YouTube2Text

Can Muslims Resist Modernity? with Hasan Spiker — Transcript

by The Thinking Muslim · 16,787 words · 950 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Islam is a transformative path like no other  you're challenging the air that they breathe
  2. 0:05yeah questioning it is very very difficult if  Islam was so successful then why did we leave
  3. 0:11all of that and embrace a western modernity we  in the Muslim World mistook a marshal victory
  4. 0:19for an intellectual Victory that's a Sufi  way of thinking separating the sacred law
  5. 0:24from the spirit Nazism liberalism  just and communism they are all
  6. 0:30they're different manifestations of the same  phenomenon which is modernity it's not possible
  7. 0:36to import liberalism elsewhere Islam won't come in  and be a polite minority Gaza is the real mask off
  8. 0:44moment how do Muslims deal with what looks like a  comprehensive success of Western Civilization is
  9. 0:54it time to accept defeat as one right to put it  or does Islam have something to offer the world
  10. 1:01that can move us Beyond this dysfunctional system  Our Guest today is Hassen Spiker he argues that
  11. 1:09modernity is Western and its Embrace is a means to  Western hegemony and domination he's the author of
  12. 1:16a soon to be published book published on the 26th  of November the unraveling of intelligibility H
  13. 1:23spum and welcome back to the thinking Muslim  lovely to see you again well it's wonderful to
  14. 1:29have you with us and I think we've got a really  interesting conversation today about many topics
  15. 1:34which I think come together and I think a lot of  our Muslims and non-muslim viewers would like to
  16. 1:40understand just how Islam gets in to the modern  world uh and whether Islam can fit into the modern
  17. 1:46world and and there's a lot of there's a lot to  unpack here but there's also a lot to Define even
  18. 1:50modern world needs to definition it uh but let's  start with your framework you place this topic
  19. 1:57within a framework of disempowerment you argue  that the Muslim Community are disempowered like
  20. 2:03explain that idea to me please well I think what  it is is that we are profoundly disempowered by
  21. 2:10our general belief that modernity is universal  and neutral so it's not specifically Western now
  22. 2:19of course everyone knows that it is Western in  historical Genesis it took place as a result of
  23. 2:25particular changes and crystallized in the postl  post Enlightenment period perod and then you have
  24. 2:30the Industrial Revolution and then colonialism and  it spreads around the world yeah but there's this
  25. 2:35fundamental belief that somehow that particularity  just like every other civilization is particular
  26. 2:41has been transcended somehow somehow it's become  Universal right you'll find in the book that there
  27. 2:47are several authors one of them is vs nle for  example who has a very famous article on the
  28. 2:52universal civilization which he identifies with  Western modernity and he says sure it was there is
  29. 2:59a colonial past there there is this eurocentricism  there is this racism and that still causes pain
  30. 3:04but that's all in the past it became Universal at  a particular point it became the the property of
  31. 3:11all of mankind um and I think what disempowers the  Muslims is this false belief that something which
  32. 3:18is profoundly idiosyncratically Western is in fact  Universal and neutral so what do I mean by say you
  33. 3:26one might say that's a genetic fallacy who cares  if it's West just because we find out where it
  34. 3:31comes from doesn't mean that there's something  wrong with it right and of course look there
  35. 3:36isn't in every way something wrong with it this is  the the world that we live in the the the air we
  36. 3:40breathe you know and as we'll find out you know as  one will find out in the in the course of reading
  37. 3:46the book and and and I'm sure we come out in our  conversation today I'm not in any way advocating
  38. 3:51bashing the west or hoping that it disappears or  not partaking in in life in the west and so on
  39. 4:00um what this empowers us is this belief that  modernity is universal and neutral when modernity
  40. 4:08developed in order to provide solutions for very  idiosyncratic tensions that Afflicted Christian
  41. 4:19civilization in Europe in the late Middle  Ages and specifically the Renaissance the
  42. 4:27Reformation that led to the emergence of what we  call Early modernity yeah so when we when we talk
  43. 4:32about modernity what are we really talking about  here I mean I I would imagine that um many people
  44. 4:38when they hear the word modernity they think the  iPhone you know technology science progress AI
  45. 4:46like how do you understand maternity yeah I'm not  advocating that we all become Lites and and um to
  46. 4:53the farm or culture communities right yeah yeah  the I mean with provisos that's not quite what I'm
  47. 4:59advocating at all so yes exactly what I was saying  was leading directly onto your aggression which
  48. 5:04is what is modern there now there's a there's  an ambiguity just on a very basic level in the
  49. 5:10word modern because modern can mean at least two  things for our purposes here two things one is
  50. 5:16just the people who happen to be alive right now  are modern so if they were alive in the late 19th
  51. 5:22century they would have been modern and if they  alive in the 15th century they would have been
  52. 5:25modern yeah a lot of the times when people hear  you talking about modernity and their puzzled
  53. 5:29they're like what's your problem with us being  alive right now you know and that's that's really
  54. 5:34not what it is at all modernity is a specific par  philosophy just like every other philosophy is so
  55. 5:41you have the philosophy of modernity yeah it has  specific commitments it's a specific ideology what
  56. 5:47it basically means is the rejection of authority  the rejection of traditional god- centered a
  57. 5:58traditional god- centered hierarchical view of  the cosmos of being right so typically in both the
  58. 6:07Islamic world and the Christian world just to take  these two examples I mean I don't want to that's
  59. 6:11enough I think for us to deal with those two very  broad examples uh typically this is really a theic
  60. 6:19understanding which is that the world is in some  sense in some sense reveals the presence of God
  61. 6:28nature reveals the presence of God you know we  have in Islam the concept of the aat you know the
  62. 6:35aat in the s in the soul in themselves rather  and on the horizons these are signs these are
  63. 6:41signs right by which we move in our heart in our  intellect from the physical phenomena as we call
  64. 6:51it today to the underlying metaphysical reality  right and this idea that on those Horizons in
  65. 6:59in our eles we acquire through the F through  the you know a pure original disposition yeah
  66. 7:07knowledge of aesthetical judgments what is the  beautiful knowledge of moral judgments what is
  67. 7:14the good and knowledge of metaphysical truths  right what is the true what is true about what
  68. 7:22is the fundamental nature of this existence  now what modernity involves and again you know
  69. 7:29I have have to kind of condense it here because  it's going to it can only come out I think when
  70. 7:33we talk about the five bations yes in detail  but what it basically involves is at a certain
  71. 7:40point in European history yeah a point of Crisis  was reached where it didn't seem possible to any
  72. 7:48longer believe in that theophanic unified vision  of existence and so you have several raptures very
  73. 7:57very cataclysmic events um like the Protestant  Reformation like the 30 years war that followed
  74. 8:06in which 4 million Europeans died it's by far  the largest loss of life until you you know have
  75. 8:13the mechanized Warfare of the 20th century yes and  you know suddenly Europe is is Ren in two and this
  76. 8:22what it fundamentally involves is a rejection  of the old Catholic order right and this new
  77. 8:29focus on the individual as the ultimate Arbiter  of Truth when it comes to metaphysical matters and
  78. 8:38really the broad idea that we are cut off from  the metaphysical fundamentally except through
  79. 8:44pure faith and all we can really hope to know is  the physical world and particularly in so far as
  80. 8:53it's knowable through the scientific method and  so you have the Scientific Revolution following
  81. 8:58on very quick ly from the Protestant Revolution  but we'll we'll get to that when we come to but
  82. 9:03but essentially it's a split you know obviously  can be summed up as the secular split yes where
  83. 9:14we all of our social formations our social  organization our political structures our
  84. 9:20even even our understanding of ethics and now all  carried out systematically without reference to re
  85. 9:29ation or metaphysics we have sorry but we have  we have we are now self-enclosed right in this
  86. 9:37in this world we don't need anything outside of  it or Beyond it I mean husand we have a lot of
  87. 9:41non-muslims who listen to and watch our show and  they will be surprised that you find that to be
  88. 9:47contentious I mean in the modern world there is  this assumption that we can't connect all of our
  89. 9:55live all of our life all of our life's problems  to a metaphysical uh reality we can't say that you
  90. 10:04know there needs to be God needs to participate  in our daily lives in our political Affairs in
  91. 10:11our social Affairs in in what we call Justice in  our moral understanding fine you know we may have
  92. 10:17some moral codes that guide us but fundamentally  that connection should be severed because when it
  93. 10:23was present in Europe uh and and maybe other parts  of the world it uh stifled creativity it's stifled
  94. 10:31progress and what's your retort to that well  it's definitely multifaceted I would say first
  95. 10:39of all yes I'm arguing from a very very marginal  position right and when you arguing from a very
  96. 10:46very marginal position it's sometimes difficult  to communicate what you mean to people because
  97. 10:51you're challenging the air that they breathe yeah  you're challenging it's it's like nature said we
  98. 10:57cannot see it because it has been Victorious  because this worldview of modernity has been
  99. 11:04so triumphantly successful everywhere questioning  it is very very difficult it's like questioning
  100. 11:12something so fundamental that you've never noticed  it's there before in it's well it's it's it's
  101. 11:17almost difficult to countenance now but why is  this so important and in reality not a marginal
  102. 11:25view at all well it's because everything which  was B ific at and severed in the west including
  103. 11:32this broad secular split we've been describing  remained whole in the Islamic world right until
  104. 11:39the end end being 20th century well right until  it it differs depending on the place I mean there
  105. 11:45are convenient dates one can give you know Indian  Mutiny uh end of the copit uh there are various
  106. 11:53and it's it's it's impossible to give a particular  date and it's not that everything has completely
  107. 11:58disappeared sure and and of course there there  there you many many uh things to discuss about
  108. 12:05that and kind of almost Infinity of details  about the precise status of that traditional
  109. 12:10worldview in the Muslim world yeah that's in  in a to a large degree what the the book is
  110. 12:14about um because many of the most passionate and  committed Advocates of this Universal neutral sent
  111. 12:29ific civilization are Muslims within Muslim  countries right um and I think that is more than
  112. 12:35anything else what the book is trying to tackle  yeah but um but what I'd say is that is uh the
  113. 12:42yes we grow up I mean speaking to the the Western  interlocutor non-muslim perhaps interlocutor that
  114. 12:48you were referring to I think it's just realizing  that what we think is just the way the world is
  115. 12:57is actually a very specific philosophical choice  that we have inherited we haven't usually thought
  116. 13:03about very much most of that stuff about well  human flourishing social Mobility creativity
  117. 13:12all that stuff it didn't exist in the medieval  world most of that is Protestant propaganda which
  118. 13:17has been very successful for hundreds of years  right there are many studies and one can Google
  119. 13:22this which show definitively there was more social  mobility in the Middle Ages in Europe than there
  120. 13:28is today and there are many there there many of  the assumptions that we make are simply not true
  121. 13:39but I think that I think what we would I think  where we'd get to the meat of this is when we talk
  122. 13:43about the five bations which or the severances or  the splits you might say which forms the the the
  123. 13:49main explanatory kind of means of analysis in this  book yeah um I think there we'd be able to to kind
  124. 13:57of bring out um details of exactly how it's not  tenable to look at modernity as as universal and
  125. 14:05neutral it was a choice it could well never have  happened um and it was very much and it didn't
  126. 14:13happen in outside of Europe right and why did  it not happen it's because those very specific
  127. 14:19tensions that existed quite uniquely in Europe  mostly in vir of the nature of Christianity and
  128. 14:25the absence of Islam didn't ex exist elsewhere  and so it's a very much an anachronistic you know
  129. 14:33out of proper chronology and anatopism place  M phenomenon for the Muslim world to Simply
  130. 14:41blly accept all of this uh all of these Western  cultural products as if they are neutral but it
  131. 14:49begs the question if if Islam was so successful  in creating a type of society that innovated and
  132. 14:59that had progress and that uh produced culture  and civilization and science then why did we uh
  133. 15:07leave all of that and embrace a western modernity  like what's the cause behind that Embrace in the
  134. 15:16first place beautiful question it's summed up by  a quotation from by muster sub the last in Islam
  135. 15:25in his three volume work which was written in the  50 and and is his it's a critique of modernity and
  136. 15:33critique of Islamic modernism all sorts of amazing  things he says we in the Muslim World mistook
  137. 15:41a marshal victory for an intellectual Victory  right so we assumed because we've been defeated
  138. 15:49militarily they must have everything right it's  so overwhelming this defeat it's so crushing for
  139. 15:55our spirit it's so difficult for our pride we  need to catch up we've fallen behind whereas
  140. 16:02yes there's no doubt the Western World developed  scientifically again we tend to think of science
  141. 16:14as neutral there's a sense in which it is there's  another sense in which it's absolutely not and and
  142. 16:23this is something that we'll discuss when we get  to the severance of knowing subject in nature but
  143. 16:28what it basic basically involves is at a certain  point in the mostly 17th century in the Scientific
  144. 16:37Revolution the West turned from a view of nature  decisively turned away from a from the previously
  145. 16:46dominant view of nature which is more largely  shared by the Islamic world as a theophonic
  146. 17:00the fundamental purpose of study of the study  of nature in that uh in that worldview in that
  147. 17:06framework is to get us closer to God closer to  knowledge of God right yes there is a place for
  148. 17:14practical contrivances and Technology but it's  not a central place what changes is a a shift
  149. 17:22from the view of nature as theophanic as revealing  the Divine to a view of nature as simply so much
  150. 17:29raw material as Brad Gregory puts it awaiting the  imprint of our desires right as in uh science is
  151. 17:38about the Mastery of nature the exploitation of  nature we don't care what it is we don't care
  152. 17:45what spiritual reality it has we don't care about  any of that that's all subjective that's all your
  153. 17:50belief you're welcome to it but the real world  is US exploiting nature and making lots of money
  154. 17:57right so I me that's a bit of no it's it's very  useful and before we get to your fications that in
  155. 18:03a sense I think that's the meat of your argument  um how much like so we've said secularism almost
  156. 18:10underpins modernity it's division between uh you  know human life and God and we will come to that
  157. 18:19um like would you would you place liberalism even  Marxism within uh this Broad La of modernity oh
  158. 18:30absolutely yeah yeah both of them yeah and so in a  in a sense what what you're arguing and I suppose
  159. 18:36will come to this is that Muslims have to reject  these ideologies U because they're not Universal
  160. 18:44they're very particular to a western experience in  particular Western experience of religion exactly
  161. 18:50so let's let's then talk about these bations  or severances as you call them or separations
  162. 18:56because I think that was really really fascinating  so the first uh bation you talk about in your in
  163. 19:02your great book is is the division between sacred  law and spirit explain that to me kids okay so
  164. 19:09one of the most characteristic aspects of Corine  Christianity right of course Paul of tarus is this
  165. 19:18disciple of Jesus is except he's not he never met  Jesus or but I'll say Jesus because we're talking
  166. 19:27in the context of you the contemporary Christian  view of everything we're discussing he never met
  167. 19:35Jesus and he was of course a Jew who before he  became a Christian was actually persecuting the
  168. 19:42church quite avidly he was a major antagonist  and enemy of the early church and on the road to
  169. 19:51Damascus he purports to have had a vision where  Jesus invited him to joined his church and he
  170. 20:01became a Christian having had this charismatic  experience this mystical experience and without
  171. 20:09getting into too many of the details of his life  he departed from the Christianity of the actual
  172. 20:15Disciples of Jesus in Jerusalem and this is even  recounted in the Acts of the Apostles in the New
  173. 20:23Testament by wanting to bring the da as it were  the the message of Christianity to the Gentiles
  174. 20:32whereas Jesus even in the gospel says that he  was only sent to the lost sheep of the children
  175. 20:37of Israel right just as indeed the Quran says of  him just as indeed Islam says of him that he was
  176. 20:43only sent um to the the the Jewish people with  his message and the key aspect of this is that
  177. 20:52Paul said the law is abrogated we don't need to  to ask new converts to follow the law it's been
  178. 21:02abrogated by Christ crucified Christ's sacrifice  where he takes away our sins and through that act
  179. 21:11of belief in him that pure grace it's abated  the law the law was this curse on us he even
  180. 21:17uses that word because we could never live up  to it we had to follow every jot and title as
  181. 21:23in as indeed Jesus says in the gospels or every  fine detail I mean that's the King James version
  182. 21:28J and title um every fine detail of the law must  be adhered to he says well that's impossible can't
  183. 21:34even do it in principle so it's this curse the  law Jesus has come to abrogate the law and the
  184. 21:39new dispensation is pure is based on this leap  of faith in Christ and this affective personal
  185. 21:46relationship with the Christ the crucified Christ  um what has this led to it's led to an inability
  186. 21:54to understand that in Islam we have a Shar to a  certain extent in Judaism but in Islam we have
  187. 22:02the Sharia which is we understand as sanctifying  it's not this kind of obsessive compulsive list
  188. 22:07of things that we have to worry about all the time  we all gosh it's something that allows us to get
  189. 22:12closer to God in every scenario in every object  in every action right it's a detailed revealed law
  190. 22:21Christianity poor land Christianity doesn't have  that uh it doesn't have this understanding that
  191. 22:28you follow a a detailed law which governs every  aspect of your life right all right um and so
  192. 22:36there's this disconnect and there's this sense not  only that they don't NE need to go together the
  193. 22:41revealed law and the spirit but they're somehow  really opposed to one another really the spiritual
  194. 22:46life is exactly not adhering to a law yeah that's  because this world is fundamentally self-contained
  195. 22:56I mean I'm bringing in a little bit of Lutheran  here I should probably save that to the for the
  196. 23:00to the faith and and reason split but the basic  idea is God hasn't revealed a detailed uh plan for
  197. 23:10every single action every single item is it Halal  is it haram and so on um and that's not what would
  198. 23:18save us anyway that's an outdated understanding  of religion what saves us is simply that faith in
  199. 23:23Christ crucified yeah and that is the litmus tast  that is the so that is what is so serologically
  200. 23:32think I said that right soteriology it means the  the uh the Salvation the nature of Salvation what
  201. 23:42what what brings about salvation and for them it's  not adherence to a revealed law it's uh simply the
  202. 23:49act of belief belief in in in Christ and and as  with later yeah it would it's not just Christ
  203. 23:56crucified but it's Christ when the the Incarnate  God crucified so it becomes even more significant
  204. 24:05and momentous it you know God himself and AR only  comes into is it only purported to come into the
  205. 24:10flesh once at one particular moment in history you  know if you miss that you're in trouble right I
  206. 24:16think that's really interesting so because of it  is the case that we come across Muslims over time
  207. 24:21today I suppose now you're packaging it you're  explaining it in the context of the supremacy
  208. 24:26I suppose of modernity Upon Our Lives m who argue  that who almost underplay the role of sharia and
  209. 24:33claim that the Sharia is is not really important  in our lives and what is important is that of his
  210. 24:39over overarching spiritual claims ex that a Muslim  need to subscribe to exactly that's so in a sense
  211. 24:45you're saying that that comes originally from  Christianity and modernity universalizes that
  212. 24:53way of thinking absolutely what I'm also saying is  it is the first chronologically in these series of
  213. 24:59bations so one thing leads to another right yes  exactly as you say it's a very insightful point
  214. 25:05because who are those Muslims who are say who are  advocating what you're what what you're saying
  215. 25:09yeah they're the modernists right usually so  that's very significant it's because of precisely
  216. 25:14what we're discussing but but more immediately  the relevance of the split between LA and spirit
  217. 25:21is that it leads directly onto the other bations  and informs them I'm going to be terribly unkind
  218. 25:27and and and ignorant here in a way but I often  hear people say no that's a Sufi way of thinking
  219. 25:33uh separating the sacred law from the spirit um  you know you we have a lot of non-muslims who
  220. 25:40may come into Islam through Sufism that's true  so explain the Sufi perspective on this matter
  221. 25:46yeah that's the exact diametrical opposite of the  truth but um but you're absolutely right that is
  222. 25:52a this is a common conception today and I suppose  that's for for number of reasons I think very much
  223. 26:00it's to do with as you said these fundamentally  Christian conceptions of the of the fundamental
  224. 26:08split between law and spirit they've got nothing  to do with each other you don't need law if you've
  225. 26:11got Spirit yeah um and simply informing the modern  mindset whether someone's a Muslim or a non-muslim
  226. 26:19and then when people want to make Islam on a DA  level uh more attractive to spiritually minded
  227. 26:27Muslims they say well here you go you've got  Sufism where you don't need the the law because
  228. 26:30that's the spiritual aspect if there's a spiritual  if there's a mystical aspect it must be antinomian
  229. 26:36right whereas that just doesn't follow in  our context but I think that's just a basic
  230. 26:39assumption they make that if if there's a spirit  if there's a mystical path it must be anomen right
  231. 26:44you know it must be opposed to the law it's quite  it's it's the total opposite of the truth um you
  232. 26:49know the the conception in Sufism is that and so  revealed law or sacred law and spiritual reality
  233. 27:03are absolutely Inseparable and complimentary yeah  you can't have one without the other without one
  234. 27:10being incomplete and having something wrong with  it um so in order to regulate and provide solid
  235. 27:19foundations for one's one's servanthood to God  which is the ultimate purpose of Sufism on one
  236. 27:25important level yes one has to adhere one has to  have that submission to the detailed law one can't
  237. 27:30just say why I'm so spiritual I don't need to pray  anymore cuz I'm already seen God no that that's
  238. 27:36part of our overa are part of our servanthood and  submission to God and then the other way around a
  239. 27:42detailed adherence to the law while forgetting  that it's God that you're worshiping that's uh
  240. 27:48that's not very good either so I think that  would be the basic Sufi understanding and and
  241. 27:54just to I know we want to go into all five  of the bations but think I find it's really
  242. 27:59interesting because uh you do find that a number  of non-muslims and Muslims who come back into the
  243. 28:05faith they Embrace this version of Sufism uh to  the degree as you said that they downplay the
  244. 28:11Sharia but then they site Imam gazali for example  as someone who rejected at the age of 40 or in in
  245. 28:18the midlife he rejected the Sharia and he placed  the spiritual side of his Spirit to be of a higher
  246. 28:27value is that a misreading of there's very much a  misreading of elali but I can understand how that
  247. 28:34narrative can take c um and it's because what  Imam Al gazali critiques are precisely what we
  248. 28:43were just discussing which are the fuka or those  who are well would you say the doctors of law or
  249. 28:49those who are engage legal scholars in the most  basic sense yeah legal Scholars he's critiquing
  250. 28:54legal Scholars who have lost sight of of the  spiritual reality which is the whole you the
  251. 28:59whole Telos the whole purpose the whole underlying  motivation for engaging in um a detailed study of
  252. 29:08the Sacred law and so his critique is that because  they lose sight of the spiritual reality and
  253. 29:14what it's all for they fall into worldliness and  there even though it has you know it it presents
  254. 29:21itself as Dean and F and all this stuff it it's  actually becomes worldly for them purely worldly
  255. 29:28um and so that's really what he's critiquing but  he's absolutely not opposed to the Sharia in any
  256. 29:33way and in fact he's quite to the contrary of  course on every level but but incidentally he's
  257. 29:38also one of the most important Sher scholars in  in history of course one of the the four schools
  258. 29:43of Islamic law um he he's one of the four or five  most important shery Scholars of them all great uh
  259. 29:52your second Severance or verification of modernity  is the separation of tor power sacred power yeah
  260. 30:00explain that to me J so Jesus in the gospels is  supposed to have said Render unto Caesar such
  261. 30:08things as a Caesars and Render unto God such  things as a Gods now I'm not in a position to
  262. 30:15say didam actually speak these words or not and  I don't think anyone really is and we have to
  263. 30:22suspend judgment on that and is there a legitimate  way of is there a legitimate way of interpreting
  264. 30:30that from a Muslim perspective from Islamic  perspective from an authentic Islamic perspective
  265. 30:34very possibly but let's look at the actual impact  that it had on subsequent Western Civilization
  266. 30:40yeah this is fundamentally the secular principle  and it plays out and gets lots of people in lots
  267. 30:47of trouble throughout the Middle Ages lots of  conflict between popes and princes and we'll
  268. 30:52mention one in just a moment and it then with  lu uh with the Treaty of olsburg and the Peace
  269. 31:01of West failure and you know the aftermath of the  of the religious wars and then trying to actually
  270. 31:08theorize about tolerance of the religious other  and so so than lock and so on then it finally
  271. 31:14crystallizes into secularism proper but what it  basically means is unlike in the Islamic world
  272. 31:22where you have a single Shere detailed law which  encompasses the political which by finds Prince
  273. 31:30and King and temporal power and the alike you  simply don't have the problems that arise in the
  274. 31:41west because of this split between temporal power  and sacred power so what it basically amounts to
  275. 31:49is the fact that you have a pope who possesses  the ultimate Authority on spiritual matters
  276. 31:58mhm and he doesn't have a detailed Shar because  there isn't one he's arbitrarily The Authority
  277. 32:07it's him what's his criteria being the pope  right whatever he says that is the actual fact
  278. 32:18of the matter when it comes to religious Doctrine  spiritual reality and so on now the princeling the
  279. 32:25prince the king is under the Pope on the spiritual  level because he's a Catholic so he's under the
  280. 32:34the Pope's Spiritual Authority but Render unto  Caesar such things as the Caesars so the temporal
  281. 32:43ruler has jurisdiction when it comes to temporal  matters however because they're not they're not
  282. 32:52governed by a Sharia that is binding on them both  you have this series of hugely disruptive disputes
  283. 33:02throughout the Middle Ages between the pope and  the temporal powers that be just one example is
  284. 33:08the 14th century dispute between Pope bonatti and  King Philip the fair of France now this is one of
  285. 33:18the most famous of these disputes these secular  disputes the or what would later come to be known
  286. 33:25as secularism what took place is that Pope bonae  wanted his clergy in France to be Exempted from
  287. 33:37all taxation because they're clergy MH um he  didn't want to be subject to taxation by the
  288. 33:45king of France and he told the king of France as  much we're not going to be taxed yes right um we
  289. 33:54are exerting our Spiritual Authority and it's you  know we must not be attacked because you know we
  290. 34:00are the spiritual Authority and we have a special  status and he was hoping that King philli was just
  291. 34:06going to go along with this but unfortunately  for Pope bfactory Philip was having absolutely
  292. 34:14none of it and he said no I'm not going to exempt  under any circumstances and of course you have to
  293. 34:19imagine the Catholic church has immense well this  is a this is a huge source of tax revenue for him
  294. 34:25it makes a difference so Pope manufa issues a very  very famous Pap ball called Unum sanum it's a very
  295. 34:38famous document in the history of the of well of  the of secularism as I suppose we'd rather anistic
  296. 34:45call it and of the Catholic church and of Western  Civilization RIT large and in that document Bona
  297. 34:54asserts the papal authority over over even the  temporal powers on most occasions we're fine to
  298. 35:02leave the temporal powers to their own business  and get on with it but there are questions like
  299. 35:06this where we actually do have ultimate authority  over you and what he tries to do is he tries to
  300. 35:13invoke the hierarchy of being and you know we  actually are you know our hierarchy of of the
  301. 35:20church is reflective of the hierarchy of the  angels and we actually do metaphysically have
  302. 35:24power over you so you better listen and he he's  invoking there the dionan dius the aropa his
  303. 35:32account of of hierarchy and metaphysical hierarchy  I've written about that this particular episode
  304. 35:38in this book but also in my other book hierarch  in Freedom where specifically about UNAM sanctum
  305. 35:42in that book um and you know the pope was hoping  that this would be an end to it and he'd he'd be T
  306. 35:49tax exempt um and uh what happened is King Philip  decided instead that well I think we're just kidna
  307. 35:57pope benaa then yes and they kidnapped him and  took him away to a castle and said no it's not
  308. 36:03going to happen well uh you know you've got to  pay your taxes and um Pope benat a few days later
  309. 36:11actually died of the shock unfortunately so that's  just one episode in you know many many uh many
  310. 36:19many episodes in the history of the this tension  between the secular powers and and the sacred
  311. 36:26Powers you know there's a similar thing at play  um in um the uh the assassination of of Archbishop
  312. 36:38um uh Beckett uh in the in the in the Cathedral  at Canterbury um that's one other major major uh
  313. 36:50violent uh dispute between the Pope the church and  the King and then of course you know you have what
  314. 37:00takes place in the English Reformation between  King Henry VII and the pope and that leads to a
  315. 37:05huge Rapture which again is one of the things that  we that is discussed in the book um so there's
  316. 37:13always been this tension and what It ultimately  leads to is this understanding that these two
  317. 37:20domains have to be kept strictly separate  the temporal and the sacred the temporal and
  318. 37:25the sacred and the sacred is ultimately going to  become something just as it is today personalized
  319. 37:31it's personalized you don't talk about it in  public it's not polite it's embarrassing we
  320. 37:37protect your right to engage in that but it's a  personal choice and you keep it at home how how
  321. 37:44important was the development of protestantism  in the 16th century to the secularism process
  322. 37:50because my understanding and and correctly if  I'm wrong is you know if we're talking about the
  323. 37:54personalizing of Faith then protestantism lends  itself to very much to a personalized faith more
  324. 38:00so than Christianity with the melding of temporal  in sacred power is that is that a fair reading of
  325. 38:07of Christian history I think very much so I think  one of the things that lends itself to secularism
  326. 38:15secularism as it develops in protestantism is  the fact that Luther what he does he's very big
  327. 38:23on this render under Caesar thing right he's very  into obeying the temporal authorities yeah and the
  328. 38:32settlement what actually Saves the Day for Luther  is that the local Prince becomes a Lutheran oh
  329. 38:41right he protects Luther the settlements which  bring the terrible Strife between Catholic and
  330. 38:49Protestant to an end Augsburg and West failure  are all about saying we respect we will tolerate
  331. 38:59we will not wage war on we will protect the rights  of subjects within a PO as long as they follow the
  332. 39:09religious choice of their ruler so he can become  a Lutheran or he can become a Catholic and this
  333. 39:17is and that this will become a a Lutheran land and  this will remain a Catholic land and we will enter
  334. 39:24into a treaty of Peace on that basis of respect  that yeah that the the religion of the people
  335. 39:30is to follow the religion of the ruler now you  can see that is a relativizing factor to a large
  336. 39:36extent it's no longer relevant which of them is  true we have a political set set settlement which
  337. 39:42is fundamentally credential and pragmatic right  and um and you know this gives rise to the in
  338. 39:50know it contributes in large to the birth of the  this conception of the nation state the sovereign
  339. 39:57nation state which is has a national church and  has a n National religion and this this tradition
  340. 40:10is kept in the line of succession of the kings  that this is a a Lutheran country or this is a an
  341. 40:16Anglican country in the case of England or this is  a a Catholic country so um yeah this is very much
  342. 40:25a consequence to a large extent of the Protestant  Reformation absolutely so I want to ask you about
  343. 40:32that because 1648 is the Treaty of West failure  and uh According to some Western historians that's
  344. 40:38sort of the birth case of the nation state and  you've explained that very well that you know now
  345. 40:43the RIT of a centralized church is torn apart  and and it's really now up to each individual
  346. 40:50principality and PR to to Define their religious  complexion and there should be non-interference
  347. 40:56between states so uh is the nation state project  then intertwined with this project of modernity
  348. 41:03can we add nation state to his bucket uh and  if so is there something particular about the
  349. 41:09nation state that uh Islam would be antagonistic  towards absolutely and I think it's very much
  350. 41:19bound up with what we've just been discussing um  I mean nationalism involves making the ultimate
  351. 41:27Criterion for identity for Collective identity  what you know a particular ethnic background a
  352. 41:34particular Geographic situatedness and context and  and location and this in many ways has proved to
  353. 41:43be a replacement for religion but it's it's  antithetical to Islamic conceptions of our
  354. 41:52fundamental you know Brotherhood and Sisterhood  Umma exactly um you we are all from Adam and Adam
  355. 42:02is from clay there's no superiority of a of an  Arab over a non-arab except but you know through
  356. 42:09Taqua um and this was played out in throughout  Islamic history and you know one of the saddest
  357. 42:19I think departures from this and and this is very  relevant to the context that we're talking about
  358. 42:24is the nationalism that you now see and you it's  been some time some decades now emerging in the
  359. 42:31in some places close to a century emerging in the  Muslim world for example in Turkey where you have
  360. 42:37this very very strong sense of Turkish identity  and nationalism to the extent that if someone's
  361. 42:41Bosnian or Albanian they will tend to hide it  because it will lead to a kind of lower social
  362. 42:46status and suspicion and so on um whereas in the  Oban world no one knew who was Arab or this or
  363. 42:54that or Albania or balcan or Turkish and I mean  it's not that it was completely unknown but it
  364. 42:59was not a significant factor at all right um and  it's true that in the later otoman period there
  365. 43:08were because of the infiltration of certain  Western ideas there were various nationalist
  366. 43:13movements that's why sulan Abdul Hamed for example  made sure to get an Arab Shak Islam because he
  367. 43:19really wanted to aim towards Islamic Unity he  wanted to just break that because he could see
  368. 43:24that it was a cancer um so so absolutely I think  that nationalism is very very much bound up with
  369. 43:32this the identitarian understanding that there  is self-creation um of identity uh it doesn't
  370. 43:43reflect a Transcendent reality it will basically  fundamentally be based on political realities and
  371. 43:50so you know the the because the the fundamental  reality is the political then we're going to
  372. 43:56Define our identity as a collectivity in terms of  that political framework which is very specific
  373. 44:02um it's the nation and so on um I know we we're  still on our second bif fication or Seance but I'm
  374. 44:09fascinated by all of this because it's putting  together a lot of discret ideas in my mind so
  375. 44:14thank you very much for that so liberalism uh you  commonly it's John known that John Lock developed
  376. 44:20the idea or the the basic Contour of this ideology  of liberalism so how how important was what you've
  377. 44:27just discussed so far the severance of sacred law  and spirit and temporal power and sacred power how
  378. 44:34important were these events or these formations to  the development of liberalism as an idea they're
  379. 44:42immensely important very very important of the  absolute utmost importance and again this is
  380. 44:49very relevant to the non-transferability of  liberalism to anywhere outside of Europe and
  381. 44:55it's just anachronistic and and the top istic  um it's one of my new favorite words I managed
  382. 45:01to say it correctly twice now um so it it's not  possible to import liberalism elsewhere and when
  383. 45:10you try it it just it doesn't work right um now  it's basically for the following reason liberalism
  384. 45:19was in its Inception meant to provide a larger  neutral societal framework for different Christian
  385. 45:34denominations to exist together yeah in that  neutral domain and religion has become a private
  386. 45:47Affair it's Blind Faith it's a leap of faith it's  you know the individual with his subjectivity with
  387. 45:55his translated Bible and it's something that one  keeps to oneself it's such a source of dissension
  388. 46:04when it's brought outside and claims are made and  so we've moved beyond that now these interminable
  389. 46:12theological debates which can't be can't be  resolved even in principle again it's a kind
  390. 46:19of self-fulfilling prophecy to say they can't be  resolved because one of Luther's great moves as
  391. 46:23we'll find out when it comes to Severance number  three faith and reason was to say you know reason
  392. 46:30human rationality has nothing to do with theology  never it can't resolve anything it's afflicted by
  393. 46:38original sin just like the accursed natural world  is as well he's a bit negative um Luther and so
  394. 46:46this has been one of the Great Tricks of the devil  in the Catholic order that Aristotle was brought
  395. 46:53in and everything was highly rationalized so  it's a kind of self aill prophecy that these
  396. 46:58debates are interminable um but the point is they  were you know in practice interminable and they
  397. 47:04were causing immense dissension so the general  and of course we're talking very broad Strokes
  398. 47:09here because we're covering lots of history but  the the general approach in early modernity post
  399. 47:17Reformation was Faith becomes a personal thing  right liberalism provides the framework in which
  400. 47:27different Christian denominations can coexist  peacefully so it's a step above just saying
  401. 47:34you're going to be whatever religion your ruler  happens to be it's saying we could actually have
  402. 47:38different Christian denominations here now it  was very limited as you know for John lock that
  403. 47:43didn't include Catholics um no Catholics and no  no atheists at that point um now I have often
  404. 47:52said and thought that it makes perfect sense  that liberalism in ultimately was not able to
  405. 48:01fulfill its own promise that it would actually be  able to genuinely tolerate Muslims yeah and we're
  406. 48:07seeing that playing out on so many levels today  and and really post 911 onwards it it escalate
  407. 48:13and then post Gaza it's become a big thing again  but you know when you look at the history this
  408. 48:19makes perfect sense liberalism wasn't created  actually to host um every species of Bel there
  409. 48:27had to be a commitment to the severance that made  it possible in the first place the severances that
  410. 48:35made it possible in the first place I.E either  Christian or post-christian but not Islam that's
  411. 48:41completely different that doesn't make sense  especially because Islam won't come in and be a
  412. 48:49polite minority and say we're not actually making  claims to the objective truth of Islam because
  413. 48:56they would like is an Islam which will come and  say well I'll just be a polite minority with
  414. 49:00my private Faith as well and and get on with you  know contributing to being a good British Citizen
  415. 49:04and that's more important to me more British  than this um which is what you know many in
  416. 49:11the western establishment want Muslims to say and  and you know many Muslims have been very obliging
  417. 49:17unfortunately um but I think the reason that  liberalism has such trouble really tolerating
  418. 49:24Islam is because it's a counter Germany MH that's  how they really view it to be fair that's what it
  419. 49:31really is good yeah um and the only thing that  liberalism cannot tolerate is anything which
  420. 49:40undermines liberalism fantastic let's move on I  mean there's a lot more to disc that but I think
  421. 49:46we could insh I think we've almost got three or  four episodes that insh we'll in the future but
  422. 49:52let's when talk about faith and reason your third  Severance explain the that bation between faith
  423. 49:58and reason okay this is very interesting you know  mely the new atheists which you know were Richard
  424. 50:06Dawkins Daniel Dennett Sam Harris all these people  you know when I was growing up in the early 2000s
  425. 50:12they were very very popular and very very dominant  they're not massively that popular anymore thank
  426. 50:16god um but I think that they're useful they're  useful case study just in terms of making sense of
  427. 50:24the split between faith and reason because it is  it is a historical phenomenon but what it led to
  428. 50:29and this is the test of all these severances what  do do they lead to this fundamental shaping of the
  429. 50:37basic assumptions of the average man and woman  in the street now Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris
  430. 50:44were actually completely inept philosophically  and theologically and many people you to give
  431. 50:49them credit many excellent books came out and  and showed this but they were able to gain many
  432. 50:59committed followers to take a lot of people along  with them in their argument because they got you
  433. 51:06to accept their basic premise now I didn't accept  that premise you wouldn't have accepted that
  434. 51:10premise you only go along with someone's argument  if you haven't stopped at the first hurdle and
  435. 51:15said although I didn't accept that premise that  you started with I'm not going to go along with
  436. 51:18you to your conclusion that premise was religious  faith is Blind Faith you may as well believe in a
  437. 51:25pink elephant on Venus you might say this person's  religion is that there exists an all powerful pink
  438. 51:32elephant or very powerful at least on Venus  and that's their religion we have to respect
  439. 51:36that because we're liberal it's nonsense you know  it's nonsense as with all religious believe that
  440. 51:41we respect it yeah we're we're tolerant well  let everyone believe whatever silly nonsense
  441. 51:45they want as long as they don't try and impose it  on us right so um basically uh this conception of
  442. 51:53Faith as necessarily blind faith is something that  let's say it it passes although I hate using this
  443. 52:01term because there's no such thing but it passes  the average person in the street test it's basic
  444. 52:07common knowledge and basic common sorry common  wisdom and that is because of fundamentally the
  445. 52:15split between which is a a consequence of the  split between knowing subject and nature the
  446. 52:21split between the humanities and the hard Sciences  the only real binding knowledge we can have is of
  447. 52:28that which is empirical um or rooted directly in  the empirical and everything else at the end of
  448. 52:34the day is just subjective interpretation and it  has no real evidence for it and this is the this
  449. 52:41is what and and enabled the dorkin and others  of this world to make so much Headway because
  450. 52:48people were going along with this completely  false initial premise but this is the the
  451. 52:56the difficulty if you play into common assumptions  you can make a lot of progress it's all it's all
  452. 53:01false can you explain that initial premise  uh suly are you arguing that at premises that
  453. 53:08uh religious Dogma can never be reasoned and  that's their premise yeah so this comes from a
  454. 53:14bation of knowing subject and knowing subject  and nature and if we would say more broadly
  455. 53:24knowing subject which is you know the individual  the individual self-consciousness self-awareness
  456. 53:32in inward Universe The Knowing subject who knows  the world and then instead of nature more broadly
  457. 53:40you could just say the extra mental whatever is  real outside of our minds this fundamental split
  458. 53:46between the two that the real properties and  the extramental world are the properties that
  459. 53:54the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century  decided are really there and they're actually
  460. 54:01a very questionable list and the historical  reality is that list was arrived at not so
  461. 54:07much because they're saying that is what's really  there in nature as because they were saying this
  462. 54:12is a methodological choice we're making because  treating nature in that way is more conducive to
  463. 54:19producing technology to mastering nature right  to to exploiting Nature to harnessing nature
  464. 54:26to our purposes decart is very explicit about this  Galileo is very explicit and that's obviously you
  465. 54:32know another split um I think we're still on the  faith and reason one here they're all related to
  466. 54:37each other um so this is again something we simply  take for granted well surely that's true well in
  467. 54:47fact the very methodological division the choice  to separate hard Sciences which are supposed to
  468. 54:58pertain in some sense to the empirical world  and the humanities let's say let's let's call
  469. 55:04them which are all ultimately fundamentally  subjective they're not really binding you can
  470. 55:09have someone who's more sophisticated or less  sophisticated but even the really sophisticated
  471. 55:12but he's not really getting it objective reality  because it's not knowable even in principle okay
  472. 55:18that very methodological choice that there's  Humanities and there's hard changes is not
  473. 55:26itself an empirical judgment it's not itself  empirical judgment the experience we have of
  474. 55:35aesthetic judgments is something beautiful right  is an experience just as much of our experience
  475. 55:42as a of a sensible object is an experience right  our experience of let's say seeing sorry for the
  476. 55:53horrible image but seeing someone Del run over an  old lady in the street God forbid oppos as opposed
  477. 56:01to seeing someone flying across the road to save  the person saving them the feeling that we have
  478. 56:08the ethical judgment that that is good and the  other one is evil is just as much an experience
  479. 56:14as our experience of the empirical object our  metaphysical sense that they're underlying all
  480. 56:20of the phenomena there is a Unity which gives  meaning to it all which is beyond time that
  481. 56:26we are moving towards that reality we come from  that reality as in our our our intuition of the
  482. 56:32Divine is an experience just as much as that  empirical one by what rate and on what empirical
  483. 56:38basis what empirical object tells me that this is  real science and all of that is just subjective
  484. 56:48there's no empirical experience it's not itself an  empirical judgment that is where metaphysics comes
  485. 56:54in that is a metaphysical physical judgment and  premodernity in the Islamic World obviously that
  486. 57:02goes up all the way up until early 20th century  and it's still retained to some extent but not
  487. 57:08with a very great degree of intelligibility and in  the Christian World up to 16th 17th century um and
  488. 57:16still kind of the flag was still held aoft by some  traditionalist Catholics right the way to the end
  489. 57:22um so there is continuity um but what they shared  in common is this understanding of the human
  490. 57:29Sciences as all interrelated and the physical  sciences not having a a privileged status and
  491. 57:35the idea that you can apply logic and very precise  modes of reasoning to non-sensible questions just
  492. 57:44as much as to empirical questions so questions  like the existence of God the existence of God
  493. 57:52objective morality yeah objective aesthetical  judgment and what everything that the the the
  494. 58:0020th century early 20th century positivist  in the Vienna Circle for example would have
  495. 58:04called literally nonsense because they don't  refer to any empirical reality and guess what
  496. 58:10exactly the same thing happened to them to what I  just described about the Humanity's hard Sciences
  497. 58:14split they realized hold on our own verification  principle which says that all true knowledge must
  498. 58:21have an empirical reference that very sentence all  true knowledge must have an empirical reference
  499. 58:25where is the empirical reference and and that was  literally I mean simplifying it a bit but that was
  500. 58:31basically the way that positivism was decisively  discredited so this is again it's the air we
  501. 58:38breathe we we just tend to think of you know the  the hard Sciences are objective and and everything
  502. 58:43else is not but that is purely a theory Choice  presupposes a very idiosyncratic history and it's
  503. 58:52not at all what our tradition has ever thought I  challenge anyone to give me an Islamic thinker who
  504. 58:59has ever thought that who is not you know he's  obviously pre modernity who's who who was prior
  505. 59:05to any influence from Western post Enlightenment  modernity so you've covered your third and fourth
  506. 59:12Severance fair is there anything more to be  said about the knowing subject and nature ideal
  507. 59:16should we move on I think we should we should do a  little bit more on that because it's really really
  508. 59:20important it's about this issue of the neutrality  of CCH yeah the the you know modern science is
  509. 59:28extraordinary it's produced amazing technology the  main I don't Advocate people stopping using it I
  510. 59:37can't live without it personally I don't think  that most people can either I think there are
  511. 59:41very important ways that we can ameliorate  some of the very negative impacts that it
  512. 59:47has and you know that's obviously everyone's very  familiar with with all of that I'm not in any way
  513. 59:53Advocate advocating becoming a Lite or whatever  which is another very interesting historical
  514. 59:59movement which is actually discussed here um  Rage Against the Machines but all I'm saying
  515. 1:00:05is it's just a factual matter modern science  is not neutral it's not and what I mean is it's
  516. 1:00:14the it's this the the set of Sciences of modes of  human knowledge which purport to study the nature
  517. 1:00:21of the natural world well the way it does it is  not neutral it's not the way that Muslims did it
  518. 1:00:27either it's not the way that Muslims practiced  natural sence Now using the term science is very
  519. 1:00:36anacronismo istic and it's and it's the same  even of the of the of the Western World until
  520. 1:00:44very recently this was called natural philosophy  the word science came in very very late there's
  521. 1:00:49a few faculties I think in abedine or something  but they still call it natural philosophy just
  522. 1:00:53because they're you know the kind of it's a kind  of Heritage thing um and what what does that mean
  523. 1:01:00it means it used to be subordinated to philosophy  in their understanding of the Mana the the T the
  524. 1:01:06the kind of scheme of the Sciences it it it had a  place that was actually below metaphysics in The
  525. 1:01:13Ordering of the sentences it needed metaphysics  for its fundamental assumption so I can prove
  526. 1:01:19that it's not neutral in a few sentences there is  a theory Choice a methodological iCal move that is
  527. 1:01:27made in the Scientific Revolution in the guise  of thing and these are this is the these these
  528. 1:01:34particular things are cited with you know from the  primary sources in the book in the scientific re
  529. 1:01:41Revolution which are common to all of the major  thinkers Francis Bacon rened de cart Galileo and
  530. 1:01:52so on we'll just stay with those three for now so  what the but of course it encompasses all of them
  531. 1:01:57I mean you know you could go on and on and on and  you and even when the santic revolution becomes
  532. 1:02:03more explicitly Phil philosophical have think is  like Hobs and lock and so on they all reject final
  533. 1:02:12causation and formal causation now I'm going to  explain these the Aristotelian understanding of
  534. 1:02:21nature that they can't escape from because that  was what was dominant and they were all respons in
  535. 1:02:26to it and they all know it and they're all using  the language recognizes four modes of explanation
  536. 1:02:33of nature they're actually called causes I mean  it it it transcends what we call nature but anyway
  537. 1:02:40we call them the four causes so they are the  efficient cause the material cause the formal
  538. 1:02:49cause and the final cause Okay so let's take  the classic example of a a bed that a carpenter
  539. 1:02:55making because it's just a met classic example and  it's very illustrative so the effici the efficient
  540. 1:03:01cause which brings the thing out of non-existence  into existence the action is the carpenter right
  541. 1:03:09the material cause are the pieces of wood  that he uses the wood the formal cause is the
  542. 1:03:17configuration the relations of the components that  configuration which is in his mind before it's
  543. 1:03:25out there there's a plan of it exactly how all the  parts relate that very configuration the aggregate
  544. 1:03:32of all the relations is the form okay that's what  the thing is but there's another very important
  545. 1:03:41aspect of what the thing is which is the final  cause the purpose what is it for so a bed is for
  546. 1:03:50sitting on or sleeping in right the carpenter is  deficient cause he's the one who brings it out of
  547. 1:03:57non-existence into existence on a pattern the form  that he has in mind the idea that he has in mind
  548. 1:04:05which is the um uh that specific configuration and  it's all tending towards a purpose which is the
  549. 1:04:12final cause now in traditional science science and  this is all the provider says about using the word
  550. 1:04:22science studies all the four causes when it comes  to Nature the form is also called The Essence the
  551. 1:04:30essence of a thing it's innermost nature now we  were talking about a man-made object but things in
  552. 1:04:35nature have Essences as well they have forms now  those forms there's human nature there's a n the
  553. 1:04:41nature of a tree there's a nature of whatever  it happens to be these are not construable as
  554. 1:04:47physical because they are the metaphysical pattern  that orders the physical aspects the empirical
  555. 1:04:53properties and so on and and everything  in nature has a purpose as well so the a
  556. 1:05:01traditional conception of physics as subordinated  to metaphysics absolutely took into account the
  557. 1:05:09purposes of nature what are they for what are  they tending towards so and that's of course
  558. 1:05:17their Telos to use the artian term so there was  a methodological move again we have the actual qu
  559. 1:05:26original quotation from the primary text and bacon  and deart and others we have this methodological
  560. 1:05:31move to explicitly throw out purposes and Essences  from nature that's not because they were saying
  561. 1:05:42this is objectively true they were and this is  how it's misunderstood as neutral this they're
  562. 1:05:47just saying what reality is really like they don't  know what reality is really like they've already
  563. 1:05:50excluded everything which would make sense of what  it is what what what are left are the efficient
  564. 1:05:57cause and the material cause that's what uh the  physical sciences should study the other thing is
  565. 1:06:08they have this distinction between there are  many things but one other important thing is
  566. 1:06:13disting between secondary qualities and primary  qualities and they say all that actually exists
  567. 1:06:18in nature are primary qualities which are purely  quantitative things like number figure solidity
  568. 1:06:25things which can be empirically measurable and  all those other things which are part and parcel
  569. 1:06:30of the experience of a thing you know like the  colors that make up the world and so on are and
  570. 1:06:39more or less everything which is on the level of  real quality as as the the Aristotelian category
  571. 1:06:45become purely subjective those are not actually  there in the object and just as we have in the
  572. 1:06:51modern conception you know oh modern science tells  us that what's really here is not me and Jalal
  573. 1:06:57but it's all of these fundamental particles and  interacting and and and purely physical properties
  574. 1:07:04which are somehow what is real and we're somehow  just kind of parasitic somehow and that we not
  575. 1:07:11well what's not really real even our Consciousness  is supposed to be an epip phenomenon of these of
  576. 1:07:16these neurons blindly firing funny irony is how  did we find out about that that that was the
  577. 1:07:24case it's through this epop phenomenon which is  supposed to be parasitic so the whole idea that
  578. 1:07:30somehow Consciousness is not real whereas only by  Consciousness that you've been able to say that
  579. 1:07:35it's not real so that's a kind of another Paradox  um but so you know yeah I mean that's that's what
  580. 1:07:41is most fundamental to and this is this is a  forgotten methodological move and that's never
  581. 1:07:50changed and what was this all in Aid of it was in  Aid of a mechanis IC understanding of nature which
  582. 1:07:59could be manipulated and exploited through the  predictive power of mathematical modeling right
  583. 1:08:09as in it's not so much they're saying this is the  real nature of nature it doesn't have purposes or
  584. 1:08:13Essence they're saying for for our purposes we  don't want to look at that they're a distraction
  585. 1:08:19yeah that's really interesting so in a sense are  you arguing there sort of it's nonrecognition of
  586. 1:08:25the metaphysical in modern scientific method  is essentially an irrational uh uh move it's
  587. 1:08:34it's an irrational way of looking at uh at the  scientific world I think it can be rational as
  588. 1:08:44long as you acknowledge this is a methodological  move I'm making I'm not saying this is the real
  589. 1:08:50nature of reality but it's a methodological  move because I want to produce technology sure
  590. 1:08:55and looking con construing nature in this way even  if I know that there's more to it than that is
  591. 1:09:02conducive to the production of the development of  Technology yeah the problem I have is when Muslims
  592. 1:09:11blly accept modern science as the ultimate  knowledge standard so as I say in the book
  593. 1:09:16you have this kind of new priesthood this kind of  fetishization and totalization of modern science
  594. 1:09:24and the enger and the Doctor Who become the new  kind of high priest of the society you go to the
  595. 1:09:29engineer and the doctor for everything they will  tell you everything because they know everything
  596. 1:09:33um because of the way that uh the way that modern  science has been misconceived um and I think that
  597. 1:09:42uh unfortunately in the period of colonialism um  and colonization there was not a and I don't blame
  598. 1:09:50obviously I mean it was it was not a time where  it was possible for um thought and philosophy and
  599. 1:09:59this type of investigation to necessarily Thrive  easily but there was an insufficiently critical
  600. 1:10:06appraisal of the nature of mity when it came in  and I would say that it mostly comes down to what
  601. 1:10:12must of a subri the last sh Islam says we mistook  a marshal victory for an intellectual Victory we
  602. 1:10:17were just so overwhelmed by by being taken over  and conquered yeah and we felt well you know
  603. 1:10:25we've we we need to catch up one has to remember  the imposition of these positivist and in many
  604. 1:10:35cases kind of Proto or Quasi liberalist on the  political and ethical level conceptions uh through
  605. 1:10:44the imposition of this kind of universalized and  really mostly rather Third Rate unfortunately uh
  606. 1:10:52secular educational system on the Muslim world  was absolutely simultaneous with a systematic
  607. 1:10:58dismantling of our indigenous alternative right  which is Islam which is Islam and our knowledge
  608. 1:11:06structures and our knowledge systems so we  don't even have that authentic lens through
  609. 1:11:10which to appraise what we're seeing you're  seeing that's been taken away from us at the
  610. 1:11:15same time as the alternative has been forced upon  us and we're being told it's neutral I mean it's
  611. 1:11:19not surprising then that after the Indian  Mutiny maybe tens of thousands of of Imam
  612. 1:11:25were were murdered were executed by the British  Absolut this is to remove that Islamic Knowledge
  613. 1:11:33from from society very similar thing under yeah  very similar thing yeah so your fifth uh and
  614. 1:11:40final bation or Severance is a division between  metaphysics and morality explain that division
  615. 1:11:47please yeah you might also say you know between  morality and ontology what it basically means and
  616. 1:11:54it's if you'll forgive me for introducing this  here it's what leads to the Gaza genocide is the
  617. 1:12:01idea that ethical Frameworks might sound nice  might sound might sound lovely but at the end
  618. 1:12:11of the day they're subjective they're not really  bounding their choices their faith even and this
  619. 1:12:18has very very weighty consequences because people  are looking at horror gas why isn't International
  620. 1:12:25law binding why isn't it being applied why is  there no mechanism by which it can simply be
  621. 1:12:34those concern can simply be compelled to abide by  its dictates well it's because what is at play is
  622. 1:12:42something much more fundamental than the internal  structure of international law international
  623. 1:12:48law is based on in in terms of philosophical  buildup of propositions on natural law that's it
  624. 1:12:55historical Genesis H grus and all of these key  thinkers and so exists in this uneasy tension
  625. 1:13:05with another dominant philosophical position  in Western thought which is melanism I would
  626. 1:13:11argue that what is really what is the reality on  the ground politically in the western well today
  627. 1:13:19and when it comes to international relations and  international politics and power politics is mavan
  628. 1:13:25is M that's the bottom line explain Melia melanism  to our listen the melanism is to put it crudely
  629. 1:13:34might is right whatever you need to do in order  to achieve your political aims and cement your
  630. 1:13:42power you do whatever you need to do the absence  of Morality In in the political realm absolutely
  631. 1:13:49the absence of Morality In the political realm the  ends justify the means the ends are subjectively
  632. 1:13:57determined they're basically determined by power  interests and if we're America we're very immoral
  633. 1:14:06so we believe in international law but then  we're not going to apply it yeah because it's
  634. 1:14:14actually a post or our power interests but we  do believe in it and we are actually very good
  635. 1:14:19at moral because we believe in international law  and fairness and you know an international rules
  636. 1:14:23based system and some but we're not going to play  it we're going to keep on vetoing vetoing vetoing
  637. 1:14:30at the end of the day why because if you look at  the actual structure of commitment philosophically
  638. 1:14:37inescapably it's on a philosophical level what  do we actually believe about the universe it's
  639. 1:14:42MERS rate Will To Power it's not actually natural  law that there are inherent rates that every human
  640. 1:14:50being has in virtue of their nature in virtue of  the nature of things in light of the the nature
  641. 1:14:57of things um there are intrinsic moral values and  judgments which are binding on all human beings
  642. 1:15:06that's what international law has to be based on  because the problem with international law is it
  643. 1:15:12transcends the internal positive law of a Nation  but then which is of course binding because of the
  644. 1:15:20um the structure of punishment and of enforcement  on so it's binding in that sense you don't need to
  645. 1:15:27invoke natural law it's binding because you're  going to get in trouble and you're going to be
  646. 1:15:30punished the the problem comes when it when when  you you're faced with the problem of the of the
  647. 1:15:36pluralism of these systems of positive internal  law domestic law and how are you going to relate
  648. 1:15:44to one one another now again the kind of survival  of the Fist might is right to rec of alienism is
  649. 1:15:50say well if we're more powerful than you then you  will do what we say well that is actually that
  650. 1:15:58that that is and always has been operative just  to say finally they have been you know why did
  651. 1:16:04all this why why do you have the League of Nations  and you have the uh Universal you know the charter
  652. 1:16:09of Human Rights and you have the um nurenberg  trails and you have thec and the incj all of this
  653. 1:16:18statute yeah I would say somewhat cynically  but I would say that the these these obtain
  654. 1:16:25in so far as you have a Europe and you have a USA  and you have a a Soviet Union obviously you're
  655. 1:16:31playing with different time periods here but to  speak very broadly which are all real players they
  656. 1:16:38have to be taken in consideration you know this is  before the total you know uni polarization of the
  657. 1:16:45world with America you actually it it matters that  there is a there is a there's a real Power Balance
  658. 1:16:51and you have to respect that and so we're going  to have a system of of uh of you know rules-based
  659. 1:16:57system in place which can uh provide this  framework within which we're going to have our
  660. 1:17:04treaties and we're going to interact and so on but  the the reality is when it comes to a nation that
  661. 1:17:10has no real standing and no real position in that  game um it doesn't really apply I don't think it
  662. 1:17:17ever has it's really interesting I know we spoke  about this in our last conversation but liberals
  663. 1:17:22argue that they' moveed beyond that the FUSD milon  dialogue the idea that might is right yeah and
  664. 1:17:29and now we do have something called International  humanitarian law and we do have these moral codes
  665. 1:17:38which everyone can subscribe to your argument  is fact at best that's no more than a like a
  666. 1:17:45a fig Le it's fair to pretend that there is a  greater cause to the west and its International
  667. 1:17:52order when in reality um it international law is  is subservient to this Machiavellian power game
  668. 1:18:00I would say that natural law international law is  engaged in a losing battle with melanism right now
  669. 1:18:06um look I don't want to be misunderstood I'm not  saying that No One Believes In human rights and
  670. 1:18:10they're not sincere um and you know it doesn't  have any reality whatsoever ever yeah um but
  671. 1:18:16you have these moments where the masks come off  you see the real exactly so the real underlying
  672. 1:18:22Dynamic is not that yeah that's what they wanted  that's what they wanted us to think and there's
  673. 1:18:29been a lot of steps in that direction you know for  throughout the history of the last 20 years and
  674. 1:18:34you know the war on Iraq was a big moment and and  the war on terror and and you know the that what
  675. 1:18:41what took place with the the suspension of civil  Li Liberties in the UK and the US and especially
  676. 1:18:47directed towards Muslims and all sorts of things  but I think Gaza is the real mask off moment the
  677. 1:18:52decisive one and I think it's one which has you  with this kind of resurgence Resurgence is not
  678. 1:19:00really the word with this kind of sudden emergence  of what they're calling the global South is this
  679. 1:19:05real um force to be reckoned with and that can't  be ignored anymore yeah um simultaneous to this
  680. 1:19:12kind of masks off moment I think it is a very very  weighty and momentous significant let me ask you
  681. 1:19:18about it because on X you sent out a post where  you said October the 7th was a defining event that
  682. 1:19:24exposes the DET terminal moral illegitimacy of the  West can you elaborate on how that's how October
  683. 1:19:307 symbolizes this crumbl in Western hegemony I  think there are so many different levels to it
  684. 1:19:37I don't think it's going to be a straightforward  process I don't think that you know I talk about
  685. 1:19:41the crumbling of hegemony um you know there are  going to be a lot of twists and turns and ups and
  686. 1:19:46downs and and the the West is still enormously  powerful I don't think I think you know we can't
  687. 1:19:50get kind of lost in this in the the excitement of  the moment because it is significant but we should
  688. 1:19:58kind of constrain restrain ourselves constrain  ourselves to its actual significance um I think uh
  689. 1:20:06its actual significance is the is the breakdown  of the post 1945 kind of moral narrative and
  690. 1:20:14universe which is basically the Western World  triumphed over evil the ultimate embodiment of
  691. 1:20:22evil which was Nazism Nazis M was kind of Pure  Evil and this is you know embodied by epitomized
  692. 1:20:34by the concentration camps and you know the war  was waged in order to liberate the concentration
  693. 1:20:42camps and and to save the Jews and to instantiate  Human Rights and that was what it was all about
  694. 1:20:50it was you know it was a just war and you know  one of the few truly just Wars because they were
  695. 1:20:56fighting this absolute epitomy of evil and then  in the newbur trials afterwards you know we had
  696. 1:21:02to say never again so we instantiated the system  of international law and accountability and so
  697. 1:21:09on and we put them on trail now look let's just  start with two things which are wrong with that
  698. 1:21:14narrative first of all the second world war wasn't  waged in order to save the Jews it wasn't waged in
  699. 1:21:26order to liberate the concentration camps yes  in fact Jewish refugees were systematically
  700. 1:21:36sent home yeah turned away yeah turned away in  their boats still on their boats at the when you
  701. 1:21:44know obviously the Nazi persecution of the Jews  had become a reality and was had become to to a
  702. 1:21:54certain extent known in the and was being reported  in the western media at the outset of the war and
  703. 1:21:59so on um there was a deliberate policy of turning  the Jews away although it was known that they
  704. 1:22:05were facing severe uh danger dangers um now one  other thing is the Newberg Trails did you notice
  705. 1:22:18them putting Churchill and bummer Harris and rth R  well revelt had just died but did you notice them
  706. 1:22:27putting themselves on trail for the firebombing  of Hamburg for the firebombing of dresdon for the
  707. 1:22:37obliteration of hundreds of other uh Germany  German towns completely gratuitously because
  708. 1:22:45they weren't even military targets and of course  it came out after the war it was um by whatever
  709. 1:22:52process um but it was eventually made public the  documents which showed that this was deliberate
  710. 1:22:59Pro policy this actually was Terror bombing it  was deliberate Terror bombing the firebombing
  711. 1:23:03of Tokyo the nuking of Hiroshima they weren't put  on trail under international law for these crimes
  712. 1:23:11these atrocities um and so nonetheless were  brought up with this narrative that the second
  713. 1:23:21world war was this just War another thing is that  the when it comes to the concentration camps the
  714. 1:23:31uh Allied Powers knew about the concentration  camps long before they um were liberated yeah
  715. 1:23:38they never got rid of them they never bombed them  they never um uh they never put a stop to it um
  716. 1:23:46so and and of course all of the details of what  came to be known in the 1970s as the Holocaust um
  717. 1:23:54and I don't for a moment deny uh huge atrocities  and indeed a holocaust which was perpetrated
  718. 1:24:01against the Jews but this was not known During the  period of the war in any way so um the the moral
  719. 1:24:10narrative that has come down to us that this  was fundamentally fighting ultimate you know
  720. 1:24:15absolute evil of Hitler is just not accurate  in any way that wasn't Hitler was the one who
  721. 1:24:21was trying to make peace with Britain cons  consistently throughout especially in 1940
  722. 1:24:27and those uh those attempts were all rebuffed he  actually wanted as his absolutely establish a main
  723. 1:24:34mainstream history wanted to make peace uh with  the British especially because of his admiration
  724. 1:24:38for the British Empire so I'm not denying  that Hitler was evil he was an evil man but
  725. 1:24:46churel was an evil man um he you know very likely  played an instrumental role in the Bengal famine
  726. 1:24:57which killed 4 million people um he was The Man  Behind the firebombing even when Harris who was
  727. 1:25:05very enthusiastic about it as well you know we're  talking about February 1945 the Germans have lost
  728. 1:25:12church WIll pushes him now we're going to flatten  Dron going to kill tens of thousands of people of
  729. 1:25:18course we don't know the real numbers of you know  non-military Target civilians just you know for
  730. 1:25:25the terror of it break break civilian morale so  you know the point is all of these all of these
  731. 1:25:33inconsistencies in the actual narrative are not  generally known they're becoming much better known
  732. 1:25:40now in the last 5 10 years but they certainly  The Narrative that has dominated post 1945 about
  733. 1:25:48you know the what the the liberal West saved the  world and it was just such a wonderful thing sure
  734. 1:25:55Nazism was a terrible thing but the slave  trade the slave trade the African slave trade
  735. 1:26:05colonialism all of the outrages of the colonial  period the genocide of the Native Americans this
  736. 1:26:14is all post Enlightenment liberal civilization so  you know this Narrative of of light and darkness
  737. 1:26:23were all brought up in it I used to believe it  even though I was brought up in a you a very very
  738. 1:26:29uh committed and and spiritually committed and  and and religiously committed Muslim family but
  739. 1:26:35you know I had a western schooling in an ordinary  state school I was brought up to believe that as
  740. 1:26:39well I used to feel you burst with pride when  I saw a documentary about the Battle of Britain
  741. 1:26:44and we saved the world and everything when in  fact you know who defeated the Nazis it was
  742. 1:26:49actually the Russians the role that we played was  mostly in the air War bombing German CI cities it
  743. 1:26:56was the real um uh ground war yeah yeah the real  ground war was was totally um totally conducted
  744. 1:27:05on the Eastern front in any case um the point is  that is the narrative that held for a long long
  745. 1:27:11time the reality is Nazism liberalism just one  of the better term and communism they are all
  746. 1:27:22the same that different manifestations of the  same phenomenon which is modernity and I you
  747. 1:27:32you can say that liberal civilization is let's  say the the kind of Patron philosophers of the
  748. 1:27:40British empiricists you know Hume and Loch and  these people Adam Smith and so on and and you
  749. 1:27:46know Nazi Germany was a more of a a nitrium  modernity and of course you know the Soviet
  750. 1:27:54modernity was more of a Marxist modernity but  these are all ideologues of modernity in this
  751. 1:28:00philosophical sense that I'm talking about I would  say that was you know you know as it says in the
  752. 1:28:06Quran you know these are these this was a  this was a civil war of modernity between
  753. 1:28:17there wasn't there wasn't a good guy there it  it was it was evil against evil and of course
  754. 1:28:22I'm not saying on an individual level I don't  believe that my great-grandfather who fought
  755. 1:28:25in the battle of the S was evil but I'm saying  in terms of the ideologies which were at play
  756. 1:28:31I don't think that there was a good guy but what  do we grow up with we grow up with this idea that
  757. 1:28:35the West is its whole CLA moral claim is based on  defeating ultimate Evil and freeing the world in
  758. 1:28:42the second world war yeah well it's it's not  true on so many different levels finally the
  759. 1:28:47final point on this you know the second world  war was you know the the ostensible cause the
  760. 1:28:56ostensible occasion of the start of the war was  protecting the sovereignty of Poland right that
  761. 1:29:03was the ostensible occasion for for declaring war  what happened at the end of the war the whole of
  762. 1:29:11Eastern Europe including Poland was given over to  an even worse well you know an arguably even worse
  763. 1:29:18certainly more murderous dictator than Hitler  yeah at East Stalin so you know even on that
  764. 1:29:24there are large inconsistencies even on that level  but what is Gaza Gaza is a live streamed horror
  765. 1:29:37that we've all looked at those images and we've  whipped we've all looked at those images and we've
  766. 1:29:44cried and we have been deeply hurt by it deeply  affected by it in a way that has never happened
  767. 1:29:53before for and the images we're seeing are worse  than anything we've ever seen at even at BV VA or
  768. 1:30:02at or at at wherever it happens to be we've never  seen images like that they have broken the barrier
  769. 1:30:10they've pushed the boundaries of horror and it's  all been live streamed to our phones and the
  770. 1:30:14technology that they created and we know they're  in a position to stop this tomorrow yeah we know
  771. 1:30:24they're in a position to stop this tomorrow and  we know that they're not and it's calling into
  772. 1:30:30question everything that we've ever been taught  about the inherent goodness of Western liberalism
  773. 1:30:41it's a masks off moment and it's a point of no  return we can't go back after this you know look
  774. 1:30:48the Iraq War was a was a horror and and I happen  to know on a very close level people who were able
  775. 1:30:57to make me feel what that was really about almost  as much as what I know about Gaza because I of the
  776. 1:31:06stories and the I know the people who died and the  the the direct impact that it had on people but on
  777. 1:31:12this Mass level that's only if you know people  that wasn't live streamed to the world like what
  778. 1:31:18we're seeing today and it wasn't as concentrated  and as brutal and as Shameless as what we're
  779. 1:31:26seeing today there wasn't this deliberate  targeting of civilians in the same way that
  780. 1:31:32we're s today there weren't you know these sniper  shots to the heads of children um this systematic
  781. 1:31:39genocide that we're seeing unfolding and again  the whole moral claim of the West is supposed to
  782. 1:31:45be or we saved the day when there was a genocide  the ultimate genocide but now they're letting it
  783. 1:31:51happen they're making it happen they are enablers  they're more than enablers Hass this is really
  784. 1:32:00fascinating uh conversation and and I really  would like to explore so many strands there and
  785. 1:32:04I think our viewers will probably suggest that  we need to have you back in the studio to talk
  786. 1:32:09about a lot of this in in a lot more detail but  let's talk about the Islam part of this because
  787. 1:32:15I I was struck by a phrasy used uh in in that  conversation that Islam provides a counter hemony
  788. 1:32:24um unpack that for me what what is it about Islam  because of course that's not you know many Muslims
  789. 1:32:30but certainly non Muses will not see you know they  noticed your critique and then and you know very
  790. 1:32:36many will agree with your critique of modernity  uh but Islam doesn't seem the automatic Faith
  791. 1:32:43at least for non-muslims to go to to provide this  counter hemony so explain that counter hemony idea
  792. 1:32:50to me please well what I meant by that is really  the that this is an this is to view Islam in a
  793. 1:32:57negative light from the liberalist perspective  but what it also exposes in a way I mean I don't
  794. 1:33:06necessarily want to use that sensationalist  language yeah is the fact that uh liberalism is
  795. 1:33:13hegemonic yeah now how that's paradoxical because  one of the core tenants principles of liberalism
  796. 1:33:19is it is setting up the societ in the kind of  rulan way let's not go there to rules but let's
  797. 1:33:28say they setting up the society in this neutral  way so that everyone is able to pursue their own
  798. 1:33:35vision of the god without let or hindrance yeah  now there's one exception to this if your pursuit
  799. 1:33:41of the good would serve to undermine liberalism  itself that's a great danger for them because
  800. 1:33:49they'll say well what will happen to the pluralism  it will be awful they won't be able to host all of
  801. 1:33:53these different arbitrary beliefs anymore so I  wasn't necessarily saying we should view Islam
  802. 1:33:59as a counter hegemony because I wouldn't use  that word myself I don't I don't think we we
  803. 1:34:04we purport to be or aspire to be hegemonic in  that sense yeah but what I but but absolutely
  804. 1:34:11we offer an alternative that is a comprehensive  view of existence it's also the framework in which
  805. 1:34:19you accommodate diversity and you know we were  second To None we are the gold standard in Islam
  806. 1:34:27in terms of the historical record in terms of our  civilizational principles for accommodating the
  807. 1:34:32other in a real way that doesn't relativize that  doesn't say you can have your own Silly private
  808. 1:34:38belief in the wrong name and all that kind of  stuff as long as you're exactly the same as us in
  809. 1:34:42every way yeah in you know in what matters which  is contributing to the economy and so on having
  810. 1:34:47you know working and um you know contributing in  in you know academically and the arts and media
  811. 1:34:57and whatever it happens to me you know the the  the me hash of the world for example not saying
  812. 1:35:02anything about him as a person because I don't  know but I'm just saying you know he he he's
  813. 1:35:07he's attractive to the that mindset that he's  he's he's just one of us but he's a Muslim and
  814. 1:35:14and you know we can relate to him um not saying  anything about obviously his personal level of
  815. 1:35:19commitment which I think is very strong actually  but just the way that he's perceived so this is
  816. 1:35:24um I think a real issue for liberalism is the the  extent to which it can it can it can tolerate real
  817. 1:35:34diversity not just superficial diversity yeah  remember on empiricism all that really exists
  818. 1:35:41are empirical properties so that's what they can  tolerate but when it comes to real conviction you
  819. 1:35:47know would they have okay now they've managed to  um tick that box of diversity because they've had
  820. 1:35:53riches sunak as the Prime Minister but if he had  been a Sufi shik and an Alim would they have let
  821. 1:36:00him yeah no it's because he's more neoliberal than  the neoliberals so all that diversity how is how
  822. 1:36:07is that diversity what's diverse about him you  can say he had to overcompensate and as you said
  823. 1:36:13he was more thatcherite than most conservatives  were at this stage exactly yeah exactly and you
  824. 1:36:18know Barack Obama was more establishment than the  establishment yeah um so I think that's always
  825. 1:36:23um I think that kind of shows what I'm getting at  when I say that liberalism is not really capable
  826. 1:36:30of tolerating Islam on on any real level yeah  now you know our our approach as Muslims look
  827. 1:36:40I want us to have this knowledge of critique  so that we can be empowered by it right not so
  828. 1:36:46that we can be disempowered by it go into our  ghettos and our bubbles and say oh they're bad
  829. 1:36:51and modernity is bad and you know the no there's  much good in modernity there's good in everything
  830. 1:36:57which Allah T has created and we there's much  good in the non-muslim population of the West
  831. 1:37:07many good human beings who have are on a good f  a good original disposition many future Muslims
  832. 1:37:16uh many people of good faith and Goodwill but  I think it's also important to realize that
  833. 1:37:23simply you know contributing to Modern  liberal secular society it's always going
  834. 1:37:30to be unsatisfying for us ultimately as Muslims  if that's where the buck stops that's all there
  835. 1:37:37is to it because there is a Telos there is a  purpose just as in any social configuration and
  836. 1:37:46political structure there is a there is a Telos to  Modern liberal Society just is there is a Telos to
  837. 1:37:58uh and I'm speaking in the very broadest sense  to Islamic civilization and and to to Islamic
  838. 1:38:04political systems and Islamic polies and every  political system you can think of and the Telos of
  839. 1:38:12modern liberal civilization is the facilitation of  arbitrary self-determination I would say and there
  840. 1:38:21are other ways of looking at it if you looking at  it from an economic lens you'd say something else
  841. 1:38:26um and that may be more of an overarching Telos um  and if you wanted to be cynical you could say all
  842. 1:38:33of the stuff about freedom is just to distract  you while you're being exploited economically
  843. 1:38:37and so on um and that what is really happening  is that we're ruled by an aligar and there's
  844. 1:38:42a lot of truth to all of that kind of thing  but I I don't particularly want to go there
  845. 1:38:45now I just think that as Muslims we need to be  empowered by this knowledge so that we can stop
  846. 1:38:53being bound by The Narrative of contributing and  we're British too and don't worry about us we're
  847. 1:39:00just like you and so yes on the human level we're  just like you but no on a on a on another level
  848. 1:39:06we have something to offer you to help you to  save you to open your mind to liberate you not
  849. 1:39:13in your conception of world religions oh you're  trying to force your religion on me no in the
  850. 1:39:19sense that if you can deconstruct the assumptions  that non-muslims hold about modernity which are
  851. 1:39:26not true just like we hold them then you can say  there's a completely different way of looking at
  852. 1:39:31the world which is not a question of Blind  Faith you becoming a Muslim it's you seeing
  853. 1:39:37something about the world that you were veiled  from previously by those assumptions and that's
  854. 1:39:42where we we say look Islam is not a religion of  Blind Faith and identity and in which case W Earth
  855. 1:39:50would an English person want to become Muslim it  it takes away all all of the familiarity and you
  856. 1:39:55know intimacy they have with their own environment  their own cultures their own their own culture
  857. 1:40:00their own history their own architecture their  own lived built environments on but it's something
  858. 1:40:05completely different to that and it is unifying  reunifying what should be whole but which has
  859. 1:40:15been severed systematically and ideologically in  Western history and and those are the five bations
  860. 1:40:23and those that what is most significant and I  think this is really what we've been building
  861. 1:40:28up to is that what is severed in the Christian  postchristian world has always been whole and
  862. 1:40:34unified and indivisible and integral in the Muslim  world there's no split between law and spirit
  863. 1:40:46there's no split between temporal power and sacred  power there's no split between faith and reason
  864. 1:40:54there's no split between knowing subject and  nature and there's no split between morality
  865. 1:40:59and ontology and so what we need to do  is on the community level our neighbors
  866. 1:41:09Muslim and non-muslim but I'm thinking  mostly about the Muslim as a starting
  867. 1:41:14point is on the level of our neighbors on  the Nevel of level of families and friends
  868. 1:41:24and the larger community that we enact on a  community level we start to instantiate on a
  869. 1:41:32community level what tashko brazada and the great  ottoman theorists of Ethics like him call where
  870. 1:41:43the Telos the purpose of our human Association in  societies is the cultivation of love love of God
  871. 1:41:53God and love a fellow man and so we and it's  essentially instantiating the prophetic model
  872. 1:42:04making sure that there's no one left behind who do  we know who is in trouble who do we know who is in
  873. 1:42:12need who who do we know who is in poverty and on  a level of devotion on a level of spirit uality
  874. 1:42:24having Gatherings instantiating Gatherings within  our communities where we have vior we have this
  875. 1:42:33deep experiential appreciation of the dean and we  make sure to cultivate that and we cultivate that
  876. 1:42:41also with the social level and you know the the  Underground Level the Grassroots level um there's
  877. 1:42:48so many families there's so many individuals who  are victims of this socially atomized Society we
  878. 1:42:54have to stop leaving them behind yeah and leaving  them on on their own and not allowing them to have
  879. 1:43:03a place where they can be embraced and brought in  that means bringing back zakat on a community and
  880. 1:43:10local local level um and it means um putting in  place all of the institutions well not all of the
  881. 1:43:21institutions it has to be obviously to some degree  compromised by it being on a community level
  882. 1:43:26rather than a a state level but the institutions  that in a traditional Islamic Society are put in
  883. 1:43:35place like the AA for example which obviously you  know very very wide- ranging um on the level of
  884. 1:43:44patronage of intellectual activity and and on the  level of looking after the poor um uh where and of
  885. 1:43:51course on on the level of madress is and the good  news is a lot of this is happening there's a kind
  886. 1:43:55of Renaissance of all of this kind of activity  in our communities I just think that it needs to
  887. 1:44:01be as we move forward more focused on classical  ethical models more explicitly because I think
  888. 1:44:10there's a lot there which can Inspire us um and uh  so that we can become more organized the problem
  889. 1:44:18with organization is it can start to happen on you  know a kind of weberian rationalized level um and
  890. 1:44:27that's not what we want we need a traditional  understanding that our associations are for a
  891. 1:44:33purpose which is and ultimately on the on the most  fundamental level in Islam it's the vice jeny it's
  892. 1:44:40the C custodianship it's the stewardship of the  world and we need to show non-muslims not because
  893. 1:44:48I to show them anything because but because this  is the reality of our religion we're not we're
  894. 1:44:52not real realizing it that we our religion is  holistic it encompasses everything unfortunately
  895. 1:44:59the ghettos that we live in um that kind of  ghettoization while very understandable and
  896. 1:45:05not in any way to discredit the enormous huge  contributions of the the communities that have
  897. 1:45:11come here and established Islam who you know as  they say in Arabica we have maximal respect for
  898. 1:45:18them but moving forward we need to have an Islam  which is holistic which Embraces every aspect of
  899. 1:45:25life not this sense that somehow we're kind of  you know almost like Orthodox Judaism we we we
  900. 1:45:31know we're so concerned about being pure and pure  of outside influences that we end up you know just
  901. 1:45:37being in this in insular and and and so on and  and I'm afraid that that I'm by I'm far from the
  902. 1:45:43the the first person to have said this and um I  appreciate obviously the challenges which have led
  903. 1:45:48to that situation how much of what you're saying  um is for a greater purpose um I'm I'm um when you
  904. 1:45:57while you were speaking there until you you you  caveated at the end um it sounded very similar to
  905. 1:46:04Rod Dreer and his Benedict option the idea that  modernity now is so overpowering and so strong
  906. 1:46:11uh we can no longer defeat or critique modernity  in a substantial way and so we need to hold on
  907. 1:46:18to our Goods as best as possible like is is that  is that the ultimate end of this this community
  908. 1:46:26building project or do you feel that there can be  a a a Resurgence Beyond um holding on to Islam and
  909. 1:46:36and building these institutions uh in so much as  you know in my introduction I mentioned the author
  910. 1:46:44whose name I forget who wrote the book after  defeat and yeah know almost like an acceptance
  911. 1:46:48that Islam like Catholicism has to accept that  it's never going to return in a in an ottoman
  912. 1:46:54esque way like do you believe that um the great  days the great history of Islam is in the past and
  913. 1:47:01now it's sort of we have to create a a uh a living  which accepts begrudgingly uh the the precepts of
  914. 1:47:13modernity well look we don't know where we are  in the in the estr olical story um we don't know
  915. 1:47:20precisely but what we do know is the Propet of  said he said who you know if the hour comes upon
  916. 1:47:28you and you have a Seedling her you have to plant  it regardless of where you are regardless of how
  917. 1:47:36dire things look yeah and so we are not we are  not charged to know where we are um in the story
  918. 1:47:44of the um is is is a a Resurgence possible is it  impossible we don't know what we know is this is
  919. 1:47:54Allah's plan this is his affair as it says even as  it says in the Quran directed towards the prophet
  920. 1:48:06Sall was you know you you have nothing in this  affair this is God's Affair this is his decree
  921. 1:48:12unfolding I've said and you know I was criticized  widely for it that modernity didn't our present
  922. 1:48:22situation Visa modernity and feeling defeated  by it is not so much because of our failure to
  923. 1:48:28progress as it is an ex an estr olical exigency  this has to happen this has to happen it's part
  924. 1:48:37of the uh what we're told has to happen um uh in  in in the latter days now those latter days 300
  925. 1:48:46years 400 years 500 years a thousand years I have  no idea and I don't think anyone should bother
  926. 1:48:52themselves with that that all we know is that if  we have a Seedling we have to plant it right um
  927. 1:48:59so we can't have a defeatist attitude we have the  revealed truth we have the transformative truth we
  928. 1:49:09have to reconnect with those individuals who are  still carrying that and inheriting that and I'm
  929. 1:49:14a firm believer in the reality of sainthood the  reality of individuals who are true inheritors
  930. 1:49:21of the Prophet on inward level and I think  that's normative to our tradition and I think
  931. 1:49:27another aspect of our weakness is the loss of that  conception and there are a lot of frauds there's
  932. 1:49:33a lot of fraudulent claims there are a lot of  shatons but the existence of those should not um
  933. 1:49:41should not blind us from the existence of willia  I think that is something that we absolutely it's
  934. 1:49:47part and parcel of Islam it goes right back to the  original sources the the understanding of willia
  935. 1:49:53and we we need to reconnect to that and you know  separate the wheat from the chaff there are a
  936. 1:49:58lot of charlatans where there are criteria there  are so we have to be very very careful but not to
  937. 1:50:02the extent that it blinds us from the reality  because that's our real connection Islam is a
  938. 1:50:08transformative path like no other and that's what  we need to communicate I think to non-muslims on
  939. 1:50:15a DA level is that this is a Liberation and this  is a comprehensive way of life which will get you
  940. 1:50:22out of that route and enable you to um become  a truly fulfilled person um and at the end of
  941. 1:50:31the day yes I believe that modernity can be saved  um and it can be saved by Islam and I think that
  942. 1:50:39that's what we should be doing here it's not a  question that it's going to happen in the west
  943. 1:50:44or it's going to happen in the Muslim world or  we have to make HRA or we have to stay here I
  944. 1:50:49think in both both are are serious options and  should remain serious options but I think what
  945. 1:50:54has to be recognized is that the illusion of  a universal neutral civilization has infected
  946. 1:51:01the west and the Muslim World alike almost  universally in the Muslim world but I think
  947. 1:51:06Real Islam will overcome in both cases inshah  tala H sping on that note thank you very much
  948. 1:51:14for your your time today and how conversations  is that could have here thank you very much it
  949. 1:51:18was a great pleasure where you please remember  to subscribe to our social media and YouTube
  950. 1:51:25channels and head over to our website thinking  muslim.com to sign up to my Weekly Newsletter ja

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Can Muslims Resist Modernity? with Hasan Spiker by The Thinking Muslim, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 16,787 words across 950 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.