ChatGPT vs Claude Make FIFA 27 From Scratch — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:00Today we're going to see who's better,
2. 0:01Chat GPT 5.6 Soul or Claude Opus 5, by
3. 0:04having both of them recreate FIFA 27
4. 0:06from scratch in just 1 hour. And to keep
5. 0:08things fair, they're both going to get
6. 0:09the exact same prompt. So, let's have
7. 0:11Chat GPT write the prompt that we're
8. 0:12going to use for both of them. Okay, so
9. 0:14I'm telling Chat GPT to make a
10. 0:15FIFA-style football game from scratch.
11. 0:17Make sure it looks and feels like FIFA,
12. 0:19has the main features you'd expect from
13. 0:21a proper football game, and is actually
14. 0:23fun and playable with no major errors.
15. 0:25And to make this prompt better and much
16. 0:26more detailed. Okay, so this is the
17. 0:28prompt that Chat GPT wrote for us and it
18. 0:30seems really, really detailed.
19. 0:31Hopefully, this can help it make us a
20. 0:33good base game. So, let's go ahead and
21. 0:35copy the prompt. Let's create a new
22. 0:37chat, switch it to 5.6 Soul, and we'll
23. 0:40put the effort to ultra. Let's go ahead
24. 0:42and paste it in, as well as the three
25. 0:43reference images that I found online.
26. 0:45Start the 1-hour [music] timer. Let's go
27. 0:46ahead and click send and see what Chat
28. 0:48GPT can cook up for us. FIFA is one of
29. 0:50my favorite games, so I'm genuinely
30. 0:52excited to see what Chat GPT is able to
31. 0:54make. Yeah, let's just let Chat GPT go
32. 0:56to work and we'll come back whenever the
33. 0:57game is ready to play.
34. 1:01Okay, so Chat GPT worked for a total of
35. 1:0340 minutes. It just finished making the
36. 1:05game. Let's see what the base game looks
37. 1:07like. It seems like we're only going to
38. 1:08have time for one revision as well. So,
39. 1:10Chat GPT's game is called Nova Football.
40. 1:12Let's see the controls. Okay, let's go
41. 1:14ahead and start the match and see how we
42. 1:15can play this. And what in the hell am I
43. 1:18even looking at? What? I'm so confused.
44. 1:21I'm so Okay, I'm losing 2-0 30 seconds
45. 1:25in. Okay, so technically, this works. We
46. 1:27can move, we can pass, we can shoot, but
47. 1:29this looks absolutely nothing like FIFA.
48. 1:31It's basically just 2D circles on a
49. 1:33pitch. So, before we judge it properly,
50. 1:35I want to give Chat GPT one last chance
51. 1:37to turn this into an actual 3D game.
52. 1:40Okay, yeah, let's not let's not waste
53. 1:42time playing this game because this is
54. 1:44not playable, or maybe I'm just not good
55. 1:45enough. But, let's go back to Chat GPT.
56. 1:47We're going to use the last 20 minutes
57. 1:49and we're going to give it this prompt,
58. 1:50basically telling it to turn the game
59. 1:51into 3D and make it look and feel a lot
60. 1:54more like FIFA. Let's send it and see
61. 1:56what it comes back with.
62. 2:00All right, so ChatGPT just finished
63. 2:01making the game 3D and it honestly looks
64. 2:04so much better already and it does it
65. 2:06does seem like it was able to make it
66. 2:073D. So, let's just go ahead and start a
67. 2:08match. Okay. Okay, this actually looks
68. 2:11pretty good. I'm not going to lie. But
69. 2:13what I forgot to mention is that to
70. 2:14properly test what these games can do, I
71. 2:16came up with a few challenges for them
72. 2:17to complete and they're only going to
73. 2:19get harder and harder as we go. So,
74. 2:20first I just want to see if I can play
75. 2:22football. Can we make passes? Can I
76. 2:24shoot? Can I dribble? So, let's let's
77. 2:25test that out real quick. Okay, so the
78. 2:27movement is actually it's not that bad.
79. 2:29All right, so let's try to move the ball
80. 2:30around. That's one pass, two passes.
81. 2:33Okay, some tiki-taka. All right, so
82. 2:35we're moving the ball around. Nice. I
83. 2:37like that the camera kind of moves with
84. 2:39the ball as the ball moves up and down
85. 2:41the field. Oh my god. Okay. Yeah, it
86. 2:43doesn't look too much like FIFA, but
87. 2:45it's honestly not that bad. Why did my
88. 2:47goalkeeper kick it into the net? Okay,
89. 2:49so it looks like we can actually play
90. 2:51football, but now it's time for the
91. 2:52second challenge. Can we score a goal?
92. 2:54And honestly don't think this is going
93. 2:56to be easy at all. All right, let's try
94. 2:57to score a goal. Let's see what we could
95. 2:58do. How am I supposed to score a goal if
96. 2:59I can't even get to the other side?
97. 3:01Okay, oh. All right, so we need a lock
98. 3:03in. We need a lock in. Get a game plan
99. 3:04going. Come on. Come on. Come on. Just
100. 3:06run. Oh, right there. Shoot. What a
101. 3:08save. All right, we need a lock in. We
102. 3:10need a lock in. We just need to score a
103. 3:12goal. That's it. From anywhere. Oh,
104. 3:14shoot it. Oh my god. Another save. Pass
105. 3:17it back. Pass it back. Bro, get the
106. 3:18ball. Why are you so slow? Oh, I think
107. 3:21this is the one. I think this is the one
108. 3:22right here. Oh, no. We lost 3-0. So,
109. 3:26we'll put play again. I think this game
110. 3:28will be able to get it. I'm not going to
111. 3:29lie.
112. 3:31Oh, no. No. No. We got so close.
113. 3:35No, I was about to shoot. I think I need
114. 3:37to shoot from outside the box. That
115. 3:39might just be the only way. How can it
116. 3:41be so difficult to score a goal? I'm not
117. 3:43that bad, yo. Like I promise y'all I'm
118. 3:45not that bad. Okay, we just need to keep
119. 3:47taking shots. We need to keep taking
120. 3:48shots. Eventually the keeper he's going
121. 3:49to mess up. Okay, the keeper's out. The
122. 3:51keeper's out. Oh my god. How did we not
123. 3:53score that? Bro, how did we not score
124. 3:55that? Is it me? Am I the problem?
125. 3:59All right, y'all. I'm I'm actually
126. 4:00getting absolutely cooked. Yeah, I don't
127. 4:02want to blame it on the AI cuz I feel
128. 4:04like it's more my fault than anything,
129. 4:05but All right, I think we had enough of
130. 4:06this game. Let's move on to Claude now,
131. 4:08yo. But all right, we're in Claude now.
132. 4:10So, let's go ahead and switch it to Opus
133. 4:125. Put the effort to ultra code. Paste
134. 4:14the prompt that Chat GPT gave us. And
135. 4:16let's drag in the three reference images
136. 4:18as well. Let's start the 1-hour timer
137. 4:20and send it off to Claude. But yeah,
138. 4:22hopefully Claude gives me the chance to
139. 4:23redeem myself. And hopefully we're able
140. 4:25to complete the final challenge. I can't
141. 4:27wait. I can't wait to see what Claude is
142. 4:29able to make.
143. 4:32All right, so Claude just finished
144. 4:34making the game. It took like an hour
145. 4:35and 40 minutes. So, let's just open it
146. 4:37up and see what it was able to make. So,
147. 4:38here we are in Claude's game and it's
148. 4:40called Peach Legends. So, we can choose
149. 4:43our club and it looks like they have
150. 4:44different overalls as well. I think I'm
151. 4:46going to go with Ravenport United. And
152. 4:50we're going to go against the Aurora
153. 4:51Blancos. And yeah, we'll leave it at pro
154. 4:53difficulty just for now. We can see the
155. 4:55controls. All right, let's just go into
156. 4:57a game and try to complete the first
157. 4:58challenge. Let's just see if we can play
158. 5:00football.
159. 5:02Oh, okay.
160. 5:04So, how was it to make a pass? Okay,
161. 5:05that's the shoot. That's the shooting
162. 5:07button. All right, but this does not
163. 5:08seem bad, y'all. Let's do a sliding
164. 5:10tackle. Let's Let's try to tackle. We
165. 5:12can play some defense. All right, so it
166. 5:13seems like you pass the ball and the
167. 5:14ball does not stop. Oh, it added lofted
168. 5:17passes as well. We can make lofted
169. 5:19passes.
170. 5:21Oh my goodness. Look at the way that
171. 5:23they run. Look at the way that they run
172. 5:25to the corner with the replay. All
173. 5:26right, let's try Let's try to do the
174. 5:27skill move. It said you could do a skill
175. 5:29move. Oh, so look at how we're able to
176. 5:31change directions. Oh, wow. Oh, off the
177. 5:34woodwork.
178. 5:36Double off the woodwork. All right, so
179. 5:38it just gave him a free kick. What?
180. 5:40Number 9 just scored a free kick on us.
181. 5:42All right, so I think that we are able
182. 5:44to play football, y'all. Let's try to
183. 5:45complete the next challenge then. Let's
184. 5:47try to score a goal. All right, let's
185. 5:48lock in.
186. 5:49Okay. Yo, I'm actually getting mad now.
187. 5:52You're telling me that this AI can score
188. 5:54four goals on us and we can't even score
189. 5:55one. All right, that's it. I'm going to
190. 5:57start playing more aggressive.
191. 6:01Nah, okay. Now, we just need to shoot
192. 6:03from anywhere then. We could just shoot
193. 6:04from anywhere then.
194. 6:07Own goal. Please don't tell me that the
195. 6:10only goal we're going to be able to
196. 6:11score in this video is an own goal. Bro,
197. 6:13why is it so difficult to score a goal?
198. 6:17Oh my god, I scored. 2 hours later, we
199. 6:20finally scored. All right, so Aurora
200. 6:22wins 6-1. But, that doesn't really
201. 6:24matter because we finally got our goal.
202. 6:26Now, it's time for the final challenge,
203. 6:29the solo run. So, what do we need to do?
204. 6:31We need to get the ball at the halfway
205. 6:33line with a player. We need to dribble
206. 6:35all the way to the other side and score
207. 6:36the goal without passing. And I'm not
208. 6:38even 100% sure that it's possible, but
209. 6:40we're going to try. But, how does he do
210. 6:41that? Why How are they able to connect
211. 6:43every pass perfectly, but I can't even
212. 6:45connect one pass? Bro, really? I feel
213. 6:48like I'm playing against prime
214. 6:49Barcelona. Oh wait, they low-key can't
215. 6:52steal the ball from me when I'm doing
216. 6:53the skill moves.
217. 6:55Oh my god, wait. Are we going to do it?
218. 6:57Oh my god, we got so close. Wait, this
219. 6:59actually might be possible. Okay, lock
220. 7:00in. Lock in. All right, we need to get
221. 7:02the ball at the halfway line. I think
222. 7:03this is our guy right here.
223. 7:05Why is he so slow? Okay, never mind.
224. 7:07That's not our guy. Okay, let's go.
225. 7:09Let's go. Okay, so it's like it gives
226. 7:10him a little speed boost. Cut inside.
227. 7:12Cut inside. Cut inside. Cut inside. Oh,
228. 7:15wait. Oh my god. Oh my god. Shoot.
229. 7:18Off the woodwork. Oh my god, what do you
230. 7:20mean off the woodwork? I thought that
231. 7:21was in. Okay, we need to try to score
232. 7:23this Messi goal. All right, let's go.
233. 7:24Let's go. This is our guy right here.
234. 7:25Cut inside. Cut inside. Oh, that's like
235. 7:27the glitch. Why is he slowing down so
236. 7:28much? Cut inside. Cut inside. Oh, fake
237. 7:30shot. Fake shot. Oh, shoot it.
238. 7:33Oh no, I pressed the wrong button. Okay,
239. 7:35so whenever we get the ball, if you guys
240. 7:37see those little particles that appear
241. 7:38by the player's feet, that's the
242. 7:40animation whenever I do a skill move.
243. 7:41And I noticed that every time I do a
244. 7:43skill move, they can't steal the ball
245. 7:45from me. So, I think that if we just
246. 7:46spam skill moves, we might be able to go
247. 7:48all the way. All right, so we need to
248. 7:50get the ball. Let's pass it to our
249. 7:51teammate.
250. 7:53Okay. Can we do it off a kick-off? All
251. 7:55right, let's go Let's get the ball here.
252. 7:57Let's spam the skill moves.
253. 8:00>> [music]
254. 8:00>> Oh, wait.
255. 8:01Okay. Oh, wait. Fake shot. Fake shot.
256. 8:04Shoot it.
257. 8:05Oh my god. Oh my god, we did it. Y'all,
258. 8:08I actually can't believe that we did
259. 8:09that. We actually did it, y'all. We
260. 8:11actually scored the solo goal. So, yeah,
261. 8:14before before I say which game I thought
262. 8:15was better, let me know which one y'all
263. 8:17think is better. Let me know which one
264. 8:19y'all prefer. Yeah, ChatGPT wasn't bad,
265. 8:21but I think Claude definitely takes this
266. 8:22one. Thank you guys for watching. If any
267. 8:24of you guys have any suggestions for any
268. 8:25other AI models that we can use or any
269. 8:27other video games that you guys would
270. 8:28[music] like me to recreate, let me know
271. 8:30down in the comments. I appreciate all
272. 8:31of y'all. Subscribe if y'all are new.
273. 8:33This is so cool, bro. As of right now,
274. 8:35Claude Opus 5 is undefeated.
275. 8:46>> [music]
276. 8:53[music]