YouTube2Text

BREAKING: Mohammed Hijab SUED Me and LOST | GODLOGIC VS MOHAMMED HIJAB — Transcript

by GodLogic Apologetics · 20,985 words · 3,259 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Well, well, well, [laughter] man.
  2. 0:04Doesn't the sound of victory sound good?
  3. 0:07Muhammad Aab, you lost to me in a debate
  4. 0:10and then you also lost the court case.
  5. 0:14Isn't that embarrassing? I make me sick.
  6. 0:16In order for you to hide the video and
  7. 0:19to stop the growth, which you couldn't.
  8. 0:21You actually made it worse. You tried to
  9. 0:24sue me for a copyright strike. And turns
  10. 0:28out it got dismissed. Ladies and
  11. 0:30gentlemen, so without further ado, this
  12. 0:33is the same discussion that I had with
  13. 0:36Muhammad Aab. This is how you deal with
  14. 0:39slobs like this. This is how you handle
  15. 0:42them. This is how you destroy them. You
  16. 0:44use their own arguments against them.
  17. 0:46You use their own book against them.
  18. 0:48This is the very conversation that
  19. 0:50Muhammad Hijab tried to hide and gave me
  20. 0:53a copyright strike with, which he lost
  21. 0:55on. Enjoy. [music]
  22. 1:01>> Oh, look who we have here.
  23. 1:04>> There we go.
  24. 1:04>> How How are you there? How are you,
  25. 1:06>> man? I'm good, man. How are you?
  26. 1:08>> Oh, you you finally come for the for the
  27. 1:11final boss, huh?
  28. 1:13>> You want to [laughter] ask me the
  29. 1:14questions, huh?
  30. 1:15>> I came for the champions.
  31. 1:17>> I came for the champ. I came for the
  32. 1:19champ.
  33. 1:19>> Go ahead and ask me the questions that
  34. 1:20you want to ask. But before we before we
  35. 1:23continue, is it okay that I also
  36. 1:25>> raise your voice a bit? I can't hear you
  37. 1:27very well there.
  38. 1:28>> Uhoh. Testing, testing. And we Okay.
  39. 1:30Testing testing.
  40. 1:31>> Yeah. Raise it a little bit higher.
  41. 1:33>> All right. [snorts] Let me uh you look a
  42. 1:37bit nervous there, boy.
  43. 1:39>> Man, you know, big boy.
  44. 1:41>> Big stage. You know what I'm saying?
  45. 1:43>> It's a big stage and a big opportunity,
  46. 1:45huh?
  47. 1:46>> Just the champ, man.
  48. 1:47>> Oh,
  49. 1:49you been waiting like a good boy. You're
  50. 1:51the Peter, you the people's champ, man.
  51. 1:53You've been st Yeah, I don't know. I
  52. 1:54don't know you was getting your courage
  53. 1:55up or what. I don't know what it was,
  54. 1:57but
  55. 1:58>> I'm the giant.
  56. 1:59>> Thank you. Is is it okay that I uh
  57. 2:02record this and put it on my channel?
  58. 2:03Just want to get a verbal confirmation.
  59. 2:04We're good.
  60. 2:05>> Well, I mean, look, you can go live
  61. 2:07right now. I mean, I haven't got any
  62. 2:08issues with that myself.
  63. 2:10You are live already.
  64. 2:12>> Yeah, I'm recording right now. So, I'm
  65. 2:13just making sure I can
  66. 2:14>> go live. Go live so that your people can
  67. 2:16see what's happening right now.
  68. 2:17>> Oh, they they will. So, I just want a
  69. 2:19verbal confirmation. You're not going to
  70. 2:20copyright strike me.
  71. 2:22>> No, you're you're going to go live and
  72. 2:23it's absolutely fine.
  73. 2:24>> Okay, cool. All right. Awesome. All
  74. 2:26right. So,
  75. 2:27>> we're going live simultaneously right
  76. 2:28now, aren't we?
  77. 2:30>> Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit
  78. 2:31are simultaneously gone. Are
  79. 2:33>> they This is This is a recording just
  80. 2:34like the Huffs and the are all
  81. 2:36simultaneously the Quran.
  82. 2:38>> Yeah,
  83. 2:38>> that's a nice segue.
  84. 2:40>> So, tell me now.
  85. 2:42This is a good way of doing it, Avery.
  86. 2:44Okay. A good way of doing it is you ask
  87. 2:47me a question about Islam.
  88. 2:48>> Yeah.
  89. 2:49>> And then we can go back and forth on
  90. 2:51that issue for some time
  91. 2:53>> and then I ask you a question about
  92. 2:54Christianity and we can go back and
  93. 2:56forth on that issue for it. So it's kind
  94. 2:58of equal.
  95. 2:59>> Yeah.
  96. 2:59>> Sounds about right. Yeah.
  97. 3:01>> Fair enough.
  98. 3:01>> So I want you to do me the following. Uh
  99. 3:03Avery, I want you in front of the people
  100. 3:06that are watching at home today.
  101. 3:08Everybody watching at home, the
  102. 3:10Christians, the Muslims, the Jews, the
  103. 3:12Zionists, your friends, the Zionists,
  104. 3:14everybody want you to tell us what your
  105. 3:18strongest. I know you're unqualified.
  106. 3:21No, no, it's okay. You're not qualified.
  107. 3:23You know, you don't have any formal
  108. 3:24qualifications. You don't have any
  109. 3:26degrees. You don't have any
  110. 3:27certificates. You don't have any
  111. 3:28diplomas. I understand all that. But I
  112. 3:30give you concession because I want you
  113. 3:33>> to tell us your strongest argument
  114. 3:36against Islam. We're all Avery.
  115. 3:39>> Nice. Thank you. I appreciate it, man.
  116. 3:40>> Want to hear that one.
  117. 3:41>> Yeah. Yeah, man. I can't wait to give
  118. 3:43it, you know, from someone who's
  119. 3:44unqualified, no credentials, just a, you
  120. 3:46know, young kid who just, you know, did
  121. 3:48a lot of YouTube University. It says a
  122. 3:50lot.
  123. 3:51>> Say, let's get [laughter]
  124. 3:53I am, man. I am. You got to set it up.
  125. 3:55>> Give us a strong boy.
  126. 3:58>> I got nervous, aren't you? Go ahead.
  127. 4:00>> Got to set it up. Got to set it up. You
  128. 4:02know, it it it it says a lot for someone
  129. 4:04who's unqualified to do what I've done
  130. 4:06to the Dava squad and now you're just
  131. 4:08laughing.
  132. 4:08>> Get on with it, mate.
  133. 4:09>> Get on with it, mate.
  134. 4:10>> So, so what I'm going to say is Muhammad
  135. 4:13Hijab is that the strongest one of the
  136. 4:15strongest I wouldn't even say it's the
  137. 4:17but one of the strongest arguments that
  138. 4:19I would like to use
  139. 4:20>> obviously would be the Islamic dilemma
  140. 4:22that you said is a easil easily uh
  141. 4:26refuted and disregarded argument.
  142. 4:28>> Sure.
  143. 4:28>> So, I would challenge before we start.
  144. 4:31That's your strongest argument. This is
  145. 4:33the way to undo Islam. The way to do
  146. 4:35undo Islam is the Islamic dilemma.
  147. 4:36You've been in this apologetics game for
  148. 4:38a very long time. You believe this
  149. 4:40>> is the strongest argument. You believe
  150. 4:42that?
  151. 4:42>> It's it's one of I I believe the
  152. 4:44strongest argument would with the
  153. 4:47Muhammad's moral character.
  154. 4:48>> Now, don't lose the confidence already.
  155. 4:50What's the strongest argument? Let's go
  156. 4:52for number one because we need to go
  157. 4:53down.
  158. 4:54>> I want to use this. I want to use the
  159. 4:55Islamic dilemma. Can we stop wasting
  160. 4:57time and talk about it?
  161. 4:57>> Of course you can. That's your strongest
  162. 4:58argument, right?
  163. 4:59>> All right. Mashah, let's do it.
  164. 5:01>> Okay, go ahead and make your argument.
  165. 5:03>> All right. Thank you. So, I'm going to
  166. 5:05argue that from the Quran standpoint, it
  167. 5:07points to the previous scriptures as
  168. 5:08being authoritative over the Quran,
  169. 5:10meaning it's the standard of truth over
  170. 5:12the Quran. Okay? And I'm going to use a
  171. 5:15few verses. I'll we could deal with one
  172. 5:16at a time. Um my one of my favorite
  173. 5:18verses to use would be chapter 10 verse
  174. 5:2294.
  175. 5:23>> Yes.
  176. 5:23>> Okay. And so this is what it says. It
  177. 5:25says, "If you are in doubt," this is
  178. 5:27Allah speaking to Muhammad. If you are
  179. 5:28in doubt about that which we have
  180. 5:30revealed to you,
  181. 5:31>> then go and ask those who have been
  182. 5:32reading the scripture before you. Truly
  183. 5:34the truth has come to you from your
  184. 5:35Lord. So be not of those who doubt.
  185. 5:37>> Sure. So let me ask you this, Avery.
  186. 5:39Have you seen any of the exedites on
  187. 5:41this? Because it says if you're in
  188. 5:43doubt, I'm sure you're aware. I know
  189. 5:44you're not qualified, but you understand
  190. 5:46that a conditional if is a conditional.
  191. 5:49If you are in doubt, that's the Arabic
  192. 5:51wording. in if you were in doubt. If you
  193. 5:55look at the exedutes, they say he wasn't
  194. 5:57in doubt and he never asked. So, it's
  195. 5:59irrelevant. Next one, please.
  196. 6:00>> Okay. So, notice since I'm unqualified,
  197. 6:03it's it's a shame I got to teach you the
  198. 6:05argument. Um I never argue anything. I
  199. 6:07assure you, my friend. There's no
  200. 6:09there's no teaching going on here.
  201. 6:11>> I got you, John. Get it out.
  202. 6:13>> Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. You said
  203. 6:14>> I can't even get it out, ladies and
  204. 6:15gentlemen.
  205. 6:16>> You said one at a time. You said one at
  206. 6:18a time. 10 minutes.
  207. 6:19>> Yes. I'm trying to respond to what you
  208. 6:20said. chapter number 10 verse 94.
  209. 6:24>> Can I respond with you?
  210. 6:26>> Wait, what are you are you are you
  211. 6:28interrupting me or
  212. 6:29>> Hey, you cut me off and now you're
  213. 6:31saying I'm interrupting you.
  214. 6:31>> No, no, no, no, no. We're dealing with
  215. 6:33one at a time here.
  216. 6:34>> I know. So you you made a second about
  217. 6:36I'm not doubting. Let me respond to
  218. 6:37that.
  219. 6:38>> If you are in any doubt, [laughter]
  220. 6:44the ones who were given the book before.
  221. 6:46>> So no, no. So now the exedites say they
  222. 6:50say this is rhetorical. If conditional
  223. 6:53you're in doubt then ask what he
  224. 6:55supposed to do.
  225. 6:55>> Then they say he never was in doubt
  226. 6:57because the prophet was never in doubt
  227. 6:59and he never asked. He never asked in
  228. 7:02this capacity. That's it. It's is it's
  229. 7:04put that to the side.
  230. 7:06>> Okay. No. So So thank you. I appreciate
  231. 7:08that. You that was a waste of time.
  232. 7:10That's not my argument. My argument
  233. 7:11isn't that Muhammad the first time.
  234. 7:13You're cutting me off again.
  235. 7:15>> This is the second time. Notice if
  236. 7:17you're not afraid of the argument. I'm
  237. 7:18unqualified. Remember, I'm unqualified.
  238. 7:20>> Second second verse, please.
  239. 7:21>> All right. I'm unqualified, ladies and
  240. 7:23gentlemen.
  241. 7:24>> Just so ladies and gentlemen, my
  242. 7:26argument is not
  243. 7:28in doubt. My My argument is not that
  244. 7:30Muhammad was in doubt. My argument is
  245. 7:32what Allah tells him to do if he does
  246. 7:35doubt. Now, just to get this just to get
  247. 7:38this under clarity, would you agree that
  248. 7:40doubt means to be uncertain of the
  249. 7:42truth?
  250. 7:43Yeah, that's that's so if Muhammad
  251. 7:46conditional granted that's what the
  252. 7:48verse says. If he's uncertain about the
  253. 7:50truth of the Quran,
  254. 7:51>> what is he told to do by Allah?
  255. 7:57>> Give ask the people who have been given
  256. 7:59the book before.
  257. 8:00>> Awesome. So if he goes and asks if he's
  258. 8:03uncertain about the truth of what the
  259. 8:04Quran is saying
  260. 8:05>> and he goes and asks those who've been
  261. 8:07reading the scripture before him, that's
  262. 8:09supposed to help him gain certainty of
  263. 8:11the truth. if he sees that the Quran is
  264. 8:13in line with what they have. Correct.
  265. 8:14>> Okay.
  266. 8:16>> Is that is that correct?
  267. 8:18>> If you if you're in doubt, it says in if
  268. 8:21you're in doubt,
  269. 8:23>> I don't know why you're smoking and
  270. 8:24grinning.
  271. 8:24>> I'm just having a good time, man.
  272. 8:26>> I know. I know. Wait, hold on. Hold on.
  273. 8:27I know why he's smoking and grinning.
  274. 8:29Cuz he's not used to being in class
  275. 8:30because he's never been in class.
  276. 8:32[laughter]
  277. 8:35>> There's nothing funny about this matter.
  278. 8:36This is This is buddy. Look, look. This
  279. 8:40is I know you're a bucktoothoth
  280. 8:41apologist and I know that you're you
  281. 8:43keep smirking and smiling. You think
  282. 8:44that this is going to get you somewhere.
  283. 8:45It's not going to get you anywhere with
  284. 8:46Muhammad Hijab
  285. 8:48with a couple of other guys here and
  286. 8:49there.
  287. 8:51>> It's not going to get you anywhere with
  288. 8:52Muhammad Hijab because the fact is this.
  289. 8:55The fact is conditionals have been even
  290. 8:58proposed in the Quran about Allah taking
  291. 9:00a son.
  292. 9:03If Allah wanted to take a son, he could
  293. 9:05have taken his. So the conditional here
  294. 9:08for the bucktooth apologist you have
  295. 9:10failed to give us anything of substance
  296. 9:13at this point.
  297. 9:14>> I'm just waiting on you. You're
  298. 9:16presenting the strongest argument
  299. 9:18against Islam. So please
  300. 9:21>> give us the strongest argument. Go on.
  301. 9:22>> All right. Awesome. Thank you. So all of
  302. 9:24that slander and all that that doesn't
  303. 9:25work here. Not with me. You're going to
  304. 9:27have to actually deal with the argument.
  305. 9:28So again, I'll ask the same question I
  306. 9:30just asked. You didn't answer.
  307. 9:31>> So here's the question again. Muhammad
  308. 9:33hijab. So if Muhammad is uncertain about
  309. 9:36the truth of the Quran in in this
  310. 9:38scenario that then he's supposed to go
  311. 9:40ahead when he asks the people the book
  312. 9:43right you read the scripture before him.
  313. 9:44Let me let me land.
  314. 9:46>> I got you. So when he when he when he
  315. 9:48does that
  316. 9:49>> if the Quran is in line with what they
  317. 9:51have then he'll be certain of the truth
  318. 9:54about what the Quran is saying. Right?
  319. 9:55If he doubt.
  320. 9:55>> No no no no no. See look this is the
  321. 9:57problem. Okay. The problem is when you
  322. 10:01haven't got a high school diploma
  323. 10:02>> and you try and use logical insults but
  324. 10:05no engagement in the argument.
  325. 10:06>> No, no. This is the the fact is this.
  326. 10:08You don't know what you're talking
  327. 10:09about. Nowhere does Hold on. Hold on.
  328. 10:12Nowhere does it say you've added and
  329. 10:14you've added an isog Jesus. You've added
  330. 10:16your own superical
  331. 10:19narrative onto the Quranic text. Nowhere
  332. 10:22does it say if the Quran is if if you're
  333. 10:26in doubt then go and then it can be
  334. 10:27corrected by the people. Where does it
  335. 10:29say that?
  336. 10:30>> Where does it say that?
  337. 10:32>> I'll show you.
  338. 10:33>> I'll show you again. So when it says
  339. 10:36that if you are in doubt, meaning which
  340. 10:37you already agreed to means to be
  341. 10:38uncertain of the truth of what the Quran
  342. 10:40is saying.
  343. 10:41>> Okay.
  344. 10:41>> What he can do to get certainty of the
  345. 10:43truth of what the Quran is saying is
  346. 10:45asking the people who read the scripture
  347. 10:47before him.
  348. 10:47>> It doesn't say any of that. It says,
  349. 10:49>> "Oh, it you could feel that earlier. No,
  350. 10:52no, no. You just read the verse as it
  351. 10:53is.
  352. 10:54>> Mhm.
  353. 10:56>> Go and ask the people before you. That's
  354. 10:58it. That's all it says.
  355. 11:00>> But the question is, the question is
  356. 11:02where's the argument here? So what? So
  357. 11:05what? What's your argument? Is this
  358. 11:07meant to undo Islam? I don't see any
  359. 11:08threat. Where's the argument?
  360. 11:10>> I got you. So, so, so again, so do you
  361. 11:13agree with the verse that in the case in
  362. 11:16the scenario that Muhammad doubts what
  363. 11:18the Quran is saying, has uncertainty
  364. 11:20about the what the Quran is saying that
  365. 11:22he can get certainty what he can get
  366. 11:24certainty by asking the people who read
  367. 11:26the scripture before. Correct.
  368. 11:27>> Ask the people. That's what it says.
  369. 11:28Yes. Ask the people. Yes. Ask the people
  370. 11:31is what the verse says. Go ahead.
  371. 11:33>> Who've been doing what?
  372. 11:35>> Say again.
  373. 11:36>> Ask the people who what?
  374. 11:38>> The ones who have been given the book.
  375. 11:40There you go. So in asking these people
  376. 11:43who read the scripture before him,
  377. 11:45>> he can then get certainty of whatever he
  378. 11:48doubted. Correct.
  379. 11:49>> No, that's you've you've added that.
  380. 11:51See, look, you have to
  381. 11:54what?
  382. 11:55>> It's what the verse says. No,
  383. 11:56>> it doesn't say that. It says
  384. 11:59it doesn't say
  385. 12:02what do you call it? So you can get
  386. 12:03certainty. It doesn't say any of what
  387. 12:04you're saying. The question is your
  388. 12:06argument. I'm trying to I'm I'm still
  389. 12:09finding
  390. 12:10I'm trying to find your argument. What
  391. 12:12was
  392. 12:12>> the argument is there?
  393. 12:14>> Yeah, you are. Okay. Hijab, let me ask
  394. 12:16you this.
  395. 12:17>> Why is Allah Why what is what is this
  396. 12:19supposed to do for Muhammad if he's
  397. 12:21uncertain about what the Quran is saying
  398. 12:23by go and going to the people who read
  399. 12:24the script before him? What does that do
  400. 12:26for him in this situation? How does that
  401. 12:27help? If this is your argument,
  402. 12:29>> do you is your argument the following?
  403. 12:31Let's just be clear about this. Is your
  404. 12:32argument straightforward question,
  405. 12:34brother?
  406. 12:34>> No. No. Is your argument that you
  407. 12:36believe that the Quran affirms the Torat
  408. 12:41and the Injil the Bible that you have in
  409. 12:43your hands? That's not my argument right
  410. 12:46now. My argument argument I said I got I
  411. 12:50said it in the beginning. I said that
  412. 12:52according to the Quran, the previous
  413. 12:54scriptures are the authority are the
  414. 12:56standard of truth over the Quran. And
  415. 12:58here's my verse to prove it.
  416. 12:59>> Wait, is that who said that again?
  417. 13:01>> Who said that? Where does it
  418. 13:02>> I said that? This is my argument. Okay.
  419. 13:04So, where does it say that in the Quran?
  420. 13:06>> I'm showing you. So, again with 1094,
  421. 13:09watch this. I'm showing you. You got to
  422. 13:12engage though.
  423. 13:13>> In 1094,
  424. 13:15it tells Muhammad if he is uncertain
  425. 13:19>> about what the Quran is saying.
  426. 13:21>> Okay.
  427. 13:21>> How he can gain certainty.
  428. 13:23>> It doesn't say that he's
  429. 13:24>> okay. So, then help me out.
  430. 13:27>> Why is he saying
  431. 13:28>> it? It doesn't say go and get gain
  432. 13:29certainty. It says just
  433. 13:33Pardon my hijab. He's talking about his
  434. 13:35doubts.
  435. 13:36Yeah, I understand what you're saying,
  436. 13:37but what I'm saying to you is the
  437. 13:39exedites have already explained that he
  438. 13:41never had that doubt and he never asked.
  439. 13:43So, it's irrelevant. I get the same type
  440. 13:45of rhetoric.
  441. 13:46>> Have you got any other arguments because
  442. 13:48this is getting boring for the
  443. 13:49>> saying that it's getting boring because
  444. 13:50you can't even deal with the argument.
  445. 13:52>> This is extreme. This is extremely
  446. 13:54boring argument.
  447. 13:55>> If it's so boring, you should be able to
  448. 13:58is what are you trying to say? Are you
  449. 13:59trying to say that the Bible according
  450. 14:02to us is preserved? Is that
  451. 14:03>> what I'm saying is I'll say it again
  452. 14:05very clearly.
  453. 14:05>> You believe that we believe the Bible is
  454. 14:06preserved? Yes or no?
  455. 14:07>> I got you. Do you believe that we
  456. 14:08believe the Bible is preserved?
  457. 14:10>> I got you. This will be my third time
  458. 14:12saying very clearly what
  459. 14:13>> I'm asking you the question. Do you
  460. 14:14believe that we believe the Bible is
  461. 14:15preserved? Yes or no?
  462. 14:16>> I know you don't believe that. I know
  463. 14:18you don't believe that. My point is that
  464. 14:20your beliefs go against Islam. That's my
  465. 14:22point. Say again. What's the What's the
  466. 14:23point? Your beliefs go against the
  467. 14:26Quran. The Quran here and I'll be very
  468. 14:28clear. My point, the point that I'm
  469. 14:30proving and I want you to focus on is
  470. 14:32that the Quran points to the previous
  471. 14:35scriptures as being the standard of
  472. 14:38truth. Well, if you're disagreeing with
  473. 14:40that, I need you to break this verse
  474. 14:41down for me and show me how I'm wrong.
  475. 14:43>> Okay. Okay. Yes. We believe in the
  476. 14:45previous scriptures. Muslims believe in
  477. 14:46the previous scriptures. Muslims also
  478. 14:48believe that the scriptures that are in
  479. 14:50our hands today from the Jews and the
  480. 14:52Christians are corrupted. These two
  481. 14:54things we believe at the same time. We
  482. 14:56believe that there was original
  483. 14:57scriptures that then got corrupted. Do
  484. 14:59you understand this point or not?
  485. 15:00>> I trust me, I know your position. I
  486. 15:02know.
  487. 15:03>> If you understand this position, what
  488. 15:05what's the what's the point here?
  489. 15:07Because if you believe that we believe
  490. 15:08that is corrupted, then you understand
  491. 15:10that there are aspects of the Bible now
  492. 15:13that you have in your hands which could
  493. 15:14have their remnants back in that they go
  494. 15:17back to the actual and aspects of the
  495. 15:20Bible which don't. For example, the
  496. 15:22aspects that talk about Lot having sex
  497. 15:24with his daughters or the aspects that
  498. 15:26talk about, you know, for example, Noah
  499. 15:28having the, you know, the the the three
  500. 15:30sons and seeing them in his nakedness
  501. 15:31and all these aspects which or that
  502. 15:33Aaron committed shik and polotheism or
  503. 15:36uh, you know, that Jesus commanded
  504. 15:38according to 31:18 to this, that, and
  505. 15:41the other, take the young girls for
  506. 15:42yourself. All of these things are
  507. 15:43corrections the Quran came to correct.
  508. 15:45You see, so as I said to you before, the
  509. 15:48corrupt
  510. 15:50Bible that we have today, which there
  511. 15:52are different versions of, there's the
  512. 15:54New International Version, there's the
  513. 15:55Revised Standard Version, there's the
  514. 15:56King James version, there's whatever
  515. 15:58version, different cannons, 66 books, 73
  516. 16:01books, whatever. We don't believe that
  517. 16:03to be God, God's word. We don't believe
  518. 16:0513 books of Paul are God's word. We
  519. 16:08don't believe in any of that. So where's
  520. 16:09the argument going here? I don't see
  521. 16:11where the argument is going. Okay. So I
  522. 16:13I I'll break it down. You know, remember
  523. 16:15I'm unqualified. So I got to d I only
  524. 16:17talk in like dummy standards. Okay.
  525. 16:20According to the Quran, the it points to
  526. 16:22the previous scriptures
  527. 16:25as being the standard of truth. Meaning
  528. 16:27if Muhammad is uncertain about what the
  529. 16:29Quran is relating, especially in regards
  530. 16:31to the previous prophets, the previous
  531. 16:33histories, their stories, and yada yada
  532. 16:34yada. If Muhammad is in doubt, this is
  533. 16:37conditional. As you said, if he doubts
  534. 16:39what the Quran is saying on these
  535. 16:40matters,
  536. 16:41>> then he can get clarity on his doubts
  537. 16:45>> by going to the people who read the
  538. 16:46scripture before him and asking them
  539. 16:47about these things.
  540. 16:48>> All right. So, so what?
  541. 16:49>> Right.
  542. 16:50>> Okay. So, it's saying that you can if
  543. 16:53you're in doubt, you can go to the
  544. 16:54people who
  545. 16:58the people who have been given the
  546. 16:59scripture before you. For example, some
  547. 17:01Jews, some Christians, those Jews like
  548. 17:04for example, who the prophet sallallam
  549. 17:06went to a person who was a monotheistic
  550. 17:08Christian at the time and he asked them
  551. 17:10for questions. You know, this is a way
  552. 17:12to reassure himself if he's in doubt or
  553. 17:15whatever it may be. Yes, this is what
  554. 17:16the Quran says. I want to understand
  555. 17:18what the issue is here. Do you see the
  556. 17:21argument?
  557. 17:21>> So, here's what's the issue. So, thank
  558. 17:22you. So, we got we got past this part.
  559. 17:24So now since we both now understand
  560. 17:27>> that he can get clarity on whatever he
  561. 17:29might have been doubting just if in this
  562. 17:31in this case he can get clarity he can
  563. 17:34get clarity on the truth of what the
  564. 17:36Quran is saying by going to the people
  565. 17:38of the book and what they're reading
  566. 17:40this means that if Muhammad if what he's
  567. 17:43receiving from the Quran matches what
  568. 17:46they tell him from the previous
  569. 17:47scriptures then that will clear up his
  570. 17:50doubts if he had any regarding what the
  571. 17:52Quran's telling him. Correct?
  572. 17:55Okay, let's go with it. Let's grant it.
  573. 17:56Yeah. Next. Next. Yeah. Go.
  574. 17:58>> Awesome. So, that would clear up his
  575. 18:00doubts if he saw that it lined up. Okay.
  576. 18:02So, this means that the inverse is true.
  577. 18:04That if he doubted and went to them
  578. 18:07>> and they told him the opposite of what
  579. 18:09the Quran was saying, then this would
  580. 18:11actually verify his doubts and he
  581. 18:13wouldn't have good reason to trust what
  582. 18:14the Quran is saying. Right.
  583. 18:16>> This is so weak. You have to understand
  584. 18:19how what's it called? Mafu Mhalifa
  585. 18:21works.
  586. 18:22is a is a principle in and it's a
  587. 18:27principle which is what is known in
  588. 18:30diametric opposition. Okay, it's not
  589. 18:32actually true that if I say for example,
  590. 18:35okay, don't if you drink this hot tea
  591. 18:39then you will be u you will be in a
  592. 18:42position where you you have to go to the
  593. 18:43toilet. Okay, it doesn't mean that if I
  594. 18:46don't drink the hot tea that I will
  595. 18:48definitely not go to the toilet, does
  596. 18:49it? So what you're saying is not by
  597. 18:51conditional. There's no reason for you
  598. 18:53to think it's by conditional that it
  599. 18:54works in a symmetrical manner. This is
  600. 18:56the the weakness of Christian
  601. 18:58apologetics nowadays. You can't even
  602. 19:00think logically. The problem is you
  603. 19:02can't even actually think properly. And
  604. 19:03the and the issue is if you did
  605. 19:05propositional logic course 101 in school
  606. 19:07before you flunked out and did whatever
  607. 19:10you done. Yeah. If you did that to be
  608. 19:12honest with you, you bucktooth apologist
  609. 19:15smiling again cuz he's been caught out
  610. 19:16once again. The point is if you
  611. 19:18understood how by conditionality works,
  612. 19:20how if one thing is happens the other
  613. 19:22thing, then you wouldn't come with these
  614. 19:24weak arguments. Okay? There is nothing
  615. 19:26in the Quran that indicates or in the
  616. 19:29hadith that indicates that if the
  617. 19:31prophet Muhammad were to go to the
  618. 19:33Christian or the Jew and that if he were
  619. 19:35to correct him, he would have to now uh
  620. 19:38go in line with what the Christian or
  621. 19:39the Jew said because the Quran itself
  622. 19:42edits the Bible. It conscientiously
  623. 19:44corrects the Bible.
  624. 19:46>> For example, in the Quran
  625. 19:49in the Quran in chapter 50 of the Quran,
  626. 19:50hold on. The Quran, the author is aware,
  627. 19:53is he not? My question to you, the
  628. 19:55author is aware, is he not in chapter 50
  629. 19:58of the Quran where it says
  630. 20:01that no tidness touched him when he
  631. 20:04created the heavens and the earth. He's
  632. 20:05aware of what what was said in Genesis
  633. 20:08chapter 1 and also in the book of Exodus
  634. 20:11where it says that God rested and he
  635. 20:13refreshed Naf. So clearly it's
  636. 20:15correcting something in the Bible,
  637. 20:17correcting something in the hands of the
  638. 20:18Christians and the Jews. is correcting
  639. 20:20it. And that's why the Quran calls
  640. 20:22itself a mu. Muhe means the corrector.
  641. 20:25It's the one that corrects it or mu and
  642. 20:27al it's the correct. So you're saying to
  643. 20:30me shotgunning indicates that the
  644. 20:32opposite is true. Then that must mean
  645. 20:34that you have no idea of the Quran. You
  646. 20:36have no idea of tap. You have no idea of
  647. 20:39what the scholars of Islam said. You
  648. 20:40have no idea of hadith. And that's what
  649. 20:42happens when you put forward when the
  650. 20:44Christian pmical community put forward
  651. 20:46an individual who doesn't know the
  652. 20:48Arabic language who doesn't know who
  653. 20:51doesn't know Quran who doesn't know
  654. 20:53anything he's never learned Islamic
  655. 20:55studies in his life and you put him
  656. 20:57forward to discuss things with me you
  657. 20:59came here too early you should have had
  658. 21:01a couple of other journeymen you should
  659. 21:02have gone to the street and spoke to the
  660. 21:04people the Quran actually says the
  661. 21:06opposite of what you're saying in
  662. 21:07chapter 5 speak bro
  663. 21:10>> the Quran says you you lied upon the
  664. 21:12Quran by saying that the Quran is
  665. 21:13indicating that if
  666. 21:15>> how long you going to preach that man
  667. 21:17let's tell Muhammad if the prophet
  668. 21:18Muhammad were to go to a Christian the
  669. 21:20Christian corrects him then he must
  670. 21:22follow that the Quran says the opposite
  671. 21:24of that the Quran says that well
  672. 21:28which means
  673. 21:30that is a guardian is a is something
  674. 21:34which distinguishes between truth and
  675. 21:36falsehood sovereign over the over the
  676. 21:39previous scriptures
  677. 21:40>> you're telling No, bro. What's going on?
  678. 21:42Is this a dialogue or not? You
  679. 21:44monologuing, preaching. You
  680. 21:46>> ask your next question because if this
  681. 21:47is your strongest argument, I don't see
  682. 21:48how it is.
  683. 21:49>> Okay. So, you saying nuh-uh nuh-uh is
  684. 21:52not a a reputation of the argument. Let
  685. 21:54me even start. Let me start with your
  686. 21:56example. Get to the point. I'm at the
  687. 21:58point. Let me start with your example.
  688. 22:00Remember, you spoke for the longest. So,
  689. 22:01please give me the same respect. You You
  690. 22:04said that if you drink this hot tea, if
  691. 22:06you say if you drink this hot tea, then
  692. 22:08you'll have to go to the bathroom.
  693. 22:10doesn't necessarily mean that if you
  694. 22:11don't drink the hot tea that you won't
  695. 22:13necessarily have to go to the bathroom.
  696. 22:14That's a false equivalence because in
  697. 22:17the in the example in your phrase that
  698. 22:19you're saying that the the tea is going
  699. 22:22to cause you to go to the bathroom means
  700. 22:24that if you don't drink the tea then the
  701. 22:26tea is not going to cause you [laughter]
  702. 22:28to go to the bathroom. Look at this.
  703. 22:31This really none of none of this is
  704. 22:34helping you. The nervous laughter is not
  705. 22:35going to get you.
  706. 22:36>> Stupid man you are. I got you. So, bro.
  707. 22:40So, so again, so again, according to the
  708. 22:43according to the passage, this is what
  709. 22:44you got, this is what you need to help
  710. 22:45me do.
  711. 22:46>> Okay, I got you. So, this is what you
  712. 22:48need to help me do.
  713. 22:50>> Since you conceded, Since you conceded,
  714. 22:52Muhammad,
  715. 22:55>> since you conceded, next question,
  716. 22:57please. You conceded that Muhammad can
  717. 23:00get clarity on the uncertainty of what
  718. 23:03the Quran is saying by going to the
  719. 23:05previous scriptures. You did. Now,
  720. 23:08brother, we're going to rewind your
  721. 23:09words and play it back in front of you.
  722. 23:11You need to watch your clip back, dude.
  723. 23:13>> Saying you've ever said it. You know,
  724. 23:16look, Avery,
  725. 23:16>> notice how you're interrupting me, man.
  726. 23:18Why can't I speak?
  727. 23:19>> Avery Avery, hold on.
  728. 23:20>> Why can't I speak? Look, look, be fair.
  729. 23:23You're a Christian. You got to let me
  730. 23:24get my argument off.
  731. 23:26Your mental opportunity.
  732. 23:27>> You conceived it earlier and now you're
  733. 23:29saying you never said that. We all saw
  734. 23:31it. All of us. Huh? You're mental. This
  735. 23:33is absolutely embarrassing. Nuhuh. Uhuh.
  736. 23:35Nuh-uh.
  737. 23:36>> One second. One second. You said clarity
  738. 23:38on what the Quran is saying. I never
  739. 23:40once said any of that. I never once said
  740. 23:42any of that. I never once said any of
  741. 23:44that. You did, bro. Now you're lying up
  742. 23:46here. Remember, you're the qualified guy
  743. 23:47and you have to take back your words
  744. 23:49like this.
  745. 23:49>> Okay. All right. I didn't say anything
  746. 23:51about clarity of what the Quran is
  747. 23:53saying. I didn't say clarity of what the
  748. 23:55uncertain things the Quran is saying. I
  749. 23:57didn't say anything about that. Okay.
  750. 23:59I've clearly said to you the position.
  751. 24:00The position is this. The position is
  752. 24:03the Quran says that it's a mu which
  753. 24:06means it's a guardian and it sives out
  754. 24:09it filters. It's a filter for the truth
  755. 24:12of a guardian. I thought it was hold on
  756. 24:15and how do you explain that please? How
  757. 24:18do you explain before you do the Muslim
  758. 24:20shuffle? the hijab twostep. But first,
  759. 24:22you should argue that the Quran says
  760. 24:24Muhammad. If you know what you said,
  761. 24:26sure,
  762. 24:26>> I'll explain it. The Quran. So, it
  763. 24:29depends on your interpretation because
  764. 24:30you have some interpreters that
  765. 24:32interpreted that Muhammad that it was
  766. 24:34Muhammad who was a Muhammad over the
  767. 24:36Quran. And so then if you're going to be
  768. 24:38consistent, then you're going to have to
  769. 24:39say that Muhammad is an authority or
  770. 24:41corruptor or it's words of Allah. That's
  771. 24:43not what anyone say. You hold and the
  772. 24:46Quran is mu. Wait, hold on. The the
  773. 24:49Quran is al mu. It's called al mu.
  774. 24:53>> Would you like to see that say otherwise
  775. 24:55that say Muhammad's man the Muhammad?
  776. 24:57>> The Quran the the verse is very clear
  777. 25:00that the Quran is the Muhamm.
  778. 25:02>> Now to everybody to some of your
  779. 25:04scholars they said Muhammad is the
  780. 25:06Muhammad.
  781. 25:07>> You see look you're having to lie now.
  782. 25:08This is quite pathetic.
  783. 25:09>> Do you want me to show you? Can I share
  784. 25:10my screen?
  785. 25:11>> No no no you don't need to share
  786. 25:12anything. [laughter] You're wasting no
  787. 25:14wasting. What are you laughing at? It's
  788. 25:15the Quran. The Quran. You don't like
  789. 25:18Muhammad. You don't like Muhammad. Okay.
  790. 25:20>> Oh man. This is a joy.
  791. 25:22>> What you laughing at? What you laughing
  792. 25:23at? I get I'm let you know. I lost the
  793. 25:25same skill set on my everyday Monday
  794. 25:27from Monday, Wednesday, Friday stream.
  795. 25:29You're no different than the everyday
  796. 25:31Muslim. What does mean? What does hukan
  797. 25:33mean?
  798. 25:33>> Means criterion.
  799. 25:35>> Okay. So what does it mean? What a
  800. 25:38standard of truth that tells you what's
  801. 25:39right and WHAT'S WRONG. [screaming]
  802. 25:45THERE YOU GO. [laughter]
  803. 25:48GUESS WHAT? [screaming] THE QURAN SAYS
  804. 25:50THE TOY IS also
  805. 25:54[laughter]
  806. 26:02hear what you're saying. I can't hear.
  807. 26:03Tell me something else. I just said I
  808. 26:05just said that according to your Quran,
  809. 26:08the Torah is alan. In chapter 21:48 and
  810. 26:11in chapter 2:53 the term is African.
  811. 26:15[laughter]
  812. 26:21[laughter]
  813. 26:22>> So what do you got to say about that?
  814. 26:24The Torah is the Quran or not? Is the
  815. 26:25Quran for or not? Is it?
  816. 26:27>> Yes. So is the Torah. So is the Torah?
  817. 26:29>> Yes. Torah in it own right. By the way,
  818. 26:32so is the Torah. Correct. Is that
  819. 26:34correct? The Torah is also for chapter
  820. 26:3625. Yeah. It doesn't say the Torah. It
  821. 26:40says I just said chapter 21:48. It says
  822. 26:43that we gave Moses and Aaron the
  823. 26:45scripture and the criterion.
  824. 26:48Torah, right? That's true. That's true.
  825. 26:49That's true. I know it's true. Hold on.
  826. 26:52Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Hold
  827. 26:54on. Can't both be true.
  828. 26:56What was given to Aaron and Hold on,
  829. 26:58hold on.
  830. 26:59>> So, what was given to Aaron was a right?
  831. 27:01>> Say it again.
  832. 27:02>> Look at me or what?
  833. 27:03>> Yeah. Aaron and given to dress for the
  834. 27:06occasion. I'm getting my getting messy.
  835. 27:08Hold on.
  836. 27:08>> Is what was given to Are you okay?
  837. 27:11What's this guy doing? Is it Get out of
  838. 27:13here. You want You want to throw the
  839. 27:14towel? You want to throw the towel, boy?
  840. 27:17You want to throw the towel?
  841. 27:18>> Oh, come on. I need to dress. It works.
  842. 27:21It works for the occasion.
  843. 27:24>> Sit down. Sit down. Sit down.
  844. 27:25>> I need to dress for the occasion. He
  845. 27:27needs to do this. He needs to do this,
  846. 27:28doesn't he?
  847. 27:29>> He's getting agitated.
  848. 27:30>> I need to I need to dress for the
  849. 27:32occasion, man.
  850. 27:33>> Okay.
  851. 27:34>> Okay. [clears throat] All right. So, now
  852. 27:35here's the question. Here's here's the
  853. 27:37question, too. Are we done with your
  854. 27:39>> Are we Are we Are we done with your
  855. 27:40logic? Are we done with your dile
  856. 27:42dilemma?
  857. 27:43>> Uh, no. You haven't you haven't dealt
  858. 27:44with it yet. You just said an answer.
  859. 27:46>> You want to ask me now?
  860. 27:47>> Okay. So So, so continuing with the
  861. 27:49argument because you said you never said
  862. 27:50this. You said you never said this. So,
  863. 27:52I'm going to make you say it again.
  864. 27:53>> What's your question? What's your
  865. 27:54question? About to give it to you. Said
  866. 27:56this. I'm about to give it to you. I'm
  867. 27:58about to give it to you. I'm about to
  868. 27:59give it to What's your question? What's
  869. 28:01your question?
  870. 28:01>> All right. So when Allah tells Muhammad,
  871. 28:04>> yeah,
  872. 28:05>> if you are in doubt
  873. 28:07>> about what we have revealed to you, if
  874. 28:09you're uncertain about the truth, about
  875. 28:10what we revealed to you like four or
  876. 28:12five times, right?
  877. 28:13>> Because you keep flip-flopping like
  878. 28:14flip.
  879. 28:15>> You asked this question like four or
  880. 28:16five times, haven't you?
  881. 28:17>> Because you keep saying you said it and
  882. 28:18you didn't say it. The relation of yes,
  883. 28:19no, yes.
  884. 28:20>> You understand? You understand that the
  885. 28:22Quran is referred to as bim and furan.
  886. 28:25Okay. You can't get away from that.
  887. 28:26Okay. Which means it's the criterion.
  888. 28:28All right. Of course, you said it's the
  889. 28:29criterion. You understand that the Quran
  890. 28:32is a criterion over the previous You
  891. 28:35understand? You understand that when
  892. 28:38Prophet Muhammad wasallam
  893. 28:41reading aspects of the Torah, he told
  894. 28:43them that you have been given something
  895. 28:45you don't need to read this which is the
  896. 28:46Quran.
  897. 28:47>> Say that again.
  898. 28:48>> Are you say that again? You
  899. 28:49>> want me to say that one more time?
  900. 28:50>> Yeah, please. When when the prophet
  901. 28:52Muhammad wasallam saw Omar Katab reading
  902. 28:55aspects of the Tawat of the time which
  903. 28:58were preserved some aspects were
  904. 28:59preserved and he was reading it he said
  905. 29:01that you've been given something which
  906. 29:02replaces this. So the point is the point
  907. 29:05is this the prophet wasallam mentioned
  908. 29:07yeah in aith
  909. 29:12you know this hadith do not bely them
  910. 29:14and do not believe them about the people
  911. 29:16of the past
  912. 29:20do not believe them and do not bely them
  913. 29:21do you know this hadith in mkari
  914. 29:22>> yes so what what does he say so so so
  915. 29:25hold on there are aspects of noct of
  916. 29:28these let me finish let me finish what
  917. 29:30I'm saying
  918. 29:30>> finish the hadith
  919. 29:34Let me explain to you. And no, finish
  920. 29:37the last line. You're skipping a line.
  921. 29:38That'sith
  922. 29:50English. Do not bel do not bel them and
  923. 29:53do not believe them. You can speak of
  924. 29:56Israel.
  925. 29:58Yeah. With no issues.
  926. 29:59>> No, that's not what he says. That's not
  927. 30:01what he says. Okay, let me let me teach
  928. 30:04you. He says
  929. 30:09this means them and do not believe them.
  930. 30:12Which means that there's aspects of
  931. 30:13what's in circulation.
  932. 30:16This is why this is important.
  933. 30:19I got you. He says, "Do not believe them
  934. 30:21nor disbelieve them, but say we have we
  935. 30:24believe in what was revealed to us and
  936. 30:26what is revealed to you." You just read
  937. 30:29it, didn't you?
  938. 30:34The point I'm making is am I correct? Do
  939. 30:36not believe them. Do not bel them. So
  940. 30:38the issue is this.
  941. 30:38>> So what are they supposed to say?
  942. 30:39>> Yeah. Yeah. And tell them that we've
  943. 30:41believed in what was revealed to Abraham
  944. 30:42and Jacob and Isaac, etc. in the Quran.
  945. 30:44It's mentioned.
  946. 30:45>> So he you're supposed to believe in what
  947. 30:47you have corrected.
  948. 30:48>> He recites caught lying on your own
  949. 30:50hadith. Sorry. Say again. You're caught
  950. 30:52lying and misquing your own hadith. I
  951. 30:54have your What are you talking about,
  952. 30:57man? Are you stupid?
  953. 31:00The Quran says that the hadith says that
  954. 31:02don't bely them and don't believe them.
  955. 31:04Which means that there's something in
  956. 31:05circulation. There is something in
  957. 31:07circulation from which is you may remain
  958. 31:11agnostic about. If the Quran contradicts
  959. 31:15it, then the Quran takes precedence.
  960. 31:18That's why never said that
  961. 31:23they didn't kill him, they didn't
  962. 31:24crucify, but it was made to appear.
  963. 31:26Clearly, it's correcting something,
  964. 31:27isn't it? In the New Testament. Let me
  965. 31:29touch on this because you're messing up
  966. 31:30your Is the Quran correcting the New
  967. 31:32Testament? It is not. And guess what?
  968. 31:34Muhammad correcting the New Testament.
  969. 31:37Let me answer. Is the Quran correcting
  970. 31:39the New Testament?
  971. 31:40>> Question. Let me answer. The answer is
  972. 31:42the answer is no. And Muhammad never
  973. 31:45ever ever says that the Quran is
  974. 31:48correcting the previous scriptures. Say
  975. 31:50that.
  976. 31:52Let me finish. The Quran's correcting.
  977. 31:53Wait, hold on.
  978. 31:56You got to let me finish, man.
  979. 31:58>> Let me ask you a question. Let me ask
  980. 31:59you a question. You trying to jump.
  981. 32:02>> When the Quran says,
  982. 32:04>> "Stop trying to not like the rest, man.
  983. 32:07Stay in there."
  984. 32:08>> Hold on for a second, Avery. Otherwise,
  985. 32:09we can't We can't speak over each other.
  986. 32:10Let me ask
  987. 32:11>> You're speaking over me.
  988. 32:12>> I You're not letting me speak.
  989. 32:15>> I just let you finish and ask me a
  990. 32:16question. You didn't let me finish my
  991. 32:17answer.
  992. 32:18>> Let me Let me tell you. I'll ask you a
  993. 32:19question. Let me ask
  994. 32:20>> You're about to ask and let me speak.
  995. 32:21>> Correct.
  996. 32:22>> You're going to You're going to give me
  997. 32:23an answer. to ask you the question,
  998. 32:24right? So, can I qualify my answer
  999. 32:26though? Can you let me ask you the
  1000. 32:28question so you can answer?
  1001. 32:28>> Of course, but I want to know if I
  1002. 32:29short. Let me ask you the question.
  1003. 32:31Don't be too scared. Don't be worried.
  1004. 32:32Don't be nervous. I know that you know
  1005. 32:34you must be scared because you don't
  1006. 32:35even let me ask.
  1007. 32:36>> It doesn't work on me. Are you Can you
  1008. 32:38assure me that when you scared?
  1009. 32:40>> Can you assure me that I will be allowed
  1010. 32:42to answer your question?
  1011. 32:42>> Can you ask the question? Let me just
  1012. 32:44ask you the question.
  1013. 32:44>> Will you allow me to answer the
  1014. 32:46question? Let me ask you the question.
  1015. 32:47Let me ask you the question.
  1016. 32:48>> So, I'm going to answer in when you ask.
  1017. 32:50>> Go ahead.
  1018. 32:50>> Okay. So, you're not letting me say
  1019. 32:52anything? Yeah,
  1020. 32:52>> I'm letting you go. I'm just saying I'm
  1021. 32:54going to answer in full.
  1022. 32:55>> When the Quran says,
  1023. 33:00yeah, that no weariness touched God that
  1024. 33:04Allah he created the heavens and the
  1025. 33:06earth and
  1026. 33:09no weariness touched him. Yeah. Is that
  1027. 33:12a correction of the Genesis and Exodus
  1028. 33:16narrative or not? Yes or no? Is it
  1029. 33:18correcting what's in the hands of the
  1030. 33:19Bible or not? Is it correcting or not?
  1031. 33:21I'm gonna answer you in full. The answer
  1032. 33:24is no. It is not a correction. No, it is
  1033. 33:27not a correction. The Bible doesn't even
  1034. 33:28teach tiredness. Notice how it doesn't
  1035. 33:32even teach that tiredness touched God.
  1036. 33:35In fact, it talks about him ceasing
  1037. 33:37working on the seventh day. Not that he
  1038. 33:39was actually tired. So, if you knew your
  1039. 33:41own, let me
  1040. 33:44hold on. If you knew your own, you know
  1041. 33:46that there's a verse allowing me to
  1042. 33:47answer. You must BE BOY. YOU MUST BE
  1043. 33:51SCARED, BOY. [laughter]
  1044. 33:53>> Let me finish. Let's go back to the
  1045. 33:56hadith that you are referring to.
  1046. 33:58>> Hold on. Hold on. It says, "Don't
  1047. 34:00believe what they say nor disbelieve
  1048. 34:02what they say." This is what you respond
  1049. 34:04to.
  1050. 34:04>> Why you changing the subject?
  1051. 34:05>> We believe. Let me finish.
  1052. 34:06>> Why you changing the subject?
  1053. 34:07>> No, you're the one who changed the
  1054. 34:08subject. You brought this. Hold on. Hold
  1055. 34:11on. Hold on.
  1056. 34:11>> You brought this up, but now you're
  1057. 34:13getting screwed. Now you're getting Why
  1058. 34:15you running? Why you running? says, "Say
  1059. 34:17believe in what was revealed to us."
  1060. 34:21>> Avery, what was revealed to you? Avery,
  1061. 34:23listen.
  1062. 34:24>> So, hold on. Are you supposed to believe
  1063. 34:25in what was going to listen or not? No.
  1064. 34:27Are you going to listen? I don't listen
  1065. 34:28to you.
  1066. 34:29>> Are you So, answer the question.
  1067. 34:31>> Let me let me let me tell you what I'm
  1068. 34:32saying to me.
  1069. 34:33>> Let me tell you what I'm saying and then
  1070. 34:34you can say what you want to say.
  1071. 34:36>> You said that. Let me speak, man. Just
  1072. 34:38give me 20 seconds
  1073. 34:40again.
  1074. 34:41>> If you It's not a dialogue if if we
  1075. 34:43can't speak to each other. You're the
  1076. 34:45only one speaking over me. Hijab,
  1077. 34:46>> if you let me speak for 20 seconds, then
  1078. 34:48you can respond for 20 seconds.
  1079. 34:50Otherwise, you're trying to you you get
  1080. 34:52it.
  1081. 34:53>> Okay. So, what I'm trying to say is that
  1082. 34:54in the book of Genesis, it's mentioned,
  1083. 34:57yeah, that God rested. However, in the
  1084. 34:59book of Exodus, chapter number 31 verse
  1085. 35:02number 17, okay, in that verse, the word
  1086. 35:06is that he not only rested, but he
  1087. 35:07refreshed. And the Hebrew word is
  1088. 35:09nafash. So here clearly in the Old
  1089. 35:12Testament corpus you have this idea of
  1090. 35:15God actually literally resting. If you
  1091. 35:18find if you look at all of the the the
  1092. 35:20the the rabbitical commentary about that
  1093. 35:22it's an actual rest. So the point is
  1094. 35:24this you're saying when the Quran says
  1095. 35:28in chapter number 50 in that it's not
  1096. 35:31correcting this. So what is it
  1097. 35:33correcting then? Why is it mentioning
  1098. 35:34that?
  1099. 35:36>> All right. So again,
  1100. 35:38>> um the the author of the Quran is
  1101. 35:41actually unfamiliar with what is in the
  1102. 35:43Bible. He only goes by word of Allah. So
  1103. 35:46notice you said that I can speak. Notice
  1104. 35:48how you said I can speak. I let you
  1105. 35:49speak. Unin
  1106. 35:50>> Okay, go ahead.
  1107. 35:51>> I already answered you. No, it is not a
  1108. 35:54correction. Muhammad is ignorant of what
  1109. 35:56is in the previous scriptures and he's
  1110. 35:58only going by word of mouth. Here's an
  1111. 35:59example. The example is what you brought
  1112. 36:02up in the hadith that you had no idea
  1113. 36:04about. The hadith says that you're
  1114. 36:06referring to it says that the Jews used
  1115. 36:08to recite the Torah in Hebrew and then
  1116. 36:11explain it in Arabic.
  1117. 36:13>> Okay. So before
  1118. 36:16let me finish this one.
  1119. 36:17>> Let me finish. Let me finish.
  1120. 36:21Go on to speak.
  1121. 36:22>> I appreciate it. So according to the
  1122. 36:24hadith that you brought up, it destroys
  1123. 36:26you because it shows that they're
  1124. 36:27hearing by word of mouth. They're having
  1125. 36:29the Torah explained to them in Arabic by
  1126. 36:31some of the Jews. Then in response,
  1127. 36:33Muhammad says, "Don't believe what they
  1128. 36:35say, nor disbelieve what they say, but
  1129. 36:38in response say,"We believe in what was
  1130. 36:41revealed to us and what was revealed to
  1131. 36:42you." So they can't trust the Jews on if
  1132. 36:45they're lying or not of what their
  1133. 36:46scriptures say, cuz they don't know it.
  1134. 36:47They don't know the scriptures
  1135. 36:48themselves. They're only going by word
  1136. 36:50of mouth. So Muhammad is not correcting
  1137. 36:52nothing. He's ignorant of the
  1138. 36:53scriptures.
  1139. 36:53>> Okay. So I've let you speak. Is it my
  1140. 36:55time to respond?
  1141. 36:56>> Thank you. I appreciate it. Finally.
  1142. 36:57>> Yeah. Fine. By the way, don't forget
  1143. 36:59that Muhammad point because I I'm going
  1144. 37:02to show you that Mujah is the one that
  1145. 37:03said that Muhammad was the Muhammad over
  1146. 37:05the Quran. Give me a second. Let me
  1147. 37:06speak. Let me respond.
  1148. 37:08>> I've given you one example. Okay, one
  1149. 37:10example is in the book of Exodus,
  1150. 37:12chapter number 31 and the book of
  1151. 37:14Genesis, chapter number one, there's
  1152. 37:16this idea of rest. Now, you can say
  1153. 37:18Genesis is not rest is ceasing to work,
  1154. 37:19but you can't say that with the book of
  1155. 37:20Exodus. And therefore, the Quran says in
  1156. 37:23more than one occasion, by the way, it
  1157. 37:24actually says this many times inah it
  1158. 37:27mentions
  1159. 37:28in chapter 46 in chapter number 50 it
  1160. 37:30mentions that no no we has touched him
  1161. 37:33no the tide has touched him so clearly
  1162. 37:35there's a correction going on but you
  1163. 37:36don't want to believe that no problem
  1164. 37:37the Quran says
  1165. 37:41the Quran clearly is responding to a
  1166. 37:44biblical narrative it's clearly
  1167. 37:47responding to a Christian narrative
  1168. 37:49saying they did not kill him they did
  1169. 37:50not crucify him
  1170. 37:53it was made to appear as if they So the
  1171. 37:57question is this is the Quran with this
  1172. 38:00verse
  1173. 38:04is it aware of what is being said by
  1174. 38:07Christians. Is this correct that they
  1175. 38:08say that he he was killed and crucified?
  1176. 38:10Is that correct representation? And is
  1177. 38:12it then correcting that or not? Yes or
  1178. 38:14no? Beautiful. So now I get to fully
  1179. 38:17answer. So this is what you're this is
  1180. 38:19notice the difference. The answer is
  1181. 38:22yes. Here's a quick answer to yes.
  1182. 38:24>> Yes. It is correcting what people
  1183. 38:27say, "Yeah, now we're talking." is
  1184. 38:29correcting what they say, not what the
  1185. 38:32scriptures say,
  1186. 38:34>> but the Christians and the Jews. So,
  1187. 38:36notice how notice how Let me Let me
  1188. 38:37land. I let you speak uninterrupted.
  1189. 38:39Right.
  1190. 38:40>> So, thank you. I appreciate it. So,
  1191. 38:42notice the difference. At first, you
  1192. 38:44were arguing that Muhammad is aware of
  1193. 38:47what the scripture says and is
  1194. 38:49correcting the scripture, not just what
  1195. 38:51the Jews and Christians say. But you
  1196. 38:53just changed your question to is
  1197. 38:55Muhammad aware of what the Christians
  1198. 38:57say and is therefore correcting what the
  1199. 38:59Christians say. And the answer to that
  1200. 39:01is yes. Unbeknownst to him that what
  1201. 39:04they are saying is actually in the in
  1202. 39:07the gospel. So Muhammad is going against
  1203. 39:11the Christians unknowingly going against
  1204. 39:14the gospel. And here's the point. This
  1205. 39:16is why. Hold on. Let
  1206. 39:19>> keep talking. Actually I appreciate it.
  1207. 39:22I didn't realize this, but [laughter]
  1208. 39:25I didn't realize this actually. Please
  1209. 39:27keep talking.
  1210. 39:28Thank you. So, what you're going to have
  1211. 39:30to deal Thank you. So, this is what
  1212. 39:32you're going to have to deal with. What
  1213. 39:33you're going to have to deal with is
  1214. 39:35Muhammad commanding you not to just not
  1215. 39:38to believe what we say or disbelieve
  1216. 39:40what we say. Notice he never goes
  1217. 39:42against the scripture. Show me anywhere
  1218. 39:45anywhere where Muhammad says, "Don't
  1219. 39:48believe in what the scripture says."
  1220. 39:50Man, what are you talking?
  1221. 39:50>> Show me one time where mom said
  1222. 39:51>> Avery, let's go back to the point.
  1223. 39:53>> This is the point, please.
  1224. 39:54>> Avery, hold on. This is what you said.
  1225. 39:57You said that it was a correction. Okay,
  1226. 40:00it was a correction. You You admitted
  1227. 40:02you actually I'm surprised and I have to
  1228. 40:04I have to commend you actually.
  1229. 40:05>> Yeah.
  1230. 40:06>> I thought you'd be a belligerent young
  1231. 40:07man.
  1232. 40:08>> Okay. I thought, you know, you put on
  1233. 40:10the hat, you put a humble, but I have to
  1234. 40:12say you're better than I thought you'd
  1235. 40:14be. You're better than I thought. You
  1236. 40:16you do you do have a future in in in
  1237. 40:19content creation and in in influencing.
  1238. 40:21>> You do have a future this and you you
  1239. 40:23know what there's some I'm starting to
  1240. 40:25like him.
  1241. 40:26>> Yeah.
  1242. 40:27>> Yeah. He's got some he's got some good
  1243. 40:28qualities. But just
  1244. 40:29>> that's usually the effect I have on
  1245. 40:31people
  1246. 40:31>> because don't just smile like that
  1247. 40:32because you look like a buck buck to uh
  1248. 40:36[laughter]
  1249. 40:37put
  1250. 40:40a we're having we're having a good time.
  1251. 40:42>> This is a humble chef. I like to cook
  1252. 40:44giant.
  1253. 40:45>> Okay. Whatever. Let me just say this to
  1254. 40:47you, right?
  1255. 40:48>> The point I'm making to you is is is
  1256. 40:49this. You have just admitted when the
  1257. 40:52Quran says,
  1258. 40:55"Yeah, that I didn't say anything."
  1259. 40:57>> No, no, no. Let me finish what I'm
  1260. 40:58saying. Let me finish. But you just
  1261. 41:00misrepresented me. I never said about
  1262. 41:01anything.
  1263. 41:02>> I didn't even say anything yet.
  1264. 41:03>> Yes, you did. You said that what I
  1265. 41:04admitted that what the Quran says I
  1266. 41:07never said anything about what the Quran
  1267. 41:08says. We're talking about what Muhammad
  1268. 41:10said. I
  1269. 41:11>> haven't finished my sentence. So, you
  1270. 41:12would you couldn't have known what I'm
  1271. 41:14saying. Go ahead, bro.
  1272. 41:15>> I said when the Quran when [laughter]
  1273. 41:16the Quran said
  1274. 41:22they did not kill him, they did not
  1275. 41:24crucify him. Where it was made to appear
  1276. 41:26to them that that was the case. Yeah.
  1277. 41:29You admitted that that was what you
  1278. 41:31thought was a correction of Muhammad of
  1279. 41:34the Christian community, but you thought
  1280. 41:36he didn't know what's in the New
  1281. 41:37Testament. Okay. He didn't know what's
  1282. 41:39in the New Testament, yet it's still a
  1283. 41:41correction somehow. The point is, is the
  1284. 41:43crucifixion mentioned in the New
  1285. 41:44Testament? Yes, the crucifixion is
  1286. 41:46without a doubt mentioned in the New
  1287. 41:48Testament, and it's mentioned multiple
  1288. 41:50times in multiple reports. It says in
  1289. 41:52the Quran that it was made to appear to
  1290. 41:54them that it was the case, it didn't
  1291. 41:57really happen. This is a correction of
  1292. 42:00the Quran which shows the author of the
  1293. 42:02Quran whether you believe it's the
  1294. 42:04prophet Muhammad or we believe it's
  1295. 42:05Allah. The author of the Quran was fully
  1296. 42:08aware of what was in that book and he
  1297. 42:11was fully aware what was in circulation
  1298. 42:12with Christians and Jews. And not only
  1299. 42:14did he reject it, he corrected it. Is
  1300. 42:17that true or is that false? False again.
  1301. 42:20So I don't know I I don't know how many
  1302. 42:22times you want me to answer this for
  1303. 42:23you. Hijab I don't know how many times
  1304. 42:25you want me to answer this. I I'll break
  1305. 42:27it down. And remember, I'm going to
  1306. 42:29break it down in in unqualified terms.
  1307. 42:31And maybe this will help you out. What
  1308. 42:33we're talking about is what Muhammad is
  1309. 42:36saying regarding what the people say,
  1310. 42:39not the scriptures. So when the Quran
  1311. 42:42says, "Oh, uh, they for," this is the
  1312. 42:45example, for their boasting. For their
  1313. 42:48boasting, we killed the Messiah. We
  1314. 42:51killed the Hold on a second.
  1315. 42:52>> For their boasting, this is chapter four
  1316. 42:54about the crucifixion verse.
  1317. 42:55>> What is this? For their boasting,
  1318. 42:58[laughter] they say, "We killed the
  1319. 43:00Messiah, son of son of uh son of Mary."
  1320. 43:02Notice this. Can you please listen? I
  1321. 43:05need you to pay attention this time so
  1322. 43:06you can learn this.
  1323. 43:07>> The Quran is addressing what people are
  1324. 43:10saying. It's never addressing what the
  1325. 43:12scriptures themselves say.
  1326. 43:14>> Why? Because Muhammad didn't know.
  1327. 43:17>> Because he was ignorant. What you need
  1328. 43:20to do, hijab, what you need to This is
  1329. 43:21what I need to do. This is what I need
  1330. 43:23you to do. I've got a question.
  1331. 43:24>> I need you to Let me finish.
  1332. 43:25>> I've got a I've got a question for you.
  1333. 43:26I've got an honest question.
  1334. 43:28>> Ask it after I'm done.
  1335. 43:29>> I've got a question for you on this
  1336. 43:30point. I've got a question for you.
  1337. 43:32Please
  1338. 43:32>> ask it after I'm done.
  1339. 43:34>> No, ask it after 20 seconds. Should I
  1340. 43:35give you 20 seconds?
  1341. 43:36>> No, I need more time than that cuz you
  1342. 43:37didn't have like 15 seconds.
  1343. 43:39>> Let me speak. When I when I finish, I'm
  1344. 43:42good.
  1345. 43:43>> Okay. Okay. I appreciate it. So, we're
  1346. 43:46talking about what they say, not what
  1347. 43:48the scriptures say. What you would need
  1348. 43:50to do for me, hijab,
  1349. 43:51>> is give me any hadith. You got thousands
  1350. 43:53to pick from. Give me any hadith where
  1351. 43:55Muhammad talks about or discredits what
  1352. 43:58the scriptures say, not what the people
  1353. 44:00say. That's number one. Number two, what
  1354. 44:02I would like for you to do is show me
  1355. 44:04where the Quran say uh critiques what
  1356. 44:07the scripture says. It says this is in
  1357. 44:09the scripture and then it and then it
  1358. 44:10goes on to correct or address what the
  1359. 44:13scripture says uh and says that that's
  1360. 44:15wrong. Okay. Don't show me cuz this is
  1361. 44:17all we have. Show me a couple things. I
  1362. 44:19promise I'm about to land.
  1363. 44:21>> Okay. What we have in the Quran and from
  1364. 44:22Muhammad, Muhammad says in jammy altern
  1365. 44:3389, chapter 2 verse 91, chapter 4 vers 7
  1366. 44:37vers 101, it says the Quran is
  1367. 44:39confirming what is with them. Never do
  1368. 44:42we ever see one unambiguous statement.
  1369. 44:44>> Okay,
  1370. 44:45>> one unequivical verse where the Quran is
  1371. 44:47correcting the previous scriptures
  1372. 44:48textually.
  1373. 44:49>> Beautiful. Let me let me respond.
  1374. 44:50>> Speak anything. Hadith of the Quran.
  1375. 44:52>> I've already mentioned to you before and
  1376. 44:54I don't know if you got this point.
  1377. 44:55Yeah.
  1378. 44:55>> Does the Quran mention that that's in
  1379. 44:56the scripture?
  1380. 44:56>> You know, have you spoken? Have I let
  1381. 44:58you speak?
  1382. 44:58>> You did interrupt me a little bit.
  1383. 45:00>> Okay. So, is it my turn now to can I
  1384. 45:02respond?
  1385. 45:03>> Yeah, sure. If you can answer that, if
  1386. 45:04you can answer my question directly.
  1387. 45:06>> So, yeah. The point is yes or no.
  1388. 45:08>> I made this point to the your previous
  1389. 45:10the previous guest that we had. When I
  1390. 45:12was saying that whenever the Quran
  1391. 45:13mentions for example the probably the
  1392. 45:15clearest verse is in I'll help you with
  1393. 45:17it.
  1394. 45:21Yeah. Which is that they see the prophet
  1395. 45:24mentioned with them. Okay. With them. So
  1396. 45:26it indicates there's something going on
  1397. 45:28with them. They have something with
  1398. 45:29them. Right.
  1399. 45:30>> The in the Torah says explicitly.
  1400. 45:32>> Yeah. So it's Torah and Injil. There's
  1401. 45:34an aspect of that which is with them.
  1402. 45:36Now the question is this.
  1403. 45:37>> What does it say?
  1404. 45:37>> Is it Can I Can I finish this?
  1405. 45:40>> I didn't I didn't know we were
  1406. 45:41butchering texts.
  1407. 45:42>> Okay. Butchering texts. I I'll explain
  1408. 45:44to you why it's not butchering text cuz
  1409. 45:46this is things I've learned when I was
  1410. 45:47in university when I was doing the Azar
  1411. 45:49degree.
  1412. 45:50>> You learned it from Orthodox Muslim.
  1413. 45:51Nice.
  1414. 45:51>> No, no, no. No. I learned this what I'm
  1415. 45:53going to tell you now. An orthodox
  1416. 45:54Muslim did teach me a few things as
  1417. 45:55well. Actually, we were sitting down
  1418. 45:56here saying I'm starting to like this
  1419. 45:58guy.
  1420. 45:59>> Yeah. Started like this guy. You kind of
  1421. 46:01humble man.
  1422. 46:02>> What do [laughter] you mean?
  1423. 46:04Orthodox Muslim is my guy, brother. He's
  1424. 46:06he's our guy, brother.
  1425. 46:10I'm happy you can admit you think I have
  1426. 46:11a problem with a with a with a person
  1427. 46:13who has
  1428. 46:13>> I'm happy you can admit that you think I
  1429. 46:15care about that.
  1430. 46:16>> Yeah. So where in the text does it say
  1431. 46:18in our religion we we we take knowledge
  1432. 46:20from whoever.
  1433. 46:21>> In fact where does it say that
  1434. 46:27someone who is two people don't learn
  1435. 46:29you're one of them by the way which one
  1436. 46:31of them is a shy person the other one's
  1437. 46:32the arrogant person. So let me tell you
  1438. 46:34this.
  1439. 46:34>> Oh so you're the arrogant person.
  1440. 46:35>> There's two people who don't like learn.
  1441. 46:37Is it
  1442. 46:38>> there? But you just described yourself.
  1443. 46:40>> Sure. Sure. Maybe you're right about
  1444. 46:41that. Actually, you're probably right.
  1445. 46:42>> Okay. Putting that to the side for now.
  1446. 46:44Let me ask let me tell you this.
  1447. 46:46>> What I learned when I was in university
  1448. 46:47was that there's a principle called
  1449. 46:51Yeah. which is that using the whole to
  1450. 46:54refer to a part of a thing. So for
  1451. 46:56example, yeah, in the Quran in chapter
  1452. 46:5812, it says
  1453. 47:00ask the town. Okay. Ask the town. What
  1454. 47:04it means to say is ask the people of the
  1455. 47:06town. But this is a rhetorical device
  1456. 47:07that's mentioned.
  1457. 47:08>> So the whole town is represented by a
  1458. 47:11part of the town is represented by the
  1459. 47:13whole of the object. Number one. Number
  1460. 47:16two in the Quran it says in chapter 71
  1461. 47:23that they put their fingers in their
  1462. 47:24ears. Right? Now they don't put their
  1463. 47:26entire fingers in their ears. They put a
  1464. 47:27part of the fingers in the ears. So the
  1465. 47:29the point the point is in English you
  1466. 47:31call this part uh Tatum propartum. Yeah.
  1467. 47:35Tatum propum which is the idea of using
  1468. 47:38a gen a general statement to talk about
  1469. 47:40a whole other thing. So if I say the
  1470. 47:41United States won the match or if I say
  1471. 47:44that England won the match doesn't mean
  1472. 47:46every single person in the country won
  1473. 47:47the match. So the the point is this this
  1474. 47:50principle super extends to all of those
  1475. 47:52instances in the Quran where it
  1476. 47:54indicates that okay it speaks in generic
  1477. 47:58terms. when it says
  1478. 48:01or or any of those terms meaning with
  1479. 48:03them it indicates a part of those things
  1480. 48:05not the whole of the thing okay so
  1481. 48:07unless you're able to undo this
  1482. 48:08principle which is a principle not just
  1483. 48:10in Arabic linguistics but in all of the
  1484. 48:12languages in the world actually
  1485. 48:14including English yeah then you don't
  1486. 48:16have a case unfortunately as I said the
  1487. 48:17the scholars of Islam people like
  1488. 48:21they have made it very clear that they
  1489. 48:23believe that what's in with the
  1490. 48:25Christians and the Jews today is corrupt
  1491. 48:28That is which scholars? Which scholars?
  1492. 48:31>> I said in
  1493. 48:34he mentions that we and our friends he
  1494. 48:36says this
  1495. 48:38that me and our friends say that what's
  1496. 48:40in the hands of the the the Christians
  1497. 48:45is
  1498. 48:47it is it is distorted textually.
  1499. 48:51>> That's what I can you show us the
  1500. 48:52reference.
  1501. 48:53>> Yeah, it's in I can pull it up for you.
  1502. 48:56>> I can't right now. I'm drinking my tea.
  1503. 48:58I'm sitting down. You can find that. You
  1504. 48:59think I'd lied to you about that or
  1505. 49:00online people. You've been lying.
  1506. 49:03>> This is uncontroversial. Avery, this is
  1507. 49:04I'm Barry.
  1508. 49:06>> Let me show you why this No, I know
  1509. 49:08there are some corrupted.
  1510. 49:10>> I know there are some scholars who
  1511. 49:11didn't believe that. I know.
  1512. 49:13>> Yeah. Yeah. I know that. I know there
  1513. 49:15are some scholars. And see, I'm loving
  1514. 49:17your honesty. So, there's some scholars
  1515. 49:19who believe in sexual corruption. Some
  1516. 49:21scholars who believe in wholesale
  1517. 49:22preservation. That's beautiful. Good
  1518. 49:23job. Good job.
  1519. 49:25>> You don't believe in Let me tell you
  1520. 49:26this. So Ib Tamir believed in the
  1521. 49:27following. He didn't believe in
  1522. 49:28wholesome preservation. He believed that
  1523. 49:30he compared in his what do you call he
  1524. 49:33had a whole book called the uh correct
  1525. 49:36response to the Jews and the Christians.
  1526. 49:38Yeah. And in this book basically he says
  1527. 49:41this. He says the similitude of the
  1528. 49:43Bible okay is like the similitude of the
  1529. 49:45weak hadith. Okay. So we we treat the
  1530. 49:48Bible like we treat weak hadith. And
  1531. 49:50that's considered to be a strong version
  1532. 49:53of Okay.
  1533. 49:54Huh? What does Bkari say? Abkari there's
  1534. 49:57a difference of opinion about him. Like
  1535. 49:59so for example Hajbar who obviously is
  1536. 50:02interpreting Albkari because fat is an
  1537. 50:05interpretation of Bkari. Yeah says that
  1538. 50:08al Bkari has this view which indicates
  1539. 50:11that they may have had some kind of
  1540. 50:13preserved text at the time.
  1541. 50:15>> Okay. He indicates
  1542. 50:16>> may have says they definitely says that.
  1543. 50:20I don't think he says that. I don't he's
  1544. 50:21unsure about it. But what I'm saying to
  1545. 50:23you is that you can interpret Bkari
  1546. 50:25maybe like that. Yeah, you can. But what
  1547. 50:27I'm saying to you is,
  1548. 50:29>> huh, Bkari, that's what he says.
  1549. 50:30>> Some scholars of Islam might have
  1550. 50:32believed in this. I'm not negating this
  1551. 50:33point that the Jews and Christians at
  1552. 50:35the time of the prophet had some kind of
  1553. 50:36preserved text. Some means that our
  1554. 50:39position is is completely Islamic that
  1555. 50:41the scriptures are uncorrupt.
  1556. 50:42>> Scholars of Islam, some scholars,
  1557. 50:43classical scholars of Islam might have
  1558. 50:45believed that. But as I said, as I said,
  1559. 50:47yeah, of I have to be intellectually
  1560. 50:48honest. What do you think? Uh I'm being
  1561. 50:51I'm intellectually honest earlier.
  1562. 50:53>> The point I'm making to you is
  1563. 50:54>> the point I'm making to you is this.
  1564. 50:56It's very clear that the scholars the
  1565. 50:59overwhelming vast majority of Muslim
  1566. 51:02scholars believed that what's in the
  1567. 51:04hands of the Christians and the Jews is
  1568. 51:06corrupt. That is clear.
  1569. 51:08>> You said majority.
  1570. 51:10>> The overwhelming vast majority of the
  1571. 51:12Muslims,
  1572. 51:13>> pardon,
  1573. 51:13>> of the early Muslims.
  1574. 51:15>> Sorry, of the early Muslims.
  1575. 51:18The overwhelming vast majority of
  1576. 51:20classical scholars throughout the
  1577. 51:21medieval period throughout the early
  1578. 51:22scholars the like Hassam had a very
  1579. 51:25staunch view. He he what do you call it?
  1580. 51:26He wro in the fourth century the fifth
  1581. 51:28century. He believed that it's like
  1582. 51:30toilet paper. It's like nothing. He
  1583. 51:31believed the Bible of the of the time of
  1584. 51:33his people were was very is distorted.
  1585. 51:35That's what he believed.
  1586. 51:36>> What is your what is your evidence that
  1587. 51:37the majority of the early scholars of
  1588. 51:39Islam
  1589. 51:40>> believe that the previous scriptures
  1590. 51:42were
  1591. 51:43>> my evidence is what Kalani mentions in
  1592. 51:45fat where he said that our
  1593. 51:48>> Bkari says something else.
  1594. 51:51>> Inn is interpreting Bkari. is the number
  1595. 51:53one person who interprets Bkari in the
  1596. 51:55world in the history of
  1597. 51:56>> Bkari explicitly says
  1598. 51:58>> you asked me to give you a reference I'm
  1599. 52:00giving you one of the most premier and
  1600. 52:02gold standard references in Islam you
  1601. 52:04don't know it you you don't when was the
  1602. 52:05hajj born when was that all of that is
  1603. 52:09>> you don't know these people you don't
  1604. 52:10know that's the thing you don't know
  1605. 52:11these people you don't know these things
  1606. 52:13you don't know these things you don't
  1607. 52:15>> you know Bkari but you that's all you
  1608. 52:17know yeah so
  1609. 52:20>> he's calling him
  1610. 52:22Yeah. Yeah. Abbas doesn't say anything
  1611. 52:24about this. Abbas doesn't say you're all
  1612. 52:26over the place. You're over the place.
  1613. 52:28[laughter]
  1614. 52:29>> I know. I know the the hadith in Bkari
  1615. 52:31about Abbas. I know.
  1616. 52:32>> Oh, nice.
  1617. 52:33>> And it's actually against that hadith is
  1618. 52:35against you. But the point I'm making is
  1619. 52:36this.
  1620. 52:37>> Okay.
  1621. 52:37>> The hadith is against you. But let's
  1622. 52:39stop going
  1623. 52:41is it's simple. It's simple. The
  1624. 52:43overwhelming
  1625. 52:45vast majority of Muslim scholars from
  1626. 52:49the classical period until now believe
  1627. 52:51that this Bible that we have in our
  1628. 52:54hands is corrupt.
  1629. 52:56>> Show me that. Don't just say that.
  1630. 52:58>> And the reference of that reference
  1631. 53:01>> and the reference of that is
  1632. 53:04>> show us brother. You you can't be making
  1633. 53:07what you show you. I don't mean you got
  1634. 53:08all those books behind you. You don't
  1635. 53:10got a reference. You don't have the
  1636. 53:11source that didn't show me with me in
  1637. 53:13this uh house. This is quite pathetic.
  1638. 53:15You're asking me to go and get you a
  1639. 53:17>> I'm asking you to provide evidence for
  1640. 53:19what you're saying, not just claiming it
  1641. 53:20cuz I can't trust anything you're
  1642. 53:21saying.
  1643. 53:22>> Well, we can get someone from the from
  1644. 53:23the from the chats to get it. It's it's
  1645. 53:25in. And it starts like this. I I
  1646. 53:27remember I memorized the first he says
  1647. 53:29that the majority of this I memorized
  1648. 53:30the first part of what this is the best
  1649. 53:32you're going to get. And for me to even
  1650. 53:33memorize Yeah. This is surprising.
  1651. 53:40that sum of our friends. He meaning when
  1652. 53:44he says our friends he means the
  1653. 53:50what is in the hands
  1654. 53:51>> all of our friends
  1655. 53:54>> yeah what is in the hands of the day the
  1656. 53:57Jews and the Christians is corrupted and
  1657. 54:01he mentions what kind of he goes on to
  1658. 54:04say
  1659. 54:05>> he goes on to say it's altered and
  1660. 54:08corrupted from a textual perspective to
  1661. 54:13see that because according to other
  1662. 54:15scholars as you already agreed they
  1663. 54:17don't hold that
  1664. 54:19they don't know what to do for you right
  1665. 54:21now I just I appreciate let me fine bro
  1666. 54:24you just spoke for a long time let me
  1667. 54:25respond
  1668. 54:26>> goodness so you don't know about this
  1669. 54:28>> just as you agree that there's other
  1670. 54:29scholars there's the other side of
  1671. 54:30Islamic scholarship
  1672. 54:32>> that disagree with that position which
  1673. 54:34and you're saying some of he says some
  1674. 54:35of our friends
  1675. 54:36>> where they believe in wholesale
  1676. 54:38preservation of the scriptures and they
  1677. 54:41quote verses the same verses that we use
  1678. 54:43today that none can alter the words of
  1679. 54:45Allah. They they even use the hadith
  1680. 54:47that a lot of Muslims today try to say
  1681. 54:49is is not authentic Abu Dh49 where
  1682. 54:52Muhammad puts the Torah in the judgment
  1683. 54:53seat. They use these arguments to
  1684. 54:55substantiate right that says that you're
  1685. 55:00right side that says on that point
  1686. 55:03scriptures I know I'm right on that.
  1687. 55:04Thank you for telling me. I appreciate
  1688. 55:06it. There are there are some scholars
  1689. 55:08who believed that the the the Bible
  1690. 55:10sorry the Torah in the was preserved at
  1691. 55:13the time of the prophet.
  1692. 55:14>> Exactly. That was a minority view. Okay.
  1693. 55:17That is a minority view. It's like this.
  1694. 55:19Look, let me tell you this. In the
  1695. 55:20Quran, there's two types of scholars.
  1696. 55:22Some of them believe the earth was flat
  1697. 55:24and some of them believed the earth was
  1698. 55:25round.
  1699. 55:26>> Okay? [clears throat] They looked at the
  1700. 55:28verses of the Quran. Some of them looked
  1701. 55:29at the vers of the Quran. They believed
  1702. 55:30the earth was flat because of them. And
  1703. 55:32some of them looked at the vers of the
  1704. 55:33Quran. They said the earth was round
  1705. 55:34because of them. Likewise, some people
  1706. 55:36looked at the verses of the Quran and
  1707. 55:38the vast majority of them interpreted it
  1708. 55:40as
  1709. 55:42that it is a distortion of the text both
  1710. 55:44in text and in meaning. Okay. And a
  1711. 55:47minority of them believed like you said
  1712. 55:49which but you've exaggerated the claim.
  1713. 55:51>> No, no, no. You you said it and I will
  1714. 55:52admit it. It's true. Yeah. That some of
  1715. 55:55the scholars of Islam scholars
  1716. 55:57>> sorry
  1717. 55:58>> heavy scholars, right?
  1718. 56:00>> Well, I mean that's it's up for debate
  1719. 56:01whether Bkari mentioned that or not.
  1720. 56:03It's up for debate.
  1721. 56:04>> No, it's it's No, it is up for debate.
  1722. 56:06I've looked at the the text text myself.
  1723. 56:07I I don't know what he says about that.
  1724. 56:09It's it's hard. You can make a case for
  1725. 56:10against either way. Either way, either
  1726. 56:13way, Tamia has a strong view on it. He
  1727. 56:16says that the what do you call it? The
  1728. 56:17Bible is like the weak hadith. Haj says
  1729. 56:20that the majority of people that what do
  1730. 56:22you call it Hassam has a very strong
  1731. 56:24view.
  1732. 56:25>> IB believed that most of it was
  1733. 56:27preserved.
  1734. 56:28>> Yeah, he did say that.
  1735. 56:29>> Mhm.
  1736. 56:29>> He believed that most of it was
  1737. 56:30preserved. But he said that the rest of
  1738. 56:33it was like weak hadith and stuff like
  1739. 56:35that. And he mentions the parts of the
  1740. 56:37Bible which he believed were in
  1741. 56:40congruent with the Quran. And he unlike
  1742. 56:42what you said today said these can't be
  1743. 56:44from God. Okay. So he has a whole book
  1744. 56:47on that called All right.
  1745. 56:49>> Which is which is something by way I got
  1746. 56:51the reference here for you. I got the
  1747. 56:52reference for you. Volume one page 161.
  1748. 56:56Okay. And he says that it's our view
  1749. 56:58that there's no disagreement against uh
  1750. 57:00on the companions on this matter of
  1751. 57:02there being a change. So Hazam is an
  1752. 57:04early
  1753. 57:06>> he believes lly he believes he believes
  1754. 57:08there changed in a textual aspect.
  1755. 57:09>> Does he say that?
  1756. 57:10>> Yeah, he does say that he is very clear.
  1757. 57:12>> Can you read the quote cuz you said you
  1758. 57:13got the verse the the reference up.
  1759. 57:16>> You can you can go to that. I've just
  1760. 57:17told you that he believes that. You can
  1761. 57:18go and and check the volume. Can you get
  1762. 57:19the volume and the the thing get one of
  1763. 57:21the guys to pull out for us? But you're
  1764. 57:23asking me to pull out you know exact
  1765. 57:25quotations. Is that the reference?
  1766. 57:27>> It's now becoming now it's becoming
  1767. 57:29ridiculous. Actually,
  1768. 57:30>> it's ridiculous for me to ask.
  1769. 57:33>> No, no problem. I'll get you the quotes
  1770. 57:35that you want. I will get them. I'll get
  1771. 57:36someone to get you the exact saying that
  1772. 57:38that's ridiculous.
  1773. 57:39>> No, no, no. But I don't have the books
  1774. 57:40with me all all of a sudden.
  1775. 57:42>> Then respectfully, don't mention it if
  1776. 57:43you're not ready to present it.
  1777. 57:44>> No. What do you mean? I've just
  1778. 57:46mentioned the name of the book and the
  1779. 57:47volume. If you want me to read the exact
  1780. 57:49quotation, what do you want? This this
  1781. 57:51is this is why I'm saying this hijab is
  1782. 57:53because earlier when you were
  1783. 57:54referencing the when you were
  1784. 57:56referencing the hadith you misqued the
  1785. 57:58hadith you didn't know what the hadith
  1786. 57:59said. You only knew a part of it but you
  1787. 58:01didn't know what the whole hadith said.
  1788. 58:02This is why this is your memory
  1789. 58:05reference now this what you said was the
  1790. 58:07said the hadith the prophet himself said
  1791. 58:09led to
  1792. 58:12and then the part of it which is that
  1793. 58:13don't bel them don't believe them. The
  1794. 58:15other part of it wasn't hadith was
  1795. 58:16actually a verse of the Quran. He
  1796. 58:17recited a verse of the Quran
  1797. 58:18>> in the hadith. Right.
  1798. 58:20>> In the hadith. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. So
  1799. 58:22that's why that you asked me about the
  1800. 58:24hadith. The hadith is not we
  1801. 58:26differentiate between the hadith and the
  1802. 58:27Quran. That's why you mistake mistaken.
  1803. 58:29>> Muham Muhammad the Quran verse in the
  1804. 58:32hadith. What are you talking about?
  1805. 58:34>> This is this. Yeah. Okay. So do you want
  1806. 58:36me to read this for you?
  1807. 58:38>> Yes.
  1808. 58:40Okay. Let me see if this
  1809. 58:52So he says this is he says that
  1810. 58:56they wrote another book with their
  1811. 58:58hands. Yeah
  1812. 59:02that they said this is he's he's he is
  1813. 59:04doing of which is you know the chapter
  1814. 59:07279
  1815. 59:09which says they wrote a different
  1816. 59:11yeah he's he's interpreting that he's
  1817. 59:14saying that it's a distortion of the
  1818. 59:16text. Do you understand?
  1819. 59:17>> Oh no no no worry. So, this is my this
  1820. 59:19is my issue cuz I understand what you're
  1821. 59:20saying. My issue is this. In that
  1822. 59:22writing doesn't exist or hold on. No,
  1823. 59:25cuz this is what I'm saying. Writing
  1824. 59:27doesn't exist.
  1825. 59:28>> You what you just read doesn't tell me
  1826. 59:30that he believed that the Torah was
  1827. 59:31textually corrupted simply because they
  1828. 59:33wrote another book and tried to sell it
  1829. 59:35for a small price. You have multiple
  1830. 59:37interpretations on this matter.
  1831. 59:40You mentioned Hold on. You mentioned
  1832. 59:42Iban earlier with
  1833. 59:44>> brother. Let me finish.
  1834. 59:46allowed me. This is insane.
  1835. 59:50>> Iban Tabbury talks about this and talks
  1836. 59:52about how they wrote another book with
  1837. 59:54their own hands. So has nothing to do
  1838. 59:56with the itself.
  1839. 59:57>> You wanted the reference.
  1840. 59:58>> Avery, we're going to read it for you
  1841. 59:59and we're moving on.
  1842. 1:00:00>> Thank you. Go ahead.
  1843. 1:00:01>> Okay. How can you ask the people of the
  1844. 1:00:02book about something while the while
  1845. 1:00:04your book which is was revealed to his
  1846. 1:00:06messenger?
  1847. 1:00:07>> That's another hadith, right?
  1848. 1:00:08>> That's that's a hadith, right?
  1849. 1:00:11>> You're asking me to to references,
  1850. 1:00:13right? You ask me to provide references.
  1851. 1:00:15cuz I'm reading the references and
  1852. 1:00:16you're now you're complaining. What do
  1853. 1:00:18you
  1854. 1:00:18>> Is this reference to Hadith? Is this
  1855. 1:00:21Saiukari the culture referencing,
  1856. 1:00:23>> bro? Let's just read it and let's move
  1857. 1:00:25on. It's too
  1858. 1:00:26>> Okay, just leave this. I mean, to be
  1859. 1:00:27honest with you, [laughter]
  1860. 1:00:30what are you laughing at? What are you
  1861. 1:00:31laughing at? There's nothing.
  1862. 1:00:33>> There's nothing to Look, Avery, you're
  1863. 1:00:35not you're not wearing anything here.
  1864. 1:00:37Genuine
  1865. 1:00:38>> what whatever you say.
  1866. 1:00:39>> Do you understand? Do you understand
  1867. 1:00:41what I'm saying to you right now? I know
  1868. 1:00:42this is high level. You wouldn't be
  1869. 1:00:44allowed my class, brother.
  1870. 1:00:45And this is what happens when you bring
  1871. 1:00:47people. You wouldn't be allowed in my
  1872. 1:00:48class because you're not understanding.
  1873. 1:00:49You said that the I'm simply asking you
  1874. 1:00:51a simple question.
  1875. 1:00:52>> I'm asking you a do you understand?
  1876. 1:00:55Can I ask you a question? Can I ask you
  1877. 1:00:57a question?
  1878. 1:00:58>> Why would you mix up the references? Do
  1879. 1:01:00you understand that in Islamic
  1880. 1:01:02scholarship that there are two views,
  1881. 1:01:05one majority and one minority? And the
  1882. 1:01:07majority I I disagree with you saying
  1883. 1:01:10majority, but I do agree that there are
  1884. 1:01:11two views on preservation of beautiful.
  1885. 1:01:14Beautiful. Excellent. Avery, now
  1886. 1:01:16>> I scholars that say that they're
  1887. 1:01:18preserved.
  1888. 1:01:19>> You said it's not unreasonable. What you
  1889. 1:01:20said is not unreasonable. What you said
  1890. 1:01:22is not unreasonable. Whether or not you
  1891. 1:01:24believe it's the majority or minority
  1892. 1:01:25view, you still believe there are two
  1893. 1:01:27views, right?
  1894. 1:01:28>> Yes. If a Muslim if a Muslim takes the
  1895. 1:01:31view that the the book that we have
  1896. 1:01:33today is corrupt which is what
  1897. 1:01:34scholarship modern scholarship has
  1898. 1:01:36already established as you know
  1899. 1:01:37>> they haven't established it that's
  1900. 1:01:38>> they have established it like Bart man
  1901. 1:01:40and all these what do you call it Bruce
  1902. 1:01:42who affirms the
  1903. 1:01:44yeah you you haven't even got a single
  1904. 1:01:47diploma to your name and you're talking
  1905. 1:01:48about
  1906. 1:01:48>> he was on your page saying laughing in
  1907. 1:01:50your face anyway
  1908. 1:01:52he was laughing
  1909. 1:01:53>> anyway anyway so Jesus was crucified
  1910. 1:01:57[laughter]
  1911. 1:01:57>> you know we definitely have essation for
  1912. 1:01:58that.
  1913. 1:01:59>> You remember that
  1914. 1:02:02I'm saying you you said you said it now
  1915. 1:02:03and we can end at this and then we can
  1916. 1:02:05move on to Christianity because you
  1917. 1:02:06you're trying to avoid Christianity
  1918. 1:02:08is hold on. So Christianity we have
  1919. 1:02:12heard I know you
  1920. 1:02:14all
  1921. 1:02:17doubts we cleared up all your doubts now
  1922. 1:02:20we can agree. Hold on for a second. Can
  1923. 1:02:24I respond what you said? I haven't even
  1924. 1:02:25said anything yet. I haven't even made
  1925. 1:02:27my point yet.
  1926. 1:02:28>> What is this?
  1927. 1:02:29>> Avery, a second. Give me a second. You
  1928. 1:02:31said that you we accept that there are
  1929. 1:02:33two views. One view that it's partially
  1930. 1:02:35uh what do you call it? Corrupt
  1931. 1:02:37>> from a textual perspective and the other
  1932. 1:02:39one that it's not corrupt from a textual
  1933. 1:02:41perspective. Correct.
  1934. 1:02:42>> I accept that. That's that's a clever
  1935. 1:02:44way of putting it. No problem. I'm
  1936. 1:02:45saying that this is the majority view
  1937. 1:02:46based on my reading. I don't think you
  1938. 1:02:48can access the books to even tell us
  1939. 1:02:50that this is the majority in the
  1940. 1:02:51minority because you can't either. I
  1941. 1:02:52can't even translate it. books that I
  1942. 1:02:55asked for that you were saying that you
  1943. 1:02:56could
  1944. 1:02:56>> it's not even digitized. I don't see how
  1945. 1:02:58you can read this and how you can know
  1946. 1:02:59this. You don't know the Arabic language
  1947. 1:03:01yet the teacher couldn't bring me the
  1948. 1:03:03reference. You couldn't bring the
  1949. 1:03:05source.
  1950. 1:03:06You said you were reading from Ibaj but
  1951. 1:03:08skipped and started reading Iban Haz.
  1952. 1:03:11>> You said you were reading Ibaj earlier
  1953. 1:03:12but started reading from H. People are
  1954. 1:03:14giving me the source. I rely on this is
  1955. 1:03:18pathetic.
  1956. 1:03:18>> Okay. I'll get you the Haj one if you
  1957. 1:03:20want. No problem. as a as a goodwill
  1958. 1:03:22favor, I'll give you in the point is
  1959. 1:03:26this is that you've already conceded the
  1960. 1:03:28point which is that there are two views.
  1961. 1:03:29So if I not
  1962. 1:03:30>> conceded that that was my point
  1963. 1:03:32>> I'm the one who I'm whatever. Okay.
  1964. 1:03:35>> Yeah. No, whatever.
  1965. 1:03:37All right. I'm the one who had to teach
  1966. 1:03:40you that there were big time scholars
  1967. 1:03:42who said who disagreed with you had to
  1968. 1:03:44teach me. You are so clever. I have to
  1969. 1:03:46teach you today. I love my lesson. And
  1970. 1:03:48the lesson is this. The lesson is that
  1971. 1:03:50there are two views. Okay. One view is
  1972. 1:03:52that textual distortion is there and the
  1973. 1:03:55other view is that textual it's not
  1974. 1:03:57textual distortion but it's a distortion
  1975. 1:03:58in meaning. There's two views. Okay. And
  1976. 1:04:00I'm saying that I take the view that
  1977. 1:04:02there is textual distortion. Just like
  1978. 1:04:04there's two views just like there's two
  1979. 1:04:05views on people looking at the Quran
  1980. 1:04:07different scholars of Islam in the past.
  1981. 1:04:10Some of them said that the earth was
  1982. 1:04:11flat and some of them said that the
  1983. 1:04:12earth was round. By the way, nobody
  1984. 1:04:15looked at the Bible and said that the
  1985. 1:04:16earth is round by virtue of the fact of
  1986. 1:04:18the Bible. By virtue of the fact, by the
  1987. 1:04:21way, the closest you have is the book of
  1988. 1:04:23Isaiah 202,
  1989. 1:04:25the circle of the earth. But no, hold
  1990. 1:04:27on. So just like you have scholars, just
  1991. 1:04:30like you have scholars of Islam who
  1992. 1:04:32looked at the verse of the Quran, some
  1993. 1:04:34of them said the earth was round and
  1994. 1:04:36some of them said the earth was uh flat.
  1995. 1:04:39And we take the view that the earth is
  1996. 1:04:40round which which corresponds with the
  1997. 1:04:42views of Ibamiani and Ahmed Muham and
  1998. 1:04:46Ham and etc etc. We do the same thing
  1999. 1:04:48with this issue here. So so long as
  2000. 1:04:51>> Okay. Yeah. Beautiful.
  2001. 1:04:53Ah we got it.
  2002. 1:04:54>> Can we switch off? Okay. Thank you. It's
  2003. 1:04:55too long on this. We switch this.
  2004. 1:04:57>> Is this is this is this thing?
  2005. 1:05:00>> Okay. Okay.
  2006. 1:05:01>> This one.
  2007. 1:05:02>> Where's the other one?
  2008. 1:05:03>> This one and this one.
  2009. 1:05:04>> Oh no. Here it is. It's exactly what I
  2010. 1:05:05said. Subhan Allah.
  2011. 1:05:07>> Okay. This is what this is what what do
  2012. 1:05:09you call it? Uh what's his name? Um says
  2013. 1:05:24actually this is even worse for you.
  2014. 1:05:27You're right about that. And I tell you
  2015. 1:05:29that that's why he said yeah. Can you
  2016. 1:05:31translate so let me let me let me let me
  2017. 1:05:34let me translate that. that our friends
  2018. 1:05:38a lot of our friends companions mean
  2019. 1:05:41yeah
  2020. 1:05:43hold let me finish that the Jews and the
  2021. 1:05:46Christians they changed the
  2022. 1:05:49changed them okay
  2023. 1:05:52they even said because they changed them
  2024. 1:05:54yeah that you can you can distort and
  2025. 1:05:57you can rip up the verses of the Bible
  2026. 1:06:01actually doesn't even say the Bible yeah
  2027. 1:06:03the verses of those distorted texts
  2028. 1:06:07Bkari that this is goes this goes
  2029. 1:06:09against what Bkari mentioned. So this is
  2030. 1:06:12you wanted a reference. This is exactly
  2031. 1:06:14done, right?
  2032. 1:06:15>> What do you want? Do you want do you
  2033. 1:06:16want the page number? Do you want what
  2034. 1:06:18do you want?
  2035. 1:06:20>> Can you shout out the page number and
  2036. 1:06:21everything so we can look at that?
  2037. 1:06:22>> Yeah.
  2038. 1:06:25Uh what do you call it? It's page number
  2039. 1:06:27531 and the J is number 13 and uh the
  2040. 1:06:32paragraph is number 7,14.
  2041. 1:06:34Done. Done. Are
  2042. 1:06:35>> we done?
  2043. 1:06:37No. Just one second. You want more of a
  2044. 1:06:39reference?
  2045. 1:06:40>> Yeah. Can I respond now?
  2046. 1:06:42>> Come on now.
  2047. 1:06:43>> Would you admit it now?
  2048. 1:06:44>> Can I respond?
  2049. 1:06:44>> Now it's time. What? Another view.
  2050. 1:06:47>> You admit it now. It's time that we're
  2051. 1:06:49going to actually ask.
  2052. 1:06:50>> Hold on. Just one second. I got to be
  2053. 1:06:51able to respond what he just said.
  2054. 1:06:52>> I respond. Then we go to Christianity.
  2055. 1:06:53Is that fair?
  2056. 1:06:54>> Yeah. Go on.
  2057. 1:06:56>> Go on.
  2058. 1:06:57>> Okay. So, thank you for finally bringing
  2059. 1:06:59the source. Now, we're going to take a
  2060. 1:07:00look at that to see what it actually
  2061. 1:07:01says in context. Um, you know, you
  2062. 1:07:04didn't put it on the screen like we
  2063. 1:07:05asked you. Did you read one second?
  2064. 1:07:07Notice how I let you interrupt it,
  2065. 1:07:09right?
  2066. 1:07:12>> You don't understand.
  2067. 1:07:13>> If you're not afraid of what I got to
  2068. 1:07:14say, man, you got to let me speak, bro.
  2069. 1:07:15>> Go on.
  2070. 1:07:16>> All right. I appreciate it. So, when you
  2071. 1:07:18when you say, are you are you going to
  2072. 1:07:20admit it? Are you going to admit it?
  2073. 1:07:21Admit what?
  2074. 1:07:22>> We've already agreed together by your
  2075. 1:07:23own concession that there are two views
  2076. 1:07:26from the scholars.
  2077. 1:07:27>> There's a view that some of them hold
  2078. 1:07:28that the scriptures are textually
  2079. 1:07:30corrupted. There's the other view that
  2080. 1:07:31people like Bkari, Ibn Abbas and others
  2081. 1:07:33according to Ibn Bkari uh I'm sorry
  2082. 1:07:36according to Bkari uh quoting Iban Abbas
  2083. 1:07:38that the scriptures are textually
  2084. 1:07:40preserved and they're only distorted in
  2085. 1:07:42meaning not intent.
  2086. 1:07:44>> So the one that we have today
  2087. 1:07:46>> just one second.
  2088. 1:07:47>> Yeah.
  2089. 1:07:47>> So in the time of Muhammad according to
  2090. 1:07:50a lot of your big scholars
  2091. 1:07:51>> the scriptures as you already said were
  2092. 1:07:54preserved in Muhammad's time. Now here's
  2093. 1:07:56the thing
  2094. 1:07:58that's true. This is what majority of
  2095. 1:08:00them.
  2096. 1:08:02>> Please allow me to finish.
  2097. 1:08:03>> Yeah. Yeah. No problem.
  2098. 1:08:03>> Please allow me to finish. Thank you. I
  2099. 1:08:05appreciate it. This is what this would
  2100. 1:08:06mean because I I I take this view the
  2101. 1:08:08the view of Bkari and others.
  2102. 1:08:10>> But this is what this means. This means
  2103. 1:08:13that the scriptures that existed in
  2104. 1:08:15Muhammad's time according to your pre-
  2105. 1:08:17Islamic scholars, notice how they got to
  2106. 1:08:19keep interrupting. Brother, have some
  2107. 1:08:20self-control. Let me talk. Thank you.
  2108. 1:08:22Have some self-control. You put on a
  2109. 1:08:24chef hat. Selfcontrol. Let me talk
  2110. 1:08:26[laughter]
  2111. 1:08:27to the occasion. I got dressed for the
  2112. 1:08:29occasion. That's all.
  2113. 1:08:34>> Since according by your concession, the
  2114. 1:08:36big scholars, some big scholars also
  2115. 1:08:38believed in full preservation of the
  2116. 1:08:40scriptures in Muhammad's time. This
  2117. 1:08:42means that according to those scholars,
  2118. 1:08:44what I have even to this day, Matthew,
  2119. 1:08:47Mark, Luke, John,
  2120. 1:08:49>> Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers,
  2121. 1:08:51Deuteronomy, the writings of the
  2122. 1:08:52prophets, everything that they had in
  2123. 1:08:54Muhammad's time that they had in
  2124. 1:08:55possession.
  2125. 1:08:57is the author is authoritative and is
  2126. 1:09:00the word of Allah in revelation.
  2127. 1:09:01>> That's a misrepresentation of those.
  2128. 1:09:03>> Please, bro. Please, if you can correct
  2129. 1:09:05me when I'm done.
  2130. 1:09:06>> Oh, I will. We'll do. Go on.
  2131. 1:09:07>> Okay. Appreciate it.
  2132. 1:09:08>> Yeah.
  2133. 1:09:08>> So, and here's here's the the other fact
  2134. 1:09:11that we have to take into account,
  2135. 1:09:12>> okay?
  2136. 1:09:13>> Is that the side that believed in
  2137. 1:09:15preservation of the of the Bible, they
  2138. 1:09:18gave references from the Quran. They
  2139. 1:09:20used the Quran and they used to prove
  2140. 1:09:23their point. But from your side, this is
  2141. 1:09:26what what the problem is. Your side of
  2142. 1:09:28the spectrum, you guys have no Quranic
  2143. 1:09:32or hadith proof to back that there's any
  2144. 1:09:35textual corruption. You're talking about
  2145. 1:09:38something that's way above your pay
  2146. 1:09:39grade. Look, let me tell you something.
  2147. 1:09:40You say it's above my grade.
  2148. 1:09:43Prove me wrong. Saying that is not a
  2149. 1:09:46proof. It's not an argument.
  2150. 1:09:47>> Okay. Do you want me to respond to you?
  2151. 1:09:48The response here,
  2152. 1:09:49>> give me evidence to this, please.
  2153. 1:09:50>> Uh, sure. So, what I've just I've just
  2154. 1:09:52given
  2155. 1:09:52>> you just say this and we can move on to
  2156. 1:09:53Christianity. you want evidences. I've
  2157. 1:09:56given you a reference and not only have
  2158. 1:09:57I given you the P number. Okay. So, no
  2159. 1:10:01longer can you play this game. I read it
  2160. 1:10:02in the original.
  2161. 1:10:03>> Wait, what game?
  2162. 1:10:05>> Sorry. Play game.
  2163. 1:10:08>> The the game that you're playing that
  2164. 1:10:09you're saying that they never refer to a
  2165. 1:10:11hadith or Quranic verse. It's not true
  2166. 1:10:12because in fact Bkari sorry
  2167. 1:10:15>> I didn't say that bro. Okay. You said
  2168. 1:10:17that they don't mention hadith versus
  2169. 1:10:20sorry hadith or the Quran. That's what
  2170. 1:10:22you said. So they they don't they don't
  2171. 1:10:24have
  2172. 1:10:24>> on my side of the scholarship. You said
  2173. 1:10:26on my side of the scholarship they don't
  2174. 1:10:28mention a Quranic verse and they don't
  2175. 1:10:30do on my um oh on yours. So sorry. Yeah.
  2176. 1:10:32So on on your on your on your side
  2177. 1:10:35there's no Quranic. What I said is
  2178. 1:10:36there's no Quranic evidence. So let me
  2179. 1:10:38respond to that.
  2180. 1:10:39>> So what the answer to that is actually
  2181. 1:10:41they do mention it and they usually
  2182. 1:10:43mention chapter 2 verse 79. Yeah. And in
  2183. 1:10:46fact himself mentions a an opinion like
  2184. 1:10:50that in
  2185. 1:10:52where it says there's an opinion that
  2186. 1:10:54says
  2187. 1:10:55>> what does what does say himself
  2188. 1:10:58>> doesn't do he just puts different names
  2189. 1:11:01okay
  2190. 1:11:02>> oh he does he's
  2191. 1:11:04viewers it's not clear to me what
  2192. 1:11:06>> I can tell you I can teach it to you
  2193. 1:11:07>> it's not clear to me I've I've looked at
  2194. 1:11:09all the verses in question it's not
  2195. 1:11:10clear to me
  2196. 1:11:10>> yeah but would you like to know what he
  2197. 1:11:11says
  2198. 1:11:14mentions something of they they dispute
  2199. 1:11:17the authenticity of that hadith saying
  2200. 1:11:19that it's etc which means want to know
  2201. 1:11:22what himself said cuz he doesn't know
  2202. 1:11:24that that tour is being corrupted.
  2203. 1:11:26>> Let me finish. Let me finish.
  2204. 1:11:27>> You don't want to know himself.
  2205. 1:11:29>> Can you let me finish? Can you let me
  2206. 1:11:30finish so you can learn something from
  2207. 1:11:31this? Can you let me finish?
  2208. 1:11:33>> I'm the only one teaching you so far,
  2209. 1:11:34man.
  2210. 1:11:34>> Okay. Well, you can teach me without
  2211. 1:11:36access to the primary sources and I can
  2212. 1:11:37learn without access to the primary
  2213. 1:11:39sources. It's quite of an asymmetrical
  2214. 1:11:41lesson.
  2215. 1:11:42>> I have I have open right now.
  2216. 1:11:43>> It's an asymmetrical lesson like you
  2217. 1:11:45actually have ready to go. You don't
  2218. 1:11:47have access to the primary sources.
  2219. 1:11:49That's an asymmetrical lesson. All
  2220. 1:11:50right.
  2221. 1:11:51open
  2222. 1:11:53right here. Let me finish. Let me finish
  2223. 1:11:55what I'm saying. Let me finish what I'm
  2224. 1:11:56saying
  2225. 1:12:01and all of these other scholars that
  2226. 1:12:02I've mentioned with the with the page
  2227. 1:12:04number and the J number and the
  2228. 1:12:06paragraph number. All of those guys,
  2229. 1:12:07they mentioned this verse in chapter
  2230. 1:12:10number 279. Some of them mentioned the
  2231. 1:12:12verse in chapter 5 verse 134. Yeah. Some
  2232. 1:12:16of them mention other verses.
  2233. 1:12:19They do interpret the Quran in that way.
  2234. 1:12:21Okay? Now, you can say they don't, but
  2235. 1:12:24that's just your interpretation. Just
  2236. 1:12:25like if someone said, "Okay, there are
  2237. 1:12:26some scholars that say the Quran is
  2238. 1:12:28flat." Yes, we believe the Quran says
  2239. 1:12:31that the earth is flat. But Hassan
  2240. 1:12:34believes that it says the Quran says the
  2241. 1:12:35earth is round. So, there are two
  2242. 1:12:37interpretations. Someone can follow this
  2243. 1:12:38one and someone can follow that one.
  2244. 1:12:40It's not a matter where if you the Islam
  2245. 1:12:43has one opinion on it. So, it can't be
  2246. 1:12:44an undercutter for Islam. Do you get it?
  2247. 1:12:46If it can't be an undercutter for Islam
  2248. 1:12:48because there's more than one legitimate
  2249. 1:12:51opinion and in my estimation it is the
  2250. 1:12:53majority opinion. Now we've finished.
  2251. 1:12:55Your strongest argument has been
  2252. 1:12:57complete. Now it's time for Christianity
  2253. 1:12:58unless you want to run away.
  2254. 1:12:59>> No no it's done. It's done. It's done
  2255. 1:13:00now. It's done now.
  2256. 1:13:03It's done.
  2257. 1:13:05People can decide. People heard you.
  2258. 1:13:06People heard me. It's done. It's done
  2259. 1:13:08now just we we spent a lot of time on
  2260. 1:13:11it. I promise you I won't even give
  2261. 1:13:13another reference. Spent a lot of time
  2262. 1:13:14on it. We spent a lot of time on it.
  2263. 1:13:19>> Torah can decide. People can decide.
  2264. 1:13:21Avery, people can decide. Now
  2265. 1:13:22>> says they wrote a book based on their
  2266. 1:13:24own interpretation.
  2267. 1:13:25>> Now it's time. Let me ask you this. Is
  2268. 1:13:26Jesus's point.
  2269. 1:13:28>> Is Jesus fully God?
  2270. 1:13:30>> We we say that he's truly God.
  2271. 1:13:31>> No. Is Jesus fully God?
  2272. 1:13:32>> Is he Is he fully God?
  2273. 1:13:34>> I already answered you. We don't say
  2274. 1:13:35fully as if there's percentages. We say
  2275. 1:13:37truly God.
  2276. 1:13:39>> Okay. Is he fully God?
  2277. 1:13:41>> How many times you want to answer this?
  2278. 1:13:42>> No. No. Is he fully God? We you're a
  2279. 1:13:44strong man in our position. Please, if
  2280. 1:13:46you're going to ask the question
  2281. 1:13:49in reference question or not,
  2282. 1:13:52>> we say truly God. Is Jesus truly? I'm
  2283. 1:13:55>> asking God.
  2284. 1:13:57>> Is Jesus fully God or not? Jesus is
  2285. 1:13:59fully God or not? Is he fully God or
  2286. 1:14:01not?
  2287. 1:14:01>> I already answered.
  2288. 1:14:02>> Yes or no?
  2289. 1:14:03>> Give me another question. I already
  2290. 1:14:04answered.
  2291. 1:14:04>> Yes. Is Is Jesus fully God or not?
  2292. 1:14:06>> Yes. Don't run. Don't be scared. Yeah.
  2293. 1:14:09Don't Don't run from an actual
  2294. 1:14:10Christianity. Is Jesus fully God or not?
  2295. 1:14:12>> You don't say fully God. God truly run.
  2296. 1:14:15Yes, he knows it's truly God in every
  2297. 1:14:17way that God Jesus fully God all the
  2298. 1:14:21essential properties to be God. Now deal
  2299. 1:14:23with my deal with my position. Fully God
  2300. 1:14:25is Jesus fully God deal with my position
  2301. 1:14:27please.
  2302. 1:14:27>> Is Jesus fully God ord not? Please deal
  2303. 1:14:29with my position. Is Jesus fully God or
  2304. 1:14:31not? I already answered you.
  2305. 1:14:32>> Just wait. Deal with my position. Don't
  2306. 1:14:34be scared now. I know what you should
  2307. 1:14:36do.
  2308. 1:14:36>> Deal with my position fully God or not?
  2309. 1:14:38I want you to notice ladies and
  2310. 1:14:39gentlemen. This is how you know someone
  2311. 1:14:42is having they have to scare the script.
  2312. 1:14:46Once you take them off their script,
  2313. 1:14:49they don't know where to go. God, they
  2314. 1:14:51don't know where to go.
  2315. 1:14:53>> Is he fully God?
  2316. 1:14:55>> Yes. Ask and answered.
  2317. 1:14:56>> What is it?
  2318. 1:14:57>> Asked and answered.
  2319. 1:14:59>> Okay, let me ask you this. Let me change
  2320. 1:15:01it because you you're not going to
  2321. 1:15:02you're not
  2322. 1:15:04gone or not. All right. No problem. No
  2323. 1:15:06problem. You run away from that one.
  2324. 1:15:08He he possesses all the essential
  2325. 1:15:10properties that make God God.
  2326. 1:15:12>> Okay. So when you say Jesus is is is
  2327. 1:15:14this statement true or false? Jesus is
  2328. 1:15:16God. Is it true or false statement?
  2329. 1:15:18>> That's a true statement.
  2330. 1:15:19>> Okay. Is the is okay. Excellent. Jesus
  2331. 1:15:21is God is a true statement, right?
  2332. 1:15:24>> I just said that.
  2333. 1:15:25>> Yeah. Great. No problem. Is that is of
  2334. 1:15:27predication or identity?
  2335. 1:15:28>> It'll be a predication.
  2336. 1:15:30>> Okay. So it's predication, is it? So he
  2337. 1:15:33has the quality of being divine.
  2338. 1:15:34>> Yep.
  2339. 1:15:35>> He has the description of being divine.
  2340. 1:15:38Yep.
  2341. 1:15:39>> Okay. So that means to say that the
  2342. 1:15:41father has this quality, the son has
  2343. 1:15:43this quality and the holy spirit has
  2344. 1:15:45this quality.
  2345. 1:15:46>> They they all have the essential
  2346. 1:15:48properties. They all have the divine
  2347. 1:15:50essence. They are all god by essence.
  2348. 1:15:53>> No problem. So they all have the quality
  2349. 1:15:54of being divine. Yeah.
  2350. 1:15:55>> They all have the nature.
  2351. 1:15:58>> Okay. Beautiful. And do they have a
  2352. 1:15:59will?
  2353. 1:16:00>> Yeah, they have the same will because
  2354. 1:16:01will is will is a faculty of your
  2355. 1:16:04essence. So wait, hold on for a second.
  2356. 1:16:07So they have the same will do they?
  2357. 1:16:10>> That's what I said.
  2358. 1:16:11>> So is the will uh predicatively okay
  2359. 1:16:16does uh God the father have the same
  2360. 1:16:19will in a predicative sense as God the
  2361. 1:16:21son?
  2362. 1:16:22>> What why would you say in a predicative
  2363. 1:16:23sense? What do you mean by by that?
  2364. 1:16:25>> Because you're mixing between Latin
  2365. 1:16:27trinitarianism and three self
  2366. 1:16:29trinitarian social trinitarianism.
  2367. 1:16:30You're mixing between
  2368. 1:16:31>> Can you explain that?
  2369. 1:16:32>> Yeah. Let me explain because No, let me
  2370. 1:16:34explain this to you. Right. is if you're
  2371. 1:16:37saying that the father is God from a
  2372. 1:16:40predicative perspective. Yes. If he's
  2373. 1:16:42God from a predicative perspective, that
  2374. 1:16:44means he has a center of consciousness
  2375. 1:16:46which is different from the sun. Is that
  2376. 1:16:47correct?
  2377. 1:16:48>> Based on what?
  2378. 1:16:50>> Because you you've just said it's
  2379. 1:16:51predicative. It's not identity is it?
  2380. 1:16:54>> Yeah. So what what is what how does it
  2381. 1:16:55follow you understand the words I'm
  2382. 1:16:57using? I don't think you do. If Jesus is
  2383. 1:17:00God by predication, just real quick, if
  2384. 1:17:02Jesus is God by predication, because he
  2385. 1:17:04derives the divine essence from the
  2386. 1:17:05father. Just let me finish.
  2387. 1:17:06>> I don't understand. I don't understand.
  2388. 1:17:08Why you get so uncomfortable? Why you
  2389. 1:17:10get so uncomfortable?
  2390. 1:17:11>> You don't even understand the question.
  2391. 1:17:12Ask Jesus full of God. You can answer.
  2392. 1:17:14>> If Jesus If Jesus because he deres his
  2393. 1:17:17source from the father and the divine
  2394. 1:17:19essence of the father and so therefore
  2395. 1:17:21is predicated the divine essence, how
  2396. 1:17:24does that entail or conclude that he has
  2397. 1:17:26a different than the father? separate
  2398. 1:17:28center of consciousness to the sun or
  2399. 1:17:30not.
  2400. 1:17:30>> Correct. What? Why? Why? Why? I don't
  2401. 1:17:32understand. What do you mean? Why? I'm
  2402. 1:17:34>> They have the same They have the same
  2403. 1:17:36mind and will, brother. They have the
  2404. 1:17:37same center of consciousness. Same mind.
  2405. 1:17:40>> They have the same mind. They have the
  2406. 1:17:41same will. They have the same essence as
  2407. 1:17:43well. They have the same every time you
  2408. 1:17:45ask me the same question.
  2409. 1:17:48>> They have the same mind. They have the
  2410. 1:17:49same will. They have the same essence.
  2411. 1:17:50Do they have the same attributes?
  2412. 1:17:53>> Yes. Aha. So now you've moved to is of
  2413. 1:17:56identification because identity because
  2414. 1:17:58now actually if they're the same in
  2415. 1:18:00essence and the same in mind and they're
  2416. 1:18:02the same in consciousness and the same
  2417. 1:18:03in will and the same in attributes that
  2418. 1:18:05means they're one and the same person
  2419. 1:18:06aren't they?
  2420. 1:18:07>> No, there's a relative identity. They're
  2421. 1:18:09identical in essence not identical.
  2422. 1:18:11There's a distinction in their
  2423. 1:18:12personhood.
  2424. 1:18:13>> Wait, hold on. Hold on. Hold on.
  2425. 1:18:14>> This this doesn't work.
  2426. 1:18:17>> This this argument probably worked back
  2427. 1:18:18in 2017.
  2428. 1:18:20>> Wait, hold on. Let me take it step by
  2429. 1:18:22step because take it step by step. We're
  2430. 1:18:24going to dismantle this step.
  2431. 1:18:25>> Don't pretend don't pretend that
  2432. 1:18:26Christianity has not been struggling
  2433. 1:18:28with this for two years.
  2434. 1:18:29>> It has it hasn't yet this this argu.
  2435. 1:18:31Okay, no problem. Yeah, we we've just
  2436. 1:18:33been pretending we've just been looking
  2437. 1:18:35at different things. There's different
  2438. 1:18:36models. If you're right now the trinity
  2439. 1:18:38on Stanford encyclopedia, you'll see
  2440. 1:18:40Latin trinitarianism, social
  2441. 1:18:41trinitarianism. There's views of this.
  2442. 1:18:43You mentioned relative identity. Do you
  2443. 1:18:45know who mentions that relative
  2444. 1:18:46identity?
  2445. 1:18:47>> Who has written book? Peter G has
  2446. 1:18:49written about it recently actually.
  2447. 1:18:51Yeah. Relative identity actually. What
  2448. 1:18:53does it have to do with what does that
  2449. 1:18:54have to say?
  2450. 1:18:55>> He's going to join us next.
  2451. 1:18:56>> He's going to join us next.
  2452. 1:18:58>> Are you Are you about to refute Peter G
  2453. 1:19:00or something? Or
  2454. 1:19:01>> Yeah. You don't know what he says? What
  2455. 1:19:02does he say? What does Peter I I I just
  2456. 1:19:04asked you if you're going to Are you
  2457. 1:19:06>> What does Peter say? If you're talking
  2458. 1:19:07about what does Peter G say?
  2459. 1:19:09>> What What is my position?
  2460. 1:19:10>> What is You said relative identity. So I
  2461. 1:19:12want to know what Peter G.
  2462. 1:19:13>> So in in regard in regards to my
  2463. 1:19:15position, how are you refuting the
  2464. 1:19:17trinity?
  2465. 1:19:17>> No. How? You said relative identity.
  2466. 1:19:19That's associated with Peter Gech. Do
  2467. 1:19:21you know what he said?
  2468. 1:19:21>> What? I I don't care who you talking
  2469. 1:19:24about, do you? You don't even know what
  2470. 1:19:26you're talking about.
  2471. 1:19:26>> If I hold the position talking identity,
  2472. 1:19:28hold on. If I hold the position of
  2473. 1:19:30relative identity, what is your argument
  2474. 1:19:32against it?
  2475. 1:19:34>> Do you do you hold the position of
  2476. 1:19:36identity?
  2477. 1:19:36>> Do you or not?
  2478. 1:19:40>> Question. So, so if you hold the
  2479. 1:19:42position of relative identity of Peter
  2480. 1:19:44Gech, my response to it is the
  2481. 1:19:46following. My response to it is in order
  2482. 1:19:48for you to come to that conclusion you
  2483. 1:19:50have to have a relative identity
  2484. 1:19:51framework and a relative identity
  2485. 1:19:53framework goes against predicate and
  2486. 1:19:56propositional logic and in particular it
  2487. 1:19:58goes against Linet's law which means
  2488. 1:20:00that in order for you to prove the
  2489. 1:20:01trinity you have to allow contradictions
  2490. 1:20:03you do you agree do you agree with that
  2491. 1:20:05no uh can you
  2492. 1:20:06>> you have to reject propositional logic
  2493. 1:20:08reject classical logic yes or no what
  2494. 1:20:11what is liben's law
  2495. 1:20:13>> it's the law of identity
  2496. 1:20:14>> no it's a specific Law of identity. Can
  2497. 1:20:16you tell me exactly what
  2498. 1:20:18>> law? It's the law of identity. What
  2499. 1:20:20specific law of identity is it? Cuz
  2500. 1:20:22there's
  2501. 1:20:24categories of categories within the law
  2502. 1:20:26of identity. Would you like what does
  2503. 1:20:28law say?
  2504. 1:20:29>> Wait. Do you want me to teach you what
  2505. 1:20:30the law of identity is? Is that what
  2506. 1:20:31you're asking me?
  2507. 1:20:32>> No. I want you to this is what we're
  2508. 1:20:34going to do cuz it show it seems like
  2509. 1:20:36you didn't know anything about anything.
  2510. 1:20:39You didn't even know that relative
  2511. 1:20:41identity was connected to
  2512. 1:20:43you. Don't understand. You don't even
  2513. 1:20:45understand.
  2514. 1:20:46>> Saying I don't understand doesn't mean
  2515. 1:20:47anything.
  2516. 1:20:48>> Hold on. Hold Avery. You didn't even
  2517. 1:20:50know that relative identity was
  2518. 1:20:52associated with Peter Geachch.
  2519. 1:20:54>> I had nothing to do with the argument. I
  2520. 1:20:56had to teach you that has nothing to do
  2521. 1:20:57with the argument. My position is
  2522. 1:20:59relative identity. What is your argument
  2523. 1:21:02against my position?
  2524. 1:21:03>> Yeah. Yeah. So my
  2525. 1:21:05>> law is law of identity. What is it?
  2526. 1:21:08>> Sure. Hold on. Hold on.
  2527. 1:21:10>> All right. We're waiting.
  2528. 1:21:11>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
  2529. 1:21:12>> Yeah. Yeah. If A is X and B is X, it
  2530. 1:21:15follows A is
  2531. 1:21:17>> finish it. You tell me. If if the father
  2532. 1:21:20[laughter] is God in your father is God
  2533. 1:21:24and the son is God, it it follows what?
  2534. 1:21:27>> Answer. You do it. Father is the son. It
  2535. 1:21:29follows the father is the son. It
  2536. 1:21:31follows.
  2537. 1:21:32Okay. What category are you? Okay.
  2538. 1:21:34You're the son.
  2539. 1:21:35>> What category of the law of identity is
  2540. 1:21:38the law.
  2541. 1:21:38>> Do you believe that the father is the
  2542. 1:21:39son?
  2543. 1:21:40>> Okay. Let let me believe the father is
  2544. 1:21:41the son. No, I don't. So, let me help
  2545. 1:21:43you out. I don't believe in the father's
  2546. 1:21:44law. Let me help you out. This is a
  2547. 1:21:46blunder cuz you don't even know what
  2548. 1:21:47life's law. Lman's law is the category.
  2549. 1:21:51He says he says that his law of identity
  2550. 1:21:54is called absolute identity. Means that
  2551. 1:21:57you have to be absolutely identical in
  2552. 1:21:59every way and every sense. Exactly. And
  2553. 1:22:02guess and guess what? There are
  2554. 1:22:03philosophers who do like Peter Gech and
  2555. 1:22:06others who do not hold to absolute
  2556. 1:22:09identity. And so we can keep going with
  2557. 1:22:10examples. So absolute identity is not
  2558. 1:22:13the abandon.
  2559. 1:22:17Let me let me teach you this. Let me
  2560. 1:22:19teach you this. Allow me to respond.
  2561. 1:22:21Identity absolute identity is a
  2562. 1:22:23necessity.
  2563. 1:22:24>> Let me let me respond to you, okay? And
  2564. 1:22:26let me teach you because this is
  2565. 1:22:27something
  2566. 1:22:30is a necessity.
  2567. 1:22:31>> Avery, have some respect because listen,
  2568. 1:22:33I've done six degrees. Yeah. Six degrees
  2569. 1:22:36of 15 years. You know, I'm trying I'm
  2570. 1:22:38trying to respect you. You're talking.
  2571. 1:22:40You're showing that you don't have you
  2572. 1:22:42got degrees. Ask me questions. Ask you
  2573. 1:22:44trivia questions. Don't ask me whatever
  2574. 1:22:46questions trivia question is. No.
  2575. 1:22:48>> You don't even know what I law.
  2576. 1:22:50>> Hold on. Hold on. Let me finish. This is
  2577. 1:22:52an education. It's a free one. Okay? So,
  2578. 1:22:54just have some respect, okay? And I'll
  2579. 1:22:56teach you about all these things.
  2580. 1:22:57>> You didn't know what Liv's law was?
  2581. 1:22:59>> What do you mean? I've written a whole
  2582. 1:23:00chapter on liess in my jealous. What
  2583. 1:23:03does this state? What is wrong?
  2584. 1:23:05[laughter]
  2585. 1:23:05>> I've read Give me one book that lives
  2586. 1:23:07wrote. See, there's another book. Give
  2587. 1:23:09me one book that liro. We're going to
  2588. 1:23:12book that wrote. Give me one book that
  2589. 1:23:14wrote book
  2590. 1:23:18is one book that wrote. Give me one
  2591. 1:23:20book.
  2592. 1:23:22One book. The Muslim shuffle doesn't
  2593. 1:23:24work. It doesn't work.
  2594. 1:23:25>> So just be quiet. Yeah.
  2595. 1:23:28>> Law is don't even know anything that he
  2596. 1:23:29wrote. I've written chapters. Tell us
  2597. 1:23:32what his law is.
  2598. 1:23:33>> Be quiet. Shut up. Yeah. [laughter]
  2599. 1:23:35Honestly, please. Lit law is equivalent
  2600. 1:23:37to the law of identity. You already
  2601. 1:23:39discussed it, man.
  2602. 1:23:40>> What are you doing, man? What you are
  2603. 1:23:41you
  2604. 1:23:41>> Hey, look. I love how my food talks back
  2605. 1:23:43to me, ladies and gentlemen.
  2606. 1:23:45>> I love it. You've run away. You've run
  2607. 1:23:47away now from the discussion, haven't
  2608. 1:23:49you?
  2609. 1:23:50>> What do you mean? You're the only one
  2610. 1:23:51acting God.
  2611. 1:23:52>> Is the father god?
  2612. 1:23:54>> I already answered this. Can you tell us
  2613. 1:23:55what lil is?
  2614. 1:23:58Are you do I need to repeat myself the
  2615. 1:24:00fourth time? You don't even know who
  2616. 1:24:01live is.
  2617. 1:24:01>> Get your thoughts together.
  2618. 1:24:02>> You don't even know.
  2619. 1:24:04What did he invent? Look at his first
  2620. 1:24:07name. Make sure his first name
  2621. 1:24:11this dude deflects.
  2622. 1:24:12>> What's his first name?
  2623. 1:24:13>> What is
  2624. 1:24:15Mohammed? You brought it up.
  2625. 1:24:18>> What is his first name? What is Lieben's
  2626. 1:24:21law? I've already explained to you. It's
  2627. 1:24:23the law of identity. Are you
  2628. 1:24:24>> No, that's a it's a category within the
  2629. 1:24:26law of identity. You know what I'm
  2630. 1:24:28talking
  2631. 1:24:31>> it's it's the law of identity. It's the
  2632. 1:24:32same as the law of identity. That's they
  2633. 1:24:34call it live law. The law of identity is
  2634. 1:24:36live at law. Be quiet now because you
  2635. 1:24:38don't know what you're talking about.
  2636. 1:24:39You don't even know who lives is. You
  2637. 1:24:40don't even know where he was from. You
  2638. 1:24:42don't even know what books he wrote. You
  2639. 1:24:44don't even know what his first name was.
  2640. 1:24:46You don't know anything about him. You
  2641. 1:24:47don't know anything about him. I'll tell
  2642. 1:24:49you. I've actually read all of his books
  2643. 1:24:51by the way. I'll teach you. You tell me
  2644. 1:24:52if I'm the ones.
  2645. 1:24:54>> I'll tell you if I'm correct. Listen.
  2646. 1:24:56Let's be quiet. Don't talk about livets
  2647. 1:24:57with me. Yeah. You're not in a position
  2648. 1:24:59to speak about liveness.
  2649. 1:25:02Look,
  2650. 1:25:02>> I'll tell you what his law is.
  2651. 1:25:04>> Tell me, tell me anything. You're not in
  2652. 1:25:05a position to do so.
  2653. 1:25:07>> You tell me. The question is this is the
  2654. 1:25:09father. Len's law is is that something
  2655. 1:25:12is identical if and only if they are
  2656. 1:25:15identical. They share all the the
  2657. 1:25:18properties. They are identical in all of
  2658. 1:25:20their properties. Is that correct?
  2659. 1:25:21>> You're reading the over AI overview,
  2660. 1:25:23right? I'm looking at you. My friend is
  2661. 1:25:25telling me all of Okay, no problem.
  2662. 1:25:28correct or not?
  2663. 1:25:28>> Oh, so so so good. Good. Do do you
  2664. 1:25:31accept lin law? Is that correct law? Do
  2665. 1:25:33you accept it or not?
  2666. 1:25:34>> Is that correct?
  2667. 1:25:36>> Yes. Yes. Yes. You
  2668. 1:25:37>> I had to teach you on what Len's law
  2669. 1:25:38was. Thank you.
  2670. 1:25:39>> Are you a stupid guy? Are you all right?
  2671. 1:25:42Are you okay? So now dealing with Len's
  2672. 1:25:44law.
  2673. 1:25:44>> Okay.
  2674. 1:25:45>> I don't go the father god's law.
  2675. 1:25:49>> Philosophers also reject lion's law of
  2676. 1:25:52identity.
  2677. 1:25:52>> Father God from a linen's law identity
  2678. 1:25:56perspective.
  2679. 1:25:56>> From a law identity. I don't hold to
  2680. 1:25:58that. I don't hold a liance law.
  2681. 1:25:59>> Ah, so you have to reject it, do you?
  2682. 1:26:01>> Yes. I don't hold to it.
  2683. 1:26:03>> So you have to reject live law. Do you?
  2684. 1:26:06>> You don't know. You don't know what you
  2685. 1:26:09accept. Wait, what are you laughing at?
  2686. 1:26:10What are you laughing at? What are you
  2687. 1:26:11laughing at?
  2688. 1:26:12>> I'm
  2689. 1:26:13going script was destroyed.
  2690. 1:26:15>> No, hold on. Hold on.
  2691. 1:26:16>> Okay.
  2692. 1:26:17>> You're you're you're putting in a
  2693. 1:26:18relative identity framework. What you
  2694. 1:26:20don't understand is the following. What
  2695. 1:26:21you don't understand is order in order
  2696. 1:26:23for you to put forward a relative
  2697. 1:26:25identity framework, you have to reject
  2698. 1:26:27Linet's law. Linenet's law or the law of
  2699. 1:26:30identity is in fact one of the three
  2700. 1:26:32major pillars of propositional logic.
  2701. 1:26:35You have three pillars of propositional
  2702. 1:26:37logic. One of them is the law of
  2703. 1:26:38identity. The other one is the law of
  2704. 1:26:40non-contradiction. And the third one is
  2705. 1:26:41what? The law of excluded middle. These
  2706. 1:26:43are the three principle of propositional
  2707. 1:26:45logic. These are the pillars of it. Now,
  2708. 1:26:46in order for you to make your case, what
  2709. 1:26:48you're essentially admitting is the
  2710. 1:26:49following. that in order for me to make
  2711. 1:26:51a case for Jesus being God and in one
  2712. 1:26:54sense and father being God in another
  2713. 1:26:55sense and the Holy Spirit being God in
  2714. 1:26:56another, I have to reject one of the
  2715. 1:26:59pillars of propositional logic.
  2716. 1:27:00Propositional logic is the most
  2717. 1:27:02foundational and accepted logic in the
  2718. 1:27:06world for the last 3,000 years 4,000
  2719. 1:27:09years. So you have to you accept that in
  2720. 1:27:11order for you to try and justify a
  2721. 1:27:14version of the trinity which is Peter
  2722. 1:27:15G's one which is repudiated by
  2723. 1:27:17Christians himself that you have to
  2724. 1:27:19accept a framework which rejects one of
  2725. 1:27:21the pillars of propositional logic. Yes
  2726. 1:27:22or no?
  2727. 1:27:23>> No. So can you demonstrate? No. No. No.
  2728. 1:27:26But you said you reject
  2729. 1:27:28so I let you don't hold to it.
  2730. 1:27:30>> I let you hold to it for a very long.
  2731. 1:27:32>> That's what you just said. You said you
  2732. 1:27:33don't hold it for a very very long time.
  2733. 1:27:35So you just said
  2734. 1:27:38God logic doesn't believe in logic
  2735. 1:27:42logic don't believe in logic logic
  2736. 1:27:44propositional logic you don't believe in
  2737. 1:27:46it do you order for you in order for you
  2738. 1:27:49to fight the trinity you have to get let
  2739. 1:27:52me beat my chest instead of have a
  2740. 1:27:54discussion so relax
  2741. 1:27:57>> I appreciate it respond
  2742. 1:27:58>> I don't have to reject of lib's law in
  2743. 1:28:04order to hold to the Law of identity.
  2744. 1:28:06The law of identity works with relative
  2745. 1:28:10identity. I'm not rejecting the law of
  2746. 1:28:11identity.
  2747. 1:28:13>> So you can be identical in one sense
  2748. 1:28:15while having distinctions in another.
  2749. 1:28:17>> No, that's not that's even how Peter Ge
  2750. 1:28:21that's not how he um articulates it. He
  2751. 1:28:24says there's a sort and then he says
  2752. 1:28:25that the sort is represented by G and
  2753. 1:28:28then you've got F and then you've got uh
  2754. 1:28:30S and you've got H. Father, Son, Holy
  2755. 1:28:33Spirit. And then he says that F is
  2756. 1:28:35relatively identical to G and the S is
  2757. 1:28:38relatively identical to G and the HS
  2758. 1:28:40which is the Holy Spirit is relatively
  2759. 1:28:42identical to G. He doesn't say what
  2760. 1:28:44you're saying. He in fact rejects the
  2761. 1:28:46law of identity which is what you've had
  2762. 1:28:48to do. You have to reject a pillar of
  2763. 1:28:50logic yet you call God logic. YOU
  2764. 1:28:53ACTUALLY CALL YOURSELF GOD LOGIC BUT YOU
  2765. 1:28:55HAVE to reject logic in order for you to
  2766. 1:28:58make some sense of the trinity. Don't
  2767. 1:29:00you? Yes or no?
  2768. 1:29:01>> No.
  2769. 1:29:04I'm I'm sorry that the script didn't
  2770. 1:29:05work. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. That's
  2771. 1:29:07false. That's false. I'm sorry that the
  2772. 1:29:09I'm sorry the script didn't work.
  2773. 1:29:10>> Logic
  2774. 1:29:14respond one second. Let me respond. Wait
  2775. 1:29:17one second. He's rejecting logic
  2776. 1:29:19[clears throat] so much. His recipe says
  2777. 1:29:21reduce until thick.
  2778. 1:29:23>> No, but thanks for adding nothing to the
  2779. 1:29:26cup. I'm asking you, guys. I'm going to
  2780. 1:29:29respond. Okay. I don't want to I don't
  2781. 1:29:31want us to talk over each other. Do you
  2782. 1:29:34reject the law of identity or not? Yes
  2783. 1:29:35or no?
  2784. 1:29:36>> No, I don't. So,
  2785. 1:29:37>> you just said you don't hold to it.
  2786. 1:29:38>> Can I please speak?
  2787. 1:29:39>> You just said you don't hold to it.
  2788. 1:29:40Please contradiction.
  2789. 1:29:43You might as well. You might as well
  2790. 1:29:45contradiction. You've just rejected one.
  2791. 1:29:47You might as well reflection. Another
  2792. 1:29:50interject.
  2793. 1:29:52Why don't you just
  2794. 1:29:55script is dismantled has been
  2795. 1:29:57intellectually molested. has been cooked
  2796. 1:29:59and chefed and stirred up.
  2797. 1:30:03I think you know I think the people can
  2798. 1:30:06see
  2799. 1:30:10you know what the situation
  2800. 1:30:12people can see in order
  2801. 1:30:16that
  2802. 1:30:20is necessary
  2803. 1:30:21>> or reject it. We're going to spend 20
  2804. 1:30:25minutes.
  2805. 1:30:25>> You reject the law of identity. You
  2806. 1:30:26demonstrate that Lieben's law
  2807. 1:30:29necessitates absolute identity cuz
  2808. 1:30:31that's what you're saying. You're saying
  2809. 1:30:33that absolute identity is the law of
  2810. 1:30:36identity which I disapp
  2811. 1:30:46notice how they're talking over me still
  2812. 1:30:48hij
  2813. 1:30:54let him speak guys and he has to
  2814. 1:30:56interrupt me and talk over me
  2815. 1:30:57>> this shows the weakness in your position
  2816. 1:30:59hijab let me speak bro
  2817. 1:31:01>> I'll give you 20 seconds Not 20 seconds.
  2818. 1:31:03Just let me say my piece.
  2819. 1:31:05>> Say your piece. Say your piece. Say
  2820. 1:31:06>> good lord. Thank you. So here's an
  2821. 1:31:09example.
  2822. 1:31:10If so, the Titanic, right? The Titanic
  2823. 1:31:14before it got shipped off. It's in
  2824. 1:31:16perfect uh condition. No scratches, no
  2825. 1:31:19bangs, you know, it's all good to go.
  2826. 1:31:22>> He's reading.
  2827. 1:31:22>> Gets shipped off, crashes into the
  2828. 1:31:24glacier, sinks, gets ripped up.
  2829. 1:31:27>> Here's my question.
  2830. 1:31:29He's reading.
  2831. 1:31:30>> Here's my question. a job is the Titanic
  2832. 1:31:34that left the shore, man.
  2833. 1:31:36>> Absolutely identical in every way to the
  2834. 1:31:39Titanic that crashed into the glacier
  2835. 1:31:41and is sunk sunken. Is it absolutely
  2836. 1:31:43identical in every way?
  2837. 1:31:43>> I wasn't hearing what you said. Look, I
  2838. 1:31:46don't even know what you're talking
  2839. 1:31:46about.
  2840. 1:31:47>> No, [laughter] no, I don't even know
  2841. 1:31:48what you're talking about. Listen, go
  2842. 1:31:50back. Stop reading GPT. This is
  2843. 1:31:53not really the new generation
  2844. 1:31:56people
  2845. 1:32:00don't know where to go.
  2846. 1:32:01>> The only Titanic is your arguments are
  2847. 1:32:03sinking, brother. That's the only thing
  2848. 1:32:05that's arguments. I don't even see your
  2849. 1:32:07arguments. Listen, let's go back.
  2850. 1:32:09[laughter]
  2851. 1:32:11>> You're not You're not up there yet to
  2852. 1:32:13where you can understand the argument
  2853. 1:32:15where you can hear the argument.
  2854. 1:32:16>> Answer the question.
  2855. 1:32:18>> What's the way
  2856. 1:32:20question?
  2857. 1:32:22reading.
  2858. 1:32:22>> Is the Titanic
  2859. 1:32:25that [laughter] left the shore?
  2860. 1:32:28>> Absolute clowns.
  2861. 1:32:30>> Is the Titanic that left the shore
  2862. 1:32:33absolutely identical in every single way
  2863. 1:32:36to the Titanic that crashed and sunk?
  2864. 1:32:40>> What? What?
  2865. 1:32:42>> The Titanic that left the shore the same
  2866. 1:32:45as the one that sunk?
  2867. 1:32:46>> They absolutely identical in every way.
  2868. 1:32:49>> PROBABLY NOT BECAUSE IT'S BEEN
  2869. 1:32:50[screaming] OH, BUT IT'S STILL THE
  2870. 1:32:52TITANIC. SO, you just affirmed that the
  2871. 1:32:55>> That is the worst That [laughter] is the
  2872. 1:32:58worst thing I've ever heard. That is the
  2873. 1:33:00worstity I have ever heard. That is the
  2874. 1:33:04worst thing I've ever heard.
  2875. 1:33:05>> Okay. Is Is the Titanic the same Titanic
  2876. 1:33:08that sunk?
  2877. 1:33:09>> What are you talking?
  2878. 1:33:10>> Is it the same ship?
  2879. 1:33:10>> So, what's the analogy here?
  2880. 1:33:11>> Is it the same ship?
  2881. 1:33:12>> What's the What's the analogy here?
  2882. 1:33:13What's the
  2883. 1:33:14>> Is the Titanic for sure the same ship
  2884. 1:33:17that sunk? What's your point? What's
  2885. 1:33:19your point? Make it again. I'll ask it
  2886. 1:33:21again.
  2887. 1:33:21>> No. No. Make your point. We don't
  2888. 1:33:23understand.
  2889. 1:33:23>> You're going to answer. You're going to
  2890. 1:33:24answer.
  2891. 1:33:25>> No, it's not the same one. It's a
  2892. 1:33:26different one. It's a different one.
  2893. 1:33:27It's a different one. Whatever. Okay.
  2894. 1:33:29Now, the shore. What does it mean?
  2895. 1:33:32>> Is it the same ship that sunk? What are
  2896. 1:33:34you talking about, man? Okay. No,
  2897. 1:33:36[laughter] it's not. No, you're right.
  2898. 1:33:37So, what does it mean? What does it
  2899. 1:33:38mean? What does it mean? What does it
  2900. 1:33:39mean?
  2901. 1:33:40>> Is I'll ask it again. I'll ask it again.
  2902. 1:33:42Cuz you just affirmed identity without
  2903. 1:33:45absolute identity. Now you waste time.
  2904. 1:33:47>> You tend to find identity without
  2905. 1:33:50absolute identity. I'll ask it again.
  2906. 1:33:52>> So is the Titanic that left the
  2907. 1:33:54>> No, no. Explain it to me how it goes to
  2908. 1:33:56Father, Son, Holy Spirit, please.
  2909. 1:33:58>> No, no, no, no. You're going to answer
  2910. 1:33:59this. I want you cuz I want I It's the
  2911. 1:34:01same. It's different. Some things are
  2912. 1:34:02different about it. No problem. Yeah. No
  2913. 1:34:04problem.
  2914. 1:34:04>> The Titanic that left the shore. The
  2915. 1:34:06same ship.
  2916. 1:34:09>> What?
  2917. 1:34:12[laughter]
  2918. 1:34:13>> Okay. What do you want me to say? I
  2919. 1:34:14don't know how he wants me to answer
  2920. 1:34:15this.
  2921. 1:34:17>> With all those degrees, man,
  2922. 1:34:20you're not educated. You're not You're
  2923. 1:34:21not qualified for this level of of of,
  2924. 1:34:24you know,
  2925. 1:34:26you're not ready, man. One sec. One
  2926. 1:34:28second. Let me clarify
  2927. 1:34:31you, ladies and gentlemen. One second.
  2928. 1:34:32You're saying the Titanic.
  2929. 1:34:33>> I'm sorry, brother. I'm sorry. Let me
  2930. 1:34:34just land this and then I'll let you
  2931. 1:34:35speak. It's
  2932. 1:34:36>> not the same one that I don't want to
  2933. 1:34:38speak over you. I want to hear what
  2934. 1:34:39you're saying. Just let me land what I'm
  2935. 1:34:40saying, okay? I'm land what I'm saying
  2936. 1:34:42and and I promise I'll sit quiet. I
  2937. 1:34:43listen to you.
  2938. 1:34:44>> So Muhammad Hijab, you just affirmed
  2939. 1:34:48identity
  2940. 1:34:50disregarding absolute identity.
  2941. 1:34:53>> That's why you're confused. Uh go ahead
  2942. 1:34:57prove relative identity. So from one
  2943. 1:34:58aspect he's God and from another aspect
  2944. 1:35:00he's not. Is that what you're trying to
  2945. 1:35:01say?
  2946. 1:35:01>> No. So what what you trying to say?
  2947. 1:35:04>> What you trying to say? What you trying
  2948. 1:35:05to say? Make your point man
  2949. 1:35:08understand you man.
  2950. 1:35:11So, so the father, son, and holy spirit
  2951. 1:35:13are identical in essence while being
  2952. 1:35:16distinct in personhood or hypostasis.
  2953. 1:35:19>> Okay. Okay. No problem. They're distinct
  2954. 1:35:21in hypoasis and in person. Okay. No
  2955. 1:35:23problem. If they're distinct in person,
  2956. 1:35:25do they have separate centers of
  2957. 1:35:27consciousness or not?
  2958. 1:35:28>> I already answered this question. I'll
  2959. 1:35:29answer it again. They have the same
  2960. 1:35:31center of consciousness. They have the
  2961. 1:35:33same mind, the same will.
  2962. 1:35:36>> Tell me what's different. Yeah. Tell me
  2963. 1:35:37what's different about it.
  2964. 1:35:38>> Oh, what's different about the persons?
  2965. 1:35:40>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah,
  2966. 1:35:40>> sure. One. So, the father begets the
  2967. 1:35:42son. The father is unbegotten.
  2968. 1:35:44>> The father is unbegotten. The son is
  2969. 1:35:46begotten from the father. And the spirit
  2970. 1:35:48proceeds from the father.
  2971. 1:35:49>> Oh, I see. So, no. Great. I let me learn
  2972. 1:35:53a bit more about the trinity because I
  2973. 1:35:54want to know.
  2974. 1:35:54>> I know. You're learning a lot today.
  2975. 1:35:56>> No, I need to learn more about the
  2976. 1:35:57trinity since I've been here all day,
  2977. 1:35:58man. I'm here to serve me.
  2978. 1:36:01>> I'm here to serve hal meals.
  2979. 1:36:03>> Hold on. Let me just ask you the
  2980. 1:36:04question so you can teach me about the
  2981. 1:36:05trinity, please. Yeah. I want to know
  2982. 1:36:06cuz everybody wants
  2983. 1:36:07>> doing that so far. What's your question?
  2984. 1:36:08>> All the Muslims want to know. All the
  2985. 1:36:10Muslims want to know. Yeah. So I'm going
  2986. 1:36:11to ask you this.
  2987. 1:36:12>> What's your question? Habibi. My
  2988. 1:36:13question boy is the following. Okay.
  2989. 1:36:16[laughter]
  2990. 1:36:17Boy, the question is the following. If
  2991. 1:36:20it's true, if it's true that the father
  2992. 1:36:25beggets the son. Okay. You said that,
  2993. 1:36:27right?
  2994. 1:36:28>> Yeah, I did.
  2995. 1:36:29>> Does that mean that the son is
  2996. 1:36:30generated?
  2997. 1:36:31>> Yes. He is generated eternally from the
  2998. 1:36:33father.
  2999. 1:36:33>> Okay, beautiful. So if he's generated,
  3000. 1:36:35that means he's caused, right?
  3001. 1:36:37>> Uh he is. No. So when we're saying let
  3002. 1:36:40me
  3003. 1:36:41>> Yeah. No. Huh? Who is it?
  3004. 1:36:43>> All this broenerated.
  3005. 1:36:45>> Let me let me explain. Let me explain.
  3006. 1:36:48All right.
  3007. 1:36:48>> Got you. So when we say that the son is
  3008. 1:36:51begotten or generated or caused by the
  3009. 1:36:54father. This is not something that
  3010. 1:36:56happens in time. But this is eternal
  3011. 1:36:58generation. An eternal begotten.
  3012. 1:37:00>> He's being perpetually caused. Is he? Is
  3013. 1:37:03he being perpetually caused?
  3014. 1:37:04>> He's he's eternally generated. Aha. So
  3015. 1:37:07generated means he's perpetually caused
  3016. 1:37:09is he?
  3017. 1:37:09>> Sure.
  3018. 1:37:10>> What?
  3019. 1:37:10>> So caused. Okay. So he's a contingent
  3020. 1:37:12existent. He's not a necessary
  3021. 1:37:13existence. He's contingent. He's a
  3022. 1:37:15dependent being. Is he? Is your God
  3023. 1:37:17depend? No. No. He's not.
  3024. 1:37:19Let me let me answer this now. He's not
  3025. 1:37:21a dependent being. To be to be a
  3026. 1:37:23dependent being means that you are
  3027. 1:37:25dependent or contingent on another being
  3028. 1:37:28outside of yourself. The son shares the
  3029. 1:37:31same essence is the same being as the
  3030. 1:37:33father. And so therefore, the father
  3031. 1:37:36eternally called regenerating the son is
  3032. 1:37:38not demonstrates that he's actually a
  3033. 1:37:42father because his essence isn't sourced
  3034. 1:37:44in any other essence.
  3035. 1:37:45>> But you just said he you just said he's
  3036. 1:37:47generated by the father. That's what you
  3037. 1:37:48just said. He's called
  3038. 1:37:49>> Yeah, that's he shares the same essence
  3039. 1:37:51as the father. This is the difference
  3040. 1:37:52between hypoatic properties properties.
  3041. 1:37:55To be independent being means that your
  3042. 1:37:57essential properties are contingent on
  3043. 1:37:58another being.
  3044. 1:38:00>> Learn the categories. remember. Okay.
  3045. 1:38:02Fantastic. So now you admit you admit
  3046. 1:38:05that he's generated by the father
  3047. 1:38:07>> eternally. Yes.
  3048. 1:38:08>> Oh, eternally. That makes even worse
  3049. 1:38:09because he's caused being caused and
  3050. 1:38:11caused and caused and caused and caused
  3051. 1:38:13that he needs to be caused over and over
  3052. 1:38:15again.
  3053. 1:38:18>> Is that what you're telling me?
  3054. 1:38:21>> Say it again. Sorry.
  3055. 1:38:21>> Can you be caused and uncaused at the
  3056. 1:38:23same time?
  3057. 1:38:24>> Depends. Yeah. It depends on what you
  3058. 1:38:26mean. So you can be you CAN BE
  3059. 1:38:28[screaming]
  3060. 1:38:30>> [laughter]
  3061. 1:38:35>> LOOK AT IT. [screaming]
  3062. 1:38:36NOW, NOW YOU'VE GONE STRAIGHT INTO the
  3063. 1:38:39non-contradiction
  3064. 1:38:40of noncontradiction.
  3065. 1:38:43YO, THE MAN
  3066. 1:38:45IT'S NON CONTRADICTION, BOY. This is
  3067. 1:38:47This is WHY
  3068. 1:38:48>> HOW DARE YOU TALK ABOUT ISLAM, BOY. How
  3069. 1:38:50dare you talk about Islam, boy. Why
  3070. 1:38:53you've been
  3071. 1:38:55called and at the same time
  3072. 1:39:01one way
  3073. 1:39:03Christianity repent for your ways
  3074. 1:39:05Christianity immediately now YOU HAVE
  3075. 1:39:08BEEN CAUGH OUT
  3076. 1:39:10NOW HAVEN'T YOU BOY and uncaused AT THE
  3077. 1:39:13SAME TIME IS IT
  3078. 1:39:13>> none of this works bro
  3079. 1:39:16at the same time it's a controvention
  3080. 1:39:18contradiction on this boy is it a is it
  3081. 1:39:21a contra
  3082. 1:39:22non contradiction or boy. You've been
  3083. 1:39:24trying to jump out the P.
  3084. 1:39:25>> Is it a contravention of
  3085. 1:39:26non-contradiction or not, boy?
  3086. 1:39:28>> Okay. All right.
  3087. 1:39:30>> Is it a contravention of
  3088. 1:39:31non-contradiction or not? Boy,
  3089. 1:39:33>> can I can I can I answer?
  3090. 1:39:34>> Oh, it's on cause, is it? Is it cause?
  3091. 1:39:39>> Can I answer? Thank you. So, now I'm
  3092. 1:39:41about to answer your question. So,
  3093. 1:39:42hijab, this is you not understanding
  3094. 1:39:45categories to for something to be a
  3095. 1:39:47contradiction. It has to be the opposite
  3096. 1:39:50in the same way in the same sense. So
  3097. 1:39:53when I say Jesus is uncaused and gone at
  3098. 1:39:56the same time, I'm not saying that he's
  3099. 1:39:58uncaused in the same sense that he's
  3100. 1:40:00caused. So in for example, him being
  3101. 1:40:03caused by the father, excuse me, him
  3102. 1:40:05being caused or eternally generated by
  3103. 1:40:07the father is a hypoatic quality.
  3104. 1:40:10>> It's a hypothetic property, a relation
  3105. 1:40:12that he has with the father.
  3106. 1:40:14>> Sure. Not saying, excuse me, excuse me.
  3107. 1:40:16He is not essentially called me.
  3108. 1:40:19>> Excuse me.
  3109. 1:40:20>> Can a necessary being be caused in any
  3110. 1:40:22way?
  3111. 1:40:22>> Excuse me.
  3112. 1:40:23>> Can a necessary being in any way?
  3113. 1:40:25>> Allow me to finish.
  3114. 1:40:26>> Can a necessary being in any way? Talks
  3115. 1:40:28to me but not a necessary being caused
  3116. 1:40:30in any way, boy.
  3117. 1:40:31>> Can a necessary being caused in any way?
  3118. 1:40:33Can an independent being in any way? Can
  3119. 1:40:36an uncaused being caused in any way?
  3120. 1:40:38Jump out.
  3121. 1:40:39>> Can an uncaused being caused in any way
  3122. 1:40:41to jump out the pot.
  3123. 1:40:44>> Stop trying to jump out. And this is
  3124. 1:40:46what the Quran says. Subhan Allah. This
  3125. 1:40:47is what the Quran. This is what the
  3126. 1:40:48Quran says.
  3127. 1:40:53>> He does not
  3128. 1:40:58forget. Why? Because he's a
  3129. 1:41:03nervousness. He's going to allow your
  3130. 1:41:05nervousness and your fear to overcome.
  3131. 1:41:08Are you going to continue to not
  3132. 1:41:11be quiet for not going to happen this
  3133. 1:41:13entire live? Let me tell you this. Hey
  3134. 1:41:15now, now the live stream, ladies and
  3135. 1:41:16gentlemen, has degraded because can't
  3136. 1:41:19allow a discourse, a dialogue.
  3137. 1:41:22>> Avery,
  3138. 1:41:23>> allow me, allow me to finish what I was
  3139. 1:41:24saying without your interruption.
  3140. 1:41:26>> Avery, Avery,
  3141. 1:41:27>> allow me to finish what I was saying.
  3142. 1:41:31>> Avery, Avery. So, I'm just going to
  3143. 1:41:33continue.
  3144. 1:41:39>> Listen, Jesus is not caused.
  3145. 1:41:42what you're saying because you're saying
  3146. 1:41:45from the father is not derived from
  3147. 1:41:48anything else.
  3148. 1:41:50>> Okay.
  3149. 1:41:50>> But however is caused hypoatically
  3150. 1:41:54eternally generated meaning it doesn't
  3151. 1:41:56happen in time because that's his
  3152. 1:41:58relation with the father. So it's not a
  3153. 1:42:01contradiction because his causation is
  3154. 1:42:04in the sense of his hypoatic relation
  3155. 1:42:06with the father while he's essentially
  3156. 1:42:08not caused by any other being. I'm
  3157. 1:42:11holding be in any sense. Can a necessary
  3158. 1:42:16being be caused in any sense?
  3159. 1:42:18>> Yes. Hypothetically, then you're you're
  3160. 1:42:21out. You're out of order because you're
  3161. 1:42:23out of order and you don't know what
  3162. 1:42:24you're talking about. A necessary being
  3163. 1:42:27cannot be in any sense with the
  3164. 1:42:29consensus of magicians.
  3165. 1:42:32You're absolutely out of order. You're
  3166. 1:42:35absolutely out of order for you to say
  3167. 1:42:38Yeah. that it's it's it's ridiculous. So
  3168. 1:42:40your god is dependent is he refute me.
  3169. 1:42:43>> Refute me. No. Again to be dependent.
  3170. 1:42:47Okay. No problem. To be dependent is to
  3171. 1:42:49rely on a being outside refutes you. The
  3172. 1:42:52>> show me that my God is is is
  3173. 1:42:54>> the Quran refutes you by telling you
  3174. 1:42:56clearly. The Quran says
  3175. 1:42:59say he's Allah one and only. Allah he is
  3176. 1:43:02the independent.
  3177. 1:43:05He begets not nor is he begotten.
  3178. 1:43:09and there's nothing like him. Why is
  3179. 1:43:11Allah telling us that he is independent
  3180. 1:43:13and then telling us he does not beget
  3181. 1:43:15nor is he begotten? Because it's clear
  3182. 1:43:17that people like you unfortunately
  3183. 1:43:20believe it's possible to be independent
  3184. 1:43:23and dependent at the same time. Allah is
  3185. 1:43:25telling us and this is in line with
  3186. 1:43:27classical logic which you've already
  3187. 1:43:28rejected today that it's impossible to
  3188. 1:43:30be independent and dependent at the same
  3189. 1:43:33time in any respect in even 1% respect.
  3190. 1:43:37You cannot be a necessary or independent
  3191. 1:43:39being in any respect in any respect and
  3192. 1:43:42then have an 1% dependency. You can't
  3193. 1:43:45have 1% dependency. You cannot have
  3194. 1:43:47hypoatic dependency. You cannot have
  3195. 1:43:50essential dependency. You cannot have
  3196. 1:43:51attributional dependency. You are not
  3197. 1:43:53having any level onlogical dependency.
  3198. 1:43:56And if you believe that you can, then
  3199. 1:43:57you are putting two things together
  3200. 1:43:59which contradict.
  3201. 1:44:02You're fooled. You're an idiot. And you
  3202. 1:44:03have misrepresented Peter Gech. He
  3203. 1:44:05doesn't believe what you just
  3204. 1:44:07Yes or no? With the with the predicative
  3205. 1:44:09view, social trinitarianism and what do
  3206. 1:44:13you call it? Latin trinitarianism and
  3207. 1:44:15trinitarian. You don't need philosophy.
  3208. 1:44:17You don't know what you're talking
  3209. 1:44:17about.
  3210. 1:44:19You don't know what you're saying.
  3211. 1:44:22Depth. You're completely out of your
  3212. 1:44:24depth. You don't know what you're
  3213. 1:44:25saying. You can drink. You can put
  3214. 1:44:26whatever hat and costume you want. You
  3215. 1:44:28have been entirely decimated today. It's
  3216. 1:44:31been destruction upon destruction upon
  3217. 1:44:33destruction.
  3218. 1:44:35Any Christian that's watching this
  3219. 1:44:36today,
  3220. 1:44:38let me tell you this Christians, if
  3221. 1:44:40you're watching this and you just heard
  3222. 1:44:41this, if you just heard this
  3223. 1:44:43presentation about the trinity and you
  3224. 1:44:45still are Christian, wah, you are
  3225. 1:44:47fooling yourselves and you should be
  3226. 1:44:48ashamed. You are absolutely there's no
  3227. 1:44:50way you believe. You don't believe in a
  3228. 1:44:53god that's dependent. You don't believe
  3229. 1:44:55in aarass. You don't believe in a
  3230. 1:44:57generated god. You don't believe in any
  3231. 1:44:59of that stuff. You believe in the one
  3232. 1:45:01God that created the heavens and the
  3233. 1:45:02earth. That's what Muslims call you to.
  3234. 1:45:05We call you to the one God who created
  3235. 1:45:07the heavens and the earth.
  3236. 1:45:08>> Yes. The father, son, and holy spirit.
  3237. 1:45:10The one God who created the heavens and
  3238. 1:45:11the earth had to
  3239. 1:45:14go to say about the god of all creation
  3240. 1:45:17and all
  3241. 1:45:19that dependent and on the central level
  3242. 1:45:22is not that is an insufficient
  3243. 1:45:23dissatisfactory otherwise incomplete
  3244. 1:45:26answer
  3245. 1:45:28possible to reconcile. And if you
  3246. 1:45:31engage, then you're either ignorant
  3247. 1:45:35engage. You know Islam is true. You know
  3248. 1:45:38there's only one God worthy of worship.
  3249. 1:45:40You know there's only one God that
  3250. 1:45:41doesn't begget nor is he begotten. You
  3251. 1:45:43know that the father is you know that
  3252. 1:45:45the father god
  3253. 1:45:48and you know that the holy spirit. This
  3254. 1:45:51is your strongest argument when it
  3255. 1:45:53crumbled. This is our strongest argument
  3256. 1:45:55against Christianity. It succeeded. We
  3257. 1:45:57finished you. Any last words before we
  3258. 1:46:00go? Depending on in order to have a son,
  3259. 1:46:02he's depending

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of BREAKING: Mohammed Hijab SUED Me and LOST | GODLOGIC VS MOHAMMED HIJAB by GodLogic Apologetics, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 20,985 words across 3,259 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.