Отношения не сделают тебя счастливым. | Сартр — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Have you noticed that everyone around
- 0:03is in a relationship? I certainly have.
- 0:06Almost all of my friends are either in
- 0:08long-term relationships or already
- 0:10married, and some of them even have
- 0:12kids. And when you observe the happy
- 0:15faces of people in relationships, it's
- 0:18easy to fall into a trap. And this is a
- 0:20trap that many people are falling into
- 0:23right now. It sounds like this: "I need
- 0:26my person to become happy." My soulmate
- 0:30, without whom my whole life turns into
- 0:32a search. And some people profit from
- 0:35this feeling of searching by releasing
- 0:38videos on how to find a girl or how to
- 0:40find a guy. Mainly, of course, I will
- 0:43be talking about girls in this video,
- 0:45but the search for a guy is, in
- 0:47principle, the same thing. The seed of
- 0:49this thought remains: "Once I find a
- 0:51relationship, life will sparkle with
- 0:53colors." This might seem natural,
- 0:56especially when all these happy couples
- 0:59flash across social media, movies, or
- 1:01even in real life. And it starts to
- 1:05feel like that's the missing piece of
- 1:07the puzzle you need to complete the
- 1:10picture of happiness in your head.
- 1:13There are more people who build their
- 1:15entire lives around this concept than
- 1:17you think. The concept that that one
- 1:20special person will appear and help you
- 1:23touch happiness. It seems right, and
- 1:26besides, you want it. You won't just
- 1:28wait for something to happen; you'll
- 1:30take action. But these actions often
- 1:32turn into absurdity. And frequently
- 1:38lead to despair. Today we will try to
- 1:41look at this problem head-on. And to
- 1:44help us with this, we have an atheist,
- 1:46a psychoanalyst, and a real rock star
- 1:48of French philosophy, Jean-Paul Sartre.
- 1:53And you'll certainly ask: "How is this
- 1:54guy related to relationships?" What if
- 1:57I tell you that Sartre's cult novel "
- 1:59Nausea," which I'm holding in my hands
- 2:01right now, can tell you more about
- 2:03relationships than all those pickup
- 2:05artists on the internet? And that the
- 2:09philosophy of this legend of philosophy
- 2:11—pardon the tautology—can turn your
- 2:13understanding of life upside down. If
- 2:16you grasp this now, you won't be able
- 2:18to forget it. Just a warning: for some,
- 2:21this video might cause pain. Therefore,
- 2:24by continuing, you are consenting to
- 2:26this. But remember, pain is the first
- 2:28companion of life. When a mother
- 2:30experiences this pain while giving
- 2:32birth to a child, a new life emerges.
- 2:34It is always worth it. Therefore, you
- 2:37shouldn't avoid this pain. Tautology
- 2:39again. You are on the AFK channel.
- 2:41Let's begin. One of Sartre's most
- 2:50famous ideas is that, at least in the
- 2:52case of humans, existence precedes
- 2:55essence. What does that mean? When
- 2:59Sartre says that existence precedes
- 3:01essence, he means that we humans arrive
- 3:04in the world without any purpose. That
- 3:08is, we are born without a purpose, and
- 3:10then, if we are bold enough, we choose
- 3:12one or more purposes in life. For the
- 3:15philosopher, this means the capacity
- 3:17for self-determination, which is
- 3:19projected into the future. It
- 3:21distinguishes us from all other beings
- 3:23in this world. Take an ordinary chair,
- 3:26for example. Before it comes to be, the
- 3:29carpenter has a goal in mind that this
- 3:31chair must fulfill. Therefore, the
- 3:34essence of the chair is established
- 3:36long before its very existence. Do you
- 3:38understand? Yes. But for some people, a
- 3:41human is like a chair because they are
- 3:44created by some divine carpenter. Many
- 3:49believe in the existence of a Creator
- 3:51God who creates people and sends them
- 3:54into the world with a specific purpose,
- 3:56a mission to fulfill, to attain
- 3:58salvation, to follow a calling, to
- 4:00participate in a divine plan, and so on
- 4:02. But Sartre did not believe that
- 4:06people arrived in the world with a
- 4:08predetermined plan from a Creator,
- 4:10unlike chairs meant for sitting. That
- 4:12is the whole essence of it. In the case
- 4:14of a human, our existence has no
- 4:16purpose according to Sartre. We were
- 4:18not created by anyone. We simply
- 4:20appeared in the world by chance,
- 4:22through a series of circumstances. And
- 4:24now we have to figure out how to deal
- 4:27with that. It is our turn to decide
- 4:29what we will do in this world. Often in
- 4:32life, a moment arises when we begin to
- 4:35expect that another person will come
- 4:37along, whom we will love, and they will
- 4:40fill our lives with meaning. As if our
- 4:43essence is to be a "half" for someone,
- 4:46as if you were created by a divine
- 4:48carpenter with the idea of becoming
- 4:51someone else's completion. And this
- 4:53thought is appealing. You can look
- 4:55forward to it with special delight. But
- 4:58in reality, if you look the truth in
- 5:01the eye, this is an active expectation
- 5:03that love will one day make your life
- 5:05happy. The hope that a partner will
- 5:08bring a ready-made essence for you.
- 5:13Meaning, you don't know why you are
- 5:15living, but if you are loved, a clear
- 5:17function emerges: you become a partner,
- 5:19a beloved, a support, and so on. But
- 5:23what is one to do with this inner void
- 5:26that exists without love, without a
- 5:28beloved, that envelops you and makes
- 5:30things very difficult? But I might
- 5:34surprise you: from Sartre's perspective
- 5:35, this void is not a defect that needs
- 5:37to be fixed by someone else's love. It
- 5:41is the very structure of human
- 5:42consciousness. Trying to fill this void
- 5:45with a partner is like building a house
- 5:48on an absolute vacuum. Happiness, or as
- 5:51Sartre would say, existential autonomy,
- 5:54is only possible when you accept your
- 5:57status as an unfinished book and pick
- 5:59up the pen yourself, instead of
- 6:02expecting someone else to write your
- 6:04story for you. And I think you’ve
- 6:07already guessed what this is about. A
- 6:10blank page and emptiness are freedom.
- 6:16Man is condemned to be free. Being a
- 6:20person condemned to be free, he carries
- 6:22the weight of the whole world on his
- 6:24shoulders. If you realize your freedom
- 6:27and that no religion, government, or
- 6:29corporation will tell you how to live,
- 6:32then you have a lot of work ahead,
- 6:34because now it’s your turn to think
- 6:36about how you want to live. And that is
- 6:40why, for Sartre, freedom is a
- 6:41condemnation. On one hand, realizing
- 6:45that we hold the pen, realizing our
- 6:47freedom, allows us to build our own
- 6:49path and reveals the entire panorama of
- 6:52possibilities in our lives. But on the
- 6:56other hand, the realization of our
- 6:58freedom comes at a high price. And that
- 7:01price is suffering. When we realize
- 7:04what we have to do, where to go, and
- 7:06who to meet, you are the only one
- 7:08responsible for all of it. We also
- 7:11notice that despite vast and diverse
- 7:13possibilities, we know at the same time
- 7:16that we have a finite life and finite
- 7:19resources to live it. And when we
- 7:22finally find someone and enter into a
- 7:25relationship with the mindset, "You
- 7:27will make me happy," we commit an
- 7:29existential crime against ourselves. We
- 7:33try to monetize another person as a
- 7:35refuge from this inner anxiety. Such a
- 7:39person tries to dissolve their
- 7:41frightening, lonely self, suspended in
- 7:43the void, into a comfortable,
- 7:45predictable "Us." I am happy because we
- 7:48are together. It sounds beautiful, of
- 7:50course, but in reality, it is an
- 7:52attempt to say, "I am no longer solely
- 7:54responsible for all this emptiness
- 7:56around me or my trajectory. Our union
- 7:59is responsible for my choices." And
- 8:03very often, expecting happiness from a
- 8:05partner is an attempt to shift the
- 8:07burden of your own condemnation onto
- 8:09them. If I feel bad, then the
- 8:11relationship is to blame. If I am bored
- 8:13, the partner hasn't given me enough
- 8:15attention. You won't even notice how
- 8:17you start running away from the fact
- 8:19that the source of your boredom or
- 8:21longing is your inability to handle
- 8:23your own freedom. And if you are in
- 8:26this position and are single, just
- 8:28imagine that it could be a huge
- 8:30spectrum of possibilities for you.
- 8:33It’s sports, developing endurance and
- 8:35strength, friends, social contacts,
- 8:37education, gaining knowledge, career,
- 8:39and financial growth. At the very least
- 8:43, right now you have a peaceful sleep
- 8:45without infants taking it away from you
- 8:48. Believe me, if you sleep well, you
- 8:50are already a happy person. Try to
- 8:53fantasize now, to imagine these spectra
- 8:55of possibilities that open up before
- 8:57you, being without a relationship. But
- 8:59if you boil all this down to one
- 9:01meaning, one essence, it’s the
- 9:03opportunity to find yourself. This is
- 9:06the key point. Finding yourself is much
- 9:08more important than finding a
- 9:09relationship. Think about what you want
- 9:12to achieve. Think about the lifestyle
- 9:14you want to lead, and how you see
- 9:16yourself in the future. If you don't
- 9:20know what you want to do in this life,
- 9:22what lifestyle to lead, and you don't
- 9:25fully know your interests, then you
- 9:27probably shouldn't get involved with a
- 9:29partner, a girlfriend, or any other
- 9:31relationship at all. Because the truth
- 9:35is that when you enter a relationship,
- 9:37your entire personal search slows down,
- 9:39and you do it less often. This applies
- 9:43to everything from your career to your
- 9:45friends, because you will be so
- 9:47enthralled by this new person who
- 9:49evokes these pleasant feelings of
- 9:51infatuation. And the entire foundation
- 9:54of your personality will take a back
- 9:56seat for a long time. Also, you need to
- 9:59consider that relationships don't
- 10:01always end well. But, of course, I
- 10:05understand that inside you might be
- 10:06raging with this longing or that very
- 10:08thirst for a relationship, for love.
- 10:11But remember that this is just a
- 10:13biological process, because for us, as
- 10:15a species, it is our goal to ensure
- 10:18survival. This is completely natural.
- 10:20And when we immerse ourselves in
- 10:22searching, a kind of ritual happens
- 10:25that reassures us that we are on the
- 10:27right track. We feel relief because we
- 10:30have already decided that this is the
- 10:32right way, and now we only have to live
- 10:34within the framework of our past
- 10:36convictions. But behind this apparent
- 10:40calm hides an existential danger that
- 10:42is worse than torment. Routine and
- 10:45customs give us calm, ensure safety,
- 10:47allowing us to live on autopilot. But
- 10:51if we stay in this comfort, we risk
- 10:53stopping the exploration of all the
- 10:55possibilities that life still offers us
- 10:57. We stop learning new things and stop
- 11:02reinventing ourselves. We stop
- 11:04projecting ourselves into a new future.
- 11:08And in Sartre's concept, you are not
- 11:10your past decisions and beliefs. You
- 11:13are what could happen. You are
- 11:16possibility. You are a project that,
- 11:19for better or for worse, ends only with
- 11:21death. And this is an important
- 11:23philosophical thought. Death is the end
- 11:26of all possibilities, all decisions,
- 11:28and all learning. But as long as this
- 11:30day is happening, you are breathing,
- 11:32watching this video, listening, it is
- 11:34useful to experience a certain level of
- 11:36anxiety. Not a paralyzing anxiety about
- 11:39the future that immobilizes us, but an
- 11:41anxiety that keeps us alert to the
- 11:43possibilities of this life. A normal
- 11:46level of anxiety. Feeling anxious is
- 11:48not very pleasant, it is uncomfortable,
- 11:50but it is a sign that we are fully
- 11:53aware of our freedom. But in all this,
- 11:56even Sartre admits that our freedom has
- 11:58limits. There are many things that I
- 12:01cannot decide in my life. I didn't
- 12:03choose, for example, when I was born or
- 12:05my gender. Even less did I choose my
- 12:08nationality or ethnic background. I had
- 12:11no say in how I was raised. Neither in
- 12:14what I received from my parents and
- 12:16teachers, nor the culture I grew up in.
- 12:18Well, you understand. And if there are
- 12:21things in my own life beyond my control
- 12:24, I can say that in most cases, there
- 12:27are many things in the world I cannot
- 12:30control. Notice how subtly the
- 12:33philosopher leads us toward modern
- 12:35anxiety therapy. There are many things
- 12:38in the world you may not be able to
- 12:40control. We are born into a culture
- 12:43that imposes on us not only its laws
- 12:45but also moral rules and social
- 12:47expectations. Such as, for example,
- 12:50these romanticized relationships.
- 12:53Sartre calls these facts about me and
- 12:56the world that are beyond my control "
- 12:58facticity." Roughly speaking,
- 13:01undeniable facts. The most important
- 13:03idea of Sartre is that our human
- 13:05selfhood is a continuous interaction
- 13:07between freedom and facticity. You are
- 13:11free not to have a relationship,
- 13:12because you were likely not designed
- 13:14for that. You are not a "half." That
- 13:16does not define your happiness. But the
- 13:19facticity is that the biological and
- 13:21evolutionary need and this urge will be
- 13:23with you for life. But how and when
- 13:27will you fulfill it? That is entirely
- 13:29your own project. It doesn't matter
- 13:32whose, when, or how it happens. And
- 13:35this balance between freedom and
- 13:37facticity can be explored through the
- 13:39concept of being a man. For example, I
- 13:41didn't choose to be born a man, but
- 13:43that is a fact. If I use my freedom to
- 13:47decide what being born a man means to
- 13:50me, then religion, government,
- 13:52corporations, culture, and media will
- 13:55all try to tell me how a person of my
- 13:57gender, age, and ethnicity should
- 14:00behave. The same applies to women. They
- 14:04will all try to tell me how I should
- 14:07speak, dress, walk, what interests I
- 14:09can have, who to build relationships
- 14:11with, and when and how. They will try
- 14:15to tell me how I should live. They will
- 14:18tell me who I should be, what I should
- 14:21do, and what I should own. But if I
- 14:24realize that I have the freedom and
- 14:26responsibility to create my own value
- 14:29system, can I forge my own path if
- 14:31there is something I don't like, even
- 14:33in my personality? Although I was born
- 14:37into a culture that tries to change me,
- 14:40I can also try to change that culture,
- 14:42and I will either succeed or fail. But
- 14:46in reality, the outcome is not what
- 14:47matters most. Well, at least, according
- 14:49to Sartre's philosophy. The main thing
- 14:51is the effort you put into testing the
- 14:53limits of facticity. When you put 100%
- 14:57of your effort into pursuing a
- 15:00relationship, despite facticity telling
- 15:03you that you’re unworthy, because
- 15:06facticity conditions you, but it never
- 15:09defines you. That is the beauty of
- 15:12loneliness and freedom. And this is
- 15:15where the main reason lies why many
- 15:17think that relationships will make them
- 15:19happy. For Sartre, human life consists
- 15:22of the interaction between freedom and
- 15:24facticity. This interaction causes us
- 15:27suffering. Because on one hand, we have
- 15:30to make decisions, which is already
- 15:31agonizing, but we must also add that
- 15:33facticity conditions those decisions,
- 15:35which is also agonizing. Your height is
- 15:38a facticity that might condition your
- 15:40decisions not to approach beautiful
- 15:42women, because in the dating culture,
- 15:44being short has a bad reputation. But
- 15:47that never defines you. And ideally, we
- 15:51should view the suffering that arises
- 15:53from this as part of life, something
- 15:55natural. Everyone has their own
- 15:58different facticity. Within the
- 16:00framework of existential philosophy,
- 16:01feeling a bit upset is completely
- 16:03normal. But Sartre understands that in
- 16:06many cases, we humans strive to avoid
- 16:09this suffering by deceiving ourselves.
- 16:13If we look closely, we will notice that
- 16:16each of us practices a kind of
- 16:18self-deception, consisting of denying
- 16:20either our freedom or our facticity.
- 16:24And this lie that we whisper to
- 16:26ourselves to avoid suffering, Sartre
- 16:29calls "bad faith." And here is how it
- 16:32manifests in the example of seeking
- 16:33relationships for the sake of happiness
- 16:35. There are two main strategies. The
- 16:38first is the denial of freedom through
- 16:40facticity. In this scenario, you use
- 16:42the search for a relationship to escape
- 16:44responsibility for your own unhappiness
- 16:46. You turn your facticity into an
- 16:49insurmountable wall and start telling
- 16:51yourself: "I am unhappy and lonely
- 16:53because I just haven't met my person
- 16:55yet.""My loneliness is an external
- 16:58circumstance, a curse, a cruel fate.""
- 17:01My happiness is blocked precisely by
- 17:03the lack of a partner in life to feel
- 17:06complete." And according to Sartre, the
- 17:09bad faith here is that you can
- 17:11consciously blind yourself. You can
- 17:14deny your freedom to change the quality
- 17:16of your life right now without outside
- 17:18help. This replaces the existential
- 17:21anxiety—that I alone am responsible
- 17:23for my life being empty—with a more
- 17:26understandable and comfortable
- 17:28suffering. "I’m just unlucky in love.
- 17:31" And the saddest thing is that even if
- 17:33such a person finds a partner, their
- 17:35bad faith does not disappear. As soon
- 17:38as the initial euphoria of the
- 17:40honeymoon phase passes and the inner
- 17:42unhappiness returns, the focus shifts.
- 17:45Now the lie of bad faith sounds like
- 17:48this: "I am unhappy because my partner
- 17:50is not the way they should be.""It is
- 17:52he or she who is ruining my life." A
- 17:55person again refuses to admit that the
- 17:57source of their unhappiness is their
- 17:59own choice of stagnation and
- 18:01self-imposed limitations on freedom.
- 18:04And there is a second strategy—the
- 18:06denial of facticity through
- 18:07transcendence. Here, a person,
- 18:10conversely, completely ignores reality,
- 18:12facts, and their past behavioral
- 18:14patterns, hiding in this invented
- 18:16project of ideal love. And you might
- 18:19think that your life is currently
- 18:21ruined, you have a bunch of
- 18:22psychological problems, debts, and
- 18:24mental crises. But as soon as I find
- 18:27this true love, everything will
- 18:28magically fix itself. Love will heal me
- 18:31, rewrite my past, and turn me into a
- 18:34different person. The bad faith here is
- 18:38that a person uses the abstract idea of
- 18:40a relationship as a magical teleport
- 18:42that supposedly saves them from having
- 18:44to deal with their real, earthly,
- 18:46grounded facticity. They refuse to
- 18:49admit that their baggage, their trauma,
- 18:51and their character are things they
- 18:53will have to deal with in any case.
- 18:56Entering a relationship from this
- 18:58standpoint, a person inevitably
- 18:59encounters the harsh resistance of
- 19:01reality. The partner turns out to be a
- 19:04living human being with their own flaws
- 19:06, not some fairy-tale savior. And
- 19:09relationships built on bad faith are
- 19:11doomed to fail because they are not a
- 19:13union of two independent individuals,
- 19:16but a tool for psychological anesthesia
- 19:18. A person tries to use another to lull
- 19:22their existential anxiety, or to fix
- 19:25themselves in the role of a beloved
- 19:27object, sacrificing their freedom. Or
- 19:30they simply run away from reality into
- 19:32some illusion, completely ignoring
- 19:34facticity. But Jean-Paul Sartre is
- 19:37adamant. Lying to oneself to avoid
- 19:40suffering always leads to even greater
- 19:43unconscious suffering, which poisons
- 19:45one's whole life and introduces a sense
- 19:48of falseness to one's own decisions.
- 19:53Happiness in a relationship is
- 19:55impossible as long as a person does not
- 19:57find the courage to step out of bad
- 20:00faith, accept their facticity as it is,
- 20:02and take on the full, terrifying
- 20:05freedom of being happy on their own.
- 20:09Therefore, the main thing I realized is
- 20:10that you shouldn't look for love, you
- 20:12should look for yourself. When you find
- 20:15yourself in this world, you will
- 20:16inevitably meet a person with whom you
- 20:19can share this happiness. And only then
- 20:22multiply it. After all, if you seek the
- 20:26sole source of happiness in your
- 20:27significant other, you will be laying
- 20:29the foundation of your house on someone
- 20:31else's land. If the partner leaves, or
- 20:34something goes wrong, your whole world
- 20:36may collapse. And after reading the
- 20:39book Nausea, beyond the existential
- 20:42horror it provides, Sartre taught me to
- 20:44rely only on myself. And the book
- 20:48reveals why two unhappy people cannot
- 20:51form one happy couple. Negative times
- 20:55negative equals positive only in
- 20:57mathematics; positives will begin with
- 21:00your decision to be free and to pay
- 21:03attention to facticity. Thank you for
- 21:05watching this video. If you liked it,
- 21:07please hit like and subscribe to the
- 21:09channel. Goodbye, everyone.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Отношения не сделают тебя счастливым. | Сартр by IFK, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,299 words across 503 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.