CA Inter SM Certified Copy Analysis (May'26) | 6 Mistakes to Avoid in Sep'26 | CA Siddhant Mehta — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01So now, we are going to analyze the
- 0:03certified copies of Strategic
- 0:04Management from the May '24 exam, and
- 0:06you will get six learnings from this,
- 0:08which, if you implement in your
- 0:10preparation, will definitely increase
- 0:11your score by 7 to 10 marks in
- 0:13Strategic Management itself. Because
- 0:16when you look at these students '
- 0:18certified copies, you will realize that
- 0:20this student knew the context, but it
- 0:22wasn't presented according to ICAI's
- 0:24requirements, and that's why marks were
- 0:26deducted. And as we always do, we are
- 0:28going to understand all these things in
- 0:29great detail. Okay? So hello everyone,
- 0:31my name is CA Siddha Mehta, and let's
- 0:33start this video. So before jumping
- 0:35into the analysis, if you are loving
- 0:36our videos, then don't forget to
- 0:38subscribe. How much work has been done,
- 0:39man? Because a lot of value-addition
- 0:41videos have already been uploaded for
- 0:43you on our YouTube channel, and more
- 0:45are coming. Like the one-shot revision
- 0:47videos where I have thoroughly revised
- 0:49all the chapters for you. Our
- 0:51last-minute chart book. Then the other
- 0:53is the ABC analysis, where we predicted
- 0:55the September '24 paper in great detail
- 0:56. Then I concluded the writing practice
- 0:59just last week. Now we are bringing the
- 1:01certified copy analysis. After that, I
- 1:03am bringing the Super 50 questions for
- 1:05you. So don't forget to subscribe. A
- 1:07lot of good content is coming your way.
- 1:09And along with that, the comment box is
- 1:11all yours, where you can manifest how
- 1:13you will clear your September '24 exam.
- 1:15Okay? So let's begin. Now, we won't
- 1:17start with the first question. Because,
- 1:19anyway, we don't look at the first
- 1:20question in the question paper. We go
- 1:22directly to the last question. So we
- 1:24will start with the last question
- 1:25itself. First, we will take Question 8B
- 1:28, and there is a specific reason for
- 1:30picking this particular question.
- 1:33Because when I checked a student's
- 1:36certified copy, the way ICAI checked it
- 1:39left me in shock. What happened here is
- 1:43that Question 8B is usually an optional
- 1:45question. For example, here you are
- 1:48given two questions. You have to write
- 1:50any one of the two questions. Now, what
- 1:52did the student do? They wrote the
- 1:55second question. What is the second
- 1:57question saying? The second question
- 1:59says to differentiate between proactive
- 2:01and reactive strategies and explain in
- 2:02detail why these two strategies are
- 2:04important for the organization. So, it
- 2:06was a very basic question. It wasn't
- 2:07that difficult. Now, in such exams,
- 2:09every question is for five marks. These
- 2:12five marks are divided based on how
- 2:13many sub-questions are asked in a
- 2:15respective question. Like here too, if
- 2:18you see, you have been asked two
- 2:19questions. First, it asked to
- 2:20differentiate between proactive and
- 2:22reactive, and then it asked to explain.
- 2:24So, two questions were asked, and these
- 2:26five marks are divided between these
- 2:27two questions. If you have done the
- 2:29differentiation correctly, you will get
- 2:30one mark. If you have explained it
- 2:32correctly, you will get four marks. So,
- 2:34we call this a two-step question. When
- 2:36three questions are asked in one, we
- 2:38call it a three-step question. If only
- 2:40one is asked. Then we call it a
- 2:41one-step question. So, what was this?
- 2:43This was a two-step question. Now,
- 2:45let's look at the answer to see how the
- 2:46student wrote it. Here, if you see, the
- 2:49student had written correctly about
- 2:50proactive and reactive. Then they
- 2:52explained why these two strategies are
- 2:54important for an organization. But if
- 2:56you look, the ICAI marked this entire
- 2:58answer wrong and gave zero marks in 8b.
- 3:01So, I thought, brother, maybe it was
- 3:02wrong. So, they must have done
- 3:03something wrong. But it was also on my
- 3:05mind that, man, proactive and reactive
- 3:07are such basic concepts. How could
- 3:08there be a mistake in this? Then, when
- 3:10I started reading the answer, I felt
- 3:12that what they had written was correct.
- 3:14Yes, at a few places, the keywords
- 3:16didn't exactly match. 70%of the
- 3:17keywords match. But nowhere has the
- 3:19student written the wrong meaning. Like
- 3:21, for example, what did they write for
- 3:22proactive strategy? Proactive strategy
- 3:24refers to the planned steps taken by
- 3:26the management to gain competitive
- 3:28advantage and improve the overall
- 3:29market position. Now let's see what the
- 3:32ICAI suggested answer says. So, here
- 3:36the ICAI suggested answer says
- 3:37proactive strategy refers to the
- 3:39planned and deliberative actions taken
- 3:40by the management to improve the market
- 3:42position and performance. It is done to
- 3:44gain the competitive advantage through
- 3:46advance planning. So, what is written
- 3:48here is exactly what the student had
- 3:50written there. But they were given
- 3:52marks for it as wrong. Then I said,
- 3:54okay, the proactive part is also fine.
- 3:55There must have been something wrong
- 3:56with the reactive part. So, I started
- 3:57reading up on reactive strategies.
- 3:59Reactive strategy refers to the changes
- 4:01made in the strategy by the management
- 4:03due to an unexpected change in the
- 4:05business environment. This also seemed
- 4:07mostly correct to me; the keywords
- 4:09didn't quite match, but the meaning
- 4:11being conveyed seemed right. Reactive
- 4:13strategy refers to the adaptive
- 4:14response. I mean, what did they write?
- 4:16Changes, but what is the keyword?
- 4:18Adaptive response to unforeseen changes
- 4:20and unexpected developments in the
- 4:22business environment. Now, this also
- 4:23seemed correct to me. So, I couldn't
- 4:25understand why ICAI was deducting marks
- 4:27here. Because how does it usually work?
- 4:29Whenever your keywords don't match or
- 4:30you don't write according to ICAI's
- 4:32language, ICAI gives you partial marks.
- 4:34Because what you have written is
- 4:35correct. But here, what they wrote is
- 4:37also correct. Just that in a few places
- 4:38the keywords didn't match, so marking
- 4:40it completely wrong was something I
- 4:41couldn't understand. And then, in this
- 4:43explanation, they elaborated on things
- 4:45a bit. They exaggerated a little, and
- 4:46the keywords here didn't quite match.
- 4:48But they hadn't written anything wrong.
- 4:51Then why did ICAI mark this entire
- 4:52answer as wrong? Now, according to my
- 4:55understanding, the thing that seems to
- 4:57have happened here is that the checker
- 5:01must have come to Question Number 8B.
- 5:03Now, Question Number 8B has two parts.
- 5:05First, they must have written the
- 5:06answer to this particular question as
- 5:08Question Number 8B. So, what did the
- 5:09checker do? They looked at the answer
- 5:11to this specific question and checked
- 5:12it against that specific question.
- 5:13Things definitely didn't match, and
- 5:15they marked it wrong. Otherwise, you
- 5:17tell me, what could be the reason for
- 5:19marking this answer wrong? Suppose your
- 5:21keywords aren't matching exactly. Is it
- 5:23an ICAI requirement that keywords must
- 5:24match word-for-word? Then ICAI gives
- 5:26partial marks. Later, I will show you
- 5:28certified copies where many students'
- 5:29keywords don't match. They have given
- 5:31partial marks. They never mark the
- 5:33whole thing wrong. But in this
- 5:34particular case, the entire answer was
- 5:36marked wrong. And the only reason
- 5:38coming to my mind for marking the whole
- 5:39answer wrong is that the checker might
- 5:41have made a mistake by looking at this
- 5:43question and checking the answer
- 5:44against it. Things definitely didn't
- 5:46match, so they marked it wrong. Now,
- 5:48there is no need to panic after seeing
- 5:50this. Because in my entire lifetime,
- 5:52brother, this is the first time I've
- 5:54seen that such a mistake can happen
- 5:56during checking. But since it has
- 5:57happened now, we need to be a little
- 5:59conscious. So, what are we going to do
- 6:00now? Whenever you are opting for an
- 6:02optional question—regardless of the
- 6:04subject, not just in Strategic
- 6:05Management, but for any question—
- 6:07whenever you opt for an optional
- 6:08question, what you need to do is: Write
- 6:10Question Number 8B here and put a
- 6:12bracket in front of it. If you want,
- 6:14draw a box around which option you are
- 6:15opting for. I mean, even in the
- 6:18worst-case scenario, if it's the case
- 6:19that the checker doesn't know there is
- 6:20another option (this never happens, but
- 6:22if they don't know), then when you
- 6:23write in the bracket that you are
- 6:25opting for the second option, they will
- 6:26understand that there is a second
- 6:27option and they will check it while
- 6:29evaluating. And such silly mistakes
- 6:31won't happen. Because when I saw this,
- 6:33I was completely...I was shocked myself
- 6:35, how could this happen? Then I looked
- 6:37at the marks, he got 33 marks, so I
- 6:39said okay. But if the student had
- 6:42received 38 or 39 marks instead, this
- 6:44particular question would have become a
- 6:46deciding factor for him, and here we
- 6:48can only submit it for recalculation.
- 6:50Later on, they won't re-check it again.
- 6:53So, to be on the safer side, do this:
- 6:55whenever you are opting for an optional
- 6:57question, write in brackets which
- 6:59option you are opting for. This is a
- 7:01very small thing. But you saw how a
- 7:03mistake can happen on the part of the
- 7:05checker. Alright? And besides that, if
- 7:08you feel that no, sir, this couldn't be
- 7:10a mistake by the checker. There must be
- 7:13some other reason. Then I can show you
- 7:15this answer if you want. You can have a
- 7:16look. If you think there was something
- 7:18else that should have been there,
- 7:19because of which this was marked wrong?
- 7:21Then tell me in the comment section. I
- 7:23will communicate this to the respective
- 7:25student as well and to the rest of the
- 7:26students too. Alright? Okay, so take a
- 7:29look once. Here, in the explanation,
- 7:36the guy has just jotted it down a bit
- 7:38roughly. But nowhere has he written the
- 7:40wrong meaning. He has written the
- 7:41meaning correctly. He just wrote a few
- 7:42things in his own words. Okay? So, this
- 7:47was about proactive and reactive. Now,
- 7:49let's look at question number eight B's
- 7:51first option. Okay? So, what was it
- 7:53asking here? It was asking two
- 7:54questions. One is the overall objective
- 7:56of strategic management and its
- 7:57limitations. This was also a two-part
- 7:58question. If you write the objectives
- 8:00correctly, you will get one mark. If
- 8:01you write the limitations correctly,
- 8:02you will get four marks. Now, I will
- 8:03show you how it works. When you write
- 8:05things in your own words or don't write
- 8:07them quite right, this is how they give
- 8:08marks. So, what did the student do here
- 8:10? They wrote two things for the overall
- 8:12objective of strategic management.
- 8:13First, they wrote to help the company
- 8:15to make a strategic plan. And the
- 8:17second point they wrote was to guide
- 8:18the company successfully through all
- 8:20changes in the environment. Now, this
- 8:21point of theirs was correct. But this
- 8:23point of theirs wasn't that accurate.
- 8:24It was wrong. The guy tried to write it
- 8:26a bit in his own words. So, the
- 8:27examiner gave them partial marks here.
- 8:29They gave five marks. And that's how it
- 8:30happens. Whenever you try to write
- 8:32things in your own words, or get some
- 8:34things wrong but get the other things
- 8:35right, you get partial marks. The whole
- 8:37question is never wrong. Okay? So, the
- 8:40objectives were like this. The overall
- 8:42objective of strategic management is to
- 8:44create a competitive advantage. For
- 8:46which, he wrote to help the company to
- 8:47make a strategic plan. This part was
- 8:49wrong. What you had to write was? That
- 8:51it helps you to create a competitive
- 8:52advantage. And it will help you to
- 8:54guide the company successfully through
- 8:56environmental changes and react in the
- 8:58right manner. Now, when you quote these
- 9:01two points correctly, the ICAI gives
- 9:03you marks. Like, let me show you a
- 9:05student's certified copy. So, what did
- 9:07they do here? The overall objectives of
- 9:09strategic management are as follows: to
- 9:11guide the company successfully through
- 9:12all the changes in the environment. So,
- 9:14this was correct. To create a
- 9:16competitive advantage so the company
- 9:17can outperform competitors in all
- 9:19aspects of organizational performance.
- 9:21So, here, as you write according to the
- 9:23ICAI's keywords. Exactly as the ICAI
- 9:25has presented it, if you write it that
- 9:26way, they will definitely give you the
- 9:28mark. Okay? Remember, you have to match
- 9:31the keywords a bit. Just as they are
- 9:33presenting the information, you have to
- 9:34present it in the exam that way. Okay?
- 9:36Then we come to the limitations. There
- 9:38are four points of limitations. One is
- 9:39a complex and turbulent environment.
- 9:41The second is a time-consuming process.
- 9:43The third is a rather costly process,
- 9:44and the fourth is the difficulty in
- 9:46predicting competitive responses. Now,
- 9:48what did this particular student do
- 9:50here? They remembered all four points,
- 9:52but couldn't recall the content inside
- 9:54as well. So, if you look, they wrote
- 9:57down all four points and underlined
- 9:59them. This is a very important thing:
- 10:02highly complex and turbulent,
- 10:03time-consuming process, costly process,
- 10:05and competitive responses. And they
- 10:08highlighted them, but the inner content
- 10:10wasn't clicking, so they tried to write
- 10:11it in their own words, which caused the
- 10:13ICAI to deduct marks and give them 2.5
- 10:15out of 4. Because if your inner content
- 10:17matches, only then do they give you
- 10:19marks. Like in this scenario, they
- 10:21first wrote: "Environment is highly
- 10:23complex and turbulent.""It is very
- 10:25difficult to estimate a complex
- 10:26business environment and exactly
- 10:28pinpoint how it will shape its near
- 10:30future.""Hence, an organization's
- 10:32estimate about its future may go wrong
- 10:34and jeopardize all its strategic plans.
- 10:36" So, this is how the ICAI wants you to
- 10:38write the answer. If you write it like
- 10:40this, they will definitely give you
- 10:41marks. So, this student wrote all four
- 10:43points correctly. It was just that the
- 10:45fourth point wasn't explained properly,
- 10:47which is why they got 3.5 out of 4. In
- 10:51total, this student got 4.5 marks,
- 10:52while the student mentioned earlier got
- 10:543 marks. And this is what I want to
- 10:57tell you guys. Both these students know
- 11:00the concepts, right? Both these
- 11:02students know the two objectives, right
- 11:04? What the four limitations are? They
- 11:05know. But this one is able to write it.
- 11:07And this one is not able to write it.
- 11:08And because of that, there is a 1.5-
- 11:10mark difference in both their answers.
- 11:12I have seen certified copies of many
- 11:14such students where they know what the
- 11:16point is, but they aren't able to
- 11:17explain it correctly. And if a 1 or 1.5
- 11:19-mark difference keeps occurring in
- 11:21every answer, then cumulatively there
- 11:24is a 10-mark difference overall,
- 11:25because there are seven questions, 1.5*
- 11:287 is 10.5. So, you shouldn't let easy
- 11:31marks slip away like this. These are
- 11:33marks easily within your reach; you
- 11:34shouldn't lose them because you already
- 11:35know the context. Just look at how you
- 11:37are able to write it down. That is why
- 11:38it is very important for you to watch
- 11:40writing practice sessions. That is why
- 11:41it is very important to take tests
- 11:42regarding these subjects. Okay? Because
- 11:44these are all marks that are easily
- 11:45within your reach. These should not be
- 11:47lost. Now, let's come to question
- 11:49number eight A. And one thing, if you
- 11:51look at this student's copy, what he is
- 11:53writing is correct. But when you look
- 11:55at his copy, things are not easily
- 11:57identifiable. Because he hasn't
- 11:59underlined anything anywhere. Now,
- 12:00suppose you are checking it. You have
- 12:01to check this particular copy. Then how
- 12:03difficult it is for you to check it. So
- 12:04, what should you do? Yes. Whenever you
- 12:06are writing an answer, when you write
- 12:08points like these, keep some space
- 12:09between them. Underline whichever point
- 12:11is important. Like competitive scenario
- 12:14, costly process, or time-consuming
- 12:16process, wherever you are writing. Then
- 12:19highly complex and turbulent. Now if
- 12:22you look at this student's copy, see,
- 12:24he has underlined all the important
- 12:26words. And then he has left a gap
- 12:28between both points. So, things are
- 12:30becoming a bit presentable. Okay? So,
- 12:32do that, your handwriting is fine, even
- 12:34if it's not that good. Okay? Your
- 12:35handwriting just needs to be legible
- 12:36enough for the examiner to understand
- 12:38what is written. Don't just go and
- 12:39write something like Spanish or
- 12:40anything else. It just needs to be
- 12:41understandable. Keep a gap between
- 12:43points and underline the things that
- 12:44are important. Okay? Now let's come to
- 12:47the next question and that is question
- 12:49number eight A. So here, question
- 12:53number eight A was on strategic
- 12:54uncertainty, which we ask in chapter
- 12:56number five, and the question asked how
- 12:58an organization can deal with this
- 12:59uncertainty. So, there are a total of
- 13:01five points for this. Flexibility,
- 13:03diversification, monitoring and
- 13:05scenario planning, building resilience,
- 13:07and collaboration and partnership. Okay
- 13:09? Now here, one minute, the screen
- 13:12froze. Now here is an ICAI requirement
- 13:15that you must fulfill, which they won't
- 13:17write down but you have to do it. Now,
- 13:19how it works is this. Whenever a
- 13:21question comes on such a topic and the
- 13:23definition of that topic is given by
- 13:25ICAI in their module, you have to write
- 13:27that definition first and start your
- 13:30answer with it. Now, if you look at the
- 13:32question here, what is the question
- 13:33asking? The question is just asking
- 13:34this much. In the light of this
- 13:36statement, discuss how an organization
- 13:38can deal with or manage such
- 13:40uncertainty. So here, students normally
- 13:43feel that they should directly start
- 13:44writing the points we studied about
- 13:46flexibility and diversification,
- 13:48regarding how to deal with strategic
- 13:50uncertainty. But I say it's not like
- 13:52that. What do you have to do first?
- 13:54What is this strategic uncertainty?
- 13:55Write its definition first. Then write
- 13:58how you should deal with it, and then
- 13:59start writing your points. If you start
- 14:01writing the points directly, I will
- 14:03deduct one mark from you. And that is
- 14:05why many students have not written
- 14:07these definitions. And I believe that
- 14:09students don't understand the need for
- 14:10definitions because it isn't explicitly
- 14:12written to write them. It directly says
- 14:13to explain how you should deal with it.
- 14:15So if I were writing, I would also have
- 14:17started writing the points directly.
- 14:18But this is an ICAI requirement. And
- 14:20this is not the only question where
- 14:22they have done this. I will show you
- 14:23two or three more questions ahead.
- 14:24Where ICAI hasn't explicitly written to
- 14:26provide the definition of a particular
- 14:28thing. But it is their requirement.
- 14:30They always start the answer with the
- 14:32definition and only then present all
- 14:35the points. If you look here as well,
- 14:37in the student's certified copies, they
- 14:38had started writing directly. Following
- 14:40are the points that the organization
- 14:42keeps in consideration when dealing
- 14:43with uncertainty. They started writing
- 14:45the points directly. They deducted one
- 14:47mark from them. Okay? So keep this in
- 14:49mind. Whenever such questions come, you
- 14:51must start with their definition first.
- 14:54Okay? Now let's come to question number
- 14:58seven. Read the question once. Okay?
- 15:06Have you seen it? So here, question
- 15:07number seven A was regarding
- 15:09globalization. So it was asked why
- 15:11companies take their business globally.
- 15:12State the reasons for it. Now even here
- 15:14, if you see, nowhere has ICAI asked
- 15:16for the definition of globalization. If
- 15:18you read the question, it is written
- 15:20here: Analyze the various reasons why
- 15:21companies choose to globalize their
- 15:23operations. So what do you think?
- 15:24Should you start directly with the
- 15:25reasons? No, no, child, first write the
- 15:28definition and then start stating the
- 15:31reasons. So always keep this in mind
- 15:34for your attempt; whether ICAI asks or
- 15:36not, you must start with the definition
- 15:38first. Same like we do in Law, same
- 15:40like we do in Tax. They don't ask you
- 15:42to write the section number, but you
- 15:43have to. But we first write the
- 15:44provision, stating that this is the
- 15:46provision, and then start explaining
- 15:47the case. So, it's the same for
- 15:49Strategic Management as well. You have
- 15:50to write the definition first, and then
- 15:52you have to start writing your answer.
- 15:54Whether they ask for the definition or
- 15:56not. You must write the definition here
- 15:59. Now, the reasons ICAI has given in
- 16:01the module here, there are a total of
- 16:03nine reasons. But many students will
- 16:04think that the question is for five
- 16:06marks, right? So, if the question is
- 16:07for five marks, we will just write five
- 16:09points. If you write five points, you
- 16:10will get marks. That is absolutely not
- 16:12the case. If ICAI has given you nine
- 16:14points, you should write all nine of
- 16:16them. If they have given you six points
- 16:18, even if it is asked for five marks,
- 16:19you have to write six points. If seven
- 16:21points are given, write seven points.
- 16:22It is absolutely not the case that if a
- 16:24five-mark question comes, you just
- 16:25write five points. And your job is done
- 16:27. Now, let me show you the copies. I
- 16:29will show you four or five copies.
- 16:30Where students have done what? They
- 16:32thought the same thing. All the
- 16:33students thought the same. The question
- 16:34is for five marks. They just came back
- 16:36after writing only five points. Look at
- 16:37Question Number Seven A, no definition
- 16:40written. Started writing points
- 16:42directly. Wrote five points. He wrote
- 16:46five points here. He scored five marks.
- 16:48His points were a bit incorrect. He got
- 16:50five marks. Here the student wrote five
- 16:53points for Question Number Seven A. Got
- 16:55two marks. Now, this is exactly what
- 16:56you must not do. What did the student
- 16:58do now? Started writing points directly
- 16:59. Didn't even give any starter or
- 17:01anything. So, you must write the
- 17:02definition. But after the definition,
- 17:04give a little introduction. These are
- 17:06the following reasons why companies go
- 17:08global. So, provide some such standard
- 17:09introduction and then start writing
- 17:11your points. Never do this thing where
- 17:12you start writing directly. Okay? It
- 17:14doesn't look good. There is a standard
- 17:16writing practice. You will have to
- 17:17follow that in the exam as well. Okay?
- 17:19Here too, he wrote five points.
- 17:21Thinking that it's a five-mark question
- 17:22. We will write five parts. And the
- 17:24work will be done. All his points are
- 17:25correct. He only got two marks out of
- 17:27five. So here is another one. Question
- 17:30Number Seven A. He also did 1, 2, 3, 4,
- 17:33five. He also wrote all the points
- 17:34correctly. But he wrote them in a
- 17:35slightly more elaborate way. So, they
- 17:37got three marks for this. They did not
- 17:38get five marks. Then here too, in
- 17:41question number seven A, they wrote
- 17:42five points and got two marks. For this
- 17:44question number seven A as well, they
- 17:45wrote five points and got two marks. So
- 17:47, if any such question comes where ICAI
- 17:49has provided more points themselves,
- 17:52it’s not at all true that it's a
- 17:54five-mark question. Just writing five
- 17:55points is not enough. You will have to
- 17:57write all those points. Keep this thing
- 17:58in mind. Because here, many students
- 18:00knew all the points, but they didn't
- 18:02write them thinking it was only a
- 18:03five-mark question. So, you shouldn't
- 18:05make this mistake. Okay? And I will
- 18:07give you a summary of all these
- 18:08mistakes at the end. So, if you haven't
- 18:10written it down, it will still be fine.
- 18:11Okay? Now let's come to question number
- 18:13seven B. Look, this is a three-step
- 18:15question. Meaning, this question asks
- 18:16three things. First of all, what does '
- 18:18channel' mean? Tell me that. Then, why
- 18:20is channel analysis important? And then
- 18:22, explain what the different types of
- 18:24channels are. Now here, the marking
- 18:26depends on how you answer the
- 18:27respective parts of the question. It
- 18:29happens according to that. Meaning, for
- 18:30example, if you have written the
- 18:31definition of a channel correctly, you
- 18:33will get one mark here. Suppose you
- 18:34wrote the channel analysis part
- 18:35incorrectly, then they will deduct
- 18:36marks there, and if you have written
- 18:38the explanation part correctly, they
- 18:39will give you three marks for that.
- 18:41It’s not at all the case that if you
- 18:42get one segment wrong, they will mark
- 18:44the entire answer as incorrect. If you
- 18:45get one segment wrong, they deduct the
- 18:47marks for that specific part. But if
- 18:49you have written the other things
- 18:50correctly, they will grant you marks
- 18:52for those. I will show you. So, here if
- 18:55you look at the channel analysis, the
- 18:57student first wrote the definition
- 18:59regarding the channel. Now, they had
- 19:01written the definition correctly here.
- 19:03I feel that perhaps this examiner was a
- 19:05bit strict in their checking. They gave
- 19:07five marks. They should have received
- 19:08one mark here. What have they written
- 19:10here? Channels are the distribution
- 19:11systems through which the organization
- 19:13distributes its products or provides
- 19:14its services. The exact same definition
- 19:16is written by ICAI in their module as
- 19:17well. So, they shouldn't have received
- 19:19five marks here. They should have
- 19:20received one mark. But okay, it's done.
- 19:22So it's done. Now here, channel
- 19:23analysis. They had written this channel
- 19:25analysis incorrectly. So look here, he
- 19:26was given zero marks for this. But then
- 19:28he wrote the types of channels
- 19:29correctly. So he was given marks for
- 19:31this again. Okay? So, just because one
- 19:33aspect of yours is wrong doesn't mean
- 19:35the entire question is wrong. That is
- 19:36not the case at all. Okay? I am saying
- 19:39this because what do a lot of students
- 19:41do? They don't know one specific aspect
- 19:43. And because of that, they skip the
- 19:44entire question. If you don't know this
- 19:46aspect, write two or three lines about
- 19:47it and write the rest of the things
- 19:49well. You will get marks for it. Okay?
- 19:51And then he wrote the types of channels
- 19:53, and he got two out of three marks
- 19:55here. Now, when you read his types of
- 19:57channels, he has written everything
- 19:59correctly. For example, if you read
- 20:00product channels. Product channels
- 20:02focus on the intermediaries who handle
- 20:04the product physically on its path from
- 20:06the producer to the end user. Now, if
- 20:08you read here as well, product channel
- 20:10refers to the intermediaries who
- 20:12physically handle and distribute the
- 20:14product from the producer to the
- 20:15customer. So whatever he has written in
- 20:17all three channels, those three things
- 20:19are correct. Personally, he received
- 20:20two out of three marks. Why? Because he
- 20:22did not write examples. So for those
- 20:25things where the ICAI has provided
- 20:27examples in their module. You have to
- 20:29put those examples in the exam. If you
- 20:32don't, your marks will be deducted here
- 20:34. So look here too, the student knows
- 20:36what the answer is. He knows what the
- 20:38channels are, and he definitely must
- 20:40know what the examples are, but he felt
- 20:42there was no need to write examples,
- 20:44and he lost a mark there. So, many
- 20:46students are losing one mark each in
- 20:47every answer like this. So, you need to
- 20:49pay attention to those aspects, and I
- 20:50am covering all those aspects in this
- 20:52video. Okay? And sir, in which other
- 20:54answers should I quote examples? Like
- 20:57in answers where you have to tell about
- 20:59horizontal integration, diversification
- 21:01, mergers, or concentric
- 21:03diversification. You have to quote
- 21:05examples there as well. If it is asking
- 21:08about market penetration or
- 21:09diversification, you must quote
- 21:10examples there. Even if it's written in
- 21:13the question or not, you should write
- 21:15them to be on the safer side. Okay? And
- 21:17this is the reason why he scored two
- 21:19marks out of three. So, this was your
- 21:22question number seven. Now let's come
- 21:25to question number six. All right? Now
- 21:28here, question number six was about the
- 21:30characteristics of business products,
- 21:31which we study in chapter number two.
- 21:33There are five characteristics, like
- 21:34your product can be tangible or
- 21:36intangible. Every product has a price.
- 21:37Then it has features. Then, a product
- 21:39plays a pivotal role in a business, and
- 21:41a product has a useful life. These were
- 21:42the five basic points. Now, like every
- 21:44student normally does in Strategic
- 21:45Management, they ask, "What should I do
- 21:47, sir?""I will just memorize the points
- 21:48, points, points, points.""And I will
- 21:49just dump some content inside." Now,
- 21:51this student memorized all the points
- 21:53and just wrote those points in the exam
- 21:55, like the product can be tangible or
- 21:57intangible. The product has a price.
- 21:58The product has features. The product
- 22:00plays a pivotal role, and then, the
- 22:02product has a useful life. He just
- 22:03quoted the points and came back. He
- 22:05didn't write the content inside at all.
- 22:07If you do this, you will not get marks.
- 22:09My friend, you don't just have to
- 22:10memorize points, points, points, points
- 22:11. Many students just do this in SM,
- 22:13thinking that if I just write the
- 22:14points correctly, I will get the marks.
- 22:16That's not the case. After writing the
- 22:17points correctly, you also need to
- 22:18write the content inside correctly.
- 22:20Only then will you get the marks. If
- 22:21you only write the points, you won't
- 22:23get marks like that. So here you can
- 22:25see, out of five, he got 1.5 marks. All
- 22:28right? So, this is the thing you should
- 22:30not do, my friend. Now let's come to
- 22:33the next question. The next question
- 22:34was very basic, asking what
- 22:35corporate-level strategies are. It was
- 22:37asking that, and along with it, four
- 22:39cases were given. Where you have to
- 22:41write which corporate-level strategy
- 22:42was used there. Tell me that. So, a
- 22:44total of five things were asked here.
- 22:45Corporate-level strategies and these
- 22:47four or five things. If you write all
- 22:50of them correctly, you will get the
- 22:51marks for them. So this was not that
- 22:53tricky. It was basic; if you write the
- 22:55corporate-level strategies correctly,
- 22:57you will get marks for that, and for
- 22:58each of the four cases, if you write
- 23:00them correctly, you will get one mark
- 23:01for each. All right? So it wasn't that
- 23:05complicated. Now let's come to question
- 23:07number five. All right? One minute. Yes
- 23:11. So let's come to question number 5A,
- 23:17and this was a three-step question, my
- 23:19friend. First, it was asking me to
- 23:21identify which model has been used here
- 23:23. Then explain it, and it further asks,
- 23:25is this a one-time process or a
- 23:26continuous process? Now, the ICAI had
- 23:28framed this particular question to be
- 23:30quite lengthy. And just by looking at
- 23:32its length, the majority of the
- 23:34students did not opt for this
- 23:35particular question. But this question
- 23:37was actually very simple. In fact, the
- 23:39answer to this question was provided by
- 23:41the ICAI right here. But a lot of
- 23:43students just panicked. Why? The length
- 23:45of that question is very long. So,
- 23:47never be afraid in the exam if a
- 23:48question's length becomes long, because
- 23:50it could be an easy question too. Read
- 23:52it once thoroughly. If any student had
- 23:55read this question properly, it would
- 23:57have clicked instantly after reading
- 23:59this paragraph which aspect this
- 24:01particular question is talking about.
- 24:03Okay? And we have discussed this
- 24:05question in detail in the writing
- 24:06practice session I concluded last week,
- 24:08where I explained how you need to write
- 24:10the answer to this question. Because
- 24:11this is a case-based question, you will
- 24:13have to write the answer in a
- 24:14case-applied manner. So, how to write
- 24:15that, I have discussed it thoroughly
- 24:16there. We had a discussion of around 30
- 24:19minutes on this question, so do watch
- 24:21that video. I will put the link in the
- 24:23description box below or attach it here
- 24:25, you can watch that video for this
- 24:26particular question, okay. Now let's
- 24:29move to the next question which was
- 24:31about Porl India Limited, 5B. Here it
- 24:33is asking to identify which Michael
- 24:35Porter strategy is being used here. It
- 24:37is asking to explain it and then asking
- 24:39for its disadvantages. So, this is also
- 24:41a three-step question. Okay? Now, even
- 24:44if it wasn't written to explain it,
- 24:46even then, whenever you write this
- 24:48particular question, just because it
- 24:51says identify, don't just write the
- 24:53name of the strategy. You should not do
- 24:56that. You will have to explain that
- 24:57strategy a little bit. Meaning, suppose
- 24:59here it says explain. It is not written
- 25:02like that. It just says identify which
- 25:04Michael Porter strategy has been used
- 25:06in the respective case. So here, a
- 25:08differentiation strategy must have been
- 25:09used. So, what many students do is say,
- 25:11"Sir, a differentiation strategy has
- 25:12been used here." They just write that
- 25:13and come back. But ICAI says no, no, no
- 25:16, if any term is used here, then define
- 25:18it first. You will have to define the
- 25:21differentiation strategy. You have to
- 25:23write in three or four lines what
- 25:24differentiation strategy means. Why is
- 25:26the differentiation strategy being
- 25:27applied in this particular case? And
- 25:29then you will have to answer the
- 25:30subsequent questions. So, here they
- 25:32have written that you need to explain
- 25:34it. But if they hadn't written that,
- 25:36you would have had to write it yourself
- 25:37. I will justify this to you. I will
- 25:41show you the justification in question
- 25:43number 5C, where things aren't asked
- 25:44but are required, and you have to write
- 25:46them; a student didn't write it, and
- 25:47their marks were deducted. I will tell
- 25:49you about it. Okay? So here, they have
- 25:52explicitly asked to identify and
- 25:53explain, and then they are asking for
- 25:55the disadvantages. So, we will
- 25:56definitely write that. And explain
- 25:58doesn't mean that you just come and
- 26:00write the definition of differentiation
- 26:02strategy. Explain means you have to
- 26:03write it in a case-applied manner.
- 26:05Write the definition, for sure, but
- 26:07then you also have to write why
- 26:08differentiation applies to this
- 26:09particular case. For example, in the
- 26:11given case, the company is offering
- 26:13higher quality, unique things. Then
- 26:15they are charging a premium price for
- 26:16that. They are working on their brand
- 26:17value. They are understanding customer
- 26:19tastes and preferences. They are making
- 26:20products accordingly. So, we do all
- 26:21these things in a differentiation
- 26:23strategy. And that is why they are
- 26:24fulfilling the condition of a
- 26:25differentiation strategy. And this is
- 26:27the differentiation strategy the
- 26:28company is following. That is what you
- 26:30will have to write here. Okay? And then
- 26:32you write three points regarding its
- 26:34disadvantages. Now let's come to
- 26:36question number 5C. So, you understood,
- 26:39right, that explain doesn't just mean
- 26:40writing the definition? Along with
- 26:42explaining, you have to write things in
- 26:44a case-applied way. Now come to
- 26:46question number 5C. This is also very
- 26:48important. Now, what is happening here
- 26:53is that ICAI is specifically asking
- 26:54which strategy is being used here. Look
- 26:56, are they asking to explain anything?
- 26:58No, what did they ask? Just state which
- 26:59specific strategy is being used here.
- 27:02Then it says to state the reasons for
- 27:03when this strategy is used, and then a
- 27:05case is given, and they are asking for
- 27:07your opinion on it. Now, many students
- 27:09did just what the question was asking
- 27:11—asking about the strategy. So they
- 27:12just wrote the names of the strategies.
- 27:14If I were in their place, I would have
- 27:15done the same. I wouldn't have done
- 27:16anything differently. Because the
- 27:17question itself was framed that way.
- 27:19But, my friend, I told you that whether
- 27:21ICAI explicitly asks or not, you must
- 27:23write the definition and explain why it
- 27:25fits here. You should just write this
- 27:28in two lines. For example, if you look
- 27:30here, a stability strategy was used. So
- 27:32, what did ICAI do? First, they wrote
- 27:34that MM Company should adopt a
- 27:35stability strategy. Then they defined
- 27:38the stability strategy as given in the
- 27:40module. Then, they wrote "in the given
- 27:42case," explained why the stability
- 27:43strategy applies, and elaborated on it.
- 27:45Were these things explicitly asked in
- 27:47the question? No, but you still have to
- 27:49write them. If you don't write them,
- 27:51they will deduct marks. Now, this part
- 27:53was for one mark. Now, if you see here,
- 27:55what did the student do? They wrote, "
- 27:57In the given situation, MM Company
- 27:58should adopt a stability strategy," and
- 28:00directly started writing the second
- 28:01question. How many marks did they get?
- 28:03They got 0.5 marks. That is why this is
- 28:06a very minor thing. It gets overlooked.
- 28:09And I can completely understand. We
- 28:10wouldn't understand this either. I used
- 28:11to write like that too. So I also
- 28:12wouldn't realize that I needed to
- 28:13explain it. But now you understand that
- 28:15you need to explain it and write the
- 28:16definition. Then, along with that, you
- 28:18have to apply it to the case. So, this
- 28:19is what you have to do. Okay? Then you
- 28:22had to write five reasons and answer
- 28:24the case that was given. Now, many
- 28:27students made mistakes here as well. If
- 28:30ICAI itself has provided reasons in
- 28:32just a few lines, write things in the
- 28:34same way. Do not try to elaborate on
- 28:36them on your own. For instance, if you
- 28:39look here, this particular student felt
- 28:41that the answer to the question was
- 28:42becoming too short. Because if I just
- 28:44write the five reasons as one-liners,
- 28:46the entire answer to this question will
- 28:48be finished in half a page. So, how can
- 28:50such a short question come for five
- 28:52marks? So, what did they do? They
- 28:55started explaining each point on their
- 28:57own. And then they received 2.5 out of
- 29:013 marks here. On the other hand, what
- 29:03did one student do? First, they wrote
- 29:06that it is a stability strategy and
- 29:07then they directly wrote these five
- 29:09points. So here, he got three out of
- 29:11three marks. So, you have to write
- 29:13things exactly the way ICAI has
- 29:15provided them. Suppose you feel that, "
- 29:17No, let me elaborate on things, that
- 29:19way I will get more marks." That is not
- 29:20the case at all. If ICAI itself has
- 29:22provided these many points, then do not
- 29:24add anything extra on your own. Do not
- 29:26try to explain it any further by adding
- 29:28something separate. If you write the
- 29:29points exactly as ICAI has given them,
- 29:31they will give you the marks. So here,
- 29:33this student got three out of three,
- 29:35and that particular student got 2.5
- 29:37marks. Now, if you look here, the
- 29:40checker gave him one mark, but gave the
- 29:42other student 1.5 marks, even though
- 29:44both wrote the same thing. He also
- 29:47wrote that the CBT strategy should be
- 29:49adopted by the MM company in the given
- 29:51situation. He also wrote the same thing
- 29:52. He was given 1.5 marks. He was given
- 29:54one mark. So sir, this is wrong. Now,
- 29:56how is it, buddy? The checking is done
- 29:58by humans. And whenever something is
- 30:00done by humans, there is some bias
- 30:03involved. Now, some checkers might
- 30:04demand that you must write the answer
- 30:06in a specific way. And some checkers
- 30:08might be fine with just as much as you
- 30:09have written. How would we know which
- 30:11checker we are going to get? So, to be
- 30:14on the safe side, prepare everything
- 30:16well so that the checker has no reason
- 30:18to give you fewer marks. And okay? And
- 30:21it is never the case that if it is a
- 30:22five-mark question......then I have to
- 30:24make it lengthy. Only if I write a
- 30:26two-page answer will it be justifiable
- 30:28as a five-mark answer. That is
- 30:30absolutely not the case. Now look at
- 30:31this student; he wrote a two-page
- 30:33answer. He got four marks. And here,
- 30:36the student wrote everything correctly
- 30:38in just half a page. He used the
- 30:39keywords as per the Suggested Answers.
- 30:40How much did he get? Four marks. So it
- 30:43is absolutely not true that you will
- 30:45get marks only if you write a lengthy
- 30:46answer. You have to write the correct
- 30:48answer. You get marks for the correct
- 30:50answer. Okay? So now I will tell you
- 30:52what the six learnings are for you.
- 30:53From this certified copy analysis.
- 30:55First of all, whenever you are opting
- 30:57for an optional question, write which
- 30:59option you are choosing in brackets
- 31:01along with the question number, buddy.
- 31:03The second thing is, whether the
- 31:05question asks for it or not, you must
- 31:06write the definition. If it asks you to
- 31:09explain a strategy, then write about
- 31:10the strategy. But also define it. Okay?
- 31:13Whether asked or not, you just need to
- 31:15do this in three to four lines. Then
- 31:17don't start writing points directly.
- 31:19Always start your answer by giving a
- 31:21bit of an introduction. Do not start
- 31:23writing points directly. There is a
- 31:24standard writing practice that you will
- 31:26have to follow. Fourth, wherever there
- 31:28are examples, you must quote those
- 31:30examples. You will get marks for that.
- 31:32The fifth thing is, thinking that I'll
- 31:34just remember point, point, point,
- 31:35point, point. My job is done. I'll just
- 31:37fill in the content inside. Don't do
- 31:38that at all. Remember the content
- 31:40inside as well. Okay? Put effort into
- 31:41that. You are currently in the revision
- 31:43phase. You can do this work right now.
- 31:45That is why this is important.
- 31:46Otherwise, even if you know the content
- 31:48, you won't get full marks. And the
- 31:49last thing is to follow the ICAI
- 31:51language. Write exactly as the ICAI
- 31:53language is. Don't try to make things
- 31:54unnecessarily lengthy. Present them
- 31:56here exactly the way they have provided
- 31:58them. And these are the six learnings.
- 32:00Meaning, these were the six mistakes
- 32:02that your singer committed in May '26.
- 32:03But you have to work on these things in
- 32:05September '26 and not commit these
- 32:07mistakes. Okay? And I will definitely
- 32:10say that if you work on this, your
- 32:11marks will easily increase by 7 to 10
- 32:13in Strategic Management. That's all
- 32:15from my side. If you liked this video,
- 32:17share it with your friends and
- 32:18definitely let me know in the comment
- 32:20section. Okay? Tata, bye-bye, see you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of CA Inter SM Certified Copy Analysis (May'26) | 6 Mistakes to Avoid in Sep'26 | CA Siddhant Mehta by CA Sidhannt Mehata, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,930 words across 1,042 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.