CAUSAS DE LA POBREZA EN COLOMBIA — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04What would you say if I told you that
- 0:05in Colombia there are places where it
- 0:07can take up to 2 hours to walk to get
- 0:09drinking water? No, it's not a myth,
- 0:12it's not something from the past, it's
- 0:14the daily life of thousands of people
- 0:15throughout our country. It's
- 0:17interesting how while in big cities we
- 0:19argue about traffic or the latest
- 0:21smartphone, millions of Colombians live
- 0:23with hardships that go far beyond
- 0:25having a low salary. Contrary to what
- 0:28we might think, poverty in Colombia is
- 0:30not just about income; it's a
- 0:32phenomenon that has many roots, from
- 0:34the armed conflict to the lack of
- 0:36opportunities in education and
- 0:37employment. And that's precisely what
- 0:40we're going to talk about in this video
- 0:41. We're going to discover the main
- 0:44causes of poverty in Colombia with
- 0:46specific data and we're also going to
- 0:48take a look that goes beyond what we
- 0:50might generally believe. The first
- 0:59thing we need to know is that
- 1:01explaining the phenomenon of poverty is
- 1:02quite difficult. It's even harder to
- 1:05think about eradicating poverty.
- 1:08However, despite the difficulty of
- 1:10these two things, we can say that there
- 1:12are seven key factors that are inherent
- 1:14to poverty. In other words, if these
- 1:16factors did not exist, poverty would
- 1:18practically not exist. The first of
- 1:20these is inequality. And listen, I know
- 1:24, I know, I know that we have heard and
- 1:26seen people mention how inequality may
- 1:28not be bad or may not directly affect
- 1:31poverty in the country, because come on
- 1:33, we are all different, we are all
- 1:35different. And we have also heard some
- 1:39people say that as inequality is
- 1:41reduced, we are going to become a
- 1:43communist or socialist society and
- 1:45nothing could be further from the truth
- 1:48. Inequality is a complex problem and
- 1:51we first have to understand what
- 1:53inequality is about before moving on to
- 1:55the other points in the video. It does
- 1:58not mean that inequality is the only
- 2:00cause of poverty, it is not, but it is
- 2:02one of the most important factors that
- 2:04continues to perpetuate poverty in a
- 2:06society like Colombia. So, what is
- 2:09inequality? According to the definition
- 2:12and in socioeconomic terms, inequality
- 2:14is the unequal distribution of
- 2:16resources and opportunities, such as
- 2:18income, wealth, education, employment,
- 2:20and access to basic services, among the
- 2:22different groups or individuals that
- 2:24make up a society. The greater the gap
- 2:27between those who have the most and
- 2:29those who have the least, the greater
- 2:31the inequality. If you notice, up to
- 2:33this point we have not talked about
- 2:35having to expropriate anyone, about
- 2:37having to take from some to give to
- 2:38others. We are defining what inequality
- 2:42is in socioeconomic terms, and in
- 2:44addition, we could say that inequality
- 2:47has three other sub-factors, so to
- 2:49speak, that comprise it, and the first
- 2:52of these is the Gini index, which is
- 2:55how inequality is measured. This index
- 2:58was invented or formulated by an
- 3:00Italian statistician named Corrado Gini
- 3:03. This index ranges from zero to zero,
- 3:06representing total equality in income
- 3:09and wealth, and one representing
- 3:11maximum inequality. To give you an idea
- 3:14, this maximum inequality could be a
- 3:16country where a family or a very, very
- 3:18small group of people controls
- 3:19absolutely all of the country's income.
- 3:23One example is Saudi Arabia, where
- 3:25there is a family that is in charge in
- 3:27absolutely all aspects of the country,
- 3:29and there are surely other places in
- 3:31the world where the Gini index is
- 3:33practically one, very close to one.
- 3:37However, in practice, in most countries
- 3:39, the Gini index is between 0.3 and 0.6
- 3:42. To give you an idea, according to
- 3:46figures from Dane, the Gini index in
- 3:47Colombia is 0.52. That means that most
- 3:52of the income in Colombia is
- 3:54concentrated in very few hands. And who
- 3:56are those very few hands? They are
- 3:58probably business groups such as
- 4:00Sarmiento Angulo, Ardilalule, etc. So,
- 4:03understanding the Gini index and
- 4:05knowing what it is about and where we
- 4:08stand as a country in terms of
- 4:10measuring the Gini index, we can talk
- 4:12about the second factor that makes up
- 4:15inequality, which is the concentration
- 4:18of wealth. According to the World Bank,
- 4:21in Colombia, the richest 10%accumulate
- 4:2440%of the country's income alone. Of
- 4:28all the money that enters Colombia,
- 4:31only the richest 10%have 40%, not the
- 4:3310%of the population, the richest 10%.
- 4:37In other words, if we take all the rich
- 4:39people there are, we take 10%from those
- 4:41rich people, and 40%of all the
- 4:43country's income is concentrated in
- 4:45that 10%. This is quite high. And if we
- 4:50add to that the third factor of
- 4:52inequality, which is monetary poverty,
- 4:55according to DANE data, in 2023
- 4:57monetary poverty was 33%. This shows
- 5:02that there is still a high proportion
- 5:04of Colombians who have insufficient
- 5:06income, in other words, almost 35%of
- 5:08Colombians do not earn enough to live
- 5:10on. Keep that in mind when you are
- 5:13going to criticize someone who you see
- 5:16is not making progress for some reason.
- 5:20I know that someone will probably tell
- 5:22me, "Well, how can they not make enough
- 5:23?" How can they not make enough? If you
- 5:26spend your time binge drinking,
- 5:28drinking at parties, buying unnecessary
- 5:31things. And I want to tell you
- 5:32something about that so that you can
- 5:34analyze it well. I know that you
- 5:36probably know someone who is like that,
- 5:38but that is a personal experience. It
- 5:41is irresponsible to take a personal
- 5:42experience and generalize about such a
- 5:44large group. Imagine, 35%of the
- 5:48population is 15,000 people. I am going
- 5:51to ask you to do an exercise. Imagine
- 5:53that you are going through a situation
- 5:56of need. I hope not. I hope not. And
- 6:00you have made a lot of effort. You have
- 6:03tried hard to get a promotion at work
- 6:04and you have not been able to, they
- 6:06have not been able to give it to you or
- 6:07in your business. You are implementing
- 6:10strategies to advance, but nothing,
- 6:11nothing seems to work for you. Nothing,
- 6:13nothing, nothing. You receive some
- 6:16money and you buy a Christmas present
- 6:18for your son. Why? Well, because your
- 6:22son, you want your son or even yourself
- 6:24to give yourself a little treat despite
- 6:26all that that's been happening to
- 6:27you, despite all the problems you've
- 6:29had. And it's valid, it's valid that
- 6:32you want to do that and you go
- 6:34somewhere, I don't know, you get home
- 6:36and someone in your family tells you or
- 6:39whispers, "But why buy that if you
- 6:41don't have money?" How would you feel?
- 6:44What would you think? Tell me, leave it
- 6:47in the comments and if you really put
- 6:49yourself in the shoes of someone who is
- 6:51going through that, you will understand
- 6:54how it feels. It feels horrible,
- 6:58because it's not fair to judge someone
- 7:01in that way who is really doing
- 7:03everything to survive, not even to get
- 7:06ahead or to progress, it is to survive
- 7:09that is even worse. Imagine, put
- 7:13yourself in the shoes of someone like
- 7:15that and tell me if perhaps at some
- 7:17point you have not been very harsh in
- 7:19judging the poverty of other people and
- 7:21the difficulties they have had to get
- 7:23out of poverty. So, we already know
- 7:26that we have this Gini index, we
- 7:27already know about the distribution of
- 7:29wealth and we already know about
- 7:31monetary poverty. We can conclude then
- 7:34that these three things contribute to
- 7:36the fact that large sectors of the
- 7:38population, specifically those 15
- 7:39million, do not can access
- 7:41opportunities for progress, and this
- 7:43lack of opportunities for progress
- 7:45causes poverty to decrease very slowly
- 7:47or not at all. Poverty can literally
- 7:50remain stagnant for many years due to
- 7:52factors such as those we mentioned.
- 7:58Look, I believe that we are all aware
- 8:00of the armed conflict in one way or
- 8:03another, even if only partially. In
- 8:06fact, I plan to make a detailed and
- 8:08well-researched video about the armed
- 8:09conflict in Colombia, so I am not going
- 8:11to go into detail describing the armed
- 8:13conflict or the events that have
- 8:14surrounded the armed conflict in
- 8:15Colombia for so many years. It is
- 8:18important to make a note here. The
- 8:20simple fact of being born in a rural
- 8:22area of Colombia where there are groups
- 8:24outside the law such as self-defense
- 8:26groups or the famous guerrillas is
- 8:28practically a lifetime pass to poverty
- 8:30and suffering. Imagine that if it is
- 8:34difficult to get out of poverty in a
- 8:36city, in some places in Colombia the
- 8:38difficult thing is to survive and not
- 8:40end up paying, as we commonly say, in
- 8:42an armed confrontation or being
- 8:44forcibly recruited by one of these
- 8:46guerrillas. Now, Okay, let's think
- 8:51about that before we come up with very
- 8:53poor solutions to poverty. Let's
- 8:57consider that the place where we were
- 8:59born, not our family, not even our
- 9:01location, geographically speaking,
- 9:03within a country that is already quite
- 9:06problematic in many ways, can be even
- 9:08worse for you: being born in a remote
- 9:10rural place that also has a constant
- 9:12threat of clashes between groups
- 9:14outside the law. Let's think, let's
- 9:18think carefully before criticizing
- 9:20people who live in these conditions,
- 9:22whether their context can truly allow
- 9:24them to escape poverty. And there is a
- 9:28devastating fact. According to the
- 9:30Victims Unit, by 2023,000 people will
- 9:35be victims of the armed conflict and of
- 9:39those 9.66 million, close to 80%are
- 9:42forcibly displaced. In fact, here is an
- 9:45even more disturbing fact. According to
- 9:47international organizations, Colombia
- 9:49is one of the countries with the
- 9:51highest number of internally displaced
- 9:53people in the world. Let's think about
- 9:56that fact for a moment. Imagine that
- 9:58one day, out of nowhere, a group of
- 10:00people and everything they have is
- 10:01taken from them for no reason. Just
- 10:04because they were born in the wrong
- 10:05place, at the wrong historical moment
- 10:07and without further ado, they have to
- 10:08start from scratch, with nothing. In a
- 10:11place where they may not know anyone
- 10:13and have nothing but their will. A will
- 10:16that may no longer exist due to what
- 10:17they have had to live through. Imagine
- 10:20that and answer, do you think that this
- 10:23situation of displacement and armed
- 10:25conflict generates a socioeconomic
- 10:28impact in the country? I am going to
- 10:33assume that the answer is yes. I am
- 10:34going to give you another piece of
- 10:35information. According to the same
- 10:38victims 'unit, displaced households
- 10:41tend to have higher levels of poverty
- 10:43than the national average and are often
- 10:45located in informal isolation, the
- 10:47famous invasions, without full access
- 10:50to basic services. Do you think that a
- 10:53person who cannot even access basic
- 10:55services has an easy time getting out
- 10:58of poverty? There will come someone who
- 11:01is going to say, "But when I was a
- 11:03child there was no water, there was
- 11:05nothing and I still managed to build
- 11:07this and that.""No, I don't want to
- 11:09make you feel like your effort is
- 11:12worthless because it is, but we come
- 11:14back to the same thing. This is your
- 11:16personal experience and you are surely
- 11:19one of the few who managed to get ahead
- 11:21. And if you managed to do it, look at
- 11:24the reasons why other people didn't
- 11:26manage to get ahead. Think about it,
- 11:28think about it carefully, right? It's
- 11:31most likely not just because of their
- 11:33actions, they are surely conditioned by
- 11:36external factors, domestic violence,
- 11:38abuse, in short, the list is endless.
- 11:41But we come back to the same thing,
- 11:43Colombia has always been a country that
- 11:45has had a series of conflicts and
- 11:46problems like the ones we are
- 11:48discussing here. And those things,
- 11:49whether you like it or not, have an
- 11:51impact on people's ability to get out
- 11:53of poverty. If you grew up in a place
- 11:55without armed conflict, near a city or
- 11:57in a transit city, in a middle-class
- 11:59family, it is very, very easy to get
- 12:01out of poverty, compared to what a
- 12:03person has to do who is born in a place
- 12:05with armed conflict, without a family,
- 12:07and although perhaps at some point they
- 12:09had the means to survive, an armed
- 12:10group comes and takes them away, and
- 12:12they have to Starting from scratch.
- 12:15That's a journey. Understand, it's not
- 12:19that your effort is worthless, it's
- 12:21that the effort that others have to
- 12:23make is inhumane, practically
- 12:24impossible to achieve. Even if they
- 12:28declare and decree everything they want
- 12:29, perhaps their lives won't be long
- 12:31enough to repair the damage done to
- 12:32them and get back to where they started
- 12:34. That's what this is all about. Let's
- 12:40add to the problem we're talking about
- 12:42that this forced displacement has a
- 12:44strong impact on rural development.
- 12:48Various studies by the Bank of the
- 12:50Republic and Fe Desarrollos indicate
- 12:52that the lack of public investment and
- 12:55insecurity have led to rural poverty
- 12:57being 10 to 15%higher than urban
- 12:59poverty.
- 13:02So, what is the effect of poverty on
- 13:04all this? In addition to what we've
- 13:07been talking about, which I think is
- 13:08quite clear, violence and displacement
- 13:10not only directly increase poverty
- 13:12through the loss of assets and means of
- 13:14subsistence, but they also prevent
- 13:15poverty from being overcome because
- 13:17access to education, health, and social
- 13:19security are limited. employment, etc.;
- 13:21even basic services, as we have already
- 13:23seen. I want to pause here to tell you,
- 13:27in case you haven't noticed, that this
- 13:30video is not just an analysis of raw
- 13:33data, but also seeks to help us put
- 13:36ourselves in someone else's shoes.
- 13:40Imagine being in that position and tell
- 13:42me, as I said before, if declaring and
- 13:45decreeing is enough. If those two
- 13:49things are enough to get you out of the
- 13:51terrible hole that some people have put
- 13:53you in and that perhaps you didn't even
- 13:54put yourself in. Think about that
- 13:58carefully before judging the poverty
- 14:00and conditions of other people in such
- 14:02a harsh way as we often do. Here it
- 14:08goes. According to figures from Dane,
- 14:11educational coverage is high, with 90%
- 14:14coverage nationwide for primary
- 14:16education and between 80 and 85%for
- 14:18secondary education. I think that
- 14:22figure is problematic because I
- 14:23couldn't find any that measured the
- 14:25quality of infrastructure. I know that
- 14:28the quality of education is measured
- 14:29through tests, let's see, but I don't
- 14:31know how to measure infrastructure. I
- 14:34don't know how to determine whether,
- 14:36despite that coverage, there is an
- 14:38infrastructure that provides good
- 14:39quality education, because imagine
- 14:41having the best teacher, but there's no
- 14:43blackboard, it doesn't rain and the
- 14:45school gets damaged. I mean, I don't
- 14:49know, it sounds to me like the figure
- 14:52is problematic, even though there is
- 14:54high coverage and primary and secondary
- 14:57education in remote places or sometimes
- 15:00not so remote, there may be problems
- 15:03teaching. I myself had to stop
- 15:05attending classes because in the school
- 15:07where I studied, if it rained very hard
- 15:09, the roof would fall off. So, I find
- 15:12that hard to believe and I never lived
- 15:14in a very rural place. I lived in a
- 15:16rural area, but it was close to a major
- 15:18city, less than an hour from a major
- 15:20city, so it's not that far. So, I
- 15:23imagine how this is measured in even
- 15:25more remote places. If you guys know
- 15:27the figure, if there is any metric from
- 15:29DANE or someone who has measured the
- 15:31quality of educational infrastructure
- 15:33in Colombia, I would like you to share
- 15:34it with me so that I can measure it.
- 15:37contrast this. But anyway, getting back
- 15:39to the topic, another problem, of
- 15:41course, with education is the quality
- 15:43of education. That educational quality
- 15:47can be low. I'll give you an example
- 15:49from my personal experience. When I
- 15:51arrived at SENA, at the age of 18, in a
- 15:53major city in Colombia, I was
- 15:55confronted with the fact that the level
- 15:57of educational quality for me was very
- 15:59low. I mean, I didn't know many things,
- 16:02not about the degree, but many things
- 16:03that my teachers already assumed I had
- 16:05to know because I had already graduated
- 16:07from 11th grade and I had no idea. And
- 16:11we're talking about comparing this to
- 16:13people who also went to public schools,
- 16:15but public schools in Cali, and the
- 16:17difference was huge. There were many
- 16:20things that I had no idea about, that
- 16:22they had mastered very well, and I had
- 16:24to reinforce and start studying to
- 16:26catch up. Fortunately, it didn't affect
- 16:29me most of the time, but at first it
- 16:31was incredibly complicated. Now, if we
- 16:34talk about higher education, the figure
- 16:36is horrible. Only 52%. Imagine, close
- 16:40to 100%of the students who attended
- 16:41public schools were in high school.
- 16:42Half of the country has practically no
- 16:44way of studying something after
- 16:46finishing high school. Not only because
- 16:49of economic difficulties, but also
- 16:50because even if they wanted to, they
- 16:52couldn't do it, because there's
- 16:53probably nowhere to study where they
- 16:55live. And the truth is that if you
- 16:58don't live in a major city, it's
- 16:59honestly very difficult to find a place
- 17:01to study a higher education degree or
- 17:03the higher education degree that you
- 17:05want. There may be some, but they're
- 17:07limited. A limited curriculum, limited
- 17:10degrees. There are five degrees. Oh, I
- 17:12don't want any of those bad ones. Who
- 17:15told you to be born in the right place?
- 17:18In the wrong place, sorry. So, assuming
- 17:20that you have the possibility of
- 17:22studying, let's ask ourselves a
- 17:23question. Can a family with monetary
- 17:25poverty afford for one of its members
- 17:27to study in another city? The truth is
- 17:30that it's almost impossible. I mean,
- 17:32let's not even talk about a 5-year
- 17:34degree, because you're not going to let
- 17:36me lie to you that a person with
- 17:37limited resources can't afford to study
- 17:40for 5 years. It's not. It's ridiculous
- 17:43to think about studying for 5 years
- 17:44because all you want is to graduate
- 17:46quickly and produce, and that's also
- 17:47what your parents are expecting. If you
- 17:49have good parents, they might not tell
- 17:51you, but you realize it yourself. You
- 17:54realize that you need to start
- 17:56producing to alleviate some needs, and
- 17:58that's when you can feel forced,
- 18:00because this is not a decision that is
- 18:03not conditioned. I mean, I can't say,"
- 18:06No, I'll take the 5 years. "" It's not
- 18:08possible. Even if you were studying at
- 18:12a public university, transportation,
- 18:14food, and probably other things I'm
- 18:17leaving out make it impossible, and I
- 18:20say it like this, impossible to even
- 18:23consider studying a 5-year university
- 18:25degree. That's why Sena is blessed. I
- 18:30mean, Sena is something that has lifted
- 18:33people out of poverty in an impressive
- 18:35way. Me included. If it weren't for
- 18:38Sena, I don't know what my current
- 18:39living conditions would be. Fortunately
- 18:41, Sena gave me the opportunity to study
- 18:44something quickly that allowed me to
- 18:46start earning money. If it weren't for
- 18:50that, I don't know what would have
- 18:51happened, because the higher education
- 18:53options are too long for a person with
- 18:55limited resources and, in addition to
- 18:57being long, they're very far away; I
- 18:59mean, they're in a place where I...I
- 19:00don't have the money to go; going for 5
- 19:02years is too long. To be honest, even
- 19:06though the coverage is low and the
- 19:07amount of things they want to put
- 19:09together so that a person can opt for
- 19:10higher education, I find it hilarious.
- 19:14and then there are a lot of random
- 19:15things that have an impact, right? For
- 19:18example, if you were born far from a
- 19:20major city, just with that alone,
- 19:22you're almost conditioned to never be
- 19:25able to set foot in a university in
- 19:27your life, or at least not in the
- 19:29crucial stage that comes after dropping
- 19:31out or finishing high school. Finish
- 19:35high school, you don't have to study
- 19:37and that's, I mean, think about it,
- 19:40it's an impressive journey to be able
- 19:42to become a technician, at best, a
- 19:44technician, a technologist. And because
- 19:48I rule out a 5-year university
- 19:49education because most people don't
- 19:50have the money for that. I mean, that's
- 19:53something that has limited spaces,
- 19:54because it's not like you can go from
- 19:56far away and say, "Oh, yeah, we'll take
- 19:57you here.""Nothing. It has to happen
- 19:59first. In addition to that, if you can
- 20:03afford the amount of expenses that you
- 20:05have to incur to achieve it, speaking
- 20:07of course about a degree at a public
- 20:09university, because I do rule out a
- 20:11private one. I am someone who can
- 20:13afford to pay for a private university,
- 20:15I am not poor, I doubt it very much. I
- 20:18mean, unless they have saved their
- 20:19whole life and I don't know, parents
- 20:21work miracles, but otherwise it is very
- 20:23difficult. Please, don't tell me that
- 20:27you can do it virtually because the
- 20:30internet is a service that is
- 20:32practically exclusive to rural areas,
- 20:37but very close to the city and well,
- 20:39urban areas, and that in cities there
- 20:41are places where there is no internet
- 20:44coverage. I mean, I have seen, I have
- 20:46close cases of people who live in the
- 20:47city and where they live there is no
- 20:49internet coverage. They have to pay for
- 20:51internet like Starling, which is owned
- 20:53by Elon Musk, for example, to give you
- 20:55an idea. I mean, who can afford
- 20:57Starling? I mean, middle class people;
- 21:00that is not for people in Monetary
- 21:02poverty, which, remember, is 33%of the
- 21:03entire country. So internet in a rural
- 21:07area is bad and, in addition to being
- 21:09bad, it is expensive. Expensive
- 21:11compared to the income that a person in
- 21:13monetary poverty can earn, right?
- 21:16Always under that premise because the
- 21:18difference or the concept of expensive
- 21:20varies according to the income level.
- 21:23So, taking into account this situation
- 21:25of difficult access to higher education
- 21:27and the problems that basic education
- 21:29has, there is something else that needs
- 21:31to be discussed and that is employment.
- 21:34According to figures from DANE,
- 21:36unemployment in 2024 was 9.1%, while
- 21:39youth unemployment was 16.2%. Although
- 21:43these figures have been decreasing in
- 21:45recent years, there is still too much
- 21:47informality around. And the thing is
- 21:50that informality reaches from 40 to 50%
- 21:52depending on the area of the country.
- 21:55And that informality, and believe me
- 21:57when I say that many of those people
- 21:58who live in informality do not do it
- 22:00because they want to, but because they
- 22:02have to, is problematic. Why is it
- 22:03problematic? Because an informal worker
- 22:05does not have access to social
- 22:07protection; that is, they cannot access
- 22:09pensions, health care, and they do not
- 22:11have coverage for occupational risks.
- 22:13And yes, I know that the anecdote about
- 22:15the lady sounds really cool: the
- 22:17Tintana 6, 7 million pesos a month,
- 22:19because I saw a video on TikTok that
- 22:21talks about that. But what happens the
- 22:24day she gets sick or what happens when
- 22:26she gets old? That doesn't sound so
- 22:28cool, does it? That's when the idea has
- 22:30already started to sink in, and that's
- 22:32precisely where the problem with
- 22:34informality lies. Furthermore, most
- 22:36informal jobs do not have income
- 22:38stability, which makes it difficult to
- 22:40plan anything. If you don't know how
- 22:43much you're going to earn, it's
- 22:44difficult to make plans, and that lack
- 22:46of plans can condemn you to economic
- 22:47and social stagnation. Informal workers
- 22:51are excluded by banks. No one lends to
- 22:54you, no bank lends to you because
- 22:56sometimes they don't even have a bank
- 22:57account, and other financial
- 22:59institutions also exclude them. This
- 23:01causes them to seek out the famous"
- 23:04gota gota "or informal lenders, and we
- 23:06already know what happens or what can
- 23:09happen when you borrow money from this
- 23:12people. Usury rates, theft, well,
- 23:14violence, in short, a problem that I'm
- 23:16not going to address in this video, but
- 23:19that I would like to discuss in another
- 23:21video. And all of these things end up
- 23:24affecting us because as a country we
- 23:26have lower tax collection and then as a
- 23:28consequence the State has a harder time
- 23:31designing effective public policies,
- 23:33basically because there are no records
- 23:35on employment or the working conditions
- 23:37of these people. And all of this, as
- 23:40you can imagine, is reflected in
- 23:42poverty in Colombia. Why? Well, because
- 23:45the lack of quality education, the lack
- 23:48of formal job opportunities lead to
- 23:50insufficient and unstable income, thus
- 23:52perpetuating poverty, of course. In
- 23:55addition, informality prevents access
- 23:57to social security and makes it
- 23:59difficult to accumulate capital, which
- 24:02is why I mentioned income variability.
- 24:05And remember something very important,
- 24:07and that is that just being born in a
- 24:09place that is not a major city can
- 24:11condemn you for the rest of your life
- 24:13and limit your ability to make
- 24:15decisions that are crucial to you. As I
- 24:18said before, there are many people who
- 24:19cannot ask themselves, what do I want
- 24:21to study? Because perhaps what they
- 24:24want to study they can't afford or
- 24:26there's no way to access it from where
- 24:27they live. Let's think about that
- 24:32before we judge and before we give
- 24:34rubbish solutions to problems as
- 24:36complicated as poverty.
- 24:41According to ECLAC, social investment
- 24:44in Colombia represents around 12 to 14%
- 24:47of GDP. A smaller figure compared to
- 24:50countries that have made very rapid
- 24:52progress in reducing poverty, such as
- 24:54Uruguay and Costa Rica, which in these
- 24:57cases exceeds 20%of GDP. And although
- 25:00there are programs such as Families in
- 25:02Action, Youth in Action or Solidarity
- 25:04Income that have had positive results,
- 25:06their coverage is still quite limited
- 25:08and does not reach all vulnerable
- 25:10people, nor does it comprehensively
- 25:12cover all their needs. And here I'm
- 25:14going to expand a bit to talk about a
- 25:16series of things that people usually
- 25:18tell me about these programs. There is
- 25:20a popular belief that people who
- 25:21benefit from these subsidies become
- 25:23rich overnight, and the truth is that
- 25:25nothing could be further from the truth
- 25:28. These programs, although they give
- 25:30out money, of course they do, people
- 25:32benefit. The amount has established
- 25:35caps. I mean, they're not going to give
- 25:37them 10,000 ones, right? That has
- 25:39specific established limits and also
- 25:42requires constant review to stay within
- 25:45the program. And although, for example,
- 25:47Familias en Acción, which is the one
- 25:49I've received the most comments about,
- 25:50is based on the number of children, no
- 25:52one can have that many children. And
- 25:55even if there is someone who wants to
- 25:56have that many children for subsidies,
- 25:58the amounts per child are limited.
- 26:01They're not going to give them 10
- 26:02million per child or 1 million per
- 26:03child. It's not far from that. So it
- 26:06wouldn't be profitable at all. I mean,
- 26:08imagine 10 children, 1,500. No, I mean,
- 26:11no, no, no, it's not profitable. These
- 26:16programs are an aid designed for those
- 26:17who need it; and although I know that
- 26:19there is corruption in them because I
- 26:21wasn't born yesterday and I'm not
- 26:22stupid, and of course, there will be
- 26:24those who do things to cheat the system
- 26:26, these people will still remain in
- 26:28poverty, because this is not enough to
- 26:29make a significant change in their
- 26:31lives. Now, the coverage of these
- 26:34programs is very limited. So much so
- 26:37that few of us know people who have
- 26:39benefited from this. When I was a
- 26:41teenager, I myself was part of Jóvenes
- 26:43en Acción and by being part of
- 26:44Jóvenes en Acción I could become part
- 26:46of Familias en Acción, for example,
- 26:48because I was already part of Jóvenes
- 26:50en Acción. So if you are one of those
- 26:54who thinks that this will solve
- 26:55people's problems, let me tell you that
- 26:57you are quite wrong. These things help,
- 27:00of course, but they are so limited that
- 27:02they fall short in terms of the
- 27:04coverage they offer, and in many cases,
- 27:06they still do not cover the basic needs
- 27:08of the beneficiaries. It is a help, but
- 27:11it does not save them as much as many
- 27:13people might believe, without
- 27:15forgetting that many of these
- 27:17initiatives are conditioned by a
- 27:18government or political changes, and
- 27:20that limits their ability to generate a
- 27:22sustained impact. A new president
- 27:24arrives and takes it away. He says," No
- 27:26, I don't want Jóvenes en Acción. "
- 27:27and goodbye. The beneficiaries are
- 27:31screwed and have to look for or wait
- 27:33for a new program to consider doing
- 27:35something. And for example, when I was
- 27:38there, there were 200,000, like 10
- 27:40years ago, which was a huge help, but
- 27:42for me, I would have spent 300 and
- 27:44something on bus tickets. So, although
- 27:47it helped me a lot, for example, if my
- 27:49mother hadn't had a way to get those
- 27:51160,000 pesos or so that I was missing,
- 27:53no, it still wouldn't have been of any
- 27:55use to me and they gave them to me,
- 27:57well, because I was in the Sena. The
- 27:59real problem with social investment is
- 28:02corruption. According to a document
- 28:05published by the Office of the
- 28:06Comptroller General of the Nation, the
- 28:08cost of corruption in Colombia for 2020
- 28:10was more than 50 billion. We're talking
- 28:14about a gigantic amount of money being
- 28:16stolen and that's it. This is
- 28:18heartbreaking data and it's another one
- 28:21in the long list of data that explains
- 28:24why there is poverty in Colombia. Let
- 28:27me give you an example. Imagine that
- 28:29those 50 billion, those 50 billion are
- 28:31invested in infrastructure. Let's give
- 28:34a complete example. That infrastructure
- 28:37is used to build a bridge, a dual
- 28:38carriageway that reduces travel time
- 28:40from one place to another from 2 hours
- 28:42to 40 minutes. This would promote trade
- 28:46, increase productivity, economic
- 28:49investment and rural areas, options for
- 28:52people to opt for higher education,
- 28:54housing, in short, many possibilities
- 28:57can open up and that is just a dual
- 29:00carriageway. A dual carriageway does
- 29:02not cost 50 billion pesos, it costs
- 29:04much less, but it never arrived, the
- 29:06dual carriageway never arrived,
- 29:07progress never reached the area where
- 29:09it had to arrive. This is an imaginary
- 29:11case, but it has surely happened in
- 29:13real life. That's how it works. This
- 29:15deprives many people of access to
- 29:17something, to what they are entitled to
- 29:20, because we all pay for it as
- 29:22Colombians and that is how poverty
- 29:24continues to perpetuate. For example,
- 29:26there is the case of the Juanchito
- 29:28Bridge, which took about 10 years to
- 29:30build and was something similar, a dual
- 29:32carriageway with a bridge that was
- 29:34under construction for about 10 years
- 29:36and was planned for about 30. These
- 29:39types of things are what significantly
- 29:41impact the lives of thousands or
- 29:43millions of people. That is why
- 29:45politics is important and why it is
- 29:47important that as citizens we exercise
- 29:49political control and verify where
- 29:51these resources are allocated, because
- 29:54without a doubt the lack of social
- 29:56investment and corruption are key to
- 29:58the continued existence of poverty in
- 30:00Colombia. Do you remember the phrase I
- 30:06said at the beginning of the video?
- 30:08Here we are going to delve deeper into
- 30:09this. I will give you a fact. In 2021,
- 30:13the DAN estimated that more than 95%of
- 30:16the urban population has access to
- 30:18drinking water, while in rural areas
- 30:21the figure could drop between 80 to 90%
- 30:23and even less in very remote regions.
- 30:27And the curious thing here is that
- 30:29although coverage is high, in many
- 30:31places the coverage is during a
- 30:32specific time slot or it is not even
- 30:34through pipes, but rather a truck can
- 30:36arrive to provide water to a particular
- 30:38community. In many rural areas, the
- 30:40water they have available and does not
- 30:41have any quality standard. Let me give
- 30:43you a personal example. I lived for
- 30:45many years near a major city, as I
- 30:47think I've already mentioned three
- 30:49times, and the water that supplied the
- 30:51town was a giant open-air tank, and the
- 30:53animals would come there and relieve
- 30:54themselves, and that was the water we
- 30:56drank. Obviously, the water was heated,
- 30:59but that wasn't done for bathing, for
- 31:01example. And people who weren't from
- 31:03there would go to that place and their
- 31:05skin would get damaged, they would get
- 31:07dermatitis, because the water quality
- 31:09was terrible. And I probably drank that
- 31:12water myself as a child, who knows how
- 31:14many times while playing or whatever.
- 31:17Yes. And it's contaminated water, it
- 31:20had no quality whatsoever, completely
- 31:22dirty water. And that place got
- 31:27drinking water less than 15 years ago,
- 31:29a place that's next to a major city,
- 31:30literally less than an hour, like 40
- 31:32minutes from a major city. And even
- 31:35with drinking water, many times it runs
- 31:37out. Drinking water arrives and then
- 31:40without warning it goes away or they
- 31:42say that it will be available at
- 31:44certain times. specific, at a specific
- 31:47time, on specific days. Do you
- 31:49understand what I mean? How can poverty
- 31:51not be perpetuated if there is not even
- 31:52potable water in many places in the
- 31:54country? I insist that although the
- 31:57coverage is relatively high, many times
- 31:59something as basic as water is
- 32:01conditioned by external factors that do
- 32:03not even depend on the will or the
- 32:05personal decision of each person. I
- 32:08myself had to receive water from a
- 32:10truck, and that same truck left us
- 32:11waiting many times with the containers
- 32:13ready, all on the block, waiting for
- 32:15the container to arrive. The truck
- 32:17never arrived and we had to manage as
- 32:21best we could; it was common to see
- 32:23people collecting water for many hours
- 32:25to fill the tank of the sink or some
- 32:27tub they had lying around. And so here,
- 32:30what is the solution? Have a good
- 32:33mentality to move forward. The truth is
- 32:36, no. Nothing like that. It is a very
- 32:38complex issue and the solution is not
- 32:40simple. A complex problem rarely has a
- 32:43simple solution. And do you know what
- 32:47all I just told you is based on? That
- 32:49even if there is access to potable
- 32:52water, According to FED Development in
- 32:552022, only 66%of rural households have
- 32:58access to improved water sanitation
- 33:00systems, so the water quality in the
- 33:03remaining 34%is extremely poor.
- 33:07Something to think about, ladies and
- 33:09gentlemen. And well, speaking of this
- 33:12issue of the distribution of resources
- 33:13and services, there is another
- 33:15important piece of data and that is
- 33:17rural poverty. It is systematically
- 33:20between 12 and 15 percentage points
- 33:23higher than urban poverty. For example,
- 33:27in 2022, monetary poverty in rural
- 33:31areas was around 44.6%, compared to
- 33:3533.4%in urban areas. And this is
- 33:40largely due to the lack of
- 33:41infrastructure, roads, energy, internet
- 33:44, sanitation, things that may be basic
- 33:46in some sectors of large cities, but in
- 33:48other places seem like a dream. And
- 33:51here we go again. When do we choose
- 33:54where to be born? That is simple chance
- 33:56. And whether we like it or not, it
- 33:58conditions us for the rest of our lives
- 34:00. In Colombia, the mining and energy
- 34:06sector, that is, oil and coal,
- 34:08represents close to 50%of the country's
- 34:11total exports. This is according to
- 34:14data from the Bank of the Republic. And
- 34:15what's wrong with that? Let me explain.
- 34:17Tax revenues depend to a large extent
- 34:20on the volatility of international oil
- 34:22and mineral prices. In other words,
- 34:24there could be a huge national impact
- 34:27due to an international conflict. That
- 34:30is a fairly serious problem and it is
- 34:32something that can greatly affect us as
- 34:34a country without much notice.
- 34:37Conflicts such as the war in Ukraine,
- 34:39conflicts in the Middle East and other
- 34:41wars around the world can affect the
- 34:43economy of each one of us directly or
- 34:45indirectly. It doesn't matter if you
- 34:47are thousands of kilometers away and
- 34:49that you are not informed about the
- 34:51subject, having a high dependence on
- 34:52the mining and energy sector can affect
- 34:54us. Something similar, in fact,
- 34:57happened with the neighboring country,
- 35:00since the dependence on that sector is
- 35:02almost 100%and the price of oil
- 35:04fluctuated a few years ago and
- 35:06everything went to hell. In this
- 35:09country, that is, in Colombia,
- 35:11agriculture is a very important sector.
- 35:13According to the Danio, agriculture
- 35:15contributes around 67%of GDP, despite
- 35:17the fact that a significant portion of
- 35:20the population lives in poverty in the
- 35:22rural sector. And it is precisely in
- 35:24these types of things where inequality
- 35:26is reflected, because many small
- 35:28producers do not have access to credit
- 35:30or technology, which makes it difficult
- 35:32to compete and they are crushed by
- 35:34large producers, companies that are
- 35:36part of the same business groups that
- 35:38we are all familiar with. In short,
- 35:41when oil and coal prices fall, tax
- 35:44revenues are affected and therefore
- 35:46public investment, reducing the chances
- 35:49of financing social programs. And since
- 35:53we are a country with little productive
- 35:55diversity, certain regions are left
- 35:56behind and in conditions of economic
- 35:58vulnerability. If you notice, it is a
- 36:00large structure that depends on each
- 36:02part of the other. If one thing is
- 36:04affected, the other is affected. For
- 36:06example, if GDP is affected by a change
- 36:08in the price of oil, social investment
- 36:10is reduced and that, in one way or
- 36:11another, increases poverty; and in
- 36:13addition to increasing it, it
- 36:15perpetuates it. It is a vicious circle
- 36:17that continues to feed itself, in one
- 36:20way or another. In a similar vein, due
- 36:22to the key factors that push Colombia
- 36:24to be a poor country. According to
- 36:29figures from the labor observatory of
- 36:31the Externado University of Colombia,
- 36:34women earn on average 20%less than men
- 36:36for doing the same job. And here,
- 36:39please, this is not about ideology,
- 36:41these are just figures. It is really
- 36:44very difficult to measure this
- 36:46accurately, but I think many of us can
- 36:48realize this by observing the places
- 36:50where we work and how society behaves
- 36:52in some aspects. So, in short, if you
- 36:55are poor and you are a woman, in
- 36:56certain circumstances it will be more
- 36:58difficult for you to get out of poverty
- 37:00. There are other cases where men have
- 37:03it harder too, but the wage gap is
- 37:05something that specifically affects
- 37:07women because of their gender. It is
- 37:10likely that in some situations they
- 37:12earn money simply because they are
- 37:13women. Another fact is that ethnic
- 37:16groups such as indigenous people and
- 37:18Afro-descendants have higher levels of
- 37:20poverty than average, according to data
- 37:21from ECLAC in 2021. Contrary to what
- 37:23your racist friend might believe, it is
- 37:25not because of their skin color. It's
- 37:28not because of their culture, it's
- 37:29because of racism. In other words,
- 37:31structurally, indigenous and Afro
- 37:33people have a harder time getting out
- 37:35of poverty solely because of the ethnic
- 37:38group they belong to. Just like that.
- 37:41They are often rejected for jobs. They
- 37:43have a harder time gaining the trust of
- 37:45their bosses. In short, if you look at
- 37:46your skin and you've never received
- 37:48comments about it, let me tell you that
- 37:50just because of that you already have
- 37:52an advantage in life. One that seems
- 37:55imperceptible, but there it is, because
- 37:56no one is going to tell you," I don't
- 37:58trust you because you're black. "" Well
- 38:00, almost no one. But they do it and
- 38:03they judge you for it, perhaps silently
- 38:05, but they do it and that's why these
- 38:07kinds of things happen. Imagine being
- 38:10born indigenous or black in a remote
- 38:12town, without access to basic services
- 38:14and also in a poor family. Is it enough
- 38:17for these people to have a mentality
- 38:19and good determination to get out of
- 38:21poverty? Is it enough for them to
- 38:23declare? Is it enough to decree what
- 38:25they want? I don't think so. I wish it
- 38:29were that simple, I wish, I wish it
- 38:31were as simple as believing that by
- 38:33deserving something or decreeing that
- 38:35something, you already have it. But the
- 38:39truth is that these people have a great
- 38:41number of structural problems against
- 38:42them or it is even ridiculous to think
- 38:44that they have the same opportunities
- 38:46as others. They don't. There are more
- 38:49privileged people and only because of
- 38:51the color of their skin. I repeat, it
- 38:54is a difficult problem, it does not
- 38:55have an easy solution. I wish there
- 38:57were, but that is not the case. Another
- 39:00of our big problems is drug trafficking
- 39:02and illegal economies. I must say that
- 39:05although there is no exact figure for
- 39:07How many people live off illegal
- 39:09economies? The Colombian Drug
- 39:12Observatory points out that in some
- 39:14remote areas, growing illicit crops is
- 39:16almost the only economic option. This
- 39:20creates cycles of violence and
- 39:21underdevelopment. I repeat, in some
- 39:25remote areas, growing illicit crops is
- 39:27the only economic option. You can tell
- 39:31me how many opportunities for a full
- 39:33life someone has who is almost forced
- 39:36to do something criminal. In addition,
- 39:39there is a phenomenon that I have
- 39:40observed and that I plan to talk about
- 39:42in another video, and that is drug
- 39:43culture. We are very permeated by it
- 39:45and honestly it seems that we have
- 39:47learned to make it part of our daily
- 39:49lives. There are references to Pablo
- 39:51Escobar and other criminals everywhere,
- 39:53to the point that some people almost
- 39:55idolize them and see them as people who
- 39:57knew how to beat the system. They knew
- 40:00how to leave poverty behind and reached
- 40:02the top of the food chain, that is,
- 40:04they became rich. The truth is that
- 40:11solving a problem as complex as poverty
- 40:13is incredibly difficult. Great minds
- 40:15have not yet achieved it and,
- 40:16furthermore, it seems that we have
- 40:17learned to make it part of our daily
- 40:18lives. This can depend on some social,
- 40:20political and cultural factors of a
- 40:22specific region. So you can imagine how
- 40:25difficult it can be. There are several
- 40:27things that we can address as a society
- 40:29, for example, giving more importance
- 40:31to education, taking a greater interest
- 40:33in politics to make better use of the
- 40:34right to vote. These are decisions that
- 40:39we can make as individuals, of course,
- 40:40and that may have some impact as a
- 40:42society, but the truth is that the
- 40:44structural problems are so great that
- 40:46perhaps our individual actions cannot
- 40:47do much, but that does not mean that we
- 40:49should not try. We do the right thing
- 40:52because it is the right thing, not
- 40:54expecting to receive a reward for doing
- 40:55it. I hope that after watching this
- 40:57video you will have a more informed
- 40:59perspective on poverty. My intention
- 41:01with this is that, honestly, ridiculous
- 41:03phrases will no longer be used to
- 41:04justify the suffering and poverty of
- 41:06other people. Phrases like, "It's just
- 41:08a mentality, whoever wants it can, I
- 41:09declare it and it will be given to me."
- 41:12These things are disrespectful to those
- 41:14in need and justify their suffering and
- 41:16perpetuate it. Again, poverty is a
- 41:19structural problem that is very
- 41:21difficult to solve and no easy solution
- 41:23, like a ridiculous phrase, is going to
- 41:26eradicate it. There are other things
- 41:29that I left out, such as the brain
- 41:31drain, drug culture, eating disorders,
- 41:33teenage pregnancy. I know I didn't
- 41:36mention these things explicitly in the
- 41:38video, but they are mostly part of the
- 41:41seven main ones I mentioned. However, I
- 41:44plan to make videos on these topics in
- 41:46the future. If you would like them, you
- 41:48would like to make any of these videos,
- 41:49first of all, the comments are a very
- 41:51useful tool and they allow me to know
- 41:53what the audience that follows this
- 41:54channel or that will continue to follow
- 41:56this channel is waiting for, because
- 41:57this is the first video. I am truly
- 42:00very excited about this new project.
- 42:03For me, it is something very important
- 42:05and something that I have always wanted
- 42:07to do, but I have always stopped
- 42:08because I don't know or I had trouble
- 42:10thinking of how to talk about these
- 42:12things respectfully so as not to offend
- 42:14those who truly live a difficult
- 42:16situation. I have experienced it myself
- 42:19and I think that is why I can
- 42:21understand what it is like to lack
- 42:23everything. And although that does not
- 42:27give me the right to understand it and
- 42:29speak for those people, it does give me
- 42:31the right to express myself and tell
- 42:33what my reality was, even more so if I
- 42:35can support it with data, not only with
- 42:37my opinions and my experiences. I do
- 42:40not have more social networks for now,
- 42:42so if you subscribe, it helps me a lot
- 42:44to continue creating content. I send a
- 42:46big hug to everyone and if you are
- 42:48going through a difficult situation,
- 42:51remember, the night is always darkest
- 42:54before the dawn. M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of CAUSAS DE LA POBREZA EN COLOMBIA by Atención Desviada, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,469 words across 1,119 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.