Brewers: Which Ones Do You Need? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00similar to how the home grinding Market
- 0:02has absolutely exploded Beyond
- 0:04Comprehension so has the dripper Market
- 0:06we have things like the Sofi which I do
- 0:08appreciate by my friends Aram we have
- 0:10the Ora look at that this is absurd what
- 0:14is the point of this is there actually
- 0:16that big of differences from Brewer to
- 0:18Brewer to necessitate kind of collecting
- 0:21them all like their Pokemon got to catch
- 0:22them all what I want to start off by
- 0:25talking about is the different styles of
- 0:27drippers and then kind of go through and
- 0:29and kind of talk about at least in my
- 0:30experience the differences that one can
- 0:33expect from dripper to dripper or from
- 0:35Style to
- 0:37Style the big kind of bifurcation that
- 0:40I'm going to make is more so of
- 0:42percolation Brew versus immersion Brew
- 0:45so with those if we kind of split them
- 0:47on one side it will look like this now
- 0:50as you see I actually have kind of three
- 0:51groups and it's because this middle
- 0:52section is kind of like the you know the
- 0:55ones that can't pick aide because this
- 0:56has a switch on it it can do immersion
- 0:58and percolation this one has a twisty
- 1:00bottom it can do immersion and
- 1:01percolation you kind of mix it up and of
- 1:03course the switch base can do that as
- 1:06well now the clever can but it is
- 1:08largely used as just like a filtered
- 1:10French press the bird can do some
- 1:11different things the air press obviously
- 1:13but we're just going to kind of look at
- 1:14that as immersion these is kind of like
- 1:16the middle men and then these are like
- 1:18mostly percolation now some of these
- 1:20will have bigger bodies like those that
- 1:22don't really use paper filters versus
- 1:24those that you know have really small
- 1:26holes in the bottom that are going to
- 1:27really limit the flow going through it
- 1:29versus ones that are are going to be
- 1:30heavy Clarity like a V60 or something
- 1:32along those
- 1:35[Music]
- 1:41lines now the flavor of say this is
- 1:43going to be closer to over here because
- 1:46they're using paper
- 1:48filters with immersion you're going to
- 1:50have a lot more kind of body into that
- 1:52beverage and the reason for that is is
- 1:54manifold but if you don't have a paper
- 1:56filter a lot of those oils that are
- 1:58usually filtered with paper are going
- 1:59going to be there you're going to have a
- 2:01lot more kind of micro particles that
- 2:02make it through that can bolster that
- 2:04body experience or that kind of uh
- 2:06texture experience in your mouth and
- 2:08you're going to have just a different
- 2:09extraction overall because you're not
- 2:10kind of plastering it with fresh solvent
- 2:12every every few seconds to like
- 2:14redistribute the bed and all this
- 2:16different stuff in order to maximize
- 2:19extraction and then of course when we
- 2:21add in paper filters you have different
- 2:23thicknesses and porosities of paper
- 2:25filters that kind of dictate the
- 2:26efficacy of them so those come into play
- 2:29and really change the game but even when
- 2:31you're using paper filters especially
- 2:33with immersion you'll still get kind of
- 2:35a more cloudy brew that is a bit heavier
- 2:37because a lot of those solubles the
- 2:38colloids Etc are able to really make it
- 2:40through that paper filter and into the
- 2:42final cup that bolsters that body and
- 2:44that really changes that cut profile
- 2:49completely I would be absolutely happy
- 2:51with just a V60 and maybe just an aor
- 2:54press for travel purposes now beyond
- 2:56that of course there are the different
- 2:57geometri so let's take a look at what
- 2:59that looks like
- 3:01we have kind of like semic conle here we
- 3:03have conle right here that's actually
- 3:06flat bottom so let's put that back where
- 3:07it should be hybrid situation where
- 3:09these are all flat bottom technically
- 3:11but they're not as straightforward as
- 3:14say these these flat bottoms are these
- 3:15cones so I have these kind of here
- 3:17because they're more no bypass style
- 3:18Brewers the flat bottom Brewers and over
- 3:21here we have more that immersion style
- 3:23uh Brew which is again flat bottom
- 3:25similar to these there is a very common
- 3:28understanding with flat bottom Brew is
- 3:29that they give you a more even
- 3:31extraction than com Brewers but in a
- 3:34specific test that was done in 2019 from
- 3:37Jonathan G's book physics of filter
- 3:38coffee under simulations where no bypass
- 3:41was assumed it was actually shown that
- 3:42overall conical drippers have a higher
- 3:45potential evenness of extraction than
- 3:47flat bottoms flat bottoms tend to
- 3:49extract very evenly that top layer but
- 3:51as it goes through it gets less and less
- 3:53extracted whereas horizontally the V60
- 3:55is inferior to to flat bottom drippers
- 3:57but overall has a bit more even raction
- 4:00throughout the whole
- 4:02bed when no bypass is assumed it looks
- 4:05like the V60 would actually give you
- 4:07that better or more even extraction pour
- 4:09and then I'll swirl now what I have
- 4:11noticed is actually somewhat similar to
- 4:13the results of the UC Davis experiment
- 4:16of semic conical versus flat now in the
- 4:18past and and still I've been very
- 4:20critical of that study and I think
- 4:21there's a lot of holes in it as well uh
- 4:23throughout the methodology and as how
- 4:25they you know actually carried out the
- 4:27experiment but I think that across Ross
- 4:29the board for the most part you will
- 4:31have a bit thinner body a bit higher
- 4:33Clarity a bit you know kind of more
- 4:35tealight coffee relatively speaking to
- 4:38that specific coffee against the flat
- 4:40bottom Brewer I think you could dial in
- 4:42to a higher threshold a more vibrant
- 4:45like flowery teal like coffee in a V60
- 4:48or something along those lines than you
- 4:50could in a flat bottom that doesn't mean
- 4:52you can't get almost there in these flat
- 4:54bottoms and vice
- 4:57versa I think this argument is similar
- 5:00to this whole cones vers flat debate in
- 5:02Grinders there are definitely different
- 5:05thresholds with each but that doesn't
- 5:07necessarily mean you're not going to get
- 5:09any Clarity with cones and you're not
- 5:10going to get any chocolate with Flats
- 5:12that's absolutely not
- 5:15correct whenever we're also looking at
- 5:17these we have to take into account these
- 5:19kind of hybrid Brew methods where we're
- 5:21doing some immersion and some
- 5:23percolation you have something like the
- 5:25next level Pulsar you have the Oro V4
- 5:27which has interchangeable bottoms and
- 5:29you have things like s Works which can
- 5:31give you the opportunity to turn off the
- 5:33Flow by twisting the base of this now
- 5:36these are very fun to play around with
- 5:38you can really maximize extraction if
- 5:39that's what you're wanting to do you can
- 5:41do the blooming period without wasting
- 5:43any water if that's the only time you're
- 5:45wanting to use of course the switch base
- 5:47has been around for a while which gave
- 5:48you this opportunity but there was a lot
- 5:50of water that would fill the space below
- 5:52the bed whereas these you're able to
- 5:54keep all the water you pour essentially
- 5:56inside so you're not wasting any of that
- 5:57Brew water throughout the process
- 6:01so if we have kind of a spectrum of the
- 6:03most clear that you can possibly get
- 6:05from a brew over here and then the most
- 6:08kind of balanced or uh heavy bodied or
- 6:11um you know sweet whatever you want to
- 6:13say and when I say sweet we're obviously
- 6:15talking about specific perceptions I
- 6:17still think the high Clarity are really
- 6:18sweet but anyway I would say the cones
- 6:20kind of live over here although you can
- 6:22come over here with cones and then flat
- 6:24bottoms come over here but it span all
- 6:26the way down to here whereas these
- 6:28hybrid ones they do a similar range to
- 6:31say the flat bottom Brewers but they can
- 6:33get a little bit more intense so if we
- 6:35were to add another access to this where
- 6:37it's like all right how intense of these
- 6:39different attributes can you really get
- 6:41it kind of intensifies them you're not
- 6:42going to get more clarity due to this
- 6:46kind of switch of of the Basse this kind
- 6:48of valve situation but you're going to
- 6:50be able to intensify certain aspects
- 6:52based off of that so being able to do a
- 6:54bit of immersion being able to do a bit
- 6:56of percolation in one go is a fun thing
- 6:58though it's not NE necessarily going to
- 7:00completely revolutionize or change your
- 7:02cup compared to some of these yes you
- 7:04can increase the no bypass which is
- 7:06going to allow for bigger ratios but in
- 7:08the end is it a necessity in order to
- 7:11completely transform or change your cup
- 7:13score by a full point or something along
- 7:14those lines arguably
- 7:19not if you are addicted to you know
- 7:22acquiring drippers and you feel the need
- 7:23to buy something new well then I think
- 7:25this is all the representation you kind
- 7:27of need
- 7:29I really enjoy something like the
- 7:31Aeropress because it's incredibly
- 7:32versatile but I also really love the
- 7:34clever dripper it is something that's so
- 7:36easy anybody can do it and it gives you
- 7:38clean her Cups than something that's
- 7:40completely unfiltered like a French
- 7:42press and it gives you just a lot of
- 7:44options with a pretty big yield of
- 7:46coffee and you can also transform it and
- 7:48use it just as a pourover device a semic
- 7:50conical
- 7:52pourover there is some validity in
- 7:55saying getting something like that Cafe
- 7:56deep 27 or it has that really deep angle
- 7:58so you can get a higher bed for smaller
- 8:00doses but that's such a specific kind of
- 8:03situation how often are you going to be
- 8:04Brewing you know 10 and Below grams if
- 8:07that's something you do often then sure
- 8:09something like that would be helpful
- 8:10because the more shallow the bed the
- 8:12more findes migration the more potential
- 8:14clogging the more potential bypass the
- 8:17the lower potential quality of the cup
- 8:19so you want to make sure you're having a
- 8:20decent thickness to the bed you know
- 8:22something around 3 cm is a pretty good
- 8:24start but in in general all of these
- 8:27Brewers are going to give you kind of
- 8:29this 15 to 30 G window you can get
- 8:32bigger than that in something like a V60
- 8:34or something like the Ora big boy but
- 8:36for the most part that's kind of the
- 8:38range we're working with the more
- 8:39shallow or thin that bed is the worse
- 8:42your Brew is likely going to be unless
- 8:44you have figured out some sort of hack
- 8:46in order to disallow as much of that
- 8:48migration like maybe using something
- 8:50like a mellow drip or something along
- 8:52those lines that really helps soften the
- 8:53blow of the water onto those grounds
- 8:59I have the big boy here from Ora because
- 9:02uh sometimes you know if you're someone
- 9:03that brews every day for two people or
- 9:05three people this is one of the few that
- 9:07can do that much coffee of course the
- 9:09kimx can I don't have it represented
- 9:10here yes it's not going to give me as
- 9:12much brightness as the kimx but
- 9:13consistency is much higher with this
- 9:16than I than I find with the kimx now
- 9:17this is a negotiator to kind of flatten
- 9:19down that those paper uh Frills in order
- 9:21to give you a bit better less bypass
- 9:23extraction that's a bit more consistent
- 9:25as well uh and then finally I have
- 9:27something that's representative of flat
- 9:28bottom Brewers but smaller obviously and
- 9:30something representative of conle now
- 9:33the reason I chose this s Works instead
- 9:34of the other ones is because it does
- 9:36have that option for the Bas to open up
- 9:39but it also has a massive uh a massive
- 9:41exit on the bottom so you're not going
- 9:43to experience clogging or anything like
- 9:45that you can choose different bases like
- 9:46the Oro V4 in order to toss down into
- 9:49the bottom for different flow rates or
- 9:51different escapes now something like the
- 9:53Stag X or the Kalita have these tiny
- 9:55holes on the bottom where paper can clog
- 9:57it and cause for a really stalled out
- 10:00pour whereas this that's never really
- 10:02going to happen because you have the
- 10:03whole bottom of the paper filter for it
- 10:05to
- 10:06release I prefer playing with this than
- 10:09something like the next level because
- 10:11this has a bit more of a conical form to
- 10:13it and I find that I'm able to get a bit
- 10:15more clarity through that cup uh and
- 10:17using the bed filtration here which is a
- 10:19bit thicker of a bed with a smaller dose
- 10:21than I get with the next level Pulsar or
- 10:23something along those lines but then the
- 10:25one that is the Supreme for me and
- 10:27probably always will be because I keep
- 10:29coming back to it year after year even
- 10:31after all this time and coffee is just a
- 10:34V60 now of course you don't have to get
- 10:36plastic you can get a ceramic you can
- 10:38get a glass or probably my choice if
- 10:41you're not wanting plastic would be to
- 10:42switch actually to brista and get their
- 10:44tornado that's a double walled glass one
- 10:47if you really want to retain a lot of
- 10:48that heat it's pretty nice it does a
- 10:50good job pretty much the same thing as a
- 10:54V60 this one has stood the test of time
- 10:57and what I honestly see all the time are
- 10:58these people who get dripper obsessed
- 11:00tend to always come back to the V60 you
- 11:03watch any of these other channels like
- 11:05Brian Quan who absolutely loves playing
- 11:06around with drippers he tends to brew
- 11:08mostly with his little Pepe uh V60 the
- 11:11workflow is something to take into into
- 11:13consideration you just toss it in you
- 11:15brew it up and you're good to
- 11:18go I remember I was taught that there
- 11:20was actually a lot bigger learning curve
- 11:22to a V60 than like a k I would actually
- 11:25disagree with that I get much more
- 11:27consistently good beverages from a v 60
- 11:29than I do from flat bottoms maybe a
- 11:31specific coffee would taste good super
- 11:33dialed into like the K wave but in
- 11:36reality I'm not ever going to hit 100%
- 11:39of a coffee's potential that's just not
- 11:41going to happen it's a fun thing to kind
- 11:42of Chase maybe I get lucky sometimes and
- 11:44it happens but I'm going to be doing
- 11:46what I know will be a good cup uh make
- 11:48minor tweaks in order to improve that
- 11:50cup but using the
- 11:54V60 then you're just worried about your
- 11:56filters which can very greatly depending
- 11:59on the quality and the style of filter
- 12:01you have which we can do another video
- 12:02on but in general when you do something
- 12:04like the Cofe light roast that's a
- 12:06really thick filter that's going to slow
- 12:07your pores down a lot so that's
- 12:10something you could use for maybe a
- 12:11coffee that drains really quickly or
- 12:13something you need more contact time
- 12:14with or something with a really low dose
- 12:17so that it's not going to speed through
- 12:18and it has a high capability to absorb
- 12:20fines whenever you're pouring a lot or
- 12:22you can do like the medium dark roast
- 12:24filters which are my favorite they tend
- 12:25to be the most porous while also being
- 12:27really even in their texture and they
- 12:29have a pretty fast flow rate while also
- 12:32being able to absorb a lot of fines
- 12:34without clogging up you can do their
- 12:36dark Ro one you can do the Hario
- 12:37untabbed the Hario tabbed the cbris
- 12:39which tend to be quite expensive but are
- 12:41incredibly high quality you can take a
- 12:43look at the cafeic Abaco which are
- 12:44really nice as far from a sustainability
- 12:47standpoint you can do something like a
- 12:48mesh filter which will obviously give
- 12:50you a cup that's closer to something
- 12:51like immersion as far as that texture
- 12:53because you're getting a lot of that
- 12:54silt that kind of small findes through
- 12:56the filter into your final cup a lot of
- 12:58those oils are going to get through you
- 12:59otherwise wouldn't get the colloids
- 13:02Etc you can play around with the feed
- 13:04rate into your grinder you can play
- 13:06around the temperature of your water the
- 13:07ratio of your water to your coffee all
- 13:09of these things I think should be played
- 13:11with before you run out and you know
- 13:13turn to a consumer again and again and
- 13:15again although I know it's fun to
- 13:17acquire and to Showcase all these
- 13:18drippers you have we're just kind of
- 13:20urging the industry to continue to pump
- 13:22out this stuff for more and more
- 13:23consumerism which we don't necessarily
- 13:25need let's take that 20 bucks we could
- 13:28buy a new dripper with put it towards a
- 13:30nice bag of coffee and you'll have a
- 13:31much better time with it I'm I'm pretty
- 13:33pretty confident of that anyway that is
- 13:36enough I'm done ranting for the day
- 13:37thank you so much for watching I hope
- 13:39this was a helpful insightful video I
- 13:40hope it answered some questions for you
- 13:42you know of course please hit the like
- 13:44And subscribe it really helps the
- 13:45channel I hope that you brew something
- 13:47tasty today regardless of what dripper
- 13:49you use and cheers
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Brewers: Which Ones Do You Need? by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,910 words across 405 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.