China quietly saved the world last month — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00So, you remember they started the Iran
- 0:01war? Everyone said there was this oil
- 0:03shock coming that was going to basically
- 0:05blow up the whole world.
- 0:06>> World fears an oil shock.
- 0:08>> Oil shock.
- 0:09>> Oil shock.
- 0:09>> Global oil shock is raising alarm. This
- 0:11has the potential to be the biggest oil
- 0:14shock in history.
- 0:15>> All the flights were going to get
- 0:16grounded.
- 0:17>> Airlines are saying expect flight
- 0:19cancellation.
- 0:20>> They are canceling flights.
- 0:21>> 13,000 flights have been canceled.
- 0:24>> Cities were going to go dark.
- 0:25>> The final um vessel carrying jet fuel
- 0:28into the United Kingdom is going to get
- 0:29here in 48 hours and there's no more
- 0:31after that.
- 0:32>> Gas was going to triple in price if you
- 0:33could get any at all.
- 0:34>> Situation's looking pretty dire.
- 0:36>> Gas prices are expected to go up again.
- 0:38>> It would take months to recover.
- 0:40>> This is just hard math. The world's oil
- 0:42was going to dry up and that would be
- 0:43that.
- 0:43>> How we emerge from this crisis
- 0:46will define us
- 0:47for a generation.
- 0:48>> And then it just kind of never happened.
- 0:51>> Oil futures, they're telling you in
- 0:53August actually [clears throat] prices
- 0:54are coming down.
- 0:55>> Markets seem to be showing far less
- 0:56alarm than they did at the start of the
- 0:58conflict.
- 0:59>> not like the predictions turned out to
- 1:00be based on some mistake. You can go
- 1:02back and check their math. It's right.
- 1:03The world should have ended like 4 weeks
- 1:05ago. No, something happened that no one
- 1:08expected, that no one thought was even
- 1:10possible. The world got a savior and it
- 1:13was the last person that you would
- 1:15guess. Yes, it was the general secretary
- 1:18himself, the party chairman, Chinese
- 1:20president Xi Jinping.
- 1:21>> [music]
- 1:23>> And if you're thinking, "Okay, why
- 1:25didn't I hear about this?" It's because
- 1:27China pulled it off basically in secret.
- 1:30Which is kind of a weird way for an
- 1:31aspiring superpower to save the world.
- 1:33And it gets even weirder because the
- 1:34country they saved most of all is their
- 1:36chief rival, the United States.
- 1:39Well, today we are going to pull back
- 1:41the curtain on how China saved the world
- 1:44from the Iran oil shock. We're going to
- 1:46start by piecing together what China did
- 1:48that saved the world since it happened
- 1:50in secret. We're going to unravel how
- 1:52China did it because this should simply
- 1:54not have been possible to pull off,
- 1:55which will help us to answer why China
- 1:57did it, the theories for what was behind
- 1:59all this, and finally, we are going to
- 2:01look at what this changes in our global
- 2:04economic order. This is a crazy one,
- 2:07guys. This story is crazy, so let's get
- 2:09into it.
- 2:13>> [music]
- 2:15>> Okay, so to understand what China did,
- 2:17we're going to use the board to map out
- 2:19the global oil economy, what happened to
- 2:22it from the Iran war, and then what
- 2:23China did to save it from completely
- 2:26imploding. Good? So, the main thing
- 2:27about oil is it's traded in one unified
- 2:31global market. That means all the
- 2:32world's producers sell into the same big
- 2:35supply of oil, which the world's
- 2:37consumers all buy from. And this is why
- 2:40when something happens in any part of
- 2:41the oil world, like say a war in the
- 2:43Middle East, it affects everyone. And on
- 2:46any given day, there are about 100
- 2:49million barrels moving through this
- 2:51system. [music]
- 2:52100 million barrels
- 2:54produced every day, and that is also 100
- 2:58million barrels that gets consumed
- 3:01every day. [music]
- 3:04And it's really important that these two
- 3:05numbers are the same. Every drop of oil
- 3:08that gets produced every day gets sold
- 3:10and consumed every day. There is zero
- 3:12slack in the system, [music] and that is
- 3:14why it is such a big deal when the Iran
- 3:16war starts and Iran shuts down the
- 3:18Strait of Hormuz.
- 3:21>> [music]
- 3:22>> In doing this, shutting down the Strait
- 3:23of Hormuz, blocks 20 million barrels of
- 3:26oil per day from reaching the world.
- 3:29>> [music]
- 3:32>> So, now we've only got 80 million
- 3:34barrels a day in output to meet 100
- 3:37million barrels a day in demand, right?
- 3:39This equation no longer balances.
- 3:42>> [music]
- 3:42>> We now have a 20 million barrel a day
- 3:45deficit.
- 3:48And this [music] this deficit means that
- 3:50pretty soon 20% of the oil-consuming
- 3:53world was going to power down. That's
- 3:55one in five flights, one in five
- 3:57factories, power plants. It's a global
- 3:59calamity. Still, the world is ready with
- 4:01a couple of defenses, including [music]
- 4:03this. Oil pipelines that go around
- 4:05Hormuz.
- 4:06>> This is the East-West pipeline, known as
- 4:09Petroline.
- 4:09>> That big one is controlled by Saudi
- 4:11Arabia, and then the United Arab
- 4:13Emirates controls the other main one.
- 4:14>> This is the Abu Dhabi crude oil
- 4:16pipeline.
- 4:18>> [music]
- 4:18>> And these pipelines add about 7 million
- 4:20barrels of oil back into the system.
- 4:23It's a lot.
- 4:25Okay, so now just to make sure we're
- 4:26keeping score, we're at a negative 13
- 4:29million barrel a day deficit.
- 4:32>> [music]
- 4:32>> Right, we removed 20 million barrels
- 4:34from the system, we added 7 million back
- 4:36in, 13 million deficit. It's better, but
- 4:38it's still really bad. Okay, so you guys
- 4:41are still with me? The other big defense
- 4:43that the world has is strategic
- 4:45petroleum reserves, emergency stockpiles
- 4:47of oil.
- 4:50>> [music]
- 4:50>> These tanks are all full of oil.
- 4:52American and other countries keep huge
- 4:53stockpiles like this for emergencies.
- 4:55And there are even bigger US stocks I
- 4:56can't show you because they're kept in
- 4:58huge salt caves thousands of feet
- 4:59underground. Tons of countries have
- 5:01these reserves. Here's Japan's, one of
- 5:02the world's largest. A week into the
- 5:04war, 32 of these countries got together
- 5:06and all opened up their reserves to the
- 5:08world. This was the largest release of
- 5:10reserve oil in history. Hundreds of
- 5:13millions of barrels from dozens of
- 5:14countries, which is a huge deal. But the
- 5:16war dragged on and on, and it was
- 5:18stretching out these releases, so in the
- 5:20end they added up to an average 2 and
- 5:221/2 million barrels per day.
- 5:26So, these were the world's big defenses
- 5:28[music] for a mass oil shock like what
- 5:31happened in the Iran war. And together,
- 5:33these bring our deficit down to 10 and
- 5:361/2 million barrels a day.
- 5:39This is still a calamity, more than a
- 5:41tenth of global energy usage. And it
- 5:43gets [music] worse. Those 32 emergency
- 5:46stockpiles from all over the world, they
- 5:48are running out.
- 5:50Here's America's reserve.
- 5:53It's dropping hard and fast toward zero.
- 5:56And here's Japan.
- 5:58It's same thing, absolutely plunging.
- 6:00So, not only are these reserves tiny
- 6:02relative to the hole they have to fill,
- 6:04but they're only good a few months and
- 6:05then they are gone, man. Which is
- 6:07exactly why everyone looked at all this
- 6:10and said, "Yeah, the world is ending."
- 6:12Until a few weeks in, people started to
- 6:15notice something weird happening.
- 6:17>> Good afternoon, everyone, or good
- 6:19morning, or good evening, or wherever
- 6:21you are.
- 6:21>> This is from a conference call a
- 6:23business intelligence firm called Kepler
- 6:25held back in April walking its clients
- 6:27through what was going on in the oil
- 6:28market and they focused on one thing in
- 6:30particular.
- 6:31>> What's happening with China, right? So,
- 6:32I just want to look at China monthly
- 6:34imports right now.
- 6:35>> China's oil imports, that's those bars
- 6:37in the chart, had suddenly dropped to
- 6:39half.
- 6:40Half.
- 6:41>> So, and how much longer How long could
- 6:42that carry on?
- 6:43>> I know those guys did not seem super
- 6:44emotive about this. I, you know, market
- 6:46analysts. But, trust me when I say this
- 6:49discovery made people lose their minds.
- 6:52And let me give you some context for
- 6:54why.
- 6:58This shows China's oil imports since
- 6:591980 and that rise is one of the biggest
- 7:02stories in the history of oil. This is
- 7:04where China surpassed the US as the
- 7:06world's biggest oil importer and just
- 7:08kept going. Oil has powered China's rise
- 7:10from the start. Fuels their factories,
- 7:12>> [music]
- 7:12>> lights their cities, it's the engine of
- 7:14their economy. Yes, China has been
- 7:16building lots of solar and wind, but
- 7:17renewables like that still produce just
- 7:19a fraction [music] of the power that
- 7:20they get from coal, gas, and especially
- 7:23oil. Which is why it seemed impossible
- 7:26that right after the Iran war started,
- 7:28China's imports that have been rising
- 7:29for decades dropped overnight by half.
- 7:32This decline here, [music] five and a
- 7:34half million barrels a day, is
- 7:35equivalent to more than all of India's
- 7:37oil imports.
- 7:39More than Europe's [music] five biggest
- 7:41economies combined.
- 7:43This was the thing that saved the world,
- 7:46China. China took its imports
- 7:50and magically cut it by five and a half
- 7:53million barrels a day.
- 7:56Which means that what started as a 20
- 7:58million barrel a day deficit from Hormuz
- 8:00closing is now after all those alternate
- 8:03pipelines, plus emergency stockpiles,
- 8:05plus China doing whatever it's doing,
- 8:07means that deficit is now down to just 5
- 8:10million barrels a day.
- 8:13And look, that's not great. That's still
- 8:14pretty serious, but everybody shaving 5%
- 8:17off of their oil usage instead of 20%
- 8:19[music]
- 8:20is the difference between mass blackouts
- 8:22and economic collapse, which is what we
- 8:23thought we'd get, and a few months of
- 8:25higher gas prices, localized flight
- 8:27cancellations, and some gas lines in
- 8:29Southeast Asia, which is what we got
- 8:31instead. So [music] yeah, I would call
- 8:32that basically saving the world. Really
- 8:35thanks to this guy.
- 8:37And before we go further, I want to
- 8:39thank our sponsor for enabling us to
- 8:41bring you this video. Sponsors are how
- 8:43we're able to do what we do. So thank
- 8:45you to Outschool. And if you don't know
- 8:46Outschool, helping you get smarter is
- 8:49actually what they do, too. If you feel
- 8:50like you need to know want to know how
- 8:52to use the latest AI tools to get ahead
- 8:54in what viewers of this channel know is
- 8:56an increasingly competitive job market,
- 8:58or you know some, but you want to know
- 9:00more, Outschool is offering its
- 9:02mastermind course this and every weekend
- 9:0510:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Two days, lots
- 9:07of practical knowledge, expert
- 9:08mentoring, and real-world tools.
- 9:10Outschool actually believes so much in
- 9:12this course that they are making it free
- 9:14to our viewers. Just use the link in the
- 9:15description to register. You'll learn
- 9:17deep research with Claude, build
- 9:19artifacts and dashboards, create
- 9:21presentations, use Claude connectors to
- 9:23automate tasks, build custom agents, and
- 9:26generate videos and visuals. Look, I
- 9:28know AI, it's a sensitive topic. I get
- 9:31it. We talk about it on the channel,
- 9:33>> [music]
- 9:33>> and there are a lot of companies in this
- 9:35field I would not partner with. I
- 9:38partner with Outschool because it's
- 9:40service by and for human beings who,
- 9:43however you, we feel about this
- 9:46technology,
- 9:47>> [music]
- 9:47>> one had better learn how to wield it.
- 9:49It's why Outschool's courses have
- 9:51already been attended by more than 10
- 9:52million people. Sign up now and you also
- 9:54get as free bonuses a full AI prompt
- 9:57library, 50 secret Claude codes, and a
- 9:59personalized AI tool kit builder. So, if
- 10:02you're interested, you can sign up for
- 10:04free using the link in the QR code or in
- 10:06the video description. So now, let's get
- 10:08back to our story. But, China has not
- 10:11said a thing. Hasn't acknowledged
- 10:13they're doing this, hasn't said how or
- 10:14why, just stopped importing oil by the
- 10:17largest amount any country has ever
- 10:20stopped importing oil. Poof, overnight
- 10:22cold turkey this substance that the
- 10:24entire industrialized world,
- 10:26>> [music]
- 10:26>> and China especially, have made
- 10:28essential to their daily functioning for
- 10:31100 years. And since China won't tell us
- 10:33how they did this, we are just going to
- 10:35have to [music] piece it together
- 10:36ourselves. Starting with a quiet change
- 10:38China made right at the start of the
- 10:40war.
- 10:41This article from 2 weeks into the war
- 10:43revealed that China had ordered a total
- 10:45ban on fuel exports. The [music] context
- 10:48here is China has a huge refinery
- 10:50industry. And what it does is it turns
- 10:52raw crude oil into stuff like jet fuel
- 10:54and gasoline. [music] And most of those
- 10:55fuels stay within China, but because
- 10:57they're good at it, they export a bunch
- 10:59of it to all over Asia. Until March,
- 11:01when China banned those refiners from
- 11:03exporting a drop of fuel. And at the
- 11:05time, everyone assumed this was to
- 11:07preempt a potential fuel shortage within
- 11:09China by building up stockpiles. One
- 11:11reason I say assume is that this ban was
- 11:13imposed, that's right, in secret. That's
- 11:14why the story is credited to four
- 11:16sources with knowledge of the matter.
- 11:17That means [music] off the record. But,
- 11:18that assumption about why China was
- 11:20doing this was wrong. Turns out it
- 11:21wasn't to stockpile jet fuel or
- 11:22gasoline. [music] It was because China
- 11:24was about to stop importing half of its
- 11:26oil, so those refineries were about to
- 11:28do a lot less refining.
- 11:31>> [music]
- 11:33>> So, rough math, I'm going to say that
- 11:34accounts for cutting about half a
- 11:37million barrels in daily demand [music]
- 11:39out of the 5 and 1/2 million that China
- 11:40cut overall.
- 11:43Okay,
- 11:44>> [music]
- 11:44>> next big move. And if you care about
- 11:45climate change or air quality, you're
- 11:47going to want to cover your ears here.
- 11:49Coal.
- 11:53This is from a few weeks before the war.
- 11:55Why China is building [music] so many
- 11:57coal plants. And it found that China
- 11:58commissioned more than 50 large-scale
- 12:00plants last year alone. So, once the war
- 12:02started, China spun a bunch of those
- 12:04plants online or pushed its [music]
- 12:05existing plants into overdrive or
- 12:07probably both. But, by April it was
- 12:09burning a record amount of coal. China
- 12:12also figured out a way to use coal
- 12:13instead of oil to make plastics, which
- 12:15usually is a petroleum product. They
- 12:17also found a way to use coal to make
- 12:20fertilizer, which usually also is an oil
- 12:22byproduct. All of which allowed them to,
- 12:25say [music] it with me, import less oil.
- 12:27And we're not sure the exact amount, but
- 12:30let's just say, and this is a guess,
- 12:32another half a million barrels.
- 12:35Now, [music] by all accounts, life
- 12:37remained completely normal within China,
- 12:39like even more so than it did in the
- 12:40United States, where gas prices [music]
- 12:42were crazy. But China did find some ways
- 12:45to nudge people to use less fossil
- 12:47fuels. According to this Wall Street
- 12:48Journal story, for example, [music]
- 12:50after Chinese airlines canceled a bunch
- 12:52of internal flights, and air passenger
- 12:53traffic declined about 6%, there was
- 12:56also a 5% rise in rail passenger
- 12:58traffic, meaning people just took the
- 13:00train. And by May, electric cars
- 13:02accounted for about a quarter of all
- 13:03vehicles on the road, up 33% from a year
- 13:06earlier. Now, China can't make and
- 13:08distribute 50 million new EVs overnight,
- 13:10but if you've already got a large fleet
- 13:11in people's hands from years of
- 13:12subsidies, then when gas prices spike
- 13:15because, say it with me, China stopped
- 13:17importing oil, people with gas cars will
- 13:19start carpooling in their friend's
- 13:21[music] Xiaomi SU70V, they'll start
- 13:22taking the train, and gas consumption
- 13:25will go down.
- 13:27The effect of this one is hard to
- 13:28measure, but let's just call it another
- 13:31half a million barrels.
- 13:34Remember, that is more than half of all
- 13:35the oil that France imports. It is a
- 13:37lot, but we're still not really close to
- 13:39explaining all 5.5 million in China's
- 13:42disappearing [music] demand. And that's
- 13:43because we've got one big thing left.
- 13:45This is China's real secret weapon,
- 13:47[music] and it's something that we, the
- 13:49world, did not know about until now.
- 13:51It's in silos, just like this.
- 13:53>> [music]
- 13:55>> This is a chart of the world's largest
- 13:56oil reserves at the start of the war
- 13:58before they got used up. But there's one
- 14:00country missing here, China.
- 14:01>> [music]
- 14:02>> And the size of China's oil reserve is,
- 14:05you guessed it, a state secret. But we
- 14:07can get a decent idea. These are some of
- 14:08China's crude oil silos, and the two
- 14:11main things to know about them are that
- 14:12they're really, really big, and that the
- 14:14domes on them go up and down based
- 14:16[music] on how full they are. All of
- 14:18which is fully visible from space. There
- 14:20are people whose whole job is to count
- 14:22those silos and how full they are to
- 14:24track how much oil China has saved up.
- 14:27They have more sophisticated ways to
- 14:28check those numbers, [music] too, but
- 14:29the silo counting works pretty well. And
- 14:31those silos alone suggest China has 1.4
- 14:35billion barrels saved up. That's more
- 14:36than every other country stockpile added
- 14:38together. It would be enough to fill a
- 14:4012-ft tank the size of Manhattan. And
- 14:42this is just the oil that we know about.
- 14:44China also has oil stashed at factories
- 14:46and refineries around the country, and
- 14:48it's been building huge underground
- 14:49caverns to store oil away where no one
- 14:51can count it up. So, actually, China
- 14:53might have way more than even the 1.4
- 14:55[music] billion barrels that we can see,
- 14:57which means China could use up, let's
- 14:58say, 4 million barrels a day from those
- 15:01reserves, and it would still take more
- 15:02than a year to run out.
- 15:06And maybe even a lot more, depending on
- 15:08how many of those caves it has. Now, I
- 15:09cannot tell you how crazy this is.
- 15:12India, for example,
- 15:13>> could live off of its stockpile for
- 15:14about 4 days. Europe's stockpile could
- 15:17serve it for maybe 10 or 20 days. And
- 15:18the US stockpile, which took decades to
- 15:20build up and is the envy of the world,
- 15:22would be good for 60 days, which is why,
- 15:25even with the US still importing from
- 15:26all sorts of sources outside the Middle
- 15:28East, Trump cried uncle 3 months into
- 15:30the war. So, you can understand the
- 15:31shockwaves it sent when it turned out
- 15:33China, the world's biggest oil consumer,
- 15:35had saved up so much it could cut itself
- 15:38off from the world like this without
- 15:39breaking a sweat.
- 15:40>> But this raises a whole other question.
- 15:42How did China store away this secret and
- 15:45impossibly huge universe of oil, a
- 15:47Manhattan of oil? Where did it all come
- 15:49from? And there are basically two
- 15:51answers to this. Answer number one is
- 15:53Iran, and answer number two is Russia.
- 15:55[music]
- 15:57Let me explain.
- 15:58>> The Iran and Libya Sanctions Bill I
- 16:00signed today will help to deny those
- 16:01countries the money they need to finance
- 16:04international terrorism.
- 16:05>> 1996, President Bill Clinton signs a law
- 16:08cutting off the world from buying
- 16:10Iranian oil. We'll get to how in a
- 16:12second. 2022, Russia invades Ukraine,
- 16:14and the head of the European Union makes
- 16:16a big announcement.
- 16:17>> So, today we will propose
- 16:20to ban all Russian oil from Europe.
- 16:23>> Which the US and other big countries
- 16:24joined. All of which did
- 16:26you know, it's easier actually if I show
- 16:27you on the board.
- 16:29>> [music]
- 16:30>> So, two of the world's biggest oil
- 16:32producers, Russia and Iran, were mostly
- 16:33cut off from this global oil market. All
- 16:36that oil sloshing around stuck with
- 16:38nowhere to go, nowhere to buy it. But,
- 16:40wouldn't you know it, bit by bit
- 16:43actually, let me show you this too on
- 16:44the board.
- 16:47China found a way to get all that
- 16:50forbidden Iranian and Russian oil. This
- 16:52is a report by a think tank called the
- 16:53Atlantic Council tracking [music]
- 16:55China's secret oil trade with Iran and
- 16:57Russia. And they did it by using dark
- 16:59fleet tankers [music] that operate
- 17:01outside of maritime laws and obscure
- 17:02their operations. They rebranded oil as
- 17:04Malaysian, funnel it through small
- 17:07independent refineries called Teapots,
- 17:09and then route the money via smaller
- 17:11back alley financial institutions with
- 17:13names like Bank of Kunlun. But, okay. If
- 17:15the world knows China is doing this, and
- 17:17all of this oil is supposedly under
- 17:19global economic sanctions that make it
- 17:21forbidden to buy it, then how does China
- 17:22get away with it? Well, it's by using
- 17:25their other secret weapon.
- 17:27This.
- 17:28China's currency, the Renminbi, the
- 17:31Yuan.
- 17:33>> [music]
- 17:34>> And the reason that this works, that
- 17:35it's a magic hack, is because of
- 17:37something I didn't tell you about
- 17:39earlier about this global oil market.
- 17:41All of it, all of this oil is traded
- 17:43[music] in this, US dollars.
- 17:47Couple of fine fellows we got up here on
- 17:49the board. All of the sales, all of the
- 17:51purchases, it's all in US dollars. And
- 17:54the reason for this is that oil trades,
- 17:55remember, happened between countries.
- 17:58But, it would be chaos if every country
- 18:00paid every other country in a different
- 18:01currency. Nobody would know what the
- 18:03real price was. And oil exporters would
- 18:05be stuck with this grab bag of a hundred
- 18:07foreign currencies that they wouldn't be
- 18:08able to use. But, everybody can use US
- 18:11dollars. Everybody wants US dollars.
- 18:13[music]
- 18:13They're a safe way to save your
- 18:14country's oil revenues because the
- 18:16dollar is stable. Every other country
- 18:18accepts it in trade. [music]
- 18:19And trading all in one currency means
- 18:22there's just one price, which is what
- 18:24you need for a unified global market to
- 18:26function. But this gives the US a lot of
- 18:28power because trading in US dollars
- 18:31means those transactions have to be
- 18:32processed by US-based bank, which means
- 18:34the US government can tell those banks
- 18:36to block oil trades with any country it
- 18:38doesn't like. People truly do not
- 18:40realize how much US [music] global power
- 18:42comes from these little greenbacks. But
- 18:44this means China and Russia and Iran
- 18:47were able to bypass this [music] whole
- 18:49system by using a different currency,
- 18:51China's currency, to process the sales.
- 18:53This makes these oil trades basically
- 18:56invisible to the US financial system and
- 18:58therefore the US government, which means
- 19:00the US can't block it from happening.
- 19:02[music]
- 19:03And if you're wondering why more
- 19:04countries don't do this kind of thing,
- 19:05it's because they don't have a currency
- 19:07Iran or Russia or whoever would want.
- 19:10The renminbi can't do everything the
- 19:11dollar can do, but it can buy stuff from
- 19:14China. And China is the world's largest
- 19:16exporter of stuff. So that is still
- 19:19useful enough for Iran and Russia to go
- 19:22to the trouble. About the only other
- 19:23currencies in the world valuable enough
- 19:24to do this are the Japanese yen and the
- 19:27euro. But Japan and the European Union
- 19:28are big supporters of sanctions on Iran
- 19:30and Russia, so they wouldn't want to do
- 19:31this. So it is really just China that
- 19:33can pull this off. And being the only
- 19:35willing buyer of Iran and Russia's oil
- 19:37means they get a big big discount, which
- 19:39is how they were able to quietly stock
- 19:41up a billion plus barrels of probably
- 19:44mostly Iranian and Russian oil so they
- 19:46can magically stop importing enough oil
- 19:48for enough time to basically save the
- 19:51world. So that is how China saved you,
- 19:53me, the global economy, and especially
- 19:56the United States and Donald Trump from
- 19:58the largest oil shock in history. But
- 20:00that still leaves us the question of
- 20:02why. Like I'm more curious than ever.
- 20:04Why? Why would they bail us out and why
- 20:06would they do it in total silence? And
- 20:09to answer this, we are going to need the
- 20:11other side of the board.
- 20:13So we're going to use the board to go
- 20:14through four theories for why China did
- 20:17this that I think all have some merit
- 20:19and some evidence to them. But first I
- 20:21want to rule out two that I think don't
- 20:23scan. Number one, probably the one
- 20:25you've been shouting at your screen for
- 20:26the last 10 minutes because it seems so
- 20:27obvious, is that China did this. China
- 20:29stopped importing oil just to protect
- 20:31themselves from high oil prices. But you
- 20:34know what? This one
- 20:37doesn't hold up. Here's why in one
- 20:39number, $74. That is the average
- 20:42replacement price on China's oil
- 20:44reserves that they have been burning up.
- 20:47>> [music]
- 20:47>> Here's the price of oil over the last 6
- 20:49months. And here's where the price
- 20:51dropped below $74. If China was just
- 20:54trying to protect itself from price
- 20:55shocks, this is the point that they
- 20:56would have started buying again. They
- 20:58would have actually made a profit by
- 20:59buying at this price. But they didn't.
- 21:01They just kept burning reserves, which
- 21:04means they had some other motive, right?
- 21:06So, second wrong theory we need to rule
- 21:08out. This was all a soft power play for
- 21:11global goodwill. I'm sorry about the
- 21:12panda. I know it's a total cliche. When
- 21:15you Google image search Chinese soft
- 21:17power, this is the first thing that
- 21:19comes up. So, I don't know. I went with
- 21:20it. Anyway, it's also wrong.
- 21:23This soft power theory does not square
- 21:25with China's big ban against its
- 21:27refiners exporting jet fuel or gasoline
- 21:29because this really hurt the neighbors
- 21:31in Asia who count on China for that
- 21:33stuff and are the exact countries China
- 21:35most wants to improve its standing with.
- 21:37For another thing, remember China did
- 21:38all this and didn't talk about it. If
- 21:40you save the world to make countries
- 21:42like you, wouldn't you, I don't know,
- 21:44mention it at least once instead of
- 21:45hiding it in secrecy? So, these
- 21:48theories, I think these are out.
- 21:51So, now let's look at the theories that
- 21:53do make sense. Starting with the big
- 21:56one, Taiwan.
- 21:58>> [music]
- 21:59>> Here's Asia. And here's the Strait of
- 22:00Hormuz, which we learned controls 20% of
- 22:02the world's oil flows. And now this is
- 22:05the Strait of Malacca, even narrower,
- 22:07even easier to close. The ships that go
- 22:09through here carry 80% of all China's
- 22:12oil. And in any war scenario with
- 22:13Taiwan, one of the very first things
- 22:15that happens [music] is the US uses its
- 22:17naval supremacy to close Malacca like
- 22:20Iran closed Hormuz, shutting off China
- 22:21from outside oil and bringing China to
- 22:24its knees.
- 22:27>> [music]
- 22:29>> So yeah, pretty powerful, right? Defeat
- 22:31China without ever coming within a
- 22:32thousand miles of it. And this has
- 22:34obsessed China's leaders for decades.
- 22:36They actually have a name for it. They
- 22:37call it the Malacca Dilemma. And it
- 22:38applies to any war scenario with the US,
- 22:41but Taiwan is probably the likeliest.
- 22:42So, how can you neutralize the threat of
- 22:45suddenly losing access to outside oil?
- 22:47Well, one way is to build up renewable
- 22:48power sources like wind and solar, which
- 22:50yeah, check, China has [music] been
- 22:51doing. Another is burning more coal,
- 22:53check. But the best way is to stockpile
- 22:56so much oil in advance that you can go
- 22:58without imports for a year and keep the
- 23:00lights on for as long as the war takes.
- 23:02>> [music]
- 23:02>> Under this theory, China had this whole
- 23:04no oil plan ready in case of war, but
- 23:07they pulled it off now both because they
- 23:09could and maybe as a little
- 23:11demonstration to the US and Taiwan that
- 23:12the Malacca problem is kind of solved
- 23:14just to threaten them anymore, so don't
- 23:16expect them to hold them back. Okay,
- 23:18ready for theory number two? Leverage
- 23:20with Donald Trump.
- 23:23Trump and Xi actually just had a big
- 23:25one-on-one summit in May. And, you know,
- 23:27watching this, it's not hard to imagine
- 23:29Xi telling him, "Hey Donald, I'm
- 23:31single-handedly saving your economy
- 23:32right now by absorbing the oil shock so
- 23:34it doesn't hit the United States. So,
- 23:36you want me to keep this up, you better
- 23:37make it worth my while because he knows
- 23:39if there's one thing Trump has shown
- 23:40he's sensitive to,
- 23:42>> [music]
- 23:42>> it's the price of oil." Now, nobody can
- 23:43prove this happened. Yeah, a few weeks
- 23:45beforehand the US did withdraw a bunch
- 23:48of missile defense and other weapons
- 23:49from China's periphery, which China like
- 23:51to use in the Middle East, but that
- 23:52might be a coincidence. I would consider
- 23:54this the softest theory. Still, as long
- 23:56as the war goes on, Xi Jinping really
- 23:58could nuke the US economy [music]
- 24:00anytime he wants by resuming Chinese oil
- 24:02imports and exhausting global supplies.
- 24:04Did he remind Trump of that fact when
- 24:06they met? You know, we don't know. If
- 24:07you're still watching, you probably want
- 24:09to understand the world better. And so
- 24:11do the thousands of members of our club
- 24:13called New Press. New Press is where
- 24:15smart, curious people get a deeper
- 24:16version of what we do across our
- 24:18channels. In-depth interviews with the
- 24:19experts we speak to, conversations
- 24:21between creators, and the ability to
- 24:23connect directly with other members to
- 24:25talk about what's going on in the world
- 24:26with other smart, curious people. Right
- 24:28now, it's 60 bucks a year to become a
- 24:30founding member. [music] That money goes
- 24:32directly to supporting this work. Your
- 24:33subscription also includes access to,
- 24:35among other things, a podcast Johnny and
- 24:37Izzy are launching this week, as well as
- 24:38an exclusive video series I'm doing and
- 24:41been doing for a while there that I'm
- 24:42really excited [music] about, No Dumb
- 24:44Questions, where I answer big questions
- 24:46about the world submitted by viewers
- 24:47like you. In this week's, I take on a
- 24:49bunch of questions about China's rise
- 24:51[music] as a world power. Like, how did
- 24:53China and the US become adversaries in
- 24:54the first place? What is China's
- 24:56ultimate end game as a great [music]
- 24:57power? What does it want? And a lot
- 24:58more. You can check it out at
- 25:00newpress.com/questions,
- 25:02and the link is in the description. Now,
- 25:04let's get back to it. Okay, theory
- 25:05number three, and I'm pretty partial to
- 25:07this one, protecting China's
- 25:09export-based economy.
- 25:13China's economy, like we said, centers
- 25:15on manufacturing and exporting basically
- 25:17everything in the world.
- 25:19>> [music]
- 25:20>> Here's every country China exports to
- 25:22scaled by overall value.
- 25:26Now, let's cross out all the countries
- 25:27whose economy would implode in a
- 25:29sustained oil shock.
- 25:31This one,
- 25:32this one,
- 25:34probably these guys,
- 25:35definitely the Europeans. Yep, here.
- 25:38Okay, well, China just lost half of its
- 25:40export market and a bunch of its economy
- 25:43with it.
- 25:44>> [music]
- 25:46>> Or if that's what would have happened if
- 25:48China hadn't propped everyone up for 3
- 25:50months by absorbing the oil shock. Now,
- 25:52I can't prove that's why they did it,
- 25:53but I do think it would make a lot of
- 25:55sense. Okay, theory number four,
- 25:57they did this to prove to the world that
- 26:00China now controls the global price of
- 26:03oil. I had to print this out of my home
- 26:05printer because the photo printer
- 26:06stopped working. That's why the Chinese
- 26:08flag is purple. I don't know. My
- 26:10apologies to China.
- 26:12>> [music]
- 26:13>> Credit for this theory goes to a
- 26:14Bloomberg columnist named Javier Blas,
- 26:16who argued this was China unveiling its
- 26:18powerful new oil price weapon. He
- 26:20compares it to the 1973 oil shock, when
- 26:23Arab oil states like Saudi Arabia and
- 26:25some others shut off oil to the US, a
- 26:27power that got termed the Arab oil
- 26:29weapon and made those states global
- 26:31player ever since. And he argues that
- 26:34yeah, on some level this was probably
- 26:35about Taiwan and Malacca. But if China
- 26:38proved that it can flip 5% of the
- 26:41world's oil demand on and off like a
- 26:42switch, that gives them Saudi Arabia
- 26:45level influence over the world's most
- 26:47valuable resource, which gives them a
- 26:49lot of leverage over any country that
- 26:51buys a lot of oil, or that sells a lot
- 26:53of oil, which is pretty much all of
- 26:55them. I think there's probably some
- 26:57truth to all four of these theories,
- 26:59right? I don't think they're mutually
- 27:00exclusive. Now, we don't know enough, we
- 27:03can't peer inside Xi Jinping's head and
- 27:05know like which one is the truest, but I
- 27:07think if you look at these four
- 27:08together, you have a pretty good
- 27:09understanding of why China did this. So,
- 27:12okay, so the question now is what does
- 27:14all this add up to? What does it change
- 27:17about our world? And we the world
- 27:19learned a few new things here. One,
- 27:22China has neutralized the so-called
- 27:24Malacca dilemma that would have allowed
- 27:26the US Navy to shut down their economy.
- 27:28And that makes war with the US more
- 27:30bearable for China, and invasion [music]
- 27:32of Taiwan therefore more likely. And
- 27:35two, China now has a lot of control over
- 27:38global oil prices. Although I don't
- 27:40think we yet know how they would use
- 27:42that power except how they did here to
- 27:44blunt a global oil shock, but you know,
- 27:45the Iran war is still at a low boil,
- 27:47which means as long as Hormuz is at
- 27:49threat of closing or partially closed,
- 27:51Xi Jinping has a lot of leverage over
- 27:53the United States. He has that button on
- 27:55his desk that [music] says nuke US
- 27:56economy. And along those lines, the US,
- 27:59China's big rival, it came out of this
- 28:01war weakened on the world stage in a lot
- 28:03of different ways that we talked about
- 28:04in [music] the last video.
- 28:08Russia, meanwhile, is still mired in
- 28:09Ukraine. That means that among the major
- 28:11world powers, China is looking pretty
- 28:13good right now, which is part of why
- 28:14there is a growing consensus that the
- 28:16war's real winner was China.
- 28:19China won, they're the winner, China's
- 28:21the big winner here,
- 28:23>> [music]
- 28:23>> China wins.
- 28:27This is a little too clever, I think,
- 28:28Iran won the Iran war, but China did win
- 28:30something very, very big, and it's
- 28:33easier to explain if I put it on the
- 28:35board for you.
- 28:39So, forever and ever, these have been
- 28:41the three world powers of oil for like
- 28:43the last century. The US, Saudi Arabia,
- 28:46Russia. They are the three biggest
- 28:48producers in the world by far. The US
- 28:50guarantees free flow of oil on the
- 28:52world's oceans and controls the US
- 28:54dollar. Saudi Arabia is the de facto
- 28:56leader of OPEC, the alliance of
- 28:57oil-producing states. And Russia, in
- 28:59addition to being a world power and a
- 29:01huge exporter, controls land-based oil
- 29:04flows across a bunch of Europe and Asia.
- 29:06But this era might be over, or at least
- 29:09starting to end. The US proved in the
- 29:11Iran war that it cannot guarantee the
- 29:13global free flow of oil anymore. And
- 29:15Russia is under global sanction and can
- 29:17barely sell its own oil. So, these two
- 29:20powers might be out.
- 29:24>> [music]
- 29:24>> And who displaces them? Well, arguably,
- 29:27one of them is Iran, which is not the
- 29:29world's biggest producer, they're ranked
- 29:31seventh, but [music] they proved that
- 29:32they can unilaterally turn on or off 20%
- 29:36of the world's oil supply and [music]
- 29:37nobody can stop them.
- 29:43And the other new global oil power, I
- 29:45think you know where this is going. I
- 29:47think you can make an argument for
- 29:48China. You know, they kind of control
- 29:51the price of oil now, or at least have
- 29:53huge influence over it because they can
- 29:54[music] switch 5% of global demand on
- 29:57and off. And because they were able to
- 29:59do what the United [music] States wasn't
- 30:00in this war, and secure sufficient flows
- 30:03of the world's most important resource,
- 30:05>> [music]
- 30:05>> single-handedly saving the oil-burning
- 30:08world from disaster. That sounds like
- 30:09the behavior of a global oil power to
- 30:11me.
- 30:16Now,
- 30:16>> [music]
- 30:17>> I don't know what China wants to do with
- 30:18that power. I mean, we have some
- 30:20educated guesses, obviously, but [music]
- 30:22they're not telling us. They might not
- 30:23even know. They might have themselves
- 30:25just discovered how powerful they are
- 30:27here, right along with the rest of us.
- 30:29But one thing is for sure, now that they
- 30:30have this power, they've demonstrated
- 30:32[music] it, they've proven to the world
- 30:33that they have it, I am certain this
- 30:35will not be the last time that we see it
- 30:37deployed.
- 30:40>> [music]
- 30:47[music]
- 31:00[music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of China quietly saved the world last month by Max Fisher, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,050 words across 940 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.