C'EST QUOI "LA NOUVELLE FRANCE" ? Sabrina Waz, Francoise Vergès, Imane El Hamzaoui — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:17I salute you, people of the nation,
- 0:19resistors of the occupation. I see in
- 0:27you bravery, and the struggle, and the
- 0:29eyes that stay awake. I salute you,
- 0:37people of the nation, resistors of the
- 0:39occupation. I see in you bravery, and
- 0:47the struggle, and the eyes that stay
- 0:49awake. O people of the nation, you
- 0:57resistors. An olive branch in one hand,
- 1:12a revolver in the other. all the
- 1:16organizations, all the people who came
- 1:19to offer books, products from Urgence
- 1:21Palestine, notably CDEC, the UJFP and
- 1:27thank you to you. Thank you for
- 1:30crossing Europe, for crossing France,
- 1:32for crossing, I’d like to say, the
- 1:34island, for crossing the "New France,"
- 1:36the future New France, to join us here
- 1:38in Gennevilliers for the political
- 1:40summer school. And of course, in just a
- 1:45few short minutes, we will get started.
- 2:14For my part, I will be very concise.
- 2:16There, I was going to say the title
- 2:18speaks for itself. What is the "New
- 2:20France"? It is true that it is a
- 2:22concept that has emerged over the last
- 2:24few months in the discourse of La
- 2:26France Insoumise. We have been able to
- 2:34hear Bompard or Mélenchon mention this
- 2:36New France, explaining it—because
- 2:38journalists are also keen to challenge
- 2:40the leaders of La France Insoumise on
- 2:42this notion, by opposing this New
- 2:43France to a possible old France. So, we
- 2:51will also be able to perhaps shed some
- 2:53light on these gray areas. And in any
- 3:00case, we have three speakers today who
- 3:01will discuss this notion of New France,
- 3:03each in their own way. I’m just going
- 3:10to put on my glasses. There. First of
- 3:18all, I ask you, of course, to give them
- 3:20a proper welcome each time. First,
- 3:24there is Iman L. Hamzaoui, a member of
- 3:33the national coordination of La France
- 3:35Insoumise, coordinator of the
- 3:37anti-fascist campaign of La France
- 3:39Insoumise, and facilitator of LFI
- 3:40Anti-racism. Is that correct? Do you
- 3:46want to add anything? You can do it
- 3:48later if you want. Of course, we also
- 3:53have Françoise Vergès with us today.
- 4:01Françoise Vergès, spontaneously, I
- 4:03would like to say—you don't have a
- 4:05chair in your hands, it's okay—I
- 4:07would like to call you a decolonial
- 4:09feminist. Well, she told me, "If you
- 4:12introduce me like that, I'll throw a
- 4:14chair at your head." So I said, of
- 4:18course, I'm going to start by
- 4:19introducing you like that because, well
- 4:21, it’s not just "decolonial feminist,
- 4:23" but let’s say for those who know
- 4:25you, and who know you well, for me at
- 4:27least, you are someone who produces
- 4:29thought. There, you’ve shown it on
- 4:33various occasions through works that we
- 4:35can find, and of course, you theorize
- 4:37the anticolonialism of the colonized.
- 4:43Not as something static, just an
- 4:45observation of a past situation, but as
- 4:47a projection, as a dynamic, as I’d
- 4:49say, the ferment of a fight that we
- 4:51must lead and that still remains to be
- 4:53led. Did I get that right? Exactly. And
- 5:02finally, of course, you also talk about
- 5:04deconstructing coloniality through
- 5:05culture, among other things, and other
- 5:07fights you lead and contribute to, to
- 5:09help nourish this struggle that is the
- 5:11anticolonialism of the colonized. And
- 5:18finally, the one I see most frequently,
- 5:21Sabrina. Huge, huge, huge. President of
- 5:29the PDA, of course. President of the
- 5:33PDA; if you don't know what the PDA is,
- 5:36you won't find out. But above all,
- 5:40above all, I want to say above all a
- 5:42sister in struggle, because we are
- 5:43together at Parole d'honneur. Do you
- 5:46know Parole d'honneur?
- 5:48Yeah. Who here, who loves Parole
- 5:50d'honneur? And with standards, Parole
- 5:54d'honneur...no, no, but there you go,
- 5:59it's a pleasure. We often have the
- 6:02opportunity to be on sets together or
- 6:04at least support each other in news,
- 6:06sports, and political shows. And in any
- 6:11case, I'll say it, I'll say it to you
- 6:14publicly: I love, well, I love Sabrina.
- 6:18And so, apart from that, Sabrina is,
- 6:21precisely, an anti-racist activist.
- 6:24There you go. For me, what...I’d say
- 6:28the first thing that comes to mind when
- 6:30I think of you, when I look at what you
- 6:32do, is anti-racist activist. Because we
- 6:37feel the genuine concern to fight, to
- 6:39fight racism, but above all to fight
- 6:41the structures that create and produce
- 6:43this racism. And I find that in all
- 6:48your interventions, your choices, the
- 6:50topics you speak on, you embody that
- 6:52and you do it very well. In any case, I
- 6:55am proud, very, very proud to be by
- 6:57your side, Sabrina. Let's give them one
- 6:59last round of applause and we’ll get
- 7:01started. But before that, you saw this
- 7:04T-shirt that was gifted to me by my
- 7:06brother Jamel. It's a "Press" T-shirt
- 7:10paying tribute to all the journalists
- 7:12killed by the genocidal Israeli state
- 7:14for over 1,000 days now. And every day,
- 7:20every single day, we must spare a
- 7:22thought for those who are still
- 7:24documenting the ongoing genocide in
- 7:26Palestine. So yes, I wanted us to spare
- 7:32a thought for all those colleagues. And
- 7:40finally, of course, and this will be my
- 7:42last word, I would like to join this
- 7:44campaign which invites you all, or
- 7:46rather not just invites you, but urges
- 7:48and compels you to go and sign the
- 7:49petition. So on this topic, the
- 7:57government is targeting the rule of law
- 8:00; we need an urgent mobilization, say
- 8:02no to bill 691 on the presumption of
- 8:04self-defense for law enforcement. It is
- 8:09a text that will be voted on, and if
- 8:11nothing is done, it will be voted
- 8:12through on Tuesday. There is still time
- 8:15to act. So everyone in the live stream,
- 8:18please go to Google, sign the petition,
- 8:20and share it with your friends and
- 8:22family. We are already at over, close
- 8:25to 150,000 signatures, no, more than
- 8:28200,000, so close to 200,000 signatures
- 8:31. But we absolutely must reach 500,000
- 8:35signatures before Tuesday, because if
- 8:37this law is passed, it will worsen an
- 8:39already dramatic situation and give the
- 8:42police even more power to kill, injure,
- 8:44and mutilate us in the streets. So
- 8:49everyone go sign against this law
- 8:51before midnight. And so, and then we'll
- 8:59get started. There will be three
- 9:04presentations, and I just wanted to put
- 9:06a small question out there, just as
- 9:07something to ponder. I was wondering,
- 9:11is "New France" an observation? I mean,
- 9:15is New France just that? A new ethnic
- 9:18composition, I don't know, a gender
- 9:20distribution? Are we just observing
- 9:23something and saying, "Ah, that's New
- 9:25France, so we have to deal with it"? Or
- 9:28is "New France" a project, a dynamic?
- 9:33That is the question I asked myself
- 9:34while coming here. Well, partly because
- 9:36I didn't have much time to write
- 9:38something down, you see, I told myself
- 9:39I shouldn't embarrass myself, so I'll
- 9:41try to say something that makes sense.
- 9:43I thought it held up, though perhaps
- 9:45you will humiliate me in public, which
- 9:47doesn't matter. But in any case, I
- 9:50wanted to put that forward as my small
- 9:52contribution to the debate. Is New
- 9:55France an observation or a project? So,
- 10:00I will hand the floor over to Iman
- 10:02immediately. And so, their presentation
- 10:07is titled: Strategy for a Breakaway
- 10:09Bloc. Let's have a round of applause.
- 10:22Hello, everyone. Can you hear me
- 10:23clearly? Yeah. Well, first of all, I
- 10:28want to thank the organizers for
- 10:30inviting me to this plenary session on
- 10:32New France. Now, about New France, you
- 10:37only need to bring up the subject for
- 10:39the debate to heat up, for criticisms
- 10:41to fly, and for verdicts to be passed.
- 10:46The commentators on New France pay us a
- 10:48unique tribute, writing much more about
- 10:50our concept than we do ourselves, all
- 10:52while making sure not to read a single
- 10:54line of our work. Because, after all,
- 10:57it is more convenient to fight an
- 10:59imaginary straw man than an understood
- 11:01idea. The subject of the debate always
- 11:05becomes the representation they have of
- 11:07it, rather than the content we give it.
- 11:13So, amidst this sterile cacophony and
- 11:15the feigned outrage raised from all
- 11:16sides, I think it is more fitting to
- 11:18explain what New France is by first
- 11:20telling those irresponsible journalists
- 11:22what it is not. I say that New France
- 11:27is not a national narrative mirroring "
- 11:29Eternal France." The latter is a fable,
- 11:33not a past. It is the story of an
- 11:37imagined community defined by blood
- 11:39that never existed, whereas New France
- 11:41starts from concrete, current realities
- 11:43. It is a homogenizing narrative that
- 11:48ignores power dynamics and political
- 11:50struggles, when, for us, those are
- 11:51precisely the engines of history. And
- 11:57furthermore, it only keeps the glorious
- 11:59kings, emperors, and dictators from the
- 12:01past, whereas for us, the people,
- 12:03though often defeated and erased, are
- 12:05the only legitimate political subject.
- 12:10Moreover, "Eternal France" is a
- 12:12projection into a fantasized past. New
- 12:17France is a projection into a possible
- 12:18future, that of building a collective
- 12:20will for radical transformation. To
- 12:26borrow very freely from Gramsci, I
- 12:28would say that the far-right fights
- 12:29against the new to preserve the
- 12:31crumbling, while New France is the
- 12:33expression of the new, meant to break
- 12:34the resistance it encounters in its
- 12:36development. But we already know the
- 12:41futility of this argument in convincing
- 12:43those irresponsible journalists. We are
- 12:47not fooled. Their accusations are not
- 12:49errors of analysis, but clumsy attempts
- 12:52to put us on the same level as the
- 12:53far-right, to cast us out of their
- 12:55sacred "republican front," and to make
- 12:57us lose, even if it means letting the
- 12:59RN win. To our political opponents. I
- 13:05say that New France is not a concept
- 13:06that fractures society. Their process
- 13:09is well-orchestrated. They take a
- 13:12concept that describes all the changes
- 13:13in French society over the last seven
- 13:15decades. They purge everything it
- 13:20contains regarding the conditions of
- 13:22women, urban and rural conditions, the
- 13:24new conditions of our elders and our
- 13:26youth, to keep only post-colonial
- 13:27immigration. They think they can
- 13:33disqualify us by draping New France in
- 13:35what they call racialism, which I could
- 13:37not even define. In doing so, they
- 13:43betray their own ethnicist obsessions
- 13:45and their inability to see the
- 13:47racialized people of this country as
- 13:48anything other than objects to whom
- 13:50they have graciously granted a
- 13:51superficial citizenship for which they
- 13:53should be grateful. For the most
- 13:58skilled among them, New France is an
- 13:59identity-based and essentializing
- 14:01concept. They forget that by decreeing
- 14:06that New France is in denial, they
- 14:07simultaneously define France as a
- 14:09transhistorical identity, an immutable
- 14:11culture. In short, they essentialize it
- 14:15. And if we were feeling playful, we
- 14:18would reply that the denial is on their
- 14:20side, for a culture that does not
- 14:22change is a dead culture. For the
- 14:26crudest among them, New France sounds
- 14:28like the death knell of France, or more
- 14:30precisely, of their France—the one
- 14:32they enjoy exclusively, which is their
- 14:34only claim to fame, and where rights
- 14:36are measured by the depth of one's
- 14:37family roots in hexagonal soil. They
- 14:41are right to be afraid, and one must
- 14:43grant them a certain lucidity and
- 14:44foresight. Their cries are the sighs of
- 14:48those who see the old order fading away
- 14:49. To our comrades, I say that New
- 14:58France is not an abandonment of the
- 15:00working class. It is a lucid and
- 15:03updated interpretation of it. They
- 15:07understand the appeal of a unique
- 15:09political subject: the white worker in
- 15:11a large industry, living in a city
- 15:12center where the concentration of
- 15:14workers is conducive to strikes and
- 15:16social mobilization. But that worker no
- 15:21longer exists, and nostalgia is a poor
- 15:23advisor in politics. Since 1958, city
- 15:27centers have been gentrified. Large
- 15:30factories have disappeared, giving way
- 15:32to small, scattered production sites.
- 15:36Logistics and transport workers have
- 15:37outnumbered industrial workers, and
- 15:39temporary contracts and other
- 15:41precarious arrangements have become
- 15:42legion. It is this new working-class
- 15:48condition—or these new conditions—
- 15:50that their outdated software refuses to
- 15:52see today, just as they refused to see
- 15:54racial and gender categories yesterday.
- 15:59Because their thinking is not only
- 16:01anachronistic, it has always been
- 16:03truncated. It has never considered
- 16:07reproductive labor as a condition of
- 16:09capitalist accumulation, nor racism as
- 16:11a method of hierarchizing the workforce
- 16:13. And it has compartmentalized
- 16:20mobilizations and frozen the figure of
- 16:21the worker into a narrow framework. As
- 16:28soon as this framework was overwhelmed
- 16:30by mobilizations of immigrant workers
- 16:32or underpaid female workers, then this
- 16:34left, this left downplayed their
- 16:36struggles, when it did not outright
- 16:38vilify them in a nationalist and
- 16:39masculinist tension. Finally, their
- 16:44doctrine is counter-productive. By
- 16:47limiting political action to the
- 16:49economic sphere alone, it can only
- 16:51produce a categorical solidarity, which
- 16:53is itself economic. However, breaking
- 16:57away requires an awareness of the
- 16:58convergence of interests of all
- 17:00dominated groups. To our friends, I say
- 17:05that the New France is not an
- 17:07electoralist renunciation. We all know
- 17:11that the word France carries within it
- 17:13slavery, colonialism, racism, and
- 17:15supremacy. But I join here, if you will
- 17:20allow me, my comrade Antoine Léoman
- 17:22when he says that of France, we have
- 17:24only retained the narrative of the
- 17:26victors, that is to say, historical
- 17:27fatalism. To this, one must oppose the
- 17:33contingency of the past, this France
- 17:34that could have been, the one carried
- 17:36by those dominated and the fighters for
- 17:38equality erased from history books. And
- 17:42so I repeat these words. We are on the
- 17:46side of the revolutionaries in 1789 and
- 17:48especially in 1792. On the side of
- 17:52Jean-Baptiste Belley for the abolition
- 17:54of slavery in 1794. On the side of the
- 17:57Haitians at the Battle of Vertières in
- 17:581803. On the side of the Republicans
- 18:01during the Three Glorious Days in 1830.
- 18:04On the side of the revolutionary
- 18:06socialists in 1848, with the Communards
- 18:09in 1871, with the mutinous soldiers of
- 18:11the 17th regiment in 1907, with the
- 18:14anti-fascist protesters in 1934. We are
- 18:18on the side of the resistance fighters
- 18:21between 1940 and 1945. We celebrate the
- 18:25victory over the Nazis on May 8th. Of
- 18:29course, of course, we are on that day
- 18:31on the side of the inhabitants of
- 18:33Sétif, Guelma, and Kherrata. That
- 18:48being said, it remains to remind our
- 18:50friends that the popular national
- 18:52perspective that is ours is not
- 18:53nationalist. This perspective is the
- 18:59necessary mediation for
- 19:00internationalism, but not its negation.
- 19:04This perspective is one of lucidity
- 19:06regarding an unfinished past. It is not
- 19:10deaf to autonomist and independence
- 19:11demands, whether they emanate from
- 19:13Corsica or Kanaky. Whether the struggle
- 19:18takes place in the National Assembly
- 19:19with the vote for Corsican autonomy or
- 19:21on the ground with the visit of my
- 19:23comrades Mathilde Panot and Bastien
- 19:25Lachaud to emphasize once again the
- 19:26necessity of the independence and
- 19:28decolonization process for Kanaky. This
- 19:41perspective is also knowing we are in
- 19:43the West, and the corresponding duty of
- 19:45non-alignment and refusal of any
- 19:47military cooperation or foreign
- 19:48interference. It is not indifferent to
- 19:53the suffering of the Iranian, Lebanese,
- 19:55Venezuelan, Ukrainian—pardon—and of
- 19:58course Iraqi people, and also, of
- 20:00course, the Palestinian people under
- 20:02the colonial yoke. So, I tell our
- 20:10friends that the battle for hegemony is
- 20:12not played out in the realm of ideas.
- 20:14It is anchored in material conditions.
- 20:17And these conditions, well, they are
- 20:18called France. And this France has
- 20:23experienced fundamental upheavals since
- 20:251958, and that is what the concept aims
- 20:27to illuminate. If a long period
- 20:32covering nearly seven decades was
- 20:34chosen, it is because it allows us to
- 20:36grasp the organic movements of history
- 20:37without being trapped by short-term
- 20:39trends. The analysis of current events
- 20:43is interesting, but it remains a
- 20:45reactionary analysis, without depth and
- 20:47, above all, without transformative
- 20:49thought. At most, it can lead to
- 20:53marginal reforms or even resignation,
- 20:55but it remains sterile in terms of the
- 20:57potential for rupture. 1958, as you
- 21:01already know, is also the year the
- 21:03Fifth Republic was established. The
- 21:07question of the Republic's
- 21:08institutional form should not be
- 21:10dismissed in our discussions. We cannot
- 21:15understand abstention if we do not see
- 21:17it as the expression of a civic strike
- 21:18fueled by the current constitution. It
- 21:23guarantees the political
- 21:24irresponsibility of the President of
- 21:26the Republic, who, once elected, is
- 21:28accountable to absolutely no one. It
- 21:31also authorizes denial, as was the case
- 21:34in 2005 and again in 2024. The
- 21:37Constituent Assembly is therefore not a
- 21:39matter for constitutional lawyers. It
- 21:41is popular sovereignty. to be reclaimed
- 21:44. The Fifth Republic was born from the
- 21:46Fourth's inability to resolve crises:
- 21:49decolonization, rural exodus, and
- 21:50industrial and agricultural
- 21:52transformation. Today, we find
- 21:56ourselves in a similar dislocation, and
- 21:58the current regime is not only unable
- 22:00to respond to it, it feeds it. A people
- 22:06always has the right to review, reform,
- 22:08and change its constitution. One
- 22:11generation cannot subject future
- 22:13generations to its laws. This is what
- 22:16Article 28 of the Declaration of the
- 22:18Rights of Man and of the Citizen says.
- 22:20And in fact, the generations of the New
- 22:22France and those of the Fifth Republic
- 22:24are profoundly different. The New
- 22:27France is, of course, the daughter of
- 22:29the emancipation—certainly partial,
- 22:31but emancipation nonetheless—of women
- 22:34. In 1958, it had only been 13 years
- 22:37since women gained the right to vote.
- 22:40They had no access to contraception or
- 22:42abortion. Opening a bank account, like
- 22:45practicing a profession, remained
- 22:47subject to a husband's approval, and
- 22:49divorce by mutual consent did not exist
- 22:51. This change must not be understated.
- 22:54It is comparable to a revolution within
- 22:56the country. But its novelty also
- 22:58highlights the vulnerability of these
- 23:00achievements. Fragile, notably in the
- 23:02face of a resurgence of masculinism,
- 23:05and of course, quite incomplete. The
- 23:08New France is a France of internal
- 23:10migrations. The face of our country has
- 23:14been entirely redrawn by the movement
- 23:16of populations within it. 55%of the
- 23:20population lived in cities in 1958.
- 23:25Today, 86%live in cities or in rural
- 23:27areas under urban influence. However,
- 23:32this evolution is not yet the most
- 23:34decisive factor. The most impactful
- 23:37structural transformations stem partly
- 23:39from the urban condition itself, which
- 23:41has profoundly reconfigured the
- 23:43lifestyles of the French people. They
- 23:47have become dependent on networks—
- 23:49that is, the infrastructures that
- 23:51ensure the transport and distribution
- 23:53of goods necessary to satisfy our
- 23:55essential needs: water, energy, food,
- 23:57and so on. Due to their indispensable
- 24:02nature and their tendency toward
- 24:04monopolization, these networks can be
- 24:05transformed into sources of rent.
- 24:10Access to them is paid for even when
- 24:11quality degrades and prices rise. They
- 24:16thus offer capitalism, which has been
- 24:18subject to a productivity crisis since
- 24:20the 1970s, new spaces for value
- 24:22creation beyond the purely productive
- 24:24sphere. Only under this condition can
- 24:29we understand the challenge posed by
- 24:30network deserts. Whether they are
- 24:34public service deserts, medical deserts
- 24:36, food deserts, or even rail deserts.
- 24:40The second consequence is the desertion
- 24:42of the countryside. The proportion of
- 24:46the population living in rural areas
- 24:48has been halved since 1958, and for
- 24:50good reason: the agricultural world has
- 24:52collapsed, and there are only 64 jobs
- 24:55for every 100 rural workers. Staying
- 25:00means traveling dozens of kilometers
- 25:01every day to get to work, to the doctor
- 25:03, to the supermarket—for everything.
- 25:08In short, staying means extreme
- 25:10dependence on networks and the
- 25:11fluctuating price of oil. The New
- 25:15France is also the France of its
- 25:17countryside, which, contrary to certain
- 25:19political discourses, is neither a
- 25:21homogeneous block nor a world frozen in
- 25:23the past. No. Not all rural residents
- 25:28are hunters. In fact, more than
- 25:31three-quarters of hunters in France
- 25:33live in urban areas. No, rural
- 25:36residents are not climate skeptics
- 25:38either. In fact, they are more worried
- 25:40about global warming than the national
- 25:42average and advocate for ecological
- 25:44measures more than others. And no,
- 25:47rural people are not brutes insensitive
- 25:49to culture and the arts. Interest in
- 25:52cultural activities is at the same
- 25:54level for rural, suburban, and urban
- 25:56youth. But because of policies of
- 25:59abandonment, they have less access to
- 26:01them than others. The New France is one
- 26:04that does not confuse itself with its
- 26:06capital and its metropolises. It is one
- 26:09that does not look down on its rural
- 26:11citizens nor play the compassionate one
- 26:13. The New France is also theirs. The
- 26:16New France, and you already know this,
- 26:18is also that of racialized people,
- 26:20overseas citizens, immigrants, and
- 26:22their descendants. But I must clarify
- 26:25from the outset that it is not yet
- 26:26another liturgy of moral anti-racism or
- 26:28a rhetoric of riposte against the far
- 26:30right. Racism is obviously not the
- 26:33exclusive preserve of the latter. The
- 26:37New France does not aim to include, or
- 26:39to put it more crudely, to integrate
- 26:40racialized people into the social body.
- 26:44It states that they are the social body
- 26:45just as much as anyone else. It does
- 26:49not claim to bring forth leaders
- 26:50capable of understanding and listening
- 26:52to them. It acknowledges that they will
- 26:55also be the leaders themselves. The
- 26:58efforts to keep racialized populations
- 27:00at a distance from politics,
- 27:02particularly institutional politics and
- 27:04its transformative potential, are
- 27:05hitting a wall, and that is precisely
- 27:07what frightens our political opponents.
- 27:12So, I will conclude by saying that the
- 27:14New France is also that of the
- 27:16precariat. At the end of the 1950s, the
- 27:20standard reference was stable salaried
- 27:22employment with a status and a fixed,
- 27:24collective remuneration based on
- 27:26classification grids. Today, this
- 27:32standard seems like a distant mirage
- 27:34because precarious contracts have
- 27:36doubled over the last 40 years and
- 27:37affect more than half of workers under
- 27:3925. Fixed-term contracts have become
- 27:44shorter and more numerous. The number
- 27:47of temporary employment agencies has
- 27:49increased by a factor of 20 since 1956,
- 27:52and part-time work has more than
- 27:54doubled. Today, one in two companies
- 27:58uses or engages in subcontracting, and
- 28:01the status of "independent" often
- 28:03exists in name only. A fifth of them
- 28:08are dependent on another economic
- 28:09entity, yet society is more educated
- 28:11than ever because capitalism is a good
- 28:13student. It learned from social
- 28:18mobilizations and solidarity among
- 28:20workers, and its response was not long
- 28:22in coming. The atomization of the world
- 28:24of work. Diplomas no longer guarantee
- 28:27employment. Labor law is eroding and
- 28:29becoming individualized, and permanent
- 28:31contracts no longer protect. We have
- 28:37entered the era and the society of
- 28:38economic insecurity, where the
- 28:40precariat and its threat have become
- 28:42management methods, and workers have
- 28:43become entrepreneurs of the self,
- 28:45expected to perform continuously. The
- 28:52working class, with its clearly
- 28:53convergent economic interests, has
- 28:55given way to a myriad of popular worlds
- 28:57that are structurally compartmentalized
- 28:59and heterogeneous. It is the era of
- 29:02exacerbated individualism. But
- 29:08paradoxically, this individualism is
- 29:10our common condition, and therein lies
- 29:12an opening that we must exploit, which
- 29:14we must widen to make it the foundation
- 29:16of our base, of our disruptive bloc.
- 29:23This shared experience must find its
- 29:25political expression not only in terms
- 29:27of immediate interests, but also and
- 29:28above all through the establishment of
- 29:30a horizontal divide between them and us
- 29:32. Between the owning, racist, sexist,
- 29:37and supremacist class and the New
- 29:39France. We must shatter the illusion of
- 29:44inevitability and unveil the inherent
- 29:46conflict in society. Therefore, the New
- 29:51France cannot be the work of a single
- 29:52group. It must be a mobilizing image
- 29:57that builds alliances between different
- 29:59social groups by distilling their
- 30:01expectations and common aspirations to
- 30:03organize their collective will. Only on
- 30:08this condition can the New France in
- 30:09itself become a New France for itself.
- 30:12Thank you. Thank you, thank you. Thank
- 30:21you. I just want to greet the Student
- 30:28Union of Aix-Marseille and Laurent.
- 30:32There, who gave me this magnificent
- 30:34sticker. And we continue with
- 30:37Françoise Vergès with a question.
- 30:40What are the borders of the New France?
- 30:42Over to you, Françoise. Thank you.
- 30:51Thank you. Since I'm...Does this work?
- 30:55Yes. Since I am mindful of the time,
- 30:58and there is still a plenary session
- 31:00after us, and I also want to leave
- 31:01Sabrina time, I will try to be quite
- 31:03concise. We are only a few months away
- 31:05from the first round of the
- 31:06presidential election. A few months,
- 31:08therefore, to prepare for victory, to
- 31:10inspire a desire for victory, to
- 31:12inspire a desire for a new France. I
- 31:15proposed speaking about the borders of
- 31:17this space, which I understand well—
- 31:19for La France Insoumise, and they
- 31:21explained very well what that meant—
- 31:22that this notion describes new social
- 31:24and cultural configurations. The human
- 31:27condition of women, the organization of
- 31:29the family, the youth, the
- 31:31transformation of urban centers. A
- 31:32completely justified observation, but
- 31:34also a France of the daughters of
- 31:36immigration, stirred by creolization,
- 31:38to use Jean-Luc Mélenchon's words from
- 31:40his blog. I am therefore thinking of
- 31:43the following questions. What are the
- 31:44physical, psychic, cultural, and social
- 31:47borders of this New France? What will
- 31:48its reception policy be? Who must be
- 31:51forbidden from crossing the border?
- 31:53Should it be forbidden to Netanyahu,
- 31:55Trump, and their cronies? Should they
- 31:58be allowed to enter? Will visa
- 32:00applications be facilitated for
- 32:01students, researchers, and artists from
- 32:04the Global South, since Westerners do
- 32:06not need visas? Will access to
- 32:08residence permits be facilitated? Will
- 32:10property ownership be regulated to
- 32:12hinder the purchase of land, ports, and
- 32:14dozens of apartments by billionaires?
- 32:17How will migration from France and to
- 32:19the overseas territories be regulated,
- 32:21which some people there see as a
- 32:22reconquest? I would like to focus here
- 32:26on three points for which I do not
- 32:27expect an immediate answer. The urgency
- 32:30in the coming months is, as I have said
- 32:32, to prepare for victory but also to
- 32:33organize, with that victory in
- 32:35perspective, for the moment after, when
- 32:37the bourgeois bloc will unleash itself
- 32:39to derail a radical left-wing movement.
- 32:41This preparation for what comes after
- 32:42cannot wait for the days following the
- 32:44victory. We must already be thinking
- 32:46about solutions today, examining what
- 32:48has been done to overcome the obstacles
- 32:49. Since I am going to talk about the
- 32:51overseas territories, you will likely
- 32:53tell yourselves that I am like the old
- 32:54cousin at family dinners who constantly
- 32:56brings up the same old story. Either
- 32:58you listen with patience, or you wait
- 32:59for it to pass while looking at each
- 33:01other and rolling your eyes. Well, you
- 33:02can go ahead and roll your eyes
- 33:04whenever you feel like it. First point,
- 33:11the borders of the France shaped by
- 33:13migrations stirred by creolization are
- 33:15therefore those of metropolitan France
- 33:17with its working-class neighborhoods
- 33:18and its regions. A territory, therefore
- 33:20, contained within the European
- 33:22political and geographical space. For
- 33:24in the overseas territories of
- 33:25slavery-based colonization, as well as
- 33:28post-slavery colonization, the
- 33:29migrations were forced migrations, the
- 33:31organization of deportation. In these
- 33:34lands, the processes of creolization
- 33:36were responses to the violence of
- 33:37having been thrown into slavery, and
- 33:39thus forced onto a land. No return was
- 33:42possible at that time. I am also not
- 33:45sure that native peoples like the
- 33:47Polynesians, the Kanaks, or the
- 33:48Amerindians of French Guiana, or those
- 33:50who established themselves by fleeing
- 33:52the plantations and forming entirely
- 33:54autonomous communities, like the
- 33:56Bushinengue of Guiana, would identify
- 33:58with these processes. That this new
- 34:00France should open itself to
- 34:01communities stemming from migration in
- 34:03the second half of the 20th century, I
- 34:04see no problem with that. However, what
- 34:06place will the peoples of the overseas
- 34:08territories have there? How will
- 34:10borders at 20,000, 9,000, or 6,000 km
- 34:12from France be managed? I strongly
- 34:15suspect that it is not a matter of
- 34:16returning to the maps of "Greater
- 34:18France" where the colonies were colored
- 34:20in pink. Yet, in the same way, we
- 34:22cannot apply the contours of profound
- 34:24social transformations, the status of
- 34:26women, new social norms, or new
- 34:28conceptions of youth to the overseas
- 34:30territories. And even when we rightly
- 34:32speak of colonial relations in
- 34:33working-class neighborhoods, we must
- 34:35undoubtedly be more precise. For while
- 34:37we observe similar policies of
- 34:38Islamophobia, anti-Black racism, police
- 34:40violence, and the abandonment of public
- 34:42services, we must also integrate an
- 34:44economic analysis that is not reduced
- 34:46to mere discrimination. These are still
- 34:49, for the most part, peasant societies,
- 34:51lands that are hit head-on by the
- 34:53climate disaster and the economic
- 34:54decisions of the French state and the
- 34:56European community. We must also
- 35:01undoubtedly consider in this New France
- 35:03regional identities as well as
- 35:05religious identities: Islam, Hinduism,
- 35:07Buddhism, and Afro-Malagasy and
- 35:09Afro-Caribbean spiritualities. And if
- 35:12an alliance between working-class
- 35:13neighborhoods, the indigenous people of
- 35:15France and the overseas territories on
- 35:16an anti-imperialist, anti-colonialist,
- 35:18and anti-capitalist basis is possible
- 35:20—because it has existed before and
- 35:21can exist again—it is undoubtedly
- 35:23those contours that must be examined.
- 35:25Second point: the realization of a new
- 35:27France, a France of immigration, will
- 35:30inevitably lead to a radical break with
- 35:32European policies. For if it is not to
- 35:35remain a mere metaphor, it must enact a
- 35:37rupture with these policies, with
- 35:38Frontex, the agency created in 2004
- 35:40that transformed Europe’s maritime
- 35:42borders into a macabre landscape of
- 35:44death, and which is responsible for
- 35:46thousands of deaths not only in
- 35:48European seas, but also in the Indian
- 35:50Ocean and the Alps. A break with the
- 35:522024 European Pact on Migration and
- 35:54Asylum, which reinforced the project of
- 35:56Fortress Europe and the externalization
- 35:58of migration policies through the
- 36:00signing of numerous agreements between
- 36:02European Union member states based on
- 36:04the notion of "third countries." A
- 36:08France that is a child of immigration
- 36:10can only disobey the "Return Directive"
- 36:12voted on in the European Parliament
- 36:14last month, which imposes new rules
- 36:15allowing member states to detain
- 36:17migrants for up to 24 months and
- 36:19creates a framework for return centers
- 36:21in third countries that have
- 36:22volunteered. It is a directive that
- 36:26authorizes body searches, property and
- 36:28home searches, the obligation to remain
- 36:30reachable during the procedure, the
- 36:32recording of biometric data, house
- 36:34arrest, and the obligation to report
- 36:36regularly for registration. This vote
- 36:39was hailed by all the right-wing and
- 36:41far-right deputies, who rose to sing "
- 36:43Stabat Mater.""It is only the beginning
- 36:46of a paradigm shift," declared Marion
- 36:48Maréchal-Le Pen. We must point out
- 36:51here the fundamental role of
- 36:52civilizational liberal feminism and
- 36:54far-right feminism in the construction
- 36:55of this Fortress Europe. For decades,
- 36:59they have contributed to reconfiguring
- 37:01borders as lines for protecting white
- 37:02women from racialized men. A front line
- 37:05that pushes back indigenous men who
- 37:06supposedly have no other desire than to
- 37:08rape white women. Indigenous men thus
- 37:11become a threat to the national
- 37:12feminine body, to a racialized white
- 37:14body, the only one authorized to bear
- 37:16children, because the colonial racial
- 37:18border demands control over women’s
- 37:20wombs. As bearers of "impure blood,"
- 37:23indigenous men must therefore be pushed
- 37:25back, condemned to death by cold,
- 37:27drowning, hunger, and police beatings.
- 37:30These feminists are fundamental allies
- 37:31of white supremacy and its borders.
- 37:34They re-sexualize the body of the
- 37:35nation. It demands that a woman seek
- 37:38the protection of the police, the court
- 37:40, and the prison. A white woman. The
- 37:43lives of migrants and refugees are
- 37:45sacrificed without mercy. Generally
- 37:48with pitiless contempt, occasionally
- 37:49with moralizing hypocrisy to serve the
- 37:51interests of establishing a new Europe
- 37:53surrounded by ever more militarized and
- 37:55secured borders. We cannot accommodate
- 37:59all the world’s misery, Michel Rocard
- 38:01once said, adding "We must take our
- 38:03share of it." But who measures this
- 38:05share? What is the threshold at which
- 38:07one deems this share to be filled? In*
- 38:10Postcolonial Melancholia*, Paul Gilroy
- 38:12wrote about racism in England, and I
- 38:14believe this remark also applies to
- 38:16France, and I quote: "The politics of
- 38:18race has been dominated by the
- 38:19combination of post-imperial
- 38:21melancholia with various versions of
- 38:23racial speech.""This unstable mixture
- 38:26identified social and political
- 38:28problems embodied in the intrusive
- 38:29presence of immigrants and their kin as
- 38:31an intrusion, an alien wedge that has
- 38:33reached the body of an unsuspecting
- 38:35nation." Third point, how to end the
- 38:38naturalization of migratory flows from
- 38:40France toward the overseas territories?
- 38:43The internal border, mobile in time and
- 38:45space, serves two often concomitant
- 38:47objectives. The first consists of
- 38:50making the administrative limits of a
- 38:51state coincide with those of its
- 38:53control and its effective spatial
- 38:54development. In the second case, it is
- 38:58a matter of offloading spaces of
- 39:00essentially demographic pressure,
- 39:01spaces considered new, yet inhabited,
- 39:03and which are to be economically
- 39:05exploited to the detriment of these
- 39:07populations. When we talk about
- 39:10migration, we must therefore analyze,
- 39:12when speaking of New France, the
- 39:13borders constructed by the migratory
- 39:15flows that bring hundreds of French
- 39:16people to the overseas territories each
- 39:18year. Migration that disrupts the way
- 39:20of inhabiting and living. All these
- 39:22retirees in Kanaky, in the Antilles, in
- 39:24Reunion, young entrepreneurs, young
- 39:26people in search of a different life
- 39:27than in France, a bit more exotic,
- 39:29families of civil servants, all these
- 39:31civil servants who, as you know,
- 39:33receive an extra salary in all these
- 39:35overseas territories—bonuses that
- 39:37local civil servants also receive but
- 39:39which profoundly transform the economy.
- 39:41Migration that also leads to a
- 39:43recolonization of demographic
- 39:45imbalances, and once again we send
- 39:47colonists, expats, to claim equality,
- 39:49in other words, to demand to be
- 39:50stakeholders in decisions regarding the
- 39:53future of these lands. Beyond the need
- 39:56for the advent of a new French person
- 39:58freed from the racial contract for "New
- 40:00France" to fully realize itself—a
- 40:02point eloquently developed by Oria
- 40:04yesterday—New France must make the
- 40:06existence of "zoreils" impossible, that
- 40:08is to say, the white person from
- 40:09mainland France as they are called in
- 40:11Kanaky and Reunion, or "mzungu," that
- 40:13Comorian word to designate a white
- 40:15person used in Mayotte, and thus
- 40:17abolish the racial colonial
- 40:18relationship that turns any French
- 40:20person, even those on the Left, into a
- 40:22"zoreil" or a "mzungu." Regardless of
- 40:25their good intentions, their desire to
- 40:27learn local languages, or their love
- 40:29for the local culture, this signals the
- 40:31strength of a colonial impulse rooted
- 40:33in mentalities. The racial colonial
- 40:35relationship does not belong to the
- 40:37past. And while it is difficult to
- 40:39acknowledge that it exists in
- 40:40working-class neighborhoods, we find
- 40:42that in the overseas territories, this
- 40:44observation is hard to admit today. It
- 40:46is as if the existence of a political
- 40:48anti-racism—finally admitted in
- 40:50France—could not be so in the
- 40:51overseas territories. The point here,
- 40:54once again, is not to pit working-class
- 40:55neighborhoods against the overseas
- 40:57territories, but to analyze how the
- 40:59decline of anti-imperialism has
- 41:01concrete consequences on struggles. In
- 41:03Reunion, for example, last month, an
- 41:05op-ed on "zoreil" privilege sparked
- 41:07lively reactions. Among the "zoreils,"
- 41:10many protested against an accusation
- 41:12they deemed unjust. They had only
- 41:15accepted a job offer. They were not
- 41:17responsible for the past. They come
- 41:19because no Reunionese has their
- 41:20expertise, either by leveling the
- 41:22accusation of "anti-white" racism, by
- 41:24pointing out the existence of
- 41:25Reunionese wealthier than "zoreils," or
- 41:27by defending, as they say, a policy of
- 41:29integration: a request in reverse of
- 41:31the integration demanded of migrants
- 41:32and their descendants in France. On one
- 41:35hand, given the deeply asymmetrical
- 41:36relationship between France and its
- 41:38territories, this integration is merely
- 41:40a name for "soft" colonization. On the
- 41:42other hand, integration will not
- 41:44resolve a racial colonial relationship.
- 41:46On the contrary, it will increase its
- 41:48asymmetries. On the Reunionese side,
- 41:50some feared division and damage to
- 41:52social cohesion. But facing these fears
- 41:55and refusals, there is the relief of
- 41:57finally naming a privilege to return to
- 41:59a critical analysis of racial colonial
- 42:01capitalism and the dead ends of
- 42:02departmentalization or regional status
- 42:04through a return to the memory of
- 42:06struggles for democratic and popular
- 42:08autonomy, where independence is welcome
- 42:10. "Zoreils" and "mzungus" refuse to
- 42:13understand what colonization is, and
- 42:15when they recognize an economic lag,
- 42:17they attribute it to the past and not
- 42:20to the current situation—that is to
- 42:22say, the dependency on the decisions of
- 42:24a wealthy, imperial, capitalist country
- 42:26: France and Europe. They perceive us,
- 42:31while they, pardon, while they treat us
- 42:33like a tree whose branches they
- 42:34constantly prune, whose watering and
- 42:36care they criminalize. And then they
- 42:41wonder: but why doesn't this tree bloom
- 42:43? Why doesn't it bear fruit? Because
- 42:47all of that is being hindered. The
- 42:49situation is serious, very serious. The
- 42:52ruin of the farming classes in these
- 42:54lands, the recolonization, and climate
- 42:56disasters only aggravate the situation.
- 42:59Repressed revolts, the regular
- 43:01enforcement of curfews, prison as a
- 43:03response to unemployment, but also what
- 43:05African Americans have known:
- 43:07narcocapitalism as a weapon to destroy
- 43:09the youth. Indeed, after the mining,
- 43:12it’s drugs and the war being waged
- 43:14against the youth in these territories.
- 43:17But we no longer want to negotiate the
- 43:19length of the chain that binds us. We
- 43:21want to break it. The third and final
- 43:23point: how do we put an end to the
- 43:25historically rooted sentiment that the
- 43:27Republic brings progress and good? In
- 43:29other words, perhaps accepting a
- 43:30mutilation of the national body that is
- 43:32not natural, as we know. The Republic
- 43:35was colonial. It was the Third Republic
- 43:37that built the post-slavery colonial
- 43:39empire. It was the Fourth and Fifth
- 43:41that waged wars against liberation
- 43:43movements. Attachment to the colonies
- 43:45was often much stronger than attachment
- 43:47to principle. Trampling underfoot
- 43:49Robespierre's phrase: "Let the colonies
- 43:50perish rather than a principle." The
- 43:53difficulty of renouncing a space
- 43:55anchored in the national psyche must be
- 43:56considered. The idea of a "Greater
- 43:58France" is not only fascist or
- 44:00reactionary; it is also republican. It
- 44:02inspired dreams. It nourished the
- 44:04imagination of generations of children
- 44:06and adults. It offered the idea of a
- 44:07generous and welcoming society that
- 44:09would distinguish France from England
- 44:11and the United States. Which was not
- 44:12always entirely false, but not entirely
- 44:14true either. The national body would
- 44:17suffer a traumatic amputation if the
- 44:18overseas territories decided to break
- 44:20away from the Republic. France would be
- 44:22reduced to a very small country. And if
- 44:26its presence on this land becomes a
- 44:27matter of negotiation, if the extracted
- 44:29wealth no longer automatically goes to
- 44:31France, if France’s borders shrink,
- 44:33then we must reimagine another idea of
- 44:35the Republic. End the sentiment that
- 44:39the French left brings the best of
- 44:41everything. Which ideas, which theories
- 44:46of liberation developed in the overseas
- 44:48territories could contribute to this
- 44:50idea of a "New France" for a
- 44:51transformative left? How will La France
- 44:54Insoumise overcome the feeling of
- 44:56betrayal that the working-class
- 44:58neighborhoods and overseas territories
- 44:59feel? How will it overcome the chills
- 45:01caused by the possibility of a
- 45:03separation from the other seas of a New
- 45:05France that can no longer imagine
- 45:06itself with the Pacific, the Caribbean,
- 45:08and the Indian Ocean? The space of a
- 45:11Republic, I repeat, which was built
- 45:13with the colonies with the idea of a
- 45:15good and generous civilizing mission
- 45:17and which today would miraculously be
- 45:19freed from these colonial and racial
- 45:21dross. In the early 1910s, Lenin
- 45:24mentioned, to welcome it, I quote him,
- 45:26the transmigration of peoples created
- 45:29by capitalism. While the communist
- 45:32leader readily acknowledged that
- 45:34capitalists exploit immigrant workers
- 45:35in the most vile way, he believed that
- 45:37only reactionaries could be offended by
- 45:39it, as it blurred narrow and
- 45:40chauvinistic frameworks and contributed
- 45:42to bringing together workers from all
- 45:44over the world in a long-term
- 45:46revolutionary perspective. A
- 45:48revolutionary perspective, that is to
- 45:50say, this horizon that we do not
- 45:52abandon, where the border is no longer
- 45:54a front in the military sense, but an
- 45:56space that is always being renegotiated
- 45:58and in flux. A new France that
- 46:00decolonizes itself, a new decolonial
- 46:02France. Thank you very much to
- 46:21Françoise Vergès. I would like to
- 46:23greet very quickly the Global South
- 46:25collective. It is, uh, well, a very,
- 46:28very, very active, very friendly, and
- 46:31very effective Swiss militant
- 46:33collective over there in Switzerland.
- 46:37So really thank you for being here and
- 46:39strength to you, and thank you, yeah,
- 46:41really thank you for being here and we
- 46:43continue immediately with Sabrina Waz,
- 46:48anti-racist activist. And so you, your
- 46:52talk is titled Eternal France. Clovis's
- 46:55France, right, that's it. Ah, we shall
- 46:58see. Not too
- 46:59much. No, but I'm asking questions
- 47:01against the New France. A fake dilemma.
- 47:04Sabrina answers you.
- 47:07Thank you. Good evening first to
- 47:10everyone, and also good evening to
- 47:12those listening to us live on Twitch
- 47:14and on YouTube, who have sometimes
- 47:15watched the whole weekend quite
- 47:17studiously. So, we send them a big
- 47:19hello. So yes, you said the title of
- 47:24the intervention, Samir. Eternal France
- 47:26against the New France. A false dilemma
- 47:28. Can you hear me well?
- 47:31I have the impression that you can't
- 47:32hear me. Can we turn up the microphone?
- 47:34Actually, I'm just coming out of a
- 47:36post-heatwave cold. OK, I'll try. I
- 47:42will try. During his meeting in
- 47:45Saint-Denis, Mélenchon declared that
- 47:46he had launched this "New France"
- 47:48formula like waving a red flag, and
- 47:50that he had done so in full awareness
- 47:52that it would make those obsessed with
- 47:54race react. From that point of view,
- 47:57the operation worked perfectly. Few
- 48:00political formulas arouse so many
- 48:02comments. Reactions first of all from
- 48:05the far right, whose nation and
- 48:07nationalism are their historical
- 48:08grounds. The radical left has come up
- 48:12with a new concept, one that does not
- 48:14reject the nation but rather chooses to
- 48:16dispute its definition. The New France
- 48:20is here, and it would supposedly
- 48:22replace the eternal France. Even though
- 48:25the FI explains that this New France
- 48:27represents all the social
- 48:28transformations since the dawn of the
- 48:305th Republic, it is precisely because
- 48:32this New France touches a sensitive
- 48:33nerve that it is causing so much talk.
- 48:37It touches on the link between race and
- 48:39nation. For the centrists, too, the
- 48:42opportunity is too good to pass up.
- 48:46Olivier Faure stated a few days ago
- 48:47that Jean-Luc Mélenchon is entering a
- 48:49terrain that is precisely that of the
- 48:51far right. Gabriel Attal, for his part,
- 48:56asserts that the New France excludes a
- 48:58portion of the French population. Quite
- 49:00ironic, considering he is the one
- 49:02behind the Abaya ban. There is
- 49:04therefore an opportunism here with many
- 49:07faces, but with a single objective: to
- 49:09weaken the FI within the field of the
- 49:13revolutionary left. The phrase is, at
- 49:15the very least, uncomfortable. We can
- 49:17take Philippe Poutou of the NPA as an
- 49:19example. When we ask Philippe about the
- 49:22New France, he replies, "Anything
- 49:24revolving around nationalism and
- 49:26sovereignism obviously poses a problem.
- 49:28" He explains that he rejects this
- 49:31concept of New France outright, which
- 49:33according to him boils down to, and I
- 49:35quote: "It’s not France like the
- 49:37right sees it, but it’s still France.
- 49:39" For the NPA, the problem with the New
- 49:42France is that it still speaks of
- 49:44France. I would like to clarify that
- 49:48this week, Philippe Poutou’s NPA
- 49:50announced it would not put forward a
- 49:52candidate for the presidential
- 49:53elections and would instead support
- 49:55Jean-Luc Mélenchon. So, we still
- 49:59salute this decision and the sense of
- 50:01responsibility of these activists.
- 50:05Important. So let's return to the New
- 50:07France. To be honest, it is no great
- 50:10surprise that this phrase chosen by the
- 50:12FI is causing so much discussion on
- 50:14both the left and the right. It
- 50:16introduces the national question when
- 50:18the center prefers to speak of
- 50:19citizenship or universalism. As for the
- 50:22revolutionary left, it prefers to speak
- 50:24of class and internationalism, often
- 50:26abstractly. Perhaps there is an
- 50:30opportunity here for the FI, because
- 50:32what is striking is not only that this
- 50:34phrase is being debated in the
- 50:35political sphere, but that it has met
- 50:37with strong popular support. There is
- 50:41something in this formula that seems to
- 50:43have been spontaneously understood by a
- 50:45part of the people. Personally, when I
- 50:50saw the New France taking hold, I
- 50:51certainly felt ambivalent, but I still
- 50:53felt happy to be a part of it. And I
- 50:57believe that's because for many
- 50:59indigenous people, Blacks, Arabs, and
- 51:01Muslims, this phrase acts as a breath
- 51:03of fresh air. It provides a way to
- 51:06express an experience that often lacks
- 51:08language: loving this country while
- 51:10constantly being reminded of one's
- 51:12outsider status. And above all, this "
- 51:16New France" doesn't force a choice
- 51:17between an attachment to one's country
- 51:19and an awareness of racism. It even
- 51:22asserts that these two experiences
- 51:24coexist. It opens a gap in the national
- 51:28narrative, and that is one of the
- 51:30strengths of this concept: it didn't
- 51:31invent a reality, but gave language to
- 51:33a popular experience that already
- 51:35existed. But "New France" is neither a
- 51:41strategy nor a political solution. From
- 51:44there, it's not a matter of stopping at
- 51:46the phrase. It's a matter of taking
- 51:48seriously what it forces us to think
- 51:49about. Thinking about what political
- 51:53conditions must be built so that this
- 51:55demographic reality is neither a
- 51:56controversial slogan nor a sociological
- 51:58observation, but becomes an aggressive
- 52:00political proposal. And our enemies
- 52:05have already understood something, even
- 52:07if they won't put it that way. "New
- 52:09France" is not a new version of "
- 52:11Black-Blanc-Beur." It doesn't just say
- 52:13that France is more diverse than it was
- 52:15yesterday. If this phrase provokes so
- 52:18many reactions, it's because it
- 52:20contains something else: the question
- 52:21of power. The model of moral
- 52:25anti-racism, "Black-Blanc-Beur," posed
- 52:27a question of representation—who is
- 52:29visible, who is recognized, who can
- 52:31finally appear as French. "New France"
- 52:35is much more dangerous because it is
- 52:37the heir to a shift that changes
- 52:38everything. The transition from an
- 52:43anti-racism of recognition to an
- 52:45anti-racism of power—one that places
- 52:47the question of power dynamics on the
- 52:49table. And it is this shift that has
- 52:54linked the fight against racism to
- 52:56state Islamophobia, institutional
- 52:58racist violence, the colonial continuum
- 53:00, Palestine, imperialism, and, more
- 53:02generally, the racial relations that
- 53:04structure our entire society and which
- 53:06we call, following Houria Bouteldja's
- 53:08term, the "integral racial state.""New
- 53:14France" is therefore not just France
- 53:16transformed by immigration; it is
- 53:18France transformed by several decades
- 53:20of political anti-racism, and we must
- 53:22recognize this as a victory. Political
- 53:25anti-racism has transformed minds and
- 53:27the left. It has made once-marginal
- 53:31issues unavoidable, and that is a
- 53:32considerable achievement. But this
- 53:36victory must not cause us to lose our
- 53:38vigilance. Moral anti-racism is not
- 53:41dead. It lurks, and it retains a strong
- 53:44power of attraction. It reappears
- 53:47regularly as soon as the fight against
- 53:49racism is reduced to an abstract
- 53:51condemnation of the far right. On June
- 53:5521st, La France Insoumise organized an
- 53:57anti-racist march, and the slogan for
- 53:59this demonstration was against racism
- 54:01and the far-right. This slogan reminds
- 54:05us that the temptation of moral
- 54:07anti-racism still exists. Of course,
- 54:11saying that we are demonstrating
- 54:13against racism and the far-right is not
- 54:15false, but it is not entirely accurate
- 54:17either. And I would even say that after
- 54:21far too many years of Macronism in
- 54:23power, this slogan is a bit behind the
- 54:25times. And I don’t mean to be too
- 54:30harsh with this criticism; it’s just
- 54:31that we know the temptation is great to
- 54:33neutralize the potential power of the
- 54:35anti-racist struggle and reduce it to a
- 54:37nice narrative of diversity and
- 54:38peaceful coexistence where the only
- 54:40target is the far-right. And it is our
- 54:45responsibility to preserve what
- 54:47political anti-racism has achieved as a
- 54:49proposal for social transformation. And
- 55:00for this "New France" to be a proposal
- 55:02for transformation, there is another
- 55:04essential issue to include: the issue
- 55:06of the white working class. One of the
- 55:10fundamental conditions for a policy of
- 55:12the "New France" will be its ability to
- 55:14learn how to speak to the white working
- 55:15class. And this requires one thing
- 55:19first: not to be naive. We know that
- 55:22this formula contains an ambiguity. The
- 55:25very term "New France" can easily be
- 55:27heard as the announcement of a
- 55:29succession. One France replacing
- 55:31another. We know that some may hear in
- 55:34it the narrative of their own
- 55:35disappearance. To dismiss this
- 55:38perception with a wave of the hand
- 55:39would be a mistake. Not because this
- 55:42perception is correct, but because it
- 55:44exists within the working class. And a
- 55:48serious policy always starts with real
- 55:50perceptions before claiming to
- 55:52transform them. If we do not clearly
- 55:57address the white working class, then
- 55:58the far-right will. That is exactly
- 56:01what it has been doing for 40 years. It
- 56:03constantly transforms social and
- 56:05economic anxieties into identity-based
- 56:07anxieties. It explains to the white
- 56:10working class that their decline is not
- 56:11the result of an economic or political
- 56:13order, but of a historical replacement.
- 56:18Some might tell me, "But LFI has never
- 56:20said that the New France meant the
- 56:21disappearance of white people." And
- 56:24that is true; LFI has never said that.
- 56:28Except the question is not entirely
- 56:29about what LFI means; the question is
- 56:31also about what some people hear. And
- 56:35if a portion of the working class hears
- 56:37a narrative of its own disappearance,
- 56:38we cannot simply reply, "Too bad, they
- 56:40didn't understand." For one, it would
- 56:44mean giving up on politics, and
- 56:46especially from a decolonial
- 56:47perspective, it would make no sense
- 56:49because these perceptions held by the
- 56:51working classes don't just fall from
- 56:53the sky. They are not produced
- 56:56spontaneously by isolated individuals.
- 56:59They are the result and the
- 57:00manifestations of the total racial
- 57:02state. These perceptions are
- 57:06manufactured and maintained, and even
- 57:08if we don't share them, they are still
- 57:10ours, and we must care about them
- 57:11because racism is politically produced.
- 57:15It must therefore be politically
- 57:17defeated by us, should we fail. And
- 57:20that is the meaning of the phrase you
- 57:21may know from Riad Sattouf, the
- 57:23alliance of the rubes and the
- 57:24barbarians. Not to deny racism, but to
- 57:27start from one conviction. No major
- 57:31political transformation can take place
- 57:33if the working classes remain lastingly
- 57:35set against one another. There is
- 57:40another point of vigilance regarding
- 57:42the working classes: not to make the "
- 57:43New France" the camp of the righteous.
- 57:47Our ambition cannot be to replace a
- 57:49sense of identity superiority with
- 57:51moral superiority. We don't want to say
- 57:55that some see themselves as superior
- 57:56French people because they are the "
- 57:58true" French. "Today, the good French
- 58:01people are us." The New France can
- 58:04carry an even greater ambition and do
- 58:05better. And that requires not just a
- 58:10solid program, but a political stance
- 58:11that is not that of a moral vanguard
- 58:13distinguishing the virtuous from the
- 58:15rest. The question of the New France,
- 58:25the question of the New France forces
- 58:27us to ask ourselves identity-related
- 58:28questions. Who is France? Who makes
- 58:30France? And that's good, but I would
- 58:32like to propose a shift in perspective.
- 58:36I would like to shift the question of
- 58:38identity so we no longer just ask who
- 58:40we are, but rather what history we
- 58:41inherit and what we are going to do
- 58:43with it. This shift is surely a very
- 58:48good way to answer the question: what
- 58:50to do with this New France? Not by
- 58:53seeking an additional definition of
- 58:55what France could be, but by placing
- 58:57ourselves on the ground of historical
- 58:58consciousness. Assuming history does
- 59:02not mean celebrating everything that
- 59:04precedes us. It also does not mean
- 59:06condemning our entire heritage
- 59:08wholesale. It means accepting that we
- 59:11inherit a contradictory history made of
- 59:14revolution, colonization, emancipation,
- 59:16sometimes nearly unthinkable massacre,
- 59:18and solidarity. Historical
- 59:21consciousness therefore consists
- 59:23neither of mythologizing the past nor
- 59:24of breaking with it. It consists of
- 59:28accepting that we are the heirs to this
- 59:30entire history and that we now decide
- 59:32what we continue and what we transform.
- 59:36From this point of view, we must agree
- 59:38to discuss certain formulations used in
- 59:40our own camp. Last May, Mathilde Panot
- 59:45was invited for a media interview. She
- 59:51was asked about New France and she said
- 59:53, and I quote: "The far-right
- 59:55fantasizes about a white and Christian
- 59:57France that never existed, a white and
- 59:59Christian France that never existed."
- 1:00:04Mathilde Panot’s intention is very
- 1:00:06clear: she wants to deconstruct the
- 1:00:08identity narrative built by the
- 1:00:10far-right, and this intention is
- 1:00:11perfectly legitimate. But politically,
- 1:00:16this phrasing can lead to a
- 1:00:17misunderstanding. And our opponents
- 1:00:21immediately had a field day with it,
- 1:00:23saying: "Look, she wants to erase our
- 1:00:24history." I, Sabrina, have never been
- 1:00:32white or Christian, as you can imagine.
- 1:00:38I am a French Muslim, Arab and Algerian
- 1:00:40woman, and I can understand the
- 1:00:42attachment to a heritage, being
- 1:00:44attached to my own. For many French
- 1:00:49people in the working class, the words
- 1:00:51"white" and "Christian" do not just
- 1:00:53refer to a historical category; they
- 1:00:55also evoke intimacy with grandparents,
- 1:00:57family celebrations, and the cemeteries
- 1:01:00where their loved ones rest. Upon
- 1:01:08hearing Mathilde Panot's comments, and
- 1:01:10when neoliberalism has already stripped
- 1:01:11you of precious ties, you may feel that
- 1:01:13there is now an attempt to take your
- 1:01:15history away from you. Yet, we will
- 1:01:19never win politically by humiliating
- 1:01:21popular attachments, even when they
- 1:01:23take the form of a vague or ambivalent
- 1:01:25attachment to Christianity. Because our
- 1:01:30problem is not that French people
- 1:01:31maintain an imaginary sense of
- 1:01:32continuity with their history. Our
- 1:01:36problem is not that they sometimes have
- 1:01:38a romantic or romanticized relationship
- 1:01:40with the nation. We, the anti-colonial
- 1:01:45activists, do not believe in an eternal
- 1:01:47France, just as we do not believe in an
- 1:01:50eternal Algeria or any immutable
- 1:01:52national identity. But that does not
- 1:01:56mean we should despise the need people
- 1:01:58have to tell themselves a common story.
- 1:02:09Every political community has produced
- 1:02:10a narrative. The real question,
- 1:02:13therefore, is not whether we need a
- 1:02:14narrative. The real question is to know
- 1:02:17what that narrative serves. Does it
- 1:02:21serve to build and justify a racist
- 1:02:23national myth, or not? Mélenchon
- 1:02:27recently stated that the issue of
- 1:02:28racism would be a major question in the
- 1:02:30next presidential election, and I think
- 1:02:32we can all agree with that here. So, La
- 1:02:38France Insoumise has a special
- 1:02:40responsibility: not to use phrasing
- 1:02:41that allows our opponents to rush into
- 1:02:44the already deep fissures of the racial
- 1:02:46pact and widen them even further. So,
- 1:02:54heritage, our heritage, is also the
- 1:02:56question of ancestors, of our ancestors
- 1:02:59. And we have no problem with the idea
- 1:03:02of claiming ancestors. The question is
- 1:03:04rather: how and why? That is,
- 1:03:07incidentally, the question we already
- 1:03:09asked a year ago during the QG des
- 1:03:11Colonials summer school, right.
- 1:03:14Moreover, I recognized many people who
- 1:03:16were there for a roundtable discussion
- 1:03:17on the choice of ancestors. And I
- 1:03:19really invite you to go watch it
- 1:03:20because there are some very, very
- 1:03:22beautiful presentations. It was truly
- 1:03:24beautiful. Do you remember, Samire? H
- 1:03:27you are, well you were, we were all
- 1:03:29there. H yeah. So, regarding the
- 1:03:32ancestors, and to be very clear, I will
- 1:03:35take a very concrete example that
- 1:03:37speaks to us all. Let's take Joan of
- 1:03:39Arc. Everyone knows Joan of Arc. Help!
- 1:03:51Help! If there is one historical figure
- 1:03:58who embodies eternal France, it is
- 1:04:00surely Joan of Arc. For several decades
- 1:04:03now, the far-right has made her one of
- 1:04:05its main symbols. However, this
- 1:04:08appropriation is itself a historical
- 1:04:10construction; in an article titled "
- 1:04:12You're not going to leave me to Le Pen"
- 1:04:16in the magazine Nous,
- 1:04:19you can show it. So, an article written
- 1:04:22by Azi. It reminds us that Joan of Arc
- 1:04:26did not always belong to the far-right.
- 1:04:29In the 19th and early 20th centuries,
- 1:04:31her legacy was contested. For the
- 1:04:35Catholic right, she embodied the saint
- 1:04:36of the nation. For part of the
- 1:04:39republican left, she was a popular
- 1:04:40resistance fighter, a figure of the
- 1:04:42people. In short, Joan of Arc didn't
- 1:04:45become racist on her own. It is a
- 1:04:48political history that gradually made
- 1:04:50her speak in the service of a
- 1:04:51xenophobic and racist project. In Latin
- 1:04:55America, the Marxist José Carlos
- 1:04:57Mariátegui even saw in her a universal
- 1:04:59figure of the resistance of the
- 1:05:01vanquished. He wrote, "She has returned
- 1:05:05to us, carried by the swell of our own
- 1:05:07storm." That is why the problem is not
- 1:05:12Joan of Arc. The problem is not even
- 1:05:15eternal France. The problem is knowing
- 1:05:17in the service of what living political
- 1:05:19project this narrative is being used.
- 1:05:23One question remains. What political
- 1:05:26strategy follows from all this? And I
- 1:05:29would like to say a word here about
- 1:05:31internationalist patriotism.
- 1:05:34Internationalist patriotism. A
- 1:05:36political proposal put forward by the
- 1:05:38QG des Colonials. I understand that
- 1:05:40this proposal may come as a surprise.
- 1:05:43The Decolonial movement was born from
- 1:05:45the critique of the nation-state and
- 1:05:46the racial order. So, how can a
- 1:05:49movement born from this critique talk
- 1:05:51about patriotism today? First, because
- 1:05:55decolonial theories do not just
- 1:05:57criticize the world as it is; they aim
- 1:05:59for social transformation. And to get
- 1:06:03there, we cannot abandon the monopoly
- 1:06:05on sovereignty, heritage, or the sense
- 1:06:07of belonging to the far-right, but also
- 1:06:09because internationalist patriotism is
- 1:06:11not just another way of talking about
- 1:06:13the fatherland. It forces us to think
- 1:06:18about the homeland differently. Perhaps
- 1:06:21that is one of the great contributions
- 1:06:23of post-colonial theory. It compels us
- 1:06:26to move beyond the obsession with
- 1:06:27identity to consider relationships. It
- 1:06:32forces us to no longer just ask who we
- 1:06:34are, but also what relationship we
- 1:06:36maintain with others. And this
- 1:06:42introspective shift changes everything
- 1:06:44because these others are both inside
- 1:06:46and outside the nation. Inside, they
- 1:06:51are those whom colonial history keeps
- 1:06:53in a position of alterity in renewed
- 1:06:55forms. Descendants of post-colonial
- 1:06:59immigration, Muslims, overseas citizens
- 1:07:01, the Roma. Outside the nation, these
- 1:07:04others are other peoples. The
- 1:07:06post-colonial movement helps us
- 1:07:08understand that these two questions are
- 1:07:09one and the same. Because the way a
- 1:07:12nation treats its own others is
- 1:07:14inseparable from how it relates to
- 1:07:15other peoples. That is why Islamophobia
- 1:07:20, Palestine, anti-Roma racism, overseas
- 1:07:22citizens, or even imperialism are not
- 1:07:25scattered topics. They all speak to the
- 1:07:29same thing: the way a nation organizes
- 1:07:30its relations with its different forms
- 1:07:32of alterity. And if we no longer ask
- 1:07:38only who we are, but what kind of
- 1:07:40people we want to become in our
- 1:07:42relationship to other peoples, then
- 1:07:44another question arises immediately:
- 1:07:45that of responsibility. What are we
- 1:07:50accountable for? What must we answer
- 1:07:52for? What are we complicit in and
- 1:07:54guilty of? What solidarity are we ready
- 1:07:57to embrace? What rupture are we ready
- 1:08:00to initiate? And also, what cost are we
- 1:08:04ready to pay for that? From this point
- 1:08:09on, imperialism and its wars cease to
- 1:08:11be subjects external to the nation.
- 1:08:14Take Palestine: when facing it, what
- 1:08:16kind of France do we want to be? And
- 1:08:19regarding the wars in the Middle East,
- 1:08:21regarding Lebanon, regarding Iran, who
- 1:08:23do we want to be? Because what matters
- 1:08:28might not be having a "New France," but
- 1:08:30inventing a political people equal to
- 1:08:32the necessary introspection. And I
- 1:08:37would like to end with a phrase from
- 1:08:38Youssef Bousoumah. Is he here or not?
- 1:08:41No. Oh, he is here. Well, he must be
- 1:08:44giving his interview; he had an
- 1:08:45interview with an Algerian channel
- 1:08:47today. He must be around, but it's not
- 1:08:49a problem. Let's applaud Youssef. So
- 1:08:58it's a phrase by Youssef Bousoumah that
- 1:09:00you might know: "The proof through
- 1:09:01Palestine." Who knows it? There you go.
- 1:09:04Well, Youssef invented it. Give credit
- 1:09:06where credit is due to Youssef. He is
- 1:09:07the one who invented it. Why is this
- 1:09:17phrase so important to us? Because
- 1:09:20Palestine is not a subject of
- 1:09:21international politics. It is a test of
- 1:09:24capability, of clarification, of
- 1:09:26courage and of resistance. A test of
- 1:09:28truth. And I say it with even more
- 1:09:31emotion because today is July 5th, the
- 1:09:33anniversary of the date Algeria freed
- 1:09:35itself from colonization. You can't
- 1:09:48read it. Easy, easy, easy, easy, easy.
- 1:09:56Take your reading.
- 1:09:58We'll do it together. Go ahead. The
- 1:10:09people we will invent will not be
- 1:10:11limited to the narrative we create
- 1:10:12about ourselves.
- 1:10:15They will prove themselves to the
- 1:10:16generations to come.
- 1:10:20And it is a free Palestine that will
- 1:10:22tell us if we have invented not only a
- 1:10:24new France,
- 1:10:27but also a France that is up to the
- 1:10:29task. A capable France.
- 1:10:31Sabrina. And the article you were
- 1:10:40talking about. So, we shouldn't promote
- 1:10:43too much because it's a these are
- 1:10:48political universities organized by the
- 1:10:50UJFP, by CDEC, by Fer Bloc, Fair Peuple
- 1:10:53, by the collective against the war and
- 1:10:55for a revolutionary peace. Obviously by
- 1:11:00Parole d'Honneur but also by the QG des
- 1:11:02Coloniales which produces this magazine
- 1:11:04, "Nous". And here is the article we
- 1:11:08were talking about, that Sabrina was
- 1:11:10talking about, whom I ask you to
- 1:11:11applaud once again. Thanks to the three
- 1:11:18speakers of this plenary session. Of
- 1:11:23course, we are continuing these
- 1:11:25political summer universities, uh,
- 1:11:27preparing for victory, organizing
- 1:11:29pessimism, and we'll see, do we take a
- 1:11:31break, do we not take a break, do we
- 1:11:33carry on directly? How is it going?
- 1:11:36Tell me, how long of a break are we
- 1:11:38taking? 5 to 10 minutes. Okay, 5 to 10
- 1:11:43minutes, we'll try to be quick and then
- 1:11:45we'll meet again for a new panel from
- 1:11:47rupture to revolution. What to do after
- 1:11:51seizing power? Go on, a little coffee,
- 1:11:53a little tea, a little glass of water
- 1:11:55and you come back. We're going full
- 1:11:57steam until the end. A magazine "Nous"
- 1:12:04already placed there. We're doing a
- 1:12:08little propaganda.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of C'EST QUOI "LA NOUVELLE FRANCE" ? Sabrina Waz, Francoise Vergès, Imane El Hamzaoui by Paroles D'Honneur, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,223 words across 1,656 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.