Breaking Down the Meteorology in Twister — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00hey everybody Trey here welcome back to
- 0:01another video in honor of the much
- 0:03anticipated release of the new movie
- 0:05Twisters I thought it would be fun to go
- 0:07back to the mother of all tornado movies
- 0:09heck one of the best movies of all time
- 0:11the original twister and take a deep
- 0:13dive into the meteorology behind the
- 0:14tornadoes in the movie of course things
- 0:17were given the Hollywood treatment
- 0:18falling semis flying cows but you can
- 0:21tell the cast and crew did their
- 0:22research and made a valiant attempt to
- 0:24incorporate real meteorology into the
- 0:25movie and it's part of why twister
- 0:27Remains the best tornado movie ever made
- 0:29nearly three decades after its release
- 0:31now that doesn't mean there weren't
- 0:32errors there were a lot of them and
- 0:34we're going to discuss where Twister's
- 0:35portrayal of supercells and tornadoes
- 0:37goes astray from actual severe storms
- 0:39meteorology but we'll also discuss where
- 0:41it went right as well as Define some of
- 0:43the advanced meteorological terms used
- 0:44in the movie at the end we'll use the
- 0:46meteorological Clues sprinkled
- 0:48throughout the movie to attempt to
- 0:49recreate the background synoptic pattern
- 0:51that spawned the fictional outbreak
- 0:53hopefully this is a fun but educational
- 0:55exercise and celebration of both the
- 0:56release of twisters and the timelessness
- 0:58of the original just a couple cou notes
- 1:00before we begin I've had some requests
- 1:02to dive into the damage these tornadoes
- 1:04caused but I'm going to stay away from
- 1:05that because a lot of the damage and
- 1:07impacts were highly fictionalized for
- 1:09example you'd be hardpressed to drive
- 1:10straight through a whole house tumbling
- 1:12across the road and pop out on the other
- 1:14side unscathed this was clearly
- 1:16hollywoodized if you will with very
- 1:18little legitimate meteorological or
- 1:20physical explanation we're going to
- 1:22focus on the actual meteorology
- 1:23portrayed in the film for example how
- 1:25the tornadoes behaved how the characters
- 1:27discussed the setup Etc so without
- 1:29without further Ado let's go ahead and
- 1:31get started let's start at the beginning
- 1:33when we get our first look inside the
- 1:35nssl we can tell from the visible
- 1:37satellite image that were still in the
- 1:38pre-dawn hours across the plains with
- 1:40the eastern half of the US illuminated
- 1:42by sunlight and the Western half still
- 1:44dark however forecaster Murphy says that
- 1:47the cap is already starting to break the
- 1:49Cap's already starting to break this is
- 1:51a bit strange as generally you need
- 1:52several hours of daytime heating to help
- 1:54build in stability and erod the cap when
- 1:57the cap is already gone in the morning
- 1:58that usually means a very convective
- 2:00Evolution as lots and lots of storms are
- 2:02able to go up at once in a weekly Capp
- 2:04environment H models are forecasting
- 2:06lifted indices from - 6 to- 10 this
- 2:09doesn't tell us much about the threat
- 2:11for severe weather the lifted index is a
- 2:13simple measure of how unstable the
- 2:15atmosphere is it's calculated by finding
- 2:17the difference between the observed
- 2:19environmental temperature at 500 M and
- 2:21the temperature a parcel of air lifted
- 2:22from the surface up to 500 MB would be
- 2:25positive values indicate that the
- 2:27atmosphere is stable while negative
- 2:29values indicate the atmosphere is
- 2:30unstable the more negative the more
- 2:32unstable the atmosphere is so lifted
- 2:34indices of - 6 to- 10 indicate a very
- 2:37unstable atmosphere however lifted index
- 2:40tells us nothing about any of the other
- 2:41ingredients needed for severe weather
- 2:43like low-level moisture lowlevel and
- 2:45deep layer Shear Etc therefore it's not
- 2:48a useful or reliable indicator of severe
- 2:50weather potential this satellite imagery
- 2:52doesn't tell us much either it looks
- 2:54like infrared imagery which tells us how
- 2:56cold the clouds are warmer colors
- 2:59yellows oranges and reds generally
- 3:00indicate colder Cloud tops which means
- 3:02taller clouds and often more robust
- 3:04convection while colder colors like
- 3:06purples blues and greens mean warmer
- 3:08Cloud tops here we really don't see
- 3:11anything convective in that case we'd
- 3:13see something like this with scattered
- 3:15Blobs of really cold Cloud tops
- 3:17indicative of developing thunderstorms
- 3:19instead we see a large area of subdued
- 3:21greens and yellows indicating a batch of
- 3:23mid or highle cloud cover which can
- 3:25actually often hamper destabilization on
- 3:27a severe weather day moving on to the
- 3:29moment once before the Chase Begins Bill
- 3:31grabs his handful of dirt tries to read
- 3:33the sky and delivers his famous line
- 3:35going green if I were out chasing I'd be
- 3:38quite worried if this was the sky I was
- 3:40seeing notice the preponderance of flat
- 3:42gray non-convective clouds you want to
- 3:45see lots of bubbling cumulus with at
- 3:47least some vertical extent this
- 3:49signifies that the atmosphere is
- 3:50destabilizing and large scale Ascent is
- 3:52overspreading the area of Interest now
- 3:54let's dive into the first tornado of the
- 3:56film Belzer catches the initial glimpse
- 3:58of it off in the distance between the
- 4:00trees it has somewhat of a land spout
- 4:02type look to it with the funnel above a
- 4:03robust dirt Swirl at the surface all
- 4:05beneath a very broad flat base normally
- 4:08supercellular tornadoes are associated
- 4:10with some sort of rotating wall cloud
- 4:12beneath the cloud base which is a
- 4:13manifestation of the rotating updraft or
- 4:15mesocyclone Lance pouts however are not
- 4:18associated with the supercell's
- 4:19mesocyclone and therefore occur
- 4:21underneath a flat base like this one the
- 4:23tornado morphs into a fully condensed
- 4:25rope or Slender cone complete with
- 4:27debris Cloud the special effects folks
- 4:29did a great job with this one as it's a
- 4:31very realistic representation save for
- 4:33the amorphous flat cloud-base that's
- 4:35still lacking a wall cloud the tornado
- 4:37begins to shape shift which is possible
- 4:40although it's especially common during
- 4:41tornado rope outs when the tornado is
- 4:43anchored to a boundary the low-level
- 4:45portion of the vortex tries to remain
- 4:46anchored to the boundary while the
- 4:47mesocyclone aoft starts to detach and
- 4:50move away after the tornado destroys the
- 4:52barn and silos and Bill crashes into the
- 4:54bridge notice how the wind is blowing
- 4:56toward Bill and Joe and away from the
- 4:58tornado this would indicate strong
- 5:01outflow when in reality the wind should
- 5:03be streaming into the Vortex since a
- 5:04tornado is an intense area of low
- 5:06pressure and air spirals inward toward
- 5:08the center of circulation the tornado
- 5:11then ropes out and dissipates and
- 5:12through a little Hollywood magic the
- 5:14Jeep falls back down to the ground even
- 5:17the strongest of tornadoes would have
- 5:18trouble lofting a truck and keeping it
- 5:20suspended for that long perhaps the most
- 5:23notable real world example of a vehicle
- 5:25being lofted is from the Smithville
- 5:26Mississippi EF5 back on April 27th 2011
- 5:30widely considered one of the most
- 5:31violent tornadoes of all time it hurled
- 5:33a Ford Explorer a half mile into the top
- 5:36of the Smithville water tower leaving a
- 5:38large Dent before it tossed the car
- 5:40another quarter mile into the opposite
- 5:42side of town again this was caused by
- 5:44one of the most violent tornadoes in
- 5:46history and this first tornado in the
- 5:47movie pales in comparison to that but of
- 5:50course this scene is one of the classic
- 5:51scenes of the movie so we'll let it
- 5:53slide on to the second tornado now and
- 5:56before we get a glimpse of it we hear
- 5:57Joe and Haynes chatting about what's on
- 5:59the mes it's cool that they included
- 6:01mention of the Oklahoma mezzet in the
- 6:02movie today it's a vital Data Network
- 6:05that stormchasers use when chasing in
- 6:06Oklahoma but back when twister was
- 6:08filmed it was only a few years old and
- 6:10didn't have nearly the Acclaim it does
- 6:11now Haynes mentions that wind are
- 6:14continuing to B the are the former is
- 6:17spot-on backing indicates that surface
- 6:20winds are becoming more southerly or
- 6:21southeasterly which often yields an
- 6:23increase in low-level Shear needed for
- 6:25tornadic supercells she also mentions V
- 6:29which stands for vertically integrated
- 6:30liquid V or Vil is an estimate of how
- 6:34much liquid water exists within a
- 6:35vertical column of air based on radar
- 6:37reflectivity with higher values
- 6:39representing greater quantities regions
- 6:41with high vill can help identify robust
- 6:43updrafts and can be a decent first look
- 6:45at where hail may be falling however
- 6:48vill is not always correlated with hail
- 6:50and it's a poor tool to use to estimate
- 6:52hail size so it should be used sparingly
- 6:55hannes says that vill is approaching 60
- 6:57kg per met squared which is quite high
- 6:59and suggests that robust storms were
- 7:01underway we then get our first look at
- 7:03the second tornado and it has some
- 7:05similarities with the first the clouds
- 7:07still look somewhat Stratus likee rather
- 7:09than nice and bubbly but at least this
- 7:11time we have a bit more of a defined
- 7:13storm base and maybe a little bit of a
- 7:15lowered area beneath which the tornado
- 7:16resides as the crews make their first
- 7:19approach to the tornado we get a look at
- 7:20Jonas's computer screen which is
- 7:22displaying radar velocity data however
- 7:24it's not showing much while it is
- 7:26showing wind shear I assume the radar is
- 7:28located here the greens indicate
- 7:30particles moving toward the radar and
- 7:32reds indicate particles moving away from
- 7:33the radar so we do have a rotational
- 7:35signature here but it's not tight at all
- 7:37like a tornado Vortex signature would be
- 7:40you'll see this kind of display in
- 7:41velocity data on calm evenings in the
- 7:43area extending outward from a radar site
- 7:45as in the example shown here the Radar
- 7:48Site is at the center of what I call the
- 7:49yin Andy Yang of velocities this area of
- 7:52Reds indicates flow moving away from the
- 7:54radar and the greens are flow moving
- 7:55toward it so we have fairly uniform
- 7:57northeasterly flow around the radar site
- 8:00it's not showing strong wind shear but
- 8:02the special effects folks likely took a
- 8:03series of these images and made it seem
- 8:05like there was a tornado Vortex
- 8:06signature on Jonas's laptop at least
- 8:08they nailed the cyclonic rotation
- 8:10present within the tornado Jonas's team
- 8:12member states that upper level winds are
- 8:14veering sir this means that the winds in
- 8:16the upper levels of the atmosphere are
- 8:18becoming more Westerly which generally
- 8:19Works to increase deep layer Shear
- 8:22especially if surface winds are backing
- 8:23to more southeasterly as Haynes said
- 8:25earlier as we know strong deep layer
- 8:27Shear is favorable for long lived super
- 8:29cells however upper level veering
- 8:31doesn't tend to happen much as a big
- 8:33trough the impetus for many large scale
- 8:35tornado outbreaks makes its way into a
- 8:37region as you'll naturally have more
- 8:39meridianal flow or flow with a greater
- 8:41southerly component ahead of the trough
- 8:43axis we get another Glimpse inside nssl
- 8:46as this tornado is ongoing and we hear
- 8:48some good meteorological conversation
- 8:50Bryce mentions increasing rotation in
- 8:52the parent storm with strong indications
- 8:53of a tornado given 90 knots of Shear
- 8:55within the vortex signature Murphy then
- 8:58mentions he sees a very pronounced
- 8:59anounced hook Echo within the storm
- 9:01which as we know indicates precipitation
- 9:03wrapping around the low-level
- 9:04mesocyclone according to Bryce storm
- 9:06motion is 225° straight out of the
- 9:08Southwest look at the updraft the angle
- 9:11I'm not sure what bill means here you
- 9:13really can't tell that a tornado is
- 9:15going to change direction by just
- 9:16looking at the geometry of the updraft
- 9:18we can forecast tornado deviants ahead
- 9:21of time but that involves an analysis of
- 9:22storm motion and the low-l wind profile
- 9:24check out Nixon and Allen 2021 just
- 9:27looking at a Storm's updraft doesn't
- 9:29give us much information at all on
- 9:30tornado motion here we finally see some
- 9:33appropriate velocity data with multiple
- 9:35vortex signatures visible notice how
- 9:37much tighter they are than the velocity
- 9:38imagery from earlier Lawrence then
- 9:40claims that they have uh F2 ladies and
- 9:43gentlemen possibly F3 okay as we know
- 9:45tornado ratings cannot be determined in
- 9:47real time the tornado eventually moves
- 9:50over the lake and twins develop we then
- 9:52see a series of interesting behaviors
- 9:54that really can only be chocked up to
- 9:55Hollywood magic for example tornadoes
- 9:58don't really split in like this there
- 10:00have been instances of two separate
- 10:02tornadoes merging to form one larger
- 10:04tornado such as the hon Kansas F5s on
- 10:06March 13th 1990 and sometimes you might
- 10:09see new vortices develop within a single
- 10:11ongoing multivortex tornado but an
- 10:13ongoing tornado splitting into two
- 10:15separate tornadoes is unheard of
- 10:17tornadoes also don't sound like
- 10:21this we'll come back to this later and
- 10:24of course perhaps the most classic scene
- 10:26of the entire movie The Flying Cow can
- 10:29this happen yes but probably not like
- 10:32this you know what let's just enjoy this
- 10:34masterpiece of a scene without debunking
- 10:36it Bill Joe and Melissa get hit by the
- 10:38tornadoes and then it's off to ant Megs
- 10:41let me just say in the middle of chasing
- 10:42a big tornado outbreak you would
- 10:44definitely not have time for a sit down
- 10:46lunch like this as the third tornado
- 10:48storm gets underway we once again see an
- 10:50accurate velocity image again notice the
- 10:53multitude of tight velocity couplets
- 10:55these are tornado Vortex signatures and
- 10:56are a much more accurate depiction of
- 10:58what the radar might look like on an
- 10:59outbreak day like this however Joey
- 11:02claims we've got a touchdown he would
- 11:04have no way to confirm a tornado was in
- 11:06progress using just velocity data this
- 11:09movie was made in the era before dual
- 11:11polarization radar came about
- 11:13traditional radar transmits and receives
- 11:15pulses in only the horizontal dual
- 11:18polarization radar what we use today
- 11:20transmits and receives pulses in both
- 11:22the horizontal and the vertical so that
- 11:24we can determine things like the
- 11:25dimensions and orientations of targets
- 11:28today we can confirm a ongoing tornado
- 11:30using only radar data if for example a
- 11:32minimum in correlation coefficient a
- 11:34dual pole product that tells us how
- 11:36similar or correlated targets are is
- 11:38collocated with a strong velocity
- 11:40couplet indicating lofted debris back in
- 11:42the days of Twister dual pole had not
- 11:44been invented therefore meteorologist
- 11:46only had reflectivity and velocity data
- 11:48to use so there would have been no way
- 11:50to confirm that a tornado was ongoing
- 11:52without actual storm reports from the
- 11:53field we get another shot of the
- 11:55computer a few moments later and it's
- 11:57now showing what appears to be a surface
- 11:58or upper air analysis with the wind
- 12:00barbs representing storm motion and a
- 12:02wind profiler wind profilers give us a
- 12:05look at the winds at each level of the
- 12:06atmosphere and how they change over time
- 12:09if we take a look at the one display
- 12:10here we don't really see a win profile
- 12:12you might expect to be associated with
- 12:14the big tornado outbreak assuming
- 12:16increasing time from left to right our
- 12:18most recent observed profile shows
- 12:20fairly uniform Westerly winds in the
- 12:21lowest kilometer or so of the atmosphere
- 12:23and above that fairly unidirectional
- 12:25southwesterly winds through the
- 12:26remainder of the atmosphere As We Know
- 12:29four tornadic supercells we want to see
- 12:31strong veering and strengthening of the
- 12:32Winds with height gradually turning from
- 12:34southernly or southeasterly at the
- 12:36surface to more Westerly in the mid and
- 12:37upper levels this creates those large
- 12:39looping hodographs that are often
- 12:41associated with big tornado outbreaks
- 12:43here we see very limited directional
- 12:45Shear which doesn't match the perceived
- 12:47setup behind the outbreak however it's
- 12:49great to see that they included a wide
- 12:50array of tools like wind profiler data
- 12:52that stormchasers might use while out in
- 12:54the field I really like the inclusion of
- 12:56real world storm shots here and there
- 12:58such as this one which shows an
- 13:00extremely low Cloud base and potential
- 13:01wall cloud definitely something you
- 13:03might see as a supercell was getting its
- 13:05act together and about to become toric
- 13:07as bill and Joel go in for intercept
- 13:09they get into a batch of small hail now
- 13:12their location relative to the storm and
- 13:13the storm's direction of motion are
- 13:15unclear from the dialogue but there
- 13:17really are only two ways that they'd
- 13:18experience this kind of hail in close
- 13:20proximity to the mesocyclone region of
- 13:22the storm they would either have to be
- 13:24driving through part of the forward
- 13:25flank of the storm which houses most of
- 13:27a supercell's heavy rain and hail or
- 13:29they'd be performing a maneuver called a
- 13:31hook slice this is when a stormchaser
- 13:33cuts through the hook and into the
- 13:34bear's cage or inflow region of the
- 13:36storm sometimes the rear flank downdraft
- 13:39which constitutes the hook can consist
- 13:41of hail so this would be plausible as
- 13:43well as the tornado drops notice how the
- 13:46cloud base is rotating this is a more
- 13:48accurate depiction of reality than the
- 13:49first two tornado scenes in which the
- 13:51cloud base was somewhat amorphous and
- 13:53lacked a lot of the features a typical
- 13:54toric supercell might have here's
- 13:57another instance of a slightly
- 13:58inaccurate portrayal of the flow field
- 14:00around a tornado all of the debris
- 14:02including the boat and the tricycle is
- 14:04uniformly moving away from the vortex
- 14:07even though debris can get centrifuged
- 14:08away from a tornado the fact that all of
- 14:10the debris and the hail are moving away
- 14:12from the tornado would indicate
- 14:13significant outflow which is detrimental
- 14:16to tornadoes as we discussed earlier the
- 14:18flow around a tornado spirals inward
- 14:20toward the center of circulation so all
- 14:22of this debris should be racing toward
- 14:24the vortex the tornado seemingly
- 14:26dissipates and preacher says that
- 14:28they've entered the cone of silence this
- 14:30is a misuse of this term the cone of
- 14:32silence is simply the area directly
- 14:34above a radar that cannot be scanned due
- 14:36to limitations in beam tilts on a radar
- 14:39display it manifests itself as the
- 14:41echo-free disc immediately surrounding a
- 14:43radar site and finally tornadoes don't
- 14:46growl like a lion they can emit some
- 14:48real low pitched Roars but they
- 14:50definitely don't sound like this you're
- 14:52right it's back
- 14:53building however director yand bont once
- 14:56said that he wanted the antagonists the
- 14:58tornado tadoes to each have their own
- 15:00personality and for the audience to view
- 15:02the tornadoes as living things and
- 15:04adding in the various sound effects
- 15:05certainly helped achieve these goals
- 15:08there's not a ton to say about the
- 15:09following tornado at the drive-in we do
- 15:11get a good depiction of the surface
- 15:13pattern on the TV and Melissa's motel
- 15:15room and a nice homage to the Storm
- 15:16Prediction Center with a categorical
- 15:18severe weather outlook we'll come back
- 15:20to this surface pattern in a bit when we
- 15:21try to recreate the background synoptics
- 15:24I will say that good stormchasers would
- 15:26not get caught off guard like Bill Joe
- 15:28and crew do here also it likely would
- 15:30not be this calm preceding the tornado
- 15:33you have to assume that there would be a
- 15:34strong low-level jet associated with an
- 15:36outbreak like this increasing
- 15:38nocturnally as is typical in the planes
- 15:40to have such a prolonged outbreak of
- 15:42significant tornado producing supercells
- 15:44you need a large slow moving trough
- 15:46which would induce a robust low-level
- 15:48response thus the low-l winds would
- 15:50likely be ripping at this time rather
- 15:52than calm as they initially are in this
- 15:54scene in the aftermath of the Wakita
- 15:56tornado we hear the voice on the radio
- 15:58talking about the F4 that hit Wakita and
- 16:01an even stronger tornado forming 25 Mi
- 16:03south of Wakita that could be the
- 16:05strongest F5 tornado that state has seen
- 16:07in more than years as we've discussed
- 16:09before damage assessments and ratings
- 16:11would not be completed this quickly nor
- 16:13can we determine a tornado's rating
- 16:15before it's even happened of course this
- 16:17is a Minor error that occurred a handful
- 16:19of times throughout the movie and then
- 16:21we get to the Big Kahuna the final
- 16:23tornado science aside this was the best
- 16:26looking tornado of the entire movie in
- 16:27my opinion the crew did did a phenomenal
- 16:29job with this tornado even if some of
- 16:31its impacts were highly fictionalized
- 16:33for starters this was an unusually high-
- 16:35based wedge often times wedges are on
- 16:38the grungier side emanating from much
- 16:40lower based storms if you think about it
- 16:42storms with higher bases make it more
- 16:45difficult to consummate the connection
- 16:46between the mesocyclone Aloft and the
- 16:48surface Vortex so most of your tornadoes
- 16:50from higher Bas storms are more conical
- 16:52cylindrical or ROP shaped so this exact
- 16:54tornado would be somewhat difficult to
- 16:56attain in real life but let's face it it
- 16:58looks awesome and the taller nature of
- 17:00the wedge makes it even that much more
- 17:01menacing during the sensor drop off
- 17:04notice once again how calm the wind is
- 17:06where they are this would almost
- 17:07certainly never be the case in close
- 17:09proximity to such an intense tornado the
- 17:11inflow would likely be extremely strong
- 17:14the tornado proceeds to accomplish some
- 17:15incredible Feats it sucks up and spits
- 17:18out a tanker truck it tosses farm
- 17:20equipment like toys it rolls a house
- 17:22across the road these occurrences are
- 17:24all nearly impossible even in the
- 17:26strongest of tornadoes for example the
- 17:28average tanker truck weighs about 33
- 17:30tons or over 70,000 lb so while a
- 17:33violent tornado could perhaps blow a
- 17:35tanker truck off the road it would take
- 17:37something much stronger to LOF it as
- 17:38high as this tornado did let's look past
- 17:41the fact that bill and Joe were able to
- 17:43outrun a tornado moving at 30 to 40 m
- 17:45hour and fast forward to the moment when
- 17:46they're strapped to the pipe and the
- 17:48tornado overtakes them this is a little
- 17:50bit off from what the inside of an
- 17:52actual tornado would look like it would
- 17:54not have a perfect funnel right in the
- 17:56center with blue skies above remember
- 17:58that a tornado is was simply an area of
- 17:59intense rotating winds and in this case
- 18:01condensation it would be quite murky
- 18:03inside and you wouldn't see much detail
- 18:05at all the tornado then dissipates once
- 18:08again much too quickly than what is
- 18:09typical rather than just going poof a
- 18:12tornado of this magnitude would likely
- 18:13undergo a prolonged rope out process
- 18:16before fully dissipating all right now
- 18:18let's go back and gather all the
- 18:19meteorological Clues given throughout
- 18:21the movie and try to recreate the
- 18:22synoptic environment in which this
- 18:24fictional outbreak occurred we're going
- 18:26to create a composite map with all the
- 18:28main features on on it including upper
- 18:29air and surface features so it might get
- 18:31a little cluttered but we'll do our best
- 18:33to keep it tidy we'll also take some
- 18:35Liberty in ignoring some of the
- 18:36meteorological discontinuities we've
- 18:38talked about throughout this video let's
- 18:40start with what we know big picture we
- 18:42know this was a multi-day outbreak with
- 18:44lots of storms producing significant to
- 18:46Violent tornadoes particularly across
- 18:48Oklahoma it appears we had a full day of
- 18:50activity that continued through the
- 18:51night and into the next day
- 18:53uninterrupted this is pretty difficult
- 18:55to achieve in real life usually storms
- 18:57will weaken and or gal into a line
- 18:59overnight decreasing the tornado threat
- 19:01before a new round of storms occurs with
- 19:03daytime heating the following day in any
- 19:06case A multi-day outbreak usually
- 19:07requires a potent slow moving perhaps
- 19:10negatively tilted trough at 500 marbar
- 19:12nssl meteorologist Bryce mentions that
- 19:15the storm that spawned the water spouts
- 19:16was moving at 225° which is due
- 19:19southwesterly we know that mature
- 19:21supercells tend to move slightly to the
- 19:23right of the mean flow so we can assume
- 19:25that the mid and upper level flow was
- 19:26somewhat meridianal over Oklahoma
- 19:28perhaps a bit more south southwesterly
- 19:30as we have here going down to the
- 19:32surface we know that there was a dry
- 19:34line in place via the voice on the
- 19:35weather radio at the beginning of the
- 19:39movie this was confirmed when we see the
- 19:41TV screen in Melissa's motel room at the
- 19:43drive-in which shows the actual surface
- 19:45weather map we can see that the dry line
- 19:47was situated from Southern Kansas down
- 19:49through West Central Oklahoma into Texas
- 19:51the greens to the east indicate robust
- 19:53low-level moisture while the Browns to
- 19:55the West represent dry air we'll draw
- 19:57that in on our composite map here as
- 20:00mentioned by the voice on the weather
- 20:01radio D points across Oklahoma were in
- 20:03the upper 60s through the early portion
- 20:05of the day and from Jonas's crew member
- 20:07Landers we know that they reached 70
- 20:09prior to the first tornado Landers what
- 20:11am I do points doing points up to 70 sir
- 20:14this indicates moisture inection was
- 20:15occurring throughout the day on what
- 20:16appears to be southernly surface flow
- 20:19the dark green area would likely
- 20:20represent the 70s dupoint plume so we'll
- 20:22add that to our map as well now the warm
- 20:25front is drawn incorrectly here it's
- 20:27normally situated at the leading edge of
- 20:29the moisture return so it would probably
- 20:30be somewhere in here using this and the
- 20:33fact that all fronts emanate from a
- 20:35surface low we can assume that it leads
- 20:36back to a surface low somewhere in
- 20:38southern or southwest Kansas this makes
- 20:40sense as the exit region of the assumed
- 20:42background trough is draped across this
- 20:44area surface lows tend to develop in the
- 20:47region of strongest height Falls and
- 20:48Divergence aoft ahead of the trough axis
- 20:50which is located in the exit region so
- 20:53we can comfortably place our surface low
- 20:55and warm front here from this we can
- 20:57infer the presence of of a strong
- 20:59low-level jet given the perceived
- 21:01negative tilt nature of the mid and
- 21:02upper level trough we can assume a
- 21:04fairly robust low-level Cyclone which
- 21:06would induce a robust low-level jet with
- 21:09surface winds out of the South as shown
- 21:10on the image on the TV screen and
- 21:12perhaps backing some with time as Hanes
- 21:14says prior to the second tornado the
- 21:16low-level jet would likely be souths
- 21:18southwesterly and significantly stronger
- 21:19than the surface winds to provide ample
- 21:21lowlevel Shear to support a significant
- 21:23tornado outbreak it also may help with
- 21:26storm mode going back to the dry line
- 21:28which which is perceived as the
- 21:29initiating boundary in this setup notice
- 21:31how it is oriented quite parallel to the
- 21:33mid and upper level flow this can yield
- 21:36a somewhat messy storm mode however we
- 21:38could assume that supercells may have
- 21:40been able to form in the open warm
- 21:41sector within the strong warm inection
- 21:43regime accompanying the low-level jet
- 21:45especially since the cap eroded fairly
- 21:46early on in this event these would be
- 21:49more discreet by nature and along with
- 21:51initial supercell development off the
- 21:52dry line would Foster a significant
- 21:54tornado threat on our map we'll draw in
- 21:56the axis of the 850 m yet to coincide
- 21:59with our low-level moisture plume
- 22:01synoptically this all makes sense now
- 22:03let's zoom in a little bit on the more
- 22:05localized environment across Oklahoma
- 22:07that helped make it ground zero for the
- 22:08outbreak we'll try to come up with what
- 22:10the morning sounding might have looked
- 22:12like at Oklahoma City prior to the event
- 22:14getting underway at the start of the
- 22:16movie we hear that at 7 a.m. in Oklahoma
- 22:18City the temperature is 75° and that the
- 22:21D points were in the upper 60s let's
- 22:23call it 68 note that temperatures are
- 22:25plotted in degrees C on the skew T so
- 22:28we'll convert our temperatures from
- 22:29Fahrenheit and note that Oklahoma City's
- 22:31surface pressure is just below 1,000 MB
- 22:34we'll plot our temperature and du point
- 22:36on the skew T and from there we can draw
- 22:38in our parcel Trace going up along the
- 22:40mixing ratio line associated with the
- 22:42dupoint and the dry adabat associated
- 22:44with the temperature until they meet
- 22:47from there we follow the moist adabat up
- 22:49the rest of the way if you're not
- 22:51familiar with this process check out my
- 22:53definitive guide to skes and photographs
- 22:55Series in the description box below we
- 22:57know there was a c as it was mentioned
- 22:59multiple times leading up to the first
- 23:01storm including by nssl meteorologist
- 23:03Murphy and hannes however it was fairly
- 23:05weak as Murphy mentions the cap was
- 23:07already starting to break at the
- 23:08beginning of the movie so there probably
- 23:10was a small inversion on the sounding
- 23:12something like this likely emanating
- 23:15from the elevated mix layer or EML
- 23:17brought in on the south southwesterly
- 23:18mid-level flow there was probably
- 23:20already quite a bit of instability at
- 23:22play we'll refine this as we move on to
- 23:24the evening sounding in just a bit D
- 23:26points would have dropped off within the
- 23:28version and EML and then likely
- 23:30recovered slightly perhaps looking
- 23:31something like this this is a kindar
- 23:34classic loaded gun sounding ready for a
- 23:36forcing mechanism to arrive and the cap
- 23:38toode to initiate a significant severe
- 23:40weather event now let's estimate what
- 23:42things might have looked like by evening
- 23:44which would basically be right in the
- 23:45middle of the outbreak pretty much all
- 23:47of the tornadoes portrayed in the movie
- 23:49were spawned by storms that were quite
- 23:51High based especially the final tornado
- 23:54this suggests that temperature Duo
- 23:55spreads were on the higher side leading
- 23:57to higher Cloud bases
- 23:59often this can mean storms that produce
- 24:00more outflow which is unfavorable for
- 24:02tornadoes but of course that was not the
- 24:04case with the setup in twister we know
- 24:07Oklahoma City started the day at 75 so
- 24:09through surface heating temperatures
- 24:11would have plausibly increased to about
- 24:12the low 90s but with d points increasing
- 24:15only to around 70 that would yield
- 24:17unfavorable temperature dupoint spreads
- 24:19exceeding the 20° rule of thumb perhaps
- 24:21some of the early cloud cover we saw on
- 24:23initial satellite imagery delayed the
- 24:25onset of surface heating so temperatures
- 24:27may have peaked around 87 to 88 yielding
- 24:30spreads still on the higher side but
- 24:31certainly within the range for tornadoes
- 24:33it's also possible that D points
- 24:35continue to rise above 70 further
- 24:37decreasing spreads so for our purposes
- 24:39let's call it 88 over 72 from that we
- 24:42can once again draw in our parcel Trace
- 24:45we can assume that the cap had fully
- 24:47eroded by this point and if we look at
- 24:48the third tornadic storm we notice that
- 24:50the vortex forms very efficiently going
- 24:53from rotating base to tornado in a
- 24:54matter of a few seconds this suggests
- 24:56that lowlevel instability was high
- 24:58helping to efficiently stretch surface
- 25:00vorticity into the vertical so our lowle
- 25:02temperature profile probably looks
- 25:04something like this we also know that
- 25:06lifted indices from - 6 to - 10 were
- 25:09expected to be in place as we discussed
- 25:11earlier the lifted index is simply the
- 25:13difference between the observe
- 25:14temperature and the parcel temperature
- 25:16at 500 Marb our parcel temperature at
- 25:19500 marbar appears to be around -4° C so
- 25:22assuming a lifted index ofus 10 our 500
- 25:25M temperature would be right in here
- 25:27with this in mind we can estimate that
- 25:29our temperature profile might look
- 25:31something like this yielding strong
- 25:33instability via a fat Cape profile of
- 25:36course strong instability is often a
- 25:38Hallmark of significant tornado
- 25:39outbreaks the dupoint profile is more so
- 25:42up to our imagination but it might have
- 25:43looked something like this with a bit of
- 25:45low-level moisture beneath slightly
- 25:47drier air aoft let's take a stab at the
- 25:49hodograph we know surface winds are out
- 25:51of the South or south-southeast we'll
- 25:53say they're about 15 knots which I'd
- 25:55estimate is about average for these
- 25:57kinds of setups we've assumed there was
- 25:59a substantial low-level jet thanks to
- 26:01the robust nature of the mid-level
- 26:02trough let's say perhaps conservatively
- 26:0560 knots out of the South Southwest
- 26:07assuming gradual veering of the low-l
- 26:09Winds with height this yields ample
- 26:11hodograph curvature and strong low-l
- 26:13Shear now again one characteristic that
- 26:16was common to all the tornadoes in the
- 26:17film is that they were quite visible
- 26:19this means that the wind profile was
- 26:21such that precipitation was efficiently
- 26:23vented away from the mesocyclone regions
- 26:25of these storms as we've discussed
- 26:27before on the Chanel we can associate
- 26:29efficient precipitation venting with
- 26:30slight backing of the winds in the mid
- 26:32levels and strong storm relative outflow
- 26:35in the upper levels we'll assume the 500
- 26:37M wind was Stronger but at a similar
- 26:39heading relative to the 850 Mar wind
- 26:42this yields a modest kink in the hod
- 26:44graph that is common in events in which
- 26:45tornadoes are quite visible strong upper
- 26:48level winds also help in this regard and
- 26:49lengthen the photograph this is
- 26:51additional evidence for why the mid and
- 26:53upper level trough must have been more
- 26:54negatively tilted with more meridianal
- 26:56flow in its exit region all in all we've
- 26:59come up with a setup that looks pretty
- 27:01conducive for a significant tornado
- 27:02outbreak a strong High amplitude
- 27:04negatively tilted trough whose exit
- 27:06region is interacting with a surface low
- 27:07and its Associated juicy warm sector
- 27:09ahead of the dry line a nearly pristine
- 27:11very unstable thermodynamic environment
- 27:13coupled with a wind profile exhibiting
- 27:15strong lowlevel and deep layer Shear
- 27:18storms developing in either regime off
- 27:20the dry line or in the open warm sector
- 27:22would quickly become supercells posing a
- 27:24risk for significant to Violent
- 27:25tornadoes not to mention the subtle
- 27:27backing a loft for more visible
- 27:29unimpeded mesocyclones and tornadoes
- 27:31clearly an upper echelon environment was
- 27:33needed to create such a prolific
- 27:34outbreak so that's going to do it for
- 27:37this video hopefully that was a fun
- 27:38little exercise trying to decipher the
- 27:40meteorology behind such a monster
- 27:42outbreak despite its meteorological
- 27:44flaws twister Remains the gold standard
- 27:46for tornado movies and remains a
- 27:48consequential and favorite movie of many
- 27:50meteorologists and stormchasers
- 27:51including myself even almost three
- 27:53decades after its release thanks for
- 27:55watching and we'll see you in the next
- 27:57video
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Breaking Down the Meteorology in Twister by Convective Chronicles, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,644 words across 846 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.