Case Interview Fundamentals: Lesson 35 [Chart Interpretation: the 4-step approach] — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Hello everyone, how's it going? This is
- 0:02Julio speaking. Let's get going with the
- 0:05last of the analytical building blocks,
- 0:08chart interpretation.
- 0:09Now, if you recall the previous modules
- 0:12from this course, you know that
- 0:15estimations were all about building a
- 0:17model, choosing assumptions, and reality
- 0:20checking. And then analysis were all
- 0:22about also building a model, but
- 0:24generally a more complex one, less
- 0:26intuitive, and also coming up with
- 0:28conclusions and next steps for whatever
- 0:31you do.
- 0:32Chart interpretation is a little bit
- 0:34different because it's all about the
- 0:37conclusion and the next steps. It's like
- 0:39someone's done the analysis for you and
- 0:41the results a little bit more complex
- 0:42than just one number, sometimes a lot
- 0:44more complex than just one number. And
- 0:46now all you have to do is look at the
- 0:48results, understand them, and guide
- 0:51whoever made that analysis or whoever
- 0:53should benefit from that analysis. Which
- 0:56could be your client, could be your team
- 0:59of consultants under you or even above
- 1:02you.
- 1:02You know, it's good stuff, partner work,
- 1:04just chill, boss people around,
- 1:06hopefully sell a couple more projects.
- 1:08You're going to like this. Let's move
- 1:10on.
- 1:12First, you need to understand exactly
- 1:14what chart interpretation is. What is
- 1:17this task that you're going to perform?
- 1:19Why are they asking you this question?
- 1:22Why does this type of question exist?
- 1:24What are they testing, right? So,
- 1:26basically, like in an analysis,
- 1:30chart interpretation is data-driven
- 1:33hypothesis testing. What that means is
- 1:35that the exhibit that you got or the
- 1:38exhibit, sometimes there's more than
- 1:40one, is trying to prove or disprove a
- 1:42hypothesis that is relevant for the case
- 1:45using data. Therefore, this hypothesis
- 1:49either is or should have been in your
- 1:51initial framework.
- 1:53It's basically what gets done, what
- 1:55happens after an analysis is done. The
- 1:58exhibits that you get are the product of
- 2:01an analysis that someone did. Could be
- 2:03your client, could be you, could be your
- 2:06team, could be an external source.
- 2:09Right? And
- 2:11basically, case interview tasks are
- 2:13analogous to consulting tasks, as you
- 2:15might be tired of hearing by now.
- 2:18The situation in consulting that we are
- 2:21simulating is basically
- 2:24you are doing a project and a project is
- 2:28a set of hypotheses, all one next to the
- 2:31other, that will answer or help answer
- 2:34the initial question that you're trying
- 2:37to answer, right? And to test that
- 2:40hypothesis, you come up with a
- 2:42comparison that you need to do. And then
- 2:44you come up with an analysis that will
- 2:45allow you to do that comparison.
- 2:47And basically, you gather data, run a
- 2:50model, and in the end you end up with
- 2:54information rather than uh raw data.
- 2:59And that information is hardly ever just
- 3:02a single number. Most of the times, it's
- 3:05one or more exhibits with
- 3:08nuance and you know, complex data that
- 3:12is related to one another, or complex
- 3:14charts.
- 3:15And
- 3:16the one thing that you need to do once
- 3:19you get to that point in the analysis is
- 3:23make a conclusion based on that chart.
- 3:25Actually say what it means to the
- 3:27hypothesis that you're trying to test.
- 3:29So, you must be able to identify
- 3:31what
- 3:33hypothesis that exhibit is trying to
- 3:35test because, well, since you didn't
- 3:38build it, you don't exactly know, and
- 3:39that is exactly the point of this type
- 3:42of question in case interviews.
- 3:44And you need to be able to tell what
- 3:47that means to that hypothesis. Does it
- 3:49mean that it's true? Does it mean that
- 3:50it's bad? And how does this affect the
- 3:52initial case question? And most
- 3:55importantly, what do we do now based on
- 3:57that?
- 3:59Differently than the other building
- 4:00blocks, in this one, in chart
- 4:02interpretation, it's like you are the
- 4:04manager. You're not an
- 4:06analyst or consultant running analysis,
- 4:10coming up with ideas. You're the
- 4:12manager. You just got new slides from
- 4:15your analysts or from your consultants,
- 4:17and they're asking you what they should
- 4:19do. What's next? Or maybe you got them
- 4:22from the client, and the client's asking
- 4:24you, you know, what do I do with this?
- 4:26And it's your job as the manager, as the
- 4:30one that is guiding that project, to
- 4:32tell them right away what is the next
- 4:35step based on that. What does that mean
- 4:37and what should they do?
- 4:39The way we simulate this in a case
- 4:41interview is you're doing a case, and in
- 4:43the middle of the case you get
- 4:45an exhibit, and you get asked what you
- 4:48think about it. Now, most people just
- 4:51say what they see. They'll say something
- 4:54like, "Oh, A is higher than B. This line
- 4:57that represents X is growing."
- 5:00But as you can imagine, that wouldn't go
- 5:02well in the situation that we're
- 5:03simulating. Imagine that the
- 5:07client brings in new information in
- 5:09forms of slides to the McKinsey manager,
- 5:12and they look at it and say, "Oh,
- 5:15A is higher than B." or whatever.
- 5:17They
- 5:18whoever brought them that slide, whoever
- 5:20brought them that exhibit or that data,
- 5:22knows exactly
- 5:24what the data shows. They can say,
- 5:30But what they want you to do, what they
- 5:32want the consulting firm, in you
- 5:33representing the consulting firm, to do
- 5:36is tell them what that means to them and
- 5:39what they should do based on that. That
- 5:42is how the consulting firm adds value,
- 5:44and that's what they're testing. If you
- 5:46can do that, you can be a consultant.
- 5:48And if you can't, well, there's no point
- 5:50in bringing you to work with them, and
- 5:53whoever's interviewing you, in their
- 5:55mind. There's no point in bringing you
- 5:57to work with them because they're going
- 5:59to have to teach you this crucial skill
- 6:02to consulting, and so they'd rather take
- 6:04someone who can do this. Okay? Now, I
- 6:08want to jump in uh a couple of examples
- 6:11of
- 6:12potential case questions, potential
- 6:15chart interpretation questions, and show
- 6:18you how those could be wrong. What are
- 6:20the most common ways people answer them
- 6:23wrong. Before I show you what
- 6:25interviewers are looking for, the
- 6:27elements that a right answer need to
- 6:28have, how often these types of questions
- 6:31appear, and then show you a step-by-step
- 6:34method so that you can
- 6:36correctly interpret every single chart
- 6:39that you get in case interviews, and not
- 6:43only that, but also impress your
- 6:44interviewer in your path. Okay? Let's
- 6:48take a look at three examples. So, let's
- 6:50say that you get a table comparing
- 6:52different countries that Nestlé could
- 6:54invest on on expansion. And then the
- 6:57interviewer tells you, "What do you
- 6:58think?"
- 6:59Or maybe you get a graph charting
- 7:01effectiveness, addressable population,
- 7:04and cost of different public policies to
- 7:06reduce childhood obesity in a specific
- 7:10location, geography, could be country,
- 7:12city, or region, right? And then the
- 7:15interviewer asks you again, "What do you
- 7:17think?" Or let's say that they give you
- 7:19a more complex chart showing the iron
- 7:22ore supply and demand curves with prices
- 7:25and volumes of all main global suppliers
- 7:28and buyers. And then the interviewer
- 7:30asks you, "What do you think?" These are
- 7:31the types of
- 7:33questions that you can get in chart
- 7:35interpretation questions. Now, what do
- 7:38wrong answers sound like? Let's say that
- 7:41you get the first question here. You get
- 7:44a table comparing different countries
- 7:46that Nestlé could invest on expansion.
- 7:49Now, you can imagine that there's a
- 7:51table over here with several different
- 7:53countries and their market sizes, their
- 7:55growth, information on competition,
- 7:58likelihood of consumers to accept our
- 8:00products, and more.
- 8:03There are three common ways that
- 8:05candidates screw these types of
- 8:08questions up.
- 8:09Common wrong way to answer this, number
- 8:12one.
- 8:13They don't connect the
- 8:17exhibit to the case at all. They solely
- 8:19talk about the exhibit. This is the A is
- 8:22higher than B situation that I mentioned
- 8:24before, and it's the most common mistake
- 8:26of all. Imagine the candidate looks at
- 8:29the exhibit and says,
- 8:31"Oh, Colombia has a lot more growth.
- 8:34Mexico has a larger market, and Brazil
- 8:36has less competition."
- 8:38What you would get with this answer in a
- 8:40real-life situation, the situation that
- 8:42we are simulating, is
- 8:44a blank look from whoever showed you the
- 8:47table that thinks,
- 8:49"Really? Is that what we're paying you
- 8:51for? Is that what we're paying Bain or
- 8:54BCG this much money for?" What we really
- 8:56expect from you is a conclusion,
- 9:00not simple readings of the chart. They
- 9:02expect you to say what it means to the
- 9:07case and what they should do next,
- 9:09right? Uh wrong answer, number two.
- 9:13It's not uh fully understanding the
- 9:16exhibit. You just
- 9:18show that you don't read charts very
- 9:20well.
- 9:21And
- 9:22that happens when you really don't
- 9:24understand the exhibit. So, in tables,
- 9:27sometimes you don't understand one or
- 9:29two terms, or even most of them. But you
- 9:32decide to speak about them anyway, you
- 9:34decide to kind of guess what that means
- 9:37because you can't [snorts] remain quiet,
- 9:39they've asked you a question, and you
- 9:41feel like asking what that means sounds
- 9:43bad. In charts, it's generally when you
- 9:45don't understand what the chart is. In
- 9:49consulting, that's it's fairly common to
- 9:51get really complicated charts that
- 9:53you're not used to seeing because they
- 9:55try to synthesize a lot of information
- 9:59in a single slide. And so, you might get
- 10:02charts with
- 10:04five or six different data sets for each
- 10:07data point, right? And so, things can
- 10:10get complicated. It's common to get a
- 10:12chart that you've never seen before. And
- 10:15if you don't fully understand it, then
- 10:17you're definitely going to screw up.
- 10:19It's not as common as the A is higher
- 10:21than B situation, but it's quite common.
- 10:24Wrong answer type number three is not
- 10:28having next steps. So, you do connect
- 10:32the exhibit to a hypothesis, and you do
- 10:35tell the interviewer what that means to
- 10:37the hypothesis, but you don't tell them
- 10:39what you do next based on that. This is
- 10:42not so bad as not connecting not as bad
- 10:44as not connecting the exhibit to the
- 10:48framework, but it makes you just miss
- 10:51such a great opportunity of being
- 10:53impressive. It's so easy to impress your
- 10:56interviewer just by simply adding what
- 10:59you would do next, that it's
- 11:01such a low-hanging fruit. It's something
- 11:03everyone should do.
- 11:04Because
- 11:05basically, I've said this a ton of
- 11:06times, and I'm going to say it another
- 11:08ton of times because this really should
- 11:11be inside your mind after you finish
- 11:13watching this video or this module, and
- 11:15that is
- 11:17these next steps is exactly where the
- 11:19consulting firm adds value. Even if
- 11:22you're giving next steps that are not
- 11:23the best, the interviewer is going to
- 11:26understand that you're someone who is
- 11:28biased towards action. You want to do
- 11:30something to solve that problem. And
- 11:33even if you're not doing the correct
- 11:35thing,
- 11:36they can teach you
- 11:37the exact right thing to do, but they're
- 11:40not necessarily able to teach you
- 11:42the attitude of always working towards
- 11:45solving the problem rather than just
- 11:47looking to the past. Now, if you feel
- 11:50like all of this is overwhelming, don't
- 11:52worry.
- 11:53I'm going to show you in a little bit a
- 11:55step-by-step process that will ensure
- 11:58that you can do this for any exhibit you
- 12:00get, even the most complicated and
- 12:02data-heavy ones.
- 12:04Now that you understand exactly what a
- 12:07chart interpretation question
- 12:10is, what it looks like, and what wrong
- 12:13answers sound like, and what they have,
- 12:16you can understand what exactly
- 12:18interviewers are looking for. Basically,
- 12:20they want to see that you can make
- 12:23conclusions from organized data.
- 12:25Only with this skill you can decide to
- 12:28create those charts in the first place,
- 12:31which is what you're going to be doing a
- 12:32lot of the time. So, if you can look at
- 12:35a chart and connect it to a hypothesis,
- 12:37then that also means that you can
- 12:40look at a hypothesis and connect to a
- 12:42chart. They're also testing this in
- 12:43other ways in the case interview, but
- 12:45this is one of the things that they're
- 12:47testing in this type of question. They
- 12:49also want to see that you're able to use
- 12:51data to decide something and to
- 12:55make conclusions. And you can use charts
- 12:58to communicate that data and to prove
- 13:00that your decision is right. And
- 13:03a lot of the work that a consulting firm
- 13:05does is not only
- 13:07deciding what is right for the client,
- 13:09but also proving to them that that
- 13:11decision is right. Many times the
- 13:14consulting firm is just hired to prove
- 13:16them that the decision that they do want
- 13:19to take is correct. So, you really need
- 13:21to be able to do that.
- 13:23Okay? And you want to show that that you
- 13:26understand the business problem and that
- 13:29you can draw conclusions directed to
- 13:31solving it, not just random conclusions
- 13:34given any data that you get. And that
- 13:37your conclusions are biased towards
- 13:38action, meaning
- 13:40you
- 13:42can know what something mean, but you
- 13:44can also know what you should do now.
- 13:48Right? And also, they're looking for
- 13:51someone who is able to read exhibits
- 13:54that they've never seen before, and they
- 13:56want to test that in you. And that's why
- 13:58you so often get exhibits that you've
- 14:00never seen before in case interviews. In
- 14:02consulting, that happens, I don't know,
- 14:04like twice a week you'll get a new
- 14:06exhibit. So, you really need to have
- 14:07this skill.
- 14:09Now, let me tell you three elements that
- 14:12a right answer must have.
- 14:15First, you must understand the entire
- 14:18exhibit.
- 14:19Keep in mind that a consultant will
- 14:21never talk about something if they don't
- 14:22understand the situation. So, they will
- 14:25ask questions about everything that they
- 14:27don't understand in an exhibit, and you
- 14:29are definitely expected to do the same
- 14:31in a case interview. They're going to
- 14:33ask questions, and so are you, about the
- 14:35labels, about the numbers, about the
- 14:37axes, about anything that they are not
- 14:39sure they understand.
- 14:41Second element is
- 14:44you can draw obvious and non-obvious
- 14:46[snorts]
- 14:47insights from an exhibit that you get
- 14:50that are all connected to the business
- 14:52situation.
- 14:53And third element,
- 14:55those insights are guided towards
- 14:57action. You don't only know the
- 14:59conclusion, you also know
- 15:01what should each part of the team and
- 15:04each department of the client do with
- 15:07this new information. What should they
- 15:10do now based on what we've learned? How
- 15:12should they act differently? Because you
- 15:15as a consultant are an
- 15:18agent of change. And if you're an agent
- 15:21of change, you must be able to say what
- 15:24will change based on the new
- 15:26information, right? And just so you
- 15:29know, you're going to get this type of
- 15:31question somewhere between
- 15:34in one every two cases and in every
- 15:36case. Of course, you don't have that
- 15:38many interviews. Even if you're doing
- 15:4110 or 15 interviews, there's a lot of
- 15:42variability in that. So, it could be
- 15:44anywhere in between those boundaries.
- 15:47Now, let's move on to the technique part
- 15:50of this video, cuz I think that's what
- 15:52everyone's looking forward to. I
- 15:53couldn't give you all of this before
- 15:55explaining to you the principles of this
- 15:58question, because honestly, if you have
- 16:00only the principles, you might already
- 16:02get everything right. But with these
- 16:04techniques, you're going to get a
- 16:06bulletproof system so that you can
- 16:09be impressive in every chart
- 16:11interpretation that you get. Because
- 16:14basically,
- 16:16chart interpretation questions are
- 16:17mostly easy to solve, but also very easy
- 16:22to be undersold in them. And if you
- 16:24master these techniques, you're not only
- 16:26going to solve all of the questions,
- 16:28even the tough ones, but you're also
- 16:30going to be impressive rather than
- 16:32undersold in the majority of them. And
- 16:34if you practice these techniques enough,
- 16:37you will have absolutely zero surprises.
- 16:39You'll be ready for any tough questions.
- 16:42And
- 16:43when your interviewer gives you a chart
- 16:46interpretation question, where they show
- 16:48you an exhibit, you're going to sigh in
- 16:50relief because you know that that's the
- 16:53moment where you differentiate where you
- 16:55set yourself apart from other
- 16:57candidates, because you know that
- 16:58everyone else is going to either not
- 17:00understand that exhibit, not be able to
- 17:02draw case-relevant conclusions from it,
- 17:05and not give next steps. But you're the
- 17:08different one. You're the one who's
- 17:09going to do all that. And
- 17:12that's what I'm going to teach you right
- 17:14now.
- 17:17Now, remember and keep in mind during
- 17:19all of this that your goal when
- 17:22interpreting charts is turning exhibits
- 17:26into action for the case that you're
- 17:28doing and for the client that you're
- 17:30serving, right? And remember that the
- 17:33principles behind this the single
- 17:35principle behind this is
- 17:37data-driven hypothesis testing.
- 17:40Data-driven means your actions must be
- 17:44based on the data that you're giving.
- 17:46The hypothesis part means that
- 17:49you should be able to connect that chart
- 17:52to the initial framework. And the
- 17:55testing part tells you that you should
- 17:57take a conclusion for it. So, you not
- 17:59only connected it to the hypothesis, but
- 18:01it's either saying
- 18:03go this way or go that way when it comes
- 18:05to that hypothesis.
- 18:08So, what are these four steps anyway?
- 18:11Here are the four steps. Step number
- 18:13one, mapping the territory. Step number
- 18:15two, reading the nuance. Step number
- 18:18three, reading the data. And step number
- 18:21four, interpreting the data.
- 18:24Before I get into what each one of those
- 18:27specifically means and how to do them
- 18:29and how to practice them, I want you to
- 18:31understand the logic behind this. What
- 18:33you're going to see is that we start
- 18:35with the metadata.
- 18:37In the first two steps, we forget about
- 18:39the data, and we only try to understand
- 18:42the structure of the chart and the
- 18:44details of the chart without looking at
- 18:47what the numbers actually say.
- 18:49And then we move on to the data on step
- 18:51number three, reading the data. But we
- 18:54don't want to do that like a fifth
- 18:56grader could, like this is larger than
- 18:59that or two times that. That any fifth
- 19:02grader could do that. And remember,
- 19:03we're emulating a consulting project
- 19:06here. So, we don't want to do fifth
- 19:08grader stuff only. And that's why we
- 19:10don't stop at the data, and we move on
- 19:13on step number four, interpreting the
- 19:15data, to
- 19:18the meanings of that data in the real
- 19:20world and what you and your team and
- 19:22your client should do based on that.
- 19:25Now, enough with this. Let's start with
- 19:27step number one, mapping the territory.
- 19:30What you're going to do is look at the
- 19:33chart, but forget the numbers. Imagine
- 19:36that chart completely empty. All right?
- 19:39Then you look at the axes, the
- 19:41information that they're giving you,
- 19:43and ask yourself,
- 19:45given these axes, given the type of data
- 19:48that this chart can tell me, what could
- 19:50it tell me? What information could it
- 19:53relay depending on what the data said?
- 19:56And you're going to get to several
- 19:58different
- 19:59many times, almost all the times,
- 20:02opposite answers cuz the chart can tell
- 20:04you, "This is a really good market. This
- 20:06is a really bad market." It's the same
- 20:08chart. The data is what's changing. The
- 20:10chart could tell you this business is
- 20:12thriving or this business is failing and
- 20:14it's the same chart. All that changes is
- 20:17the data. And so, that's what you want
- 20:18to ask yourself.
- 20:20And then you want to ask yourself, "What
- 20:22would this chart look like if it were
- 20:24going to tell you each one of those
- 20:26things?" So,
- 20:27if the chart says the business is
- 20:29failing, what does it look like? If the
- 20:30chart says the business is thriving,
- 20:32what does it look like? And what do
- 20:34these scenarios in the middle look like
- 20:36as well? And are there answers if there
- 20:38are two?
- 20:39All right?
- 20:40And this is mapping the territory. It's
- 20:44understanding what the chart would look
- 20:45like depending on what type of
- 20:47information it gave you.
- 20:49Just as a curiosity, this is the type of
- 20:52skill that consultants used when they
- 20:54created things like the BCG matrix.
- 20:57They'll look at a empty chart and say,
- 21:01"Points that are in this quadrant are
- 21:03cash cows." It's the skill of looking at
- 21:05an empty chart and understanding what it
- 21:09would look like if it were to tell you
- 21:11each of the possible answers that it
- 21:13could tell you.
- 21:15Now, let's move on to step two, reading
- 21:17the nuance.
- 21:19Most candidates are in such a rush to
- 21:22finish the interview that once they
- 21:24understand the axis, they look at the
- 21:26numbers and they start blurting out
- 21:28conclusions.
- 21:29And the problem is
- 21:31everything in an exhibit is there for a
- 21:34reason. The footnotes are there because
- 21:36they absolutely needed to be there. The
- 21:39labels, the legends, the colors,
- 21:41everything is there because they needed
- 21:43to be there for some reason. They are
- 21:45communicating something
- 21:47that is potentially important or it
- 21:50they're addressing an objection for the
- 21:51chart or something like that. And so,
- 21:54that's why you absolutely cannot ignore
- 21:56them and that's why step number two is a
- 21:59time that you'll take to specifically
- 22:01read the footnotes, read the legends,
- 22:03read the colors, the labels, read
- 22:05everything that's on the chart that's
- 22:07not necessarily the axis that you read
- 22:09on the previous step so that you be sure
- 22:13that you understand everything in it
- 22:15before you start talking about it. And
- 22:18this is going to keep you from making
- 22:20mistakes that the rookies will all make,
- 22:22which is taking conclusions based on
- 22:24data that they don't fully understand,
- 22:26and then, of course, making wrong
- 22:28conclusions.
- 22:29And this is something you must do before
- 22:32looking at the numbers at all because it
- 22:34might change the territories that you
- 22:37just mapped a little bit. Okay?
- 22:39And this is also the point where you're
- 22:42going to ask questions if you need to
- 22:45ask questions. This is another thing
- 22:47that trips up so many good candidates.
- 22:49There's a dichotomy here, right?
- 22:51Candidates are usually afraid to ask
- 22:54questions, so they talk with half-assed
- 22:56understanding of the terms and the
- 22:58jargons that are used in the chart.
- 23:00Consultants, on the other hand, are
- 23:02afraid to talk without understanding the
- 23:05terms because consultants are often
- 23:07talking to people that are more senior
- 23:09than them that have a long time in the
- 23:11industry.
- 23:12When they talk, if they don't fully
- 23:15understand the jargon that they're
- 23:16talking about or the that they're
- 23:19answering or the terms or acronyms,
- 23:22the other person can see it clearly. So,
- 23:25that makes talking about a term or a
- 23:28jargon without understanding it 10 times
- 23:30worse than asking what it means right
- 23:33away. And that's why consultants always
- 23:35ask before they talk if they don't
- 23:37understand. And that's also why they're
- 23:39going to judge you on whether you can
- 23:42ask questions to understand what you
- 23:44don't know.
- 23:45So, basically, the point I'm trying to
- 23:46say here is
- 23:47if you're not sure what a term or an
- 23:49acronym means when you see a chart, ask.
- 23:52Always ask. All right? Now, let's move
- 23:55on to step number three, reading the
- 23:57data. This is where things start getting
- 23:59cool.
- 24:01This step is basically what everyone
- 24:03thinks chart interpretation is all
- 24:05about. This is what everyone thinks the
- 24:07interviewer is looking for when they
- 24:08give you a chart. It's not, okay? It's
- 24:11absolutely necessary to do what they
- 24:14want, but it's not exactly what they're
- 24:16looking for. Basically, this step is
- 24:18reading the numbers in the chart. What
- 24:20do they tell you? Where do they fall in
- 24:22the territory that you mapped? You're
- 24:24going to start with the simple
- 24:25conclusions like A is greater than B.
- 24:28This line over here is going up. This
- 24:30line over here is going down. And then
- 24:32you can connect those simple conclusions
- 24:34like A is greater than B, but B grows a
- 24:37lot faster, so it will reach A in X
- 24:40years. There seems to be a correlation
- 24:42between this line going down, this line
- 24:44going up, and this might be the
- 24:45causation.
- 24:47And then, once you do that, you're going
- 24:48to make a bullet list next to the chart
- 24:51with those conclusions cuz this is going
- 24:53to be super [snorts] important for the
- 24:55next step, which is what the
- 24:57interviewers are really looking for.
- 24:59Now, most candidates stop here. They
- 25:02come up with these conclusions. They
- 25:04read charts like 5-year-olds, fifth
- 25:06graders,
- 25:07and interviewers will just roll their
- 25:09eyes at that because, of course, that's
- 25:12not what they wanted to see. That's
- 25:13something that they can see themselves.
- 25:15Anyone can see by themselves. And no
- 25:17client would hire a consultant for that.
- 25:20And so, this is where you're going to
- 25:22set yourself apart from the rookie
- 25:24candidates and this is where you'll
- 25:26start to do exactly what the interviewer
- 25:29wants you to do.
- 25:31And you're not going to do this by
- 25:33having a partner's mind inside a
- 25:34candidate's body. It's not magic. It's
- 25:37all about the technique. And now I'm
- 25:39going to show you exactly how to get to
- 25:41the best insights in a case in step
- 25:44four.
- 25:46Step number four is interpreting the
- 25:48data.
- 25:50This is when you start moving outside of
- 25:53the exhibit and inside the case and
- 25:55really start solving the problem that
- 25:58you got at hand.
- 25:59We're going to do this in two parts.
- 26:01Part number one is connecting those
- 26:04insights to the case and part number two
- 26:07is coming up with next steps based on
- 26:09that. All right? So, let's start with
- 26:13connecting that those insights to the
- 26:15framework. What you want to do right now
- 26:17is ask yourself how those insights that
- 26:20you came up with in the chart connect to
- 26:22the case question. Right? That bulleted
- 26:25list with what the data says, where does
- 26:28it go in the framework? In what
- 26:29direction does it point? What does it
- 26:31mean to the initial case question that
- 26:34we're dealing with? You're going to
- 26:35repeat those questions for each chart
- 26:38insight that you came up with.
- 26:40There's a almost mechanical way to do
- 26:42that. You're going to have to use your
- 26:44intelligence and creativity, sure, but
- 26:46you're also going to have a method
- 26:47behind you to make sure that you're in
- 26:49the right direction.
- 26:51First, you take your framework paper and
- 26:53you put it next to the chart paper where
- 26:56you drafted the list of insights. Now,
- 26:58of course, you must have a good
- 26:59framework behind you and you must have
- 27:02it right there with you. So, I highly
- 27:04encourage that before you start
- 27:05practicing with a chart interpretation
- 27:08question, you create the framework for
- 27:11the case at hand and keep it with you.
- 27:13All right? Now, after you have both
- 27:16pages,
- 27:17draw lines connecting the bullet list of
- 27:20insights to the framework issues that
- 27:22you raised. So, which questions are each
- 27:26of the chart insights answering? And
- 27:28what's the answer? Given this answer,
- 27:31what does it mean to the initial case
- 27:33question?
- 27:34Of course, all insights must mean
- 27:36something to the case. Otherwise, you
- 27:38can just cross them out. Either they are
- 27:40in your framework or they should be. And
- 27:42if they should be, then you just add
- 27:43them in there anyway. All right? And
- 27:46then, you can word those chart insights
- 27:49as answers to the questions of the
- 27:52framework.
- 27:53Now, this is what the interviewers are
- 27:55looking for. This is already going to
- 27:58place you in the top 1% in the skills
- 28:01that they're testing for in chart
- 28:02interpretation questions. So, once you
- 28:04get those insights regarding the case
- 28:08and not only the chart, you can already
- 28:10synthesize them and communicate them to
- 28:12the interviewer. But what I'm going to
- 28:13show you now is what you can do to go
- 28:16beyond and get the interviewers to fight
- 28:19for you, not only approve you in the
- 28:21case, but fight for you because they
- 28:24want you in their team right now. So,
- 28:26we're going to do now part two of step
- 28:28four, which is coming up with next
- 28:31steps.
- 28:32This is actually really simple to do if
- 28:35you've done the previous step correctly.
- 28:37Just basically, for each of the
- 28:41chart case-related insights that you
- 28:43created, state what you, your team, or
- 28:47your client should do based on this.
- 28:49Now, these conclusions could be
- 28:51finishing the branch of your framework
- 28:54that the insight is related to. Of
- 28:57course, you're not going to say finish
- 28:58this branch. You're going to say what
- 29:00actually needs to be done. That also
- 29:02could be closing that branch with a
- 29:04conclusion that you're going to state
- 29:05and then moving on to the next branch.
- 29:07And of course, you're also not going to
- 29:08say I'm moving on to the next branch.
- 29:10You're going to say what you're actually
- 29:12doing next.
- 29:13Sometimes, if the insights are not in
- 29:16your framework, but they're relevant,
- 29:17you're going to create an entire new
- 29:19branch and you're going to start working
- 29:21on it.
- 29:22And another possible conclusion is just
- 29:24closing the case and start moving on to
- 29:27execute. And then you should, of course,
- 29:29say
- 29:30what is the
- 29:31next thing that you would do in terms of
- 29:33execution.
- 29:35If the previous step is well done and
- 29:36your framework is in front of you, this
- 29:38is going to be obvious, right? If you
- 29:40know what the conclusions are to the
- 29:42case, then you're going to have a really
- 29:45easy time coming up with what exactly
- 29:48you should do next. But,
- 29:50this is not obvious to people who don't
- 29:53know that you can do this. And
- 29:56if consultants see you doing this,
- 29:59they're going to be super happy and
- 30:01they're going to feel like they're
- 30:02talking to another consultant because
- 30:03that's what they're doing every single
- 30:05day. They're taking a chart, they're
- 30:07interpreting it based on the case that
- 30:10they're getting, and they're coming up
- 30:12with what should I, the client, and my
- 30:14team do next based on this.
- 30:17This is such a simple step that I am
- 30:20going to be bold here and tell you to
- 30:22never ever not do this or screw this
- 30:25step or negative. Always do this every
- 30:27single chart interpretation question you
- 30:29get and analysis for that matter.
- 30:32Always come up with next steps after
- 30:34coming up with your chart with your
- 30:36case-related insight. Okay? Now, I'm
- 30:39going to show you a secret sauce that's
- 30:42going to make consultants in your
- 30:44interviewer ask you where you work in
- 30:47consulting before joining the firm
- 30:50because this is something that
- 30:51consultants do all the time when they
- 30:54speak and that other people who are not
- 30:57consultants usually don't. And that is
- 31:00quantifying your arguments.
- 31:03You know, there's one thing that is a
- 31:06pet peeve for all consultants in the
- 31:09world, probably. And that is when
- 31:11someone says a
- 31:14unquantified claim. So, the consultant's
- 31:17talking to a client and the client says,
- 31:19"Oh, this market is so much bigger."
- 31:21The consultant will instantly get
- 31:23annoyed and ask, "By how much? How much
- 31:26bigger?" They want to know if it's 50%
- 31:28larger or if it's 10 times larger or
- 31:322% larger.
- 31:33Consultants are inherently skeptical
- 31:36because when they're they're making
- 31:37their claims, when they're making their
- 31:39slides, when they're making their
- 31:41answers to the projects that they're
- 31:43working on, they can't make up numbers.
- 31:46So, they need to ask because they're
- 31:48going to use that somewhere and they're
- 31:50going to do math with that. So, they
- 31:51can't really work with just this market
- 31:54is bigger.
- 31:55So, when you're doing cases, always
- 31:58always always quantify your claim. This
- 32:00is going to get you a instant spot in
- 32:03your interviewer's heart. And honestly,
- 32:05they probably won't even know why cuz I
- 32:07don't think this is something that they
- 32:08are
- 32:09actively looking for and crossing boxes.
- 32:12They're This is just something that's
- 32:14going to make them feel like they're
- 32:16talking to one of their kind. So, the
- 32:18way you do this is you don't say A is
- 32:21larger than B, you say A is 30% larger
- 32:24than B. You don't say that B grows a lot
- 32:27more, you say that B grows twice or
- 32:30three times as much. Or even better,
- 32:32you'll say that B will reach A in X
- 32:35years, for example. So, that's how you
- 32:38quantify your claims and this is going
- 32:40to I guarantee this is going to get you
- 32:42a spot in your interviewer's heart when
- 32:44you do it. All right? Now, before I let
- 32:46you go from this video, I want to drop a
- 32:49quick few words on how to practice these
- 32:53steps.
- 32:54There are just a couple really important
- 32:56points that I want to drive home here.
- 32:58And they are first,
- 33:00you 100% depend on your framework. So,
- 33:03always make sure that you have next to
- 33:06you a high-quality framework for the
- 33:08next case that you're going to use for
- 33:10practice of
- 33:11chart interpretation questions. Right?
- 33:14Second, run these steps, these four
- 33:16steps, thoroughly even if it takes a
- 33:19while. Like if you have each drill is
- 33:21taking you 20 minutes, it doesn't
- 33:23matter. Remember, you're practicing like
- 33:26a pro athlete. You're practicing a skill
- 33:29that you don't necessarily have right
- 33:30now, but you want to develop. It's going
- 33:33to take longer at first, but you're
- 33:34going to get better with time. The
- 33:36principle we're following here is
- 33:38getting good before you get fast. The
- 33:42other path, getting fast before you get
- 33:44good, is just really not possible. Just
- 33:47look at any of the other skills you
- 33:49could learn. That's not how it's done.
- 33:51Now, it might take a while until they're
- 33:54internalized,
- 33:55but once these steps are internalized,
- 33:57you're going to be a top 1% candidate.
- 34:00What's going to happen is once you get
- 34:02an exhibit in a case, you're almost
- 34:05going to laugh in excitement because you
- 34:06know at that moment that you've got it.
- 34:10That is where you set yourself apart.
- 34:12That's where you get the benefit of the
- 34:15doubt from the interviewer even if
- 34:16you've made a couple of mistakes. That's
- 34:18when you get a spot in their heart and
- 34:20you get them to fight for you in their
- 34:23meeting to decide whether you go forward
- 34:25or not.
- 34:26All right, guys. This is it for this one
- 34:28video. I'm going to leave you right now
- 34:30to practice with the drills that are
- 34:32coming.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Case Interview Fundamentals: Lesson 35 [Chart Interpretation: the 4-step approach] by CraftingCases, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,723 words across 900 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.