Вся правда про СЕТЕВОЙ бизнес: развод, миллионы или новая религия? | Александр Перевезенцев — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I can teach you all right now how to
- 0:02spot a Ponzi scheme. That's it.
- 0:04What was it?
- 0:06It was a real pyramid scheme, a
- 0:08risky business.
- 0:09I wasn't there. I didn't know Mavrogi
- 0:12personally.
- 0:13The followers, let's call them that,
- 0:15deceived them. We're shutting down and
- 0:17running.
- 0:18Seriously. I've been
- 0:20taking dietary supplements since I was
- 0:2118. Where's the
- 0:22negativity coming from?
- 0:23From the fireplace.
- 0:24Cool. I need the
- 0:25worst, always the majority. I think
- 0:28you're holding back a little here, of
- 0:32course.
- 0:33Friends, today is going to be a blast.
- 0:34ML and network marketing sounds like
- 0:37some kind of insulting expression for
- 0:39the people who do it. It sounds like a
- 0:41pyramid scam. Is that true or not? Why
- 0:45do some projects end so quickly and
- 0:47people lose their money, while others
- 0:49make money, and some companies are 140
- 0:52years old? And why did Alfa-Bank start
- 0:55using network marketing methods in its
- 0:57operating model? We'll be discussing
- 0:59this today. My guest is Alexander
- 1:02Perevezentsev. Alexander, hello.
- 1:04Hello. Hello. You've raised a great
- 1:06topic; we'll talk about it today. When
- 1:07you said "ml," it was almost like a
- 1:10swear word, like "Mmmm," but not "Mmmm,
- 1:12"
- 1:12absolutely not. Yes, that's exactly how
- 1:14it sounds for most people. And today,
- 1:15my friends, I want to structure our
- 1:17episode in exactly this way. I'm a
- 1:18little skeptical about this type of
- 1:21business. Alexander will insist that
- 1:23this is a good, correct business that
- 1:25can be successfully developed, and that
- 1:28it's all clean and environmentally
- 1:30friendly, and even allows you to become
- 1:32a different person. Alexander's goal is
- 1:34to convince me that I was wrong. And
- 1:36after this episode, please decide and
- 1:38write in the comments whose beliefs and
- 1:41arguments have become more important,
- 1:43better, and more interesting to you.
- 1:50Alexander, let's get started. And
- 1:52anyway, let's give a little
- 1:53introduction. What is the MLM business
- 1:56model?
- 1:56Let's get started. What is any business
- 1:58anyway? It's sales. Well, because you
- 2:01can produce anything—a huge number of
- 2:04washing machines, vacuum cleaners,
- 2:06refrigerators, food. But if it's not
- 2:09sold, no one needs it. That's right.
- 2:11Any business is ultimately about making
- 2:13money through the sale of services,
- 2:15services, or goods. What is MLM? It's a
- 2:19tool for selling services or goods.
- 2:23There are wholesale and retail trade,
- 2:26advertising, dealers, small and medium
- 2:29wholesalers, and so on. Yes, there are
- 2:32direct sales, and sales-driven sales.
- 2:35It's no longer fashionable, but
- 2:36remember those door-to-door sales, like
- 2:38, "Buy an iron, get knives for free,"
- 2:40and so on. There are direct sales, and
- 2:42then there are network sales. MLM is
- 2:45when any company client becomes not
- 2:48only a client but also has the right to
- 2:51recommend, that is, sell, and has the
- 2:54right to recruit, recruit, and involve
- 2:58other salespeople. Essentially, this
- 3:01client has the role of a sales manager,
- 3:04a sales manager, or a head of the sales
- 3:06department. That's what MLMM is—a
- 3:10tool for selling through word of mouth.
- 3:14Listen, on the one hand it sounds clear
- 3:16, but on the other hand, I think we're
- 3:18complicating things a bit. Where does
- 3:20the money come from when I sell a
- 3:23product? Say I have a product, someone
- 3:25recommended it, and they got their
- 3:28commission.
- 3:28Okay,
- 3:30someone else recommended it, then a
- 3:31third, and there's a chain of events
- 3:33where the participants make a huge
- 3:35profit. Where does the profit come from
- 3:37? Where do these budgets come from to
- 3:39pay out these profits? Look, it's
- 3:41called a marketing plan or a
- 3:43compensation plan. Compensation is paid
- 3:46. And in any product, honestly, look,
- 3:48we're talking about an honest MLM
- 3:50company. We'll talk later about Ponzi
- 3:52schemes and dishonest companies. We're
- 3:55talking about an honest MLM company. It
- 3:57has a product, and this product has an
- 3:59economics. That is, it has a cost price
- 4:03, it has a company profit, and it has a
- 4:06certain amount of money that goes
- 4:08towards paying people. Let's take a
- 4:12traditional business example. There's a
- 4:15sales manager. When they sell a product
- 4:17, they receive a commission. It's all
- 4:19clear here. There's a sales manager, a
- 4:22head of sales. They don't sell the
- 4:24product; they hire a manager, train
- 4:26them, the manager sells, and the sales
- 4:28manager receives their commission.
- 4:30Where does the money come from? Okay,
- 4:34the sales manager has a regional sales
- 4:36department, maybe a large regional
- 4:38sales department or something. Where
- 4:39does they get their money? And how does
- 4:42the owner of a wholesale company buy a
- 4:44Mercedes for their daughter? Similarly,
- 4:47every product has a commission built
- 4:50into it, and it's calculated in an
- 4:53honest MLM company. It's calculated in
- 4:56such a way that the commission is at
- 4:59least 100%sufficient to pay everyone
- 5:02involved in selling the product. If
- 5:05someone isn't involved, they don't just
- 5:07get paid.
- 5:08Friends, another short and very
- 5:10important break for managers and
- 5:12business owners. Do you want to take
- 5:14your sales department to the next level
- 5:16, make its work transparent, and
- 5:17increase profits with the help of
- 5:19artificial intelligence? Then listen,
- 5:21at Sol, we've prepared a pre-configured
- 5:24CRM system, which our experts will use
- 5:27to demonstrate the real capabilities of
- 5:30Bitrix24 in just one hour. You'll see
- 5:33how artificial intelligence helps you
- 5:36monitor managers, improve your
- 5:38processes, onboard employees, analyze
- 5:41data, and much, much more. Sign up for
- 5:44a free meeting with our expert directly
- 5:46via the link in the description of this
- 5:48video. In one hour, we'll show you
- 5:50everything, explain it in detail, and
- 5:52help you implement it in your sales
- 5:55department. The link to the recording
- 5:56is in the description of this episode.
- 5:58And now, back to the topic of the
- 6:00podcast. Well, if I understand
- 6:02correctly, it's simply a matter of
- 6:04finite
- 6:05mathematics.
- 6:06Mathematics, of course, but also a
- 6:07finite gradation of people based on
- 6:09payouts. It's not infinitely powerful,
- 6:11as we're talking about a pyramid scheme
- 6:13where there's endless new new new for
- 6:15themselves, but rather, businesses
- 6:16allocate, I don't know, 15 to 30%to
- 6:18marketing. And in this case, it's the
- 6:21same money, simply distributed by
- 6:23password.
- 6:24Yes. Yes. There are certain rules,
- 6:26there are different types of marketing
- 6:28plans. There's the classic unleveling,
- 6:30there's a breakaway, and various tiered
- 6:32ones. There's a binary, and there's a
- 6:34long-term one. There are different
- 6:36types of compensation, but they're all
- 6:38thought out and calculated so that
- 6:40there's enough money for everyone. So,
- 6:43if at this point, for example, you're
- 6:45too deep in the sales, the sale happens
- 6:47too far away from you, or the person
- 6:49has caught up with you in rank, you're
- 6:51a regional representative, and he's
- 6:53some kind of regional representative,
- 6:56yes, a brilliant director, for
- 6:58sake, and you get 20%, and he gets 20%.
- 7:0120-20 = zero. And you no longer receive
- 7:04compensation from his sales, because
- 7:06he's outgrown you, outgrown you, and so
- 7:08on. So, there are rules that
- 7:11mathematically make this system
- 7:14unbreakable. What you're talking about
- 7:16is a pyramid scheme. What does a
- 7:18pyramid scheme look like? Bring
- 7:19Pinocchio your money, put it on the
- 7:21field of miracles, a magical crypto bot
- 7:24, artificial intelligence in trading,
- 7:27or some other legend. Bring your money,
- 7:29put it there, and earn interest. The
- 7:32suckers are running out—the ones who
- 7:34bring in the money, while those who
- 7:36earn interest—they're becoming more
- 7:38numerous. At that point, the math
- 7:40doesn't add up, meaning there's not
- 7:42enough money left, and the pyramid
- 7:44scheme creators take their money and
- 7:46run. In network marketing, imagine you
- 7:49built a sausage factory. Let's say you
- 7:52hired people, bought equipment, bought
- 7:55raw materials, got a bunch of permits
- 7:58—you put in a ton of effort—you
- 8:00produced the sausage, opened the store
- 8:03yourself, for example, and did
- 8:05everything else—merchandisers, a
- 8:07store janitor, made it pretty, put the
- 8:10sausages on display. A customer comes
- 8:13in, buys some sausage, and you're like,
- 8:15"Ha, I cheated you." We're closing and
- 8:17running away. Why? Did you sell the
- 8:20sausage? Yes, you did. Is your reward
- 8:21included in the sausage? Yes, it is.
- 8:23Did the client get their money? Yes,
- 8:24they did. Why close down? That's why
- 8:27MLM companies haven't just been around
- 8:29for decades, but for 100 years. The
- 8:32oldest MLM company is Avon. It's almost
- 8:35140 years old, or maybe even 140 years
- 8:36old, I don't remember. Think about it,
- 8:38just look at how many girls were
- 8:39running around with these catalogs.
- 8:41Avon. Avon. And it's a network
- 8:43marketing company. And they have
- 8:44billions in turnover. Billions in
- 8:46turnover, and they're 140 years old.
- 8:49Why close down? It's
- 8:50clear here, well, we've covered the
- 8:53basics, for example. Let's dive deeper
- 8:56into this topic, perhaps through the
- 8:58most painful part, which is clear to
- 9:00the entire post-Soviet space: MmmM.
- 9:04What was that?
- 9:05Sergey Panteleevich, I think it was a
- 9:08real pyramid scheme.
- 9:10She had no chance. There are pyramid
- 9:11schemes, there are pyramidologists, and
- 9:13there are pyramidists. It depends on
- 9:16how you feel about them. And not a
- 9:18single pyramid has a chance of
- 9:20surviving. And I know there were fairy
- 9:22tales there. I wasn't in MM, not even
- 9:25close. I was really young back then.
- 9:28That's it. But even when he came in
- 9:302011, I prophesied and predicted the
- 9:32demise of all the major financial
- 9:34pyramids that existed in the CIS market
- 9:36. I can teach you all now how to
- 9:38identify a financial pyramid. That's
- 9:40how it is. You don't have to be a guru.
- 9:42There's one simple trick that can help
- 9:45you expose any pyramid scheme.
- 9:47Come on,
- 9:48when you're promised crazy interest
- 9:50rates, no matter what legend they tell
- 9:53you, ask yourself: "Are you being
- 9:56promised 5%per month?" It's not the
- 9:58crazy ones who promise more in pyramid
- 9:59schemes. Well, 5%per month is 60%per
- 10:02annum on your money. Attention, is 60%
- 10:06per annum cheap or expensive money?
- 10:08We'll take out a loan like this for
- 10:10investments, for a business. This is
- 10:12very expensive money.
- 10:13Very expensive money, of course.
- 10:15Very expensive money. Okay. You have a
- 10:18miracle super-mega nanobot that can do
- 10:21100%500%. You'll go and borrow
- 10:25expensive money from people and end up
- 10:28with everyone shaming you and calling
- 10:30you a Pyramid Scheme. Or you'll go to
- 10:33the smart bigwigs and say, "Bigwigs,
- 10:35give me a couple hundred million
- 10:37dollars, look what I can do." But the
- 10:39smart bigwigs say, "No, listen, I think
- 10:42you're a scammer, we don't believe you.
- 10:45" So they don't go to the smart bigwigs
- 10:47; they go and collect, they hoard the
- 10:49money. So, if you really have a cool
- 10:52idea that yields high interest rates,
- 10:55why would you pay people these high
- 10:57rates? 60-100%. Take cheap money from
- 11:00the bank for 20%per annum. Why would
- 11:04you take expensive money? So, any story
- 11:07where they tell you about some
- 11:09astronomical sum of money, ask yourself
- 11:12: how many people in the world have big
- 11:15money? Smart guys with millions, they
- 11:18just don't know what to do with it.
- 11:21They dream of investments with 20-30%
- 11:25per annum. Why are they so stupid,
- 11:28didn't they realize that you have a
- 11:30CryptoSpermega nanobot or yours from
- 11:33auctions or whatever other legends they
- 11:35tell? Those are all legends. Why are
- 11:38they all so stupid? It doesn't happen.
- 11:40Where it's too easy and there's too
- 11:42much money, it's immediately a fairy
- 11:45tale, because, well, all the smart guys
- 11:47with big money would go there. That's
- 11:49all. That's the difference. As soon as
- 11:51you see high interest rates,
- 11:53unreasonably expensive money, that's it
- 11:55, don't listen to any legends, stop
- 11:57playing the game immediately. For
- 11:59example, gold pyramid schemes are all
- 12:02the rage here in Dubai right now. They
- 12:06say they have gold production in Africa
- 12:08. It's true. It's just that the gold
- 12:12has run out there, and they're mining
- 12:15it for a living. And they actually even
- 12:18transport it to Dubai and sell it, but
- 12:21not in such quantities. And they
- 12:23collect money for it and give good
- 12:26interest. That's how much money it is.
- 12:28I immediately have a question: what
- 12:29about all these sheikhs? Why haven't
- 12:31all these rich people gotten involved?
- 12:32Why are they so stupid? Well, there are
- 12:34such interest rates, such a beautiful
- 12:36legend. That's it, that's the simple
- 12:38difference, how to expose any pyramid
- 12:42scheme.
- 12:43Well, that's clear, thanks for the
- 12:45advice. And I think we'll find some
- 12:48other options too. Eh, I'll have more
- 12:50questions on this topic. Let's get back
- 12:53to km. So, it was a pyramid from the
- 12:55start. It wasn't like, "Oh, I wanted to
- 12:57build a new world, but it didn't work
- 12:58out." It was a conscious journey.
- 13:00I wasn't there. I didn't know Mavrodi
- 13:04personally, although I knew Len Glubkov
- 13:07, I saw him. That's it. But he's just
- 13:10an actor. I don't know if he himself
- 13:13believed in the utopia he promised to
- 13:15build a new world. His followers did,
- 13:18but I wouldn't have believed it from
- 13:21the outside. Why? Because the math
- 13:24doesn't work. You can build a new world
- 13:26if you're offering 100%annual returns.
- 13:29Simple math leads you to understand
- 13:31that it's, well, unrealistic,
- 13:33impossible. That's what everyone would
- 13:35do then.
- 13:35Fire. Thank you. So, we come to the
- 13:38first important point I hear today: MLM
- 13:40is a business, and in business, the
- 13:42most important thing is numbers.
- 13:45Therefore, first and foremost, you have
- 13:47to count.
- 13:47In business, of course, beyond numbers,
- 13:49we'll talk a lot more about the MLM
- 13:51companies from Kamyanets. But forgive
- 13:54me, you're talking to entrepreneurs.
- 13:57What are the statistics on how many
- 14:00normal, traditional businesses fail?
- 14:03How many survive to the third year?
- 14:05Yeah, it's business as usual. 90%die in
- 14:07the first year, another 90%die within
- 14:09the first three years.
- 14:10In short, 3%survive to the third year,
- 14:12as far as I know the statistics. Right,
- 14:15right?
- 14:16Right. Scams.
- 14:20Risky business. That's it, that's right
- 14:22. Business. The reward for success. It
- 14:23just didn't work out. It just didn't
- 14:26work out. People didn't want to fail.
- 14:28They started a furniture production
- 14:30line, they didn't want to fail. They
- 14:31started a production line of, I don't
- 14:33know, cottage cheese bars. They didn't
- 14:35want to fail. They opened an MLM
- 14:37company selling dietary supplements,
- 14:41cosmetics, services. They didn't want
- 14:44to fail. They opened it as a normal
- 14:47business. But it didn't work out. As
- 14:50usual, the employees screwed up, the
- 14:53laws changed, someone stole something.
- 14:55Well, there are various reasons. But
- 14:58when regular companies scam,
- 15:00everything's okay. When an MLM company
- 15:02scams, everyone's like, "Oh-oh-oh, a
- 15:05pyramid. Ouch, a pyramid, a pyramid, a
- 15:08pyramid." No, it just didn't work out
- 15:10for people. They wanted to open a
- 15:11normal business, they made normal,
- 15:13honest products, but people invested
- 15:16money. People don't invest money in MLM
- 15:18. When someone tells me, "I invested in
- 15:20MLM and lost money," I say, "You're an
- 15:22idiot." You were either in Pyramid
- 15:23Systems, because that's where they
- 15:25invest money. Nobody invests money in
- 15:27MLM. In MLM, you buy a product from
- 15:31this company, become a client, get the
- 15:34right to sell it, recruit, and hunt for
- 15:38new clients. You bought a product, you
- 15:41know, I went to the store, bought some
- 15:43sausage, the store closed down right
- 15:45away. Right away. I lost money. That's
- 15:49how I invested in sausage.
- 15:50A minute of important and very useful
- 15:53information. If you're a business owner
- 15:55or manager, you know how important it
- 15:58is to make decisions based on real data
- 16:00, not assumptions. That's why we at SOL
- 16:03have prepared a special demo stand
- 16:05where our experts will demonstrate how
- 16:08Bitrix24 bio-designers work. In one
- 16:12hour, they'll show you how to implement
- 16:14bioanalytics in your business,
- 16:16demonstrate what reports and dashboards
- 16:19you can generate, and how SOL can help
- 16:21you set this up for your business. Want
- 16:24your business to be as transparent and
- 16:26manageable as possible? Sign up for a
- 16:27free demo using the link in the
- 16:29description of this video. And we'll
- 16:31continue our podcast. Okay, I get it. I
- 16:34understand what you're saying. So,
- 16:36where do so many negative reviews come
- 16:39from? People are screaming about losing
- 16:41money. If you can access the internet,
- 16:43you can find a huge number. Yesterday,
- 16:45I spent a couple of hours reading some
- 16:47very interesting reviews and some very
- 16:49interesting problems. Where does all
- 16:51this come from?
- 16:51By the way, we'll talk about reviews
- 16:53separately. There are two types of
- 16:54reviews. There are genuine reviews,
- 16:56really, from people. And then there are
- 16:58a huge number of reviews, I don't know
- 17:00them, black PR people or whatever you
- 17:01call them. They deliberately slander
- 17:04either companies or top leaders. And
- 17:07people who come to MLM, when they open
- 17:10the internet, Google, they see positive
- 17:12articles, they don't read them because
- 17:14they're looking for a catch, they're
- 17:17looking for doubts, they're afraid. And
- 17:19when they see negative ones, they click
- 17:21on them. Google is like, "Oh, what
- 17:23interesting content, I'll push it
- 17:26higher." And then these black PR people
- 17:28are simply extorting. Just extorting.
- 17:31Pay us money. Look, there are sites
- 17:34there that are disguised as Wikipedia.
- 17:37It's not Wikipedia, it's crap. Just
- 17:39disguised as Wikipedia. And there they
- 17:42slander top leaders, there they slander
- 17:45MLM companies. And this negativity is
- 17:47easy to spot. It says there in big
- 17:50letters: "Scam, I invested money." It's
- 17:54like, you read it and it all sounds
- 17:56exactly the same. It's a bunch of
- 17:58negativity. And the other negativity
- 18:00that's actually about MLM, where does
- 18:02it come from? This business has one
- 18:05major drawback. For example, if we were
- 18:07to compare—by the way, today it would
- 18:09be possible to joke around, have a
- 18:11battle, compare traditional business
- 18:13and MLM. I've been in both, and I have
- 18:16a lot of friends in both. You could
- 18:18have a great battle here, tell all
- 18:19about it. But if you compare
- 18:22traditional MLM, MLMA has only one big,
- 18:24the biggest drawback compared to
- 18:26traditional. It has no filter. People
- 18:30who go into traditional business are
- 18:33those with nerves of steel and a steel
- 18:35crowbar instead of a backbone. They
- 18:38have money, they have brains, and they
- 18:40weren't afraid, they went for it.
- 18:42Anyone can get into network marketing.
- 18:45And then there's Granny Lyusya, the
- 18:47trolleybus driver, trying to persuade
- 18:50Andrey Petrovich, the security guard.
- 18:53She's no good at persuasion. She's just
- 18:54pouring it in his ears. Listen, you'll
- 18:57be rich from our supervitamins, your
- 19:00teeth will grow. And then this nonsense
- 19:03starts. What's all this about? There's
- 19:05no filter here. Anyone and everyone
- 19:07flocks in. And when someone comes along
- 19:11who's just ordinary, who can't think,
- 19:14who's never been in business, who
- 19:16always blames them? The boss, the
- 19:19country, their parents, whoever. He
- 19:21comes along the same way I did. When I
- 19:23joined my first company, I quit after
- 19:26six months. And you know what I said? I
- 19:27said, "The company is bad, the
- 19:29marketing plan is complicated, the
- 19:31product is expensive, and most
- 19:32importantly, the people are stupid, I
- 19:34sell to them, but they don't buy."
- 19:37Everyone else is to blame.
- 19:38Okay. So, you say, "There's no filter,
- 19:39they go to the network card." So, who's
- 19:41to blame? Well, the very same ones who
- 19:43start this business. Okay, I'm not
- 19:44arguing that it's not a scam, they want
- 19:46to build a proper business, but they're
- 19:49also attracting these old ladies, this
- 19:51mechanic, this trolleybus driver.
- 19:52They're not attracting anyone. God
- 19:55forbid, they're building it further, so
- 19:58the next adherents, let's call them
- 20:00that.
- 20:01I'm a top leader. I'm an adherent. I'm
- 20:04a top leader. I'm a super pro. When I
- 20:07recruit someone, invite them to the
- 20:09business, I tell them honestly, I say,
- 20:11"Look, you'll have to work hard here,
- 20:13buy a ticket like a gym membership and
- 20:15not do a damn thing. You'll still end
- 20:17up fat." It's the same thing here. Here
- 20:19you'll have to learn how to sell, learn
- 20:21how to talk, learn how to manage
- 20:23yourself so that when you're sitting
- 20:26there, glued to the couch, scrolling
- 20:28through your Instagram feed or watching
- 20:30another podcast on YouTube, doing
- 20:32absolutely nothing with your life
- 20:34except watching, nothing will change
- 20:36here. You won't make money like that.
- 20:38Here you'll have to study, you'll have
- 20:40to work, it'll be hard here, you
- 20:41understand? I understand. I teach him
- 20:43not to deceive people. I teach him not
- 20:45to promise mountains of gold. I tell
- 20:48him how to look, how to talk. This is a
- 20:50really cool school. This is the best
- 20:52business school, because you don't have
- 20:54the carrot or the stick to fire or hire
- 20:57or give a bonus. No, you have to
- 20:59understand people psychologically, talk
- 21:01to them. He moved on to the next person
- 21:04. I'm a confident top leader. And if
- 21:07someone says to me, "No," or I don't
- 21:10like them, I tell them, "No." Because I
- 21:13don't have the job of signing
- 21:15everything that moves, and what doesn't
- 21:18move, I have to move and sign. But
- 21:20ordinary networkers do. And then the
- 21:23degradation begins. So, one goes to the
- 21:25next, and he's like, "Dude, in short,
- 21:27you'll have to work here, you'll
- 21:29succeed." That one goes to the next,
- 21:32says, "You'll succeed no matter what."
- 21:34That one goes to the next, says, "You
- 21:36don't have to do a damn thing, you'll
- 21:37be rich." Companies are fighting this.
- 21:41Companies themselves and top leaders
- 21:43conduct training, explain things, put
- 21:45out disclaimers, saying that not
- 21:47everyone will make money here, that
- 21:49you'll have to learn, that you have to
- 21:52use the product, and all that. But
- 21:54since there's no filter, everyone comes
- 21:58. On the other hand, I think it's a
- 22:02plus that anyone can come, because,
- 22:04honestly, I just thought about it for a
- 22:06second, I'm smashing the network card
- 22:09here so much that everyone comes, and
- 22:11because of that, it's just crazy. I
- 22:13came here once, just like everyone else
- 22:17. I came from the factory, I didn't
- 22:20swear at my mother, I spoke English. I
- 22:22still know how to show it, and YouTube
- 22:24will ban me. Ah, I had no prospects in
- 22:29life, really. I had a vocational school
- 22:32background, usually just help me study.
- 22:35I actually worked at the factory as a
- 22:37general mechanic. And my parents
- 22:40started drinking when I was a kid. So I
- 22:42started drinking too. I was raised on
- 22:44the streets there, surrounded by drug
- 22:47addicts and alcoholics, almost 90%of
- 22:49them. What was I supposed to become? A
- 22:54dollar millionaire who traveled half
- 22:56the world, whose education has raised
- 22:58thousands of people, who tell me every
- 23:00day: "Thank you, you changed my life.
- 23:02Thanks to your education, I became
- 23:04there." Some people become
- 23:05entrepreneurs, some achieve success
- 23:07online, some achieve something in life.
- 23:10But if there had been a filter, if it
- 23:11had been expensive, if it had been
- 23:13scary, if they told us like they did
- 23:14when we were kids: "If you lose your
- 23:16apartment, you'll go into business," I
- 23:18wouldn't have gone into business and
- 23:19nothing would have come of it. What
- 23:21chance does an ordinary machine
- 23:22operator have? Listen, well, I think
- 23:24you're exaggerating a bit here, of
- 23:26course. You got some kind of start, and
- 23:29I watched, listened, and read your
- 23:31story there, what you say: yes, thanks
- 23:34to being brought in once, you started
- 23:36thinking about the need to change
- 23:38something in your life, that you want
- 23:41to live differently, and the way you
- 23:43live now—at that moment, you won't be
- 23:46able to do it. But let's be honest, you
- 23:49have a fire in you, uh, somewhere, that
- 23:52would definitely push you. You realized
- 23:55something, and you would go to a
- 23:56construction site, become some kind of
- 23:58manager there, and develop from there.
- 24:00You would have gone into sales, you
- 24:01would have ended up in, well, a regular
- 24:03, classic business. You would have
- 24:05developed there, and you would have
- 24:06launched a business sooner or later,
- 24:08most likely. But it's not a fact.
- 24:11Really not a fact. Today, I'm so bold
- 24:15and confident. But back then, no. I had
- 24:20a girlfriend I didn't really want to
- 24:22live with. She was shorter than me,
- 24:24fatter than me, and older than me. It's
- 24:26just that the people I wanted to
- 24:28communicate with, they didn't even want
- 24:29to communicate with me. I had no
- 24:31friends. I was an insecure, shy loser.
- 24:36Why didn't I succeed in the online
- 24:38business? If I had been talented, I
- 24:40would have succeeded right away. I came
- 24:41and barely built a team of seven people
- 24:44in the first year, and earned $ 500 in
- 24:47my first year of work. Or rather, no, I
- 24:50quit my first company after six months,
- 24:53sold two jars in six months, and blamed
- 24:55everyone around me. And he sold one jar
- 24:58to his dad, and one to another relative
- 25:01, oh, his mother, his husband, his
- 25:04sister. That's it. But thanks to the
- 25:07fact that in the network business there
- 25:09is training, thanks to the fact that in
- 25:10the network business you don't have to
- 25:11pay a salary every month. By the way, I
- 25:13didn't actually join the second network
- 25:14business for the business. I was
- 25:16disappointed in the first, but in the
- 25:18second, where I had already achieved
- 25:19something, I joined for the training. I
- 25:21thought: "Those networkers are suckers,
- 25:23ha, suckers, they take money from you
- 25:25once because you bought a product for
- 25:27yourself, and then they teach you for
- 25:29free as much as you want. A pass to a
- 25:31super training, where they teach you
- 25:32thinking, and negotiations, and sales,
- 25:35and self-management, and planning,
- 25:36everything, everything, everything,
- 25:38everything, everything. I'm a sucker, I
- 25:41bought $ 300 in groceries and go and
- 25:43learn."
- 25:44No, well, okay. And then I realize,
- 25:45I didn't believe in network business
- 25:47back then.
- 25:47I dropped out of sales for a while in
- 25:49about 2010. So, to get back into sales
- 25:51properly, I deliberately joined a
- 25:53telemarketing company for six months
- 25:55and worked there on cold calls,
- 25:57developing every skill I had and
- 25:59reaching a completely different level.
- 26:01That's understandable, all right, but
- 26:04still, what did network marketing give
- 26:06you that suddenly changed you, that you
- 26:09were a nobody and wouldn't have
- 26:11succeeded, had no chance, and suddenly,
- 26:14only through training, they made you.
- 26:16Well, there's training everywhere. What
- 26:18was called motivation, training,
- 26:20experience?
- 26:21Why motivation? It's not motivation. So
- 26:23, they tell you, "Look, you're talking
- 26:26to a client." Well, for example, at my
- 26:28company, where I teach—this is my
- 26:31professional training—what am I
- 26:33teaching? Oh, calibration. Look at the
- 26:36client, see what's happening with their
- 26:38face. If you see that they're tense,
- 26:40well, stop trying to sell them
- 26:42something. You see, he's happy, keep
- 26:46talking. At least that's what most
- 26:48people say to us, you know, "Why, why
- 26:50did you get divorced?" Well, I just
- 26:52kept yelling and didn't realize I
- 26:53needed to shut up somewhere. At least
- 26:55just communication, to see what happens
- 26:57to a person when you interact with them
- 26:59. You have to, you have to. When you
- 27:01went and interacted with hundreds of
- 27:04people after that, you yourself said, "
- 27:06I joined a telemarketing company."
- 27:08Because reading about sales is useless,
- 27:11listening, watching YouTube is useless,
- 27:13you have to go and do it. And when you
- 27:15have a coach next to you, who—
- 27:17attention, mentoring has become very
- 27:20popular in recent years—this scam, in
- 27:22my opinion, is a scam, because people
- 27:24who aren't super-successful take a lot
- 27:27of money, big checks—also a scam—to
- 27:29teach you something. I'm your mentor. I
- 27:32say, "Listen, if you're such a great
- 27:34mentor, let's make money off my results
- 27:36." So, you taught me, I made a ton of
- 27:38money, and you got a ton of money for
- 27:40it. Honestly, honestly, it's network
- 27:42marketing. Someone comes to me, they
- 27:46bought a product from the company once,
- 27:48and then they get a bunch of mentors,
- 27:50the whole chain of command. It's like
- 27:53all the sales department managers. Each
- 27:55of them is eager to help you, because
- 27:57the more you earn, the wider my smile
- 27:59is, if I'm standing above you. Plus,
- 28:01network marketing made me think. I went
- 28:03to all sorts of trainings, personal
- 28:05growth trainings, where they dug up all
- 28:07my childhood traumas, and there were so
- 28:09many of them, that everything in my
- 28:11life changed.
- 28:12Good. It seems to me that you and I are
- 28:15going in that direction, deeper, and
- 28:17not useful for the average person. We
- 28:19still wanted to talk, and I'm an
- 28:21advocate for network marketing as a
- 28:23business, that it's definitely not a
- 28:25scam, and you're the accuser. Let's
- 28:28continue this.
- 28:29Well, that's really what's important
- 28:30here. Well, that's actually where we're
- 28:33heading, because again, MLM is exactly
- 28:37where the negative promise of results
- 28:40comes from. You're right that
- 28:43traditional businesses are dying, and,
- 28:45God willing, 3%survive. And here too,
- 28:48God willing, 3%will become top leaders.
- 28:51Am I right? Yes, those who will earn
- 28:54those
- 28:54wonderful, fabulous sums of money they
- 28:57always talk about. And most won't have
- 28:59that kind of income. There's just
- 29:01one thing, though. For example, if I go
- 29:04into the info business now, how many in
- 29:06the info business will achieve decent
- 29:09income? The same 3%. If I go into
- 29:12entrepreneurship, what's the likelihood
- 29:14, no matter where I go, it's still the
- 29:16same 3%. But if I go into the info
- 29:19business, I'll most likely go broke,
- 29:21I'll have a shitload of debt. If I go
- 29:23into traditional businesses, the same
- 29:25thing. If I go into a network marketing
- 29:27business, I buy a product once, maybe,
- 29:30okay, I need to buy a little of this
- 29:32product there every month for $ 100.
- 29:34Maybe, if I can't sell it, I'll eat it
- 29:36myself. But I don't have to pay
- 29:39salaries and get into debt. I don't
- 29:42have to pay rent. I don't have to pay
- 29:44to hire people there, open a bunch of
- 29:47legal entities, monitor the staff.
- 29:50There's a profit, there isn't, pay. I
- 29:52don't owe anything, I won't go broke.
- 29:54And in network marketing, there's this
- 29:55phrase, it's my favorite phrase. I
- 29:57brought it into network marketing in
- 29:59the Russian-speaking world. There are
- 30:02no unsuccessful networkers, only
- 30:04impatient ones. Once I started learning
- 30:07to meditate, and my teacher gave me
- 30:09instructions, said: "Go home, practice,
- 30:12come back tomorrow." I come the next
- 30:14day and say: "Listen, Kostya, I'm not
- 30:16doing it." And he, you know, he's such
- 30:18a true, meditating person. He has eyes
- 30:19like a Krishna devotee, have you seen
- 30:21them? His eyes were so full of love.
- 30:22And then he looked at me with these
- 30:24eyes, so full of love, and said, "Sasha
- 30:27, how many years had you been
- 30:28meditating before?" I said, "Kostya,
- 30:30are you kidding me? You know I never
- 30:32have." He looked at me again with these
- 30:34eyes and said, "Why the hell should you
- 30:36be able to do it?" And I just sat down.
- 30:39I say, "Listen, it's like in my
- 30:41business. A guy worked his whole life
- 30:43in a factory, worked in an office,
- 30:45worked somewhere else, he was even an
- 30:47entrepreneur. He's never been in
- 30:48network marketing, he's never been in
- 30:50direct sales. Direct sales is a magical
- 30:53art. Plus, you have to be a
- 30:56psychologist, a salesperson, a manager,
- 30:59a speaker, a psycho—that leader who
- 31:03doesn't just lead, but leads. You've
- 31:07never been in any of these roles. How
- 31:09the hell do you expect it to work out
- 31:12right away? But people want it right
- 31:15away, and when they don't succeed, they
- 31:17blame everyone around them. They say, '
- 31:19It's the company's fault, it's the
- 31:21sponsors, it's the mentors' fault,
- 31:23whoever trained me, it's the people's
- 31:25fault that they're not buying. 'You
- 31:28have everything fine in your capital,
- 31:30but in our village, they make all these
- 31:33excuses and so on. That's where all the
- 31:35negativity comes from.
- 31:37So, maybe they're being promised this
- 31:39at the moment. That's exactly why they
- 31:41think they'll get it quickly. And no
- 31:43one at the entrance probably says,"
- 31:45Listen, dude, it's business as usual
- 31:46here. You invest either money or time.
- 31:49So, you'll have to learn to scrape by
- 31:51for a couple of years.
- 31:53Money won't do. It takes time and
- 31:55effort. Yeah, it takes time and effort.
- 31:57You won't get by with just money. Ah,
- 31:59no matter how much you invest, you
- 32:01won't be successful in this business.
- 32:03This is a real school for superhumans.
- 32:06But for me, if someone is a top MLM
- 32:09leader, they're downright superhuman.
- 32:11Wherever they go, they'll be successful
- 32:13. Everywhere. Because there are people
- 32:15everywhere, they know how to manage
- 32:17themselves and others. Well, they
- 32:19basically have all the skills I listed.
- 32:22But people don't come because they were
- 32:24deceived, and that's how it works for
- 32:26them. More often than not, no one
- 32:28deceives them; they're told normally
- 32:29that yes, you'll have to work. At least
- 32:31, even if an ordinary person got you in
- 32:33the wrong way, you joined the company.
- 32:35The company has training, sometimes on
- 32:38stage, sometimes on YouTube, sometimes
- 32:40in webinars. Your superiors tell you, "
- 32:43Guys, you need to work hard here, be
- 32:46patient, and so on." But what was
- 32:48written on the fence in Greece, where
- 32:50democracy wandered in? The worst are
- 32:53always the majority. Why do only 3-5%of
- 32:56people live well there, while the rest
- 33:01are served? The rest are served. Why is
- 33:03someone not giving them anything? Why
- 33:06are people fat? Don't they know they
- 33:08should eat less and go to the gym? Why
- 33:10do people consume all sorts of crap?
- 33:12They don't watch podcasts like yours
- 33:14and mine, they consume all sorts of
- 33:16crap, and it has views of a girl
- 33:18sitting and eating a hamburger. And
- 33:20views approaching a million. Normal,
- 33:22intelligent things that can change a
- 33:25person's life are views of crap. Why?
- 33:28The worst are always the majority.
- 33:30Consumers who don't really think about
- 33:33the future, blaming everyone around
- 33:35them. There you have the whole truth.
- 33:37Why so much negativity?
- 33:38Good. But not everything seems so rosy
- 33:42to me. You're telling me now. I
- 33:43understand your logic. I understand
- 33:45perfectly well that it really is a
- 33:47wonderful school. I'm very aware of
- 33:50that. I really understand how they'll
- 33:52train you there, what skills they'll
- 33:53impart, that it's necessary to go
- 33:55through it. But especially considering
- 33:57that there are legitimate projects
- 33:59nearby, yes, and then there are, well,
- 34:01outright scams, which are enticing you
- 34:04to get billions tomorrow, just enter,
- 34:06just bring in the money, and so on.
- 34:08Naturally, when you rightly say that
- 34:11everyone goes, that maybe they'll learn
- 34:14there—naturally, the percentage is
- 34:16small, the sample is very large, but
- 34:19there are also naive souls who actually
- 34:22take out loans, who fall into slavery,
- 34:25into bondage to banks, to the very
- 34:27companies they joined, and everything
- 34:30else. And the perception is there.
- 34:32Let's
- 34:32look again. Again. Wait, are you
- 34:36talking about pyramid schemes again?
- 34:38What the hell loans? In most MLM
- 34:41companies, the entry fee is up to $
- 34:441,000. Most MLM companies have entry
- 34:47fees of up to $ 1,000. Trainings are,
- 34:50damn it, even more expensive. What kind
- 34:52of bondage is this? But the thing is,
- 34:55in recent years, by the way, thank God,
- 34:57since the time of Phoenix, the pyramid
- 34:59industry has practically died out.
- 35:02There was this pyramid scheme called
- 35:03Phoenix.
- 35:04Yeah. It was one of the largest and
- 35:07most powerful after the MM, it was the
- 35:11era of pyramids. There were so many of
- 35:14them. And a galaxy of pyramid schemers
- 35:18emerged. I, as I say, I call them
- 35:20pyramidologists. These are the ones who
- 35:22come and honestly say: "Yes, this is a
- 35:24pyramid scheme, guys, who knows when it
- 35:26will collapse. Play it or not." That is
- 35:29, they are like that, they are honest
- 35:31pyramid schemers, pyramidologists. And
- 35:33are there pyramidists? Those who say, "
- 35:35What are you talking about, we are
- 35:37changing the world, this is a
- 35:38completely new thing." That's it. And
- 35:40often they don't even know they are
- 35:43pyramid schemers. They think and
- 35:44believe. Well, there are those who
- 35:47don't think that. So, this wave, there
- 35:50were so many of them a few years ago
- 35:52that a whole new generation of pyramid
- 35:55schemers emerged. You come to someone,
- 35:57meet them, and they say, "I'm an MLMer"
- 36:00or "I'm a network marketer." And they
- 36:02invented the term "MLMer" because
- 36:04before them, there was no such thing as
- 36:06an MLMer. There was a network marketer.
- 36:07So they say, "I'm an MLMer." I say, "So
- 36:09, which MLM companies have you been
- 36:11with?" Well, Kubek, Finika, Antares,
- 36:14Cashbery. Listen, do you realize you
- 36:17haven't named a single network
- 36:18marketing company? He says, "Well, we
- 36:20have a principle of attracting network
- 36:22marketers." I say: "Wait, a referral
- 36:24program and just a hierarchy of
- 36:26communication and word of mouth is not
- 36:29a network, it is a principle of
- 36:31transmitting information. There was the
- 36:34most ancient networker, he walked on
- 36:36water, turned water into wine. He had
- 36:3812 first lines, do you understand? Yes.
- 36:41And so it grows, like the
- 36:45coolest was Genghis Khan, who had
- 36:48foremen. This is the one who has his
- 36:51own army of 10 small people. There were
- 36:54centurions, this is the one who has 10
- 36:55foremen. There were thousanders,
- 36:57temniks. These are the ones who had.
- 36:59And why did Genghis Khan win then?
- 37:02There were no radios, messengers
- 37:03galloped everywhere for a long time,
- 37:05and information was slow. And he came
- 37:07up with this theme and said:" I give
- 37:09information to the ten-thousander, he
- 37:11to the thousander, he to the centurion,
- 37:13he to the foreman. "If information did
- 37:15not reach someone somewhere, it stopped
- 37:18, their head was cut off. Instantly,
- 37:21everyone learned to instantly transmit
- 37:22information. The oldest Setevuho, look,
- 37:25there's internet everywhere, yeah, just
- 37:27word of mouth. I say," What the hell
- 37:29kind of MLM guys are you? You're
- 37:30pyramid schemers. "You're
- 37:32deceiving people." And when they say, "
- 37:34I lost my apartment," I don't get it.
- 37:37Did you buy cosmetics from Avon for the
- 37:39same amount as your apartment? Why the
- 37:41hell? Did you buy your dietary
- 37:44supplements from Herbalife? Look,
- 37:47Herbalife. Everyone laughs at Herbalife
- 37:50, but Ronaldo still runs around in a
- 37:52Herbalife T-shirt. Oh, how is that
- 37:54possible? It's a pyramid scheme. Or
- 37:56Amway, which was back in 1960 or
- 37:59something in America, where consumer
- 38:01laws and consumer protection are much
- 38:04stronger than anywhere else in the
- 38:06world. So, Amway proved it, won the
- 38:09global court case, and proved to the
- 38:11whole world that MLM is MLM, and it's a
- 38:13Ponzi scheme. By the way, the rest of
- 38:15the world doesn't call financial
- 38:17pyramids, it's called a Ponzi scheme.
- 38:18But a Ponzi scheme is a different story
- 38:20. It's different, again, very simply.
- 38:23Either here consumers pay real money,
- 38:26and there are also pyramids that are
- 38:29disguised as a network, so They have a
- 38:32product, but there are no free payments
- 38:35. And it's supposedly a network. But
- 38:37when they sell you some porridge that
- 38:40costs 3 kopecks, and then sell it to
- 38:42you for 30,000, that's also a kind of
- 38:47pyramid scheme. When they tell you, "
- 38:49Buy five buckets of porridge," you're
- 38:51like, "Damn, why do I need five buckets
- 38:53?""Well, here are our rules. This is
- 38:56also a veiled pyramid scheme. It's
- 38:58different, it's just for the dumb. It
- 39:01won't scam like regular pyramid schemes
- 39:03. It's different.
- 39:05Okay. We're
- 39:07just talking about consumability,
- 39:08yes, to the important question. Look,
- 39:09from what I've studied, what I've seen,
- 39:12the difference between a really strong
- 39:17MLM business in general, one that can
- 39:18exist and work, is the presence of a
- 39:20strong product. That is, if we're
- 39:22talking about sales, sales are all
- 39:24simply, well, a tool for selling a
- 39:26strong product. That is, we create a
- 39:27product, which is what we actually
- 39:29started with initially, that there is a
- 39:30product, you said that sales are the
- 39:32main thing. But I would still say that
- 39:33the product is the main thing. Without
- 39:35it, you won't build anything. You have
- 39:37nothing to sell that is reliable,
- 39:39high-quality, that will be trusted,
- 39:41that will be useful, valuable for
- 39:43people, and so on, then without this it
- 39:45doesn't work. We have a product like
- 39:47Avon, for example. They start Create
- 39:49cosmetics. I don't know how they
- 39:50started, to be honest, but now we know
- 39:52they have cosmetics.
- 39:54I can tell you, they started out, their
- 39:56owner was selling books. The books
- 40:01weren't selling well, so he started
- 40:03giving away perfume samples to the
- 40:05ladies who bought the books. He noticed
- 40:07that the perfumes were really selling,
- 40:10and it was a gamble, that is, direct
- 40:12sales. He didn't even have a
- 40:13multi-level sales system back then. He
- 40:15noticed that the perfumes were doing
- 40:17really well, so he turned into perfume,
- 40:18started selling perfumes, then added
- 40:20multi-level sales, and so on. And so it
- 40:22grew into the great Avon corporation.
- 40:25Cool. Excellent. Well, there's a
- 40:27product, and then we sell it. And the
- 40:30difference between a company that dies
- 40:32launching an MLM model or stays alive
- 40:35is the availability of the product. Am
- 40:37I right?
- 40:38No, whether it dies or stays alive
- 40:41depends not only on the product, it
- 40:43depends on everything. How stupid is
- 40:45the management, for example, the owner
- 40:47of the company, some nonsense Created,
- 40:49the company can die. Even with a good
- 40:51product, companies fail. But if we're
- 40:54talking about a product, it's important
- 40:57to pay attention to how honest and
- 41:00useful this product is. What does
- 41:03honest mean? It means its price is more
- 41:05or less within the market price,
- 41:07meaning it's not inflated by a million
- 41:10times. And then, it's a proven product
- 41:14that actually works. So, when they sell
- 41:16some structured water, I say," Remember
- 41:19Kashpirovsky? "Oh, and he's talking
- 41:21about the effectiveness of this product
- 41:25, what's claimed and what's actually
- 41:28there matches. They don't make things
- 41:30up, they don't hype it up. It's become
- 41:33very fashionable now. We don't have
- 41:35biologically active supplements, we
- 41:37have cellular nutrition. I'm like," Oh,
- 41:40damn it, let's ask the GPT chat what
- 41:42cellular nutrition is. Is it a
- 41:45marketing ploy by networkers, or what
- 41:47is it? "" Well, the GPT chat says,'
- 41:49Listen, who the hell knows. 'Well,
- 41:50there's nothing like that in the world,
- 41:52it's not proven. So. And so, reality is
- 41:56stated, a real statement about what it
- 41:59is. One. The market price, not inflated
- 42:03many times over, two. And then we check
- 42:05whether MLM will survive or not. And
- 42:08will people buy this product in these
- 42:12quantities at this price without a
- 42:15marketing plan? Will people buy this
- 42:20product in these quantities at this
- 42:22price without network marketing? That
- 42:25is, if I come to you and tell you about
- 42:28this product, and you buy it for the
- 42:30sake of the product at this price and
- 42:32say,' Oh, great, not everyone will buy
- 42:34it, not everyone needs it, everyone has
- 42:36their own needs, everything's okay. '
- 42:39But if there are those people and their
- 42:41normal number, well, an average of
- 42:4310-20%, yes, among clients, as with any
- 42:46business, it's not that everyone can't
- 42:48buy, it's not that people are different
- 42:50. But if there are a normal number of
- 42:53people, 10-20%buy at this price,
- 42:55regardless of whether they make money
- 42:57in this company or not, that's the
- 43:01argument for a good product. So you're
- 43:03saying that people will buy it only
- 43:05because there's money in it, only
- 43:08because there's a business there. At
- 43:10one time, too, as I'm saying, I've been
- 43:12in this business for 27 years, there
- 43:13was a time when it was fashionable to
- 43:15say that the product wasn't important
- 43:17in network marketing. The main thing is
- 43:19the money. We don't sell the product
- 43:21anyway. We sign people up for a
- 43:22marketing plan, we tell them how they
- 43:24can make money here. And that was
- 43:26really fashionable. Lately, that hasn't
- 43:29worked for many years. The product must
- 43:32be reusable. What does reusable mean? I
- 43:35bought it once, then came back, bought
- 43:37it again, then came back, bought it
- 43:39again. Lately, the network card has
- 43:41been breaking down badly. Now it's
- 43:42going to be a real pain for network
- 43:43marketers. Even though I'm an advocate
- 43:44for network marketing here, I'm going
- 43:46to criticize this too. I've been taking
- 43:48dietary supplements since I was 18.
- 43:50That is, I have Breakfast is a handful
- 43:52of dietary supplements, biologically
- 43:54active additives. If someone doesn't
- 43:56take biologically active additives,
- 43:57people, understand, you'll starve.
- 43:59There are no vitamins in food today.
- 44:02Remember, remember when you bit into an
- 44:04apple as a child, how quickly did it
- 44:06rust? Instantly. Now an apple is sliced
- 44:09for the table for New Year's, and put
- 44:11away on May 9th. It just dried out,
- 44:13didn't even rot, because it contains
- 44:14only antibiotics and no iron. It didn't
- 44:17rust. You need to eat vitamins. Look,
- 44:20I'm a super networker. Networker of the
- 44:22entire Russian-speaking planet. How
- 44:25many dietary supplements do I have, a
- 44:27bucket of about 20 at a time. Wherever
- 44:29I go or travel. How many of them are
- 44:32from network marketing, what do you
- 44:34think?
- 44:34Well, I think most.
- 44:38Zero,
- 44:38yes. Okay. They all used to be. They
- 44:42all used to be. Why? Because the
- 44:45pharmacies sold junk. There were no
- 44:48normal vitamins. There was this,
- 44:50Remember Aevit, Renit, or whatever it
- 44:53was called, Revit? Oh, and calcium,
- 44:56gluten from calcium. Well, that was
- 44:58brutal. Poisoned. Nothing happened
- 45:00today with the development of the
- 45:02internet, with the development of
- 45:04marketplaces. There's this thing called
- 45:06IHB. Who in Russia says, "Google is
- 45:09banned here, for God's sake, tell me
- 45:11how to buy products from iHerb in
- 45:13Russia." Even if it's not Herb, there
- 45:16are stores, after all. And there are so
- 45:19many manufacturers of dietary
- 45:21supplements in the world that they have
- 45:23supplements much better than those from
- 45:26networkers. Just the number of
- 45:27milligrams. You look at the active
- 45:31ingredient. Here it's calcium, and here
- 45:33it is calcium. Only here it's 200 mg
- 45:34per capsule, and here it's 1,000. Oh,
- 45:37it turns out that if I eat one of these
- 45:39capsules, I have to gobble up five of
- 45:41these. And they cost the same. It turns
- 45:43out that in network marketing, the
- 45:44product is five times more expensive.
- 45:46The world has changed a lot, network
- 45:48marketing too. It changes. There are
- 45:50companies that have a really good
- 45:52product, and there are companies that
- 45:54have a so-so product. Here, people have
- 45:57a choice whether to buy or not, but
- 45:59that's all okay. But when they sell you
- 46:01a piece of junk that costs 100 rubles
- 46:03for 30,000, it's no longer about
- 46:04network marketing, it's about marketing
- 46:06, about money, about a pyramid scheme.
- 46:08Got it? That's the ideal picture of the
- 46:09world. Indeed, I talked to you, you
- 46:11told me what your product is, and said:
- 46:13"Cool, I need it." You told me the
- 46:14price. I said: "Cool, for this money I
- 46:17need it." I took it, used it, and
- 46:19realized that, wow, for this money I
- 46:21got the result I expected, maybe even
- 46:23more. I sincerely would like to
- 46:25recommend it to others, but at that
- 46:27moment they also tell me: "And you can
- 46:29also make money on this."
- 46:30Yes.
- 46:32Yes. That's the
- 46:35ideal picture.
- 46:36This is network marketing, right? This
- 46:37is network marketing. I come to clients
- 46:40, I look at the product, I use it, I
- 46:44like it. At that moment, they say to me
- 46:46: "If you tell others about this, money
- 46:49will come to you, and you will receive
- 46:51this product, essentially, for free."
- 46:53And if they tell me more, if you choose
- 46:56this as a profession and help people,
- 46:59develop, teach, collect, organize. For
- 47:01example, what do I do? I'm a networker,
- 47:04right? What does a networker do? I
- 47:07organize a sales system for a large
- 47:10international company. Let's translate
- 47:12it into business language. Really, what
- 47:14does a networker do? I organize a sales
- 47:16system. I find people, I sell, I train,
- 47:20I engage, I motivate, I set up systems
- 47:23there, I don't know, there are gifts,
- 47:26something else. I say, whoever sells
- 47:29the best this month, I'll give them an
- 47:31iPhone. For example, I work for a
- 47:35company now, I say: "Whoever sells the
- 47:37best this month, I'll invite them to
- 47:39visit me for a week on my yacht for
- 47:41free." I live on a yacht On a sailboat,
- 47:43on a round-the-world voyage. I travel,
- 47:46and I have a business related to travel
- 47:48. And that's my motivation, what I do.
- 47:52Rob, when he says: "Guys, whoever
- 47:53fulfills the plan by the New Year will
- 47:55get a 20%bonus." It's not the same.
- 47:58Same.
- 48:00Okay. Look,
- 48:01only Rob is fulfilling the owner's
- 48:03dream, and I am fulfilling mine.
- 48:06Okay, I agree with you. No questions.
- 48:08But look, it turns out that, in essence
- 48:11, if at the first level, then this is a
- 48:13regular referral program for attracting
- 48:16and word of mouth. Well, I'll tell you
- 48:18even more now. I'll tell you with my
- 48:20own example. My main business is the
- 48:22Bitrix 24 integrator. We come to people
- 48:25, implement Btrix, we set it up
- 48:28properly for them. If they like it,
- 48:30they happily go and say: "Look, these
- 48:32guys are implementing Bitrix great."
- 48:34They come to us, we implement Btrix. We
- 48:36have a referral program for attracting.
- 48:38Similarly, if we They recommend it,
- 48:40we'll pay 10%for the recommendation.
- 48:43That's it. Well, that's essentially the
- 48:45top step. We just don't go to the next
- 48:48stages, am I right? When we don't
- 48:50recruit, don't assemble these groups
- 48:52and all that?
- 48:53Yes. Yes. Yes. But at the same time, by
- 48:56the way, today you just reminded me,
- 48:57you started talking about traditional
- 48:59business, right? Today I'm making fun
- 49:01of people who call MLM a pyramid scheme
- 49:04. I say, "Dude, honestly, don't tell
- 49:06anyone else, don't embarrass yourself."
- 49:09And you know why? Look at Alfa Bank.
- 49:12Alfa Bank is the largest, one of the
- 49:14largest private banks in the Russian
- 49:17Federation. The largest bank. They have
- 49:20network marketing, which is called Svoy
- 49:23v Alfa. And there is a multi-level
- 49:26network program, absolutely network
- 49:29marketing. Let's move on. VTB Bank is
- 49:32the largest, well, in second place is
- 49:35the State Bank. First is Sberbank, then
- 49:37VTB. VTB is going, a year ago VTB
- 49:40launched its own network, a multi-level
- 49:43A network program, network marketing,
- 49:47pure and simple.
- 49:49Why did they go there?
- 49:50Not a single-level referral program,
- 49:51but a multi-level one.
- 49:52What changed? Why did they go with this
- 49:54model? It's a
- 49:54model. Well, more and more
- 49:57entrepreneurs understand that it's the
- 50:00same sales model, it's just more
- 50:03effective. Well, for example, if I do
- 50:06something, my goal is to attract
- 50:08clients, right? Right. If I do a
- 50:11standard marketing program, I have to
- 50:14spend a ton of money, and there's no
- 50:17guarantee it will work and they'll
- 50:19bring me clients. I pay money upfront
- 50:22and wait for results. Right. Leads,
- 50:25purchases, blah-blah-blah, marketing
- 50:28steps, advertising, and so on. Network
- 50:30marketing. I tell people: "People,
- 50:33bring me clients, the clients will give
- 50:36me money, and I'll pay you from that
- 50:39money." That is, without investing
- 50:42money upfront, I get clients, I get a
- 50:46stream of leads, non-leads, ready-made
- 50:49clients, and I pay for them from their
- 50:52money. Magic. Come on, entrepreneurs.
- 50:58I understand. Interesting. Like it.
- 51:01Model. Indeed, I understand. And let's
- 51:04be honest, I have no complaints. I
- 51:06understand that any entrepreneur will
- 51:08sit down and do the math. If they know
- 51:11how to calculate financial models and
- 51:12math, they'll find how it will work in
- 51:14numbers. But here, the biggest problem,
- 51:17which we need to figure out, is that
- 51:20this negativity that comes from the
- 51:23side, constantly flies from all sides.
- 51:25And if we just talked about why this
- 51:28negativity happens there, when people
- 51:31come, uh, and start to burn out there
- 51:33or something else, it's a scam and so
- 51:36on, but the negativity remains even
- 51:39towards people who work in the same
- 51:41normal network marketing companies.
- 51:44Well, the same Avon, there's more or
- 51:45less. Well, it's just that the girls
- 51:47seem to be doing something. That's
- 51:48usually the case. Herbalife in general
- 51:50immediately gets a lot of complaints.
- 51:52They're like, "Oh, the turtle's gone,
- 51:54dude, goodbye." I have a friend who's
- 51:57now working at Herbalife. He's lost a
- 52:00lot of weight, he's very Well done. He,
- 52:02and, well, I'm sure that this is a good
- 52:04example, when he believed in it, he saw
- 52:06the result in himself and went to do it
- 52:08, to convey to others. But I also see
- 52:11how everyone from the outside is like:
- 52:13"Eh, what started? What's going on?"
- 52:16This also scares people. Like here?
- 52:19Well, well, the question again. The
- 52:22worst are always the majority. When you
- 52:25start a business, and you are from an
- 52:27ordinary circle, your circle also tells
- 52:29you: "You're a fool, you'll lose your
- 52:31apartment, you'll lose everything."
- 52:32What are you doing, what are you
- 52:33getting yourself into? We are poor, but
- 52:35honest, more than the rich. There's no
- 52:37point in starting when A, but in the
- 52:40end, winners don't judge. When I came
- 52:42to MLM, my relatives, friends,
- 52:44acquaintances all made fun of me. When
- 52:48I earned my first million dollars in a
- 52:51year, more precisely 1.5 million
- 52:52dollars in a year, I had so many new
- 52:54relatives for the New Year who
- 52:58congratulated me for some reason. I was
- 53:01the biggest loser. All the parents made
- 53:04fun of me, everyone. And today, the
- 53:06most respected member of the family.
- 53:08Look, you're telling me this again. I
- 53:10wanted to ask a different question, but
- 53:12let's get back to it. Again, you say, "
- 53:14I was nobody." Well, it turns out you,
- 53:17damn it, endured being ignored. You've
- 53:20been through so much. And if people
- 53:22like that can endure it, that's a
- 53:24completely different story. I mean, I'm
- 53:26sure you would have found and achieved
- 53:29success anywhere. It has nothing to do
- 53:32with something like MLM. Maybe that's
- 53:35why,
- 53:35but you wouldn't have achieved such
- 53:38success. It's
- 53:40not a fact. It's
- 53:41not a fact. That's the point. It's very
- 53:43difficult to judge,
- 53:43because once again, I became the person
- 53:47you see now thanks to MLM. Would I have
- 53:50survived in another business, where
- 53:52salaries had to be paid constantly,
- 53:54where there was competition, where else
- 53:57? It's not a fact, far from a fact. You
- 53:59certainly wouldn't have, well, not
- 54:01exactly, and perhaps you wouldn't have
- 54:03reached that level. So, you know, a
- 54:05dollar millionaire, traveled half the
- 54:07world, has his own yacht, and so on.
- 54:08It's not a given. The question is, as
- 54:11for the winners, you started saying
- 54:13that there's this whole vibe, yes,
- 54:15there is. But today, if before, you
- 54:17know, this was many years ago, people
- 54:20didn't understand what MLM was, most
- 54:23people didn't understand. And there
- 54:25really was, well, the stench of network
- 54:27marketing. If you were invited to
- 54:29network marketing, it was like there
- 54:31was something wrong with you. Today, in
- 54:33fact, I'm already deeply involved in
- 54:35this industry. Today, the narrative has
- 54:38changed. Today, if you're not invited
- 54:40to MLM, then there's something wrong
- 54:41with you. I mean, it's just disgusting
- 54:43that you're not even invited to MLM.
- 54:46Normal people are invited with pleasure
- 54:48. I really love telling people that I'm
- 54:51a networker, because when I meet
- 54:53someone, I'm talking, and they look at
- 54:55me, and they understand that I'm a rich
- 54:57, successful entrepreneur, that I'm a
- 54:59reasonable person, it's interesting to
- 55:01be with me, I'm very versatile, I've
- 55:04traveled half the world, I'm really,
- 55:06damn, I'm an Expat, imagine, on a
- 55:08round-the-world trip. I know you're in
- 55:09Argentina right now. So, I was running
- 55:11in the park, uh, across from this
- 55:13American embassy, the goose park, I
- 55:15call it, and this text message popped
- 55:17into my head. Hello, young man. You're
- 55:19getting old. Your trial period on
- 55:21planet Earth is over. Something needs
- 55:23to be done. I freaked out, because the
- 55:25only thing that prolongs life is travel
- 55:27. And I've always been traveling anyway
- 55:29. I haven't lived anywhere since '16.
- 55:31When I say 70 countries, well, that's
- 55:33not entirely true, because, well, I've
- 55:35been to Italy 20 times, I've lived in
- 55:37Spain, um, I've lived in Argentina,
- 55:39I've lived in Uruguay, I've been to
- 55:41Germany 10 times, and so on. These have
- 55:43been around since 2016. I mean, if you
- 55:45count all the countries, I don't know
- 55:46how many. So, I freaked out and went on
- 55:49a round-the-world trip on my sailing
- 55:51yacht. Look, this guy meets people,
- 55:54talks to them, and he's like, "I'm a
- 55:57networker, I love watching people's
- 56:00eyes go,' Wait, those old ladies or
- 56:02girls running around with badges like,"
- 56:05Want to lose weight, ask me how. "Or
- 56:08want me, ask me how to lose weight.
- 56:10Herbalife. That's it. And you, are you
- 56:12sure you're talking about networking? I
- 56:15say," Yeah, dudes, that's networking,
- 56:19that's real. "And I just love to screw
- 56:22with people's minds, defending the MLM
- 56:25industry. But most can't, they're
- 56:27insecure, they're weak, but they need
- 56:30to grow.
- 56:31Okay.
- 56:33And all this flair...Wait, I almost
- 56:35didn't fully answer your question. And
- 56:37all this flair, but it's with Me today,
- 56:39well, it's me, I rather look at it with
- 56:42the mockery of stupid people. Because
- 56:44when people say:" Network is crap,
- 56:47network is trash, it's a scam, "you say
- 56:50:" Who are you compared to Alfa Bank or
- 56:53VTB Bank? Maybe you should just get
- 56:55some treatment? "Well, go learn
- 56:56something about life, don't talk about
- 56:59things you don't know about. Well, why
- 57:01Herbalife and Mike Ronaldo? Ronaldo
- 57:05became the richest footballer in the
- 57:08world. He got 1.3 billion dollars or
- 57:11something there. The first athlete, the
- 57:14first billionaire. Yes, yes. And he
- 57:17runs around wearing Herbalife T-shirts.
- 57:19And this Donald Trump said in one of
- 57:21his old interviews, someone asked him
- 57:23—he wasn't president yet, that's all
- 57:25—he was asked:" What will you do if
- 57:27you lose all your money and all your
- 57:28real estate? You'll lose everything,
- 57:30all your connections. "He said:" I'll
- 57:32pick a good networking site at the
- 57:33start and go there. "The audience burst
- 57:36into laughter. That talk show was when
- 57:38the audience stopped laughing. He
- 57:40looked at them like this and said:"
- 57:41That's exactly why you're there, and
- 57:43I'm here. "I don't care when people who
- 57:46go to work, get hired for $ 500,
- 57:48fulfill the boss's dreams, and they
- 57:51experience financial impotence every
- 57:53day, when they laugh at something they
- 57:56don't understand. Well, okay,
- 57:59I get it. Here I also have this, well,
- 58:01a continuation of our whole topic. Ah,
- 58:03the model is clear, the management is
- 58:05clear. Where else does the skepticism
- 58:07most often come from? What's starting
- 58:09to resemble a cult, specifically, when
- 58:11these constant gatherings of everyone,
- 58:14like they used to shout" Juice "in the
- 58:1690s, yeah, everyone, I think. That's it
- 58:18. And all this is frightening. Now at
- 58:22Alfa Bank, the same thing, they have
- 58:24the same model, uh, they gather people
- 58:26together, then we disperse them, or
- 58:29does it all work differently now?
- 58:31Uh, tell me, please, don't other
- 58:34non-networkers have any gatherings?
- 58:36There's Eurovision, there they also
- 58:39stand in the hall, sing, hold hands,
- 58:42hold hands. And religion, we're not
- 58:44talking about cults, just regular
- 58:46religion. Who's asking
- 58:48questions? Cults, religion, let's not
- 58:50discuss what's a cult or what's a
- 58:51religion,
- 58:52right now. Okay, okay. No, there are
- 58:54accepted ones, unrecognized ones,
- 58:56whatever. Next. And business clubs,
- 58:59trainings, those are all cults. Let it
- 59:03be a cult, I agree. Screw it, let it be
- 59:06called a sect. I just have one question
- 59:09. If I'm in this sect, there is a sect,
- 59:13we sit at the table, discuss show
- 59:16business, mothers, drink on Fridays,
- 59:20dream about the future, and curse
- 59:23everyone who bought an iPhone, because
- 59:25we say:" Ah, morons. "Because we don't
- 59:28have the money for an iPhone ourselves.
- 59:30Beautifully said.
- 59:31This is also a sect, a network. A sect
- 59:33of stupid paupers. They discuss things
- 59:36that make no sense. They love holidays.
- 59:40All entrepreneurs, dear entrepreneurs,
- 59:42you understand me, we hate holidays.
- 59:44Holidays are evil. If you, I don't know
- 59:46, sell flowers and March 8th, okay. But
- 59:49holidays are evil, because there's New
- 59:51Year's and all your employees have to
- 59:53drink for a week, do nothing, and you
- 59:55have to pay them. Also a sect. Also a
- 59:59sect. And now our sect. We talk about
- 1:00:02success, we talk about the need to play
- 1:00:05sports, because if you look like,
- 1:00:07it will be hard for you to do business.
- 1:00:10We talk about the need to be able to
- 1:00:12communicate with people, to be able to
- 1:00:14build relationships, to network. We go
- 1:00:17to our sectarian gatherings, where
- 1:00:21professional trainers tell people how
- 1:00:24to change their lives for free. I just
- 1:00:28had a gathering of our sectarians here
- 1:00:32in Dubai. And I had a hall for 125
- 1:00:35people, but 175 showed up. They were on
- 1:00:39my Instagram, I post them, you can see
- 1:00:42some excerpts there. I spent three
- 1:00:45hours pouring smart thoughts into them
- 1:00:49for free. Three hours for free. They
- 1:00:53didn't pay a damn for it. Cult. Cult.
- 1:00:59But we don't ask for money. We don't
- 1:01:01say," Sell your apartment and transfer
- 1:01:03it to a pastor. "A good sect can even
- 1:01:06make money. Screw it, let it be a sect.
- 1:01:10Okay. But nevertheless, yes, it's
- 1:01:12classic MLM, I understand, we're really
- 1:01:14talking about business, about business
- 1:01:17models that businesses can apply to
- 1:01:19themselves, entrepreneurs who will
- 1:01:21watch this episode. And it's about
- 1:01:24building a team through management,
- 1:01:26right? There are probably also special
- 1:01:29methods, regulations, and rules there.
- 1:01:32I mean, well, why don't most companies
- 1:01:34do this? Because it's replaced by
- 1:01:36regulations. You have regulations, you
- 1:01:37follow them and work. That is,
- 1:01:39motivation here and there, ah, pumping
- 1:01:41up emotions, an emotional background, a
- 1:01:44conclusion, something else. This is
- 1:01:46also probably a principle, rules, and
- 1:01:48processes. So, I think
- 1:01:49there's a whole science here. MLM is a
- 1:01:52very complex business. In fact, it
- 1:01:55seems like just go tell a friend and
- 1:01:57that's it. Start. Go tell a friend.
- 1:02:00Okay. But when you already have 10
- 1:02:02friends, you need to somehow interact
- 1:02:04with them. And when you already have a
- 1:02:05thousand, you need to interact with
- 1:02:07them. So, you have two generals, and
- 1:02:09they're fighting among themselves. Ah,
- 1:02:11but here you need to create this kind
- 1:02:13of motivation. But if we give this one
- 1:02:15a gift, then those others will be
- 1:02:17offended. It's a whole science. There
- 1:02:20are so many rules about this, even the
- 1:02:22marketing plan, in the marketing plan
- 1:02:24there are, for example, the company I'm
- 1:02:26currently working with, there are nine
- 1:02:28types of rewards. Of them, uh, look how
- 1:02:31good everyone is in this company. Well,
- 1:02:34I just get a thrill myself. I have an
- 1:02:36intellectual orgasm when I see how this
- 1:02:38is done. But I've seen and written
- 1:02:39marketing plans myself many times. Ah,
- 1:02:42when there are types of rewards that
- 1:02:44are just like helicopter money, that is
- 1:02:46, you hand them out, it would work
- 1:02:47without them too. And then there are
- 1:02:50those that are truly key. Thanks to
- 1:02:51them, you build your network. How to
- 1:02:53write a marketing plan, how to conduct
- 1:02:56training, how to build relationships
- 1:02:58between generals. In your corporate
- 1:03:00environment and at work, you have a
- 1:03:02carrot and stick. If I fire someone,
- 1:03:04I'll give them a bonus. Here, you can't
- 1:03:07fire anyone. Here, they still have no
- 1:03:09rules for how to behave. They can still
- 1:03:12quarrel among themselves, leave for
- 1:03:14another company, when some key, big
- 1:03:16leader of yours leaves for another
- 1:03:18company. But it's just like in the
- 1:03:20traditional business: you developed a
- 1:03:22good employee, your entire business
- 1:03:24depended on him, but after a while he
- 1:03:26realized that you, the boss, were
- 1:03:27getting on his nerves, went off, opened
- 1:03:29his own business, and took all your
- 1:03:31clients. Here, the same story can
- 1:03:33happen: how to prevent this, how to
- 1:03:35recognize it, how to motivate him, how
- 1:03:37to create competition for him, and so
- 1:03:40on and so forth. It's a huge,
- 1:03:42super-serious science. This business
- 1:03:46is scary at this point. Well, I mean, I
- 1:03:49understand perfectly well that it's
- 1:03:51really not a freebie, going in this
- 1:03:53direction or building this model. It's
- 1:03:55really, like any other business, it's
- 1:03:57not just that simple, it's difficult.
- 1:04:00Only a few achieve success. The model
- 1:04:02is truly very complex and specific.
- 1:04:04Naturally, this scares people there,
- 1:04:06because there's all this flair that
- 1:04:08they'll think of you:" Wow, you decided
- 1:04:11to become a networker "and so on.
- 1:04:13What's the advantage? For what? Well, I
- 1:04:15need to outline the image of the
- 1:04:18advantage. An advantage, my dears. The
- 1:04:22first advantage. And I can get up right
- 1:04:26now, finish a conversation with you,
- 1:04:29make three calls or send three text
- 1:04:32messages. I'm in Dubai now, India is
- 1:04:34not far from here. I could go to India
- 1:04:36for a month or two or three, and
- 1:04:38nothing will fall apart for me, because
- 1:04:40my entire network will continue to work
- 1:04:42without me. Because they didn't come
- 1:04:44into this business for me, I didn't
- 1:04:46hire them, they came for themselves,
- 1:04:47they are building their own business.
- 1:04:49In traditional business, this doesn't
- 1:04:51happen. They'll screw you over
- 1:04:52instantly, steal your clients, destroy
- 1:04:54your business, your employees. You need
- 1:04:57to build this, you need to build a
- 1:04:59super-corporate big business. It's not
- 1:05:02like that here. Here it's there right
- 1:05:03away. Well, right away, more or less
- 1:05:05right away. Next. I don't need to pay
- 1:05:08salaries if I have no sales tomorrow.
- 1:05:10Well, tomorrow there's a pandemic,
- 1:05:12tomorrow some other crap. No sales at
- 1:05:15all. I won't go broke. I don't need to
- 1:05:18pay anyone anything as long as there
- 1:05:20are no sales. There are sales, there
- 1:05:21are payments. No sales, no payments. I
- 1:05:23don't need to pay rent, office space,
- 1:05:25or anything else. Moreover, there is a
- 1:05:28network business, when you are a
- 1:05:30company owner, you created the company,
- 1:05:32I was there in the shoes of an owner,
- 1:05:34and then there is a network business,
- 1:05:36when you are a distributor, you came in
- 1:05:39simply as a salesman, became a leader,
- 1:05:41and so on. If we compare traditional
- 1:05:44business, opening a regular company or
- 1:05:46opening a network company, as a company
- 1:05:49owner, one or the other-it's a
- 1:05:50traditional business. Both are there,
- 1:05:52you hire employees, both are there,
- 1:05:54both are there. You have a ton of risks
- 1:05:56, hemorrhoids, and so on. But network
- 1:05:58business is just a little more stable
- 1:05:59in terms of if you built a network, uh,
- 1:06:01you don't invest millions in
- 1:06:03advertising and so on. Well, there are
- 1:06:05some pains. But as a leader, that's
- 1:06:07where I'm a real fan. I have a
- 1:06:10kilometer of people on my team right
- 1:06:11now. Well, just recently we were
- 1:06:13talking with top leaders. I have
- 1:06:15several very high-profile top leaders,
- 1:06:16so you understand. These are checks of
- 1:06:18a million dollars a year and more. Here
- 1:06:21we are, sitting and talking. We all
- 1:06:23once came to the online market with the
- 1:06:24thought:" Once I earn some money, I'll
- 1:06:26open a traditional one. "We all opened
- 1:06:28traditional ones. We've all been there.
- 1:06:32I can have a heart-to-heart talk with
- 1:06:34any entrepreneur right now, because
- 1:06:36I've been there seriously. I understand
- 1:06:38all this pain. Never, ever will I go
- 1:06:42back to a traditional one. Why? I don't
- 1:06:45want to. I want to be free. The company
- 1:06:48produces the product for me. The
- 1:06:51company handles the legal framework,
- 1:06:53payments, payment acceptance, hires
- 1:06:56employees, and monitors the quality of
- 1:06:59these employees. I don't do this; the
- 1:07:01company does it. I organized the
- 1:07:03distribution system, and as long as
- 1:07:05this distribution exists, I make money.
- 1:07:07Am I afraid the company will screw me
- 1:07:08over if I do nothing? I'm not afraid,
- 1:07:10because if she screws me over, everyone
- 1:07:12else will leave because they'll say,"
- 1:07:14Damn, we came here to build this and be
- 1:07:16free, like him. "And they screwed him
- 1:07:18over, so they'll screw us over too, and
- 1:07:20they'll leave. That's why the company
- 1:07:22can't cheat me. It's a very honest and
- 1:07:24transparent business. It can't. I can
- 1:07:27be free. How much money did I invest? $
- 1:07:32100. Well, what did I invest? I bought
- 1:07:34a product. I bought a product. I can't
- 1:07:38say how much I earned.
- 1:07:40Companies forbid it so there's no
- 1:07:42motivation for money; they forbid us
- 1:07:44from giving specific figures. But if I
- 1:07:46were to give that figure live on air,
- 1:07:49I'd think 90%of the entrepreneurs
- 1:07:52watching us right now don't make as
- 1:07:54much money as I do. Although they make
- 1:07:59much more, invest much more, and risk
- 1:08:03much more. And they have absolutely no
- 1:08:06freedom.
- 1:08:07Okay, go ahead.
- 1:08:09But why do we become entrepreneurs
- 1:08:11anyway? To get a life. I want to argue
- 1:08:15with you.
- 1:08:16First, you said,"
- 1:08:18Okay,
- 1:08:18so you can leave. "
- 1:08:21In the beginning, you're just like that
- 1:08:23, building your network, assembling a
- 1:08:25team, setting up the entire
- 1:08:27distribution system—you work like a
- 1:08:29pro. You're also creating work
- 1:08:31processes, just like any other business
- 1:08:33. If it's working, it doesn't just
- 1:08:36throw everything together, but creates
- 1:08:38rules, regulations, hires managers,
- 1:08:40each other, balanced processes, and
- 1:08:43everything else that supports it. And
- 1:08:45it all works just as well, more or less
- 1:08:47. And, of course, when you leave your
- 1:08:49role as CEO or whatever, you can become
- 1:08:52an owner, an owner, specifically,
- 1:08:54switch to a dividend-paying business
- 1:08:56model and live your life peacefully.
- 1:08:59And I'm sure
- 1:09:00you know a lot of owners?
- 1:09:03Most often, the problem isn't that it
- 1:09:05doesn't work, it's that they enjoy
- 1:09:07doing it, and that's why they never
- 1:09:09built it in the first place. I'll just
- 1:09:11finish one thought now. And yet, I'm
- 1:09:13sure that even if you're gone for a
- 1:09:15month, a year, or longer, if you don't
- 1:09:18interact with your team, it will
- 1:09:20gradually begin to relax, crumble, fall
- 1:09:23apart, and so on.
- 1:09:24That's the first thing.
- 1:09:25On the one hand, yes, on the other hand
- 1:09:27, no. It depends on who you have. Also,
- 1:09:29if, for example, you've just joined a
- 1:09:32network marketing organization and you
- 1:09:34have a couple of distributors of my
- 1:09:37level, I swear to you: you can do
- 1:09:39absolutely nothing, earn this much
- 1:09:42money for the next 10 years, and do
- 1:09:44absolutely nothing, because there are
- 1:09:47super-professionals who will do it for
- 1:09:49you. Absolutely nothing. For 10 years,
- 1:09:53you can never show up at a single event
- 1:09:55and make money. And why do you even
- 1:09:57need to be in this system at that point
- 1:09:58? Because if you get screwed, everyone
- 1:10:03else down there will leave too,
- 1:10:06because the system works.
- 1:10:12Yes, I brought you in, you're working
- 1:10:15hard, I'm doing absolutely nothing and
- 1:10:17still making money. But if I hadn't
- 1:10:20brought you in, you wouldn't be here.
- 1:10:23I read that you...
- 1:10:24Why are you working so hard? Because
- 1:10:27you dream just like me, of doing
- 1:10:28absolutely nothing and still making
- 1:10:30money.
- 1:10:30I read that early in your career, there
- 1:10:33was a company you worked so hard for,
- 1:10:35and they,
- 1:10:35like, kicked you out. Why did that
- 1:10:40happen? Was it because they were being
- 1:10:42greedy or were they
- 1:10:43just being greedy? There are
- 1:10:45different things. I've never been
- 1:10:50kicked out by a company when I was a
- 1:10:54distributor. I was screwed by a partner
- 1:10:59, a close friend. It happened. But it's
- 1:11:02like in any traditional business, in
- 1:11:04any life. As I've always said, money
- 1:11:06doesn't corrupt people. Money is a
- 1:11:08litmus test. It brings out your true
- 1:11:11essence. If this isn't the essence, but
- 1:11:14the essence, and you fell for the big
- 1:11:16bucks and screwed your neighbor,
- 1:11:18business has nothing to do with it.
- 1:11:20It's about people. And my stupidity in
- 1:11:23allowing it to happen.
- 1:11:24Okay. I understand, no questions there.
- 1:11:27Let's continue. The second thing you
- 1:11:30said was that there are no costs for
- 1:11:33salaries. But I don't know about the
- 1:11:35model you're working with now, but, for
- 1:11:38example, AVN (they have production, I
- 1:11:40think, they'd be very upset about how
- 1:11:42much they have in their warehouses
- 1:11:45constantly being produced, etc., if
- 1:11:47suddenly there are no sales). The costs
- 1:11:49of creating products, maintaining
- 1:11:51production. But
- 1:11:53look, these are different things. There
- 1:11:55is a leader, and then there is the
- 1:11:57owner of the company. The company has
- 1:12:00costs for employees, it has costs for
- 1:12:03production, it has costs for logistics,
- 1:12:07for everything, like any manufacturer,
- 1:12:10any seller. A networker, a top leader,
- 1:12:13they have no costs. No, I also have
- 1:12:16costs for salaries. I have an assistant
- 1:12:19, I pay her a salary. I have
- 1:12:21translators. When I work with other
- 1:12:23countries, I hire translators. For
- 1:12:25example, today I entered the Turkish
- 1:12:27market, and my translator said," I pay
- 1:12:29salaries. "I have SMM teams there, I
- 1:12:31pay salaries. But that's my choice. I
- 1:12:33can cancel it at any time, and my
- 1:12:35business won't die because of it. I'm
- 1:12:38buying myself freedom so that I don't
- 1:12:39have to deal with this crap.
- 1:12:40Okay. So, uh, what's the difference
- 1:12:42then? My managers and directors don't
- 1:12:44pay salaries themselves either. Their
- 1:12:47company pays them in exactly the same
- 1:12:48way. Do
- 1:12:48you have a business? A large, systemic
- 1:12:52business. Let's remember the ABCs.
- 1:12:56Uncle Kiasaki once wrote a book called
- 1:12:58The Cashflow Quadrant.
- 1:13:00Okay.
- 1:13:01He said, guys, there are four types of
- 1:13:03things you can do. Four paths. Working
- 1:13:07for hire, when you get fat and sell
- 1:13:10part of your life for a pittance. The
- 1:13:13state or a private individual. Whether
- 1:13:16you're a director or an ordinary
- 1:13:18employee, it doesn't matter; you're
- 1:13:20selling your life for cash. Second,
- 1:13:23this is small-scale entrepreneurship.
- 1:13:26When you're walking around, you're a
- 1:13:28reader and a womanizer, a philistine
- 1:13:30and a highlander, with a maximum of one
- 1:13:32or two employees, if any, most likely
- 1:13:34none. You do everything yourself. Third
- 1:13:37, this is business. Business isn't
- 1:13:40about buying cheap and selling
- 1:13:41expensive. Most people think that way,
- 1:13:43unfortunately. Business is about
- 1:13:44organizing the work of other people in
- 1:13:46production or services. And then there
- 1:13:49are investments, four types of
- 1:13:52businesses: employment and small
- 1:13:55business. We all have the same ultimate
- 1:13:58goal. People just rarely think about it
- 1:14:00. They've also been taught to dream of
- 1:14:02a car of a certain color, and so on and
- 1:14:04so forth. All of this is complete
- 1:14:05. If a person has brains, they
- 1:14:07understand that there is only one goal:
- 1:14:09money and free time. Well, health, of
- 1:14:11course. If you have a lot of money and
- 1:14:13a lot of free time, you realize
- 1:14:14everything else in your life. But what
- 1:14:17about love? If you're struggling with
- 1:14:19love, go to training, see a
- 1:14:20psychologist, get some head treatment,
- 1:14:22go change, see a beautician, go to the
- 1:14:25gym. And that's all it takes? Money and
- 1:14:27free time. Employment. No money, no
- 1:14:31time. Even if you become a director,
- 1:14:33you won't have any time. Top managers
- 1:14:35are hired at every turn. And if you're
- 1:14:39a small entrepreneur, no money, no free
- 1:14:42time, so we're left with either
- 1:14:44investments or a large, systemic
- 1:14:46business. Investments are for selling
- 1:14:49something unnecessary, you need to buy
- 1:14:51something unnecessary. We don't have
- 1:14:53the money. As Uncle Fyodor once said, I
- 1:14:55think, or Matroskin, I don't remember.
- 1:14:57That is, you need a lot of money to
- 1:14:58invest. If you bought shikokoin with
- 1:15:01the last $ 5,000 you got from your
- 1:15:03grandmother's funeral or on credit,
- 1:15:06you're an idiot; that's not an investor
- 1:15:08. An investor means millions. And all
- 1:15:11these" Invest little by little "stories
- 1:15:13. That's a very long time. Maybe by
- 1:15:16retirement something will work out. I
- 1:15:18want to live now. The only thing left
- 1:15:20is large-scale systematic business.
- 1:15:21It's the only thing that will get us
- 1:15:23where we need to be. Freedom and money.
- 1:15:25There are two types of business.
- 1:15:27There's MLM, and there's traditional.
- 1:15:31The business we're talking about, this
- 1:15:33small entrepreneurship, is not a
- 1:15:35business. It doesn't have that freedom,
- 1:15:38the kind where you have a $ 100,000 a
- 1:15:40month check and can do absolutely
- 1:15:42nothing. It doesn't have that freedom.
- 1:15:44In a large, systematic business, when
- 1:15:46you have a board of directors, when you
- 1:15:48have a built corporation, there is
- 1:15:50freedom and big money. But let's be
- 1:15:53honest, what kind of brains and
- 1:15:55experience do you need to build all
- 1:15:59that? Most people think you need money
- 1:16:01and ideas. There's no money or ideas in
- 1:16:04this world, damn it. Experience and
- 1:16:06brains. Where the hell is an ordinary
- 1:16:08person supposed to get them? Well, and
- 1:16:10a mile of money. Okay, they can be
- 1:16:12found. Network marketing. You can come
- 1:16:14to it as a complete novice. No
- 1:16:16experience, no brains. Just don't give
- 1:16:20up. Just keep moving forward. That's it
- 1:16:23. And study, do, study, do, study, do,
- 1:16:26study, do. You can do it. You don't
- 1:16:28have to pay salaries, you won't go
- 1:16:30broke unless you quit. That's what I'm
- 1:16:32talking about. I'm not saying," Go
- 1:16:34start your own traditional MLM company.
- 1:16:37"Although, entrepreneurs, guys, have a
- 1:16:39whole other story to tell: they need to
- 1:16:42use these tools in their business.
- 1:16:44Teach their clients, recommend them,
- 1:16:46train their employees. You can use a
- 1:16:49lot of cool stuff, you can do all of it
- 1:16:52.
- 1:16:52So, what should entrepreneurs do? Well,
- 1:16:55if you understand, some are just
- 1:16:56looking for a way to figure out what to
- 1:16:58do, yes, MLM as a scenario, that's it,
- 1:17:00maybe, listening to you now, they'll
- 1:17:02choose. But there are also
- 1:17:04entrepreneurs who simply have their own
- 1:17:05businesses, they're running them,
- 1:17:07they're unlikely to quit now. Well,
- 1:17:09maybe some will drop everything and go.
- 1:17:11But what in business can you just
- 1:17:14implement? What MLMA tools would make
- 1:17:16you really money? Well, first, teach
- 1:17:19your clients to recommend you for a
- 1:17:21reward. One.
- 1:17:23What for?
- 1:17:23Train your employees.
- 1:17:26Well, listen, you can't explain it like
- 1:17:28that in five minutes. You probably need
- 1:17:31to hire a top-tier networker and pay
- 1:17:34them a lot of money for a consultation.
- 1:17:37Ideally, they should have previously
- 1:17:39owned a company, so they understand
- 1:17:40networking. Because most people in
- 1:17:42networking aren't at that level of
- 1:17:44professionalism anyway. It would be
- 1:17:46good to get involved in networking
- 1:17:47yourself. Why? To get a taste of it
- 1:17:50from the inside, to see how it works,
- 1:17:52to see how it works. That would be cool
- 1:17:55too. And for most entrepreneurs, if
- 1:17:58you're already well-off and have a
- 1:18:00great business, then go to good
- 1:18:03consultants, hire them, talk, have a
- 1:18:06couple of consultations, and you'll
- 1:18:08understand everything, because you're
- 1:18:11already doing great in your business.
- 1:18:14You'll just learn some tips about
- 1:18:16networking, which you can implement
- 1:18:18without embarrassing yourself, without
- 1:18:20turning it into a network card, without
- 1:18:22catching all this flair, and so on. But
- 1:18:24if you realize today that you're, ah,
- 1:18:27in that state, the horse is dead, get
- 1:18:29off. You know, yes, the old Indian
- 1:18:32saying. The horse is dead, get off,
- 1:18:34don't kick it, don't think it always
- 1:18:36galloped like that. No need to hold a
- 1:18:38symposium on dead horses. No need to go
- 1:18:41and learn how others gallop on dead
- 1:18:43horses. Fix the losses and look
- 1:18:46at a different business model, one that
- 1:18:49doesn't involve investments, without
- 1:18:51all this hassle. Yeah, some people I
- 1:18:53know might laugh. And he who laughs
- 1:18:56last, laughs best.
- 1:18:57Tell me, please, we're talking about
- 1:19:00tourism now, what's your business like?
- 1:19:03What's that? Briefly, what's this
- 1:19:05project?
- 1:19:05There's a large international company,
- 1:19:0912 years old, a tour operator, a travel
- 1:19:12club. You come and pay for membership.
- 1:19:16For being a club member, a club
- 1:19:18resident, you get all sorts of perks.
- 1:19:21Like, for example, traveling at
- 1:19:23wholesale prices. I just booked a hotel
- 1:19:25in Dubai. It was listed at 1,800 on
- 1:19:28Booking.com, and I got it for $ 900.
- 1:19:30They offer hotels, car rentals, trains,
- 1:19:34planes, apartment rentals, event
- 1:19:36tickets—in short, a ton of travel
- 1:19:39products, guides, excursions, all at
- 1:19:43wholesale prices. The tour operator
- 1:19:45itself takes all these products at
- 1:19:47wholesale prices. Instead of marking
- 1:19:49them up, it gives them to us with a
- 1:19:51minimal markup to stay within the legal
- 1:19:53framework; otherwise, it would be
- 1:19:55illegal, typically 1-2%. And we pay
- 1:19:58membership fees to the club to have
- 1:20:00access to these products at these
- 1:20:03prices. It's a common story; Margulan's
- 1:20:08Equium club costs, I think, $ 13,000 to
- 1:20:11join, and so on. We have a similar club
- 1:20:14, but in addition to having access to
- 1:20:16these products, we travel together in
- 1:20:19groups, learning, developing, and
- 1:20:21hanging out. We've been to Altai, we've
- 1:20:24flown to Dubai, and we're planning to
- 1:20:26go to Kailash, along with the usual
- 1:20:29destinations like Turkey, Egypt, and so
- 1:20:31on. CIS tourism is currently developing
- 1:20:34at full speed. Soon, we'll announce
- 1:20:36Baikal, Sochi, and so on. Kazakhstan
- 1:20:38was already a forest, there was Iskul,
- 1:20:40there was Georgia, so there was both
- 1:20:42national tourism and global tourism.
- 1:20:44And now I just went to Portugal, next
- 1:20:49year I'm flying to Iceland. For being a
- 1:20:52good salesperson, I was given a trip to
- 1:20:54Miami, and so on. We sell access to
- 1:20:57tourism. The product, the product, is
- 1:21:00worth the money. It is worth it. It
- 1:21:02pays for itself instantly. I get
- 1:21:05networking, I get training, I get
- 1:21:07exposure, I earn money from this and
- 1:21:10extend my life thanks to travel. If
- 1:21:13someone tells me I'm doing, I
- 1:21:14say," Well, I don't know where
- 1:21:16someone's brains are supposed to be to
- 1:21:18understand that this is not,
- 1:21:19that it's cool. "Sounds interesting.
- 1:21:22Okay. It really makes me want to take a
- 1:21:27look. Tourism. I think it's something
- 1:21:29that hooks people. The opportunity to
- 1:21:32travel. Indeed,
- 1:21:33I thought the same thing, remember,
- 1:21:35forgive me, remember, I said that I had
- 1:21:37no more online supplements left. A year
- 1:21:40and a half ago, when I decided to buy a
- 1:21:42yacht, I retired online. I said," My
- 1:21:44network card is dead. "Because, well,
- 1:21:46supplements are expensive. Why?
- 1:21:47Cosmetics, detergents. Why did these
- 1:21:50pyramid schemers ruin the market like
- 1:21:52God knows what? Expert mentors, mentors
- 1:21:54of experts, and other info-cygans have
- 1:21:56pestered everyone, saying," You don't
- 1:21:59have to work, you should become a
- 1:22:01blogger or put your information on
- 1:22:03Marketplace. "And, in short, they've
- 1:22:05plundered all the more or less sane
- 1:22:07people. And sane people are needed
- 1:22:08everywhere, online and offline. They're
- 1:22:10what hold everything together. They've
- 1:22:12plundered everyone, I retired, bought
- 1:22:14myself a yacht, and set off on a
- 1:22:15round-the-world trip. And when I heard
- 1:22:17about tourism, you just said," Sounds
- 1:22:18interesting. "I'm like," Tourism sounds
- 1:22:21interesting, well, well, well, it's
- 1:22:24just pure fun. "People love to travel.
- 1:22:27Okay. So that's
- 1:22:28how it all started.
- 1:22:31Where can I read more, look, where
- 1:22:33should I dig, if I want to really
- 1:22:36understand MLM? I have a channel where
- 1:22:39I don't do any recruiting. I just talk
- 1:22:43about MLM, share some secrets, teach. I
- 1:22:47have a book, we'll give you a copy in
- 1:22:50the description. A book in which I
- 1:22:52break down the 14 doors to wealth and
- 1:22:55freedom. I mean, I go through it step
- 1:22:59by step. You live out the 14 paths of
- 1:23:02life, like," Aha, if I were to go down
- 1:23:04this path, then what would it be like,
- 1:23:07based on other people's examples, "with
- 1:23:09a ton of humor and silliness. Oh,
- 1:23:12follow the links, read, watch, figure
- 1:23:15it out, and write to me on social media
- 1:23:17if you want. The most important thing
- 1:23:20in online business is that when you
- 1:23:21come for the first time, this is often
- 1:23:22why there's negativity, by the way.
- 1:23:24Most often, people get into online
- 1:23:25business by accident. So, a friend
- 1:23:27comes and says," Can't you think for
- 1:23:28yourself? "I'm like," Oh, cool. "The
- 1:23:30second or third company, when you're
- 1:23:32starting to get your head around it,
- 1:23:33you're like," Aha, but how am I going
- 1:23:35to sell this? And to whom? And why
- 1:23:37should these people buy it? "For
- 1:23:38example, why did I go into tourism? If
- 1:23:40we went out into the street now and
- 1:23:42asked 100 people what they dream about,
- 1:23:44just name your top five places.
- 1:23:47I don't think we'll meet anyone there.
- 1:23:50I want a dietary supplement, an
- 1:23:52environmentally friendly detergent. No,
- 1:23:55they'll say a dacha, a car, a dog. Well
- 1:23:57, that means a car, an apartment, money
- 1:24:00, and travel,
- 1:24:02right. That's
- 1:24:02why I went into this topic.
- 1:24:04I agree with you. Thank you very much.
- 1:24:07I had a really interesting conversation
- 1:24:08. It turned out to be very emotional
- 1:24:10today. We've touched on so many things
- 1:24:13that really tug at my heartstrings.
- 1:24:16Friends, please leave your comments and
- 1:24:18tell me what you think: is this a
- 1:24:20normal, proper business, and what are
- 1:24:22MLM business models in general, or are
- 1:24:24they pyramid schemes, a scam? Alexander
- 1:24:27was selling us nonsense here.
- 1:24:29Personally, I think so, and as a
- 1:24:30sober-minded entrepreneur, I can say
- 1:24:32one thing: there are definitely cool,
- 1:24:34useful tools out there that many people
- 1:24:37should use and apply in their own
- 1:24:38businesses. There are models, and you
- 1:24:41can fine-tune them. And I have no doubt
- 1:24:43that with the right companies, you can
- 1:24:45simply join, not worry about building
- 1:24:47and creating your own business, taking
- 1:24:49on that responsibility, but join the
- 1:24:51network business and earn good money
- 1:24:53there. If you're ready, open to the
- 1:24:55world, if you're good at talking,
- 1:24:57willing to develop, and want that kind
- 1:25:00of ease, it works. Personally, I have
- 1:25:03no doubt. The huge problem remains that
- 1:25:05pyramid schemes will always exist
- 1:25:07alongside normal businesses and normal
- 1:25:09business models. There will be no
- 1:25:12quality control, just pushy sales,
- 1:25:14promises of instant results. And this
- 1:25:17is a problem where we simply need to
- 1:25:19learn to separate the wheat from the
- 1:25:21chaff. And, perhaps, it really is a
- 1:25:22responsibility. First and foremost,
- 1:25:24everyone should take responsibility for
- 1:25:26where they're going and how they're
- 1:25:28going. Anything they've been sold can
- 1:25:30be a rip-off anywhere. We need to see
- 1:25:33that things are
- 1:25:33actually getting better, little by
- 1:25:35little. It's getting better, little by
- 1:25:36little. People are getting smarter, the
- 1:25:38internet is helping, people are
- 1:25:39starting to think, and models are
- 1:25:40becoming more sophisticated. Well,
- 1:25:41forgive me, Alfabank, VTB, these are
- 1:25:44real warning signs that this is an
- 1:25:47industry, and it's becoming more
- 1:25:49civilized. Use your own brain. And when
- 1:25:52you hear someone singing songs about
- 1:25:55something to someone, somewhere, think
- 1:25:57about it: is this someone a
- 1:25:59professional or not? I'm sure that
- 1:26:01after listening to me today, it's hard
- 1:26:03to argue. Hard to argue. Why? Because,
- 1:26:06well, it's a clear and coherent picture
- 1:26:09of the world. There are just some
- 1:26:11rumors, there is some solid information
- 1:26:14, think about it, weigh it up. I think
- 1:26:16we had a great chat. Thank you. It
- 1:26:18was great. Very interesting. Thank you
- 1:26:20for coming. Friends, thanks for
- 1:26:22watching. Subscribe, like us to see
- 1:26:25more videos like this. And this video
- 1:26:28has spread across the internet for
- 1:26:29everyone to see. Thank you and see you
- 1:26:31again. เฮ
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Вся правда про СЕТЕВОЙ бизнес: развод, миллионы или новая религия? | Александр Перевезенцев by Пуд Соли. Интервью, бизнес и автоматизация, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,522 words across 2,258 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.