Bitcoin: The Bull's Dilemma — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Hey everyone and thanks for jumping back
- 0:02into the cryptoverse.
- 0:05Today we're going to talk about Bitcoin,
- 0:08the bull's dilemma. If you guys like the
- 0:10content, make sure you subscribe to the
- 0:12channel, give the video a thumbs up, and
- 0:14also check out the sale on ITC Premium
- 0:18at into the cryptoverse.com.
- 0:21The ITC conference is only two days
- 0:25away, so I look forward to seeing every
- 0:28one of you guys there. that is able to
- 0:30make it. There have been a lot of people
- 0:33that have asked if you can view it
- 0:36online. So, I did want to address that
- 0:38because I know a lot of you have those
- 0:40questions. We've got a lot of great
- 0:41speakers coming. Um, obviously Michael
- 0:44Sailor will be there. Uh, we've got
- 0:45Grant Cardone, Jim Carson, Mark Yusco,
- 0:48Mike McGlo, we've got Allesio and James
- 0:50Czech, Guy, Rob, Gareth. I mean, you
- 0:53guys see the list, right? David, Jason,
- 0:55Leah, Tom, FA, Randy, Evan, Dana, Matt,
- 0:59Crosby, and Mauricio. So, I think it's
- 1:01going to be a pretty good lineup and
- 1:03it'll be a mix of both people who are
- 1:06more bullish and people who are bearish.
- 1:11And in this video, I want to talk about
- 1:14the bull's dilemma. But as far as the
- 1:17conference goes, if you can't make it,
- 1:21there will be a way for you to view it
- 1:23online. Okay? So, I actually just set
- 1:27this up on my YouTube channel. I turned
- 1:30on memberships. So, if you want, you can
- 1:32sign up for that. You could always just
- 1:34sign up, watch it, and then be done with
- 1:37it. If you don't want to do that, right?
- 1:40If you don't want to pay, which is fine.
- 1:42Like, I hear you. I hear you. We will
- 1:44make the videos public I think the week
- 1:48of December 7th. Okay. So, if you want
- 1:51to view it live, that's different. But
- 1:54if you don't if you don't care about
- 1:55that and you just want to be able to see
- 1:57the talks, then you'll be able to do
- 2:00that in just a few weeks. So, don't
- 2:02worry. It will all get out there. But, I
- 2:04just want to let you guys know there
- 2:06will be a way to view it online. You
- 2:07won't completely just miss out if you
- 2:09can't be there. And I know some of you
- 2:11would like to be there, but you can't
- 2:14you just can't make it there, right? And
- 2:15I understand that. I mean, I have I have
- 2:17five kids. I've there have been hundreds
- 2:20of conferences that I've wanted to go
- 2:22to,
- 2:25but I can't, you know, because um
- 2:28there's other more important
- 2:29responsibilities like family. So,
- 2:33let's talk about the bull's dilemma,
- 2:34right? And I I'm going to go through
- 2:37this as systematically as I can. And I I
- 2:40want you guys to see the market in the
- 2:44way that I see it. You don't have to
- 2:46agree with it. In fact, many of you
- 2:48won't. But I think at this point, we
- 2:51could at least all agree whether you are
- 2:54a bull or a bear,
- 2:57you haven't really gotten what you want
- 2:59over the last eight months or so, right?
- 3:02Like neither side has really gotten what
- 3:05they want. Obviously, the Bears want
- 3:08Bitcoin below 60. The Bulls want it
- 3:11below uh above 80 and the Bears briefly
- 3:15got it below 60 in the summer and the
- 3:18bulls briefly got it above 80 in Q3.
- 3:22Neither side is really getting what they
- 3:25want. Okay, so I want to talk about the
- 3:29bulls.
- 3:32If you like hearing me cough online,
- 3:36you're going to love hearing me cough at
- 3:37the conference. Okay. So,
- 3:40what I want to do is I want to show you
- 3:42guys a few charts
- 3:45that
- 3:46are close to being at the point where
- 3:49you could argue they've reset, but
- 3:52they're not quite there. And we also
- 3:54find ourselves in Q4 of a midterm year,
- 3:57which is a window of weakness for this
- 3:59theoretically to occur. I can't promise
- 4:02and there's some exceptions and I'll
- 4:03show that. But this is the window of
- 4:06weakness, right? This is this is where
- 4:08you would expect it to happen. And if it
- 4:10doesn't happen in the next 7 weeks, then
- 4:14it's less likely to happen for a while,
- 4:16right? Seven or eight weeks. If it
- 4:17doesn't happen in that in that window,
- 4:19then I imagine a lot of bears will
- 4:22simply become bulls again. So, here we
- 4:25go. We're going to start. Okay. Number
- 4:29one,
- 4:31look at the market in a different way
- 4:33than just the USD valuation. The USD
- 4:36valuation is misleading, right? It is
- 4:38because they're never going to stop
- 4:41printing money. And you know, you should
- 4:44measure Bitcoin against other things.
- 4:46But one really interesting thing to
- 4:48measure it against is USDT
- 4:53dominance.
- 4:55USDT dominance. And you might be
- 4:57scratching your head, but I want you to
- 4:59look at this chart.
- 5:01What you'll notice is that this chart
- 5:06has a habit of resetting
- 5:09to the lows, right? Has a habit of
- 5:12resetting to the lows. And you'll see
- 5:16that it reset to the lows from
- 5:19essentially the same level in November
- 5:21of 2018. The main differences then is
- 5:25that the high is where we currently are
- 5:28now after the drop. But that's because
- 5:30we had a larger counter trend rally in
- 5:32Q3 than we did back in 2018. And that's
- 5:35why I say that there's remnants of 2020
- 5:38and also 2015. But in 2020, there was a
- 5:41rally above a prior high when you look
- 5:43at it divided by USDT dominance, just
- 5:46like there was right here. And you can
- 5:48see back then, we still eventually made
- 5:50it down here. And then look in 2022,
- 5:54we were actually at this level more or
- 5:57less in March and we still made it down
- 6:02there, right? We still made it down
- 6:04there. So I think part of the bull's
- 6:08dilemma
- 6:09is that if you want to be a bull, which
- 6:13I I wouldn't mind flipping soon, right?
- 6:16And I wouldn't mind flipping to the more
- 6:18bullish bias soon, especially in the
- 6:19pre-h having year.
- 6:22But if you want to be a bull,
- 6:24you look at this chart and you're like,
- 6:26well, is this time really different
- 6:29or is the drop to that level
- 6:33just hasn't happened yet? Right? So I
- 6:36look at it, I'm like, what if it just
- 6:38hasn't happened yet?
- 6:40That's number one. Now, this chart is
- 6:44not the easiest to understand.
- 6:46One of the reasons is because USDT
- 6:50dominance changes, right? Like you're
- 6:52dividing by something that changes. And
- 6:54if you look at USDT dominance, you'll
- 6:57see that it's been going up recently,
- 6:59right? So, we're dividing it by
- 7:01something that is changing. And if USDT
- 7:05dominance goes up,
- 7:08right, if it goes up, then you're
- 7:10dividing, you're taking Bitcoin and
- 7:12dividing it by something that is going
- 7:14up. meaning the ratio would go down. So
- 7:18when you when you look at a chart like
- 7:20Bitcoin divided by USDT dominance, it
- 7:23might seem like it's a larger drop than
- 7:26it really is because from this level, if
- 7:28you just take this down, it looks like
- 7:30it's like an 80% drop, but that's not
- 7:32true, right? Like it's not an 80% drop.
- 7:35It because you're dividing it, you'd be
- 7:36dividing it by something that is going
- 7:38up while Bitcoin is going down. So it's
- 7:42not as large of a drop as it may seem.
- 7:46Furthermore, what also affects this
- 7:49chart is the market cap of USDT. That is
- 7:54also changing. So, I it's really
- 7:56complicated when you really get into the
- 7:58weeds of it. But this chart right here
- 8:00is another reason why this is a bull's
- 8:04dilemma. This is another reason. And the
- 8:07reason is if you look at USDT dominance,
- 8:11and by the way, some of you guys are
- 8:13going to be like, well, why don't you
- 8:14include [laughter]
- 8:17other stable coins? Why don't we, right?
- 8:19Why don't we just go ahead and do that?
- 8:20Okay, let's look at stable coin
- 8:22dominance. What do you notice?
- 8:25Or sorry, this is stable coin market
- 8:27cap. What do you notice?
- 8:30There was a February low. There was a
- 8:35July low. Guess what? We've completely
- 8:39taken that out in Q4. Completely. It's
- 8:42gone in the rearview mirror. And you
- 8:44guys know how I spent like all year for
- 8:47Bitcoin saying, "Expect a February low,
- 8:51a summer low, and a Q4 low."
- 8:55Look at this chart.
- 8:59February low, summer low, Q4 low. But
- 9:05the dilemma here for the bulls
- 9:10is that the February low and the July
- 9:13low for Bitcoin were more or less the
- 9:15same thing, right? They were around 60K.
- 9:18But now, stable coin dominance or sorry,
- 9:21stable coin market cap did not find
- 9:23support
- 9:26at 305 billion like it did back in July
- 9:31and and February. It's now at 293
- 9:34billion. So, liquidity
- 9:37is leaving the space.
- 9:41So, it's hard for me to pretend like
- 9:46like I it can't go lower than it did in
- 9:49July when I see stable coin market cap
- 9:53bleeding out.
- 9:56Okay, so that kind of covers it from the
- 9:59stable coin perspective.
- 10:03You know how when you look at Bitcoin
- 10:06USD divided by USDT dominance,
- 10:11this level that we just hit
- 10:14is similar to March of 2022.
- 10:19The other thing similar to March 2022
- 10:23is the Bitcoin performance after the
- 10:27first rate hike in a rate hiking cycle.
- 10:30Now, I don't believe that this rate
- 10:32hiking cycle will be nearly as bad as
- 10:35the one we had in 2022, 2023, etc. But
- 10:40if you simply look at what Bitcoin did
- 10:43after the rate hikes starting in March
- 10:45of 2022 compared to September 2026, it's
- 10:49nearly a carbon copy. You can see there
- 10:52is an initial rally after the first rate
- 10:54hike. It gets everyone bowled up and
- 10:58excited. You have all the bulls dunking
- 11:00on the bears. They drag my name through
- 11:02the mud, right? You've seen it happen
- 11:04many, many times. And then we just go
- 11:07back down. And if you look at this,
- 11:11I wonder if what's going to happen is
- 11:15this part of it, right? like this part
- 11:17of it the first 90 days or so after the
- 11:21first rate hike but not necessarily this
- 11:24part way over here because I don't
- 11:26believe the rate hiking cycle will be as
- 11:29as egregious
- 11:31and also if you look at 2018 we had a
- 11:35lot of rate hikes priced in for 2019 and
- 11:37then all those got priced out following
- 11:39the correction in equities that we got
- 11:42and what's interesting is if you look at
- 11:45the year-to-ate ROI of the NASDAQ
- 11:50in 2026 and compare it to 2018, it's
- 11:54almost a carbon copy, right? Like it's
- 11:56topping. You had a correction in the
- 11:58beginning of the year and now we're
- 11:59getting a correction at the end of the
- 12:02year.
- 12:04This is what we talked about the entire
- 12:05time. What did we say? We always said
- 12:08the drop by Bitcoin at the end of the
- 12:10year is not always related to Bitcoin.
- 12:14Usually it happens on the back of a
- 12:16correction in equities, which is what
- 12:19you're seeing now, right? Like we've
- 12:21been getting a correction in equities.
- 12:22Look at the NASDAQ. It just put in a new
- 12:24low yesterday. The S&P just put in a new
- 12:28local low yesterday.
- 12:32So, this is the bear's dilemma. Now, if
- 12:35you look at proxies for Bitcoin, they're
- 12:39already breaking down below the summer
- 12:42low. Look at Coinbase for example. If
- 12:45you look at Coinbase, you'll see there
- 12:48was a February low. There was a summer
- 12:52low. And you know how stable coin market
- 12:56cap has already broken down. Coinbase
- 12:58also broke down this around the same
- 13:01time the stable coin market cap did.
- 13:05It's just that Bitcoin represents the
- 13:08best of the cryptoverse. So you would
- 13:11expect it to hold up a little bit
- 13:13longer, right? You would expect that. If
- 13:16you look at Micro Strategy, for example,
- 13:20I have seen this pattern a thousand
- 13:22times as an investor. A thousand times
- 13:25at least. And I've been pointing it out
- 13:26for a while now. When you have a massive
- 13:29blowoff top like this, a lot of times
- 13:32after a big drop, you get two counter
- 13:35trend rallies. And I think we've already
- 13:38had both of them.
- 13:40So it normally goes like this, right? It
- 13:41drops, you rally, you drop lower high
- 13:45and then you sort of bleed out like
- 13:46that. That is the way it normally works.
- 13:48And then you base out down here and then
- 13:50hopefully start to go back up. That is
- 13:53the pattern I have seen a thousand
- 13:55times. So the bears dilemma for Bitcoin
- 13:59is that like a lot of the proxies are
- 14:01already breaking down. Now, Micro
- 14:03Strategy is not at a new low,
- 14:09but this is a pattern we have seen in so
- 14:12many other charts. Okay, let's go
- 14:15through some of them.
- 14:18Number one,
- 14:20look at the NASDAQ. If the NASDAQ can go
- 14:23below the summer low,
- 14:26why can't Bitcoin, right? It's a
- 14:29reasonable statement. If the NASDAQ can
- 14:31go below its summer low, why can't
- 14:33Bitcoin? Well, the answer is is that it
- 14:35could?
- 14:38If you look at
- 14:40commodities, metals, commodities often
- 14:45times in midterm years show Bitcoin what
- 14:48it's going to do. Okay, so take a look
- 14:52at gold.
- 14:53Gold is stuck in traffic on Struggle
- 14:57Street, right? is bleeding out.
- 15:03And one of the reasons it's bleeding out
- 15:05is because expectations for rate hikes
- 15:08have continued to increase. If you if
- 15:11you look at at what the markets are
- 15:12expecting, we're looking at a rate hike
- 15:16in December and then the market is
- 15:18pricing in two more rate hikes. I don't
- 15:20know if we're going to get more rate
- 15:22hikes or not. What I do know is that I
- 15:24told you guys this all year that the
- 15:26Dixie was going to go back up. The
- 15:28short-term target was 103. The long-term
- 15:31target was 105 106. I'm arguing now that
- 15:35when we get to around 105 106 on the
- 15:38Dixie, I think that's going to be about
- 15:40peak hawkishness for a while.
- 15:44We're already almost to 104. And I made
- 15:46a video back over here saying that the
- 15:50market is wrong about the Dixie and when
- 15:53it was selling off and I got destroyed
- 15:55on Twitter for saying that when it was
- 15:58back in '98. Look where it is now. When
- 16:00the Dixie goes up,
- 16:03guess what happens? Liquidity bleeds out
- 16:06of risk of just liquidity goes down
- 16:08globally.
- 16:10And when that happens historically in a
- 16:12midterm year, Bitcoin goes down. The
- 16:15Dixie is still likely going to trend up
- 16:18into the end of the year.
- 16:21And if you look at the return path in
- 16:27presidential cycles for the Dixie, the
- 16:29DXY, what you'll notice is that when
- 16:34comparing Trump's second term to his
- 16:37first term, the Dixie is following
- 16:40pretty closely, right? Like it's
- 16:42basically doing the same thing it did
- 16:43back then. It goes down during Trump's
- 16:45first term. It forms a low early in the
- 16:48second term or sorry in the first year,
- 16:50forms a low early in the second year,
- 16:53starts trending up, maybe slows down a
- 16:56little bit in the uh in the pre-election
- 16:59year, and then goes down later on. So, I
- 17:02think the dollar is going to remain
- 17:04bullish until about 105 to 106.
- 17:08That's what I think about 105 106 which
- 17:11sounded crazy to call for that earlier
- 17:14in the year back in uh back in January
- 17:16when it was trading 95 doesn't really
- 17:19seem that crazy now you know I mean
- 17:21we're not I mean if 105 is not that far
- 17:25away and you can see that this trend
- 17:26line is not that far away but if you
- 17:29look at commodities what do you notice
- 17:32look at gold
- 17:34you have
- 17:36a February low or sorry a March low, a
- 17:39Q1 low, a summer low, and a Q4 low. Look
- 17:44at silver.
- 17:47Same thing, right? Same thing's
- 17:50happening. You have a Q1 low, a summer
- 17:54low,
- 17:56and a Q4 low. Now, what's interesting
- 17:59about that is if you look at gold, when
- 18:02does it normally bottom? Gold normally
- 18:05bottoms in midterm years before Bitcoin.
- 18:09Look at 2022 for example. Okay, look at
- 18:122022.
- 18:13[laughter] In
- 18:15in 2022,
- 18:18gold bottomed the week of September 26.
- 18:21Bitcoin did not bottom until about a
- 18:24month and a half later. Right? Okay.
- 18:27Look at 2018.
- 18:29Gold in 2018
- 18:32bottomed
- 18:35in August by mid August. Bitcoin didn't
- 18:38bottom until mid December. Right? So
- 18:42what you notice is that Bitcoin tends to
- 18:46bottom after gold in midterm years.
- 18:51But guess what?
- 18:56Gold keeps going lower.
- 19:00So if you were to believe that history
- 19:02repeats itself, then what it means is
- 19:04that Bitcoin will bottom after gold
- 19:07does. But gold
- 19:10hasn't even necessarily bottomed yet,
- 19:12right? Like it just keeps going down
- 19:14because the Fed has to raise rates. Why
- 19:18does the Fed have to raise rates? Well,
- 19:21tariffs, a war in the Middle East,
- 19:24inflationary pressures from AI, you name
- 19:27it. But they're going to raise rates
- 19:29whether we like it or not. So, gold is
- 19:34dropping.
- 19:36Gold normally drops before Bitcoin does.
- 19:39It's more It's more sensitive to the
- 19:41rate hikes. It prices it in sooner and
- 19:44then it recovers out of it quicker.
- 19:47Let me show you another
- 19:50example. If I can make it through this.
- 19:55Okay, I'm doing the best I can. I'm
- 19:57struggling. I'm stuck in traffic on
- 19:59Struggle Street. Look at 2008.
- 20:04Look at 2008.
- 20:06When did gold bottom? We had a
- 20:08recession. When did gold bottom? It
- 20:09bottomed in October of 2008.
- 20:13When did the stock market bottom back
- 20:15then?
- 20:17Stock market didn't bottom in in October
- 20:19of 2008. Stock market did not bottom
- 20:22until March of 2009,
- 20:25five months later.
- 20:28So the point that I'm trying to make is
- 20:32that gold will likely bottom before
- 20:36Bitcoin, but gold keeps going lower. So
- 20:39until gold finds a low, I can't I I just
- 20:43don't feel like it makes sense to have a
- 20:45bullish bias on Bitcoin. I just I mean,
- 20:48how well you guys see the same chart?
- 20:51You're seeing the same thing I'm looking
- 20:52at.
- 20:54But that's the point is that if gold is
- 20:55to bottom first,
- 20:58how can I how can I with a clear
- 21:00conscience say that Bitcoin has already
- 21:03gone through whatever it needs to go
- 21:04through when normally it doesn't do it
- 21:05until after? And so when I look at a
- 21:07chart like this, I'm like, well, who's
- 21:09to say Bitcoin can't just go tag the
- 21:12trend line again? I mean, gold and
- 21:14silver are doing it. The NASDAQ already
- 21:17took it out. Look at at at Netflix.
- 21:21Look at I mean, you can see the pattern
- 21:23across a lot of different charts.
- 21:25Netflix
- 21:27February low,
- 21:29summer low,
- 21:31Q4 low.
- 21:33The bull's dilemma is that you're seeing
- 21:37this pattern play out over other assets
- 21:41and commodities normally bottom before
- 21:44Bitcoin and they just keep going lower.
- 21:47You couple that with Bitcoin divided by
- 21:51USDT dominance
- 21:53and you can see
- 21:56the bull's dilemma, right? It's like the
- 21:59bulls want the bull market without going
- 22:01to the place at which bull markets
- 22:03normally start from.
- 22:07Now, if you look at Bitcoin, what it
- 22:11does after the first rate hike in
- 22:13September of a midterm year, right?
- 22:17September of a midterm year. Guess what?
- 22:22On average,
- 22:24this is the path that Bitcoin takes. It
- 22:27doesn't do anything for about a month
- 22:28and a half and then it drops into Q4.
- 22:32It's almost a carbon copy, right?
- 22:36If this were to go down here to the
- 22:39average, and I'm not saying it needs to
- 22:40be what it did in 2018, right? Because
- 22:432018, you can see that like we've
- 22:46already had a similar drop as the FTX.
- 22:48I'm saying what if it's somewhere in
- 22:50between, right? where it's a little more
- 22:52bearish than what happened with FTX
- 22:55in terms of the drop, but not
- 22:56necessarily as bad as 2018.
- 23:00Because in 2018 when we started
- 23:01dropping, we were, you know, Bitcoin
- 23:03when the stock market started to drop,
- 23:05Bitcoin was already at 60K. This time,
- 23:08Bitcoin was at 80K when the stock market
- 23:09started to drop. So, I'm thinking maybe
- 23:13we look at the average. Now, one of the
- 23:16charts that's been going around recently
- 23:17that everyone's talking about, I hope
- 23:19you guys recognize that I was showing
- 23:21you guys this two and a half weeks ago
- 23:22when it wasn't cool to show it, okay?
- 23:26Because what I find is that a lot of the
- 23:28people who are price cheerleaders will
- 23:31only so will only show these things
- 23:33after a large drop has occurred. They
- 23:36will not show it to you before. I showed
- 23:39you guys this chart on October 29th, I
- 23:42believe, and it was in the the memo. If
- 23:47you go to the website and you go to
- 23:50research
- 23:52and you go look at Bitcoin and the cycle
- 23:54clock,
- 23:56right? If you scroll down in this
- 23:58report, which was published in October,
- 24:02and you go all the way down,
- 24:05you'll see what I'm talking about. We
- 24:07published this chart right here. Bitcoin
- 24:08normalized ROI 30 days before and after
- 24:11an IPO. SpaceX in blue
- 24:15versus the anthropic.
- 24:18And you can see we showed this before
- 24:20the drop occurred. Now this chart is
- 24:24circulating everywhere,
- 24:27right? It's circulating everywhere.
- 24:29We showed it ahead of time. I would
- 24:32encourage analysts, don't be afraid to
- 24:35show the stuff ahead of time. If you
- 24:37only ever show it as a bullc case,
- 24:42then it's hard to to sort of take it as
- 24:46seriously because it's like, well, if
- 24:47this was so obvious, why was it not
- 24:49pointed out 3 weeks ago? Why is it only
- 24:52pointed out after the drop occurs to
- 24:55confirm a bullish bias? Okay, so that is
- 24:59what I would say. These reports, by the
- 25:02way, are free. I've talked about this
- 25:04chart a thousand times on here, but if
- 25:07you want to get these memos, just sign
- 25:09up. Just put your email in, sign up, and
- 25:11we show this stuff usually well in
- 25:13advance from what other people are
- 25:15showing it. So, I want to draw I want to
- 25:16show you another one that I don't think
- 25:18people are looking at, okay? Because and
- 25:21this is one that I could see making its
- 25:23rounds in a few weeks after it's played
- 25:26out. And I'm going to show you
- 25:30why this could work out
- 25:33perfectly.
- 25:36We know that Bitcoin is sort of tracked
- 25:38what it did going into the SpaceX IPO.
- 25:41And if it does, it could bounce and then
- 25:43maybe come back down a little bit more.
- 25:45But there's something else coming up.
- 25:46See, this is the thing. When people are
- 25:49looking at this now, it's already
- 25:51happened, right? We have to think ahead.
- 25:53We can't we can't look at this now. This
- 25:54has already played out. We have to look
- 25:56ahead. What's going to happen next month
- 25:59or what might happen next month? Guess
- 26:02what might happen next month? There's
- 26:04not a guarantee that it will, but
- 26:08our favorite thing, the thing that we
- 26:10all roll our eyes at, and if you're not
- 26:12in the United States, you're probably
- 26:13looking at us like, why why can't you
- 26:16guys get your act together? It is the
- 26:18fact that [cough and laughter]
- 26:21we have a potential government shutdown
- 26:26coming in on December 12th.
- 26:29Coming on December 12th. By the way, by
- 26:31and by the way, the IPO we suggested
- 26:34back then that the IPO, if you look at
- 26:37this, would be on November
- 26:4019th. That's when it's going to be,
- 26:41right? And we speculated just based on
- 26:43the chart that it looked like the IPO
- 26:45would be on the 19th of November because
- 26:47it just that's what it matched up to be
- 26:49and that's when it's going to happen.
- 26:51Look at look at this.
- 26:55Don't keep looking at this chart. This
- 26:56has played out. The people talking about
- 26:58it now, they missed it three weeks ago
- 27:00when they should have been looking at
- 27:01it.
- 27:03Look what Bitcoin does going into
- 27:05government shutdowns.
- 27:07Okay,
- 27:10this is currently.
- 27:12Now, we're going to go through each one.
- 27:14We're going to go through the last
- 27:15seven, and then we're going to average
- 27:16them out. They're not all bearish, but
- 27:18let's just look at them. Here's 2013.
- 27:20You can see that it dropped to where it
- 27:23is now. Went up a little bit, remained
- 27:25flat, and then had a capitulation right
- 27:27after the shutdown. See that? Right
- 27:30after the shutdown,
- 27:32December 12th,
- 27:34drop, then up.
- 27:37One thing that's interesting, by the
- 27:39way,
- 27:40what do you guys remember about large
- 27:42drops for Bitcoin?
- 27:46What do you guys remember?
- 27:48Well, look on the daily.
- 27:52This is a little This is really dubious.
- 27:54Like, I if I'm being honest, I don't
- 27:56even really know why I'm pointing this
- 27:57out. It seems a little silly. This is
- 27:59kind of, you know, you know, not not
- 28:02like me as much. But in 2022,
- 28:08FTX was collapsing
- 28:10around November 11th, right? So 1111.
- 28:14In 2025,
- 28:17Bitcoin had this massive drop on October
- 28:2010th, 10:10,
- 28:231212, right? 1212 coming up. And it's
- 28:28right after the FOMC meeting, right?
- 28:30FOMC is December 9th.
- 28:33So if you look at at December 9th, that
- 28:36is a Wednesday and then the 12th is that
- 28:39that weekend. So what if the Fed comes
- 28:42out on the 9th peak hawkishness despite
- 28:46a correction in equities and the markets
- 28:48just like nuke after
- 28:54if you look at it compared to that
- 28:56government shutdown, it could line up.
- 28:58Now look at it in 28. There's a
- 28:59government shutdown here in January 2020
- 29:01or sorry uh January 2018.
- 29:05You can see it it had a rally or so. It
- 29:08dropped but then it had a rally and then
- 29:09it sort of sold off into the shutdown.
- 29:11If you look at 20 February 2018, you can
- 29:13see it sold off into the shutdown. If
- 29:15you look at December 2018, you can see
- 29:17it sort of bounced around and then sold
- 29:18off into the shutdown. Here's 2025. That
- 29:22one's not as bearish. Uh here's early
- 29:242026. You can see it sort of sold off
- 29:26right after the shutdown.
- 29:29Here's earlier in 2026 again sort of
- 29:31sold off into the shutdown. Now average
- 29:34all of them compared to the current one.
- 29:38You can see on average Bitcoin drops
- 29:41through the shutdown maybe even a little
- 29:42after on average about 20%.
- 29:45starting 30 days starting 30 days before
- 29:49we've already dropped 10, right? So,
- 29:51another 10% drop from here,
- 29:54right? Another 10% from here would get
- 29:57you back down to the lows. Now, I think
- 30:00it could go lower than that, right? But
- 30:03it is something to keep in mind. Now,
- 30:05what else is the bull's dilemma? This is
- 30:08the I'm going to talk about something
- 30:09that I really truly do not understand
- 30:11from other analysts that that talk about
- 30:13onchain stuff. I really don't understand
- 30:15it. I'm hoping at the conference I will
- 30:18get a better understanding of like what
- 30:19I am missing because
- 30:22to me like I feel like I'm looking at
- 30:25the chart in a reasonable way about some
- 30:28of the onchain metrics. But I feel like
- 30:31I'm one of the only people looking at
- 30:33the onchain stuff that views it in a
- 30:34bearish way. And I'm like I'm like want
- 30:35to know what am I missing here, right?
- 30:37Right? I mean, is it just because of the
- 30:38ETFs? What is it? What's the reason?
- 30:41Because when I look at the onchain
- 30:44metrics like the MVRV Zcore, I see a
- 30:49market that normally bottoms after the
- 30:52MBRVZ score goes below zero.
- 30:56[laughter]
- 30:582011, 2015, 2019, 2018, 2019, 2020,
- 31:042022.
- 31:05Do you see a market this time where it's
- 31:07gone below zero? No. Right? Like it
- 31:10hasn't gone below zero.
- 31:12How can I look at this and say that it's
- 31:14been fully reset and that the bull
- 31:16market has arrived when it hasn't gone
- 31:18below zero, which is what it always
- 31:20does.
- 31:22Another chart, right? It's not just one.
- 31:25Look at the
- 31:28realized price of Bitcoin. Bitcoin
- 31:32historically goes below the realized
- 31:33price in 2018. It didn't even happen
- 31:36until November.
- 31:38Also happened in 2020. It also happened
- 31:40in 2022. It also happened in 2014 and
- 31:452015.
- 31:48It hasn't happened yet. Realized price
- 31:51is at around 54K.
- 31:57Don't even get me started on the balance
- 31:58price. We'll talk about the balance
- 32:01price if we go below the realized price,
- 32:03right? But if you look at the balance
- 32:05price, that's even lower, right? That's
- 32:08even lower. So, I struggle to get on the
- 32:13onchain bull bandwagon
- 32:17because I'm looking at these charts and
- 32:19I'm like,
- 32:21what am I missing? you know, like why
- 32:23why are why are other onchain analysts
- 32:25so bullish when you can see that
- 32:29historically
- 32:31we go reset these onchain indicators and
- 32:34there's a lot more. So if you take all
- 32:38of the onchain indicators that that I've
- 32:40sort of compiled here or at least some
- 32:42of them the PO multiple MBRV score MBRVZ
- 32:46score transaction fees the terminal
- 32:48price the market cap to thermal cap
- 32:49ratio the minor cap to thermal cap ratio
- 32:51you can even turn on the [laughter]
- 32:54R huddle ratio and you can also turn on
- 32:56the supply and profit and loss. What do
- 32:57you notice?
- 33:00You notice that the onchain risk tends
- 33:04to bottom below where we currently are.
- 33:07I normally turn off these two because
- 33:09they're not as they're not as useful in
- 33:11my opinion for for measuring this stuff.
- 33:13And what you'll notice is that when you
- 33:15turn off those two, historically this
- 33:17thing bottoms below where we currently
- 33:20are. Onchain risk is 0.18. Normally it
- 33:23goes below that, right? Normally it goes
- 33:26below 0.1. Um, if you look at 2020, you
- 33:30can see that it it uh it it did go below
- 33:340.1 if we included the intraday wick all
- 33:36the way down to 3,800. So, even with an
- 33:39apathetic top, it still ended up
- 33:41happening.
- 33:46So, this is the bull's dilemma. It's
- 33:49like the bulls want the bull market
- 33:53without starting from the place that
- 33:56bull markets normally start from.
- 34:01If these things were all reset, then I'd
- 34:04put my bull cap on, right?
- 34:10At that point, I would say bring on the
- 34:12bull market, right? I'd make all the
- 34:13videos, dreaming of spring, right? Like
- 34:16all that stuff. I'd make all of that
- 34:17stuff, but it's hard for me with a clear
- 34:21conscience to come out and do that when
- 34:24I don't actually feel like the onchain
- 34:26metrics have been reset. And when I look
- 34:29at stable coin market cap, see it
- 34:32breaking down, look at commodities, see
- 34:34those breaking down, knowing that they
- 34:37normally bought them before Bitcoin,
- 34:41it's hard for me
- 34:43to then go be a price cheerleader. Right
- 34:47now, there's one chart I have to remind
- 34:49you guys of because there is a chance
- 34:51this plays out. I hope it doesn't, but
- 34:53it's a difficult market. It's the silver
- 34:56chart. I know you guys already know what
- 34:57I'm going to say. It's silver from 2011.
- 35:01Okay.
- 35:04Silver
- 35:07[laughter]
- 35:08back then
- 35:10did something like this.
- 35:13It had a Imagine this is the Bitcoin
- 35:15chart. Imagine this is the February low.
- 35:17This is the summer low. And then imagine
- 35:19this is the Q4 low. Like imagine we're
- 35:21like right here, right? Where we're like
- 35:23we're off of the first drop. it's sort
- 35:25of gonna rally back up and then maybe
- 35:28drop again. If this is what Bitcoin
- 35:31does, you can see you had a first high
- 35:34and then you went above that high and
- 35:36then it was a lower high and then
- 35:38eventually it it completely sold off.
- 35:41This is the chart which which
- 35:45keeps me up at night, right? Because if
- 35:48we can get a lower low now on Bitcoin,
- 35:50then I think it could help really align
- 35:52with the four-year cycle. If we go
- 35:55through Q4 and we just hold at around
- 35:5960K,
- 36:01we would still likely have a rally in
- 36:04early 2027. But my concern is that all
- 36:07the people that got trapped at the
- 36:08summer high or at the Q3 high are going
- 36:11to then be selling pressure and we're
- 36:12just going to go down.
- 36:14However, if instead Bitcoin sells off to
- 36:19lower lows in Q4, then I think the bull
- 36:22market that could happen next year could
- 36:25go a lot further.
- 36:27I want people to keep this in mind
- 36:30because we are in a window of weakness
- 36:32for Bitcoin that is likely going to last
- 36:34for several more weeks. And yes, you
- 36:36could, yes, we could bounce back up.
- 36:39It's likely going to last for several
- 36:40more weeks, probably for most of the
- 36:42rest of the year. It could even go into
- 36:43January 2026 or sorry, January 2027 just
- 36:47like it went into January 2015,
- 36:50right? So, when you look at this,
- 36:54I wonder I'm like, you know, what is
- 36:55what are the chances that it does
- 36:57something like this that it finds
- 36:58support again at 60K, rallies back up,
- 37:03and then you guys know how everyone's
- 37:04talking about the anthropic IPO now?
- 37:07Guess what's coming next year? The Open
- 37:09AI IPO. So, what happens if we go back
- 37:11up to 80K again and then the Open AI IPO
- 37:15comes and then Bitcoin just sells off a
- 37:17fourth time to 60K? That might sound
- 37:19crazy.
- 37:22It's possible.
- 37:24I don't want that to happen. That'd be
- 37:26brutal. I'm almost hoping that by
- 37:28showing you guys this, maybe it doesn't
- 37:30happen, right? I'd prefer for it to just
- 37:33sort of sell off now
- 37:35over the next couple of weeks. let's
- 37:37just get it over with and let's get back
- 37:39in the bull market. But I also know
- 37:43there's going to be a lot of people that
- 37:45are going to be looking at this
- 37:46thinking, hey, you know what? I missed
- 37:4860K twice. I don't want to miss it a
- 37:50third time.
- 37:53Just keep it in mind. Keep that in mind.
- 37:56Is there a scenario where Bitcoin does,
- 37:59you know, the unthinkable where it holds
- 38:0260, rallies back up, and then sells off
- 38:06when everyone least expects it? Because
- 38:08by that point, if you think about it, it
- 38:09would make sense because now you got all
- 38:10the four-year cycle believers buying,
- 38:12right? I mean, then everyone gets
- 38:15wrecked, right? I mean, that would be
- 38:16the way you wreck everyone. I'm putting
- 38:19it on your radar, not as my base case,
- 38:23but as a case to consider. And if we do
- 38:28not go to a lower low before mid
- 38:31January, right? If we do not go to a
- 38:33lower low, that could turn into my base
- 38:37case, but it's not my base case now.
- 38:39Because if that happens, guess what? We
- 38:41still would have not reset the onchain
- 38:43indicators. They're still not reset. If
- 38:46we reset them now,
- 38:50then I think that it would be really
- 38:52helpful for next year. But who knows?
- 38:55Who knows when commodities are going to
- 38:56bottom? Normally, it's after commodities
- 38:58bottom that Bitcoin bottoms. Okay, so
- 39:03hopefully that explains
- 39:06the bull's dilemma. It is not that dis
- 39:09dissimilar to the altcoiners dilemma
- 39:13last cycle. Do you guys remember what
- 39:14the altcoiner's dilemma was? We talked
- 39:17about it for five years straight.
- 39:20The altcoiners dilemma was that a lot of
- 39:23people wanted alt season to happen
- 39:26without actually going to the range
- 39:27lows, right? For years. We talked about
- 39:30this like, oh, they keep calling for alt
- 39:31season.
- 39:33They keep calling for it. But guess
- 39:35what? Alt season doesn't happen from an
- 39:37alt Bitcoin ratio of.3 or point4, right?
- 39:40It happens all the way down here, right?
- 39:43That's where it happens from. That was
- 39:45the altcoiner's dilemma. People keep
- 39:47calling for alt season, but you haven't
- 39:49satisfied the conditions necessary for
- 39:51it.
- 39:53And by the way,
- 39:56my true belief with altcoins is not that
- 39:59they oscillate against Bitcoin. That is
- 40:01theopium view. The realistic view
- 40:05is that altcoins bleed against Bitcoin.
- 40:09That is the realistic view.
- 40:12So the altcoiner's dilemma is that they
- 40:14keep calling for alt season,
- 40:18but from a level that alt season doesn't
- 40:20historically start from.
- 40:23Now if you want to include USDC, you
- 40:26could argue that we already did go to
- 40:270.25. But the point is is that this is a
- 40:31downtrend channel. What if the next alt
- 40:33season starts from a level way lower
- 40:35than what currently people think? And
- 40:38we're also going to tighter monetary
- 40:39policy. The last chart I'll leave you
- 40:41with,
- 40:43the Bitcoin chart against gold.
- 40:48Told you guys for a while about this
- 40:51chart. And before we look at this chart,
- 40:53look at Bitcoin against silver.
- 40:57Notice where Bitcoin found a low against
- 40:59silver
- 41:01when it swept the low.
- 41:06Has Bitcoin found a low against gold? I
- 41:09don't think so.
- 41:11Why?
- 41:13Hasn't swept the low. And it swept the
- 41:16high. If it can sweep the high, it can
- 41:18sweep the low. Now, this is where it
- 41:21gets interesting. Okay,
- 41:24we've talked about it. You've seen this
- 41:26before. These are higher lows, but guess
- 41:28what? These things normally break down,
- 41:30right? You'll what the way these P
- 41:32patterns work is you drop you get your
- 41:35little your your little flag up
- 41:38and then you break down. Now this chart,
- 41:42a lot of people are going to be looking
- 41:43at this chart in a few in a few weeks, a
- 41:45few months. Why? Because the low that it
- 41:48should probably go to is around 10.
- 41:53It's around 10.
- 41:56Well, what does that mean? It means that
- 42:00what if Bitcoin bottoms at a ratio
- 42:03against gold of 10? Well, guess what?
- 42:05Bitcoin right now, sorry, gold right now
- 42:10is at 3783.
- 42:13So, a ratio of 10 puts it below 40,000.
- 42:19Below 40,000, which sounds really scary,
- 42:22right? Like, it really does. But if you
- 42:25look at the balance price,
- 42:29the balance price is at 37.67K.
- 42:36It's right around 38K.
- 42:39The Bitcoin valuation against gold at a
- 42:42ratio of 10 would with a with the
- 42:45current gold valuation of 37.85
- 42:49would put Bitcoin exactly at the
- 42:51realized price. Sorry. At the balance
- 42:54price.
- 42:58You might say that sounds crazy, but
- 43:00guess what? In both 2018
- 43:04and 2019,
- 43:06Bitcoin found support at around $6,000.
- 43:12Right? That's where it found support at
- 43:14around $6,000.
- 43:19Guess what? Both times the actual low
- 43:24ended up being between three and $4,000
- 43:28which coincidentally
- 43:31is where the balance prices this time
- 43:34just add a zero. Right? Instead of 6,000
- 43:37and 3,000 sorry instead of 6,000 to the3
- 43:40to $4,000 range it's 60,000 to the 30 to
- 43:44$40,000 range. that would h if that were
- 43:48to happen and Bitcoin were to go below
- 43:50or at least around the balance price,
- 43:53every onchain indicator is fully reset
- 43:55at that point, right? And then 2018 and
- 43:572020
- 43:59have played out for a third time. By the
- 44:02way, when you look at fake outs, if you
- 44:05look at 2015,
- 44:08after a fake out, you normally go put in
- 44:10a new low. Look at 20. Look at 2015,
- 44:14fake out above it. Look at 2020.
- 44:17It was a fake out and then you go down.
- 44:23I'm not saying we got to go to 40k
- 44:26because guess what? What if gold bottoms
- 44:28first? This is this is where it's going
- 44:29to get tricky. If gold bottoms first and
- 44:33then goes back up to say 4500,
- 44:38right? Then the ratio would be 45,000.
- 44:42And the trend is that we're kind of
- 44:44trending towards not going below the
- 44:46bounce price. So that's why it's going
- 44:49to be tricky. If gold bottoms first and
- 44:52starts to go up,
- 44:55then the Bitcoin gold ratio of around 10
- 44:58is going to depend on where gold is. If
- 45:00gold goes back to say $6,000, then maybe
- 45:03the low is 60K.
- 45:05But that's not what we're seeing right
- 45:07that's not what we're seeing right now.
- 45:09Okay.
- 45:11So, if you guys like this, you want more
- 45:13of it, check out ITC Premium into the
- 45:15cryptoverse.com. More importantly, we
- 45:17got the conference coming up. I'm going
- 45:18to be talking about some of the stuff I
- 45:19don't talk about as much here. So, check
- 45:21it out. Links in the description below.
- 45:23A lot of great speakers. And if you do
- 45:26not have a way to get there and you want
- 45:28to view it online, just become a member
- 45:30of the channel and we will live stream
- 45:32it to the members of the channel. And if
- 45:34you don't want to do that, we'll release
- 45:36it sooner to ITC Premium members, right?
- 45:39But if you don't want to do any of that,
- 45:43then just wait until the week of
- 45:45December 7th and then we'll try to
- 45:46upload it then. Okay. Does that sound
- 45:48fair? I know some people are like, well,
- 45:50you know, why can't it just be free?
- 45:51Conferences are expensive, right? They
- 45:53are, right? Right? I mean, they're
- 45:54really expensive. And I'm just trying to
- 45:57see if we can bring together a community
- 46:00of investors who really want to
- 46:03understand the markets. Not just be
- 46:06price cheerleaders, not just be doomers,
- 46:10but who really want to understand the
- 46:13markets and aren't going to get booed
- 46:16off stage for expressing an opinion that
- 46:19is different than what consensus is.
- 46:21Think about it. Think about how many
- 46:22times I've been wrong. Think about how
- 46:24many times you've been wrong. If I've
- 46:26been wrong and you've been wrong, why
- 46:28should we
- 46:30tell someone else that their opinion
- 46:32doesn't make sense?
- 46:35Maybe if we had listened to their
- 46:36opinion, we would have gotten it right.
- 46:40Perhaps we were too stubborn in our
- 46:41views to see another side. So, come with
- 46:46an open mind.
- 46:48Listen to the bare case. There's going
- 46:51to be a lot of bear cases. There's also
- 46:52going to be a lot of bull cases. Listen
- 46:54to them. And then hopefully you can
- 46:57leave
- 46:59at least with an understanding
- 47:01as to why everyone believes what they
- 47:04do. And then you
- 47:06can then come to your own conclusions.
- 47:09That is the goal. And I hope it is
- 47:10something that people look forward to
- 47:12every year. if we end up doing it every
- 47:14year or every other year, whatever we
- 47:16whatever we end up doing, hopefully it's
- 47:18something that people can look forward
- 47:18to and say, you know what, this is where
- 47:20I can go and I know I'm not just going
- 47:24to be told the bull case constantly and
- 47:26I'm not just going to be told the bear
- 47:28case, but I can go there and I can hear
- 47:30different views and I will be
- 47:32open-minded. Why?
- 47:35Because we all are wrong at some point.
- 47:37And if we're all wrong, then don't laugh
- 47:40at someone else because you don't like
- 47:41their opinion, right? Because maybe
- 47:43maybe,
- 47:45just maybe, their opinion is the one
- 47:47that is right and our opinion is the one
- 47:50that is wrong. So think about that if
- 47:52you're at the conference or if you're
- 47:54watching it online. Thank you guys for
- 47:55being here. Subscribe, give the video a
- 47:57thumbs up, and I'll see you guys next
- 47:58time. Bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Bitcoin: The Bull's Dilemma by Benjamin Cowen, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,233 words across 1,075 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.