Capital vs. Capacity vs. Comprehensive Campaigns: What’s the Difference? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Comprehensive campaigns, capital
- 0:02campaigns, capacity campaigns, oh my.
- 0:07There's a lot of language and
- 0:09terminology around campaigns and it can
- 0:12be confusing.
- 0:17>> [music]
- 0:22>> Hi, I'm Amy Eisenstein. I'm here with my
- 0:24colleague and co-founder Andrea Kilstad
- 0:27and today we're going to talk about the
- 0:30confusing terminology around campaigns.
- 0:34Andrea, we're going to talk about
- 0:36capacity campaigns and comprehensive
- 0:39campaigns and capital campaigns and
- 0:41endowment campaigns. Get us started.
- 0:45>> Yes. All right, Amy. This is, you know,
- 0:47this is a topic that it has taken me
- 0:50years to sort through and to figure out.
- 0:52So, I'm not surprised that other people
- 0:54are confused by it, right, when this
- 0:56language gets bandied around. But let's
- 0:58start right at the top. What do we mean
- 1:01by the phrase capital campaign?
- 1:04Now, even that's not so simple because
- 1:08generally we speak about capital
- 1:10campaigns as an umbrella, it's an
- 1:12umbrella term that covers a wide variety
- 1:16of campaigns that all follow a
- 1:20particular kind of fundraising. That is
- 1:23leadership fundraising, top-heavy
- 1:25fundraising, where the bulk of the money
- 1:28comes from a fairly small group of
- 1:31wealthy people.
- 1:33Now,
- 1:34okay, then you might say, well, don't
- 1:37you mean building campaign when you talk
- 1:39about capital campaigns? Well, one way
- 1:42to think about that is that the word
- 1:43capital might mean building, but it also
- 1:47might mean money. Right?
- 1:50>> Assets.
- 1:51>> Assets, right? So, it's a matter of
- 1:54which side of those you're you're
- 1:56thinking about. But but understand that
- 1:59when we talk about are you going to have
- 2:01a capital campaign, just the general
- 2:04question, we are using an umbrella term
- 2:06that covers all different kinds of
- 2:09campaigns. And we're going to dive into
- 2:11those now.
- 2:12>> All right, so let me just add
- 2:15all kinds of campaigns that are once in
- 2:18a while transformational,
- 2:20transformative, I was going to say,
- 2:22transformational and transformative for
- 2:25organizations.
- 2:27And it's not
- 2:29usually or always, and we're going to
- 2:32talk about when it is and when it isn't,
- 2:34inclusive of your annual operating
- 2:37funds. So,
- 2:40you I'm sure you have much more to say
- 2:42on that topic, but I just want to put
- 2:44out there that it's for a special
- 2:45project, it's for over and above usually
- 2:48your annual operating funds, it's once
- 2:51in a while.
- 2:53>> Go ahead.
- 2:54>> Yeah, it's that kind of fundraising,
- 2:56right? Capital
- 2:57The general phrase capital campaigns
- 2:59refers to a particular kind of
- 3:02fundraising.
- 3:04Where the money raised can be used for a
- 3:06variety of topics. And what's included
- 3:10is what determines the sub genre, what
- 3:14kind of a campaign it is. So, let's just
- 3:17run run those through.
- 3:19The simplest is, and the most common
- 3:21perhaps, is when an organization is
- 3:23going to build a new building
- 3:25>> [music]
- 3:25>> or expand their building. That's using
- 3:28the word capital in the sense of
- 3:30expanding your capital for your
- 3:33>> infrastructure.
- 3:34>> Your infrastructure. That kind of that
- 3:37kind of capital. And very often
- 3:39organizations decide they're going to do
- 3:42a campaign because they've run out of
- 3:45space, because their building has been
- 3:47knocked over by a tornado, because their
- 3:50building no longer suits their needs.
- 3:53So, they do a strategic plan and the and
- 3:56this plan says, "Yes, we need a new
- 3:58facility." And then someone says, "Well,
- 4:00okay, let's do a capital campaign."
- 4:02Meaning, let's do a building campaign.
- 4:05>> And and let's just add that cap- capital
- 4:08campaigns, when they include a building,
- 4:10also include program startup and often
- 4:14endowment and maintenance funds and
- 4:17rainy day funds and all sorts of other
- 4:19things. So, it's not to the exclusion of
- 4:22other uh
- 4:24pots of money. It's not just the
- 4:26building itself that you're raising
- 4:28money for in a capital campaign. Lots of
- 4:30things are often included. I get that
- 4:33question a lot.
- 4:34>> Yeah, well, and I what I was going to
- 4:36say is that is that often
- 4:38it it starts by people thinking that
- 4:41they need a new building.
- 4:43And then they say, "Well, what else
- 4:46might we tuck into this campaign?"
- 4:48Right? What else might we include? So,
- 4:52the the kinds of things that are put in
- 4:55into this campaign generally grows and
- 4:58in- and increases. And that's when we
- 5:01start using the terminology differently.
- 5:03So, when we have a building campaign
- 5:07and a uh combined with program funds,
- 5:12let's say for
- 5:14a grow- growth in your program over the
- 5:16next 3 years, combined with um with
- 5:21maybe money for your endowment, we often
- 5:24call those combined campaigns.
- 5:27Right? It is a capital campaign in the
- 5:29broad sense, but it is a combined
- 5:32campaign in the sense that you have put
- 5:34together several things that are all
- 5:36going to be counted in [music] your
- 5:38campaign goal.
- 5:40And that's in some sense, if you were to
- 5:42look for the right language for this,
- 5:44you would say this this is all stuff
- 5:47that increases your capacity.
- 5:50So, if we were trying to be accurate, we
- 5:52would say, "Well, overall, all of these
- 5:54campaigns are capacity-building
- 5:56campaigns. They're capacity campaigns."
- 5:59And if I were to create the language
- 6:01from scratch, that's probably the
- 6:03language I'd use. But, I didn't create
- 6:06the language from scratch, nor did Amy.
- 6:08So, we're stuck with this with the
- 6:10terminology we have, which is capital
- 6:12campaigns in the umbrella sense, then
- 6:15capital campaign in the sense that it is
- 6:17a building just a building campaign,
- 6:20and then a combined campaign, which puts
- 6:23various things together under one
- 6:26rubric, and you're raising money for all
- 6:30for all of that. What we haven't yet
- 6:32talked about is where your annual
- 6:35fundraising lives, where the money you
- 6:38raise annually during your campaign
- 6:41period, how that fits into your campaign
- 6:44or if it does.
- 6:46And honestly, this is where there is the
- 6:48most confusion.
- 6:50The um
- 6:52pretty much every organization that is
- 6:54going into a capital campaign has an
- 6:56annual operating budget and raises
- 6:59philanthropic money every year towards
- 7:03that budget.
- 7:05Right? Your annual operating fund,
- 7:07right? And you probably every year have
- 7:09a have a standard set of things you do
- 7:13to to raise to raise that money.
- 7:16Everyone is nervous about whether their
- 7:18campaign is going to
- 7:20cannibalize that that fund. So, some
- 7:23people decide what they're going to do
- 7:25is they're just going to include that
- 7:27annual fundraising right into their
- 7:30campaign, and they're going to increase
- 7:32the goal of their campaign
- 7:34by the amount they anticipate bringing
- 7:37in through annual fundraising during the
- 7:39period of the campaign.
- 7:42>> And most universities do that.
- 7:44>> Yes. So, a university might say, for
- 7:48example, we're going to have a campaign
- 7:50for Big Red, right? Big Red, right?
- 7:55They're going to ask all of their alumni
- 7:58to give. The campaign is going
- 8:00Universities tend to have long
- 8:01campaigns. So, let's say the campaign's
- 8:03going to take 10 years, which is long,
- 8:05but
- 8:05>> A billion dollar campaign, right?
- 8:08>> For $20 billion, right? Over 10 years.
- 8:11And what they do is that they add all of
- 8:13the money that they're going to bring in
- 8:15over those 10 years, including annual
- 8:17fund, which is going to go up year by
- 8:19year by year. And they add all of that
- 8:21money, and then they add it to their
- 8:23campaign goal, which also includes some
- 8:26buildings and some new program support
- 8:28and some endowment
- 8:29>> scholarships.
- 8:29>> Scholarships, right? Named faculty
- 8:32positions. I mean, all kinds of things.
- 8:35They lump it all together, and they have
- 8:37what is called a comprehensive campaign.
- 8:41Right? Now, that works quite well for
- 8:43universities.
- 8:44And that's why That's why they do it.
- 8:49When you are not a university, and
- 8:51you're an organization that has a
- 8:53specific mission,
- 8:55the mission is to save the wildlife, to
- 8:59feed the children, to
- 9:02make sick people healthier, to to put on
- 9:06theater, to Right? Whatever your mission
- 9:09is,
- 9:10it may make a little less sense to lump
- 9:14everything together.
- 9:16Right? Because you don't have the kind
- 9:19of alumni loyalty that Big Red does.
- 9:23>> Mhm.
- 9:23>> Right? When Big Red alumni give to their
- 9:27campaign,
- 9:28they're not giving
- 9:30really to to this or to that. They're
- 9:33giving to their institution
- 9:36to which they feel loyalty and identity
- 9:40and they want the institution to do well
- 9:42and to do better and they want to be
- 9:44part of it. So, so the ability to
- 9:47actually articulate
- 9:50the specifics
- 9:51of a campaign are less important than
- 9:54they are in these smaller organizations
- 9:56that have targeted missions.
- 10:00Right. Now, what that says is that okay,
- 10:02let's say let's stick with one of these.
- 10:04Let's talk about feed the hungry a feed
- 10:07the you know a
- 10:08a soup kitchen in your community for the
- 10:10sake of discussion.
- 10:11>> Yeah.
- 10:12>> And you're and you need a new new
- 10:14expanded kitchen. I mean we all know
- 10:16that soup kitchens are in fact going to
- 10:18be more important coming up because
- 10:21funding has been cut
- 10:23um for for people.
- 10:25>> And the need has risen. Yes.
- 10:27>> has risen so you need an expanded
- 10:30kitchen, you need better equipment, you
- 10:32need right you there
- 10:34>> More space.
- 10:35>> More space.
- 10:36>> More freezers, more refrigerators,
- 10:38everything.
- 10:39>> And and you need that because you want
- 10:43to be able to accommodate twice the
- 10:44number of people in your community that
- 10:46you then you can currently accommodate.
- 10:49Right. Now, you too have an annual fund.
- 10:52Let's say you raise $100,000 a year
- 10:54regularly.
- 10:56And you have a group of of loyal donors
- 10:58who give you year after year.
- 11:01But you want to go back in your campaign
- 11:03you're going to go back to those donors
- 11:05and you're going to ask them for for
- 11:07significantly higher gifts to expand
- 11:10your facilities so that they can do
- 11:13more.
- 11:14For you it probably doesn't make sense
- 11:17to lump the annual fund into
- 11:21your campaign. You want to still keep
- 11:24going back to those donors year after
- 11:26year after year and you want to be
- 11:28asking them for a special gift to do
- 11:31something that is going to make a big
- 11:32difference, a big specific difference in
- 11:35their community.
- 11:38You are probably going to want to do a
- 11:40combined campaign
- 11:42that's going to include the renovations
- 11:44to your kitchen, new equipment, perhaps
- 11:46new programming, perhaps additional
- 11:49staff for your cup two or three years of
- 11:52growth,
- 11:53perhaps endowments so you can support
- 11:55the the the facility for the future.
- 12:00But your annual fundraising is going to
- 12:02be separate. So you're not going to have
- 12:04a have a comprehensive campaign. You're
- 12:07going to have a combined campaign and
- 12:09you're going to keep your annual funding
- 12:11going year after year just like you
- 12:13always do.
- 12:15>> And one of the important reasons to keep
- 12:17it separate is because it really helps
- 12:20clarify things for donors. You can
- 12:23explain to them that you need first and
- 12:26foremost them to continue their ongoing
- 12:29annual support to feed the community the
- 12:32people in the community
- 12:34as they always have, as you always have,
- 12:37and you're asking for a one-time special
- 12:40gift over and above that annual amount
- 12:43to support this one-time growth need.
- 12:47And so it's very clear to you at the
- 12:50organization and your donors and the
- 12:52community what you're doing with the
- 12:55money, what you're asking for, what the
- 12:57ongoing needs are, um and it's just it's
- 13:01really clear to people and I think it's
- 13:03important certainly when we're working
- 13:05with clients, we
- 13:08try to make sure that everybody can
- 13:10articulate the difference between the
- 13:13ongoing needs and the one-time special
- 13:16campaign effort so the donors
- 13:19understand. And you know, being able to
- 13:22explain that if donors just simply
- 13:24transfer their annual support to the
- 13:27campaign, that doesn't work for an
- 13:29organization. You know, we often use an
- 13:32analogy of the house, right? You know,
- 13:34when you need a new roof, you can't stop
- 13:37buying groceries or paying the electric
- 13:39bill or paying, you know, your
- 13:41sanitation. Those are the annual
- 13:43operating needs of your house. And you
- 13:46still need to put a roof on. And so,
- 13:48that's sort of a good analogy to use
- 13:50with board members or donors who are
- 13:53questioning, you know, [clears throat]
- 13:55why can't they just switch their their
- 13:58giving from one to the other? It doesn't
- 13:59work that way.
- 14:02>> Yeah, you know, in
- 14:03people as I said, people do worry about
- 14:06losing their annual operating funds,
- 14:09their their philanthropic funds during a
- 14:12campaign. We we actually see just the
- 14:14opposite. We see that when an
- 14:16organization is in campaign mode and
- 14:19they're doing a great job of
- 14:20communicating with their donors. And
- 14:22they are talking to their donors about
- 14:24both their annual gift and their
- 14:27campaign gift, that the donors are
- 14:30perfectly happy to continue and even
- 14:32increase their annual gift during the
- 14:35campaign. That we see that again and
- 14:37again, that annual fundraising actually
- 14:39goes up during the campaign period and
- 14:41not down. And the very same donors give
- 14:45two gifts.
- 14:46Often at great multiples of what they
- 14:49usually give with an annual in their
- 14:52annual fundraising.
- 14:53>> And and here's why. Here's one of one of
- 14:56many reasons why. Um you're clarifying,
- 15:00you're outreach, you're increasing your
- 15:02communication, you're articulating
- 15:05better, you're there's more activity,
- 15:07there's better branding and and
- 15:10outreach. Um there's just more
- 15:12communication, more events, more
- 15:14activities during various stages and
- 15:17parts of the campaign. And so, people
- 15:19are often confused about why the annual
- 15:22fund would go up during a campaign when
- 15:25you're already asking your donors to
- 15:27give significantly increased gifts. But
- 15:30but that's why you're there's buzz.
- 15:33People are talking about your
- 15:34organization. You're you know, you're
- 15:36out in the community more. You're
- 15:38talking to more people. So um that's why
- 15:42we often see an increase in the annual
- 15:44fund in addition to the campaign dollars
- 15:47that come in.
- 15:48>> You know, Amy, let let me see if I can
- 15:50clarify where people usually get
- 15:52confused.
- 15:54The question is not whether you can talk
- 15:57to your donors about both annual and
- 16:00capital gifts. You do and can and should
- 16:05be talking to those donors about both
- 16:07kinds of gifts.
- 16:09The question is whether you include
- 16:13the amount of money you're going to
- 16:14raise in your annual fund in your
- 16:16campaign goal
- 16:19or whether you keep the goals separate.
- 16:23And that's what confuses people. In a
- 16:26university-style comprehensive campaign,
- 16:29everything is included in these great
- 16:31big campaign goals.
- 16:33In a local campaign where the more
- 16:35targeted campaign, well, we talk to our
- 16:38donors about both kinds of giving and
- 16:40wanting both giving both gifts from
- 16:43them. We keep the goals separate.
- 16:45Capital campaign goal and the annual
- 16:48goal.
- 16:50Right? And that's so those are not
- 16:52comprehensive campaigns because we're
- 16:54not lumping the goals together. It's not
- 16:57that we're not talking about them.
- 16:59[clears throat] It's that just we're not
- 17:00including the annual fundraising in our
- 17:03campaign goal.
- 17:05>> Excellent. Important differences because
- 17:08[music]
- 17:09when you're talking about a campaign
- 17:11with your board members early on with
- 17:13your leadership team, there is a lot of
- 17:15confusion around capacity campaigns. Are
- 17:18we doing a capital campaign? Are we
- 17:20doing a comprehensive campaign? And so,
- 17:23clarifying the language, um,
- 17:26establishing what you're doing and how
- 17:28you're going to be talking about it, I
- 17:30think is important up front. So, feel
- 17:33free to share this podcast with your
- 17:35team, send it to your board chair, your
- 17:37leadership team, your executive
- 17:39director. Um, Andrea, I think putting
- 17:42you're putting a clear framework around
- 17:45how [music] to think about these massive
- 17:48fundraising efforts is [music] so
- 17:51important, and I appreciate, once again,
- 17:54you sharing your wisdom with us.
- 17:56>> Thanks, Amy.
- 17:57>> All right. Thanks for listening, and
- 17:59we'll see you next time. Bye for now.
- 18:06>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Capital vs. Capacity vs. Comprehensive Campaigns: What’s the Difference? by Capital Campaign Pro, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,635 words across 440 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.