YouTube2Text

⚡Can YOU Spot a Psychopath? SUSAN SMITH Up For Parole! — Transcript

by The Behavior Panel · 6,836 words · 1,071 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00We had the best time doing the initial
  2. 0:01breakdown of the body language and
  3. 0:03behavior in this video, and we decided
  4. 0:05we'd revisit some of our favorite
  5. 0:06moments from it.
  6. 0:08So what if I can't I I can't do anything
  7. 0:10but think about them?
  8. 0:13And I
  9. 0:16I just want to hug them, Scott.
  10. 0:19And tell them I love them.
  11. 0:20Greg, what do you got?
  12. 0:22Yeah, so right off the beginning of
  13. 0:24this, it might be true that she wants to
  14. 0:26hug them, she wants to do this, she
  15. 0:27wants to do that, but she's eye
  16. 0:29blocking. There is not a single bit of
  17. 0:33grief. There's no concern, nothing in
  18. 0:35the forehead, there's no snot, no tears.
  19. 0:37It's the worst kind of fake cry. It's a
  20. 0:39Scott, I'm so sorry. You really don't
  21. 0:41like what I did. That's all it is. This
  22. 0:43is garbage. Chase, what do you got?
  23. 0:46Yeah, I agree with you. So this eye
  24. 0:48closure is not from the crying.
  25. 0:51This is exactly what you just said,
  26. 0:53Greg. This is avoidance.
  27. 0:55There's no movement here in the chin
  28. 0:56boss, which we always see when we see
  29. 0:58shame and and grief. There's a hygienic
  30. 1:01gesture during the crying.
  31. 1:04And it's not to wipe tears, which is
  32. 1:07very unusual. So adjusting your hair
  33. 1:10while crying
  34. 1:11doesn't look very good. So she's kind of
  35. 1:13just pushing her hair back there. That's
  36. 1:15what we call in the behavior business a
  37. 1:16hygienic gesture.
  38. 1:18And she said, "I just want to hug them."
  39. 1:20I just want to hug them, Scott.
  40. 1:22There's a baton gesture she does with
  41. 1:24her hand as she's talking. Her hand's
  42. 1:27back here. Something that we always look
  43. 1:29for is things that don't line up. Scott
  44. 1:30talks about this in a lot of the other
  45. 1:32videos when a gesture doesn't really
  46. 1:34match up with a person's phrases. What I
  47. 1:37think is interesting here is that the
  48. 1:39gesture doesn't match up with anything
  49. 1:41that's going on. Doesn't match up
  50. 1:42emotionally with the tone of her voice
  51. 1:44or the cadence or the words that she's
  52. 1:46saying. So I would I would like to
  53. 1:48invent a new a name for what we're
  54. 1:50seeing here where it doesn't match up
  55. 1:51with anything and just call it gesture
  56. 1:53arrhythmia.
  57. 1:55Okay, I I called it
  58. 1:58ill
  59. 1:59illustrator non-alignment or something
  60. 2:01like that with the word alignment in
  61. 2:02there for the illustration. So, it was
  62. 2:03close.
  63. 2:04Yep.
  64. 2:05The past. Yep.
  65. 2:06Yeah.
  66. 2:07I think this is
  67. 2:08this gesture isn't associated with
  68. 2:10sadness or grief or loss or anything
  69. 2:12there.
  70. 2:13And
  71. 2:14that's all I got for this video. Mark,
  72. 2:16what do you see?
  73. 2:17Yep. So, I agree. There is what I would
  74. 2:20call incongruence. But I think you're
  75. 2:22talking about some extreme incongruence
  76. 2:25where it just doesn't really match up
  77. 2:27with anything. So, misalignment,
  78. 2:30arrhythmia, I think they're all good
  79. 2:32descriptions of that. Here's what jumps
  80. 2:34out at me. I I I them.
  81. 2:38Okay, so if I can't
  82. 2:39I can't do anything but think about
  83. 2:41them.
  84. 2:42Then the grooming that you were talking
  85. 2:44about there, I them them I.
  86. 2:46I just want to hug them so bad.
  87. 2:49And tell them I love them.
  88. 2:50So, there's way more I's than them.
  89. 2:54They're they're a
  90. 2:55a collective. There's not even any names
  91. 2:57of the children. So, it's very
  92. 2:59egocentric at this point. The male is
  93. 3:02very different from the female.
  94. 3:04Different rhythm going on. Not joining
  95. 3:06in with this this crying. You know, even
  96. 3:09if it is you know, kind of fake. He's
  97. 3:12not even joining in. Not enjoying in
  98. 3:13with anything real or fake here. And I
  99. 3:16think he gives a sour taste in his mouth
  100. 3:19as well. So, I think there is some
  101. 3:20strong differences between the male and
  102. 3:22the female here. Female here very
  103. 3:24self-centered in the description there.
  104. 3:27And the grooming as you say, Chase, is
  105. 3:30just it's just not applicable in this
  106. 3:32situation at all.
  107. 3:35Uh Scott, what do you got on this one?
  108. 3:37All right. She's moving really slow.
  109. 3:39This lets us know that she there's a lot
  110. 3:41going on up here. She's thinking through
  111. 3:43what she's going to say. She she doesn't
  112. 3:44really she's not really experiencing
  113. 3:46these emotions. So, we're not seeing
  114. 3:47them on her face. She's she's showing us
  115. 3:49what she thinks we that we want to see
  116. 3:52or should be seeing at this point. When
  117. 3:54you compare Susan with her husband,
  118. 3:57do this throughout all these videos when
  119. 3:59he's in there, too. Dramatic. I remember
  120. 4:01when this happened, and I remember when
  121. 4:02she got busted or soon before she got
  122. 4:05busted because the the we'll see a video
  123. 4:08I'll I'll I'll tell you that story when
  124. 4:10we get to that video because it's it's I
  125. 4:13I'll never forget I'll never forget that
  126. 4:14day.
  127. 4:15Um and everything is based on feel sorry
  128. 4:17for me. It's all about me and and and
  129. 4:19just feel sorry for me. I You're right,
  130. 4:21Marcus. I me. It's all about me at this
  131. 4:24point. And when you turn the sound off,
  132. 4:26as you'll see in all these videos if
  133. 4:27you'll do this, she looks like she's
  134. 4:29retiring from
  135. 4:30a job somewhere or she These are the
  136. 4:33same faces you see and same emotions you
  137. 4:35don't see that you're not seeing when
  138. 4:37someone's retiring or someone is um
  139. 4:41leaving a job and they're telling
  140. 4:42everybody goodbye. That's what it looks
  141. 4:44like. It doesn't look like somebody
  142. 4:45who's grieving over their children.
  143. 4:48It it it doesn't look like that at all.
  144. 4:50The stress we're seeing is is when she's
  145. 4:52moving slow and not looking at the
  146. 4:54camera and not connecting with anyone.
  147. 4:57So, these are all we're all we're seeing
  148. 4:58a bunch of stress on her, rightfully so
  149. 5:01because she's not telling the truth
  150. 5:02here, but she's sort of creating this I
  151. 5:04I I think she had a pretty good idea of
  152. 5:06what she was going to say, but that was
  153. 5:07it. I don't think she rehearsed this at
  154. 5:09all when she get when it before it came
  155. 5:11down to game time for showtime for her.
  156. 5:14All right.
  157. 5:14God, I disagree with one thing you said
  158. 5:16fully.
  159. 5:17What?
  160. 5:18There's a lot going on in her head. I
  161. 5:19disagree.
  162. 5:23Okay, I stand corrected.
  163. 5:25I can't sleep. I can't eat. I can't do
  164. 5:27anything but think about them.
  165. 5:30And just
  166. 5:33I just want to hug them so bad.
  167. 5:36And tell them I love them.
  168. 5:39I want to say to my babies
  169. 5:43that your mama loves you so much. And
  170. 5:45your daddy this whole family's love you
  171. 5:47so much.
  172. 5:50And you guys have got to be strong.
  173. 5:54Because you are we we we I just know
  174. 5:57I just feel in my heart that you're
  175. 5:59okay, but you got to take care of each
  176. 6:02other.
  177. 6:05And your mom and daddy going to be right
  178. 6:06here waiting on you when you get home.
  179. 6:09I'm going to go first on this one
  180. 6:10because it goes back to that video
  181. 6:13our last video when I was telling you
  182. 6:14about
  183. 6:16something happened. When this happened,
  184. 6:18when this video came out, there are two
  185. 6:19versions of this video. I couldn't I
  186. 6:21spent all night last night looking for
  187. 6:22the second version of it. It's a wider
  188. 6:24shot of everybody in it and it's got
  189. 6:25family members and other people in it.
  190. 6:28And she's talking, her eyebrows are up.
  191. 6:30Look at everyone else. They show
  192. 6:31concern, their eyebrows are down like
  193. 6:33this. They're they're thinking, "Oh my
  194. 6:34no you know my lord, what's happened?"
  195. 6:36That's when my this is before you had
  196. 6:38cell phones, you know, or before I had
  197. 6:40one anyway, my phone started ringing and
  198. 6:42it was everybody I knew going, "Did you
  199. 6:44just see that on Did you just see that
  200. 6:46on the news? Did you see uh Susan
  201. 6:47Smith?" I was like, "Yeah, we're all
  202. 6:49like, holy smokes man, she's going to
  203. 6:50the pokey because she did this." At
  204. 6:53least look at her husband. That's really
  205. 6:55the only one you can see in here. Look
  206. 6:56at his eyebrows. That's what her's
  207. 6:57should be doing, showing concern. She
  208. 6:59shows no concern. And again, this is all
  209. 7:01about her. The content is all focused on
  210. 7:04her, on me, on I. Listen to what she's
  211. 7:06saying.
  212. 7:07No brow no brow movement in there no no
  213. 7:10expressions really of anything. Nothing
  214. 7:12much moving at all. And there's no plea
  215. 7:14to kidnap her.
  216. 7:15You know, and she's telling these little
  217. 7:16children, one of them is three and the
  218. 7:18other one is a year and a half and she's
  219. 7:20saying, "Look, take care of each other."
  220. 7:21You got to take care of each other.
  221. 7:23Really? Have you ever said that to a
  222. 7:26a three-year-old and and the other one,
  223. 7:28"You two take care of each other." Are
  224. 7:29you kidding me? If they saw it, you know
  225. 7:31your mother's No. She
  226. 7:34No, she stepped in it here. So and no
  227. 7:36anger, no nothing. We're seeing none of
  228. 7:38the emotions or expressions we should be
  229. 7:40seeing here. So that's a lie and her
  230. 7:42eyes especially with her eyebrows, they
  231. 7:44shouldn't be up, they should be down.
  232. 7:45She should be
  233. 7:46focused and telling whoever's got her
  234. 7:48children that they're going to find them
  235. 7:50and and
  236. 7:52they need to bring them back. That's
  237. 7:53what should be going on there. Okay,
  238. 7:54Chase, what do you got?
  239. 7:57Even Even better, I fully agree with
  240. 7:59that. She met this alleged person who
  241. 8:02did this. She spent time with this
  242. 8:04person face-to-face.
  243. 8:07So, that even makes it a worse case for
  244. 8:10the vanishing perpetrator.
  245. 8:13And what we're seeing here, there's
  246. 8:14showing of this more eye contact
  247. 8:16avoidant behavior, which is what she
  248. 8:18what she's doing. This is not avoiding
  249. 8:20to stop herself from crying at all.
  250. 8:23And I think it's interesting to note
  251. 8:24that she does this while she her eyes
  252. 8:26are staying at kind of 5:00. Cuz you can
  253. 8:29see where her eyes are looking
  254. 8:31uh
  255. 8:31certain direction there, which suggests
  256. 8:33internal dialogue and not any emotion
  257. 8:36going on.
  258. 8:38And
  259. 8:39when does the chin boss move? It moves a
  260. 8:41couple of times here. It moves when
  261. 8:43she's talking about herself and how good
  262. 8:45she is as a mother.
  263. 8:47Your mama loves you so much.
  264. 8:49And while she's saying a lot of this
  265. 8:50stuff, we have lip licking. There's uh
  266. 8:53right at the end here. Lip licking,
  267. 8:54there's lip retraction. Lip licking is
  268. 8:57to make ourselves look better. Lip
  269. 8:59retraction is typically a need for
  270. 9:00reassurance.
  271. 9:02Right there at the end.
  272. 9:03And there's a complete lack of emotion.
  273. 9:05So, I want you to go look and see what's
  274. 9:08missing here. If if a person if she had
  275. 9:10met and witnessed a person take her
  276. 9:13children,
  277. 9:14what's really missing from this
  278. 9:15conversation? What's being hidden? And
  279. 9:18this is what's being hidden from this is
  280. 9:20the perpetrator. So, when there's data
  281. 9:22being hidden,
  282. 9:23that's a huge red flag. Should be for
  283. 9:24anybody. Uh Greg, what do you think?
  284. 9:27Yeah, I'll take it a step further. She
  285. 9:29didn't just meet him, she described him,
  286. 9:32even had an artist draw a picture and it
  287. 9:34was all BS. It was all made up. But here
  288. 9:36we see no grief, no concern. She
  289. 9:38stumbles through words because she's
  290. 9:40trying to think of what to say.
  291. 9:41Interestingly, Scott, you say her brows
  292. 9:43aren't down, they're up. But they're not
  293. 9:44even up, they're just flat. They're
  294. 9:46emotionless. That's even worse. If she
  295. 9:48was going like this or shock or
  296. 9:49something, we might feel good about it.
  297. 9:51The only time I see any concern in her
  298. 9:53brow at all is when she says, "I know
  299. 9:56you are okay." and her brows do
  300. 9:58something odd. You get a little flash of
  301. 10:00something right between her brows cuz
  302. 10:01she knows he isn't. Now, we often will
  303. 10:04talk about lip licking and that. But
  304. 10:06Desmond Morris talked about something
  305. 10:07called a tongue jut and he said it's
  306. 10:09baby's first way to reject something or
  307. 10:11something distasteful to push out. We're
  308. 10:13going to see her do the Morris tongue
  309. 10:15jut, not just this time, but other
  310. 10:16times, too. When she talks about your
  311. 10:19mama and your daddy and she goes
  312. 10:21like that, that's a that's a Morris
  313. 10:23tongue jut all day.
  314. 10:24And your mama and daddy are going to be
  315. 10:25right here waiting on you when you get
  316. 10:26home.
  317. 10:27Then she bites her lip as she draws it
  318. 10:30back in. And I think that might be
  319. 10:31containment or an adapter. This is ugly.
  320. 10:34This is There's nothing good in anything
  321. 10:37she's doing. And to your point, Scott,
  322. 10:39the husband looks just like he's out of
  323. 10:41touch with everything. Now, he's also
  324. 10:43there estranged before she does this.
  325. 10:45One thing you should know is they
  326. 10:46believe that the reason she disposed of
  327. 10:48her children is because somebody she had
  328. 10:50had an an affair or at least a starting
  329. 10:52relationship with didn't want children.
  330. 10:54Sound familiar? Mark, what do you got?
  331. 10:57Uh yeah, I'll tell you what's missing
  332. 10:58for me, uh Chase, and you know,
  333. 11:01whatever's missing for all of you. And
  334. 11:03you know, put it down there. But um it's
  335. 11:06all eye block as far as I can see. So
  336. 11:09there's zero from this angle for me.
  337. 11:12There's zero eye contact with that
  338. 11:15potential audience who might have
  339. 11:17information on where her kid is. You
  340. 11:20know, I would expect, and if it were me,
  341. 11:24you know, to be making a lot of eye
  342. 11:25contact with the public and trying to
  343. 11:27get information across is here's who
  344. 11:29we're looking for and if you know
  345. 11:30anything, all of those standard things,
  346. 11:33I'm getting none of that.
  347. 11:35Um yeah, the lip licking, the biting as
  348. 11:37well.
  349. 11:38They're very out of the ordinary for
  350. 11:41what we saw from her before, so they
  351. 11:44kind of come out of nowhere. That rings
  352. 11:46alarm bells. It's around when you get
  353. 11:49home. So, there's something about that
  354. 11:52that push on when you get home and the
  355. 11:55lip bite there, that's alarming for me
  356. 11:57as well.
  357. 11:59Biggest alarming thing for me is
  358. 12:02when I usually see you know, a couple or
  359. 12:05a mother or a father or any kind of, you
  360. 12:07know, primary caregiver who is in this
  361. 12:11situation, the emotions collide. It's
  362. 12:14quite complex. There's a lot going on
  363. 12:16because they're trying to get
  364. 12:17information across. As well, they've got
  365. 12:19the job of trying to contact the
  366. 12:21audience. They've got this job of trying
  367. 12:23to hold themselves together while doing
  368. 12:25that. Their mind is in a thousand places
  369. 12:28trying to understand what might be
  370. 12:30happening
  371. 12:31with this kid here or, you know,
  372. 12:33regardless of what emotion she's doing
  373. 12:36or isn't doing, it's super simple what's
  374. 12:39going on. It's too simple as far as I'm
  375. 12:42concerned. Now, often what we get is
  376. 12:44with this collision of emotions, it's
  377. 12:46quite complex and and often observers
  378. 12:49will look at it and go, "Ah, there's
  379. 12:50something up there." There's something
  380. 12:52up because it's not easily
  381. 12:53understandable. I usually expect it to
  382. 12:56not be easily understandable because
  383. 12:59this is a situation that no human being
  384. 13:02on the planet has rehearsed for. They
  385. 13:04haven't had that moment of, "Well, you
  386. 13:06know what? When my kids go missing,
  387. 13:08here's how I'll handle my feelings.
  388. 13:10Here's how I'll understand this
  389. 13:12situation." Well, she's handling herself
  390. 13:14in a very simplistic way here. That
  391. 13:17rings alarm bells for me. Uh that's all
  392. 13:19I got on that one. Have we all We've all
  393. 13:20been?
  394. 13:21Yeah.
  395. 13:22Good.
  396. 13:24I want going to my babies,
  397. 13:28that your mama loves you so much. And
  398. 13:31your daddy this whole family loves you
  399. 13:33so much.
  400. 13:36And you guys have got to be strong.
  401. 13:39Because you are we we
  402. 13:41I just know
  403. 13:43I just feel in my heart you're okay, but
  404. 13:46you got to take care of each other.
  405. 13:50And your mom and dad are going to be
  406. 13:51right here waiting on you when you get
  407. 13:52home.
  408. 13:55Sources close to the investigation,
  409. 13:57Susan, uh
  410. 13:58Tippett told NBC News that federal
  411. 14:00agents are focusing, in fact, on the
  412. 14:02relationship between you and Mitchell
  413. 14:05Sinclair, the the man that you were
  414. 14:06going to visit that night, the man you
  415. 14:08said you were going to visit with your
  416. 14:10children.
  417. 14:11Uh they've told NBC that there were
  418. 14:13inconsistencies
  419. 14:15in your stories. Do you know what
  420. 14:16inconsistencies uh they were referring
  421. 14:18to?
  422. 14:19Uh no, ma'am, I really do not know that.
  423. 14:22Um
  424. 14:23All right. Chase, what do you got?
  425. 14:26Yeah, we see her stop herself from
  426. 14:28smiling here,
  427. 14:30which is
  428. 14:31pretty unusual. There is some pucker,
  429. 14:34some lip compression, there's licking,
  430. 14:36uh there's lip retraction going on here,
  431. 14:39which suggests all kinds of crap. But
  432. 14:42one thing I really want to pick on
  433. 14:44is watch her blink rate
  434. 14:47from before she hears the word
  435. 14:49relationship, when she actually learns
  436. 14:52what the question is about.
  437. 14:54And watch the change in blink rate
  438. 14:56before the word relationship, and then
  439. 14:58after the word relationship, and you
  440. 15:00will see a perfect example of what we
  441. 15:03always talk about.
  442. 15:04Federal agents are focusing, in fact, on
  443. 15:06the relationship between you and
  444. 15:08Mitchell Sinclair, the the man that you
  445. 15:11were going to visit that night, the man
  446. 15:12you said you were going to visit with
  447. 15:14your children.
  448. 15:14And there's also some hesitancy here,
  449. 15:16there's this qualifier where she uses
  450. 15:18the word really in the middle of her
  451. 15:20denial.
  452. 15:21No, ma'am, really did not know that.
  453. 15:23There's a non-contraction, but please
  454. 15:25keep in mind
  455. 15:26we just saw an example of her most
  456. 15:28likely being truthful with a
  457. 15:30non-contraction.
  458. 15:32And there's also some double access to
  459. 15:35internal dialogue to craft an answer.
  460. 15:37And that would mean that there's
  461. 15:38accessing to internal dialogue, remaking
  462. 15:41eye contact, and then going back down
  463. 15:43again in quick succession.
  464. 15:46Uh which is also a pretty large red
  465. 15:48flag. And we know this is deceptive
  466. 15:50already, so I'll give my answer at 100%.
  467. 15:53How about that?
  468. 15:55Scott, what do you think?
  469. 15:57All right. I thought when she said um
  470. 16:00do you know what inconsistencies
  471. 16:03what what inconsistencies were made or
  472. 16:05whatever, I thought she's going to say,
  473. 16:06"Do you know what inconsistencies
  474. 16:08means?"
  475. 16:08Yeah.
  476. 16:09I swear to god. And I laughed so hard
  477. 16:11after that cuz I thought she was talking
  478. 16:12down to her.
  479. 16:13Anyway, at the top we see her lips,
  480. 16:16you're right, Chase. We see lip pursing,
  481. 16:17we see retraction, we see all kinds of
  482. 16:19things in there. Because what she's
  483. 16:21talking about she's she's it it's
  484. 16:24catching her a little bit off guard cuz
  485. 16:25she brings up the guy she's seeing. She
  486. 16:27want to hear about that? But at the same
  487. 16:30right before that she says something
  488. 16:31that makes it that this like, "Yeah."
  489. 16:33Makes her feel like, you know, that's
  490. 16:34okay because she smiles at that point.
  491. 16:36It's not duping delight because at that
  492. 16:38point she's not saying anything where
  493. 16:40she's duping anybody. But we we there's
  494. 16:43a whole lot going on there. So, and
  495. 16:44especially when she gets back to the to
  496. 16:46the the part about the guy she's going
  497. 16:48to see, watch there cuz we see full-on a
  498. 16:51lip pursing there. And that and that
  499. 16:54indicates that the that that person is
  500. 16:57doesn't agree with what's being said,
  501. 16:58and she sees it as a threat.
  502. 17:00Also, when you see her eyes darting
  503. 17:02around, that indicates the person is
  504. 17:05going through and um
  505. 17:07processing the threat, processing
  506. 17:09whatever's being said, and getting and
  507. 17:11getting ready to as they structure their
  508. 17:13answer for that threat. That's what
  509. 17:15we're looking at there.
  510. 17:16Um
  511. 17:17that's that's all I got on that one.
  512. 17:19Craig, what do you got?
  513. 17:20Yeah, that eye that eye movement can
  514. 17:22mean that she is processing information.
  515. 17:24It can also mean that she is looking for
  516. 17:26an answer to something that she doesn't
  517. 17:28have. I mean,
  518. 17:29she's prepared for all this stuff and
  519. 17:30she's probably got something she wants
  520. 17:32to say. There's also a high likelihood
  521. 17:35in her case that she can't hold a
  522. 17:36thought long enough to answer that
  523. 17:38question because if you watch how she
  524. 17:39behaves, she rambles and does whatever
  525. 17:42and then throws out something.
  526. 17:44Here's what's interesting. She's a low
  527. 17:46horsepower romancer because most
  528. 17:48romancers when they look at you, they
  529. 17:49make really good eye contact. She'll say
  530. 17:51something and make really quick eye
  531. 17:52contact and then break away again.
  532. 17:55Probably something that's a learned
  533. 17:56behavior. She was in an abusive
  534. 17:57childhood and that kind of thing. So,
  535. 17:59there's probably some of that not making
  536. 18:00really solid eye contact. Um, but that
  537. 18:03actual smile that she tries to hide is
  538. 18:05when she's thinking about this
  539. 18:06relationship or something comes up and
  540. 18:08then she breaks eye contact and does
  541. 18:10that tongue jut again. Is she going into
  542. 18:12memory? Is there something going on?
  543. 18:14Because then her blink rate goes through
  544. 18:15the roof, her breathing goes up and she
  545. 18:17does that nervous confirming nod about
  546. 18:19the guy. So, it makes me think she's got
  547. 18:21some kind of positive thing going on in
  548. 18:23her head about the guy but then
  549. 18:25realizes, "Oh, oh, oh, oh, that was the
  550. 18:26wrong thing to do." Makes quick eye
  551. 18:28contact and does that the nod.
  552. 18:31She does a mouth grimace and when she
  553. 18:33says, "No, ma'am." her brows flash.
  554. 18:35No, ma'am. I really do not know that.
  555. 18:37We only see this eyebrow flash when she
  556. 18:40is doing something that's negative so
  557. 18:42far as far as I can tell. Mark, what do
  558. 18:44you got?
  559. 18:45Yes, so I agree. There is a complexity
  560. 18:46of emotions happening here which she
  561. 18:48hasn't rehearsed for delivering or
  562. 18:52controlling in any way. So, I think this
  563. 18:54idea of the boyfriend that comes up and
  564. 18:58and it there's a a real emotion that
  565. 19:01comes with that and she doesn't know
  566. 19:03what to do with that and she suppresses
  567. 19:06that delight. And it would be so easy to
  568. 19:09go to see that as duper's delight but
  569. 19:12Scott, you're absolutely right. This is
  570. 19:14not dupers delight because it's the
  571. 19:16suppression of a real feeling of her
  572. 19:19imagining her boyfriend and she hasn't
  573. 19:21she hadn't prepared for this question in
  574. 19:23any way. So, there's this huge kind of
  575. 19:26collision in many ways.
  576. 19:28Uh you know, this is her being very real
  577. 19:31with us because she's not good when not
  578. 19:34rehearsed of being simple enough and
  579. 19:37controlling her feelings. So, we get
  580. 19:40that suppression of delight and then she
  581. 19:43lets it out. She hasn't fully managed to
  582. 19:45suppress it. We get the lip lick.
  583. 19:48There's a lot of swallowing goes on
  584. 19:49there.
  585. 19:50Um
  586. 19:51non-contractions, polite as well. So,
  587. 19:54some elements that we've seen before. Uh
  588. 19:57yeah, I think that's all I have to say
  589. 19:58about that one.
  590. 20:00Sources close to the investigation,
  591. 20:01Susan, uh
  592. 20:03have told NBC News that federal agents
  593. 20:05are focusing in fact on the relationship
  594. 20:07between you and Mitchell St. Claire that
  595. 20:10the man that you were going to visit
  596. 20:12that night, the man you said you were
  597. 20:13going to visit with your children. Uh
  598. 20:16they've told NBC that there were
  599. 20:17inconsistencies
  600. 20:19in your stories. Do you know what
  601. 20:21inconsistencies uh they were referring
  602. 20:23to?
  603. 20:24Uh no, ma'am. I really do not know that.
  604. 20:27Um
  605. 20:28Right now, we want to go to Union to get
  606. 20:29the story first hand from Susan Smith
  607. 20:32and her husband, David.
  608. 20:34Susan, how are you doing this morning?
  609. 20:36Uh doing okay. Uh very little sleep last
  610. 20:39night, but I'm okay.
  611. 20:41There was uh some news yesterday and and
  612. 20:43some promising leads uh in this case.
  613. 20:47Uh how are how are you coping with the
  614. 20:49disappointment of the news from
  615. 20:50yesterday?
  616. 20:51Um it was um
  617. 20:54I was running around um my house
  618. 20:55yesterday morning all excited. I really
  619. 20:57thought that they had uh had had really
  620. 20:59found something that
  621. 21:01was I really thought they'd found one of
  622. 21:03my children and um
  623. 21:05when I got to the courthouse and found
  624. 21:07out that the lead had
  625. 21:09disintegrated or there was nothing
  626. 21:11there, I was very devastated, very
  627. 21:13disappointed. Uh
  628. 21:15got my hopes up and was let down, but I
  629. 21:18haven't given up hope.
  630. 21:21You know, that was
  631. 21:23uh maybe one of many disappointments,
  632. 21:25but maybe the next going to uh
  633. 21:29be be right.
  634. 21:31Mark, what do you got?
  635. 21:33Yeah, so she's very focused on her
  636. 21:35feelings, and I'll go through those in a
  637. 21:37moment. But, I want to give her Well,
  638. 21:39not some credit, but but put it in the
  639. 21:41context of
  640. 21:43there's two pretty bad questions that
  641. 21:46come forward in this. The first one is,
  642. 21:49"How are you doing?" So, the interviewer
  643. 21:51has asked for her
  644. 21:53emotion. So, we could kind of go, "Well,
  645. 21:55of course, she's going to give her
  646. 21:57feelings cuz that's what she was asked."
  647. 22:00And I'll come to that in a moment. And
  648. 22:02then he goes, "Well, how are you coping
  649. 22:05with the disappointment?" So, he even
  650. 22:07delivers her a feeling to attach to.
  651. 22:11I would say terrible interviewing there
  652. 22:15unless you want to lead somebody into
  653. 22:18stating those emotions. Now, of course,
  654. 22:20she does. She says, "Very little sleep,
  655. 22:23excited,
  656. 22:24devastated, disappointed." So, she lays
  657. 22:27in what she's been asked for. Hopes up,
  658. 22:30let down, many disappointments. And she
  659. 22:33kind of ends on on that. So, she's been
  660. 22:35a little bit led on that. Now, having
  661. 22:39said all of that, what I do notice in
  662. 22:42interviews with people who are not the
  663. 22:45culprit, the perpetrator, the criminal
  664. 22:47in this sense is you can lead them into
  665. 22:50emotions, and they instantly go to
  666. 22:53uh you know, they don't necessarily say,
  667. 22:55"This is not about me." But, they take
  668. 22:57it off them, and they naturally get on
  669. 23:00to
  670. 23:01uh find my kids. They will get onto the
  671. 23:04kids immediately. She doesn't find her
  672. 23:06way there. She is led into her feelings
  673. 23:10and being self-centered. So, there is
  674. 23:12that going for her, but she should be
  675. 23:14able to find her way out of that. And
  676. 23:17she doesn't. Greg, what have you got on
  677. 23:18this one?
  678. 23:19Yeah, let's talk about leading her into
  679. 23:21something.
  680. 23:22When you see her left eye accessing this
  681. 23:24time, that's not her making up
  682. 23:25something, that's her repeating a word
  683. 23:27she has heard. Disintegrate is not a
  684. 23:29word she uses. That's a word that that
  685. 23:31one of the investigators said, "Oh, oh,
  686. 23:33that lead disintegrated." That's the way
  687. 23:35they got her in to talk to her, just
  688. 23:36about guaranteed.
  689. 23:38Look at her, this is what I'm talking
  690. 23:39about, she's braced. She's in a fighting
  691. 23:40position. By that I mean, when you're in
  692. 23:42the army, you dig a hole, you get in
  693. 23:44there, you get your rifle, and you
  694. 23:45defend yourself. She's braced. She's
  695. 23:47locked back in the chair. She's
  696. 23:49barrier-ed. She's got what I call egg
  697. 23:52protector. In men, we call it the fig
  698. 23:53leaf, we we cross our primary sex
  699. 23:55organs. She's crossed her arm in front
  700. 23:57of her abdomen. And she's locked down
  701. 24:00with her husband there, and she's
  702. 24:01twitching fingers and doing all kinds of
  703. 24:04adapters.
  704. 24:05Her blink rate is through the roof, and
  705. 24:07she's braced for whatever you're going
  706. 24:08to ask her. She's ready for this whole
  707. 24:10thing.
  708. 24:11She gets pressure.
  709. 24:13And she does something we've only seen
  710. 24:14one other time on the entire behavior
  711. 24:16panel show, and that's she does this
  712. 24:18pressured release of words at the end.
  713. 24:21She's feeling pressure, she rambles, and
  714. 24:23when she's done, she didn't edit. So,
  715. 24:25she's got words left over that mean
  716. 24:27nothing.
  717. 24:27You know, that was
  718. 24:29uh maybe one of many disappointments,
  719. 24:31but maybe the next going to um
  720. 24:35be be right.
  721. 24:37Something is wrong right there. Be right
  722. 24:38with those leftover words. Something's
  723. 24:40wrong. She had a plan what she was going
  724. 24:41to say, and it didn't come out
  725. 24:42correctly. She tries to redirect. And if
  726. 24:45you look, and you really want to think
  727. 24:46about what would a person like this look
  728. 24:48like, they wouldn't be pushed back
  729. 24:50against the chair if they've been
  730. 24:51through all this trauma. They would look
  731. 24:52like him.
  732. 24:54He's shocky. You can see his brain can't
  733. 24:57comprehend what's going on. Never mind
  734. 24:59the TV camera might be part of it, but
  735. 25:01she has none of that. It's all just her.
  736. 25:04It's all just her telling whatever story
  737. 25:06she came there for, and the only place
  738. 25:07we see it's that pressure in the end and
  739. 25:09her using the wrong words. Uh Chase,
  740. 25:11what do you got?
  741. 25:13Yeah, so I think uh
  742. 25:15she starts this video off in stress. Her
  743. 25:18respirations are around 20 to 23.
  744. 25:22Her blink rate is at around 60. And keep
  745. 25:25in mind, the average blink rate is like
  746. 25:2713, 15, somewhere in there. Everybody's
  747. 25:29a little different.
  748. 25:32Her
  749. 25:33she uses a 3:00 eye movement to answer
  750. 25:36this question. So, her eyes go to your
  751. 25:393:00 as you're watching it, which is her
  752. 25:41baseline. So, that's her baseline. She's
  753. 25:43probably genuinely recalling how she
  754. 25:45feels for just a moment here. But, I
  755. 25:48think her thumb is a great, reliable
  756. 25:50indicator, and she's using her thumb as
  757. 25:52a pacifier a little bit with her
  758. 25:54husband. But, with the the biggest red
  759. 25:57flag in this entire interview in its
  760. 25:59entirety
  761. 26:00is her saying, "I think they they might
  762. 26:03have found one of my children."
  763. 26:06I really thought they found one of my
  764. 26:07children.
  765. 26:08Her just saying that is a huge indicator
  766. 26:11that this is something is way off in
  767. 26:14this.
  768. 26:16And then there's a uh
  769. 26:18super increase in blink rate right when
  770. 26:20she says, "One of my children."
  771. 26:23I think she either realized she made a
  772. 26:24mistake or that topic alone caused her
  773. 26:26some stress.
  774. 26:28Uh you can decide that.
  775. 26:30But, there's some internal dialogue
  776. 26:32where her eyes are going down this
  777. 26:33direction to describe her uh
  778. 26:36disappointment.
  779. 26:38But, I think what's interesting to see
  780. 26:40the whole picture here
  781. 26:41is that this is a woman hoping her
  782. 26:44children are never found, trying to show
  783. 26:47excitement for children being found, and
  784. 26:49then disappointment that they were not
  785. 26:52found
  786. 26:53at the same time.
  787. 26:55So, there's a whole lot going on and
  788. 26:56we're seeing a lot of mixed emotions. I
  789. 26:58think that's one of the reasons we're
  790. 26:59seeing a lot of this strange unusual
  791. 27:02behavior going on here because I think
  792. 27:04the husband here
  793. 27:06uh might still be a little hopeful and
  794. 27:09might still be a little scared or might
  795. 27:11be starting to suspect the person
  796. 27:12sitting beside him, which is another
  797. 27:14reason for him to be frozen still in
  798. 27:16this video.
  799. 27:18Uh Mark, what do you got?
  800. 27:20Uh I went.
  801. 27:21All right, good. That was a test.
  802. 27:23I passed.
  803. 27:24Let's be Scott, I think.
  804. 27:26What do you got?
  805. 27:26me.
  806. 27:27All right. Uh let's take a look at her
  807. 27:29thumbs. Where are in this her thumbs?
  808. 27:31She's She's over there in that She's
  809. 27:32adapting like a you know what on that
  810. 27:34guy, man. Just pulling her hand and
  811. 27:36pulling his hand and and squeezing it
  812. 27:38and doing her thumb up and down. That's
  813. 27:40an adapter. She's trying to get rid of
  814. 27:41that built-up stress or tension she's
  815. 27:43feeling at that time. And she's under a
  816. 27:45lot of stress. We know that because
  817. 27:46she's really still. She looks like
  818. 27:48somebody just walked in and said, "What
  819. 27:49are you doing?" And she's like, "What?
  820. 27:50Nothing. What are you doing?" And she's
  821. 27:52in the middle of doing something she
  822. 27:53shouldn't be doing. You're right, her
  823. 27:54blink rate is high. It goes through
  824. 27:56there and starts tick tick tick tick
  825. 27:57tick tick. I just did it, Greg. But her
  826. 28:00her blink rate goes way up. So, she's
  827. 28:03under attack and she's feeling that
  828. 28:04threat. That's another reason she's
  829. 28:05really really still. Um that's that odd
  830. 28:09smile at the top. That's she she doesn't
  831. 28:11know that's not the thing to do.
  832. 28:13Uh that's why we're seeing that. And
  833. 28:14this And this video we're seeing her her
  834. 28:17nostrils are flared
  835. 28:19uh more than any other video up to this
  836. 28:21point. I mean, they're almost the whole
  837. 28:22time they're wide open taking in that
  838. 28:24oxygen. Her fight or flight's on because
  839. 28:25she's under attack and she and she knows
  840. 28:28that. So, all these things we're talking
  841. 28:30about here, we're seeing all the
  842. 28:31distress. She's extremely stressed at
  843. 28:33this point. And when she starts talking
  844. 28:35about uh hoping the children are okay
  845. 28:38and they find at least one and all that,
  846. 28:40that she I think that's dawning on her
  847. 28:42as it's coming out that that's that's
  848. 28:44odd to be to be talking like that. And I
  849. 28:46agree with you, Chase. You're seeing a
  850. 28:47lot of things going on
  851. 28:49uh about what she's thinking right
  852. 28:51there. And she's thinking about one
  853. 28:53thing as she's talking about something
  854. 28:54else, but trying to make it look like
  855. 28:55something else. That's uh that's a great
  856. 28:58find. But all that leads to stress. So
  857. 29:01we're we're just seeing somebody If you
  858. 29:02want to see somebody under a lot of
  859. 29:03stress, take a look at her at this
  860. 29:04point.
  861. 29:05All right.
  862. 29:05Just keep watching.
  863. 29:07Yeah.
  864. 29:08Right now we want to go to Union to get
  865. 29:10the story first hand from Susan Smith
  866. 29:12and her husband David.
  867. 29:14Susan, how are you doing this morning?
  868. 29:16Uh doing okay. Uh very little sleep last
  869. 29:19night, but I'm okay.
  870. 29:22There was uh some news yesterday and and
  871. 29:24some promising leads uh in this case. Uh
  872. 29:28how are how are you coping with the
  873. 29:29disappointment of the news from
  874. 29:31yesterday?
  875. 29:32Um it was um
  876. 29:34I was running around uh my house
  877. 29:36yesterday morning all excited. I really
  878. 29:37thought that they had uh had had really
  879. 29:40found something that
  880. 29:42was I really thought they found one of
  881. 29:43my children and um
  882. 29:46when I got to the coal house and found
  883. 29:47out that the lead had um
  884. 29:50disintegrated or when there was nothing
  885. 29:51there, I was very devastated, very
  886. 29:53disappointed. Um
  887. 29:55got my hopes up and was let down, but uh
  888. 29:58I haven't given up hope. Uh you know,
  889. 30:02that was
  890. 30:03uh maybe one of many disappointments,
  891. 30:05but maybe the next going to um
  892. 30:09be be right.
  893. 30:11David, the question that that arises and
  894. 30:14and people who have been following this
  895. 30:15so closely and and certainly you have to
  896. 30:17know how much emotion that this is has
  897. 30:19generated across the country is why
  898. 30:22someone who would be interested in in in
  899. 30:26carjacking or or stealing a car would
  900. 30:28want to continue to to take a couple of
  901. 30:31little kids with them. Have Have you
  902. 30:33been able to fathom that or or could you
  903. 30:35think of why someone would want to
  904. 30:37kidnap a couple of little kids unless
  905. 30:39there was some ransom or something
  906. 30:41involved.
  907. 30:44No, I have no idea why
  908. 30:47the suspect has why he even took the
  909. 30:50children and why he has not released
  910. 30:52them yet. We have no knowledge
  911. 30:53whatsoever.
  912. 30:55All right.
  913. 30:58Wait a minute. I'll say it. I was going
  914. 30:59to do it, man.
  915. 31:02All right.
  916. 31:04I'm still going to do it. All right,
  917. 31:06Chase, what do you got? All right, Greg,
  918. 31:07what do you got?
  919. 31:10All right, Mark, what do you
  920. 31:13She's going to pass out if she keeps
  921. 31:15this interview up. She's in a place
  922. 31:16where her respiration is fluttering now.
  923. 31:18You can't miss it. I mean, you watch her
  924. 31:21her her breathing rate. I didn't count,
  925. 31:23but I'm going to guess it's somewhere
  926. 31:24around 40. That's pretty fast. It might
  927. 31:26even be higher than that. Chase, you
  928. 31:28probably counted.
  929. 31:29She's licking. She's grooming her mouth.
  930. 31:31All this stress is now caught up with
  931. 31:33her. Her eyes are down down to the right
  932. 31:35and then back up and then when he says,
  933. 31:37my favorite in the whole thing, and I'll
  934. 31:38leave it at that, when he says,
  935. 31:41"Well, we don't know."
  936. 31:44Her mouth moves.
  937. 31:45We have no knowledge whatsoever.
  938. 31:47Children, if you have a child and you
  939. 31:49don't teach them not to when they color,
  940. 31:51they'll go
  941. 31:53because when we're thinking and working
  942. 31:55out something, we move our mouths.
  943. 31:57Mammals do. It's just what we do.
  944. 31:59Horses do it. Dogs All All of us move
  945. 32:01our mouths a lot, but humans, when
  946. 32:03they're little children, will do it all
  947. 32:04the time. And I think that's leakage in
  948. 32:06her case of "Well, maybe." I think she's
  949. 32:09trying to figure out what she's going to
  950. 32:10say to make that
  951. 32:12come to the next level. If she were in a
  952. 32:14chair, I think we'd see pre-confession
  953. 32:15movement. She would start changing her
  954. 32:17body style here. Uh Scott, what do you
  955. 32:19got?
  956. 32:21I got 10 bucks that says somebody's
  957. 32:22going to make a GIF of you doing that
  958. 32:23with your mouth a second ago.
  959. 32:25I think within a week it'll be on
  960. 32:27Instagram. You know, they won't take
  961. 32:28bets on that.
  962. 32:29I'll go to I'll go to 50 bucks.
  963. 32:31I know where you live.
  964. 32:33I know.
  965. 32:35Anyway, so that's going
  966. 32:36shows up at your with a chain and drags
  967. 32:38your Traverse around, it wasn't me.
  968. 32:41Yeah. Ever tell you and so, go out and
  969. 32:44get something else.
  970. 32:46So, at this at this point I think her
  971. 32:48fight or flight is is the highest it's
  972. 32:49been so far. She's panicking as this guy
  973. 32:51is talking because she's thinking, "Is
  974. 32:53he going to say something that's going
  975. 32:53to get me in trouble? Is he going to say
  976. 32:55something
  977. 32:55something that that I'm not ready for
  978. 32:57that I can't defend at this point?" Her
  979. 32:59blink rate is through the roof and her
  980. 33:01nasal nostrils are flared again. We said
  981. 33:04one more time. I think her fight or
  982. 33:05flight is through the roof. Mark, what
  983. 33:07do you got?
  984. 33:08Yeah, I think you're right. I I think we
  985. 33:10actually see her ramp up in this. I
  986. 33:12mean, she starts pretty high and she
  987. 33:14goes up higher. And I think it's because
  988. 33:16her her partner here, I guess it's her
  989. 33:18husband, um uh
  990. 33:20really starts kneading into her her
  991. 33:23muscle tissue there. Uh because he is
  992. 33:26not prepared for this at all. He's in
  993. 33:29high anxiety. That is a strong signal
  994. 33:33for her. She I think is now going,
  995. 33:36"Well, this guy is out of control." So,
  996. 33:38just as you said there, Scott, "What's
  997. 33:40he going to say? Is he reliable?" And I
  998. 33:44think her breathing rate ramps up even
  999. 33:46further at at that moment there. So,
  1000. 33:49always great to see the combinations
  1001. 33:52that happen. Not just focus on one
  1002. 33:54individual, but how's the partnership
  1003. 33:56working? Just as I think it was Scott
  1004. 33:59was saying earlier, you know, that in
  1005. 34:01that video um that I don't think we can
  1006. 34:03see, but he was saying, "Look, you know,
  1007. 34:05if you look around the subject, you get
  1008. 34:08to understand the subject. Look at the
  1009. 34:11partnership that's happening here to
  1010. 34:13understand the subject." Chase, what do
  1011. 34:16you got on this one?
  1012. 34:17Yeah, I love that. So, let's really
  1013. 34:19quickly touch on nostril flaring or wing
  1014. 34:22dilation, as we call it. We have an
  1015. 34:25adrenaline spike that produces an an
  1016. 34:28equally high demand for oxygen. And when
  1017. 34:30you're trying to conceal your need for
  1018. 34:32oxygen cuz most of us will just open our
  1019. 34:34mouth
  1020. 34:35and openly breathe bigger.
  1021. 34:37But when we're trying to conceal it, we
  1022. 34:39use the nostril flaring unconsciously.
  1023. 34:41Our brain just says, "Okay, dilate the
  1024. 34:43nostrils if you're trying to keep your
  1025. 34:44mouth shut to oxygenate the blood going
  1026. 34:47to the brain primarily."
  1027. 34:50I like that the perpetrator appears. The
  1028. 34:53husband is asked and now there's a
  1029. 34:54perpetrator. We even hear the word
  1030. 34:56suspect, which is great. And he's using
  1031. 34:59his wife as a pacifier
  1032. 35:02throughout this thing. You can see him
  1033. 35:04just kind of going crazy. And she I
  1034. 35:06think she's stroking his hand to help
  1035. 35:07calm him down and just kind of get him
  1036. 35:10ready. Just remember what we talked
  1037. 35:11about. Just kind of just go right along
  1038. 35:13what we talked about.
  1039. 35:15But I think there's a strong drop of the
  1040. 35:17thumb of her thumb onto his hand at the
  1041. 35:20end of his statement. Right when he's
  1042. 35:21saying "No knowledge whatsoever."
  1043. 35:24We have no knowledge whatsoever.
  1044. 35:25But you're right, the blink rate and
  1045. 35:28breathing spikes as he begins. So we
  1046. 35:30actually in this clip, we're not seeing
  1047. 35:32it super high. We're seeing it spike
  1048. 35:35from the beginning. So we're getting to
  1049. 35:37see it escalate. So you'll be able to
  1050. 35:39see that and kind of train your brain to
  1051. 35:40see that in your everyday life using
  1052. 35:43this video as well. That's all I got.
  1053. 35:46Dave, but the question that that arises
  1054. 35:48in in people who have been following
  1055. 35:49this so closely and and certainly you
  1056. 35:51have to know how much emotion that this
  1057. 35:53has has generated across the country is
  1058. 35:56why someone who would be interested in
  1059. 35:59in carjacking or or stealing a car would
  1060. 36:03want to continue to to take a couple of
  1061. 36:05little kids with them. Have Have you
  1062. 36:07been able to fathom that or or could you
  1063. 36:10think of why someone would want to
  1064. 36:11kidnap a couple of little kids unless
  1065. 36:14there was some ransom or something
  1066. 36:15involved?
  1067. 36:18No, I have no idea why
  1068. 36:21the suspect has why he even took the
  1069. 36:24children and why he has not released him
  1070. 36:26yet, we have no knowledge whatsoever.
  1071. 36:30So, what do you got?

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of ⚡Can YOU Spot a Psychopath? SUSAN SMITH Up For Parole! by The Behavior Panel, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,836 words across 1,071 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.