YouTube2Text

Betting Against Stability · Wayne Himelsein — Transcript

by Chat With Traders · 12,733 words · 2,073 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:03markets
  2. 0:03speculation and risk this is the chat
  3. 0:06with traders podcast
  4. 0:08hosted by aaron field
  5. 0:11what's up folks welcome to chat with
  6. 0:13traders podcast
  7. 0:15number 202 featuring on this episode i
  8. 0:19have with me
  9. 0:20wayne hemelstein wayne is a clever
  10. 0:23mathematical mind who views markets
  11. 0:25through a quantitative lens
  12. 0:27he started trading on a proprietary
  13. 0:29trading desk in the mid 90s doing
  14. 0:32statistical arbitrage
  15. 0:34come 99 wayne launched a fund and begun
  16. 0:37managing money for clients and
  17. 0:39institutions
  18. 0:40then in 2011 wayne founded logica
  19. 0:44capital advisors where he currently
  20. 0:46takes the role of
  21. 0:47chief investment officer logica is
  22. 0:50a six-person team using various
  23. 0:53model-driven strategies which
  24. 0:55for the most part generate alpha from
  25. 0:58trading
  26. 0:59volatility so that's essentially what
  27. 1:01this episode is
  28. 1:02all about you know after some brief
  29. 1:04discussion about wayne's early prop days
  30. 1:07we then move on to talk about trading
  31. 1:09long volatility
  32. 1:11modeling methods and wayne imparts some
  33. 1:14wisdom from his 25 years in markets
  34. 1:17just in fyi this interview was recorded
  35. 1:209th of june 2020 and if you do like this
  36. 1:24episode
  37. 1:25wayne's also done a really good
  38. 1:27interview with
  39. 1:28real vision tv that you might want to
  40. 1:31check out
  41. 1:32i'll pop a link in the show notes
  42. 1:35anyway let's get to it now here is wayne
  43. 1:38hamelscene
  44. 1:39for episode 202
  45. 1:44one of the places i'd like to begin with
  46. 1:46and we won't spend too much time on this
  47. 1:48but
  48. 1:49it might just be good for a little bit
  49. 1:50of context
  50. 1:52you began trading mid 90s i believe
  51. 1:55uh where did you start out and who were
  52. 1:58you trading for
  53. 1:59sure yeah uh so the firm you're right it
  54. 2:02was mid 90s
  55. 2:03specifically 1995 so i can't get more
  56. 2:06mid
  57. 2:06than the middle uh the firm was called
  58. 2:09carlin financial and i say was
  59. 2:11uh because they actually acquired around
  60. 2:14the year 2000 they were acquired by a
  61. 2:16royal bank of canada so it became
  62. 2:18rbc's prop desk but carlin had a it was
  63. 2:21a really cool
  64. 2:22firm um and some history to that is
  65. 2:25uh of course i'm sure you've heard of
  66. 2:27millennium capital so
  67. 2:28millennium was started by uh two
  68. 2:31individuals uh izzy englander who's
  69. 2:33of course now famous for his involvement
  70. 2:35with millennium and
  71. 2:36uh built it up and then his partner when
  72. 2:38it was first started was a gentleman
  73. 2:40named ron scheer
  74. 2:41so they had started together and i guess
  75. 2:43over the first few years
  76. 2:45uh returns weren't so hot or it wasn't
  77. 2:47working out as hoped
  78. 2:48and so ron um and and izzy had a
  79. 2:52some disagreement about the future and
  80. 2:54split up and ron said i'm out of here
  81. 2:55and he left to start a proprietary
  82. 2:57trading firm of his own
  83. 2:59uh which was carl and financial and so
  84. 3:02uh it was
  85. 3:02izzy's ex-partner and of course the
  86. 3:04funny future story is that
  87. 3:06millennium and izzy went on to become
  88. 3:08one of the biggest best hedge funds in
  89. 3:09the world and
  90. 3:10carlin of course was a good prop trading
  91. 3:12shop but certainly not the
  92. 3:15the magnitude of growth of millennium so
  93. 3:17but that was its history and ron was an
  94. 3:19amazing
  95. 3:20uh trader uh and uh had i think what was
  96. 3:23most beautiful about the environment
  97. 3:25was the diversity of trading styles on a
  98. 3:28floor
  99. 3:29and so i was at their midtown manhattan
  100. 3:31office i think they had about
  101. 3:33let's say 50 or so offices around the
  102. 3:34country it was a decent sized prop firm
  103. 3:37i think one of the larger ones at the
  104. 3:38time so the but the mid manhattan office
  105. 3:40had some of the better
  106. 3:42i guess traders who who had been at
  107. 3:45generally bigger shops before that and
  108. 3:47now had come to trade
  109. 3:49a mix of either their own capital the
  110. 3:50firm's capital a bunch of smaller hedge
  111. 3:52funds
  112. 3:53uh but the uh the the nice part was that
  113. 3:56everyone for the most part had really
  114. 3:59good experience at some meaningful place
  115. 4:00and i remembered
  116. 4:01of course so well the guy who sat
  117. 4:03immediately to my left had been on the
  118. 4:05floor
  119. 4:06of the it was either the sibo or the
  120. 4:07ammo i forget exactly what but he had
  121. 4:09been on a trading floor
  122. 4:10for he told me 13 14 years and so you
  123. 4:13know all he was
  124. 4:14everything that would come out of his
  125. 4:15mouth would be how you'd see the order
  126. 4:17flow on the floor and so that's like on
  127. 4:20my left ear and then my right ear
  128. 4:21uh was a lehman brothers fixed income uh
  129. 4:24arbitrager and and
  130. 4:25you know and eight nine years at lehman
  131. 4:28and so he had
  132. 4:29just a completely different view of the
  133. 4:30world and and ones on my right ones on
  134. 4:32my left and so
  135. 4:33you know and this went on as you went on
  136. 4:35to the different desks or around the
  137. 4:37floor i should say
  138. 4:38there was that much diversity in views
  139. 4:41and approaches
  140. 4:42and um so that was just a beautiful
  141. 4:44experience to come out of college i
  142. 4:46i came out of uc berkeley i had a great
  143. 4:47education but then to be
  144. 4:49immersed in this world of of just
  145. 4:52knowledgeable traders doing so many
  146. 4:54different things and and all very
  147. 4:56interesting and me just
  148. 4:57like i was i was just so immersed and
  149. 5:01absorbed in in how much i could learn
  150. 5:03and and grow in that environment and i
  151. 5:04did
  152. 5:06being surrounded by such a diverse mix
  153. 5:08of traders
  154. 5:10how were you trading in those early days
  155. 5:12like what type of strategies did you
  156. 5:14gravitate towards
  157. 5:16yeah that's a great question so it's of
  158. 5:18course we always gravitate
  159. 5:20right to what is more naturally us i
  160. 5:22guess is that generally would be the
  161. 5:23path and so for me
  162. 5:25i had a really strong math background i
  163. 5:27was always a quant at nature
  164. 5:29uh and when i say at nature and when
  165. 5:31you're like it's i just looked at the
  166. 5:32world
  167. 5:33numerically or geometrically this when i
  168. 5:36when i
  169. 5:36you know as a little kid i'd i'd note
  170. 5:38things that were symmetric and things
  171. 5:40like that so it's just it was the who i
  172. 5:42was it was in my blood so to speak and
  173. 5:43so
  174. 5:44for me the the natural incarnation was
  175. 5:46anyone doing anything really
  176. 5:47quantitative
  177. 5:48and and so the the the the discretionary
  178. 5:51traders who had
  179. 5:52ideas they'd talk about in companies i
  180. 5:54was less interested in that
  181. 5:55but i'd go sit down next to people who
  182. 5:58are running big spreadsheets and
  183. 5:59uh doing some other forms of programming
  184. 6:01and try to understand what they're doing
  185. 6:02and how they're viewing it and
  186. 6:04uh so if yeah the easy answer high level
  187. 6:07was
  188. 6:07quant um and then the more granular the
  189. 6:11more mathematical it was the more it
  190. 6:13intrigued me and i remember that one of
  191. 6:14the early models that got my attention
  192. 6:16was
  193. 6:16was a a a model in stat arb and that was
  194. 6:20the first strategy that i fell in love
  195. 6:22with was statistically
  196. 6:23understand or looking at a statistical
  197. 6:25view of the market to understand what
  198. 6:27was
  199. 6:27um kind of normal or or abnormal i guess
  200. 6:30people would call
  201. 6:31anomalous behavior versus the normal
  202. 6:34and using statistical methods to derive
  203. 6:36that or to extract that
  204. 6:38so that that fascinated me and of course
  205. 6:41therefore i went down that road
  206. 6:43what sort of products or assets were you
  207. 6:45trading the arbitrage between
  208. 6:48uh so at the time uh my initial entry
  209. 6:51was
  210. 6:52through equities and i was just trading
  211. 6:54just as simple as you call it stocks
  212. 6:56right and uh
  213. 6:57i i i think that's certainly the right
  214. 6:59place to start is a good place for me to
  215. 7:01start just to get familiarity with
  216. 7:02markets
  217. 7:03i was happy that i learned both along on
  218. 7:05the short side early on
  219. 7:07um a lot of traders start out more long
  220. 7:10biased or tilted and i think for me the
  221. 7:13the idea of not of being around a lot of
  222. 7:16arbitrageurs who were
  223. 7:17who would take on trades of course that
  224. 7:19were both long and short especially
  225. 7:20instead arb
  226. 7:21um there's always a pair i mean in fact
  227. 7:23they called it pairs trading
  228. 7:25as a nickname so with that initial take
  229. 7:29on the market i didn't have this
  230. 7:31early on get get brought up so to speak
  231. 7:33with a directional view that the market
  232. 7:34had to go up and so
  233. 7:36i was equally looking for long or short
  234. 7:37trades in equities and then over the
  235. 7:39course of time
  236. 7:40i started to get intrigued by options
  237. 7:42and of course
  238. 7:43once again the mathematical nature of
  239. 7:45optionality um
  240. 7:47and the the mathematical modeling behind
  241. 7:49uh converting
  242. 7:50an underlying an equity into an option
  243. 7:53was all just
  244. 7:54you know of course black shoals is the
  245. 7:56is the standard model but
  246. 7:57the the the the math behind that and how
  247. 7:59something could be a derivative of
  248. 8:01something else
  249. 8:02would just pulled me right in and so i
  250. 8:04got into options trading
  251. 8:05and between the two between equity and
  252. 8:06options i that's where my career
  253. 8:08has gone from there on with those two uh
  254. 8:10instruments
  255. 8:11okay did you still go through the same
  256. 8:15stage of trial and error like many new
  257. 8:17traders do
  258. 8:18i mean i guess it was a great advantage
  259. 8:20that you were in this particular
  260. 8:22environment where you were surrounded by
  261. 8:23so many
  262. 8:24uh more advanced traders but um did you
  263. 8:27pick it up pretty easily
  264. 8:30so yeah my to the to your first question
  265. 8:32did i go through trial and error i
  266. 8:33i i cannot say without any like oh i'll
  267. 8:36say with absolute
  268. 8:37uh uh is i i yes i i did and have
  269. 8:41continued to i think
  270. 8:42trial and error is the is the crux of
  271. 8:44everything and
  272. 8:46i think all we do is as we age and get
  273. 8:47wiser in the markets and and
  274. 8:49learn more it's it's going through those
  275. 8:51trials
  276. 8:52and quicker and finding the errors
  277. 8:54better but trial and error will never
  278. 8:56stop that's the
  279. 8:57the bane of markets always changing on
  280. 9:00you but
  281. 9:00um so that was to answer that question
  282. 9:02yes i went through trial and error
  283. 9:04and yes i had a a leg up in in the sense
  284. 9:07of the wisdom that was around me
  285. 9:09sorry i forgot what was the second part
  286. 9:10of your question was did you pick it up
  287. 9:12did you like did you pick it up quickly
  288. 9:15yeah yeah so
  289. 9:16i did i did because um i i
  290. 9:19i guess and i'm a smart guy so that
  291. 9:21helped uh but particularly on the quant
  292. 9:23side
  293. 9:24it was the stuff was really intuitive to
  294. 9:26to me i was
  295. 9:27um call it efficient water and so i just
  296. 9:29i loved it i
  297. 9:31i picked it up quickly and the more i
  298. 9:32picked it up the more i wanted it i i
  299. 9:34think there's this
  300. 9:35you know common um among people who are
  301. 9:38get good at stuff is having a passion
  302. 9:40for it
  303. 9:41because that drives you to want to put
  304. 9:42in the time and so for me
  305. 9:44i i was right away passionate and i
  306. 9:46remember you know half the trading floor
  307. 9:48if not more than half the majority of
  308. 9:49people
  309. 9:50would leave after the close by 5 pm
  310. 9:52eastern everyone's gone and i stayed and
  311. 9:54i was out there using all the
  312. 9:56computers and the the the systems i'd
  313. 9:58stayed till late in the evening i was
  314. 9:59like one of the only people there at pat
  315. 10:01you know when it got dark
  316. 10:02it just because i was so immersed in
  317. 10:05wanting to understand and wanted to know
  318. 10:06and yes it was easy for me and yes i was
  319. 10:08passionate so
  320. 10:09put those two things together and you
  321. 10:11get um you get better at stuff
  322. 10:13yeah it's like when you're good at
  323. 10:15something you kind of want to see how
  324. 10:16far you can take it
  325. 10:18exactly exactly and it's enjoyable like
  326. 10:20you know
  327. 10:21i remember at the time i like people
  328. 10:23telling me you you worked too hard
  329. 10:24they still tell me today and i'm like
  330. 10:26i'm like yeah but i don't actually i
  331. 10:27don't feel like i'm working i'm having
  332. 10:29the time of my life
  333. 10:30doing this stuff so i'm not really i
  334. 10:32don't know what they mean when they say
  335. 10:33that
  336. 10:34right right so let's jump forward uh
  337. 10:37many years
  338. 10:38i know we're missing a lot out here but
  339. 10:40fast forward to i think it was around
  340. 10:422011
  341. 10:43uh when you formed logica can you just
  342. 10:46briefly describe
  343. 10:48uh what is logica today
  344. 10:52yeah logica today is i'll say the
  345. 10:54culmination of all my
  346. 10:55trial and error over over 15 20 years
  347. 10:59but the thesis was uh primarily to
  348. 11:03use i'll call mean expansion investing
  349. 11:06or long volatility investing and it's
  350. 11:08the the way i understood markets from an
  351. 11:10early standpoint is
  352. 11:12go back to the statistical arbitrage and
  353. 11:14all the different uh arbs that people do
  354. 11:16is
  355. 11:16that there's a lot of reversion trading
  356. 11:18going on and you know whether it's
  357. 11:20value investing which is uh buying a a a
  358. 11:23position that people expect to revert
  359. 11:25back to the upside of course and then or
  360. 11:27or or arbitrage trading where there's a
  361. 11:29pair that's on and
  362. 11:30you know something that is out of whack
  363. 11:31should come back together quote
  364. 11:33um so all of this was one side of the
  365. 11:36bra
  366. 11:36of the big market that a lot of people
  367. 11:38were doing and i early on
  368. 11:39took this approach of the or the other
  369. 11:42side of that which i call mean expansion
  370. 11:44so
  371. 11:44that world fits into for example
  372. 11:46momentum or trend following
  373. 11:48uh it's where you you expect things to
  374. 11:50continue it's the exact opposite of
  375. 11:52of of a reversionary trade so
  376. 11:55all my education into um investing in
  377. 11:59i don't want to call it momentum because
  378. 12:01that really dilutes the the
  379. 12:03it's such a broad category but things
  380. 12:05like stocks that would break out to the
  381. 12:07top side or
  382. 12:08the convexity of options that you know
  383. 12:10the ways to participate
  384. 12:12in uh through option structures these
  385. 12:14these versions of
  386. 12:16long volatility or mean expansionary
  387. 12:17investing um
  388. 12:19all came together for me in my mind and
  389. 12:21with starting logic
  390. 12:22to say as i want to come up with a a
  391. 12:24better mousetrap
  392. 12:25for for that type of investing and one
  393. 12:27of the problems
  394. 12:28with long vol or trend following all the
  395. 12:31all the things that fit into the mean
  396. 12:32expansion category
  397. 12:34is that they tend to have a low hit rate
  398. 12:36meaning
  399. 12:37um they can do well for a period of time
  400. 12:40but you need to wait for that that swing
  401. 12:43it's like you have to be patient and
  402. 12:44then
  403. 12:45a big swing comes and and but you could
  404. 12:47wait a long time and
  405. 12:49people will know that in in options
  406. 12:51world you can lose money
  407. 12:52month after month and then eventually
  408. 12:54you have this big payoff it's like the
  409. 12:56lottery right and
  410. 12:58of course you you get paid a bundle when
  411. 13:00you get paid
  412. 13:01because you have such an asymmetric
  413. 13:03payoff structure but
  414. 13:04you it can cost you either in actually
  415. 13:07losing money or just in not making any
  416. 13:09money and being flat
  417. 13:11in the period of waiting and so i i
  418. 13:12understood this and i
  419. 13:14i love long volatility mean expansion
  420. 13:16investing that's where all my
  421. 13:17career had been but i understood its
  422. 13:20flaw or its void which is
  423. 13:22having to wait or lose till you get that
  424. 13:24that big payoff
  425. 13:26so logico was set up to say how can i
  426. 13:28fix that hole
  427. 13:30how can i be a long vol investor but
  428. 13:33make money along the way like like they
  429. 13:35do in mean reversion like they do in
  430. 13:36arbitrage and that's what's so
  431. 13:38so widely loved about the whole other
  432. 13:40side of the world the mean reversion
  433. 13:42side is
  434. 13:42and all this arbitrage is that it's
  435. 13:44consistent you can the people pump out
  436. 13:46you know 50 100 bibs a month like
  437. 13:48clockwork right because it's it's
  438. 13:50it that that allows for it in that type
  439. 13:52of investing but then
  440. 13:54to to their void they have this once in
  441. 13:56a while big drawdown and so it's got
  442. 13:58what's called negative skew it it has a
  443. 14:00lot of little ups and once in a while a
  444. 14:02big down
  445. 14:03i like the idea of of either flat and
  446. 14:06once a while a big up
  447. 14:07or being up a little bit and then once
  448. 14:09in a while
  449. 14:10an even bigger up right and so that
  450. 14:12became the core ideas how do you achieve
  451. 14:14that how do you take something that does
  452. 14:17have those big ups
  453. 14:18but layer on it an ability to make money
  454. 14:20along the way
  455. 14:21and that became of course many years of
  456. 14:23research and work
  457. 14:24okay well i'd love to drill down into
  458. 14:27this further
  459. 14:28and and spend a bit of time here talking
  460. 14:30about trading
  461. 14:31long vol sure so just in very simple
  462. 14:35terms
  463. 14:35what does it mean to trade long
  464. 14:37volatility like what is the
  465. 14:39what is the objective here so going back
  466. 14:43to
  467. 14:44i guess what i just said in that last
  468. 14:45paragraph or however long i was i was
  469. 14:47talking
  470. 14:48um was that
  471. 14:51volatility is mean expansion right so
  472. 14:53something is going to take off in
  473. 14:54in a direction um and so i guess
  474. 14:58being i that's one side of it i'll
  475. 14:59answer it in two different ways so
  476. 15:01it's that pop or or expansion that you
  477. 15:04want to take advantage of that's one
  478. 15:06version of long volatility you want to
  479. 15:07be
  480. 15:08long a big change if you if you want to
  481. 15:11take the word volatility volatility is
  482. 15:12just
  483. 15:13of course uncertainty so that's another
  484. 15:15way to think about it but it's it's
  485. 15:16change
  486. 15:17right low vol is less change and high
  487. 15:18vol is more changing
  488. 15:20so to be long change is to say i expect
  489. 15:23a bigger change to occur
  490. 15:24it's that simple so if you expect a big
  491. 15:27change occur buying a lottery ticket
  492. 15:29is betting on a big change you have a
  493. 15:31dollar and you're gonna make a hundred
  494. 15:33million
  495. 15:33right on this one exchange or on this
  496. 15:36one transaction
  497. 15:37uh that's that's a long vault payoff
  498. 15:40that's one way of thinking about it also
  499. 15:42being longval
  500. 15:43is saying i'm i believe more that
  501. 15:45there's gonna be
  502. 15:46more drastic change in the future than
  503. 15:48there has been in the past
  504. 15:49uh so you're you you in a way bet
  505. 15:51against
  506. 15:52stability uh you you bet against an
  507. 15:55environment that is just status quo and
  508. 15:57say well something drastic is on the
  509. 15:58horizon
  510. 15:59uh and there's a big difference people
  511. 16:01often associate longval with being more
  512. 16:03focused on market downside
  513. 16:05uh but for me it's not there's you can
  514. 16:07be longval to the top side too meaning
  515. 16:10uh the easiest version of that actually
  516. 16:12just happened
  517. 16:13the last month and a half where we came
  518. 16:15off the march bottoms to now being
  519. 16:17basically at
  520. 16:18you know flat on the air on the s p uh
  521. 16:21with the v recovery that
  522. 16:22that yeah vol itself crushed but you
  523. 16:25could be long that expansion in the
  524. 16:27market if you had
  525. 16:27bought the bottom on march 22nd or
  526. 16:30whatever that date was that that was the
  527. 16:32absolute bottom and held that through
  528. 16:33today to me that's a mean expansion
  529. 16:36position in the market you you rode that
  530. 16:38whole thing up uh and so
  531. 16:40vol it's a little bit of a conundrum
  532. 16:42because volatility itself
  533. 16:43that the way it's measured in the market
  534. 16:46did come down over this period
  535. 16:48but that that would be that payoff
  536. 16:50structure in by let's say had you bought
  537. 16:52a long call in the market
  538. 16:53would be a long vault payoff uh because
  539. 16:55you're there's an extension
  540. 16:57to the to an extreme of the distribution
  541. 17:00so it i mean people talk about in
  542. 17:03different ways and i guess more of the
  543. 17:04world is focused on volatility being
  544. 17:06uh to the downside um but i i see it
  545. 17:10on both sides and so we're trying to
  546. 17:11take advantage of both sides of
  547. 17:12volatility
  548. 17:13okay so just some to save any confusion
  549. 17:17the way you positioned
  550. 17:19uh you are market agnostic like you have
  551. 17:22no bias on direction
  552. 17:24correct okay yeah to me it's dangerous
  553. 17:28to have that bias
  554. 17:29but yes right so can you give an example
  555. 17:33for like a long vol model like how would
  556. 17:36you express
  557. 17:37a long volatility trade idea
  558. 17:41well i mean long volatility is in is the
  559. 17:44simple
  560. 17:45simplest way to think about it is
  561. 17:46through an option right if you if you're
  562. 17:48long vol and you want to be and you want
  563. 17:50to take advantage of the market going up
  564. 17:52you buy a call
  565. 17:53it's that's as simple as it gets because
  566. 17:55you're by owning a long call
  567. 17:57you are long volatility you're in a
  568. 17:59volatility instrument uh i.e a call
  569. 18:02option
  570. 18:02um and but you're betting on the markets
  571. 18:04upside you're betting that the upside
  572. 18:06will be
  573. 18:06much more extreme than uh other people
  574. 18:09think and you know
  575. 18:10so what do i mean by that i mean as if
  576. 18:12you think the market's going to just
  577. 18:13cruise its way
  578. 18:14up over the course of time you would
  579. 18:17want a linear
  580. 18:18pay or not you'd want you you'd be okay
  581. 18:21with a linear payoff to that
  582. 18:22upside movement to that trend if you
  583. 18:25believe the market's going to take off
  584. 18:26rapidly
  585. 18:27you know that that's there's convexity
  586. 18:29in that you'd want a better payoff
  587. 18:31if you knew that information if you knew
  588. 18:33that was going to happen that'd be this
  589. 18:34huge upside move
  590. 18:36you bet you want to take a bet on that
  591. 18:37right tail payoff
  592. 18:39so you do that through a call option and
  593. 18:40then hence your long vol
  594. 18:42for in for what i'd call an up capture
  595. 18:45and it's
  596. 18:46different than say i i don't i i we
  597. 18:48don't use the words long or short
  598. 18:49because in we are long all options but
  599. 18:52if you're long a call your long up
  600. 18:54capture and if you're long a put your
  601. 18:55long
  602. 18:56down capture is the way we talk about it
  603. 18:59okay so i think it might be interesting
  604. 19:01to pick up on one of the things you
  605. 19:03highlighted
  606. 19:04a little earlier you spoke about how
  607. 19:07there can be kind of long periods where
  608. 19:09you may lose a bit of money or you
  609. 19:12certainly don't make much money
  610. 19:14but then every now and then there's a
  611. 19:16huge payout sure
  612. 19:17so how do you hedge your portfolio to
  613. 19:20minimize the bleed during those periods
  614. 19:22of
  615. 19:23what i presume would be low volatility
  616. 19:26yeah so that's that's the magic i'll
  617. 19:28call it um and that's that's what was
  618. 19:29spent many years
  619. 19:30uh we spent many years trying to figure
  620. 19:32out because that's the whole problem is
  621. 19:33how do you make money while you
  622. 19:35shouldn't be making money why you should
  623. 19:36be losing uh so
  624. 19:38if in that easy example if you're
  625. 19:40betting on market upside you can just
  626. 19:41get long a call and if you did that
  627. 19:43naively
  628. 19:44you'd say okay i'm going to buy some s p
  629. 19:46calls and you're going to hold them for
  630. 19:47the month and roll them until the next
  631. 19:49month and
  632. 19:49if if the market doesn't do much that
  633. 19:51month you're that's going to cost you
  634. 19:53you're going to pay theta you're going
  635. 19:54to pay for
  636. 19:55that cost of ownership for that long vol
  637. 19:58that you're buying for that convexity
  638. 19:59that you're trying to own
  639. 20:01that's going to cost you of course with
  640. 20:03a price the option and the decay of that
  641. 20:05option
  642. 20:06over time so the the easy answer for me
  643. 20:09and i i i guess first generally i'll say
  644. 20:11that the way people
  645. 20:12traditionally finance that trade would
  646. 20:15be to sell
  647. 20:16optionality elsewhere so if you want to
  648. 20:18be long in the market you might say okay
  649. 20:19i'll buy a long call
  650. 20:21at this level at this strike and i'm
  651. 20:22going to short a much further out call
  652. 20:24to give me some income to pay for this
  653. 20:26call because i don't believe i believe
  654. 20:27the market will go up
  655. 20:28maybe 10 but if there's no way it's
  656. 20:30going up 25
  657. 20:32so i'll short some up there where i
  658. 20:34think it's highly unlikely and that'll
  659. 20:35that that income will pay for my for
  660. 20:38where i want to be long so that's the
  661. 20:39traditional approach
  662. 20:40i i did not like that approach uh
  663. 20:43because i viewed it as
  664. 20:45uh being a counter trade it's you got
  665. 20:47kind of going against what you want to
  666. 20:48be doing
  667. 20:50and so my my version or my method
  668. 20:53to paying for that ownership was i
  669. 20:55realized could be through
  670. 20:56trading that was one of the components
  671. 20:58meaning
  672. 21:00instead of just buying that call and
  673. 21:01holding it for the month and waiting for
  674. 21:03the market to do what it's going to do
  675. 21:05one could trade around it right the way
  676. 21:07you might think a market maker could
  677. 21:09trade right so
  678. 21:10my experience on a trading desk was
  679. 21:12learning to trade so
  680. 21:13the the the cool kind of realization for
  681. 21:16me was
  682. 21:17being able to lay over or or combine
  683. 21:21trading with holding long volatility and
  684. 21:23so how do you do that you say okay
  685. 21:25instead of buying and holding this call
  686. 21:26for a month i'm gonna
  687. 21:28do i believe that i can you know the
  688. 21:30market's going to be a bit down over the
  689. 21:31next few days let's say as a swing
  690. 21:33trader
  691. 21:33i'd say okay it sell it looks a bit
  692. 21:35toppy here so it's going to pull
  693. 21:37pull in so i'm going to sell some of the
  694. 21:38calls i have and the market pulls in
  695. 21:40over the next few days
  696. 21:41and then you buy them back and you buy a
  697. 21:43bit more because it looks a bit oversold
  698. 21:44and then the market runs up for the next
  699. 21:46few days
  700. 21:47and but you had more than you needed
  701. 21:48because you you bought you bought a bit
  702. 21:50more when it sold off
  703. 21:52and so after it runs up you take some
  704. 21:54off the table you're taking a little bit
  705. 21:55of profit but still keeping some of the
  706. 21:57calls you have what you've effectively
  707. 22:00achieved or if you can do that well
  708. 22:02in in as a trader you you've you've
  709. 22:05maintained this long volatility exposure
  710. 22:08scaling up and down your your holdings
  711. 22:10you're modulating your inventory
  712. 22:12but by doing that you're scalping you're
  713. 22:14pulling out little profits out of the
  714. 22:15market
  715. 22:16all the while holding on for this big
  716. 22:19pop
  717. 22:19for when it's going to happen right so
  718. 22:21if that lasts for two months
  719. 22:23you're you're trading the noise while
  720. 22:25you're waiting for the pop
  721. 22:27and that's the idea and that's what ends
  722. 22:29up working out
  723. 22:30i guess fairly well and in fact it has
  724. 22:32for us
  725. 22:34and even more so is aligned with
  726. 22:36volatility
  727. 22:37because volatility itself tends to be a
  728. 22:39more
  729. 22:40mean reversionary asset meaning um like
  730. 22:43it
  731. 22:44it it it moves up and down a lot right
  732. 22:46so if you if you think about a low
  733. 22:48volatility environment i
  734. 22:49and i'll i'll use an easy example of
  735. 22:51this the year 2017.
  736. 22:54most people would agree was a really
  737. 22:56quote low vol
  738. 22:57year right so you'd say to me well
  739. 22:59there's not much volatility there wayne
  740. 23:00it's that's so much
  741. 23:01it's it's the lowest fall it's ever been
  742. 23:03let's say vix down at 10.
  743. 23:05yeah sure it was low vol it was down at
  744. 23:0710 but it didn't just sit at 10 every
  745. 23:09day
  746. 23:10in fact it moved from let's say you know
  747. 23:1210 to 13. let's just give it that small
  748. 23:14range
  749. 23:15that's a small range 10 12 11 and it's
  750. 23:18bouncing up and down with a little bit
  751. 23:20noisy around there
  752. 23:21in a few points of all up and down but
  753. 23:23you know 10 to 13 is is
  754. 23:2530 of movement that's that's a ton
  755. 23:28that's
  756. 23:28i mean if i told you a stock's going to
  757. 23:30move 30 tomorrow
  758. 23:31that's an incredible thing to trade as a
  759. 23:33trader right that's like trading netflix
  760. 23:35or google or whatever it might be
  761. 23:37so or probably tesla right that's the
  762. 23:40kind of thing that moves a lot that you
  763. 23:41want to trade if you're a trader
  764. 23:43so that idea that even in a low volume
  765. 23:46you get a lot of a lot of noise and so
  766. 23:49if you could buy that
  767. 23:50vol every time it dipped down to nine
  768. 23:52you bought up the vix and then it popped
  769. 23:54up to 11
  770. 23:54and you sold some and then it popped
  771. 23:56back down to nine and a half and you
  772. 23:58bought it back and
  773. 23:59popped up to 11 and a half and you sold
  774. 24:00some you're you're long
  775. 24:02vixx the whole time but you're trading
  776. 24:04the noise you're you're scalping
  777. 24:07in and all that requires is being a good
  778. 24:10enough
  779. 24:10i guess swing trader to be able to buy
  780. 24:12those lows sell those highs
  781. 24:14while maintaining your long vault
  782. 24:15inventory and it even does exist
  783. 24:17during low volumes that's the beauty
  784. 24:20when you are trading around
  785. 24:21in the noise are these directional
  786. 24:24trades you're placing
  787. 24:27uh they're directional uh partly
  788. 24:30in the sense that yeah if you buy more
  789. 24:32calls you're buying more
  790. 24:33up capture right but so there's there's
  791. 24:36a bunch of answers to that question so
  792. 24:38the first answer is
  793. 24:39yes they're directional in the sense
  794. 24:41that you're adding or subtracting to a
  795. 24:43direction of the market
  796. 24:44at the same time there there's the
  797. 24:48instrument itself
  798. 24:49has a convex of course upside and a
  799. 24:53concave downside
  800. 24:54so go with the example that you you buy
  801. 24:56some calls
  802. 24:57if you're wrong the next day and the
  803. 24:59market continues going lower
  804. 25:01your your delta shrinks right you you've
  805. 25:04got negative gamma so you're
  806. 25:06uh you're you're less wrong than had you
  807. 25:09bought
  808. 25:09that underlying um because you're it's
  809. 25:12like a built-in stop loss you're the
  810. 25:14amount you're losing is shrinking
  811. 25:16really quickly all you could lose at the
  812. 25:17end of the day is your premium
  813. 25:19so if you had 100 bucks and you spent
  814. 25:20only a dollar or one percent of capital
  815. 25:22on this long call
  816. 25:23sure you could make 10 if you're right
  817. 25:26but if you're wrong you could only lose
  818. 25:27a dollar
  819. 25:28so you're you in a sense you're you're
  820. 25:30going more into a direction
  821. 25:32but you've still as a trader capped your
  822. 25:34downside so that's one
  823. 25:36one kind of piece of the of the more
  824. 25:38complex answer the other pieces
  825. 25:40of that is that at logica because we're
  826. 25:42market agnostic
  827. 25:44we're going to do that same thing on
  828. 25:45both sides so as much as
  829. 25:48vol's coming down i'm buying some more
  830. 25:49calls i might be buying some more puts
  831. 25:52effectively we're we're adding up
  832. 25:54capture and non-capture
  833. 25:55at different times so we are definitely
  834. 25:57tilting but
  835. 25:58then you end up trading not one side but
  836. 26:02i guess the position would be called a
  837. 26:03straddle right
  838. 26:05once again a naive straddle would just
  839. 26:07be saying i want to buy a hundred calls
  840. 26:09and 100 puts
  841. 26:10from at the money and and so you wait
  842. 26:12for this v shape to pay off
  843. 26:14your long both tails uh or your long up
  844. 26:17caps and your long down capture equally
  845. 26:19the way you do it as a trader is say i
  846. 26:21want to do that same thing but i'm
  847. 26:23trading around
  848. 26:24the noise but on both sides so i might
  849. 26:26be adding a few puts selling a few calls
  850. 26:28adding a few calls selling a few puts
  851. 26:30therefore all the time you
  852. 26:33you're anti-fragile in a sense that if
  853. 26:35the market goes extremely in one
  854. 26:37direction
  855. 26:38you have convexity to that direction and
  856. 26:40concavity in being wrong
  857. 26:42right you're going to lose your premium
  858. 26:43on your puts and you're going to make a
  859. 26:44bundle on your calls or you're going to
  860. 26:46the opposite's going to happen you're
  861. 26:47going to make a bundle in your puts and
  862. 26:48your calls go to zero
  863. 26:49it doesn't matter because you're because
  864. 26:51you're along the other side
  865. 26:53but you could trade the noise on both
  866. 26:54sides and then each side is quote paying
  867. 26:56for itself and collectively the whole
  868. 26:58thing is paying for itself
  869. 26:59that's to me the most beautiful trade
  870. 27:01there is because
  871. 27:03you are along the extremes you're going
  872. 27:04to participate in both directions
  873. 27:06but you're you're managing yourself
  874. 27:08you're making money while you're waiting
  875. 27:10for those big pops
  876. 27:12now just another question on this still
  877. 27:16trading around in the noise are these
  878. 27:18trades
  879. 27:19model driven still or is there some
  880. 27:21discretionary which comes into play
  881. 27:24yeah so there's a beautiful interaction
  882. 27:27between the two and i
  883. 27:29i always um struggle with this question
  884. 27:32not not personally but as a like to me
  885. 27:35that it's it's it's such an
  886. 27:36uh inner weave uh in the sense that you
  887. 27:39know a model
  888. 27:40is discretionary because we the human
  889. 27:43built the model right i don't mean to be
  890. 27:44all philosophical here but in a way i do
  891. 27:46because
  892. 27:47the the like yeah i i build a model and
  893. 27:50it's a model and everything that went
  894. 27:51into that model
  895. 27:52was how i understood as a discretionary
  896. 27:55trader how that
  897. 27:56thing should go and all i've done really
  898. 27:58is codify the rules in my head
  899. 28:00okay so now that's done and that's a
  900. 28:02model and say okay it's fully systematic
  901. 28:03and then it starts trading
  902. 28:05and and you know let's say a month later
  903. 28:07it does something that i'm saying well
  904. 28:08wait a second that's not exactly what i
  905. 28:10would have done there
  906. 28:11uh it may it it really bought too much
  907. 28:13on that dip and i don't like that so i
  908. 28:15go back to the model and i
  909. 28:16and i tweak it for not being as
  910. 28:18sensitive to certain moves or
  911. 28:19changing its its rate of uh uh
  912. 28:23modulation or whatever it is that i'm
  913. 28:24going to tweak as a parameter
  914. 28:26now it's a new model or it's a refined
  915. 28:28model based on my
  916. 28:30once again discretion so for me the idea
  917. 28:33of being systematic is nothing
  918. 28:35ever that's going to be you know plug it
  919. 28:37plug and play or
  920. 28:38plug it in and leave it alone it's going
  921. 28:40to be forever infusing my discretionary
  922. 28:43understanding
  923. 28:44of markets and interweaving the two yes
  924. 28:46i'm trying to codify
  925. 28:48all the rules and and we want to just be
  926. 28:50able to plug it in and let it go
  927. 28:52but that it never works out that way
  928. 28:54because markets are always
  929. 28:56a little bit different because things
  930. 28:58change because this v recovery was
  931. 29:00unprecedented
  932. 29:01uh the the rate at which the market went
  933. 29:03back from its lows to now is just i mean
  934. 29:06i think it's definitely on record as one
  935. 29:08of the biggest
  936. 29:09up moves in history so had you built a
  937. 29:12model to all past behaviors well you
  938. 29:13wouldn't have captured this
  939. 29:15so models work and then they don't work
  940. 29:17and so i'm a big believer in a
  941. 29:19systematic approach
  942. 29:21to i'll say set the boundaries of your
  943. 29:24trading and to
  944. 29:24and to give you a framework with which
  945. 29:27to trade but we'll never stop
  946. 29:29uh every day i'm in the market
  947. 29:31understanding what it's what the trade
  948. 29:33that's going on and and
  949. 29:34asking myself is that what i would do
  950. 29:36here and if
  951. 29:37if if yes all good if no go back to the
  952. 29:40the model and therefore you know is it
  953. 29:42is it systematic or not i'm not sure
  954. 29:44it's both okay that's a great answer and
  955. 29:47i have
  956. 29:48quite a few questions for you around
  957. 29:50modeling which we'll get to in just a
  958. 29:52moment
  959. 29:52just one last question before we do you
  960. 29:55spoke earlier about
  961. 29:57you know the insurance costs i guess you
  962. 29:59could call it you know the bleed
  963. 30:01which can go on during low volatility
  964. 30:03periods and how you try to hedge against
  965. 30:05that
  966. 30:06i guess that is one of the risks of
  967. 30:08running a long vol strategy
  968. 30:10are there other risks which are inherent
  969. 30:13to these
  970. 30:14types of strategies i mean i think
  971. 30:17all of the risk surrounds the cost of
  972. 30:20ownership
  973. 30:20you call it the cost of insurance or the
  974. 30:22bleed it's just how much of that risk
  975. 30:24right so in other words if um you know
  976. 30:28the
  977. 30:29the market can go i guess you can be
  978. 30:31directly wrong but in a straddle that's
  979. 30:33not going to happen so
  980. 30:34if you you know if one gets tilted too
  981. 30:36much to one side if you only bought
  982. 30:38calls or only bought puts you can
  983. 30:40be in a much worse situation than if
  984. 30:42you're buying both
  985. 30:43um because uh uh of course you can be
  986. 30:45directionally wrong
  987. 30:46and you can bleed but given that you're
  988. 30:48in uh or that you take a market agnostic
  989. 30:51approach
  990. 30:52you can't really be totally directly
  991. 30:54wrong so then it just becomes about the
  992. 30:56bleed but the bleed itself isn't just uh
  993. 30:59oh you can bleed
  994. 31:00there's there's many ways in which you
  995. 31:01can bleed right so
  996. 31:03you can bleed in uh of course just
  997. 31:06the market being still right and not
  998. 31:09moving much
  999. 31:10uh and you can bleed in being whipsawed
  1000. 31:12where you you can i guess
  1001. 31:14that this would be really not as much
  1002. 31:15bleed but more a directional
  1003. 31:18misjudgment where it goes one direction
  1004. 31:21you get tilted to one side and then it
  1005. 31:22goes the other direction you get tilted
  1006. 31:24to the other and you keep on getting it
  1007. 31:25wrong
  1008. 31:26you know because the market's just not
  1009. 31:28doing what it's quote supposed to in
  1010. 31:29your mind
  1011. 31:30um right so that that's a kind of
  1012. 31:32directional mismatching but the other
  1013. 31:34form of
  1014. 31:35um bleed is in vulcrush where
  1015. 31:38uh the the market can go up and vol
  1016. 31:41could drop a lot
  1017. 31:42you know vault doesn't always totally
  1018. 31:44associate with what's going on in the
  1019. 31:46world i mean right now
  1020. 31:47um we say we've we've come back to all
  1021. 31:50time highs i guess the nasdaq's made
  1022. 31:52you know the nas qq's have made all-time
  1023. 31:54highs s ps right about flat on the ear
  1024. 31:57but vol or the vix is still up around 25
  1025. 32:00that's still
  1026. 32:01two times the historical or close to two
  1027. 32:04times the historical vol on the s p
  1028. 32:06so um they're still
  1029. 32:09with extended vol you can be right in a
  1030. 32:11direction
  1031. 32:12but if tomorrow the market goes up up a
  1032. 32:15percent and vix crushes let's say
  1033. 32:17seven percent you could have been right
  1034. 32:19in buying your call
  1035. 32:21meaning your direction is perfect but
  1036. 32:24you lose more because of all crushed
  1037. 32:25more than the
  1038. 32:26the delta made right so your your short
  1039. 32:29vega is worse than your
  1040. 32:30in your positive delta that's the
  1041. 32:32problem so there's that's what i mean
  1042. 32:34when i say there's different types of
  1043. 32:35bleeds
  1044. 32:36there's there's you're more subject to
  1045. 32:38bleed when the overall environment is at
  1046. 32:40higher vol
  1047. 32:41and so you have to be more right on your
  1048. 32:43directions or you have to do something
  1049. 32:45else to manage that
  1050. 32:46though that that height of bleed so i i
  1051. 32:48guess i can call it the
  1052. 32:50the magnitude of bleeding changes and
  1053. 32:52that's relative to where vol is
  1054. 32:54and how choppy the market is around that
  1055. 32:56position or around that vol
  1056. 32:59okay okay gotcha uh wayne let's focus in
  1057. 33:04a bit on modeling just in general terms
  1058. 33:07uh and perhaps some uh words of wisdom
  1059. 33:11for
  1060. 33:11aspiring quants out there my first
  1061. 33:14question around this
  1062. 33:15might be you know what are some of the
  1063. 33:17mistakes or the flawed practices
  1064. 33:20which you made early on the beginning of
  1065. 33:22your trading career
  1066. 33:24i think you know i mean i'm very happy
  1067. 33:26to say that i didn't
  1068. 33:27make one of the worst mistakes or flaws
  1069. 33:31which is
  1070. 33:32overfitting i was really i understood
  1071. 33:35that from
  1072. 33:36the very beginning i understood um that
  1073. 33:38if you
  1074. 33:39you search enough in data you can find
  1075. 33:41anything uh and i think that's so
  1076. 33:43that's not something that i was subject
  1077. 33:44to so much but i believe that that's
  1078. 33:46something that is
  1079. 33:48very um prevalent are widespread
  1080. 33:52um and so that's what i caution everyone
  1081. 33:54about is
  1082. 33:55is uh the the ability to you know find
  1083. 33:58something it's so easy to find something
  1084. 33:59everyone's
  1085. 34:00out there searching for different data
  1086. 34:02sets and looking at different
  1087. 34:04things at different angles and and and
  1088. 34:07trying to find a pattern in data and
  1089. 34:09if you do that enough you're inevitably
  1090. 34:11there's you're always going to find
  1091. 34:12something it just doesn't have any
  1092. 34:13meaning
  1093. 34:14and it may not last very long and so
  1094. 34:17that's my biggest caution is the whole
  1095. 34:19curve fitting mining uh concern and but
  1096. 34:22i think that's that's known
  1097. 34:23generally as as a risk by people i think
  1098. 34:26the problem is
  1099. 34:26not understanding in the in testing how
  1100. 34:30easily that can creep up on you and i
  1101. 34:32think that's where so
  1102. 34:33as i guess going back to myself i knew
  1103. 34:35intuitively
  1104. 34:36that i can't just i don't want to just
  1105. 34:38search for a pattern i want to have an
  1106. 34:39idea in my mind
  1107. 34:40and i want to look into the data to try
  1108. 34:42to confirm
  1109. 34:43that idea right so it's not it's not
  1110. 34:46seeking a pattern it's seeking
  1111. 34:48validation of something that my mind
  1112. 34:50thinks it makes sense
  1113. 34:52so that that was step number one and
  1114. 34:53there therefore i had
  1115. 34:55curve fitting or data mining licked from
  1116. 34:57from a top level
  1117. 34:58but where it went wrong for me i guess
  1118. 35:00where trial and error helped to learn
  1119. 35:02was you can make those same curvature
  1120. 35:04mistakes even though you start with that
  1121. 35:05premise
  1122. 35:06right what i mean is that let's say you
  1123. 35:08have an idea
  1124. 35:09and you test you test for confirmation
  1125. 35:11or validation of that idea
  1126. 35:13and it doesn't come out exactly as you
  1127. 35:15hoped it would right and then you say
  1128. 35:17okay well let me
  1129. 35:18let me let me turn that like let me
  1130. 35:19shift let me you know instead of
  1131. 35:21buying it every 10 down i want to buy it
  1132. 35:23every nine percent down and you test
  1133. 35:25that and
  1134. 35:26so what you've done is you've started
  1135. 35:27out with a good thesis that was
  1136. 35:29independently
  1137. 35:30hypothesized by you uh and it's got a
  1138. 35:33sound approach
  1139. 35:34but once you start testing in not
  1140. 35:36getting the
  1141. 35:37the outcome you'd want you start
  1142. 35:39tweaking until you get the outcome
  1143. 35:41that's terrible right so that's
  1144. 35:43that's like it's terrible because you
  1145. 35:44started out with with a good thesis you
  1146. 35:46start out trying to not be
  1147. 35:48a fitter but then you became a fitter in
  1148. 35:50the testing process
  1149. 35:51that's something that i probably made
  1150. 35:53mistake not probably i definitely made
  1151. 35:55mistakes with early on
  1152. 35:56and learn very quickly how just
  1153. 36:01how incredibly aware one has to be
  1154. 36:04on every test you do and every iteration
  1155. 36:07you make
  1156. 36:08to know that you're not biasing your
  1157. 36:11your test
  1158. 36:12it's just it's it's almost unbelievable
  1159. 36:14how we check ourselves today before
  1160. 36:16i i'll say the time it takes uh the
  1161. 36:18biggest caution is
  1162. 36:20taking time to set up a test today when
  1163. 36:22we have an idea
  1164. 36:23we don't just go do the test we we talk
  1165. 36:25for
  1166. 36:26hours like brainstorming like is this
  1167. 36:28the right test and what are we missing
  1168. 36:30and like you want to go through all this
  1169. 36:32brainstorming and discussion
  1170. 36:34just in setting up the experiment to
  1171. 36:37know
  1172. 36:37that you haven't done anything wrong in
  1173. 36:39the experimental phase then you go
  1174. 36:41test and if the results don't look right
  1175. 36:43then you move on to something totally
  1176. 36:45different
  1177. 36:45that's i guess that's the biggest um
  1178. 36:48learned
  1179. 36:48or trial and error learned lesson i've
  1180. 36:50had over decades
  1181. 36:52is uh getting better at that feature of
  1182. 36:55testing and
  1183. 36:56um it's just so easy to do we're so we
  1184. 36:58so easily fool ourselves as humans
  1185. 37:00especially when we're
  1186. 37:01of course biased to want to find
  1187. 37:02something right we all when we're
  1188. 37:04sitting there as quants testing we want
  1189. 37:05to find something we want it to be
  1190. 37:07to find the you know dig for the gold
  1191. 37:09and there's a little sparkle in the
  1192. 37:10ground oh my god i found it
  1193. 37:12and and we want to make money and so
  1194. 37:13we're so inclined to believe quickly
  1195. 37:16uh and it's just it's much harder than
  1196. 37:18people think
  1197. 37:19to find things that work uh and so most
  1198. 37:22things don't
  1199. 37:23and and therefore spend more time being
  1200. 37:26sure
  1201. 37:27and spend more time setting up one's
  1202. 37:28experiment to and expect it not to work
  1203. 37:31uh and the anomaly should be when
  1204. 37:33something does work out really well in
  1205. 37:34testing
  1206. 37:36okay that's interesting so you spend a
  1207. 37:39lot of time
  1208. 37:40as you said brainstorming these ideas
  1209. 37:42all
  1210. 37:43before you actually go to running a test
  1211. 37:46and if you run a test and the first
  1212. 37:49iteration of that test
  1213. 37:50shows uh you know undesirable results
  1214. 37:54you pretty much just abandoned that idea
  1215. 37:55all together
  1216. 37:58yeah that's a it's a it's a good
  1217. 37:59question i mean that's a great follow-up
  1218. 38:01question to what i just said but it's
  1219. 38:02the problem is there's nuance there
  1220. 38:03right so it's what i say i abandon that
  1221. 38:06idea altogether
  1222. 38:07sometimes yes other times i'd say if i
  1223. 38:10if there's something about the idea that
  1224. 38:12struck me then
  1225. 38:14i i may not abandon it all together i
  1226. 38:16might i might sit there
  1227. 38:18and think or discuss and talk about what
  1228. 38:20did we miss
  1229. 38:21what i will not do is say okay let me
  1230. 38:24let me just shift this one parameter by
  1231. 38:26seven degrees and re-test
  1232. 38:27that's the big no-no right so there's
  1233. 38:29somewhere in between tweaking parameters
  1234. 38:33of a model and going back to the drawing
  1235. 38:34board and saying
  1236. 38:35okay we believed and you know whatever
  1237. 38:38what what's
  1238. 38:38you know some silly thesis you know we
  1239. 38:41believe growth outperforms value right
  1240. 38:43you know and get into that big debate
  1241. 38:45but um yeah
  1242. 38:47we and that's not the kind of things
  1243. 38:48that we we do at logical but just to
  1244. 38:50talk about that one as an easy concept
  1245. 38:52right so you could do that and say okay
  1246. 38:54and you do a test and it doesn't work
  1247. 38:55say okay let's try instead of big calf
  1248. 38:57let's try small caps and
  1249. 38:59well it worked over there right so
  1250. 39:00that's interesting because there's a we
  1251. 39:02understand the difference between big
  1252. 39:03caps and small caps and
  1253. 39:05why growth would be more powerful in
  1254. 39:06small caps makes sense because there's
  1255. 39:08perhaps more room to grow
  1256. 39:10if you're small versus when you're
  1257. 39:11already big so in that example there's
  1258. 39:14there's a when you tweaked that
  1259. 39:16parameter to look at not small
  1260. 39:18large caps but small caps in in trying
  1261. 39:20to identify the the benefit of growth
  1262. 39:22or the alpha in growth you're you've
  1263. 39:25you've not just tweaked it by some
  1264. 39:27mathematical metric you've sat at a
  1265. 39:29table and said wait a second
  1266. 39:31it may be large caps don't have as much
  1267. 39:33room to grow versus smaller
  1268. 39:34companies because they're you know
  1269. 39:36they're by by definition there's there's
  1270. 39:38more
  1271. 39:38more room and of course we'd say this
  1272. 39:40you know this is not true of amazon
  1273. 39:42or some of the bigger boys but but put
  1274. 39:43the anomalies aside is that
  1275. 39:45there's a sound reasoning behind
  1276. 39:49changing a parameter now going to a new
  1277. 39:51test
  1278. 39:52where you've you've deliberated and
  1279. 39:54you've understood
  1280. 39:55what was wrong in your first experiment
  1281. 39:57and why in your next experiment
  1282. 39:59there's you've stuck to the core idea
  1283. 40:01that there's alpha in growth
  1284. 40:03but you've changed a parameter that has
  1285. 40:05a reasoning for it to change and a logic
  1286. 40:07behind
  1287. 40:08why the new one should work so that's
  1288. 40:10the difference between just saying
  1289. 40:12i'm going to run this array of tests and
  1290. 40:14and find something does that make sense
  1291. 40:16or is that helpful to that answer
  1292. 40:18that does make sense yes
  1293. 40:21as you stated that most or in all cases
  1294. 40:25before you run any test there's always a
  1295. 40:27goal and
  1296. 40:28a brainstorming process which takes
  1297. 40:31place beforehand
  1298. 40:34for newer traders out there and aspiring
  1299. 40:36quants in particular
  1300. 40:39where do those ideas come from
  1301. 40:42where do the how do you form those goals
  1302. 40:45yeah that's a great question um
  1303. 40:50the the toughest part is the the the
  1304. 40:53paradox i guess
  1305. 40:54is that you said for aspiring quants
  1306. 40:57is that for me those ideas have come
  1307. 40:59from experience so how do you
  1308. 41:01how do you put experience in in a new
  1309. 41:03trader right that's
  1310. 41:04that's tough um
  1311. 41:07on top of that though i i think there's
  1312. 41:09if i had to say
  1313. 41:10like the the merging of three different
  1314. 41:12things so one is of course experience
  1315. 41:15two is reading and um just
  1316. 41:18absorbing from other great
  1317. 41:21uh investors slash traders out there i
  1318. 41:23mean i when i was young i was just
  1319. 41:25you know when i i stayed late to the
  1320. 41:27trading firm and then i went home and
  1321. 41:28read a book right that's that's all i
  1322. 41:30just it's just absorbing yourself in
  1323. 41:32what
  1324. 41:32all the wisdom before you has had to
  1325. 41:35share
  1326. 41:36reading and taking in all you can from
  1327. 41:38from those who have done it
  1328. 41:39the third thing is trading on your own
  1329. 41:42capital i can't stress that enough i i
  1330. 41:46this idea of simulating an idea of paper
  1331. 41:48trading and all that is just
  1332. 41:50absolute nonsense because there's all of
  1333. 41:52the all of it comes down to
  1334. 41:53how emotion where you know people try to
  1335. 41:57build systematic approaches because our
  1336. 42:00our emotions
  1337. 42:01can do us wrong and and you know as much
  1338. 42:03as they're systematic people go in and
  1339. 42:04try to trade a systematic approach and
  1340. 42:06they end up over trading it or or
  1341. 42:09disagreeing with it and
  1342. 42:10it because the emotions always come in
  1343. 42:12and you say oh this doesn't feel right
  1344. 42:13and
  1345. 42:14you do something different and so for me
  1346. 42:16the biggest gain in in
  1347. 42:18in ideas has been just literally to put
  1348. 42:21money in account and start doing it and
  1349. 42:23i tell this i get into a bunch of
  1350. 42:25conversations i do a lot of tweeting and
  1351. 42:28i guess i like the twitter environment a
  1352. 42:30lot of people ask me they dm me new
  1353. 42:32traders know how
  1354. 42:32what's the best way to start and my
  1355. 42:34answer generally is open an account and
  1356. 42:36put in some money and start trading
  1357. 42:38like that i can't think of a better
  1358. 42:40version of gaining real life experience
  1359. 42:42on your own capital to feel what it
  1360. 42:44feels like
  1361. 42:44when when you're sitting there and you
  1362. 42:46think something's a good trade and you
  1363. 42:47get in and then it just
  1364. 42:49the floor just drops and it just starts
  1365. 42:51falling rapidly and
  1366. 42:52what do you do and you you know your
  1367. 42:53body freezes up and
  1368. 42:55and understanding how that how those
  1369. 42:58behaviors work and how you feel and how
  1370. 43:00the market does it and where
  1371. 43:02so many times traders will say like
  1372. 43:04something goes wrong
  1373. 43:05against them and they stop out and then
  1374. 43:08two minutes later it reverses right and
  1375. 43:10it's like this common
  1376. 43:11no it's a common thing that people talk
  1377. 43:13about as being that that
  1378. 43:15being shaken out that's because everyone
  1379. 43:17behaves the same and so
  1380. 43:19unless you go in there and do it you
  1381. 43:20don't learn that behavior and once you
  1382. 43:22learn that behavior by doing it
  1383. 43:24then you could start to model you know
  1384. 43:26okay now i can see
  1385. 43:27like it's where my emotions are coming
  1386. 43:29into play and where
  1387. 43:31where behaviors need to be overridden by
  1388. 43:33certain rules and so you can better
  1389. 43:34build the mouse trap
  1390. 43:36by knowing what it is that you're that
  1391. 43:38that's going on uh so that that's where
  1392. 43:40my
  1393. 43:41advice i guess culminates yeah great
  1394. 43:45are there any testing or modeling
  1395. 43:47methods which you use
  1396. 43:49that are unique in some way
  1397. 43:52you know from common practices in the
  1398. 43:55industry
  1399. 43:56or common practices used by you know
  1400. 43:58quants just generally speaking
  1401. 44:02uh yeah i mean i'd say that we generally
  1402. 44:05don't like to use
  1403. 44:06just what's out there the the the
  1404. 44:08off-the-shelf models
  1405. 44:10there's a lot of stuff that you can i
  1406. 44:12mean i know people read and i i do too
  1407. 44:15the white papers there's new ideas every
  1408. 44:18day and
  1409. 44:18being published and i guess i have the
  1410. 44:20general feeling that if it's a white
  1411. 44:22paper and it's being published
  1412. 44:23especially if it's published by aqr
  1413. 44:25uh who are putting out so many like that
  1414. 44:28it's like the market knows that
  1415. 44:29like you're not gonna learn anything
  1416. 44:31there that no that people are i'm sure
  1417. 44:33sure it can continue working i'm not
  1418. 44:34that's you know maybe it will maybe
  1419. 44:36that's just enough of the way the market
  1420. 44:38works
  1421. 44:38but if it's a white paper you're not the
  1422. 44:40only one who has seen it
  1423. 44:41right and so if there's some
  1424. 44:43mathematical approach that you know in
  1425. 44:45volatility investing people use garch
  1426. 44:48as a very typical model um for the way
  1427. 44:50volatility behaves
  1428. 44:52uh it's uh and so what we say is we're
  1429. 44:55not going to use any of that we're not
  1430. 44:57going to
  1431. 44:57do something off of a white paper we're
  1432. 44:59not going to do something we're not
  1433. 45:00going to use garch we're going to
  1434. 45:01develop our own stuff based on how we
  1435. 45:03understand
  1436. 45:04it and so the the for me the beauty of
  1437. 45:07that in
  1438. 45:08using uh i'll call it proprietary
  1439. 45:10mathematics
  1440. 45:11is that yes you can be wrong but by
  1441. 45:13definition you'll be different
  1442. 45:16and if you can figure out something that
  1443. 45:18has alpha where you can be
  1444. 45:20quote right and you're using different
  1445. 45:22mathematics then
  1446. 45:23then people won't come upon it right and
  1447. 45:26don't go
  1448. 45:27issue a white paper on it because then
  1449. 45:28it will be known and it'll be
  1450. 45:30and then you know you'll be competing
  1451. 45:31with yourself and and all the others
  1452. 45:33that that figure
  1453. 45:34that saw it from you right so you know i
  1454. 45:37i think
  1455. 45:38my uh broad answer will be that yes we
  1456. 45:42we we don't we we do all our own stuff
  1457. 45:44um we use interesting mathematical
  1458. 45:46approaches
  1459. 45:47i like integrating um like
  1460. 45:50uh i guess more disconnected ideas in
  1461. 45:53mathematics so
  1462. 45:54you know for example the the phd that we
  1463. 45:57have in-house is a
  1464. 45:59algebraic geometer right so what does
  1465. 46:00that mean he is his phd is in
  1466. 46:02the combination of algebra and geometry
  1467. 46:05uh and those two are beautifully
  1468. 46:06intertwined um the
  1469. 46:08you know it's a little bit of math back
  1470. 46:09history here is the first
  1471. 46:11uh formula or algorithm that that
  1472. 46:13combined
  1473. 46:14algebra and geometry was the pythagorean
  1474. 46:16theorem right that you could take this
  1475. 46:18a squared plus b squared equals c
  1476. 46:19squared that there's this geomet
  1477. 46:21the algebraic formula that perfectly fit
  1478. 46:25this geometric shape that the hypotenuse
  1479. 46:27would be the square of the two sides
  1480. 46:29right that's that's that's a cool way
  1481. 46:31that geometry and algebra
  1482. 46:33came together and that was the first one
  1483. 46:35where they did come together so
  1484. 46:36building on that approach now come shoot
  1485. 46:39forward thousands of years in markets
  1486. 46:41people can use algebra but you could
  1487. 46:43also use geometry and so
  1488. 46:45for me you know when somebody's looking
  1489. 46:47at for example standard deviations
  1490. 46:49i want to look at that topologically i
  1491. 46:51want to look at that in geometric space
  1492. 46:52like what are the distances between two
  1493. 46:54things
  1494. 46:55that's more interesting than how much
  1495. 46:56they you know specifically deviate as a
  1496. 46:58percentage
  1497. 46:59and if you can uh come up with distance
  1498. 47:01relationships and how that what that
  1499. 47:03means and
  1500. 47:04do things take on certain shapes or
  1501. 47:06symmetries these are
  1502. 47:07these are ways of using mathematics and
  1503. 47:10and doing things differently than most
  1504. 47:11other people are
  1505. 47:12and i think they help if you can figure
  1506. 47:14stuff out using such approaches
  1507. 47:17just out of curiosity what is your level
  1508. 47:19of mathematical education like
  1509. 47:21how much of this is self-taught versus
  1510. 47:24formal education
  1511. 47:26yeah so it's a nice mix probably not
  1512. 47:29probably most definitely more
  1513. 47:31self-taught because i i'm so much older
  1514. 47:34than i have been out of
  1515. 47:35school now for um 25 years so by
  1516. 47:38definition i have more time out of
  1517. 47:39school than in school for four years
  1518. 47:41right so
  1519. 47:42um therefore i i definitely have more
  1520. 47:44self teaching
  1521. 47:45uh so the the the background for me is i
  1522. 47:48i
  1523. 47:49certainly had a strong mathematical
  1524. 47:51understanding or
  1525. 47:52as i talked about earlier as a kid i
  1526. 47:54just i saw things numerically very
  1527. 47:56easily and so i had
  1528. 47:57that intuition um in fact so much so
  1529. 48:00that i i got more advanced in math as
  1530. 48:02a youngster and um in high school i was
  1531. 48:05so
  1532. 48:06advanced over my peers i started
  1533. 48:08university level math and getting
  1534. 48:09through
  1535. 48:10i remember i was like starting i guess
  1536. 48:12college calculus in in 10th grade of
  1537. 48:14high school and so i was really
  1538. 48:16leaping ahead but then the funny thing
  1539. 48:18happened to me is because
  1540. 48:20i was taking all these college classes
  1541. 48:22when i was in high school by the time i
  1542. 48:23actually got to college
  1543. 48:24i was kind of sick of math right or i
  1544. 48:27was just like i had been that
  1545. 48:28that youngster in the college classes
  1546. 48:30the high school kid in there and so
  1547. 48:32when i got to college when i actually uh
  1548. 48:34went to formal university i thought to
  1549. 48:35myself all right
  1550. 48:36at that point i didn't want to do it
  1551. 48:38anymore i didn't want to be that i had
  1552. 48:39kind of negative experiences with being
  1553. 48:41the younger kid in those in those
  1554. 48:43college classes while in high school so
  1555. 48:45i said you know what i'm not doing any
  1556. 48:46much math and i was able to transfer all
  1557. 48:48my credits because i did so much
  1558. 48:49university work
  1559. 48:50and so i actually took on an english
  1560. 48:53degree and did english and creative
  1561. 48:55writing
  1562. 48:55out of berkeley so um in that way i
  1563. 48:58didn't
  1564. 48:59formally go further with my math
  1565. 49:01education but i was this advanced math
  1566. 49:03kid
  1567. 49:04so when i came out of college and then
  1568. 49:06got into the real world of course my
  1569. 49:07love for math
  1570. 49:08was quickly pulled back in but what it
  1571. 49:11gave me the opportunity to do is to
  1572. 49:13understand things really quickly in in
  1573. 49:15the mathematical realm and to be able to
  1574. 49:16pick up where i left off and then
  1575. 49:18self-educate for the next 25 years
  1576. 49:20so my my love my passion my intuition
  1577. 49:23for math
  1578. 49:24has has grown a lot of education in me
  1579. 49:27but
  1580. 49:27formally it wasn't actually even that
  1581. 49:29much other than
  1582. 49:30um this advanced stuff i did early on uh
  1583. 49:33so but
  1584. 49:34it's i love the way it came together for
  1585. 49:36me because i it allowed me to see things
  1586. 49:39in different ways than people learned
  1587. 49:42who did the i'll call it the formal
  1588. 49:43route
  1589. 49:45for someone who doesn't have a strong
  1590. 49:47mathematical education
  1591. 49:49but is uh very interested in
  1592. 49:52quantitative trading
  1593. 49:54do you have any advice for someone in
  1594. 49:55that situation
  1595. 49:57yeah i mean i i would liken that to to
  1596. 49:59myself right
  1597. 50:00is that if you if somebody has the
  1598. 50:04um the interest and not just the
  1599. 50:06interest and passion but the intuition
  1600. 50:08in math if you're
  1601. 50:09intuitively good with numbers and with
  1602. 50:12understanding that that sort of thing
  1603. 50:14then self-education is amazing i mean i
  1604. 50:17there's it's incredible what you can get
  1605. 50:18online now and i mean it's
  1606. 50:20right they didn't even have as much of
  1607. 50:22it was when i was i mean
  1608. 50:24they did of course 25 years ago it
  1609. 50:25wasn't it wasn't it was there was still
  1610. 50:27wikipedia was still around right or was
  1611. 50:29uh already around i should say
  1612. 50:31but today there's even more i mean the
  1613. 50:33classes that you can get through
  1614. 50:35coursera or any number i mean through
  1615. 50:37khan academy
  1616. 50:37it just goes on and on and on and you
  1617. 50:39can i mean there's online classes out of
  1618. 50:41out of every major ivy league put
  1619. 50:43through different um
  1620. 50:44online entities so one can
  1621. 50:47fully educate i mean you can give
  1622. 50:48yourself a phd if you want to by just
  1623. 50:50taking online stuff
  1624. 50:52the answer is if you have the passion
  1625. 50:54and the basic understanding and
  1626. 50:55intuition then
  1627. 50:56go just get out there and do it all
  1628. 50:58right grab everything you can and learn
  1629. 51:00learn learn and
  1630. 51:01i mean that's that's what i did for
  1631. 51:03myself over over decades and
  1632. 51:05you just keep on go i mean if again it's
  1633. 51:07like that thing what we were saying
  1634. 51:09earlier is if
  1635. 51:09people say you work too hard but no not
  1636. 51:11if you love what you do then it's not
  1637. 51:12really work so
  1638. 51:13same for me it's like on the weekend i
  1639. 51:15um i i would i read math stuff
  1640. 51:18because that's i'm so just interested in
  1641. 51:20it i in fact i remember there's a funny
  1642. 51:22story i was out um
  1643. 51:23when i i'm a big cyclist i go biking
  1644. 51:26it's my kind of
  1645. 51:27sport of choice and uh for many many
  1646. 51:29years i was listening to
  1647. 51:31math lectures in my ipod while i'm
  1648. 51:33biking i was by i was out somewhere
  1649. 51:35biking and i was uh
  1650. 51:36i i ran into somebody i knew and he saw
  1651. 51:39my
  1652. 51:39my i had my iphone i had my little
  1653. 51:41earphones in and he he
  1654. 51:43uh he knew me he walked up to me so what
  1655. 51:45do you listen to and he grabbed my ear
  1656. 51:47thing and he stuck
  1657. 51:48my the one the left pulled the left he
  1658. 51:49stuck it in his ear
  1659. 51:51and there's some like you know partial
  1660. 51:52differential equations
  1661. 51:54you said what the hell is this right and
  1662. 51:57that but that's what i wanted to do when
  1663. 51:58i was biking and it helped me
  1664. 52:00to like take it in as i you know because
  1665. 52:02i was concentrating on listening
  1666. 52:03i could climb the hill better right so
  1667. 52:05that's my answer is if you love
  1668. 52:06something then do it and you could learn
  1669. 52:08all you
  1670. 52:09you want um and um and if you if you
  1671. 52:12have the intuition then then it'll come
  1672. 52:13to you
  1673. 52:14[Laughter]
  1674. 52:16that's a great little anecdote there um
  1675. 52:18yeah
  1676. 52:19just jumping back into uh modeling
  1677. 52:23before jumping on this call with you
  1678. 52:25wayne i spent
  1679. 52:26uh more time than i expected to
  1680. 52:28scrolling through your twitter feed it
  1681. 52:30was just
  1682. 52:30fantastic thank you one of the things i
  1683. 52:34pulled from it was you had a tweet about
  1684. 52:37trade frequency and the importance of it
  1685. 52:40and
  1686. 52:41i think you may have called it mastering
  1687. 52:42the art of trade frequency
  1688. 52:44so i just thought that would be an
  1689. 52:45interesting question to ask you
  1690. 52:47uh to get your thoughts on
  1691. 52:51the importance of trade frequency i
  1692. 52:53guess
  1693. 52:56trade frequency is i'll say i love that
  1694. 52:58idea
  1695. 52:59in the sense that there is no uh
  1696. 53:02right frequency right there's not
  1697. 53:04absolute version that
  1698. 53:05that works um and so the the new
  1699. 53:08the important point is that one has to
  1700. 53:12use multiple frequencies and
  1701. 53:13the market actually shifts a lot of the
  1702. 53:15time the the general behaviors don't
  1703. 53:17shift but the frequency shifts right so
  1704. 53:19markets
  1705. 53:20run up and down but at different
  1706. 53:22frequencies and so
  1707. 53:23to one it's very very hard to time just
  1708. 53:26like it's hard to time
  1709. 53:27a regime shift let's say from a value to
  1710. 53:29a growth regime or
  1711. 53:30on the broader level of factors it's
  1712. 53:33equally difficult if not more to
  1713. 53:35to really hone in on on the right
  1714. 53:37frequency
  1715. 53:38and or shift in that frequency so my
  1716. 53:41general approach and that's something
  1717. 53:42that we do in logica is to
  1718. 53:44have multiple frequencies running you
  1719. 53:47know at the same time and it's like
  1720. 53:49it it it i guess i liken it to hedging
  1721. 53:52right
  1722. 53:52so let's say i have one frequency in
  1723. 53:55which we do
  1724. 53:56which is which day trades right it makes
  1725. 53:57a trade per day and another frequency
  1726. 53:59let's say which uh twice a month trades
  1727. 54:03and another which is monthly right so
  1728. 54:04you have slower and slower
  1729. 54:06at different rates so what could happen
  1730. 54:07there is on a day trading level the
  1731. 54:09market's overdone
  1732. 54:11and so you you take some off the table
  1733. 54:13you sell some s p
  1734. 54:14let's say but the next day the you know
  1735. 54:16of course unemployment comes out
  1736. 54:18the number on friday much better than we
  1737. 54:20expected
  1738. 54:21uh right still drastic but of course
  1739. 54:23much better than the world thought
  1740. 54:25or the us thought and so boom the market
  1741. 54:27gaps up two percent so as much as the
  1742. 54:29day before was extended and you in your
  1743. 54:31day trade soul some
  1744. 54:32took some off the table on your on your
  1745. 54:34on your two week frequency trade
  1746. 54:36you you still were net long right so you
  1747. 54:39you're you're hedging
  1748. 54:40not being wrong um and so it's not that
  1749. 54:43you
  1750. 54:45it's not that one was wrong or not that
  1751. 54:46the day trade decision to take some off
  1752. 54:49the table was incorrect
  1753. 54:50it's that both were correct that each is
  1754. 54:53correct
  1755. 54:54under its own time frame and i can't
  1756. 54:55stress that enough and the market people
  1757. 54:57use these words of of you know that
  1758. 54:59you're
  1759. 54:59a profit or loss being right or wrong
  1760. 55:01it's not really right or wrong it's that
  1761. 55:03there's there's a lot of different
  1762. 55:07things going on and a day trader is
  1763. 55:10right
  1764. 55:10to have taken an over bought position
  1765. 55:12off the table
  1766. 55:13but if you're a month-long trader you
  1767. 55:15want to hold on to that mean expansion
  1768. 55:17longer
  1769. 55:18and so by having both you're hedging
  1770. 55:21your own
  1771. 55:22ability to to time and you're you're
  1772. 55:24taking both approaches that over time
  1773. 55:26can be successful and
  1774. 55:27of course merging them to have a more i
  1775. 55:30guess noise canceling the downs
  1776. 55:32and of course hopefully keeping the
  1777. 55:33alpha associated with your with whatever
  1778. 55:35edge you have in each frequency
  1779. 55:38wayne let me ask you one last question
  1780. 55:41as someone who mostly ignores
  1781. 55:43macro more focused on the math and in
  1782. 55:46their trading
  1783. 55:47what have been the greatest observations
  1784. 55:49for you from this recent market crash
  1785. 55:52and recovery like
  1786. 55:53as you said before it's probably been
  1787. 55:55the the greatest rise in markets which
  1788. 55:58we've seen for a long time
  1789. 55:59and i think very few people
  1790. 56:03expected to see this and people have
  1791. 56:05been making predictions everywhere and
  1792. 56:07almost everyone's been wrong about
  1793. 56:08what's actually happened
  1794. 56:10what has this taught you or what has
  1795. 56:11this if not taught you what does it
  1796. 56:13kind of enforced
  1797. 56:18it's enforced to keep on ignoring macro
  1798. 56:21as simple as that yeah yeah no i i i
  1799. 56:24two things i want to say that and then i
  1800. 56:26want to actually contradict myself in a
  1801. 56:28second but
  1802. 56:29um so the first thing is that what's
  1803. 56:32long been my premise is that nobody has
  1804. 56:34any idea
  1805. 56:34right it's just it i i with the funny
  1806. 56:37thing is i actually did a
  1807. 56:39interview um a while ago um which was
  1808. 56:42after the december 18 sell-off and
  1809. 56:45and the in january 19 recovery and what
  1810. 56:47i talked about on that
  1811. 56:49um on that cast was how wrong people got
  1812. 56:52it right in december of 18
  1813. 56:54as the market's selling off people are
  1814. 56:56saying our economy's done and this is it
  1815. 56:57the bubble is burst
  1816. 56:59and then not three weeks later in
  1817. 57:01january of 19
  1818. 57:02it's everything's back to normal the
  1819. 57:04market's right back up new highs and
  1820. 57:05like nothing happened and
  1821. 57:06you know i'll say i was talking about
  1822. 57:08how wrong everybody got it on that
  1823. 57:10you in the v and how how you know
  1824. 57:12doomsday though the world begot
  1825. 57:14and it became on on the initial initial
  1826. 57:17weeks in in december
  1827. 57:18and then suddenly how optimistic
  1828. 57:20everybody was in late january
  1829. 57:22and lo and behold the exact same thing
  1830. 57:24happens again
  1831. 57:25right in february march the world was
  1832. 57:27ending this was worse than 08 this was
  1833. 57:29going to be the
  1834. 57:30you know the the gloom we've all been
  1835. 57:32waiting for and here we are again
  1836. 57:34you know making having made new highs on
  1837. 57:36the nasdaq once
  1838. 57:37you know and close to it on the s p so
  1839. 57:41the the highlighted point is once again
  1840. 57:44nobody knows
  1841. 57:45once again uh people get the the
  1842. 57:48emotional behavioral side
  1843. 57:50really always just falls into the what's
  1844. 57:52happening now
  1845. 57:53and if you if you look at even the you
  1846. 57:55know the twitter environment of the
  1847. 57:56fintu it or
  1848. 57:57the media in general most of it and the
  1849. 58:00panic is associated with
  1850. 58:02what happened in the market today and
  1851. 58:03yesterday and that tells us so little
  1852. 58:06and and we're all the all the people
  1853. 58:07that follow that media
  1854. 58:09end up getting immersed in what's being
  1855. 58:11said now which is just a function of
  1856. 58:12what just happened
  1857. 58:13which inevitably tells us nothing about
  1858. 58:16the next two weeks
  1859. 58:17so i double tripled quadruple down on
  1860. 58:21that thesis
  1861. 58:22okay so that's that's where everything
  1862. 58:24stays the same on the other side of that
  1863. 58:26i i've had a really amazing new
  1864. 58:29experience in the in the last year where
  1865. 58:31actually logic took on a a new partner
  1866. 58:33somebody i
  1867. 58:34found enough met on twitter uh michael
  1868. 58:36green he he was
  1869. 58:37uh at the time he was working at teo
  1870. 58:39macro um
  1871. 58:40and he had traded in the vault space for
  1872. 58:42a while and and uh
  1873. 58:44so we came together and just having a a
  1874. 58:47common respect and understanding of what
  1875. 58:48each other was doing i guess
  1876. 58:50having found each other on twitter and
  1877. 58:52met and started talking about some stuff
  1878. 58:54that was for
  1879. 58:55i i didn't know about but he was sharing
  1880. 58:57with me that there was this
  1881. 58:58big reasoning from a macro perspective
  1882. 59:01of
  1883. 59:02why the trades i was putting on were
  1884. 59:04were working really well and you know he
  1885. 59:06he basically said to me is
  1886. 59:08like yeah you're producing alpha but
  1887. 59:09it's not all yours right
  1888. 59:11and in a very polite way like yeah maybe
  1889. 59:14you know you have something for sure but
  1890. 59:16there's there's more alpha associated
  1891. 59:18with what's happening in the market as a
  1892. 59:19function of
  1893. 59:20uh passive the growth of passive and how
  1894. 59:23that's distorting
  1895. 59:24the market where you have this um i'll
  1896. 59:27call it agnostic
  1897. 59:29buyer so a long-only buyer who who's
  1898. 59:31whose
  1899. 59:32basic model is if cash then buy right
  1900. 59:35it's a it's a um and and every two weeks
  1901. 59:38everybody's paycheck
  1902. 59:39dumps more money into this this this
  1903. 59:42premise if cash then buy and here's
  1904. 59:44every two weeks need more cash in
  1905. 59:45everybody's
  1906. 59:47retirement and of course uh corporate
  1907. 59:50match plans and all the rest trillions
  1908. 59:51of dollars that's going into this stuff
  1909. 59:53on a regular basis
  1910. 59:54just buying buying buy and by definition
  1911. 59:57exacerbating momentum because you're
  1912. 59:59uh the the more the stock is represented
  1913. 1:00:01in the s p
  1914. 1:00:02the more it gets bought so indeed
  1915. 1:00:04passive indexing is becomes the
  1916. 1:00:06self-fulfilling prophecy and so
  1917. 1:00:08all of his work around from a macro
  1918. 1:00:10perspective how
  1919. 1:00:11that has been influencing market
  1920. 1:00:13structure over the last 10 20 years and
  1921. 1:00:17really opened my eyes to this whole new
  1922. 1:00:19framework of macro which is not to say
  1923. 1:00:22we're going to use macro to predict the
  1924. 1:00:24future or to make a forecast about the
  1925. 1:00:26economy in six months
  1926. 1:00:27it's that we're gonna use macro to
  1927. 1:00:29understand the structure of the market
  1928. 1:00:31and therefore how we can better profit
  1929. 1:00:33off of that and so
  1930. 1:00:34integrating mike's work with what i was
  1931. 1:00:38doing
  1932. 1:00:38we now had a better mousetrap because we
  1933. 1:00:40could say okay
  1934. 1:00:41that does make sense that's why a
  1935. 1:00:43straddle you know
  1936. 1:00:45a lot of short vol exposure out there is
  1937. 1:00:47helping push down the pricing of our of
  1938. 1:00:49the vault we're trying to get long
  1939. 1:00:51uh and so this call overriding is
  1940. 1:00:53bringing down the price of of calls that
  1941. 1:00:54we're trying to get long
  1942. 1:00:56that's why there's a little bit more
  1943. 1:00:57alpha there so yes i had a good idea but
  1944. 1:01:00i was being helped by this larger
  1945. 1:01:02structural dynamic of the market and so
  1946. 1:01:05i
  1947. 1:01:05i now have come to a newfound
  1948. 1:01:08appreciation
  1949. 1:01:09for macro in its ability to
  1950. 1:01:12uh help explain what's going on and into
  1951. 1:01:16to help i guess uh structurally
  1952. 1:01:19uh build a model or to design a model to
  1953. 1:01:23what what could be more of the thesis
  1954. 1:01:24behind why something's working
  1955. 1:01:26uh and so again we're not using it for
  1956. 1:01:28making predictions other than saying hey
  1957. 1:01:30if this is going to continue which it
  1958. 1:01:32looks like it will
  1959. 1:01:33as as a as just in line with the us
  1960. 1:01:35population and
  1961. 1:01:36growth then the market should continue
  1962. 1:01:40to do this therefore we can make certain
  1963. 1:01:42beds therefore
  1964. 1:01:43uh we could bet more on extreme outcomes
  1965. 1:01:45therefore that what happened in february
  1966. 1:01:47march and now april may this
  1967. 1:01:49insane v in the market uh
  1968. 1:01:52was to be more expected given the
  1969. 1:01:54influence of passive this
  1970. 1:01:55explains it better therefore our tr
  1971. 1:01:58going back to what we were training
  1972. 1:01:59talking about before trade frequency if
  1973. 1:02:01that's the case
  1974. 1:02:02then we have to slow down our our or
  1975. 1:02:05perhaps speed up or
  1976. 1:02:06make changes to our trading cadence
  1977. 1:02:09because
  1978. 1:02:10this is the market will take on more
  1979. 1:02:11extremes based on the influence of
  1980. 1:02:14passive
  1981. 1:02:14so it just adds this whole new dimension
  1982. 1:02:16to what we're doing
  1983. 1:02:17uh and so for me it's a way to infuse
  1984. 1:02:20a macro view without actually being a
  1985. 1:02:22forecaster which is what i'm always
  1986. 1:02:24going to stay away from
  1987. 1:02:26that's brilliant wayne thank you very
  1988. 1:02:29much for coming on the podcast
  1989. 1:02:30very grateful for your time this has
  1990. 1:02:32been an incredible conversation
  1991. 1:02:34so um yeah once again thanks a lot for
  1992. 1:02:36coming on the podcast
  1993. 1:02:38uh if somebody wants to follow you or
  1994. 1:02:41connect with you online
  1995. 1:02:42where is the best place to do so and i
  1996. 1:02:45know you also have a non-profit as well
  1997. 1:02:47so would you like to give that a mention
  1998. 1:02:50uh sure yeah the non-profit wow that's i
  1999. 1:02:52started that back in 2003
  2000. 1:02:55um i just uh that's called informed by
  2001. 1:02:57nature it's i
  2002. 1:02:58i just love love uh i guess scientific
  2003. 1:03:01thinking and
  2004. 1:03:02rigorous experimentation and um this
  2005. 1:03:06mathematical view of the world and so i
  2006. 1:03:08as a believer in that i wanted to fund
  2007. 1:03:10some projects that
  2008. 1:03:11did that type of thing and um at one
  2009. 1:03:14point we were
  2010. 1:03:14we had this little solar cars and that
  2011. 1:03:17we had kids were building in a classroom
  2012. 1:03:19and
  2013. 1:03:19things like that it's done different
  2014. 1:03:20things right now we work with some uh
  2015. 1:03:22journalists who are promoting some um
  2016. 1:03:24kind of innovative scientific ideas
  2017. 1:03:27and another group that does a science
  2018. 1:03:30camp
  2019. 1:03:31for budding scientists younger
  2020. 1:03:33scientists or scientific thinkers and so
  2021. 1:03:35it's just a way to give back to the
  2022. 1:03:37world for for me
  2023. 1:03:39what has helped me so much in along my
  2024. 1:03:41path and the way i think
  2025. 1:03:43um so that's what that does and then how
  2026. 1:03:46to get a hold of me that's pretty easy i
  2027. 1:03:48guess i'm on twitter right and and
  2028. 1:03:49at to your point i've got my a lot that
  2029. 1:03:52i i like to say stuff
  2030. 1:03:53often and i've got a lot of thoughts
  2031. 1:03:54that i like to share so there
  2032. 1:03:56my handle is just my first and last name
  2033. 1:03:58at wayne hemelstein
  2034. 1:03:59um and so uh and from there my firm
  2035. 1:04:02logica of course we're at
  2036. 1:04:04logicofunds.com
  2037. 1:04:05so that's easy and um i guess you know
  2038. 1:04:07if one were to just
  2039. 1:04:08google me there would be and a lot of
  2040. 1:04:11stuff i'm sure
  2041. 1:04:12that's what a lot of people tell me
  2042. 1:04:14these days i think anyone's easy to find
  2043. 1:04:15right it's there
  2044. 1:04:16we're google away but yeah i i
  2045. 1:04:18definitely think that if someone's
  2046. 1:04:20interested in hearing more then my
  2047. 1:04:21twitter is a great place to start
  2048. 1:04:23because i
  2049. 1:04:23i love sharing my my thoughts as they
  2050. 1:04:25come yeah folks listening to this
  2051. 1:04:27podcast i would certainly encourage you
  2052. 1:04:29to follow wayne
  2053. 1:04:30on twitter uh you know there's very
  2054. 1:04:32little fluff
  2055. 1:04:33very little feel good stuff it's just a
  2056. 1:04:34lot of really wise thoughts so
  2057. 1:04:37we're worth your time wayne thanks once
  2058. 1:04:39again
  2059. 1:04:40and hopefully uh we'll chat again soon
  2060. 1:04:43thank you thank you very much
  2061. 1:04:46you've reached the end of this episode
  2062. 1:04:48of chat with traders
  2063. 1:04:49but rest assured there are more episodes
  2064. 1:04:52loaded with real market insight and zero
  2065. 1:04:54hype
  2066. 1:04:55on the way soon so to stay updated with
  2067. 1:04:58each great new release
  2068. 1:04:59subscribe to the podcast and itunes and
  2069. 1:05:02we'd love it if you leave a rating and
  2070. 1:05:03review
  2071. 1:05:04we'll catch you next time on chat with
  2072. 1:05:06traders
  2073. 1:05:08[Music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Betting Against Stability · Wayne Himelsein by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,733 words across 2,073 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.