Busting Every Female Fitness Myth (ft. Antonella Schwarz PhD) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Women and men are physiologically
- 0:01different. There's no doubt about it. No
- 0:02one's arguing that. No one's saying that
- 0:04they aren't. However, that doesn'
- 0:06dictate different training principles.
- 0:08Or it doesn't dictate different training
- 0:10programs. But I think there's a lot more
- 0:12in our control as women than we tend
- 0:14[music] to think. And I think it's an
- 0:15injustice to say that just because I am
- 0:17a woman, it is inherently harder. Or my
- 0:19beef with this question lies is like the
- 0:21pinkified movement, right? Like let's
- 0:23pinkify this creatine. This is women's
- 0:25creatine. It won't cause you to bloat.
- 0:27This is a women's specific supplement
- 0:29for hormone balancing. Take this if
- 0:31you're a woman just because like blanket
- 0:34statement. That is not true. There is
- 0:36really nothing that I could say that
- 0:38should deter you from taking whatever
- 0:41contraceptive you choose to take for
- 0:42your personal life [music] um that could
- 0:44affect your performance. So I would say
- 0:45whatever is best for you works for your
- 0:47life. There's just nothing convincing
- 0:48enough for me to say you should not
- 0:50consume that or it will have this effect
- 0:52on you.
- 0:52>> That would have been a good clip if you
- 0:53said it though.
- 0:54>> That would have been great clickbait.
- 0:58>> All right. So I'm here with Dr.
- 0:59Antonella Schwartz. Thanks for coming on
- 1:01the podcast.
- 1:02>> Thanks for having me.
- 1:03>> So you've got this paper here and it is
- 1:05absolutely massive.
- 1:07You see this?
- 1:08>> Yes.
- 1:09Just huge.
- 1:10>> So this is not out yet. So you guys are
- 1:11going to get like kind of a sneak peek.
- 1:12>> Yep.
- 1:13>> Um it's called Common Questions and
- 1:15Misconceptions about Female Training and
- 1:17Nutrition. What does the scientific
- 1:19evidence really show? And correct me if
- 1:22I'm wrong, but I think you go through
- 1:23like 17 common myths in this paper and
- 1:26like it seems like you do a pretty
- 1:27thorough treatment on each.
- 1:29>> our best. Yes, yes, yes. It's a big
- 1:31massive group effort. So I have to give
- 1:33credit where credit's due. Um it's a lot
- 1:35of great scientists and authors and
- 1:37people helping with revisions and it's
- 1:38truly a team a team project. And
- 1:41couldn't do it without all the amazing
- 1:42people on this work.
- 1:43>> You are the lead author on this, all
- 1:44right?
- 1:45>> Yes.
- 1:45>> Yeah.
- 1:46>> [laughter]
- 1:46>> Yes, it's been a lot of work, but I do
- 1:48have to give credit where credit's due.
- 1:49>> Mhm. I'm really excited for that to come
- 1:51out because I feel like there are a lot
- 1:53of myths and misconceptions around
- 1:55female specific training. So what I want
- 1:58to do with you is I'm going down into
- 1:59four categories. So training, nutrition,
- 2:02supplementation, and metabolism.
- 2:05>> Let's do it.
- 2:05>> And I'm going to give you like two,
- 2:07maybe three myths in each category and
- 2:10we can just talk through them.
- 2:11>> Sounds great to me.
- 2:11>> Okay, sweet.
- 2:13Um actually, before we do that, I'm
- 2:14curious. So like um you you have your
- 2:16PhD. Um can you tell me a little bit
- 2:18about like what you're up to, like what
- 2:20you're working on other than this paper
- 2:21obviously, and like what your background
- 2:23is?
- 2:23>> Yeah, yeah, yeah. My background is
- 2:24heavily in resistance training. I was
- 2:27once a bodybuilder. I'm retired now from
- 2:29the bodybuilding world, but that's
- 2:31really where my love for training,
- 2:33nutrition, and just overall like body
- 2:35composition stem from.
- 2:37>> Mhm.
- 2:38Um I think that when I first began this
- 2:41journey before even knew a thing about
- 2:42science, it was basically just kind of
- 2:45vain in aesthetics.
- 2:46Um I
- 2:48that was my true love, but then I think
- 2:50I realized quickly that there was so
- 2:53much more to it. Like it's so much more
- 2:54than just the way I look and
- 2:57you know competing for what I look like
- 2:59and putting on muscle mass um I guess
- 3:01just acutely, right? Like what are the
- 3:03chronics of chronic effects and where
- 3:05could that kind of take me long-term?
- 3:07And once I kind of started learning
- 3:09about that
- 3:10um I think it just opened up a whole new
- 3:13world for me and I kind of
- 3:15took a step back and thought, wait,
- 3:16okay, there is a lot more to this and
- 3:18it's really worth investigating because
- 3:21the field is truly in its infancy. So I
- 3:23was like, wow, I feel like I got in at a
- 3:24lucky time where there's so much work
- 3:27that needs to be done. So there's so
- 3:28much it's not as saturated as you might
- 3:31think. I mean maybe from the outside
- 3:32looking in it could be, but once you're
- 3:34in it, you're like, whoa, there's still
- 3:35so much we don't know. Um which kind of
- 3:38really piqued my interest cuz I'm I've
- 3:39always kind of been like the
- 3:41character what's that movie?
- 3:44Um it might be Upwards like squirrel,
- 3:45squirrel, right? I think it's Up. That's
- 3:47the dog and he's like, oh, squirrel,
- 3:49squirrel. That's me. So like my I'm
- 3:51always needing to like be stimulated. I
- 3:53just have a brain that works like that.
- 3:54I'm always asking why, why, what what's
- 3:56next? Um and so I think that really was
- 3:59where everything changed for me. Like oh
- 4:00whoa, there's a lot more to this than
- 4:02what I look like in training for that.
- 4:04Um so I really went on to like pursue
- 4:06higher ed and that led me to doing a PhD
- 4:10and I was still kind of in the bro
- 4:12science space at the time and most of my
- 4:14work then was in uh specifically
- 4:16hypertrophic effects of different
- 4:18training like advanced training
- 4:19techniques.
- 4:20>> Mhm.
- 4:21>> And I looked at myo reps
- 4:22>> Mhm.
- 4:22>> and kind of their comparison to straight
- 4:24sets and what that looks like and
- 4:25there's a lot of claims about myo reps
- 4:26right oh they're better because XYZ and
- 4:29um all these like mechanistic
- 4:31assumptions which are great and there's
- 4:34some merit there but um
- 4:36yeah I thought it was really cool to
- 4:37look at and that's what I looked at and
- 4:39compared them to straight sets and
- 4:40ultimately they're great time saver
- 4:42>> Mhm.
- 4:43>> um but I wouldn't say that they are
- 4:46um I guess
- 4:47what they're all cut out to be like
- 4:48they're amazing I think it's a great
- 4:50tool to have in the toolbox and but I
- 4:51think it's a tool.
- 4:52>> Yeah okay so since you brought it up so
- 4:55you're you're the top of your PhD was
- 4:56myo reps so if anyone isn't familiar
- 4:59could you just like briefly explain what
- 5:01that is and then we'll then we'll get
- 5:03into the female specific stuff but I'm
- 5:04actually interested in myo reps so like
- 5:06I'm curious what what you found.
- 5:07>> It is basically a way to manipulate
- 5:10training rest times in order to do to
- 5:14increase work density and so you're
- 5:16doing more work in less time. Um there
- 5:18are some
- 5:20um theories related to I guess kind of
- 5:24like the effective reps and
- 5:27being able to kind of stimulate
- 5:28stimulate more like metabolic stress
- 5:30therefore leading to greater
- 5:31adaptations. That's not quite the case
- 5:34and I think it's too soon to make those
- 5:36kinds of assumptions. Um what we found
- 5:39was really similar outcomes in
- 5:40performance
- 5:42um think like strength and body comp
- 5:44across both groups doing the myo reps
- 5:46and doing the straight sets.
- 5:48The major difference we found though was
- 5:50that when they completed the myo rep
- 5:52training program they were able to do
- 5:54the same work
- 5:55achieve essentially the same gains in a
- 5:57fraction of the time I think it was
- 5:59actually like in a third of the time. So
- 6:03yes they're awesome and advantageous and
- 6:05I would say that it's a great tool to
- 6:08kind of have in your back pocket,
- 6:09especially if you're pinched for time,
- 6:10which most adults in today's day and age
- 6:12are.
- 6:12>> Yeah.
- 6:13>> Um but I wouldn't say that they're
- 6:14magical
- 6:15>> Yeah.
- 6:15>> in comparison to anything else. So I
- 6:17think it's just a time and place.
- 6:18>> I think you're slightly underselling
- 6:19them though because Yeah. That's like a
- 6:21scientist move. Because I think like I
- 6:24think one of the things I've noticed is
- 6:25more people are chasing like efficiency
- 6:27over optimization more than ever before.
- 6:29And like especially as you get later in
- 6:30your training career, you're like I want
- 6:32to be able to get good gains in you know
- 6:34a reasonable amount of time, not
- 6:35necessarily get like an extra 1 or 2% of
- 6:37extra gains. So that that is how I would
- 6:39think of them. Now when I do my RPEs, I
- 6:41go so I do my normal set to failure. So
- 6:44let's just say I do 10 reps. Then I'll
- 6:46rest for like a couple breaths, like a
- 6:48few seconds. And then I'll do another
- 6:50three reps. And then I'll rest for
- 6:52another couple breaths. I'll do another
- 6:54three reps if I can. And I just keep
- 6:55repeating that until I can't hit three.
- 6:57Is that how you did it?
- 6:58>> yeah exactly. So basically until you
- 7:00can't usually the range is three to
- 7:01five. Most people start off. You keep
- 7:03the weight the same from like that first
- 7:05original 10 10 set or 10 rep set. And
- 7:08then you go into your three to five. And
- 7:10then once you can't hit three, that's
- 7:11when you terminate the set.
- 7:12>> Yeah. Makes sense. And and I think like
- 7:14hmm
- 7:17well it's kind of like a drop set except
- 7:18you don't actually drop the weight if
- 7:19that makes sense.
- 7:20>> Yeah yeah yeah. It's kind of like
- 7:21clustering, not like a cluster. Yeah
- 7:22yeah. Yeah and and so you just hit those
- 7:24threes. And
- 7:27yeah I've been doing them a bit myself.
- 7:29And I I do like them because like the
- 7:32way I think of it is you kind of get
- 7:35more
- 7:37high tension reps in much shorter of a
- 7:40time frame, right? So now this will be a
- 7:42whole thing. We could probably talk for
- 7:43an hour about it. I don't want to get
- 7:44derailed on it. But like if you think
- 7:46about it like those last like three to
- 7:48five reps on a set of 10 are the harder
- 7:51reps. Like they're the higher tension
- 7:52reps, right? And so if you're not
- 7:54resting for a full two to three minutes
- 7:55after those, your muscle is still in
- 7:58that like fatigued state where you're
- 8:00going to activate the higher threshold
- 8:01fibers. And so then you hit another
- 8:03three. You hit another three effective
- 8:05reps like yeah, yeah, get air quotes.
- 8:07And then you know then you rest a little
- 8:08bit, you get another So, I I can see how
- 8:10it would have a time-efficient
- 8:12advantage. Um, but then the question
- 8:14would be like, okay, it gives you a
- 8:16time-efficient advantage if you match
- 8:17for volume, but like if you just did
- 8:18those more often, then maybe you could
- 8:20actually just do more volume and make
- 8:21better gains.
- 8:22>> the next step, right? That's like after
- 8:24I completed the study, that was our next
- 8:25Originally, that's what I wanted to do,
- 8:27but my advisor was like, let's just
- 8:28match the volume for now, like and then
- 8:30in the future that could be something to
- 8:32explore. But I agree, I think that
- 8:34definitely prompts that question and
- 8:35that's a good like hypothesis and maybe
- 8:37something to do.
- 8:38>> Yeah, cuz like if you're getting the
- 8:39same gains with myo reps
- 8:41>> Yeah.
- 8:41>> in less time, and if you just train for
- 8:43the same amount of time, you could in
- 8:45theory you could get better gains, but
- 8:46you'd need to test it of course.
- 8:47>> but then you have to think about like
- 8:49right recovery and all the other million
- 8:51It's so multi-factorial. So, can you
- 8:53recover from that enough to get
- 8:54efficient training sessions in the
- 8:55future? So, it's a it's a give and take
- 8:57and that's why I think it's too soon to
- 9:00You're right. I think I am under selling
- 9:01them a little bit, but I I try to err on
- 9:03the side of caution just cuz
- 9:06as of now, I think it's too soon to like
- 9:08>> Yeah.
- 9:08>> to hype them up too much, right? So, I
- 9:10think it's a great tool though. I think
- 9:11everyone should know what they are, have
- 9:13them in their back pocket and utilize
- 9:14them here and there in training or even
- 9:16when you hit a training plateau or when
- 9:17you're finished for time and you just
- 9:19want to do something different, fun.
- 9:21>> Yeah, I like them. All right. So, let's
- 9:22get started with the myths. So,
- 9:25we'll start with training. Um, I think
- 9:27there are a lot of myths around
- 9:29female training.
- 9:30>> Yeah.
- 9:31>> I would say probably the biggest one I
- 9:34hear is like
- 9:36women shouldn't lift heavy because it'll
- 9:38make them bulky.
- 9:39>> Right.
- 9:40>> Um, you could I could reframe it more
- 9:43generally as though like women should
- 9:44like men should train heavy and women
- 9:46shouldn't. But like yeah, maybe you can
- 9:49speak to that one.
- 9:50>> Yeah, that one is controversial. You're
- 9:53right. Um, I
- 9:55ultimately I want to give you like a
- 9:56straight answer so people can kind of
- 9:58get like a yes or no, explain the
- 10:00nuance, and then just maybe like a take
- 10:01home. So,
- 10:03do women need different training
- 10:05programs than men? No. Ultimately the
- 10:07simple answer is no. However, there's so
- 10:09much nuance right that needs to be
- 10:10discussed. Um
- 10:13the women and men are physiologically
- 10:15different. There's no doubt about it. No
- 10:16one's arguing that. No one's saying that
- 10:18they aren't. However, that doesn't
- 10:20dictate different training principles or
- 10:22it doesn't dictate different training
- 10:24programs.
- 10:26Um and I think that's where the
- 10:27the misconceptions exist. The
- 10:30one like two things can be true at once,
- 10:32right? And so those two things are true.
- 10:33Men and women are different, but they
- 10:34don't need different training
- 10:36principles. And that's like the beauty
- 10:37of science and right? Originally we see
- 10:39we compare men and women. We look at
- 10:41them across the lifespan, hormones, you
- 10:43name it. They're different. We know
- 10:44that. So in our human brains we are
- 10:46inclined to think, okay, they're
- 10:47different so they do maybe demand
- 10:49different things, right? And that's a
- 10:51totally valid thing to think. Um and I
- 10:53think that's again the beauty of science
- 10:55is we think these things and we test
- 10:56them. And once they've been tested
- 10:59the results just don't say that. Like
- 11:01they don't really see that in the
- 11:02science and
- 11:03they don't tend to demand different
- 11:05training techniques and women can also
- 11:06train heavy and not become bulky and has
- 11:08way more to do with body composition
- 11:10than the actual training itself.
- 11:11>> Mhm.
- 11:12>> Um so
- 11:13yeah, women just don't need different
- 11:15training programs, but we do need to
- 11:17kind of auto regulate to the seasons of
- 11:19life. And I think that in itself is
- 11:21female specific, right? Experiencing
- 11:24um a menstrual cycle, uh perimenopause,
- 11:26actual menopause, child bearing years.
- 11:29And so these things do demand
- 11:32potentially different programs for
- 11:34different women at different stages of
- 11:35life, but also sometimes not. Like every
- 11:37even on in like inter individual level
- 11:39women are
- 11:41different on a day-to-day basis, on a
- 11:43month-to-month basis. And so I know for
- 11:45some people
- 11:46during pregnancy later on
- 11:48training heavy may be difficult. And so
- 11:50that would definitely warrant different
- 11:51training program and different training
- 11:53approaches. For some it's not. I know
- 11:55some awesome women hitting like crazy
- 11:56PRs eight months pregnant. It's nuts. Um
- 12:00and so for them it doesn't warrant, you
- 12:02know, a ton of training change in their
- 12:03training. And so I think that's where
- 12:06the lines get crossed and we have to
- 12:08kind of look at it on an individual
- 12:09basis. And it's just
- 12:12too I wouldn't even say it's soon. It's
- 12:13just really not appropriate to say like
- 12:15give a blanket statement and say that
- 12:17they do need two different training
- 12:18programs, men and women.
- 12:19>> Yeah, no, it makes sense. Um I do still
- 12:22find like a lot of women want a female
- 12:26specific approach and I I think that's
- 12:28understandable. Like a lot of the
- 12:30research is on men and so I think a lot
- 12:32of women are like, oh, is this going to
- 12:34apply to me? And like I think the news
- 12:36is like basically good, you know, it's
- 12:37like it would be really nice obviously
- 12:39to have more women in research at
- 12:41subjects, but like
- 12:43this the fundamental physiological
- 12:45principles seem to apply to both sexes.
- 12:48>> They definitely do.
- 12:48>> Yeah, like you need to have high tension
- 12:50on the muscle. Like that's what causes
- 12:51it to grow. Like you know, the the the
- 12:53fundamental principles are the same, but
- 12:55I I wouldn't mind getting a little bit
- 12:57into the weeds of what you said there
- 12:58and those like four things, right? So um
- 13:01we could talk about like the menstrual
- 13:02cycle. There's a lot of stuff out there
- 13:04if you really want to dig into it on
- 13:06like how you should structure your
- 13:08training around the different phases.
- 13:10And like you'll see this online too with
- 13:12like influencers like, oh, I'm in my
- 13:14luteal phase therefore XYZ versus
- 13:16follicular phase I feel different. And
- 13:18you know, I don't know maybe on an
- 13:19individual like basis there is some
- 13:21legitimacy to that. I'm not really
- 13:23>> that deep into it. So like what do what
- 13:25do you think of structuring your
- 13:26training around the menstrual cycle?
- 13:28>> Simple answer, not necessary.
- 13:31>> Mm.
- 13:31>> Again, ton of nuance to discuss. So
- 13:34at face value not necessary simply
- 13:37because
- 13:38we are just so different. Like on a
- 13:39month-to-month basis and on an
- 13:41individual basis for a for a woman um
- 13:44it's really and truly not necessary and
- 13:47it can actually be detrimental because
- 13:48we know one of the greatest drivers of
- 13:51any performance adaptation is
- 13:53consistency. And so if we're disrupting
- 13:55consistency on a consistent level, then
- 13:57it's basically inconsistent training,
- 13:59right? And therefore minimal adaptations
- 14:02or at least not to the individual's
- 14:04greatest uh potential.
- 14:05>> Yeah.
- 14:05>> And I think that is detrimental
- 14:07especially in the world that we live in
- 14:08where
- 14:09it's kind of tough to get women in the
- 14:11gym and it's it's we're moving in the
- 14:13right direction, but it's definitely not
- 14:15equal. The, I don't know, gym culture,
- 14:17gym vibes between men and women. And so
- 14:21making training something that women
- 14:24need to like a bunch of hurdles to jump
- 14:26through, well, there's already a ton of
- 14:28hurdles in place, right? Ton of barriers
- 14:29in place for women.
- 14:31Um and the goal is to kind of delete
- 14:32those, get rid of those. And so I think
- 14:34asking somebody to structure without
- 14:37really knowing what's going on is just
- 14:39getting in their way of real true
- 14:41adaptations that we need as we age, our
- 14:43bone and our muscle mass decrease. And
- 14:45so
- 14:46again, if we're disrupting that, then it
- 14:47has a lot more
- 14:49has potentially detrimental effects. And
- 14:51so
- 14:52I think we need to look at it on an
- 14:53individual level where
- 14:55um and that's not to dismiss female
- 14:57symptoms because there are true real
- 14:59symptoms and everybody experiences them
- 15:01at different cadences throughout their
- 15:02cycles and years and what not. And there
- 15:05may be periods
- 15:07of your cycle where you are bleeding
- 15:09heavily and that will definitely cause
- 15:11disruption in your training, where
- 15:13you're not sleeping well, where
- 15:15you're in a season of life where you're
- 15:18really pregnant and you don't feel good
- 15:19and definitely will demand again auto
- 15:22regulation. And so
- 15:24it's an individual basis cuz I
- 15:26personally have also experienced cycles
- 15:27where I don't even know what's happening
- 15:29and I don't feel a thing and I don't
- 15:30feel a difference and I'm grateful that
- 15:32I didn't disrupt my training cuz I
- 15:34wouldn't have achieved what I could have
- 15:35what I did achieve in those seasons of
- 15:37life. And so um a lot of the research
- 15:40shows us that that the changes are just
- 15:42so variable and not consistent enough to
- 15:45make any blanket statements. Um and when
- 15:47we do and we do
- 15:49and people do say, oh, cycle sync this,
- 15:51cycle sync that, then we're kind of
- 15:54impeding people's progress and we
- 15:56already know how difficult that can be
- 15:57for women.
- 15:58>> Yeah, I actually like the answer of like
- 16:00it being an extra barrier where it's
- 16:01like an it adds another layer of
- 16:03complication um and then it's like, oh
- 16:05no, you can just go in and lift
- 16:07according to like the same basic
- 16:08principles.
- 16:09That said, I think I think some people
- 16:11like an extra layer of complication
- 16:12because it feels more individualized so
- 16:14you're like, oh, this is for me as a as
- 16:16a woman, but like you're saying it
- 16:18actually might be counterproductive.
- 16:20Now, would you say it's true that during
- 16:22say like the luteal phase versus
- 16:26ovulation versus the follicular phase
- 16:28versus like menstruation?
- 16:29[clears throat]
- 16:30Like are there changes that you see in
- 16:33performance and mood and these sorts of
- 16:35things?
- 16:35>> Yeah, there's definitely changes.
- 16:36Changes definitely happen. They exist.
- 16:39But I think going back to the previous
- 16:41answer, they fluctuate
- 16:43often between women and
- 16:45even within women on a month-to-month
- 16:46basis and different periods of life or
- 16:48seasons of life, no pun intended.
- 16:50>> Yeah. No, it makes sense. But like I've
- 16:52heard that like in general, and correct
- 16:54me if I'm wrong,
- 16:56I think women tend to be like a bit
- 16:58stronger during the follicular phase. Is
- 17:00that not true? Or like I've heard that
- 17:02anecdotally that seems to be the case.
- 17:04And so you could make the case to like
- 17:07Okay, well
- 17:09during that phase, if you're going to be
- 17:10stronger because of hormonal reasons,
- 17:12whatever, then like
- 17:14you might want to lift a little heavier
- 17:15during that and maybe go a little
- 17:16lighter during the other phase.
- 17:19Forgive me if I have those reversed, but
- 17:20regardless,
- 17:22do you think there's any merit to any of
- 17:23that or is it kind of just like
- 17:26because this is something men don't have
- 17:27to worry about, right? So it strikes me
- 17:28as a like legitimate sex difference
- 17:30where it's like if you are a woman with,
- 17:33you know, a cycle, then like you're
- 17:35going to you might have these
- 17:37fluctuations in training. Like is it
- 17:39better to kind of just like ignore them
- 17:41so to speak and just focus on the
- 17:43overall trend while not get like beating
- 17:45yourself up if you're noticing your
- 17:46energy is lower or is it better to like
- 17:49you know, lean into that and say like,
- 17:50okay, well during this phase, I will be
- 17:52stronger, therefore I should lift
- 17:53heavier. Like, you know, that feels like
- 17:55there there there could be something
- 17:56there. Like it's not just like complete
- 17:57nonsense.
- 17:58>> totally. There's merit because
- 18:00it affects women very differently, but
- 18:03it can affect women their moods and
- 18:04certain phases or strength, even just
- 18:06perceptions of strength and how we feel.
- 18:09So there is some merit. It just is not
- 18:13consistent enough to give that kind of
- 18:15just recommendation. Like you should
- 18:17during this phase of your cycle, you
- 18:19should train heavier and then this
- 18:21phase, you should train lighter. And so,
- 18:22I
- 18:23um,
- 18:25while the fluctuations fluctuations
- 18:27exist, and this is not to diminish or,
- 18:29um, negate any symptoms cuz they're real
- 18:32and they happen, and we feel them as
- 18:34women, um, I think it's doing an
- 18:36injustice to prescribe heavier or
- 18:39lighter during this phase cuz what if
- 18:40you wake up and you feel great or what
- 18:42if you wake up and you don't feel great?
- 18:43Then what happens to the training
- 18:44program? Are you then then discouraged?
- 18:47Um, and one thing about women that a lot
- 18:49of the data does show uh does show,
- 18:52um, Dr. Stacy Sims she's shown some of
- 18:53this where
- 18:55women are going to show up regardless.
- 18:56So, they are amazing, and they are like
- 18:59women running in the Olympics and doing
- 19:01crazy things during, you know, said
- 19:03periods of estrogen decline or said
- 19:06periods of oh, you should take it
- 19:09lighter, you know, you can't program the
- 19:10Olympics around your training cycle, you
- 19:12know, when you're going to compete or be
- 19:13at your peak, but people do it and they
- 19:15do it so well. And I think that's a
- 19:17testament to just
- 19:19maybe the psychology behind training and
- 19:21how sure we can
- 19:23prescribe and give and inform you of
- 19:26this you might feel like this when these
- 19:28hormonal cascades are happening, um, but
- 19:31is that always going to be reflected in
- 19:33actual output? And that's not always the
- 19:35case, and I think that's pretty neat and
- 19:36that's pretty cool because
- 19:38physiology is awesome, but there's also
- 19:40room at the table for psychology and
- 19:42kind of where where our minds are at and
- 19:45what we can kind of override sometimes.
- 19:47And
- 19:47it goes back to like have you ever seen
- 19:49those posts about those athletes that
- 19:50are like I'm not wearing a Whoop. I'm
- 19:51not wearing an Apple Watch. I don't want
- 19:52to know if I slept well or not cuz I
- 19:54don't want that to even
- 19:56dictate how I train or how I perform or
- 19:59how I compete in this game or in this
- 20:00event.
- 20:01Um, and so I think that's kind of where
- 20:05we go from like clinical significance to
- 20:08actual practical or like just
- 20:10statistical significance to practical
- 20:11significance. Like is this actually
- 20:14applicable to my life as a female who's
- 20:18training and competing in XYZ? Um, and
- 20:21that 's kind of the art of I think
- 20:23coaching there, right? We got science
- 20:25and we got like the real coaching and a
- 20:26practical application. And there's like
- 20:27this art form that lives in the middle.
- 20:31>> So would you say like broadly speaking
- 20:33the meth like the
- 20:35your cycle doesn't need to be synced
- 20:38with your training and you can kind of
- 20:39just train based on like the
- 20:41the central tenants of progressive
- 20:42overload. Like try to do a little more
- 20:44each week. Like train close to failure,
- 20:47you know, do enough volume. Like you can
- 20:49obviously get into the weeds about that,
- 20:50but I wanted to focus on more of the
- 20:52differences. And then on an individual
- 20:54level,
- 20:56yeah, I'm curious what you would say
- 20:58because like let's just say you were
- 20:59someone who was like, you know, during
- 21:00this phase of my cycle, I really notice
- 21:02my mood is significantly worse. Like my
- 21:04strength is down, my energy is lower.
- 21:06Um
- 21:09would you say to like yeah, would you
- 21:11say to lean into that in the sense that
- 21:13like okay, well then you know, maybe go
- 21:15a little bit lighter during that time
- 21:17and then during the other phase go a
- 21:19little heavier or would you just kind of
- 21:21like brute force it and like pretend it
- 21:23doesn't exist? Do you know what I'm
- 21:24saying? Yeah.
- 21:25>> I would definitely not pretend it
- 21:26doesn't exist because it does exist. And
- 21:28again, not to dismiss women's symptoms
- 21:30because I'm a woman myself and I feel
- 21:31these things and I feel these symptoms
- 21:32and I definitely listen to them and I
- 21:34definitely regulate on the spot and say
- 21:35hey, I slept horrible last night or I am
- 21:39um in feeling like my mood is off or I
- 21:42just like can't seem to recover well
- 21:44from my last workout and it might be due
- 21:46to like what's happening inside my body
- 21:48right now. Therefore, I will adjust my
- 21:50training. So I definitely think that we
- 21:51should not ignore these symptoms. And in
- 21:53fact, we should
- 21:54pay attention to them and we should
- 21:55journal them and we should kind of keep
- 21:57a log of
- 21:58what does
- 21:59like what's happening during this time
- 22:01of the month for me, during this time of
- 22:02the year for me,
- 22:03because then that can help help you make
- 22:05informed decisions in the future because
- 22:06you might find that consistently
- 22:09when you're menstruating, you are just
- 22:11not as strong. And it just seems to be a
- 22:14consistent thing month to month and heck
- 22:15yeah, like regulate and
- 22:18um program accordingly. That's awesome
- 22:20because that's an informed personal
- 22:22individual decision and choice and
- 22:24that's
- 22:25where everybody should kind of lie and
- 22:27land instead of just like hey during
- 22:29this specific week of your cycle every
- 22:31week you should be training, every month
- 22:32you should be training
- 22:34with super light loads or you should be
- 22:35training with super heavy loads, right?
- 22:36And so I think
- 22:38journaling, logging, and making your own
- 22:40personal informed decision is where is
- 22:42where the money's at. I think that's
- 22:43like the most beneficial on an
- 22:44individual basis cuz you may also find
- 22:46the other side of it. You may also find
- 22:47that you're not really seeing any
- 22:49differences and you maybe don't need to
- 22:51make any changes, right? And so
- 22:53informed decision making I think
- 22:55is great and you should definitely
- 22:56definitely into your symptoms.
- 22:58>> Yeah, I think that's a good point. I
- 22:58think like um
- 23:00some people not just like in this vein
- 23:03but just in general will like no see no
- 23:05see both themselves into something so
- 23:06it's like oh I'm supposed to be stronger
- 23:07during this phase but I'm not is
- 23:09something wrong or whatever and it's
- 23:11like no no no no like this is very
- 23:12individual and I think I think that
- 23:14could be why when you look at like the
- 23:16larger body of science you you tend not
- 23:18to see much there because there just is
- 23:21so much individual variability so it's
- 23:23like okay it kind of cancels out in a
- 23:25way but for all that it doesn't
- 23:27necessarily mean that on an individual
- 23:29level there aren't real effects to
- 23:30monitor so yeah I think that's that's
- 23:32excellent. I want to quickly touch on
- 23:34the other
- 23:36um factors you mentioned so like
- 23:38perimenopause and menopause. How do you
- 23:40feel training would be different for say
- 23:43a woman going through menopause or
- 23:45perimenopause versus a man?
- 23:47>> Yeah.
- 23:48For women there is a right massive
- 23:51massive like estrogen decline that well
- 23:53it's not always a decline right? It's
- 23:54kind of massive fluctuations and then a
- 23:56potential like massive decline
- 23:57afterwards.
- 23:58Um
- 24:00that can truly affect how you feel and a
- 24:02lot of these like vasomotor symptoms and
- 24:05just
- 24:06uh psychological symptoms
- 24:09feeling fatigued, tired and whatnot that
- 24:12can definitely dictate
- 24:14what your training looks like when you
- 24:15show up but the principles the same,
- 24:17right? So like if you are experiencing
- 24:20similar symptoms for potentially
- 24:21different reasons during your cycle or
- 24:23during a specific season of life that's
- 24:24not perimenopause or menopause um you
- 24:27would still auto regulate, right? You
- 24:28would still,
- 24:29hey, I need to potentially change
- 24:31training to better reflect how I'm
- 24:34feeling on a consistent basis. Like
- 24:35maybe I just can't handle the heavy
- 24:37stuff right now. I can't handle spending
- 24:40an hour plus at the gym. I can't handle
- 24:42whatever training technique you're doing
- 24:44or program you're following. Um and so I
- 24:47think that's applicable during that
- 24:48season of life as well.
- 24:50And
- 24:52what I will say though is that with some
- 24:54of these changes,
- 24:57more so
- 24:59we're worried about the effects of aging
- 25:02as well. So like we're aging during this
- 25:04perimenopause and menopausal period,
- 25:05right? It lines up with those 40s, 50s
- 25:07and this is when we start to see like
- 25:09the bone mineral density decline, um
- 25:11sarcopenia starts to creep in and
- 25:13osteoporosis starts to creep in or
- 25:14osteopenia.
- 25:16And this is a perfect window of
- 25:17opportunity to really start lifting and
- 25:20training for those adaptations, at least
- 25:22to hedge against the loss of these
- 25:24tissues cuz they will happen. And so
- 25:27we're basically this is the perfect time
- 25:30to try and reserve and create that like
- 25:32tissue bank.
- 25:33>> Mhm.
- 25:34>> Um and so I think that maybe the
- 25:36training doesn't need to necessarily
- 25:37revolve around
- 25:40hormonally what's going on, but more so
- 25:43the trajectory of life. Like where are
- 25:45you headed? And we're all aging and
- 25:47we're all
- 25:48kind of predisposed to these
- 25:51loss of muscle and bone mass and
- 25:54it's the perfect window of opportunity,
- 25:55this like perimenopause time to catch um
- 26:00stuff that would be therefore
- 26:02accelerated cuz we're aging and
- 26:03changing.
- 26:05Um so yeah, I think that during those
- 26:06seasons of life, changing your training
- 26:08to hedge against those tissue losses is
- 26:12your best bet.
- 26:12>> What does that look like to change your
- 26:14training to hedge against tissue losses?
- 26:16Does that just mean like find a way to
- 26:17train where you can just be consistent
- 26:19essentially?
- 26:20>> be consistent, lifting weights,
- 26:21resistance training, um also getting
- 26:23your cardio in, whether I mean at least
- 26:26just meeting the minimum 150 minutes a
- 26:29week of, you know, your steady or
- 26:31moderate intensity cardio and then the
- 26:33resistance training three ish days a
- 26:35week and beautiful perfect schedule
- 26:38right um and so I think if we haven't
- 26:40nailed that before that would be that
- 26:42perfect window of opportunity is like
- 26:44hey let's really focus on this now
- 26:45because before you may not have felt the
- 26:49effects of the lack of training or not
- 26:52lifting or not doing your consistent
- 26:54cardio but you will in the future and
- 26:56like the next couple of decades those
- 27:00the consequences will surface and so I
- 27:02think that is the perfect window of
- 27:03opportunity and it also does kind of
- 27:06help
- 27:07manage some of those symptoms that women
- 27:08feel during that time like during the
- 27:10perimenopausal period um the resistance
- 27:13training does kind of help with some of
- 27:14those symptoms and we have a cool
- 27:16commentary that me and Dr. Alyssa Parten
- 27:18and um
- 27:20another students wrote
- 27:22about
- 27:23kind of the similar
- 27:25overlaps between resistance training and
- 27:28um menopause like hormone therapy so
- 27:31yeah I think it's the perfect season of
- 27:32life to definitely make sure that you're
- 27:33including resistance training
- 27:36if you haven't already been.
- 27:37>> Great. Um and then what about pregnancy
- 27:40so like I feel like anytime a woman
- 27:42posts
- 27:43herself lifting while pregnant online
- 27:45you just get like an onslaught of
- 27:48commentary about it right a lot of it
- 27:49negative and what
- 27:50>> Even in person people came up to me all
- 27:52the time at the gym like oh is that safe
- 27:54or how long can you do that for I'm like
- 27:56it's crazy you're lucky that I'm nice
- 27:57and I don't get easily offended because
- 28:00I was just like I'm happy to tell you
- 28:01that it's okay and safe but
- 28:03>> Men or women asking you?
- 28:05>> Uh both yeah both and my family too it's
- 28:07actually it was crazy surprising how
- 28:09many of my family members immediately
- 28:11found out I was pregnant I'm like be
- 28:12careful don't be doing all that lifting
- 28:13you're always doing I'm like whoa whoa
- 28:15whoa.
- 28:16>> So it's yeah so what is the answer to
- 28:18that is it just safe all the way up like
- 28:20the whole time yeah.
- 28:21>> safe and there actually have been a lot
- 28:24there's actually a ton of research
- 28:25supporting
- 28:26just maternal health outcomes and fetal
- 28:28health outcomes
- 28:30for women who have lifted throughout
- 28:32their pregnancy it's pretty neat. Dr.
- 28:34Christina Prevett, she was on this paper
- 28:36as well, and she's her sections were
- 28:38really about pregnancy and
- 28:40training during pregnancy. She's she's
- 28:42doing and has done a ton of research in
- 28:43this area.
- 28:45She's the expert here, but yeah, it's
- 28:47essentially very safe.
- 28:49Of course, on an individual level, got
- 28:51to talk to your clinician. It's not
- 28:52always that straightforward. Um
- 28:54different women experience different
- 28:55symptoms, which could dictate how you
- 28:57modify your training. I know for me
- 28:59personally, I have trained my entire
- 29:02life. I've lifted, I've ran, done the
- 29:03whole
- 29:05done it all. And so when I became
- 29:06pregnant, I thought, oh, I'm doing this
- 29:08all the way up till I can't. And
- 29:09basically
- 29:11thinking, oh, I'm doing this all the way
- 29:12up to the nine months, but some things I
- 29:14had to stop early on. So like running
- 29:16didn't feel good past four months for
- 29:17me. I just
- 29:18a lot of like round ligament pain and
- 29:20just waking up really sore. And so on a
- 29:22personal level, while I know that it's
- 29:23safe to run long term, I decided this is
- 29:26where running stops for me. And so
- 29:28instead of, you know, just completely
- 29:30throwing cardio out the window, I got on
- 29:31a bike for the rest of my pregnancy. So
- 29:33I was doing a ton of spinning for my
- 29:34cardio.
- 29:35Um however, lifting felt great. So I
- 29:37lifted pretty heavy up until I couldn't.
- 29:40Um back squats specifically felt
- 29:42horrible for me at like seven, eight
- 29:43months. A lot of round ligament pain,
- 29:46just not fun. So I tossed those out of
- 29:48my training program and just modified um
- 29:53So overall, yes, very safe.
- 29:54>> of squats?
- 29:55>> I did a lot of single leg stuff.
- 29:56Surprisingly, single leg stuff just
- 29:58didn't bother me as much. Um
- 30:00lunges and split squats,
- 30:03step ups, all kinds of that stuff. So
- 30:05that was really helpful for me.
- 30:06>> And then like what about lifting heavy?
- 30:08Like what So what would like your Let's
- 30:10just say like non-pregnancy squat be for
- 30:13like, you know, a few reps, like five
- 30:14reps or something.
- 30:15>> Um
- 30:17205.
- 30:17>> Okay, so like a couple plates.
- 30:19>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 30:20>> And then during pregnancy, like let's
- 30:22say you're like six months because you
- 30:23said you stopped squatting around like
- 30:24seven months. Is that what you said or
- 30:26something like or what?
- 30:26>> yep, closer to like eight months. Yeah,
- 30:28yeah, I have eight months.
- 30:29>> so so let's say you're seven months
- 30:31pregnant and you're squatting, what are
- 30:32you squatting?
- 30:33>> 135. Anything over that Yeah, much
- 30:35lighter. Anything over that was just not
- 30:38comfortable for me. Just not for me. Um
- 30:41but I've a lot of my friends who also
- 30:43lifted throughout pregnancy said they
- 30:44love back squatting and they felt super
- 30:45strong, but there there were other
- 30:47things that just didn't feel comfortable
- 30:48for them. So I think it comes down to it
- 30:50just individual anatomy
- 30:52and being able to pivot when needed. But
- 30:55overall, the lifting is safe.
- 30:57>> Yes.
- 30:58>> I think previously people were worried
- 31:00about, you know, your baby's heartbeat
- 31:03and elevation and um heart rate, mom and
- 31:06baby, but Dr. Christine Private has done
- 31:09some research on this and there are no
- 31:12like red flags, right? No major
- 31:13associations that pop up um
- 31:17when your heart rate is raised.
- 31:18>> Yeah.
- 31:19>> It during training while you're
- 31:20pregnant.
- 31:21[snorts]
- 31:22Yeah.
- 31:22>> I've heard it can even have benefits
- 31:24like during delivery itself, like in
- 31:27terms of just the strength required and
- 31:28the like pain management and things. So
- 31:31it seems to be totally good. Now, do do
- 31:34most people experience some strength
- 31:36loss through pregnancy or like is that
- 31:38something to be aware of?
- 31:39>> I think
- 31:41I would
- 31:42I would say that it's might not be
- 31:45directly due to being
- 31:47physically pregnant, but more so due to
- 31:50the potential restraints you may
- 31:52experience or just like mood and energy
- 31:55levels that can't get you to the gym to
- 31:59train consistently. That's what I
- 32:00experienced at least towards the end of
- 32:01my pregnancy. I just didn't have the
- 32:04mental bandwidth, the like emotional
- 32:07strength to lift heavy and get there on
- 32:09a consistent basis that last month. That
- 32:11was tough for me that last month.
- 32:13>> Yeah.
- 32:13>> Um so
- 32:15but then I also know women again that
- 32:17are hitting PRs like the week before
- 32:18they deliver. It's wild. I think
- 32:20personally for me though, the benefits
- 32:22that I saw were on the other side, the
- 32:24recovery, the postpartum recovery.
- 32:26I think consistently training
- 32:30reduced the gap between delivery and
- 32:33getting back to my regular training.
- 32:35Like I was able to do that pretty
- 32:37quickly even after having emergency
- 32:39which
- 32:40that also is a whole another kind of
- 32:43demon to battle out because I mean
- 32:45that's a full on surgery. So I had a lot
- 32:46of like tissue repair to do and recovery
- 32:48and immediate atrophy that you
- 32:50experience after any surgery.
- 32:52Um
- 32:53but I
- 32:55give a lot of credit to what I like to
- 32:57call like the tissue bank that I've
- 32:59created and I consistently kept up with
- 33:01and even if I wasn't putting on mass, I
- 33:03was maintaining my mass during
- 33:04pregnancy. So I had a ton of tissue from
- 33:07this tissue bank to pull. So even though
- 33:09I experienced that atrophy, um I still
- 33:11feel like my baseline was probably
- 33:13higher than average, which made my
- 33:15recovery a lot smoother and just a lot
- 33:18quicker, which was amazing for my mental
- 33:20health.
- 33:22>> That's great. [snorts] Okay, so so there
- 33:23it sounds like there are these
- 33:24differences, but rather than just
- 33:25framing it as like women must do this
- 33:28because of
- 33:30menopause and because of pregnancy and
- 33:31because of menstrual cycle and so on,
- 33:34like it's more so just like that's
- 33:36something to monitor on an individual
- 33:38basis, okay? Um the fundamental
- 33:40principles between the two are the same.
- 33:42Now in my coaching experience, I have
- 33:43noticed a few things though and I'm
- 33:44curious what you think of these. So one
- 33:47is I find women are generally able to
- 33:50like
- 33:52tolerate more high rep training and it
- 33:55does seem to be the case that women have
- 33:56like a higher proportion of type one
- 33:58muscle fibers. So like would you say
- 34:00that's that's a genuine difference?
- 34:01>> Yep, that's a definitely that's
- 34:02definitely a real difference. Like we
- 34:04know that, we see that show up in the
- 34:05data, we see that show up um across
- 34:08different trials, across like just
- 34:10muscle biopsies and looking at fiber
- 34:12differences. So that's very real and
- 34:14that's yeah that's you've noticed that
- 34:15and that's totally real.
- 34:16>> So like but from a but still from a like
- 34:19coaching or like programming
- 34:21prescription standpoint, you don't just
- 34:23because women can tolerate higher reps
- 34:25better doesn't necessarily mean you have
- 34:27to give them higher reps, right? So it's
- 34:29like they would probably just like maybe
- 34:32um yeah, they would just tolerate it
- 34:34better than they don't get fatigued in
- 34:35quite the same way as a man might,
- 34:37right? So like it you probably have more
- 34:39flexibility to get more high reps to
- 34:40women.
- 34:41>> Totally.
- 34:41>> Okay. I [snorts] say that that is one
- 34:43thing. And then the other thing perhaps
- 34:45related is like I do find anything above
- 34:49like maybe eight reps-ish like women can
- 34:51just grind out more reps than I would
- 34:53expect, especially with lower body work.
- 34:56So like with men, I find let's just say
- 34:57we're doing like pendulum squats, okay?
- 35:00A set of eight reps
- 35:01I find I can tell very easily. Now I
- 35:04have trained more with men than I have
- 35:05with women's, but so keep that in mind.
- 35:07But I find
- 35:09generally speaking, when men get to that
- 35:10like eighth rep and it's like grinding
- 35:12down, they might get a ninth. And then
- 35:14if that's a slow rep as in like they
- 35:16have to really grind to get through the
- 35:17concentric or through the positive
- 35:20they're not going to get a 10th rep.
- 35:21>> Yeah.
- 35:22>> With women, I find it the eighth rep
- 35:23might really slow down and they're
- 35:25grinding, but then it's like all right,
- 35:27let's go for one more. And then they get
- 35:28the ninth and then it's like if you got
- 35:30one more, go for it. And then they get
- 35:31the 10th, but then they get to 12. Do
- 35:33you know what I mean? So it's like the
- 35:34ability to grind and they're genuinely
- 35:36hard reps. It's not like they're just
- 35:38sandbagging on rep eight. I find women
- 35:40have a unique ability to like grind
- 35:43through
- 35:44fatigue with low especially with lower
- 35:47body work.
- 35:47>> Right. I agree. And
- 35:50I think it go comes back to that fiber
- 35:52type distribution, but also I think it's
- 35:55a testament to how like badass women
- 35:57are, right? I don't know. Like I
- 35:59I think there needs to be more work done
- 36:01in that and potentially looking at like
- 36:03when you standardize everything, right?
- 36:05Like pound for pound
- 36:08>> Yeah.
- 36:08>> whatever the like standardize everything
- 36:12what differences do we see and
- 36:14is it consistent across the sexes? That
- 36:16would be really interesting to see
- 36:18really hard to do and manipulate, but or
- 36:20get done.
- 36:22But
- 36:23I guess just like
- 36:24from what I know now and from today's
- 36:27point of view, I think that it is just a
- 36:29testament to how awesome women are and
- 36:30also maybe the fiber type distribution,
- 36:33kind of the things you noticed
- 36:34>> Yeah.
- 36:35>> that you said with like training women.
- 36:37>> Yeah. And then the other thing I've
- 36:38noticed is just related to goals. I find
- 36:40that women have much more like lower
- 36:42body goals than men do. Like they they
- 36:44want to train legs more. They seem to
- 36:46like training legs more. And um
- 36:49they I think tend to also grow their
- 36:52legs more relative to body mass and
- 36:55starting place.
- 36:57Would you say that's true?
- 36:59>> I would say it's
- 37:02potentially true. I think it
- 37:05I I think it's maybe also like who
- 37:09we're around more and kind of what what
- 37:12exercise science bubble we live in. You
- 37:14know what I mean? So like in the
- 37:16bodybuilding world, absolutely that's
- 37:17true. That's so true.
- 37:19Um in potentially like a
- 37:23sport performance world that might not
- 37:26hold
- 37:26>> Mm.
- 37:27>> to the same
- 37:28>> Mm.
- 37:28>> trueness value.
- 37:29>> Kind of.
- 37:30>> Um
- 37:32and then I also and I think that
- 37:35those two differences are true because
- 37:37of our culture. And I think our culture
- 37:39shapes that a ton and just
- 37:41kind of what women are supposed to look
- 37:43like, how we're supposed to train, what
- 37:45we're supposed to
- 37:47develop more than the other muscle
- 37:49group, kind of what is socially and
- 37:51culturally acceptable
- 37:52>> Mm.
- 37:53>> and how we like physically view women. I
- 37:54think that's kind of where that that
- 37:56difference comes from. And I've
- 37:57struggled with that myself, just
- 38:00having I just naturally I'm predisposed
- 38:02to carrying more weight and
- 38:05easily developing my upper body. My legs
- 38:07definitely develop as well, but it just
- 38:09like has come more naturally in my upper
- 38:11body as well. And so I think that
- 38:13over like
- 38:14before I was kind of like able to accept
- 38:16like, hey, women don't have to look a
- 38:18certain way. It's nice to look a certain
- 38:20way, sure, and you're allowed you're
- 38:21allowed to feel how you want to feel
- 38:22about looking a certain way, but
- 38:25before I really kind of accepted that, I
- 38:28remember feeling like, wow, why
- 38:31is my why are my shoulders so broad? Why
- 38:33is my back so wide? And kind of
- 38:34struggling mentally with that and
- 38:36thinking, why do I look this way? But
- 38:39who like who made those rules? You know?
- 38:41And so I think
- 38:42it has a lot to do with like culture,
- 38:45society, what
- 38:46women are like supposed to look like.
- 38:48So, yeah.
- 38:49>> Yeah, that that's probably true. I do I
- 38:52do find whether societal or cultural or
- 38:55not, I do find women
- 38:57>> [snorts]
- 38:57>> really do seem to like training legs
- 38:59more than men. Like like men like I
- 39:01don't really like training legs unless
- 39:03it's like squats and deadlifts.
- 39:04>> No, for sure.
- 39:06>> But
- 39:07I love training upper body
- 39:09>> Yeah.
- 39:09>> and like
- 39:10I don't know. Yeah. I it it could be a
- 39:13genuine like it could be slightly a
- 39:14biological difference, could be a
- 39:15combination of things, but I I would say
- 39:17like yeah, the preponderance of focus
- 39:19that you see on lower body might be more
- 39:21societally driven.
- 39:22>> I think so too, but I agree with you
- 39:23because I personally love to train legs.
- 39:25I could train legs every day all day.
- 39:26Don't care about training my upper body
- 39:28really. My husband's the opposite. He
- 39:29loves training upper body and chest, all
- 39:31the fun stuff, and he hates when I
- 39:33program any leg press and he's like,
- 39:34what the heck? And I'm like, sorry, it's
- 39:35just my favorite.
- 39:36>> Yeah. All right, well, I think that
- 39:38that's a good treatment for the um
- 39:41for the training stuff.
- 39:42>> Yep.
- 39:42>> Let's go on to nutrition myths.
- 39:46Maybe I'll ask you what what would you
- 39:47say is like the the biggest nutrition
- 39:49related myth for women?
- 39:52>> Probably
- 39:55probably that women just require less
- 39:59calories, they should eat less, they
- 40:01should
- 40:03they can't eat like guys. Um I see it
- 40:06all the time like I have friends say
- 40:08like, if I just look at that, I'll gain
- 40:09weight. But my husband doesn't have that
- 40:11problem and
- 40:12that is probably that is probably the
- 40:15largest myth, the largest kind of
- 40:18>> So, how would you say that that's a
- 40:19that's a myth because
- 40:23>> Yeah.
- 40:23>> I mean, sometimes it's like on average
- 40:25would it
- 40:26like assuming that the goal is like
- 40:27weight maintenance or what have you like
- 40:30I would imagine that like
- 40:32women would have lower
- 40:34total daily energy expenditures on
- 40:36average or is that not true?
- 40:38>> I
- 40:41I think it
- 40:42boils down to a lot more than just like
- 40:44basic metabolism and I think it's a lot
- 40:47of just behaviors and like we were just
- 40:49talking about training, right? It's much
- 40:51more difficult to get a woman training
- 40:53and in sport and doing
- 40:56some of those things that we see our
- 40:57male counterparts doing. Um I think
- 41:00we're moving in the right direction
- 41:01culturally, but I do think that it is a
- 41:02lot harder and therefore we see some of
- 41:05those effects with
- 41:06maybe body composition, right? Women may
- 41:09not be training as hard to their full
- 41:10potential
- 41:12uh or lifting enough or have enough
- 41:15scale muscle mass cuz they haven't been
- 41:16lifting cuz they have been scared to
- 41:18become bulky and what not. And so I
- 41:19think that can show up on the body comp
- 41:22nutrition side where we're like, oh,
- 41:24why can't I keep the weight off? Why
- 41:27can't I achieve this body comp? What's
- 41:29going on? Well, what does your training
- 41:31look like too, right? Like are you
- 41:33lifting enough and lifting weights in
- 41:35general? What does your skeletal muscle
- 41:37mass? What does that free fat mass look
- 41:38like? And so
- 41:40um
- 41:42yeah, I think that that's kind of where
- 41:44that disconnection is.
- 41:46And I think that
- 41:50men have it
- 41:51a little different in that arena of
- 41:53training and being able to kind of like
- 41:55express those things and therefore that
- 41:57shows up in potentially more favorable
- 41:59body compositions.
- 42:00>> So are you saying like women basically
- 42:02like because they maybe don't exercise
- 42:05as much like they're not like
- 42:06necessarily burning as much?
- 42:07>> Potentially, yeah.
- 42:08>> But there's also like a size difference
- 42:10too, right? Like
- 42:11>> Like absolutely. Yeah.
- 42:12>> And if men are larger on average or have
- 42:16more like lean mass then like bigger
- 42:18bodies tend to just like burn more
- 42:19calories.
- 42:20Um but yeah, I mean like I just feel I
- 42:22don't know. It's it's tricky when it's
- 42:24like talking about myths because it's
- 42:25like I don't doubt that like yeah, there
- 42:27probably is a couple where it's like
- 42:29the like the female in the relationship
- 42:31like can't just the objectively cannot
- 42:34eat nearly as much and like that shows
- 42:36up and it's probably frustrating. So
- 42:38it's like is it a myth that there are
- 42:39metabolic differences or is it more so
- 42:41just like once you scale for body weight
- 42:43and control for lean mass then it kind
- 42:44of goes away?
- 42:46>> I know that's so hard. It's so hard to
- 42:48give a clear answer, but I think there's
- 42:50a lot more in our control as women than
- 42:52we tend to think and I think that
- 42:55I don't know, I think it's almost like
- 42:56doing us an injustice to say
- 42:59just because I'm a girl like it's so
- 43:00much harder for me, which I don't doubt
- 43:02that it's harder for hard for women or
- 43:04some women. I don't doubt that, but I do
- 43:06think overall I think it's an injustice
- 43:08to say that just because I am a woman it
- 43:10is inherently harder um because there's
- 43:13a lot of stuff that we can control. Like
- 43:14we can control the way we train, we can
- 43:15control the some of the things we eat.
- 43:17Of course like
- 43:19speaking on a standard basis like a
- 43:21healthy woman know all the
- 43:22complications.
- 43:23>> Yeah.
- 43:23>> Um
- 43:25so yeah, while there may there
- 43:27definitely are biological differences, I
- 43:29don't think that
- 43:31just because you're
- 43:33because we are women that that is always
- 43:36true. I think there's a lot of the stuff
- 43:37that
- 43:38we can control ourselves and I think
- 43:39that's the beauty of exercise science
- 43:41and the female physiology space that's
- 43:44been exploding lately like
- 43:46giving women tangible tools instead of
- 43:49just
- 43:51you know
- 43:52thinking that because I'm a woman I'm
- 43:54screwed. Like I'm just destined to gain
- 43:56a ton of weight as I age because of XYZ
- 43:58hormonal cascades, whatever. So that's
- 44:00that's my goal at least is to give women
- 44:02tangible goals like you can lift this
- 44:04way, you can eat this way, you can
- 44:07um try these things and
- 44:09live an awesome fruitful healthy life
- 44:12instead of just like you know.
- 44:13>> Yeah, I think another thing too is like
- 44:15there's such a
- 44:17like a pressure to maintain a standard
- 44:19that isn't probably like sustainable or
- 44:21realistic for a lot of women. I think it
- 44:23happens to men too, but I feel like it's
- 44:24probably worse for women. Like almost
- 44:26certainly is. Um and
- 44:30that might make you feel like oh I can't
- 44:33eat this, I have to eat nothing, but
- 44:34it's like no no no like you're just
- 44:36trying to maintain a level of leanness
- 44:38that isn't really realistic or
- 44:39sustainable for you and it might be for
- 44:41somebody else, right? So again it just
- 44:43kind of comes back to like
- 44:45being individuals rather than like these
- 44:47ultra distinct like sexes. I although
- 44:50there are obviously you know
- 44:52physiological differences, but like
- 44:53there's there's a lot of like overlap in
- 44:55the middle, right? So it's like yeah, it
- 44:57probably is true that like a man who's
- 44:59250 lbs with a wife who's
- 45:02150 lbs, there probably are going to be
- 45:04genuine metabolic differences. Like the
- 45:05man is going to be able to eat more. But
- 45:07like
- 45:09they're at fairly opposite ends of the
- 45:10curve, whereas like in the middle and
- 45:13like even throughout like there are
- 45:14going to be like tons of overlap. Like
- 45:16there's obviously going to be women who
- 45:18can eat way more calories than a man
- 45:20even at the same weight. So like I think
- 45:22that there's just too much
- 45:23>> Variability.
- 45:24>> variability to like draw those like firm
- 45:26distinctions when it comes to
- 45:28metabolism. Yeah.
- 45:29>> I totally agree and I think that's why
- 45:30it's important when
- 45:32people are seeking answers to these
- 45:35questions on a personal level that
- 45:38they don't just go straight to social
- 45:39media because it's it's so hard to
- 45:42discuss the nuance on social media in a
- 45:44singular post. Like sure, you can say
- 45:47I don't know. I can give you a black and
- 45:49white answer to a question, but that
- 45:51dismisses so much and
- 45:53>> Mhm.
- 45:53>> it's important to either work with a
- 45:55professional or
- 45:57maybe know where who to get appropriate
- 46:00information for your specific
- 46:02season of life
- 46:04whatever individual state. And so
- 46:06that's kind of my beef with social
- 46:08media. It's it's so hard to convey a
- 46:10message appropriately because so much
- 46:13variability.
- 46:13>> Yeah, and the more sensational thing you
- 46:15say or the more like clear-cut you say
- 46:17it, the more extreme it is, the more
- 46:19likely it is to take off, right? It gets
- 46:20more engagement
- 46:21>> Yeah, but that's also what people want
- 46:23because I don't
- 46:24expect everybody to know the answer to
- 46:26everything, right? That's why they trust
- 46:29that's what people should be able to
- 46:30trust people who are maybe in higher
- 46:32education or have spent many years
- 46:34looking and researching and doing this
- 46:35stuff
- 46:36because we've put in this time and so we
- 46:38we should be trusted to deliver accurate
- 46:41information
- 46:43concisely for people to actually put
- 46:46into practical or for practical
- 46:47application. And
- 46:49that's where like the mess starts to
- 46:51happen is like people get trusted
- 46:54um
- 46:55and And the information is like too
- 46:57concise and then it gets applied
- 47:00wrong, wrongfully. And not even at
- 47:03anybody like not even maliciously. Like
- 47:05it's just difficult to put out a post
- 47:07and say, hey,
- 47:08this is the easy answer to this without
- 47:11discussing the nuance and it's hard.
- 47:13It's just a hard hard line.
- 47:14>> is. It is hard. And then there are
- 47:16malicious actors as well who just prey
- 47:18on these things and exploit it, but
- 47:21Anyway, um okay, so I think that's good
- 47:24for the metabolic side. I do actually
- 47:27No, sorry. Um
- 47:29so it was it was basically like so the
- 47:31first nutrition myth was like women need
- 47:33to eat less than men. Now, I will be
- 47:36honest with you. I'm still not like 100%
- 47:37convinced that that is
- 47:39a myth because on average I feel like
- 47:42given the differences in body weight,
- 47:44that probably is true. Like I mean in my
- 47:46coaching experience I I like there have
- 47:48been examples where when I've given
- 47:50women Like let's just say men and let's
- 47:52just say like fat loss is a common goal,
- 47:54you know. Let's just say that fat loss
- 47:56is the goal. Usually
- 47:59women will have to diet on lower
- 48:00calories than men in my coaching
- 48:01experience. So like what is what is the
- 48:04myth there exactly? Like can you can you
- 48:06try to wrap that up like because I feel
- 48:08like we could we're kind of saying it's
- 48:09a myth, but it's like only a myth
- 48:11because of in this like really nuanced
- 48:12way. Like where what is the actual truth
- 48:15there?
- 48:16>> Oh, okay. So all right, let's circle
- 48:18back here.
- 48:19So do women need to eat less than men?
- 48:23Are we talking about when we compare
- 48:24them like pound for pound? Like if we
- 48:26are
- 48:27completely standardizing the equation?
- 48:30>> Um
- 48:33I think no because I feel like in the
- 48:36real world
- 48:37>> Right.
- 48:37>> there is just a generally a size
- 48:39difference.
- 48:40>> so then yeah, absolutely you're right.
- 48:41There definitely is going to be a
- 48:43difference, right? A 250 lb man can
- 48:45consume much more calories and still
- 48:47achieve XYZ or whatever his goals are um
- 48:50compared to a 150 lb woman. It just
- 48:52comes down to body size and comp uh comp
- 48:55composition.
- 48:56Um so you're right. Women tend to need
- 48:59lower caloric because we're just
- 49:00smaller, right? We have absolute less
- 49:03muscle mass. We start off with less
- 49:04muscle mass, less everything mass
- 49:05essentially. We're just smaller beings
- 49:07in general.
- 49:09Um but then when we talk about it
- 49:11relatively,
- 49:13there doesn't tend to be a massive
- 49:15difference. So I would say on an
- 49:17absolute scale, yeah, definitely. On a
- 49:19relative scale,
- 49:21not as drastic of a difference. And we
- 49:23also see that in training. I know that
- 49:25we've seen some awesome studies come out
- 49:26recently looking at like relative
- 49:29um gains and adaptations and
- 49:30specifically hypertrophy and performance
- 49:32gains and we don't see much of a
- 49:34difference between the sexes when it
- 49:35comes to relative muscle mass gain. Um
- 49:38on an absolute scale, absolutely, but
- 49:40yeah.
- 49:40>> No, that makes sense. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 49:42It's basically just like on average
- 49:44women tend to start with less, but then
- 49:46relative to where they started, they
- 49:47tend to gain the same amount. It's
- 49:48similar with metabolism, I would
- 49:50imagine. Um okay, and then um the other
- 49:53thing that like you had mentioned
- 49:54earlier was like I think I think there
- 49:56is almost like a
- 49:57fatalistic
- 49:59slant to this where it's like, oh, I I'm
- 50:01doomed to only eat like 1,000 calories a
- 50:04day or whatever it is and it's like
- 50:05that's what I need to eat. And it's like
- 50:07you had mentioned exercise earlier. Like
- 50:09that's within your control. Like you
- 50:11know, you can actually like
- 50:13the more active you are, the more you
- 50:14not only tend to burn more calories, but
- 50:15like also regulate your appetite better
- 50:17and you know, improve your overall
- 50:19health. It's not just about getting as
- 50:20like lean as possible. So I think um
- 50:23yeah, I I I can see how it has like I
- 50:26can see how it's a myth, but I think it
- 50:27depends on exactly how you frame it. Um
- 50:30and then obviously there's like the
- 50:31social side of like women need to eat
- 50:33less than men. It's like, no, you don't
- 50:34need to. Like you just want.
- 50:36>> Like I you know, my brain goes
- 50:38completely to the
- 50:40this the post or like the memes and
- 50:42stuff and those videos on Instagram
- 50:44reels like, and for the lady, have you
- 50:45seen those? Yeah. It's just like, oh,
- 50:47for the lady, like a small meal or small
- 50:50drink. Like
- 50:51is that and it's a joke because it's
- 50:54it's I don't know, it's just kind of
- 50:56like the societal thing, right? The lady
- 50:58is supposed to eat the salad and the man
- 50:59gets the big steak and potatoes. And is
- 51:01that necessarily the case? No, right? It
- 51:04all just really depends on one, your
- 51:06goals, what um
- 51:09what kind of training you are doing.
- 51:11Does it demand more calories? Does it
- 51:12demand less calories on your goal and
- 51:14training?
- 51:15A specific example I know I've
- 51:17experienced as a woman is
- 51:20postpartum. I got a lot of just
- 51:23unsolicited advice about training and
- 51:25breastfeeding and like, oh, you better
- 51:26not train as hard cuz you won't and
- 51:28breastfeeding is going to be difficult.
- 51:29You won't produce as much milk, whatever
- 51:31the case might be. And that's just so
- 51:33silly to say and think
- 51:35because that has a lot more to do with
- 51:37nutrition than actual training, right?
- 51:38It's just basically the caloric demand.
- 51:40So as long as I'm matching my needs
- 51:43calorically, then
- 51:45I'll be okay and like I won't my milk
- 51:47supply won't suffer from it. And so I
- 51:49think
- 51:50I have explained that to so many people,
- 51:51especially just like family and just
- 51:53like be careful with your milk supply
- 51:54with all that training you do. I'm like,
- 51:55well, you know that I'm eating enough to
- 51:57sustain my training. And so like
- 52:00at the end of the day, the net positive
- 52:02caloric intake that I'm consuming would
- 52:04be the same whether I was training this
- 52:06much or not.
- 52:07>> Yeah.
- 52:08>> So
- 52:09um that's a that's a good like kind of
- 52:11real world application to that.
- 52:13>> Mhm. All right, let's let's touch on
- 52:15protein here briefly. I've I've heard
- 52:17this go two ways like
- 52:19I've heard women don't need to eat as
- 52:21much protein as men and then I've also
- 52:23heard like women need to during one
- 52:26phase of their cycle, they can eat more
- 52:27like during the follicular phase they
- 52:29eat more. So like what what what's your
- 52:30best protein recommendation for women
- 52:32and does it differ from men?
- 52:33>> I would say that no, it does not differ
- 52:35from men. At least in today's
- 52:37landscape of what we know today, that
- 52:39could totally change. I think that's
- 52:40again the beauty of science is being
- 52:42able to change your views and adapt and
- 52:44what not with the new research that
- 52:45comes out. But
- 52:47right now I would say no, there
- 52:49shouldn't be
- 52:51a difference in how much protein you
- 52:52consume strictly because you are female.
- 52:54Now again, there are
- 52:56many other things that might dictate
- 52:58higher protein consumption, lower
- 52:59protein consumption. Yes, things like
- 53:01activity level. If you're a professional
- 53:03elite athlete training multiple times a
- 53:05day, does your protein content or does
- 53:08the amount of protein you eat need to be
- 53:10super super high? Well, it depends. Is
- 53:11that going to get in the way of how much
- 53:13carbohydrate intake like you're
- 53:14consuming which which you need
- 53:16a substantial amount when you're
- 53:17training at super high levels.
- 53:19Potentially something to consider, maybe
- 53:21potentially lowering so you can get more
- 53:22carbon intake. Are you somebody dieting
- 53:25really strongly um you're in a massive
- 53:27deficit. That may warrant more protein
- 53:31in order to hedge against you know
- 53:33tissue loss or muscle muscle loss.
- 53:35Um so the answer to do women need more
- 53:38or less protein at any time in their
- 53:40life compared to men? Likely not. That
- 53:421.6 is
- 53:44that 1.6 g per kilo is kind of the sweet
- 53:46spot for everybody and it seems to work
- 53:49for both men and women and still yield
- 53:52gains in mass maintenance for mass. Um I
- 53:57know the RDA is 0.8 g per kilo which is
- 54:00really low.
- 54:01>> Yeah.
- 54:02>> And like in class when I kind of teach
- 54:04this subject
- 54:06I show them that. I tell them hey the
- 54:07RDA is 0.8 g per kilo but I always say
- 54:09that's just enough to survive. But we
- 54:11don't want to survive, we want to
- 54:12thrive. And so if you want to thrive
- 54:14that 1.2 to 1.6 is where a lot of the
- 54:17evidence shows
- 54:19we are thriving or you can kind of help
- 54:22help your tissues thrive and recover and
- 54:24um whatnot.
- 54:26Anything over that is
- 54:28I would say not detrimental. So
- 54:31>> Yeah.
- 54:31>> on a case-to-case
- 54:33prescription
- 54:36you may want to prescribe more than 1.6
- 54:39simply due to
- 54:42mitigating
- 54:44eating under 1.6. So like yeah you tell
- 54:45somebody eat 1.6 but what if they tend
- 54:48to only get like the 1.4 they're
- 54:50miscalculating or whatnot. Maybe asking
- 54:53somebody to eat 1.8 hedges against that
- 54:55and so maybe that is their true 1.6. And
- 54:57so there's a lot of like contextual and
- 54:59situational times when you may prescribe
- 55:01more than 1.6 and
- 55:03the research shows that it's not
- 55:04detrimental. You're not going to face
- 55:06kidney damage and
- 55:08anything crazy.
- 55:10Um and so there's really nothing wrong,
- 55:13but knowing why is important.
- 55:14>> Yeah.
- 55:16Um so that's 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein
- 55:19per kilogram of body weight, total body
- 55:21weight. Um
- 55:23and then I'm just going to for the
- 55:25Americans and Canadians actually use
- 55:27grams per pound too. I guess that would
- 55:29be like is that like 0.7 to 0.8 grams
- 55:32per pound of body weight, something like
- 55:34that? I could sure Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 55:36>> You're an American too.
- 55:37>> I know. But you're a scientist, so yeah,
- 55:38yeah, yeah.
- 55:39>> in kilos for
- 55:40>> Yeah, fair enough. So let's just think
- 55:42here if you weighed like what 70 kilos,
- 55:46what would that be like 135?
- 55:48>> Yeah.
- 55:49>> Is that right? Something like that
- 55:49around 130 grams a day. I feel like
- 55:51that's actually pretty good. Like I I
- 55:53actually don't hate just giving like a
- 55:55kind of a like a blanket recommendation
- 55:57for protein too, like 120 130 grams a
- 56:00day for most people's probably going to
- 56:01be pretty good unless you're like really
- 56:03tall, you might want a little bit more.
- 56:04But like for the most part like that's
- 56:07going to be you know four solid meals
- 56:11with like 30 grams of protein at least.
- 56:13And that's that's going to be like I
- 56:15think as close to optimal as you need to
- 56:17get. And then like if you're in a big
- 56:19deficit or like you said if you're a
- 56:20professional bodybuilder or like you
- 56:22know professional athlete and you're
- 56:23just like burning through energy like
- 56:25really lean, sure you could go a little
- 56:26higher. But like I feel like that's
- 56:28probably around optimal for most people.
- 56:30>> agree and that's just really what the
- 56:32research has shown and consistently it's
- 56:34been showing that. Now that's not to say
- 56:36that
- 56:37more is detrimental like for the most
- 56:39part, right? So we're not going to face
- 56:41kidney failure, you're not going to
- 56:43um gain a ton of extra weight and for
- 56:45some people it may even help with body
- 56:47composition due to just like satiety of
- 56:49protein.
- 56:50>> Mhm.
- 56:51>> Keeping you full longer, um the lower
- 56:54tendency of overeating it, that may be
- 56:56also beneficial for someone that is
- 56:58working on their body composition. So
- 57:00maybe you do opt to go for 1.8 1.9 2
- 57:04grams per kilo of protein a day versus
- 57:07something lower and increase your carbon
- 57:09fat intake because maybe tend to overeat
- 57:11the carbon fat intake and maybe you just
- 57:13feel fuller with your protein options.
- 57:16Um and so I don't think it's dangerous
- 57:17to recommend more, but
- 57:20it could be again like
- 57:22not there's no really like muscle gain
- 57:25advantage when we're specifically
- 57:26talking about muscle gain.
- 57:27>> Yeah. I kind of messed up the math on
- 57:28that. Let me
- 57:29>> Yeah. You're good.
- 57:31>> I think it actually went higher than
- 57:32normal cuz like that is usually what I
- 57:34say like or
- 57:34>> * 1.6
- 57:35>> * 1.6
- 57:37>> Yeah, it should be right around
- 57:39one
- 57:40108 I think. Yeah, 112. So so I feel I
- 57:43feel like but like let's just say so
- 57:45let's just say you were I'm so much
- 57:47better with pounds. Well, let's say
- 57:48you're 130 lb woman um 130 would be so
- 57:54that'd be like around let's just say
- 57:55around 60 kilos, right? Um and you said
- 57:581.2 to so 1.2 would only be 72 g of
- 58:02protein a day and then 60 * 1.6 would be
- 58:0696. So like you're looking at like 72
- 58:09100 g. I mean like typically for people
- 58:11who have like muscle building goals,
- 58:13like would would would you say it would
- 58:14you say that that's enough? Like it
- 58:16sounds It sounds kind of low, right?
- 58:18Yeah. I actually think it sounds kind of
- 58:20low instinctively. Um
- 58:22the research shows that it's enough.
- 58:24>> Yeah.
- 58:25>> Would I personally
- 58:29on a maybe more personal anecdotal
- 58:31practical
- 58:34note
- 58:35think that's kind of low and maybe
- 58:38you know recommend a little higher?
- 58:39Yeah, personally for me.
- 58:41I just think it helps with satiety and
- 58:44not overeating the other macronutrients
- 58:45that are much easier to overeat. I
- 58:46always tell my class when we talk about
- 58:48protein and like macronutrient
- 58:50distribution, have you ever sat down to
- 58:53eat grilled chicken and felt like you
- 58:55couldn't stop? [laughter]
- 58:57I wish I had that problem, but have you
- 58:58ever sat down and eaten a bag of potato
- 59:00chips and felt like you can't stop,
- 59:01right? And so I think that has
- 59:03some merit to it and some some
- 59:05application when you're talking about
- 59:07individuals and how we prescribe or how
- 59:09we um advise on macronutrient intake.
- 59:12And so I think that's something to think
- 59:14about and that's kind of the that art
- 59:15form of like, okay, this is what the
- 59:16science says, but how can we apply it?
- 59:18And when you think about, okay, this is
- 59:20what the science science says, 1.2 to
- 59:211.6,
- 59:23my brain would instinctively go to,
- 59:25okay, but what if I wanted to am I going
- 59:27to hurt someone by saying 1.8 to 2.0 g
- 59:30per kilo?
- 59:32The research has been done and you're
- 59:33not. So
- 59:34>> True.
- 59:34>> when we go to apply it, it's safe to say
- 59:37that. And so you could say that and say,
- 59:38hey,
- 59:39it may not yield more muscle mass or
- 59:43greater muscle mass recovery or whatever
- 59:46kind of performance-ish goal you may be
- 59:49searching when it comes to skeletal
- 59:50muscle mass, but it may help you with
- 59:52satiety. It may help you with um overall
- 59:55caloric intake. It may help you with
- 59:57XYZ. And so
- 59:59that's kind of the beauty of it is like
- 1:00:00we can test, we can have hypotheses and
- 1:00:02test them and then say, hey, we're not
- 1:00:04hurting anybody by saying this. So yeah.
- 1:00:07>> True, true, true. I think that is a
- 1:00:08common myth as well is that you think if
- 1:00:09you eat too much protein, it's going to
- 1:00:10be bad for your kidneys, bones, whatever
- 1:00:13it is.
- 1:00:13Um
- 1:00:15yeah. The only downside then of like
- 1:00:17hedging higher is like it is more
- 1:00:18expensive and I think a lot of people
- 1:00:20just like find it annoying to have to
- 1:00:22get that much protein and like you kind
- 1:00:23of run out of sources. Um so I think
- 1:00:25it's good to know that like, yeah, you
- 1:00:27can optimize with like 1.2 to 1.6 g per
- 1:00:30kilo. Again, if you're trying to do this
- 1:00:32like very seriously on an advanced
- 1:00:33level, maybe air towards the upper end,
- 1:00:36I would say, or perhaps even a little
- 1:00:37higher is safe, but you don't need to.
- 1:00:39Um yeah.
- 1:00:40>> actually some data that supports I mean,
- 1:00:42they have fed people like an overfeeding
- 1:00:44pro I think
- 1:00:45I know Dr. Jose Antonio is involved in
- 1:00:46all this. Um
- 1:00:48and there is data to support even 4.4 g
- 1:00:52per kilo.
- 1:00:52>> that. I know. Crazy.
- 1:00:53>> That's crazy.
- 1:00:54>> Mhm.
- 1:00:54>> But no detrimental effects, nothing with
- 1:00:57the kidneys. I mean, it's wild. And just
- 1:01:00so again, like on a personal level, if
- 1:01:02like you said, if you're super intensely
- 1:01:04training, if you
- 1:01:07want to just err on the side of caution,
- 1:01:08then go ahead, eat the 2.2, eat the 3.2
- 1:01:11for all that matters. [clears throat] Um
- 1:01:14but you're right, it's expensive and
- 1:01:15it's annoying and it's not as tasty and
- 1:01:18it's not necessary.
- 1:01:20>> Yes. Yeah, true, true. Okay. And then
- 1:01:22the other one that I hear quite a bit
- 1:01:24with uh women is like women need to
- 1:01:26avoid carbs. Like carbs are really bad.
- 1:01:28They're going to make you fat.
- 1:01:29>> Yeah.
- 1:01:29>> Any truth to that?
- 1:01:30>> No, no, no, no. The demonization of the
- 1:01:33macronutrients is wild. Like we went
- 1:01:35from the from demonizing [snorts] fat
- 1:01:37and then demonizing carbs and like
- 1:01:38what's next? Like I'm sure protein is
- 1:01:40going to get the bad rep one day. I
- 1:01:41don't know.
- 1:01:42>> It does though, like we just said with
- 1:01:43the bones and kidneys and stuff. So
- 1:01:45yeah, they
- 1:01:46>> It's always something. It's always
- 1:01:47something. But
- 1:01:48it's
- 1:01:50not directly
- 1:01:52the carbs that are bad, right? It's not
- 1:01:54that anything's bad, but it's not
- 1:01:55directly if the carbs are going to make
- 1:01:57you gain weight. It is the amount of
- 1:02:00whatever we're consuming that would
- 1:02:02cause weight gain. And so
- 1:02:04like I actually just said earlier in
- 1:02:05like the example of the chicken and the
- 1:02:07potato chips, what are you going to tend
- 1:02:08to overeat more?
- 1:02:10Right? And what often gets paired
- 1:02:11together? Carbs and fat. And we know
- 1:02:12that fat carry more calories per gram.
- 1:02:14So
- 1:02:15therefore increasing caloric intake
- 1:02:17quickly, exponentially almost. And so
- 1:02:20how it's not the carbs the carbs are not
- 1:02:24the bad guys. They're just potentially
- 1:02:25the vessel for the
- 1:02:28consequences that you may not want if
- 1:02:29that's not your goal.
- 1:02:30>> Yes. Now I will continue to play devil's
- 1:02:33advocate.
- 1:02:34>> love this. No, this is great. I love
- 1:02:35this.
- 1:02:36>> Um like I think I've seen that like
- 1:02:38there is a psychological preference
- 1:02:41where women tend to prefer sweeter foods
- 1:02:45and men tend to prefer savory foods.
- 1:02:46That's at least
- 1:02:47>> Yeah, yeah.
- 1:02:48>> true in like most of my experience. So
- 1:02:50like could it be that it's like no,
- 1:02:52carbs are not making you fat directly,
- 1:02:54but like indirectly if you know that
- 1:02:57like ice cream is something that you
- 1:02:58really, really love, then like yeah,
- 1:03:01that could be making you fat if you're
- 1:03:02overeating it, right?
- 1:03:04>> totally. And that but that's applicable
- 1:03:05across sexes, right? Men and women. So
- 1:03:07>> But if women do prefer sweets more, then
- 1:03:09like that could be where that comes
- 1:03:11from, right? Because it's like
- 1:03:12chocolate, ice cream, candy, whatever,
- 1:03:15like those are sweet foods. If women
- 1:03:16like those more, ipso facto, they might
- 1:03:19be more likely to overeat on them. So,
- 1:03:20be more careful with those if assuming
- 1:03:22your goal is fat loss. Whereas men,
- 1:03:24you know, tend savory foods. So, it's
- 1:03:26like french fries, potato chips,
- 1:03:27burgers, pizza. Like be more cautious
- 1:03:30with those. Be aware of those. Like, you
- 1:03:32know, that that might be the the kind of
- 1:03:34like
- 1:03:35glimmer of truth in that myth, I guess,
- 1:03:37if there is one.
- 1:03:37>> Cassie Evans does a lot of This is like
- 1:03:39her dissertation. This is where she That
- 1:03:40was actually her section in the paper is
- 1:03:42she's she's the expert on that
- 1:03:45on like the preferential
- 1:03:47>> Mhm.
- 1:03:47>> foods between men and women. And you're
- 1:03:49totally right. Like there there is some
- 1:03:51merit to that and there's definitely
- 1:03:53some merit to the hormonal fluctuations
- 1:03:56that can impact appetite across the
- 1:03:58lifespan. Whether it's across your
- 1:03:59menstrual cycle or across different like
- 1:04:01a female's lifespan, perimenopause,
- 1:04:03menopause, and like estrogen dropping
- 1:04:05and
- 1:04:06appetite suppression or not suppression,
- 1:04:08right? So, there's some merit there for
- 1:04:10sure.
- 1:04:12Um but again, it can kind of extend
- 1:04:13across both sexes, too. But yeah.
- 1:04:15>> Yeah. And it ultimately just comes back
- 1:04:17to eating more, right? Because I think
- 1:04:19that's like I don't want to go too far
- 1:04:21down this rabbit hole, but like with the
- 1:04:22like Ozempic and like the other GLP-1
- 1:04:24data, like what does it do? It makes you
- 1:04:26eat less, right? So, it's like and it
- 1:04:28works. It works. Like you don't have to
- 1:04:30split it out based on like whether
- 1:04:31you're a carb sensitive or fat sensitive
- 1:04:34or if you're a sweets person or a savory
- 1:04:36person. Like
- 1:04:37take the GLP-1, your appetite goes down,
- 1:04:39you lose weight on average. Obviously,
- 1:04:40there's tons of terms and conditions
- 1:04:42and, you know, don't do it without a
- 1:04:43doctor's blah blah blah. But like I
- 1:04:45still I still feel like like at this
- 1:04:47point, it would be hard to deny that
- 1:04:49it's like energy balance and caloric
- 1:04:50intake that's driving this. It's not
- 1:04:52like no, women can't eat carbs because
- 1:04:54it just suddenly gets turned to fat.
- 1:04:55It's like no, no, it will get turned to
- 1:04:56fat if you overeat. But like that's what
- 1:04:58it comes down to.
- 1:04:59>> yeah, yeah, right, right, right.
- 1:05:00>> Okay. All right. That's good. Um so,
- 1:05:02let's let's quickly cover supplements.
- 1:05:03>> Yeah.
- 1:05:04>> Um I think the main one I see Uh there's
- 1:05:07a few that come to mind, but I think the
- 1:05:09big one is creatine. Like women
- 1:05:11shouldn't take creatine because it'll
- 1:05:13make you bloated or
- 1:05:14>> Right, right, right, right.
- 1:05:15>> make you manly or something.
- 1:05:16>> Right, right.
- 1:05:17Dr. Abby Smith Ryan, she is the goat
- 1:05:19when it comes to this stuff and her lab
- 1:05:21is such amazing work, um, specifically
- 1:05:23in creatine and across the female
- 1:05:25lifespan. She also has this really
- 1:05:27awesome paper in JISSN
- 1:05:29um, about creatine across the female
- 1:05:30lifespan.
- 1:05:32Um, so
- 1:05:33she's a queen and an expert on all this
- 1:05:35stuff. But
- 1:05:36um
- 1:05:37no, women don't respond less favorably
- 1:05:40to creatine supplementation just simply
- 1:05:42because they are women. So
- 1:05:44um when it comes to the bloating claim
- 1:05:47that
- 1:05:49got blown out of proportion, right? That
- 1:05:51is simply the bloating claim stems from
- 1:05:54just intracellular water and water
- 1:05:57creatine promoting this, therefore kind
- 1:06:01of helping also give you this appearance
- 1:06:03of like
- 1:06:05toned muscle, more muscle, more
- 1:06:08mass to the naked eye, but not always
- 1:06:09cuz when you do like body contesting,
- 1:06:11there's water and what not. So
- 1:06:13um that's where that comes from and
- 1:06:17it's unfortunate because it has created
- 1:06:19this like bubble of fear around creatine
- 1:06:23and women taking it when there are so
- 1:06:26many awesome benefits
- 1:06:27especially for just aging and across a
- 1:06:31lifespan.
- 1:06:32>> Mhm.
- 1:06:33>> So no, women will not become bulky or
- 1:06:36manly or bloated from taking creatine.
- 1:06:38If anything, it will help you with the
- 1:06:40opposite, right? It'll help you
- 1:06:42achieve this toned look, which we know
- 1:06:44toned is really only all that body
- 1:06:46composition, right? Increase muscle
- 1:06:48mass, decrease fat mass, um and creatine
- 1:06:50can help with that. Creatine can help
- 1:06:51with bone, um mitigate bone loss and
- 1:06:54increase um mass across the lifespan,
- 1:06:56especially when combined with resistance
- 1:06:58training. Um, there's some awesome
- 1:06:59papers showing that
- 1:07:01uh where like
- 1:07:03I think I don't I can't remember the age
- 1:07:04group, but it was
- 1:07:06late later aged women there was a group
- 1:07:08taking creatine, no exercise, creatine
- 1:07:11resistance training, and just resistance
- 1:07:13training, and the bone mineral density
- 1:07:16increases
- 1:07:17between all the groups are
- 1:07:20different, but much more advantageous
- 1:07:21for the people taking creatine and
- 1:07:23combining it with their resistance
- 1:07:25training in later later later
- 1:07:28um aged women. And that's so cool. Like
- 1:07:30we used to think that creatine was just
- 1:07:32for bodybuilders or for the science bros
- 1:07:34and for the lifters, but now we're
- 1:07:36seeing some really cool stuff come out
- 1:07:38about its advantages for
- 1:07:41women later in life, women now, women
- 1:07:43training. Um and yeah, this the bloating
- 1:07:45claim has just been blown out of
- 1:07:47proportion. It's really not true.
- 1:07:49>> Yeah. And and also uh cognitive benefits
- 1:07:53too.
- 1:07:53>> Right. There's a ton of stuff that has
- 1:07:55benefits and brain is a metabolically
- 1:07:58expensive organ and creatine is just
- 1:08:01so beneficial because it can cross that
- 1:08:03blood brain barrier and so we have seen
- 1:08:05these cognitive effects now.
- 1:08:07We see them at really high doses though.
- 1:08:09>> Right, right, right.
- 1:08:10>> just at like three to five kind of daily
- 1:08:12gram, but they're there and it's very
- 1:08:15much in its infancy and that research
- 1:08:17line is so grown. Dr. uh Darren Candow
- 1:08:19is doing a ton of stuff and Scott Forbes
- 1:08:21um are also
- 1:08:23kind of like crusading that.
- 1:08:25Um yeah.
- 1:08:26>> Um okay. Now the on the watery claim
- 1:08:29like people are like oh it makes you
- 1:08:30look bloated and watery like definitely
- 1:08:32not true. Like the water it will store
- 1:08:35water as you said, but it's inside the
- 1:08:37muscle and it's like your muscles mostly
- 1:08:39water anyway. So like why do you care
- 1:08:40about it? Like yeah, you want muscles
- 1:08:42that water. It's not going to go under
- 1:08:43your skin and make you look all like
- 1:08:45flabby or anything like that. Um
- 1:08:49and then but I do I have seen that
- 1:08:53gastrointestinal distress is a fairly
- 1:08:56common side effect. So it's like I would
- 1:08:58have it can happen. So it's like if if
- 1:09:00you're experiencing that, I could see
- 1:09:02how you'd be like oh anytime I take
- 1:09:04this, I feel bloated, I get bloated. Do
- 1:09:06you know what I'm saying? So it could be
- 1:09:08from there as well.
- 1:09:09>> It could be. I would say that it's
- 1:09:11not super common, but it does happen and
- 1:09:13it can happen especially if maybe you're
- 1:09:14more just more sensitive to it, taking
- 1:09:16it on empty stomach, um maybe taking
- 1:09:19more than you think you are, etc. So I
- 1:09:21would say starting at 3 gram dose and if
- 1:09:25you can absolutely tolerate that five
- 1:09:26gram dose is usually the sweet spot and
- 1:09:29where we have the most literature to
- 1:09:31support that dosage. Um there are people
- 1:09:33that take 10 and there are people that
- 1:09:34take 20 grams a day. Yeah and they love
- 1:09:37it and they don't have any weird GI
- 1:09:39symptoms but that's also been like an
- 1:09:41overtime gradual increase and so
- 1:09:43I would say if you're going to take it
- 1:09:44start small.
- 1:09:45>> In my own experience with clients and
- 1:09:47myself the only time I've noticed any
- 1:09:49bloating like gastrointestinal
- 1:09:51gastrointestinal distress is during a
- 1:09:54loading phase where you are taking like
- 1:09:5520 grams but you don't need to load.
- 1:09:58Like you can just take three to five
- 1:09:59grams forever and you know I can just
- 1:10:02rapid fire through some of the myths
- 1:10:04here and if there's anything you want to
- 1:10:05add but like you don't need to cycle on
- 1:10:07and off it. It's not a steroid. It's
- 1:10:09naturally occurring in your body anyway.
- 1:10:11Your body naturally creates it. That
- 1:10:12doesn't necessarily mean it's safe but
- 1:10:14like it is something that your body's
- 1:10:15making anyway. It's the preferred source
- 1:10:17of energy for like any high intensity
- 1:10:19bouts so like if you're lifting a heavy
- 1:10:20weight it's the preferred energy source.
- 1:10:22It's going to be in any meat and fish
- 1:10:24that you eat anyway. Um
- 1:10:26it doesn't really matter I don't think
- 1:10:29when you take it. Some people suggest
- 1:10:30like post workout but I don't think that
- 1:10:32I think that's splitting hairs um and
- 1:10:33you should just stick with like straight
- 1:10:35creatine monohydrate. You don't need to
- 1:10:36get any of the fancy stuff and it
- 1:10:38doesn't matter if you take it with like
- 1:10:40carbs or just drink it with water and it
- 1:10:42doesn't give you an immediate benefit so
- 1:10:44like it probably takes about a month for
- 1:10:45it to like fully saturate your muscles
- 1:10:47and don't expect like a gigantic effect
- 1:10:50from it because I feel like yes it
- 1:10:52probably is the most researched and like
- 1:10:54the most efficacious supplement but at
- 1:10:55the same time it's still not like that
- 1:10:57crazy. Like don't expect and beware that
- 1:11:00like you know there seems to be
- 1:11:01responders and non-responders so
- 1:11:04if you don't get anything from it
- 1:11:06okay no big deal um and if you do though
- 1:11:10be prepared that like you might gain a
- 1:11:11pound or two after taking it from water
- 1:11:13retention.
- 1:11:14>> Yeah
- 1:11:14no big deal.
- 1:11:15>> No big deal. Yeah but it's but it's it's
- 1:11:17lean mass. Yeah yeah exactly.
- 1:11:19So
- 1:11:20okay so that's creatine.
- 1:11:21>> Love that. That's creatine.
- 1:11:24>> And then the other one myth I would say
- 1:11:26that I hear from women is they need like
- 1:11:28there're specific like women specific
- 1:11:31supplements and vitamins and this kind
- 1:11:32of thing. Like, is there anything to
- 1:11:34that?
- 1:11:35>> Yes, there is. Um, there is in the sense
- 1:11:39that different seasons of life will
- 1:11:40warrant different amounts of different
- 1:11:43micronutrients, right? Whether that's
- 1:11:46folic acid and choline during pregnancy
- 1:11:48or iron during I don't know for some of
- 1:11:51us like myself across my entire
- 1:11:52lifespan. Um, for some people maybe they
- 1:11:54have heavy menstrual bleeding and they
- 1:11:56do need supplement with iron.
- 1:11:58Um,
- 1:12:00so yes, there are different season of
- 1:12:02life that may warrant different kinds of
- 1:12:04supplementation protocols. I always say
- 1:12:06food first and then supplements if you
- 1:12:07know you're deficient in something. So
- 1:12:09uh I guess for myself specifically I
- 1:12:12know I'm deficient in iron and vitamin
- 1:12:13D. That's just what my blood work always
- 1:12:14consistently says, so I always
- 1:12:16supplement.
- 1:12:17Um, do I
- 1:12:19think that it's
- 1:12:20just cuz I'm a girl?
- 1:12:22Probably not. I mean I think it has a
- 1:12:24lot to do with my own personal just
- 1:12:25making and physiology.
- 1:12:27Um, so tests first, make an informed
- 1:12:29choice not just hey let me buy all these
- 1:12:31cool supplements off the counter. And
- 1:12:34where my
- 1:12:35beef with this question lies is like the
- 1:12:37pinkified movement, right? Like let's
- 1:12:39pinkify this creatine. This is women's
- 1:12:41creatine. It won't cause you to bloat.
- 1:12:43This is a women's specific supplement
- 1:12:45for hormone balancing. Take this if
- 1:12:47you're a woman just because like blanket
- 1:12:50statement. That is not true, right? And
- 1:12:53that's just not necessary. Um,
- 1:12:57again mostly just like my answer to the
- 1:12:59other ones it really just depends on the
- 1:13:00season of life and kind of what the
- 1:13:03your how you're making the decision,
- 1:13:05what's informing the decision, right?
- 1:13:06Supplementation
- 1:13:08just
- 1:13:10if you're just a healthy
- 1:13:12female and you're being compared to a
- 1:13:13healthy male,
- 1:13:15let's also say you're not pregnant and
- 1:13:17let's also say
- 1:13:19um
- 1:13:20your blood work comes back and you're
- 1:13:22not deficient anything. Same for the man
- 1:13:24is there
- 1:13:25a supplement that you should be taking
- 1:13:26just cuz you are a woman? Not
- 1:13:28necessarily.
- 1:13:29>> Right. So I think it comes back
- 1:13:31>> to again, just like treating people as
- 1:13:32individuals. So like, it's it's not
- 1:13:34necessarily Yeah, yeah. Cuz men can be
- 1:13:36deficient in iron as well.
- 1:13:37>> Absolutely.
- 1:13:38>> Um, and do you like iron supplements in
- 1:13:40those cases or would you say to like
- 1:13:42increase like your red meat or your like
- 1:13:44uh
- 1:13:46leafy green vegetable consumption?
- 1:13:48>> food first approach person and then
- 1:13:50However, that's not always attainable
- 1:13:51for people, right? If you're training a
- 1:13:52ton of hours a day, you don't like
- 1:13:54certain foods, can't get them down, you
- 1:13:57have an allergy, supplements play an
- 1:13:59awesome and critical role there. And
- 1:14:02that's when I would supplement with
- 1:14:03them. For myself personally, I
- 1:14:06even if I try to increase my red meat,
- 1:14:08even if I try to increase green
- 1:14:11vegetables, leafy vegetables to try to
- 1:14:13increase iron and whatnot, it doesn't
- 1:14:15seem to move the needle for me.
- 1:14:16>> Mhm.
- 1:14:17>> And whether that's like an absorption
- 1:14:18issue, whether that is just
- 1:14:20I'm not increasing them enough. I don't
- 1:14:23have the bandwidth or the appetite to
- 1:14:25eat more of them. Therefore,
- 1:14:26supplementation is my my route that I
- 1:14:29choose along with the diet modification.
- 1:14:31So yeah.
- 1:14:32>> Okay. This one I guess isn't like
- 1:14:34supplementation as much as like
- 1:14:35medication, but like contraceptives.
- 1:14:37>> Yeah.
- 1:14:38>> Do you think that there's anything that
- 1:14:40women need to like be aware of or make
- 1:14:43modifications to their training because
- 1:14:45of being on
- 1:14:47various forms of birth control?
- 1:14:48>> This is Alyssa Olenick, Dr. Alyssa
- 1:14:50Olenick's field of expertise and she
- 1:14:52wrote the section in this in the paper
- 1:14:53for that. She's amazing and her work on
- 1:14:55this is so awesome and
- 1:14:57she's the expert in this area and
- 1:14:58overall what
- 1:15:00the overarching body of evidence tells
- 1:15:02us is that there may be maybe very small
- 1:15:06variable
- 1:15:08performance
- 1:15:09potential detriments. They also may not
- 1:15:11be. Uh it's very variable across women,
- 1:15:13the types of contraceptives they can
- 1:15:15they are on take or whatever the case
- 1:15:17might be and it's really really hard to
- 1:15:21kind of standardize it and just pinpoint
- 1:15:25like the what's what else like nothing
- 1:15:27else is changing, just the
- 1:15:28contraceptive. Is that going to affect
- 1:15:30anything, right? It's multi-factorial on
- 1:15:31a day-to-day basis how we perform.
- 1:15:33Um
- 1:15:34so
- 1:15:35>> I think it's too soon to say that a
- 1:15:38specific contraceptive or all
- 1:15:40contraceptives will have performance or
- 1:15:42you will experience a performance
- 1:15:43decrement if you're on them. Too soon to
- 1:15:46say that. Um again, it boils down to
- 1:15:48just like an individual thing and I
- 1:15:50think it's a really
- 1:15:52potentially dicey topic that people need
- 1:15:55to make those decisions with their
- 1:15:57specific clinician
- 1:15:58>> Mhm.
- 1:15:59>> because there's a lot
- 1:16:01more to
- 1:16:04a woman than just her performance,
- 1:16:05right? And so depending on like her
- 1:16:08family planning issues and advice and
- 1:16:11timelines and what she wants to achieve,
- 1:16:13a teeny tiny change in performance may
- 1:16:17be minuscule and may not even matter in
- 1:16:19the grand scheme of it all. Like if she
- 1:16:21is trying to compete in in the Olympics,
- 1:16:24you know, in 2028
- 1:16:26and she needs to make sure that she
- 1:16:28doesn't get pregnant before then or
- 1:16:29whatever the case might be,
- 1:16:31she may opt for hormonal contraceptive
- 1:16:34even though she may have experienced
- 1:16:36some performance
- 1:16:37decrements in the past. Um so it's so so
- 1:16:40so individualized and it's a tough topic
- 1:16:43to
- 1:16:44to tease out a good answer.
- 1:16:47>> Mhm.
- 1:16:48>> So
- 1:16:48it's tough, but
- 1:16:49>> So would you would you say like, okay,
- 1:16:51someone is on birth control, hormonal
- 1:16:53birth control, like
- 1:16:55what what do you on average do you
- 1:16:57notice anything versus women who are not
- 1:17:00on it like when it comes to like muscle
- 1:17:01mass and like strength and training and
- 1:17:05this kind of
- 1:17:05>> Yeah, nothing consistently. Nothing
- 1:17:07where you can say this during this
- 1:17:10phase, this time, this birth control
- 1:17:13pill, this, whatever, this will for sure
- 1:17:16happen. That is we still can't say that
- 1:17:18definitively.
- 1:17:19>> And do you think And do you think you
- 1:17:20can't say that because there's just like
- 1:17:21isn't much research on it or is it that
- 1:17:23like there's just too much variability
- 1:17:25between people?
- 1:17:25>> sure. It's still kind of like a newer
- 1:17:27thing that's being looked at and
- 1:17:29researched.
- 1:17:30Um but also so much individual
- 1:17:32variability.
- 1:17:33>> Yeah. And would you say that it's like
- 1:17:35if there is an it sounds like you're
- 1:17:37like hinting towards it like being
- 1:17:38slightly negative at least from like a
- 1:17:40performance standpoint?
- 1:17:42>> Uh yeah, that's kind of what I've read
- 1:17:44and seen
- 1:17:46that people are that that has come up.
- 1:17:49Like small teeny tiny effects that are
- 1:17:50like potentially could be detrimental
- 1:17:53during this time for
- 1:17:55I don't know, muscle mass retention and
- 1:17:58whatnot. So
- 1:17:59yeah.
- 1:18:00>> And do you think that would be more of
- 1:18:01like a
- 1:18:03physiological difference or is it like
- 1:18:05psychological? Like I know some women on
- 1:18:06birth control will have like more
- 1:18:08depressed mood and like lower energy
- 1:18:11especially initially. Like
- 1:18:13would you say it's more that or is it
- 1:18:14something that's going on like
- 1:18:15hormonally under the hood?
- 1:18:17>> I think it's a combination for sure and
- 1:18:19I also think that
- 1:18:22we have to
- 1:18:23and my my brain works in like net
- 1:18:25output. So like
- 1:18:27if let's say in a hypothetical situation
- 1:18:31there are
- 1:18:33um there is decreased performance
- 1:18:34because you are on the hormonal
- 1:18:36contraceptive. Let's just say that. But
- 1:18:38let's say you don't know or realize or
- 1:18:40it's so small you don't even noticed and
- 1:18:43you are essentially able to like
- 1:18:45override that psychologically, right?
- 1:18:47The net outcome here is
- 1:18:50I will perform and I'm going to still do
- 1:18:52it well. It essentially is not going to
- 1:18:54affect my performance. And so
- 1:18:56that is I think
- 1:19:00kind of how we look at that right now.
- 1:19:01Like women will
- 1:19:03perform regardless and the change isn't
- 1:19:04large enough that it's affecting
- 1:19:06performance. Whether it's physiological
- 1:19:08or psychological, I think it's a mixture
- 1:19:10of all of it all
- 1:19:11all of it together. Um and I think the
- 1:19:13net outcome here is that
- 1:19:15performance is still going to happen and
- 1:19:17it's still going to happen well and
- 1:19:18people on hormonal contraceptives at the
- 1:19:20Olympics and in big training events and
- 1:19:22during big competitions and
- 1:19:25we still see awesome things happening
- 1:19:26and world records being broken and
- 1:19:28whatnot. So
- 1:19:29[snorts] yeah, I think just the effect
- 1:19:31is not large enough to even make any
- 1:19:32conclusion.
- 1:19:33>> Based on the science, is there any like
- 1:19:35warnings against contraceptives that you
- 1:19:37like wouldn't use because of a training
- 1:19:39reason or a body composition reason? Or
- 1:19:41do you feel like honestly like the the
- 1:19:43approved and common ones are like
- 1:19:46probably not going to have a big enough
- 1:19:47impact on your training that like if you
- 1:19:49feel it's appropriate for you then like
- 1:19:50there's no you know
- 1:19:53ill advising from me.
- 1:19:55>> the latter. That's how I feel. It's just
- 1:19:57if it's appropriate for you
- 1:19:58there's nothing from what I've read and
- 1:20:00looked at and the awesome experts that
- 1:20:02I've talked to that have written these
- 1:20:05portions of this paper there is really
- 1:20:07nothing that I could say that should
- 1:20:09deter you from taking whatever
- 1:20:12contraceptive you choose to take for
- 1:20:14your personal life that could affect
- 1:20:15your performance. So I would say
- 1:20:17whatever is best for you works for your
- 1:20:19life. There's just nothing convincing
- 1:20:20enough for me to say you should not
- 1:20:22consume that or it will have this effect
- 1:20:23on you.
- 1:20:24>> That would have been a good clip if you
- 1:20:25said it though.
- 1:20:26>> That would have been great clickbait.
- 1:20:28>> [laughter]
- 1:20:29>> All right.
- 1:20:30So I I know we touched on the metabolism
- 1:20:32stuff a little bit with training but
- 1:20:35like I want to see if there's a more
- 1:20:37specific angle to this. So the best
- 1:20:39research I have seen
- 1:20:41shows that like
- 1:20:43people massively overestimate how much
- 1:20:45your metabolism slows down as you age.
- 1:20:47Like there really is like a slight
- 1:20:48decline but it seems to be mostly due to
- 1:20:51just changes in activity. Like people
- 1:20:53are just not as active as they get into
- 1:20:54their like thirties and forties and
- 1:20:55fifties.
- 1:20:56>> Yeah.
- 1:20:57>> And then I think after around like
- 1:20:59sixty-five there does tend to be like a
- 1:21:01bit more of a downward slope and that
- 1:21:03might be
- 1:21:04more
- 1:21:06I'll say like biological clock related
- 1:21:09as opposed to
- 1:21:11behavioral in terms of activity related.
- 1:21:14Would you say that same trend is true
- 1:21:16for women? Like yeah yeah.
- 1:21:18>> I would say the same trend is true.
- 1:21:21Like you said as we age a lot of the
- 1:21:23research doesn't support your metabolism
- 1:21:25like massively declining, right? And so
- 1:21:27when I
- 1:21:28I actually love this like teaching this
- 1:21:30in class because it's
- 1:21:32I ask the students all the time often in
- 1:21:34exercise science a lot of my students
- 1:21:35are also student athletes because it
- 1:21:37just seems to go together.
- 1:21:40And I would ask them like what do you
- 1:21:40think your life's to look like if you
- 1:21:42don't play professional sports? Like,
- 1:21:43when you graduate? Like, what's it going
- 1:21:44to look like? Oh, I'm going to get a
- 1:21:45job. I'm going to start a family. Like,
- 1:21:47okay, cool. So, what does it a nine to
- 1:21:49five? What does a
- 1:21:50nine to nine look like for you then?
- 1:21:51Like, oh, go to work, you know, hang out
- 1:21:53with my family, whatever. And then what
- 1:21:55does that same day look like for you
- 1:21:56now? Oh, wake up, train, walk around
- 1:21:59campus, go to class, train again, go
- 1:22:02here, walk there, go to film, go out and
- 1:22:04party all night long. I mean, on your
- 1:22:06feet a ton, right? You're expending so
- 1:22:08much more energy whether you know it or
- 1:22:10you don't. And so that is the the
- 1:22:13biggest driver of just inactivity or
- 1:22:15like the activity imbalance as we get
- 1:22:18older. And so
- 1:22:20it's not directly your metabolism, but
- 1:22:22it's the things that you do that will
- 1:22:24therefore affect your potential
- 1:22:26metabolism. And then your body
- 1:22:27composition, right? Like we talked about
- 1:22:29with men and women and just lean mass.
- 1:22:31Um
- 1:22:33as we age, like you said, like
- 1:22:34metabolism does dip
- 1:22:37in those later years, like 60, 70, like
- 1:22:38once we get older, but that probably has
- 1:22:40a lot to do too with your body comp,
- 1:22:42right? And sarcopenia and osteoporosis
- 1:22:44and all these things that basically
- 1:22:46diminish our tissue bank, which
- 1:22:47therefore affect our, you know, um
- 1:22:51metabolic rates. And so
- 1:22:54I think the main point of a lot of these
- 1:22:57questions is there's really no one bad
- 1:22:59guy to blame, right? It's not your
- 1:23:00metabolism. It's not your woman. It's
- 1:23:02not that you're a male or man or
- 1:23:04whatever. Um it's just multi-factorial.
- 1:23:07There's so many things that need to be
- 1:23:08addressed and so many reasons why one
- 1:23:10thing may happen and so many reasons why
- 1:23:12it may not.
- 1:23:13>> Yeah.
- 1:23:14Um
- 1:23:17I think like someone who is like
- 1:23:19frustrated with like their metabolism or
- 1:23:21like, you know, they're they're not
- 1:23:22getting to the weight loss that they
- 1:23:24want to, like
- 1:23:25I think it's good
- 1:23:27psychologically to like have something
- 1:23:29to blame. That's like, oh, it's because
- 1:23:30my metabolism's broken. It's because I'm
- 1:23:31getting older. It's because I you know,
- 1:23:34I just can't eat carbs. Like, you know,
- 1:23:36there's there's a thing. So it's like
- 1:23:37what do you say then to someone like
- 1:23:39that who like is struggling? Like, you
- 1:23:41know, what what's the like empowering
- 1:23:43message? Because it's like, no, it's not
- 1:23:44that. No, no, it's not that. No, it's
- 1:23:46not that. It's like, okay, well, then
- 1:23:47why why am I struggling to get to where
- 1:23:48I want to be?
- 1:23:49>> They're not wrong. Like they're they're
- 1:23:51not wrong. It is cuz you're getting
- 1:23:52older. Like but
- 1:23:54how can we control what can we control
- 1:23:57besides our actual biological age,
- 1:23:59right? So you're getting older and so
- 1:24:01you're therefore sitting more. So how
- 1:24:03can we sit less, right? Or you're
- 1:24:05getting older so you are have way more
- 1:24:08responsibilities. It's difficult to cook
- 1:24:11your own food. You're tending to eat out
- 1:24:12more, therefore increasing
- 1:24:14total
- 1:24:16caloric intake. How can we
- 1:24:18not do that? How can we potentially give
- 1:24:21you
- 1:24:22how take something off of your plate so
- 1:24:23that maybe you can cook at home more? Or
- 1:24:25how can we maybe shop for pre-made meals
- 1:24:27that are already cooked in, you know,
- 1:24:29not and healthier for you or fit your
- 1:24:31goals better?
- 1:24:33Um so it's less about being like, no,
- 1:24:35you're wrong. That's not why. It's more
- 1:24:36about you're actually right, but there
- 1:24:38are things we can still do. Like you're
- 1:24:40right. You are getting older and it is
- 1:24:41getting harder. That's very true, but
- 1:24:43maybe not exactly for
- 1:24:46like that's not that you're right, but
- 1:24:47that's might not be the exact reason.
- 1:24:49And sometimes the exact reason doesn't
- 1:24:50really matter to, you know, the average
- 1:24:52person. They just they objectively they
- 1:24:54see what's happening and they they
- 1:24:56notice it and they just want help and
- 1:24:57that's what they hire coaches for. Like,
- 1:24:59hey, you know why this is happening.
- 1:25:01Help me. And that's really it. Like
- 1:25:03people are not wrong. They're totally
- 1:25:04right. They are experiencing these
- 1:25:05things because they're getting older.
- 1:25:07Um
- 1:25:08so yeah, I don't you're right. Like
- 1:25:09sometimes coaches can dismiss,
- 1:25:11especially in the science world where
- 1:25:13everyone's like, oh, the answer to this
- 1:25:14is this and you're wrong.
- 1:25:15It's it's can be really dismissive and
- 1:25:17discouraging. It doesn't always have to
- 1:25:19be the case and people are right. They
- 1:25:21just
- 1:25:21>> Yeah.
- 1:25:21>> there's
- 1:25:22different ways to address it.
- 1:25:23>> I think one of the like issues with the
- 1:25:25science in this is that like it is
- 1:25:26reporting averages and so like there
- 1:25:28very well could be like if you were to
- 1:25:29just zero in on one person in this study
- 1:25:31with 100 people, like it could actually
- 1:25:34be like an instance where like
- 1:25:37some of the concerns you have are valid,
- 1:25:39but like it's not going to show up on
- 1:25:41the total level, but like when speaking
- 1:25:43broadly you have to start with the total
- 1:25:45level. And I think infinitely worse to
- 1:25:47do the opposite where you take like one
- 1:25:49person's experience experience and then
- 1:25:51flip that onto everybody. And it's like,
- 1:25:52oh, I need to avoid XYZ and I'm messed
- 1:25:54up because of it. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 1:25:56yeah. Um now and I do agree like I think
- 1:25:58that that that is the empowering message
- 1:26:01in the metabolism stuff is like it's
- 1:26:03actually more within your control than
- 1:26:04you think. It's not that like you're
- 1:26:05getting old therefore your metabolism is
- 1:26:07wrecked. It's like you're getting older
- 1:26:10and and you're probably just not moving
- 1:26:12around as much. Like you're not doing as
- 1:26:13much activity. You're not exercising as
- 1:26:14much. So like you can just exercise more
- 1:26:16and offset that. So
- 1:26:17>> yeah, yeah. There's so many different
- 1:26:19tools to make to increase adherence too,
- 1:26:21right? Like hey, you're getting older.
- 1:26:23There's a lot of thing I've experienced
- 1:26:24it myself. There's just so many things
- 1:26:26on our plate that we have to juggle on a
- 1:26:27daily basis. Getting consistent exercise
- 1:26:29or just even increasing our activities
- 1:26:31of daily living like just walking more.
- 1:26:33Like I walk way less than I did when I
- 1:26:34was in college walking around campus all
- 1:26:35day long. Um it gets
- 1:26:38increasingly difficult as we age and
- 1:26:39that's just the world and the culture we
- 1:26:41live in. And so
- 1:26:42being a coach and working with real
- 1:26:44humans forces you to like look at that
- 1:26:47and kind of this art form. Like how can
- 1:26:49I help this person just like kind of put
- 1:26:51this build this into their life in a
- 1:26:53manageable [clears throat] way but
- 1:26:54they'll adhere to it? Cuz I could easily
- 1:26:56tell you just work out more and eat
- 1:26:58less. Like that's but that's not
- 1:26:59applicable. That's not doesn't
- 1:27:01work
- 1:27:02for everybody. There's so many other
- 1:27:03things that you know we have to
- 1:27:05consider. And so yeah.
- 1:27:07>> Um now going back to like the person who
- 1:27:09is like okay, well like what is it then?
- 1:27:11Because I find like I find with women
- 1:27:14probably more than men, also men though
- 1:27:16like there there seems to be this like
- 1:27:17frustration or there's this like gap
- 1:27:19between like what you want your body to
- 1:27:20look like and where it currently is. And
- 1:27:23you're working really hard and you're
- 1:27:25dieting and all these things but you're
- 1:27:26still not able to get here
- 1:27:28>> Yeah.
- 1:27:28>> um to where you want to be.
- 1:27:30And um
- 1:27:31I think there's like a few things there
- 1:27:33like I think I think part of it is like
- 1:27:36what we talked about earlier with the
- 1:27:37standards where it's like you might just
- 1:27:39be trying to maintain a body that you
- 1:27:41just can't realistically sustain um
- 1:27:45without negative effects. Like you could
- 1:27:47probably sustain it if you just didn't
- 1:27:48eat, but like you're going to have like
- 1:27:50negative repercussions from that,
- 1:27:52obviously, right? So like maybe a goal
- 1:27:54shift where it's like you focus on like
- 1:27:55health and performance while still like,
- 1:27:57you know, you can still have physique
- 1:27:59goals, obviously, but maybe just like
- 1:28:01update them. Like realistically, I can't
- 1:28:03maintain 6% body fat as a man. Like I
- 1:28:05can't do it. It'd be cool. I can't do
- 1:28:06it. Like it's not worth it.
- 1:28:08>> There and there are people who Yeah,
- 1:28:10there are people who can, exactly, but
- 1:28:11like those shouldn't be the standards
- 1:28:12and I think that's a big part of where
- 1:28:14it comes from. Like people
- 1:28:16are less willing to like accept a body
- 1:28:19composition that is healthy,
- 1:28:21>> Yeah.
- 1:28:21>> productive, functional. Like you perform
- 1:28:25well, you feel good. Like okay, that's
- 1:28:27good. Like you're doing better than most
- 1:28:28people. line up with
- 1:28:30the aesthetic you have in your mind,
- 1:28:32then it's not good. But that's not true.
- 1:28:34Like sometimes it's just the the way
- 1:28:37that we want to look in our mind is
- 1:28:39shaped by so many like socio-cultural
- 1:28:41things that
- 1:28:42that it doesn't dictate good or bad or
- 1:28:44capabilities or potential at all. And so
- 1:28:46that's why I think hyper focusing on
- 1:28:48that
- 1:28:49leads us to that position of like why
- 1:28:51can't Nothing's working. What is it?
- 1:28:52Like why can't I look the way I want to
- 1:28:53look? Well, maybe you're just not
- 1:28:55destined to and we're all built really
- 1:28:57differently. There are genetic
- 1:28:58predispositions to all kinds of
- 1:29:00fat storage,
- 1:29:02um building muscle in certain areas,
- 1:29:04whatever the case might be. And I wish I
- 1:29:06had the answer and we had more answers
- 1:29:07to how we can like target all these
- 1:29:09things and create your perfect physique
- 1:29:11on the dime, but we just don't and
- 1:29:13there's just these dispositions that
- 1:29:14exist. And learning to learning that and
- 1:29:17learning to be okay with that
- 1:29:19is hard in today's day and age, but it's
- 1:29:21freeing and it 's empowering and you're
- 1:29:23just like okay, wait, I can
- 1:29:25feel really well. I can achieve really
- 1:29:27awesome things. I may not look
- 1:29:29the way that I want to or the world
- 1:29:32should want to perceive me, but that's
- 1:29:36really not important. And that changes
- 1:29:38era to era, right? Like many years ago,
- 1:29:40we were supposed to look a certain way
- 1:29:41and now today's day and age you're
- 1:29:43supposed to look a certain way. And in
- 1:29:4410 years, the female like cultural, you
- 1:29:47know, the way you're supposed to look is
- 1:29:48going to change again.
- 1:29:50So it's just a never-ending battle.
- 1:29:52>> I think that
- 1:29:52>> that's a good message for most people. I
- 1:29:54do think that there are some people who
- 1:29:55are like, yeah, but I'm a little
- 1:29:57overweight and I want to get down in
- 1:29:59weight a little bit and I'm struggling
- 1:30:00and
- 1:30:01when you're struggling, you're looking
- 1:30:02to look for something to blame and you
- 1:30:04know, we've been saying, okay, it's not
- 1:30:05that, it's not that, it's not that.
- 1:30:07>> Mhm.
- 1:30:07>> One thing that I think it probably is is
- 1:30:10like
- 1:30:10and and I don't know how you'll feel
- 1:30:11about this. I don't know sure how I feel
- 1:30:13about it. But like I think people expect
- 1:30:15to lose weight on more calories than
- 1:30:17they actually can eat. And I find like a
- 1:30:21lot of people are like, you know, you
- 1:30:22might see an influencer who has like a
- 1:30:24faster metabolic rate or has more muscle
- 1:30:26than you or is more active than you,
- 1:30:27like all these sorts of other genetic
- 1:30:29factors as well, who's eating like 2,500
- 1:30:32calories or 2,400 calories a day and
- 1:30:34they're losing weight on that and
- 1:30:35they're leaning they have the body that
- 1:30:36you want. It's like you might have to go
- 1:30:38lower than you expect and that's a harsh
- 1:30:42reality, but a reality nonetheless and
- 1:30:45then you have to make your own informed
- 1:30:46decision about like do you want to go
- 1:30:48that low on calories to get to your goal
- 1:30:50or do you want to set a new goal, right?
- 1:30:52Um but I think like having that
- 1:30:53information is important because
- 1:30:55I do think a lot of women in particular
- 1:30:57are misled by influencers who have like
- 1:31:00really genetically fast metabolic rates.
- 1:31:04>> or what I eat or
- 1:31:04>> and you're like, whoa, that's a lot of
- 1:31:06calories and it's like I can't do that.
- 1:31:08Is my metabolism broken? And it's like,
- 1:31:09no, I think if you look at like the
- 1:31:10average data, like maintenance intakes
- 1:31:13are lower than what you might expect.
- 1:31:16Now you can offset that by being more
- 1:31:17active and like, you know, doing these
- 1:31:18healthy habits and like maybe more
- 1:31:20closely monitoring what you eat and all
- 1:31:21those sorts of things. But like I do
- 1:31:24wish there was a little more
- 1:31:25transparency amongst like what it is you
- 1:31:27need to eat and like there is a certain
- 1:31:29level of like
- 1:31:32low calorie fear mongering a little bit.
- 1:31:35Like I'm not saying women should diet on
- 1:31:37low calories. That was like a this is a
- 1:31:38fine line here, but like but but at the
- 1:31:41same time like if if you're a woman and
- 1:31:43you have a goal of losing weight for
- 1:31:44your health or for aesthetic reasons or
- 1:31:46whatever,
- 1:31:46>> Yeah.
- 1:31:47>> I'm not going to tell you you can't do
- 1:31:48it. Like obviously. Like yeah, you can
- 1:31:50do it, but like at the same time you
- 1:31:52might need to diet harder and longer and
- 1:31:54on lower calories than you expect. And
- 1:31:56that's actually quite common.
- 1:31:57>> Yeah. And I
- 1:31:59I appreciate my bodybuilding days so
- 1:32:02much for this because
- 1:32:04I you like we learn this in bodybuilding
- 1:32:05the hard way. Like you you learn it
- 1:32:07doing it in the trenches, dieting on
- 1:32:10the lowest possible human calories you
- 1:32:13can
- 1:32:14for yourself on an individual individual
- 1:32:16basis. And
- 1:32:18you see it happen. Like you are shredded
- 1:32:20by the time showtime comes and you've
- 1:32:22been eating sometimes like feels like
- 1:32:24nothing. Like at least in the moment it
- 1:32:25feels like nothing.
- 1:32:26So you're right. And it's a hard subject
- 1:32:30to
- 1:32:32talk about cuz it's so emotionally
- 1:32:33charged. And it's
- 1:32:35but when you look at it objectively
- 1:32:39it it can it can be true. Like
- 1:32:41everyone's
- 1:32:42kind of
- 1:32:43lower
- 1:32:46like
- 1:32:47I don't know. What's it called? The
- 1:32:48floor
- 1:32:48>> Mhm.
- 1:32:49>> of caloric intake is different. And for
- 1:32:51some people, like you said, it might
- 1:32:52look like 2,500 calories and you can be
- 1:32:53shredded. That's awesome. For some
- 1:32:55people it's
- 1:32:571,600 calories. And that feels really
- 1:32:59low if that's not how you're normally
- 1:33:01eating. If you're consistently eating
- 1:33:022,000 calories and you feel great, but
- 1:33:04let's say you want to lose weight and
- 1:33:06you have to drop down to 1,600, that's
- 1:33:07going to feel like crazy like a drastic
- 1:33:09change.
- 1:33:10Um and that's again back to what you
- 1:33:12said. That's when you make your informed
- 1:33:14choice. Like is it worth it for me in my
- 1:33:16life? Like if do I have a competition
- 1:33:18coming up? Sure, it's worth it then. If
- 1:33:19I'm just doing it for what? Like to look
- 1:33:22a certain way? Is that worth it? Is it
- 1:33:24worth skipping out on family meals? Is
- 1:33:25it worth skipping out on going out with
- 1:33:27your friends? Like
- 1:33:29that's a personal decision. And you're
- 1:33:31right. I think more people need to know
- 1:33:32that. Like it it's tough to lose weight
- 1:33:35sometimes for some people. And
- 1:33:38you just have to kind of choose your
- 1:33:39health. Like do you want it? Is that
- 1:33:41what you want? And knowing why you have
- 1:33:43these goals is important cuz that is
- 1:33:45ultimately also what's going to drive it
- 1:33:46here. And it's
- 1:33:47>> Yeah. Yeah. That's great. Okay. I'm I'm
- 1:33:49happy to end there. Is there any other
- 1:33:51myth that is like just burning in your
- 1:33:53brain right now? No? Okay. So where So
- 1:33:55this paper is not out yet, but it's
- 1:33:57coming in soon. So maybe by the time the
- 1:33:58podcast comes out, it'll be out. If not,
- 1:34:00>> does the podcast come out?
- 1:34:01>> Um I'm not sure as of right now, but
- 1:34:03regardless, um I'll I'll put a link to
- 1:34:05it once it's out. And in the meantime,
- 1:34:07um I'll put links to where people can
- 1:34:08find you. So like your social media,
- 1:34:10website, all that kind of stuff.
- 1:34:12Um and I do have one more question that
- 1:34:14I do tend to ask guests, so this is a
- 1:34:15surprise question. Um
- 1:34:18what's something that you think is true
- 1:34:20but you don't currently have the
- 1:34:22scientific evidence to support it?
- 1:34:25You can think about it.
- 1:34:26>> Okay.
- 1:34:28Something that I think is true but don't
- 1:34:30have the evidence to support it.
- 1:34:33>> But you don't have the evidence yet.
- 1:34:34>> Yeah, no evidence yet.
- 1:34:36Um
- 1:34:37this one's not super exciting.
- 1:34:40I could come up with something exciting
- 1:34:41if you want me to, but this
- 1:34:43>> Whatever comes to mind.
- 1:34:44>> Yeah, we have been working on a trial
- 1:34:47with magnesium L-threonate. It's
- 1:34:48basically magnesium
- 1:34:51paired with L-threonic acid, the
- 1:34:52metabolite of vitamin C, and it's
- 1:34:54supposed to help shuttle that magnesium
- 1:34:55to the brain to like cross the blood
- 1:34:57brain barrier. And the blood brain
- 1:34:58barrier is strict. I think of it as like
- 1:34:59I teach it as like a It's like a strict
- 1:35:01security guard. Like you can't get past
- 1:35:03it unless you're like VIP. And magnesium
- 1:35:05doesn't tend to be VIP by itself, but
- 1:35:07when you pair it with L-threonate
- 1:35:08L-threonic acid, it gets in there. Or
- 1:35:10it's supposed to get in there. It's
- 1:35:12presumed, speculated. There's some like
- 1:35:15mechanistic stuff, and there's some
- 1:35:17rodent models that have shown that it
- 1:35:19can when it's paired with
- 1:35:21um L-threonic acid, which therefore can
- 1:35:23give like awesome cognitive benefits and
- 1:35:25better sleep and whatnot. Um we have not
- 1:35:28measured this directly. Nobody has in
- 1:35:30humans directly.
- 1:35:31We've done it indirectly, and we've
- 1:35:33shown
- 1:35:34cool cognitive effects, specifically
- 1:35:37under like mental fatigue. That's like
- 1:35:39our recent paper that we just is in in
- 1:35:41revision right now.
- 1:35:43Um
- 1:35:45but I think that it does. And do I have
- 1:35:47anything like super concrete or any real
- 1:35:49evidence? No, I don't. I just from some
- 1:35:52of the indirect stuff that we've done, I
- 1:35:53think that it has the potential to cross
- 1:35:55the blood brain barrier when it's in
- 1:35:57that like
- 1:35:58magnesium L-threonate form.
- 1:36:00Um,
- 1:36:01so it's
- 1:36:03and a lot of like supplement companies
- 1:36:05or there are supplement companies that
- 1:36:07claim that it does or say that it does,
- 1:36:08but we can't confidently say that in
- 1:36:10humans because it's never been tested in
- 1:36:11humans. And we need like MRS and whatnot
- 1:36:14to do that. So that's kind of what I
- 1:36:15want to mission to do is I want to
- 1:36:17mission to
- 1:36:18test it in humans and
- 1:36:21hopefully show that it does because we
- 1:36:22think that it does and it's
- 1:36:25marketed and sold as it does, but
- 1:36:28we don't actually know. Like we're
- 1:36:29assuming by indirect measurements, but I
- 1:36:31want to measure it directly because I
- 1:36:33think that it does, too, and I want to
- 1:36:34show that. And yeah, we'll see what the
- 1:36:36evidence actually says.
- 1:36:37>> magnesium before you sleep?
- 1:36:38>> Yeah.
- 1:36:38>> Yeah, I find it I find it creates a
- 1:36:41>> Yeah, I agree and I think it does. I
- 1:36:43also Okay, this is actually kind of a a
- 1:36:45decent take that I think is potentially
- 1:36:48true for me. So context dependent and
- 1:36:50hopefully it doesn't ruffle feathers,
- 1:36:51but
- 1:36:52I have a wonderful sleeping baby. She
- 1:36:55sleeps through the night. She's awesome
- 1:36:57and it's kind of like a unicorn baby
- 1:36:58because most babies don't sleep through
- 1:37:00the night when they're You know, she's 4
- 1:37:02months old now.
- 1:37:03Um,
- 1:37:05and people are like, what are you doing?
- 1:37:06Like how do you get a baby to sleep
- 1:37:07through the night? And the only My brain
- 1:37:09goes to this because I'm in this field
- 1:37:10and I study this, but
- 1:37:12I have a theory that because I take
- 1:37:15creatine and the magnesium L-threonate
- 1:37:17consistently, that it
- 1:37:19enters my bloodstream with which
- 1:37:20therefore enters my breast milk, which
- 1:37:22therefore enters my baby,
- 1:37:24which potentially causes her to sleep
- 1:37:25longer, sleep long stretches. Again,
- 1:37:28totally a theory, totally not backed by
- 1:37:30any real science as of now.
- 1:37:32>> the question.
- 1:37:32>> Just a theory that I think it's fun and
- 1:37:35if I were some kind of like
- 1:37:36pre-postnatal baby scientist, I don't
- 1:37:39know, maybe I'd look at that. But um,
- 1:37:41it's just my simple simple theory. Of
- 1:37:44course, there's probably so many other
- 1:37:45things that are at play here like her
- 1:37:46sleep environment and genetics, blah
- 1:37:48blah blah. But that's just my like small
- 1:37:50theory that no real data to support, but
- 1:37:53I think because I consistently take it
- 1:37:54that she sleeps well.
- 1:37:55>> I like it.
- 1:37:56All right, Antonella, thanks so much for
- 1:37:57coming on. I really appreciate it. It
- 1:37:58was great. It was really good. All
- 1:38:00right, and I'll I'll link everything
- 1:38:01down below um you guys want to check out
- 1:38:03her stuff. Um that was great. Um thank
- 1:38:05you guys so much for watching. Um and
- 1:38:07I'll see you all here in the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Busting Every Female Fitness Myth (ft. Antonella Schwarz PhD) by The Jeff Nippard Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 19,769 words across 3,152 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.