YouTube2Text

Big Luca Teologo a Dubai — Transcript

by Cantina Wesa · 15,631 words · 2,388 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hey Hey M. Hey Hey Hey,
  2. 3:11what is that?
  3. 3:13Well, eh, I'd like you to meet a friend
  4. 3:16, her name is Guitar.
  5. 3:19Nice to meet you.
  6. 3:23Want to hear her?
  7. 3:26Okay.
  8. 3:28Okay. Promise me that you won't laugh.
  9. 3:41I won't laugh. I promise.
  10. 3:49I want to trust you. And it's Orlo, you
  11. 4:08know I will find you wherever you are.
  12. 4:14I will trigger you and I'll grip the
  13. 4:20controller in my hands, while I look
  14. 4:23for the Twatbox that will beautifully
  15. 4:26appear in the shadows. pimped out like
  16. 4:32I've never been before. And when the
  17. 4:38reaction happens, if you really love me
  18. 4:42, keep your shield down and my claymore
  19. 4:50will arrive. Oh come on come on. There
  20. 5:13we go.
  21. 5:16Well, it's terrible.
  22. 5:20I'll take that as a compliment. Good
  23. 5:28evening, good evening everyone. Welcome
  24. 5:32back to Wesa Twitch. It's July 9th,
  25. 5:362026, a hot July 9th, 2026, but it is
  26. 5:44simultaneously, as we know, the hottest
  27. 5:47and the coldest. July 9th, 2026, ever.
  28. 5:53As someone here in the chat anticipated
  29. 5:56, this evening at 8:00 PM on eh Wesa
  30. 5:59Channel there will be, so following
  31. 6:02this live, there will be another live
  32. 6:05on Wesa Channel with Parabellum as a
  33. 6:08guest. Ehm, as someone here in the chat
  34. 6:13not only anticipated, but understood,
  35. 6:17sensed, this live will have me as an
  36. 6:20absentee because it's Thursday evening
  37. 6:24and then there's the weekend, if you
  38. 6:27get what I mean. But this is this is
  39. 6:32this is the reason why some years ago I
  40. 6:36split myself, giving birth to Eugenio
  41. 6:40Manprint. The creation from nothing, or
  42. 6:45rather from my own rib, of Eugenio
  43. 6:48Manprint was intended for days like
  44. 6:51this. So I have complete trust in
  45. 6:54MANPRIN and everything will go
  46. 6:56perfectly. Begotten, not made. Exactly.
  47. 7:00Everything will go perfectly. I won't
  48. 7:02We will see then, well, all the various
  49. 7:05clarifications, explanations and
  50. 7:07counter-explanations and and it will be
  51. 7:09interesting for everyone. And that
  52. 7:14being said, don't miss it at all, as
  53. 7:17far as I know, but I'd say I'm sure
  54. 7:19about it, the live eh this evening
  55. 7:22won't be for subscribers, so it should
  56. 7:24be open to everyone, I'm fairly sure.
  57. 7:29Or or not? Well, but if if it's for
  58. 7:31subscribers it's written in the in the
  59. 7:36live, guys, I'm not sure, but it seems
  60. 7:38to me that it's for everyone. It will
  61. 7:42go perfectly. I am sure that the MPR
  62. 7:46will be eh seraphic. Ehm the video.
  63. 7:56Great job Chirale, thanks for asking me
  64. 7:58. Normally at the end of you already
  65. 8:01understand how the mprint works.
  66. 8:04Normally at the end of this live the
  67. 8:06video from Japan would have come out,
  68. 8:07which is already uploaded and
  69. 8:08completely ready on the Channel. Almost
  70. 8:12an hour, it's a bit longer than the
  71. 8:14last one, my trek across the city of
  72. 8:17Tokyo from Meguro to Ueno on foot,
  73. 8:19burning calories for you. Calories I
  74. 8:22might have regained quite quickly,
  75. 8:24though. Back in Italy, well, this video
  76. 8:28is being postponed a few days due to
  77. 8:30obvious scheduling overlaps with other
  78. 8:32things like tonight's live stream,
  79. 8:34etcetera, etcetera. So, you'll need to
  80. 8:38have a little bit of patience. That
  81. 8:40said, we're here today, thanks to
  82. 8:43Simone Sef and also thanks to
  83. 8:46Untitledam, we are here on a day that
  84. 8:52is very challenging, and I want to be
  85. 8:53completely honest with you, very
  86. 8:55challenging. These are the kind of live
  87. 8:57streams where, before you start them,
  88. 8:59you ask yourself, but then you answer
  89. 9:03yourself. There are gems like this to
  90. 9:08share. I managed to set up a screen.
  91. 9:15Yes, this morning while, uh, thanks
  92. 9:21Bluestone, while I was doing—no, my
  93. 9:24morning routines, guys, I don't even
  94. 9:27know what I'm saying. I'm wiped out,
  95. 9:30but we'll make it, and we'll pull off
  96. 9:32this live stream. Um, the YouTube
  97. 9:34algorithm, I don't know why the YouTube
  98. 9:38algorithm on my phone, by the way,
  99. 9:41wanted to do this to me, but perhaps
  100. 9:44simply because it wasn't the algorithm,
  101. 9:47but a promoted video, so it paid to
  102. 9:50appear, in short, it was an ad. I saw
  103. 9:54this, and I must say the title really
  104. 9:58struck me because I don't know Big Luca
  105. 10:02well, I mean, I know him by reputation
  106. 10:06like everyone else, a promoter of
  107. 10:11things that people really desire, like
  108. 10:16becoming rich easily. More or less,
  109. 10:20that should be it. Or if not easily,
  110. 10:22allegedly becoming rich with his method
  111. 10:25. I never understood, I can't wrap my
  112. 10:30head around it, because making videos
  113. 10:33while renting a Ferrari or from a beach
  114. 10:35in Dubai is something anyone can do. So
  115. 10:38I never understood if, in the end, Big
  116. 10:43Luca is actually rich. Because I think,
  117. 10:48thanks Rabusco, because I believe that
  118. 10:51ultimately, at the end of the day, the
  119. 10:53biggest question one asks about a
  120. 10:56seller, right, uh, of hope and wealth,
  121. 11:02is: is this person rich, absurdly rich,
  122. 11:07who decides out of generosity to share
  123. 11:12with everyone, right, his path, how he
  124. 11:17did it? And I absolutely don't want to
  125. 11:23think, as Aragosta 97 or other
  126. 11:26detractors might, that his selling of "
  127. 11:30how to become rich" is actually his way
  128. 11:33of becoming rich. Thanks, il Bonsy, I
  129. 11:38absolutely don't want to think that.
  130. 11:40Certainly, as you have already noticed
  131. 11:43from this thumbnail, he enjoys those
  132. 11:46patriarchal asymmetries characteristic
  133. 11:49of our society; he can show his nipples
  134. 11:52with impunity. So, we have a well-known
  135. 11:56salesperson and we have a theme, the
  136. 11:59very theme of this cover. But I, I, I
  137. 12:01already clicked on this video in
  138. 12:03private. Eh, you have no ide—you have
  139. 12:05no idea, guys, because it’s not—
  140. 12:06it’s not a coincidence that we’re
  141. 12:08here, eh. Eh, I must have watched 2
  142. 12:11minutes, 2 to 3 minutes, maybe I’m
  143. 12:15exaggerating. Anyway, I watched a bit
  144. 12:17of it. Um, the incredible thing is that
  145. 12:21by clicking on this video, it’s not
  146. 12:25—it’s not clickbait, because why
  147. 12:28does God allow evil, right? The theme
  148. 12:33of theodicy, theology at the beach. One
  149. 12:38might say, "Is he going to—I don't
  150. 12:40even know if, during the video, he
  151. 12:42actually sells things because, in
  152. 12:44reality, okay, now let’s watch this
  153. 12:49video together. By the way, by
  154. 12:51compromising this video on YouTube, I
  155. 12:53hope Big Luca isn't such a poor sport
  156. 12:57as to take down my video on Cantina
  157. 12:58Wesa. In that case, guys and friends of
  158. 13:00Cantina Wesa, you are about to see a
  159. 13:02cut; see you at the next topic, because
  160. 13:03we won’t do the whole live stream on
  161. 13:05this video, I’m saying that now.
  162. 13:08Immediate questions on religion.
  163. 13:11Well, I don't—I don't have them
  164. 13:12prepared, but I’ll say the first one
  165. 13:14that comes to mind,
  166. 13:15eh. On religion.
  167. 13:16Does God have a dad?
  168. 13:17Yes.
  169. 13:18Who is it?
  170. 13:19Eh,
  171. 13:19God. God. Does God have a dad?
  172. 13:21No, God does not have a dad. God is an
  173. 13:23essence. The Father doesn't have a dad
  174. 13:25because he is already the Father. The
  175. 13:27Son has a father who is the Father.
  176. 13:30Okay? The Holy Spirit doesn't have a
  177. 13:32father because he proceeds from the
  178. 13:33Father and the Son. Okay? So God—God
  179. 13:36is one essence in three persons. Okay?
  180. 13:41So even when people ask who Jesus was
  181. 13:43praying to in the Garden of Olives, in
  182. 13:45Gethsemane, it was the Son praying to
  183. 13:47the Father. There are things and
  184. 13:50properties that all three persons of
  185. 13:52the Trinity have. There are things,
  186. 13:55without getting too technical, that all
  187. 13:57three have. I mean, I absolutely have
  188. 14:00to read Shanil's comment. This video
  189. 14:02has all the elements I prefer. Annoying
  190. 14:05audio, unbearable accent, Big Luca
  191. 14:08naked, religion. He seems quite big to
  192. 14:16me, I mean, he hits the gym, eh.
  193. 14:21But we descriptively ascribe to only
  194. 14:23one, and there are some properties that
  195. 14:24only one person has. For example,
  196. 14:27sonship, the Father doesn't have it.
  197. 14:30All three have, for example,
  198. 14:32unbegottenness, okay? Because they have
  199. 14:35always existed. Okay? The second one,
  200. 14:38obviously, the divine word has always
  201. 14:40existed. The incarnation had a precise
  202. 14:43moment in time. Okay? We see this in
  203. 14:46the Greek as well. For example, when
  204. 14:49the Gospel speaks of God, it uses the
  205. 14:51past tense of the verb to be, okay? En
  206. 14:55archē ēn ho logos, for instance. In
  207. 14:59the beginning was the Word, but when
  208. 15:01speaking of the incarnation, it uses ho
  209. 15:03logos, egeneto. And egeneto means to be
  210. 15:08created, as in to be, okay? Meaning to
  211. 15:12appear, you could say, okay? To be, but
  212. 15:16from a point that is no longer
  213. 15:18temporally infinite, but well-specified
  214. 15:20in time. It's a bit difficult to
  215. 15:22explain in Greek. Okay? So when Jesus
  216. 15:28found himself on Earth,
  217. 15:31Yes.
  218. 15:32Go on, go on. Even if
  219. 15:33he couldn't he couldn't be, I mean,
  220. 15:36there couldn't be the possibility
  221. 15:39somehow that he fell in love with some
  222. 15:42maiden. Well, first of all, Jesus
  223. 15:46didn't just find himself on Earth; the
  224. 15:49second person of the Holy Trinity
  225. 15:52subsisted in human nature; therefore,
  226. 15:55the second person of the Trinity
  227. 15:59assumed and attended to human nature.
  228. 16:02Since human nature cannot reach toward
  229. 16:04the divine, it is the divine that
  230. 16:05subsisted in human nature. Guys, as
  231. 16:10someone is perhaps already hinting, who
  232. 16:16could have ever imagined that an expert
  233. 16:21on how to become rich, a generous rich
  234. 16:26man sharing the path to wealth with the
  235. 16:32poor, who could have ever imagined he
  236. 16:36would dabble in theology. This is a big
  237. 16:42surprise. It's a bit like when I
  238. 16:44discovered Adinolfi with the flag of
  239. 16:45Israel. Who could have ever said that?
  240. 16:48Who would have ever imagined it? How
  241. 16:52many degrees of separation are there
  242. 16:54between Jesus, called the Christ, the
  243. 16:56Lord's anointed, and Big Luca? There
  244. 17:03are very few.
  245. 17:07This is Christology, it's a divinely
  246. 17:09complex thing, he had the possibility,
  247. 17:11obviously, he didn't have original sin,
  248. 17:13he was preserved from original sin.
  249. 17:17Even the blessed ever-Virgin Mary was
  250. 17:19preserved from original sin. Okay? Um,
  251. 17:25not for nothing the Immaculate
  252. 17:27Conception of Mary, which is a Marian
  253. 17:29dogma, people think it's the virginal
  254. 17:31birth of Jesus, whereas the Immaculate
  255. 17:33Conception is the fact that Mary
  256. 17:35herself was conceived without sin.
  257. 17:39Anyway, let's not digress, let's not
  258. 17:41that what he just specified is true,
  259. 17:43mind you, but the same question always
  260. 17:46follows. But Mary was a virgin.
  261. 17:52Otherwise we have a problem, eh?
  262. 17:56We're digressing too much. And he had
  263. 18:00the possibility, but obviously not
  264. 18:03having original sin, he could feel a
  265. 18:06pure love, but not that sick love, that
  266. 18:09concupiscence that we human beings feel
  267. 18:12. Okay? Anyway, Jesus also had a human
  268. 18:18sensibility; he suffered as a man right
  269. 18:21on the cross, so he could feel
  270. 18:23everything that men feel. But, for
  271. 18:27example, his divine will—Jesus had
  272. 18:29two wills, one divine and one natural
  273. 18:32—brought his human will, uh, back
  274. 18:34into line with what the Father wanted,
  275. 18:37so in full obedience to his divine will
  276. 18:39. Maybe I'll make a video on the divine
  277. 18:42and human will of Jesus because they
  278. 18:44are somewhat difficult concepts,
  279. 18:45otherwise it turns into Christology.
  280. 18:53It's a livestream of two" dubs. "Well,
  281. 18:54you see that anyway, uh, the the dub,
  282. 19:00how can I put it, the winning Dubaino,
  283. 19:04even when it comes to moving into the
  284. 19:07theological realm, doesn't lose, no,
  285. 19:09his own charm, he doesn't lose his own
  286. 19:12appeal. Eh, I always ask myself one
  287. 19:18thing, when the when the [ __ ]
  288. 19:20reaches these levels, because [ __ ]
  289. 19:22has many levels, but this you can
  290. 19:24clearly see is the maximum level and it
  291. 19:27applies to other religions too. Eh, I
  292. 19:30ask you one thing. In cases like these,
  293. 19:36in themes like these, believing is
  294. 19:39memorizing, because you understand that
  295. 19:42there is an entire terminology, an
  296. 19:44entire definitional precision that has
  297. 19:47no type of real referent, no type of
  298. 19:50meaning in everyday life, which becomes
  299. 19:52, um, how can I tell you, true and
  300. 19:55recognized as such the moment you give
  301. 19:58it back just as you received it, right?
  302. 20:05And I ask myself: but believing it for
  303. 20:08real, not just believing, no, in the
  304. 20:11metaphysical aspect, etcetera etcetera,
  305. 20:14but really believing that all those
  306. 20:17things that he said are defined in
  307. 20:19those ways there and that all those
  308. 20:22definitions, no, in all this closed
  309. 20:24enclosure in itself that is theology,
  310. 20:27have a sense and that it is, and that
  311. 20:30it is talking about something real,
  312. 20:36isn't it incredible? Is it harder to
  313. 20:39believe this or I'm just throwing it
  314. 20:44out there. Big Luka's most viewed video
  315. 20:51or getting rich in six steps. It's not
  316. 21:01really clear, Fraz rightly says. Um,
  317. 21:05behind you there are many fish
  318. 21:09beautiful ones. Eh, explain to us
  319. 21:12better the concept of when you say
  320. 21:16sometimes it's God who allows it
  321. 21:17because Jesus allows it, right? When
  322. 21:19bad things happen, people come to God
  323. 21:23and evil
  324. 21:23of God doesn't exist. Jesus doesn't
  325. 21:25exist.
  326. 21:25Yes. So, first of all, it's good to
  327. 21:27understand that it does not logically
  328. 21:29follow that God does not exist from the
  329. 21:30fact that something you declare bad
  330. 21:32happens. I mean, it would be like
  331. 21:34saying, since a bad thing happened to
  332. 21:36you, your dad doesn't exist, it doesn't
  333. 21:37logically follow. God exists, even if a
  334. 21:39bad thing happens to you. We also need
  335. 21:41to understand what we mean by ugly.
  336. 21:43People even use the term evil, without
  337. 21:45realizing that it doesn't mean anything
  338. 21:47. They say," Well, this thing here is a
  339. 21:49bad thing. "I mean, what does that mean
  340. 21:51? It's something that shouldn't happen.
  341. 21:53Why shouldn't it? And why
  342. 21:56is it teaching us humility? I mean, we
  343. 21:59shouldn't think we understand what can
  344. 22:01only be clear to God. Eh,
  345. 22:05and at a certain point you realize that
  346. 22:07without the existence of God, evil as
  347. 22:08evil does not exist; it is simply a
  348. 22:10sociocultural byproduct, okay? So it is
  349. 22:14not something that can be objectively
  350. 22:16negative, only subjectively. Therefore,
  351. 22:19when you say that an ugly thing is
  352. 22:21objectively negative or bad, where are
  353. 22:23you getting this objectivity outside of
  354. 22:25yourself? We're going to talk about how
  355. 22:28God must necessarily exist. You may not
  356. 22:30believe in God, but
  357. 22:32I am especially interested in the step
  358. 22:34where we discuss how God must
  359. 22:35necessarily exist. From the fact that
  360. 22:41subjectivity exists, we derive the
  361. 22:42existence of God. But we are commenting
  362. 22:45.
  363. 22:45If God does not exist,
  364. 22:47however,
  365. 22:48it's of no use. So, God can have
  366. 22:52sufficient moral reasons for allowing
  367. 22:57evil. So let's say God's ultimate goal
  368. 23:00is to bring as many people as possible
  369. 23:03to faith freely, because He cannot
  370. 23:05force you to love Him. It's another one
  371. 23:07of the things God cannot do. God cannot
  372. 23:09force you to love Him freely because it
  373. 23:10is a contradiction. Okay? Just as He
  374. 23:12also cannot,
  375. 23:13so one is also free to hate Him; He
  376. 23:15leaves you free, even to crucify Him.
  377. 23:18Certainly. Um, so God leaves you free,
  378. 23:21but let's see what His final plan is.
  379. 23:24But if God has moral reasons, it means
  380. 23:25that there is a morality independent of
  381. 23:27God. Frazuk, stay in your lane. You
  382. 23:35have to put omnipotence aside. It is to
  383. 23:38bring, to allow as many people as
  384. 23:40possible to choose Him freely. How can
  385. 23:44we prove that He does not have
  386. 23:46sufficient moral reasons to allow some
  387. 23:48evil with this plan? I mean, how do we
  388. 23:51know, logically, how do we know if it
  389. 23:53is logically possible for God to reach
  390. 23:54His ultimate plan without being able to
  391. 23:56allow, without being able to allow some
  392. 23:57evil? In fact, no atheist, no
  393. 24:00non-believer, or no, let's say, skeptic
  394. 24:03, whatever you want to call them, has
  395. 24:05been able to prove it because it places
  396. 24:07an unsustainable burden of proof on the
  397. 24:09shoulders of the non-believer or the
  398. 24:12critic. I mean, you would literally
  399. 24:14have to prove that God does not have
  400. 24:16sufficient moral reasons—and God is
  401. 24:18the subsistent morality—to allow some
  402. 24:20evil. So things simply happen, God
  403. 24:23permits them, He doesn't cause them,
  404. 24:25because God cannot be the author of
  405. 24:27evil. It's possible because God is good
  406. 24:30, meaning when one says" good, "they
  407. 24:31say" God. "God is subsistent goodness.
  408. 24:35Okay? So essentially, God can also
  409. 24:38permit evil,
  410. 24:39right? He can permit evil. Certainly,
  411. 24:44if I put down the microphone now and go
  412. 24:46strangle someone, God is permitting it,
  413. 24:48He did not want it. God could stop it
  414. 24:50with a miracle. Yes, He could do that.
  415. 24:53Usually, He doesn't. Well, it's called
  416. 24:54a miracle if He does.
  417. 24:56Miracles.
  418. 24:57What...what are miracles? Miracles are
  419. 25:01...it is God working in parallel to the
  420. 25:05laws of the universe, so He stops a
  421. 25:08thing from happening according to its
  422. 25:11natural process. Remember that these
  423. 25:15processes are created or permitted by
  424. 25:18God, but He acts in parallel to them.
  425. 25:23Okay? So, a completely incurable
  426. 25:26disease is cured definitively. There
  427. 25:30are criteria for miracles, I don't
  428. 25:31remember them by heart right now, for
  429. 25:33example, regarding healings. The
  430. 25:35healing must be inexplicable, immediate
  431. 25:37, and must be permanent, so it can't
  432. 25:38just be something that improves a
  433. 25:40little. And then
  434. 25:44the fact is that God should know what
  435. 25:46He lets happen. What is the difference
  436. 25:51between doing something and letting it
  437. 25:53happen, knowing it will occur, and
  438. 25:57knowing that you could intervene at any
  439. 25:59moment to prevent it? Beyond that,
  440. 26:06naturally, the fact that He acts in
  441. 26:08parallel to natural processes is
  442. 26:10somewhat...it's interesting.
  443. 26:13It comes back, okay? Because, for
  444. 26:17example, it could also be someone
  445. 26:19else's work. The problem is that
  446. 26:22usually when it's the work of the" left
  447. 26:24hand, "things come back, right? Those
  448. 26:27who go to certain magicians, etc., no,
  449. 26:29but beyond suggestion, there can also
  450. 26:32be a recourse to the powers of darkness
  451. 26:34which, not being able to create, okay,
  452. 26:37maybe the pain goes away for a while,
  453. 26:39then it returns. In fact, those who go
  454. 26:42to these people, the evil often returns
  455. 26:44, or they even predict things that they
  456. 26:45actually cause themselves when they
  457. 26:47predict the illnesses. In fact, many
  458. 26:49people have
  459. 26:53so the charlatans that unfortunately
  460. 26:56people turn to when they are desperate,
  461. 27:01sometimes they are the ones who cause
  462. 27:03the evil for you. I see. Really, really
  463. 27:10. Etc., but besides suggestion, there
  464. 27:16can also be a recourse to the powers of
  465. 27:20darkness that but they can't cre...So,
  466. 27:25does the...let's say, the magician
  467. 27:30resort to the powers of darkness
  468. 27:32because God lets him do it?
  469. 27:35but since they cannot create, okay,
  470. 27:38maybe the pain goes away for a bit,
  471. 27:40then it comes back to you, the ailment
  472. 27:43even returns; they predict it, so they
  473. 27:45are capable of causing you a relapse,
  474. 27:48right, of something, but not just
  475. 27:50anything. The power of magicians, of
  476. 27:54the forces of darkness, stops at making
  477. 27:56something happen to you again, but they
  478. 27:58cannot make something happen that has
  479. 28:00never happened before, because only God
  480. 28:03could, or in reality, God could let
  481. 28:05that happen. So if it happens, it's
  482. 28:08because it was allowed to happen, also
  483. 28:12because it’s not as if something that
  484. 28:13happens to you is created, is it?
  485. 28:16Otherwise, creation would never end.
  486. 28:20And so what would God ever allow to
  487. 28:22happen? These are things that they
  488. 28:24actually cause you when they predict
  489. 28:25illnesses. In fact, many people have—
  490. 28:28let's drop it here, the powers of the
  491. 28:30dark forces. Let's leave it alone, come
  492. 28:32on, let's leave it alone. Topic is too
  493. 28:34long, too long.
  494. 28:34I won't stop going from
  495. 28:39It is very interesting because this
  496. 28:41video, I can presume—because I am not
  497. 28:43an expert, but I presume like others of
  498. 28:45his and similar ones—has a
  499. 28:47characteristic that is super, super
  500. 28:48interesting. tone, the relationship
  501. 28:58between the tone and—it's not just
  502. 29:01the tone, no, it's the facial part, if
  503. 29:04you will, of this monologue or, well,
  504. 29:07speech and the contents. And I have to
  505. 29:12tell you that there are six steps, how
  506. 29:15to become rich, etcetera, etcetera, eh
  507. 29:23how do I do it? Thank you. Pff, right?
  508. 29:29How do I convince you that I know it?
  509. 29:35The most banal thing of all is that I
  510. 29:38must seem to know it because,
  511. 29:40unfortunately, the targets of theology,
  512. 29:43just like the targets of certain
  513. 29:48certain products that, as you were
  514. 29:50writing earlier, are the same target.
  515. 29:53Eh, often that is enough. The problem
  516. 29:56that Primo Levi also notoriously spoke
  517. 29:59about, right, in the notes to" If Not
  518. 30:01Now, When? ", the problem of
  519. 30:02charismatic leaders. What is charisma?
  520. 30:08Charisma is that which, as you can
  521. 30:10define in a thousand ways, but applied
  522. 30:12to what we are seeing, none of us here
  523. 30:14would define him as charismatic, but
  524. 30:16the reason he has a clientele and that
  525. 30:18there are those who will find him
  526. 30:20charismatic, right? Ehm, what is
  527. 30:24charisma? Charisma is the ability of
  528. 30:28manners to, ehm, prevail and in some
  529. 30:34way replace the content. Thank you
  530. 30:38Moria. Quite convinced, eh, the context
  531. 30:44that the person envies, the muscles
  532. 30:47that the person envies, eh, whatever
  533. 30:50you want, right? the target of this
  534. 30:55communication does not pay attention to
  535. 31:00the content, no, but pays attention to
  536. 31:02the charisma. It's no coincidence that
  537. 31:07many preachers and figures throughout
  538. 31:09religious history were charismatic,
  539. 31:12meaning we could call them hypnotists,
  540. 31:14enchanters, right? Now, I know this
  541. 31:20doesn't enchant us. Overconfident
  542. 31:24people are often overachievers. This is
  543. 31:26very true. And resistors, what are
  544. 31:33resistors, Shanil? Forgive me, sorry,
  545. 31:37did you bring me to YouTube? Mister Rip
  546. 31:55, who is this? I don't know him. Cool.
  547. 32:05I don't know anything about it. And so
  548. 32:11let's move on. Let's see where it goes.
  549. 32:13If it's just this or something else.
  550. 32:15These magicians, I don't know how to
  551. 32:17define them,
  552. 32:19because they claimed they actually
  553. 32:21caused pain, like saying," Tomorrow you
  554. 32:23will break a leg, "and they would break
  555. 32:24it." Yes, right? The way they predict
  556. 32:26it. I was explaining earlier. So, keep
  557. 32:28in mind that, first of all, going to
  558. 32:30magicians is a mortal sin because it's
  559. 32:32a violation of the first commandment.
  560. 32:33You shall have no other gods before me.
  561. 32:37Mind you, this is the reason for not
  562. 32:39going to magicians. Um, and so it's a
  563. 32:41bad thing that cannot be done and is
  564. 32:44behavior that is not acceptable for a
  565. 32:46Christian, neither for a Catholic nor a
  566. 32:49Protestant. For a Christian, it is
  567. 32:51absolutely unacceptable. Magic is
  568. 32:53always evil. There is no such thing as
  569. 32:56white magic, black magic, red magic,
  570. 32:58which is sexual, etc. It's all magic.
  571. 33:00Even just getting your cards read,
  572. 33:02simply put.
  573. 33:02Yes, yes, yes, yes. It is absolutely a
  574. 33:04violation, divination. Eh, this is
  575. 33:07strictly forbidden since Deuteronomy,
  576. 33:09so it's not a game, it's idolatry. Okay
  577. 33:12, the cards tell me; the cards don't
  578. 33:14tell you anything because they are
  579. 33:15objects, so either we believe objects
  580. 33:16tell us things, in which case we're in
  581. 33:18real trouble, or we believe in the rest
  582. 33:19. It's fantastic, how it's something
  583. 33:25I've always found absolutely amusing,
  584. 33:27how for strongly religious people,
  585. 33:30magic is just something for the poor in
  586. 33:32spirit, for the gullible, for—what
  587. 33:34the hell—aside from being a bad thing
  588. 33:36, etcetera, etcetera, because in
  589. 33:38reality, it works as he said before,
  590. 33:41according to them. Um, it's a, it's a
  591. 33:45fantastic thing because one says, "But
  592. 33:47what is the limit for believing? I mean
  593. 33:50, I shouldn't believe in something that
  594. 33:52isn't credible, that doesn't hold up,
  595. 33:54that has no grounding in reality, that
  596. 33:56cannot be shown or demonstrated,
  597. 33:57etcetera, etcetera. But then it will be
  598. 33:59very difficult, no, to support
  599. 34:01metaphysics. But the metaphysics from
  600. 34:03before supports itself with all its
  601. 34:05internal logic, which is a logic that
  602. 34:07holds up as long as it doesn't touch
  603. 34:09reality. And so no, we are simply
  604. 34:12talking about what can effectively be
  605. 34:15defined as metaphysical gatekeeping,
  606. 34:17meaning anyone who believes in a piece
  607. 34:19of those infinite metaphysical or
  608. 34:21magical beliefs—you realize there is
  609. 34:23no difference between these two terms.
  610. 34:27Whoever believes in a piece of them
  611. 34:28automatically disqualifies everything
  612. 34:30else. But why? As Eco understood very
  613. 34:34well in Foucault's Pendulum, quoting
  614. 34:36Chesterton, since people stopped
  615. 34:38believing in God, it's not that they
  616. 34:39believe in nothing anymore; they
  617. 34:41believe in everything. But that was
  618. 34:43already God's fault. The problem of the
  619. 34:47death of God, of that credulity talked
  620. 34:50about in the pendulum, is not a problem
  621. 34:52of the loss of faith, understood as the
  622. 34:57one true faith. It is a problem of the
  623. 35:00loss of power of those who made that
  624. 35:01one true faith mandatory. The death of
  625. 35:06God is a worldly fact, like any fact,
  626. 35:07like anything; there is nothing but
  627. 35:09worldly facts. Uh, the moment you, uh,
  628. 35:16how do you say, right? You open the
  629. 35:19stable, the oxen run out, and it's over
  630. 35:21. You can no longer force people to say
  631. 35:25there is a difference, that the
  632. 35:27magician is ridiculous, but also sinful
  633. 35:28, but also that it's self-fulfilling,
  634. 35:30or rather he makes it happen, but he
  635. 35:32doesn't, but he can only summon it,
  636. 35:33etc. So then the magician has power.
  637. 35:36Thanks, Grecot. And that is wrong, it's
  638. 35:39ridiculous, while the other is sacred
  639. 35:40and totally true. And this gatekeeping
  640. 35:49is fundamental for an institutional
  641. 35:51religion. What he is doing is defending
  642. 35:55the institutional theses of the
  643. 35:58Catholic religion, which is an
  644. 36:00institution that defines itself as the
  645. 36:03holder of the right and correct
  646. 36:06interpretation of texts that it itself
  647. 36:09defines as sacred. There is no reason
  648. 36:12in the universe to define them as
  649. 36:13sacred other than the fact that they
  650. 36:14tell you so. All the power, a monopoly,
  651. 36:19certainly yes, all the power of a
  652. 36:21religious institution is based on the
  653. 36:24fact that this institution holds the
  654. 36:26truth and others are lying. Which is
  655. 36:30why dialogue between religions has
  656. 36:31gigantic intrinsic problems. Which is
  657. 36:37why there are—think of The Name of
  658. 36:38the Rose, right? The discussion of
  659. 36:40heresies. Eh, if I have the whole truth
  660. 36:45, nothing but the truth, if you change
  661. 36:47a comma you are disqualified, or rather
  662. 36:48excommunicated. It's fundamental.
  663. 36:53Otherwise I stop being, right, the
  664. 36:56Vicar of Christ, the Pope, right? Or
  665. 37:03uhm, the cards are a medium through
  666. 37:05which someone speaks; God does not
  667. 37:07speak through cards, so we are already
  668. 37:09invoking something that is not God, and
  669. 37:11it's not done because God himself tells
  670. 37:14us so. You don't even need to know who
  671. 37:16or what it is. Worth noting.
  672. 37:18This is the fundamental thing. Religion
  673. 37:21is based on this principle he just laid
  674. 37:22out. Guys, this video is so interesting
  675. 37:24. Religion is based on this principle
  676. 37:26he just laid out. There is always,
  677. 37:29ultimately, a censorship, um, beyond
  678. 37:32which you must no longer ask questions.
  679. 37:36It is not permitted to ask questions.
  680. 37:37It is obviously also the discourse of
  681. 37:40original sin, if you think about it. He
  682. 37:43, God, in this case, places a limit on
  683. 37:48you and says," It’s like this, period
  684. 37:50, and you have to accept it and ask no
  685. 37:53more. "This is obviously highly
  686. 37:57paternalistic, but beyond the discourse
  687. 38:00itself, naturally God is a human
  688. 38:03invention and so we must ask ourselves,
  689. 38:06what is the reason for the invention of
  690. 38:09an authority of this kind? It is to
  691. 38:13transfer an analogous authority to
  692. 38:16institutions that are not in heaven,
  693. 38:19but on earth, like the great, great
  694. 38:22religious institutions. And you are
  695. 38:26already conditioned that there exists
  696. 38:28an authority that you cannot question
  697. 38:30beyond certain limits, to which you
  698. 38:32basically shouldn't be a pain in the
  699. 38:34ass because you can't understand, and
  700. 38:36there exists a worldly institution that
  701. 38:38in fact is its intermediary; even this
  702. 38:42worldly institution will be able to
  703. 38:44tell you the same thing. Even a father,
  704. 38:46in a religious or non-religious sense,
  705. 38:48will be able to tell you the same thing
  706. 38:50. It is anti-curiosity, anti-critical
  707. 38:58thinking, and it is the basis of a
  708. 39:00dogmatic type of obedience. Let us
  709. 39:05remember that the term dogmatic is
  710. 39:07applied in a, let's say, imprecise way.
  711. 39:13In reality, one occurrence of the term
  712. 39:15dogmatic is the dogmas of the Catholic
  713. 39:17Church, like the Immaculate Conception.
  714. 39:20The Immaculate Conception, that is, the
  715. 39:22fact that the Virgin has no original
  716. 39:25sin, is a dogma of the Catholic Church.
  717. 39:27But the fact that the Virgin is a
  718. 39:29virgin is also a dogma, but it is not
  719. 39:30simply a dogma of the Catholic Church,
  720. 39:32it is always a dogma. That is,
  721. 39:34something you have to believe in, and
  722. 39:35that’s the end of it, okay? You have
  723. 39:37to believe in it just because. So be
  724. 39:41careful when they want to screw with
  725. 39:42you with arguments like these," Oh no,
  726. 39:44because virginity is not a dogma "—
  727. 39:45they are all dogmas, only they, for
  728. 39:47their own institutional reasons, define
  729. 39:48some as dogmas of the Catholic Church,
  730. 39:50like papal infallibility, I believe
  731. 39:51that's the latest one, right? Which was
  732. 39:54, but no, there are an infinite number
  733. 39:58of dogmas if we use the word as it
  734. 40:00should be used. Heh heh. Certainly yes,
  735. 40:05Pasidelis, absolutely yes. Yes, yes,
  736. 40:09yes, yes. Metaphysics is based only on
  737. 40:10internal logical consistency. A
  738. 40:11logically valid argument is considered
  739. 40:13true a priori, without verification.
  740. 40:15This allows for the construction of
  741. 40:16imposing superstructures and infinite
  742. 40:17theoretical palaces. No empirical fact
  743. 40:19or data can ever refute such concepts.
  744. 40:21Reason thus produces perfect logical
  745. 40:22castles, yet ones that are entirely
  746. 40:23unfalsifiable. Though, the logical
  747. 40:25perfection is up for debate, because in
  748. 40:27reality, especially in the era when
  749. 40:29these theologies were being constructed
  750. 40:31, the logic was really based on natural
  751. 40:33languages and, therefore, was actually
  752. 40:35based heavily on the interpretation of
  753. 40:37the meanings of terms, which is also
  754. 40:39the basis for the interpretation of
  755. 40:41sacred texts. And so, exactly. The
  756. 40:44internal logic, in reality, is not a
  757. 40:45true internal logic; it is a...okay, it
  758. 40:50is a" you have to trust, "that is the
  759. 40:52meaning. It's not just that; it is full
  760. 40:54of, it is full of passages like this,
  761. 40:55eh. But it has a sound, it has a sound
  762. 40:58and an extraordinary structure, and it
  763. 41:00becomes what for many is religion or,
  764. 41:03even more so, if a person is more
  765. 41:05intelligent, they need theology more
  766. 41:08than religion. What theology becomes is
  767. 41:11a refuge for the mind, it is an escape,
  768. 41:14a place where you can continue to think
  769. 41:16but far away from reality. And it is a,
  770. 41:20it is a bad trap. Naturally, let it be
  771. 41:23clear that this argument could also be
  772. 41:25made for formal logic, but that is a
  773. 41:27whole other level that nowhere has the
  774. 41:30Church claimed, nowhere is it in
  775. 41:31scripture, nowhere is it in tradition
  776. 41:33that magic does not exist. They just
  777. 41:37say not to practice it.
  778. 41:39Do you understand? This, this we had,
  779. 41:40this we had already understood.
  780. 41:43So you just leave it alone. Mh. So when
  781. 41:45someone says," Ah, but I went to this
  782. 41:47functioner, "yes, yes. Okay, but I
  783. 41:49don't get involved in these things here
  784. 41:51. And
  785. 41:52why did they tell me that?
  786. 41:54Eh,
  787. 41:54so it is established that Satan exists.
  788. 41:56Certainly. And how could Satan not
  789. 41:59exist? Sorry, now this, this, this was
  790. 42:01a naive question. Revealed by Jesus
  791. 42:04Christ, by God on earth, also because
  792. 42:06God came to earth to defeat, as we read
  793. 42:09in the Gospel, the works of the devil.
  794. 42:14So, in full obedience, Jesus Christ,
  795. 42:16who is the new Adam, obeyed the Father
  796. 42:18fully—something that Adam and Eve had
  797. 42:20not done—took upon his shoulders the
  798. 42:22sin and the punishment of the world,
  799. 42:24otherwise it wouldn't be fair for the
  800. 42:26sin, and gave us the possibility to go
  801. 42:28back to paradise. I
  802. 42:32the thing that strikes me now, not
  803. 42:34about this video, but about these
  804. 42:35issues—because here we are cracking
  805. 42:37jokes, I came across this video this
  806. 42:38morning, I couldn't believe it—it
  807. 42:40actually becomes very interesting. The
  808. 42:43thing that strikes me, that interests
  809. 42:45me so much it's the relevance of these
  810. 42:51issues that, for some, for me and I
  811. 42:54think many of you, is disheartening,
  812. 42:59but it isn't at all when we see the
  813. 43:02various military and political leaders
  814. 43:05and the great religious leaders, right?
  815. 43:10and we see practices that are truly
  816. 43:12bordering on delirium with Trump, with
  817. 43:14others, right? and the Messiah is
  818. 43:19coming, the Messiah is arriving, the
  819. 43:21antichrist is returning, they are
  820. 43:23satanists, and we are, well, what the
  821. 43:25hell...We realize that in reality the
  822. 43:33people who laugh at this are very few,
  823. 43:37they are truly few. Consider how
  824. 43:42unpopular science is, how an approach
  825. 43:47that we could define as down-to-earth,
  826. 43:49pragmatic, materialist, etc., is
  827. 43:51considered by so many to be a human
  828. 43:53misery. People who perhaps don't reason
  829. 44:00like him, eh, but who share his
  830. 44:03certainty. It's not even a belief. In
  831. 44:07fact, I dare say it is a certainty
  832. 44:09without being a belief. they are
  833. 44:12certain without believing in it. um,
  834. 44:15the certainty of the metaphysical, of
  835. 44:17the magical, right, etc., there are so
  836. 44:20many of them. Eh, it never ceases to be
  837. 44:24, by the way, since we'll deal with it
  838. 44:27later, it never ceases to be on the
  839. 44:29agenda, to be relevant. In this,
  840. 44:32Foucault's Pendulum, eh, no, never ever
  841. 44:34. the number of people who keep,
  842. 44:40perhaps even at home, perhaps only
  843. 44:41metaphorically within themselves, a
  844. 44:43little magic altar, right? It is
  845. 44:47boundless. And this, the thing that I
  846. 44:51think is interesting and history proves
  847. 44:53it unequivocally, is that believing in
  848. 44:56the magical, the metaphysical, and so
  849. 44:58on, is not something specific to or
  850. 45:00that distinguishes the poor or the
  851. 45:03stupid. It might have a different
  852. 45:09incidence, perhaps, but religious,
  853. 45:12economic, and political leaders of
  854. 45:15every level have, and how, believed or
  855. 45:22believed they believed in things of
  856. 45:25this kind. Um, even when you go, almost
  857. 45:29at a gossip level, to see, right? I
  858. 45:33remember once, Alessi, because there
  859. 45:35was one in the Corriere della Sera—I
  860. 45:37read the interview, I think it was Mara
  861. 45:39Venier, one of those figures, you know,
  862. 45:42from Italian TV and cinema, not the
  863. 45:44highest level—who talked about how
  864. 45:46many big shots went to the psychic,
  865. 45:48among the Agnellis, among...there have
  866. 45:55been figures, I'm talking about Italy,
  867. 45:57but just imagine abroad too, who have
  868. 45:59made fortunes on what he here
  869. 46:01disqualifies, right? Reading cards,
  870. 46:03things like that, because naturally, if
  871. 46:06I'm someone who reads coffee grounds,
  872. 46:08I'll ask an idiot for 50 euros, maybe
  873. 46:10from an industrial president I'll ask
  874. 46:12for 5,000 per session, you get it?
  875. 46:15I’ve seen these things with my own
  876. 46:17eyes, among other things, in the sense
  877. 46:19that I saw, I saw the studio and a
  878. 46:22psychic working in an incredible
  879. 46:23coincidence in my life. And guys, there
  880. 46:27was a line just like going to the
  881. 46:29doctor, huh? Just like going to the
  882. 46:30primary care physician. The brave
  883. 46:32mediums. Sure, sure, sure, sure. Eh, eh
  884. 46:40, let’s just say that well, I saw a
  885. 46:47person who earned € 250 an hour, if
  886. 46:50I’m not mistaken, reading tarot cards
  887. 46:52. Imagine the invoices she was issuing.
  888. 46:54But beyond that, I don't even think she
  889. 46:56was one of the ones earning the most,
  890. 46:59eh. And the people who turned to, you
  891. 47:02can tell from the amount, the people
  892. 47:04who turned to her weren't exactly
  893. 47:06starving. Just think, I mean, it’s
  894. 47:14one thing to be a millionaire, right?
  895. 47:17It’s one thing to be a millionaire.
  896. 47:20It’s another thing to be well-off,
  897. 47:22earning a decent living, but € 250 is
  898. 47:24€ 250. But think about deciding to
  899. 47:28allocate that for a magic reading. I
  900. 47:31mean, what the hell kind of budget
  901. 47:37management is that? There is a huge
  902. 47:42market in telling people what they want
  903. 47:43to hear. This is perhaps the, is the
  904. 47:45best, is the best summary we could give
  905. 47:47, eh a refuge for people. Now we are
  906. 47:55listening to Big Luca who naturally
  907. 47:58acts as this character and so on and so
  908. 48:00forth. Be that as it may, I believe
  909. 48:03that by hearing him speak we can credit
  910. 48:04him with the fact that he is not a
  911. 48:06stupid person, okay? He might be a con
  912. 48:08artist, I’ll pretend I don’t have
  913. 48:10an opinion, okay? But he is clearly not
  914. 48:13a stupid person. How much of this stuff
  915. 48:17has he filled his head with? Then
  916. 48:24obviously at every level there are the
  917. 48:26con artists among the con artists who
  918. 48:28stir up ghosts to manipulate, who
  919. 48:29don’t actually believe a damn thing
  920. 48:31about these things, but they have
  921. 48:32understood very well that you have to
  922. 48:34know how to navigate them, how to
  923. 48:36handle them, and how to use them. And
  924. 48:38then there are those who you really
  925. 48:40thought were the big, the big boss, and
  926. 48:42they will certainly be the big boss,
  927. 48:43but maybe deep down they are also there
  928. 48:45hoping that their soul doesn't die;
  929. 48:49which, apparently, it’s useless to
  930. 48:51deny, is a very human thing, it’s a
  931. 48:52very human desire, but we understand
  932. 48:54the reason. One of the things, last
  933. 48:58week I was at a local fair in
  934. 48:59Monterenzio and there was obviously the
  935. 49:01magic tent reading tarot cards. There
  936. 49:03was a line of at least 10 people. You
  937. 49:05know, by the way Shanil, I drove past
  938. 49:06it in my car, who knows if you were
  939. 49:08there too. And you know, there’s
  940. 49:10always a veil of irony, it’s done for
  941. 49:12a gag, it’s done for a joke, but we
  942. 49:15understand each other. Forens Mario
  943. 49:21Azzoni was a renowned psychic with
  944. 49:22offices in Milan and various other
  945. 49:24cities, including New York. He even
  946. 49:26appeared on TV on Rai. Of course, he
  947. 49:27wrote books; today he has vanished,
  948. 49:29disappeared into thin air. When I was a
  949. 49:30small child, I found myself in his
  950. 49:32Milan office; there was a line, you
  951. 49:34literally gave € 5 as you pleased, he
  952. 49:38made thousands upon thousands of euros
  953. 49:40a day, top-tier lawyers, doctors, and
  954. 49:41others. It doesn't surprise me in the
  955. 49:42slightest. Honestly, it doesn't
  956. 49:44surprise me in the slightest. This
  957. 49:48scares me. If there are so many blind
  958. 49:50believers in the Christian religion who
  959. 49:52, all in all, don't hurt anyone today
  960. 49:54because it's secularized and therefore
  961. 49:55practically doesn't exist anymore.
  962. 49:57there will be, there are, on the other
  963. 49:59side of the world, just as many blind
  964. 50:00people who believe in religions that
  965. 50:02profess evil ideas, but who, out of
  966. 50:03that same blindness, are led to persist
  967. 50:05in them, to persevere in them without
  968. 50:06asking questions. This is a major theme
  969. 50:09, and it is the reason why, uh, in my
  970. 50:11opinion—look, let's actually move to
  971. 50:14the second—why Kubrick wanted to make
  972. 50:16the film of Foucault's Pendulum, why
  973. 50:21Kubrick wanted to make a film of
  974. 50:22Foucault's Pendulum and why Foucault's
  975. 50:24Pendulum tells the things it tells,
  976. 50:26considering that these two minds here,
  977. 50:28Umberto Eco and Stanley Kubrick, were
  978. 50:30certainly not the last of the idiots.
  979. 50:33And why then did Kubrick end up making
  980. 50:35Eyes Wide Shut, which now I say a bit
  981. 50:37jokingly, is exactly the film someone
  982. 50:39would make who couldn't make the film
  983. 50:41about Foucault's Pendulum and in
  984. 50:44reality, it goes further. Why? Because
  985. 50:49the thing is, when does it become, when
  986. 50:51does this whole world, uh, from the
  987. 50:53super official religion, right?
  988. 50:56Recognized and all the, the, the, the
  989. 51:00side paths, right? Even this thing that
  990. 51:03he said, that the Catholic religion
  991. 51:05doesn't say that psychics don't exist,
  992. 51:07but that you shouldn't consult them.
  993. 51:09You understand that it leaves you, it
  994. 51:11leaves you with side paths even for
  995. 51:12those who still want to tell themselves
  996. 51:14that they keep believing, that they
  997. 51:16still keep Christ with them. But do you
  998. 51:18, do you understand how many
  999. 51:19possibilities are created within a
  1000. 51:20person's internal narrative, right? Why
  1001. 51:23? Why these two super-duper mega
  1002. 51:25geniuses, two of the greatest minds
  1003. 51:27we've ever had, why do they get the
  1004. 51:29urge to create content about that stuff
  1005. 51:31? Exactly because of the point Arthur
  1006. 51:36Hanks was making, about the discourse
  1007. 51:38of evil, not the evil of God, that God
  1008. 51:41allows evil, but in the sense that you,
  1009. 51:43with a belief, with charisma—because
  1010. 51:46the psychic, as we were told earlier,
  1011. 51:48etc., are charismatic characters. you,
  1012. 51:53with charisma, right? You know, the,
  1013. 51:56the, the witch. and you can make people
  1014. 52:00do evil without them even perceiving it
  1015. 52:03as evil. Yes, yes, yes, Giulio,
  1016. 52:11certainly. No, I was thinking about our
  1017. 52:12home now. Of course, Josa, I totally
  1018. 52:16agree with you. Even politics without
  1019. 52:19dogmatism wouldn't go anywhere. When we
  1020. 52:25talk about Foucault's Pendulum or Eyes
  1021. 52:27Wide Shut style rituals, the most
  1022. 52:30interesting thing in my opinion is that
  1023. 52:33we are talking about criminals, meaning
  1024. 52:35regardless of whether they think about
  1025. 52:38Baphomet or crap like that, we are
  1026. 52:41talking about criminals who commit
  1027. 52:43crimes. This is the interesting core,
  1028. 52:47besides the fact that we're talking
  1029. 52:50about secret societies—so I drifted a
  1030. 52:53bit, but not much, since we were
  1031. 52:55talking about Eyes Wide Shut,
  1032. 52:57Foucault's Pendulum, and secret
  1033. 52:59societies—we are talking about
  1034. 53:01totally undemocratic parastatal
  1035. 53:03institutions. If the ideal democracy is
  1036. 53:08that of the glass palace, of absolute
  1037. 53:10transparency before the citizens—this
  1038. 53:12is truly Bobbio, and therefore Kant—
  1039. 53:15the more you head toward the" arcana
  1040. 53:17imperii, "the further you move away
  1041. 53:19from democracy. The more I discover—
  1042. 53:23so to speak, since they came out
  1043. 53:25recently—the list of those at
  1044. 53:26Bohemian Grove, the list of that other
  1045. 53:28Peter Thiel group, one says:" Damn, who
  1046. 53:29cares? "But damn, I care because these
  1047. 53:32lists aren't lists of people who have a
  1048. 53:34WhatsApp chat—maybe they even have a
  1049. 53:36WhatsApp chat—but these are people
  1050. 53:38who notoriously meet up. They meet up
  1051. 53:41to do what? They meet up to give rise
  1052. 53:45to decision-making processes that
  1053. 53:47completely bypass the citizenry. To me,
  1054. 53:53if while they do it, let's say they
  1055. 53:55burn an effigy for Baal, maybe they
  1056. 53:58don't, but I'm only interested in those
  1057. 54:01things up to a point, even if obviously
  1058. 54:04a horror is prefigured, but the point
  1059. 54:07is these people and democracy are not
  1060. 54:10compatible. This type of elite far from
  1061. 54:19the sunlight where Big Luca is, is
  1062. 54:21strongly antidemocratic. The P2, let's
  1063. 54:25not act surprised. That is the problem
  1064. 54:29first and foremost, the crimes they
  1065. 54:32might commit directly. And then what is
  1066. 54:35the result for us? What is Parliament
  1067. 54:39for? Why do we elect these [ __ ] to
  1068. 54:42Parliament? We know perfectly well that
  1069. 54:46companies are private, etc., heaven
  1070. 54:48forbid, but there is a place, there are
  1071. 54:50buildings, there are institutions where
  1072. 54:53democratic life happens and that's
  1073. 54:55where it must happen, where a record
  1074. 54:57can be kept. The less it's like that
  1075. 55:01and the more they just pass around
  1076. 55:02papers on what was decided elsewhere,
  1077. 55:04the emptier democracy becomes—it
  1078. 55:05doesn't exist. And so vacuum cleaners,
  1079. 55:20maybe I haven't seen that one in
  1080. 55:21particular. But the problem of
  1081. 55:27dogmatism applied in this case, we're
  1082. 55:28talking about...I'll use the term
  1083. 55:30metaphysics, which in my opinion,
  1084. 55:31actually—even if they wouldn't agree
  1085. 55:33—really encompasses everything; you
  1086. 55:34even include magic if you say
  1087. 55:35metaphysics, even if he would get
  1088. 55:37pissed off. Um, the problem with
  1089. 55:40metaphysical beliefs is that uh, it's
  1090. 55:46that they aren't pragmatic. Reality has
  1091. 55:52no say in the matter. As you were
  1092. 55:55saying earlier, the house of cards, the
  1093. 55:58, uh, logical construction that is made
  1094. 56:01without any falsifiability, without any
  1095. 56:04criterion of verifiability, etc.—
  1096. 56:06reality becomes secondary to the idea,
  1097. 56:09to these fantasies, to these dogmas
  1098. 56:12which, as always, will have gullible
  1099. 56:14people, the frightened, the terrified
  1100. 56:17—and therefore, the more easily
  1101. 56:19manipulated. First, second, and
  1102. 56:22third-level manipulators, because maybe
  1103. 56:24you'll have the manipulator who
  1104. 56:25believes, who is nonetheless a great
  1105. 56:27manipulator within the belief, and then
  1106. 56:28you'll have the final manipulator, who
  1107. 56:30is one who doesn't believe—who is
  1108. 56:32neither a believer nor a non-believer,
  1109. 56:33but simply a total opportunist. and the
  1110. 56:41manipulability of a mind, um, that
  1111. 56:44lacks the tools to rebel against
  1112. 56:46dogmatism. is what allows an irrational
  1113. 56:55power to achieve its objectives. This
  1114. 57:03is a huge problem, right? Certainly,
  1115. 57:09Pasidelli, I agree with you. The
  1116. 57:11dogmatist condemns pragmatism because
  1117. 57:13they prefer illusion to the effort of
  1118. 57:15research. Accepting doubt and error is
  1119. 57:17mistaken by dogmatism for a moral
  1120. 57:19weakness that leads to a miserable life
  1121. 57:21. And I agree, Arthuranks, I agree. In
  1122. 57:27fact, one of the things that interested
  1123. 57:29me about the Epstein Files, right? Is
  1124. 57:32discovering the many levels of
  1125. 57:34loyalty-building used on those
  1126. 57:36considered to be at the very highest
  1127. 57:38levels, because it's too easy to think
  1128. 57:40it's all just [ __ ] for the poor
  1129. 57:42wretches. It is absolutely not just
  1130. 57:45like that. How people belie—this is
  1131. 57:55pure, right? How people come to believe
  1132. 57:59something. If you really think about it
  1133. 58:02, it's one of the themes. What is the
  1134. 58:05most central, focal theme of this? How
  1135. 58:08does someone come to believe something?
  1136. 58:11How can you make someone believe
  1137. 58:13something? We are already in the realm
  1138. 58:15of propaganda. But propaganda—even
  1139. 58:17when we speak now, rightly so, about
  1140. 58:19propaganda and so on—but propaganda,
  1141. 58:21communication, persuasion, we're always
  1142. 58:23there, always the same gag. Making them
  1143. 58:26believe. Woe betide you if you pretend.
  1144. 58:36Everyone believes you, guys. Eco saying
  1145. 58:40that he reached the center of the
  1146. 58:41center. Well, anyway, no need for me to
  1147. 58:42repeat it to you. Woe betide if you
  1148. 58:45pretend, everyone believes you. Which
  1149. 58:48from an amoral or immoral perspective
  1150. 58:50is—yum, let's pretend, everyone
  1151. 58:51believes you. from the table being
  1152. 58:56shaken during the séance and you'll
  1153. 58:58have the one who thinks he believes,
  1154. 59:00the one who decides to believe, the one
  1155. 59:03who truly believes, right up to whoever
  1156. 59:05you like. we will never get rid of
  1157. 59:12being. The, the, how can I put it, the
  1158. 59:25we must not confuse the lucidity and
  1159. 59:27intellectual honesty of the champions
  1160. 59:30of humanity. Here I include Eco and
  1161. 59:32Kubrick. I’ve decided they are the
  1162. 59:34champions of humanity regarding what
  1163. 59:36humanity is. It is very difficult to be
  1164. 59:43content with being human. Death itself,
  1165. 59:48we know it all too well, and the idea
  1166. 59:50that it might be defeated, bypassed,
  1167. 59:53death with the pain, obviously, that
  1168. 59:56usually precedes or alludes to it,
  1169. 59:59right? Our body, our brain together
  1170. 1:00:05expose us to experiences that are
  1171. 1:00:10dizzying. Which are dizzying because at
  1172. 1:00:14the same time we experience the bland
  1173. 1:00:17practicality of every problem daily.
  1174. 1:00:22And yet we are, we have a capacity for
  1175. 1:00:23abstraction and desire, right? The
  1176. 1:00:27first essay by Kant on the platypus on
  1177. 1:00:30being. A fundamental text, desire,
  1178. 1:00:34desiring, well, it’s a vertigo,
  1179. 1:00:37imagining, here too Yume etc., the
  1180. 1:00:41capacity to imagine, to desire, to
  1181. 1:00:44digress, to go elsewhere, to reject
  1182. 1:00:47what is in front of your eyes, right?
  1183. 1:00:52and interpretation. We are truly, as
  1184. 1:00:59the greats understood, we are truly
  1185. 1:01:02this paradoxical animal, an animal like
  1186. 1:01:05all the others, but gifted with a
  1187. 1:01:07faculty for escapism through the
  1188. 1:01:09complexity of its own brain that is
  1189. 1:01:12simply a mortal checkmate to its life,
  1190. 1:01:15to its condition. The more I think
  1191. 1:01:24about it, the more interesting Lem’s
  1192. 1:01:26book Golem XIV is, because it really is
  1193. 1:01:27spot on. Eh, I think these are all
  1194. 1:01:29books that I’ve put on the shop
  1195. 1:01:30anyway, if you want to go take a look.
  1196. 1:01:34Golem XIV, I think I put it there, I
  1197. 1:01:35don't know if I put it under
  1198. 1:01:36non-fiction or fiction, but I recommend
  1199. 1:01:37it to you. It’s a good text. Yes, I
  1200. 1:01:44agree, Fraz, I'm glad you think so too.
  1201. 1:01:48And so, you know, here it’s typically
  1202. 1:01:50Leopardi, right? Nature, oh nature, oh
  1203. 1:01:52nature. Why do you promise them what
  1204. 1:01:54Why do you not then give what you
  1205. 1:01:55promise them? Why do you deceive your
  1206. 1:01:57children so much, sorry. And we are, we
  1207. 1:02:01are always on the edge, right? To have
  1208. 1:02:06so much mind just to then say there was
  1209. 1:02:08nothing to understand. I mean, you are
  1210. 1:02:12the most stubborn person who has ever
  1211. 1:02:14existed, or something like that, and
  1212. 1:02:16here in this very book, Foucault's
  1213. 1:02:18Pendulum, you end up saying there was
  1214. 1:02:20never anything to understand. But it's
  1215. 1:02:25a phrase, a realization that not only
  1216. 1:02:27can you allow yourself at the end of
  1217. 1:02:29the most important book that exists,
  1218. 1:02:31but you can allow yourself after you've
  1219. 1:02:33gone through everything, absolutely
  1220. 1:02:35everything, without any shortcuts, but
  1221. 1:02:45first you suffer if not all religions
  1222. 1:02:51know it. Religions, even those that are
  1223. 1:02:53absolutely not Western. You suffer the
  1224. 1:02:56pain caused by physical pain, naturally
  1225. 1:02:59, which is certainly not secondary, but
  1226. 1:03:02then the pain caused by desire. You
  1227. 1:03:07desire, right? When the dog brushes
  1228. 1:03:10against the door handle, saying," there
  1229. 1:03:12, it's peering into the human condition
  1230. 1:03:15, "what the hell am I supposed to tell
  1231. 1:03:21you? And you are there, you have to
  1232. 1:03:28accept that you are the, well, that you
  1233. 1:03:30are an animal, you have to accept that
  1234. 1:03:32you have to die. It is up to us to
  1235. 1:03:35establish how and when we must die.
  1236. 1:03:45It’s complicated, it’s for a few,
  1237. 1:03:52and who knows how few among the few we
  1238. 1:03:54think of. Do you remember the bad part,
  1239. 1:04:00in my opinion, a very tasteless and
  1240. 1:04:02unpleasant part of an otherwise
  1241. 1:04:04beautiful book, Fooled by Randomness by
  1242. 1:04:07Taleb, right? The part about the death
  1243. 1:04:10of Cavafy, the great poet between the
  1244. 1:04:1319th and 20th centuries, Greek, but
  1245. 1:04:15modern slash contemporary Greek, a
  1246. 1:04:17great poet and a Stoic anyway, right?
  1247. 1:04:22And what does Taleb say? He says," Eh,
  1248. 1:04:24but Cavafy, who had all this stoicism,
  1249. 1:04:26then died trembling, terrified, et
  1250. 1:04:28cetera, et cetera. "It's bad taste. But
  1251. 1:04:32it's not bad taste because it's
  1252. 1:04:33Cavafy's privacy—I'm still live—but
  1253. 1:04:36it's bad taste because it's not fair to
  1254. 1:04:38link the legacy, in this sense, and
  1255. 1:04:40also the intellectual dimension of a
  1256. 1:04:42great man like Cavafy, with what may
  1257. 1:04:44have been the final moments or the last
  1258. 1:04:46days of his life. I still find it a
  1259. 1:04:50slip in style on Taleb's part, but at
  1260. 1:04:54the same time I don't understand the
  1261. 1:05:00desire to go and peek at the deathbed
  1262. 1:05:03of the great sage because you want to
  1263. 1:05:06see if the wisdom is really there.
  1264. 1:05:10That's why Hume, right? Obviously, it
  1265. 1:05:12will have already crossed your mind,
  1266. 1:05:14that's why Hume and his letters, right?
  1267. 1:05:17Which were in that famous book, they're
  1268. 1:05:19all in the workshop, they were in the
  1269. 1:05:21book Dialogues Concerning Natural
  1270. 1:05:23Religion, all the letters about Hume's
  1271. 1:05:28death, Hume's death, which was this
  1272. 1:05:30incredible event, right? The atheist
  1273. 1:05:34who is not afraid and who dies with a
  1274. 1:05:36smile, the maximum inconceivable thing,
  1275. 1:05:40but it really is all there. And then at
  1276. 1:05:44a certain point, you can also, you can
  1277. 1:05:47also imagine the the better it is, the
  1278. 1:05:53worse it is, and so anything goes. you
  1279. 1:05:58can imagine the true opportunist, we
  1280. 1:06:01could call him a nihilist, completely
  1281. 1:06:04amoral, who doesn't—who rejects any
  1282. 1:06:17kind of game, playing any kind of game
  1283. 1:06:25and who can enjoy doing evil just as
  1284. 1:06:26much as doing good because they are the
  1285. 1:06:28same thing. There is already an ethic
  1286. 1:06:34in deciding to follow the rules of a
  1287. 1:06:36game which could be the game of
  1288. 1:06:38morality, that is, all the discussions
  1289. 1:06:40we've already had. Anyway, are you guys
  1290. 1:06:44still there? Did I—did I bore you to
  1291. 1:06:46death? The chat is dead. Everything
  1292. 1:06:49okay? Ah, nice, nice, nice. Let's hear
  1293. 1:06:52—let's hear what good old Big Luca
  1294. 1:06:54has to tell us. Nice, nice. Are you
  1295. 1:06:56alive? Always in doubt.
  1296. 1:06:57What is it that Jesus Christ did? He
  1297. 1:06:59said," Look, there is a punishment to
  1298. 1:07:01serve for the disobedience of the first
  1299. 1:07:05man. "Okay. Um, just—just—just this
  1300. 1:07:10alone. There is a punishment to serve
  1301. 1:07:13for the disobedience of the first man.
  1302. 1:07:16But the sadism of God, of the God of
  1303. 1:07:19these people here, but God, Holy Mother
  1304. 1:07:21, Christ, just take it easy. And death
  1305. 1:07:31entered into man and because all men
  1306. 1:07:34have sinned. Okay. And so
  1307. 1:07:37no, this is what the Old Testament God
  1308. 1:07:40would say. Re
  1309. 1:07:42so basically you can no longer reunite
  1310. 1:07:44with God because the relationship was
  1311. 1:07:46broken by original sin. I will come, I
  1312. 1:07:49will suffer. Okay? So that you can, if
  1313. 1:07:53you are baptized in me, reunite with me
  1314. 1:07:55in heaven when you die. Before, you
  1315. 1:07:58couldn't. Think about the kind of
  1316. 1:08:01[ __ ] system of rules, absolutely
  1317. 1:08:04perverse and sadistic, that the God of
  1318. 1:08:06these people would have given to
  1319. 1:08:08humanity. And they are, apart from the
  1320. 1:08:11fact that they are clearly things
  1321. 1:08:13conceived in another era at every level
  1322. 1:08:15, it's evident, but then—really—but
  1323. 1:08:25then, and I tell you Giulio, the
  1324. 1:08:27challenge is always the soul, it's
  1325. 1:08:28never God. I—this thing is too it's
  1326. 1:08:33too little. God, God is too little. The
  1327. 1:08:37soul is the point, because the soul is
  1328. 1:08:39what you are or believe you are, you
  1329. 1:08:41know, God is the heptadimensional being
  1330. 1:08:48before the big bang. Whatever, who
  1331. 1:08:52cares. And the soul, the claim of
  1332. 1:08:56immortality, obviously the rejection of
  1333. 1:08:59mortality, the rejection when you see,
  1334. 1:09:02when you're on the road in the car,
  1335. 1:09:04right? And sometimes it happens to you,
  1336. 1:09:08because unfortunately it happens, to
  1337. 1:09:09see the animal squashed, you know what
  1338. 1:09:10I mean? No. It could be a hedgehog, a
  1339. 1:09:15cat, something else. And you see the
  1340. 1:09:17animal squashed on the road to the moon
  1341. 1:09:24. And you know that it's you, eh. Eh,
  1342. 1:09:35and then perhaps in everyone's life you
  1343. 1:09:37may have seen a person you loved, maybe
  1344. 1:09:39not splattered, partly. Think of wars,
  1345. 1:09:41let's not even go there. But anyway,
  1346. 1:09:45you've lived the experience of losing a
  1347. 1:09:47loved one, of having seen someone you
  1348. 1:09:50knew dead, of simply having seen a dead
  1349. 1:09:53person. I believe it, Giulio, I believe
  1350. 1:10:04it. Oh my. Certainly, Julius Caesar.
  1351. 1:10:08Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. And do you see
  1352. 1:10:12this this image? L-let's stop at the
  1353. 1:10:15splattered animal. And for heaven's
  1354. 1:10:21sake you know that you are more complex
  1355. 1:10:24than the animal, but regardless you
  1356. 1:10:26breathe, you're born, you die, you age
  1357. 1:10:28like it and muscles and infinitely more
  1358. 1:10:31than it, but you think like it and and
  1359. 1:10:38you know that if a semi runs you over
  1360. 1:10:40you get splattered just the same, get
  1361. 1:10:44it? Let's go right to the to the core,
  1362. 1:10:47right? I mean, I'm sitting here now,
  1363. 1:10:51you're sitting there, you're calm, I
  1364. 1:10:53hope in your air-conditioned homes,
  1365. 1:10:56etc. But guys, if a wrecking ball like
  1366. 1:10:58Miley Cyrus's arrives and hits me or
  1367. 1:11:00you, guys, they'll have to pick us up
  1368. 1:11:03with a spoon our pieces, right? The
  1369. 1:11:09integrity of our body fails, we are
  1370. 1:11:11reduced to pieces and they are mostly
  1371. 1:11:14red or there are bones, there's blood
  1372. 1:11:16and there's even worse, right? And we
  1373. 1:11:21at this moment are this thing here, we
  1374. 1:11:23don't smell our insides, which is
  1375. 1:11:25something that would make us sick,
  1376. 1:11:27thanks to our skin. We don't we don't
  1377. 1:11:35see our brain while it's working. But
  1378. 1:11:40if we slammed our head really really
  1379. 1:11:43hard on a corner, what remains? Where
  1380. 1:11:48have you gone when you become a
  1381. 1:11:50vegetable? And yet you are there. But
  1382. 1:11:52where are you? Where is the soul? And
  1383. 1:11:59you know that you are that thing there
  1384. 1:12:01and you deal with it and you have to
  1385. 1:12:03deal with it every day because life is
  1386. 1:12:08full of reminders. Reminders can range
  1387. 1:12:11from a splattered animal to a cough. At
  1388. 1:12:18this point you can you can believe for
  1389. 1:12:20fun. I think about it every now and
  1390. 1:12:21then. I want to make a confession to
  1391. 1:12:22you. This video by Big Luca triggered
  1392. 1:12:24me big time. Eh, I want to make a
  1393. 1:12:26confession, but maybe I've already
  1394. 1:12:28talked to you about it in the past, but
  1395. 1:12:29know that I still think about these
  1396. 1:12:30things. Um, at a certain point one
  1397. 1:12:34could for fun stop being rational.
  1398. 1:12:38We've all been children, right? We all
  1399. 1:12:40remember the beautiful beautiful
  1400. 1:12:42because you're a child, the
  1401. 1:12:43irrationality of childhood when you
  1402. 1:12:45enjoy inventing the most outlandish
  1403. 1:12:47stories, finding the most incredible
  1404. 1:12:49coincidences. As a child you too are
  1405. 1:12:52the conspiracy theorist of Foucault's
  1406. 1:12:54Pendulum who lives in the forest of
  1407. 1:12:55symbols where everything calls to
  1408. 1:12:57everything else and you enjoy it, right
  1409. 1:12:59? Maybe the home garden, or the park,
  1410. 1:13:02or that spot by the sea, or that wall
  1411. 1:13:04—those things—and with friends, you
  1412. 1:13:06invent stories and live in a world that
  1413. 1:13:08, all things considered, isn't so
  1414. 1:13:09different from Foucault's Pendulum,
  1415. 1:13:11from that of Foucault's Pendulum. All
  1416. 1:13:13right, one could, one could even decide
  1417. 1:13:18. I think about it now and then, I
  1418. 1:13:20don't know if I ever will. You could
  1419. 1:13:22also decide at some point in adulthood
  1420. 1:13:25to say:" Okay, I've lived for so many
  1421. 1:13:29years like this, and in the end, no, I
  1422. 1:13:36have been, I have tried to be, if not
  1423. 1:13:38rational, reasonable. You know what?
  1424. 1:13:43Starting tomorrow, I'll slack off.
  1425. 1:13:47Slack off. I'll start, I'll start
  1426. 1:13:48looking at the world again as if it
  1427. 1:13:50were a magical adventure entirely
  1428. 1:13:51designed around me. Big deal. But
  1429. 1:13:56that’s where, that’s where the
  1430. 1:13:58other person comes into play, enters
  1431. 1:14:00the scene, as they would say. You’re
  1432. 1:14:05not a solipsist; you’re not alone.
  1433. 1:14:10That’s why I like the Japanese, those
  1434. 1:14:13little Japanese eyes, right? One might
  1435. 1:14:16say, "You know, all this worrying about
  1436. 1:14:18what others will say, how others will
  1437. 1:14:19look at you, etc., it's disgusting,
  1438. 1:14:21right? You have to free yourself from
  1439. 1:14:23the judgment of others." In a certain
  1440. 1:14:25sense, okay, fine, there are the others
  1441. 1:14:32. Why don't you make a scene at the
  1442. 1:14:37museum or in the library? Because there
  1443. 1:14:41are the others. Why don't you go crazy?
  1444. 1:14:45So, the point I was making earlier:
  1445. 1:14:47because there are the others. Behavior,
  1446. 1:14:57knowing how to behave, as the ultimate
  1447. 1:15:05goal of being human. Self-mastery,
  1448. 1:15:11which is the deepest form of humility
  1449. 1:15:14that exists and therefore the most
  1450. 1:15:16sincere form of recognition: not just
  1451. 1:15:18that you are equal to everyone else,
  1452. 1:15:20that you aren't a damn thing compared
  1453. 1:15:22to others, but that your signs are
  1454. 1:15:24borrowed, that all life's problems are
  1455. 1:15:26interpersonal problems, and so on,
  1456. 1:15:28quoting various pragmatists, and there
  1457. 1:15:33is no escape. The adult who were to
  1458. 1:15:36then make the decision to return to
  1459. 1:15:38being a child in that sense would be
  1460. 1:15:42the spoiled one who rejects how things
  1461. 1:15:50are and you shouldn't do it for the
  1462. 1:15:58most Confucian of reasons. If you like.
  1463. 1:16:02You're being a nuisance. And it's the
  1464. 1:16:05reason Marcus Aurelius stated when,
  1465. 1:16:06well, he says, no, people are always
  1466. 1:16:08deciding how and when one should die,
  1467. 1:16:09and Marcus Aurelius said at a certain
  1468. 1:16:10point you have to die because others
  1469. 1:16:12want you to die. I put it a bit simply,
  1470. 1:16:14but he says it almost exactly like that
  1471. 1:16:16. The others, the others are something
  1472. 1:16:26we would very much like to [escape],
  1473. 1:16:28because naturally, the thought of the
  1474. 1:16:29anchorite, right, of the hermit who
  1475. 1:16:31retreats. But the world comes with you,
  1476. 1:16:37there is no escape. The world will
  1477. 1:16:40always come with you. Even if you go to
  1478. 1:16:43stroke the grass in a place where there
  1479. 1:16:45is no one, the world has come with you
  1480. 1:16:51because you are made of the world, you
  1481. 1:16:53are made of others, you cannot escape
  1482. 1:16:54it. Then you understand the greatness
  1483. 1:17:01of Eastern thought, both Confucian and
  1484. 1:17:03Buddhist/Zen, obviously removing any
  1485. 1:17:05metaphysics, otherwise we wouldn't be
  1486. 1:17:06here having this discussion, but you
  1487. 1:17:08understand that's why it doesn't matter
  1488. 1:17:19how Cavafy died, because any society
  1489. 1:17:22that has a modicum of humanity allows
  1490. 1:17:25the dying to die as they wish. Heaven
  1491. 1:17:29forbid, we wouldn't judge a person by
  1492. 1:17:31how they behaved when they could no
  1493. 1:17:33longer control themselves. What remains
  1494. 1:17:36of Cavafy is how he behaved, beyond
  1495. 1:17:39obviously the works he left behind, the
  1496. 1:17:43behavior. Sure, obviously if I say
  1497. 1:17:50behavior, Gaber's song comes to mind,
  1498. 1:17:52but here we are having a different
  1499. 1:17:53discussion. I think it is also the
  1500. 1:18:05reason, here I can only speak by
  1501. 1:18:06hearsay, evidently, given that there is
  1502. 1:18:08Big Luca with his chest in the wind. I
  1503. 1:18:10think it is also the reason why a
  1504. 1:18:12person who works out a lot is very
  1505. 1:18:13proud to show themselves off. I don't
  1506. 1:18:16think it's so much for hooking up,
  1507. 1:18:17because I can assure you all, you know
  1508. 1:18:19that you can hook up even without the
  1509. 1:18:21gym, but I believe that deep down it is
  1510. 1:18:23a pride in showing that you have
  1511. 1:18:24exercised great self-control. In this I
  1512. 1:18:26respect him. Now, beyond the fact that
  1513. 1:18:29someone might show off, okay, in
  1514. 1:18:31ridiculous ways, let's pretend, I can
  1515. 1:18:33understand the pride for the big muscle
  1516. 1:18:36, because it means there is a lot of
  1517. 1:18:38work and a lot of self-control, a lot
  1518. 1:18:40of discipline, some kind of now who
  1519. 1:18:44cares about that, eh. I mean, in the
  1520. 1:18:46sense it has no value in itself, it can
  1521. 1:18:47have it for the individual, but who
  1522. 1:18:48cares. but some kind of inner
  1523. 1:18:51discipline to accept what you are. Sun
  1524. 1:19:04and Steel. Certainly yes. Vacuum
  1525. 1:19:06cleaners. Certainly yes. I think that's
  1526. 1:19:08in the shop too. Let's move on. All
  1527. 1:19:23people before Jesus Christ were in hell
  1528. 1:19:26. They were in the part for those who
  1529. 1:19:27had not, let's say, committed serious
  1530. 1:19:29things. In the hell of the righteous,
  1531. 1:19:32in Sheol, the hell of the damned and
  1532. 1:19:36Gehenna or gehenna, pronounce it as you
  1533. 1:19:38like, depends on the language. Um, when
  1534. 1:19:41Jesus Christ, for example, died, we
  1535. 1:19:44Catholics say he descended into hell,
  1536. 1:19:47okay? Descendit ad Inferos, tertia die
  1537. 1:19:50resurrexit a mortuis. These things must
  1538. 1:19:52be known, he descends into hell with
  1539. 1:19:54his grace thanks to the
  1540. 1:19:55these things must be known because they
  1541. 1:19:59are the truth and ask no more of this,
  1542. 1:20:03no. But there is little this is I must
  1543. 1:20:05say, I actually break a lance for Big
  1544. 1:20:08Luca. This is a believer. Sure, it’s
  1545. 1:20:12really annoying unionism because it’s
  1546. 1:20:15a refuge. It’s a refuge from the
  1547. 1:20:17crushed animal, but certainly yes.
  1548. 1:20:21Intellectually dishonest, as all
  1549. 1:20:23religions and dogmas are intrinsically
  1550. 1:20:25dishonest. But at least, hey, at least
  1551. 1:20:28this much it can tell you. I, however,
  1552. 1:20:30I, however, am being serious. If there
  1553. 1:20:32is Christ God, God is my Christ, I am
  1554. 1:20:33being serious. Then, for heaven’s
  1555. 1:20:36sake, like how to get rich in six steps
  1556. 1:20:39.
  1557. 1:20:41The people who were waiting for him, he
  1558. 1:20:42brings them up during those three days
  1559. 1:20:44Jesus was dead. Okay. Okay.
  1560. 1:20:47And he visited the limbo of the just.
  1561. 1:20:50He didn’t go to the hell of the
  1562. 1:20:51damned because God is not present in
  1563. 1:20:53the hell of the damned. But his
  1564. 1:20:56presence reverberated even there to
  1565. 1:20:59shame the people, to punish them even
  1566. 1:21:01more with something they can no longer
  1567. 1:21:04obtain. But the wickedness of this
  1568. 1:21:11whole system, all those in hell because
  1569. 1:21:13they were born earlier and are further
  1570. 1:21:15humiliated, is a wonderful thing, no,
  1571. 1:21:17it’s a stupendous thing. He did
  1572. 1:21:20damnation shaming.
  1573. 1:21:25I refer to the Summa Theologica for
  1574. 1:21:27these things, by Saint Thomas Aquinas.
  1575. 1:21:29And so in reality, oh guys, I haven't
  1576. 1:21:31read it. He has, he’s more "Ecchian"
  1577. 1:21:34than me because Eco read the Summa
  1578. 1:21:35Theologica too, so it’s the text Eco
  1579. 1:21:37was formed on. So what are you going to
  1580. 1:21:39say to him?
  1581. 1:21:40And so the resurrection of Jesus
  1582. 1:21:42assuming, of course, that good old Big
  1583. 1:21:44Lucas has actually read the whole thing
  1584. 1:21:45. Let’s say for those who don’t
  1585. 1:21:48believe, look, in the devil, even the
  1586. 1:21:50priests are...guys, you can't be PR, I
  1587. 1:21:51mean, it’s unclear why Jesus Christ
  1588. 1:21:53arrived with his resurrection. He saves
  1589. 1:21:55us from what? He saves us from the
  1590. 1:21:58eternal damnation in which we were
  1591. 1:22:00before and were without God. Because
  1592. 1:22:03it’s really the same discussion as
  1593. 1:22:05The Silmarillion. I remember once a
  1594. 1:22:08friend of mine read me the first good
  1595. 1:22:11chunk of pages of The Silmarillion and
  1596. 1:22:14it’s super fascinating, right? It’s
  1597. 1:22:18wildly cool, like boom. And it’s the
  1598. 1:22:21same thing, I mean think about
  1599. 1:22:22believing it, believing it, I mean that
  1600. 1:22:27is true and it’s dogma and that’s
  1601. 1:22:29how it is, so that’s how you get it.
  1602. 1:22:33This is the...this is the Silmarillion,
  1603. 1:22:35which is wonderful, huh? The
  1604. 1:22:36Silmarillion probably makes more sense,
  1605. 1:22:37and is probably even more literary,
  1606. 1:22:39more beautiful. Beyond that, it’s
  1607. 1:22:42wonderful, right? Does no fantasy
  1608. 1:22:47universe hold up to comparison with the
  1609. 1:22:49sacred books of the Abrahamic religions
  1610. 1:22:50? I tend to think so too, but I don’t
  1611. 1:22:54know, if you go further back, into the
  1612. 1:22:56India of the Vedas, perhaps you go even
  1613. 1:22:59further. Who knows. that the connection
  1614. 1:23:06had been interrupted. So, if there is
  1615. 1:23:07no Satan who tempted the first man
  1616. 1:23:10But that is not, this, Gorgia, this is
  1617. 1:23:12a question for another live stream. But
  1618. 1:23:15isn't the world more interesting than
  1619. 1:23:17all these nice castles in the air? But
  1620. 1:23:23the world is interesting. But the, the
  1621. 1:23:26problem is, the problem with the world
  1622. 1:23:29has never been that it wasn't
  1623. 1:23:31interesting. But I agree with you. The
  1624. 1:23:36world is full of interesting things.
  1625. 1:23:37The problem with the world isn't that
  1626. 1:23:40it's boring or not interesting, nor
  1627. 1:23:42that it's difficult. The problem with
  1628. 1:23:45the world is that there is suffering in
  1629. 1:23:46the world. The world is painful, it is
  1630. 1:23:54pain. The world will hold pain for us.
  1631. 1:24:01You are born, you are taught to attach
  1632. 1:24:03yourself to everything, and you spend
  1633. 1:24:04your life realizing you have to detach
  1634. 1:24:06from everything, and like it or not,
  1635. 1:24:08you detach from one thing at a time. It
  1636. 1:24:10is very painful. It is one pain after
  1637. 1:24:13another. Then, for heaven's sake, there
  1638. 1:24:17is no shortage of curiosities, but it
  1639. 1:24:19is complicated. I understand it, I
  1640. 1:24:21understand those who flee. We all flee,
  1641. 1:24:23eh, in some way, let's be clear,
  1642. 1:24:25meaning we all try to minimize pain and
  1643. 1:24:27, if possible, well, enjoy a bit of
  1644. 1:24:28pleasure too, but I think that is the
  1645. 1:24:30point. Eh, here these are, these are
  1646. 1:24:33significant escapes, these are
  1647. 1:24:35structured escapes.
  1648. 1:24:39Ok? And who
  1649. 1:24:40in the world there are limits. The
  1650. 1:24:42limit of limits is death, but that in
  1651. 1:24:44reality is just a name for the fact
  1652. 1:24:46that the world is made of eh of matter
  1653. 1:24:50and and nothing else
  1654. 1:24:53he forces, he tempts us, he doesn't
  1655. 1:24:54force us, never, he forces, he proposes
  1656. 1:24:56, but he does not impose, he tempts us
  1657. 1:24:59to commit sins so that we end up in
  1658. 1:25:03hell sooner. But I wonder, with all
  1659. 1:25:07these discussions about hell etcetera
  1660. 1:25:08etcetera, but Big Luca, is he not going
  1661. 1:25:10to hell? He doesn't commit sins, but
  1662. 1:25:13then in reality it's very easy to
  1663. 1:25:15cleanse yourself of sins, I believe.
  1664. 1:25:17Like you confess and you are, you are
  1665. 1:25:18clean.
  1666. 1:25:20One could even say there wasn't even a
  1667. 1:25:21need for temptation because, Satan or
  1668. 1:25:23no Satan tempting you, with the fact
  1669. 1:25:24that you no longer had a relationship
  1670. 1:25:26with God, you ended up at least in the
  1671. 1:25:27hell of the righteous, but not with God
  1672. 1:25:29. So if there is no Satan, the whole
  1673. 1:25:32system comes crashing down. One cannot
  1674. 1:25:34be a Christian without believing that
  1675. 1:25:36Satan is a real, intelligent being, he
  1676. 1:25:39has an angelic intelligence. Like all
  1677. 1:25:42angels, they have infused knowledge, so
  1678. 1:25:43they do not learn through observation.
  1679. 1:25:45Thanks Pedro. Pegro.
  1680. 1:25:47And that Jesus Christ saved us from the
  1681. 1:25:49infinite yoke of the devil. When we are
  1682. 1:25:52on this earth, which is the test, we
  1683. 1:25:54can resist temptations.
  1684. 1:25:57Look, excuse me Big Luca, I don't want
  1685. 1:26:00to be argumentative, but if this earth
  1686. 1:26:03is a test from 5,000 to 45,000 euros a
  1687. 1:26:09month. Giacomo's testimony is clear. Is
  1688. 1:26:13this how, Big Luca, one passes God's
  1689. 1:26:17test? Is it? Is this how you pass it?
  1690. 1:26:23By the way, he was skinny until two
  1691. 1:26:25weeks ago. But it's the same person. My
  1692. 1:26:29God. Oh well, anyway, sometimes we'll
  1693. 1:26:34fall, it's expected, etcetera, but
  1694. 1:26:36there's confession. We can choose to
  1695. 1:26:38walk the straight and narrow like this
  1696. 1:26:39there's confession, so it's easy that
  1697. 1:26:43then
  1698. 1:26:43we are deserving. God will choose
  1699. 1:26:46justice because He is justice itself,
  1700. 1:26:48and we will go with Him to heaven.
  1701. 1:26:50Before we couldn't do it.
  1702. 1:26:53Okay. Uh, I have two more questions.
  1703. 1:26:57Go ahead.
  1704. 1:26:57Well, if they're too stupid, we'll cut
  1705. 1:26:59this.
  1706. 1:26:59Go, go, go, go, go.
  1707. 1:27:00So, one is what would you say to a
  1708. 1:27:02person who doesn't believe in God, okay
  1709. 1:27:05? Doesn't believe in God,
  1710. 1:27:06yes.
  1711. 1:27:08And you somehow help them
  1712. 1:27:11to to find this path? What would you
  1713. 1:27:13say to them to? Well, first of all, I
  1714. 1:27:15would say to forget about religion for
  1715. 1:27:17a moment and address the logical
  1716. 1:27:18arguments for the existence or
  1717. 1:27:20non-existence of God. The good news is
  1718. 1:27:24that I have never heard a logical,
  1719. 1:27:25rational argument for the non-existence
  1720. 1:27:28of God. I mean, if you
  1721. 1:27:30we're always at the same point,
  1722. 1:27:32obviously an atheist, why atheist? He
  1723. 1:27:34can't tell you. No,
  1724. 1:27:36it's not the same. By the way, here he
  1725. 1:27:38said two different things. It's one
  1726. 1:27:39thing that you can't prove the
  1727. 1:27:41non-existence of God. It's another
  1728. 1:27:43thing that an atheist can't tell you
  1729. 1:27:45why he's an atheist; they are two
  1730. 1:27:46completely different levels. Imagine if
  1731. 1:27:48an atheist can't tell you why he's an
  1732. 1:27:50atheist. Any atheist, if you ask him
  1733. 1:27:52why he's an atheist, has an answer from
  1734. 1:27:56from a dogmatic position. What do you
  1735. 1:28:00expect? Eh, never in the But for
  1736. 1:28:03example, well in Italy we also have
  1737. 1:28:04caricatures, for example Professor
  1738. 1:28:06Odifreddi, right? Ladies, gentlemen and
  1739. 1:28:14ladies
  1740. 1:28:15in Italy, if he has ever explained why
  1741. 1:28:17he has, I mean every time they've had
  1742. 1:28:18the honor of asking him, I said "Okay,
  1743. 1:28:20why are you an atheist?" and no, but he
  1744. 1:28:23should explain to me
  1745. 1:28:24But I want, I want the timestamps, the
  1746. 1:28:27timestamps of when Odifreddi stumbles
  1747. 1:28:29and doesn't know how to answer the
  1748. 1:28:31question: "Why are you an" atheist. It
  1749. 1:28:35seems to me that Odifreddi doesn't lack
  1750. 1:28:37, doesn't lack the gift of gab,
  1751. 1:28:39especially when talking about these
  1752. 1:28:41topics, and this fantastic story of an
  1753. 1:28:43Odifreddi who doesn't know what to say
  1754. 1:28:45when they ask him "Why are you an"
  1755. 1:28:47atheist, which is the most trivial of
  1756. 1:28:48questions, is quite imaginative. Yes,
  1757. 1:28:52he’s written books, but why do you
  1758. 1:28:57but it’s interesting that the enemy
  1759. 1:28:58is still "audieddi" for these people.
  1760. 1:29:00You believe because if one has a beard
  1761. 1:29:03and one doesn't, then I ask you why you
  1762. 1:29:05...Oh, wonderful, so why doesn't God
  1763. 1:29:07exist? atheism, as opposed to theism. I
  1764. 1:29:10am a theist. There are those who call
  1765. 1:29:12themselves atheist or atheistic, okay?
  1766. 1:29:15In English, atheist, okay? Um, I claim
  1767. 1:29:18that God exists, so I have the burden
  1768. 1:29:20of proof when I say that God exists,
  1769. 1:29:23right? So, for example, I can make an
  1770. 1:29:25argument like everything that begins to
  1771. 1:29:27exist has a cause, the universe began
  1772. 1:29:29to exist, therefore the universe has a
  1773. 1:29:31cause.
  1774. 1:29:32But it’s not written—first of all,
  1775. 1:29:34it’s not a given that everything must
  1776. 1:29:35have a cause. Secondly, but these
  1777. 1:29:39things are old, they’ve been—what
  1778. 1:29:41did poor David Hume even live for?
  1779. 1:29:44Secondly, it’s not written anywhere
  1780. 1:29:46that the cause is God. How imaginative
  1781. 1:29:53they are. But then again, they have had
  1782. 1:29:55plenty of imagination. Now we know that
  1783. 1:29:58time, matter, and energy had a
  1784. 1:30:00beginning, so the efficient cause of
  1785. 1:30:03the beginning of time is
  1786. 1:30:06we don't know. Also, they are rather
  1787. 1:30:09hasty regarding physics; we don’t
  1788. 1:30:12exactly know how the universe works
  1789. 1:30:14from that point of view, from that
  1790. 1:30:17point of view. There are many theories,
  1791. 1:30:21there’s the Big Bang, but it’s not
  1792. 1:30:23the only one, and they always make it
  1793. 1:30:24simple, they always make it "it’s
  1794. 1:30:26like this," and so in reality, we
  1795. 1:30:28aren't that far along, eh. It was
  1796. 1:30:34outside of time because time didn't
  1797. 1:30:36exist, it was immaterial, it was
  1798. 1:30:38enormously powerful, and since there
  1799. 1:30:41was absolutely nothing, it must be
  1800. 1:30:43personal,
  1801. 1:30:44right? Certainly, but we know nothing
  1802. 1:30:46about what was there before the Big
  1803. 1:30:47Bang, and there are so many theories.
  1804. 1:30:51In your book, you explain that you have
  1805. 1:30:52faith, even if it is a different kind
  1806. 1:30:54of faith than the classical one. In
  1807. 1:30:57your opinion, can believing in science
  1808. 1:30:59really be a valid alternative to
  1809. 1:31:01believing in God? Eh, in my opinion, it
  1810. 1:31:04can become a valid alternative, but I
  1811. 1:31:06don't think it's that natural. Science
  1812. 1:31:09is an endeavor that requires much more
  1813. 1:31:11attention, much more effort than
  1814. 1:31:13religious faith, because everything
  1815. 1:31:15that is "believed," in quotes, in
  1816. 1:31:17science is believed precisely because
  1817. 1:31:20it has passed through the scrutiny of
  1818. 1:31:22experimentation, of proof, of being
  1819. 1:31:24framed within theory, right? And this
  1820. 1:31:29obviously requires, first of all,
  1821. 1:31:31scientific literacy in the good sense
  1822. 1:31:34of the word, and then, anyway, daily
  1823. 1:31:36grinding, whereas faith, from a certain
  1824. 1:31:39point of view, is more self-rewarding,
  1825. 1:31:41right? It is easier to believe. You
  1826. 1:31:45understand perfectly well that this is
  1827. 1:31:47the answer to why you don't believe and
  1828. 1:31:49why you are an atheist, but apparently
  1829. 1:31:51for Big Luca this is not an answer
  1830. 1:31:52because only a mind without a body has
  1831. 1:31:54—the body could not exist because the
  1832. 1:31:56body is made of matter, and matter
  1833. 1:31:57began to exist.
  1834. 1:31:59So we have just postulated that a mind
  1835. 1:32:01without a body exists. But do you
  1836. 1:32:05realize the, how can I put it, the
  1837. 1:32:08intellectual courage required to
  1838. 1:32:10support these theses?
  1839. 1:32:13Nothing, eh. It must be personal
  1840. 1:32:16because only a mind without a body has
  1841. 1:32:18—the body doesn't exist, right? So,
  1842. 1:32:21for example, I can make an argument
  1843. 1:32:23like everything that begins to exist
  1844. 1:32:25has a cause, the universe began to
  1845. 1:32:26exist, therefore the universe has a
  1846. 1:32:28cause. Now we know that time...
  1847. 1:32:32It didn't take much for him to believe.
  1848. 1:32:34Anyway, eh, I almost get the feeling
  1849. 1:32:35that he believed independently of this
  1850. 1:32:37very weak argument. Energy had a
  1851. 1:32:40beginning, so the efficient cause of
  1852. 1:32:42the beginning of time was outside of
  1853. 1:32:45time because time wasn't there, it was
  1854. 1:32:47immaterial, it was enormously powerful
  1855. 1:32:49and, since there was absolutely nothing
  1856. 1:32:52, eh, it must be personal, because only
  1857. 1:32:54a mind without a body—the body could
  1858. 1:32:56not exist, because the body is made of
  1859. 1:32:59matter.
  1860. 1:33:00I would like an example of a mind
  1861. 1:33:02without a body. Clearly, there was
  1862. 1:33:07nothing. We cannot say anything about
  1863. 1:33:08what there was because there was
  1864. 1:33:09nothing yet. So, clearly, there was a
  1865. 1:33:11mind without a body. Ok. Ok. But does
  1866. 1:33:16ChatGPT have a body or what? Take away
  1867. 1:33:18the body from ChatGPT and absolutely
  1868. 1:33:20nothing remains, eh. Above all, it
  1869. 1:33:31doesn't have a mind, but we can even
  1870. 1:33:33give it a mind, that's not the point.
  1871. 1:33:36The point is that, eh, the mind is a
  1872. 1:33:38byproduct of a body, obviously, but it
  1873. 1:33:40would be interesting if he gave
  1874. 1:33:42examples of a mind without a body. If
  1875. 1:33:44you ask him, he will tell you that an
  1876. 1:33:45example of a mind without a body is God
  1877. 1:33:47. And so, what was to be proven is the
  1878. 1:33:49premise, and therefore, like everything
  1879. 1:33:51related to religion, it is a circular
  1880. 1:33:53argument, but you have to believe it.
  1881. 1:33:56Matter began to exist. So which things
  1882. 1:33:59have this property? A number, but
  1883. 1:34:02numbers don't do anything, or an
  1884. 1:34:03unembodied, that is, a great mind. Ok?
  1885. 1:34:06So the mind could decide from nothing,
  1886. 1:34:09ex nihilo, to
  1887. 1:34:10It's not like if you say ex nihilo
  1888. 1:34:12after "from nothing" you've given
  1889. 1:34:13greater strength to the fact that there
  1890. 1:34:15was a mind in the nothingness that was
  1891. 1:34:16deciding, because you were the one who
  1892. 1:34:18decided it. creating is that the
  1893. 1:34:21efficient cause rather than, uh, we see
  1894. 1:34:23effects with causes and so we arrive at
  1895. 1:34:25an uncaused first cause because
  1896. 1:34:27otherwise there is an infinite regress
  1897. 1:34:29backwards that is problematic,
  1898. 1:34:31especially without time. So the concept
  1899. 1:34:34of the first cause, not caused by
  1900. 1:34:36anything, which is then the cause of
  1901. 1:34:37everything else, is a thing
  1902. 1:34:39it's incredible how these things have
  1903. 1:34:41been refuted for centuries. But really,
  1904. 1:34:44believers, the ones who act like how
  1905. 1:34:48can I put it, irrational, are still
  1906. 1:34:51stuck there, they've never moved past
  1907. 1:34:53this [ __ ].
  1908. 1:34:55Which makes a lot of sense if we have
  1909. 1:34:57infinite yesterdays, how did we get to
  1910. 1:34:58today with, certainly there must be a
  1911. 1:34:59creative beginning, I can go on for a
  1912. 1:35:00while. There are the five ways of Saint
  1913. 1:35:03Thomas Aquinas
  1914. 1:35:05which have all obviously been refuted,
  1915. 1:35:07are you kidding me? etc. So I can offer
  1916. 1:35:10arguments and it's also the best
  1917. 1:35:12explanation for life, the best
  1918. 1:35:13explanation for the historical facts
  1919. 1:35:15regarding Jesus of Nazareth. Anyway,
  1920. 1:35:17Jesus really existed.
  1921. 1:35:19Well, on that, there are few doubts,
  1922. 1:35:21really. Now they even grant you that.
  1923. 1:35:23Eh, by the way, you can still find
  1924. 1:35:25videos of Professor Di Freddy who says
  1925. 1:35:26that God, that Jesus didn't exist.
  1926. 1:35:28Let's drop it. Ok, do that.
  1927. 1:35:31Which, by the way, I remind you that we
  1928. 1:35:34are in a country where Big Luca mocks
  1929. 1:35:36Professor Di Freddy like he's an idiot.
  1930. 1:35:38I explaining to us that in the void
  1931. 1:35:43there was a mind without a body that
  1932. 1:35:47thought and gave the initial kick to
  1933. 1:35:50the causal chain. And in Italy, they
  1934. 1:35:54even grant you this. In Italy, we are
  1935. 1:35:57truly as far behind as a dog's balls.
  1936. 1:35:59You are, I don't live in Italy. Um, so
  1937. 1:36:01the historical facts regarding Jesus of
  1938. 1:36:04Nazareth are
  1939. 1:36:05you are the best explanation, God, etc.
  1940. 1:36:07The atheist at this point, even if they
  1941. 1:36:10were to destroy all my arguments that
  1942. 1:36:12I've now presented in such a, well,
  1943. 1:36:14let's call it messy way, I might have
  1944. 1:36:16already planted more than one seed of
  1945. 1:36:18doubt.
  1946. 1:36:19In Dubai, they're all Catholics, in
  1947. 1:36:21Italy we are, guys, in Italy, I mean,
  1948. 1:36:23regarding Catholicism we're doing
  1949. 1:36:25poorly, but in Dubai let's say you
  1950. 1:36:33destroy all these arguments. There are
  1951. 1:36:35others, obviously. For example, the one
  1952. 1:36:38that God is the best explanation for
  1953. 1:36:39the existence of objective moral values
  1954. 1:36:41. Okay?
  1955. 1:36:43Ah, objective moral values,
  1956. 1:36:44etc. The mythical explanation that God
  1957. 1:36:48is the best reason for the existence of
  1958. 1:36:50objective moral values.
  1959. 1:36:54Wow! Mh, we would find ourselves in a
  1960. 1:36:56situation of agnosticism, that is 0-0,
  1961. 1:36:58it is not atheism. For atheism to win,
  1962. 1:37:02the atheist must give
  1963. 1:37:04Here I agree with him; in fact, one
  1964. 1:37:06should always call themselves agnostic
  1965. 1:37:08and not atheist when being serious. Old
  1966. 1:37:10topic. You can find a live stream for
  1967. 1:37:12subscribers with Eugenio where we
  1968. 1:37:14reasoned about this. of the motivations
  1969. 1:37:16for the non-exis
  1970. 1:37:17Eugenio, obviously, being a young man,
  1971. 1:37:18calls himself an atheist, but in
  1972. 1:37:19reality, he’s an agnostic, which is
  1973. 1:37:21how one should define themselves, but
  1974. 1:37:22they don't
  1975. 1:37:23existence of God, they can't manage it,
  1976. 1:37:25also because it's truly very difficult.
  1977. 1:37:28But besides, evolution explains
  1978. 1:37:29morality perfectly well. Morality
  1979. 1:37:30doesn't need to be explained. What is
  1980. 1:37:31morality? What is morality? Morality is
  1981. 1:37:36not something different from a bottle
  1982. 1:37:39that requires explanation. It is simply
  1983. 1:37:42a cultural construct along with many
  1984. 1:37:44others, and no cultural construct
  1985. 1:37:46exists without a physical world
  1986. 1:37:47underneath it. But what the hell—this
  1987. 1:37:51whole thing where you end up getting so
  1988. 1:37:53carried away by terms, by the emphasis
  1989. 1:37:54you give them—how do you justify the
  1990. 1:37:56existence of morality? What the hell do
  1991. 1:37:58I have to justify? What the hell is
  1992. 1:37:59morality? Morality is simply shared
  1993. 1:38:01rules that we give ourselves to get by.
  1994. 1:38:05Oh no, because instead the grand
  1995. 1:38:06principles of the...principles of my
  1996. 1:38:07ass, but what the hell are you talking
  1997. 1:38:09about? Don't let's talk [ __ ]. Oh my
  1998. 1:38:12God, even language, honestly. Where is
  1999. 1:38:15Frege here? Here, Wittgenstein—that
  2000. 1:38:17language, how it messes with us, huh.
  2001. 1:38:20How do you justify the necessary and
  2002. 1:38:22debatable existence of the state of
  2003. 1:38:23Israel if not through Satan? Checkmate.
  2004. 1:38:33I feel sick.
  2005. 1:38:34In this, he has a truly thankless job
  2006. 1:38:37because eliminating the first uncaused
  2007. 1:38:39cause and thus going into an uncreated
  2008. 1:38:42infinite that self-creates...because
  2009. 1:38:44then he falls into these dynamics. Here
  2010. 1:38:47there was a very famous scientist,
  2011. 1:38:49Stephen Hawking, a genius who sure,
  2012. 1:38:56Stephen Hawking, but probably to the
  2013. 1:38:58average follower of a Big Luca video, "
  2014. 1:39:00Oh, what the hell is this Stephen Haw?"
  2015. 1:39:04Asking Stinker
  2016. 1:39:05he wrote the beginning of a book where
  2017. 1:39:07he made three errors in three lines. "
  2018. 1:39:10Eh, because of the force of gravity,
  2019. 1:39:12the universe can and will create itself
  2020. 1:39:14from nothing." Spontaneous creation and
  2021. 1:39:18the effect. So, let's examine these
  2022. 1:39:20sentences here. "Because of the force
  2023. 1:39:23of gravity," the universe—he says the
  2024. 1:39:25force of gravity causes nothing; it’s
  2025. 1:39:27gravity that causes. The force of
  2026. 1:39:30gravity is the way scientists describe
  2027. 1:39:32gravity. But imagine yourself
  2028. 1:39:35explaining this thing to Stephen
  2029. 1:39:38Hawking. Imagine, imagine, imagine,
  2030. 1:39:43imagine having to explain it to Stephen
  2031. 1:39:46Hawking without being able, obviously,
  2032. 1:39:53to understand the various registers
  2033. 1:39:55that Hawking may have used in those
  2034. 1:39:56lines. But it’s truly the
  2035. 1:39:58Dunning-Kruger effect in person; it’s
  2036. 1:39:59, it’s literally him. Eh, in my
  2037. 1:40:04opinion, this video captures an idea, a
  2038. 1:40:08concept, an image, how can I say it? If
  2039. 1:40:15a person wants to believe, they must be
  2040. 1:40:20content with being irrational. If they
  2041. 1:40:28want to have their cake and eat it too,
  2042. 1:40:31they must first of all practice
  2043. 1:40:33limitless presumption. Um, Especially
  2044. 1:40:43when you’re, you know, you know what
  2045. 1:40:44they tell you, "Yeah, but there must be
  2046. 1:40:45something out there, just look at how
  2047. 1:40:46beautiful that sunset is." Especially
  2048. 1:40:49if you are actually defending the
  2049. 1:40:51official position of the Catholic
  2050. 1:40:52Church, you're really jumping on the
  2051. 1:40:57bandwagon with Adinolfi, with Fusaro,
  2052. 1:41:00with these kinds of characters. The
  2053. 1:41:08force of gravity doesn't exist, gravity
  2054. 1:41:10exists. Okay, very good. So, first
  2055. 1:41:12dubious thing.
  2056. 1:41:14First, let's teach Stephen Hawking
  2057. 1:41:15about gravity, because it seems only
  2058. 1:41:17right that Big Luca should be the one
  2059. 1:41:19to teach Stephen Hawking about gravity.
  2060. 1:41:21Big Luca perhaps ignores what Stephen
  2061. 1:41:23Hawking actually dealt with and what he
  2062. 1:41:25wrote about in his life.
  2063. 1:41:28The universe.
  2064. 1:41:29But who, who could have told him this
  2065. 1:41:30thing? Because clearly, he hasn't read
  2066. 1:41:32it. Who could have told him this thing
  2067. 1:41:33about Stephen Hawking? It must be
  2068. 1:41:36something they say in those
  2069. 1:41:38ultra-Catholic circles. The famous
  2070. 1:41:40three, three, three lines of Stephen
  2071. 1:41:42Hawking GPT.
  2072. 1:41:44He makes it up himself. And so, if I
  2073. 1:41:49say that X creates Y, I'm assuming the
  2074. 1:41:51existence of X to explain Y. But if I
  2075. 1:41:52say that X creates X, I'm assuming the
  2076. 1:41:54existence of X to explain X. It's
  2077. 1:41:55completely illogical, I mean.
  2078. 1:41:58Said the guy who lives on circular
  2079. 1:42:00reasoning, that the thing that wasn't
  2080. 1:42:01there self-created while it wasn't
  2081. 1:42:03there—come on, that makes no sense.
  2082. 1:42:05Okay? And this is problematic for
  2083. 1:42:07scientists, for non-scientists, for
  2084. 1:42:08atheists, for non-atheists. It’s true
  2085. 1:42:12, but the fact that—as Odifreddi
  2086. 1:42:14would say, who here has obviously been
  2087. 1:42:16mocked like a complete idiot—the fact
  2088. 1:42:18that there are questions science can't
  2089. 1:42:20answer or doesn't know how to answer
  2090. 1:42:22yet, or that there are obviously
  2091. 1:42:24conceptualizations that might even be
  2092. 1:42:26controversial among scientists, etc.,
  2093. 1:42:28doesn't mean that religion has the
  2094. 1:42:30answers to those questions. As I was
  2095. 1:42:34saying about Odifreddi, at least
  2096. 1:42:36science solves some problems, unlike
  2097. 1:42:38religion, which solves none. At least
  2098. 1:42:42science says something true, unlike
  2099. 1:42:44religion, which says nothing true. The,
  2100. 1:42:50the usual, the, the usual rhetoric that
  2101. 1:42:52science doesn't have all the answers
  2102. 1:42:54does not imply that someone else has
  2103. 1:42:56them just because science doesn't. This
  2104. 1:43:00is the great frustration of everyone,
  2105. 1:43:05of all those whom he is describing very
  2106. 1:43:08well here, who think that, since reason
  2107. 1:43:14, study, research, etc., the scientific
  2108. 1:43:17method, etc., haven't gotten us
  2109. 1:43:19everywhere and haven't explained every
  2110. 1:43:22single thing, then other methods that
  2111. 1:43:25aren't the scientific method must be
  2112. 1:43:28better for understanding reality. No,
  2113. 1:43:34because if a fantasy-based method is
  2114. 1:43:36valid—because this is a fantasy-based
  2115. 1:43:39method—then the Flying Spaghetti
  2116. 1:43:41Monster or whatever the [ __ ] it’s
  2117. 1:43:43called, the Pastafarian one, which in
  2118. 1:43:46fact destroys all religions as a parody
  2119. 1:43:48, is valid too. We can ramble on
  2120. 1:43:52forever. There is no limit, there is no
  2121. 1:43:55boundary. Anything goes. Anything goes.
  2122. 1:44:07You tell me what stops anyone from
  2123. 1:44:09building a house of cards analogous to
  2124. 1:44:12that of any religion. What is the limit
  2125. 1:44:16? There isn't any. It’s fantasy,
  2126. 1:44:19anyway. We can fantasize more, or less.
  2127. 1:44:22We can write the Silmarillion or the
  2128. 1:44:24Vedas, we can do whatever we want with
  2129. 1:44:26fantasy, we can do whatever we want. We
  2130. 1:44:29just have to respect the fact that we
  2131. 1:44:30can't speak of what we don't know. Yum
  2132. 1:44:34docchet. But we can build that dragon
  2133. 1:44:37however we like. How boring. But anyway
  2134. 1:44:45, it was, it was incredible, it was, it
  2135. 1:44:48was surprising for me. It was
  2136. 1:44:50surprising. It is surprising, but then
  2137. 1:44:53again, it’s surprising. Um. It would
  2138. 1:45:01be, it would be, I have to be honest,
  2139. 1:45:03it would be a surprising profile that
  2140. 1:45:06would emerge if I knew him, because
  2141. 1:45:08I’m telling you the truth, I know
  2142. 1:45:10nothing about Big Luca. I’ve
  2143. 1:45:14obviously seen some promotions before
  2144. 1:45:17his videos and the fame he has—and
  2145. 1:45:19these are not my words, but others ', a
  2146. 1:45:22"fu-guru." But I don't know a damn
  2147. 1:45:25thing about him. I don't know a damn
  2148. 1:45:28thing, and I don't have the heart to
  2149. 1:45:30click these thumbnails, and I never
  2150. 1:45:32will unless it promises me God, and so
  2151. 1:45:35in reality, I will never manage to get
  2152. 1:45:37that human perspective which, in my
  2153. 1:45:39opinion, is the true content of all
  2154. 1:45:42this. It’s messy, then he invents it
  2155. 1:45:54out of thin air. Eh, but if there was
  2156. 1:45:58gravity, there was something. Gravity
  2157. 1:46:01is not nothing.
  2158. 1:46:03I mean, if Stephen Hawking wrote those
  2159. 1:46:06three lines at the beginning of one of
  2160. 1:46:08his books, they must have been
  2161. 1:46:10metaphorical, but surely he explained
  2162. 1:46:12what the [ __ ] he meant, or did he just
  2163. 1:46:14leave them there like Nostradamus?
  2164. 1:46:20Every time one tries, let's say, to
  2165. 1:46:22eliminate the first cause or the
  2166. 1:46:24creator, one enters into very, very
  2167. 1:46:26complex arguments.
  2168. 1:46:28But the first cause and the creator
  2169. 1:46:30aren't the same thing; they are only
  2170. 1:46:31because you want them to be. Why can't
  2171. 1:46:41the first cause be the God of, what's
  2172. 1:46:43it called? Come on. Family Guy, the God
  2173. 1:46:50from Family Guy who lights his own
  2174. 1:46:53farts. Why not? Why not?
  2175. 1:47:00The same thing, in my opinion, for the
  2176. 1:47:02origin of life, eh. Or for evolutionary
  2177. 1:47:07arguments, which can be as valid as you
  2178. 1:47:09want, but the problem is the beginning,
  2179. 1:47:12isn't it? The life of
  2180. 1:47:15Stephen Hawking is smarter than Big
  2181. 1:47:16Luca even now that he is dead. You are
  2182. 1:47:20very handsome. Even Thomas Aquinas
  2183. 1:47:23explaining Stephen Hawking's physics is
  2184. 1:47:24very beautiful.
  2185. 1:47:26It comes from non-life. Perfect. What
  2186. 1:47:28is a non-life? It is, it is really
  2187. 1:47:31tough to explain. Then
  2188. 1:47:32it's tough to explain. You have to call
  2189. 1:47:34Giacomo for this. We know it's a very
  2190. 1:47:35interesting question, but it is tough
  2191. 1:47:37to explain though. It's, it's tough to
  2192. 1:47:39explain. But look, I can, I can speak
  2193. 1:47:41up, I'll speak up for Big Luca. It is
  2194. 1:47:44tough to explain, but from, it is tough
  2195. 1:47:46to explain to God, to the God of the
  2196. 1:47:48Catholic Church, there is a leap and
  2197. 1:47:50you have to explain to me how and why,
  2198. 1:47:52especially why you have to make that
  2199. 1:47:54specific leap and not another.
  2200. 1:47:55Let's examine it, right? Nature is all
  2201. 1:47:57made by God, so we don't have any kind
  2202. 1:47:59of problem, in fact, science was born
  2203. 1:48:01precisely in Judeo-Christian
  2204. 1:48:03environments, precisely because by
  2205. 1:48:05believing in a creator who gave an
  2206. 1:48:07order to the universe, one wants to
  2207. 1:48:09examine it. Let's examine it, etc.
  2208. 1:48:11Clearly, by examining it at a
  2209. 1:48:12scientific level, we cannot reach the
  2210. 1:48:14creator. We can see evidence of a
  2211. 1:48:16creator, but not the creator, just like
  2212. 1:48:19an engineer who examines.
  2213. 1:48:21Yet your religion got very close to the
  2214. 1:48:23creator because it gives us a lot of
  2215. 1:48:26stuff, including precepts and whatnot.
  2216. 1:48:29Uh, anyway, this is a research fact. Uh
  2217. 1:48:35,
  2218. 1:48:35a computer cannot see the engineer, the
  2219. 1:48:37creator who made the computer, it can
  2220. 1:48:38understand that there is a creator
  2221. 1:48:39behind it. But where is the creator?
  2222. 1:48:41But as long as you analyze the computer
  2223. 1:48:42, the creator isn't there. Ok. The same
  2224. 1:48:45thing is, for example, with scientific
  2225. 1:48:47natural investigation.
  2226. 1:48:48Uh, but G, you've run out of questions.
  2227. 1:48:50In my opinion, you're asking other
  2228. 1:48:51stupid questions, but we can do
  2229. 1:48:53something else, also because people
  2230. 1:48:54miss theology in a Ferrari. Now let's
  2231. 1:48:55do theology on the beach.
  2232. 1:48:56On the beach? Yes, come on, maybe let
  2233. 1:48:59us know if you like this format. The
  2234. 1:49:02Oh God, no, no, no, damn, I gave him
  2235. 1:49:04views. Now I'm getting a feeling for
  2236. 1:49:05others. The shorts, you told me. You
  2237. 1:49:08need to view the shorts.
  2238. 1:49:09Another place is Switzerland. Banal,
  2239. 1:49:11but Switzerland and taxes, you are
  2240. 1:49:13doing the oldest profession in the
  2241. 1:49:14world. In short, there are complex
  2242. 1:49:16situations. Find at least a way, a way
  2243. 1:49:20to be able to cash this, this cash. In
  2244. 1:49:25Switzerland, you can at least cash the
  2245. 1:49:26money, so maybe it's worth paying some
  2246. 1:49:28taxes. Ok? Another place is Switzerland
  2247. 1:49:31, banally.
  2248. 1:49:32But I totally lack the context for this
  2249. 1:49:35. But it's one big piece of content.
  2250. 1:49:41How many Reels did he make on this car
  2251. 1:49:43trip? Structure your money. Don't let
  2252. 1:49:51them structure your money. Why not
  2253. 1:49:53structure yourselves instead?
  2254. 1:49:55They only rented it out once. It’s
  2255. 1:49:58obvious, guys. Well, do it right from
  2256. 1:50:05the start. Actually, some people, guys,
  2257. 1:50:08use their influencer agency for this—
  2258. 1:50:10if we don't forget about the influencer
  2259. 1:50:12and manager agency. Sometimes one came
  2260. 1:50:15out recently in a scandal. Nothing new
  2261. 1:50:16under the sun.
  2262. 1:50:17But Vz, if you make a reel, cut out the
  2263. 1:50:19side chatter. God, what do you need to
  2264. 1:50:21tell me?
  2265. 1:50:21Event planning, actually they were
  2266. 1:50:22doing the escort stuff. Oh, my goodness
  2267. 1:50:24. Okay, perfect. We didn't know that.
  2268. 1:50:26Okay,
  2269. 1:50:27but I want to structure your money and
  2270. 1:50:28not have you get scammed.
  2271. 1:50:29Okay, great. Eh, but structure
  2272. 1:50:31yourselves, right? Open a consulting
  2273. 1:50:33company somewhere, right? Trust
  2274. 1:50:37companies that can help you, like
  2275. 1:50:38Protect Your Wealth, link in
  2276. 1:50:40description, okay? And some people do
  2277. 1:50:43it, yeah, I mean it happens. I want to
  2278. 1:50:45get regularized because one understands
  2279. 1:50:47, I can't live, saying where the hell
  2280. 1:50:48do I put all this cash? Some do it in
  2281. 1:50:50Italy, maybe you only have a house in
  2282. 1:50:52Italy. But guys, this is the premise of
  2283. 1:50:54a person swimming in cash and doesn't
  2284. 1:50:55know what to do with it. The premise is
  2285. 1:50:58Breaking Bad, but what cash? I wanted
  2286. 1:51:02to structure Cleopatra Piumente Catti 4
  2287. 1:51:05. Instagram account banned. Daddy
  2288. 1:51:10doesn't stop. Let's look at these,
  2289. 1:51:11these. Let's see the drama.
  2290. 1:51:13Here we are, gentlemen. Big look.
  2291. 1:51:16There's a lake behind us. We're in the,
  2292. 1:51:19in the smoking area of a restaurant on
  2293. 1:51:20the lake, so you understand the level
  2294. 1:51:22is high.
  2295. 1:51:25I wake up and, rightfully, our
  2296. 1:51:27Instagram profile is still suspended
  2297. 1:51:29and it's embarrassing that we can't
  2298. 1:51:32move, move an inch.
  2299. 1:51:35Do you have a video for the escorts? He
  2300. 1:51:36says get paid in cash, that's where I
  2301. 1:51:38understood. I understood.
  2302. 1:51:42Without someone attacking us digitally
  2303. 1:51:44and getting our Instagram banned. So
  2304. 1:51:47guys, get over it, I mean, I tell you
  2305. 1:51:50from the bottom of my heart, I love you
  2306. 1:51:53, just get over it. This is not how you
  2307. 1:51:55fight Big Luca, okay? Does
  2308. 1:51:57But why do you need to fight Big Luca?
  2309. 1:51:59Who is even fighting Big Luca, guys?
  2310. 1:52:02Everyone is laughing indiscriminately.
  2311. 1:52:04Alright? So clearly our training, our
  2312. 1:52:07AI, our company always cause too much
  2313. 1:52:10trouble.
  2314. 1:52:11Our AI. No, no, I'm closing now, I'm
  2315. 1:52:15closing now. In 8 minutes, go to Wesa
  2316. 1:52:16Channel. I'm away tonight and then the
  2317. 1:52:18weekend starts, I'll throw that at you
  2318. 1:52:20as a greeting and I'm closing in 8
  2319. 1:52:22minutes on Wesa Channel. I need to
  2320. 1:52:24understand who is bothered by this, who
  2321. 1:52:26wants to take down Big Luca, and above
  2322. 1:52:28all, which AI has made such a mess.
  2323. 1:52:33Besides, it competes with
  2324. 1:52:35we have outperformed everyone with our
  2325. 1:52:37artificial intelligence.
  2326. 1:52:38They outperformed everyone. Guys, I'm
  2327. 1:52:40losing the plot here. I didn't realize
  2328. 1:52:41that Big Luca had outperformed everyone
  2329. 1:52:43with his artificial intelligence.
  2330. 1:52:44Sorry, but that’s the reality.
  2331. 1:52:46Cleopatra, crazy feedback, we are very,
  2332. 1:52:49very happy. Big Luca International,
  2333. 1:52:51ladies and gentlemen.
  2334. 1:52:52Cleopatra is an artificial intelligence
  2335. 1:52:55.
  2336. 1:52:56It will continue to serve entrepreneurs
  2337. 1:52:58and freelancers, bringing them extreme
  2338. 1:53:00value, value that is clearly unmatched.
  2339. 1:53:02Thanks, Paglia. by anyone. But that’s
  2340. 1:53:06not how you fight Big Luca, you little
  2341. 1:53:08mice with your Instagram botting. Just
  2342. 1:53:10imagine that. With botting and
  2343. 1:53:12reporting. Come on. Eh, come on.
  2344. 1:53:14Botting with reports because they are
  2345. 1:53:16afraid of Cleopatra.
  2346. 1:53:18We aim high. Mh. We prob We don't even
  2347. 1:53:21have the same potential clients, guys.
  2348. 1:53:23Can you imagine people who buy from us
  2349. 1:53:25also buying from them? Impossible. Ok,
  2350. 1:53:27so we’ll say goodbye, guys.
  2351. 1:53:29But Big Luca's clients are very
  2352. 1:53:31high-level, eh. Clients of a certain
  2353. 1:53:33caliber. Can you imagine? I mean, for a
  2354. 1:53:37Big Luca client, you have to pay, eh? I
  2355. 1:53:40mean, here, you pay.
  2356. 1:53:41Yes, get over it, accept it. Okay, come
  2357. 1:53:45on, let's all get back to work.
  2358. 1:53:47Work? What clients? I don't understand,
  2359. 1:53:51I'm missing some context here. Guys,
  2360. 1:53:54you did well to remind me about Wesa
  2361. 1:53:57Channel, folks. So, I remind you that
  2362. 1:54:00the video on Japan is already done and
  2363. 1:54:03uploaded, but it will come out in a few
  2364. 1:54:07days and not immediately as originally
  2365. 1:54:10planned, because tonight there's a
  2366. 1:54:13surprise live print with Mirko
  2367. 1:54:15Campocchiari Parabellum to discuss the
  2368. 1:54:19Mossad issue and so on, so that some
  2369. 1:54:22points that, apparently, were not clear
  2370. 1:54:25can be clarified. Um, eh, I have my
  2371. 1:54:30evening planned and then my weekend.
  2372. 1:54:34Thank you so much for following along.
  2373. 1:54:37Follow Eugenio tonight and, uh, in 5
  2374. 1:54:40minutes on Wesa Channel. Eh, what can I
  2375. 1:54:45say? We will naturally see each other
  2376. 1:54:48Monday at 9:00 PM with Eugenio for the
  2377. 1:54:51Monday live stream, Tuesday, Thursday,
  2378. 1:54:54all the usual stuff. it comes out on
  2379. 1:54:57Wednesday and so on. Tonight's live is
  2380. 1:54:59for everyone, it’s not just for
  2381. 1:55:01subscribers, eh, so you can all watch
  2382. 1:55:03it. Thanks, folks. It was a strange one
  2383. 1:55:07, in the end, it was almost interesting
  2384. 1:55:10. Awesome, see you soon. Go and, how
  2385. 1:55:14did it go? Go and preach my Gospel.
  2386. 1:55:19Word of Yahweh. Leave your land, go
  2387. 1:55:22where I will show you. of leave your
  2388. 1:55:28land.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Big Luca Teologo a Dubai by Cantina Wesa, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,631 words across 2,388 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.