YouTube2Text

Child Psychiatrist Dr. Miriam Grossman's Guide Out of Trans Madness — Transcript

by Andrew Klavan · 4,789 words · 699 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00[Music]
  2. 0:15hey it's Andrew Clen with this week's
  3. 0:17interview with Dr Miriam Gman the author
  4. 0:20of lost and transnation last Friday on
  5. 0:24the show we were talking about the way
  6. 0:26language got detached from meaning
  7. 0:28During the post-modern period about the
  8. 0:30kind of progression from Faith where we
  9. 0:35understood what we were all talking
  10. 0:36about and we all kind of had a sense of
  11. 0:38the the human person to the
  12. 0:40disintegration of the idea of the human
  13. 0:42being as a source of values a source of
  14. 0:44experience uh Shakespeare saw this
  15. 0:46coming in Hamlet's mad scene uh where
  16. 0:49Hamlet has asked what he's reading and
  17. 0:50he said words words words I genuinely
  18. 0:53believe that that was Shakespeare's
  19. 0:54prophecy of where the culture was going
  20. 0:57and how words were going to lose their
  21. 0:59meaning and it shouldn't come as any
  22. 1:00surprise that one of the ways in which
  23. 1:03this Detachment of of language from
  24. 1:05meaning uh is being used is to detach us
  25. 1:08and alienate us from the central fact of
  26. 1:11human existence and the central joy for
  27. 1:13most of us the central joy and Miracle
  28. 1:15of human existence which is the fact
  29. 1:17that some humans are made male and some
  30. 1:19are female through most of human history
  31. 1:21this has been the source of joy and it
  32. 1:23still Remains the source of the creation
  33. 1:24of the human race and somehow we have
  34. 1:26lost the plot of that essential bit of
  35. 1:30business uh that that is the creation
  36. 1:32and the love and the uh goal of humanity
  37. 1:36Miriam Gman is a medical doctor she
  38. 1:39doesn't just call herself a doctor she
  39. 1:40is one she is board certified in
  40. 1:42Psychiatry and in the subsp specialty of
  41. 1:44Child and Adolescent Psychiatry she's
  42. 1:46the author of four books including
  43. 1:48unprotected and you're teaching my child
  44. 1:50what and also the book I mentioned in at
  45. 1:53First lost in transnation her work
  46. 1:55exposing the origin and Hazards of the
  47. 1:57sexuality and gender industry uh has
  48. 1:59been been translated into many languages
  49. 2:01and of course she appeared in Matt
  50. 2:03Walsh's uh terrific film what is a woman
  51. 2:07Dr Grossman thank you so much for coming
  52. 2:08on oh you're so welcome Andrew and I
  53. 2:11love what you just said about Detachment
  54. 2:15perfect Bingo Bullseye home run well
  55. 2:20thank you that's good that's good to
  56. 2:21hear since you actually are a a doctor
  57. 2:23in a psychiatrist you must be seeing
  58. 2:25this a lot in a practice that deals with
  59. 2:28with young people before I I want to
  60. 2:30talk about some of your personal
  61. 2:32experiences and some of the things that
  62. 2:33you're seeing but can you give us some
  63. 2:36kind of history of how I mean it's
  64. 2:38always stunning to me how these things
  65. 2:40are introduced on a Wednesday and by
  66. 2:42Thursday they are absolute doctrinaire
  67. 2:46religion and you can't speak against
  68. 2:48them or you get censored you get
  69. 2:49cancelled how did that happen how did
  70. 2:52that happen so quickly okay well of
  71. 2:55course that's usually the number one
  72. 2:57question and I have to say say we could
  73. 3:00be here for many hours just just just
  74. 3:03answering that particular question but
  75. 3:05in a
  76. 3:06nutshell I would say that a number of
  77. 3:10decades ago in the 50s and 60s there was
  78. 3:14uh there were people that were I'm going
  79. 3:18to have to say
  80. 3:20Wicked okay bad immoral people people
  81. 3:24who wanted to destroy our
  82. 3:28judeo-christian heritage
  83. 3:30and to move us away from those
  84. 3:33judeo-christian roots and
  85. 3:36truths and one of those truths as you
  86. 3:40mentioned is the uh is the fact that
  87. 3:44humans are male or female we are mammals
  88. 3:49mammals are either male or female that
  89. 3:53is a established at conception the
  90. 3:56moment that the egg and the sperm Unite
  91. 4:00we get a cell that is either male or
  92. 4:02female and that cell develops into a
  93. 4:06full human being whose every cell in
  94. 4:10that fully developed human is male or
  95. 4:13female so it is established at
  96. 4:17conception it is
  97. 4:19permanent and of course there are more
  98. 4:23feminine boys and more masculine boy
  99. 4:26girls that is
  100. 4:28personality that is not sex so what's
  101. 4:32happening now is that we are living
  102. 4:34through a a a a period of mass delusion
  103. 4:40Mass
  104. 4:41psychosis especially among young people
  105. 4:45who have been indoctrinated to believe
  106. 4:48that male and female are human
  107. 4:52inventions that biology can be
  108. 4:56dismissed and basically that reality can
  109. 4:58be dismissed
  110. 5:00this is very
  111. 5:02dangerous it's funny you couldn't even
  112. 5:04say a boy was feminine if there weren't
  113. 5:06such a thing as femininity that existed
  114. 5:08in girls who wouldn't even know what it
  115. 5:10was can you though I just want to say
  116. 5:13you said these people were Wicked you
  117. 5:14said they had it in for judeo-christian
  118. 5:16values just so people know that we're
  119. 5:18not uh just raving you know shaking our
  120. 5:20fists at at the world can you be
  121. 5:22specific and and tell me like give me an
  122. 5:25example yes of course uh I'm referring
  123. 5:28now to Dr John money who was an eminent
  124. 5:32psychologist at John's Hopkins
  125. 5:35University and Dr money was a troubled
  126. 5:39soul he was the person who uh Advanced
  127. 5:44the theory that male and female is a
  128. 5:47social construct in other words that he
  129. 5:51he believed that we are born um gender
  130. 5:56neutral that a boy could depending on
  131. 5:59the environment could grow up to be a
  132. 6:01girl and a girl could grow up to be a
  133. 6:04boy depending on uh the expectations and
  134. 6:08messages from her family and her
  135. 6:11environment of course you know he
  136. 6:14admitted that there are some anatomical
  137. 6:17differences between between male and
  138. 6:20female but everything else aside from
  139. 6:23those anatomical differences and the
  140. 6:26ability of women to get pregnant and
  141. 6:29gestate give birth and nurse he said
  142. 6:33everything else is a social
  143. 6:36construct and so what he did was um he
  144. 6:42really devoted his life John money to
  145. 6:45proving this
  146. 6:46Theory and I'm I'll just give you a
  147. 6:49brief overview of this very fascinating
  148. 6:53and tragic story of the reamer twins
  149. 6:57that many of your listeners have
  150. 6:59probably we heard about but just in a
  151. 7:01nutshell this was an unfortunate family
  152. 7:05um who gave birth to twin boys and one
  153. 7:09of them during their circumcision the
  154. 7:12equipment
  155. 7:13malfunctioned and one of the boys penis
  156. 7:16was burnt off he was left without a
  157. 7:20penis the parents were desperate of
  158. 7:22course they heard Dr money on television
  159. 7:26this was in the 60s they heard Dr money
  160. 7:30uh talking about how a boy could be
  161. 7:32raised as a girl you just have to do it
  162. 7:35early enough castrate him um put him in
  163. 7:39dresses give him dolls raise him as a
  164. 7:41girl and he'll be
  165. 7:43fine so uh in their desperation they
  166. 7:46turned to him they went down to John's
  167. 7:48Hopkins from Winnipeg Canada and they
  168. 7:51followed his instructions to the te they
  169. 7:54had him castrated they they told
  170. 7:57everyone that he was a girl they told
  171. 8:00him obviously that he was a girl he was
  172. 8:02about 18 months at that time so this was
  173. 8:05the ultimate quote unquote social
  174. 8:08transition what we what we now call
  175. 8:10social transition a new name new
  176. 8:13pronouns new presentation to the world
  177. 8:16dresses toys the whole thing and they
  178. 8:20they went on like this for a few years
  179. 8:23now John money when the Twins were about
  180. 8:27five or six years old reported this
  181. 8:30experiment to be a complete success and
  182. 8:34it was a huge Splash it got a tremendous
  183. 8:37amount of attention in the Press both
  184. 8:40the medical and you know the um
  185. 8:43professional press and in the lay press
  186. 8:45as well because look he was telling to
  187. 8:49the world this was during a time of the
  188. 8:52nature versus nurture debate right
  189. 8:54what's more important
  190. 8:57chromosomes uh Anatomy
  191. 9:00or the way that you're raised the
  192. 9:03society uh the messages from society and
  193. 9:06John money says said that his experiment
  194. 9:09proved beyond a shadow of the doubt that
  195. 9:13it was nurture that makes the difference
  196. 9:15and so he achieved great Fame with this
  197. 9:19experiment with the twins the thing is
  198. 9:22that many years later in the late
  199. 9:2690s uh this twin who had been renamed
  200. 9:31Brenda uh came out publicly as David and
  201. 9:37told his story his disastrous story The
  202. 9:40Experiment was a hoax the experiment was
  203. 9:44a catastrophe he never felt comfortable
  204. 9:47as a girl he was extremely masculine
  205. 9:51stereotypically masculine in terms of
  206. 9:54his behaviors the way that he walked his
  207. 9:57gestures um he was an aggressive child
  208. 10:01he enjoyed fighting he preferred his
  209. 10:04brothers his twin brothers toys his
  210. 10:07trucks over the dolls that his parents
  211. 10:11gave him he ripped off those dresses he
  212. 10:14wanted to wear boy
  213. 10:16clothes so
  214. 10:18obviously obviously um John's money
  215. 10:21theory about uh David having been born
  216. 10:25gender neutral was false it his proof of
  217. 10:31concept study his experiment with the
  218. 10:34twins failed miserably the thing is that
  219. 10:37John money was an evil man and he
  220. 10:40concocted this Theory because of his own
  221. 10:44inner emotional problems he was raised
  222. 10:48by a raging alcoholic father who
  223. 10:52regularly beat him and his mother and
  224. 10:56John money wrote about his own
  225. 10:59discomfort with his masculinity with his
  226. 11:03genitals so John money had what we would
  227. 11:06call today gender
  228. 11:10dysphoria he was unhappy uncomfortable
  229. 11:13with his body so you know you don't have
  230. 11:16to be a genius to figure out how this
  231. 11:20theory of his would help to solve some
  232. 11:23of his issues because if he wanted to
  233. 11:27escape his manhood if he wanted to be
  234. 11:30the opposite of his
  235. 11:33raging
  236. 11:35Maniac
  237. 11:37father then he could in his own mind say
  238. 11:41well it doesn't matter that I'm you know
  239. 11:44that I'm ex that I have XY chromosomes
  240. 11:47it doesn't matter that I have male
  241. 11:49genitals like my father did I can be
  242. 11:53different than him because it's really
  243. 11:55nurture that makes the difference not
  244. 11:57nature when you say he was evil what
  245. 12:00aside from the obvious stupidity of his
  246. 12:04ideas what constituted his evil well
  247. 12:07there were many things that he did that
  248. 12:08was evil first of all he was Pro uh he
  249. 12:13was an advocate of of he was a pedophile
  250. 12:17yeah that's what I so he was an advocate
  251. 12:19of of adult child sexual behavior he was
  252. 12:24a he spoke out publicly for incest he
  253. 12:29said that incest is not necessarily a
  254. 12:31negative experience for the
  255. 12:33child okay he his life was devoted to
  256. 12:38taking down judeo-christian values um he
  257. 12:42also presented this data about the twins
  258. 12:47he falsified his
  259. 12:49data um the twins yeah the the twins
  260. 12:53mother reported back to him that Brenda
  261. 12:58or DAV Avid was having a lot of issues
  262. 13:01and not doing well and in fact she wrote
  263. 13:04John money when the Twins were 14 that
  264. 13:07the parents had informed them that David
  265. 13:10that Brenda was not a girl that Brenda
  266. 13:13had been born a boy which John money had
  267. 13:16told them never to do but because Brenda
  268. 13:20David had become suicidal when he
  269. 13:24entered puberty and he realized that he
  270. 13:27was attracted to girls
  271. 13:29he was growing breasts because John
  272. 13:31money had arranged for him to be given
  273. 13:34estrogen and John money was trying to
  274. 13:36convince him to have a vaginoplasty the
  275. 13:40construction of a vagina and so this
  276. 13:43poor Brenda David was
  277. 13:46suicidal and his psychiatrist in uh in
  278. 13:50Winnipeg told his parents you must tell
  279. 13:53him the truth now when he was told the
  280. 13:55truth and this is an amazing story it's
  281. 13:58told in the book by John kapino called
  282. 14:01as nature made him the boy who was
  283. 14:03raised as a girl but the moment that he
  284. 14:06was told his true identity that he is a
  285. 14:10boy he felt tremendous
  286. 14:14relief he felt that he knew all along
  287. 14:17that something was terribly wrong he was
  288. 14:21never comfortable as a girl and yet and
  289. 14:24he had been abused by the way every time
  290. 14:27every year that they took the twins down
  291. 14:29to see John money John money was
  292. 14:31sexually abusing those boys of course of
  293. 14:34course
  294. 14:35yeah all right my boys gather around
  295. 14:38because I've got a holiday gift idea
  296. 14:40that's sure to make you the hero of the
  297. 14:41Season we all know the holidays can be a
  298. 14:44bit hectic the shopping the cooking the
  299. 14:46never-ending list of things to do but
  300. 14:48fear not because I've discovered a gift
  301. 14:50that's not just thoughtful it's
  302. 14:51downright transformative the gift of
  303. 14:53genus cell skincare from now until
  304. 14:55Christmas genus cell's most popular
  305. 14:57package has a special special discount
  306. 14:59just for my listeners at genucell.com
  307. 15:01claven treat yourself and your loved
  308. 15:03ones to the absolute best skincare in
  309. 15:06the world those troubling farhead
  310. 15:07wrinkles Fine Lines skin redness and yes
  311. 15:10even a sagging jawline will disappear
  312. 15:12right before your eyes with jys cell's
  313. 15:14most popular collection you will see
  314. 15:16results in less than 12 hours guaranteed
  315. 15:19or your money back I myself Met George
  316. 15:21the CEO of Jus Cell last week great guy
  317. 15:24our favorite thing about gen cell is how
  318. 15:26clean their products are they're Simply
  319. 15:27the Best you deserve to look and feel
  320. 15:29your best this holiday season go to Jus
  321. 15:31cell.com claven to get this incredible
  322. 15:34holiday discount every order today is
  323. 15:36instantly upgraded to free express
  324. 15:38shipping that's genus cell.com claven
  325. 15:40today I know what you're thinking you're
  326. 15:42thinking please oh please please please
  327. 15:44please tell me how to spell claven it's
  328. 15:47k v
  329. 15:52an all right so now do you are are are
  330. 15:56you still in practice do you see
  331. 15:58children yourself and you must be seeing
  332. 16:01some of this as you said it's kind of a
  333. 16:03mass psychosis it's an induced psychosis
  334. 16:05but it's still a mass psychosis every
  335. 16:08day you've seen it every day now
  336. 16:11what is this something that just appeals
  337. 16:15to kids who are already troubled or is
  338. 16:17it something that speaks to Something in
  339. 16:20them that you know that you recognize
  340. 16:22why why does this catch on I'm gonna say
  341. 16:25one more thing about David and then I'll
  342. 16:26answer your question I just want want to
  343. 16:28add I want your audience to know that
  344. 16:32David and his
  345. 16:34brother uh his brother died of an
  346. 16:37overdose uh at the age of
  347. 16:4036 and David uh killed himself with a
  348. 16:44shotgun at the age of 38 okay and their
  349. 16:47parents blamed John money for their
  350. 16:51deaths yeah overall it is kids who are
  351. 16:56vulnerable I would I would say
  352. 16:57vulnerable
  353. 16:59who are attracted to this ideology and
  354. 17:05this delusion of being born in the wrong
  355. 17:08body but that is not to say that it
  356. 17:10doesn't affect
  357. 17:12everybody but
  358. 17:14yes you know you are correct for example
  359. 17:17kids who are on the autism spectrum and
  360. 17:21these are kids
  361. 17:22who you know have social issues they
  362. 17:25don't fit in anywhere they have
  363. 17:28difficult because of their autism with
  364. 17:31um you know with socializing with
  365. 17:33picking up on cues understanding um you
  366. 17:37know facial expressions understanding
  367. 17:39jokes understanding
  368. 17:41sarcasm and they they have a hard time
  369. 17:46understandably especially when Middle
  370. 17:48School comes finding their peer group
  371. 17:52where they feel accepted and they feel
  372. 17:55good about themselves and they all also
  373. 17:59kids who are on the autism spectrum have
  374. 18:01something called black and white
  375. 18:03thinking what that means is that they
  376. 18:06see the world in terms of either or they
  377. 18:09don't see the gray so if you have a girl
  378. 18:12for example who is uncomfortable with
  379. 18:16her developing body and she hates
  380. 18:19getting her
  381. 18:20period and she hates the attention that
  382. 18:24she's getting from men because of her
  383. 18:26changing body she might say to herself
  384. 18:29you know I don't like being a girl I
  385. 18:32must be a boy so is is there a treatment
  386. 18:36for that condition that actually works
  387. 18:40that you know that keeps them from
  388. 18:41butchering themselves and oh of course
  389. 18:44there is of course these kids can be can
  390. 18:47be helped the thing is that they're
  391. 18:50being indoctrinated at an early age you
  392. 18:53know I speak in my book about these
  393. 18:56books that are being written for
  394. 19:00toddlers for toddlers And preschoolers
  395. 19:04that say things like um adults make
  396. 19:08mistakes when you were born they may
  397. 19:11have taken a look at your body and said
  398. 19:13oh you're a boy oh you're a girl they
  399. 19:17you couldn't speak up when you were born
  400. 19:19and tell them no I'm not a boy but now
  401. 19:22you can speak up and you need to tell
  402. 19:24the world who you really are cuz adults
  403. 19:27make mistakes so what I'm saying is that
  404. 19:30Andrew yes I mean there is help of
  405. 19:33course there's help for these kids but
  406. 19:35the problem is they become indoctrinated
  407. 19:38they start hearing about this you know
  408. 19:41this these falsehoods um they and they
  409. 19:45they take it in you know left and right
  410. 19:48not only from our media our
  411. 19:50entertainment but at school from their
  412. 19:53teachers from their guidance counselors
  413. 19:55from their peers online YouTube tube
  414. 19:59everywhere and one of the things that I
  415. 20:01warn parents about is they have to get
  416. 20:04control of their child's uh internet use
  417. 20:07and I have instructions in my book I
  418. 20:09have an appendix written by an IT expert
  419. 20:12on how to get control of your child's
  420. 20:15internet use not you don't please don't
  421. 20:19wait until your kid comes home and at
  422. 20:21dinner one day says Mom Dad I'm not your
  423. 20:24daughter I'm your
  424. 20:26son if you wait until that point you you
  425. 20:29have a you have a very Steep Hill to
  426. 20:32climb you want years years before that
  427. 20:35happens you want to present the proper
  428. 20:40information the biological truths to
  429. 20:42your children you want to tell your
  430. 20:44child when they're still
  431. 20:46young you want to say you know from the
  432. 20:49moment that you first existed when you
  433. 20:52were
  434. 20:53inside your mother's womb or inside your
  435. 20:57mother's womb
  436. 20:59um you were either a boy or a girl from
  437. 21:02the very f it has nothing to do with
  438. 21:04being assigned there's no assigned at
  439. 21:08Birth and they're gonna you know we hear
  440. 21:10this I read this all over the medical
  441. 21:13literature and it drives me crazy I read
  442. 21:17in the you know journals of Pediatrics
  443. 21:19Endocrinology child psychiatry sex
  444. 21:23assigned at
  445. 21:25Birth this is wrong sex is established
  446. 21:30at conception and I recently testified
  447. 21:33to that effect in our Congress and the
  448. 21:36fact that I had to be asked a medical
  449. 21:39doctor has to go to the House of
  450. 21:41Representatives in Washington DC and
  451. 21:44testify that sex is established at Birth
  452. 21:47and it cannot be changed gives you an
  453. 21:50idea of the appalling situation that
  454. 21:52we're in well this is something I want
  455. 21:54to ask you we're talking to Dr Miriam
  456. 21:56Gman author of Lost in trans Nation uh
  457. 21:59she is a psychiatrist and a medical
  458. 22:01doctor in in fact I wouldn't ask you
  459. 22:03this question I'm going to ask you to
  460. 22:05speculate a little bit I wouldn't ask
  461. 22:06you to do this if you weren't a a doctor
  462. 22:08and a psychiatrist
  463. 22:10but it you know when we put this up on
  464. 22:13on YouTube they may censor parts of it
  465. 22:15because they don't want this obvious
  466. 22:17scientific truth against which there's
  467. 22:20no 0% evidence they don't want it spoken
  468. 22:23they think that it is wrong to speak it
  469. 22:25for a long time you get thrown off uh
  470. 22:28social media you could get condemned
  471. 22:30people would curse you for saying what
  472. 22:33is the obvious truth there is a this guy
  473. 22:36Richard LaVine who calls himself Rachel
  474. 22:38LaVine who is in our uh government who
  475. 22:40is telling people that children should
  476. 22:42trans transition and and nobody's doing
  477. 22:45what I think should be done which is
  478. 22:46arrest him but but I I would like you to
  479. 22:49speculate why is this taking off like
  480. 22:52that I mean if this had been told to
  481. 22:54people in in my day and you know in the
  482. 22:5660s and I don't think anybody would have
  483. 22:58bought into it except maybe maybe I'm
  484. 23:00wrong because of the story you tell
  485. 23:01about money but still you know I don't
  486. 23:03think it would have spread this way why
  487. 23:05do you think that this the um the
  488. 23:08society was ready for this particular
  489. 23:10poison plant to bloom okay so there I
  490. 23:13think there's a Confluence of different
  491. 23:16factors one is that uh the American
  492. 23:20Psychiatric association in
  493. 23:232013 changed the status of their
  494. 23:27diagnosis of gender identity
  495. 23:29disorder to call it gender dysphoria now
  496. 23:33that may sound like just a technical
  497. 23:35nomenclature change but it was much more
  498. 23:38than that because in doing that the
  499. 23:41American Psychiatric association was
  500. 23:44saying it's not a
  501. 23:46disorder to
  502. 23:48feel uh in conflict with your body it's
  503. 23:53not a disorder to feel basically
  504. 23:55disembodied like you're like your
  505. 23:58identity as a male or female is separate
  506. 24:01from your body that that's not a
  507. 24:03disorder we had already we had all
  508. 24:06always for decades considered it a
  509. 24:09disorder they changed that so that was
  510. 24:13one thing another thing that happened in
  511. 24:182015 as you know the definition of
  512. 24:21marriage was
  513. 24:23changed and marriage now that word now
  514. 24:29includes the union of Two Men and two
  515. 24:32women and before
  516. 24:352015 uh that uh that issue was really at
  517. 24:41the heart of of the entire
  518. 24:44LGBT um you know machine you know the uh
  519. 24:51yeah I'll call it a industry machine
  520. 24:52whatever you want to call it
  521. 24:55um and so so so a lot of money and
  522. 24:59energy went into that once that passed
  523. 25:03the Supreme Court passed that um there
  524. 25:08had to be a next thing I mean as you
  525. 25:10know Andrew with the left there's always
  526. 25:13going to be something else yeah and so
  527. 25:16that so this is another thing so for
  528. 25:18example the Human Rights Campaign um if
  529. 25:21you look at their policy statements
  530. 25:25before 2015 it was most there was very
  531. 25:28very little about
  532. 25:30transgenderism but then with 2015 it
  533. 25:33became focused on trans the transgender
  534. 25:36issue and the Human Rights Campaign is
  535. 25:39nothing to sneeze at they're a very very
  536. 25:42powerful Lobby group now the other thing
  537. 25:45that happened is social
  538. 25:47media okay an
  539. 25:50explosion of social media kids being
  540. 25:53given young kids being given
  541. 25:56smartphones intern internet access and
  542. 25:59so all this stuff is just they carry it
  543. 26:03around in their
  544. 26:05pockets and the internet is filled with
  545. 26:08groomers yeah people that want to reach
  546. 26:11children and influence them you know
  547. 26:14there there there's other things as well
  548. 26:16there's you know the rise of the
  549. 26:18transhumanism movement and all the money
  550. 26:20that's from that movement that's also
  551. 26:23put into
  552. 26:25transgenderism so I think it's a variety
  553. 26:28of issues you know there there do seem
  554. 26:30to be the occasional rare there does
  555. 26:33seem to be the occasional rare person I
  556. 26:35remember uh James Morris who was a
  557. 26:38writer and kind of a masculine adventure
  558. 26:40writer who became this kind of uh Mrs
  559. 26:43Tiggy Winkle sort of uh woman writer in
  560. 26:46his later years but who seemed actually
  561. 26:49to have found some kind of peace with
  562. 26:51himself so so this does see you agree
  563. 26:55that this does exist this condition does
  564. 26:57exist abs absolutely and I'm glad you
  565. 26:58brought that up okay Jan Morris very
  566. 27:02interesting person wrote a fascinating
  567. 27:04book called canundrum
  568. 27:06so he or she because in this instance I
  569. 27:10would say she actually very very rare
  570. 27:14instance we've always known in
  571. 27:17Psychiatry that there are extremely rare
  572. 27:20instances one in many tens of thousands
  573. 27:24of people in which from an early ear age
  574. 27:28age three four the person not from being
  575. 27:33on the internet not from hearing about
  576. 27:35it at
  577. 27:36school okay not from seeing it at Target
  578. 27:41but from some inner process something
  579. 27:44emotional is going on with them we don't
  580. 27:47understand it um they have a persistent
  581. 27:52inner sense of of not belonging in their
  582. 27:57sex
  583. 27:59bodies and it is a serious
  584. 28:03condition um again extremely rare the
  585. 28:09problem is that this you see this is a
  586. 28:12completely different population than our
  587. 28:15current um epidemic of kids okay and I
  588. 28:20explain this in the book very very
  589. 28:22important our current epidemic of kids
  590. 28:25we have a 5,000% increase in kids who
  591. 28:29are identifying as the opposite sex just
  592. 28:31in the past 10 years or so 5,000%
  593. 28:35increase so it's a new population it's a
  594. 28:38population that's mostly
  595. 28:42girls um
  596. 28:44teenagers and uh kids who never before
  597. 28:48had discomfort with being boys or girls
  598. 28:51so it's a totally different population
  599. 28:55than the Jan morrises of the world
  600. 28:58and I will add the also the um the Jazz
  601. 29:01Jennings of the world because Jazz
  602. 29:04Jennings is another example of a child
  603. 29:07from a very young age who had a sense of
  604. 29:11of being a girl or or wanting very much
  605. 29:14to be a girl the thing is with jazz jazz
  606. 29:16was not given the opportunity of going
  607. 29:19through normal male puberty which may
  608. 29:22have uh gotten him to a place of comfort
  609. 29:27with his body going through natural
  610. 29:29puberty he went on puberty blockers at
  611. 29:32age 11
  612. 29:33so he was never able to do that but you
  613. 29:37bring up a very very important point and
  614. 29:39I want people to understand that I'm not
  615. 29:42saying that there not that that this
  616. 29:45doesn't exist it does exist extremely
  617. 29:49rare cases and there are people that
  618. 29:53have been helped their mental status
  619. 29:58their me their emotional state has
  620. 30:01improved
  621. 30:03significantly with the medical
  622. 30:05interventions however we have no way of
  623. 30:08knowing
  624. 30:09beforehand who that's going to be who's
  625. 30:12going to feel better and who's not going
  626. 30:15to feel better so this is a it's a very
  627. 30:18complex subject um but my position is
  628. 30:23that no minor no minor at all should be
  629. 30:28given these uh experimental
  630. 30:31interventions yeah no that seems that
  631. 30:33seems clear uh you know I'm out of time
  632. 30:35I the only thing I'd like to ask if you
  633. 30:37can give me a short answer um is this do
  634. 30:41you think this is the sort of Madness of
  635. 30:43crowds thing that will pass or do you
  636. 30:45think this is a genuine disturbance in
  637. 30:48the society that we're not going to get
  638. 30:51over oh it's going to pass yeah because
  639. 30:54it doesn't you can't stand pass because
  640. 30:56it's not true true it doesn't it doesn't
  641. 30:59have a foundation of truth right so we
  642. 31:02know that it can't it can't last yeah
  643. 31:04okay because of the foundation but I do
  644. 31:06want to say Andrew that I want to I want
  645. 31:09to tell your listeners um your viewers I
  646. 31:13really I put my heart and soul I put my
  647. 31:16heart and soul into this book because I
  648. 31:19don't want to see more families in my
  649. 31:22practice who say to me they were
  650. 31:24blindsided I want parents to to
  651. 31:27inoculate their families and be educated
  652. 31:30and have the skills to fight this
  653. 31:33madness um and I'll also mention that
  654. 31:36many people I I know that many people
  655. 31:38can't sit down and and read a book
  656. 31:40either because they don't have the time
  657. 31:42or they have ad or whatever it is um and
  658. 31:45so they prefer audio and I did the
  659. 31:48narration for the audio book and people
  660. 31:51are loving it and I actually love doing
  661. 31:54the narration I was nervous about it but
  662. 31:56once I started it was great fun to read
  663. 32:00my book um and and and I imagined while
  664. 32:04I was narrating it people in their cars
  665. 32:07listening and people listening while
  666. 32:08they were doing the dishes and please
  667. 32:12please I'm urging parents to not be
  668. 32:16blindsided I don't want your family to
  669. 32:19be destroyed by this issue there are
  670. 32:22families that are torn apart I don't
  671. 32:24want to see your kid and your entire
  672. 32:27family suffer terribly from this I want
  673. 32:31your child to grow up healthy and uh and
  674. 32:35able to thrive and have biological
  675. 32:39children and have a normal sexual
  676. 32:41response and all that stuff yeah well
  677. 32:44the book again the author is Dr Miriam
  678. 32:47grman the book Is Lost in Translation
  679. 32:49it's very engagingly written it's not a
  680. 32:51scientific difficult to get through
  681. 32:53toome and I'm I'm really enjoying it too
  682. 32:56thank you so much for coming on uh was
  683. 32:58really interesting talking to you I hope
  684. 32:59we'll talk again I do too thanks andrewy
  685. 33:03if you want more information uh about
  686. 33:05what Dr Gman was talking about she has a
  687. 33:08website it's Miriam m i r i a m Miriam
  688. 33:13Grossman
  689. 33:14md.com Miriam Grossman md.com her book
  690. 33:19as I say is engagingly written I know a
  691. 33:21lot of people uh parents are dealing
  692. 33:23with problems like this and uh she will
  693. 33:25uh she has more information on her
  694. 33:27website uh meanwhile I hope you have a
  695. 33:29great Thanksgiving we will have a show
  696. 33:31after the holiday and an interview in
  697. 33:34the week after that so have a wonderful
  698. 33:36[Music]
  699. 33:49holiday

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Child Psychiatrist Dr. Miriam Grossman's Guide Out of Trans Madness by Andrew Klavan, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,789 words across 699 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.