Case Interview Fundamentals: Lesson 37 [Drill: Cosmetics M&A] — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, how's it going? This is
- 0:02Julio speaking. Let's get ready for
- 0:05another chart interpretation drill.
- 0:07Just so you know, this chart
- 0:08interpretation drill is going to be a
- 0:10little bit different than the previous
- 0:12one that we did because the chart is a
- 0:15lot more data-heavy. And what this means
- 0:18is that
- 0:19you will need a lot more time to read
- 0:21the chart carefully.
- 0:23And there will also be heavier business
- 0:26insights. So, be prepared to also follow
- 0:29the step-by-step to creating hypothesis
- 0:32and next steps thoroughly.
- 0:34Just to set some expectations here, I
- 0:36would not be surprised if you take 20
- 0:38minutes or even more on this exercise.
- 0:42Remember, you are building a whole new
- 0:45skill set here while reading charts,
- 0:48connecting insights to your framework,
- 0:52synthesizing them. So, it is expected
- 0:54that you take longer than in a regular
- 0:57case. And this is a complex one, so it
- 1:00is going to take more time, especially a
- 1:02lot more time than the exhibits in the
- 1:04previous drill. All right? And of
- 1:07course, as you practice this long-form
- 1:09method more and more, it will get
- 1:12intuitive to you and you will eventually
- 1:14be able to do it right away from your
- 1:16mind. Right?
- 1:18Just one last thing, like in the
- 1:19previous case, I will show you my
- 1:21framework for this case after I show you
- 1:23the case question. And I highly
- 1:25encourage you to make your own
- 1:26framework. As
- 1:28frameworks are key to creating a
- 1:31high-quality answer for a chart
- 1:33interpretation question.
- 1:35As I said, as you practice more and
- 1:36more, you'll be able to do this without
- 1:39the framework right in front of you
- 1:41because you'll be able to create a
- 1:43simplified framework in your mind. But
- 1:45until then, this is absolutely the best
- 1:47way to practice, all right? Let's go.
- 1:49Let's get to the case question right
- 1:51away.
- 1:52Your client is a major mass market
- 1:56cosmetics, personal care, and fragrances
- 1:58company in Brazil called Bright.
- 2:01Bright is currently number two in the
- 2:03Brazilian cosmetics market with 10% of
- 2:06market share and 5 billion
- 2:09Brazilian reals in revenues. All right,
- 2:11so we're talking about the Brazilian
- 2:12currency here.
- 2:14Bright executives have recently been
- 2:16approached by representatives of the
- 2:18eighth player in the market called Teen,
- 2:21who wanted to sell the company to
- 2:22Bright.
- 2:24Bright executives believe this could be
- 2:25a good deal and that it might be a good
- 2:27opportunity to enter the masstige, which
- 2:30means the intermediate segment between
- 2:32mass and prestige, market in which Teen
- 2:35operates.
- 2:36They have asked for your opinion on
- 2:38whether this is a good acquisition or
- 2:39not. How would you approach this
- 2:41question?
- 2:42All right, now take some time, come up
- 2:44with your own framework, then look at
- 2:45mine, and fill in any gaps that you
- 2:48might have, and then let's move on to
- 2:51the chart interpretation question.
- 2:53Basically, my overall approach to this
- 2:55case would be trying to answer three
- 2:56questions. Question number one, do we
- 2:59really want to enter the masstige
- 3:01market? Is that a good strategic
- 3:03decision right now? Number two,
- 3:05is acquiring Teen's the best entry
- 3:08strategy, or are there other better
- 3:11strategies than that? Like acquiring
- 3:13other players or entering with a new
- 3:15brand or even with our own brand.
- 3:17And number three,
- 3:19is the Teen's acquisition a good deal by
- 3:23itself?
- 3:24So, will it have good synergies within
- 3:26and is it a good company to acquire as
- 3:29an investment? All right, now I'm going
- 3:31to dive into a little bit more depth
- 3:33into each one of those. So, to evaluate
- 3:35whether the masstige entry is a good
- 3:38decision, I would look at
- 3:41elements of the demand, elements of the
- 3:44Bright company, and elements of the
- 3:45competition. So, basically, within
- 3:47demand, I want to know if this market
- 3:49has a significant size compared to the
- 3:52market that we're currently in and to
- 3:54our current company
- 3:55and whether it's growing. So, I want to
- 3:57know if it's
- 3:59the segment is growing in comparison to
- 4:01the other segments in the cosmetics
- 4:03market and if it's a large growth by
- 4:05itself.
- 4:06Then, within the bright company, I would
- 4:09try to understand if our current
- 4:11distribution channels would work for
- 4:13prestige
- 4:14and whether our current brand would be
- 4:16damaged or not by this entry.
- 4:19And when it comes to the competition I
- 4:23would try to understand number one if
- 4:24this is a profitable market. So, I'd
- 4:26want to know if the players in the
- 4:28prestige segment are profitable.
- 4:30And I would also want to know if we can
- 4:32charge a price premium in that market
- 4:35but not incurring a lot of cost
- 4:37increase.
- 4:38And number two within competition, I'd
- 4:40like to see if our competitors have
- 4:42entered the prestige market. So, I know
- 4:44if this is something that is an
- 4:46opportunity that we don't want to miss
- 4:48out because of the timing. All right?
- 4:50Now, when it comes to deciding if teens
- 4:53is a good entry strategy by itself I
- 4:56would see
- 4:57if teens is well positioned to capture
- 5:00the market growth.
- 5:01So, do they have a good distribution and
- 5:04does their brand have good recognition
- 5:07within customers?
- 5:09Also, if their brand is loved. So, not
- 5:12only is it recognized but also the
- 5:14customers who purchase it love it or do
- 5:17they purchase because they have no other
- 5:19options. All right? And I'd like to see
- 5:21if they have a clear brand positioning.
- 5:23So, that means
- 5:24basically if we enter this market using
- 5:27their brand, would there be confusion in
- 5:30the minds of customers? Okay? And I
- 5:32would also like to see but I think I'll
- 5:34already have data for that from the
- 5:37previous bucket that I analyzed, whether
- 5:39our own distribution channels would be
- 5:42enough for this entry or whether we need
- 5:44to acquire a new player inside.
- 5:46Okay? And then next, I would look at
- 5:49Teams as a standalone deal. If this a
- 5:53good acquisition by itself. So,
- 5:55basically I look into two different
- 5:57points of view. One of them is Team as
- 5:59an asset and the other is the merger
- 6:02synergies that we would get.
- 6:03In Teams as an asset, I'd like to know
- 6:05if the company is profitable, if it's
- 6:07loved by its customers, so that we can
- 6:10have good customer retention, and if
- 6:12there's room to grow in its segment. And
- 6:16within synergies, I'd like to see if
- 6:18there are product gaps on either sides
- 6:20that the
- 6:22other
- 6:23company could fulfill.
- 6:26If there are cost-saving opportunities,
- 6:27and within this I see mostly
- 6:30manufacturing cost-saving opportunities,
- 6:31procurement of goods, procurement of
- 6:34media placement, and research and
- 6:36development cost-saving opportunities.
- 6:39And I'd like to see if there are
- 6:41distribution synergies as well. So, will
- 6:43we have
- 6:45more shelf space for our current
- 6:47products, and would Team have more
- 6:50distribution or more shelf space for
- 6:53their products within our stores or our
- 6:55distribution methods? All right? This is
- 6:58basically my framework. This is how I
- 7:00would solve this case. Now, let's say
- 7:02that the interviewer says, "All right,
- 7:04very nice. Now, take a look at this
- 7:06exhibit and tell me what you think." As
- 7:08you know, by now you should pause the
- 7:10video and go through this chart on your
- 7:13own. Following the four-step approach,
- 7:17and then listen to my answer and see
- 7:19what you can learn from it. What I would
- 7:20do here is, of course, first look only
- 7:23at the axes and then map the territories
- 7:26in this chart. To do this, I want to
- 7:29show you this chart without the data,
- 7:32only with the
- 7:34concept of the information within. What
- 7:36I can see in it is that it has a Y axis
- 7:40that goes from 0 to 100% and it tells me
- 7:44the market share of each company within
- 7:48their segments. And on the x-axis we
- 7:51have the market segments. So, each
- 7:54column is a market segment and it's
- 7:56divided into the companies that are
- 7:58within showing their market share. On
- 8:01top of each column we have the market
- 8:04size of the segment, right? And on the
- 8:07bottom of everything we can see the
- 8:09growth of the segment in in a data row.
- 8:13All right? And basically what this can
- 8:16tell me is from the size of the market
- 8:19segments if Mustique is a large enough
- 8:23market to be a significant opportunity,
- 8:24if it's really large and it's an amazing
- 8:27opportunity, or if it's not, right? The
- 8:30companies and their market shares within
- 8:32each segment can tell me if Teen is well
- 8:36positioned to capture the growth inside
- 8:38that segment, if there is room to grow,
- 8:41and how it's Mustique competitors are
- 8:44doing. And the growth in the data set in
- 8:49the bottom can tell me if Mustique is
- 8:51growing and becoming larger as a segment
- 8:54or if it's not, right? So, this is
- 8:56basically my reading of the chart
- 8:58overall. And as of nuances, I would look
- 9:02and understand that the charts shows
- 9:05different brands, right? And they are
- 9:08all different. There isn't a repetition
- 9:10of brands between segments. And I can
- 9:13also see that there's this growth YOY.
- 9:16And if I didn't know this, I would ask
- 9:18the interviewer, and YOY basically means
- 9:21year over year. So, it's the yearly
- 9:23growth.
- 9:24All right? This is basically the way I
- 9:26would read and map the territories of
- 9:28this specific chart. I didn't exactly
- 9:32draw a map as I would in different
- 9:34charts because this would look awkward
- 9:37this one chart, but
- 9:39the conclusions that I took from each
- 9:41type of data here as of what it can show
- 9:44me is already the mapping the territory
- 9:47stage. And now I'm going to interpret
- 9:49the data, but I'm not going to do it as
- 9:51I would do it to an interviewer because
- 9:53I want to show you my thought process
- 9:55behind so that you can follow it and you
- 9:58can develop your own thought process
- 10:00that's not only intuition,
- 10:02but then eventually a structured thought
- 10:05process will become intuitive to you.
- 10:06And then I'm going to tell you how I
- 10:08would tell this to an interviewer.
- 10:11All right, let's go.
- 10:13Basically, what I'm going to do here is
- 10:15first read the data and see what the
- 10:18data shows me exclusively.
- 10:20Then I'm going to turn that into
- 10:22hypotheses and insights by connecting it
- 10:25to my framework so that these insights
- 10:27are relevant to the case.
- 10:28And then I'm going to synthesize all
- 10:31that into a few relevant insights and
- 10:35next steps that I'm going to communicate
- 10:37to the interviewer. All right, and I'm
- 10:38going to show you exactly how I'm doing
- 10:39all of this. So basically, what I see in
- 10:42the chart from the numbers exclusively
- 10:44is
- 10:45this prestige segment is very small.
- 10:48It's less than 4% of the total
- 10:52cosmetics, personal care, and fragrances
- 10:54market. All right? What it also shows me
- 10:57is that
- 10:58the segment of prestige grows a lot less
- 11:01than all others, significantly less. So
- 11:03it's comparatively shrinking. All right?
- 11:06It grows almost 10 times less than
- 11:08prestige. It grows six times less than
- 11:10the mass market.
- 11:12Right? And
- 11:14another thing that I can see here is
- 11:16that the teen, our target of the
- 11:18acquisition, has a 50% market share,
- 11:21which is a lot more than
- 11:24all other players have market shares
- 11:26within their segments. And I'm not still
- 11:28not going to go into what that means,
- 11:30but I can already tell that this is a
- 11:32relevant insight. Okay? And now, I'm
- 11:35going to connect these to my framework
- 11:38so that I can understand what
- 11:41this all means to the case and how I can
- 11:44get to next steps based on this
- 11:47simple data reading. I can see that the
- 11:50market segment is growing very little
- 11:53and comparatively shrinking within the
- 11:55market. And I can see that this market
- 11:57segment is also very small, less than 4%
- 12:00of the total. I also noticed that my
- 12:03competitors seem not to have entered the
- 12:06mustache market, at least not
- 12:08significantly. And what I'm going to do
- 12:11with all of this, what all of this means
- 12:13to the
- 12:14mustache entry category of my framework
- 12:17is I would only enter this market if
- 12:20it's super profitable and therefore it
- 12:23can be relevant to my bottom line.
- 12:25All right? Now,
- 12:27I can also see that there is not that
- 12:30much room for growth for Teen because
- 12:33they already have around 50% of the
- 12:35market. There could even be room for
- 12:37another player to compete with Teen,
- 12:40but probably not room to become even
- 12:42more than 50% of the market because that
- 12:45would just mean that
- 12:47more than half the people that consume
- 12:50that market adhere to the values of this
- 12:52brand and that would simply be weird.
- 12:54But it is possible that there is another
- 12:58segment of customers within the segment
- 13:00that would like a brand that is
- 13:02different, right? With a different
- 13:04positioning. So, I would expect another
- 13:06competitor to grow and compete with Teen
- 13:08inside that segment. This 50% also means
- 13:12that Teen could be well positioned to
- 13:15capture the market growth if there was
- 13:17any. So, they probably have a good
- 13:18distribution to reach all that 50% of
- 13:21people. So, if market was growing, they
- 13:23would be in a good position. But But
- 13:25problem is it's not. It's not growing.
- 13:27And
- 13:29another thing that this 50% of market
- 13:30share tells me is that despite the
- 13:33market being small, Teen has a relevant
- 13:36market size to us. So,
- 13:38they are around
- 13:4025% of our size.
- 13:43The problem is they seem doomed to this
- 13:44size since their market doesn't grow and
- 13:47they're already too big for this market.
- 13:50And so, I would write above my
- 13:53Teen as an entry strategy segment of my
- 13:55framework,
- 13:56could be
- 13:58a good entry strategy, but only if the
- 14:00synergies are dramatically large.
- 14:03So, I would want to understand if the
- 14:06increase in profits that we can bring to
- 14:10Teen could be relevant. So, maybe we can
- 14:12improve their margins by a lot with our
- 14:15manufacturing process or if we can use
- 14:18their products for our own product gaps
- 14:20or our products for their own product
- 14:22gaps with just a little bit of change.
- 14:25Or maybe we can drastically improve
- 14:27their profitability with our R&D process
- 14:31or maybe with purchasing uh volume,
- 14:34increasing purchasing volume, right?
- 14:37Now,
- 14:38what you can see from this is that
- 14:41it's a ton of insights and this is not
- 14:44how you'd present it to an interviewer
- 14:45because it's just too much. I would
- 14:47distill it based on my framework to
- 14:50become just a few insights and
- 14:54a few next steps in high-quality
- 14:56brainstorming afterwards. And this is
- 14:59how I'd present it to the interviewer.
- 15:01So, I can see that the mustache segment
- 15:04is very small. It's around 4% of the
- 15:06total and it's shrinking comparatively.
- 15:10And Teen has a relevant size in
- 15:12comparison to Bright, but there isn't
- 15:15that much room for growth in their
- 15:17segment. And I also predict that it's
- 15:20possible that a new incoming player
- 15:22could appear and press margins of team
- 15:25in that market. So, the only thing that
- 15:28could make me save this merger and still
- 15:31consider it is if there are dramatic
- 15:34synergies. So, I would look into whether
- 15:38Bright can fill their product gaps or
- 15:40they can fill Bright's product gaps. I
- 15:43would look into distribution channel
- 15:46synergies. So, maybe our distribution
- 15:49channels would be good for their
- 15:50products or vice versa. I'm not too
- 15:53confident of that because they're
- 15:54different market segments.
- 15:56And I would see if there are
- 15:57manufacturing advantages on both sides
- 16:00and other advantages and synergies such
- 16:02as procurement, procurement of media
- 16:05placement, and research and development.
- 16:08So, that's what I'd investigate next so
- 16:10that I can make the best decision
- 16:12possible on whether this deal should
- 16:14happen or not. And one thing that I'd
- 16:16keep in mind is that entering the
- 16:18prestige market is probably a better
- 16:20option than mastige right now. It's a
- 16:22larger market and it has a much, much
- 16:26larger growth. So, I'd keep that in mind
- 16:28for the future after we've ruled out
- 16:31this acquisition, which I think it's
- 16:34probably what we're going to do. Now, I
- 16:35just want to go over a few quick key
- 16:38insights that I want you to take home
- 16:39from this drill, right? Number one,
- 16:42data-heavy charts like this are ultra
- 16:44common in the consulting jobs.
- 16:46Sometimes,
- 16:47a lot more data than what you have in
- 16:49this one chart. So, be aware of that and
- 16:52practice this case thoroughly so that
- 16:55you have the process ready for when you
- 16:57get even harder case charts than this
- 16:59one, right? Number two, all of these
- 17:02data-heavy charts have a ton of nuance
- 17:04on the chart itself. So, take your time
- 17:06understanding the axes and the data
- 17:08that's included and ask your interviewer
- 17:10for help if you need. This is expected
- 17:13and it is encouraged when you have a
- 17:15data-heavy chart cuz it's hard to
- 17:17compress all that data in a single
- 17:19chart, so you need to be creative in how
- 17:22you build it. And so, it's probably
- 17:23going to be a chart that no one else has
- 17:25ever seen before, right? Number three,
- 17:29when you get a data heavy chart like
- 17:30this, the chart is going to have a ton
- 17:33of insights. It's no coincidence that it
- 17:35has a ton of data inside. It's because
- 17:36all of the data in it is insightful. And
- 17:39so, in these cases,
- 17:41your framework is your best friend, as
- 17:43I've told you many times. Have your
- 17:45framework next to you and connect your
- 17:47data insights with the framework to come
- 17:50up with
- 17:51good insights to the case and with good
- 17:54next steps. In number four, I want to
- 17:57warn you about a common trap that
- 17:59candidates fall into when doing
- 18:02chart interpretation questions with data
- 18:04heavy charts. And that is looking only
- 18:07to the hypotheses on one side, either
- 18:10positive or negative. So, as you see,
- 18:12there are there will always be
- 18:13hypotheses. There will always be data
- 18:15that point to
- 18:17yes or to no in the case question, or to
- 18:19good or to bad, to do the investment or
- 18:21don't do the investment. And
- 18:24that's common because that's how real
- 18:25life is. Not everything points in the
- 18:27same direction. When it does, you hardly
- 18:29ever need to hire a consulting firm. So,
- 18:32data is going to be pointing in several
- 18:34different directions, and you need to be
- 18:36ready to recognize that they
- 18:38are pointing to different directions and
- 18:40that and ready to synthesize those into
- 18:44coherent next steps that will help you
- 18:46decide once and for all what the client
- 18:49should do.
- 18:51All right, guys. This is it for this one
- 18:53case. I hope you enjoyed it, and I'll
- 18:55see you in the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Case Interview Fundamentals: Lesson 37 [Drill: Cosmetics M&A] by CraftingCases, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,135 words across 485 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.