C'est Votre Argent - L'économie mondiale en danger après la défaite de Donald Trump ? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04BFM Business presents
- 0:08It's your money.
- 0:10Marc Fiorentino.
- 0:11>> Yes, I know, I know. We’re navigating
- 0:13between general strikes, protests, and
- 0:15riots, but I have three pieces of good
- 0:17news. It's your money, it's your weekend
- 0:18, and guess what?
- 0:20It’s an exceptional show. Well,
- 0:22exceptional because we’re going to
- 0:24revisit the exceptional events that
- 0:26marked an exceptional week—I’m not
- 0:28exaggerating—and that have all started
- 0:30to impact the economy and, of course,
- 0:32the markets. You noticed it on Thursday
- 0:34, and on "It's Your Money," we’ll
- 0:36explain why these events are piling up
- 0:38in today’s summary. The word of the week
- 0:40, obviously, is rout: the rout of the
- 0:42Republicans and the rout of Donald Trump
- 0:44. The stance of the week is the American
- 0:46election. That’s what I think, anyway.
- 0:48Obviously, everyone will disagree with
- 0:49my idea, but that's fine. I'm saying it
- 0:51anyway: the American election will slow
- 0:53down the development of AI and,
- 0:54therefore, American growth.
- 0:56The figure of the week is 4%, and I have
- 0:59a guest who will have to explain it, as
- 1:01it’s the inflation rate in the Eurozone
- 1:04.
- 1:05Second part of the show: where is the
- 1:07stock market headed after this dark day
- 1:08for AI? The money question: what is the
- 1:10investment of the week? In this turmoil
- 1:12, everyone is calling us asking, "What
- 1:13do I do?" Should I put my money in
- 1:15Luxembourg? Do I need to go to
- 1:16Switzerland? What should I do?
- 1:19Panic, everyone is panicking about
- 1:20capitalization especially, so we’re
- 1:22going to try to reassure you, explain
- 1:23the truth about all these products, the
- 1:25top or flop of the week, the managers '
- 1:26top 3, and the stocks to buy or sell.
- 1:29But you know by now, for an exceptional
- 1:30show, what do you need? Exceptional
- 1:32guests. I therefore have the pleasure of
- 1:34introducing our Jedi of economics and
- 1:36finance. She analyzes macroeconomics
- 1:38with relevance and talent.
- 1:40Anne-Sophie Alsif, hello.
- 1:42>> Hello.
- 1:42>> You are Chief Economist at BDO France
- 1:44and an economics professor at the
- 1:46Sorbonne. I didn't make the usual joke.
- 1:48About me following your classes and all
- 1:49that, because......
- 1:50>> because you still haven't come.
- 1:51>> Yes, I still haven't come, and well,
- 1:53after a while you'll get tired of it, so
- 1:55you won't want me to come anymore, which
- 1:56would be very bad for the show. He
- 1:58co-manages one of the finest investment
- 1:59firms in the market, and to me, he is
- 2:01the French Warren Buffett: Robin Bernard
- 2:03. You are the President of Moneta AM.
- 2:05>> Hello, Marc. Happy to be with you?
- 2:07>> Well, yes, you're still the French
- 2:09Warren Buffett.
- 2:10>> I'm not quite sure what a French Warren
- 2:11Buffett is, to be a French Warren. It's
- 2:13a man, well, yes, it's a man who invests
- 2:16for the long term, who has convictions,
- 2:18who has a conviction-based management
- 2:20style, someone who looks at the
- 2:22fundamental value of companies and
- 2:24doesn't get caught up in current trends
- 2:26. Is that a bit like you?
- 2:27>> It's a bit like that on that side.
- 2:29>> Well, there you go, managing portfolios
- 2:31and advising clients during periods of
- 2:33euphoria, but also during times of storm
- 2:35.
- 2:36That's his job. Stéphanie Moget, you are
- 2:37a portfolio manager at Financière du ZES
- 2:39.
- 2:40Do you, like me or others, have all your
- 2:41clients calling you and asking, what
- 2:43should I do?
- 2:44Should I open a life insurance policy in
- 2:46Luxembourg, or should I open an account
- 2:47in Switzerland? Should I move my money
- 2:49out?
- 2:50>> Well, a little, but it's not complete
- 2:51madness. I think clients are becoming
- 2:53quite educated and
- 2:56know how to navigate, well, volatility.
- 2:59Uh, but yes, that question still comes
- 3:01up, regardless. Especially for certain
- 3:03age groups, perhaps more about whether
- 3:06Luxembourg is a solution. Because you
- 3:08still need to have a custodian there,
- 3:09right?
- 3:10So, well, we'll talk about that.
- 3:12>> We'll talk about that.
- 3:14>> Do we have the drumroll or not?
- 3:17No, we don't have it. For a giant, for
- 3:19an oracle, for a monument of economics,
- 3:22the one and only, Jean-Marc Daniel.
- 3:24Jean-Marc,
- 3:26>> hello.
- 3:27>> Hello.
- 3:28>> Are you
- 3:29>> We're missing that drumroll. This won't
- 3:31do.
- 3:31>> Yeah, I'll do it. I'll do it. I'll
- 3:32announce them, but it's not the same.
- 3:35Are you ready for the word of the week?
- 3:38>> I am absolutely ready.
- 3:39>> The word of the week is rout.
- 3:43>> Well, I grant you, it wasn't a defeat;
- 3:45it was a rout. The Democratic wave swept
- 3:47everything in its path.
- 3:50The House of Representatives, the Senate
- 3:51; Trump was severely punished, even
- 3:53though he says it wasn't his election
- 3:54and that the elections are rigged.
- 3:57Well, that's his latest thing.
- 3:58Americans did not let the drop in their
- 4:01purchasing power slide, despite high
- 4:03growth.
- 4:04It's still "It's the economy, stupid."
- 4:06So, a new era is opening for the next
- 4:09two years. What should we expect for the
- 4:11American economy and the global economy
- 4:13? Anne-Sophie, I turn to you.
- 4:16First of all, it's true there has been a
- 4:18major blow to purchasing power because
- 4:20inflation has been higher than
- 4:22anticipated due to four factors. The
- 4:24first factor is customs duties. We
- 4:25talked about this, and you were already
- 4:27predicting a recession in 2025, while I
- 4:28was saying no, there would be no
- 4:30recession. Why? Because all companies
- 4:31overstocked, so in 2025 there was
- 4:33inventory available. So the inflation is
- 4:352026-27, as you can see, we are there
- 4:37now.
- 4:38The second factor is energy prices. Even
- 4:40though the United States has been a net
- 4:41exporter since 2019, they inevitably
- 4:43still feel the impact of energy prices.
- 4:45And the third factor is housing, which
- 4:46is also a very strong contributor to
- 4:48inflation. Donald Trump had promised to
- 4:50reduce housing costs for household
- 4:52purchasing power. And that didn't work
- 4:54either.
- 4:55Fourth factor, the customs duties; the
- 4:57goal was reindustrialization and having
- 4:59a more diversified economy.
- 5:01When we look at growth, you said it was
- 5:03robust, we're at 2.3 or 2.5 this year,
- 5:05right? You said two-thirds of it is AI
- 5:06investment.
- 5:07>> We were at 3.4 in the last quarter. Yes
- 5:10, but when Donald Trump arrived, we were
- 5:12at over 4%with a potential growth rate
- 5:13of over 3%.
- 5:16So we see that in two years, our growth
- 5:18potential has been cut in half for the
- 5:20non-AI economy.
- 5:21No.
- 5:22>> Yes,
- 5:23>> but you say you're sanctioning the
- 5:24Eurozone; you must also sanction the
- 5:25United States when you have factual
- 5:27figures, which is the case here.
- 5:29And so when you look at that, what do
- 5:30you see? You see there hasn't been a
- 5:32reindustrialization and therefore no
- 5:33massive value creation outside of AI and
- 5:35the bubble we know. However, when you
- 5:37say there will be a slowdown—except for
- 5:39AI, it's just the industrial revolution
- 5:41of the century perhaps.
- 5:42>> We completely agree. There's no argument
- 5:45there, but as you know, in economics,
- 5:47the key word is diversification. And so
- 5:49, when you aren't diversified, if there
- 5:51is a bubble, of course there will still
- 5:52be growth. And I don't believe in a
- 5:54collapse of growth in the US, even if
- 5:56the bubble bursts, for reasons of
- 5:57sovereignty. We can come back to that;
- 5:59we will continue to have investment
- 6:00thanks to that. But on the other hand,
- 6:02we risk having a slowdown in a context
- 6:04where rates are higher. You have
- 6:06inflation that is going to remain
- 6:07durably higher, well, necessarily, that
- 6:09will mean less global growth and
- 6:10therefore a slowdown in the Eurozone
- 6:12which, indeed.
- 6:13>> So, you are saying a slowdown in the
- 6:14Eurozone, a slowdown in the United
- 6:16States too, you already agree with my
- 6:18bias from earlier. For once, we are
- 6:19going to agree.
- 6:20>> No collapse, a slowdown, I'm moderate as
- 6:22always.
- 6:22>> Slowdown as always. Yes. Jean-Marc, what
- 6:24does that inspire in you? We will talk
- 6:25about inflation. Don't get worked up
- 6:26about inflation just yet, because it's
- 6:28the third theme of the first part. Yes,
- 6:29yes, yes. Well, it inspires two things
- 6:31in me.
- 6:32The first is an anecdote, I won't make
- 6:33it too long, but right now in the United
- 6:35States, there's a whole skit of Ronald
- 6:37Reagan being broadcast where we see
- 6:38Reagan, he is being criticized by people
- 6:40saying "You don't understand anything
- 6:41about the economy."
- 6:43He says "I'm going to tell you a story.
- 6:44Three men who just died arrive before
- 6:46Saint Peter, and Saint Peter tells them
- 6:48" I only have one spot in heaven. I
- 6:50don't really know who I should take. I
- 6:51have to take the one who corresponds to
- 6:53the oldest profession in humanity.
- 6:55"So the first steps forward saying it's
- 6:56me, because when Eve was taken from
- 6:58Adam's rib, a surgeon was needed.
- 7:00I am a surgeon, it's me.
- 7:03The next one says no, not at all,
- 7:04because for Adam to exist, there had to
- 7:05be order.
- 7:06Before there was chaos, it was someone
- 7:08who transformed chaos into order. It's
- 7:10an engineer. I am an engineer, so I was
- 7:12there before Adam. It's me. And the
- 7:14third one arrives, no, he says it's me,
- 7:16I am an economist and for there to be
- 7:18chaos, there necessarily have to be
- 7:19economists. And so
- 7:22>> thanks for the profession, and so all of
- 7:24this is spreading abundantly, saying
- 7:26that people keep saying he says
- 7:28economist and so on and so forth.
- 7:32Actually, all of that is extremely
- 7:34disorganized, and in particular
- 7:35regarding the fact that, to come back to
- 7:37the core of the subject, I think that at
- 7:39the start, Donald Trump had made a good
- 7:41diagnosis: that is to say that America
- 7:42is living beyond its means and is a
- 7:44victim of its twin deficit, the budget
- 7:46deficit which becomes an external
- 7:47deficit.
- 7:49The answer he provided was protectionism
- 7:51. It was an aberration. I don't know if
- 7:53it's the economists who create the chaos
- 7:55, but it is the protectionists who
- 7:56create the chaos.
- 7:58In other words, roughly speaking, he
- 8:00effectively increased customs duties in
- 8:02a totally disorganized way, with
- 8:03consequences that were completely
- 8:05unequal.
- 8:07That is also what N. Gregory Mankiw says
- 8:09, the famous economist who wrote a
- 8:10reference textbook.
- 8:12He says," Look, I pay customs duties on
- 8:14European products because most of what I
- 8:16consume comes from Europe.
- 8:18But my secretary, she pays customs
- 8:20duties on Chinese products because most
- 8:21of what she consumes comes from China.
- 8:23Yet, what Donald Trump wanted to
- 8:25sanction was supposedly China, but it's
- 8:28my secretary he sanctioned. "So she
- 8:30didn't vote for him. That's clear. So he
- 8:32pursued a policy that was absurd in the
- 8:35face of problems that are real.
- 8:37>> And now
- 8:38>> so and now
- 8:41>> And now, I think we are entering...Well
- 8:42, the thing is, when you look at the new
- 8:44majority and the two speeches, the two
- 8:46elements that the Democrats are
- 8:48highlighting, notably the person running
- 8:49to become the Speaker of the House of
- 8:51Representatives, is to say: there are
- 8:53two things we must highlight, corruption
- 8:55and inflation.
- 8:58So, I think regarding inflation, they
- 9:00will inevitably call for—even if it's
- 9:02not the right solution—the easing of
- 9:05monetary policy, but we are heading
- 9:07towards a kind of fight for checks,
- 9:09stimulus, the classic Keynesian demand
- 9:11that you adore; and then, we are
- 9:13effectively heading towards a kind of
- 9:16battle that will totally paralyze the
- 9:18American executive branch.
- 9:20Well, in itself
- 9:21>> that might be good news.
- 9:22>> Yes, that is actually rather good news.
- 9:25That is to say, to borrow from the
- 9:27American press, it’s" Mr. Veto "that we
- 9:29now have to follow.
- 9:31>> He has a hat called" Mr. Veto. "
- 9:33>> Mr. Veto, meaning he will constantly be
- 9:35in opposition to what is happening. So,
- 9:37ultimately, that means that in concrete
- 9:39terms on the ground
- 9:40>> it won't change much.
- 9:41>> It won't change much.
- 9:43>> I turn to the managers. Does the
- 9:45election change your life? You say less
- 9:47volatility. Change your life because one
- 9:49could expect less unpredictability in
- 9:52foreign policy and economic policy, and
- 9:54yet, in the end, you hope for calm, but
- 9:56that's not what we're finding in the
- 9:58market.
- 10:00>> Okay for now, but do you think—and this
- 10:02isn’t about political bias, that’s not
- 10:03the idea—do you think, Stéphanie, that
- 10:05we’ll be a bit more at ease because
- 10:07he’ll be somewhat constrained, there
- 10:08will be a stalemate, constant
- 10:10arm-wrestling, so he won’t get anything
- 10:11done, which would be just fine.
- 10:14>> I think we always need to return, as
- 10:15usual, to the fundamentals of what
- 10:17companies are actually doing. And when
- 10:19we look at the third-quarter earnings
- 10:21releases in the United States, 84%of
- 10:23companies have reported, and 78%beat
- 10:25expectations, with over 4%coming in
- 10:27above estimates. So, in fact, yes, let
- 10:29them live their lives; they are doing
- 10:30their jobs very well, and in Europe,
- 10:31while the numbers aren’t exactly the
- 10:33same, they are still much better than
- 10:34expected. So, for
- 10:36>> you, the impact of politics is
- 10:37ultimately
- 10:38>> the impact of politics
- 10:39>> because we’re talking about chaos here,
- 10:41after all.
- 10:45Companies have already absorbed part of
- 10:46the customs duties, so all of that was
- 10:48just a balancing act.
- 10:50>> Very quickly.
- 10:51>> That’s, that’s, that’s not always the
- 10:52case. Where, if we talk about that since
- 10:54Covid, we see that we’ve had many, many
- 10:55crises. So, there too, we must always
- 10:57look at the consequences in terms of
- 10:59numbers.
- 11:00And regarding customs duties, we knew
- 11:02there would be a significant
- 11:03inflationary impact this year and next,
- 11:05and we knew there wouldn’t be massive
- 11:07reindustrialization, since, as we’ve
- 11:09said, you won’t relocate production just
- 11:11by imposing tariffs.
- 11:13So that is somewhat the economic
- 11:15consequence of what was expected.
- 11:17After that, in terms of foresight and
- 11:19the real issues—like productivity,
- 11:21demographics, and the ecological
- 11:23transition—those are massive underlying
- 11:25factors, and I don't think these
- 11:27elections will change much in the long
- 11:29term.
- 11:29>> Agreed. So you think it will have a
- 11:31limited impact. I don’t think so, that’s
- 11:33not my opinion, but we shall see. The
- 11:35position of the week. Well, you’ve
- 11:36already answered that. I say that
- 11:38Trump's defeat will impact AI. Since AI
- 11:41accounts for two-thirds of American
- 11:42growth, directly or indirectly. So it
- 11:44will impact American growth. We saw that
- 11:47with Thursday’s performance. Thursday,
- 11:49that’s 3.5 to 4 trillion dollars wiped
- 11:51out. That's 3.5 to 4 trillion that won't
- 11:53go into consumption, into investment,
- 11:55and therefore into growth. Is there
- 11:57something wrong in my reasoning as usual
- 11:59, Anne-Sophie?
- 12:00>> No, no, the reasoning is sound.
- 12:02Indeed, there will be a correction, but
- 12:03I don't think it's necessarily
- 12:04election-related; it's that we see an
- 12:06excess of investment with profitability
- 12:07that perhaps won't materialize.
- 12:09Agreed. Yes, but that will slow down
- 12:11growth if we say that 2/3 comes from...
- 12:13>> So it will slow down growth. Don't
- 12:15forget that the underlying driver of
- 12:17American growth is household consumption
- 12:18, and it's a country that consumes
- 12:20heavily in a context of full employment
- 12:21.
- 12:22>> Yes. But if the market wealth effect is
- 12:24gone, if household consumption persists
- 12:26—and in my view it will—We won't be in a
- 12:29collapse or recession scenario, but
- 12:31rather, once again, a slowdown. Well,
- 12:34it's...a slowdown.
- 12:37So, since household consumption remains
- 12:39quite vigorous, I think we're looking
- 12:40more at around 0.5.
- 12:42We calculated that, a point less which
- 12:44could be because of the AI bubble, and
- 12:46the other important element is the
- 12:48aspect of sovereignty.
- 12:50I imagine that this summer, you read the
- 12:51publication of China's 15th Five-Year
- 12:53Plan while on the beach.
- 12:55>> And since you read it so well, well,
- 12:58what's point 4? It's that we will become
- 13:00—we will continue to be leaders in
- 13:02artificial intelligence.
- 13:04So there you have it, meaning the
- 13:05struggle will be one of sovereignty and
- 13:07not just in terms of returns, struck by
- 13:09point 4.
- 13:10That's true.
- 13:11>> Yeah, it left a mark on me. You
- 13:13>> are mocking me, but it's...
- 13:14>> No, I would never allow myself to mock
- 13:15you.
- 13:17>> Regarding the collapse, effectively, of
- 13:19the value of a certain number of
- 13:20companies. Talking about it, but are you
- 13:23saying today that American growth will
- 13:26slow down because, well, Donald Trump,
- 13:28the Democrats are anti—basically the
- 13:31Democrats are anti-data center,
- 13:33anti-tech leader, anti...
- 13:35>> An...
- 13:36>> No, not anti-an, of course not anti, no
- 13:39, no, you'll see...
- 13:42You...
- 13:42>> Anti, let's say anti-data center, we
- 13:44agree on that.
- 13:48But still, it's mostly California.
- 13:51>> We can't even say things in bad faith on
- 13:53this show anymore without being
- 13:55interrupted. It's unbearable.
- 13:58It's mostly California, and California
- 13:59has really become the quintessence of
- 14:01the current Democratic Party's spirit.
- 14:04Well, not of the whole Democratic Party
- 14:06, indeed, there's Texas.
- 14:07Yes, Texas, it’s Texas that has
- 14:09rediscovered—though with quite a strange
- 14:11narrative—since they’ve found their good
- 14:13old Southern reflexes again, saying:" We
- 14:14must not forget that the Republicans are
- 14:16not only the party of Trump, but also
- 14:18the party of Lincoln. "So, it allows
- 14:20them to settle some old, old scores.
- 14:24But concerning the losses, these are
- 14:26losses on the value of assets.
- 14:28However, the reality is concrete: it’s
- 14:30what people have in their wallets. It's
- 14:32not what people have in their vaults. I
- 14:34didn't invent the" wealth effect "
- 14:35myself.
- 14:36The fact is, I am convinced that this
- 14:37wealth effect has been largely
- 14:39overestimated.
- 14:40What is important is the reality of the
- 14:42income that you actually hold. This
- 14:44wealth effect is useful if it allows you
- 14:46to take on debt.
- 14:47As for the level of debt of Americans,
- 14:49anyway...people say today, when we talk
- 14:51about the economy, that for all these
- 14:53people who have enormous amounts of
- 14:54money, who are households that drive
- 14:56consumption, who are invested in the
- 14:58stock market, who have benefited from
- 14:59the surge in valuations—it hasn't driven
- 15:01the consumption of the wealthiest
- 15:03households.
- 15:05I am still—and this is a bit of a point
- 15:07of disagreement I have with Sophie—I
- 15:08think that consumption is quite, quite
- 15:10inert.
- 15:12I have remained attached to the good old
- 15:14IS-LM model, where there is a
- 15:15consumption coefficient, even if it's
- 15:17totally Keynesian; but it's...I was
- 15:18forced to teach it for years, which, by
- 15:20...
- 15:23by integrating a part of the discourse
- 15:25behind it. This idea that consumption is
- 15:27relatively inert has the consequence
- 15:29that what is at stake in all of this is
- 15:31effectively the impact of the budget
- 15:32deficit. We have exceeded a budget
- 15:35deficit of 2 trillion dollars. The real
- 15:37one, yes. Yes. More than 6%, I mean, we
- 15:40are...we are, yes. That's it. We are
- 15:42beyond everything, everything that had
- 15:43been envisaged until now.
- 15:45The real problem in all of this, to
- 15:47return to the IS-LM model or the
- 15:48multiplier—a question you addressed in a
- 15:50previous show—is that all of this is now
- 15:52spilling over in the form of imports.
- 15:55Meaning the real problem of the American
- 15:57economy is the management of these twin
- 15:59deficits. We have a 100 billion trade
- 16:02deficit per month now. And so the
- 16:04question regarding growth is, will the
- 16:07US economy continue to widen its
- 16:09external deficit, or will part of this
- 16:11budget deficit actually turn back toward
- 16:14the American economy and domestic
- 16:16production? When you look at this budget
- 16:19deficit, you have to realize there are $
- 16:221.25 trillion in interest payments. I
- 16:24mean, it's it's
- 16:25>> it's colossal. And you have it worse
- 16:27than us. Yes.
- 16:29And you have $ 920 billion in military
- 16:30spending, and one wonders about this
- 16:32military spending—as a number of
- 16:33Democrats say, we have the largest
- 16:35military budget in the world and we are
- 16:36incapable of winning a war.
- 16:38So there is a question that arises. It
- 16:40is
- 16:40>> You didn't answer whether the economy
- 16:42was going to slow down with Trump's
- 16:44defeat. That was
- 16:47Don't give me an anecdote about—no, I
- 16:49won't go back to Ronald Reagan or Texas
- 16:51facing Lincoln.
- 16:53I will answer the two questions you
- 16:55asked.
- 16:56Will the fact that stock prices and
- 16:58assets—yes, yes, fine—collapsed have no
- 17:01consequences?
- 17:03Will the US economy slow down? I don't
- 17:05think so. I think it will plateau,
- 17:07notably because there is a budget
- 17:09deficit that sustains its economic
- 17:11activity.
- 17:12>> Romain tried to get a word in.
- 17:13>> Yes. So, on AI, I think we have to look
- 17:15at the market reaction on Thursday.
- 17:17>> Yes.
- 17:18>> In fact, there might be a slowdown in
- 17:21data center rollout
- 17:24>> and but we clearly saw the stock
- 17:25market's reaction, a strong one so far;
- 17:27the problems with AI were the problems
- 17:29of funding, right?
- 17:31And the funding problem was exacerbated
- 17:33by the fact that there was incredible
- 17:34inflation, particularly in
- 17:36semiconductors.
- 17:37>> Yes.
- 17:37>> And because there, we really have a
- 17:39shortage of semiconductors. So prices
- 17:41have exploded. Semiconductor company
- 17:43earnings have sometimes multiplied by 10
- 17:45, as is the case in Korea. So we really
- 17:48had inflation. Yesterday—well, Thursday
- 17:51—the price drop in semiconductor stocks
- 17:54was over 10%.
- 17:57On the other hand, the drop for the
- 17:59hyperscalers—those who manage AI and are
- 18:01potential clients of data centers and
- 18:03semiconductors—they only dropped by 2 or
- 18:053%at most.
- 18:08>> So we can clearly see the market is
- 18:10saying the funding problem is ultimately
- 18:12less terrible than expected, because we
- 18:14will potentially have a future drop in
- 18:16semiconductor prices, and in the end, we
- 18:18will have growth that might be a little
- 18:20less rapid but more economically sound.
- 18:23>> Interesting. May I venture to say
- 18:24>> well, you may venture, no, but here you
- 18:26can
- 18:28>> wait, wait, I want to move on because
- 18:29this is the debate I was waiting for, no
- 18:31, he's the chairman, so he was right to
- 18:32say it
- 18:33>> the figure of the week Jean-Marc Daniel
- 18:36, 4%inflation in the Eurozone, twice the
- 18:38ECB's target, so I'll tell you, I've
- 18:40been repeating for months what Jean-Marc
- 18:43Daniel tells me, foolishly I go on all
- 18:45the sets and say there is no inflation
- 18:47>> yes
- 18:48>> but here I am facing people who tell me
- 18:50, Marc Fiorentino, there is 4%inflation
- 18:52in the Eurozone. I don't know what to
- 18:54answer anymore, Marc Daniel.
- 18:55>> Well, look, you have to answer the same
- 18:57thing every time, which is that
- 18:59inflation is a rise in the price level
- 19:01that is general and lasting. It is not
- 19:03general and it is not lasting. We will
- 19:06see that soon. I have behind me, and
- 19:08rest assured, you have Jean-Marc Daniel
- 19:09with you, which is important.
- 19:10>> Yes, it's important.
- 19:11>> Yes, but you also have
- 19:12>> well, that doesn't help much.
- 19:14>> You also have Paul Krugman, who is quite
- 19:16a reference. He is a Nobel Prize winner
- 19:17after all, and Jean-Marc Daniel should
- 19:19be one too. But anyway, for now, well,
- 19:20>> we keep campaigning, we keep campaigning
- 19:22,
- 19:22>> We keep campaigning. so, why do I
- 19:23maintain my point of view and my
- 19:25diagnosis?
- 19:27Because I think that, indeed, you've had
- 19:29price increases that are linked to
- 19:31mechanisms, essentially mechanisms
- 19:33regarding energy and certain food
- 19:35products, but you still don't have the
- 19:37wage-price spirals appearing, with the
- 19:39consequence that people are indeed
- 19:41suffering from this price increase in
- 19:43their purchasing power.
- 19:45This explains the discontent, the rout,
- 19:47but also the riots in France.
- 19:49the riots in Belgium, the riots in Italy
- 19:51, almost everywhere, there is a revolt
- 19:53over purchasing power. And why doesn't
- 19:54it follow through? Because
- 19:56>> do you really think that what is
- 19:57happening in France is a revolt over
- 19:58purchasing power.
- 19:59>> Ah, I think that's the essential part.
- 20:01Yes, I think it's the same logic as what
- 20:03happened in May '68. It is
- 20:05>> we'll have to do a real show on that.
- 20:07It starts with a student revolt and all
- 20:09that, and afterwards, what bounces back
- 20:11is indeed popular anger, which is anger
- 20:13linked to the evolution of purchasing
- 20:14power and the evolution of social
- 20:16conditions.
- 20:18>> And I think that, indeed, this situation
- 20:20reflects the fact that the global wage
- 20:23is destined to fall.
- 20:25Ah yes,
- 20:26>> Among the news, not just of the week,
- 20:28but of the month, is the speech by the
- 20:30World Bank president at the general
- 20:31assembly of the two institutions, the
- 20:33IMF and World Bank, who said," We are
- 20:35forced to revise our international labor
- 20:37market projections.
- 20:39"There will still be 1.1 billion people
- 20:41who, over the next 10 years in the
- 20:43Global South, will be entering the labor
- 20:45market, will be on the job market. But
- 20:47we anticipated that these countries
- 20:49would be able to create 800 million jobs
- 20:51. Now, we think that under current
- 20:52circumstances, they will be able to
- 20:54create 400 million jobs. So, there are
- 20:56800 million potential unemployed people
- 20:58who will place colossal pressure on the
- 21:00general level of
- 21:01>> not counting the unemployed we will have
- 21:02in developed countries,
- 21:03>> not counting the unemployed we will, not
- 21:05counting the fact that AI, contrary to
- 21:07what you think, will continue to develop
- 21:08and so it will effectively re.
- 21:10>> No, I never said it wouldn't continue to
- 21:11develop. I simply said that there is an
- 21:13AI bubble on the stock market. That has
- 21:14nothing to do with it.
- 21:17>> So there is downward pressure, a
- 21:18pressure that means there is no
- 21:20inflation.
- 21:21I hang on his every word, I repeat the
- 21:23same thing, and then I read Les Échos.
- 21:25There you go.
- 21:27And Les Échos reports 4%inflation in the
- 21:30Eurozone.
- 21:31Is that true or false?
- 21:33>> Well, it is true.
- 21:34>> Or is it a rise in consumer price
- 21:36indices, or is it the same thing as
- 21:39inflation?
- 21:40>> It is the same thing, and it is a
- 21:41general rise in prices, as has been well
- 21:43stated, which is primarily based on
- 21:44energy. And why is there this debate
- 21:46about inflation compared to the United
- 21:47States? We've said it, there are other
- 21:49factors like housing that we explained.
- 21:51In the Eurozone, it's really about
- 21:53energy, and we don't actually have this
- 21:56contagion effect on other sectors. Often
- 21:58you have energy inflation, then
- 22:00fertilizer, we have that, it moves to
- 22:02industry, we're starting to see that,
- 22:03which is why there's a drop in profit
- 22:05margins, then it moves to services, then
- 22:07it hits prices, and we don't have that
- 22:09in the Eurozone.
- 22:10>> But if you want, he tells me, Jean-Marc
- 22:12says there is no inflation.
- 22:14>> No, but what he means is that there is
- 22:15no inflation in the classic sense of the
- 22:17term, having an impact on prices and
- 22:18wages. We don't have that here.
- 22:20You only have inflation in one sector
- 22:22that remains contained to this day,
- 22:24inflation at 4%, and people go out into
- 22:26the street even though their purchasing
- 22:27power is not dropping.
- 22:30They go out into the street to say
- 22:32purchasing power this year will drop by
- 22:330.4%precisely because you have an
- 22:35increase in energy costs and wages are
- 22:37not keeping up, as has been said.
- 22:39So this year you are going to have a
- 22:41drop in purchasing power. That is just
- 22:43factual. However, why are we not talking
- 22:45about an inflationary crisis?
- 22:47Because this repercussion of inflation
- 22:49so far is limited to energy, it doesn't
- 22:51extend to wages, excuse me, the managers
- 22:54, because I just want to, when Les Échos
- 22:56, in which you write...
- 22:58>> Yes.
- 22:59>> Agreed. ...
- 23:00>> ment.
- 23:02>> Next to your headline, inflation is at 4
- 23:05%, is that false?
- 23:08It's just that it was, oh, it's badly
- 23:09...
- 23:11>> Not at all. It's a misuse of language.
- 23:13Moreover, you make a reference to Les
- 23:15Échos, well it's also important, it's a
- 23:17poor use of the word inflation.
- 23:20That is to say, if you remember in Les
- 23:23Échos, there is a paper I did in the...
- 23:33He chose a short title.
- 23:36He chose a short thing. Yes, but that's
- 23:38why we have people in the street.
- 23:40You say it yourself, because for the
- 23:42sake of these genius headlines in Les
- 23:44Échos, they are in the street not
- 23:46because there is a kind of misuse of
- 23:48language, which is a usage that in my
- 23:50opinion is erroneous, and once again, in
- 23:52Les Échos...
- 23:54>> But what...
- 23:58Always, no, but when she is on TV she
- 24:00says there is inflation, there is
- 24:02inflation, agree with me, but then it is
- 24:04convenient indeed to use this word even
- 24:06if its precise meaning is not exactly
- 24:08the one we are giving it at the moment.
- 24:11And so the real...
- 24:12>> You understand that we don't understand
- 24:13anything.
- 24:13>> Yes. Yes. Romain, do you agree?
- 24:16He's confusing both of us. No, wait,
- 24:18wait, wait, I'm going to tell you, go
- 24:20ahead, you have 40 seconds for just a
- 24:22word to conclude: where it becomes
- 24:24dangerous, which is what I said in Les
- 24:25Échos and on this set, is that by using
- 24:27the word inflation, we create a perverse
- 24:29mechanism.
- 24:30We say the central bank must now raise
- 24:32its rates.
- 24:34>> Yet that is what is dangerous, that the
- 24:36use of a wrong word has the consequence
- 24:37of generating a bad, Lagarde reads Les
- 24:39Échos, she says inflation is at 4%, I'm
- 24:41raising rates.
- 24:43>> There you go. Oh yes, but her mandate is
- 24:452%, so she has the right to raise rates
- 24:47because her mandate is two and we are at
- 24:49four.
- 24:49>> She shouldn't be reading Les Échos.
- 24:52>> She needs to think a bit about what
- 24:53she's doing, what's happening, and say,
- 24:54listen,
- 24:55>> No, she's not going to think about it,
- 24:57she's leaving.
- 24:57>> Yes, she's leaving, but she should say,
- 24:58listen, they're asking me a question and
- 25:00all that. Do I have the right tool? The
- 25:02right tool isn't necessarily the one
- 25:03you're thinking of.
- 25:04>> She watches TF1, she hears that people
- 25:06are wearing sweaters because heating is
- 25:08becoming...
- 25:09>> In any case, I will continue to read Les
- 25:11Échos regarding the rate hikes. Come on
- 25:13, let's move to the second part of the
- 25:14show. We're obviously going to talk
- 25:16about the spectacular market crash on
- 25:18Thursday. We'll see how we react to...
- 25:21>> Well, hold on, they won't stop talking.
- 25:24>> No, no, I don't know, he...I agree, you
- 25:26shouldn't invite any more experts here.
- 25:29I...No, so we were talking about
- 25:31inflation again. Well, I still haven't
- 25:32understood a thing, but that's okay. But
- 25:34hey, that's usually the rule with the
- 25:36monumental Jean-Marc Daniel, who
- 25:38confused us, and we understood nothing.
- 25:41With Stéphanie Moget and Romain, you'll
- 25:43bring some calm to this, and with her,
- 25:45who's navigating all this, wondering
- 25:47what on earth she's even doing there,
- 25:49because...
- 25:53>> Let's head straight to the markets. What
- 25:55a week! Wow!
- 25:57Thursday's session. It was very
- 25:59surprising after the tech results, I
- 26:01don't know if you were as surprised as I
- 26:03was; I saw the markets climb, the Nasdaq
- 26:05too, and oil drop as if there were going
- 26:07to be a truce in Iran or a deal, I don't
- 26:09know. And then the next day, boom, a 5.5
- 26:13%drop on the Nasdaq.
- 26:16We're calculating roughly 3 to 4
- 26:18trillion dollars wiped out in a few
- 26:21hours.
- 26:22That's basically double the market cap
- 26:24of the CAC 40, all in a few hours.
- 26:28And ultimately, there's something quite
- 26:30funny too, which is that the CAC had a
- 26:32good performance; it goes to show that
- 26:34sometimes being a dunce pays off because
- 26:36we don't really have tech stocks.
- 26:38Now Romain will tell me," Yes, there are
- 26:40some, but it's more subtle than that.
- 26:42"Well, I don't do" subtle, "Romain, I do
- 26:44things that are fast and understandable
- 26:46.
- 26:47And so...
- 26:49We find ourselves with a market today
- 26:51that is asking the question; I was asked
- 26:54it Friday morning on BFM, we are asking
- 26:56it everywhere.
- 26:58First question, I am addressing
- 27:00Stephanie here, and I am also addressing
- 27:02Jean-Marc, if he promises not to take 45
- 27:04minutes, and Romain.
- 27:06Is there a bubble?
- 27:09Well, if you recall, I came in June and
- 27:12I said it, there is a sense of a bubble
- 27:15; on this, I suggested you read the book
- 27:18by Jonas Gahr on the economics of crises
- 27:21. So, there was a sentiment, there was a
- 27:23lot of leverage in the system.
- 27:25There were, you remember, the leveraged
- 27:27ETFs which, in particular, kind of
- 27:29defined the bubble, all of that.
- 27:32>> That defines a bubble: people are buying
- 27:34not for future results, but because they
- 27:36think prices will go up.
- 27:38>> And so that effectively leads to
- 27:40positions that are speculative. These
- 27:42positions still deflated quite a bit
- 27:44over the summer, right? Or...
- 27:46>> Not that much, though, right?
- 27:48Well, later, other ingredients came in
- 27:50and it started up again.
- 27:52But there is still good resistance in
- 27:54the global market indices, right? The
- 27:56global indices remain up since the
- 27:58beginning of the year, even despite the
- 27:59decline. So there is a good...
- 28:02>> So we have cleared things up a bit.
- 28:03>> OK.
- 28:04>> Well, I am perhaps less confident about
- 28:06the impact. Indeed, I find that we are
- 28:09in a dangerous market because, I find
- 28:10that, indeed, there are balances that
- 28:12were mentioned earlier, and also there
- 28:14is American consumption that was cited
- 28:16as being robust.
- 28:17But I think it is—I rather agree with
- 28:19you—that it is very concentrated in the
- 28:21top 10%of the wealthiest population,
- 28:23where the wealth effect is not just an
- 28:25effect, it is still an effect of feeling
- 28:27wealthy.
- 28:29That is to say, when your wealth
- 28:31increases, you tend to make more
- 28:33discretionary spending than when the
- 28:35sentiment of wealth is...
- 28:37>> We see in the markets a lot of
- 28:39speculative positions that have possibly
- 28:41been unwound, and that is what we are
- 28:43seeing in my opinion again today, well,
- 28:45again this week, and particularly after
- 28:47the midterm elections. We are in a form
- 28:49of uncertainty and the hedge funds,
- 28:52which were quite leveraged, which are
- 28:54less so today, are still sufficiently so
- 28:57that I think many players have lost
- 29:00money.
- 29:01So at one point perhaps theirs should
- 29:03have gone up but theirs went down
- 29:04because perhaps they were forced to
- 29:06unwind.
- 29:07So there you have it, we are in a market
- 29:09that has been extremely, you say caution
- 29:10and selectivity, is that it?
- 29:11>> I say yes, a form of caution.
- 29:13Meaning, we are in markets that are high
- 29:16, we are in a macroeconomic situation
- 29:18that is still unstable due to all the
- 29:20deficits you described, and we are
- 29:22indeed without much of a safety cushion
- 29:24given the public deficits a bit
- 29:26everywhere in the world.
- 29:28>> Stéphanie, so what Romain is telling us
- 29:30is that there is a bubble, it’s starting
- 29:33to deflate, it will likely continue to
- 29:35deflate without any major accidents.
- 29:37Well, that's...
- 29:38>> We have no idea.
- 29:38>> We have no idea. Stéphanie,
- 29:40>> there is a return to fundamentals.
- 29:42Which is very good for managers like us
- 29:44, right, because up until now, there was
- 29:46a first phase where everything went up;
- 29:47then afterwards, there was a second
- 29:49phase where we started looking at
- 29:50leverage and ultimately, the capacity
- 29:52and profitability of these investments.
- 29:54Well, suddenly we're thinking, with more
- 29:57regulation, will we slow down? And I
- 30:00think it's a very good thing because we
- 30:03will indeed resolve these bottlenecks
- 30:05anyway. There is still a lot of talk
- 30:07that we are listening to.
- 30:09Microsoft still announced that, in fact
- 30:11, if they could have had more capacity,
- 30:13they would have sold more.
- 30:15But in parallel, you also have ARM,
- 30:17Qualcomm, who announced numbers that
- 30:18were a bit disappointing. So, we are
- 30:20finding good players and not-so-good
- 30:22players. With Romain, what you were
- 30:24saying earlier about the premium for
- 30:26hyperscalers, who are the ones that
- 30:28already have the infrastructure, who
- 30:29already have their data centers under
- 30:31construction for 2027, and that is
- 30:33already underway; we're not going to
- 30:35stop them.
- 30:37And then, indeed, these states, notably
- 30:39Texas, 25%of data center projects
- 30:40shifting toward the Democrats.
- 30:43Very well. We’ll stick with the
- 30:44Americans who will remain pragmatic. A
- 30:46data center means many jobs in
- 30:48construction. Afterward, it brings in
- 30:51taxes.
- 30:52There are still jobs to keep it running
- 30:54.
- 30:55So, I think here, we're in a sort of" oh
- 30:57my, what's happening?
- 30:58"effect. And we’ll stick with the
- 31:00Americans who are present. You're
- 31:02somewhat on the same page; it's a bit of
- 31:04a wait-and-see approach, and Micron has
- 31:07really dropped a lot today. Well,
- 31:10>> twice, uh, next year's earnings. Yes, it
- 31:14is cyclical, indeed, but if things take
- 31:15a bit longer, well, that's going to be
- 31:17very good because, ultimately, they will
- 31:19be able to produce more calmly, and
- 31:20maybe it will be less of a race for
- 31:22gigantic, massive investments just
- 31:23because they need to produce very
- 31:25quickly.
- 31:26And so, all of this will perhaps allow
- 31:28for easing both, well, the debt and the
- 31:30leverage we might find.
- 31:33>> And therefore ease rates a little,
- 31:34perhaps also because there will be less
- 31:36, I imagine, when valuations drop, their
- 31:38investment plans will also be lower.
- 31:41It's...rates actually fell after the
- 31:43results from the U.S., it was likely a
- 31:44reflection of both, this combination of
- 31:45these two things.
- 31:47Probably a bit less growth in the U.S.
- 31:48and then a bit less stress on,
- 31:50ultimately, well, the financing of this
- 31:51whole ecosystem which was still very
- 31:53tense. Yeah.
- 31:54>> Anne-Sophie, does what has been
- 31:56happening with AI for the last year or
- 31:58year and a half qualify as a bubble for
- 32:00you, or not?
- 32:02>> Well, I think there is a bubble. However
- 32:04, indeed, as we talked about the
- 32:05sovereignty aspect behind it, I think
- 32:07that even if it bursts, there will
- 32:09continue to be massive investments.
- 32:11>> So you are all more or less on the same
- 32:12page, meaning that there will be
- 32:13investment, but that we
- 32:15>> despite, even if there is a bubble, even
- 32:16if there are losses.
- 32:18>> Jean-Marc, to you and me, when we say
- 32:19there's a bubble, that still means there
- 32:21could be a real deflation of the markets
- 32:23,
- 32:23>> or rather, that there is a risk of
- 32:25market deflation, and therefore an
- 32:26impact on the economy, right. Oh yes, no
- 32:28,
- 32:29not saying what is interesting, though,
- 32:31is that it's a little bubble. It's...we
- 32:33have, we have markets that are very
- 32:35jittery with themes that, that pass by
- 32:37very, very quickly, right! The theme—
- 32:39well, Bitcoins are, they're separate—
- 32:41but which have, each one has its moment
- 32:43of glory.
- 32:44Defense had its moment of glory, you
- 32:46have a whole series of sectors that have
- 32:48their glory and then fall into oblivion
- 32:49, and, and everyone was focused on AI,
- 32:51effectively 40%of the American market,
- 32:53and that, that could fall into oblivion
- 32:55.
- 32:56>> What's interesting is to see—we have
- 32:58always repeated, well, that if the
- 32:59United States went down, Europe would
- 33:01necessarily be dragged along, and we saw
- 33:03something interesting this week.
- 33:05>> To see that on Thursday there was no
- 33:08contagion effect; it went down, it
- 33:10dropped in Japan, nearly 6%, but in
- 33:12Europe, it didn't happen.
- 33:14>> Because all the defensive stocks went up
- 33:16; there's an apprehension, there's still
- 33:18money in the financial system, and so
- 33:19people...
- 33:21>> For those listening, what are these
- 33:22so-called defensive stocks?
- 33:23>> Well, they are stocks whose business is
- 33:25less dependent on the economic climate,
- 33:27so consumer staples, stocks like Danone
- 33:30, stocks like Estée Lauder, for example
- 33:32, and they are defensive stocks,
- 33:34pharmaceutical stocks too, so those are
- 33:36the stocks that went up.
- 33:37>> Are defense stocks defensive?
- 33:39>> Well, defense stocks are not defensive
- 33:41because they depend on government
- 33:43budgets.
- 33:45>> Defense stocks are not defensive. Price
- 33:47increases are not inflation. Honestly,
- 33:49we don't understand anything. There
- 33:51>> is one thing that is important.
- 33:52>> No, wait, no, no, because you're going
- 33:54to start a long monologue. No, no, I
- 33:56have a question to ask you. Do you
- 33:57remember you and I lost quite a bit of
- 34:00money when the tulip bubble burst?
- 34:02>> Yes, yes.
- 34:03>> Yes. Absolutely. Yet I felt it coming.
- 34:07Do you
- 34:07>> But I got carried away.
- 34:09>> Yes. Well, remember, we talked about it
- 34:11often.
- 34:12And do you have the impression that with
- 34:13AI, we are in what qualifies as a bubble
- 34:15?
- 34:17I think that, indeed, everyone pretty
- 34:18much agrees that one of the challenges
- 34:20is knowing how much it will ultimately
- 34:21yield.
- 34:22Meaning, people who buy either think it
- 34:24will yield a lot because it will create
- 34:26a lot of wealth, or it will yield a lot
- 34:28because in 6 months they will have
- 34:29someone ready to buy the stock they
- 34:31bought for more, regardless of the
- 34:32reality of the sector behind it.
- 34:34That was the case with the tulips.
- 34:36People bought tulips without knowing
- 34:37what they were, telling themselves...
- 34:39but I think we have been in that phase
- 34:41for a long time, and now the question
- 34:42being asked is: how much will it truly
- 34:44yield through the service provided and
- 34:45the ability to sell a product with
- 34:47monetization?
- 34:48>> But you, when you see this over the last
- 34:496 months or a year, do you say it's a
- 34:51bubble? Well, I think we have indeed
- 34:53reached a point where we are asking
- 34:55ourselves how much we are going to gain
- 34:56from the introduction of artificial
- 34:58intelligence in terms of productivity
- 35:00gains and, ultimately, profit-making
- 35:02capacity. As for the wealth effect, you
- 35:03answered the question right away. You
- 35:05said I went to the hairdresser despite
- 35:07the drop in my purchasing power.
- 35:10No, I-I didn't say that.
- 35:12Due to, due to the hi-,
- 35:16and so, well, despite the stock's
- 35:18fundamentals, because my hair was too
- 35:20long...And so, at some point, it's not,
- 35:22well, it's not Nvidia's share price that
- 35:24determines what...We talked about Danone
- 35:27, we know the...the yogurt
- 35:30that I eat...that I eat in the morning.
- 35:32I don't check the stock price before
- 35:33knowing if I'm going to eat it.
- 35:34That's why it's defensive.
- 35:37On the other hand, buying luxury goods,
- 35:38buying, buying, buying very big cars,
- 35:40that, he...No, forget about that, he
- 35:42doesn't know about it.
- 35:44No, don't talk to him about that stuff,
- 35:45he doesn't know it. I'm turning to the
- 35:47two managers precisely in this context.
- 35:49Uh, the investment, I'd like to say, of
- 35:51the week.
- 35:52Well, Stéphanie, as I said in the
- 35:53introduction, people have questions
- 35:55about Luxembourg, custodians in
- 35:56Switzerland, we hear everything.
- 35:58Uh, Luxembourg life insurance, it's the
- 36:00hype of the moment.
- 36:02What do you advise your clients?
- 36:04Well, we must not forget that when you
- 36:06are a French tax resident, even if you
- 36:08have life insurance in Luxembourg, you
- 36:10will depend on French tax law, Sapin 2.
- 36:13>> Certainly, there is Sapin 2.
- 36:15In fact, basically, indeed, when you
- 36:17have life insurance in Luxembourg, you
- 36:19will not be subject to the Sapin 2 law
- 36:21which, for the record, can freeze
- 36:23withdrawals from your life insurance for
- 36:256 months, and you will benefit from the
- 36:27Luxembourg insurance security triangle,
- 36:29which means that if your insurance
- 36:31company goes bankrupt, your assets are
- 36:33normally secured, they are guaranteed.
- 36:35There you go. Still, if we reach the
- 36:38context of a presidential election with
- 36:41a president who says:" We are going to
- 36:43levy x%on life insurance policies above
- 36:46a certain amount, "I don't see why
- 36:48Luxembourg would oppose that levy.
- 36:51>> Understand?
- 36:52open
- 36:54open your insurance contract in
- 36:56Luxembourg.
- 36:57Clients, of course, clients today are
- 36:58worried, some are even ready to make
- 37:00withdrawals to switch to contracts in
- 37:02Luxembourg.
- 37:03But that remains a small portion who,
- 37:05basically, want to protect themselves
- 37:06from a worst-case scenario, that is to
- 37:08say, a collapse of the eurozone.
- 37:10Personally, I think that for the moment
- 37:11, that is not our scenario. Nevertheless
- 37:13, if it reassures you and allows you to
- 37:15sleep, you should always follow those
- 37:16intuitions.
- 37:18And whether you are in France or
- 37:19Luxembourg today, insurance companies
- 37:21have bonus policies that are very, very
- 37:24advantageous for those who bring in new
- 37:26money, allowing them to get rates with
- 37:28bonuses over 2 years, practically almost
- 37:30above 5%.
- 37:32So there you go, that is what we call
- 37:34boosted euro funds.
- 37:35>> Euro funds.
- 37:36However, that is simply to allow them to
- 37:39compensate for the latent losses they
- 37:41have on their current stock of bonds.
- 37:44And so with the new money, they will be
- 37:46able to subscribe to bonds with rates
- 37:48around 4, 5, 6%. That's it.
- 37:50>> Today, if I show up at Moneta and I say
- 37:52," I'm afraid of the elections, "
- 37:55We know the polls, we don't know what
- 37:57will happen. What do you advise people?
- 37:59Do you tell them to continue as before,
- 38:01open a stock portfolio?
- 38:03Well, you see, we are talking about, we
- 38:06are talking about the problems in the
- 38:09United States.
- 38:11Ultimately, Europe is relatively more—
- 38:13well, you might tell me we are of course
- 38:16dependent on our neighbors and possibly
- 38:18our clients, but Europe is still
- 38:20healthier financially overall. We aren't
- 38:22just talking about, we aren't talking
- 38:23about France, we are talking about the
- 38:24eurozone, right.
- 38:25You were saying, did we—Europe, and you
- 38:28noticed it, fell less, of course,
- 38:30because the markets also rose less, so
- 38:32it's a bit like the losers who resisted
- 38:34, we don't have shares, we don't have
- 38:36...
- 38:38>> We have stocks that provide things like
- 38:40Legrand, we have a few stocks indeed
- 38:42that are in microchips, but they aren't
- 38:44the big caps of Europe, apart from ASML
- 38:47, really, but so we are much less, and
- 38:49we have an economy that is less
- 38:51unhealthy, it seems to me, by far than
- 38:53the American economy, with companies
- 38:55that are solid, not necessarily very
- 38:57indebted.
- 38:59>> So I invest my money.
- 39:00>> So where do you invest your money? I
- 39:01think Europe is not necessarily a bad, a
- 39:04bad geographical area.
- 39:06Especially since we often forget—we talk
- 39:08about France, but we often forget to
- 39:10consider that there are a few states in
- 39:12Europe, and sometimes even in the
- 39:14eurozone, with growth as significant as
- 39:16in the United States.
- 39:18You have Greece—now, you'll tell me it's
- 39:19an indebted country, but Greece has
- 39:21learned its lesson. It is bouncing back
- 39:22.
- 39:24You have Central European countries that
- 39:25will benefit from the
- 39:26reindustrialization of Europe.
- 39:29That is to say, industries won't
- 39:31necessarily come from China to Paris,
- 39:33but they might stop, for instance, in
- 39:35Central European countries, and that's
- 39:37what's happening, with significant
- 39:39competitiveness.
- 39:41So these are factors that are drivers of
- 39:43growth within Europe.
- 39:45We've seen Spain, which also has growth
- 39:47that is quite reasonable, relatively
- 39:48solid, and debt that has...
- 39:52As for us, anyway, we only talk about
- 39:54what we know, so we are—you have
- 39:56long-short funds, for example.
- 39:58>> Yes, of course, there are long-short
- 39:59funds with European underlyings that
- 40:01work very well, and we have small-cap
- 40:02funds; and it's true that when I founded
- 40:04Moneta 23 years ago, people asked me,"
- 40:06Why are you returning from London to
- 40:07Paris, Romain? "Anyway, I may have
- 40:09already told this story, and those funds
- 40:12have returned 15%annually without
- 40:13leverage.
- 40:14>> On a European small-cap underlying, you
- 40:17see. So, that's management; there are
- 40:19always things to do regardless of the
- 40:21trend.
- 40:22>> Stephanie, sorry, very quickly.
- 40:24Yes, just—actually, today, what's quite
- 40:27pleasant is that we can find, depending
- 40:29on the type of investor you are, both in
- 40:32rates, really new returns with bonds,
- 40:34dated bond funds or not, which for
- 40:36investment grade is almost 5%, for high
- 40:38yield it's almost 7%, and then for
- 40:40equities, indeed, we have a whole range
- 40:43.
- 40:44So today, if you aren't invested at all
- 40:46, go ahead and add a little touch of US
- 40:48, why not, after all.
- 40:49And then afterwards, there are indeed a
- 40:51quantity of great stocks that are
- 40:53investable.
- 40:54Anophie, the top or the flop of the week
- 40:56?
- 40:56>> Yeah. So it was a top, with the increase
- 40:59of the Livret A ceiling announced by the
- 41:01Prime Minister, up to 25. So it's a top
- 41:04because it will finance productive
- 41:06investment. We already know that social
- 41:08housing brings in almost 1 billion for
- 41:09the state per year, so it's not
- 41:11insignificant.
- 41:13And now, uh, nuclear power, because as
- 41:15you know, we are one of the world
- 41:17leaders in carbon-free energy, and also
- 41:20in infrastructure.
- 41:22So we see that the idea is really to
- 41:23finance productive projects.
- 41:25Infrastructure, for example,
- 41:26school-related.
- 41:28>> Yes. School or otherwise, there is an
- 41:29infrastructure deficit.
- 41:30>> Will that make money? We’re talking
- 41:32about the long term, like renovating a
- 41:34high school.
- 41:35That’s the idea, that we are looking at
- 41:37the long term; it worked for social
- 41:38housing, it’s working for nuclear, and
- 41:40now the idea is to apply it to
- 41:41infrastructure.
- 41:42So it’s rather good to have a
- 41:44significant amount of money directed
- 41:46toward productive projects, even if the
- 41:48yield...
- 41:51That will be used to renovate a high
- 41:53school that burned down—is that going to
- 41:54make me money?
- 41:55>> Well, in the long term, you have a
- 41:56guaranteed rate. We’re at 1.7%now, we’ll
- 41:58be at 2%. That’s the point of the Livret
- 42:00A savings account, and it allows for
- 42:01long-term investment in infrastructure.
- 42:02>> Yes. But honestly, how are they going to
- 42:04make money on the construction of this
- 42:06high school?
- 42:06>> Well, because you will have
- 42:07infrastructure development, particularly
- 42:09with the ecological transition, which
- 42:10will pay off. So you will have
- 42:12profitability, but not in the short term
- 42:13—in the long term. And that is why this
- 42:15type of instrument, in my opinion, is
- 42:17effective over the long term.
- 42:18>> So it’s a" top. "Romain, top or flop?
- 42:21>> Not convinced. You aren't going to
- 42:22increase your savings cap.
- 42:24Well, first you'd need to have the money
- 42:26to put in it.
- 42:26>> 15%of people who have a Livret A are at
- 42:28the maximum limit. Well.
- 42:30>> My" top, "then, is a protectionist" top
- 42:32"—Europe is finally taking an interest
- 42:34in its automotive industry.
- 42:36>> So, you know, there have been debates
- 42:37for a long time. The Germans were very
- 42:39open toward China because, in fact, they
- 42:41sold a lot of cars there. The French
- 42:43never really managed to sell any, at
- 42:45least not recently. And finally, as the
- 42:47Germans are selling fewer and fewer to
- 42:49the Chinese, they are aligning
- 42:51themselves with the French.
- 42:54These two countries proposed that Europe
- 42:56restrict imports of electric vehicles.
- 42:58That has been done.
- 43:00The Chinese partially bypassed it by
- 43:02selling plug-in hybrids that weren't
- 43:04counted, and so Europe decided to crack
- 43:07down; a quota has been established.
- 43:10I love that. I'm like Jean-Bard Daniel;
- 43:12I'm all for protectionism.
- 43:14So, two years after" Liberation Day, "
- 43:16Europe is no longer playing by the rules
- 43:18with these discussions.
- 43:20We're using the same rules, the same
- 43:21rules as China, really. Stéphanie.
- 43:23>> Well, for me it's a flop, and Elon Musk
- 43:25. Actually, it might even be a top,
- 43:27having invested nearly 500 million
- 43:29dollars in this campaign to get
- 43:31Republicans elected, including 230
- 43:32million dollars in Texas alone, and he
- 43:34didn't succeed. Yeah, well, and even
- 43:36compared to what he lost in two days on
- 43:38the markets, and that's the second
- 43:40cooling effect, it's specifically Tesla
- 43:42shares that dropped, so well, he still
- 43:44has a few seconds to make it back, or
- 43:45...
- 43:46>> Jean-Marc, top or flop? For me, it's a
- 43:48flop, and it's the same thing as what
- 43:50Sophie just said, but to me, it's a
- 43:52mistake.
- 43:53I'll explain why: what she said is
- 43:55completely true, or what she said is
- 43:57completely true, and the answer, the
- 43:58answer to your question is: how are we
- 44:00going to pay for it?
- 44:02But it's public debt, simply put, it's
- 44:04just public debt in disguise.
- 44:07Exactly, remunerated.
- 44:10>> At 2%when the state just borrowed at 4.7
- 44:14%this week.
- 44:16So, that's a top for the state, but it's
- 44:18a flop for me because the saver is truly
- 44:20being cheated in this deal, and the
- 44:22people who will benefit from this are
- 44:24mostly relatively wealthy individuals.
- 44:27She said it, 15%of savings accounts are
- 44:29at their maximum, even though the goal
- 44:32of these savings was a...
- 44:34>> popular savings plan. A guaranteed
- 44:35popular plan, intended for people with
- 44:37low income, to ensure they get a
- 44:39significant return on their savings. So
- 44:42, in my opinion, we should lower the cap
- 44:43and increase the rate, rather than the
- 44:45other way around. Let's move on to the
- 44:47top 3 right away. During this turbulent
- 44:48week, Frédéric Rosier is doing very well
- 44:50. She still shows a loss of 16%, Pierre
- 44:5312.6%, Pierre Chang, Pascal Séville 9.4
- 44:56%. I want to scare Romain Burnand.
- 45:01And we'll display Romain Burnand's
- 45:03portfolio.
- 45:04Romain.
- 45:06>> No, seriously, relax, okay? No, we are
- 45:08very, very kind here. You see, we're
- 45:11benevolent. You have Altea.
- 45:13>> Yes, that...
- 45:14>> It's bounced back well. It's good, but
- 45:16we're going to, we're going to trim our
- 45:18position. We're going to, we're going to
- 45:19sell.
- 45:19>> We're going to sell LDC, our friends
- 45:20from the chicken business, Canal Plus.
- 45:22We're selling...
- 45:23...
- 45:24>> taxation...
- 45:24>> Double taxation of VAT. That's always
- 45:27possible. Erste Bank, I'm selling it for
- 45:29another Austrian bank.
- 45:30>> OK. Strabag.
- 45:32>> Strabag. We're keeping it.
- 45:33>> EFG Eurobank Ergasias.
- 45:35>> Eurobank is a Greek bank, a Greek bank
- 45:37that we're keeping.
- 45:39>> Keep Danone.
- 45:39>> We're keeping it.
- 45:41>> And UCB, bravo UCB, up 35%since you
- 45:44recommended it to us.
- 45:46What are we buying, Romain?
- 45:49>> Well, we're buying, we're buying Renault
- 45:50, so I told you about Renault, it's a
- 45:51stock nobody wants.
- 45:53Yeah, really.
- 45:57Of
- 45:59not disappointed by the results. It's
- 46:01crazy.
- 46:01>> It's 8 billion euros in market
- 46:03capitalization. It's a very small market
- 46:05cap, nobody is interested in it. There's
- 46:0714%of the free float that's shorted by
- 46:09people who think it's going to go down.
- 46:11So if it doesn't go down, one day
- 46:13they'll have to buy back, and that will
- 46:14drive the stock up.
- 46:15And the market cap is equal to the cash
- 46:17on hand.
- 46:19You add a stake in Nissan worth around 2
- 46:21billion, and financial activities that
- 46:23are admittedly dependent on the Renault
- 46:25group but are still profitable.
- 46:27>> And so there you go, it's really a value
- 46:29stock, nobody is interested in it
- 46:30because, well not nobody, but the stock
- 46:32just keeps
- 46:33>> And Raiffeisen is, uh, well it's
- 46:35>> to replace
- 46:36>> it's to replace those because it's a
- 46:38bank that isn't well-known. Has some
- 46:40good news to announce to us. These are
- 46:42quite complex subjects related to the,
- 46:44the, the
- 46:46Russian issues. So a large subsidiary in
- 46:48Russia that it was deprived of, but it
- 46:50will be able to surf on a
- 46:53>> a new one. So we're going for it because
- 46:55people haven't understood the story and
- 46:56we think we've understood it a bit.
- 46:58>> Stéphanie Moget, I'm going to scare you
- 47:00too. We're going to display your
- 47:01portfolio. You have some L'Oréal, tell
- 47:02me quickly. Visision, I
- 47:04>> Dassault Aviation. Look
- 47:08at it for a while.
- 47:09>> Alibaba.
- 47:10>> Yes. Well, I think that with what's
- 47:12happening in the US, Chinese AI should
- 47:14actually be able to
- 47:15>> benefit from it. Bolloré, we're keeping
- 47:17.
- 47:17>> La Française de l'Énergie.
- 47:19>> V4
- 47:19>> V4, very good results today. Robert
- 47:22>> or Robert in perfumes.
- 47:25>> It's suffering a bit but trade
- 47:27>> STMicroelectronics had a great
- 47:28performance.
- 47:31Yeah, we're keeping it, I think it can
- 47:32still really have a good run.
- 47:34Jacquet Metal also published some very
- 47:36good figures.
- 47:36>> All right. M6 and Nexans, we're keeping
- 47:38everything. So we're keeping everything
- 47:40.
- 47:40So I'm going to buy back because I sold
- 47:42Vallourec at 24 euros and we're buying
- 47:44back Vallourec.
- 47:45>> Why, well, you're going to have to
- 47:47explain yourself? I wanted to explain,
- 47:48because Vallourec, first of all, is a
- 47:50company that has undergone massive
- 47:52financial restructuring, which today,
- 47:54well, has a very strong balance sheet,
- 47:56which has, which is in markets...So,
- 47:57they are specialists in seamless tubes
- 47:59that are used today both for oil
- 48:01exploration, but now, increasingly, for
- 48:03geothermal energy.
- 48:04So we will be able to benefit from this
- 48:06need to diversify all these oil sources
- 48:08, uh, because we can clearly see that
- 48:09there are certain places where it is a
- 48:11bit more complicated to extract it.
- 48:14And then, uh, this geothermal energy is
- 48:17really a growth driver for them, and so
- 48:20it is, I think, a real way to diversify
- 48:22.
- 48:24It’s a company that is going to, uh,
- 48:26gain, have its profitability really
- 48:28increase, which generates a large cash
- 48:29flow that will go from 290 million to
- 48:31nearly 500 million in cash next year.
- 48:34An improvement in profitability, a very
- 48:36nice dividend between 7 and 9%depending
- 48:38on the year.
- 48:39Uh, so I think that in the current
- 48:41context, buying Vallourec for your
- 48:42portfolio, you don't have a big risk and
- 48:44you have a nice dividend that also
- 48:46allows you, well, to wait for the stock
- 48:48price to appreciate.
- 48:49Jean-Marc, you who are a specialist in
- 48:51seamless tubes, did it convince you?
- 48:54>> Ah, perfectly. Well, we'll see, and on
- 48:57Danone too, since earlier I said I eat a
- 48:59yogurt every morning.
- 49:01>> But should we invest in what we eat?
- 49:03>> Well, it's a market, right? It's, it's
- 49:06...
- 49:08Do you know Warren Buffett? You talked
- 49:09to us about War, what did Warren Buffett
- 49:11say? You have to invest. You saw, he
- 49:12succeeds, Warren Buffett, so he's the
- 49:14French Warren Buffett. Thank you all. I
- 49:16still haven't understood anything about
- 49:17inflation. We'll try to do it again once
- 49:19, and we'll do it again in the lobby.
- 49:21So,
- 49:21>> yes,
- 49:22>> you have to, ah, obviously, obviously.
- 49:25Thank you, thank you for following us.
- 49:27If you understood, send me a little
- 49:28message.
- 49:29We'll see you next week for a show that
- 49:31I'm told will be exceptional.
- 49:33You know that you can watch us, rewatch
- 49:35us, listen to us again on replay and in
- 49:37podcasts and on YouTube where we are
- 49:39getting impressive numbers.
- 49:43>> It's your money on BFM Business.
- 49:46Ah.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of C'est Votre Argent - L'économie mondiale en danger après la défaite de Donald Trump ? by BFM Business, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,711 words across 1,599 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.