YouTube2Text

Board of Directors Broadcast - SAULT 8/31/26 — Transcript

by Sault Tribe TV · 39,234 words · 5,743 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 4:33They have increased costs to their
  2. 4:35silos, so to speak. Can I My memo didn't
  3. 4:38have all of their information.
  4. 4:39>> Okay. Yep. Yeah, we can handle that.
  5. 4:44>> Okay.
  6. 4:50I'm going to try and share my screen for
  7. 4:53our I have a memo here that gives some
  8. 4:55estimated costs and we'll go from there.
  9. 5:02[clears throat]
  10. 5:03>> Yeah, feel free to join me up here
  11. 5:04y'all.
  12. 5:26should be loading on the screen here.
  13. 5:27But uh
  14. 5:31I have a memo. It should also be in your
  15. 5:32packets. This is mostly focused of
  16. 5:35course for my my silo so to speak. So,
  17. 5:39this is more startup cost in the legal
  18. 5:42realm
  19. 5:44of what it will take to get a three
  20. 5:46branch government going.
  21. 5:49Um, I have a Excel spreadsheet that
  22. 5:51we'll get to you guys soon. Holly is
  23. 5:53working on um revising that and that's
  24. 5:56what in much more detail, but I've
  25. 5:58summarized the costs here in this memo
  26. 6:00which we can go through here in public.
  27. 6:03So, we're I'm estimating right now a
  28. 6:06cost of about $3.8 8 million. If you
  29. 6:08recall, that's closer to my initial
  30. 6:11estimate way back in I don't remember
  31. 6:13now, January of this year.
  32. 6:16And we'll go through each silo and the
  33. 6:18anticipated cost and kind of explain a
  34. 6:21little bit of the breakdown. Um, this is
  35. 6:24not probably all the costs. We're going
  36. 6:26to have stuff that is quote hidden cost,
  37. 6:28things we maybe didn't anticipate. One
  38. 6:30thing that's not in this memo that
  39. 6:32Holly, your CFO, and I spoke about
  40. 6:34earlier this morning was um cost of
  41. 6:38running elections. Um whether that's a
  42. 6:40constitutional election or just the new
  43. 6:42elections that are in the the
  44. 6:45constitutional reform election or just
  45. 6:47the new elections that are in the
  46. 6:48revised constitution. Um and those could
  47. 6:52be several hundred,000 in addition to
  48. 6:54what we norm currently spend on
  49. 6:57elections. But I don't So there's other
  50. 6:59costs that are not here that maybe Holly
  51. 7:01or another executive can help illuminate
  52. 7:04on. But starting with the legislative
  53. 7:06branch,
  54. 7:10the biggest cost for the legislative
  55. 7:12branch startup costs would be legal
  56. 7:15counsel or legislative staff.
  57. 7:19And we've had multiple discussions over
  58. 7:20the past few weeks of what that would
  59. 7:22look like. Is that a law firm? Is that a
  60. 7:24legal consultant? Is that a a staff
  61. 7:27attorney akin to a general counsel or a
  62. 7:30senior attorney? It's to be determined
  63. 7:33based on what budget the tribal council
  64. 7:35wishes to push to adoption, but for the
  65. 7:38sake of trying to get as close as I can
  66. 7:40to an all-in cost estimate.
  67. 7:44Um, I based this on
  68. 7:47a typical year spending of our outside
  69. 7:50cost now for outside law firms.
  70. 7:54um and a mid-range of a general counsel
  71. 7:58position. It doesn't have to be that
  72. 8:00high. You might not need that level of a
  73. 8:03a candidate. Um but if you're trying to
  74. 8:06have a legislative attorney who maybe
  75. 8:08also advises the different authorities
  76. 8:11who are under the legislative branch,
  77. 8:12maybe that type of candidate is what you
  78. 8:15want to to shoot for. Um, so there's
  79. 8:18obviously wiggle room depending on what
  80. 8:20candidate and what type of position
  81. 8:22ultimately gets adopted by the board
  82. 8:24here or by the tribal council. Um, but
  83. 8:26you're looking at just shy of $700,000
  84. 8:29year one anticipated extra cost in legal
  85. 8:33fees. This this is to hire a general
  86. 8:36counsel type level attorney inhouse and
  87. 8:40spending about 200 grand um in outside
  88. 8:44um law firm fees. And those are all
  89. 8:49dependent on how many uh lawsuits are
  90. 8:52the travel council's involved or what
  91. 8:54involved in or what type of workload.
  92. 8:56Um, but that's probably a pretty safe
  93. 8:59gueststimate based on just historical
  94. 9:01spending of our tribe with legal fees.
  95. 9:04>> So, Ryan, if you could repeat that. Um,
  96. 9:07basically how much it will cost to build
  97. 9:08the legislative branch. I'm going to ask
  98. 9:10you the question for each branch of
  99. 9:11government.
  100. 9:13>> Uh, I'm estimating right now $649,69927
  101. 9:20for a year one cost.
  102. 9:22>> So about 650 in year one to build our
  103. 9:24legislative branch. And that includes
  104. 9:26wages, fringe, and outside law firm if
  105. 9:30the travel council goes that route. So
  106. 9:32if they don't go all in, it will cost
  107. 9:35less. But that I'm trying to give an
  108. 9:36all-in potential maximum cost.
  109. 9:40>> Increased cost. Increase cost.
  110. 9:43>> All right, we can keep going. Ryan,
  111. 9:46>> the judicial branch will be the biggest
  112. 9:49cost in uh whether it was a two or a
  113. 9:51three branch government because you're
  114. 9:52building out a independent court system.
  115. 9:54something we currently don't have. And
  116. 9:57the new constitution mandates a certain
  117. 10:00level of judges with a certain level of
  118. 10:02experience. Namely, they are for the
  119. 10:04most part all at all attorneys. Um,
  120. 10:09say for one that is not that cannot be
  121. 10:11an attorney or could be either an
  122. 10:14attorney or a lay person that is on the
  123. 10:15the Supreme Court. So the judicial
  124. 10:19branch we're estimating you're going to
  125. 10:22need because it's mandated by the
  126. 10:23constitution an associate trial court
  127. 10:25judge. So you have two judges in your
  128. 10:27trial court and the cost estimates are
  129. 10:30based on the mid of a senior attorney.
  130. 10:33That's a comparable like position that
  131. 10:35we have now.
  132. 10:38And then the uh Supreme Court justices,
  133. 10:43there's three of them. We're presuming
  134. 10:44that they're part-time, but we're
  135. 10:47estimating their their salary to be
  136. 10:50based off of our current chief judge
  137. 10:52wage grid for the trial court as well as
  138. 10:55the senior attorney wage grid for the
  139. 10:57associate judges, justices, excuse me.
  140. 11:00That'll be a well, in our current wage
  141. 11:02grid, a comparable like position. And
  142. 11:05we're also estimating about a million
  143. 11:06dollars to potentially have to build out
  144. 11:10a bigger courthouse. [clears throat]
  145. 11:11So you have two courtrooms running, one
  146. 11:13the chief judge is running, one the
  147. 11:15associate judge is running and
  148. 11:18it may be prudent to figure out if one
  149. 11:21of those or a third court needs to be
  150. 11:23done for the Supreme Court. So all in
  151. 11:26with all of those um all the judges
  152. 11:29positions
  153. 11:30and a potential new building or addition
  154. 11:32to our current building.
  155. 11:35year one judicial branch cost increase
  156. 11:39to our current budget of 2,155,24968.
  157. 11:49The wiggle room here besides negotiating
  158. 11:53power with bringing on the judges at
  159. 11:55certain wages is if you don't build out
  160. 11:59if you don't feel the need or at least
  161. 12:01initially don't build out any more
  162. 12:04building capacity in the courthouse. Of
  163. 12:06course, that saves you a million dollars
  164. 12:08right off the top if you just try to go
  165. 12:10forward with your current capacity in
  166. 12:12your current courthouse.
  167. 12:15But the other wiggle room with the wages
  168. 12:18are a little more concrete because the
  169. 12:21constitution does mandate those
  170. 12:22positions get filled at some at some
  171. 12:25kind of of wage, right?
  172. 12:30Executive branch.
  173. 12:34This is one where we probably have a
  174. 12:36little more wiggle room.
  175. 12:39This estimate is based off of two
  176. 12:42additional support staff at the mid wage
  177. 12:45mid wage range of an administrative
  178. 12:48assistant position
  179. 12:50and an also an estimated increase to
  180. 12:53outside legal fees that may entail with
  181. 12:57different increased litigation of
  182. 12:59$200,000 for a total increase to the
  183. 13:03executive branch or the current
  184. 13:05chairman's office of 420. 23,343444.
  185. 13:14This one might be one of the easier ones
  186. 13:16to initially save cost because you might
  187. 13:19not need any additional support staff
  188. 13:22and if you rely on in-house team
  189. 13:25primarily as we have been for the past
  190. 13:27few years under my leadership then you
  191. 13:30can maybe save that increase to outside
  192. 13:34legal fees. But this is kind of a middle
  193. 13:35ground safe estimate so to speak of what
  194. 13:38it what the increase could be to that to
  195. 13:40that branch which is not a lot. It's
  196. 13:42mostly in the court of course
  197. 13:44>> I can't see myself requesting for two
  198. 13:45additional positions. So I think this is
  199. 13:47lowhanging fruit. I think the main cost
  200. 13:49associated with setting up the OGA's
  201. 13:52office is the ink that it would take to
  202. 13:54revise the organizational chart. So I
  203. 13:56mean you just laid it out like the OGA's
  204. 13:58office the executive branch is the
  205. 14:00cheapest to transition to but the court
  206. 14:02is the most expensive. So it doesn't
  207. 14:04make sense for people to say they don't
  208. 14:06support a three branch government
  209. 14:08because the costs associated with it but
  210. 14:09then state well we support having
  211. 14:12standing for tribal members in court and
  212. 14:14establishing that judiciary. The two
  213. 14:16just aren't compatible. Judge Leaport.
  214. 14:20>> Yeah. The other thing I just wanted to
  215. 14:21say if it's okay and appropriate for me
  216. 14:23to put in a plug for this public
  217. 14:24defender position, which obviously would
  218. 14:26be outside of the court, but you know,
  219. 14:28currently we do spend based on my
  220. 14:31initial review of our budgets, which
  221. 14:33again I just started on the third, but
  222. 14:35we do spend a pretty significant amount
  223. 14:37of funds on outside representation for
  224. 14:40indigent uh defendants. most of our
  225. 14:42criminal defendants re re like meet or
  226. 14:45are just about at the standard right for
  227. 14:47indigency and where we're requiring them
  228. 14:49only to pay back a little bit of that
  229. 14:50money but having a public defender's
  230. 14:52office would both ease the process in
  231. 14:55terms of appointments um and would help
  232. 14:57with some consistency um in terms of uh
  233. 14:59fees and um budgeting. So just wanted to
  234. 15:02offer that up.
  235. 15:03>> Judge Leaport, do you feel like
  236. 15:04establishing that office would save the
  237. 15:06tribe money in the long run?
  238. 15:08>> I do. Um
  239. 15:11s to my surprise the the criminal docket
  240. 15:14is actually relatively extensive at Sue
  241. 15:17tribe which is again fine I mean it's to
  242. 15:19[snorts] be expected right with the
  243. 15:20number of individuals that are enrolled
  244. 15:23um and with the fact that you all or we
  245. 15:25all excuse me do exercise uh special um
  246. 15:28criminal jurisdiction under the VAWA
  247. 15:30provisions from 2022 and 2013. So um to
  248. 15:34me yes I I think it's it's reasonable
  249. 15:36that it'll be a cost-saving effort. Um,
  250. 15:38it might also [clears throat] help in
  251. 15:40terms of some liability aspect, but
  252. 15:42obviously in-house council would have to
  253. 15:44advise you all on that.
  254. 15:46>> Okay. I appreciate you pointing that
  255. 15:47out.
  256. 15:48>> Yeah. And if it's not appropriate for me
  257. 15:50to speak in these uh meetings too,
  258. 15:52please let me know and I will I will zip
  259. 15:54the lip. So,
  260. 15:55>> no, no, no. I think it's perfectly
  261. 15:56appropriate you speaking. So, I mean,
  262. 15:59you're our chief judge. You're the only
  263. 16:00one that has a voice for the court right
  264. 16:02now. So, as of now, it's a department
  265. 16:03within the tribe, but we're striving to
  266. 16:05separate it from the court. and you're
  267. 16:07really the only person that we have
  268. 16:08available to be the voice for the court
  269. 16:10at this point. So, we appreciate you
  270. 16:11being here and we appreciate you
  271. 16:12speaking to Tyler.
  272. 16:13>> No, not a problem at all. The other
  273. 16:15thing I wanted to say that um might be
  274. 16:17important to note on the back on the
  275. 16:19judicial uh side is that currently we
  276. 16:22have a position that is open right until
  277. 16:25filled uh for a baiff or a field um like
  278. 16:28a field surveillance officer. Right now
  279. 16:30what we do is um based on sort of the
  280. 16:33goodwill of department we utilize the
  281. 16:35current law enforcement um to tribe law
  282. 16:37enforcement and eventually I think those
  283. 16:39probably do need to be separate just for
  284. 16:41um public integrity sake. So that would
  285. 16:43be an additional piece but it is in our
  286. 16:45current budget. So just being aware of
  287. 16:47that too.
  288. 16:47>> I appreciate that. Judge Tyler.
  289. 16:51>> I just wanted to clarify the legislative
  290. 16:55branch and executive branch. you have a
  291. 16:57cost increase of $650,000
  292. 17:01based on us h having to hire um our own
  293. 17:04in-house counsel as well as external
  294. 17:06counsel, but legal is currently under
  295. 17:08the board of directors. So, is this a
  296. 17:11$650,000
  297. 17:12increase on top of what we're already
  298. 17:14paying for our legal department?
  299. 17:19Because ultimately if if legal is going
  300. 17:22to the executive, we would see a
  301. 17:24decrease in spending in the legislative
  302. 17:26branch and a much higher increase in the
  303. 17:28executive branch. Sure, it all adds up,
  304. 17:31but it's not an increase in the
  305. 17:33legislative branch.
  306. 17:36>> So the constitution empowers the
  307. 17:38legislative branch to hire their own
  308. 17:41legal counsel. So this is anticipating
  309. 17:43that you want your own attorney and that
  310. 17:45you may want your own
  311. 17:46>> cost though. So if we're already paying
  312. 17:48legal's expenses out of the legislative,
  313. 17:51which is what the board of directors is,
  314. 17:53the board is everything, right? So it
  315. 17:56wouldn't it wouldn't necessarily be an
  316. 17:58increase in legislative expenditures.
  317. 18:01>> I think he's pointing out that it's
  318. 18:02going to be an overall increase for the
  319. 18:04entire tribe. That's what he's
  320. 18:05highlighting. Not increase. Okay, this
  321. 18:07branch is paying more, that branch is
  322. 18:09paying more. He's talking about the
  323. 18:11overall increase, the amount of money
  324. 18:12that will cost the tribe to transition
  325. 18:14this form of government. If you guys are
  326. 18:16going to be hiring an additional
  327. 18:17attorney, of course, that's going to
  328. 18:18cost the tribe more money than if just
  329. 18:20the legal department were to transition
  330. 18:21to the executive branch. Those costs
  331. 18:23will remain the same. But if you're
  332. 18:24hiring an additional attorney, that's
  333. 18:26increased costs.
  334. 18:27>> But the way I'm reading this is it says
  335. 18:29total one-year legislative branch cost
  336. 18:31increase is $650,000.
  337. 18:34Is that on top of what we're already
  338. 18:36paying for our in-house council? all of
  339. 18:38all of these costs are on top of our
  340. 18:40current budget.
  341. 18:41>> But I think that needs to be separated
  342. 18:43out to show what it looks like in each
  343. 18:44branch as well
  344. 18:46>> because that would be an executive cost,
  345. 18:47not a legislative cost. And
  346. 18:49>> it's a legislative cost if you're hiring
  347. 18:51your own attorney.
  348. 18:53>> But but you're no longer going to be our
  349. 18:55cost.
  350. 18:59>> Okay.
  351. 19:00What he's trying to do is he's trying to
  352. 19:01assign all the bills to the executive,
  353. 19:03but what we're trying to do truthfully
  354. 19:05is try to highlight how much more this
  355. 19:07government will cost than the one we
  356. 19:09currently have. It isn't about, okay,
  357. 19:10this one's going to cost that, that's
  358. 19:12going to cost that. Obviously, we're
  359. 19:13having that talk, but overall is to talk
  360. 19:16about how much more expensive this is,
  361. 19:17>> right? But that's not what the
  362. 19:19discussion is. The discussion is to be
  363. 19:22transparent with where all of the costs
  364. 19:23are going. I'm fine with showing how
  365. 19:26much more it is for the tribe, but I
  366. 19:29think each branch should be built out
  367. 19:31and Holly had her hand raised, so I
  368. 19:32think she has a better answer for us.
  369. 19:34But like when I'm reading this, I'm
  370. 19:36thinking of the 1.2 we've already
  371. 19:37allocated to legal and another 650 on
  372. 19:40top of it for the legislative branch.
  373. 19:42>> Yeah, you're bringing on more you're
  374. 19:44bringing on more attorneys. So you're
  375. 19:46going to bring on additional cost unless
  376. 19:48you're going to take your current legal
  377. 19:49department and parse it out where some
  378. 19:52of you stay with executive and some of
  379. 19:53you stay with legislative. That's an
  380. 19:56option,
  381. 19:56>> right?
  382. 19:57>> But if you're this this is assuming you
  383. 19:59keep all the current legal staff stays
  384. 20:02with executive branch in this example,
  385. 20:04but the legislative branch is like,
  386. 20:06well, we need some attorney
  387. 20:07representation, too. So then you have to
  388. 20:09hire more attorneys. The only branch to
  389. 20:11stick it under for the increase is
  390. 20:13legislative because they're separate
  391. 20:15legal teams and separate branches. It
  392. 20:17wouldn't be an increase to the current
  393. 20:19legal department if they're all under
  394. 20:21the executive branch. It would have to
  395. 20:22be an increase to a new department that
  396. 20:25you're creating under the legislative
  397. 20:26branch for the legislative attorney and
  398. 20:28their team. Right.
  399. 20:31>> I don't think you understand what I'm
  400. 20:32saying.
  401. 20:33>> I don't I do not understand what you're
  402. 20:34saying. That is correct.
  403. 20:35>> But Holly had her hand raised, so I
  404. 20:36think she does.
  405. 20:37>> Yeah. You done, Tyler?
  406. 20:39I'd like to hear from Holly.
  407. 20:40>> So, Holly and then I guess we're
  408. 20:42circling back to Tyler and then Rob,
  409. 20:44then Aaron.
  410. 20:55>> So, and I think right now with regards
  411. 20:58to the legislative, the two budgets that
  412. 21:00come into play are the chairman's travel
  413. 21:03and then the 1165, which is the board of
  414. 21:05directors. There are currently no legal
  415. 21:08fees in either of those budgets. All of
  416. 21:10the fees are accounted for in the tribal
  417. 21:12attorney. So, this is truthfully an
  418. 21:15additional if the board chooses to
  419. 21:19structure it the way Ryan has mentioned.
  420. 21:22>> But is it additional to what we're
  421. 21:24already paying? That's what we're trying
  422. 21:25to establish here. If you already have
  423. 21:27approved budget for the legal department
  424. 21:29and then if they change who they
  425. 21:30directly report to,
  426. 21:32>> of course, that money is going to be
  427. 21:33housed in a different location. But the
  428. 21:35amount of money that the tribe is still
  429. 21:36paying for the legal department remains
  430. 21:38exactly the same. The only thing that
  431. 21:40increases is this body become the
  432. 21:42legislative branch and them hiring an
  433. 21:43attorney so they don't get sued.
  434. 21:46>> My impression of this is that it would
  435. 21:48be an additional cost because it would
  436. 21:50be adding additional staff members and
  437. 21:53the only things that are in here. So,
  438. 21:54for example, space cost isn't included
  439. 21:57in here because space cost that we
  440. 21:59currently have with the exception of
  441. 22:00maybe adding a new courtroom is already
  442. 22:03encompassed in our either 1160 tribal
  443. 22:06ops or by each building.
  444. 22:09So, this truthfully would be adding
  445. 22:12another position, adding another
  446. 22:13employee. Ryan, your current staff in
  447. 22:15legal would stay
  448. 22:18>> intact.
  449. 22:18>> But that's my question. If we're talking
  450. 22:20about reducing expenses and and Ryan
  451. 22:22kind of hinted at the next part of my
  452. 22:24question is would the entire council
  453. 22:27legal department have to go? Would there
  454. 22:29be a way for us to start out kind of
  455. 22:32slim and build from there? So the entire
  456. 22:34$600,000 $650,000
  457. 22:37expense isn't an expense on day one or
  458. 22:42until it's necessary. like we're if
  459. 22:45we're trying to work through this like
  460. 22:46I'm just trying to to to come up with
  461. 22:48solutions here and get to the bottom of
  462. 22:49all these things.
  463. 22:51>> Yeah. So, in the transition resolution,
  464. 22:53which hopefully we'll have time to go
  465. 22:54through today, I am
  466. 22:57I called it a unified legal department
  467. 22:59for lack of a better term. I am adi
  468. 23:01advising that we keep our legal
  469. 23:04attorney structure in place now. and
  470. 23:06they're going to have to we'll have to
  471. 23:07figure it out in practice how to do
  472. 23:09this, but let let the current team
  473. 23:12advise both branches. Assign one of them
  474. 23:14potentially to the legislative branch.
  475. 23:17You do not you do not have to just go
  476. 23:19out and hire your own attorney. Part of
  477. 23:22our anticipation is there's been uh
  478. 23:24multiple resolutions about doing that,
  479. 23:27hiring an attorney or a legal
  480. 23:29consultant. So, it feels like the board
  481. 23:31was primed to want to get that position
  482. 23:33filled sooner than later, which is why
  483. 23:36somewhere in year one, we anticipated
  484. 23:37tribal council wants their own attorney.
  485. 23:39It might be an attorney that's not on
  486. 23:41your radar, that's not on your current
  487. 23:43team, but certainly we can see how we
  488. 23:46can take our current team of attorneys
  489. 23:49and um just use them as the workforce
  490. 23:53without having to get another law firm
  491. 23:55or get another attorney. I previously
  492. 23:58advised that and but it did not feel
  493. 24:00like the majority wanted to go that
  494. 24:02route.
  495. 24:02>> Right.
  496. 24:02>> Thank you, Ryan. And that's the point I
  497. 24:04was ultimately trying to get at is this
  498. 24:06may not necessarily be an expense on
  499. 24:09year one. That's all I was trying to get
  500. 24:11out there.
  501. 24:11>> Y I agree with that,
  502. 24:13>> Rob. Then Aaron,
  503. 24:16>> okay. I was just going to clarify
  504. 24:18basically what uh the vice chair just
  505. 24:20said. I understood what he was trying to
  506. 24:22say here. And um I was one of the ones
  507. 24:24that was pushing for to hire outside
  508. 24:26counsel. Uh hearing what I just heard,
  509. 24:28I'm going to retract that. I would
  510. 24:30rather have it be someone from our
  511. 24:32current team, move them over, uh put
  512. 24:34them under the direction of the board.
  513. 24:35We save money. If cost is going to be
  514. 24:37the issue that people bring up to try
  515. 24:39not to afford our members our rights, um
  516. 24:42then let's let's start cutting cost. We
  517. 24:44got a lot of failing businesses. We got
  518. 24:46a lot of a lot of stuff the board likes
  519. 24:48to spend money on. If all those things
  520. 24:50are more important than to the members,
  521. 24:52I'm going to start putting resolutions
  522. 24:53on the table and you're going to have to
  523. 24:55show the members what you really care
  524. 24:56about. You know, you want you want to
  525. 24:58keep failing businesses. Well, you're
  526. 25:01going to have to tell your members that
  527. 25:02they're more important than uh than
  528. 25:04their rights,
  529. 25:06>> Aaron.
  530. 25:07>> So, all right. So, one thing I think
  531. 25:10that's missing in this process is um so
  532. 25:15we've had numbers now presented to us
  533. 25:18that have varied by the first estimate
  534. 25:21to the second estimate was 50% off to
  535. 25:24the third estimate which is about 25%
  536. 25:26off the last estimate. So that tells me
  537. 25:29that we haven't done a good enough job
  538. 25:32with focusing in on the actual expenses
  539. 25:36and also um the deducts for what we
  540. 25:40currently um already expense. So I kind
  541. 25:43of imagine that was already happening um
  542. 25:45because we have a whole fleet of
  543. 25:47professional staff to work on this. So
  544. 25:50what we're missing is a budget tracker,
  545. 25:52a budget tracker that has the
  546. 25:54assumptions built into it on separate
  547. 25:56worksheets. So, I'm It's too bad budgets
  548. 25:59is not here right now, but um but I know
  549. 26:02Holly and and um Jessica know and Bill
  550. 26:06know this inside and out because your
  551. 26:08your budgets that conform to the
  552. 26:11financial review process is made up of
  553. 26:13your primary worksheet that pulls all
  554. 26:15the assumptions from the separate
  555. 26:17worksheets or they're they're called
  556. 26:19spreadsheets, worksheets um for each of
  557. 26:22the cost centers and then the very
  558. 26:24varied the variables that will affect
  559. 26:27back that cost and then the deduct of
  560. 26:29the existing costs that we're already
  561. 26:31expending. So, um, unless somebody can
  562. 26:34pull that out of their hat right now and
  563. 26:36tell me that it's already existing, I
  564. 26:37don't think so because these numbers
  565. 26:39have varied pretty wildly in the last
  566. 26:42three projections that we've gotten. And
  567. 26:43that's not that's not to say that we're
  568. 26:46that people aren't professional or
  569. 26:48whatever, but for us to to gauge what
  570. 26:51actual expenses need to happen because
  571. 26:54what you're presenting is is a
  572. 26:56theoretical sort of if we did this, this
  573. 26:58is what the number would be, but we're
  574. 27:00also not then deducting what the
  575. 27:02existing costs are. Um, at least not
  576. 27:04that I can see in a workable um budget
  577. 27:07tracker. So, we need a budget tracker.
  578. 27:09So, one of the also we're working on a
  579. 27:12bunch of assumptions. So, one assumption
  580. 27:14is and I I don't want to irritate the
  581. 27:17board with this because I'm not
  582. 27:18proposing this, but um and I did see a
  583. 27:22post a lot of people sent me a post that
  584. 27:23a board member sent um accusing me of
  585. 27:27different things of of creating the
  586. 27:29current salary for the board, which is
  587. 27:31just not factual. Um, at some point at
  588. 27:34some point we probably need to think
  589. 27:36about clarifying when an individual's
  590. 27:38posting something as fact as if it's the
  591. 27:40tribe's position that it's not that
  592. 27:43that's an individual board member's
  593. 27:44opinion and it's not representative of
  594. 27:46the tribe because well once once we have
  595. 27:50a line of liability if that ever comes
  596. 27:52to fruition then then there will be um
  597. 27:55possible liability for putting out
  598. 27:57information that's just not true because
  599. 27:59it isn't true that I proposed the
  600. 28:01current board salary. It's absolutely
  601. 28:03not true. It's not factual. And if I had
  602. 28:05the ability to bring a cause of action,
  603. 28:07I would be able to shut people up for
  604. 28:09>> we got to stick the orders of the day,
  605. 28:10though.
  606. 28:11>> Okay. So, but so with that premise
  607. 28:14though, um there's a presumption that
  608. 28:16the current board salary has to be the
  609. 28:18current board salary before and after a
  610. 28:20separation. And that's not factual. Um
  611. 28:23that's just an assumption because the
  612. 28:26current board salary is based on loosely
  613. 28:29based on meeting every week um based on
  614. 28:33additional meetings and once the
  615. 28:36legislature is established separately
  616. 28:38the legislature will have the ability
  617. 28:40then to decide if they're going to meet
  618. 28:41weekly. If they choose to meet once
  619. 28:44every two weeks or if they choose to we
  620. 28:46meet you know differently like a
  621. 28:48legislature then those numbers will
  622. 28:50change significantly but the current
  623. 28:52salary is based on actually it was two
  624. 28:54meetings a week u when it was calculated
  625. 28:57in 2000 it was a Monday no a Tuesday and
  626. 29:01a Wednesday there was workshops on
  627. 29:02Wednesdays there was meetings on
  628. 29:04Tuesdays every other Tuesday was a
  629. 29:06workshop and we don't meet that much we
  630. 29:09are right now um we are doing the
  631. 29:11constitution amendment on a Monday on on
  632. 29:13a Tuesday. The other thing is in the new
  633. 29:15constitution that the the citizens will
  634. 29:17have a right of initiative. So while we
  635. 29:19could start out with a board salary
  636. 29:21that's the same as it is now, the
  637. 29:23citizens will be able to bring a cause
  638. 29:25of action to then vote on the board
  639. 29:27salary and that could very well change.
  640. 29:30So So that's a big assumption is that
  641. 29:31the board salary stays exactly as it is
  642. 29:34today. Another assumption is um is that
  643. 29:40uh and I think it's probably true we're
  644. 29:42going to see see an increased case load.
  645. 29:45Um but you just shared that the appellet
  646. 29:48court or not the appellet court I think
  647. 29:49we call it the Supreme Court. The
  648. 29:51Supreme Court um is based on the chief
  649. 29:54judge's salary um for three people. So
  650. 29:57it's it's you know times three. So that
  651. 29:59presumes that we're going to have so
  652. 30:01much so many cases that we're going to
  653. 30:03have the uh the appellet level or the
  654. 30:06Supreme Court level um working as much
  655. 30:08as the chief judge. And that's that is a
  656. 30:11good assumption to have as a high-end
  657. 30:13estimate of what it could be. It could
  658. 30:16and maybe it won't be that way. Maybe
  659. 30:17maybe the citizens won't be bringing
  660. 30:19lawsuits. Um, you know, if we have a
  661. 30:23struggle with the transition between the
  662. 30:25legislature and the executive, you
  663. 30:27you'll probably see the legislature
  664. 30:29filing lawsuits, but that'll be at their
  665. 30:30discretion. It won't be because the
  666. 30:32structure calls for it. It'll be because
  667. 30:34they're filing lawsuits. There could end
  668. 30:36up being frivolous lawsuits, too. And at
  669. 30:38some point, we could probably build in
  670. 30:40penalties for filing frivolous lawsuits.
  671. 30:43And then then we can recoup costs if you
  672. 30:46know if the legislature files a lawsuit
  673. 30:48that is ends up ultimately being
  674. 30:50frivolous and um and it's just a power
  675. 30:53struggle and there's the ability to
  676. 30:55recoup costs and the court could
  677. 30:56actually recoup a lot of those costs. So
  678. 30:58that's a potential deduct. So, so I
  679. 31:02think for a budget tracker um the the
  680. 31:05presumption should have flexibility to
  681. 31:07say okay well if the current board
  682. 31:09salary stays as it is this is what the
  683. 31:11the projected cost is. If the board
  684. 31:14salary if the people bring an initiative
  685. 31:16to cut the board salary in half this is
  686. 31:18what the salary would be for the board.
  687. 31:20Same with the cases. If the case load is
  688. 31:22this this is what it would be. If the
  689. 31:24case load is this this is what it'll be.
  690. 31:26So um but we're projecting the very top
  691. 31:29end of what the project uh potential
  692. 31:31expenses would be. Um so what I would
  693. 31:34suggest then is I think we need it might
  694. 31:37be an exercise in futility because
  695. 31:38tomorrow this all might come to a
  696. 31:40screeching halt but I do think if we are
  697. 31:43continuing we should um develop a budget
  698. 31:45tracker process so that we can more
  699. 31:48finitely look at the estimates and then
  700. 31:51be able to see where the deducts occur
  701. 31:54for the existing expenses that we're
  702. 31:56already incurring. So, um, if you know
  703. 31:58the budgets well, if you if we all take
  704. 32:01a look at the budgets well, then we can
  705. 32:03see that there's there's deducts that
  706. 32:05can happen of what we're already
  707. 32:06spending. So, and I don't know and I'm
  708. 32:09I'm not satisfied without a budget
  709. 32:10tracker to be able to say that these
  710. 32:14estimates are real without the deduct.
  711. 32:17So,
  712. 32:19>> Judge Leaport.
  713. 32:21>> Yep. So, one thing I was going to say is
  714. 32:23that um again, I'm I'm very new, so
  715. 32:26excuse me if I'm not speaking correctly
  716. 32:28in accounts and budget can uh kick my
  717. 32:30butt later if this is inaccurate, but
  718. 32:32the [snorts] way that we do it now is
  719. 32:33they submit invoices uh based on the
  720. 32:36amount of time that they spend per case.
  721. 32:37Right? So when I was doing my budget,
  722. 32:39our appellet justices submit based on an
  723. 32:41hourly and we sort of make that estimate
  724. 32:43from there based on the assumption that
  725. 32:47in previous years you've had at most
  726. 32:49about five to six appellet cases that
  727. 32:51get filed that just as a function of a
  728. 32:55three branch government will as you
  729. 32:57stated get amped up uh to a pretty
  730. 33:00significant degree. it for from my
  731. 33:02perspective, you know, it's board
  732. 33:05determination about whether or not you
  733. 33:06all want to pay a stipen, you want to
  734. 33:08pay hourly, or you want to pay them on a
  735. 33:10part-time salary. Um, you know, at other
  736. 33:12tribes I know they'll give a monthly
  737. 33:14stipen plus health insurance. Um, and I
  738. 33:16think there's plenty of options to sort
  739. 33:18of think that through, but it depends on
  740. 33:20what maybe people's expectations are
  741. 33:22going forward. The court um is certainly
  742. 33:24absolutely willing to look at all
  743. 33:27alternatives to be as budget friendly as
  744. 33:30possible. Um but just understanding
  745. 33:31right that five to six appellet cases,
  746. 33:34appeals cases is is highly unlikely um
  747. 33:37when you [clears throat] all do split.
  748. 33:38And I I would put in a second nod for
  749. 33:40the provision around frivolous lawsuits
  750. 33:42as well. I think that's just an
  751. 33:43important good protection factor for
  752. 33:44both branches of government to have. Um
  753. 33:47[clears throat] and it it requires
  754. 33:49people to post a a bond if they want to
  755. 33:52file a certain type of lawsuit, right?
  756. 33:53Or if they are being frivolous that they
  757. 33:55have to actually pay the other side's
  758. 33:57attorney's fees. It's just a good
  759. 33:58protection measure regardless. Um, and I
  760. 34:01have examples of that, Ryan, if it'd be
  761. 34:02helpful to send it to you
  762. 34:04>> if I could share this as well. So, Cole
  763. 34:06Goodro shared a flight with a candidate
  764. 34:08that was running for office for the
  765. 34:09Onidita Nation. And the Onidita Nation
  766. 34:11recently separated their government. And
  767. 34:13one of the recommendations that they had
  768. 34:14for Cole, um, just a decrease on the
  769. 34:17amount of, you know, cases that we had,
  770. 34:19which will save the tribe money if we're
  771. 34:20giving our citizens standing in tribal
  772. 34:22court, uh, was to invest money and time
  773. 34:24into mediation. Um, so that could
  774. 34:26prevent people from going to court. If
  775. 34:28we can figure out a solution, um, you
  776. 34:30know, that will prevent and being in
  777. 34:32front of a judge, that will save us
  778. 34:33money in the long run. I think we should
  779. 34:35consider that as well.
  780. 34:37>> Yeah. I mean, there's certainly certain
  781. 34:38types of cases too, right, where you can
  782. 34:41uh require parties to go um before a
  783. 34:43mediator prior to filing or at initial
  784. 34:45stages of filing, but again, that would
  785. 34:47be up to you all to pass legislation uh
  786. 34:49that mirrored that.
  787. 34:51>> So, I appreciate that. Okay. Anything
  788. 34:53else on financials?
  789. 35:00>> I'm not done to the memo yet.
  790. 35:02>> Okay.
  791. 35:02>> And I just wanted to state that we can
  792. 35:04absolutely get a more accurate number. I
  793. 35:06think the biggest problem with this is
  794. 35:08all of the unknown variables at this
  795. 35:10point in time of what this structure is
  796. 35:11going to look like. Once we have that
  797. 35:13narrowed down, it will be a lot easier
  798. 35:15to come up with really accurate
  799. 35:17projections.
  800. 35:19Aaron,
  801. 35:20>> so what I would request is so we could
  802. 35:22build a tracker that could then be
  803. 35:25modified to incorporate the different
  804. 35:29variables. So like I just used it as an
  805. 35:32example. So I'll move off of the board
  806. 35:34salary because I know that one got a
  807. 35:35little gah just a few minutes ago.
  808. 35:37Instead I will focus on the case load.
  809. 35:40So you could you could say based on the
  810. 35:44the price per hour or however you do it
  811. 35:46that's how much the increased case
  812. 35:48load's going to cost but then you can
  813. 35:50vary that saying okay if that you could
  814. 35:52have a separate worksheet so I'm going
  815. 35:53to talk in your terms a separate
  816. 35:54worksheet that says if the case load
  817. 35:56increases by 20% 30% 40% this is what it
  818. 36:00would look like then you get a range of
  819. 36:02values um so you have a better sort of
  820. 36:04focus because what we're doing and I I
  821. 36:06think in the absence of doing that level
  822. 36:08of detail giving a high-end estimate is
  823. 36:11probably the most rational thing to do,
  824. 36:13but that doesn't mean that's what it's
  825. 36:15going to be. That that's the top end of
  826. 36:17what it could be. So,
  827. 36:19>> okay, Quit Su,
  828. 36:23>> just a couple things. Um, one, I want to
  829. 36:25address the board pay because, um, we
  830. 36:28seem to throw out these points to make
  831. 36:31political points online with people.
  832. 36:34Having just been elected, I will tell
  833. 36:36you the board pay with the amount of
  834. 36:38work that we put in is reasonable. This
  835. 36:40was not a financial decision for me to
  836. 36:42take this job. With the help of this
  837. 36:45board, our frontline workers were able
  838. 36:48to come to the board and get a raise for
  839. 36:50where I was working before. Something
  840. 36:52that we tried the administrative way and
  841. 36:55the HR way. It didn't happen. But once
  842. 36:58there were increased step pay further up
  843. 37:01and we came to the board, it was
  844. 37:04rectified.
  845. 37:06The last year that I worked for the
  846. 37:08tribe in the my previous position, I was
  847. 37:11better off financially after with a
  848. 37:13master's degree in 23 years of working
  849. 37:15in that position than I am making now.
  850. 37:20I got benefits. I got paid into social
  851. 37:22security. I had 1,300 hours of vis of
  852. 37:26sick time banked over 250 hours of
  853. 37:29vacation. You paid me out for 160. I
  854. 37:32lost the rest. I lost 1300 hours of sick
  855. 37:35time because there's no bank that we put
  856. 37:37it in for people who need it. These are
  857. 37:39things we I would really like to be
  858. 37:41discussing how we can improve programs
  859. 37:43and services for our people and our team
  860. 37:45members. So, this was not a financial
  861. 37:48gain for me. I now do not have social
  862. 37:50security. I do not have a 401k, right?
  863. 37:54And I have earned every penny I have
  864. 37:56made since I've come to this table. And
  865. 37:58this last weekend was just an example.
  866. 38:02I will say for the record for everybody
  867. 38:04at this table, I did not know that this
  868. 38:07resolution was coming through on
  869. 38:08Thursday and then my phone started to
  870. 38:11blow up and I am looking at a big event
  871. 38:14that we all invested in paddle out and
  872. 38:17our pow-wow and I had to put my board of
  873. 38:20directors phone in its dock and take
  874. 38:23that half hat off and do the work I do
  875. 38:25in this my community every day. For
  876. 38:28those of you who came to the paddle, I
  877. 38:30thank you and you heard me then. If your
  878. 38:32agenda was other than praying for the
  879. 38:34water and standing up for the water, you
  880. 38:35need to put it over there because that
  881. 38:37wasn't the place for it.
  882. 38:41I did have people at our pow-wow
  883. 38:43afterwards talking to me. People from
  884. 38:45unit 3. I will tell you one thing they
  885. 38:48did say, they appreciated seeing the
  886. 38:49board. I think nine of us showed up, but
  887. 38:53nobody came to the powow. So, I'm I'm
  888. 38:56just sharing the information that was
  889. 38:58expressed to me. I didn't talk about
  890. 39:01politics at the POWO, but if one of my
  891. 39:04members or one of my elders asked me a
  892. 39:06questions, I did. And I will say this,
  893. 39:09no amount of bullying, threats,
  894. 39:13uh, slander online is going to change my
  895. 39:17vote. I am here for the people. I'm not
  896. 39:19in anybody's camp. I want to hear the
  897. 39:22truth. I'm concerned. For 23 years, I've
  898. 39:25done nothing but build a nest of
  899. 39:28preserving and um protecting our our
  900. 39:32children, our families, our citizens,
  901. 39:35our tribe, and I will do that every day
  902. 39:38I sit at this board table.
  903. 39:41I am nervous about what I see.
  904. 39:45And yes, I'm allowed to change my mind.
  905. 39:50I ran on protecting our traditions, our
  906. 39:52families, and our way of life and our
  907. 39:55lands. That's what I'm here for. When I
  908. 39:58sat as a candidate answering questions,
  909. 40:00yes, I want a three branch government. I
  910. 40:02want a government that works for our
  911. 40:04people, that's balanced, that have a
  912. 40:05count,
  913. 40:07checks and balances. That checks and
  914. 40:09balances is our dialogue.
  915. 40:13It always is. But how do you do that
  916. 40:15when it's not safe to ask questions? How
  917. 40:17do you do that when
  918. 40:19people
  919. 40:20if you have a different opinion, they
  920. 40:22just attack you? I didn't think it was
  921. 40:24right or cool that I had to go to my
  922. 40:2678-year-old mother and tell her,
  923. 40:30"Don't don't engage in social media, my
  924. 40:33siblings, my children, because they were
  925. 40:35upset. I'm being personally attacked
  926. 40:38online because people think they know
  927. 40:40how I'm going to vote, right? And in the
  928. 40:43meantime, in my community, I'm presented
  929. 40:45with an eagle feather for creating and
  930. 40:48all the work that I've been doing for
  931. 40:50our people every day for 23 years.
  932. 40:54So, I apologize for those who thought
  933. 40:55that they should be able to talk to me
  934. 40:57about these issues. This is where we
  935. 40:59talk and I want the membership to see as
  936. 41:02much of this conversation as we could
  937. 41:04because I am concerned. I'm here to
  938. 41:05protect and preserve our way of life.
  939. 41:07I'm not here to make friends, but I am
  940. 41:10here to build relationships
  941. 41:12because that's what I've done every day
  942. 41:14with all of you. Every single one of you
  943. 41:16have shown me why you sit at this table.
  944. 41:18I've appreciated things that you've
  945. 41:20brought forward and I hope that you have
  946. 41:22done that, too. There's times that I
  947. 41:23thought, hm, I need to have a further
  948. 41:25conversation with them about that
  949. 41:26because I don't see that perspective.
  950. 41:28That's the mediator in me. 20 years of
  951. 41:31mediation. I sit and I listen to people
  952. 41:33and then try to pull them together.
  953. 41:35That's where progress is made.
  954. 41:37Not in demeaning each other. I'm sorry.
  955. 41:39I'll get off my soap box. I do have one
  956. 41:41question for Holly if I might.
  957. 41:45I watched a workshop on 11:2525
  958. 41:50in which one of the board members here
  959. 41:52asked you what your recommendation was
  960. 41:56and that you had said that if you
  961. 41:59thought we could afford if we could
  962. 42:01afford this have and I I heard your
  963. 42:04answer loud and clear. Have we
  964. 42:06identified increased revenues? Have we
  965. 42:08identified ways we can cut costs?
  966. 42:13And I know that you said some of the
  967. 42:15cost in this 3.8 million. At least that
  968. 42:17matched that that same workshop um
  969. 42:20didn't didn't cover building
  970. 42:22renovations, didn't cover uh cola, any
  971. 42:25kind of judgments that might have to
  972. 42:27come up. Have those things been
  973. 42:29identified? I would like to know that.
  974. 42:31Um and and of all the people, you know,
  975. 42:34respect is the standard. I will show you
  976. 42:37respect. I won't slander you online. I I
  977. 42:40I I expect that from the children I've
  978. 42:43worked for with for 23. That's the
  979. 42:45standard, right? Trust is another thing.
  980. 42:48Trust is built upon. And one of the
  981. 42:50people that I that has gained my trust
  982. 42:52at this table is Holly. And I would like
  983. 42:55to know if your answer is the same as
  984. 42:58that time or if we've made any progress
  985. 43:00in almost a year on that very question,
  986. 43:02which is core to this, right? I want a
  987. 43:05government that works for our people.
  988. 43:07But I also want to do it right. So I I
  989. 43:11ask you that if you I don't mean to put
  990. 43:12you on the spot. I'm sorry if I am. I
  991. 43:14just want to know you're honest.
  992. 43:16>> That's okay. And I will tell this board,
  993. 43:18and I think my co-workers know this, I
  994. 43:20will be honest about things because in
  995. 43:22order for this board to make a decision,
  996. 43:23you need to have
  997. 43:25>> the accurate, correct information in
  998. 43:27front of you. And so when I was asked
  999. 43:31about that back in October, um we were
  1000. 43:34doing a few things. We were looking to
  1001. 43:37replace some of our tribal support with
  1002. 43:39third party revenue, which we did. um
  1003. 43:42director um Lelant brought forth a
  1004. 43:46resolution recently or discussed it
  1005. 43:49about increasing um some of our tax that
  1006. 43:52we would assess on our third party
  1007. 43:54revenues. So that is one thing that we
  1008. 43:56do need to look at. We have not
  1009. 43:58finalized that. We also need to look at
  1010. 44:00taxing housing and potentially there's a
  1011. 44:03couple of areas that we could look to
  1012. 44:05tax with housing. They currently have
  1013. 44:08contracts in place. I did ask for all of
  1014. 44:10those documents. I have not had a chance
  1015. 44:12to review them. I think that was at the
  1016. 44:13end of last week where I was able to get
  1017. 44:15all the contracts. Um, so that is in
  1018. 44:18process. I think there's a couple of
  1019. 44:21different things. One of which, and I
  1020. 44:22had mentioned this to the board
  1021. 44:24previously, is that the government is
  1022. 44:26not in the business of generating
  1023. 44:28revenue that has to come from our
  1024. 44:30outside businesses. We can tax and that
  1025. 44:34generates revenue to fund our membership
  1026. 44:36services and our internal services. Um,
  1027. 44:40with that being said, at the time, and I
  1028. 44:42would like to explain this a little bit
  1029. 44:44more too, is because there was some
  1030. 44:45fluctuation in those projections. The
  1031. 44:48initial one was more of a what do we
  1032. 44:51foresee we're going to need? Maybe we
  1033. 44:53won't need it day one, and it was closer
  1034. 44:55to the 3.8, roughly 3.9 million, I
  1035. 44:58believe, if I'm remembering correctly.
  1036. 45:00And then Ryan and I met and we backed
  1037. 45:02that down to, okay, what is are the bare
  1038. 45:05bones that we can get away with? and
  1039. 45:07that was substantially lower. Now today
  1040. 45:09we've come back and added some positions
  1041. 45:12and I understand where the board is
  1042. 45:14coming from in if we can backfill or use
  1043. 45:17existing resources. We tried to back
  1044. 45:19some of those out at this point. I did
  1045. 45:21not do case scenarios on different wages
  1046. 45:24for the board or different things like
  1047. 45:26that at this point in time because like
  1048. 45:27I had just mentioned there's a lot of
  1049. 45:29variables that we don't know how that's
  1050. 45:31going to play out yet. And so as we
  1051. 45:34learn how that's going to play out, um,
  1052. 45:37we can fine-tune those numbers.
  1053. 45:40I will tell you though, and I mentioned
  1054. 45:43this the other day in our discussions we
  1055. 45:47had here, is that we don't have all of
  1056. 45:51the investment funds that we have right
  1057. 45:53now are not unlimited. We have
  1058. 45:56restrictions on those funds. Those
  1059. 45:58restrictions come from our grtors.
  1060. 46:01So, we had I had mentioned we had
  1061. 46:03probably around 33 million and again I'm
  1062. 46:05going off the top of my head so please
  1063. 46:07don't hold me exactly to these numbers.
  1064. 46:09I don't have the paperwork in front of
  1065. 46:10me um of available funds.
  1066. 46:14We approved a deficit for 2026
  1067. 46:19of 14 million. I don't believe that
  1068. 46:21that's going to come to fruition. We are
  1069. 46:23working to backfill again. I do have
  1070. 46:25concerns financially about this
  1071. 46:28situation. And I've said it before and
  1072. 46:29I'm being 100% honest. We can work
  1073. 46:32through some of it. I don't think we
  1074. 46:34need to add in if Ryan's telling me that
  1075. 46:36he can utilize some of his existing
  1076. 46:38staff, that could potentially be a
  1077. 46:40savings. It's not going to be the
  1078. 46:42$650,000
  1079. 46:43that we just talked about. Um,
  1080. 46:47unfortunately it's not just an easy cut
  1081. 46:49and dry because we do have a lot of
  1082. 46:52programs and we do need to assess each
  1083. 46:54and every one and look at it
  1084. 46:56individually as to what we can do to
  1085. 46:59infuse it maybe with some of the BIA the
  1086. 47:03ARPA funds and things like that. But
  1087. 47:04this board does need to be aware that
  1088. 47:07those funds are done at the end of 2026
  1089. 47:10for the for all practical purposes. the
  1090. 47:13majority of those funds are done and we
  1091. 47:15don't have that to rely on and and so I
  1092. 47:19do have some concerns about
  1093. 47:21paying for this. And I think if we are
  1094. 47:24going to work through this and do this,
  1095. 47:25we need to be very aware of the
  1096. 47:28decisions that are made and where our
  1097. 47:30funding is.
  1098. 47:32>> If I could also add this, if we're
  1099. 47:33talking about additional revenue to help
  1100. 47:35pay for this government transition, I
  1101. 47:36think we always leave off STI as well.
  1102. 47:38So STI, they're not taxed at our
  1103. 47:40corporate rate. So, I think that they
  1104. 47:42need to be included in that conversation
  1105. 47:43along with the housing authority and the
  1106. 47:45health division.
  1107. 47:46>> Yes, and I agree 100%. We have
  1108. 47:48historically left STI off of this and
  1109. 47:50I'm not sure how that ever came to be,
  1110. 47:53but they did a presentation where they
  1111. 47:55would start paying us dividends, but
  1112. 47:57when you really get down to looking at
  1113. 48:00them and they are performing fairly
  1114. 48:02well. So
  1115. 48:04when you look at them um they have
  1116. 48:08historically not paid us anything and in
  1117. 48:10the audit their auditors even note that
  1118. 48:13those funds are to come back to this
  1119. 48:14organization and that has not been the
  1120. 48:16case.
  1121. 48:18>> Okay. Whenever you're done Sue
  1122. 48:20>> do you have other questions or did I
  1123. 48:22answer everything? I'm not sure that I
  1124. 48:23>> you pretty much answered it. I you know
  1125. 48:25I do have the I share your concerns
  1126. 48:28because also the other thing that makes
  1127. 48:30me really nervous is I would really like
  1128. 48:33to be able to glimpse you know November
  1129. 48:36ahead because I'm a I fear for what may
  1130. 48:40happen if we don't kind of get some
  1131. 48:42checks and balances on the federal
  1132. 48:44level. Um what we could be facing if we
  1133. 48:48don't kind of balance that power up on
  1134. 48:50the federal level. We've seen we we un I
  1135. 48:54E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A
  1136. 48:54E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A E A
  1137. 48:54and I had this conversation back when I
  1138. 48:56was just a working for YA um
  1139. 49:00that this administration has not been
  1140. 49:02favorable to to
  1141. 49:04Indian country and if we don't have some
  1142. 49:07checks and balances there we could I
  1143. 49:09think that that will be ramped up and
  1144. 49:11we'll actually see if there really is
  1145. 49:13any bounds to that uh
  1146. 49:17level of attack. So I so I I'm always
  1147. 49:21about a nest and preserving and
  1148. 49:23conserving. You know, I was a single
  1149. 49:25mother of children, so that's kind of
  1150. 49:27where I'm at. Um and and then this
  1151. 49:30conversation coupled with what we had
  1152. 49:31with the renovations for the casinos, it
  1153. 49:34it worries me. And and it's no
  1154. 49:37disrespect for anybody in this room.
  1155. 49:39It's just this is how I think we will
  1156. 49:41move for forward if whatever direction
  1157. 49:44we take is by having these hard
  1158. 49:46conversations in respectful ways and
  1159. 49:48honest ways and build trust with each
  1160. 49:49other. So yeah, I appreciate you. I
  1161. 49:51didn't I didn't want to put you on the
  1162. 49:53spot, but
  1163. 49:53>> that's okay. I you
  1164. 49:55>> we do and I do have concerns about cash
  1165. 49:58flowing the governmental side of things
  1166. 50:00because I don't want us to get into a
  1167. 50:02situation where we become a going
  1168. 50:04concern and where our grantors look at
  1169. 50:06us as that same
  1170. 50:08>> and and I know how much our programs and
  1171. 50:11our services are needed and utilized and
  1172. 50:13they're the lifelink of some of our
  1173. 50:16members. They're not just oh I'll use it
  1174. 50:18if I can. this is all they have and and
  1175. 50:21so I definitely you know our elders
  1176. 50:25we're protecting our most vulnerable
  1177. 50:27that's our young people and our elders
  1178. 50:28right
  1179. 50:29>> and our families and that's a big lift
  1180. 50:32and I want to do it in a good way and I
  1181. 50:34want to feel good about what we're doing
  1182. 50:35so thank you for your honesty and I I'll
  1183. 50:38yield
  1184. 50:39>> Rob Kimly then Aaron
  1185. 50:42>> okay I just want to respond to you a few
  1186. 50:45things but I also agree with Sue on on a
  1187. 50:48couple things there. Um, one, I think
  1188. 50:50that everyone at this table works hard
  1189. 50:53enough to earn their pay. Uh, it's not a
  1190. 50:55lot of pay. It's probably not
  1191. 50:57advantageous to any of us really to be a
  1192. 50:59board member with the economy we're in.
  1193. 51:01Um, I'm sure we could all go get other
  1194. 51:03jobs and make more than 67,000 a year.
  1195. 51:06Um, well, most of us. Um, but with that
  1196. 51:09said, um, our number one job as a
  1197. 51:12government is to afford our members
  1198. 51:13their rights. And that is the number one
  1199. 51:16job of a government. You need to make
  1200. 51:17sure your members have rights. You need
  1201. 51:19to make sure they have standing in
  1202. 51:20court. You need to make sure they have a
  1203. 51:22way to challenge their government. And I
  1204. 51:24don't know any job in this world that
  1205. 51:26you can show up and tell your boss,
  1206. 51:28look, I'll do everything about the job
  1207. 51:29except for the number one thing that you
  1208. 51:31told me to, you'll be fired. Any of us,
  1209. 51:34you walk into any job and tell your
  1210. 51:35boss, I'm willing to do everything but
  1211. 51:37not the number one goal.
  1212. 51:39If you can't do that, you lose your job.
  1213. 51:42You lose your pay probably, too. So, I
  1214. 51:44mean, it is what it is. Um, the bullying
  1215. 51:46thing, I'm pretty sure that was geared
  1216. 51:47towards me. It started last night online
  1217. 51:49with Bridget when she mentioned my
  1218. 51:50health and my uh transplant. So, if
  1219. 51:53that's the direction we're going to go
  1220. 51:54is call people bullies for telling the
  1221. 51:56truth. I would challenge anyone to name
  1222. 51:57one time I've lied or one time I've
  1223. 51:59mentioned you by name. I haven't. So, if
  1224. 52:02telling our members the truth is now
  1225. 52:04being the bully, I'm the bully and it's
  1226. 52:05not going to stop. So, there's that. Um,
  1227. 52:09the other thing is that,
  1228. 52:13you know, when you run for election and
  1229. 52:16you get into one of these seats, you
  1230. 52:18have to expect debate. You can't just
  1231. 52:20point at someone and call them a bully
  1232. 52:22for disagreeing with you. Um, you know,
  1233. 52:25when I speak the truth online and then
  1234. 52:28someone comes back and says, "It's a
  1235. 52:29rumor." Was it a rumor that we didn't
  1236. 52:31notify our members to a meeting? Is it
  1237. 52:34within the bylaws and the constitution
  1238. 52:36in chapter 96 that we shall do that?
  1239. 52:39Yes. That's not a rumor. That's the
  1240. 52:41truth. That's what happened. So, you
  1241. 52:44know, I'm not going to be silenced
  1242. 52:45because people want to call me a bully.
  1243. 52:46I go I'll post right now that I'm the
  1244. 52:48bully. I'm not going to quit telling the
  1245. 52:50truth, you guys. And our number one goal
  1246. 52:53here is to afford our members their
  1247. 52:55rights. And I believe that everything is
  1248. 52:58built off trust. And when you tell your
  1249. 52:59members something in a campaign and
  1250. 53:01months later take it back.
  1251. 53:04I mean, how can they trust you? They
  1252. 53:06can't. They literally can't. I've read
  1253. 53:08it on everyone's platforms. We all voted
  1254. 53:13in public and haven't really learned
  1255. 53:16anything new. So, why did nine of us
  1256. 53:18vote yes that are sitting here today on
  1257. 53:21something and then say, "Oh, well, uh,
  1258. 53:24now I'm worried. We haven't gained
  1259. 53:26anything new since you voted yes." So, I
  1260. 53:29mean, if this is the direction we're
  1261. 53:30going to go, I'm I'm ready to have the
  1262. 53:32debate publicly. I mean, it it's
  1263. 53:35definitely disingenuous to tell your
  1264. 53:37people something. Oh, please vote for
  1265. 53:38me. I'll support what you want. Never
  1266. 53:40mind.
  1267. 53:42Took my took my seat. Took my oath. I'm
  1268. 53:44good on that. No, it's not going to
  1269. 53:46happen. Or or it might happen. You guys
  1270. 53:48might outvote it, but I mean, it it's
  1271. 53:51going to be what it's going to be. And I
  1272. 53:53believe that we should be honest to the
  1273. 53:54members. And I'm not going to be back
  1274. 53:57down on that by being called a bully as
  1275. 54:00I tell the truth. Sorry.
  1276. 54:05Kim Lee, Aaron, then Sue.
  1277. 54:13Okay. So, I believe we have learned a
  1278. 54:15few new things as [clears throat] of
  1279. 54:16last Tuesday.
  1280. 54:18Do we now have
  1281. 54:21um
  1282. 54:23a handle on where we're at with third
  1283. 54:25party revenue?
  1284. 54:33>> What would you like to know about third
  1285. 54:34party revenue? I can look it up and give
  1286. 54:36you any information on that. I do know
  1287. 54:39that we are waiting still to collect. I
  1288. 54:42know that there has been some holdup
  1289. 54:44with the new system implementation where
  1290. 54:46we haven't been able to bill for some of
  1291. 54:49the services that we've provided and
  1292. 54:50that's problematic because we're not
  1293. 54:52bringing in that revenue.
  1294. 54:54>> Could you tell how much third party
  1295. 54:56revenue we have?
  1296. 54:57>> Yeah, I can. Did you want to say
  1297. 54:59something about that?
  1298. 55:00>> I was just going to clarify that
  1299. 55:02implementation issue is with the health
  1300. 55:04care system, I believe is what you're
  1301. 55:05referring to as far and then possibly
  1302. 55:07the um the housing authority too. So, go
  1303. 55:09ahead, Kim.
  1304. 55:12So, I'd like to know that because as of
  1305. 55:14last week, we were kind of unsure where
  1306. 55:17we were sitting at.
  1307. 55:21Um,
  1308. 55:23and where do we see
  1309. 55:26without gaining any new revenue
  1310. 55:28structures,
  1311. 55:30how long is this sustainable?
  1312. 55:34Okay. So, I'm going to answer the third
  1313. 55:36party revenue first and then we'll talk
  1314. 55:38about the other.
  1315. 55:40Okay.
  1316. 55:42Through August 31st,
  1317. 55:47we have collected 1.5 million more in
  1318. 55:51third party revenue
  1319. 55:54revenue
  1320. 55:56>> over
  1321. 55:58>> the projection for through 831.
  1322. 56:02And now I will tell you for three
  1323. 56:04months.
  1324. 56:05>> I will tell you we are not closed for
  1325. 56:07August 31st yet. So we would have been
  1326. 56:10substantially higher
  1327. 56:13in our collections if we had been
  1328. 56:15billing from June, July and August.
  1329. 56:21>> What was projected to be collected is
  1330. 56:24$24,465,5629.
  1331. 56:29in what was collected
  1332. 56:31>> $25,96627
  1333. 56:35or I'm sorry $25,966,62747
  1334. 56:41>> $1 million more than expected and that's
  1335. 56:44without several months of billing.
  1336. 56:45>> That is correct. 1.5 more without now
  1337. 56:49I'll get to the expenses.
  1338. 56:53And then the housing authority too if
  1339. 56:54you have that information handy.
  1340. 56:59>> They budgeted to transfer out through
  1341. 57:01August 31st of 2026 $47 million.
  1342. 57:0647343,447.
  1343. 57:12They transferred out $31,135,313.
  1344. 57:20So
  1345. 57:22they are currently $16 million 16.2
  1346. 57:25million less than they projected to
  1347. 57:27spend. However, they are 3.5 million
  1348. 57:30over spent right now and I suspect that
  1349. 57:32that would not be the case if we were
  1350. 57:35collecting the revenue.
  1351. 57:38>> Okay,
  1352. 57:38>> that is we're still in an uncertainty
  1353. 57:41there. Okay,
  1354. 57:45so next question. How long do you
  1355. 57:47believe if we were status quo that this
  1356. 57:50is sustainable?
  1357. 57:52So,
  1358. 57:54I'm going to say that right now with
  1359. 57:59what I presented the other day, we had
  1360. 58:02um and I don't have my papers in front
  1361. 58:03of me, so I apologize for that.
  1362. 58:06We have some funds in our corporate tax
  1363. 58:11roughly 10.6 million that are earmarked.
  1364. 58:14They are settlement funds. They are the
  1365. 58:15Juul funds, the opioid, the IHS contract
  1366. 58:18support, and the Rama settlement funds.
  1367. 58:21Those funds total about 10.6 million
  1368. 58:24that are earmarked. So that's going to
  1369. 58:26offset what we have. And I believe I
  1370. 58:29gave a tax presentation and the
  1371. 58:30materials to this board and I want to
  1372. 58:32say it was about 49 million.
  1373. 58:36And so with those earmarked and then we
  1374. 58:38have a deficit of over 10 million in our
  1375. 58:41general fund. So, we have to net that
  1376. 58:44against what we have in our tribal
  1377. 58:46support coffers for 125 as part of the
  1378. 58:49general fund. Um, and what that's going
  1379. 58:52to do is that with our deficit that we
  1380. 58:55budgeted and approved
  1381. 58:57of 14 million, that's going to leave us
  1382. 59:00about one year to continue on operations
  1383. 59:03at the current level of spend if we
  1384. 59:05continue to spend another 14 million.
  1385. 59:09Now, I will tell you historically we've
  1386. 59:11backed that down and it's been the true
  1387. 59:14realized loss in corporate tax is about
  1388. 59:16six million.
  1389. 59:18>> I was about to say we didn't lose 14
  1390. 59:20million.
  1391. 59:21>> We didn't. And that would give us a year
  1392. 59:23probably
  1393. 59:24of cash flows at that expenditure level.
  1394. 59:28>> Okay. So, I'm looking for a very direct
  1395. 59:30answer.
  1396. 59:31>> Okay.
  1397. 59:31>> On what you believe is sustainable. And
  1398. 59:35maybe this question isn't even fair to
  1399. 59:36you, right? are governmental.
  1400. 59:39This gentleman just arrived not too long
  1401. 59:43ago. Maybe this question is for Mr.
  1402. 59:46Connelly who knows all of our finances
  1403. 59:48inside and out.
  1404. 59:52>> Come on up, Bill, if you mind.
  1405. 59:59>> Well, my point of information is going
  1406. 1:00:01to be is the projection changed when you
  1407. 1:00:03take into that new revenue that the
  1408. 1:00:05government can take. If you taxed
  1409. 1:00:07housing authority, health division, and
  1410. 1:00:09STI,
  1411. 1:00:10>> it will change
  1412. 1:00:10>> while also trimming costs.
  1413. 1:00:12>> Yes, it will change.
  1414. 1:00:14>> Go ahead.
  1415. 1:00:18>> But that wasn't the question I asked.
  1416. 1:00:21>> Well, as a point of information, though,
  1417. 1:00:22too, I don't know how fair it is to even
  1418. 1:00:24be asking about some of these questions
  1419. 1:00:26because we as a board need to balance
  1420. 1:00:29our budget, too. And and so we're we're
  1421. 1:00:32kind of throwing a lot on here because
  1422. 1:00:34we're saying, "Hey, can we afford to do
  1423. 1:00:35this when right now we're already have a
  1424. 1:00:38$14 million deficit and actual about
  1425. 1:00:41six." But in either instance, asking the
  1426. 1:00:45financial person, can we afford it? We
  1427. 1:00:46already know the answer. The answer is
  1428. 1:00:48no. We as a board though had to balance
  1429. 1:00:51our budget and then make room for this
  1430. 1:00:55too. We had to balance our budget no
  1431. 1:00:56matter what we do, whether we go down to
  1432. 1:00:58three branch government or not. We as a
  1433. 1:01:00board need to come together and balance
  1434. 1:01:02our budget because tapping into the
  1435. 1:01:04funds isn't an answer. It isn't a
  1436. 1:01:06solution. We need to make cuts. And
  1437. 1:01:09nobody likes to say that word, but at
  1438. 1:01:11the end of the day, we cannot afford to
  1439. 1:01:13keep going tapping into the funds. We
  1440. 1:01:16need to reduce government services
  1441. 1:01:17somehow. We can increase taxes. We can
  1442. 1:01:20do all that, but at the end of the day,
  1443. 1:01:22it is not going to equal 14 million or
  1444. 1:01:24even the six mill. And on top of that,
  1445. 1:01:27throw the three branch thing. we have to
  1446. 1:01:29make we are gonna have to make some hard
  1447. 1:01:31decisions on how we move forward and
  1448. 1:01:34what we need to to prioritize. So I
  1449. 1:01:37don't think it's a fair question to put
  1450. 1:01:39on our CFOs right now and say hey can we
  1451. 1:01:41afford to do this because
  1452. 1:01:43>> we're not doing it.
  1453. 1:01:44>> I absolutely agree. So that's why I said
  1454. 1:01:47status quo where this board sits right
  1455. 1:01:49now.
  1456. 1:01:50>> Yep.
  1457. 1:01:51>> What is the sustainability?
  1458. 1:01:55So can I guess will you repeat uh Kim
  1459. 1:02:00what you're would like me to answer.
  1460. 1:02:02nothing changes, right? If we continue
  1461. 1:02:06with our funding the way it is right
  1462. 1:02:08now, how long is it sustainable to take
  1463. 1:02:13on
  1464. 1:02:14before we start
  1465. 1:02:16having nothing to to pull from to be
  1466. 1:02:18able to replace those funds, right,
  1467. 1:02:20where those cuts are going to have to be
  1468. 1:02:22made.
  1469. 1:02:25>> Well, I I agree with Holly. um unless we
  1470. 1:02:29can um do something currently,
  1471. 1:02:34it's not sustainable at all because
  1472. 1:02:37we're operating at a deficit each year.
  1473. 1:02:40So, I guess the question to me is
  1474. 1:02:43currently, as Mike mentioned, uh, the
  1475. 1:02:46road we're on, you know, do we have
  1476. 1:02:49three, four years at the $6 million or
  1477. 1:02:53whatever it is that we would
  1478. 1:02:56uh, you know, anticipate losing before
  1479. 1:02:59the constitution goes into the changes
  1480. 1:03:02would go into effect
  1481. 1:03:05maybe. But, you know, some things have
  1482. 1:03:09to happen in order to be able to sustain
  1483. 1:03:13the route we're on right now. I mean,
  1484. 1:03:15frankly,
  1485. 1:03:19so I don't know if that answers your
  1486. 1:03:20question or not, but it
  1487. 1:03:21>> does answer my question. Thank you.
  1488. 1:03:23>> Okay, I have Aaron, Sue, then Tyler. Did
  1489. 1:03:26I miss anybody? Okay, go ahead, Aaron.
  1490. 1:03:29>> Okay, so in 2022,
  1491. 1:03:34No, let me back up. In 2020
  1492. 1:03:38before the pandemic hit, we were
  1493. 1:03:41pledging um all of our net revenue to
  1494. 1:03:45services and it was roughly we called it
  1495. 1:03:47tribal support. It was roughly about 17
  1496. 1:03:49million. Um we always over projected
  1497. 1:03:52what the budget needs were. We always
  1498. 1:03:53underspent. Um the administration used
  1499. 1:03:57to try to give um budget um parameters,
  1500. 1:04:01drivers out to so that programs and
  1501. 1:04:04services would not overp project their
  1502. 1:04:05budgets. But then after I left office, I
  1503. 1:04:08understand the board ordered um uh not
  1504. 1:04:12to limit those projections so that
  1505. 1:04:15departments could just ask for whatever
  1506. 1:04:17they wanted without regard to how much
  1507. 1:04:19money we would have also because of the
  1508. 1:04:22pandemic. Um and we we did the
  1509. 1:04:24responsible thing by shutting down our
  1510. 1:04:25doors and not putting people's health at
  1511. 1:04:27risk. And then um the whole pandemic
  1512. 1:04:30affected ability to generate revenue. Um
  1513. 1:04:34and and then we became dependent upon or
  1514. 1:04:37reliant might be a better word reliant
  1515. 1:04:39on U PO and um and I I know people
  1516. 1:04:44bristle when I say it, but I was on the
  1517. 1:04:46budget formulation to get the $500
  1518. 1:04:49million that we got to sustain us for
  1519. 1:04:52the time period following the the
  1520. 1:04:53pandemic. And one thing that changed
  1521. 1:04:56from when I left to when I came back was
  1522. 1:05:00a recalculation of what the tribal
  1523. 1:05:02government could depend upon in terms of
  1524. 1:05:05um tribal support from our enterprises.
  1525. 1:05:07And that makes sense because the
  1526. 1:05:09enterprises weren't generating it. So we
  1527. 1:05:11couldn't give 17 million. But as I
  1528. 1:05:15understand it, we're we're doing about
  1529. 1:05:17as well as we were pre- pandemic right
  1530. 1:05:20now. But we haven't changed back the
  1531. 1:05:22calculation to collect the the revenue.
  1532. 1:05:25And I, as I understand it, it's because
  1533. 1:05:28we see the need to reinvest in our
  1534. 1:05:31facilities um so that we can try to
  1535. 1:05:34drive even more revenue out of our
  1536. 1:05:36gaming. And I and I support that. But I
  1537. 1:05:38also want to make clear that that's an
  1538. 1:05:41artificial um way of looking at where we
  1539. 1:05:44were before where we are now. because
  1540. 1:05:46now we're facing a deficit because we
  1541. 1:05:48don't have a guarantee of tribal support
  1542. 1:05:50at $17 million.
  1543. 1:05:52So, um, had we had that still, which it
  1544. 1:05:55seems like we should be able to go back
  1545. 1:05:57to that because it's post pandemic and
  1546. 1:05:59the revenue we're generating is is um
  1547. 1:06:02about what we were generating or a
  1548. 1:06:04little bit better today. So, um, so
  1549. 1:06:07that's that's a creation of government
  1550. 1:06:09that we have a deficit that we're facing
  1551. 1:06:11a deficit. Um but also I wanted to say
  1552. 1:06:15all right so as a government you you
  1553. 1:06:17provide programs and services we don't
  1554. 1:06:19tax people. Um at one point we had the
  1555. 1:06:22idea to you know build this big
  1556. 1:06:24beautiful big bear. So that's a BBB. Um
  1557. 1:06:28and uh under the presumption it was
  1558. 1:06:31going to generate revenue and carry its
  1559. 1:06:33own costs which is total nonsense
  1560. 1:06:34because anybody who fell for that hook
  1561. 1:06:36line and sinker was really naive um
  1562. 1:06:39because it's a it's a loss leader. The
  1563. 1:06:41big bear is a loss leader, so we have to
  1564. 1:06:43supplement it. But we do because it
  1565. 1:06:44provides a recreation outlet hopefully,
  1566. 1:06:47you know, improve your house so that you
  1567. 1:06:49don't have chronic disease. Um, we also
  1568. 1:06:52have some loss leaders on the enterprise
  1569. 1:06:54side that our our enterprise structure
  1570. 1:06:56today is is in has inherited. Um, we've
  1571. 1:07:00heard from our enterprise director that
  1572. 1:07:02he would never have recommended those.
  1573. 1:07:04In fact, I as I understand it, I wasn't
  1574. 1:07:06here, but as I understand it, they
  1575. 1:07:08weren't recommended. they there wasn't a
  1576. 1:07:10favorable recommendation to move
  1577. 1:07:12forward, but we have lost leaders. So,
  1578. 1:07:14it it's a little bit difficult for me to
  1579. 1:07:16hear we can't afford it when we are
  1580. 1:07:19sitting on loss leaders on the
  1581. 1:07:20enterprise side that we know are never
  1582. 1:07:22going to generate a revenue. I've asked
  1583. 1:07:24for that since I've been back and and we
  1584. 1:07:26know they are never going to generate
  1585. 1:07:28revenue. They're never going to turn a
  1586. 1:07:30profit. Let me say it that way. Um
  1587. 1:07:32because if you're budgeting for it and
  1588. 1:07:34then you're generating revenue and it
  1589. 1:07:36you know if if you're looking at that
  1590. 1:07:37naively and you're thinking oh it's
  1591. 1:07:39generating money. No it's not even
  1592. 1:07:40covering its fixed costs. It's not even
  1593. 1:07:43covering its operational cost. So so
  1594. 1:07:46when we talk about being concerned about
  1595. 1:07:48the expenses the expenses of affording
  1596. 1:07:51people the right to do process um as a
  1597. 1:07:54government as a real government. Um but
  1598. 1:07:56we're not willing to make and and look
  1599. 1:07:58honestly at the cuts that we need to
  1600. 1:08:00make. So, um, yeah, we do, we are faced,
  1601. 1:08:03Mike made a good point, we are faced,
  1602. 1:08:05which you would expect from a treasurer,
  1603. 1:08:07we are faced with trying to figure out
  1604. 1:08:08how to balance the budget. Um, but some
  1605. 1:08:11of the budget, um, is of our creation
  1606. 1:08:14through the way that we do reporting and
  1607. 1:08:16what we do as cash sweeps. If we're not
  1608. 1:08:18if if otherwise we're saying we are 11
  1609. 1:08:22million down in casino revenue, and I
  1610. 1:08:25don't think that's correct. Um because
  1611. 1:08:27otherwise why why do we why are we at a
  1612. 1:08:31$14 million deficit? If we were still
  1613. 1:08:34collecting 17 million out of our
  1614. 1:08:36casinos, why are we at that deficit if
  1615. 1:08:38we're doing just as good as we were
  1616. 1:08:40doing before the pandemic? And I don't
  1617. 1:08:42think that's true. I think we are doing
  1618. 1:08:43just as good or better right now. Okay.
  1619. 1:08:46Uh so then the other side of the coin is
  1620. 1:08:49how are we going to generate revenue to
  1621. 1:08:51go forward? This is a question to ask
  1622. 1:08:53whether or not we're debating the
  1623. 1:08:54constitutional amendment at all. How are
  1624. 1:08:57we going to survive going forward if we
  1625. 1:08:59have a projected deficit and the casino
  1626. 1:09:02it's not going to be from casinos. It's
  1627. 1:09:04not that's not going to happen. Um we'll
  1628. 1:09:06do better. We are doing better but it
  1629. 1:09:08we're not going to have this big
  1630. 1:09:09phenomenal increase in revenue from
  1631. 1:09:11casinos. Um we have been doing really
  1632. 1:09:13well in enterprises and Sutribe Inc.
  1633. 1:09:15also has been doing well but I don't
  1634. 1:09:18foresee this big giant surplus coming
  1635. 1:09:20from those either. So then we have to
  1636. 1:09:23make some tough choices. That's that's
  1637. 1:09:24reality.
  1638. 1:09:26or we have to figure out where can we
  1639. 1:09:28generate revenue. All right, so the
  1640. 1:09:29board made a decision when I was out of
  1641. 1:09:32office again and I think it was the
  1642. 1:09:34right decision. Um it would be cowardly
  1643. 1:09:36just to say well they made that
  1644. 1:09:37decision. I had nothing to do with it
  1645. 1:09:39but they made the right decision when
  1646. 1:09:40they contracted with Bluestone to come
  1647. 1:09:42in and give us their assessment of how
  1648. 1:09:44can we generate revenue. They gave a
  1649. 1:09:46list of recommendations. They include
  1650. 1:09:49recruitment and retention, generating
  1651. 1:09:51additional third-party revenue. And to
  1652. 1:09:54my knowledge, I've asked and a couple
  1653. 1:09:56other board members at this table have
  1654. 1:09:57asked repeatedly, how was that coming?
  1655. 1:10:00You know, what's the health division
  1656. 1:10:01doing to generate that revenue? And um
  1657. 1:10:05the revenue that we can generate through
  1658. 1:10:07thirdparty revenue in the health side is
  1659. 1:10:09multiples more lucrative than and this
  1660. 1:10:12is no offense no um than what the casino
  1661. 1:10:15is going to be able to do or what the
  1662. 1:10:16enterprises are going to be able to do.
  1663. 1:10:18Um when I left office we were making
  1664. 1:10:21about $15 million in thirdparty revenue
  1665. 1:10:23from healthcare and I think it's
  1666. 1:10:25probably what's the total projected
  1667. 1:10:29>> if we were collecting all of it?
  1668. 1:10:31Well, I was going to ask you this,
  1669. 1:10:33Holly. How long would it take you to get
  1670. 1:10:35projections to determine how much we
  1671. 1:10:38would receive from the housing
  1672. 1:10:38authority, health division, and STI if
  1673. 1:10:40our tax code was applied to them? Even
  1674. 1:10:42just a general rough estimate.
  1675. 1:10:44>> Our existing tax code, um, probably not
  1676. 1:10:47that long. I could probably whip that up
  1677. 1:10:49in a couple of days.
  1678. 1:10:50>> Okay. Do you know ballpark off the top
  1679. 1:10:52of your head how much you think it could
  1680. 1:10:53generate?
  1681. 1:10:54>> I don't. I would not want to answer
  1682. 1:10:56that.
  1683. 1:10:56>> Okay. I respect that.
  1684. 1:10:58>> So, our our best opportunity for
  1685. 1:11:01generating revenue right now is
  1686. 1:11:03thirdparty revenue in healthcare is our
  1687. 1:11:05absolute best. It's the biggest bang for
  1688. 1:11:08the buck. It's the white buffalo,
  1689. 1:11:09whatever you want to call it. But we
  1690. 1:11:12aren't doing what we need to do to
  1691. 1:11:13maximize that because that opportunity
  1692. 1:11:15is out there. So, okay, let's talk about
  1693. 1:11:18the political climate. the political
  1694. 1:11:20climate. I watch this stuff really
  1695. 1:11:21closely is even with the big beautiful
  1696. 1:11:23budget that passed in 2025 and what was
  1697. 1:11:26it June in 2025 where the president of
  1698. 1:11:29uh brought his budget and the arm
  1699. 1:11:30twisted and and got it approved and it
  1700. 1:11:33would decimate rural health care. We
  1701. 1:11:36have survived that. We survived it
  1702. 1:11:38because the speaker of the house is Tom
  1703. 1:11:40Cole and he's minimized the impact on
  1704. 1:11:43Indian country. Um, so even though other
  1705. 1:11:45other health care delivery systems are
  1706. 1:11:48suffering, real health care systems are
  1707. 1:11:50suffering, we also probably are going to
  1708. 1:11:53see a wave. We're going to see a wave, a
  1709. 1:11:56blue wave in 64 days. And you're going
  1710. 1:11:58to see a solidification and and a return
  1711. 1:12:01of the deficit that was created by the
  1712. 1:12:05president and the Republican legislature
  1713. 1:12:07in terms of health care. So you're going
  1714. 1:12:09to see that stabilize. And what does
  1715. 1:12:10that mean? That means that we are going
  1716. 1:12:13to be able to be bankable in terms of
  1717. 1:12:15going after third-party revenue. And so
  1718. 1:12:18I have suggested for years, Kathy
  1719. 1:12:20Abramson, so I'll tell you how long ago
  1720. 1:12:21it was. Kathy Abramson and I were
  1721. 1:12:23suggesting we create our own navigator
  1722. 1:12:25system under the health care system.
  1723. 1:12:26We're still largely underinsured. We
  1724. 1:12:28have a lot of tribal members in UNUP
  1725. 1:12:30that show up that don't have health care
  1726. 1:12:33that end up using purchase and referred
  1727. 1:12:34services and then put a drain on that.
  1728. 1:12:36That is what it's for. but if we could
  1729. 1:12:39sign them up for some kind of health
  1730. 1:12:40care. And as far as I know, we don't
  1731. 1:12:42have an active plan on how we're signing
  1732. 1:12:44people up for um Medicaid, Medicare um
  1733. 1:12:48on the exchange. Um so we're not doing
  1734. 1:12:51that. Um we could be doing that. That is
  1735. 1:12:53what we should be doing. Um, so, so I
  1736. 1:12:57it's just it's difficult for me to hear
  1737. 1:12:59that we can't afford to be a government
  1738. 1:13:01with due process rights and affording
  1739. 1:13:03people the right to due process when
  1740. 1:13:05when number one, we aren't reducing the
  1741. 1:13:08the losses, the loss leaders. We're just
  1742. 1:13:10those are sacred calls that we're not
  1743. 1:13:12even willing to touch. I I tried I'm
  1744. 1:13:14trying to move past that because the the
  1745. 1:13:16climate's not there. The the the
  1746. 1:13:18politics aren't in favor of changing
  1747. 1:13:20that at this board table. I beat my head
  1748. 1:13:22against the wall of that in the first
  1749. 1:13:23two years. I I've given up on that. It
  1750. 1:13:26isn't going to happen. Um but it's
  1751. 1:13:28difficult to hear the argument we can't
  1752. 1:13:29afford something when we're sitting on
  1753. 1:13:31loss leaders. And it's also difficult to
  1754. 1:13:33hear when we are not demanding an
  1755. 1:13:36affirmative plan for how we're going to
  1756. 1:13:38generate revenue in the biggest bang for
  1757. 1:13:40the buck that's in front of us. And
  1758. 1:13:41that's thirdparty revenue in healthcare.
  1759. 1:13:44You know, I I I know people goff at when
  1760. 1:13:46I propose that we take a look at Sibi
  1761. 1:13:49and and potentially converting that.
  1762. 1:13:50There's a lot of Indians that live in
  1763. 1:13:52that area. There's a lot of people once
  1764. 1:13:54this this fight over the Affordable Care
  1765. 1:13:57Act is passed that that could bring
  1766. 1:14:00revenue to the Sibly property. Um, but
  1767. 1:14:03what we need is we need somebody that
  1768. 1:14:04knows how to do a budget projection of
  1769. 1:14:06perform. We thought we got that. You all
  1770. 1:14:10thought we got that when you hired
  1771. 1:14:11somebody and you apparently don't have
  1772. 1:14:13that yet, but we need that. So rather
  1773. 1:14:16than point fault at the pass, we need it
  1774. 1:14:18now because it is going to be the
  1775. 1:14:20biggest bang for the buck. We can
  1776. 1:14:22generate I I would guess that if we had
  1777. 1:14:24that facility up and running, we could
  1778. 1:14:26generate more than we're generating
  1779. 1:14:28here. And if we're generating is it 28
  1780. 1:14:30million in third party revenue, Holly,
  1781. 1:14:32>> I'm sorry.
  1782. 1:14:33>> Did you give even a rough estimate? Is
  1783. 1:14:35it I thought it was closer to 30 million
  1784. 1:14:38in projected third party revenue from
  1785. 1:14:40healthcare.
  1786. 1:14:41>> Sorry, Erin. One just one second. So
  1787. 1:14:44what they had projected it is it's 27.2
  1788. 1:14:47million that they projected in their
  1789. 1:14:50budget.
  1790. 1:14:52>> Okay. 27.2 million versus 6 million that
  1791. 1:14:55we can rely on from the casino.
  1792. 1:14:58So where should we be putting our effort
  1793. 1:15:00right now in healthcare? And if it's not
  1794. 1:15:03sibly if sibly is just a pipe dream
  1795. 1:15:05whatever the politics are behind sibly.
  1796. 1:15:07>> Can I can I share this Aaron?
  1797. 1:15:10If they can't afford a new government,
  1798. 1:15:12how can they afford to develop Sibi?
  1799. 1:15:14>> I I'll tell you how. Because we have we
  1800. 1:15:17have banked third party revenue. We have
  1801. 1:15:20um we have obligated healthc care funds
  1802. 1:15:23and Rama that could be used. We have um
  1803. 1:15:28>> yeah we And so how you do it is like how
  1804. 1:15:32businesses do start. You you identify
  1805. 1:15:34what the fixed costs are for startup. So
  1806. 1:15:37there would be fixed costs for for
  1807. 1:15:38renovating a facility for for getting it
  1808. 1:15:41up and running for getting equipment and
  1809. 1:15:43all of that. Um but this is going to be
  1810. 1:15:46so lucrative that it's easily going to
  1811. 1:15:48pay its own cost. So that's why right
  1812. 1:15:51now if you look at it in a static you
  1813. 1:15:53know the cost is going to be probably be
  1814. 1:15:5620 million to to do a development in say
  1815. 1:15:58sibly but the revenue is going to be 20
  1816. 1:16:02million annually at least. It's gonna
  1817. 1:16:05it's going to transcend our revenue
  1818. 1:16:06here. If our revenue here is 27 million,
  1819. 1:16:08a sibly property is going to generate 30
  1820. 1:16:10or $40 million. So within two or three
  1821. 1:16:13years, you're going to be able to retire
  1822. 1:16:14your debt on a facil on a healthcare
  1823. 1:16:17facility. And casinos can't promise
  1824. 1:16:19that. There's no way. None of the
  1825. 1:16:22enterprises we've ever done can promise
  1826. 1:16:23that and they never will. So the other
  1827. 1:16:26one area all right so moving off that
  1828. 1:16:28the other other the other one area that
  1829. 1:16:31could potentially start generating
  1830. 1:16:32revenue but it's going to take the this
  1831. 1:16:35blue wave and because a lot of the
  1832. 1:16:38federal contracting that we were
  1833. 1:16:39depending on that we were ramping up
  1834. 1:16:41Sutra Inca was really going in the right
  1835. 1:16:43direction we had budget projections
  1836. 1:16:45there a lot of those got chokeold
  1837. 1:16:48because the president interpreted that
  1838. 1:16:50those were DEI and American Indians are
  1839. 1:16:53not DEI it's you know we're a political
  1840. 1:16:55entity. But once we have a a a shift
  1841. 1:16:59paradigm shift in November, you're going
  1842. 1:17:01to see those projects return. You're
  1843. 1:17:03going to see energy projects return,
  1844. 1:17:06clean energy projects return. You're
  1845. 1:17:08going to see government contracting to
  1846. 1:17:10pre-qualified
  1847. 1:17:12uh individuals return. And we are we're
  1848. 1:17:15poised for that. Our suture tribe has
  1849. 1:17:16been doing a really good job. You're
  1850. 1:17:18going to see increased revenue there,
  1851. 1:17:20too. So, um,
  1852. 1:17:23all of this to say, the sky is not
  1853. 1:17:26falling. We have endured much, much
  1854. 1:17:28worse than anything we're facing now.
  1855. 1:17:30The picture that's being painted is that
  1856. 1:17:31we're on the brink of crisis. If that
  1857. 1:17:34were true, we would be trying to figure
  1858. 1:17:36out I'd give up half of my salary. And I
  1859. 1:17:38and I I do think, as Sue said, I do
  1860. 1:17:41think some board members are worth it.
  1861. 1:17:43Some board members do earn their keep
  1862. 1:17:45with constituent work with getting calls
  1863. 1:17:48all the time um with those that are on
  1864. 1:17:51national committees that are out
  1865. 1:17:52advocating and getting additional
  1866. 1:17:54revenue for our tribe. Um some some are
  1867. 1:17:57earning definitely earning their keep.
  1868. 1:17:59But if we were truly on the brink of
  1869. 1:18:01financial ruin, why isn't that on the
  1870. 1:18:04table? Why aren't we shutting down
  1871. 1:18:06failing businesses that are losing money
  1872. 1:18:08that we've been told by our experts that
  1873. 1:18:11they're never going to turn a profit?
  1874. 1:18:13Why isn't that happening? And it isn't
  1875. 1:18:15happening because we're not at the brink
  1876. 1:18:17of a crisis. So, all right, I'll turn it
  1877. 1:18:20back. Sue, Tyler, Rob.
  1878. 1:18:24Tyler,
  1879. 1:18:27that was a lot. Sue, you got a friend in
  1880. 1:18:29me. Um, I don't know. My kid loves Toy
  1881. 1:18:32Story. So,
  1882. 1:18:34>> yeah.
  1883. 1:18:35>> I just I feel for you because I
  1884. 1:18:37understand what you're going through.
  1885. 1:18:38And and to be honest with you, like it's
  1886. 1:18:40not fair for you, Cole, and and Ashley,
  1887. 1:18:44to come into this and ask questions and
  1888. 1:18:46feel like you're put down by anybody,
  1889. 1:18:48whether that's online or in the room.
  1890. 1:18:50It's not fair to any of you. And I
  1891. 1:18:51agree. And I can 100% feel for you on
  1892. 1:18:54being attacked. My entire family is
  1893. 1:18:57being attacked right now. Um
  1894. 1:18:59unnecessarily. I was born into this
  1895. 1:19:00tribe in 1982.
  1896. 1:19:02So, I mean, I may be younger than some
  1897. 1:19:04people at this table, but uh Garden
  1898. 1:19:07River Church Records didn't exist till
  1899. 1:19:092011. So, I've been a C tribe member my
  1900. 1:19:13whole life, but now it's not just me
  1901. 1:19:15being attacked. It's the entire Lelant
  1902. 1:19:17side. And I don't even want to get my
  1903. 1:19:19mom's side involved into it because I
  1904. 1:19:20get my lineage from both sides. So, it
  1905. 1:19:22is unfortunate, but even if we disagree
  1906. 1:19:25at this table, I'm never going to leave
  1907. 1:19:26here hating anybody. you know, we're
  1908. 1:19:28we're we are paid to make decisions
  1909. 1:19:31based on our constituents, based on what
  1910. 1:19:33we know as individuals. That's why we're
  1911. 1:19:35a council and not one individual making
  1912. 1:19:37the decisions. So, with that being said,
  1913. 1:19:41you know, I know it's it's tough and you
  1914. 1:19:42guys are coming into a really really
  1915. 1:19:44really tough time. Um, last year we had
  1916. 1:19:48anticipated a $21 million $23 million
  1917. 1:19:52government deficit spend. Um, we did the
  1918. 1:19:56projections in Lancing. I loosely
  1919. 1:19:58projected out and clearly I did this in
  1920. 1:19:59a closed session but the the final
  1921. 1:20:02numbers came out and I had said in that
  1922. 1:20:05meeting by my projection we would only
  1923. 1:20:08be down $4.5 million by the end of the
  1924. 1:20:10year and I believe it was $4.8 million
  1925. 1:20:13by the end of the year. So clearly the
  1926. 1:20:15projections are not what they seem to
  1927. 1:20:17be, which is why I think both our
  1928. 1:20:19constituents and the board of directors
  1929. 1:20:21need a one to three to fiveyear
  1930. 1:20:23performer projections so they can see
  1931. 1:20:26where we're at with both the government
  1932. 1:20:28as well as our individual businesses.
  1933. 1:20:30And if we decide to keep the individual
  1934. 1:20:32businesses closed, that's fine because
  1935. 1:20:34it will roll up into the entire
  1936. 1:20:36government budget so that the people can
  1937. 1:20:37actually see um what we truly spend and
  1938. 1:20:41what we're projected to spend over the
  1939. 1:20:42next 3 to 5 years. I think that's
  1940. 1:20:44appropriate and then add in um any
  1941. 1:20:47amendments. But I do want to highlight a
  1942. 1:20:48few things as Aaron touched on
  1943. 1:20:50healthcare. I've been pushing this. You
  1944. 1:20:52know, we renegotiate our annual funding
  1945. 1:20:54agreement to be able to use the funds
  1946. 1:20:56towards health related services. That
  1947. 1:20:58includes public health. One of the
  1948. 1:21:00biggest things that it's supported that
  1949. 1:21:02we never have to worry about again is
  1950. 1:21:03our elder services because all of our
  1951. 1:21:05elder services are health related
  1952. 1:21:06expenses. And that's just to name one
  1953. 1:21:08thing. I'm not going to go through the
  1954. 1:21:10whole list of all the things that we
  1955. 1:21:11found, but we've we've offset that and
  1956. 1:21:13instead of just pulling from third
  1957. 1:21:15party, what we're trying to do with the
  1958. 1:21:16tax is do it appropriate as a government
  1959. 1:21:19so that the third party so that the
  1960. 1:21:20health division knows exactly what
  1961. 1:21:22they're going to spend every year that
  1962. 1:21:25they have a fixed cost, whether that be
  1963. 1:21:26a percentage or just a a bullet proof
  1964. 1:21:30soundproof number that at least they'll
  1965. 1:21:32have a fix fixed cost that they'll know
  1966. 1:21:34that they have to give the government
  1967. 1:21:35every year and that we can't just reach
  1968. 1:21:37in there saying we're going to expand
  1969. 1:21:38health services and these related
  1970. 1:21:40things. We know what we're going to be
  1971. 1:21:41able to spend in health related services
  1972. 1:21:43as well. If their business increases and
  1973. 1:21:45the that taxes at a percentage, the
  1974. 1:21:48government services can ex expand in
  1975. 1:21:51health related activities. So, I'm fully
  1976. 1:21:54supportive of that. And and Erin, one of
  1977. 1:21:55the things you didn't mention with Sibly
  1978. 1:21:57is the amount of veterans around the
  1979. 1:21:59Detroit area far exceeds probably the
  1980. 1:22:01number of natives there. So, I think
  1981. 1:22:03your projection is low to be honest with
  1982. 1:22:06you. So, I do believe healthcare is the
  1983. 1:22:08next generation. Now, there are options,
  1984. 1:22:10but there are options that we're going
  1985. 1:22:11to have to come up with as a board of
  1986. 1:22:13directors. Uh, one of those things is to
  1987. 1:22:16only approve the tribal support we're
  1988. 1:22:17willing to approve. Like, we we approved
  1989. 1:22:20a $14 million deficit spend. We know
  1990. 1:22:23that we're not going to hit it, but when
  1991. 1:22:25we found out that we only spent over
  1992. 1:22:27spent $4.8 $8 million last year. We
  1993. 1:22:29should not have overapproved a penny
  1994. 1:22:31more than that to help slow things down
  1995. 1:22:35and make our finance department a little
  1996. 1:22:37more comfortable. Granted, it's a
  1997. 1:22:39deficit spend. They're still going to be
  1998. 1:22:40uncomfortable, but we should have never
  1999. 1:22:42approved a penny more than that $4.8
  2000. 1:22:44million. We shouldn't have. And whatever
  2001. 1:22:46we come up with this year for 2027
  2002. 1:22:48budgets when they come right around the
  2003. 1:22:50corner, we should not overapprove those
  2004. 1:22:53things again. And I've been saying this
  2005. 1:22:54for the last couple years, but we just
  2006. 1:22:56keep doing it to keep things moving
  2007. 1:22:58forward or we're too busy talking about
  2008. 1:22:59other things. So, we do really have to
  2009. 1:23:01have serious conversations about that. I
  2010. 1:23:03totally agree.
  2011. 1:23:05Um the the other thing that I wanted to
  2012. 1:23:07bring up is there are other sources of
  2013. 1:23:09funding that we could tap into. I don't
  2014. 1:23:11want to. Um but to say that, you know,
  2015. 1:23:15we can't do this, we can't do that.
  2016. 1:23:18online gaming went from Sue Tribank and
  2017. 1:23:20we pushed it right over to the Quaidon
  2018. 1:23:23Gaming. Now, I like to see our
  2019. 1:23:27properties reinvested in and things of
  2020. 1:23:29that nature. Like, we need to finish
  2021. 1:23:32this off. We need to see this through.
  2022. 1:23:35But one of the things that we can do is
  2023. 1:23:37tap into that because that is now just
  2024. 1:23:40going straight to capital improvements,
  2025. 1:23:42which is something that Kuwaiten needs
  2026. 1:23:45um in all of our properties because it's
  2027. 1:23:48it investing in ourselves is investing
  2028. 1:23:50in our future and it's going to benefit
  2029. 1:23:52us. But that's another thing that we can
  2030. 1:23:53discuss and an argument we can make uh
  2031. 1:23:57about our about the services and how to
  2032. 1:23:59how to pay for the services. So, I just
  2033. 1:24:02I wish instead of
  2034. 1:24:04coming at this and and either feeling
  2035. 1:24:07like we're attacked or attacking each
  2036. 1:24:09other or or the hyperbole or whatever,
  2037. 1:24:12that instead people would come forward
  2038. 1:24:14with solutions and resolutions like I've
  2039. 1:24:16been trying to do. like that we it took
  2040. 1:24:18me what eight months to get that tax the
  2041. 1:24:22health tax just on a tribal board member
  2042. 1:24:25meeting just so you guys could see what
  2043. 1:24:27it would look like to talk about it
  2044. 1:24:29instead of just loosely grabbing at the
  2045. 1:24:31health division you know so those are a
  2046. 1:24:35few of the things that I wanted to talk
  2047. 1:24:36about I think one of the most important
  2048. 1:24:37things is showing a public model of a
  2049. 1:24:40perform perform based on what we're
  2050. 1:24:42currently expecting and what we could be
  2051. 1:24:44expecting with the new improvements and
  2052. 1:24:46then finally I want going to state this
  2053. 1:24:48and you know I totally support our
  2054. 1:24:50courts and and uh and Justice Leaport um
  2055. 1:24:54but 1 million to build or expand on the
  2056. 1:24:57the court like is that needed on day one
  2057. 1:24:59or year one or can we find the funding
  2058. 1:25:01later on? I don't think that should be
  2059. 1:25:03part of the projection. I think that's
  2060. 1:25:05something that we can either lobby down
  2061. 1:25:06the road through through um uh law
  2062. 1:25:10enforcement grants or some other kind of
  2063. 1:25:13funding source like we've done before
  2064. 1:25:15for our homeless shelter and things like
  2065. 1:25:17that. That's one of the things that
  2066. 1:25:18Austin and I or or maybe all of us can
  2067. 1:25:21hit our constit or our legislators with.
  2068. 1:25:23Um also I don't think a million dollars
  2069. 1:25:26is going to get us much of a wing on
  2070. 1:25:28that court house or even if it can hold
  2071. 1:25:31it. So, I just I feel like that should
  2072. 1:25:33be pulled as a future consideration and
  2073. 1:25:36not a year one expense because there's
  2074. 1:25:38there ain't no way we're putting
  2075. 1:25:40anything up for a million dollars in
  2076. 1:25:41year one in that courthouse. Like I just
  2077. 1:25:43I don't see that happening. So, I wanted
  2078. 1:25:46to throw that out there again as another
  2079. 1:25:47solution as cost savings of this
  2080. 1:25:50implementation of the three branch and
  2081. 1:25:52just you know like let's come up with
  2082. 1:25:54solutions and uh work together to figure
  2083. 1:25:57this out. Now, I know we're limited on
  2084. 1:25:59space, so please uh judge don't hate me.
  2085. 1:26:01Um, but I just don't see like nothing in
  2086. 1:26:05the tribe is happening in a year for a
  2087. 1:26:07million dollars. You know, we've we've
  2088. 1:26:09had that annex on the agenda for three
  2089. 1:26:11and a half years now. So, I'll yield
  2090. 1:26:14that.
  2091. 1:26:15>> Judge Leaport, if you could talk about
  2092. 1:26:16the spatial issues and capacity at the
  2093. 1:26:18court, we'd appreciate it.
  2094. 1:26:19>> Yeah, absolutely. So, I'm not entirely
  2095. 1:26:22sure where the capacity issue originates
  2096. 1:26:25from. Um it like you said it sounds like
  2097. 1:26:28you've been having those conversations
  2098. 1:26:29for a few years. So um from my view we
  2099. 1:26:32can utilize the space we currently have.
  2100. 1:26:35The other thing that I will tell you is
  2101. 1:26:36that we have um met with Larry in your
  2102. 1:26:40grants department to start discussing
  2103. 1:26:42the possibility of applying for the SEOs
  2104. 1:26:44funding which does have um it does have
  2105. 1:26:48a I believe a purpose area for that
  2106. 1:26:50allows for tribal infrastructure. So
  2107. 1:26:52anything that we would need in addition
  2108. 1:26:53we might be able to fund out of that.
  2109. 1:26:55Um, an additional thing that I would
  2110. 1:26:57say, and again, this doesn't help
  2111. 1:26:58because I'm just throwing out a million
  2112. 1:27:00hypotheticals, and I feel like that's
  2113. 1:27:02part of the problem, right, in these
  2114. 1:27:03discussions. Um, you all have uh other
  2115. 1:27:07reservations besides
  2116. 1:27:09besides Sus Marie, and it might be nice
  2117. 1:27:11if we would just have some equipment so
  2118. 1:27:13that we could go to the other
  2119. 1:27:14reservations and almost host like a
  2120. 1:27:16traveling court. Um, and so we can set
  2121. 1:27:18up in those spaces and make sure that
  2122. 1:27:20those members have the same access and
  2123. 1:27:22availability to us as um as those that
  2124. 1:27:25are here or that are closer. Um, but
  2125. 1:27:27again, that's something that um to me we
  2126. 1:27:31can either apply for grant funding for
  2127. 1:27:33if we determine that we need it.
  2128. 1:27:35Immediate expenses are just going to be
  2129. 1:27:37an office outfitting for the associate
  2130. 1:27:39judge.
  2131. 1:27:41>> Okay. I want to I want to ask you this
  2132. 1:27:43though before we um get back to the
  2133. 1:27:44speakers list, Judge Leort. So, we asked
  2134. 1:27:47Holly, you know, because she's our CFO,
  2135. 1:27:49financial questions. Um, I'm going to
  2136. 1:27:51ask you as our chief judge, what are
  2137. 1:27:53your thoughts on this transition?
  2138. 1:27:55Obviously, you know, you just represent
  2139. 1:27:57one branch of this uh government that
  2140. 1:27:59we're proposing, but it's a big one. It
  2141. 1:28:01provides standing to tribal members in
  2142. 1:28:03our court. What are your thoughts about
  2143. 1:28:05that and its importance in your opinion?
  2144. 1:28:10>> You have a bill of rights in your
  2145. 1:28:12existing constitution, right? It's
  2146. 1:28:13article
  2147. 1:28:15seven, I believe. Is that correct? Or
  2148. 1:28:16article eight that incorporates IKRA uh
  2149. 1:28:21as I'm reading it fully within that
  2150. 1:28:23within that provision. So whether or not
  2151. 1:28:25members have standing uh in your current
  2152. 1:28:28court structure to request injunctive
  2153. 1:28:31relief, right, might be something that's
  2154. 1:28:32already presently on the table. Any
  2155. 1:28:34other further waiverss of sovereign
  2156. 1:28:36immunity would obviously be up to you
  2157. 1:28:37all to make as the board of directors.
  2158. 1:28:39And I certainly would never want to
  2159. 1:28:40overstep. Um, to me, you know, from
  2160. 1:28:43looking at it from a 30,000 foot view
  2161. 1:28:47where I am really stepping into this
  2162. 1:28:49very new and am worried that I'm going
  2163. 1:28:51to shove my foot right in my mouth. Um,
  2164. 1:28:53I would say that if your members have
  2165. 1:28:56elected this type of government and this
  2166. 1:28:59is what they've raised forward, then
  2167. 1:29:00certainly it would be um, you know, your
  2168. 1:29:03duty to see that out. But I also I also
  2169. 1:29:06think that there's a prudence in being
  2170. 1:29:09in being mindful of the long-term cost
  2171. 1:29:11of it. I will say that I think um I was
  2172. 1:29:15actually expecting the cost to be a lot
  2173. 1:29:16more than what was projected. So for me
  2174. 1:29:19it seems like it's not
  2175. 1:29:20>> I was too to be quite honest with you.
  2176. 1:29:21>> Yeah. For me it doesn't seem as bad. But
  2177. 1:29:23I will say this. I mean the court is
  2178. 1:29:25willing to work uh within whatever
  2179. 1:29:27parameters the other branches of
  2180. 1:29:29government provide it. Right. You have
  2181. 1:29:30the power of the person. you have the
  2182. 1:29:31powers that are for the executive branch
  2183. 1:29:33and those are going to be reserved for
  2184. 1:29:34both of you. They're not going to be for
  2185. 1:29:36the court to step on your toes, etc. Um,
  2186. 1:29:39so just know that at least from my
  2187. 1:29:40perspective, whatever edict is provided
  2188. 1:29:42to the court in terms of making sure
  2189. 1:29:44that members have quality access to the
  2190. 1:29:46space and that they can have their
  2191. 1:29:47disputes heard in a a timely and
  2192. 1:29:49unbiased manner is really our goal. Um,
  2193. 1:29:52and if the members feel that a three
  2194. 1:29:53branch government is what secures that,
  2195. 1:29:55then I think that's that puts a period
  2196. 1:29:58on the end of that sentence. Um but in
  2197. 1:30:00terms of budget for the court right uh
  2198. 1:30:04whatever we need to do the court will
  2199. 1:30:06work towards doing it's I I have always
  2200. 1:30:08viewed court as being a serviceoriented
  2201. 1:30:10space for membership
  2202. 1:30:12um and that's but that's my personal
  2203. 1:30:14view right and I I'm recognizing that my
  2204. 1:30:16personal view might not be as relevant
  2205. 1:30:18in this space um so I just also want to
  2206. 1:30:20be respectful of you all and the role
  2207. 1:30:21that you all have. Okay, I appreciate
  2208. 1:30:23it. Judge Rob, then Aaron,
  2209. 1:30:28I just wanted to clarify a couple
  2210. 1:30:30things. So, just so nobody actually
  2211. 1:30:33thinks I'm a bully. Well, you you still
  2212. 1:30:35can. Um, but I would never tried to
  2213. 1:30:37bully Sue or Director Sange. Um, I've
  2214. 1:30:41been very open about this. She was on a
  2215. 1:30:43team of ladies who literally saved my
  2216. 1:30:45life. She's a hero to me and that's
  2217. 1:30:48transcends any argument that we have at
  2218. 1:30:49this table. It always will. That'll be
  2219. 1:30:51for life. If I appreciate everything
  2220. 1:30:53you've done and the team of ladies you
  2221. 1:30:55worked with, I literally wouldn't be
  2222. 1:30:57here. So,
  2223. 1:31:00>> okay. [laughter] Okay. I just wanted to
  2224. 1:31:03>> I just wanted to make sure I I just
  2225. 1:31:05wanted to make sure I wasn't coming
  2226. 1:31:07across as a bully. Um, and
  2227. 1:31:10>> Okay.
  2228. 1:31:12>> Okay. But but seriously, that transcends
  2229. 1:31:14anything at this table is that I I can't
  2230. 1:31:17say how much that group of our YEA staff
  2231. 1:31:20has changed my life and the lives of a
  2232. 1:31:22ton of uh our youth moving forward. So,
  2233. 1:31:26um there's that. The the other thing I
  2234. 1:31:28want to point out is that I I none of
  2235. 1:31:30this is personal to me. Um this is all
  2236. 1:31:32on my fundamentals. That is our job to
  2237. 1:31:35afford our members their rights. Period.
  2238. 1:31:38And there and there's no argument about
  2239. 1:31:39that to me. um that's our number one
  2240. 1:31:42job. So if we can't if the sentiment is
  2241. 1:31:45that we can't afford them their rights,
  2242. 1:31:47then I have to say that I failed and the
  2243. 1:31:50board failed as a whole as an entire
  2244. 1:31:53government. That's a failure. When you
  2245. 1:31:55when you have to look at your members
  2246. 1:31:56and say we can't afford to give you your
  2247. 1:31:58rights, that's a failed government.
  2248. 1:32:00Period. And when you fail at your job, I
  2249. 1:32:03think you should sacrifice your your
  2250. 1:32:05pay. And I'm willing to I I will
  2251. 1:32:07tomorrow. Um, if if if we cannot afford
  2252. 1:32:12our members our rights, I don't want
  2253. 1:32:13that pay. And I'm going to have that
  2254. 1:32:16resolution on the table because that is
  2255. 1:32:18the number one function of government is
  2256. 1:32:20to afford your people the rights.
  2257. 1:32:22Everything else comes after. And like
  2258. 1:32:24Director Mccertie said, that's our job.
  2259. 1:32:27I believe our job is to take direction
  2260. 1:32:29from the membership and then it's our
  2261. 1:32:32job to balance the budget. whether it's
  2262. 1:32:33a three branch or right now it's been
  2263. 1:32:36pointed out we're failing at that and
  2264. 1:32:38that's true. So if we're running our
  2265. 1:32:40government in a deficit we should not be
  2266. 1:32:42receiving a paycheck and that was
  2267. 1:32:44actually built into the new constitution
  2268. 1:32:47that if you cannot balance your budget
  2269. 1:32:49you will not get paid and the board
  2270. 1:32:51removed that. So that's going to be
  2271. 1:32:53reminded uh when we have this
  2272. 1:32:54discussion. Um
  2273. 1:32:57you know the board removed that and
  2274. 1:32:59essentially we are saying that our pay
  2275. 1:33:02is more important to us than your rights
  2276. 1:33:05and I don't see any other way to frame
  2277. 1:33:07that. Like that that is my fundamental
  2278. 1:33:09belief. If we cannot afford our people
  2279. 1:33:11their rights and we're saying that's the
  2280. 1:33:13main thing we need to sacrifice our pay.
  2281. 1:33:16And I guarantee you that's going to be
  2282. 1:33:18the sentiment of the members. um that
  2283. 1:33:20that's not going to be questionable to
  2284. 1:33:22them. They are literally going to say,
  2285. 1:33:23"If you can't get that ballot to my
  2286. 1:33:25table, you don't need to be paid." And I
  2287. 1:33:27agree with them. Um
  2288. 1:33:30so, I mean, that's where I'm at with it.
  2289. 1:33:32I I just want to make sure everyone
  2290. 1:33:34knows this isn't personal. I mean, it's
  2291. 1:33:35turned personal towards me already, but
  2292. 1:33:37that's okay. I'm tough. I I signed up
  2293. 1:33:39for it. You know, you want to bring up,
  2294. 1:33:41you know, people on the board want to
  2295. 1:33:43bring up people's transplant and health
  2296. 1:33:44issues and stuff like that. Call them
  2297. 1:33:46bullies. orders of the day.
  2298. 1:33:48>> Yeah, I mean I think that's the orders
  2299. 1:33:50of the day. That's what the discussion
  2300. 1:33:51was based on is this exact issue. But I
  2301. 1:33:54I mean I I'll be done. I just want to
  2302. 1:33:56say those things.
  2303. 1:33:58>> Aaron, Kim Lee, then Cole.
  2304. 1:34:00>> So I I appreciate hearing our judges
  2305. 1:34:04uh uh opinion about what rights
  2306. 1:34:09currently exist. Um because the way that
  2307. 1:34:11I read our Constitution, our existing
  2308. 1:34:13Constitution, is we um uphold the United
  2309. 1:34:17States Constitution, that's black and
  2310. 1:34:19white in our Constitution, but we hide
  2311. 1:34:22behind sovereignty. And I don't I'm not
  2312. 1:34:24pointing at anybody at this table, but
  2313. 1:34:26for years, for generations, our board
  2314. 1:34:29hides behind sovereignty. Even though we
  2315. 1:34:31know our constitution says that we are
  2316. 1:34:34afforded the rights in the United States
  2317. 1:34:35Constitution, speech is one that you
  2318. 1:34:38don't really have the right here because
  2319. 1:34:40if you exercise that speech, you get
  2320. 1:34:42shut off or you get um you know punished
  2321. 1:34:44for it. Um and also the Tribal Civil
  2322. 1:34:48Rights Act. Um she referenced it as an
  2323. 1:34:50acronym, but uh we also uphold the
  2324. 1:34:53Tribal Civil Rights Act in our
  2325. 1:34:54constitution. Um, we used to have in our
  2326. 1:34:57in our oath of office that we would
  2327. 1:34:59uphold the United States Constitution.
  2328. 1:35:01Somewhere along the line, that
  2329. 1:35:02disappeared. I don't know if that was an
  2330. 1:35:04exercise of sovereignty or if it was
  2331. 1:35:06more nefarious, but that's no longer in
  2332. 1:35:08our oath of office. I went back and look
  2333. 1:35:10at all my old oath of offices as
  2334. 1:35:12chairperson. It was in there then, but
  2335. 1:35:14it isn't in the in the oath of office
  2336. 1:35:16now. And I I'm not accusing anybody
  2337. 1:35:18because I don't know when it happened.
  2338. 1:35:19But um but that I agree with that
  2339. 1:35:23opinion, but that is not the opinion of
  2340. 1:35:26our unitary form of government,
  2341. 1:35:27legislative branches, legal council. And
  2342. 1:35:31I'm not also not pointing the finger at
  2343. 1:35:32Ryan because it has long been the
  2344. 1:35:35opinion of our legal department um at
  2345. 1:35:38the behest of their supervisor, which is
  2346. 1:35:40the board, that we don't have those
  2347. 1:35:43rights. um that we don't just
  2348. 1:35:45automatically have due process rights,
  2349. 1:35:47that we don't have standing. Right now,
  2350. 1:35:49you don't have standing. And the way
  2351. 1:35:51that our judge just explained it that
  2352. 1:35:52it's arguable that we do, but we've had
  2353. 1:35:56um experiences year after year after
  2354. 1:35:59year when um removal petitions were
  2355. 1:36:01submitted where legal counsel for the
  2356. 1:36:02tribe would just interpret that the
  2357. 1:36:04signatures didn't count, so they didn't
  2358. 1:36:06count. or as late as 6 20 um 16 there
  2359. 1:36:11was a referendum with three times as
  2360. 1:36:13many signatures required and um the
  2361. 1:36:17lower general or the general counsel and
  2362. 1:36:19the lower court senior attorney all
  2363. 1:36:21advised that it was a good valid
  2364. 1:36:23petition but then for several months we
  2365. 1:36:26kept coming back and and pressure from
  2366. 1:36:28the board level you know to their
  2367. 1:36:30employee the general counsel was their
  2368. 1:36:32employee then came back and said well
  2369. 1:36:34maybe it doesn't meet the requirements
  2370. 1:36:36but you know So then that one got
  2371. 1:36:37dismissed and then more recently in 2022
  2372. 1:36:40there was uh there was a referendum
  2373. 1:36:43petition to overturn the soul source
  2374. 1:36:45contracting. There was again about uh
  2375. 1:36:47twice as many signatures. That one also
  2376. 1:36:50got dismissed by the board of directors.
  2377. 1:36:52And um I don't believe that the board
  2378. 1:36:55has the authority just to dismiss
  2379. 1:36:57somebody's referendum rights. I don't
  2380. 1:36:59think that that exists. Um, but it it
  2381. 1:37:02happened and citizens could have
  2382. 1:37:05challenged either one of those decisions
  2383. 1:37:08if we had standing in tribal court. And
  2384. 1:37:10currently we don't have standing in
  2385. 1:37:11tribal court because the current law of
  2386. 1:37:14the tribe or interpretation of the law
  2387. 1:37:16of the tribe by by our legal department,
  2388. 1:37:20not the current legal department because
  2389. 1:37:21they haven't written something that says
  2390. 1:37:23that, but that citizens just don't have
  2391. 1:37:26standing in tribal court. So, um, one
  2392. 1:37:30thing that All right. So then some will
  2393. 1:37:31say, "Well, we would never do that to
  2394. 1:37:33our people. We would never persecute our
  2395. 1:37:34people." But I know in 2009
  2396. 1:37:38there was a proposal and a couple board
  2397. 1:37:41members contacted me because they
  2398. 1:37:42thought I just hate Bernard to the core.
  2399. 1:37:44There was a proposal, well, let me sit
  2400. 1:37:46back up. The proposal to rem uh to
  2401. 1:37:49remove from the roles a member of the
  2402. 1:37:51council because of stuff that that
  2403. 1:37:53person had done. And I'm like, are you
  2404. 1:37:56crazy? I'll never support that. That
  2405. 1:37:58person's a citizen of the tribe. you
  2406. 1:38:00don't have any right to take away their
  2407. 1:38:02citizenship. But that was an active
  2408. 1:38:04proposal. And um I I told that person I
  2409. 1:38:07did not respect that request. I can't
  2410. 1:38:09believe you're even thinking about that.
  2411. 1:38:11But that could happen today. That could
  2412. 1:38:13happen today. And at the benevolence of
  2413. 1:38:15the existing council, you know, it's
  2414. 1:38:18left up to us to decide. If we if we
  2415. 1:38:20voted right now, there's a there's a
  2416. 1:38:22question mark on the citizens that are
  2417. 1:38:24Batchawana, not Bachelana Garden River.
  2418. 1:38:27So, uh, Tyler, I want to clarify the
  2419. 1:38:30practice for counting church records
  2420. 1:38:33predates 2010. So, I got clarification
  2421. 1:38:37about that. That vote that changed in
  2422. 1:38:392010 just changed the blood quantum
  2423. 1:38:42calculation. We have all from the
  2424. 1:38:44beginning enrollment verified from the
  2425. 1:38:46beginning. We have been using Garden
  2426. 1:38:48River Church records for enrollment in
  2427. 1:38:50the tribe. So now there's a question
  2428. 1:38:52about the legitimacy of Garden River
  2429. 1:38:54people and there's a request for a
  2430. 1:38:56workshop to bring that back. So there
  2431. 1:38:59could be a vote, I'm not saying that
  2432. 1:39:01that's why that board member brought it
  2433. 1:39:02up, but there could be a vote to
  2434. 1:39:03disenroll all descendants of Garden
  2435. 1:39:05River. Over the years has been the same
  2436. 1:39:08sort of thing on the Meno band. Um that
  2437. 1:39:11could come up and if that happened right
  2438. 1:39:13now, you you couldn't do anything about
  2439. 1:39:15it. The board could vote to disenroll
  2440. 1:39:17all Garden River and all Machina Bandan
  2441. 1:39:19members tomorrow night. No, not tomorrow
  2442. 1:39:21night. Hopefully, you respect the
  2443. 1:39:22five-day notice, but giving five-day
  2444. 1:39:24notice and and as a citizen of the
  2445. 1:39:27tribe, you could do nothing about it.
  2446. 1:39:29You couldn't. And correct me if I'm
  2447. 1:39:31wrong, either the legal department or
  2448. 1:39:33our judge, members could not go and file
  2449. 1:39:37a cause of action in tribal court to
  2450. 1:39:39overturn that decision because we have a
  2451. 1:39:42unitary form of government that has not
  2452. 1:39:45granted um standing in tribal court to
  2453. 1:39:48overturn such a decision. That's the
  2454. 1:39:51importance why the importance of a
  2455. 1:39:52separation of powers is so critical
  2456. 1:39:54because that could happen whether
  2457. 1:39:59I guess see who's laughing. I heard a
  2458. 1:40:02laugh earlier. Um which would be out of
  2459. 1:40:04order. But whether um whether people
  2460. 1:40:07will stay here, stand here and say, "Oh,
  2461. 1:40:09we would never do that. We would never
  2462. 1:40:10do that." Um but it could happen. It
  2463. 1:40:13could absolutely happen. And if it
  2464. 1:40:15happened right now, you would not have
  2465. 1:40:17standing in tribal court to overturn the
  2466. 1:40:19decision.
  2467. 1:40:21That's why we need a separation of
  2468. 1:40:22powers. that is worth every penny that
  2469. 1:40:25we pay for it. As a citizen of this
  2470. 1:40:27tribe, I interpret my entire existence
  2471. 1:40:30as a citizen of this tribe. I'm also a
  2472. 1:40:33citizen of the United States and of
  2473. 1:40:34Michigan, but but we are not afforded
  2474. 1:40:38the same rights that you are as a
  2475. 1:40:40citizen of the United States, even
  2476. 1:40:42though our Constitution says it. So,
  2477. 1:40:44that's why we need to amend our
  2478. 1:40:46Constitution to clarify that citizens
  2479. 1:40:49have standing in tribal court. That's
  2480. 1:40:51important. that's worth every single
  2481. 1:40:54penny. And I think every citizen that
  2482. 1:40:56might be facing disenrollment or or some
  2483. 1:40:59some action adverse action against them
  2484. 1:41:02that they then realize you don't have
  2485. 1:41:03standing in tribal court, I think they
  2486. 1:41:05will all line up. And here's the bottom
  2487. 1:41:07line.
  2488. 1:41:08We're denying them the ability to tell
  2489. 1:41:11us what is they want in their form of
  2490. 1:41:13government. If we tell them how much
  2491. 1:41:15it's going to cost, who are we to deny
  2492. 1:41:19them their right to make the selection,
  2493. 1:41:21to make the choice? We're a
  2494. 1:41:23representative democracy. We're not a
  2495. 1:41:25dictatorship, or we should be. Let's let
  2496. 1:41:28the people decide. If they know the pros
  2497. 1:41:30and cons of the expense, and they choose
  2498. 1:41:32to weigh the benefit of due process in
  2499. 1:41:35tribal court over the costs, let them
  2500. 1:41:38make that decision. Because right now
  2501. 1:41:39we're the only there's 12 of us, 13 of
  2502. 1:41:42us standing in the way of them making
  2503. 1:41:44the decision. This should be their right
  2504. 1:41:47for their government to have their
  2505. 1:41:49governance as they see fit, not as we
  2506. 1:41:53see fit.
  2507. 1:41:55All right. So, I have a couple hands up
  2508. 1:41:57from staff. Holly, if you don't mind
  2509. 1:41:58sharing what you put your hand up to
  2510. 1:41:59share, then Judge Leaport, and then I'll
  2511. 1:42:01get back to the board of directors.
  2512. 1:42:02Oftentimes, when I call in staff,
  2513. 1:42:04they'll recenter it and focus it where
  2514. 1:42:05it needs to be focused. At that point,
  2515. 1:42:08after I exhaust this list, which would
  2516. 1:42:09be Kim Lee and then Cole, I ask that we
  2517. 1:42:13continue on this conversation.
  2518. 1:42:14Otherwise, it's going to be just like
  2519. 1:42:15last Monday where we don't get a whole
  2520. 1:42:17lot accomplished. Everyone spoke several
  2521. 1:42:19times. We're going to get several
  2522. 1:42:20opportunities to speak about this issue
  2523. 1:42:22later on today and tomorrow. So, let's
  2524. 1:42:24just hold it after this.
  2525. 1:42:26>> Go ahead, Holly.
  2526. 1:42:27>> My my point that I just wanted to bring
  2527. 1:42:29up is that we've taken our cash, our
  2528. 1:42:32liquid asset. We had quite a bit of ARPA
  2529. 1:42:34funding and some other funds. We turned
  2530. 1:42:36them into capital assets. We made
  2531. 1:42:38buildings. We created structures. Those
  2532. 1:42:42structures are fine right now because
  2533. 1:42:44they're new. Those will eventually cost
  2534. 1:42:46us more money. And so I was just going
  2535. 1:42:49to ask Judge Leaport a question about
  2536. 1:42:52she had mentioned the court and we had
  2537. 1:42:54talked about the cost of adding an
  2538. 1:42:56addition to the court. My question would
  2539. 1:42:58be and this kind of goes for the health
  2540. 1:43:01centers as well is is there a way to
  2541. 1:43:04become more creative because we know
  2542. 1:43:05that bricks and mortar are expensive.
  2543. 1:43:08It's costly to maintain. It's costly to
  2544. 1:43:10construct. So, is there a way to do a
  2545. 1:43:14combination of in courtroom
  2546. 1:43:19um sessions in addition to a
  2547. 1:43:21teleconferencing type thing where maybe
  2548. 1:43:23we can look at that space and revise it
  2549. 1:43:26at a lesser cost and become creative
  2550. 1:43:29with how we structure that. And then as
  2551. 1:43:32we're scheduling these, maybe schedule
  2552. 1:43:34them so that they work for our needs,
  2553. 1:43:36but that it's not just additional rooms
  2554. 1:43:39and more space and more to maintain.
  2555. 1:43:43Now, I think the same thing with regards
  2556. 1:43:45to our health centers when we're looking
  2557. 1:43:47at potential for tele. So, we have a
  2558. 1:43:51hard time recruiting providers, but
  2559. 1:43:52maybe we wouldn't if we looked for
  2560. 1:43:54specialists that weren't in our area
  2561. 1:43:56where we could have a nurse present at
  2562. 1:43:58the clinic to do the intake, to have the
  2563. 1:44:00hands on the patient and then see a
  2564. 1:44:02specialist through a telemed type of
  2565. 1:44:04situation. And so I'm just bringing that
  2566. 1:44:06forth because I feel like we look at
  2567. 1:44:09things oftent times as this is what
  2568. 1:44:11we've done and this is kind of the
  2569. 1:44:12traditional way to go about it, but
  2570. 1:44:14sometimes maybe it's going to require a
  2571. 1:44:15little bit of creativity and we might be
  2572. 1:44:18able to make our space work more for us.
  2573. 1:44:21That's just my two cents.
  2574. 1:44:23>> Chief Judge Leaport.
  2575. 1:44:25>> Yeah, thank you. Um Holly, great
  2576. 1:44:27question. So again, I'm not entirely
  2577. 1:44:29sure where the request to mod the court
  2578. 1:44:32came from. I'm going to assume it came
  2579. 1:44:33from a previous
  2580. 1:44:36uh court staff, right? Um I wouldn't
  2581. 1:44:40suggest that at all right now. To me,
  2582. 1:44:42the court has enough on its plate to
  2583. 1:44:44figure out about how we're going to get
  2584. 1:44:46all the information, right, that we need
  2585. 1:44:48as an entirely new staff, entirely new
  2586. 1:44:51judge, bringing on another new judge,
  2587. 1:44:53right? And kind of trying to figure out
  2588. 1:44:54where some of these gaps are that like
  2589. 1:44:56just just me being humble, right? I I
  2590. 1:44:59don't have all that information yet. And
  2591. 1:45:00I think I still have a lot of work to do
  2592. 1:45:02to to get my arms around the court as a
  2593. 1:45:04whole. So I don't think I would add a an
  2594. 1:45:07annex to my plate. Um I don't think we
  2595. 1:45:10need it either. I will say this. I think
  2596. 1:45:11eventually should you all choose that
  2597. 1:45:14that's something that you all would like
  2598. 1:45:15to see the court do. I'd be happy to
  2599. 1:45:17come up with a proposal for it and work
  2600. 1:45:19with Ryan or whomever, right? I think we
  2601. 1:45:21all work really well together. Again,
  2602. 1:45:22the court's goal here is just to be a
  2603. 1:45:24collaborative partner, but all that we
  2604. 1:45:26would need is just a desk for our for
  2605. 1:45:29our associate judge in an existing space
  2606. 1:45:31that we already have. Um, so for me,
  2607. 1:45:34that's that's really it. I mean, we can
  2608. 1:45:36be minimal on that, right? And then
  2609. 1:45:38again, happy to work with Larry to look
  2610. 1:45:40for alternative funding sources to be
  2611. 1:45:42able to do something like an
  2612. 1:45:43infrastructure build later if you all
  2613. 1:45:45choose that that's what you all would
  2614. 1:45:46want to do, right? Um, so yes, uh, for
  2615. 1:45:50me, I think we're fine for the moment.
  2616. 1:45:51Um, we can be creative with scheduling.
  2617. 1:45:54We can be creative with location. You
  2618. 1:45:55know, scheduling conferences with your
  2619. 1:45:57appellet or supreme court, for example,
  2620. 1:45:59don't have to happen in person. Those
  2621. 1:46:00can happen virtually. Um, and then
  2622. 1:46:03again, there's spaces in each community
  2623. 1:46:05that we can utilize if we want to travel
  2624. 1:46:07to those communities and and access
  2625. 1:46:09those spaces, too. And I don't think
  2626. 1:46:10there's a whole lot of modding that
  2627. 1:46:11would need to be done. Just making sure
  2628. 1:46:12things were confidential and that we had
  2629. 1:46:14some recording equipment. Um, that's
  2630. 1:46:17that's easy enough to do. As for the the
  2631. 1:46:20sovereign immunity discussion, right, I
  2632. 1:46:22don't currently have a case in front of
  2633. 1:46:23me that deals with a citizen suing you
  2634. 1:46:25all, which is why I was comfortable even
  2635. 1:46:27offering a general statement about it,
  2636. 1:46:29but that's not an advisory opinion. Um,
  2637. 1:46:33you know, for me, if if if I'm looking
  2638. 1:46:35at something and talking about sovereign
  2639. 1:46:37immunity, my understanding of it is
  2640. 1:46:38always that Congress has to wave it
  2641. 1:46:41expressly within federal statute or the
  2642. 1:46:43tribe, the board of directors or tribal
  2643. 1:46:45council has to wave it via resolution or
  2644. 1:46:47ordinance, right? Um, court would never
  2645. 1:46:51I would never, for example, like uh
  2646. 1:46:54infer a waiver somewhere where there
  2647. 1:46:55wasn't one that was clear. But as to
  2648. 1:46:57injunctive relief, that is different. um
  2649. 1:47:01you know say that you had a say you had
  2650. 1:47:03a um you know an employee violate
  2651. 1:47:06someone's you know substantial rights I
  2652. 1:47:09mean they would be and continued to do
  2653. 1:47:11that right let's like let's say you had
  2654. 1:47:12a like I I had this situation another
  2655. 1:47:14tribe where there was um somebody being
  2656. 1:47:16kept in a state impatient right someone
  2657. 1:47:19asked for injunctive relief because it's
  2658. 1:47:20the government holding them there I mean
  2659. 1:47:23there's you know it's it's clear that
  2660. 1:47:25there has to be a remedy in that
  2661. 1:47:26situation and it is to hold the
  2662. 1:47:27government accountable where it needs to
  2663. 1:47:29be but that's just on injunctive relief.
  2664. 1:47:31Um, as to monetary damages, etc. That's
  2665. 1:47:33different and standing is different than
  2666. 1:47:35a waiver of sovereign immunity. So, you
  2667. 1:47:37know, it's it's thinking through those
  2668. 1:47:38things that I think are really
  2669. 1:47:39important, but just understanding that I
  2670. 1:47:42don't have one of those cases in front
  2671. 1:47:43of me, but if I did, uh, I would still
  2672. 1:47:45be looking at your Bill of Rights
  2673. 1:47:46section in your Constitution.
  2674. 1:47:49>> Okay. Thank you.
  2675. 1:47:50>> Hopefully that helps. And again, that's
  2676. 1:47:51why I said I didn't want to stick my
  2677. 1:47:52foot in my mouth. So, apologies if I
  2678. 1:47:54stepped on anyone's toes there.
  2679. 1:47:55>> You good, Holly? Okay. So, judge, you
  2680. 1:47:58had your hand up for something separate.
  2681. 1:48:00Did you have anything to add in addition
  2682. 1:48:01to what you just stated?
  2683. 1:48:03Okay. Thank Kim Lee and then Cole,
  2684. 1:48:10thank you for that. Um, so
  2685. 1:48:15where my biggest concern is right is
  2686. 1:48:17around this table. It is not a safe
  2687. 1:48:20space to speak. It's not a safe space to
  2688. 1:48:22speak on the internet. And that's okay.
  2689. 1:48:25My shoulders are strong.
  2690. 1:48:27Um, but divide doesn't come from a
  2691. 1:48:30difference in opinion. It comes from a
  2692. 1:48:31lack of respect.
  2693. 1:48:33And unfortunately,
  2694. 1:48:36that face right there is a lack of
  2695. 1:48:38respect. I mean, so this isn't about
  2696. 1:48:42whether or not I believe that the
  2697. 1:48:46members should be afforded their rights,
  2698. 1:48:48but we also have to be responsible for
  2699. 1:48:51protecting their well-being
  2700. 1:48:53because that isn't a competing
  2701. 1:48:55responsibility. They're equal in my
  2702. 1:48:58opinion and that's what good governance
  2703. 1:49:00is. So, I want to hear from everybody. I
  2704. 1:49:04want to move forward but we have c heard
  2705. 1:49:08nothing but a lot of uncertainties today
  2706. 1:49:13and uncertainties
  2707. 1:49:15can be pretty scary when we're talking
  2708. 1:49:17about people's well-being. So that's all
  2709. 1:49:21>> cool.
  2710. 1:49:23>> I'm good. A lot of my questions got uh
  2711. 1:49:26brought up with the core expansion um
  2712. 1:49:28and how we could utilize different
  2713. 1:49:29spaces. Um,
  2714. 1:49:33>> well, one thing
  2715. 1:49:35>> WhatsApp.
  2716. 1:49:36>> No, go ahead. I apologize.
  2717. 1:49:38>> Yeah, just the one thing is like
  2718. 1:49:41I don't want to keep this going like you
  2719. 1:49:43said, Austin. I want to keep moving on
  2720. 1:49:44this, but I I can't sit here and say
  2721. 1:49:46that I'm not I'm not taking this
  2722. 1:49:49personal because I'm taking it personal
  2723. 1:49:52because I'm just I'm I'm a board member,
  2724. 1:49:54but I'm a a tribal member, right? and
  2725. 1:49:58the decisions that we're going to make
  2726. 1:49:59here are going to last a long time
  2727. 1:50:02beyond our years here on the board. Um,
  2728. 1:50:05and furthermore,
  2729. 1:50:07and we can talk about this resolution
  2730. 1:50:09that's going to come up. I think we're
  2731. 1:50:10going to look at that tomorrow before
  2732. 1:50:13the meeting if we can go over that
  2733. 1:50:14because I have some questions on that as
  2734. 1:50:16well. Um, as far as forfeiting
  2735. 1:50:20forfeiting our pay, but um, no, I just I
  2736. 1:50:23think we all should take this personal.
  2737. 1:50:25you know, this is a huge deal here. Um,
  2738. 1:50:28and thanks for putting all this
  2739. 1:50:30together, Ryan. I know you worked hard
  2740. 1:50:32on this, um, getting this together and
  2741. 1:50:34thank you, Chief Judge, too, for
  2742. 1:50:36supporting it and helping out as well.
  2743. 1:50:38So, appreciate that. And we'll just try
  2744. 1:50:40to keep this moving, like you said,
  2745. 1:50:41Austin. So,
  2746. 1:50:42>> yep. Let's keep it moving. I'll share my
  2747. 1:50:44response and my thoughts on this till
  2748. 1:50:46the end. So, go ahead, guys.
  2749. 1:50:49>> All right. Uh the final piece, Judge
  2750. 1:50:52Leaport did reference it as though this
  2751. 1:50:55is not a requirement of the new
  2752. 1:50:57constitution. It's something that we've
  2753. 1:50:59spoken about uh numerous times with the
  2754. 1:51:02board and something that we the legal
  2755. 1:51:04department and uh the court are
  2756. 1:51:06recommending that we fund up a public
  2757. 1:51:09defender's office. Um ideally we would
  2758. 1:51:12do it now, but I think it's a day one
  2759. 1:51:16as close to a mandatory need as as as I
  2760. 1:51:18can stress. I think it would just it
  2761. 1:51:20would provide better representation
  2762. 1:51:22overall for our citizens long term
  2763. 1:51:24short-term and long term. I believe it
  2764. 1:51:26will save the tribe money long term. Um
  2765. 1:51:29so we've estimated
  2766. 1:51:33three staff initially, a a kind of a
  2767. 1:51:35senior level attorney, a staff attorney,
  2768. 1:51:37and a legal assistant. Again, as you'll
  2769. 1:51:40see in the summary here at the bottom,
  2770. 1:51:42doesn't mean we need to fund it at that
  2771. 1:51:44level initially. But if you did fund it
  2772. 1:51:46at that three staff member level
  2773. 1:51:49initially, you're looking at $582,51763.
  2774. 1:51:55Another one where we can slowly build
  2775. 1:51:58it. Maybe we just want to bring in one
  2776. 1:52:00attorney
  2777. 1:52:02um and see where we're going and slowly
  2778. 1:52:04build towards that and see what the
  2779. 1:52:06capacity is in that first year. and
  2780. 1:52:08beyond. Um, but director payment alluded
  2781. 1:52:11to this. The attempt here with this memo
  2782. 1:52:14was to give you guys a starting point
  2783. 1:52:16that could be closer to like maximum
  2784. 1:52:20all-in estimated cost and then you at
  2785. 1:52:24the table figure out how you can scale
  2786. 1:52:26back with the help of staff on are these
  2787. 1:52:29costs all needed in the beginning or are
  2788. 1:52:32they something that we need later on?
  2789. 1:52:34Are there ways to minimize it? grants,
  2790. 1:52:36federal funding,
  2791. 1:52:38increased revenue, etc. So, this 3.8
  2792. 1:52:41million doesn't necessarily have to be
  2793. 1:52:43the the cost. It doesn't necessarily
  2794. 1:52:44have to be all tribal support, and there
  2795. 1:52:47are ways um to to save on that, right?
  2796. 1:52:50We already in the initial member in the
  2797. 1:52:52initial memo identified that you could
  2798. 1:52:55um look at maybe not funding the
  2799. 1:52:57executive branch increase, no new
  2800. 1:53:00courtroom, maybe just one public
  2801. 1:53:02defender. I didn't put in here because I
  2802. 1:53:04didn't believe that had majority support
  2803. 1:53:06and and we've already talked about it in
  2804. 1:53:08my opinion exhaustively previously. We
  2805. 1:53:11can circle back again. Always happy to
  2806. 1:53:12do that. The fact that we have a could
  2807. 1:53:14have a unified legal department. Um but
  2808. 1:53:16I wasn't going to spend time banging my
  2809. 1:53:19head against that wall when it didn't
  2810. 1:53:20seem like that was the direction of this
  2811. 1:53:21tribe. But I'm happy to to see that
  2812. 1:53:24maybe that's back on the table. Um so I
  2813. 1:53:27made some notes here in closing ways to
  2814. 1:53:30fund it, right? third parties settlement
  2815. 1:53:32funds grants of course we need to do
  2816. 1:53:34better as a tri there's more core grants
  2817. 1:53:36out there probably than we and more
  2818. 1:53:37legal adjacent grants than we actually
  2819. 1:53:40get or try for um increase economic arms
  2820. 1:53:44kg enterprise authority SCI
  2821. 1:53:47uh Indian energy
  2822. 1:53:50increase health services something that
  2823. 1:53:52I'm helping director Leant try to push
  2824. 1:53:54forward um I think that if you're going
  2825. 1:53:57to fund a three branch government one of
  2826. 1:53:58the things that needs to be on the table
  2827. 1:54:00not to a dead horse because Tyler
  2828. 1:54:02already eloquently explained it earlier,
  2829. 1:54:04but you got to look at that third party
  2830. 1:54:06revenue. It it's a really kind of
  2831. 1:54:08lowhanging fruit of stuff that can help
  2832. 1:54:10fund this tribe and we have a lot it's
  2833. 1:54:13upward potential to increase increase
  2834. 1:54:14that over the years. Uh no court
  2835. 1:54:17expansion. That's great. That was based
  2836. 1:54:19on some previous estimates from former
  2837. 1:54:21general counsel and former CFO. Um it's
  2838. 1:54:24been we've been back and forth over the
  2839. 1:54:26years and whether the core capacity is
  2840. 1:54:27there. If we can utilize different
  2841. 1:54:30outline areas and and do that capacity
  2842. 1:54:32different way then that saves you money.
  2843. 1:54:35>> Um what do you think all these savings
  2844. 1:54:37amount to? Like we don't do a court. I
  2845. 1:54:39don't hire staff in my office. Um, if
  2846. 1:54:42you utilize some of the recommendations
  2847. 1:54:43that Judge Leaport has made, such as
  2848. 1:54:46create a public defender's office so
  2849. 1:54:47you're not paying contract attorneys to
  2850. 1:54:49provide subpar representation to our
  2851. 1:54:51tribal citizens court. Like, what do you
  2852. 1:54:54think that would adjust it to? If we
  2853. 1:54:55don't increase the court building
  2854. 1:54:57capacity and if we do not increase any
  2855. 1:55:00legal costs, so we we figure out a way
  2856. 1:55:02to have both branches
  2857. 1:55:04utilize some form of the current
  2858. 1:55:06attorneys that you have on staff and you
  2859. 1:55:08don't increase the executive branch,
  2860. 1:55:11then that 3.8 million becomes 1.7
  2861. 1:55:14million.
  2862. 1:55:15>> Is this the conclusion of the
  2863. 1:55:16presentation
  2864. 1:55:17>> of this part of the Yeah. Well, then I
  2865. 1:55:19pose this question then like when we
  2866. 1:55:21talk about separating our government,
  2867. 1:55:23like the idea that we could do it for
  2868. 1:55:25free is absolutely ludicrous. Like if
  2869. 1:55:27you build branches of government, that's
  2870. 1:55:29obviously going to cost money. You're
  2871. 1:55:30going to have to hire staff,
  2872. 1:55:32specifically judges. You're going to
  2873. 1:55:33have to hire support staff. You know,
  2874. 1:55:35depending on the capacity of the court,
  2875. 1:55:37you may have to do a courtroom
  2876. 1:55:38expansion, which the chief judge is
  2877. 1:55:40saying isn't needed right now. But like,
  2878. 1:55:41we're not going to fund a government
  2879. 1:55:43transition with fairy dust. So my
  2880. 1:55:45question is we don't offer standing to
  2881. 1:55:47our tribal citizens in tribal court
  2882. 1:55:49within this government. Okay? So if I
  2883. 1:55:51live in Sue St. Marie, I'm a resident of
  2884. 1:55:53the city of Sue Staint Marie, the state
  2885. 1:55:54of Michigan and the federal government.
  2886. 1:55:56I have standing in each one of those
  2887. 1:55:58forms of government. The only one I
  2888. 1:56:00don't is my own tribe. And that's an
  2889. 1:56:02issue. So my question is realizing that
  2890. 1:56:05this was never going to be free,
  2891. 1:56:08what's the investment that we would be
  2892. 1:56:10willing to pay on this? Because I mean,
  2893. 1:56:13while we have an unbalanced budget,
  2894. 1:56:14we're also workshopping several things
  2895. 1:56:16that are going to cost money that we're
  2896. 1:56:18going to contribute to that deficit. One
  2897. 1:56:19of them would be the enhanced licenses.
  2898. 1:56:22That's not going to operate off fairy
  2899. 1:56:24dust. Another one is the new licenses.
  2900. 1:56:26Another one is a new website with a
  2901. 1:56:28portal. And I mean, we're all going to
  2902. 1:56:30be presented with the cost of those
  2903. 1:56:32projects. And then we're going to have
  2904. 1:56:33to make a decision. But I mean, if we
  2905. 1:56:36are supportive of this, what's the magic
  2906. 1:56:38number, guys?
  2907. 1:56:44Okay, back to you guys then.
  2908. 1:56:48>> All right, I'm going to stop sharing
  2909. 1:56:49this screen. Um, I don't I don't know
  2910. 1:56:52what the board's pleasure is already
  2911. 1:56:543:00. Um, I can summarize a little bit
  2912. 1:56:57what I think some of my colleagues on
  2913. 1:56:59the table will say. I think there's a
  2914. 1:57:01way that we can with the enterprise
  2915. 1:57:03authority and with Kuwait and gaming
  2916. 1:57:05authority, you're not going to need to
  2917. 1:57:07see
  2918. 1:57:09any and or just very minimal increased
  2919. 1:57:11costs. So, I know they have
  2920. 1:57:13presentations of potential costs, but I
  2921. 1:57:16believe that we
  2922. 1:57:18I'll leave it to the board and the other
  2923. 1:57:20executives, but I I've talked to them
  2924. 1:57:22and I know we can figure out a way to do
  2925. 1:57:25a three branch government for the
  2926. 1:57:27economic arms that can pretty much be a
  2927. 1:57:30net zero. It won't really cost them any
  2928. 1:57:33more money, at least not initially. And
  2929. 1:57:35we have to see what time will tell
  2930. 1:57:36there. So, I don't know if we want to go
  2931. 1:57:38through all those presentations or if my
  2932. 1:57:40summary is sufficient for that.
  2933. 1:57:42>> Well, if you guys don't mind, let's take
  2934. 1:57:44a 10-minute recess. We've gone through a
  2935. 1:57:46lot. We'll reconvene um and then we'll
  2936. 1:57:48finish out the day. You guys okay with
  2937. 1:57:49that? All right. So, let's reconvene at
  2938. 1:57:513:05 sharp.
  2939. 2:09:03Um, when we recess for uh the break,
  2940. 2:09:06Aaron said he had a question or comment.
  2941. 2:09:07So, Aaron, you want to get us started?
  2942. 2:09:15>> What's the magic number?
  2943. 2:09:16>> I mean, what's the magic number? So, we
  2944. 2:09:18hear from different projects all the
  2945. 2:09:20time, every single project is an
  2946. 2:09:21investment. Like, it wasn't meant to be
  2947. 2:09:23a facicious question. Like, at what rate
  2948. 2:09:27would we support this?
  2949. 2:09:29>> That's a good question. Thank you for
  2950. 2:09:30asking it. Um,
  2951. 2:09:33I don't fault
  2952. 2:09:35board members who have legitimate
  2953. 2:09:38concerns about the cost.
  2954. 2:09:41Um, I said earlier I have difficulty
  2955. 2:09:44reconciling when we're sitting on lost
  2956. 2:09:47leaders and we have been for years. Um,
  2957. 2:09:50and I don't hear that concern when it
  2958. 2:09:53comes to those losses because we're
  2959. 2:09:56we're bleeding. We're, you know, it's
  2960. 2:09:58it's not a a trickle. We're we're
  2961. 2:10:01bleeding like a jugular gushed in some
  2962. 2:10:03of our businesses that are that I've
  2963. 2:10:05asked in earnest. Are we ever going to
  2964. 2:10:07turn a profit? And our economic
  2965. 2:10:10development guy said no. Would you have
  2966. 2:10:13recommended it? No. And at that point,
  2967. 2:10:18you have to make a decision. A good a
  2968. 2:10:21good business decision is cut your
  2969. 2:10:23losses, try to sell it, you know, try do
  2970. 2:10:25what you can do, but that's not even on
  2971. 2:10:28the table. So So I don't fault board
  2972. 2:10:31members for wanting to know, you know,
  2973. 2:10:33what the cost is going to be and how do
  2974. 2:10:35we mitigate the cost. Um, but I also
  2975. 2:10:38don't feel it's genuine for for those
  2976. 2:10:40who've sat on lost costs, lost leaders
  2977. 2:10:43for years and years, and that's not a
  2978. 2:10:45concern. So,
  2979. 2:10:47it seems like it seems like what you're
  2980. 2:10:50asking, Mr. Chair, is this a moving
  2981. 2:10:52target? If we if we get this number down
  2982. 2:10:55to almost nothing, is it still not worth
  2983. 2:10:57the price of due process rights for
  2984. 2:11:00citizens? Um and and ultimately the
  2985. 2:11:03bottom line is
  2986. 2:11:06as a government, as a representative
  2987. 2:11:08government, we're elected to represent
  2988. 2:11:10their interest. And some people believe
  2989. 2:11:12that once they give us the right to
  2990. 2:11:13represent them, that it's our job to
  2991. 2:11:16represent them with whatever we think.
  2992. 2:11:19But when they tell us what they want and
  2993. 2:11:21they consistently tell us what they want
  2994. 2:11:22over and over again, then it seems like
  2995. 2:11:25there's a duty to to a sacred duty to
  2996. 2:11:28represent their interest and to bring
  2997. 2:11:31forward what they're asking us to do,
  2998. 2:11:33which is to let them make the decision.
  2999. 2:11:36So in front of us is the decision. Are
  3000. 2:11:38we going to are we going to and put when
  3001. 2:11:40I say let them that's just the sound of
  3002. 2:11:42that paternalistic. Are we going to let
  3003. 2:11:45them decide what their government looks
  3004. 2:11:47like? Or are we going to discern decide
  3005. 2:11:50for them in a paternalistic way what you
  3006. 2:11:53deserve or what you get? You get what
  3007. 2:11:55you get. You elected me that you get
  3008. 2:11:56what you get. I I think that there's
  3009. 2:11:59nothing wrong with putting out to the
  3010. 2:12:02people what they've been asking for and
  3011. 2:12:04and doing an honest assessment of what
  3012. 2:12:06the cost is and let it letting them
  3013. 2:12:08weigh the pros and cons and let them
  3014. 2:12:11decide. I know there was I won't be
  3015. 2:12:14specific enough, but there was a
  3016. 2:12:15referendum once that a board member said
  3017. 2:12:18that our people wasn't weren't smart
  3018. 2:12:20enough to make the decision. This is a
  3019. 2:12:22long time ago. And I just think that's
  3020. 2:12:24wrong. That's not the right way to
  3021. 2:12:26think. Our people are smart. All right.
  3022. 2:12:28Um my 11 12-year-old, he's 12, he's
  3023. 2:12:33almost 13 now. He knows the score. He
  3024. 2:12:36knows what a separation of powers is. He
  3025. 2:12:38knows how valuable that is. He's a
  3026. 2:12:39citizen. He's only 12 years old, but he
  3027. 2:12:42knows that he he prioritizes having due
  3028. 2:12:45process rights. He knows that. He knows
  3029. 2:12:47that no one government this is the the
  3030. 2:12:49this nation was formed in the
  3031. 2:12:51repudiation of a unitary form of
  3032. 2:12:54government. That was the the um well it
  3033. 2:12:57was mostly was several countries but it
  3034. 2:13:00was mostly the United Kingdom that had
  3035. 2:13:02you know a king and um we don't have a
  3036. 2:13:06king. We won't have a king afterwards.
  3037. 2:13:07will have a three branch separation of
  3038. 2:13:10powers that disperses the authority
  3039. 2:13:13based on the Irakcoy confederacy great
  3040. 2:13:15law of peace and I know there was some
  3041. 2:13:17information out there about you know
  3042. 2:13:19whether or not because we were
  3043. 2:13:20apparently at we were at the war with
  3044. 2:13:22Ericoy but we are along and we did
  3045. 2:13:24follow a separation of powers so it's
  3046. 2:13:26going back to our indigenous um belief
  3047. 2:13:29that no one branch should have unitary
  3048. 2:13:32authority over us so the bottom line is
  3049. 2:13:36will the citizens weigh pay out their
  3050. 2:13:38desire for a balance of power and due
  3051. 2:13:41process rights against the cost. We will
  3052. 2:13:44never know if we don't let them make the
  3053. 2:13:48decision. And that's to me what it's all
  3054. 2:13:50about. There's a lot of ways of looking
  3055. 2:13:52at this, but the way I look at it is are
  3056. 2:13:54we going to afford our citizens the
  3057. 2:13:56ability to make that decision or are we
  3058. 2:13:59going to deny them and say we know
  3059. 2:14:01better for them what their needs are. I
  3060. 2:14:04don't think anybody here should pretend
  3061. 2:14:06like they know better than what our
  3062. 2:14:07citizens needs and wants are. So, thank
  3063. 2:14:11you,
  3064. 2:14:12>> Rob.
  3065. 2:14:14>> Well, that was along the lines of what I
  3066. 2:14:16was going to say is that uh we're we're
  3067. 2:14:18we're at a point where we have to
  3068. 2:14:22determine to our membership
  3069. 2:14:25uh what we are as a government, whether
  3070. 2:14:27that's the one branch or the three
  3071. 2:14:28branch, and can we afford them their
  3072. 2:14:31rights? And do we sit at a high enough
  3073. 2:14:33place to where we can say we get
  3074. 2:14:36determine what your rights cost you. I'm
  3075. 2:14:39all for transparency. Like we can tell
  3076. 2:14:41them this is what the cost is.
  3077. 2:14:45Your government has to adjust. We might
  3078. 2:14:47have to make cuts. Um but to me when the
  3079. 2:14:51question's posed is at what cost do you
  3080. 2:14:53fund it? At all cost. That's where I'm
  3081. 2:14:56at. At all cost. Because the number one
  3082. 2:15:00goal of government, and I'm going to say
  3083. 2:15:02this over and over and over, is to make
  3084. 2:15:04sure your members have their rights. And
  3085. 2:15:07there's no cost that you guys are going
  3086. 2:15:09to throw at me to think that
  3087. 2:15:12maybe it's not a good idea. We provide
  3088. 2:15:14them those rights. They'll have the
  3089. 2:15:15right of initiative where they could
  3090. 2:15:17initiate laws. They'll have a right to
  3091. 2:15:20initiate amendments to our constitution.
  3092. 2:15:22they'll have initiate a right to
  3093. 2:15:24challenge this board. When we make bad
  3094. 2:15:27business decisions, they could challenge
  3095. 2:15:28that. So, when the when the question
  3096. 2:15:32comes up to the cost, well, we have
  3097. 2:15:35probably $8 million in golf courses that
  3098. 2:15:37we're never going to see return on
  3099. 2:15:39investment. Um, this board wants to talk
  3100. 2:15:42about the cost of providing their
  3101. 2:15:45membership the rights. Yet, we have
  3102. 2:15:48literally thrown away $10 million
  3103. 2:15:50because we didn't pay a lawsuit bill.
  3104. 2:15:55We have a $35 or $35 million judgment
  3105. 2:15:59against us. We lost $167,000
  3106. 2:16:03maybe in Creek Town, right? There's
  3107. 2:16:05$200. You're looking at almost a hundred
  3108. 2:16:07years of a funded government just by
  3109. 2:16:09making this. We can't afford not to do
  3110. 2:16:11it.
  3111. 2:16:11>> No, you're not talking about thousand.
  3112. 2:16:13You're talking about million.
  3113. 2:16:14>> Yeah. Millions. It's a billion.
  3114. 2:16:16>> Yeah. Huh?
  3115. 2:16:17>> It's a billion.
  3116. 2:16:18>> So, a [snorts] billion dollars. Um,
  3117. 2:16:22and you have We're looking
  3118. 2:16:24>> You guys stop. You're not at a billion
  3119. 2:16:26dollars. When Aaron Schlay Huber was the
  3120. 2:16:27general counsel, I asked him what the
  3121. 2:16:29Greek town bankruptcy was, and he was
  3122. 2:16:31making it at about a hundred million at
  3123. 2:16:33that point. You tack on JLJ, I don't
  3124. 2:16:36know, rough estimate, you were at about
  3125. 2:16:37$130 million of losses for this failed
  3126. 2:16:40experiment to expand gaming downstate.
  3127. 2:16:43Not at a billion. Well, well, the
  3128. 2:16:44lawsuit itself on Greek Town was a lot
  3129. 2:16:46more than a hundred million.
  3130. 2:16:49>> Yeah, I think 120 some million. Either
  3131. 2:16:54way, the thing is is you're at at least
  3132. 2:16:56$200 million that this board has
  3133. 2:16:58squandered of our people's money and
  3134. 2:17:00we're going to sit up here and talking
  3135. 2:17:01about $3.8 million is not enough to
  3136. 2:17:04afford them the rights when they could
  3137. 2:17:06challenge our decisions in court when
  3138. 2:17:08they have standing in court.
  3139. 2:17:11uh when you have a chairman who could
  3140. 2:17:13veto bad business decisions
  3141. 2:17:16and the membership can walk right into
  3142. 2:17:18court and say, "Hey, I want to file a
  3143. 2:17:20petition. This law that the board just
  3144. 2:17:22passed is going to bankrupt us." And go
  3145. 2:17:25to the membership and say, "Hey, let's
  3146. 2:17:26stop this." And know that when that
  3147. 2:17:29referendum gets to this table, we can't
  3148. 2:17:31deny it. This board's literally denied
  3149. 2:17:33them. I mean, throwing away referendums
  3150. 2:17:36of your members. So, at what cost do we
  3151. 2:17:39want to prov provide them those
  3152. 2:17:40protections at all cost? Um, because by
  3153. 2:17:43doing so, literally just I pointed out
  3154. 2:17:45saved a $200 million potentially. Um,
  3155. 2:17:49and then the other thing I want to
  3156. 2:17:50address because no, you know,
  3157. 2:17:54everyone should know by now, you're not
  3158. 2:17:55going to address me and not have a
  3159. 2:17:56response. So, if this idea is that I'm
  3160. 2:17:58disrespectful
  3161. 2:18:00or this isn't a safe place to talk, we
  3162. 2:18:03are all afforded the First Amendment.
  3163. 2:18:07And we all have the freedom to talk.
  3164. 2:18:09I've never made anyone feel threatened
  3165. 2:18:13by talking. We We're politicians. We We
  3166. 2:18:15are elected to have discussions. And
  3167. 2:18:18yes, they're going to get heated. But if
  3168. 2:18:21any one of you guys ever make me feel
  3169. 2:18:23unsafe to speak, I will walk out that
  3170. 2:18:26door because that's not going to happen.
  3171. 2:18:28You are never going to make me feel
  3172. 2:18:30unsafe to speak. Um, and now my face is
  3173. 2:18:35disrespectful.
  3174. 2:18:39Like like am I expected to just not talk
  3175. 2:18:42and not and not to say my piece about
  3176. 2:18:44things? No. Every time I'm going to
  3177. 2:18:45talk. And uh I I believe this stuff. I I
  3178. 2:18:49100% believe our members rights
  3179. 2:18:50shouldn't have a price tag on it. And if
  3180. 2:18:52it does, which it does have a price tag,
  3181. 2:18:55it it should be the members who decide
  3182. 2:18:57whether it's worth it. Not for us to sit
  3183. 2:18:59up here at a high spot on the board and
  3184. 2:19:01say, "Well, that might be too
  3185. 2:19:02expensive." We'll decide not to give the
  3186. 2:19:04members to ship the vote. Put the ballot
  3187. 2:19:06on their table. Put the information on
  3188. 2:19:08their table. Let them decide. Let them
  3189. 2:19:11decide. You know, it's our job to make
  3190. 2:19:14it work after that. Um, so I mean, I I'm
  3191. 2:19:19>> point of information. How do we plan on
  3192. 2:19:21putting that
  3193. 2:19:22in their mailbox
  3194. 2:19:24without the information attached to it
  3195. 2:19:26for them to make an educated decision
  3196. 2:19:28when we don't even have all that
  3197. 2:19:29knowledge.
  3198. 2:19:30>> Why did you vote about it on the 19th
  3199. 2:19:32then?
  3200. 2:19:33>> Because a lot of things have come
  3201. 2:19:34forward stated. A lot of things have
  3202. 2:19:36come forward since then.
  3203. 2:19:37>> No, no.
  3204. 2:19:40Both of you both you have the floor. I
  3205. 2:19:43know you do. That's not a point of
  3206. 2:19:44information. You can finish your turn.
  3207. 2:19:45Kimley has the uh has her turn next, I
  3208. 2:19:48believe.
  3209. 2:19:48>> Okay. Okay.
  3210. 2:19:51We didn't have all this figured out on
  3211. 2:19:52the 19th,
  3212. 2:19:55but we knew what the membership wanted.
  3213. 2:19:56So, we gave them what they wanted then.
  3214. 2:20:00I mean, any anything that's pointed out
  3215. 2:20:02right now is also the information we
  3216. 2:20:04didn't have on the 19th. So, I mean, it
  3217. 2:20:07it really is. I mean, you can't answer
  3218. 2:20:09any questions. You couldn't answer these
  3219. 2:20:12questions on the 19th. I promise it. So,
  3220. 2:20:17okay. Kim Lee, then Ashley.
  3221. 2:20:22You're right. We couldn't answer these
  3222. 2:20:24questions, but we also had some
  3223. 2:20:26misinformation. Um, and I think that
  3224. 2:20:30this conversation has went from
  3225. 2:20:34what was not supposed to be today's
  3226. 2:20:37agenda,
  3227. 2:20:38probably more so tomorrow's um, in these
  3228. 2:20:42conversations. So, I'm going to leave it
  3229. 2:20:45alone and let our executives get back to
  3230. 2:20:47whatever they've got to say, but I I
  3231. 2:20:50just and I appreciate them doing their
  3232. 2:20:53diligence and we still have to come
  3233. 2:20:55together and so we can provide members
  3234. 2:20:58with information because we can't ask
  3235. 2:21:00them to make a decision
  3236. 2:21:03when there's the information doesn't
  3237. 2:21:06match it. We can't even make that
  3238. 2:21:09decision. Our executives can't make that
  3239. 2:21:11decision right now. I mean, it's just
  3240. 2:21:14irresponsible to sit here and argue
  3241. 2:21:17that this again, right? It could be 1.7,
  3242. 2:21:20it could 3.8, it could be we've been all
  3243. 2:21:23over the place. And all I'm asking is
  3244. 2:21:25not to take away the membership's
  3245. 2:21:26rights, is to give them their rights
  3246. 2:21:29with accurate information. So, I'm going
  3247. 2:21:32to stop now and uh I guess I'll save the
  3248. 2:21:34rest for tomorrow's conversation.
  3249. 2:21:36Ashley,
  3250. 2:21:38>> I'm just going to kind of follow up with
  3251. 2:21:40that. Thank you guys so much for being
  3252. 2:21:41here to try and give us the information
  3253. 2:21:43that is needed. It's really appreciated
  3254. 2:21:46and I am sorry that this has gone off
  3255. 2:21:48subject. What everybody keeps talking
  3256. 2:21:50about is what's on the agenda for
  3257. 2:21:52tomorrow. So, if we could get back to
  3258. 2:21:54you guys giving us the information that
  3259. 2:21:56is needed today, I'd greatly appreciate
  3260. 2:21:57that. That's why I came today. Thank
  3261. 2:21:59you.
  3262. 2:22:00>> Thank you, Ashley. Ready to recenter
  3263. 2:22:02things, guys? All right, let's do that.
  3264. 2:22:07All right, if it's okay with the
  3265. 2:22:10executive team and the board, let's jump
  3266. 2:22:11into day one. Day zero and day one
  3267. 2:22:14things that need to happen. I think
  3268. 2:22:16we've exhausted our conversation on the
  3269. 2:22:18economic impact. We've been having the
  3270. 2:22:20same conversation since last November
  3271. 2:22:22when my initially gave you the 3.9
  3272. 2:22:24million. So, the numbers from our side
  3273. 2:22:25of the table haven't fluctuated too
  3274. 2:22:27much. They are the same that they've
  3275. 2:22:30been for over a year. Um we'll get we'll
  3276. 2:22:33get the details more that was requested
  3277. 2:22:35earlier but if we can let's move on to
  3278. 2:22:39the things that we've identified that
  3279. 2:22:41have to happen day one. Some of them I'm
  3280. 2:22:44flagging as day zero and we'll have that
  3281. 2:22:46discussion.
  3282. 2:22:52[snorts]
  3283. 2:22:53Pull my screen up here.
  3284. 2:22:58Ryan, this is an obvious question, but
  3285. 2:23:00assuming the board of directors doesn't
  3286. 2:23:02pass the resolution rescending this
  3287. 2:23:04constitutional election, how quickly is
  3288. 2:23:06the BIA in a position to mail those
  3289. 2:23:08ballots?
  3290. 2:23:09>> Well, now it it was going to be
  3291. 2:23:11September. Now it's going to be October
  3292. 2:23:14that they get mailed. End of September.
  3293. 2:23:17October. The printer is ready to go.
  3294. 2:23:20They were able to pause printing. I gave
  3295. 2:23:22them the heads up that we had a
  3296. 2:23:24resolution pending for tomorrow. Did
  3297. 2:23:26they pause because of this conversation
  3298. 2:23:27that we're having because we might not
  3299. 2:23:29do it so they don't sink additional
  3300. 2:23:30financial resources into it?
  3301. 2:23:32>> That's correct.
  3302. 2:23:33>> So we're looking at November. We're
  3303. 2:23:35looking at November for tabulation
  3304. 2:23:36night, end of September for initial
  3305. 2:23:39mailing for registration and October for
  3306. 2:23:41mailing of ballots.
  3307. 2:23:42>> So we were in a position to have this
  3308. 2:23:44election
  3309. 2:23:46in September, but it's getting postponed
  3310. 2:23:49>> originally September. Then it was
  3311. 2:23:51postponed by the BIA because of the
  3312. 2:23:54amount of changes and then the new date
  3313. 2:23:57was tenatively October 29th and then
  3314. 2:23:59they paused again pending what the board
  3315. 2:24:03majority decides to do tomorrow.
  3316. 2:24:05>> Okay, Kim.
  3317. 2:24:07>> And for clarification, what are the
  3318. 2:24:09additional costs?
  3319. 2:24:13>> Uh there shouldn't be any additional
  3320. 2:24:18costs right now. So, we're not going to
  3321. 2:24:21owe them. I just wanted clarification.
  3322. 2:24:22>> Correct. There's nothing indicates to me
  3323. 2:24:25that we would owe the federal government
  3324. 2:24:26any money at this point because they
  3325. 2:24:28were able to stop the printing that had
  3326. 2:24:31started last week when I when I gave
  3327. 2:24:33them a call. So, no additional cost and
  3328. 2:24:35I anticipate no requests from the
  3329. 2:24:38government at this point to pay back the
  3330. 2:24:40minimal cost that they did spend.
  3331. 2:24:41Correct.
  3332. 2:24:42>> So, they're going to eat the funds that
  3333. 2:24:44were paid with taxpayer dollars to get
  3334. 2:24:46this thing set up if we were send it.
  3335. 2:24:47>> It was minimal if anything. Okay. Well,
  3336. 2:24:50talking about cost, when we sent out
  3337. 2:24:51that constitutional survey last summer,
  3338. 2:24:53how much did the tribe, not the BIA,
  3339. 2:24:55send spend on that?
  3340. 2:24:56>> We spent about 68,000,
  3341. 2:24:59>> 70 grand.
  3342. 2:25:00>> Yeah. Give or take.
  3343. 2:25:02>> Okay, let's keep going.
  3344. 2:25:06>> All right. All right. So, the legal
  3345. 2:25:07department previously sent a memo and we
  3346. 2:25:09we workshopped it a while back of a
  3347. 2:25:10proposed timeline for implementation of
  3348. 2:25:13code
  3349. 2:25:14um including the structure of how we
  3350. 2:25:17envision things will probably land in
  3351. 2:25:20the new government as well as an
  3352. 2:25:2118-month timeline for code adoption
  3353. 2:25:23that's required under the new
  3354. 2:25:25constitution. This memo that we'll go
  3355. 2:25:27through today is an attempt to flag
  3356. 2:25:31items that should be priority for day
  3357. 2:25:34one sooner if the board is will if the
  3358. 2:25:38board is moving forward with
  3359. 2:25:40constitution reform. These day zero
  3360. 2:25:42things should be should and can be
  3361. 2:25:45things we can do proactively before the
  3362. 2:25:48day of separation.
  3363. 2:25:50If we move forward with the election in
  3364. 2:25:52November
  3365. 2:25:54and the tabulation happens and the
  3366. 2:25:56majority of those vote meet the
  3367. 2:25:58threshold required by under federal law
  3368. 2:26:00of 30% of registered voters and it's yes
  3369. 2:26:03they want this constitutional reform in
  3370. 2:26:06approximately 30 days from that date. So
  3371. 2:26:08sometime in December we will get a
  3372. 2:26:10letter from the BIA saying here yes good
  3373. 2:26:14job sue tribe your new constitution is
  3374. 2:26:16approved and that will be day one. and
  3375. 2:26:18it'll be sometime in December
  3376. 2:26:21under the current timeline if things
  3377. 2:26:23progress as as they as they will.
  3378. 2:26:29That being said, so day zero
  3379. 2:26:33things that we're recommending that we
  3380. 2:26:34talk about now and some of these things
  3381. 2:26:38I will advocate for even if our tribe
  3382. 2:26:40does not go forward with a separated
  3383. 2:26:42government and these are we'll go
  3384. 2:26:45through the code changes first. So, we
  3385. 2:26:47flagged chapter 61, barring individuals
  3386. 2:26:51from tribal lands. We're working on a
  3387. 2:26:53current revision. Ah, my Zoom crashed.
  3388. 2:26:56Hopefully that stays on the screen while
  3389. 2:26:58my computer restarts. Nope.
  3390. 2:27:01[clears throat]
  3391. 2:27:02Well, you have in your packet and I'll
  3392. 2:27:04put it back on the Zoom when I can. Uh,
  3393. 2:27:07barring individuals from tribal lands.
  3394. 2:27:09We're working on revisions now that work
  3395. 2:27:11under our current code in the new
  3396. 2:27:13constitution. The OGMA, the executive
  3397. 2:27:16branch, is the branch empowered to bar
  3398. 2:27:18individuals from tribal lands. So, we're
  3399. 2:27:20looking at how that might have to be
  3400. 2:27:22changed in the future. Right now, we
  3401. 2:27:24throw it all basically to the court
  3402. 2:27:26system. Um, there may need to be some
  3403. 2:27:28tweaks to that. Um, as we would not want
  3404. 2:27:31to diminish the OGA's office power to do
  3405. 2:27:33that. So, might we're workshopping that
  3406. 2:27:36and that's uh one that we feel like
  3407. 2:27:39should be a priority at day zero.
  3408. 2:27:42something that can happen now and I've
  3409. 2:27:44talked to a number of board members who
  3410. 2:27:45are interested in having a discussion
  3411. 2:27:47sooner than later in general with
  3412. 2:27:48barring individuals from tribal lands.
  3413. 2:27:50So, we flag that as a high priority day
  3414. 2:27:53zero. And then the other ones flagged
  3415. 2:27:55here are mostly ones that touch the
  3416. 2:27:57court system and um our rights as
  3417. 2:28:00citizens under our new constitution and
  3418. 2:28:02under our codes. that is criminal
  3419. 2:28:04procedure, criminal offenses, working on
  3420. 2:28:06the tribal law and order act revisions,
  3421. 2:28:09but there's other revisions that
  3422. 2:28:10probably need and should happen. Uh,
  3423. 2:28:13chapter 80, tribal court, civil
  3424. 2:28:15jurisdiction and civil procedure, our
  3425. 2:28:18appellet court,
  3426. 2:28:20uh, evictions, foreclosures, and civil
  3427. 2:28:22remedies and forfeite. These are all
  3428. 2:28:24there might be a couple that I missed,
  3429. 2:28:26but these are codes that touch the
  3430. 2:28:28operation of the court and affect our
  3431. 2:28:31individual rights um both criminally and
  3432. 2:28:33civily as tribal citizens. And we
  3433. 2:28:35believe they should be workshopped
  3434. 2:28:37sooner than later. They should be at
  3435. 2:28:39least ready on day one, but if they can
  3436. 2:28:41be ready sooner, that's great. some of
  3437. 2:28:43these reforms, even if we didn't
  3438. 2:28:45separate into three branches, I would be
  3439. 2:28:48pushing this board, and we've talked
  3440. 2:28:50about it in different contexts before,
  3441. 2:28:52to legislate more judicial independence
  3442. 2:28:55and better court processes for our
  3443. 2:28:58citizens anyway. So, we've identified
  3444. 2:29:00these as as day zero. Do it sooner than
  3445. 2:29:02later in our recommendation. And I'll
  3446. 2:29:04pause for a second if there's any
  3447. 2:29:05questions.
  3448. 2:29:08>> Questions, not comments, guys. We got to
  3449. 2:29:10move through this. Tyler, then Rob,
  3450. 2:29:12>> I got the I get the day zero thing, but
  3451. 2:29:14you get the day zero and the same stuff
  3452. 2:29:15as the final three months for the six
  3453. 2:29:19chapter 61.
  3454. 2:29:22>> So, I didn't Yeah, I did not change the
  3455. 2:29:25timeline. Is that what you're asking
  3456. 2:29:27about, Tyler?
  3457. 2:29:27>> Yeah, because uh day zero code, the one
  3458. 2:29:30that conflicts with it is chapter 61,
  3459. 2:29:32the barring individuals. It's like on
  3460. 2:29:33the final three months of the 18-month
  3461. 2:29:35implementation.
  3462. 2:29:36>> I'll have I'll have to tweak that one. I
  3463. 2:29:37apologize. I tried to I tried to move
  3464. 2:29:39them around a little bit, but I must
  3465. 2:29:40have just missed that one. That's that
  3466. 2:29:42can be subject to change before we have
  3467. 2:29:44you guys vote on it.
  3468. 2:29:45>> Okay. Yeah. No, no questions. And then
  3469. 2:29:46where are you at having these before us
  3470. 2:29:50>> for since it's day zero?
  3471. 2:29:53>> So, we have working drafts of the
  3472. 2:29:56appeals court which we previously
  3473. 2:29:58workshopped that substantially finished.
  3474. 2:30:01We have working uh drafts of the civil
  3475. 2:30:04jurisdiction, the criminal offense,
  3476. 2:30:09and then I'm working on the criminal
  3477. 2:30:11procedure in the barring of individuals.
  3478. 2:30:14So, we have we have about half of these
  3479. 2:30:15ready to be workshop soon if the if the
  3480. 2:30:18board is willing. The ones we don't have
  3481. 2:30:19any pen to paper yet, but they may not
  3482. 2:30:22need a huge amount of tweaks are the 83
  3483. 2:30:25and 84, the evictions and foreclosures
  3484. 2:30:27and civil remedies and forfeite. I just
  3485. 2:30:31haven't had the opportunity for me or my
  3486. 2:30:32staff to look at those in depth to see
  3487. 2:30:34if they need any tweaks or how
  3488. 2:30:37substantial they are. But we flagged
  3489. 2:30:38them because they do affect individual
  3490. 2:30:40rights as as citizens, but they may not
  3491. 2:30:43need as much revisions as like chapter
  3492. 2:30:4570 and 71, chapter 80 and 82 will, but a
  3493. 2:30:48lot of those we have drafts ready. We
  3494. 2:30:50tried to workshop some of them
  3495. 2:30:51previously and they're they can just be
  3496. 2:30:54thrown out of workshop whenever the
  3497. 2:30:56board has room frankly. And with Chief
  3498. 2:30:58Judge Leaport on, and I know is totally
  3499. 2:30:59separate, but um can we just get the
  3500. 2:31:02courts to recommend us a chief judge for
  3501. 2:31:05the appallet so we can get that on the
  3502. 2:31:06books and get it done with? I mean,
  3503. 2:31:08that's a day zero thing as well, so we
  3504. 2:31:10might as well
  3505. 2:31:11act as if we're independent or separate
  3506. 2:31:14and get a recommendation from the
  3507. 2:31:15courts.
  3508. 2:31:16>> I do have I did have a number of emails
  3509. 2:31:19back and forth with our magistrate and
  3510. 2:31:22there are there are applicants ready. We
  3511. 2:31:24we needed to just the court needs to
  3512. 2:31:25help with the with Lana to schedule the
  3513. 2:31:28interviews and we can have judge
  3514. 2:31:30Leaport. Normally the chief judge hadn't
  3515. 2:31:33historically weighed in. I'm not opposed
  3516. 2:31:34to it. Um the legal department has and
  3517. 2:31:37then the board can and we do like an
  3518. 2:31:38interview of all the applicants and then
  3519. 2:31:40we recommend to the board who of those
  3520. 2:31:42interviews we think are the best ones to
  3521. 2:31:44choose and that I think I don't want to
  3522. 2:31:46speak for the court maybe judge Leaport
  3523. 2:31:48has some insight but I think that's can
  3524. 2:31:50happen any time now. I think we have
  3525. 2:31:52enough we have applicants. We just have
  3526. 2:31:53to coordinate now with the court to get
  3527. 2:31:55the interviews and then get it on one of
  3528. 2:31:57your agendas.
  3529. 2:31:57>> I mean either way that needs to get
  3530. 2:31:59cleaned up. So it it seems like low
  3531. 2:32:01hanging hanging fruit because it's
  3532. 2:32:02something we need to do now anyway. So I
  3533. 2:32:04agree.
  3534. 2:32:04>> All right. Thank you,
  3535. 2:32:06>> Rob.
  3536. 2:32:09>> So you mentioned that we're not going to
  3537. 2:32:10incur great cost from the initiating the
  3538. 2:32:14amendment change with the BIA.
  3539. 2:32:17>> That is that's correct. At this point,
  3540. 2:32:19we're the BIA has not incurred any great
  3541. 2:32:21costs. So, they will not be sending us
  3542. 2:32:23any uh any bill at this point. If if we
  3543. 2:32:26end up canceling the
  3544. 2:32:27>> Are we 100% sure we're not going to get
  3545. 2:32:29that bill?
  3546. 2:32:31>> I'm n I'll say I'm 99% sure. Okay.
  3547. 2:32:34>> I will not say 100%.
  3548. 2:32:36>> Oh, thank God. Thank God. Uh, also,
  3549. 2:32:38could you draft an amendment to the
  3550. 2:32:40resolution I have on the table to
  3551. 2:32:42include the cost of the survey? If we're
  3552. 2:32:45not going to listen, we better pay for
  3553. 2:32:47it.
  3554. 2:32:49Yes.
  3555. 2:32:49>> All right, we can keep going, guys.
  3556. 2:32:54>> All right, so those those are the codes.
  3557. 2:32:56Um I've sent this to the executives so
  3558. 2:32:58they can weigh in and we might have to
  3559. 2:33:00tweak this um as we go forward.
  3560. 2:33:05But I think standing up the court, as we
  3561. 2:33:07talked about before, is like priority
  3562. 2:33:09numero uno and and we already have a
  3563. 2:33:11really good core system. I'm just
  3564. 2:33:12fleshing it out more to function the
  3565. 2:33:14best I can in a three branch government
  3566. 2:33:16for day zero processes things we should
  3567. 2:33:19talk about and figure out uh before the
  3568. 2:33:21separation
  3569. 2:33:23is we would like the board to workshop
  3570. 2:33:27and discuss the transition resolution if
  3571. 2:33:29we get to it today uh great if not as
  3572. 2:33:32soon as possible. we've talked about
  3573. 2:33:33before and it's been in multiple memos
  3574. 2:33:35that I've sent the board. But the
  3575. 2:33:36transition resolution would solidify by
  3576. 2:33:40law like these are the dates that these
  3577. 2:33:42things must be hit that the date if we
  3578. 2:33:44go forward with constitutional reform.
  3579. 2:33:47It sets date certain where codes need to
  3580. 2:33:49be adopted and it also creates that
  3581. 2:33:51stability where we're we're maintaining
  3582. 2:33:54our current processes, maintaining our
  3583. 2:33:56current executive team etc. while we
  3584. 2:33:59transition and figure out the landscape
  3585. 2:34:02of the land, right, and what needs to
  3586. 2:34:04change. I think that that transition
  3587. 2:34:06resolution um is going to hold everyone
  3588. 2:34:09accountable, all three branches and and
  3589. 2:34:11all the staff.
  3590. 2:34:14Uh Tyler already mentioned this, but who
  3591. 2:34:16is your court of appeals? We got to we
  3592. 2:34:18got to figure that out sooner than
  3593. 2:34:19later. Um, we don't have a fully
  3594. 2:34:23appointed court of appeals because we
  3595. 2:34:24did a resolution in 2024
  3596. 2:34:27that mandated all five judges sit on all
  3597. 2:34:30cases. It used to be just three of the
  3598. 2:34:31five had to sit on the cases.
  3599. 2:34:34Um, and so we have two justices who did
  3600. 2:34:37not resign, Judge Botch and Judge
  3601. 2:34:40Corbier. And Judge Deore did resign, but
  3602. 2:34:42the board never officially accepted her
  3603. 2:34:44resol resignation. and I've spoken with
  3604. 2:34:46her and she would like to rescend it and
  3605. 2:34:49be in consideration potentially to be to
  3606. 2:34:51stay on and or be appointed.
  3607. 2:34:54Uh and then like I said earlier, we have
  3608. 2:34:55multiple applicants. We we need to get
  3609. 2:34:58>> Who's wanting to get reappointed?
  3610. 2:34:59>> Uh Judge Judge Deore
  3611. 2:35:02resigned. We never took action as a
  3612. 2:35:04board. the board never took action,
  3613. 2:35:05excuse me, to accept her resignation and
  3614. 2:35:08she would like to resend it and be in
  3615. 2:35:11consideration for either a seated
  3616. 2:35:14position position on our court of
  3617. 2:35:16appeals or a reserve judge.
  3618. 2:35:18>> Okay. Yeah, I'm fine with either. I
  3619. 2:35:19think she does a good job.
  3620. 2:35:20>> And then like Tyler said, we need to we
  3621. 2:35:22need to name a chief judge. We have a
  3622. 2:35:24sue tribe member who's on the reserve.
  3623. 2:35:25We can call him up to as soon as the
  3624. 2:35:28board wants to put it on agenda, call
  3625. 2:35:29him up and make him chief judge if you
  3626. 2:35:31want to. He's he's been waiting to see
  3627. 2:35:33what we're going to do. I've had
  3628. 2:35:35sporadic contact with him, but it is a
  3629. 2:35:36sue tribe citizen. I'm not sure how many
  3630. 2:35:38applicants
  3631. 2:35:40who are waiting in the wings are also
  3632. 2:35:42such tribe members. Um, but that's a
  3633. 2:35:45discussion that the court can have at
  3634. 2:35:46the board when we schedule those
  3635. 2:35:47interviews.
  3636. 2:35:48>> Yeah. And he's been a reser for at least
  3637. 2:35:50two, three years. Go ahead, Judge Leort.
  3638. 2:35:53And then I'm going to call on Kim Grall.
  3639. 2:35:55>> I'm so sorry for interrupting all those
  3640. 2:35:57disrespectful of me. Okay. I apologize.
  3641. 2:35:59Um, I was just going to say I'm I'm
  3642. 2:36:01happy to have Josh provide you all a
  3643. 2:36:03written update too on the list of
  3644. 2:36:05candidates that he sent over. Um, per
  3645. 2:36:07the current code and the way it's
  3646. 2:36:09organized, the magistrate and the
  3647. 2:36:12basically who who defaults as the court
  3648. 2:36:14of appeals clerk handles it, which makes
  3649. 2:36:15sense because I shouldn't be involved in
  3650. 2:36:17selecting who reviews my opinions,
  3651. 2:36:19right? So, um, so I want to try and keep
  3652. 2:36:22that as separate as possible. I'm happy
  3653. 2:36:24to be involved to the extent that you
  3654. 2:36:26all think that's appropriate and it's
  3655. 2:36:27and it's like waved somehow on some sort
  3656. 2:36:29of record, but um we can get that
  3657. 2:36:32information over to you all from Josh uh
  3658. 2:36:33Ryan if that's helpful. I'll send him an
  3659. 2:36:35email right now.
  3660. 2:36:37>> Thank you. I believe you may have sent
  3661. 2:36:38it to Lana previously and I but can you
  3662. 2:36:40if you can send it again that would be
  3663. 2:36:42great so we can get it get those
  3664. 2:36:44scheduled for interviews and get them in
  3665. 2:36:45front of the board.
  3666. 2:36:55Yeah, I don't know how we normally
  3667. 2:36:56scheduled them, honestly. So,
  3668. 2:37:00>> all right, go ahead, Kim.
  3669. 2:37:02>> Okay. Um, when did Judge Deore resign?
  3670. 2:37:05Because I don't remember hearing
  3671. 2:37:06anything about that.
  3672. 2:37:11>> Uh,
  3673. 2:37:13>> it was around the same time that all the
  3674. 2:37:14court turnover happened. I don't
  3675. 2:37:16remember the specific date. I'm sure
  3676. 2:37:18Lana has it somewhere in her name.
  3677. 2:37:20>> Okay, thank you.
  3678. 2:37:21>> She's she's one of our attorney judges,
  3679. 2:37:24non-native.
  3680. 2:37:28>> All right, we keep going.
  3681. 2:37:30>> Um Holly might have some insight into
  3682. 2:37:32this. Her and I talked about it, but one
  3683. 2:37:34thing to flag for discussion is
  3684. 2:37:39right now our judges or our judge is a
  3685. 2:37:42is a team member. So they are they get
  3686. 2:37:44certain benefits, but elected positions
  3687. 2:37:47like the board doesn't get access to all
  3688. 2:37:50of our benefits. So we have to figure
  3689. 2:37:51out what we're going to do going forward
  3690. 2:37:54and that should be determined before
  3691. 2:37:56we're making all these appointments and
  3692. 2:37:57and then in 2028 having all these
  3693. 2:37:59elections under the new constitution.
  3694. 2:38:02Um and I don't know if there's a
  3695. 2:38:03financial cost to that change or
  3696. 2:38:05anything, but I can pause and let Holly
  3697. 2:38:07kind of give you the lay of that
  3698. 2:38:09landscape.
  3699. 2:38:10>> You go ahead, Holly. it would be the
  3700. 2:38:12401k that if they're an elected
  3701. 2:38:15position, they would not be eligible
  3702. 2:38:17for. So, they would be eligible for the
  3703. 2:38:20health, um the long-term disability and
  3704. 2:38:23the life.
  3705. 2:38:25And the 401k would be what they would
  3706. 2:38:27not be eligible to receive. Now, in my
  3707. 2:38:30projections, I did put
  3708. 2:38:33um when I thought they were going to be
  3709. 2:38:34employees, I did put that value in
  3710. 2:38:36there. I want to say Oh, let me pull up
  3711. 2:38:39that. So there's something that
  3712. 2:38:40prohibits elected officials from
  3713. 2:38:42receiving a 401k.
  3714. 2:38:43>> Yeah, they're not eligible for it. So do
  3715. 2:38:45you want these positions to be as
  3716. 2:38:47they're elected not eligible for the
  3717. 2:38:48401k then? I'm assuming
  3718. 2:38:51>> I mean there's no other alternative. So
  3719. 2:38:52I mean we're kind of stuck between a
  3720. 2:38:54rock and a hard place because at the
  3721. 2:38:55same time we're not eligible for the
  3722. 2:38:57401k. Our membership does not support us
  3723. 2:39:00receiving a separate pension from what
  3724. 2:39:01they receive because I mean you can
  3725. 2:39:03break it down. It's more lucrative than
  3726. 2:39:04what the 401k is. So there's no other
  3727. 2:39:07option at this point. I mean it's about
  3728. 2:39:08service. It's not a a career. Basically,
  3729. 2:39:10that's how I interpret it. I mean, I'm
  3730. 2:39:12in the same position. I was elected here
  3731. 2:39:14in 2020. Not a single cent that I've
  3732. 2:39:16earned is going towards social security.
  3733. 2:39:18And back when I was a therapist and
  3734. 2:39:20board member, I made a lot more money,
  3735. 2:39:22you know. So, this is about public
  3736. 2:39:23service.
  3737. 2:39:25>> Okay.
  3738. 2:39:26>> Yeah. Go ahead, Mike.
  3739. 2:39:28>> Along that same regards, then if they're
  3740. 2:39:29not eligible for 401k, are they eligible
  3741. 2:39:31for social security?
  3742. 2:39:34That would not be I can confirm but that
  3743. 2:39:36then would not probably be factored into
  3744. 2:39:39that either. Right. They're going to be
  3745. 2:39:40unelected unelected.
  3746. 2:39:42>> Yes.
  3747. 2:39:42>> Okay.
  3748. 2:39:44>> That's only because we decide they're
  3749. 2:39:46not eligible though. There's nothing at
  3750. 2:39:47the federal level that prohibits it.
  3751. 2:39:51>> But that's something we can explore as a
  3752. 2:39:52body.
  3753. 2:39:53>> Yes. Under the general welfare exemption
  3754. 2:39:55act, the board could adopt participation
  3755. 2:39:57in social security like all the other
  3756. 2:39:59tribes across the country are doing
  3757. 2:40:01since 2015.
  3758. 2:40:04Okay.
  3759. 2:40:05>> All righty. Let's keep going, guys.
  3760. 2:40:09And then uh day zero, I think we should
  3761. 2:40:13start creating the associate judge
  3762. 2:40:14position. I can work with judge leaport
  3763. 2:40:17on that and so we can get it created
  3764. 2:40:18factored uh on our wage grid and that
  3765. 2:40:21can help determine uh the financial
  3766. 2:40:23costs that we might incur to fund that
  3767. 2:40:25fund that position. That would probably
  3768. 2:40:27be a more full-time position. May maybe
  3769. 2:40:29Judge Leapor can correct me if I'm
  3770. 2:40:31wrong, but unlike the Supreme Court,
  3771. 2:40:33probably both of our trial court judges
  3772. 2:40:34are much more full-time.
  3773. 2:40:39>> That that is correct. That one I do
  3774. 2:40:41believe needs to be full-time appellet
  3775. 2:40:42justices. Again, I think that's
  3776. 2:40:43negotiable.
  3777. 2:40:47>> All right. Day one action items.
  3778. 2:40:52Obviously, all the code drafting uh
  3779. 2:40:54starts starts day one. some of it
  3780. 2:40:56hopefully sooner, but we'll have you
  3781. 2:41:00vote at least on the transition
  3782. 2:41:02resolution that will solidify our
  3783. 2:41:0318-month timeline. I'll look at if
  3784. 2:41:05there's any more tweaks that need to
  3785. 2:41:06happen. Like Tyler pointed out, there's
  3786. 2:41:08probably a couple codes I missed that
  3787. 2:41:10might need to be higher priority.
  3788. 2:41:12Um, but on day one, I would recommend
  3789. 2:41:16that we adopt any day zero codes that
  3790. 2:41:18are still outstanding that we didn't get
  3791. 2:41:19to before day of separation.
  3792. 2:41:22And I would like to have ready an
  3793. 2:41:24alternative dispute resolution code.
  3794. 2:41:27Several of you uh alluded to that
  3795. 2:41:29earlier, a mediation, some kind of uh
  3796. 2:41:32statutory requirement for the branches
  3797. 2:41:34and for different litigants to to have
  3798. 2:41:36to mediate in certain circumstances
  3799. 2:41:38instead of jumping right into court
  3800. 2:41:40litigation.
  3801. 2:41:42um flesh out more our peace. We have a
  3802. 2:41:44sort of a peacemaking code section right
  3803. 2:41:46now in our code to flesh that out more
  3804. 2:41:48and see how that could interplay with
  3805. 2:41:50the alternative dispute resolution,
  3806. 2:41:51mediation, etc. And I think that is
  3807. 2:41:54something that u my team and the court I
  3808. 2:41:56think we together uh we can work on
  3809. 2:41:59having a draft uh for discussion uh day
  3810. 2:42:03one. I don't have a draft currently.
  3811. 2:42:04There's other drafts I've looked at from
  3812. 2:42:05other tribes that we certainly don't
  3813. 2:42:07have to recreate the wheel. That's
  3814. 2:42:08something that we think should be day
  3815. 2:42:09one.
  3816. 2:42:11Also day one the tribal coun the board
  3817. 2:42:14will switch to the tribal council and
  3818. 2:42:16the constitution names at least one
  3819. 2:42:19officer of that tribal council that that
  3820. 2:42:22is different than today and that is the
  3821. 2:42:23speaker of the council. So that should
  3822. 2:42:25be elected uh day one at their very
  3823. 2:42:27first meeting of the tribal council.
  3824. 2:42:32uh the with the authorities the
  3825. 2:42:33immediate change would as we as we the
  3826. 2:42:36legal department reads the constitution
  3827. 2:42:39would be the the OGO would step down
  3828. 2:42:41from sitting and sharing those
  3829. 2:42:42authorities. The speaker of the tribal
  3830. 2:42:44council would share those authorities up
  3831. 2:42:47until we adopt new authority codes per
  3832. 2:42:51our previous discussions on creating
  3833. 2:42:54different governing bodies that are not
  3834. 2:42:56tribal council. But immediately day one,
  3835. 2:42:58unless those codes are also ready, but
  3836. 2:43:01they're not on our super high priority
  3837. 2:43:04list right now. Um, tribal council would
  3838. 2:43:07retain that role during the 18-month
  3839. 2:43:10transition, and the speaker would share
  3840. 2:43:12those authorities pending the code
  3841. 2:43:14changes.
  3842. 2:43:15>> So, if we don't mind pausing, this is
  3843. 2:43:16one of the biggest sources of
  3844. 2:43:18misconception about this constitutional
  3845. 2:43:20amendment. It will be about who the
  3846. 2:43:22OGA's office supervises. So as it
  3847. 2:43:25stands, the authorities will supervise
  3848. 2:43:27the majority of operations. So we
  3849. 2:43:29already have an established authority
  3850. 2:43:30for the gaming authority. Only change is
  3851. 2:43:32I would step down. The speaker would
  3852. 2:43:34pick up chairing those meetings until we
  3853. 2:43:37could populate that committee with
  3854. 2:43:38qualified people. Same thing would apply
  3855. 2:43:40to the EDC authority and we're talking
  3856. 2:43:42about building a health authority as
  3857. 2:43:43well. So if you guys want to see how
  3858. 2:43:45this will operate, if you guys go to
  3859. 2:43:47Little Travers's website, they recently
  3860. 2:43:49posted a couple vacancies in those
  3861. 2:43:52authorities and they have the
  3862. 2:43:53qualifications listed. basically states
  3863. 2:43:55something like this. Hey, we're looking
  3864. 2:43:56for a gaming commissioner. If you're
  3865. 2:43:58interested in applying for this, contact
  3866. 2:44:00the chair of the tribe. She will
  3867. 2:44:02nominate you and then it will go through
  3868. 2:44:04a confirmation process, but it has basic
  3869. 2:44:07qualifications and credentials that
  3870. 2:44:08you're supposed to have. So, like, you
  3871. 2:44:10know, so many years working in gaming,
  3872. 2:44:12maybe in education that's aligned with
  3873. 2:44:14that as well. But, I mean, the model is
  3874. 2:44:16right there in front of us and you only
  3875. 2:44:18have to go about an hour and a half
  3876. 2:44:19south of here. Go on Little Travers's
  3877. 2:44:21website and you can see how those
  3878. 2:44:22authorities would operate. Aaron,
  3879. 2:44:24>> one other thing, and I've said this, you
  3880. 2:44:26know, again, beat a dead horse, is we're
  3881. 2:44:29the gaming authority currently.
  3882. 2:44:31We're also the gaming commission with
  3883. 2:44:33the exception of, I think, one board
  3884. 2:44:34member. And the National Indian Gaming
  3885. 2:44:38Commission has posted bulletins for 20
  3886. 2:44:40years to tell us that's not advisable.
  3887. 2:44:43And tribes all across the country do not
  3888. 2:44:45have their tribal council be their
  3889. 2:44:48gaming authority. First of all, they're
  3890. 2:44:50not also the gaming authority. And
  3891. 2:44:52they're certainly not their gaming
  3892. 2:44:53commission because there's an inherent
  3893. 2:44:55conflict with being the gaming authority
  3894. 2:44:57and the gaming commission because the
  3895. 2:44:59gaming commission is the regulatory body
  3896. 2:45:01over the gaming authority but we're the
  3897. 2:45:04same people with the exception of one
  3898. 2:45:06board member. So, um, so I'm hoping that
  3899. 2:45:11when this
  3900. 2:45:13I'm hoping that if we move forward
  3901. 2:45:15tomorrow at all that we don't get smart
  3902. 2:45:18and just populate those authorities with
  3903. 2:45:20board members because um, you know, with
  3904. 2:45:24a few exceptions over the years, like
  3905. 2:45:26for this, we're talking about a health
  3906. 2:45:28authority, there might be one or two
  3907. 2:45:30people that might be qualified to be
  3908. 2:45:31that from this board to that entity. Um,
  3909. 2:45:35the same with gaming authority. There
  3910. 2:45:37might be one or two people. I don't know
  3911. 2:45:39if anybody currently has experience as
  3912. 2:45:42executives in a gaming authority
  3913. 2:45:45structure. Um, so it seems like what we
  3914. 2:45:49would like or should want is to get
  3915. 2:45:52experts in their field that have either
  3916. 2:45:55credentials or years of experience in
  3917. 2:45:57their field to be those experts. I
  3918. 2:46:00wouldn't purport to be a gaming
  3919. 2:46:02authority executive. I wouldn't purport
  3920. 2:46:04to be well I might have some health
  3921. 2:46:06health background actually I do um but
  3922. 2:46:10I'm not a health executive and I don't
  3923. 2:46:12know anyway so I I hope that when that
  3924. 2:46:15happens we don't just because it's
  3925. 2:46:17incestuous for us to be the gaming
  3926. 2:46:19authority and the gaming commission
  3927. 2:46:20can't even make a straight argument
  3928. 2:46:22about that one um so but that's the
  3929. 2:46:24structure we have currently have
  3930. 2:46:29>> you guys might have went over it I just
  3931. 2:46:30ran to the restroom um on day won the
  3932. 2:46:33actions elect a speaker of the
  3933. 2:46:36legislative branch. Is that just a
  3934. 2:46:38simple vote of the legislative branch?
  3935. 2:46:40>> Yeah, that would be the legislative
  3936. 2:46:42branch within itself elects who they
  3937. 2:46:45want to be their
  3938. 2:46:45>> simple vote of up or down.
  3939. 2:46:47>> Um and will there still be a treasurer
  3940. 2:46:50and secretary?
  3941. 2:46:51>> Yeah, those are still in the bylaws. So
  3942. 2:46:53those those would be retained. Yes.
  3943. 2:46:55>> Okay, let's keep going, guys.
  3944. 2:46:58>> Uh so day one, hopefully during day
  3945. 2:47:00zero, we've got the associate judge
  3946. 2:47:02position. uh created, factored, and uh
  3947. 2:47:05approved by the board. And so we can uh
  3948. 2:47:09post the associate judge position, try
  3949. 2:47:11to recruit and appoint someone or um to
  3950. 2:47:14be determined. We can work with judge
  3951. 2:47:16Leaport and see if that is not a
  3952. 2:47:18necessity until the 2028 elections.
  3953. 2:47:21That'll be the first election cycle um
  3954. 2:47:24that would kick in all the new elections
  3955. 2:47:26under the adopted constitution. Um, so
  3956. 2:47:30that one is we have as a day one, but
  3957. 2:47:32that one maybe can fall off day one if
  3958. 2:47:34we don't need a day one. Um,
  3959. 2:47:39but something that we should be at least
  3960. 2:47:41working towards um building up either
  3961. 2:47:44way because in 2028 that that position
  3962. 2:47:47can be an elected position.
  3963. 2:47:52Supreme Court day one.
  3964. 2:47:54Um hopefully we've we've uh during day
  3965. 2:47:58zero
  3966. 2:48:00or close to day one we have everything
  3967. 2:48:02ready to go to to populate the Supreme
  3968. 2:48:04Court under the new threeperson panel
  3969. 2:48:08per the new constitution. And if we've
  3970. 2:48:11named a chief judge, chief justice as we
  3971. 2:48:13call them in the new structure, then
  3972. 2:48:15they will help manage the court. But
  3973. 2:48:17with that, we'll have to figure out how
  3974. 2:48:19to train them up on operations and
  3975. 2:48:21budgets because in the new constitution,
  3976. 2:48:23the chief justice of the Supreme Court
  3977. 2:48:26is the um elected official empowered to
  3978. 2:48:32manage and create and present those
  3979. 2:48:34those budgets. So they do have unlike
  3980. 2:48:36the other two associate judges,
  3981. 2:48:39justices, excuse me, the chief justice
  3982. 2:48:41of the Supreme Court does have explicit
  3983. 2:48:43authority and responsibilities under the
  3984. 2:48:45Constitution that they'll have to get up
  3985. 2:48:46to speed speed on and they they will be
  3986. 2:48:49in charge um just like chief judge the
  3987. 2:48:51court would be for the trial court of
  3988. 2:48:54managing all the the affairs, the
  3989. 2:48:56finances and the and the day-to-day of
  3990. 2:48:58the Supreme Court. Just keep that in
  3991. 2:49:01mind as you're appointing a chief judge
  3992. 2:49:03in the interim um before they get
  3993. 2:49:06elected in 2028. Someone who can take
  3994. 2:49:10the reigns and and be that executive
  3995. 2:49:11level type position.
  3996. 2:49:18Um hire a Supreme Court clerk. So, this
  3997. 2:49:22is another one that I would like some
  3998. 2:49:24input more with with the court
  3999. 2:49:27potentially, but uh right now our
  4000. 2:49:30magistrate of the of our court helps
  4001. 2:49:33manage both the trial court and the
  4002. 2:49:36court of appeals. Um our advice
  4003. 2:49:38previously and it stands today is we
  4004. 2:49:40don't believe that that same position
  4005. 2:49:43should manage the affairs of both
  4006. 2:49:45courts. So, u Holly had budgeted in her
  4007. 2:49:48projections and and in my summary
  4008. 2:49:52projections, this is also a budgeted
  4009. 2:49:53position at least part-time
  4010. 2:49:56um for a Supreme Court uh court
  4011. 2:49:59administrator that manages all their
  4012. 2:50:02affairs separately. So, you keep those
  4013. 2:50:04really clear distinction in lines drawn
  4014. 2:50:07uh for the court. And that's something
  4015. 2:50:08that should happen day one or if not day
  4016. 2:50:11one if it falls off this list it should
  4017. 2:50:13be being built towards for in in that
  4018. 2:50:16first year building towards that uh 2028
  4019. 2:50:19election when we are electing our chief
  4020. 2:50:21justice.
  4021. 2:50:24Initially the freedom information
  4022. 2:50:26requests will have to move away from the
  4023. 2:50:28board administrative office because
  4024. 2:50:30under the new constitution the Lana's
  4025. 2:50:34excited about that uh legal we won't get
  4026. 2:50:37to pull ourselves out of it
  4027. 2:50:38unfortunately or fortunately uh but
  4028. 2:50:40because the executive branch implements
  4029. 2:50:43and administers all the functions of the
  4030. 2:50:45government that are adopted by the
  4031. 2:50:47tribal council the executive uh branch
  4032. 2:50:52doesn't necessarily have to the um the
  4033. 2:50:54OGMA's office. We've identified that as
  4034. 2:50:57uh maybe the initial landing spot for
  4035. 2:50:59it, but it would be handinhand with the
  4036. 2:51:00legal department as it is now to help
  4037. 2:51:02manage those freedom information
  4038. 2:51:05requests. But that can immediately and
  4039. 2:51:06should immediately fall away from the
  4040. 2:51:08legislative branch and move towards
  4041. 2:51:09executive branch to allow them to
  4042. 2:51:11exercise their author proper authority
  4043. 2:51:13under the constitution.
  4044. 2:51:15>> Yep. And right now I don't have any
  4045. 2:51:17control over what's foyed and what's
  4046. 2:51:19granted. I just want to put that out
  4047. 2:51:21there. Sometimes I get blamed for it,
  4048. 2:51:22but I don't have anything. Lana does an
  4049. 2:51:25awesome job and she follows code. She
  4050. 2:51:26works with the legal department, but I'm
  4051. 2:51:28not in that at all. Aaron,
  4052. 2:51:30>> and that's the way it'll be afterwards.
  4053. 2:51:32Neither the um executive nor the legisl
  4054. 2:51:35legislature will make the decisions.
  4055. 2:51:38However, they will write the code. So a
  4056. 2:51:41lot of times, you know, what we're
  4057. 2:51:43hearing out there is all of this fake
  4058. 2:51:45news about how this is going to create
  4059. 2:51:48this big, you know, power structure
  4060. 2:51:50under the chairman, which is it's it's
  4061. 2:51:53idiocy to be honest. Anybody that's
  4062. 2:51:55promoting that doesn't know what they're
  4063. 2:51:56talking about. The board will still
  4064. 2:51:59write our laws. The board will still
  4065. 2:52:03appropriate our budgets. and then
  4066. 2:52:05whoever is implementing it has to follow
  4067. 2:52:08the law that the board the legislature
  4068. 2:52:11wrote. So this notion that somehow it's
  4069. 2:52:14going to amass power under the executive
  4070. 2:52:16branch and discretionary authority
  4071. 2:52:18that's just the opposite of what this is
  4072. 2:52:20doing right now. That is what we
  4073. 2:52:22currently have because we have
  4074. 2:52:23discretionary authority under one branch
  4075. 2:52:26with no ability to challenge those
  4076. 2:52:28decisions. In the future, if um if
  4077. 2:52:31you're denied your FOYA, you can file a
  4078. 2:52:34lawsuit. Right now, you can't. Oh, can
  4079. 2:52:36you
  4080. 2:52:37>> you can Yeah, you can you can appeal to
  4081. 2:52:38the to the tribal court.
  4082. 2:52:40>> Oh, okay.
  4083. 2:52:41>> Well, and then then we can fire the
  4084. 2:52:43judge.
  4085. 2:52:44>> Important to note, under this new model,
  4086. 2:52:46the majority of key employees would be
  4087. 2:52:48supervised by an authority. Not my
  4088. 2:52:51office, not by the board of directors.
  4089. 2:52:52The board of directors would be vacated.
  4090. 2:52:54So, you'd have the gaming authority. You
  4091. 2:52:56got two key employees within that. you
  4092. 2:52:58have EDC, you have one key employee in
  4093. 2:53:00that and then you have um health if we
  4094. 2:53:02create that. So there'd be a handful of
  4095. 2:53:04key employees that would become direct
  4096. 2:53:06reports to the chairman's office, but
  4097. 2:53:07the majority of operations would be
  4098. 2:53:09would be supervised by professional
  4099. 2:53:11authorities that within 18 months myself
  4100. 2:53:14and the board of directors would vacate
  4101. 2:53:16those seats and through a nomination and
  4102. 2:53:17confirmation process, we'd have
  4103. 2:53:19professionals fill those seats.
  4104. 2:53:22>> Right? the executive branch, the OGAM
  4105. 2:53:24would oversee just the governmental
  4106. 2:53:25executives, government CEO, government
  4107. 2:53:28CFO, CIO, general counsel, health until
  4108. 2:53:32we get health.
  4109. 2:53:32>> It says government in front of it. It's
  4110. 2:53:34a direct report to the chairman's
  4111. 2:53:35office. No matter who the chairman is,
  4112. 2:53:37if I'm that person, I do a bad job. Fire
  4113. 2:53:39me come election time. I'll be
  4114. 2:53:41completely fine. But the majority of
  4115. 2:53:43operations will be supervised by
  4116. 2:53:45professional staff instead of elected
  4117. 2:53:46leadership.
  4118. 2:53:48>> Did I miss a hand?
  4119. 2:53:49>> Yeah.
  4120. 2:53:50>> Okay. Go ahead.
  4121. 2:53:51>> Yeah. So in light of what Erin just
  4122. 2:53:53said, so just so I understand it. Um and
  4123. 2:53:56I like this layout that you have for day
  4124. 2:53:58zero, day one, day two and all all
  4125. 2:54:00through that because this this um says a
  4126. 2:54:04lot and puts a lot into um vision on
  4127. 2:54:08what's moving forward. And I like to see
  4128. 2:54:10this so we can refer back to it. And I
  4129. 2:54:12wasn't going to say much today, but the
  4130. 2:54:14freedom of information requests that
  4131. 2:54:16will go from the board administrator and
  4132. 2:54:19she's happy about that to the chairman's
  4133. 2:54:22office.
  4134. 2:54:22>> Yeah.
  4135. 2:54:23>> The OGIMA. So the OGA's office will have
  4136. 2:54:25it, but if he denies something or I deny
  4137. 2:54:27something if I'm ever there or anybody
  4138. 2:54:29else that's ever there, it says that it
  4139. 2:54:32says it right here.
  4140. 2:54:33illegal.
  4141. 2:54:34>> So we have it going right now to the
  4142. 2:54:36>> freedom of information request move from
  4143. 2:54:38board administrator office tribal
  4144. 2:54:40council to the chairman's office OGIMA.
  4145. 2:54:42That's what it says.
  4146. 2:54:43>> I and I said that legal would as we do
  4147. 2:54:45now we would assist
  4148. 2:54:46>> you're going to help out assist with
  4149. 2:54:48that.
  4150. 2:54:48>> And if you would let me finish. Yes. So
  4151. 2:54:50if it goes to the OGA's office whether
  4152. 2:54:52it's Austin or somebody else someday
  4153. 2:54:55members would have standing in court if
  4154. 2:54:57the OGA denied those.
  4155. 2:55:00>> Correct.
  4156. 2:55:01>> Correct. And right now we're right now
  4157. 2:55:02we do have that's one of the explicit
  4158. 2:55:04areas
  4159. 2:55:05>> commented that didn't make sense because
  4160. 2:55:07it said just something completely
  4161. 2:55:09different in the day
  4162. 2:55:12[clears throat] what is it day zero. Um
  4163. 2:55:16so I I was kind of confused there.
  4164. 2:55:17>> What he's getting at though is even in
  4165. 2:55:20the current structure we have a foye
  4166. 2:55:21officer within the tribe and that's
  4167. 2:55:23Lana. And if Lana were to you know deny
  4168. 2:55:26it there's still an appeal process. It
  4169. 2:55:28goes to the appellet court. No, it goes
  4170. 2:55:30>> chief judge. Chief judge goes to the
  4171. 2:55:32trial court.
  4172. 2:55:33>> Yeah, we just had a whole fiasco about
  4173. 2:55:34that.
  4174. 2:55:35>> Okay, thank you.
  4175. 2:55:36>> Okay, go ahead, Aaron.
  4176. 2:55:37>> Under the new structure,
  4177. 2:55:39>> does the OGA have discretionary
  4178. 2:55:41authority to decide to honor the the
  4179. 2:55:44foyer request or is it follow the code?
  4180. 2:55:46>> It follows the code. So the it would
  4181. 2:55:48follow our current code minus going to
  4182. 2:55:51the board office until we create a new
  4183. 2:55:53code which is mandated in within six
  4184. 2:55:55months of the new constitution. We have
  4185. 2:55:58to have a new foy code freedom
  4186. 2:56:01information ordinance because there's
  4187. 2:56:04different requirements that are now
  4188. 2:56:05going to be enshrined in the
  4189. 2:56:06constitution. But until we get the new
  4190. 2:56:08code, the OGMA's office and legal or
  4191. 2:56:11whoever he designate the designate is to
  4192. 2:56:14to process them has to follow our
  4193. 2:56:16current laws. So they don't have
  4194. 2:56:17discretion. They they can only deny it
  4195. 2:56:19for the reasons in current code. If they
  4196. 2:56:21deny it, it goes to judge leaport to
  4197. 2:56:23determine whether the denial was proper.
  4198. 2:56:26And then it's obviously ultimately up to
  4199. 2:56:29what this body will become to set what
  4200. 2:56:31that code is going to be as legislators.
  4201. 2:56:33So I mean my office would just execute
  4202. 2:56:35within the codes that the legislature
  4203. 2:56:37enacts. That's it. You guys create the
  4204. 2:56:39rules. I exist within those rules.
  4205. 2:56:41>> That's correct, Aaron.
  4206. 2:56:42>> So all right, help me understand because
  4207. 2:56:45I never watched it closely enough, but
  4208. 2:56:46and I'm not doing a cause or effect
  4209. 2:56:48here. I'll say that up front, but the
  4210. 2:56:51AOYA request that went in front of a
  4211. 2:56:54previous judge was um was honored as
  4212. 2:56:58having uh no, it was the
  4213. 2:57:01administration's interpretation was
  4214. 2:57:02overturned by the judge. Um then we
  4215. 2:57:05separated with that judge. The second
  4216. 2:57:08judge that saw it also interpreted. Is
  4217. 2:57:11that correct? That that that the
  4218. 2:57:13decision to deny that citizen that
  4219. 2:57:17information was incorrect. Was that is
  4220. 2:57:19that right?
  4221. 2:57:20>> That case is still ongoing. It has not
  4222. 2:57:22been determined by our prom judge. The
  4223. 2:57:25final just just the final determination
  4224. 2:57:27has not been issued yet.
  4225. 2:57:28>> Okay.
  4226. 2:57:30>> Oh, I understand that. But I it's also
  4227. 2:57:33it's it's it's important because I'm not
  4228. 2:57:35asking what's going to happen going
  4229. 2:57:37forward. I'm asking what happened up to
  4230. 2:57:39this point. So it's important that we
  4231. 2:57:42have due process. Um so but earlier and
  4232. 2:57:46and I got my answer because while it's
  4233. 2:57:48positioned in the chair's office, the
  4234. 2:57:51chair doesn't have discretionary
  4235. 2:57:52authority to deny a request. Correct.
  4236. 2:57:54>> The the chair's office has to follow the
  4237. 2:57:56law. Correct. And if the chair's office
  4238. 2:57:58doesn't follow the law, then the citizen
  4239. 2:58:02who's denied has the ability to
  4240. 2:58:05challenge that. So, I do think I don't
  4241. 2:58:07know why that's there in the chair's
  4242. 2:58:08office if that's just going to happen
  4243. 2:58:10temporarily, but I think um even though
  4244. 2:58:13you could argue if the chair supervises
  4245. 2:58:15the general counsel, it's the same
  4246. 2:58:17thing. But it it seems our current
  4247. 2:58:19structure does at least create the um
  4248. 2:58:23semblance of some functional separation
  4249. 2:58:26of powers because we put regulatory
  4250. 2:58:28stuff under legal. It's not under the
  4251. 2:58:30chair's office and and at one time it
  4252. 2:58:32was before I was chairperson. The
  4253. 2:58:34chairperson had discretionary authority
  4254. 2:58:36over all this stuff but that changed. So
  4255. 2:58:39we had a functional separation. But I
  4256. 2:58:41want to make it clear because the the
  4257. 2:58:42line of questioning might have lead
  4258. 2:58:44people to believe that the chairperson's
  4259. 2:58:46office will have discretion whether that
  4260. 2:58:48was intended or not. But clearly the
  4261. 2:58:50chair's office
  4262. 2:58:50>> intended it was a whether it was or not
  4263. 2:58:53the chair's office will not have the
  4264. 2:58:56discretion to not follow the law. And if
  4265. 2:58:59the if the chair's off Loima's office
  4266. 2:59:01abuses that there is a judicial remedy
  4267. 2:59:05to the court system.
  4268. 2:59:06>> Yep. there's a judicial remedy now and
  4269. 2:59:08in the new uh code in the new
  4270. 2:59:11constitution they will probably be even
  4271. 2:59:13better uh more heightened um recourse in
  4272. 2:59:16court if need be for the citizens who
  4273. 2:59:18think that their foyer was denied
  4274. 2:59:20unlawfully.
  4275. 2:59:22>> Okay, any objection to a recess right
  4276. 2:59:23now? All right, 10 minute break, guys.
  4277. 3:09:10we left off, please. All right. Last
  4278. 3:09:13kind of day one action item that we
  4279. 3:09:15flagged is um
  4280. 3:09:18and maybe this will necessitate that we
  4281. 3:09:20put the legislative process code even
  4282. 3:09:22higher than it might already be. But how
  4283. 3:09:24do we interact with the does the OGA
  4284. 3:09:28interact with tribal council? or is he
  4285. 3:09:30sending his executives? We have to I
  4286. 3:09:32don't have the answer today except for
  4287. 3:09:33the transition resolution kind of keeps
  4288. 3:09:35everything status quo during the
  4289. 3:09:37transition, but um sooner than later we
  4290. 3:09:40need to think about what the legislative
  4291. 3:09:41process looks like and how the executive
  4292. 3:09:44branch interacts with the with the
  4293. 3:09:45tribal council. We're still going to be
  4294. 3:09:47needing to have the executive branch
  4295. 3:09:49bring resolutions to to the tribal
  4296. 3:09:52council. Is that the OGMA's office
  4297. 3:09:53always? Is he just tagging in his
  4298. 3:09:55design? It's not like a it's a small
  4299. 3:09:58little thing. I think it's just it's
  4300. 3:09:59just a process to to iron out. It's not
  4301. 3:10:01like a deal breakaker and and a similar
  4302. 3:10:04process to how we currently operate can
  4303. 3:10:06can work. Um in addition to like we down
  4304. 3:10:10here later like resolution information
  4305. 3:10:12sheets is the OGA signing everything
  4306. 3:10:14before it goes to tribal council. Just
  4307. 3:10:16little process things that we got to
  4308. 3:10:17iron out um close to that day one. Erin,
  4309. 3:10:21>> so the way it works at the federal level
  4310. 3:10:23right now is the um legislature writes
  4311. 3:10:26the enacting law that compels the
  4312. 3:10:30executive branch to testify
  4313. 3:10:33um on any aspects that affect the
  4314. 3:10:36governance. So whether it's
  4315. 3:10:38appropriations or if it's proposed laws
  4316. 3:10:42um so the legislature um has authority
  4317. 3:10:47over that. Um, so that's the way it
  4318. 3:10:49works for the federal government.
  4319. 3:10:52Can we keep going?
  4320. 3:10:53>> Yep. Understood. But we still need to
  4321. 3:10:55figure out what that looks like for our
  4322. 3:10:56version of these separated powers.
  4323. 3:10:59>> Tyler.
  4324. 3:11:01>> Yeah, I was just going to say like it
  4325. 3:11:02wouldn't really make sense for the OGA
  4326. 3:11:03to sign off on something before it comes
  4327. 3:11:05to us. If he's going to just veto his
  4328. 3:11:07own things that he's sending to us,
  4329. 3:11:09right?
  4330. 3:11:10>> I mean,
  4331. 3:11:11>> right. Yeah. And then I would expect the
  4332. 3:11:13same process because we don't see the
  4333. 3:11:14the the president of the United States
  4334. 3:11:16going before legislature to ask for
  4335. 3:11:19certain things or explain how each
  4336. 3:11:21professional indivision operates.
  4337. 3:11:23>> So a a similar process but a humane
  4338. 3:11:26approach you know and
  4339. 3:11:28>> it work like this. So the executive
  4340. 3:11:30branch is most likely going to be
  4341. 3:11:32bringing most the resolutions forward
  4342. 3:11:33because we're the ones executing the
  4343. 3:11:35government operating within the rules
  4344. 3:11:37that the tribes provided. Right? So it
  4345. 3:11:40wouldn't be me if it's a government
  4346. 3:11:42thing. It would be Jess or one of the
  4347. 3:11:43program directors so they can explain
  4348. 3:11:45it. Be similar situation to where Jess
  4349. 3:11:47is over top of ACFs. But most of the
  4350. 3:11:50time when ACFs has a resolution, Jamie
  4351. 3:11:52is there to present on it because she's
  4352. 3:11:54the subject matter expert. Go ahead.
  4353. 3:11:56>> Just I want to clarify because I wasn't
  4354. 3:11:58saying at all that that the legislature
  4355. 3:12:02has to get permission from the executive
  4356. 3:12:04branch at all. What I was saying is all
  4357. 3:12:06right. So let's use budgets as a as an
  4358. 3:12:08example. Okay. So, currently there's
  4359. 3:12:11federal law that directs the OM on what
  4360. 3:12:15the uh budget ceilings are, what um
  4361. 3:12:17sequestration is, and all of that.
  4362. 3:12:20That's all enacted by the legislature.
  4363. 3:12:22That the administration doesn't get to
  4364. 3:12:24set that. Um and then the executive
  4365. 3:12:28branch has to operate within those
  4366. 3:12:30parameters as defined by the legislative
  4367. 3:12:32branch. Now whether they do or not is
  4368. 3:12:34another question. But for the budget,
  4369. 3:12:37the executive branch drafts up the
  4370. 3:12:39budget. They they submit their proposal,
  4371. 3:12:41the House submits their budget, the
  4372. 3:12:44Senate submits their budget, and then
  4373. 3:12:45they the House and Senate try to
  4374. 3:12:47reconcile. Um and sometimes it's most of
  4375. 3:12:51the time it's way off between three
  4376. 3:12:53branches. They don't even come close,
  4377. 3:12:55but they have to reconcile all of that.
  4378. 3:12:57and but the legislature has the
  4379. 3:13:00authority to compel testimony from the
  4380. 3:13:02executive branch. The executive could
  4381. 3:13:05choose to present all the budgets and
  4382. 3:13:08the detail and all of that, but that's a
  4383. 3:13:10lot of detail that mostly one person's
  4384. 3:13:12not ever going to know. So, they send
  4385. 3:13:14their their respective uh cabinet
  4386. 3:13:16members. In this case, it would be our
  4387. 3:13:18executives would then come in front of
  4388. 3:13:20the council um to present the uh
  4389. 3:13:24administration's budget. But the
  4390. 3:13:27legislature would also propose their
  4391. 3:13:29budget and they would have the ability
  4392. 3:13:31to do congressional oversight to compel
  4393. 3:13:34the administration to come in and and
  4394. 3:13:37answer questions. Um, and if if there's
  4395. 3:13:39a proposed legislation, so now separate
  4396. 3:13:42from the budget process, but proposed
  4397. 3:13:44legislation, the legislature writes the
  4398. 3:13:47laws. So the administration doesn't have
  4399. 3:13:48the discretion not to participate. They
  4400. 3:13:51have to participate. So the legislature
  4401. 3:13:53could write a law. they could say,
  4402. 3:13:54"Okay, we don't know what the fiscal
  4403. 3:13:55impact of this all is going to be." So
  4404. 3:13:58then they have the same access to all
  4405. 3:14:00the same CFO or the executives that they
  4406. 3:14:02do now. And then they can compel
  4407. 3:14:04testimony. How much is this going to
  4408. 3:14:06cost? What are the implications? What is
  4409. 3:14:08your best estimate of the impact on
  4410. 3:14:11existing laws? But that's why it is
  4411. 3:14:13going to be helpful for the legislative
  4412. 3:14:15branch to have their own legis uh
  4413. 3:14:17legislative council because then you
  4414. 3:14:19don't just have to take the
  4415. 3:14:20administration's word for it. you they
  4416. 3:14:22get to do their own interpretation of
  4417. 3:14:24what the the impact on the laws will be
  4418. 3:14:26or what um code changes might have to
  4419. 3:14:28happen. So that truly is a balance of
  4420. 3:14:31power. Um, and
  4421. 3:14:34so yeah, I wasn't suggesting that the
  4422. 3:14:37executive gets to decide whether or not
  4423. 3:14:39staff participate because but by having
  4424. 3:14:43the purse strings and by having the
  4425. 3:14:45legislative authority, the execut the
  4426. 3:14:48legislative branch is the most powerful
  4427. 3:14:50branch of government because they set
  4428. 3:14:52the laws um and they don't get to
  4429. 3:14:55interpret law anymore, but they also set
  4430. 3:14:58the budget authority. So
  4431. 3:15:01>> okay we can keep going.
  4432. 3:15:02>> Uh so day one processes to consider
  4433. 3:15:04changing immediately and problem
  4434. 3:15:06separation. So obviously uh like Austin
  4435. 3:15:09alluded to the exe in governmental
  4436. 3:15:11executives will be directly supervised
  4437. 3:15:13by the OGMA's office instead of the
  4438. 3:15:16tribal council.
  4439. 3:15:18Um so and I think this currently is
  4440. 3:15:20happening right leave those the for
  4441. 3:15:22leave slips etc. administrative
  4442. 3:15:24processes, leave those with the OGMA's
  4443. 3:15:26office. For the authority executives,
  4444. 3:15:29maybe we send that to the speaker's
  4445. 3:15:31office um in the interim until there's
  4446. 3:15:33different governing bodies to how to
  4447. 3:15:35handle that. I'm not going to pretend to
  4448. 3:15:37be an expert on all of our internal
  4449. 3:15:38processes, but some of these things to
  4450. 3:15:40consider as we're separating out so we
  4451. 3:15:42don't have the executive branch
  4452. 3:15:43processing payroll for the legislative
  4453. 3:15:46and vice versa.
  4454. 3:15:48Um,
  4455. 3:15:51in the interim, could that be handled by
  4456. 3:15:54the tribal council's board
  4457. 3:15:55administrator? Probably, but maybe we
  4458. 3:15:59smarter than mine's than I at the table
  4459. 3:16:02can figure out, not today, but how we do
  4460. 3:16:04that day one to figure out how to
  4461. 3:16:06separate those processes and keep those
  4462. 3:16:08different branches on on paper separated
  4463. 3:16:11as well. Uh more importantly than that,
  4464. 3:16:13probably the tribal council meetings
  4465. 3:16:14will have to follow the new 10-day
  4466. 3:16:16notice timeline in the constitution. So
  4467. 3:16:18that will be um a change from our
  4468. 3:16:22five-day notice right now.
  4469. 3:16:25Something to keep in mind. And then uh
  4470. 3:16:28the resolution process, we talked about
  4471. 3:16:29some of these and I think you guys are
  4472. 3:16:31right. Most of the internal process of
  4473. 3:16:34the executive branch can remain the same
  4474. 3:16:36where the executives are signing the
  4475. 3:16:38information sheets
  4476. 3:16:40etc. But we'll have to figure out are
  4477. 3:16:42the internal process whatever is most
  4478. 3:16:44effective to once tribal council enacts
  4479. 3:16:46a law they have five days to get that
  4480. 3:16:49over to the OGA's office the OGMA's
  4481. 3:16:52office has 10 days to sign it or veto
  4482. 3:16:54it. So yeah 15-day minimum for
  4483. 3:16:55resolutions now um to or maximum excuse
  4484. 3:17:00me I should say maximum 15-day maximum
  4485. 3:17:02for resolutions to take effect.
  4486. 3:17:04>> Oh there's a question or comment.
  4487. 3:17:05>> I mean technically it's 25 days with
  4488. 3:17:0710day notice.
  4489. 3:17:08>> Oh you're right. Yeah. Yeah. Counting
  4490. 3:17:10the notice period.
  4491. 3:17:11>> Yeah. So, with the we have the 10day
  4492. 3:17:14notice, we could still wave the rules.
  4493. 3:17:15We still follow Robert's rules of order.
  4494. 3:17:18Um but but just noting that like people
  4495. 3:17:21we'll have to make sure that our
  4496. 3:17:22divisions are getting stuff into us
  4497. 3:17:24within that timeline because it's going
  4498. 3:17:26to people are down to the wire already.
  4499. 3:17:28You know, I see Lana all the time. Hey,
  4500. 3:17:30noon today. Noon today. So, we just
  4501. 3:17:33really have to make sure we're on top of
  4502. 3:17:34it to maximize efficiency in government.
  4503. 3:17:39Um, and I don't think it's going to take
  4504. 3:17:415 days for the board, like once once
  4505. 3:17:43council approves something, I'm assuming
  4506. 3:17:45Lana just shoots it off to Elaine or
  4507. 3:17:47whoever in the executive office for the
  4508. 3:17:48OGA to sign
  4509. 3:17:50>> and likely he's just going to
  4510. 3:17:51automatically sign things unless he
  4511. 3:17:52wants to veto them, right? So, yeah,
  4512. 3:17:55it's not 15 days minimum. Like it could
  4513. 3:17:58be 15 days minimum, but I mean with the
  4514. 3:18:0010day notice, there's 10 days right
  4515. 3:18:02there, right?
  4516. 3:18:03>> Yeah. No, you're right. And so that that
  4517. 3:18:04might be one of the bigger growing pains
  4518. 3:18:06for not only the governing the
  4519. 3:18:08government at the top, but also just uh
  4520. 3:18:12all of us at towards, you know, further
  4521. 3:18:14down getting make sure we're on top of
  4522. 3:18:16things to to meet those new new time and
  4523. 3:18:18account for that potentially longer
  4524. 3:18:22actionable period. We can still yeah add
  4525. 3:18:24things for emergencies and such. There's
  4526. 3:18:26even emergency provisions to call quick
  4527. 3:18:2924-hour meetings if it's an actual
  4528. 3:18:31emergency in the constitution. But by
  4529. 3:18:33and large, most things won't be. So just
  4530. 3:18:36we'll just have to make sure everyone at
  4531. 3:18:37from the top down is aware of these new
  4532. 3:18:40new timelines to make sure we maximize
  4533. 3:18:42efficiency.
  4534. 3:18:44>> Erin,
  4535. 3:18:44>> I have a point of inquiry then I have a
  4536. 3:18:46point to make. So where did the 10 days
  4537. 3:18:48come from?
  4538. 3:18:51>> All right. I know the answer, but I
  4539. 3:18:54would just want to
  4540. 3:18:54>> originally it was one of the timelines
  4541. 3:18:57in the 2008
  4542. 3:19:00draft.
  4543. 3:19:01>> Seven
  4544. 3:19:01>> 2007 draft.
  4545. 3:19:03>> The version I have was 2008
  4546. 3:19:05>> and it was 10 days. It wasn't longer.
  4547. 3:19:07>> No, it was it was um there was a comment
  4548. 3:19:11and notice period uh in there that I
  4549. 3:19:14don't remember this. I haven't pulled up
  4550. 3:19:16the specifics, but there was also
  4551. 3:19:18certain legislation,
  4552. 3:19:20not budgets I don't believe, but a lot
  4553. 3:19:22of other legislation hit this notice
  4554. 3:19:25period. So then there was even longer.
  4555. 3:19:27It it was like 45 to 60 days depending
  4556. 3:19:29on the type of legislation under that
  4557. 3:19:31that draft.
  4558. 3:19:32>> Okay. So here's what I remember. It's
  4559. 3:19:34pretty close is the notice and comment
  4560. 3:19:37requirement and the extended time period
  4561. 3:19:39was because members that participated,
  4562. 3:19:4229 members in the committee process, um
  4563. 3:19:44we're not satisfied that we were
  4564. 3:19:47operating like a government and giving
  4565. 3:19:49the citizens time to mull over whether
  4566. 3:19:52or not legislation that was coming in
  4567. 3:19:54front of the council was sufficient time
  4568. 3:19:57for them to see it, react to it, and
  4569. 3:20:00contact their their representatives to
  4570. 3:20:02say, "Yes, I like that or I don't like
  4571. 3:20:04that or would you consider this sort of
  4572. 3:20:06thing. The notice and comment
  4573. 3:20:07requirement was um was I think specific
  4574. 3:20:13to any changes in your rights from the
  4575. 3:20:16constitution, any treaty rights, any
  4576. 3:20:19referendum. So those so those sorts of
  4577. 3:20:22things would require a longer period of
  4578. 3:20:23time and notice comment. So the way that
  4579. 3:20:25the legislature, the state legislature
  4580. 3:20:27or the federal legislature works now,
  4581. 3:20:29and I know a lot of people immediately
  4582. 3:20:31want to dismiss that because we're not
  4583. 3:20:32white, we're not the white government,
  4584. 3:20:34but there's value in following notice
  4585. 3:20:37and comment and opportunity for people
  4586. 3:20:39to weigh in on whether or not they like
  4587. 3:20:41what's going to be enacted that affects
  4588. 3:20:42their lives. So um so 10 days doesn't
  4589. 3:20:47have to be 10 days. It could be whatever
  4590. 3:20:49this council decides, but that's what's
  4591. 3:20:51in the draft. um it is absolutely
  4592. 3:20:54manageable. Um it's it's not an undue
  4593. 3:20:57burden. The one thing that I think and
  4594. 3:20:58and you know there's a lot of
  4595. 3:21:00assumptions that go into all of this is
  4596. 3:21:03I think that once we have a separation
  4597. 3:21:06of powers and we can bring a cause of
  4598. 3:21:08action. I think somebody's going to
  4599. 3:21:09bring a cause of action that suspending
  4600. 3:21:11the rules to add something to the agenda
  4601. 3:21:13in violation of the 10-day notice is not
  4602. 3:21:16acceptable because, you know, we should
  4603. 3:21:20be able to get our government poop in a
  4604. 3:21:22group and, you know, have our act
  4605. 3:21:23together such that we have notice and
  4606. 3:21:26comment if it's 5 days or 10 days. And
  4607. 3:21:30um it depends on how the legislature set
  4608. 3:21:32up. Um right now we have we accommodate
  4609. 3:21:36people who don't get their act together
  4610. 3:21:39and bring stuff at the last minute. We
  4611. 3:21:41accommodate that um when we should not
  4612. 3:21:44we should actually require them to have
  4613. 3:21:46their stuff submitted. The other thing
  4614. 3:21:48I'm not sure how it's going to fit.
  4615. 3:21:50We've made it an accommodation where at
  4616. 3:21:52one time the the chair or the executive
  4617. 3:21:55director could submit a um a grant
  4618. 3:21:58request um administratively
  4619. 3:22:01um because we didn't have a meeting
  4620. 3:22:03scheduled. Um so
  4621. 3:22:06I think that's a good accommodation but
  4622. 3:22:08it may not meet the requirement. Um, and
  4623. 3:22:11again, if if our planning department or
  4624. 3:22:14if our programs and services are not on
  4625. 3:22:17top of no notice of funding
  4626. 3:22:19announcements or or whatever, then we
  4627. 3:22:21just need to get better. We need to
  4628. 3:22:23improve so that we're not having stuff
  4629. 3:22:25at the last minute submitted. Um,
  4630. 3:22:28because that really frustrates the legis
  4631. 3:22:29I think it puts it as a disadvantage to
  4632. 3:22:31getting it enacted if you bring it at
  4633. 3:22:34the last minute. We shouldn't be doing
  4634. 3:22:35things at the last minute. We should be
  4635. 3:22:37more carefully as a government looking
  4636. 3:22:39through it and proposing it. So, but I
  4637. 3:22:41think the suspension of the rules is
  4638. 3:22:43something we put in the parliamentary
  4639. 3:22:44meeting rules um as an accommodation,
  4640. 3:22:48but I I don't think that should apply to
  4641. 3:22:50the notice and comment or the
  4642. 3:22:52requirement to put something on the
  4643. 3:22:54legislative agenda. So,
  4644. 3:22:59>> okay, I didn't miss anybody, did I?
  4645. 3:23:01Okay, we can keep going then.
  4646. 3:23:05>> And just speaking of notice and
  4647. 3:23:06comments, it's something that will help.
  4648. 3:23:09We you we will the legal department or
  4649. 3:23:11your future legislative attorney
  4650. 3:23:13something that you can flesh out more in
  4651. 3:23:14your legislative process code is not
  4652. 3:23:16enshrined in the constitution but can
  4653. 3:23:19you can still account for all that in
  4654. 3:23:20the future if the tribal council wants
  4655. 3:23:24uh to uh we're recommending
  4656. 3:23:28that the budget office be separated out
  4657. 3:23:31to be kind of our version of I I keep
  4658. 3:23:34referring it to OM our version of of a
  4659. 3:23:38federal ederal independent eye on the
  4660. 3:23:41tribe and all its entities. I think that
  4661. 3:23:43we should create a code and have it
  4662. 3:23:45ready day one that makes budgets
  4663. 3:23:48department a independent agency that
  4664. 3:23:52cannot be subject to the political whims
  4665. 3:23:54of any branch that has access as it does
  4666. 3:23:58now to all the branches and all the
  4667. 3:24:00entities so it can properly um and
  4668. 3:24:03independently advise the government on
  4669. 3:24:06budgetary needs. I think that's
  4670. 3:24:08something that we we in the legal
  4671. 3:24:10department think that should be day one,
  4672. 3:24:11but it's definitely a high priority even
  4673. 3:24:13if it's not day one.
  4674. 3:24:15>> So, real quick before Tyler, I think
  4675. 3:24:16that's a great idea. Who would that
  4676. 3:24:18report to? Like ultimately someone has
  4677. 3:24:20to have a boss. If it's not an elected
  4678. 3:24:22position to where they have a membership
  4679. 3:24:24to answer to, similar to what we answer
  4680. 3:24:26to, who do they answer to?
  4681. 3:24:29that that was going to be my
  4682. 3:24:31recommendation actually is to create the
  4683. 3:24:34audit commission into the audit
  4684. 3:24:36authority and put it under that
  4685. 3:24:39potential authority. Um now there are a
  4686. 3:24:41few board members that sit on that but
  4687. 3:24:43it is like split between board and
  4688. 3:24:46professionals.
  4689. 3:24:47>> So I would be supportive of that if the
  4690. 3:24:49board vacated that and that would apply
  4691. 3:24:51to myself too. Um, you know, I don't
  4692. 3:24:54know. I I really don't know why we have
  4693. 3:24:57these committees that are advisory to
  4694. 3:24:58the board when board members sit on them
  4695. 3:25:00to be quite honest with you. I I don't
  4696. 3:25:02know. Like it provides an opportunity
  4697. 3:25:05for a tribal citizen who's unelected to
  4698. 3:25:08provide their feedback to see whatever
  4699. 3:25:10situation the tribe is dealing with
  4700. 3:25:12through their lens. And it's like,
  4701. 3:25:13what's the point if it eventually just
  4702. 3:25:15reaches the board of directors? A board
  4703. 3:25:16member will have their opinion about it
  4704. 3:25:18anyways and then they'll be able to take
  4705. 3:25:20action on it. but one committee lower on
  4706. 3:25:23the advisory level, what's the point of
  4707. 3:25:24having board members there? And it's
  4708. 3:25:25something we've talked about internally
  4709. 3:25:27uh various meetings on um if we're going
  4710. 3:25:31to have a similar approach in the future
  4711. 3:25:33to have these committees then I believe
  4712. 3:25:37if they if they can't if we can't get to
  4713. 3:25:38the plans to try where they're like
  4714. 3:25:40independent and the tribal council and
  4715. 3:25:42the executive branch are out of it then
  4716. 3:25:44having representation from all three
  4717. 3:25:47branches some kind of hybrid where the
  4718. 3:25:50the executive branch has
  4719. 3:25:51represententation on it tribal council
  4720. 3:25:53has representation and the judicial
  4721. 3:25:55branch. So then all three branches are
  4722. 3:25:58working together in a collaborative way
  4723. 3:26:00is maybe a way that we can bridge the
  4724. 3:26:02gap for our tribe. Um if we can't
  4725. 3:26:04completely eliminate or or restructure
  4726. 3:26:07the way we do a tax audit commission,
  4727. 3:26:10having representation from all three
  4728. 3:26:11branches so there is no imbalance of
  4729. 3:26:13power might be a way that could work for
  4730. 3:26:15our tribe.
  4731. 3:26:16>> Erin,
  4732. 3:26:18>> all right. So at the state level, you
  4733. 3:26:20have a house fiscal agency and then you
  4734. 3:26:22have a senate finance committee. At the
  4735. 3:26:24federal level, you have the Office of
  4736. 3:26:25Management and Budget under the
  4737. 3:26:27executive branch and you have the
  4738. 3:26:29Congressional Research Service or
  4739. 3:26:31Congressional Budget Office. Um,
  4740. 3:26:33Congressional Research Service is
  4741. 3:26:35something different. So, um, the
  4742. 3:26:38legislature enacts the laws on how to
  4743. 3:26:41draft the budgets and so the C the OM
  4744. 3:26:44and the Congressional Budget Office have
  4745. 3:26:46to follow within those laws. So um so
  4746. 3:26:50unless we planning on creating two
  4747. 3:26:52separate arms to report up to the
  4748. 3:26:55government overall I I think I don't I
  4749. 3:26:58don't think it should be under the audit
  4750. 3:27:00committee because it they're it's apples
  4751. 3:27:02and oranges. Audit committee does
  4752. 3:27:04something entirely different. The budget
  4753. 3:27:06department um whichever structure I
  4754. 3:27:08think they should be independent. Um we
  4755. 3:27:11created this and Al remembers this. We
  4756. 3:27:13created this at Greektown when we
  4757. 3:27:15created Alakica's position because um
  4758. 3:27:18the management authority wanted to have
  4759. 3:27:20independence from the management on the
  4760. 3:27:22budgets. So the the budget I don't
  4761. 3:27:26remember what his title was but
  4762. 3:27:28compliant. Yeah, he was compliance uh
  4763. 3:27:30but uh the compliance officer reported
  4764. 3:27:32directly to the management board. So
  4765. 3:27:35that way the the administration which
  4766. 3:27:37would be the management authority could
  4767. 3:27:39not manipulate the numbers or whatever.
  4768. 3:27:41It was pure. So, I think that's what we
  4769. 3:27:43should the structure we should have. I
  4770. 3:27:45don't think we should have a whole bunch
  4771. 3:27:46of those structures. But I think that's
  4772. 3:27:48one um when when we proposed the budget
  4773. 3:27:53process, the appropriations process and
  4774. 3:27:54the budget authority, we brought in Bill
  4775. 3:27:57Matson who was an accountant, long-term
  4776. 3:27:59accountant at Little or at uh Mount
  4777. 3:28:01Pleasant Tribe. He came in and he
  4778. 3:28:03drafted up our budget authority and it
  4779. 3:28:05was to be independent of the CFO because
  4780. 3:28:08at the time the CFO was heavy armed
  4781. 3:28:12under the chairman of the tribe and kept
  4782. 3:28:15information from the council stuff the
  4783. 3:28:16council never ever got to see um and it
  4784. 3:28:19was very manipulative. So, so I think
  4785. 3:28:22that we need to have that independence.
  4786. 3:28:24I don't think it should be positioned
  4787. 3:28:26under any individual branch, but I think
  4788. 3:28:29it should be responsible to all the
  4789. 3:28:31branches. But then I also think we can
  4790. 3:28:33write a code for what they do. And what
  4791. 3:28:36they do is they draft up the bud or no,
  4792. 3:28:39they take the draft budgets and they the
  4793. 3:28:42legislature will draft a budget and
  4794. 3:28:43submit it. The executive branch will
  4795. 3:28:45draft a budget and submit it. The
  4796. 3:28:47judicial branch will draft one and
  4797. 3:28:48submit it. Their job is a very technical
  4798. 3:28:50job to submit all that information in so
  4799. 3:28:53that those can then come forward and
  4800. 3:28:55those proposals can be picked apart by
  4801. 3:28:58the legislative branch, picked apart by
  4802. 3:29:00the executive branch and picked apart by
  4803. 3:29:02the judicial branch. But ultimately all
  4804. 3:29:04three branches have to get to a point
  4805. 3:29:07where they have a consolidated budget or
  4806. 3:29:09an ominous budget package to propose
  4807. 3:29:12approval of a budget. So I do think it
  4808. 3:29:14should be an independent body. I don't
  4809. 3:29:16think it fits under any committee
  4810. 3:29:18structures. Um, unless unless the way it
  4811. 3:29:21could work, and we haven't talked about
  4812. 3:29:23this yet, but if we create a regulatory
  4813. 3:29:26structure for the tribe and the and the
  4814. 3:29:28legislature enacts laws,
  4815. 3:29:31I think we would have to have it in the
  4816. 3:29:33constitution so that they can't write
  4817. 3:29:34laws that are that would weaken another
  4818. 3:29:38branch's authority. But all of the the
  4819. 3:29:41commissions and the authorities should
  4820. 3:29:43come under a separate regulatory
  4821. 3:29:44structure. Um, but we're not there yet.
  4822. 3:29:47I think that's probably going to come.
  4823. 3:29:49Um, so, but in the meantime, I think the
  4824. 3:29:51budget authority could be independent of
  4825. 3:29:53any individual branch, but in an
  4826. 3:29:56ordinance spell out their duty and
  4827. 3:29:58responsibility to each separate branch,
  4828. 3:30:00and then they can do their job. So,
  4829. 3:30:03>> we can keep going.
  4830. 3:30:04>> Been thinking about this for more than
  4831. 3:30:0620 years.
  4832. 3:30:08>> Um, if it's okay with the board, I don't
  4833. 3:30:09want to go through the phase transition
  4834. 3:30:11provisions because I want to tweak them.
  4835. 3:30:13I tweaked them, but I want to tweak them
  4836. 3:30:14even further for you. They're
  4837. 3:30:16substantially what I've already sent out
  4838. 3:30:18to you, but um they don't accurately
  4839. 3:30:21reflect the day one, day zero. And if we
  4840. 3:30:23all are tentatively in agreement that
  4841. 3:30:26that's a okay approach as we move
  4842. 3:30:28forward with day one, day zero. I will
  4843. 3:30:30further tweak our transition timeline
  4844. 3:30:32more in more accordance with those
  4845. 3:30:34priorities that we talked about earlier
  4846. 3:30:36before we ask you to vote on them.
  4847. 3:30:39>> Okay, Tyler,
  4848. 3:30:40>> I'm good with that. I I think we made
  4849. 3:30:42decent progress today after talking
  4850. 3:30:44about that. Um Mike had mentioned
  4851. 3:30:46something to me during the break though
  4852. 3:30:47that I want to make sure we bring up is
  4853. 3:30:49that what can we add to this transition
  4854. 3:30:52the implementation plan to create teeth
  4855. 3:30:55to it. Other than it just being law um
  4856. 3:30:58how many times have we seen law passed
  4857. 3:31:00and then things get ignored for 3
  4858. 3:31:02months, 6 months, 9 months, so on and so
  4859. 3:31:04forth. So what can we do to hold all of
  4860. 3:31:06us accountable? our executives, the
  4861. 3:31:08board of directors, the OGA, the the the
  4862. 3:31:11Justice Department um to create teeth to
  4863. 3:31:16this resolution to make sure that we do
  4864. 3:31:18not breach it, that we do our 0 to 90
  4865. 3:31:22days, so on and so forth and with it
  4866. 3:31:24attached. So, you have the you don't
  4867. 3:31:26have it fully worked out. You said you
  4868. 3:31:27want to come back to it. I'm fine with
  4869. 3:31:29you coming back because I feel like this
  4870. 3:31:30the day zero, day one, like um answered
  4871. 3:31:33a lot of questions, brought up more. We
  4872. 3:31:35have some some things to work through,
  4873. 3:31:36but can you think about what we can do
  4874. 3:31:39to create teeth so that this if this
  4875. 3:31:42were to pass that we we follow it?
  4876. 3:31:50Yeah, I'll um I'll think about that more
  4877. 3:31:53how we can create more te certainly if
  4878. 3:31:55this is enacted I have on the screen now
  4879. 3:31:58that would be the law of our tribe right
  4880. 3:32:00the transition resolution and if
  4881. 3:32:02>> an elected leader violates it there
  4882. 3:32:05they're subject to removal now and and
  4883. 3:32:07in the new constitution um but outside
  4884. 3:32:10of that further teeth I don't have an
  4885. 3:32:12answer today Tyler but I will uh
  4886. 3:32:15workshop that with the team and figure
  4887. 3:32:16out some options to create even beyond
  4888. 3:32:19that obvious tooth that has the removal
  4889. 3:32:23and recall. What else we can do to make
  4890. 3:32:25sure we hold uh each other accountable
  4891. 3:32:27for it? Yeah.
  4892. 3:32:28>> Okay.
  4893. 3:32:29>> Go ahead.
  4894. 3:32:31>> In the draft that came from 2007 and
  4895. 3:32:34then also reaffirmed in 2012 and with
  4896. 3:32:37the elders unanimously uh put forward in
  4897. 3:32:40uh 2024,
  4898. 3:32:42there was a remedy for not approving a
  4899. 3:32:44budget. What was that? Uh that would be
  4900. 3:32:47that tribal council would forfeit their
  4901. 3:32:50salaries until such time as a budget was
  4902. 3:32:52passed,
  4903. 3:32:53>> right? That that's budget, but we're
  4904. 3:32:55talking about all of these codes as
  4905. 3:32:57well. And we really are at the whim of
  4906. 3:33:00the rest of the tribe when it comes to
  4907. 3:33:01making sure that these are in alignment,
  4908. 3:33:03too,
  4909. 3:33:04>> right? It's not just it's not just the
  4910. 3:33:06OGMA or tribal council. It's all the
  4911. 3:33:08executive staff. It's the legal
  4912. 3:33:10department. like how do we besides that
  4913. 3:33:12we just want the best for our tribe and
  4914. 3:33:13we want to make sure this gets done in a
  4915. 3:33:15good way. What other legal teeth can we
  4916. 3:33:18add to just in reinforce that and hold
  4917. 3:33:21each other accountable? I understand. I
  4918. 3:33:22don't have the answer today, but I'll
  4919. 3:33:24think of some language.
  4920. 3:33:24>> I appreciate that,
  4921. 3:33:26>> Rob.
  4922. 3:33:29>> I was just going to suggest some kind of
  4923. 3:33:31a code that would force us to be in this
  4924. 3:33:33room until it was done pretty much. I
  4925. 3:33:35mean, like a 9 to5. I mean, if you don't
  4926. 3:33:37get it done, your job's to get it done.
  4927. 3:33:39you show up every day, work together in
  4928. 3:33:42this room till it's done. But maybe that
  4929. 3:33:44may maybe not getting it done on the
  4930. 3:33:46timeline would be a trigger for that and
  4931. 3:33:48you guys are to report every day to your
  4932. 3:33:50to your council workshop and until you
  4933. 3:33:53guys come up with a solution. I mean the
  4934. 3:33:55other obvious teeth that are built in to
  4935. 3:33:58this if if
  4936. 3:34:01the executive branch doesn't fulfill a
  4937. 3:34:04duty say that they're drafting the foy
  4938. 3:34:07code and they miss that sixmonth
  4939. 3:34:09benchmark to get it to you all at the
  4940. 3:34:13there are if we build them at mediation
  4941. 3:34:15or ADR or if we don't have that set up
  4942. 3:34:19we can sue each other if I mean we don't
  4943. 3:34:22want to always res resort to that but
  4944. 3:34:23there is the pending potentiality that
  4945. 3:34:28if a branch misses its deadline that
  4946. 3:34:31especially if the if the legislature
  4947. 3:34:32misses the deadline in the 18 months and
  4948. 3:34:34we have codes that aren't adopted that
  4949. 3:34:37you're people are going to start
  4950. 3:34:38pointing fingers at each other and
  4951. 3:34:39gearing up to maybe want to to go to
  4952. 3:34:41mediation or alternative dispute
  4953. 3:34:43resolution arbitration or ultimately
  4954. 3:34:46maybe be in tribal court suing each
  4955. 3:34:47other and I think that all branches
  4956. 3:34:50would want to avoid that. So that's the
  4957. 3:34:52other kind of already builtin teeth that
  4958. 3:34:55we have. So we have the removal for
  4959. 3:34:57elected officials. We have the pending
  4960. 3:35:00potentiality of having to sue each other
  4961. 3:35:02which no one wants to do that. That's
  4962. 3:35:03that's waste of time and money and
  4963. 3:35:05costs. Um so those things are teeth now
  4964. 3:35:08so to speak that are that are in there
  4965. 3:35:10and that hold all the branches
  4966. 3:35:13accountable. Um and I'll we'll figure
  4967. 3:35:15out how we can maybe
  4968. 3:35:17reinforce that and buff that out
  4969. 3:35:19further.
  4970. 3:35:21Holly, do you know off the top of your
  4971. 3:35:23head what our consolidated budgets are
  4972. 3:35:24across all the different silos within
  4973. 3:35:26the tribe? That would include obviously
  4974. 3:35:29health, EDC,
  4975. 3:35:31um gaming, governmental.
  4976. 3:35:37>> Um let me see if I can put that. I don't
  4977. 3:35:41have gaming. I know that.
  4978. 3:35:44>> Al, what do you what is their annual
  4979. 3:35:46budget for gaming? You can let her know
  4980. 3:35:48and she can add it to it.
  4981. 3:35:53Well, we budget for about 86 I think in
  4982. 3:35:56gross game
  4983. 3:35:58>> and we're right around 20 million IBRA.
  4984. 3:36:00>> Correct.
  4985. 3:36:01>> You got that, Holly?
  4986. 3:36:06>> 86 gross gaming and about 20 million
  4987. 3:36:08IBRA.
  4988. 3:36:12>> How long are you going to need for that,
  4989. 3:36:14Holly? A couple minutes.
  4990. 3:36:14>> Yeah, I just need a couple minutes.
  4991. 3:36:16Okay, we can keep going then. Okay.
  4992. 3:36:19>> Uh that's that's all I had for for that
  4993. 3:36:22portion. I think maybe if there's
  4994. 3:36:25questions on that from either executive
  4995. 3:36:28team or the tribal tribal council.
  4996. 3:36:30>> Okay. Before I call on them, I'm going
  4997. 3:36:32to Is there anything else in the
  4998. 3:36:34presentation?
  4999. 3:36:35>> Well, we had on the agenda health
  5000. 3:36:37authority code development. Um but we'll
  5001. 3:36:41need more unless we're going extra time
  5002. 3:36:44after five. we we're going to need more
  5003. 3:36:46time than a half hour for that probably.
  5004. 3:36:48>> So I mean in a nutshell we would build
  5005. 3:36:50it similarly to the gaming authority and
  5006. 3:36:52the EDC authority. Um but obviously if
  5007. 3:36:55we were to transition to that there
  5008. 3:36:57wouldn't be board members in there. You
  5009. 3:36:58would have professionals and I would
  5010. 3:37:00strongly encourage the board of
  5011. 3:37:02directors to place basic criteria on who
  5012. 3:37:04you admit there. So like within the
  5013. 3:37:05gaming authority, it's or not gaming
  5014. 3:37:08authority within the housing authority,
  5015. 3:37:09we're always appreciative of all the
  5016. 3:37:10volunteers, but there's no educational
  5017. 3:37:13requirement. There's no professional
  5018. 3:37:15experience required. And if we're going
  5019. 3:37:17to replace ourselves with a professional
  5020. 3:37:18body to oversee the health division,
  5021. 3:37:20which I think is necessary because
  5022. 3:37:22that's so crucially important. Like I
  5023. 3:37:24think one of the problems of the board
  5024. 3:37:25of directors is that we have an
  5025. 3:37:26unrealistic expectation of the capacity
  5026. 3:37:29of the health division. That's not to
  5027. 3:37:30say that they don't do good work, but us
  5028. 3:37:32as tribal politicians, we have a
  5029. 3:37:34tendency to try to squeeze things to
  5030. 3:37:35make make ourselves look good. You know
  5031. 3:37:37what I mean? But like there's there's
  5032. 3:37:39capacity. You only have so many offices
  5033. 3:37:41in there. You only have so many bodies
  5034. 3:37:43in there. You only have so many
  5035. 3:37:44resources. And I will say this until I'm
  5036. 3:37:46blue in the face. It should be a
  5037. 3:37:48professional health authority with
  5038. 3:37:50people who have worked in that field,
  5039. 3:37:51people that have studied in that field,
  5040. 3:37:53people near the tail end of their career
  5041. 3:37:55that can contribute. But we need a
  5042. 3:37:57bigger conversation. It's going to be
  5043. 3:37:58like a full workshop. Yeah. And we sent
  5044. 3:38:00we sent out to the board two drafts. One
  5045. 3:38:02that's modeled after our housing
  5046. 3:38:05authority, one that's modeled after KGA
  5047. 3:38:07and enterprise authority to be the two
  5048. 3:38:10like starting points because those are
  5049. 3:38:13the two examples we have as a tribe and
  5050. 3:38:14then we can workshop more in depth and
  5051. 3:38:17go forward. Something I will throw out
  5052. 3:38:19to the universe for
  5053. 3:38:22better or worse. I guess if as a tribe
  5054. 3:38:25we are struggling to get on the same
  5055. 3:38:28page now we're in the separation on who
  5056. 3:38:32should be those governing bodies. I
  5057. 3:38:34would like if we're at an impass just
  5058. 3:38:36I'm going to put that out there. We
  5059. 3:38:37should talk about maybe some kind of
  5060. 3:38:39hybrid approach where tribal council or
  5061. 3:38:42maybe even the executive branch can be
  5062. 3:38:43on there with the professionals if we
  5063. 3:38:46can't get to the point where we can have
  5064. 3:38:47it entirely of professionals. I have
  5065. 3:38:50seen our tribe from afar. I've seen it
  5066. 3:38:52now from the inside and I know there can
  5067. 3:38:54be sometimes struggles there and that
  5068. 3:38:56can be not saying we have to lead with
  5069. 3:38:58that but just something to keep in mind.
  5070. 3:38:59We do not we don't have to fight about
  5071. 3:39:00it amongst ourselves. We can come to a
  5072. 3:39:02compromise in a way that works and
  5073. 3:39:04creates independence and gets that
  5074. 3:39:06professional level um guidance and on
  5075. 3:39:10these governing boards without too much
  5076. 3:39:11strife. So, I want to throw that on the
  5077. 3:39:13plate now because I'm anticipating some
  5078. 3:39:16of the conversations we're going to have
  5079. 3:39:17and it doesn't have to be all or nothing
  5080. 3:39:18and there are ways to kind of bridge the
  5081. 3:39:21gap.
  5082. 3:39:22>> Lena then Erin.
  5083. 3:39:24>> Yeah, I'm I didn't know if I know that
  5084. 3:39:27we didn't talk about I know that we
  5085. 3:39:29talked about the cost estimate and that
  5086. 3:39:31went down from us sitting here today and
  5087. 3:39:34thinking of ways that we can reduce it.
  5088. 3:39:37Um, does Bill have anything? I mean
  5089. 3:39:39because we're we're going to be
  5090. 3:39:40reflecting on a new um IT
  5091. 3:39:45um website and I'm not sure if any and
  5092. 3:39:48Dan I think we talked about EDC and no
  5093. 3:39:50additional costs there but and then my
  5094. 3:39:53the question I would have is what is the
  5095. 3:39:55final that we had lowered it down from
  5096. 3:39:57the 3.8 eight.
  5097. 3:40:00>> Um, just to have a clear Yes.
  5098. 3:40:02>> I mean, I'm sure we're gonna have this
  5099. 3:40:03conversation again tomorrow and it might
  5100. 3:40:05even change just a little bit, but
  5101. 3:40:07>> yeah. So, based on the memo I
  5102. 3:40:09distributed in our discussions earlier
  5103. 3:40:11this afternoon, that 3.8 went down to
  5104. 3:40:141.7
  5105. 3:40:16million. I was talking to Holly on one
  5106. 3:40:19of the breaks. That doesn't account for
  5107. 3:40:21potential increase uh to our elections
  5108. 3:40:24or the election commission. There
  5109. 3:40:27something else we talked about. Is that
  5110. 3:40:28that's that was going to be my question
  5111. 3:40:30too. Is the elections of OP the election
  5112. 3:40:32of judges and things like that. Is any
  5113. 3:40:35of that in included
  5114. 3:40:37in this?
  5115. 3:40:38>> I do not have that in in the in this
  5116. 3:40:40number. So I if if we say it's 1.7 it's
  5117. 3:40:44going to be more than 1.7 because I I
  5118. 3:40:46didn't haven't figured out with Holly
  5119. 3:40:48what the
  5120. 3:40:49>> potential increase to our elections will
  5121. 3:40:51be. I don't think it's going to be a
  5122. 3:40:53huge increase compared to
  5123. 3:40:55>> it is important to know that what is not
  5124. 3:40:57included in that though as well because
  5125. 3:40:59you've done a great job of putting
  5126. 3:41:00what's included in it and where we can
  5127. 3:41:02and we can estimate that.
  5128. 3:41:04>> Um but not included is elections not
  5129. 3:41:07included is new you know what uh Bill's
  5130. 3:41:10working on for different things. Um and
  5131. 3:41:14I don't know if anybody else has any
  5132. 3:41:16comments about Jess.
  5133. 3:41:18>> We're going to get to Jess. I'm going to
  5134. 3:41:19give a round any of the executives. But
  5135. 3:41:21I mean it's also important to remember
  5136. 3:41:23this like the body that the board will
  5137. 3:41:25become will control the purse strings of
  5138. 3:41:27the tribe. So that's one of the reasons
  5139. 3:41:29why the number has been constantly fluid
  5140. 3:41:31because at the end of the day it's this
  5141. 3:41:32body who's going to approve the budgets
  5142. 3:41:34that's going to operate it. So I mean I
  5143. 3:41:36could put forward a resolution that says
  5144. 3:41:38hey I need those two staff if we're not
  5145. 3:41:40close to balancing the budget. You guys
  5146. 3:41:42just don't pass.
  5147. 3:41:42>> We also have mandates though. There's
  5148. 3:41:44mandates that and those are the things
  5149. 3:41:46that I you know that we we aren't
  5150. 3:41:48addressing here and you know
  5151. 3:41:50>> there are but at the same time there's
  5152. 3:41:52great flexibility in what this body pays
  5153. 3:41:54for.
  5154. 3:41:55>> Erin,
  5155. 3:41:57I'm sorry. Did anyone have their hand
  5156. 3:41:59up? All right. Even
  5157. 3:42:03>> Okay, go ahead then. Jess,
  5158. 3:42:06>> I guess just a comment on Lana's last
  5159. 3:42:09question. Some of my departments would
  5160. 3:42:11have increased cost. Um, one for example
  5161. 3:42:13would be law enforcement. I mean, they
  5162. 3:42:15could have potential additional
  5163. 3:42:17reporting that's required, additional
  5164. 3:42:18court appearances, you know, more
  5165. 3:42:21subpoenas, those sort of things. So,
  5166. 3:42:23that may require additional staffing,
  5167. 3:42:25you know, overtime training, those sort
  5168. 3:42:26of things. Um, but the one thing I did
  5169. 3:42:28want to mention, I know we've had a lot
  5170. 3:42:30of discussion on tribal support. The one
  5171. 3:42:33other thing that I had flagged to the
  5172. 3:42:34board previously was um federal funding
  5173. 3:42:38um and that proposed OM rule that was
  5174. 3:42:41supposed to go into effect in October,
  5175. 3:42:43which has been now delayed until
  5176. 3:42:44December. Um but we currently receive
  5177. 3:42:47and Holly can correct my numbers if I'm
  5178. 3:42:49wrong, but over $60 million in federal
  5179. 3:42:52funding. And if there's changes there,
  5180. 3:42:54if those funds get cut, um, eliminated,
  5181. 3:42:58you know, there there could be some
  5182. 3:43:00issues there where we would be looking
  5183. 3:43:01at additional tribal support. And for
  5184. 3:43:0326, our tribal support was over 21
  5185. 3:43:06million that was requested. Obviously, a
  5186. 3:43:08$13 million def or 13 million deficit.
  5187. 3:43:11In FY27, the numbers that have come in
  5188. 3:43:13so far are we're looking at 23.6 million
  5189. 3:43:17in tribal support requests. So, the
  5190. 3:43:19requests for 27 have gone up 2.6 6
  5191. 3:43:22million. So, the deficit I would imagine
  5192. 3:43:25would be less or increased, I'm sorry,
  5193. 3:43:28for
  5194. 3:43:28>> Can you tell me what the $2.6 million um
  5195. 3:43:31worth of additional expenses are?
  5196. 3:43:33>> No, I don't have that right now. I was
  5197. 3:43:34just working with Jen on the numbers.
  5198. 3:43:36So, but we can pull that together.
  5199. 3:43:38>> Okay. Aaron. So, um I think Tyler might
  5200. 3:43:41have said it, but we shouldn't let
  5201. 3:43:43justice slip past us without doing
  5202. 3:43:45something about it. um we have been not
  5203. 3:43:49giving direction to staff about what
  5204. 3:43:52they should be requesting to stay
  5205. 3:43:53within. So we need to do that. We need
  5206. 3:43:56to do drivers out to tell them because
  5207. 3:43:59here we have how much more two and a
  5208. 3:44:00half million more. Um and I I still
  5209. 3:44:03don't think I think the creation of this
  5210. 3:44:05deficit spending is of our own doing
  5211. 3:44:07because we haven't reset the 17 million
  5212. 3:44:10um tribal support draw down which was in
  5213. 3:44:13place before the pandemic. That's all
  5214. 3:44:15artificial, but um whatever number we
  5215. 3:44:18decide on, that's the number we should
  5216. 3:44:20be sending out to departments to draft
  5217. 3:44:23up. And what we used to do at different
  5218. 3:44:24times when we were facing sequestration
  5219. 3:44:27is we would go through the exercise of
  5220. 3:44:29saying, "Okay, project your budget at um
  5221. 3:44:33here's the ceiling, projected at a 5%
  5222. 3:44:36decrease, a a one and a half% decrease,
  5223. 3:44:40a 3% decrease. Um what would that look
  5224. 3:44:42like?" and and it's it's more work, but
  5225. 3:44:45it's really not that much more work for
  5226. 3:44:47people who know what they're doing. Um,
  5227. 3:44:49so if we were to send that directive out
  5228. 3:44:52ahead of time, um, then we wouldn't be
  5229. 3:44:54getting budgets asking for these
  5230. 3:44:57increases that that we can't
  5231. 3:44:59accommodate. So, so Tyler mentioned it.
  5232. 3:45:02I've been saying it since I came back to
  5233. 3:45:04office, but we haven't done anything to
  5234. 3:45:06give them direction. So, Mike
  5235. 3:45:13Just to add on to that, um I and I said
  5236. 3:45:16this at a previous workshop and I'm
  5237. 3:45:18going to keep on continuing saying it is
  5238. 3:45:20that we have all of you right here too.
  5239. 3:45:23And so when something comes forward and
  5240. 3:45:25it's not you guys don't think it's good
  5241. 3:45:28fiscally responsible to be doing, we
  5242. 3:45:31need to hear no more often from all of
  5243. 3:45:33you guys. And so I will stand on that
  5244. 3:45:36every single time too is that we rarely
  5245. 3:45:39rarely rarely hear no. We hear this is
  5246. 3:45:42requested and then we approve, but at
  5247. 3:45:45the end of the day we we need that no
  5248. 3:45:48too. We really do. We need to hear it
  5249. 3:45:50from you guys. Um
  5250. 3:45:53and I'm hoping it happens more often. So
  5251. 3:45:57I will leave I'll leave it at that.
  5252. 3:45:59>> Holly, have you gotten that number?
  5253. 3:46:03Still still working on it. Okay. All
  5254. 3:46:05right. Anything else, Ryan?
  5255. 3:46:08>> No.
  5256. 3:46:09>> Then dare I say final questions,
  5257. 3:46:11comments from the board?
  5258. 3:46:14>> There you heard the word. No,
  5259. 3:46:15>> just procedurally. Sorry.
  5260. 3:46:17>> Yeah, mine is just procedurally.
  5261. 3:46:20>> Does Bill have anything to add on the
  5262. 3:46:21infrastructure of it once we make these
  5263. 3:46:24changes happen within our three branch?
  5264. 3:46:27>> Come on up, Bill. All you're already
  5265. 3:46:29there talking about a different bill.
  5266. 3:46:30So, Bill, how would uh the department
  5267. 3:46:31that you manage be impacted if our
  5268. 3:46:34membership were to enact this
  5269. 3:46:36constitutional amendment?
  5270. 3:46:38>> So, um Ryan, [clears throat] do you have
  5271. 3:46:39that um slide? What I'm slide number two
  5272. 3:46:42is what I'm after.
  5273. 3:46:45[clears throat]
  5274. 3:46:46So, in short, um and it it'll be up here
  5275. 3:46:49in just a moment. Um I showed this at
  5276. 3:46:52the um this second one. I showed this at
  5277. 3:46:55the uh board training um for the new
  5278. 3:46:58members recently and I know this is a
  5279. 3:47:01bit of an eye chart here but um if you
  5280. 3:47:04look at that overall organizational
  5281. 3:47:06structure of information technology here
  5282. 3:47:07at the tribe what you see on the extreme
  5283. 3:47:10right column is Q8 IT and there's a fair
  5284. 3:47:14number of people in there because
  5285. 3:47:15they've got 247 operations lot you know
  5286. 3:47:18so on and so forth. Um, then there's
  5287. 3:47:21health IT, which you can see doesn't
  5288. 3:47:24really have a whole bunch of people. And
  5289. 3:47:25then there's everything to the left, and
  5290. 3:47:28that's all government IT. And government
  5291. 3:47:31it does shared services for
  5292. 3:47:35QA, well for everybody basically. So
  5293. 3:47:38that org chart is covering things like
  5294. 3:47:41wiring, IT service desk, cyber security,
  5295. 3:47:45things like that. So the message that I
  5296. 3:47:48have for the you know for the board of
  5297. 3:47:49directors here today is
  5298. 3:47:52changing over day one has a couple of
  5299. 3:47:54factors but I don't see a huge
  5300. 3:47:56substantive change in terms of what it's
  5301. 3:47:59going to require to get us transition to
  5302. 3:48:02the new government. We already support
  5303. 3:48:03the courts. We already support the PD.
  5304. 3:48:06We already support the legislature. Um
  5305. 3:48:09all of those things can continue on. Um,
  5306. 3:48:12and we're leveraging the fact that we've
  5307. 3:48:14got it's really hard to hire people up
  5308. 3:48:17here and it's hard to retain them. We've
  5309. 3:48:19had six people go to Bay Mills within
  5310. 3:48:22the past uh year since I've been here.
  5311. 3:48:25So, and basically it's more money for
  5312. 3:48:28effectively less work. So that's an
  5313. 3:48:32issue that we're trying to to address
  5314. 3:48:34obviously, but the the the big point is
  5315. 3:48:37the challenge that we have getting
  5316. 3:48:39people to come to the Sue with the kind
  5317. 3:48:42of skill sets that we need to run
  5318. 3:48:44technology. So that's a factor. Um, so
  5319. 3:48:47changing dramatically what we're doing
  5320. 3:48:49right now, particularly given the fact
  5321. 3:48:52that we've got four major in-flight line
  5322. 3:48:55of business changes, which I keep
  5323. 3:48:57telling everybody who in their right
  5324. 3:48:58mind would do that in one year, but um,
  5325. 3:49:01clearly I'm not in my right mind, but we
  5326. 3:49:03were so bagged up against the wall on it
  5327. 3:49:06that we just had to absorb all that
  5328. 3:49:08stuff. Those those things are in flight.
  5329. 3:49:10We're changing the financial system that
  5330. 3:49:12affects every one of the verticals.
  5331. 3:49:13We're changing the payroll and uh human
  5332. 3:49:16capital management systems. We're
  5333. 3:49:18changing um the health record system.
  5334. 3:49:21All of these things are foundational and
  5335. 3:49:24modernizing. But we can't we got to keep
  5336. 3:49:27the lights on. So going forward, I think
  5337. 3:49:31the best model for technology is to as
  5338. 3:49:35these imperatives come with code changes
  5339. 3:49:38and things like that that we stay on top
  5340. 3:49:39of it. I'm not going to sit here and
  5341. 3:49:41tell you that it may not make sense to
  5342. 3:49:43change the structure somewhat, but I
  5343. 3:49:46think right now given what we have going
  5344. 3:49:48for the tribe and the strategic
  5345. 3:49:50initiatives that are after we get
  5346. 3:49:52through all of this basic renovation and
  5347. 3:49:55elimination of 15 years of technical
  5348. 3:49:57debt. um once we get through that
  5349. 3:49:59renovation, we're going to be in a
  5350. 3:50:01really good position to start actually
  5351. 3:50:03um efficiently serving the membership
  5352. 3:50:06with u with new things without
  5353. 3:50:08substantially increasing the cost. And I
  5354. 3:50:11heard a bunch of discussion today about
  5355. 3:50:13well we can do this and we can save
  5356. 3:50:14money here and save money there. Well,
  5357. 3:50:16every single thing that we do is touched
  5358. 3:50:18by technology like having the courts
  5359. 3:50:21work remotely touched by technology. How
  5360. 3:50:24do we plan to to move that stuff out? a
  5361. 3:50:27lot of that stuff is already licensed.
  5362. 3:50:29It's already part of what we have. So,
  5363. 3:50:32um that's going to be my focus um and my
  5364. 3:50:36commentary for this moment.
  5365. 3:50:39>> Okay, Tyler. So, with your with your um
  5366. 3:50:44expertise gap, um isn't there isn't it
  5367. 3:50:48part of your plan to go more and more to
  5368. 3:50:50remote employment to fill that gap?
  5369. 3:50:53>> Well, that's something we have to
  5370. 3:50:54consider. Um there has been an
  5371. 3:50:56institutional
  5372. 3:50:58um an institutional bias towards hiring
  5373. 3:51:01people and putting them in a chair here.
  5374. 3:51:03Many of the jobs like cyber security
  5375. 3:51:05analysts that type of job doesn't need
  5376. 3:51:07to be here.
  5377. 3:51:08>> There's there's three dozen people that
  5378. 3:51:11I know of that work remotely in
  5379. 3:51:13Marquette. [clears throat]
  5380. 3:51:14>> You know there there's no reason
  5381. 3:51:15especially for cyber security and and IT
  5382. 3:51:18infrastructure. The Sue tribe has a
  5383. 3:51:20policy standing that you can have a
  5384. 3:51:23remote workforce. So, as the director of
  5385. 3:51:26IT or the CIO, like if that is your
  5386. 3:51:29recommendation, just move on it. Get it
  5387. 3:51:31get those seats filled, you know, and
  5388. 3:51:34and make sure that people are doing what
  5389. 3:51:36they're supposed to be doing. Just hold
  5390. 3:51:37them accountable.
  5391. 3:51:39>> Okay, you got it. I
  5392. 3:51:41>> I don't know where the bias is coming
  5393. 3:51:42from because right now it is in code
  5394. 3:51:44that they are allowed to work remote if
  5395. 3:51:46they have the capability to do so.
  5396. 3:51:48Okay, Aaron, Lana, and then I'm going to
  5397. 3:51:51ask if any other executives have any
  5398. 3:51:53questions, comments about things. I'll
  5399. 3:51:55give the board of directors one final
  5400. 3:51:57opportunity for question or comment and
  5401. 3:51:59then we'll adjourn for the day. So
  5402. 3:52:01Aaron, then Lana, and then we'll go
  5403. 3:52:03through here, see if anyone has anything
  5404. 3:52:05to say. Go ahead.
  5405. 3:52:06>> Yeah. So the with respect to the remote
  5406. 3:52:09work for those team members um there
  5407. 3:52:12especially the the crew that are trained
  5408. 3:52:14to do that kind of work in two places I
  5409. 3:52:17worked uh while I was out of office um
  5410. 3:52:19you um that work was all contracted work
  5411. 3:52:23100% of it. So um what we're doing is
  5412. 3:52:26antiquated in the way that the rest of
  5413. 3:52:27the world does this. So because um for
  5414. 3:52:30whatever reason I I don't think it's the
  5415. 3:52:32geek shall inherit the earth but they
  5416. 3:52:34have a lot of power and they can set the
  5417. 3:52:36tone of where they want to work and
  5418. 3:52:38that's what they choose to do. So um and
  5419. 3:52:40you do as uh Tyler said you do have that
  5420. 3:52:43because the board put that in place they
  5421. 3:52:44never rescended it. So you have that
  5422. 3:52:46luxury right now.
  5423. 3:52:48>> Lena.
  5424. 3:52:50Yeah, and just to piggyback off that,
  5425. 3:52:51that's one of the reasons why we did it
  5426. 3:52:53is so that um you guys would have the
  5427. 3:52:55flexibility in order to retain and
  5428. 3:52:58recruit those specialty positions. So,
  5429. 3:53:01if um we had asked or I had asked months
  5430. 3:53:04ago, you know, about uh a report on
  5431. 3:53:07whether it's working and whether it's
  5432. 3:53:08not and it's, you know, it's kind of
  5433. 3:53:11saddening to find out that we're not
  5434. 3:53:13doing that when that's one of the main
  5435. 3:53:15reasons that we put it into effect. I
  5436. 3:53:17didn't support it at the beginning.
  5437. 3:53:19Tyler convinced me it was a perfect
  5438. 3:53:22opportunity for us to recruit and
  5439. 3:53:24retain. So, I would also say that as
  5440. 3:53:27well. I mean, if they I hear from so
  5441. 3:53:29many tribal members that when they can
  5442. 3:53:30work remote, they get a lot more done.
  5443. 3:53:33But, it is going to take a strong uh
  5444. 3:53:35manager to make sure that work is
  5445. 3:53:37getting done and complete. We still have
  5446. 3:53:39glitches in our system. I believe that
  5447. 3:53:41some people it's working for and some
  5448. 3:53:43people it's not. I haven't seen that on
  5449. 3:53:45paper yet, but I hear from different
  5450. 3:53:47departments. So, I'm waiting on that for
  5451. 3:53:49the board to see, but um especially in
  5452. 3:53:54your line of work, that is something
  5453. 3:53:56that we should and that was one of the
  5454. 3:53:59reasons why I supported is because of
  5455. 3:54:02it. So,
  5456. 3:54:03>> so, um, if I could address that a couple
  5457. 3:54:06of points. I was aware that we do have a
  5458. 3:54:08remote work policy. Um, and it's been a
  5459. 3:54:12whirlwind of a year working with the
  5460. 3:54:14staff that we have. We're in the throws
  5461. 3:54:15of some turnover right now. Um, many of
  5462. 3:54:19the applicants that we get are require
  5463. 3:54:23H-1B support or things of that nature.
  5464. 3:54:26So when you when you put out a wide
  5465. 3:54:28cast, you end up having trouble culling
  5466. 3:54:30through some of the resumes and all of
  5467. 3:54:32that. So that whole thing comes to the
  5468. 3:54:35four and now that I'm having this
  5469. 3:54:37discussion with you, which I had planned
  5470. 3:54:38on bringing up with the board, um
  5471. 3:54:42I'm all for it. I worked for the last
  5472. 3:54:44three years completely virtual. My
  5473. 3:54:46company was in six time zones. So um
  5474. 3:54:49over 200 employees and of that only
  5475. 3:54:51about 30 of them were actually in
  5476. 3:54:54company facilities. So, I get the model.
  5477. 3:54:58I love it.
  5478. 3:55:00[laughter] I love it.
  5479. 3:55:02>> Okay. So, I called on Aaron. I called on
  5480. 3:55:04Lana. Do any executives here at the
  5481. 3:55:06table have any questions, comments,
  5482. 3:55:08anything at all?
  5483. 3:55:12>> I have the number that you asked for.
  5484. 3:55:15However, I'm going to throw out that I
  5485. 3:55:17put it together pretty quickly, so I
  5486. 3:55:19don't want to be held to
  5487. 3:55:21>> this exact [laughter] value. I'm
  5488. 3:55:23throwing the disclaimer out.
  5489. 3:55:25>> So, this would be the past budgets for
  5490. 3:55:26casino, EDC, health, government. What's
  5491. 3:55:29it all at?
  5492. 3:55:30>> Correct. And I um
  5493. 3:55:34my total is 322,641,74169.
  5494. 3:55:41>> 322 million. And And what's the what's
  5495. 3:55:43the rest?
  5496. 3:55:4532 3 mil 322,641,74169.
  5497. 3:55:53>> So let's just round to 32.5 million3
  5498. 3:55:58>> 33
  5499. 3:56:00>> 323 $323 million. Let's just round it up
  5500. 3:56:03a little bit.
  5501. 3:56:04>> Okay. 323. Ryan, what is the last
  5502. 3:56:06estimate for bare bones operating this
  5503. 3:56:10new government?
  5504. 3:56:13uh 1.7 million give or take uh probably
  5505. 3:56:16a few hundred thousand for the things we
  5506. 3:56:18mentioned that aren't in that estimate
  5507. 3:56:20like elections. So say 2 million 2
  5508. 3:56:23million.
  5509. 3:56:24>> So about a half half a percent increase
  5510. 3:56:26in the total cost of operating our
  5511. 3:56:28government. I just wanted to break that
  5512. 3:56:29down for you guys. About a half a about
  5513. 3:56:33a half a percent more. That really puts
  5514. 3:56:36it in perspective. Also what can put it
  5515. 3:56:38in perspective? I know it isn't
  5516. 3:56:40completely relevant because we passed or
  5517. 3:56:42we're getting close to the obligation
  5518. 3:56:43deadline. How much money do we receive
  5519. 3:56:45in ARP and care both combined?
  5520. 3:56:55>> It'll take me just a second to put that
  5521. 3:56:56together.
  5522. 3:56:57>> All right. Well, I I'll say what I'm
  5523. 3:56:58going to say then.
  5524. 3:57:00>> So,
  5525. 3:57:02you just heard I mean our government
  5526. 3:57:04costs $323 million to operate every
  5527. 3:57:07single year. half a percent increase
  5528. 3:57:09gets you that new government. I'm
  5529. 3:57:10convinced that within that $323 million,
  5530. 3:57:13there is fat. There is savings. So,
  5531. 3:57:16Holly was correct earlier today when we
  5532. 3:57:17talked about our government's inability
  5533. 3:57:19to collect its own revenue. We have to
  5534. 3:57:21tax revenue. And to answer some board
  5535. 3:57:23members questions, we already have
  5536. 3:57:25identified new funding sources for this
  5537. 3:57:27government. That would include
  5538. 3:57:28potentially taxing the housing
  5539. 3:57:29authority, taxing the health division,
  5540. 3:57:31and taxing STI. all those businesses
  5541. 3:57:34would be taxed in the real world if they
  5542. 3:57:35would operate outside the reservation.
  5543. 3:57:37In addition to that, a big goal of this
  5544. 3:57:39government is that we make more
  5545. 3:57:41responsible choices moving forward.
  5546. 3:57:43Choices that won't get us sued. So, the
  5547. 3:57:45biggest thing that's hurt the tribe
  5548. 3:57:47moving forward is the downstate gambling
  5549. 3:57:49expansion. Between Greek Town and JLJ,
  5550. 3:57:51you're well over $und00 million. And you
  5551. 3:57:54know, we had to use a lot of our ARPA
  5552. 3:57:56and CARES Act funding for cleanup. And
  5553. 3:57:58that was a big reason. If you subtract a
  5554. 3:58:00hundred million dollars and then some
  5555. 3:58:01from a tribal community, you are going
  5556. 3:58:03to feel the impact of that. So with
  5557. 3:58:05this, you have a board of directors that
  5558. 3:58:07becomes legislators. And in that role, I
  5559. 3:58:09think they do a better job passing the
  5560. 3:58:10budget. If they're just focused on
  5561. 3:58:12passing a budget and passing
  5562. 3:58:14legislation, I think that we have a
  5563. 3:58:16balanced budget if we do that. I really
  5564. 3:58:18do. Beyond that, we can't ignore the
  5565. 3:58:21fact that this supervision model that we
  5566. 3:58:23currently have is notoriously tough on
  5567. 3:58:24employees. I told Al the other day he is
  5568. 3:58:27the only key employee since I've been
  5569. 3:58:29part of the board of directors that
  5570. 3:58:30hasn't been terminated or resigned and
  5571. 3:58:32we have another resignation that we have
  5572. 3:58:34to approve tomorrow. It's a difficult
  5573. 3:58:36place to work under this model and that
  5574. 3:58:38can't be disputed because the statistics
  5575. 3:58:40speak for itself. Um in addition to
  5576. 3:58:42that, we talked about some of the
  5577. 3:58:43misconceptions with this government
  5578. 3:58:45model. Most of the operations will be uh
  5579. 3:58:47supervised by authorities. The
  5580. 3:58:49government ones would be supervised by
  5581. 3:58:51my office. Uh but if I don't do a good
  5582. 3:58:53job, vote me out. And that's that's what
  5583. 3:58:54you have to do to produce this kind of
  5584. 3:58:56accountability. So in short, I thought
  5585. 3:58:58that this would be much more expensive.
  5586. 3:59:00I really did and I see how we spend
  5587. 3:59:02money in this tribe. So to be able to
  5588. 3:59:04provide tribal members with standing
  5589. 3:59:06within our government, I think is
  5590. 3:59:08definitely worth just south of $2
  5591. 3:59:10million because again, I'm a resident of
  5592. 3:59:12the city of Sue St. Marie, the state of
  5593. 3:59:14Michigan, and the federal government. I
  5594. 3:59:15have standing in each of those
  5595. 3:59:17governments. I don't have it in the
  5596. 3:59:18tribal government at all. I can't sue
  5597. 3:59:20this government if they screw me over.
  5598. 3:59:22Neither can any one of our well we have
  5599. 3:59:25over 50,000 citizens and that's a
  5600. 3:59:26problem. Um so I think this is
  5601. 3:59:28affordable. Beyond that it increases the
  5602. 3:59:31uh protections for our citizens. It
  5603. 3:59:33lowers the threshold to do referendums
  5604. 3:59:35significantly. Also under this new model
  5605. 3:59:38tribal citizens would be able to amend
  5606. 3:59:40our constitution which they currently
  5607. 3:59:42don't have the ability to do. And that's
  5608. 3:59:44huge. And we wouldn't have to go through
  5609. 3:59:46the BIA again. we'd be able to exercise
  5610. 3:59:48our sovereignty as a sovereign nation to
  5611. 3:59:50amend our own constitution. But namely
  5612. 3:59:54the biggest thing that I like about this
  5613. 3:59:56is that we had a choice in it. So you
  5614. 3:59:59create board of directors to oversee
  5615. 4:00:01businesses like Coca-Cola.
  5616. 4:00:04Corporate boards aren't meant to
  5617. 4:00:05supervise and lead nations. You know
  5618. 4:00:08what I mean? And I mean because we have
  5619. 4:00:09a corporate board, that's one of the
  5620. 4:00:11reasons why we have the shortcomings
  5621. 4:00:12that we do. I think you know we have a
  5622. 4:00:14lot of infighting. All it takes is one
  5623. 4:00:16person from this body to create a toxic
  5624. 4:00:18work environment for one of our key
  5625. 4:00:20employees and there's not a whole lot
  5626. 4:00:22that board members can do to please each
  5627. 4:00:24other if that occurs and that
  5628. 4:00:25contributes to the issues that we have.
  5629. 4:00:27Um so those are the reasons that I'm
  5630. 4:00:29supportive of this. This is affordable.
  5631. 4:00:31Again, it costs you less than half of a
  5632. 4:00:34percent compared to what's currently
  5633. 4:00:36costing your government right now. You
  5634. 4:00:38know, Holly, did you come up with how
  5635. 4:00:39much we had in cares and ARPA? Well, I
  5636. 4:00:43know we had probably at least I remember
  5637. 4:00:46the first deposit being 47 million in
  5638. 4:00:49CAR's funds, but we had 272 million um
  5639. 4:00:53that I'm showing in ARPA that pass
  5640. 4:00:55through the ARPA cost center. I think it
  5641. 4:00:59is important to note though that some of
  5642. 4:01:00these funds are restricted as we're
  5643. 4:01:02looking at these, right? There's
  5644. 4:01:04restrictions. Some of it's coming in
  5645. 4:01:05from federal government. So,
  5646. 4:01:07>> right, but it's also important to note
  5647. 4:01:09that we could have used some of the ARP
  5648. 4:01:10and CARES Act funding to create some of
  5649. 4:01:12the infrastructure that we're now being
  5650. 4:01:13forced to pay out of our own pockets.
  5651. 4:01:15And that's a fair thing to point out.
  5652. 4:01:16>> Very much so.
  5653. 4:01:17>> Okay. So, that's my two cents. This is
  5654. 4:01:19affordable. You have Judge Leaport
  5655. 4:01:22that's on there that's not screaming for
  5656. 4:01:23the hills. This isn't going to work. You
  5657. 4:01:25have general counsel. Like, we're
  5658. 4:01:26willing to make this work, you guys.
  5659. 4:01:28Okay? And if we can't afford this, we
  5660. 4:01:30can't afford a whole lot of things that
  5661. 4:01:32are coming down the pipeline. And I'm
  5662. 4:01:33going to point that out every single
  5663. 4:01:34time. We've been workshopping different
  5664. 4:01:36projects while we don't have a balanced
  5665. 4:01:38budget. And I'd be willing to bet that
  5666. 4:01:40if you add up the cost of all those
  5667. 4:01:42projects such as a new license plate
  5668. 4:01:44program, enhanced licenses,
  5669. 4:01:47um potentially a new website, I'd be
  5670. 4:01:49willing to bet that that would cost over
  5671. 4:01:51a couple million bucks, you know, and I
  5672. 4:01:53put low hanging fruit to sibly property
  5673. 4:01:54on there. I know some people have some
  5674. 4:01:56differing opinions as far as what we can
  5675. 4:01:58do with it, but that property, nothing
  5676. 4:02:00has been done with it the last 15 years.
  5677. 4:02:02It will never be a casino. Not now, not
  5678. 4:02:04ever. We pursued that all the way up to
  5679. 4:02:06the US Supreme Court, and they declined
  5680. 4:02:07to hear that case. So, it can't be a
  5681. 4:02:09casino. So, if it's going to become
  5682. 4:02:11something else, then we need to figure
  5683. 4:02:13out what it's going to be. And if we
  5684. 4:02:15can't afford a new government, it puts
  5685. 4:02:17into question whether or not we can
  5686. 4:02:18afford developing that property. You're
  5687. 4:02:20most likely not going to be able to get
  5688. 4:02:21partners on that. Considering our last
  5689. 4:02:23partner with that very specific property
  5690. 4:02:25had to take us to court, not once, but
  5691. 4:02:27twice, because we had an $88 million
  5692. 4:02:29judgment found against us, and then we
  5693. 4:02:31missed the payment and had to pay him
  5694. 4:02:32again. So, it's my position. Um, it's
  5695. 4:02:36something that I told the membership I'd
  5696. 4:02:37support and I'm going to keep my word on
  5697. 4:02:39it. So, Holly, did you get those
  5698. 4:02:42numbers? So, just south of what, 400
  5699. 4:02:44million?
  5700. 4:02:46>> Um, yeah, definitely 300 million for
  5701. 4:02:50sure.
  5702. 4:02:50>> Okay. So, we've got hundreds of millions
  5703. 4:02:52of dollars the last six years between
  5704. 4:02:54ARP and CARES and they are restricted,
  5705. 4:02:56but as evidence, we could have been
  5706. 4:02:58smarter about it. And that's all I'm
  5707. 4:02:59going to say. I'm not going to put my
  5708. 4:03:00hand up again today. Just as a point of
  5709. 4:03:02information, some of the restricted
  5710. 4:03:04dollars are spendable if it meets those
  5711. 4:03:08requirements and because some of them
  5712. 4:03:10are like uh Rama the Rama settlement or
  5713. 4:03:13contract support cost settlement. Those
  5714. 4:03:15dollars can be spent on health. So
  5715. 4:03:17they're not completely off limits. They
  5716. 4:03:19could be applied towards um reducing um
  5717. 4:03:23well we don't have tribal support third
  5718. 4:03:24party or in the health division but
  5719. 4:03:26reducing third party revenue that would
  5720. 4:03:28make that available too. So So Correct.
  5721. 4:03:31Or for software. Some of it like the IHS
  5722. 4:03:34contract support could be for software.
  5723. 4:03:36Yep.
  5724. 4:03:37>> Okay. Anything else from anybody?
  5725. 4:03:40>> All righty. I'll see you guys tomorrow
  5726. 4:03:41then.
  5727. 4:03:42>> Can I
  5728. 4:03:43>> I want to just remind everybody we are
  5729. 4:03:45not meeting next Monday because it's
  5730. 4:03:46Labor Day. So the next meeting on a
  5731. 4:03:49Monday is the 14th.
  5732. 4:03:52And if everybody's good with it, I'll
  5733. 4:03:54just work with Ryan on what we're going
  5734. 4:03:56to present that day and we'll notice it
  5735. 4:03:58as a workshop. Again, I'm assuming we're
  5736. 4:04:01going to start going through some of the
  5737. 4:04:02priority codes during these sessions.
  5738. 4:04:06>> Yeah, that's fine. I will not be there
  5739. 4:04:07on that Monday, but Josh, you're in good
  5740. 4:04:09hands with Josh and we'll make sure that
  5741. 4:04:11we're all prepped and ready to go. So,
  5742. 4:04:14>> all right, everybody. Workshop adjourns.
  5743. 4:04:16See everyone tomorrow.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Board of Directors Broadcast - SAULT 8/31/26 by Sault Tribe TV, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 39,234 words across 5,743 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.