Can stereotypes ever be good? - Sheila Marie Orfano and Densho — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:06In 2007, researchers surveyed over 180 teachers
2. 0:11to understand if they held stereotypes about students from three racial groups.
3. 0:16The results surfaced several negative stereotypes,
4. 0:20labeling Black students as aggressive and stubborn,
5. 0:23white students as selfish and materialistic,
6. 0:25and Asian students as shy and meek.
7. 0:28But regardless of the teachers’ other biases,
8. 0:31the most commonly held opinion was that Asian students
9. 0:34were significantly more industrious, intelligent, and gentle than their peers.
10. 0:39On the surface, this might seem like a good thing,
11. 0:42or at least better than other, negative characterizations.
12. 0:45But treating this seemingly favorable stereotype as reality
13. 0:49can actually cause a surprising amount of harm—
14. 0:51to those it describes, those it doesn’t, and even those who believe it to be true.
15. 0:56This image of humble, hard-working Asians is actually well-known
16. 1:00as the “model minority” stereotype.
17. 1:03Versions of this stereotype emerged in the mid-20th century
18. 1:06to describe Chinese Americans.
19. 1:08But following World War II,
20. 1:10the label became commonly used to claim that Japanese Americans
21. 1:14had overcome their mistreatment in US incarceration camps,
22. 1:18and successfully integrated into American society.
23. 1:21Former incarcerees were praised as compliant, diligent,
24. 1:25and respectful of authority.
25. 1:27In the following decades, “model minority” became a label
26. 1:31for many Asian populations in the US.
27. 1:33But the truth behind this story of thriving Asian Americans
28. 1:36is much more complicated.
29. 1:39During World War II,
30. 1:41the US government tried to “Americanize” incarcerated Japanese Americans.
31. 1:46They did this through English language classes, patriotic exercises,
32. 1:50and lessons on how to behave in white American society.
33. 1:54When incarcerees were released,
34. 1:56they were instructed to avoid returning to their own communities
35. 1:59and cultural practices,
36. 2:00and instead, integrate into white society.
37. 2:04But after decades of anti-Asian policies and propaganda,
38. 2:07white Americans had to be persuaded that Japanese Americans
39. 2:10were no longer a threat.
40. 2:12So the government organized media coverage to transform the public perception
41. 2:17of Japanese Americans from suspected traitors to an American success story.
42. 2:22In fact, the phrase “model minority” was coined by one such article from 1966.
43. 2:29But this article, and others like it,
44. 2:31didn’t just cast Asian Americans as an obedient and respectful “model minority."
45. 2:36They also criticized so-called “problem minorities,”
46. 2:40primarily Black Americans.
47. 2:43Politicians who were threatened by the rising Civil Rights movement
48. 2:47used this rhetoric to discredit Black Americans’ demands
49. 2:50for justice and equality.
50. 2:52They presented a fabricated story of Asian American success
51. 2:56to paint struggling Black communities as inferior.
52. 2:59This narrative put a wedge between Black and Asian Americans.
53. 3:03It erased their shared history of fighting oppression
54. 3:06alongside other marginalized groups,
55. 3:08and pit the two communities against each other.
56. 3:11In doing so, the model minority myth also enforced a racial hierarchy,
57. 3:16with white Americans on top and everyone else underneath.
58. 3:20Certainly, many people who still believe the model minority stereotype,
59. 3:25either consciously or unconsciously, might not agree with that idea.
60. 3:30But comparing the imagined strengths and weaknesses of racial groups
61. 3:33places value on how well those groups meet certain standards—
62. 3:37typically, standards set by a white majority.
63. 3:40In this case, the model minority stereotype
64. 3:43suggests that marginalized groups who are compliant, gentle, and respectful
65. 3:47of white authority are deserving of tolerance,
66. 3:50while groups that challenge the status quo are not.
67. 3:54This stereotype also negatively impacts the Asian individuals it describes.
68. 3:59According to a psychological phenomenon known as stereotype threat,
69. 4:04members of a group often place pressure on their individual actions
70. 4:08to avoid encouraging negative group stereotypes.
71. 4:11But this phenomenon can occur around seemingly positive stereotypes as well.
72. 4:16The pressure associated with living up to impossibly high standards
73. 4:20can lead to poor performance.
74. 4:22And teachers are less likely to notice when Asian students are struggling.
75. 4:27Outside the classroom, social programs catering to Asian communities
76. 4:31are frequently overlooked or cut,
77. 4:33because they’re assumed to need less support than other disadvantaged groups.
78. 4:38The favorable portrait created by this stereotype
79. 4:41can also make it harder to recognize racially motivated violence
80. 4:45and discrimination against Asian Americans.
81. 4:47And since this stereotype carelessly groups all Asians under the same umbrella,
82. 4:53it impacts people with various backgrounds and unique histories of discrimination.
83. 4:58So while the model minority label might appear
84. 5:01to benefit Asian populations at first,
85. 5:03in practice, it works like every other racial stereotype.
86. 5:08It reduces a group of people to a one-dimensional image.
87. 5:12And that single image hinders our ability to understand the history,
88. 5:16struggles, and triumphs of the individuals within that group.
89. 5:21Acknowledging and challenging these labels is essential for building coalitions
90. 5:25across communities and eliminating harmful stereotypes for good.