Careers After ISB | Management Consulting @ BCG — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, welcome back to the
- 0:01channel as part of our uh career
- 0:04conversations that we uh keep hosting
- 0:07for all of you every now and then. Today
- 0:09we have uh someone who is uh who has
- 0:13spent broadly three and a half years in
- 0:15management consulting. We have Mr. Weber
- 0:18Dingra today with us. Weber completed
- 0:21his bachelor's from Punjab Engineering
- 0:23College. He then worked with Amazon as
- 0:27an area manager. Then he came to do his
- 0:29MBA from ISB Indian School of Business
- 0:32and then he worked with Nestle in uh as
- 0:35a management traininee and uh in the
- 0:37demand planning team for broadly 2
- 0:40years. Then he switched to BCG where he
- 0:43joined as a senior associate. Then he
- 0:45was promoted to become a consultant and
- 0:47right now he is a project leader. So he
- 0:50has spent 3 years 7 months with BCG. So
- 0:54my first question to you Weber is can
- 0:56you help us understand your day-to-day
- 1:00via a project that you have recently
- 1:02completed.
- 1:04>> Mhm. First of all thanks for the
- 1:05introductions Saruk.
- 1:07>> I did not know that you have researched
- 1:08me so well to the to the point of saying
- 1:11that 3 years 7 months I had not
- 1:12calculated that in my own head.
- 1:14>> Yeah but uh thanks for the
- 1:16introductions. Uh to answer your
- 1:18question um currently uh I'm a project
- 1:20leader at PCG right. So uh a typical day
- 1:24would look different compared to when I
- 1:27was a consultant 6 months back. Uh so
- 1:30let me actually answer from my current
- 1:32work perspective which is the project
- 1:34leader role and then I'll also give you
- 1:36uh some idea about how a deal would look
- 1:39like if you are a typical consultant or
- 1:40a senior consultant at BCG or uh any
- 1:43similar firm. Right.
- 1:44>> Sure. So for me uh I am my my work
- 1:48currently is with a US-based IT services
- 1:51client right uh it's sort of an
- 1:55exception because we have to travel to
- 1:58the client location in US so because of
- 2:00that uh we don't have to travel weekly
- 2:03as you would imagine because we we stay
- 2:04in India I stay in in New Delhi uh but
- 2:08of course it it is a proper management
- 2:11consulting role wherein you have to be
- 2:13very hands-on with the client
- 2:15So I have typically a lot lot of lot
- 2:17lots of lots of calls right and uh my
- 2:20day is a little skewed compared to when
- 2:22I was doing a project back in India. Of
- 2:24course you have to do all sorts of
- 2:25projects.
- 2:26>> Uh so a typical day for me starts with a
- 2:30check-in with my team. So I have about
- 2:32three people reporting into me. So uh we
- 2:34start a little late in the day because
- 2:36we end a little late in the day given
- 2:38the timings with the US client. So we
- 2:40start at about 11:00. uh we have a
- 2:43check-in at 11:00. Uh we have a 30-inut
- 2:45roundup meeting wherein all the three
- 2:47members present the priorities of the
- 2:49day. It's not a very formal meeting and
- 2:51that also depends upon your personal
- 2:53style of working. Some people prefer it
- 2:55a very uh formal meeting with with some
- 2:58uh screen shared and some content being
- 3:00shared. I don't personally prefer that
- 3:02for content purposes. I plan one-on ones
- 3:05with my teams which is throughout the
- 3:07day. But in the check-in call, I just
- 3:09want to understand where we are headed.
- 3:10If our directions are aligned, if our
- 3:12priorities are aligned. So each of the
- 3:14three reporties align their priorities
- 3:16with me. Then I sort of give my inputs
- 3:18on those and rep prioritize those for
- 3:20them. At 11:30 we get into deep work. Uh
- 3:23I always prioritize and focus deep work
- 3:26with my team. So it's like 11:30 to 1:30
- 3:29or 2 is is deep work time for my team
- 3:31and myself. For me it's more about
- 3:33reviewing the content which which my
- 3:35team has already prepared uh the day
- 3:38before uh or any any uh sorry I in fact
- 3:41missed one thing. So essentially after
- 3:43my check-in um I also wind up some of my
- 3:46emails that I have to clear from the
- 3:49last day. Uh and in fact sometimes of
- 3:51course I'm a PL so I have to start
- 3:53earlier than the team. So before my
- 3:55check-in at 11, I probably spend either
- 3:57while I'm traveling, commuting to work
- 3:59or maybe early in the morning um at my
- 4:02own house. Uh I check my emails and
- 4:04clear all the client related urgent
- 4:06emails in the first 30 minutes or 1 hour
- 4:08of the day. Uh and that actually helps
- 4:10me rep prioritize when I give the inputs
- 4:12to to my team at 11:00. And then of
- 4:14course there is there is some bit of a
- 4:16backlog in terms of client
- 4:17communications which I uh then complete
- 4:20in my deep work session from 11:30 to 1
- 4:231:30 and also review some of the content
- 4:26made by by team. Then about 1:30 or two
- 4:29we break for about 30 minutes of lunch.
- 4:31I also promote like uh a very active
- 4:35lunch session with my team wherein we we
- 4:37we chat we we sort of refresh uh of
- 4:40after lunch then we have some focus
- 4:42sessions. I I connect with my team
- 4:43members one-on-one with each of them. I
- 4:45have like a longer one one and a half
- 4:47hour working session to give them a
- 4:49detailed input on whatever modules that
- 4:51they're working on. So that brings me to
- 4:54let's say about 5 5:30 p.m. of of active
- 4:56engagement. Then again at about 5 to
- 4:595:30 p.m. I take another 1 to 2 hours of
- 5:02deep work. Uh maybe take a coffee at
- 5:04around that time. uh and then as soon as
- 5:07it the clock hits 7:00 p.m. we have to
- 5:09gear up for u the calls with the clients
- 5:12right uh in fact sometimes the clients
- 5:14if there there are some clients on the
- 5:15east coast of US we might be able to
- 5:18start in like 6:30 p.m. India time which
- 5:20is for an east coast person that's like
- 5:228:00 a.m. or 9:00 a.m. But for for the
- 5:25clients in the west of course we have to
- 5:26take calls late in the night. So,
- 5:28usually around 6:30, 7:00 p.m. I take my
- 5:30calls. Uh, I take about 2 to three calls
- 5:33uh till about 9:00 p.m. Uh, then about 9
- 5:35to 9:30 p.m. I uh use that time to
- 5:38travel back home. Uh, in my travel, I I
- 5:41I just connect with my family. Uh, and
- 5:44maybe after getting back home, I have my
- 5:47meal and then again get back on work,
- 5:49right? We we can't end the day early.
- 5:51Uh, 10:00 p.m. I get back to work. Then
- 5:53about 10 to 12 p.m. 12 10:00 p.m. to
- 5:5712:00 a.m. I do another set of round of
- 5:59calls with my clients. And then about
- 6:01midnight uh it's supposedly a closing
- 6:04hour. We we try to close the day at
- 6:05midnight at least for the team. But of
- 6:07course there's always some client
- 6:08requests urgently coming up. So you need
- 6:10to turn around something. So like about
- 6:1312 to 1 is the buffer time. But yeah, I
- 6:15I usually close my days at about 1:00
- 6:16a.m. Uh catch myself some some quick
- 6:20episode come some show or just some
- 6:23online scrolling or whatever I like last
- 6:2530 minutes of the day. Sometimes reading
- 6:27I I try to be healthier with my um with
- 6:30with my hobbies and yeah so I then end
- 6:33the day at about 1:30 and then of course
- 6:36about 6 to 7 hours of sleep get up at 8
- 6:389 and yeah the I have I love lazy
- 6:42mornings by the way. So I started my day
- 6:44day from 11:00 but I am able to start my
- 6:46day from 11:00 because I get up early
- 6:48and enjoy maybe 1 to two hours of lazy
- 6:50morning getting ready very slowly for
- 6:52work. Uh that makes me less anxious and
- 6:56uh that actually helps me to uh do work
- 6:59very efficiently throughout the day. So
- 7:00yeah so very detailed answer but I hope
- 7:03this will actually uh useful for for
- 7:06someone listening and wanting to plan
- 7:08their day.
- 7:09>> Definitely. And tell me something. This
- 7:11might be a controversial question, so
- 7:13you can choose not to answer. Can you So
- 7:16there are tons and tons of Reddit post
- 7:18and YouTube videos, but as someone as
- 7:20someone who's on the inside,
- 7:22>> can you help me understand what are the
- 7:24pay packages that someone can expect in
- 7:26management consulting right from right
- 7:28from let's say when they're hired as a
- 7:30senior associate out of business school
- 7:32to the point when they become a partner
- 7:34in BCG India.
- 7:36>> Okay. So yeah, I mean I'm also not very
- 7:38well versed with the exact ranges,
- 7:40right? They they keep on revising. Uh
- 7:42but yeah, my estimate is that if if you
- 7:45talk about an entry- level senior
- 7:47associate level one, uh I think
- 7:50currently the base starts from somewhere
- 7:52around 30 to 35 and with your variables,
- 7:54you can reach up to 40.
- 7:57>> Then for a consultant level, I think the
- 8:00base is somewhere around the 45 to 50
- 8:03mark. And with your uh good bonuses, if
- 8:05you are a good performer, you can reach
- 8:08somewhere between 55 to 60, maybe
- 8:10sometimes more than 60.
- 8:12>> Uh then as a senior consultant, like if
- 8:14you're a consultant too, then that in
- 8:16fact you have very high bonus component.
- 8:18So that might even reach 70.
- 8:20>> Um then at a project leader level, your
- 8:23base starts somewhere between 65 to 70
- 8:26lakhs peranom. And of course bonuses is
- 8:30there there's a lot of ranges to the
- 8:31bonus associated with that. But I think
- 8:34an entry- level project leader is use is
- 8:37usually an average performer is able to
- 8:39make at least uh 15 to 20 lakhs of
- 8:42bonus. Uh and that helps the person
- 8:44reach about like a CTC annual CTC of
- 8:46about 80 to 90 right for entry and for
- 8:49an entry- levelvel average performing uh
- 8:53project leader. uh if it's like a good
- 8:55performance and if it's like the best
- 8:57ratings as an entry- level project
- 8:59leader you can touch uh a CR
- 9:02>> and uh then of course from project level
- 9:05leader level it it goes on to principal
- 9:07from principal to partner and then MDPs
- 9:09right so the progression from princip
- 9:11from a project leader the ranges that I
- 9:12gave to you even I'm not aware of the
- 9:14exact of that but what I can broadly
- 9:16speak is that uh the increment uh is is
- 9:20not insanely high when you once so the
- 9:22most high increments is in first few
- 9:24stages right from a senior associate to
- 9:26consultant and consultant to PL
- 9:27>> from PL to
- 9:29>> principal and from principal to partner
- 9:32is maybe like a 10 to 15% raise
- 9:34>> and uh then the next major and a very
- 9:37major jump comes when you become an MDP
- 9:39which is the the actual gold post for a
- 9:42lot of people in consulting right and
- 9:44over there I would feel that of course
- 9:47it it all depends upon the amount of uh
- 9:49cases that you're able to sell the deal
- 9:52that you're able to sell but Yeah, I
- 9:53don't think an entry- level partner
- 9:56would definitely be making an excess of
- 9:582C cr if if he or she is is is doing the
- 10:01the targets well.
- 10:02>> Wow. And all these stages that you
- 10:05talked about typically come after one
- 10:07and a half years of tenure in a
- 10:09particular hierarchical level.
- 10:11>> Yeah. Yeah. About about two years is is
- 10:13I think the the benchmark. If you are a
- 10:15great performer, maybe a few months
- 10:17less, sometimes a little maybe 3 to six
- 10:20months more, but yeah, an average is
- 10:22about two years. Got it. And uh tell me
- 10:24more about BCG interviews. How many
- 10:27interview rounds happen? Is it more
- 10:29difficult to crack it as compared to the
- 10:31other two uh contemporaries of MBB or is
- 10:34it easier? And how did you prepare?
- 10:37>> See, I uh I would not be very sure about
- 10:40the comparison with the contemporaries,
- 10:42but I do feel that the process uh at BCG
- 10:46India for hiring is very structured and
- 10:48streamlined for one, right?
- 10:50uh and in fact it has been getting
- 10:52better and better over the time right
- 10:53for my own if if I take my own example
- 10:56uh I entered BCG laterally which is
- 10:59never easy in any of the top consulting
- 11:01firms right so the campus procedure all
- 11:04of us would be aware that it's a very
- 11:05streamlined structured process wherein
- 11:07on one particular day you have two to
- 11:09four rounds of interviews and then you
- 11:11get in right but uh let me actually
- 11:13speak more about the lateral process I I
- 11:15can definitely say that uh in lateral
- 11:18process compared to the contemporaries
- 11:20the BCG process is much more structured
- 11:23and streamlined for me end to end the
- 11:25process as a lateral was completed
- 11:27within a month less than a month I would
- 11:29say right and this is considering all
- 11:31the MD like I had four rounds of
- 11:33interviews right and all those four
- 11:34rounds of interviews uh were sort of
- 11:37completed within let's say about 15 days
- 11:39and all the decision and all all the
- 11:41formalities uh in fact even before there
- 11:45are a few days of time before your first
- 11:47interview so I think end to And it took
- 11:49me less than a month which is uh great
- 11:51in fact probably even less than a month.
- 11:54I think it was probably 25 days right so
- 11:56very structured streamlined process and
- 11:58the other thing is that uh BCG is also
- 12:03valuing a lot of people who have some
- 12:05expertise in a particular industry like
- 12:07I think I was able to get into BCG
- 12:09because I could demonstrate my rich
- 12:11experience in my early stages of career
- 12:14uh in the e-commerce and the consumer
- 12:16goods sector right
- 12:18>> so I feel that that really worked in my
- 12:21favor because people have that
- 12:23conception that for the interview
- 12:25process some of the top consulting firms
- 12:27just want raw talent people who have not
- 12:30really worked for a long time in the
- 12:32industries but this this this is a
- 12:34misconception I feel uh consult top
- 12:37consulting firms still do want you to
- 12:39join the firm young because that's
- 12:41that's a stage wherein you can
- 12:42contribute the best you have a sharper
- 12:45mind and then you have all the vigor and
- 12:47the energy to work like a like like like
- 12:50a 25 year old uh kid in the blog who's
- 12:54very enthusiastic. But uh having said
- 12:56that the in consulting industry and the
- 12:59top consulting firms like BCG are also
- 13:02now more and more valuing more and more
- 13:04your experience right and if you have
- 13:06like a good rich experience in the first
- 13:08three to four years of your career
- 13:10before consulting I think that's sort of
- 13:12uh a very good spot to be in right
- 13:15>> so yeah to to again summarize your
- 13:17answer uh I am definitely a fan of the
- 13:20BCG recruitment process uh and uh I
- 13:23genuinely believe that the process
- 13:24process is better than the other firms.
- 13:27>> Got it. But number of rounds were three
- 13:28or four.
- 13:30>> For me, in the lateral process, there
- 13:31were four rounds.
- 13:33>> Uh but actually it varies, right?
- 13:35>> The least number of rounds that I've
- 13:37ever heard of in a lateral setup is
- 13:39maybe three.
- 13:40>> The most is maybe five, right?
- 13:42>> Wow.
- 13:43>> So I don't think people go beyond five
- 13:46or less.
- 13:47>> So yeah, about four is an average.
- 13:49>> Got it. And this would be a mix of
- 13:51guesstimates, cases, uh, and everything
- 13:54in between.
- 13:55>> That that is correct. Yes.
- 13:57>> Now, let me ask you a very nuanced
- 13:59question. You have spent broadly one and
- 14:00a half years with Nestle and you've done
- 14:03a bunch of demand forecasting with them
- 14:05specifically for Maggie.
- 14:06>> Now, just to just to help others
- 14:08understand uh the difference between uh
- 14:11a general management role in a
- 14:13conglomerate versus a strategy
- 14:15consulting role. If I ask you that okay
- 14:18in Nestle you were doing uh demand
- 14:20forecasting for an FMCG for a consumer
- 14:23goods conglomerate.
- 14:24>> Y
- 14:25>> and how would Nestle react or how would
- 14:29Nestle operate if instead of giving it
- 14:31to you they have hired BCG to handle the
- 14:35same demand forecasting problem? Would
- 14:37the BCG consultant's work who's an
- 14:40outsider
- 14:41>> versus your work as an insider when you
- 14:43were in SLA in demand forecasting would
- 14:45that be identical?
- 14:47>> That would never be identical and I'll
- 14:49tell you why. Right? And and I'm not
- 14:51saying that one is better than the
- 14:52other. So let let that be the biggest
- 14:54disclaimer before my answer comes in.
- 14:56Right? M
- 14:56>> so when you're in the industry you have
- 14:58to think more from a day-to-day basis
- 15:01and a more operational
- 15:04lens of taking things forward and doing
- 15:06it on a day-to-day basis right
- 15:08>> when you are a consultant your biggest
- 15:10goal is to set up that process right and
- 15:12set up the the process in the best way
- 15:14possible so that a person who is working
- 15:16in the industry in that role can take
- 15:18that forward right
- 15:19>> and in fact I give you an example of
- 15:22>> my time at Nestle uh I'm for for some
- 15:26reasons I would not be able to name the
- 15:27consultant but while I was working with
- 15:30Nestle when Nestle had hired one of the
- 15:32consulting firms to do a project in the
- 15:34demand planning function right now that
- 15:36project was simply geared towards
- 15:39upgrading or modernizing
- 15:42uh the systems and the tools that were
- 15:44required to do demand planning estimates
- 15:46right
- 15:47>> stuff like if traditionally the demand
- 15:49planning was used using some methodology
- 15:52but that methodology was plugged in into
- 15:54detailed macro enabled Excel models. Now
- 15:57you just take those macro enabled Excel
- 15:58models to to to the cloud and have have
- 16:02like a software or or uh some processes
- 16:06some more structured cloud-based
- 16:08subscriptions around it. Right.
- 16:09>> Very true.
- 16:10>> So that's that's the work of a
- 16:11consultant and maybe this in this
- 16:13example this is more of not not exactly
- 16:15a strategy work. So that was doing it
- 16:18actually was more of an implementation
- 16:20consultant not one of the top three
- 16:23consulting firms in strategy. However,
- 16:25still the the idea is that me in the
- 16:28demand planning role, I was doing almost
- 16:31the same thing but with that consulting
- 16:33firm coming and helping us, they just
- 16:35made my job easier, right? So, that is
- 16:37the help they provided to me. Now, how
- 16:39did I help them? So, they sometimes the
- 16:41people in the consulting firms are also
- 16:43generalists, right? They know about the
- 16:45software and then the setup and the
- 16:46processes, but they don't really know
- 16:48the methodology, the the richness of the
- 16:51work that we do on the day-to-day basis,
- 16:52right? So they also needed me as much as
- 16:55I needed them. They needed to lend them
- 16:57the experience of working in that
- 16:59function, the depth of the role which I
- 17:01provided to them so that we could
- 17:02together work in the solution. Right?
- 17:04Another thing is that I feel that
- 17:05>> the consultants are the most effective
- 17:08if they get enough and more support from
- 17:10the clients and similarly the clients
- 17:12get the best result if they support the
- 17:14consultants. Right? So it's just always
- 17:16uh a function wherein we have to work
- 17:18hand inhand with the clients.
- 17:20>> Very true. Got it.
- 17:21>> Hope that answers your question.
- 17:22Definitely. And my last question to you
- 17:24before we wrap up is tell me two things
- 17:27from ISB that you learned that really
- 17:30helped you in cracking a consulting
- 17:32role.
- 17:34>> Okay, that's that's a good one.
- 17:37H I think the first thing I would say is
- 17:40uh dealing with ambiguity, right?
- 17:43>> So and and it's an interesting one,
- 17:45right? Um and I it just came into my
- 17:48mind, right? uh when I was not at BCG or
- 17:52in fact when I was not at ISB we were
- 17:55always
- 17:57uh trained to deal with a lot of data
- 17:59coming in our way. So I have an
- 18:01engineering background as you know
- 18:02right? Yeah.
- 18:02>> So as an engineer you was always trained
- 18:05to actually get that data uh do some
- 18:08detailed analysis and then get to the
- 18:09answer right however in your MBA and
- 18:12especially at ISB you learn to solve
- 18:14problems when you don't have the most
- 18:16relevant information to solve that
- 18:18problem right
- 18:19>> you have to make educated guesses you
- 18:21have to be very comfortable in hand
- 18:23handling uh complexity and managing
- 18:25ambiguity right
- 18:27>> so I think that's one thing that I
- 18:29learned from ISP that
- 18:30>> really helped me at my time at BCG
- 18:32because the real life problems are not
- 18:34always do not always come with a
- 18:36detailed note on what what needs to be
- 18:38done right
- 18:39>> so yeah that's that's maybe one uh if I
- 18:42have to really think about another one
- 18:48I think the other one is maybe more
- 18:51towards the soft skills soft skills per
- 18:54se in terms of uh
- 18:57maybe even networking I would say right
- 19:00>> not not only networking right It's it's
- 19:02beyond networking. In my own case, I
- 19:05feel that I was uh an an introvert back
- 19:08then, right? And of course, you can
- 19:10never change your personality. Maybe I'm
- 19:11still an introvert, right?
- 19:12>> But now uh I think the ISB experience
- 19:16gives you an opportunity to be more
- 19:18comfortable in talking to new people.
- 19:20>> Right.
- 19:21>> Uh and that has has also helped me
- 19:24immensely while now I'm in a role
- 19:26wherein I have to have to correspond
- 19:28with clients on a day-to-day basis.
- 19:29Right.
- 19:30uh in this current role and in fact even
- 19:33when I was a consultant uh when you're
- 19:36working in the top three consulting
- 19:37firms as I already mentioned in my
- 19:39previous answer you get the best results
- 19:41when you work hand in hand with the
- 19:43client right and if that person who's
- 19:45not even comfortable uh with with
- 19:47speaking up with talking to the clients
- 19:49and have some inhibitions uh you'll not
- 19:52be able to be as successful as a person
- 19:53who's who's very comfortable in talking
- 19:56to new people and discussing ideas right
- 19:59>> so Yeah, short answer uh the the the
- 20:02component of networking and the ability
- 20:04to talk to new people very comfortably
- 20:07is I learned uh from ISB.
- 20:09>> Very nice. Awesome. Thank you so much uh
- 20:12for this super duper insightful
- 20:15conversation Weber. I'm 100% sure that
- 20:17this will help all ISB/
- 20:20consulting aspirants. So thank you so
- 20:22much for your time. And it is shat I did
- 20:24not say this in in the beginning but I
- 20:26didn't know I thought we just connecting
- 20:27on a precall to a line for [laughter]
- 20:31that you're going to take me. I was not
- 20:32prepared for this interview but I think
- 20:34that that really helped me because had I
- 20:36been prepared I would have had thoughts
- 20:38which would not naturally come to me. So
- 20:40all the words that I could share were
- 20:41were very naturally coming to me. So
- 20:44yeah uh I I appreciate you for for for
- 20:48orchestrating this and pleasure to talk
- 20:50to you.
- 20:51>> Awesome. Thank you so much.
- 20:52>> Thank you so much. Take care. Bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Careers After ISB | Management Consulting @ BCG by Sarthak Verma, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,981 words across 555 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.