YouTube2Text

Bad Worldbuilding vs Good Worldbuilding (Writing Advice) — Transcript

by Writer Brandon McNulty · 4,447 words · 668 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Get ready cuz your world is about to
  2. 0:02change. Today we're going to separate
  3. 0:03bad world building from good world
  4. 0:05building. The way this works is that
  5. 0:07we'll discuss what makes worldbuilding
  6. 0:09engaging. Then we'll look at specific
  7. 0:11types of bad world building. For each
  8. 0:13type, I'll give you a bad example from a
  9. 0:15story and I'll explain why it sucks.
  10. 0:17Then I'll give you a good example and
  11. 0:19explain why that one works. Quick note
  12. 0:22before we start. This week I'm giving
  13. 0:24away free audiobook copies of my writing
  14. 0:26guide, Story Made Simple. If you want to
  15. 0:28enter to win, leave a comment about your
  16. 0:31favorite or least favorite example of
  17. 0:33worldbuing and include the word
  18. 0:34audiobook somewhere in your comment.
  19. 0:37I'll pick one random winner per day.
  20. 0:39Now, let's start off by answering the
  21. 0:40question, what makes world building
  22. 0:42engaging? I came up with six things. The
  23. 0:46first is when there's emotion before
  24. 0:48exposition. This is the number one thing
  25. 0:50to keep in mind with world building.
  26. 0:52Always remember to create an emotional
  27. 0:54experience before you start info
  28. 0:56dumping. This means helping us
  29. 0:57understand a character's relationship to
  30. 0:59their world. Does it make them feel
  31. 1:01strong? Does it make them feel
  32. 1:02threatened? Do they have mixed feelings
  33. 1:04about the world? Whatever it is, lead
  34. 1:06with emotion before spilling details.
  35. 1:09Remember the parking garage scene from
  36. 1:10the Terminator? There's a major info
  37. 1:13dump here, but it works well because by
  38. 1:14this point, we care about Sarah Connor.
  39. 1:17We recognize that she's in danger. And
  40. 1:19when Kyle Ree explains the future war,
  41. 1:21we care about that info because it's
  42. 1:23emotionally relevant to Sarah. Second
  43. 1:26thing that makes world building engaging
  44. 1:28is settings and sensory details. Setting
  45. 1:31is what usually comes to mind when
  46. 1:32people think of world building. They
  47. 1:34picture vivid landscapes or isolated
  48. 1:37haunted houses or floating cities in a
  49. 1:39galaxy far, far away. And setting is
  50. 1:41important. It's the present-day world
  51. 1:43that your character experiences. In
  52. 1:46order to make it work, you have to
  53. 1:47provide sensory details. Obviously, show
  54. 1:50us what it looks like, but also hit on
  55. 1:52the other four senses as well. What does
  56. 1:54it sound like? feel like, smell like,
  57. 1:56and taste like. Sometimes senses other
  58. 1:58than sight and sound can be hard to
  59. 2:00incorporate, but consider things like
  60. 2:02the temperature in the room or the smell
  61. 2:04of a dead body at a crime scene or the
  62. 2:06taste of salty air near the beach. There
  63. 2:08are plenty of possibilities, so look for
  64. 2:10opportunities to engage the senses and
  65. 2:13bring the setting to life. Third thing
  66. 2:15that makes world building engaging, lore
  67. 2:17that layers out the world. If setting is
  68. 2:20the world's present, then lore is its
  69. 2:22past. But lore is much more than just
  70. 2:25backstory. It's a tool for making your
  71. 2:27world feel layered and lived in. Even
  72. 2:29little details about the past go a long
  73. 2:31way. Think about Die Hard. Most of the
  74. 2:34movie takes place in an office building.
  75. 2:35Yet throughout the story, we get nuggets
  76. 2:37of lore that paint a picture of the
  77. 2:39larger world. John Mlan is a New York
  78. 2:42cop with a backlog of cases back home.
  79. 2:44John's former captain retired out near
  80. 2:46LA in a town called Pomona. Then the
  81. 2:48villain, Hans Gruber, he was once a
  82. 2:50member of a German terrorist group. and
  83. 2:52Joe Takagi, he grew up in Japan before
  84. 2:54working his way up to the head of the
  85. 2:55Nakatomi company. All these things paint
  86. 2:58the picture of a larger world beyond the
  87. 3:00setting. Lore can be especially critical
  88. 3:02in certain types of stories like
  89. 3:04mysteries. Right now, I'm playing a game
  90. 3:06called Emo the Smiling Man. It's a
  91. 3:09murder mystery where a private
  92. 3:10investigator has to solve a case
  93. 3:12involving a victim who was strangled and
  94. 3:14left with a paper bag over his head. The
  95. 3:16story comes alive when we learn about
  96. 3:18similar murders from 18 years ago, as
  97. 3:20well as an urban legend about the
  98. 3:21Smiling Man, this entity who kills
  99. 3:23people with depression unless they smile
  100. 3:26back at him. The past lore is what
  101. 3:28spices up the present-day stakes and
  102. 3:30deepens the overall mystery. Fourth
  103. 3:32thing that makes world building engaging
  104. 3:33is appropriate atmosphere. Atmosphere is
  105. 3:37the world's personality. I like to think
  106. 3:39of it as what you get when you combine
  107. 3:40the setting with the lore. A setting on
  108. 3:43its own can certainly create atmospheric
  109. 3:45vibes, but lore is what deepens our
  110. 3:47understanding of the world and juices up
  111. 3:49that atmosphere. For example, in the
  112. 3:51movie The Thing, the setting is an
  113. 3:53Arctic research station. This alone
  114. 3:55generates an isolated vibe, but things
  115. 3:58get much darker when we learn about
  116. 3:59brutal murders that recently took place
  117. 4:01at a nearby camp and how an alien
  118. 4:03spacecraft had been frozen under the ice
  119. 4:05for centuries. Another thing to keep in
  120. 4:07mind with atmosphere is tone. Tone is
  121. 4:10the writer's attitude toward the story,
  122. 4:12and it's usually either serious or
  123. 4:14light-hearted. We can, of course, switch
  124. 4:16between tones, and when done well, this
  125. 4:18can keep the atmosphere fresh. However,
  126. 4:20if we get careless, we might create
  127. 4:22tonal shifts that clash with the
  128. 4:23atmosphere and ruin it. This is one of
  129. 4:25the major problems with Metroid Prime 4.
  130. 4:28Now, for context, the Metroid series has
  131. 4:30always relied on a dark, mysterious, and
  132. 4:32isolating atmosphere that enriches its
  133. 4:35hostile sci-fi worlds. Prime 4 aims for
  134. 4:38this early on, but then it introduces
  135. 4:40this cartoony comic relief character who
  136. 4:43clashes with the established tone.
  137. 4:44>> HEY, MISS
  138. 4:46COMING OUT.
  139. 4:48>> It's about to get real nerdy in here.
  140. 4:51>> The worst part is this guy just doesn't
  141. 4:53go away. Even after Samus escorts him to
  142. 4:55his objective, he continues to interrupt
  143. 4:57her with radio calls. And every time the
  144. 5:00atmosphere starts to reassert itself, he
  145. 5:02opens his mouth again and kills it.
  146. 5:04Fifth thing that makes world building
  147. 5:05engaging is consistent rules. When we
  148. 5:09talk about rules, we're talking about
  149. 5:10how a world works in terms of its logic.
  150. 5:13A fantasy world infused with magic is
  151. 5:15going to have a different set of rules
  152. 5:16than contemporary America. And likewise,
  153. 5:19contemporary America is going to have a
  154. 5:21different set of rules than contemporary
  155. 5:23Japan. Rules affect everything from
  156. 5:25power structures to society's
  157. 5:27expectations to magic systems. This also
  158. 5:30includes the special abilities of
  159. 5:31mythical creatures such as werewolves,
  160. 5:33unicorns, Trevor Lawrence, etc. And when
  161. 5:36introducing rules, focus on the ones
  162. 5:38that are relevant to your story and
  163. 5:40characters. If you're telling a story
  164. 5:42about teenagers getting busted for
  165. 5:44underage drinking, then sure, mention
  166. 5:46the drinking age and legal consequences.
  167. 5:49But if you're telling a story about a
  168. 5:5070-year-old man drinking beers out on
  169. 5:52his porch, the drinking age is
  170. 5:54irrelevant. Finally, the last thing that
  171. 5:56makes world building engaging is when it
  172. 5:58acts as its own character. This is the
  173. 6:01secret weapon to remember with
  174. 6:03worldbuing. Always think of it as a
  175. 6:05character that impacts and is impacted
  176. 6:08by the actual cast. This idea is most
  177. 6:11obvious when the conflict involves man
  178. 6:13versus nature, but don't sleep on this
  179. 6:15advice in other types of stories. Think
  180. 6:17about Harry Potter and how the rules of
  181. 6:19the wizarding world both help and hinder
  182. 6:21him. Or think about Game of Thrones and
  183. 6:23its complex power dynamics and how
  184. 6:25characters create ripple effects through
  185. 6:27the world that shape alliances and
  186. 6:29warrant punishments. Or think about a
  187. 6:31movie like When Harry Met Sally, where
  188. 6:33city life brings the two main characters
  189. 6:35together on various occasions. If you're
  190. 6:37ever stuck in a story, ask yourself,
  191. 6:39what can my setting, lore, atmosphere,
  192. 6:42or rules do that can steer my characters
  193. 6:45and plot in a new direction? All right,
  194. 6:47now it's time for the bad versus good.
  195. 6:49I'm going to give you four types of bad
  196. 6:51world building. I'll explain what each
  197. 6:53one is. Then I'll give you a bad example
  198. 6:55to illustrate what I mean. And I'll
  199. 6:57explain why it sucks. And then I'll give
  200. 6:59you a good example that does the job
  201. 7:01better. And I'll explain why that one
  202. 7:02works. First bad type is the empty
  203. 7:05world. This is a shallow one-dimensional
  204. 7:08world that acts as a backdrop for the
  205. 7:10story, nothing more. It may lack lore or
  206. 7:13rules. The atmosphere usually falls flat
  207. 7:16and the world has minimal impact on the
  208. 7:18characters and plot. For a bad example,
  209. 7:21let's look at Terrifier. Now, right up
  210. 7:23front, I want to say that I love this
  211. 7:25movie and I love the franchise that it
  212. 7:27spawned. Art the Clown is my favorite
  213. 7:29horror character to emerge in recent
  214. 7:31years, and Terrifier 1 is on my Mount
  215. 7:33Rushmore of guilty pleasures, which
  216. 7:35includes movies like Rocky 4, Revenge of
  217. 7:37the Sith, and Jurassic Park 3. So, don't
  218. 7:40mistake my criticism here for hatred.
  219. 7:42That said, the world building in this
  220. 7:44movie is atrocious. The setting, if you
  221. 7:46could call it that, is this generic
  222. 7:48American town called Miles County. What
  223. 7:50is there to say about Miles County?
  224. 7:52Well, nothing at all, really. The only
  225. 7:54thing I know about Miles County is that
  226. 7:55it has a strip mall, a creepy building,
  227. 7:58and some empty streets. And they're not
  228. 8:00even empty in an unsettling way. They're
  229. 8:02just plain old empty. Now, you might
  230. 8:04think, well, okay, the setting sucks,
  231. 8:06but it's a low-budget movie, so cut it
  232. 8:08some slack. Let's take a look at the
  233. 8:10lore. Surely there has to be some
  234. 8:11nuggets of lore that get sprinkled in to
  235. 8:13expand the world a bit, right? Well, the
  236. 8:16main character, Tara, she has a sister
  237. 8:18who goes to a college within driving
  238. 8:19distance, and that's it. Then there's
  239. 8:22this radio station, and you might think
  240. 8:23the DJ would talk about local events or
  241. 8:26a sports team or anything to clue us in
  242. 8:28on what daily life is like in this area,
  243. 8:30but all the radio does is tell the
  244. 8:32characters that Art the Clown is killing
  245. 8:33people, which we of course already know.
  246. 8:35Then you might ask, well, what about the
  247. 8:37characters themselves? Do they have any
  248. 8:39personal connection to this world? Do
  249. 8:40they have any history within it? And
  250. 8:42here's the thing. When we get introduced
  251. 8:44to the two main characters, all we learn
  252. 8:45is that they just came from a bar where
  253. 8:47they got drunk and that's it. There's
  254. 8:50nothing about where they go to school or
  255. 8:51if they go to school or if they have
  256. 8:53jobs or anything at all that might
  257. 8:55connect them to this world. The other
  258. 8:57characters we meet, we just meet like
  259. 8:58this exterminator guy who just works as
  260. 9:00an exterminator. That's it. He doesn't
  261. 9:02have anything beyond this. And then
  262. 9:03there's a homeless woman who lives
  263. 9:05inside the building that he's
  264. 9:06fumigating. And that's it. That's all
  265. 9:08this world has to offer. So yeah, this
  266. 9:10one sucks because the setting is a
  267. 9:12shallow, lifeless backdrop. There's
  268. 9:15limited lore surrounding the town and
  269. 9:17its businesses. There's one-dimensional
  270. 9:19characters who have no lives outside of
  271. 9:21the present moment. And as a result, the
  272. 9:23atmosphere falls flat, and Art the Clown
  273. 9:25has to carry the movie all by himself.
  274. 9:28For a good example, let's look at John
  275. 9:30Wick. One thing that separates this
  276. 9:32movie from the 63 million other action
  277. 9:34thrillers out there is its unique
  278. 9:36worldbuing. It takes a minimalist
  279. 9:38approach to its setting while using lore
  280. 9:41to invite audiences to imagine a larger
  281. 9:43world beyond the screen. The movie opens
  282. 9:46with Jon mourning the death of his wife.
  283. 9:48And as simple as this is, it signals
  284. 9:50that the world has been lived in. Later,
  285. 9:52we learn that Jon has a past connection
  286. 9:54to the Russian mob. And that's when the
  287. 9:56juicier details start trickling out.
  288. 9:58Little by little, we learn about things
  289. 10:00like the impossible task that Jon
  290. 10:02completed or these special coins that
  291. 10:04enable him to pay for services in the
  292. 10:06criminal underworld or his friendly
  293. 10:08relationship with a local cop who knows
  294. 10:10not to interfere with his business. Then
  295. 10:11we get introduced to the Continental
  296. 10:13Hotel, a safe haven for assassins that
  297. 10:16has its own set of rules. Most notably,
  298. 10:18the rule that no murders may be
  299. 10:20committed on hotel grounds. And speaking
  300. 10:22of the hotel grounds, we see countless
  301. 10:24assassins wandering through the place.
  302. 10:26And as we see them, we can only wonder
  303. 10:28what business they may have conducted in
  304. 10:30the past or what business they plan to
  305. 10:32conduct in the future. This works
  306. 10:33because a simple setting is enhanced by
  307. 10:36small yet explosive details. We get
  308. 10:38intriguing hints about the criminal
  309. 10:40underworld. And thankfully, the movie
  310. 10:42doesn't overexlain its rules, economy,
  311. 10:44or anything else. Instead, the world
  312. 10:47building shines because it provides
  313. 10:48small hints that invite the audience to
  314. 10:50participate in the storytelling. Beyond
  315. 10:53that, there are several mysteries
  316. 10:54surrounding Jon and his past. And though
  317. 10:57Jon himself is quiet and reserved about
  318. 10:59his history, it nonetheless feels rich
  319. 11:02because of how he's regarded by the
  320. 11:04people within this world. Second type of
  321. 11:06bad world is the unconvincing world. And
  322. 11:10this is one that may include flashy
  323. 11:11ideas, but it lacks important details or
  324. 11:15logic that makes the world believable.
  325. 11:17As a result, large-scale stakes feel
  326. 11:19hollow. There's little meaning beyond
  327. 11:21the small personal conflicts, and
  328. 11:23everything feels more like an obstacle
  329. 11:25course than a true universe. For a bad
  330. 11:28example, let's look at the movie
  331. 11:30Divergent. This is a sci-fi story set in
  332. 11:33a dystopia where people are divided into
  333. 11:35factions based on their personality
  334. 11:37type. It's kind of like using the
  335. 11:39sorting hat to organize society. And
  336. 11:41there are five groups. One group is
  337. 11:43Abnigation, which is made of these
  338. 11:45selfless people who somehow run the
  339. 11:47government. Then you have Dauntless who
  340. 11:49serve as the military. And then there's
  341. 11:50Arudite, who I'm told are these evil,
  342. 11:52smart people who want to take over. And
  343. 11:54finally, there's Hufflepuff and
  344. 11:56Ravenclaw to pad things out. Now, the
  345. 11:58main character, Tris, she comes from an
  346. 12:00abnigation family, but she chooses
  347. 12:02Dauntless, and we get to see her
  348. 12:04battling her way up the ranks to prove
  349. 12:06that she belongs. What we don't get to
  350. 12:08see, however, is the larger world
  351. 12:10itself. The movie opens with a brief
  352. 12:12overview of how this society is
  353. 12:14organized, but we don't get to
  354. 12:15experience what everyday life is like.
  355. 12:18We do get occasional hints that Arudite
  356. 12:20wants to take power away from
  357. 12:21abnigation, but we don't really know
  358. 12:23what that means or what's at stake for
  359. 12:25the greater world. Instead, the story
  360. 12:27zeros in on Tris and her training. Now,
  361. 12:29don't get me wrong, her personal journey
  362. 12:31of defining herself is important, but
  363. 12:33the bigger picture here carries no
  364. 12:35weight. Anytime there was a break in the
  365. 12:37action, I kept asking myself, why should
  366. 12:39I care about what happens in this world?
  367. 12:41What's at stake? Why should I root for
  368. 12:43Tris to defeat the bad guys? It's
  369. 12:45unclear exactly why these factions are
  370. 12:47fighting for power. And if Ardodke gets
  371. 12:49power, I guess things will get worse. I
  372. 12:51don't know. And this sucks because
  373. 12:53interesting ideas and rules are let down
  374. 12:55by unclear stakes. The personal journeys
  375. 12:58matter, but there's a lack of
  376. 13:00large-scale context. There's also a lack
  377. 13:03of lore that makes the world feel like
  378. 13:04it only existed for 5 minutes and this
  379. 13:07leads to a flat atmosphere and the world
  380. 13:09as a whole ends up feeling like a
  381. 13:10generic dystopia rather than something
  382. 13:13original and meaningful. For a good
  383. 13:15example, let's look at Lord of the
  384. 13:17Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring. Now,
  385. 13:19obviously, Middle Earth has vivid
  386. 13:21settings, loads of lore, a full spectrum
  387. 13:24of atmosphere, and plenty of rules,
  388. 13:26systems, and structures in place. It's a
  389. 13:28well-designed world, but more
  390. 13:30importantly, it's a believable one that
  391. 13:32gives context to the characters
  392. 13:34journeys. Right from the get-go, we
  393. 13:36learn what's at stake in Middle Earth.
  394. 13:38And just like Divergent, Lord of the
  395. 13:40Rings opens with a voice over that clues
  396. 13:42us in on the world building. But here,
  397. 13:44we also learn about historical battles
  398. 13:46and sacrifices, as well as the looming
  399. 13:48threat of Sauron and the ring that acts
  400. 13:50as his source of power. From there, we
  401. 13:53get introduced to the present-day
  402. 13:54setting and those who populate it. We
  403. 13:56meet humans, hobbits, elves, and
  404. 13:58dwarves, all of whom have strengths and
  405. 14:00weaknesses, preferences, and grudges,
  406. 14:03and they're all impacted by the world
  407. 14:05while attempting to impact it
  408. 14:06themselves. As we learn about the
  409. 14:08characters, we learn about the world.
  410. 14:10Arguments flesh out the past and remind
  411. 14:12us of the present threat. Grudges must
  412. 14:14be pushed aside for the greater good,
  413. 14:16and the ring must be destroyed because
  414. 14:17if it isn't, Sauron will destroy the
  415. 14:19world and those who inhabit it. And this
  416. 14:21works because clear big picture stakes
  417. 14:24provide meaningful context for the
  418. 14:26characterser's personal journeys.
  419. 14:28Humans, hobbits, elves, and dwarves are
  420. 14:30introduced at a steady pace, and their
  421. 14:32relationship with the world makes it
  422. 14:33more believable. Lore adds clarity,
  423. 14:36stakes, and depth, and the story not
  424. 14:38only establishes the threat early, but
  425. 14:40it builds it up throughout the movie and
  426. 14:42throughout its sequels. The third bad
  427. 14:45type is the abandoned world. This is
  428. 14:47when a story opens with high impact,
  429. 14:50meaningful worldbuing events, but the
  430. 14:52story fails to explore the aftermath
  431. 14:54effectively. The world has limited
  432. 14:56influence on the characters. The
  433. 14:58atmosphere doesn't ring true, and the
  434. 15:00story retreats into safe plot
  435. 15:02developments and tropes. For a bad
  436. 15:05example, let's look at season 6 of 24.
  437. 15:0824 is my favorite TV show of all time,
  438. 15:11but I always like to beat up on season 6
  439. 15:13because that's what fans do. Now, for
  440. 15:16context, this show is about federal
  441. 15:17agent Jack Bower and his never-ending
  442. 15:20battle against terrorism. Throughout the
  443. 15:22first five seasons, he thwarts multiple
  444. 15:24threats to the city of Los Angeles. And
  445. 15:26after having Jack repeatedly rescue the
  446. 15:28city from doom, the writers decided to
  447. 15:30do something bold at the start of season
  448. 15:326. What they did is they had the
  449. 15:34terrorists detonate a nuke in Los
  450. 15:36Angeles, like an actual nuke. It goes
  451. 15:38off at the end of the fourth episode,
  452. 15:40and with 20 episodes left to go in the
  453. 15:42season, there's plenty of time to
  454. 15:44explore the chaos in the aftermath. You
  455. 15:46would think that this would cause a
  456. 15:47city-wide panic, and there would be
  457. 15:49lawlessness, and it would make life
  458. 15:50difficult for Jack as he attempts to
  459. 15:52locate the remaining nukes. But instead
  460. 15:54of exploring the effects of a nuclear
  461. 15:56weapon going off in Los Angeles, the
  462. 15:58story sweeps it under the rug. And by
  463. 16:00mid-season, it feels like another
  464. 16:02typical 24 storyline where Jack has to
  465. 16:04survive shootouts, bureaucracy, and a
  466. 16:07cast of corrupt villains. And this sucks
  467. 16:09because it introduces a bold
  468. 16:11worldbuilding gimmick, but fails to
  469. 16:13explore it effectively. It raises the
  470. 16:15stakes, then ignores the consequences,
  471. 16:17and we're left with world building that
  472. 16:19exists purely for spectacle and shock
  473. 16:21value. As a result, the atmosphere
  474. 16:23suffers, and the story falls apart over
  475. 16:26time. For a good example, let's look at
  476. 16:28Saving Private Ryan. The opening battle
  477. 16:31from this one is arguably the most
  478. 16:33iconic war scene from a movie. I won't
  479. 16:35show any blood or gore because I know
  480. 16:37some of you eat lunch while watching my
  481. 16:39videos, but the Omaha Beach sequence is
  482. 16:41something special. It's horrific, but
  483. 16:43also mesmerizing, and it unloads some
  484. 16:46powerful emotions. Every time I watch
  485. 16:48it, the part that absolutely guts me is
  486. 16:50when the American soldiers are on the
  487. 16:51boats and the ramps get lowered. You
  488. 16:53have these guys in their late teens,
  489. 16:55early 20s, and they don't even make it
  490. 16:56off the boat. They just get shot right
  491. 16:58there. There's all this hype and then
  492. 17:00boom, they're just dead. It's brutal to
  493. 17:02think about. I mean, nowadays, we spend
  494. 17:04early adulthood with things like
  495. 17:05PlayStation, YouTube, and one day
  496. 17:07shipping, and then you see these guys
  497. 17:08and what they had to go through. It's
  498. 17:10just brutal stuff. And I bring this up
  499. 17:12because the opening battle is a
  500. 17:14fantastic piece of world building. It
  501. 17:16transports us to a nasty, merciless
  502. 17:18world where bravery and good intentions
  503. 17:20aren't rewarded. Men die in the most
  504. 17:23horrific ways. And once this battle
  505. 17:25sequence is over, we have a clear sense
  506. 17:27of this war and how gruesome it is. Now,
  507. 17:29since the movie opens with a massive
  508. 17:31battle, audiences might expect it to
  509. 17:33deliver more of this epic, highstakes
  510. 17:35stuff. But instead, it opts to tell a
  511. 17:38more personal story about a rescue
  512. 17:40mission. Tom Hanks and his crew have to
  513. 17:42seek out Matt Damon, who landed in
  514. 17:44German territory after driving off at
  515. 17:46the end of Goodwill Hunting. Once Hanks
  516. 17:47and his crew set out, there are no more
  517. 17:49epic D-Day scale battles. But that's not
  518. 17:52a crime against worldbuing. Not at all.
  519. 17:54The effects of the opening sequence are
  520. 17:56felt throughout the story as the
  521. 17:57characters fight smaller skirmishes, as
  522. 17:59they reflect on those they've lost, as
  523. 18:01they consider their own mortality, and
  524. 18:03as they face the ever evolving
  525. 18:05consequences of the D-Day invasion.
  526. 18:07Though the action quiets down, the world
  527. 18:09building heats up as we learn more about
  528. 18:11the characters and the deadly universe
  529. 18:13they find themselves in. And this works
  530. 18:16because the movie uses a bold highstakes
  531. 18:18historical event to establish emotion,
  532. 18:21setting, and atmosphere. From there, the
  533. 18:24story continues in a new direction while
  534. 18:26introducing personal stakes and allowing
  535. 18:29characters to feel the effects of the
  536. 18:30D-Day invasion. Finally, the world
  537. 18:33continues to develop as the plot
  538. 18:34progresses and we get a greater sense of
  539. 18:37the overall war. Finally, the fourth bad
  540. 18:40type is the overexplained world. And
  541. 18:43this is when a story trips all over
  542. 18:45itself while trying to explain its
  543. 18:47worldbuilding. It tries too hard to
  544. 18:49establish clarity by using info dumps.
  545. 18:51It force-feeds lore and rules and
  546. 18:54mysterious questions, things that are
  547. 18:56actually interesting. Those questions
  548. 18:57are immediately answered, which kills
  549. 18:59curiosity and also kills suspense. For a
  550. 19:03bad example, let's look at Avatar. And
  551. 19:05the first 30 minutes of this movie are a
  552. 19:08worldbuing nightmare. The story is so
  553. 19:10concerned with setting the stage and
  554. 19:12explaining itself that it never allows
  555. 19:14the audience to become curious about the
  556. 19:16world or settle into it. The movie opens
  557. 19:19with Jake Sullie telling us about his
  558. 19:21situation. He's a parapolgic former
  559. 19:23marine who gets recruited to replace his
  560. 19:25deceased twin brother in the Avatar
  561. 19:27program. What's the Avatar program?
  562. 19:30Well, he tells us about it. Then he
  563. 19:32tells us about Pandora and who his
  564. 19:33brother was and the company behind it
  565. 19:35all. And it's infodump. Info dump. Info
  566. 19:38dump. Then about 12 minutes in, the
  567. 19:40movie mentions Avatar training, which
  568. 19:42sounds interesting. It's a simple idea,
  569. 19:44yet it makes you wonder what the
  570. 19:46training consists of. This would be the
  571. 19:48perfect time to switch to another scene
  572. 19:49and allow the audience to feel suspense
  573. 19:51and use their imagination. But instead,
  574. 19:54the script immediately tells us what the
  575. 19:56training is. Then, next thing you know,
  576. 19:58we're bombarded with log books and
  577. 20:00excessive details, and the explanations
  578. 20:02just never quit. At 15 minutes in, we
  579. 20:05get an As You Know Bob exchange about
  580. 20:07Jake's brother. Then at 17 minutes in,
  581. 20:09we get introduced to unoptanium, which
  582. 20:11is immediately explained to us. Then
  583. 20:13around 30 minutes in, we meet these
  584. 20:15strange animals that might be dangerous.
  585. 20:17But don't worry, because we're
  586. 20:18immediately told they're not aggressive.
  587. 20:20It's just one explanation after another,
  588. 20:23and this sucks because it overwhelms the
  589. 20:25audience with info dumps and lectures.
  590. 20:28The world building has no time to
  591. 20:30breathe, and interesting details lead to
  592. 20:32explanations instead of emotions. There
  593. 20:35is lore and it's plentiful, but we get
  594. 20:37buried underneath it. This causes the
  595. 20:40atmosphere to struggle to develop. And
  596. 20:42worst of all, the constant lecturing
  597. 20:44makes this potentially intriguing world
  598. 20:46feel safe and sterile. For a good
  599. 20:49example, let's look at Clare Obscure
  600. 20:52Expedition 33. This won game of the year
  601. 20:55for many reasons, and the world building
  602. 20:57was a major part of the experience. The
  603. 21:00story opens by introducing us to two
  604. 21:02people, Gustav and Myel. Who are they?
  605. 21:04What's their relationship to one
  606. 21:06another? Well, we don't know quite yet,
  607. 21:08and that's okay. We do know that
  608. 21:10something important is about to happen
  609. 21:11to a woman Gustav once loved, and now he
  610. 21:14wants to talk to her before this event
  611. 21:15occurs. He and Myel head off to meet
  612. 21:17her. And as they hurry through their
  613. 21:19home city, we see a gorgeous setting,
  614. 21:21and oh, look, magic. They can use it to
  615. 21:24travel across rooftops, and the
  616. 21:25characters take it all in stride because
  617. 21:27this is everyday to them. They have more
  618. 21:29important things to discuss. Questions
  619. 21:31are raised, but not all are answered. We
  620. 21:33hear about someone called the paintress,
  621. 21:35and we're left to wonder who this
  622. 21:36paintress is. What does she want? And
  623. 21:39how did she become so powerful? Rather
  624. 21:41than explaining things to the audience,
  625. 21:43the characters head into the center of
  626. 21:44town, which holds atmosphere and energy.
  627. 21:47And then there's an emotional moment
  628. 21:48between Gustav and his former love
  629. 21:50before a major event occurs. Before
  630. 21:53long, we learn about the expeditions
  631. 21:54that have been launched to stop the
  632. 21:56paintress. The upcoming one is
  633. 21:58Expedition 33, and there have been
  634. 22:00dozens that have failed before, which
  635. 22:02sets our imaginations on fire with
  636. 22:04wonder. It makes us curious about how
  637. 22:06this world works and why these people
  638. 22:07must participate in these doomed
  639. 22:09journeys. We're eager to learn more. And
  640. 22:12best of all, instead of having it
  641. 22:14immediately explained to us, we get to
  642. 22:16naturally experience the world alongside
  643. 22:18Gustav, Myel, and their friends. And
  644. 22:21this works because it presents emotional
  645. 22:23worldbuing details without immediate
  646. 22:26explanations. It invites us to be
  647. 22:28curious about this unique world and it
  648. 22:31answers some questions while keeping us
  649. 22:33guessing about others. It also surprises
  650. 22:35us with magical abilities and shocking
  651. 22:38events. And the world impacts the
  652. 22:40characters who attempt to impact the
  653. 22:42world. So, I hope this helps. Question
  654. 22:45of the day, what are some of the worst
  655. 22:47or best examples of worldb buildinging
  656. 22:49that you've come across in a story? Let
  657. 22:52us know in the comments section below.
  658. 22:54Thank you for watching. If you want to
  659. 22:56support the channel, please pick up a
  660. 22:57copy of any one of my books, and be sure
  661. 22:59to leave reviews on Amazon. Story Made
  662. 23:02Simple is great if you're a writer. It
  663. 23:04covers the eight key elements of
  664. 23:06storytelling, and it does so in
  665. 23:08nononsense fashion. Also, be sure to
  666. 23:10check out my other videos, like, share,
  667. 23:12and subscribe. Maybe support me on
  668. 23:14Patreon.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Bad Worldbuilding vs Good Worldbuilding (Writing Advice) by Writer Brandon McNulty, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,447 words across 668 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.