“Buy the Dip” Is a Trap: Why This Selloff Is Different | Jason Shapiro — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Following
- 0:01last week's route, and you we can just
- 0:05illustrate your point when you mentioned
- 0:07Intel.
- 0:08Intel started following falling
- 0:10beginning of October and the the the
- 0:12fall really accelerated towards the end
- 0:15of October
- 0:16two and a
- 0:17week and a half ago.
- 0:20Google also fell 12% in a single day
- 0:22after it reported bad earnings. That was
- 0:24the biggest single day drop
- 0:25in
- 0:26Google's history. If you were to take a
- 0:28look at just the market moves in the
- 0:31first week and a half of November,
- 0:34can you just go back and tell us how you
- 0:36were
- 0:37how you were positioned and what you
- 0:39were doing to react to that massive move
- 0:42downward? Surely if everyone is selling,
- 0:45you were probably positioning yourself
- 0:47to buy at some point or were you just
- 0:49waiting on the sidelines to think?
- 0:50>> think that everyone was selling.
- 0:53I came into this whole thing fortunate
- 0:56enough to be short the Nasdaq
- 0:58because the positioning report starting
- 1:01like, you know, a little over a month
- 1:02ago was showing some massive longs in
- 1:05the Nasdaq.
- 1:06So
- 1:08that got me short
- 1:12which
- 1:14great, but
- 1:15short the stock indices are
- 1:19very very difficult trades
- 1:22because even when they work,
- 1:26most of the time are very huge squeezes
- 1:30higher that try to get you out of those
- 1:32shorts. You know, it's it's very hard to
- 1:34remain short. You look at like you said
- 1:36on the day after election day, the
- 1:38market gap down
- 1:40overnight and then went straight up
- 1:43after that.
- 1:44To have stayed short
- 1:48after that day would have been very very
- 1:50very difficult.
- 1:52And then of course the next day is when
- 1:53you had that big fall, right? But to
- 1:56have stayed short the day before that
- 1:58big fall would have been very difficult,
- 1:59which I think is why there was such a
- 2:01big fall because anyone who was trying
- 2:02to short
- 2:04was probably out of that. If I were a
- 2:06discretionary trader and just trading my
- 2:08feel kind of thing, even if my feel was
- 2:10bearish,
- 2:11I don't think that I would have been
- 2:12able to stay short
- 2:14after that election day. I would have
- 2:15looked at it and been like, okay, you
- 2:16know.
- 2:17Um
- 2:19so
- 2:20I think that's why it went down so much,
- 2:21but now it's rebounded, you know, pretty
- 2:24much that whole loss has been has been
- 2:26taken back.
- 2:27So
- 2:28where we left, I don't know. Like it's
- 2:30like it's very very difficult to
- 2:32decipher
- 2:34is
- 2:35this just another squeeze in a bear
- 2:38market
- 2:39or
- 2:40is this the start of the next leg of the
- 2:41bull market? They look exactly the same
- 2:44when those two things happen.
- 2:45So it's very hard to decipher which one
- 2:48is which and and I I can't tell you I
- 2:50know which one is which because I
- 2:51absolutely do not.
- 2:53Um
- 2:55until we make a new high, you know, then
- 2:58you know because now, you know, clearly
- 3:00that's a bull market if we make a new
- 3:01high. So
- 3:02you know, buying these dips clearly has
- 3:05been the thing to do.
- 3:07Um
- 3:10and maybe it's a thing to do again now.
- 3:12I I think that
- 3:14there's a difference this time from the
- 3:16stuff that I look at,
- 3:17which isn't right 100% of the time by
- 3:20any means, but
- 3:21there's a big difference in the stuff
- 3:23that I look at between even you go back
- 3:25to the COVID dip
- 3:27um
- 3:30and you go back to
- 3:34the
- 3:35the dip on the um on the trade war, that
- 3:39dip,
- 3:39and even go back to the one this summer.
- 3:42Um
- 3:44my stuff had no problem being long those
- 3:47dips.
- 3:49This one's different
- 3:51from my point of view because of the
- 3:53positioning thing and because I think
- 3:55that
- 3:58a lot of the consensus seems to be that
- 4:01you buy the dip here, and was not during
- 4:03those other ones. It was more panic, the
- 4:05bubble's over kind of thing during those
- 4:07other dips. Whereas this time I see not
- 4:10just a consensus, but I see a lot of the
- 4:12money movements into these levered ETFs
- 4:15and all that.
- 4:16This time it seems to be a buy the dip.
- 4:18So I think
- 4:20from my point of view it's different,
- 4:21but
- 4:24my point of view has a way of being
- 4:25right sometimes and a way of being wrong
- 4:27sometimes. So, you know, the idea is to
- 4:29make as much money when it's right and
- 4:31and lose a little bit of money when it's
- 4:32wrong.
- 4:33Um
- 4:34so but but definitely
- 4:36from the stuff that I look at
- 4:38this dip is different than the other
- 4:40ones.
- 4:41>> So buying the dip seems safer compared
- 4:43to previous times. Is that the summary?
- 4:45>> It seems less safe
- 4:47than previous times. Yes.
- 4:50>> Well
- 4:51>> I would say is not a good a risk reward
- 4:53this time
- 4:54as it was the other times.
- 4:56>> Does the magnitude and the speed of the
- 4:59text drop impact your decision at all?
- 5:03>> No.
- 5:04>> No.
- 5:05>> No.
- 5:06>> It's purely
- 5:07It's purely based on how
- 5:09other traders are positioned. Uh I mean
- 5:11>> how participants are reacting. That's
- 5:13what it's based on.
- 5:14>> Um several hedge funds notably got wiped
- 5:18out
- 5:19uh or at least lost a lot of money.
- 5:21Um when institutional capital um
- 5:25flows out like that um
- 5:28does that count as as
- 5:31positioning at all? Um in a sense that
- 5:34>> does. And that's what I was saying at
- 5:35the beginning. We certainly had some
- 5:36people wiped out
- 5:38>> Yeah.
- 5:38>> of a lot of these of a lot of these
- 5:39names.
- 5:40And so once they get wiped out, that's
- 5:42usually a good time to pick them up. And
- 5:43like I say, that's why
- 5:45[snorts] something like Apple 11
- 5:47you know, these things can happen across
- 5:48all these stocks, right? Up I mean the
- 5:50thing was up 68% in a week,
- 5:52right?
- 5:53>> Mhm.
- 5:54>> After being down 70% you know, like
- 5:57yeah, you [snorts] can get moves like
- 5:59that. No question about it.
- 6:00>> If you liked this clip, then like the
- 6:02video and share it with your friends.
- 6:03And if you to watch the entire full
- 6:05length long form video, then check out
- 6:08the link in the description down below.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of “Buy the Dip” Is a Trap: Why This Selloff Is Different | Jason Shapiro by The David Lin Report Clips, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,044 words across 188 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.