YouTube2Text

Changing Name of Minor Child in a Divorce Case- Best Interest of Child — Transcript

by Florida Trust, Real Estate, Probate, & Foreclosure · 4,431 words · 646 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00thank you we're ready to proceed morning
  2. 0:04your honors miss Conklin Cynthia Hall is
  3. 0:07severe in Hall PA representing the
  4. 0:09father who's the appellant in this
  5. 0:10action I'm confident that the courts
  6. 0:13familiar with the factual background of
  7. 0:15the case but I just want to mention a
  8. 0:17couple of facts
  9. 0:19yes your honor thank you five minutes I
  10. 0:24even wrote it down but I thank you the
  11. 0:28parties were divorced in 2012 and the
  12. 0:31final judgment of dissolution marriage
  13. 0:33actually incorporated a marital
  14. 0:34settlement agreement which provided for
  15. 0:36the parenting rights and obligations of
  16. 0:39the parties I think that's important for
  17. 0:41the court to know this was a marriage
  18. 0:44that was dissolved it's not a paternity
  19. 0:47case and Ms Conklin decided at that time
  20. 0:50not to have her maiden name restored as
  21. 0:53we're all familiar with the rules that's
  22. 0:55an opportunity at the time of the final
  23. 0:56judgment it's one of the factors in the
  24. 0:58special interrogatories where a wife is
  25. 1:02asked whether or not she wants to
  26. 1:03restore her name two years later when
  27. 1:06the minor child is now four and a half
  28. 1:08years of age the mother filed a petition
  29. 1:10to change her own name and the minor
  30. 1:13child's name after being served with the
  31. 1:16petition the father objected to the name
  32. 1:18change for the minor child unless the
  33. 1:21court has any questions I'll skip over
  34. 1:22the hearing that occurred before Judge
  35. 1:24career as it was there was a rehearing
  36. 1:28on and we went to trial in September and
  37. 1:30that particular hearing the mother went
  38. 1:33forward and presented her case our brief
  39. 1:36outlines why we don't believe that the
  40. 1:38wife established the former wife that it
  41. 1:40was in the best interest of the minor
  42. 1:42child to have her name changed and we
  43. 1:45have relied on our brief heavily on the
  44. 1:47Wilson versus Smith case out of this
  45. 1:49Court judge Wallace was on that panel in
  46. 1:52the concurring opinion and it's
  47. 1:55important to if you read the chronology
  48. 1:56of these cases on name changes that one
  49. 1:59of the first factors is that there must
  50. 2:01be finding that it's in the best
  51. 2:03interest of the child or that it's
  52. 2:06necessary for the welfare of the child
  53. 2:08but when you read the Wilson Smith case
  54. 2:10they go on to say that
  55. 2:12the court should order the change of a
  56. 2:14miners surname over the objection of one
  57. 2:17parent only where the evidence of permit
  58. 2:20of Lee shows that such a change is
  59. 2:23necessitated by the welfare of the child
  60. 2:25and if you read all of the various cases
  61. 2:27there are a lot of them here on name
  62. 2:29changes of minor child that becomes a
  63. 2:32second step basically in cases where
  64. 2:34it's a parent who has objected to the
  65. 2:37name change that you must find that it's
  66. 2:40necessary for them what kind of things
  67. 2:42would you have to prove to show that the
  68. 2:45Dames is in the best interest of or is
  69. 2:49necessitated by the welfare of the child
  70. 2:52and what kind of things would prove that
  71. 2:54there are cases of long-term
  72. 2:56incarceration for crimes of notary that
  73. 3:01are public where the minor child's name
  74. 3:04associated with the parent who's
  75. 3:06committed the crime is well publicized
  76. 3:08it could reflect the enjoyment of life
  77. 3:11of that child or where there's a huge
  78. 3:13security risk for a particular child
  79. 3:15there are cases where there is a
  80. 3:17complete abandonment of the child
  81. 3:20meaning that there is not only no
  82. 3:21contact but no financial support I
  83. 3:24didn't see a case I stand to be
  84. 3:26corrected but I didn't see one where
  85. 3:28they didn't have both those components
  86. 3:30even when they did factor it in that it
  87. 3:32was an abandonment of time and money
  88. 3:34which was not this case the parents that
  89. 3:42seeking the name change is interested in
  90. 3:45having the last name of the child
  91. 3:48conformed to the parents name there are
  92. 3:53outside the state of Florida there are
  93. 3:55some cases but in the state of Florida
  94. 3:56in a divorced case with a minor child of
  95. 3:59two parents I have not seen that case
  96. 4:02where that name change on the standard
  97. 4:05that you've just raised in fact in the
  98. 4:07Wilson versus Smith case the the mother
  99. 4:09argued that she wanted to change the
  100. 4:11name so the mother and child would have
  101. 4:13the same name what's interesting about
  102. 4:15this case and different than the other
  103. 4:17cases is that miss Kahn Flynn caused
  104. 4:21this problem she and her daughter did
  105. 4:24have the same
  106. 4:24for the her daughter's entire life they
  107. 4:27both shared the name ayersman so she has
  108. 4:30created this issue that she would like
  109. 4:33her daughter's name to be the same as
  110. 4:34hers if she hadn't changed her own name
  111. 4:37which she was using for over two years
  112. 4:39after the date of divorce she used it
  113. 4:42during the marriage she used it not only
  114. 4:45personally but professionally as we put
  115. 4:47in our brief and we established in the
  116. 4:49record she decided to create that
  117. 4:51difference between herself and her child
  118. 4:52and as a result now she wants to change
  119. 4:55the child's name why was it necessary
  120. 4:58for her to change her name it creates
  121. 5:01that difference between mother and
  122. 5:03daughter we believe that it's pretty
  123. 5:06clear that the child didn't know her
  124. 5:10name the child had used that name the
  125. 5:13child did have a relationship with the
  126. 5:16paternal side of the family that the
  127. 5:17father had not abandoned the child there
  128. 5:20were several hoops that he had to jump
  129. 5:22through in order to have his share
  130. 5:24parental responsibilities rights
  131. 5:25reestablished but he was on his way the
  132. 5:28grandparents were involved the paternal
  133. 5:31aunt was involved I think that it showed
  134. 5:33the quite the desperation had changed
  135. 5:35the child's name in the transcript where
  136. 5:39the mother made absolute statements that
  137. 5:42the only family name that the child is
  138. 5:44associated with his conflict that was
  139. 5:46not truthful when you go through the
  140. 5:49record and you see the different
  141. 5:50circumstance the child knew her
  142. 5:52grandparents knew her father she had
  143. 5:55contact with the paternal aunt the the
  144. 5:58mother obviously would like her name
  145. 6:01changed but didn't establish why it's
  146. 6:04helpful for this child there was no
  147. 6:07evidence demonstrated that the child was
  148. 6:10at risk there was no evidence that the
  149. 6:13child had suffered some kind of upset or
  150. 6:18questioning of why her names different
  151. 6:20than her mother's because it hadn't been
  152. 6:22different there could be no evidence or
  153. 6:24testimony because the child was
  154. 6:26registered at a preschool registered at
  155. 6:28her activities as ayersman she had there
  156. 6:32had not been that issue so there was no
  157. 6:34evidence to support it it was
  158. 6:35speculating that this child would later
  159. 6:38problems well miss Conklin tells us in
  160. 6:42the brief that the father has a limited
  161. 6:48if any role in the child's life is his
  162. 6:51post dissolution she argued that your
  163. 6:54honor and and and it's very clear from
  164. 6:56the record that there were some hoops
  165. 6:58that the father had to go through he was
  166. 7:00severely depressed he was drinking he
  167. 7:03was in inpatient treatment at the time
  168. 7:06of the divorce all facts known to the
  169. 7:08mother when she didn't change her name
  170. 7:10and she went into a after a rehab
  171. 7:14facility went into a halfway home
  172. 7:16then he re-enrolled in school and
  173. 7:18attempted contact the way that it was
  174. 7:21outlined in the marital settlement
  175. 7:22agreement it had to be through his
  176. 7:24parents his parents would supervise the
  177. 7:27father and both put the grandparents of
  178. 7:30paternal grandparents testified of their
  179. 7:32efforts the father testified that when
  180. 7:34he was in Boca at the halfway house
  181. 7:36house and in school he would sometimes
  182. 7:39ask four or five times a week that he
  183. 7:43would travel across the alley to Naples
  184. 7:46to see the child only to be told that
  185. 7:47the circumstances had changed you know
  186. 7:51if you know the emails are reviewed
  187. 7:55there were excuses raised and the mother
  188. 7:59herself when she testified she said
  189. 8:00she's a very busy person she's on all
  190. 8:02kinds of committees she's busy at work
  191. 8:05she and her daughter have a lot to do
  192. 8:07all of the standard things we see in
  193. 8:10cases where someone is throwing up
  194. 8:11roadblocks to contact the husband
  195. 8:14testified clearly of his attempts to
  196. 8:15work with his attorney to get some time
  197. 8:18that there were communications with his
  198. 8:20Conklin's attorney to try to get
  199. 8:21parenting time MS Conklin was asked
  200. 8:24under cross-examination at the hearing
  201. 8:27well why wouldn't you even agree to let
  202. 8:29the father see the daughter while he's
  203. 8:32here in town for this trial or the
  204. 8:34paternal grandparents and she basically
  205. 8:37hemmed and hawed about what that was and
  206. 8:40late notice and who requested it but the
  207. 8:43fact of the matter was the father the
  208. 8:45paternal grandparents were there they
  209. 8:47had asked in advance of the trial which
  210. 8:49was
  211. 8:49well known to the parties the trial was
  212. 8:51in September for contact and she didn't
  213. 8:54make it happen so the husband testified
  214. 8:57that when he understood through new
  215. 9:00representation that there is something
  216. 9:02called a motion to enforce a motion for
  217. 9:04contempt that that was filed that
  218. 9:06instead of sitting back trying to work
  219. 9:08it out
  220. 9:09trying to go through his parents trying
  221. 9:11to go through his attorney was not
  222. 9:12working and he filed a motion to enforce
  223. 9:14the mother even tries to argue that the
  224. 9:17father was delinquent in his support
  225. 9:20obligations that are not financially
  226. 9:21supported the child by saying that his
  227. 9:23parents wrote the check well if you go
  228. 9:25back and you look at the marital
  229. 9:26settlement agreement that the mother
  230. 9:27entered into the agreement always was
  231. 9:31that the parents were going to write
  232. 9:33that check on behalf of the father so
  233. 9:36it's not even you know a sincere
  234. 9:38argument to say that he wasn't
  235. 9:39financially supporting the child that
  236. 9:41was his child support obligation through
  237. 9:43his parents to pay that check I think
  238. 9:45that you know this Court has seen a lot
  239. 9:47of high conflict divorce cases come
  240. 9:49through an appeal and I think it's
  241. 9:50interesting to note that in her own
  242. 9:52answer brief the mother cannot even
  243. 9:54bring herself to call mr. Esmond father
  244. 9:57she identifies herself as mother and
  245. 9:59he's the appellant and that's consistent
  246. 10:01with the tone and her testimony
  247. 10:03throughout the hearing she tried to
  248. 10:06rehash events from her perspective were
  249. 10:10horrible events during the divorce yet
  250. 10:13this is the man that she agreed would
  251. 10:14have contact with her daughter who she
  252. 10:16didn't feel the need to change the name
  253. 10:18at the time not even her own name she
  254. 10:20tried to rehash things that existed
  255. 10:22before the final judgment she did not
  256. 10:25bring up any evidence or testimony that
  257. 10:27there was anything that would put the
  258. 10:29child at risk there had been nothing in
  259. 10:31the two years since the final judgment
  260. 10:34had been entered both parties wrote not
  261. 10:37very friendly emails once in a while but
  262. 10:39there was no domestic violence no
  263. 10:41threats and nothing with regard to the
  264. 10:44child that would make the court be
  265. 10:45concerned about the safety or welfare of
  266. 10:47the child there's absolutely no doubt
  267. 10:49that if Miss Conklin would like to
  268. 10:51distance herself from her former husband
  269. 10:53that she should be allowed to change her
  270. 10:54name
  271. 10:55but the statute on name change requires
  272. 10:58the consent of the other parent for very
  273. 11:02good reason
  274. 11:03that parent should be consulted these
  275. 11:05parties got married they decided to have
  276. 11:07a child they jointly named this child
  277. 11:09and there and there is absolutely no
  278. 11:12basis in the record to change the name I
  279. 11:14don't think that mr. Esmond quote was
  280. 11:16quite as articulate in that in the
  281. 11:18record below with regard to his position
  282. 11:21but I think he was very clear when he
  283. 11:23said I love my daughter I want to be in
  284. 11:25her life I haven't abandoned her I've
  285. 11:27hired counsel to pursue my parental
  286. 11:29rights I'm paying support I want her to
  287. 11:32have contact with my family and know my
  288. 11:34family and those are all the reasons why
  289. 11:36we look to we have hearings to see
  290. 11:38whether or not you know it should be
  291. 11:40changed whether or not there's consent
  292. 11:41but there was not one shred of evidence
  293. 11:44that I believe that anyone could argue
  294. 11:46that there was testimony or evidence
  295. 11:49that the welfare of the child was at
  296. 11:51risk or there was a necessity for that
  297. 11:54particular reason I've gone through and
  298. 11:58addressed you know some of the facts but
  299. 12:01I I know this courts reviewed it and I
  300. 12:03think if the court doesn't have any
  301. 12:05other questions I'll reserve my time
  302. 12:24may it please the court my name is Erika
  303. 12:26Conklin and I'm representing myself in
  304. 12:28this appeal therefore for purposes of
  305. 12:30the oral argument I would be referring
  306. 12:31to myself in the third person as the
  307. 12:33mother your honors this Court should
  308. 12:36affirm the judgment of the trial court
  309. 12:37because there was competent substantial
  310. 12:39evidence below that the name change was
  311. 12:41in the best interest or the welfare of
  312. 12:43the minor child the determination of a
  313. 12:46petition for name change for a mild
  314. 12:47child is a very fact-specific inquiry
  315. 12:49and the trial court is vested with broad
  316. 12:52discretionary powers in determining the
  317. 12:53issue of a child's welfare welfare and
  318. 12:56best interests the appellate court
  319. 12:58sitting here today cannot reweighed
  320. 13:00evidence on disputed factual issues for
  321. 13:04the competent substantial evidence
  322. 13:06standard as a general rule and decision
  323. 13:09in a non jury case based on a finding of
  324. 13:11fact from disputed evidence it's subject
  325. 13:14to a competent substantial evidence
  326. 13:15standard of review on appeal because the
  327. 13:17trial judge competent substantial
  328. 13:23evidence that would support a trial
  329. 13:26court finding that changing this child's
  330. 13:29name is in the child's best interest or
  331. 13:31is necessitated for her welfare your
  332. 13:35honor at the trial court the mother
  333. 13:39presented the mother presented evidence
  334. 13:43that it was in the child's best interest
  335. 13:45to have her name change to have to bear
  336. 13:46the same name as the mother the mother
  337. 13:48testified that since the date of the
  338. 13:50child's birth she had been the one who
  339. 13:52provide all the nurturing physical and
  340. 13:53emotional support for the child
  341. 13:55the mother testified that she chooses
  342. 13:57the chooses registers and paid for the
  343. 14:00child's preschool
  344. 14:01health insurance physicians dentists
  345. 14:04camps caregivers extracurricular
  346. 14:06activities travel housing clothing food
  347. 14:09and all necessities of life the mother
  348. 14:12has parental responsibility for the
  349. 14:14child 24 hours a day seven days a week
  350. 14:17the mother is raising the child alone
  351. 14:19the mother testified that the minor
  352. 14:22child now and as she grows is going to
  353. 14:24note need to know her place within the
  354. 14:26family and within society the mother
  355. 14:29testified that the only family the
  356. 14:30mother child has ever truly had consists
  357. 14:33of herself aren't there
  358. 14:34I mean there's got to be millions of
  359. 14:38children all over this world whose name
  360. 14:43is different from their mother's name so
  361. 14:48I mean and I don't think there's any
  362. 14:51empirical evidence certainly none
  363. 14:53presented at the hearing that those
  364. 14:55children are damaged as a result of that
  365. 14:57so what is there specific to this case
  366. 15:00that would support a finding by the
  367. 15:05trial court that changing this
  368. 15:08particular child's name was in her best
  369. 15:11interest or necessitated for her welfare
  370. 15:13your honor and in this particular case
  371. 15:16it's a situation where as miss Hall
  372. 15:21described the the divorce took place
  373. 15:24when the child the mother separated from
  374. 15:27the father when the child was 17 months
  375. 15:31old as you can see from the facts there
  376. 15:35was severe domestic violence and in the
  377. 15:39child's presence the court when when you
  378. 15:45look forward to the the best interests
  379. 15:48of the child standard the case of levine
  380. 15:50vs best states that the trial court is
  381. 15:56to look at the same statutes that
  382. 15:58determine child custody cases those
  383. 16:01statute those sections are set out in
  384. 16:03section 61 13 subsection 3 of the
  385. 16:06florida statutes and that statute says
  386. 16:09the determination of the child's best
  387. 16:11interests shall be made by evaluating
  388. 16:13evaluating all the factors affecting the
  389. 16:15welfare and interest of the particular
  390. 16:17minor child and the circumstances of
  391. 16:19that family in this family it's
  392. 16:23undisputed that the mother pursuant an
  393. 16:26american settlement agreement shall make
  394. 16:29all decisions with regard to the health
  395. 16:31education and welfare of the minor child
  396. 16:33the mother had full physical custody
  397. 16:35the father's visitation was limited to
  398. 16:37supervised visitation which he was not
  399. 16:39exercising
  400. 16:43the evidence before the trial court was
  401. 16:46that in over two years the father only
  402. 16:48made five attempts just by request to
  403. 16:51see the minor child no miss Howell
  404. 16:53testifies Falk has said that the father
  405. 16:56they stated in his testimony that he
  406. 16:59would try to see the child four to five
  407. 17:01times over the course of the week but I
  408. 17:03but the evidence before the trial court
  409. 17:06and the record states otherwise the
  410. 17:10husband agreed that the only
  411. 17:12communication between himself and the
  412. 17:14mother was between text met was came
  413. 17:17informer test messages and all of those
  414. 17:19text messages were presented in the
  415. 17:21mothers exhibit which is that the record
  416. 17:22between record 83 and 165 that exhibit
  417. 17:27which contains all the communication
  418. 17:29between the mother and the father in two
  419. 17:31years there were five dates that the
  420. 17:34father asked to see the child the record
  421. 17:37citations are February 5th 2013 that's a
  422. 17:40record 87 February 17 2013 that's a
  423. 17:44record 90 February 22nd 2013 that's it
  424. 17:48record 93 is there a case or some other
  425. 17:53authority you can point us to that says
  426. 17:55that a history of not visiting as much
  427. 18:03as one might or conflict between the
  428. 18:05parents are are sufficient reasons to
  429. 18:09support a name change when the other
  430. 18:12parent opposes it your honor there the
  431. 18:16case law in the state of Florida
  432. 18:18most of the there's few cases that are
  433. 18:23on point here and most of the cases when
  434. 18:27it is the appellate court finds that it
  435. 18:29was not in the best interest to change
  436. 18:31the child's name it's because there was
  437. 18:33no evidence below that the change of the
  438. 18:37name would be in the child's best
  439. 18:38interest for example in some of those
  440. 18:40cases the father says well I think the
  441. 18:43change should be because I want the
  442. 18:45child to carry my name or I want the
  443. 18:47child to continue the family history or
  444. 18:49because because it's quote old-fashioned
  445. 18:52and that's exactly what the husband and
  446. 18:53this
  447. 18:54case stated he said that his objection
  448. 18:58was that it was it was old-fashioned and
  449. 19:03that's the way things work and there are
  450. 19:07kick Taggart in case and Girton versus
  451. 19:12Andrew and McKay versus Heike both of
  452. 19:15those cases hold where the father says
  453. 19:17that the only reason that he wants to
  454. 19:19take the child's name was because he
  455. 19:20fears he wants a child to maintain that
  456. 19:23familiar name is not sufficient to to
  457. 19:28change the child's name in in this case
  458. 19:35the the the judge heard multiple
  459. 19:38evidence from the mother and from the
  460. 19:41father and of course it was disputed but
  461. 19:45that Judge he was sitting there and he
  462. 19:48he had the discretion to to determine
  463. 19:53the issue of the child's best welfare
  464. 19:54and best interest he had the ability to
  465. 19:57weigh the testimony of the mother and
  466. 20:00the father he had the ability to make
  467. 20:02determinations as far as the credibility
  468. 20:04of the witnesses and those decisions of
  469. 20:07the trial court are not to be are not to
  470. 20:11be questioned by this court the question
  471. 20:14before this Court is where there was
  472. 20:15competent substantial evidence to affirm
  473. 20:18the name change below and I represent
  474. 20:21you that there was
  475. 20:26Florida case law holds that the
  476. 20:28consideration of the child's best
  477. 20:29interest in welfare are one in the same
  478. 20:31the Stan versus stam case says that in
  479. 20:34custody proceedings the prime
  480. 20:36consideration is the welfare of the
  481. 20:37child all vectors factors affecting the
  482. 20:40best interest and welfare of the child
  483. 20:41must be considered miss hall raised the
  484. 20:49Wilson case which was decided by this
  485. 20:54Court the Wilson case is clearly
  486. 20:58distinguishable from from this case
  487. 21:00again in the Wilson case there was no
  488. 21:03evidence presented as to whether the
  489. 21:04change in the name was for the child's
  490. 21:06best interest and also in that case the
  491. 21:08magistrate had placed the burden of
  492. 21:10proof on the father as to why he was
  493. 21:12objecting to the child's name change
  494. 21:14rather than requiring the mother to
  495. 21:16establish while she believed been named
  496. 21:17change was in that child's best interest
  497. 21:19importantly also in Wilson it wasn't
  498. 21:22just the last name of the child that the
  499. 21:24mother was trying to change the mother
  500. 21:26was trying to change the minor child's
  501. 21:27first middle and last names and the
  502. 21:30mother when she was asked why she was
  503. 21:33changing the child's name testified only
  504. 21:35that she never liked the name she didn't
  505. 21:38give evidence to the court that the
  506. 21:40mother here did below she didn't give
  507. 21:43evidence that she was the only one
  508. 21:44raising the child that she plans enrolls
  509. 21:48pays for and transports to child to
  510. 21:50school to extracurricular activities to
  511. 21:52doctors to dentists to her caregivers
  512. 21:54the mother is the one that interacts
  513. 21:56with the mother minor child's peers and
  514. 21:58the peers parents and when the mom when
  515. 22:01the mother picks up the child from
  516. 22:03school picks her up from ballet from tap
  517. 22:06from piano from all of those those
  518. 22:08things the mother the mother is a
  519. 22:12security issue with with the having the
  520. 22:15same next name as the mother when when
  521. 22:18they are picked up at school when they
  522. 22:20register for dentists and doctors
  523. 22:21appointments when they travel the mother
  524. 22:24testified that she didn't want the minor
  525. 22:27child to be subject to feelings of
  526. 22:28embarrassment or abandonment because
  527. 22:30she's burying the last name that has
  528. 22:31nothing to do with anyone that has a
  529. 22:33in her life in this case there was
  530. 22:35testimony that since the date of the
  531. 22:38separation in November of 2011 through
  532. 22:41the date of the trial in September 2014
  533. 22:43which was almost three years the father
  534. 22:45had only been in the minor child's
  535. 22:47presence for seven and a half hours
  536. 22:52the mother noted that if the father in
  537. 22:54the future wanted to have her establish
  538. 22:56in a relationship with a minor child it
  539. 22:58would be on him to do so and it should
  540. 23:00have nothing to do with what her last
  541. 23:01name was and in fact the father
  542. 23:04testified and admitted at transcript at
  543. 23:07transcript 9091
  544. 23:09that if the minor child's name was
  545. 23:11changed it would not affect her as a
  546. 23:13relationship with her your honor your
  547. 23:20honors I can go through each of the
  548. 23:22statutory factors and the evidence that
  549. 23:25the mother presented on those but those
  550. 23:26are I think are very well laid out and
  551. 23:29the mother's brief in conclusion the
  552. 23:33mother carried her burden of proof below
  553. 23:34there's ample basis in the record to
  554. 23:36support the finding made by the trial
  555. 23:38court but it was in the minor child's
  556. 23:39best interest to bear the same surname
  557. 23:41as her mother for these reasons and
  558. 23:43those set forth in the mother's brief
  559. 23:45and in the record there was competent
  560. 23:47substantial evidence to support the
  561. 23:48trial court's finding that the mother is
  562. 23:50the sole caregiver and custodial parent
  563. 23:52and that it's in the minor child's best
  564. 23:54interest to bear her surname I would
  565. 23:57also point out the specific findings of
  566. 23:59fact were not required in a name change
  567. 24:02case especially here when the basis for
  568. 24:05the award is reasonably clear and
  569. 24:06supported by the record but even if they
  570. 24:08were the trial court specifically found
  571. 24:10that the name change was in the child's
  572. 24:12best interest and he specifically found
  573. 24:14the mother was the custodial parent and
  574. 24:16the sole caregiver therefore I
  575. 24:19respectfully request that this court
  576. 24:20affirm the Carla child court's judgment
  577. 24:22and granting the change of name and
  578. 24:24thank you for your time today and unless
  579. 24:26there are any other questions
  580. 24:39the standard the court relied upon to
  581. 24:43change they must be accurate and there
  582. 24:46wasn't any findings with regard to the
  583. 24:48best interest of the child or that the
  584. 24:51name change was necessary for the
  585. 24:53welfare of the child there was an
  586. 24:54objection so you have to use the right
  587. 24:56standard and I respectfully disagree
  588. 24:58with miss Coughlin that the Wilson
  589. 25:00versus Smith case in the facts they said
  590. 25:03the mother argued that the child's
  591. 25:05father had limited contact with the
  592. 25:07child he had more time to serve in
  593. 25:09prison he was not financially supporting
  594. 25:11the child that he did not support the
  595. 25:14child's mother so there were many other
  596. 25:16reasons alleged by the mother other than
  597. 25:19just wanting the same name change I
  598. 25:21don't think I have to remind you but the
  599. 25:23financial responsibility for the payment
  600. 25:25of school and activities that was
  601. 25:27determined pursuant to the Florida child
  602. 25:29support guidelines in their agreement it
  603. 25:31has nothing to do with whether or not a
  604. 25:32nîmes should be changed as to who is
  605. 25:34paying what portion of those activities
  606. 25:36there was a lot of he said she said with
  607. 25:39regard to what happened during the
  608. 25:41marriage we tried to limit that the
  609. 25:43judge did hear some of that but it was
  610. 25:45rebutted testimony with regard to what
  611. 25:48happened during the marriage judge
  612. 25:52Wallace he specifically asked Miss
  613. 25:54Conklin whether or not she had found a
  614. 25:55case where there was a limiting or where
  615. 25:58a parent did not exercise all or some
  616. 26:01part or of their parenting time and the
  617. 26:04question respectfully was not answered
  618. 26:06she obviously has not found a case where
  619. 26:08a name change was granted on that basis
  620. 26:10alone there were no real findings by
  621. 26:13judge foster in this ruling as to why he
  622. 26:16thought it was in the best interest of
  623. 26:18this child nothing about the welfare
  624. 26:20again this is a this need to have
  625. 26:24daughter's name match mom's was
  626. 26:27orchestrated by mom when she requested
  627. 26:29her name change if she didn't want the
  628. 26:31child to have a different name if she
  629. 26:33didn't want any which she's now saying
  630. 26:35here before the court some security risk
  631. 26:37of picking the child up from ballet or
  632. 26:39school wide she changed her name
  633. 26:41it's not enough I think the record is
  634. 26:43clear that mom wanted to change both
  635. 26:46names my client of the father testified
  636. 26:50about all his efforts and his parents
  637. 26:52efforts who were the designated
  638. 26:54go-between for parenting time they
  639. 26:58testified over the number of temps they
  640. 27:00made this is just another factor that
  641. 27:03the court can consider where mom is
  642. 27:05attempting to distance the child from
  643. 27:07her father
  644. 27:08we'd respectfully request that the final
  645. 27:11judgment changed in the name of this
  646. 27:12minor child be reversed thank you

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Changing Name of Minor Child in a Divorce Case- Best Interest of Child by Florida Trust, Real Estate, Probate, & Foreclosure, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,431 words across 646 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.