
- 19:55taking him off his
- 19:56pedestal and to reduce him completely an
- 20:04influence in its effort to reduce Dr
- 20:08King and influence to take him off his
- 20:10pedestal and
- 20:13to change if you will
- 20:16His Image before the uh masses we begin
- 20:21to see we began to get some insight into
- 20:24the thought
- 20:25process of the FBI
- 20:29at this time the thinking was that this
- 20:32would not be a terribly difficult task
- 20:35the memo indicated for example
- 20:37that this can be done and will be
- 20:41done obviously confusion Will Rain
- 20:45particularly among the Negro
- 20:47people the Negroes will be left without
- 20:49a national leader of sufficiently
- 20:51compelling personality to steer them in
- 20:53the proper
- 20:54direction so the FBI decided that if
- 20:58they were going to take King off his
- 21:00pedestal it was a part of their task to
- 21:03find and bring into prominence a new
- 21:06quote National negro
- 21:08leader uh after the March on Washington
- 21:12there was an acceleration he was defined
- 21:15because of his speech in that
- 21:18demonstration in Washington as the most
- 21:20dangerous and effective leader in the
- 21:22country and there was a paper battle
- 21:24between within the bureau as to how best
- 21:26to attack him and he was attacked uh
- 21:29After Time magazine named him as Man of
- 21:31the Year again the bureau finds that
- 21:34reprehensible believes it must attack
- 21:35and Destroy uh when he was given the
- 21:38Nobel Prize again they seek to discredit
- 21:42Dr King with the persons who welcomed
- 21:45him back from that award uh when he
- 21:48began to speak out against the Vietnam
- 21:50War there's a new Crescendo of efforts
- 21:53by The Bureau to discredit and Destroy
- 21:55Dr
- 21:56King when the poor people's campaign
- 21:59took place once again they go after Dr
- 22:02King and their activity to go after Dr
- 22:05King didn't even cease when he died
- 22:08because as Congress began to consider
- 22:12the question of whether or not Dr King's
- 22:15birthday should be named and M made a
- 22:18national holiday uh the bureau developed
- 22:21plans to call in Friendly Congressman
- 22:24for off- the record briefings concerning
- 22:26King in the hopes that those Congressman
- 22:29could keep any such bill from being
- 22:30reported out of
- 22:35committee the period surrounding the
- 22:37March on Washington and directly
- 22:39following it is particularly revealing a
- 22:42report was written uh for the director
- 22:45uh
- 22:46by his chief intelligence officer
- 22:50reporting that the Communist Party in
- 22:53fact for 40 years had been trying to
- 22:55control the Negro movement uh and that
- 22:59it had always failed and that its
- 23:01efforts in connection with the March on
- 23:03Washington were
- 23:05infinitesimal this was not accepted uh
- 23:08by the director of the FBI he found that
- 23:12thinking wrong unacceptable and said
- 23:16that it must be changed and it was
- 23:19changed uh and then we find paper coming
- 23:21in in which the lower level people in
- 23:24the FBI apologize for having
- 23:25misunderstood matters and on they go
- 23:29uh with this effort to discredit and
- 23:31start they do the
- 23:34bugs on Dr King the FBI sought to
- 23:38prevent the pope from meeting with Dr
- 23:41King uh it intervened with a cardinal
- 23:44prevent the Pope the pope from meeting
- 23:46with Dr King it did and when the pope
- 23:50despite despite that effort did meet
- 23:52with Dr King the FBI documents record
- 23:56the adverb astounding must have been
- 23:59post Pope John was it uh it was in
- 24:051964 and now someone's got to help me on
- 24:08that who was the pope then pop Paul was
- 24:11it Pope Paul in any event that effort
- 24:14didn't work the
- 24:16paranoia the belief that American
- 24:19citizens couldn't deal themselves with
- 24:22Dr King is indicated by this story uh at
- 24:25one point Governor Rockefeller was
- 24:27planning a trip to Latin America and the
- 24:31bureau felt that it had to approach
- 24:33Governor Rockefeller so he could be he
- 24:35was planning to see Dr King before going
- 24:38so that he could be warned of what a
- 24:40great danger Dr King was this effort
- 24:43went on and on and on each time that he
- 24:45was doing something important there was
- 24:48an effort to discredit him each person
- 24:50who the bureau felt uh could give
- 24:54further credit further further
- 24:56recognition to Dr King an effort to stop
- 24:59that from happening uh the bureau went
- 25:01so far as to mail Anonymous letters to
- 25:04Dr King and his wife which were mailed
- 25:08shortly before he was awarded the Nobel
- 25:10Peace
- 25:12Prize uh and finishes with
- 25:16this suggestion King there is only one
- 25:19thing left for you to do you know what
- 25:21it is you have just 34 days in which to
- 25:24do it this exact number has been
- 25:26selected for a specific reason and it
- 25:28has definite practical significance it
- 25:30was 34 days before the award you are
- 25:36done uh if I can interrupt that was
- 25:39taken by Dr King to mean a suggestion
- 25:41for suicide was it not that's our
- 25:43understanding
- 25:46Senator the who wrote The Letter uh well
- 25:51that's a matter of dispute it was found
- 25:53in the files of Mr
- 25:55Sullivan uh who was the assistant
- 25:57director of the FBI was heavily involved
- 25:59in these programs he claims uh that it's
- 26:02a plant in his files and that someone
- 26:04else in the bureau in fact wrote the
- 26:06document the document which was found is
- 26:09a draft of the letter which was the
- 26:11anonymous letter which was actually sent
- 26:12is there any dispute that the letter did
- 26:14in fact come from the FBI uh we've heard
- 26:17no dispute of
- 26:21that one thing that is very clear as we
- 26:24examine the king information is that
- 26:29the FBI has not only
- 26:31presumed to know an awful lot about the
- 26:34movement which Dr King headed but that
- 26:37many of its fumbling efforts many of its
- 26:40failures to convince people that Dr King
- 26:43should be discredited was born out of
- 26:46the ignorance and if you will the very
- 26:50clear racism at large then in the
- 26:53agency a particularly
- 26:55revealing aspect of the
- 26:58bureau's approach to the question even
- 27:01at a time when they were examining the
- 27:04so-called negro
- 27:06question is evidenced by the response to
- 27:10a memorandum which then attorney general
- 27:13Kennedy wrote Mr Hoover Mr Kennedy wrote
- 27:16a memorandum asking Mr Hoover how many
- 27:19negro special agents he
- 27:21had Mr Hoover wrote back we don't
- 27:24catalog people by race Creed or color
- 27:28and now reading from Mr Sullivan's
- 27:29transcript on the
- 27:31point it was assumed by Mr H that this
- 27:34would take care of Mr Kennedy Mr Kennedy
- 27:37came back with another very nice letter
- 27:39that's a little auditory attitude you're
- 27:41commended to have it but I still want to
- 27:44know how many negro special agents do
- 27:46you
- 27:46have so we were in trouble it so
- 27:50happened that during the war he had five
- 27:52Negro chauffers so he automatically made
- 27:55them special
- 27:56agents did not matter whether they
- 27:58finished college or high school or
- 27:59grammar school or had a law degree so
- 28:02now we wrote back and said we had
- 28:05five then Mr Kennedy came back and said
- 28:07this was atrocious at the time according
- 28:10to Mr Sullivan the FBI had 5,500 special
- 28:14agents out of that number 5500 and you
- 28:17only have five Negro agents Mr Solomon
- 28:21again of course we did not say in that
- 28:22memorandum that none of them conducted
- 28:24investigations they were just drivers
- 28:27this is not
- 28:281961 is any wonder that the FBI was
- 28:32later presumptuous enough to feel that
- 28:34it could determine the next new National
- 28:38negro
- 28:39leader part of the problem as they
- 28:41attempted to translate the tactics used
- 28:43first against the Communist Party
- 28:45against virtually every perceived enemy
- 28:48as the bureau looked across the
- 28:49landscape and decided who should be
- 28:51neutralized discredited or destroyed as
- 28:54we all know the bureau was originally
- 28:56set up as a crime fighting agency but in
- 28:591939 in a directive by President
- 29:01Roosevelt it assumed a new task of
- 29:04seeing that the country's internal
- 29:05security was maintained in the face of a
- 29:08growing threat from fascism and
- 29:11communism in
- 29:131939 uh the
- 29:16FBI uh had and established uh an index
- 29:20called the security
- 29:21index uh which was a list of individuals
- 29:25both aliens and
- 29:27citizens now quoting on whom there is
- 29:29information available to indicate that
- 29:31their presence at Liberty in this
- 29:33country in time of war or National
- 29:35Emergency would be dangerous to the
- 29:37public peace and safety of the United
- 29:38States
- 29:39government uh the documents which
- 29:42notified all FBI offices of such lists
- 29:45and to prepare names uh indicated that
- 29:49the bureau should make certain uh that
- 29:51the fact it was making such
- 29:52investigations does not become known to
- 29:55individuals outside of the bureau
- 29:58nevertheless the Department of Justice
- 30:01uh was then
- 30:02informed uh and in
- 30:051941 the Department of Justice commenced
- 30:08to work with the B Bureau on classifying
- 30:10persons as to degree of
- 30:12dangerousness in 1943 however the
- 30:16Attorney General then in office um Mr
- 30:19Biddle uh wrote a memorandum for Jay
- 30:22Edgar Hoover in which he instructed Jay
- 30:27Edgar Hoover
- 30:28to get rid of the lists and to stamp on
- 30:33each document in which a person had been
- 30:35given a
- 30:36classification for the purpose of being
- 30:38locked up the following Legend this
- 30:41classification is unreliable it is
- 30:43hereby canceled and should not be
- 30:46used uh attorney general bidd told Jay
- 30:50Edgar Hoover that after full
- 30:52reconsideration of these classifications
- 30:54I am satisfied that they serve no useful
- 30:56purpose
- 30:58there is no statutory authorization or
- 31:01other present justification for keeping
- 31:03a custodial detention list of citizens
- 31:06the department fulfills its proper
- 31:08functions by investigating the
- 31:10activities of persons who may have
- 31:12violated the law it is not aided in this
- 31:15work by classifying persons as to
- 31:18dangerousness now within a few
- 31:21days of that instruction very flat
- 31:24instruction from the attorney
- 31:26general uh the director ctor of the
- 31:29FBI uh indicated
- 31:33to all FBI agents uh that the
- 31:38instruction in effect indicated that the
- 31:40instruction should not be carried
- 31:42out uh he's told them that what they
- 31:45should do is simply to change the label
- 31:48on the files from quote security M to
- 31:51quote security matter and from quotes
- 31:55custodial detention and he instructed
- 31:58the Agents of the FBI as follows that
- 32:01the bureau will also continue to prepare
- 32:04and maintain security index cards and
- 32:07this was for the same purpose of knowing
- 32:08who the bureau might lock up and he
- 32:11further instructed them the fact that
- 32:13the security index and security index
- 32:16cards are prepared and maintained should
- 32:17be considered as strictly confidential
- 32:20and should at no time be alluded to in
- 32:23investigative reports or discussed with
- 32:25agencies or individuals outside the
- 32:27bureau
- 32:28other than representatives of the
- 32:31military intelligence agencies who were
- 32:33going to be l in on the
- 32:37secret in 1948 there was a new attorney
- 32:40general in office and
- 32:43he contrary to attorney general bidd who
- 32:47had instructed that this be turned off
- 32:49the new Attorney General in
- 32:511948 uh instructed the FBI to prepare an
- 32:56emergency detention program
- 32:58following something called the attorney
- 33:00general's
- 33:02portfolio uh this included plans to
- 33:04suspend the rid of habus Corpus it
- 33:07included uh ultimately plans for a
- 33:11master warrant of arrest whereby on the
- 33:13signature of the Attorney General uh and
- 33:16only that signature and without
- 33:17reference to the courts thousands of
- 33:19people could be locked
- 33:21up have they continued to um uh maintain
- 33:26these files for for lock up
- 33:30purposes the key question is your last
- 33:33three words senator they have
- 33:36continued uh upon the agreement of the
- 33:39Department of
- 33:40Justice to maintain the same files the
- 33:45numbers have now been reduced to 1,200
- 33:49persons the name has been changed to
- 33:53something called the administrative
- 33:55index what purpose that reses and
- 33:58whether it still is used as a reserve
- 34:01list of persons to lock up I think we're
- 34:03going to have to ask the bureau and I
- 34:05can't give you a definitive answer well
- 34:08for most of the hearing the members of
- 34:09the senate committee sat silently
- 34:11listening to the documentation of abuses
- 34:13from Stafford Schwarz and Smothers one
- 34:16Senator said he regarded the FBI
- 34:18wrongdoing as more serious than the CIA
- 34:21wrongdoing all were stunned and appalled
- 34:23by the disclosures and at Day end
- 34:26several gave vent to their fear
- 34:28feelings I've been told for
- 34:32years by among others some of my own
- 34:37family that this is exactly what the
- 34:40bureau was doing all the
- 34:42time and in my great wisdom and high
- 34:47office uh I assured them they
- 34:54were uh on pot
- 34:57this just wasn't
- 34:59true couldn't happen they wouldn't do
- 35:03it
- 35:08uh what you've described is a series of
- 35:11illegal
- 35:13actions
- 35:16um intended squarely to deny First
- 35:20Amendment rights to some
- 35:23Americans that's what my children have
- 35:25told me was going on now I didn't
- 35:28believe
- 35:29it the trick
- 35:31now as I see it Mr
- 35:34chairman is for this
- 35:36committee to be able to figure out how
- 35:39to
- 35:40persuade the people of this country that
- 35:43indeed it did go
- 35:46on and how shall we ensure that it never
- 35:50happened
- 35:52again and I would hope as we lead to the
- 35:55strengthening of the FBI and the
- 35:57criminal field we impose very clear and
- 36:02unquestioned limits so that this kind of
- 36:06um
- 36:08unrestrained
- 36:10illegal
- 36:12secret intimidation and
- 36:15harassment of the of the
- 36:17essential ability of Americans to
- 36:20participate
- 36:21freely in American political life shall
- 36:24never happen
- 36:25again seems to me that we have moved
- 36:28away from concern by The
- 36:31Bureau for actual actions that might be
- 36:34violent or might be uh
- 36:38criminal toward action toward ideas that
- 36:42might be unpopular or may not be
- 36:44acceptable to some people within the
- 36:47bureau or perhaps within the
- 36:50administration the FBI has never had a
- 36:53statute clearly defining its Authority
- 36:59and after all these many years this is
- 37:01the first serious Congressional
- 37:03investigation of its
- 37:07activities and we have seen today the
- 37:09Dark Side of those
- 37:13activities where many Americans who were
- 37:16not even suspected of
- 37:20crime were not only spied
- 37:24upon but they were harassed
- 37:29they were
- 37:31discredited and at
- 37:33times
- 37:37endangered uh through the uh covert
- 37:41operations of the Federal Bureau of
- 37:46Investigation such Revelations um place
- 37:50a serious responsibility upon this
- 37:54committee uh to see to it that
- 37:58that can't happen again FRS as a result
- 38:02of the committee's investigation did you
- 38:04ever learn who wrote that letter to
- 38:06Martin Luther King or who authorized
- 38:09it well um I think it was a man called
- 38:12Sullivan Who We examined actually
- 38:16Senator Montel took his deposition up in
- 38:19New Hampshire and then he died before we
- 38:21could call him at a public hearing but
- 38:24he was head of the domestic intelligence
- 38:26group on under Jay Edgar Hoover and I
- 38:29think he was the person who did it um
- 38:32whether
- 38:34Hoover himself
- 38:37authorized I'm certain Hoover would not
- 38:39have objected because all of the
- 38:43so-called Co Andel Pro proposals like
- 38:47for example one in Chicago where the FBI
- 38:50tried to get one black leader to kill
- 38:54another black leader um by sending an
- 38:57anonymous letter to the the one they
- 38:59wanted to do the killing but all of
- 39:02those actions were authorized by Hoover
- 39:06and he would say okay go ahead and do it
- 39:10so long as you don't embarrass the
- 39:12bureau that was the exact word so long
- 39:15as you don't embarrass the bureau by
- 39:17which of course he meant so long as you
- 39:19can keep it secret but we didn't
- 39:22find internal evidence in the FBI Beyond
- 39:27being certain that Mr Sullivan had been
- 39:30responsible for producing that letter we
- 39:33didn't find internal evidence about
- 39:36whether the approval went up to Hoover a
- 39:39lot of Hoover's documents the day he
- 39:41died
- 39:43his famous close secretary and one of
- 39:48his closest AIDS went through his files
- 39:51and destroyed a lot of them fortunately
- 39:55they didn't destroy everything and we
- 39:56found an enormous amount but it may be
- 40:00there was a over approval of the suicide
- 40:03letter but that was one of the things
- 40:05that was destroyed I I don't know the
- 40:07answer to that Mr Maxwell do we know did
- 40:09the committee find out what impact this
- 40:11had on Dr Martin Luther King at the time
- 40:14well I think it was I'll I'll leave that
- 40:16to Fritz to to answer because Fritz was
- 40:18much more much deep more deeply involved
- 40:20in the uh domestic side than I was so
- 40:23all right do was there any uh witness
- 40:26that who testified whether or not the
- 40:28FBI's uh was Dr Martin Luther King aware
- 40:31of the FBI's uh surveillance of him and
- 40:33did it affect his
- 40:35activities yeah yes he was and yes it
- 40:38did affect his activity but it didn't it
- 40:40didn't suppress his activity but that
- 40:45letter which was received and talked
- 40:47about not only between King and his wife
- 40:51but between King and his close advisors
- 40:55was of great concern Le to them it just
- 40:59proved further the extent to which the
- 41:01FBI was trying to hurt them I mean the
- 41:05FBI pedal information about King to the
- 41:09pope to the White House to universities
- 41:12to foundations to foreign leaders they
- 41:15tried to prevent his getting the Nobel
- 41:18PR Peace Prize but you know Eliot made a
- 41:22great point which where he used Phil
- 41:24Hart for this the king of course is a
- 41:30known counter leader to the the
- 41:34practices of Jay Edgar Hoover but the
- 41:37FBI did things that injured all kinds of
- 41:41people civil rights leaders where they
- 41:43would write anom Anonymous letters
- 41:46trying to break up
- 41:48marriages um unitarians
- 41:52from Ohio who traveled to Chicago for
- 41:56the Democratic a convention in 1968
- 41:59where the FBI used false information to
- 42:02have them not have housing and get all
- 42:05mixed up in where they were staying uh a
- 42:08an actress who did commit suicide after
- 42:12the FBI had pedal information about her
- 42:17relations with um people of another
- 42:21race um and it was it was deeply deeply
- 42:26disturbing
- 42:27that a law enforcement
- 42:30agency uh knowingly and intentionally
- 42:33violated the law and did it in ways that
- 42:36were designed to hurt lots of ordinary
- 42:40people and lots of significant and
- 42:44famous people in just a few minutes
- 42:46you're going to see 30 minutes of the
- 42:48Deputy associate FBI director whose name
- 42:50is James Adams who appeared before the
- 42:53committee the day after the Martin
- 42:54Luther King Revelations but to give you
- 42:56a taste for what that 30 minutes is like
- 42:58let's show you a short clip of uh
- 43:00Democratic senator Phil Hart questioning
- 43:02director Adams it's the segment that we
- 43:04just heard about from Mr Maxell let's
- 43:06watch there were an awful lot of people
- 43:09who never got close to a Nobel
- 43:12Prize whose name is Jones and
- 43:16Smith that my review of the file
- 43:19show had violence done to their first
- 43:22amendment
- 43:24rights and uh
- 43:33Nobel Prize winners will always get
- 43:36protection but Joe potatoes
- 43:39doesn't and this committee should focus
- 43:41on him
- 43:43too Joe potatoes quite a memorable
- 43:45reference by Senator Phil Hart uh we're
- 43:48going to show the entirety of this in a
- 43:50few minutes and you talked about the the
- 43:52impact of this on you Mr Maxwell but
- 43:54would you give us a sense of what the
- 43:55atmosphere was like in that room at the
- 43:58time I I think it it was
- 44:01electric the extent of what the FBI had
- 44:06done was almost
- 44:09unbelievable and it came against a uh a
- 44:13public backdrop about the FBI which was
- 44:18the Crime Busters the elite uh police
- 44:22activities on on the federal level
- 44:25Incorruptible uh
- 44:28unbeatable the a bul workk of American
- 44:32institutions and to think that these
- 44:35things had been going on below the
- 44:39surface uh and in such contrast to the
- 44:42image of the FBI was extraordinary sure
- 44:45and we should tell people because this
- 44:46is such a vintage time but that image
- 44:48was propelled by Hollywood because there
- 44:49were in the popular culture the FBI
- 44:51agent was always the type of person that
- 44:53you describ so this was a real
- 44:55Revelation to the public that there were
- 44:57two sides absolutely it was The
- 44:59Untouchables in in a sense and all of a
- 45:02sudden to think that the Untouchables
- 45:04had been doing things that were so
- 45:06destructive so wrong so uh in violation
- 45:10of the oath that they took was I think
- 45:14uh almost unimaginable at the start of
- 45:17the at the investigation so thanks to
- 45:20Elli Maxwell and frit Schwarz for
- 45:22setting the stage for this and up next
- 45:23you're going to see from November 19th
- 45:261975 the PBS uh broadcasting of uh this
- 45:31hearing and it's anchored by Paul Duke
- 45:33which might be a familiar name to many
- 45:35of you watching and it's the edited
- 45:38highlights of testimony of Deputy
- 45:39associate FBI director James Adams let's
- 45:44watch from the outset today it was plain
- 45:47that much of the interrogation would
- 45:48revolve around the committee's
- 45:50disclosures yesterday of the attempts to
- 45:52discredit Dr King an intensive campaign
- 45:55that was waged over a year span the hand
- 45:59of Hoover was everywhere in the
- 46:00harassment of Dr King Adams told of 25
- 46:04separate acts acknowledging there was no
- 46:07legal basis for any of them as we pick
- 46:10up the proceedings Adams is being
- 46:12questioned about an anonymous letter
- 46:14sent to Dr King in 1964 shortly before
- 46:17he received the Nobel Peace Prize a
- 46:20letter which some suggest was an attempt
- 46:22to induce suicide Democratic chairman
- 46:25Frank Church quoted directly ly from The
- 46:27Letter King there is only one thing left
- 46:30for you to do you know what it
- 46:33is you have just 34 days in which to
- 46:38do
- 46:40this exact number has been selected for
- 46:44a specific reason it has definite
- 46:46practical significance you are done
- 46:49there is but one way out for you
- 46:59now if you had received such a letter
- 47:01[Music]
- 47:04um how would you have interpreted it uh
- 47:08what would you have thought it
- 47:10meant I have read that statement uh I
- 47:13have heard the conclusions of your staff
- 47:15that it was a suicide urging I can't
- 47:18find any basis upon which they drew that
- 47:22conclusion I think that uh approaching
- 47:25it from an objective standpoint as I
- 47:28read it I don't know what it means uh I
- 47:31could uh I think uh rather than a
- 47:34conclusion it should be a speculation in
- 47:37a realm of possibilities as to what was
- 47:40intended but uh I I cannot uh I don't
- 47:44understand the basis for it it's a
- 47:46possibility but uh I certainly would not
- 47:49reach such a conclusion from my reading
- 47:51of now if you had received a letter of
- 47:52this
- 47:54kind and and and it had been directed to
- 47:56to you and you were in in Dr King's
- 48:01position and you read King there is only
- 48:03one thing left for you to do you know
- 48:05what it
- 48:07is you have just 34 days in which to do
- 48:11it now that happens to roughly
- 48:13correspond
- 48:15to uh the
- 48:18time before which he was to receive the
- 48:22Nobel Peace Prize
- 48:27what would you think that meant I would
- 48:29have to consider what I was being
- 48:31accused of I would have to consider what
- 48:33the facts were I would have to consider
- 48:36uh what the intent of the person was uh
- 48:40uh writing such a note uh uh coming just
- 48:43before Christmas I don't know if it
- 48:45means uh is an urging to repent from
- 48:48something this person whoever he was
- 48:50that sent it I have no idea what it is
- 48:52certainly no Christmas card is it it's
- 48:53certainly no Christmas card it reads it
- 48:56read if you are done there is but one
- 48:58way out for you what does that
- 49:02mean I don't know I don't know if it
- 49:04means confession I don't know if it
- 49:06means uh uh uh suicide as has been
- 49:10raised uh I have no idea uh you have the
- 49:13statement uh
- 49:17uh I'm not in a position to to say uh I
- 49:21haven't interviewed anyone that uh was
- 49:23with him at the time he received it
- 49:25would you just would you disown this
- 49:26statement and and say that that any
- 49:29connection the FBI had with it was
- 49:32utterly improper and grotesque I
- 49:34certainly would say it was improper and
- 49:36I can't justify it's being prepared or
- 49:39sent yes sir I gather that there was no
- 49:42never any question raised about whether
- 49:46Dr King was a communist that was never
- 49:48charged not as a Communist Party member
- 49:51that's right never remember or that he
- 49:53was about or had committed acts of
- 49:56violence no all right but the the peg
- 49:59for investigating was apparently that he
- 50:02was subject to communist influence yes
- 50:05now
- 50:06what what makes that a Justified reason
- 50:09for investigating him is it is it a
- 50:12crime to
- 50:14be approached by someone who's a
- 50:16communist no what what is the legal
- 50:19basis for that
- 50:23investigation the basis would be the uh
- 50:28uh
- 50:30communist influence on him and the
- 50:32effect it would have upon the
- 50:34organization
- 50:36uh would be in connection with our basic
- 50:39investigation of the Communist Party
- 50:42yeah well I'm as I understand the law
- 50:44today it
- 50:47um it is not a crime to be a member of a
- 50:50Communist party that's
- 50:52correct how can it be a crime to know
- 50:55someone who is a member of the Communist
- 50:58Party it isn't well then how do you
- 51:01investigate something as tenuous as that
- 51:04what is the basis for it
- 51:07legally well it it falls into the area
- 51:10of one the intelligence jurisdiction of
- 51:14uh the activities of the Communist party
- 51:17uh you
- 51:18have
- 51:20um a situation where an
- 51:24individual uh in an organization a
- 51:26leader of an organization efforts are
- 51:29being made to influence him and Achieve
- 51:32control over the
- 51:33organization and uh it's part of the uh
- 51:37overall investigation of the
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Church Committee Hearings FBI Ops against MLK 1975 by Kike Freeman, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,867 words across 1,126 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.