“Bigger Than a Business Story”: Nvidia Shakeup — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00We start with the biggest story
- 0:01of the week.
- 0:02Jensen Huang's stepping down as head of NVIDIA
- 0:05after news of an inappropriate relationship
- 0:07with someone alleged to be a Chinese spy.
- 0:10It is a huge story for investors
- 0:12and for a world consumed with building out AI.
- 0:15But it's bigger than that.
- 0:16Richard Haass served as the head
- 0:18of the Council on Foreign Relations
- 0:20and now is a senior counselor to Centerview Partners.
- 0:24The business world was rocked by news
- 0:25coming out of NVIDIA
- 0:27about the problems of Jensen Huang.
- 0:28Normally, you'd say that's a business story.
- 0:31But this is the most valuable company in the world
- 0:33on the cutting edge with AI microchips
- 0:36and really... really in that intersection
- 0:38of U.S.-China competition over AI.
- 0:41What are the ramifications
- 0:43for international diplomacy here?
- 0:44-Well, it is a business story, and at the same time,
- 0:46it's much more than a business story.
- 0:48The business story is going to be governance at the company.
- 0:51They got some real issues to contend with.
- 0:53Let's park that to the side.
- 0:54No, this is not just any company.
- 0:56They are producing the largest number
- 0:59of the most advanced capable chips in the world.
- 1:02So what happens there, shall we say,
- 1:04affects the U.S. and global economy.
- 1:06Then, as you say, you've got the China connection.
- 1:08If all the reports are true,
- 1:10they seem to be that this woman
- 1:11was not simply a paramour, but was a spy.
- 1:14It's actually a central part of the Chinese growth model,
- 1:16the theft of intellectual property.
- 1:19So it would totally fit with... with that tradition.
- 1:22But then there's some also very interesting
- 1:24national security aspects.
- 1:25What did the president know, and when did he know it?
- 1:28Months ago, he had been informed
- 1:30through the intelligence community,
- 1:32through the National Security Advisor,
- 1:33Marco Rubio's second hat,
- 1:35that this woman was most likely a Chinese spy.
- 1:38Why was this individual allowed to travel
- 1:40with the president, have the access?
- 1:42Why did the Justice Department
- 1:44not investigate every aspect of his life?
- 1:47And then it raises other issues. Is it just the China connection?
- 1:50Well, where else has NVIDIA
- 1:51been selling large amounts of chips, David?
- 1:53To the United Arab Emirates.
- 1:54Well, what about that?
- 1:56That is not, shall we say, a place that has a...
- 1:58necessarily where the technology stops there.
- 2:01And this administration and, you know,
- 2:04the personal figures around the president,
- 2:06the family, have all sorts of business ties
- 2:08with that part of the world.
- 2:10So this is a really interesting set of political issues,
- 2:13business issues, and national security issues.
- 2:16And I would say if the Justice Department,
- 2:18as is likely, is unwilling to look into this,
- 2:21then I would think this is actually a legitimate topic
- 2:23for the new Congress
- 2:24and one of its committees to get to the bottom of this.
- 2:28Westin: There's been a lot of talk about, and use,
- 2:30of export controls for national security purposes
- 2:33to make sure that we're not exporting,
- 2:35particularly to China,
- 2:36particularly some advanced technology.
- 2:38What does this say about that whole apparatus
- 2:40if you can get around it that easily?
- 2:42-It's an interesting question,
- 2:43because I think export controls are intellectually well-disposed
- 2:46towards them in principle.
- 2:48But in practice, I'm not sure they work that well.
- 2:50In a global economy there's so many connections
- 2:53where the people can talk about something
- 2:54or physically hand over something,
- 2:56and then people can copy it or what have you.
- 3:00So my guess is export controls
- 3:03aren't nearly as effective as we would like them to be.
- 3:06And in some cases,
- 3:07that might even be counterproductive,
- 3:09that they require and stimulate someone else
- 3:11to become more self-sufficient, that if denied something,
- 3:15then they make it an urgent priority
- 3:17to produce it themselves.
- 3:19So my guess is when the historical record
- 3:20of export controls is written,
- 3:23it won't be quite as positive
- 3:24as its advocates would have it to be.
- 3:26Westin: There was a midterm election.
- 3:28-Thank you, David.
- 3:30Westin: We've had a lot of ramifications
- 3:31for the Congress,
- 3:32where you had both houses switch.
- 3:35Generally think of that as domestic, the Congress.
- 3:39What possible effects could it have
- 3:40on international relations and President Trump's position?
- 3:43Well, the first point to make
- 3:44is a version of the point you made,
- 3:46that historically,
- 3:48the lion's share of the control
- 3:50over American foreign policy
- 3:51has been the prerogative of the executive.
- 3:54What, 50, 60 years ago,
- 3:55Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote a book, what?
- 3:57"The Imperial Presidency."
- 3:58And that was in the context of Vietnam.
- 4:00But every president since has gone to war
- 4:02or used military force without congressional approval.
- 4:06Congress has delegated enormous powers.
- 4:08For example, when it comes to tariffs,
- 4:10presidents can do what they want in diplomacy and so forth.
- 4:14So the short answer to your question, David,
- 4:16is the election won't matter that much.
- 4:18So if tomorrow Donald Trump wants to make a new proposal,
- 4:21more pro-Russian, more pro-Ukrainian,
- 4:24when it comes to that war, he can do it.
- 4:26But for 95% or more,
- 4:29presidential leadership
- 4:31on foreign policy is going to remain.
- 4:33Plus, this administration doesn't have ambassadors,
- 4:35for the most part.
- 4:36About three-quarters of our embassies are empty.
- 4:39The way policy is made gives informality a new meaning.
- 4:42So again, there's not a lot of entry points
- 4:45for the Congress here.
- 4:46Westin: You have dealt with U.S. diplomacy
- 4:48at the highest levels of government,
- 4:50both in the White House as well as the State Department.
- 4:52So you've seen this over years.
- 4:54To what extent does the political standing
- 4:56of the president in the United States
- 4:58domestically affect his position
- 5:00with respect to others, like Vladimir Putin,
- 5:02and even more important, perhaps,
- 5:03President Xi that he's meeting with at the ASEAN summit?
- 5:06-No, you're exactly right.
- 5:07I think it hurts Donald Trump with the Iranians.
- 5:10They are pretty good readers
- 5:11of the American political system.
- 5:13A lot of their senior people went to school here.
- 5:15So they're watching. They saw the midterms.
- 5:17My guess is they've decided they can drive a harder bargain,
- 5:21that one of the takeaways from the election
- 5:23is the American people
- 5:24don't have much more stomach for this.
- 5:25Donald Trump's standing is diminished.
- 5:27So I think we'll see probably a tougher line,
- 5:29if possible, tougher.
- 5:31It's been pretty tough up to now out of Tehran.
- 5:33Yeah, and you've got these upcoming meetings
- 5:35with President Xi and with Vladimir Putin.
- 5:39So yeah, they've taken note of what's happened.
- 5:40Funnily enough, though, David,
- 5:41I think all 3 are somewhat weakened.
- 5:43Donald Trump comes out of the midterms
- 5:45with very little wind that is back, so to speak.
- 5:47Vladimir Putin's not winning,
- 5:49and over the last couple of months
- 5:50has been more losing the war against Ukraine.
- 5:52His economy is in shambles.
- 5:55Xi Jinping also, as you know, has enormous economic problems.
- 5:58So the so-called "big 3" ain't so big right now.
- 6:02And that's an interesting context for this meeting.
- 6:05Westin: Another hallmark of President Trump's
- 6:06foreign policy has been tariffs,
- 6:09including those he levied on Canada.
- 6:11Chrystia Freeland, former Canadian Deputy Prime Minister
- 6:14and author of the book "Unreliable Boyfriend,"
- 6:16negotiated a trade deal
- 6:18with the first Trump administration.
- 6:20Bring us up to speed, if you can,
- 6:22on the nature of U.S.-Canadian relations right now.
- 6:25Particularly when it comes to trade.
- 6:26We've talked a lot about it.
- 6:28There were some statements coming out
- 6:29of the Trump White House just on the eve of the election.
- 6:31Things are getting better. It's hopeful with Canada.
- 6:33Maybe it'll work out.
- 6:34From your point of view, is that right?
- 6:38-Not yet.
- 6:39And, you know, what I think Americans
- 6:42need to remember
- 6:44is we have a trade deal with the United States.
- 6:48According to that trade deal,
- 6:50we're not supposed to impose tariffs on each other.
- 6:53According to that trade deal,
- 6:54if we have problems with each other,
- 6:57we have a whole system of tribunals
- 7:00to work those problems out.
- 7:02We went through Trump 1.
- 7:04We negotiated a really good deal.
- 7:07And then out of the blue,
- 7:09new tariffs are imposed on us
- 7:12directly in contravention of that deal.
- 7:16And those tariffs are all still in place.
- 7:18I find those comments, though, that you cite really telling.
- 7:23And one of the things that happened
- 7:25as we got closer to the election
- 7:27is you saw U.S. officials getting really nervous
- 7:31that the tariffs were hurting Republicans politically.
- 7:35Westin: And I must say, as an American,
- 7:38I was a little surprised,
- 7:39not disappointed, but surprised,
- 7:41the extent to which Canadian relations
- 7:43played into elections, particularly in border states,
- 7:46in my host state of Michigan, in Ohio, in Maine.
- 7:49It was a real issue where people were saying,
- 7:51"We don't want to pick a fight with Canada."
- 7:52Is that a source of some encouragement
- 7:54for someone like you from Canada?
- 7:56-Huge encouragement.
- 7:58You know, I really believe, again,
- 8:01a little bit to my surprise,
- 8:03Canada was on the ballot
- 8:05and Americans voted
- 8:07for a good relationship with Canada.
- 8:09American voters are also really smart
- 8:11and they get that tariffs and like a trade war with Canada
- 8:16is not only kind of ridiculous, but actually that it hurts them.
- 8:21And I think especially in the border states,
- 8:23Americans are seeing it's raising prices.
- 8:27It's maybe hurting my business,
- 8:28partly because I'm not getting those Canadian tourists anymore,
- 8:32partly because, you know,
- 8:33about 60% of Canada's exports
- 8:35to the United States are intermediate goods.
- 8:39So tariffs on Canada
- 8:41are quite literally a tax on U.S. manufacturers.
- 8:45I think Americans saw all of that.
- 8:48And for me, a moment when I thought,
- 8:50you know, maybe this is all going to work out
- 8:53is when Obama started talking about Canada in his speeches.
- 8:57And, you know, he would say, like,
- 9:00"This fight with Canada, isn't it ridiculous?"
- 9:03And those were his biggest laugh lines.
- 9:05So I'm now cautiously optimistic.
- 9:08Westin: Pulling back more broadly
- 9:10from U.S.-Canada to the world, as it were,
- 9:13you served in various very senior positions in Canada,
- 9:16including as foreign minister.
- 9:18What does an election like this mean
- 9:20for a world leader like Donald Trump
- 9:22as he sits down with his counterparts,
- 9:25whether they're their adversaries
- 9:26or their friends and allies?
- 9:28How does it change potentially his position with them?
- 9:30And could it change our policy?
- 9:32-I think, David, it weakens Donald Trump,
- 9:36and I think it strengthens America.
- 9:39I think prior to these midterms,
- 9:42there was a real question mark around the world
- 9:45about whether American democracy was going to endure.
- 9:50There was a real question about was it going to be possible
- 9:54to have a fair and uncontested vote?
- 9:57And remember, of course,
- 9:58the reaction to the presidential elections.
- 10:01So the fact that there was this blue tsunami
- 10:07and that it was recognized by Republicans,
- 10:11I think means something really important,
- 10:14which is, you know,
- 10:15a lot of the world,
- 10:17especially America's Democratic allies,
- 10:19had been losing faith in America as a democracy,
- 10:24as a leader of the free world.
- 10:26And I think this vote means a lot of us,
- 10:30you know, America's traditional friends,
- 10:32are thinking actually American democracy works.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of “Bigger Than a Business Story”: Nvidia Shakeup by Bloomberg Television, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,856 words across 274 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.