Careers After ISB | Management Consulting @ McKinsey & Company — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, hope all is well. Welcome
- 0:02back to another episode of career
- 0:04conversations.
- 0:05Uh today we have Miss Rashi Muraka with
- 0:08us. Rashi has a CV uh which is as
- 0:13illustrious as it can get. She is a
- 0:16bachelor's of science graduate from LSR
- 0:18and then she worked with Bay & Company
- 0:21for broadly four years and then she went
- 0:25to complete her MBA from the Indian
- 0:27School of Business ISB and she is right
- 0:30now working with Mckenzie and company uh
- 0:32as a junior associate.
- 0:34So my first question to Rashi as part of
- 0:38this conversation which is careers after
- 0:41ISB in management consulting is um
- 0:46what was your CGP at ISB?
- 0:49[laughter]
- 0:50So um see I would say like for me
- 0:54personally I did stay concerned with my
- 0:57CGPA till the time you know it was
- 0:59getting considered in your uh resume
- 1:02reviews or rather like uh rum
- 1:04submissions and that time it was about
- 1:063.76
- 1:08>> um but post that like it did like vary a
- 1:12little so I would not want to disclose
- 1:14the final that's okay. [laughter] So,
- 1:17was it was it a part of the top 10th
- 1:19percentile cohort as we call it?
- 1:22>> No, it was not.
- 1:23>> Oh, wow. You still got a McKenzie short
- 1:25list?
- 1:26>> Yeah. Uh, sorry. Are you talking about
- 1:28the one before ré submissions or after?
- 1:30>> Before resume submission. Good, good,
- 1:32good catch.
- 1:33>> No, no, even before it was not
- 1:35>> Oh, wow.
- 1:37I was in fact like I would say that even
- 1:39during my entire prep time I had reached
- 1:42out to a lot of McKenzie folks who were
- 1:46already like who had already joined
- 1:47Mckenzie were just like one or two
- 1:49batches senior to me to understand
- 1:51typically you know what is it that they
- 1:53look for and what I was able to
- 1:56understand and this is a misconception
- 1:57that a lot of students have that you
- 1:59know if you are a fourpointer or if you
- 2:01are the top% you can actually make it uh
- 2:05But that is not the truth. Um, and
- 2:08having been associated with the firm as
- 2:10well for some time now, I can definitely
- 2:13say that it's more that they look at you
- 2:15holistically as you know from an
- 2:18academic standpoint as well. So it's not
- 2:20just that one single four-pointer that's
- 2:22going to make or break your case. Um
- 2:253.76 if you look at it very objectively,
- 2:27it is an above average score, right? So
- 2:29you're doing better than most of your
- 2:31peers and especially like if you compare
- 2:34it I mean year on year also like how the
- 2:36cohort is performing varies a lot but um
- 2:40>> like at least for the you know for our
- 2:42cohort like for the class of 23 the
- 2:44class before us there was some changes
- 2:47in the curriculum because of which a lot
- 2:48of people were able to score a 4.0 So it
- 2:51kind of diluted the value of a of 4
- 2:54CGPA.
- 2:55All of that being said, I would just say
- 2:57that yes, like if you have if you look
- 3:00at my background, right? Like with LSR
- 3:03in the picture with my um like 12th
- 3:07score, etc. That just showed consistency
- 3:10from an academic standpoint. So it was
- 3:12just about maintaining that instead of
- 3:15like you know being a top 10% student or
- 3:19anything of that.
- 3:21>> Interesting. Um so at ISB
- 3:26you I I was reading your uh experience
- 3:30section for ISB education section. So
- 3:32you were a part of the finance and
- 3:33governance psych council which is a part
- 3:35of the graduate student board and you
- 3:38did a proono consulting project which
- 3:40might be in cahoots with the net impact
- 3:42club.
- 3:45>> Yes that's good.
- 3:46>> Got it. Uh so you know a lot of people
- 3:51uh affiliate a consulting short list
- 3:53with a four on four GPA which you uh
- 3:56demystified for us and a lot of people
- 3:58say that you have to become the
- 4:00president or the vice president of a
- 4:02student club win a lot of case comps if
- 4:05you want to land a consulting short list
- 4:07at ISB. So is that entirely true?
- 4:13I would actually like I mean you bring
- 4:15up a really good point with both
- 4:16academics and positions and like one
- 4:18thing I definitely would like to
- 4:20emphasize on and this is a I would say a
- 4:23misconception that a lot of people hold
- 4:25during placements. what you do at ISB
- 4:28does not define what is going to happen
- 4:30during placements you know like even um
- 4:33prior to ISB uh leadership that you may
- 4:37have showcased even during your work
- 4:39experience right so it's it's like it's
- 4:41a factor of everything and that together
- 4:43kind of shows who you are so just being
- 4:46a president or vice president does not
- 4:48really have that great of an impact it's
- 4:50about what you do definitely like it
- 4:52adds to it like I would not take away
- 4:55the value of
- 4:56But that being said, it's not what you
- 4:59do at ISB that will guarantee you a
- 5:01position anywhere. It is also ISB plus
- 5:04everything that you've done before.
- 5:07>> Talking about everything that you've
- 5:08done before, I'm pretty sure you believe
- 5:10that your experience with Bane was
- 5:13instrumental in you getting a short list
- 5:16with Mckenzie. But since you've worked
- 5:18both
- 5:20uh let's say in the mid office or the
- 5:22back office with one consulting firm as
- 5:25well as the front office now with
- 5:26Mckenzie, what's the difference between
- 5:29a front- [snorts] end role and a backend
- 5:31role?
- 5:33>> Um so I think there are like a lot of
- 5:35differences for sure.
- 5:37>> Uh starting with I would say your
- 5:40contribution
- 5:41>> like that would be the very first thing
- 5:43that I would probably like to highlight.
- 5:46um both in terms of how you are working
- 5:49right like in a front- end consulting it
- 5:51is a lot more of an individual
- 5:53contributor role where even though
- 5:56you're working in like small teams of
- 5:58three or four people there is an entire
- 6:00end to-end work stream that you would be
- 6:02uh like you know responsible for versus
- 6:05in a backend or a mid- office setup
- 6:06where an entire team is working on the
- 6:09same work stream so there's a lot of
- 6:11like cross collaboration and rather I
- 6:13would say um team effort that goes into
- 6:17that kind of a work. So that in itself
- 6:20is a very very big difference because
- 6:21the ownership is a lot higher like even
- 6:25with like no matter what your position
- 6:26is right like no matter how senior
- 6:28junior you are in the firm your
- 6:31ownership is extremely high
- 6:33>> and second is also the kind of work that
- 6:35you're doing. So as like there is uh
- 6:38very you know like this term that's very
- 6:40commonly used the blue sky thinking that
- 6:43is something where you need to come up
- 6:44with the solution for anything out of
- 6:46the blue right like you you it's there
- 6:48is no defined path that you can take uh
- 6:52for a lot of problems. So that is a
- 6:54skill set that definitely gets developed
- 6:57in front-end consulting a lot more than
- 6:59it does in mid office because mid office
- 7:01again like the at the structure is more
- 7:05specialization focused where you are
- 7:08working on very defined like slightly
- 7:11repetitive problem statements. You know
- 7:14what you have to do, how you want to go
- 7:15about it and there are consultants who
- 7:17have kind of structured that for you. M
- 7:20>> that is a very big difference like for
- 7:22us like at least for mid office there is
- 7:24already an interface of consultants who
- 7:27are putting that problems like you know
- 7:29they're putting their problem solving
- 7:30skills into place and structuring the
- 7:32ask to you versus us where clients are
- 7:35coming to us without any kind of
- 7:38structure you know just a vague ask and
- 7:40we are the ones who are putting it into
- 7:44>> very interesting and let me ask you a
- 7:47controversial question now do you think
- 7:49you needed an ISB MBA to pivot to
- 7:52front-end consulting.
- 7:55>> Um see there I would say it's um it
- 7:59entirely depends on where you were
- 8:01preisp. So for example Bane at least
- 8:05they do give opportunity to people who
- 8:08have been a part of Bane capability
- 8:10network for some time
- 8:12>> to you know through like an official
- 8:13route that they have where they let you
- 8:15pivot to the front end but that is only
- 8:18if you are in already like a company
- 8:20like Bane
- 8:21>> it does not mean that you know you're in
- 8:22an industry role and then you get to
- 8:24automatically get picked up for a
- 8:26front-end consulting role so I would say
- 8:29pivoting does become difficult and
- 8:32having worked in front end I also
- 8:33understand why like the like if as
- 8:37somebody who as you mentioned right like
- 8:39I'm a BSE statistics honor graduate so
- 8:43um theoretically speaking I don't I did
- 8:46not at least before ISB have like that
- 8:49theoretical understanding even of a lot
- 8:51of things that go together you know for
- 8:54you to holistically understand how a
- 8:55business works
- 8:56>> so I think that lack of knowledge is
- 8:59something or rather
- 9:01Knowing that through ISB is something
- 9:03that has definitely helped me perform
- 9:05better
- 9:06>> uh you know in front end consulting
- 9:09looking at things more holistically.
- 9:10>> Got it. And uh consulting interviews
- 9:14talking about them. Any major difference
- 9:16in a consulting interview for an
- 9:18undergrad student
- 9:20uh and a B school student? I mean the
- 9:23gueststimates and the case interviews
- 9:25the broad construct remains the same.
- 9:28one difficult one one difference would
- 9:30definitely be difficulty but anything
- 9:32else barring that
- 9:34>> I mean definitely like I mean the
- 9:37typical your case interviews
- 9:38gueststimates they do remain the same
- 9:40but what gets added on
- 9:42>> is behavioral questions right like they
- 9:44also they they do see what you have done
- 9:47like from an undergrad the expectation
- 9:49would be a lot less
- 9:51>> um in terms of what they have done
- 9:53because obviously they've not had very
- 9:54formal experiences one or two internship
- 9:57ships at max and whatever leadership
- 10:00exposure they've had they've had it in
- 10:01college probably through some societies
- 10:04but um once you've worked that gets
- 10:08added on right like so there there are
- 10:10also skills that you've acquired through
- 10:11work
- 10:12>> which will be which you will be tested
- 10:15on
- 10:16>> during these interviews so I would say
- 10:18like that is definitely an add-on uh
- 10:20factor while assessing a candidate
- 10:23>> got it and McKenzie versus Bane any
- 10:26differences in terms of work life,
- 10:28quality of work, anything else.
- 10:31>> Um, I would say it's comparing apples to
- 10:34oranges here because I No, hear me out
- 10:38on [laughter] this. So, um, if you were
- 10:41to ask me between Mckenzie front end and
- 10:43Bane front end, right, then then
- 10:45definitely I can comment on it. But I
- 10:47also thought about this like a lot when
- 10:50I like when I had initially joined. And
- 10:52it's actually not very easy to compare
- 10:54because BCN at least is global facing
- 10:59>> there are you are working with
- 11:00international like you know consulting
- 11:02teams global consulting teams and I mean
- 11:06the nature of work the expectation
- 11:08everything is so much more different
- 11:10than what a front-end team working with
- 11:12a lot of Indian clients would do. So I I
- 11:15feel that it I mean maybe like a Bane
- 11:18consulting front-end consulting would be
- 11:20very similar to a Mckenzie front end
- 11:21consulting or an MCKC might be very
- 11:23similar to a Bane BCN setup, right? But
- 11:26these two not exactly comparable for
- 11:29from a perspective of work life or
- 11:32expectations because they're very
- 11:33different entities in their own self.
- 11:36>> Got it. And uh if I ask you if I
- 11:40rephrase my question and ask you
- 11:42Mckenzie front end versus Bane front end
- 11:45any difference
- 11:48>> not I mean again like not having worked
- 11:50with Bane front end it's again difficult
- 11:53for me to comment like had I been in
- 11:54that situation and I always like believe
- 11:56this personally that everybody has a
- 11:59different experience even in the same
- 12:01place right so I do not want to comment
- 12:04on it based on whatever hearsay like you
- 12:06know based
- 12:07>> [clears throat]
- 12:08>> who are currently in front
- 12:12but yeah I mean journey it's been a
- 12:16journey for me for sure
- 12:18>> got it any skills that you cultivated
- 12:21after getting into consulting be it at
- 12:23Bane or Mckenzie which you in hindsight
- 12:26believe would have been easier to
- 12:28cultivate in college or in ISB if you
- 12:32had learned those skills beforehand
- 12:35>> understood
- 12:36Yeah, I think um so my journey at least
- 12:40at Bane was a very very um um I mean
- 12:44like the learning was extremely steep
- 12:46there and the the reason for that was
- 12:49like very basic skills like Excel skills
- 12:52um PPD making skills right these were
- 12:54some things that I had not at all like
- 12:57learned well at least when I was in
- 13:00college and initially I think I
- 13:02struggled a bit but on the job like
- 13:04whatever I know today is like I would
- 13:07owe it all to wait because I learned
- 13:10everything that I learned over there. So
- 13:12if somebody wish to apply, I would just
- 13:14say it helps you for sure. Like I mean
- 13:17there is a very nurturing environment in
- 13:19the company and people do understand
- 13:21that you you're a fresher out of college
- 13:22and you know you might not know
- 13:24everything um right off the bat but um I
- 13:28I would just suggest that definitely if
- 13:30you do know some things beforehand like
- 13:32it helps it helps you uh feel more
- 13:35confident when you're you know starting
- 13:37your journey
- 13:38>> and um
- 13:40>> yeah I think other than that like um I
- 13:42would just say participating
- 13:45Um even at ISB I would say just like
- 13:47participating in case competitions and
- 13:49all not because um you know you need it
- 13:51on your CV but it just helps with
- 13:54thinking in the way that you would once
- 13:56you even join when once you're at
- 13:58workplace right like you're thinking
- 13:59about problem statements you're
- 14:00discussing with colleagues you're taking
- 14:02ownership of something within you know
- 14:04the different solutions that you guys
- 14:06are coming up with so just like that it
- 14:08just helps you get a sense of how life
- 14:11would be once you join consulting and
- 14:14that is is the uh another thing that I
- 14:16would say but yeah I mean definitely
- 14:18like there's a lot of learning on the
- 14:20job as well that happens and u it's very
- 14:23difficult to do all of that before you
- 14:26join I mean then what is even the point
- 14:27right
- 14:28>> exactly [laughter]
- 14:29>> working
- 14:30>> understood and last question from my
- 14:32side uh anything about ISB that an
- 14:37outsider
- 14:38would not know be it life at ISB or
- 14:42careers after ISB two things.
- 14:45>> Okay. Um
- 14:48I would have to think about this one a
- 14:50little bit
- 14:50>> that only an alam or a student will
- 14:53know.
- 14:55>> I think again like um I I would like I
- 15:00mean this is probably me repeating
- 15:02myself
- 15:03>> but uh when you join ISB right like one
- 15:08I would say like this is just a takeaway
- 15:09for me personally.
- 15:12I would just say be a little bit more
- 15:14realistic in your expectations
- 15:16uh when you join ISB about what will be
- 15:19life afterwards. Like I personally feel
- 15:22that a lot of people felt slightly
- 15:25disappointed after you know their
- 15:27journey at ISB whenever they joined
- 15:29their first job and I feel that also
- 15:31came from a lot of expectations uh about
- 15:33how life would just suddenly become um
- 15:36amazing you know and you would be like
- 15:39um
- 15:40>> you will be picking out from like
- 15:42multiple
- 15:44you know opportunities but that is not
- 15:46true like it takes time it is a
- 15:48long-term investment that you're
- 15:50And second, as I just mentioned earlier
- 15:52as well, right? Like please do not think
- 15:54that everything you do at ISB defines
- 15:57your future completely. There is a lot
- 15:59of things that you have done before. So
- 16:01that holds true for both both those
- 16:04instances where you know you become
- 16:05overconfident because of some things
- 16:06that you've achieved at ISB
- 16:08>> or you become underconfident because you
- 16:10feel like you're lagging behind from
- 16:12your peers and and kind of discount what
- 16:14you've done before. So I would say like
- 16:17these are the thing few things that I
- 16:18would just say like mentally to prepare
- 16:20yourself for that entire journey at
- 16:22least the placement times which is any
- 16:23which way stressful right um it's
- 16:26important that you keep that in mind
- 16:28>> so a follow up on that a lot of people
- 16:30say that broadly 60% of ISB the the
- 16:34recent grads 60% of them changed their
- 16:36first job within 6 months of graduating
- 16:39which you also alluded to
- 16:42>> the reason for that frustration or
- 16:44change Is is their salary expectation
- 16:48not met or are they looking to get a
- 16:51better work life balance somewhere else?
- 16:55I think as I said again right like you
- 16:59if you start with like a very high
- 17:01expectation of a jump
- 17:03>> and see like whoever you're competing
- 17:06with on campus everybody has that ISB
- 17:09tag so whatates you right like it it's
- 17:12whatever you've done in the past
- 17:14>> and that is why like I think those
- 17:16expectations not being met in the first
- 17:18job
- 17:19>> lead you to feeling a little
- 17:21disappointed and then and I've also seen
- 17:23instances where people have just gone
- 17:25back to their original like the job that
- 17:27they had before ISP and that's happening
- 17:29with a lot of my friends right now. So I
- 17:31I feel that that is just a factor of
- 17:33this only that expectations not being
- 17:36met and coming with very high
- 17:38expectations to begin with. Uh so I
- 17:41think that that if people just kind of
- 17:43like mentally tune themselves to um you
- 17:46know uh not feel like they're being led
- 17:51down a path that uh they had a lot of
- 17:54hopes from
- 17:54>> and I think once you are applying off
- 17:57campus you are only so your ISB brand
- 18:00and tag really matters a lot there
- 18:01because not everybody else who who you
- 18:04are competing with off campus or
- 18:06laterally will have that tag. So your
- 18:09mobility to switch to a better role or a
- 18:12better package or a better positional
- 18:14responsibility is much higher.
- 18:17>> Yeah. I think there I think it's not
- 18:19just the tag. I'll tell you why what I
- 18:22feel is B really helps with is and if
- 18:25you I I I mean I don't know if you agree
- 18:27with this fact or not but when you're
- 18:29applying for any job right like there
- 18:32are a lot of portals that you can apply
- 18:34through
- 18:34>> but um having an in that firm somebody
- 18:39putting a referral for you putting in a
- 18:40name for you matters a lot it improve it
- 18:43it increases your chances by a lot and
- 18:46that is what ISB does you know that kind
- 18:48of a network that you get of people who
- 18:50are already placed in companies that you
- 18:52would be interested in and willing to
- 18:54help out a fellow ISBN. That is where
- 18:57the tag comes in is what my thinking is
- 19:00rather than the tag itself.
- 19:01>> Got it. Awesome. And thank you so much
- 19:04for this uh very insightful conversation
- 19:08and I'm 100% sure that this will help
- 19:10all ISB and consulting aspirants.
- 19:13>> Yeah, happy to help.
- 19:15>> Awesome. Thank you. Take care.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Careers After ISB | Management Consulting @ McKinsey & Company by Sarthak Verma, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,308 words across 484 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.