Australian Naval Leaders - The Early Years — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:05hello
- 0:07I'm professor Rob McLaughlin at the
- 0:08University of New South Wales campus at
- 0:10the estranged Defense Force Academy in
- 0:11Canberra welcome to this episode of the
- 0:14Australian naval history podcast series
- 0:16where we examine an event in the history
- 0:18of the Royal Australian Navy the naval
- 0:21studies group at the University of New
- 0:23South Wales is supported in this series
- 0:25by the Royal Australian Navy Australian
- 0:27Naval Institute the naval Historical
- 0:29Society of Australia and the submarine
- 0:31Institute of Australia in this the first
- 0:34of three episodes we hear from
- 0:36historians who gathered for the 2019
- 0:38King Hall naval history seminar which
- 0:40discussed Australian Chiefs of naval
- 0:42stars their collective work will be
- 0:44brought together in a future book
- 0:45entitled Australian naval leaders the
- 0:48seminar was held at the strain Defence
- 0:50Force Academy in June 2019 this episode
- 0:54deals with the first Chiefs of naval
- 0:55staffs who successively led the Royal
- 0:57Australian Navy until the commencement
- 0:58of world war ii the discussion is led by
- 1:01Commander Alastair Cooper and the panel
- 1:03consists of Rear Admiral James goldrich
- 1:05is Allison Hartigan commander jeff
- 1:08mckinley dr. Joe Strasser and dr. David
- 1:11Stevens good morning ladies and
- 1:12gentlemen welcome so I thought I might
- 1:15start out by asking you David about
- 1:19Creswell who in many ways doesn't follow
- 1:23the mold in any way shape or form that
- 1:26it's a subsequent Chiefs of Naval Staff
- 1:29did I guess what could you start out by
- 1:32telling us a bit about him and how he
- 1:34came to be chief of naval staff I think
- 1:37you got to remember of course that he
- 1:39started at all so he was setting the
- 1:41mold but of course his situation was
- 1:46unique and the fact that he spent such a
- 1:49long time in the Navy in various in in
- 1:53various roles and particularly as its
- 1:55chief he was an ex Royal Navy officer
- 2:00who left early as lieutenant due to the
- 2:05fact that his father had died and he'd
- 2:07lost his private allowance because in
- 2:09those days you needed a private
- 2:10allowance to make a success for a naval
- 2:12career
- 2:13this is in the the 18 and 1880s and
- 2:17agree then came out to Australia to
- 2:19assist his brother trying to set up a
- 2:22past as a pastoralist
- 2:24and that didn't work too well and
- 2:27subsequently he was grabbed by one of
- 2:30his old shipmates come out of John
- 2:32Walcott who was the senior naval officer
- 2:35all and the in South Australia and
- 2:37Creswell ended up being the first
- 2:40lieutenant of the protector the gun the
- 2:43the I'm an armored Cruiser that the
- 2:48South Australians had and from that time
- 2:51once he'd joined that ship his career
- 2:55was basically set on its path that
- 2:57eventually led to him being the
- 2:58commander of the Australian Navy and
- 3:00part of that was just circumstances when
- 3:04he joined Protector is the first
- 3:06lieutenant he was unmarried there wasn't
- 3:09much to do he set himself to writing and
- 3:12he started realizing the problems that
- 3:14South Australia's defensed had in terms
- 3:17of the fact that the all the interest
- 3:20was in the army despite the fact as far
- 3:23as he could see the only possible threat
- 3:25to South Australia was from raiding
- 3:27cruisers and that really got him started
- 3:29and that basic argument about why are we
- 3:33spending all our time and energy
- 3:34worrying about giving people a rifle and
- 3:38marching them around when really in
- 3:40Australia first fully started with South
- 3:43Australia then he moved to the rest of
- 3:44Australia in terms of his strategic
- 3:46thinking the only real thread was going
- 3:50to be coming from sea from the sea and
- 3:54that basic fact was the core of his
- 3:57strategic thinking and he spent a lot of
- 3:59time writing getting published being
- 4:03mentioned in Parliament South Australian
- 4:04Parliament just because of his arguments
- 4:06which were which were bandied about and
- 4:09I'm not saying he was initially
- 4:10successful but he kept pushing and
- 4:12pushing and pushing and such that he
- 4:14eventually he rose through the South
- 4:16Australian Defence Forces spent time as
- 4:20the commander of the queensland naval
- 4:23defence forces the victorian navy
- 4:26and until eventually it became time when
- 4:28we federated that he was chosen as the
- 4:31first director of the Commonwealth naval
- 4:32forces and from there eventually to the
- 4:36first mobile member would it be fair to
- 4:39break from Cresswell's tenure up into
- 4:42maybe three parts being essentially
- 4:48arguing for the creation of the Navy the
- 4:51the form that that Navy would take with
- 4:54the first fleet unit and in the time
- 4:58that he spent his first naval member
- 5:01during the first world war so actually
- 5:02operating the Navy yeah it's um you can
- 5:06you can do that it's obviously a lot
- 5:08more complicated one of the things that
- 5:11you've got to remember about Creswell is
- 5:13that his ideas he was very much a
- 5:16politician he was very good at talking
- 5:19to the guy talking to the politicians
- 5:20convincing him of the of his ideas and
- 5:24how he's how how relevant they were but
- 5:28that didn't mean he initially got it all
- 5:30correct all the time particularly in
- 5:32those two in those times in the early
- 5:34twentieth century when there wasn't much
- 5:36money going around a naval defense
- 5:39tended to be a secondary thought because
- 5:41the the prime idea was to get Australia
- 5:45ready for an invasion by ensuring our
- 5:50land defenses were fine and of course
- 5:53creds would always say well what's the
- 5:54point of that if you're going to lose
- 5:56your trade but the other thing was for
- 6:00Creswell he it was a time of obviously
- 6:04major technological changes and it was
- 6:07very hard to come up with a force
- 6:10structure that would work with not much
- 6:12money and with things changing and he
- 6:16from sort of 1902 onwards he was pushing
- 6:19out you know do we need 24 destroyers or
- 6:23what sort of destroys that he's going to
- 6:25be and of course a destroyer in those
- 6:27days wasn't the same as a destroyer in
- 6:29these days and in fact one of the things
- 6:31he suggested was what was called a
- 6:33cruiser destroyer and one of the I think
- 6:36most people tend to think that what he's
- 6:38trying to talk talk
- 6:39about is a combination of a cruiser and
- 6:42a destroyer but what he was really
- 6:44talking about was like a torpedo boat
- 6:46destroyer ie something that destroys
- 6:48cruisers in said that sense of the term
- 6:52because that's what he saw as the major
- 6:54threat to Australia raiding cruisers
- 6:55that would it take our trade and of
- 6:58course he was still thinking along those
- 7:01lines in as we moved into the you know
- 7:05the the second decade of the of the
- 7:06twentieth century when he finally got
- 7:10some traction with people like Andrew
- 7:13Fisher and and Deakin our prime
- 7:16ministers who actually started to
- 7:18support the building up of an Australian
- 7:20Navy and in fact when we get to 1909 and
- 7:24the fleet unit decision what we got to
- 7:27remember there is it wasn't actually
- 7:29Crystal's idea it was it was Admiral
- 7:31Fisher the First Sea Lord in the UK v it
- 7:36was his idea for the fleet unit for the
- 7:37Dominions not CREZ oars Creswell would
- 7:40much rather have spent but the money or
- 7:42at least this is what it was saying at
- 7:44the time on what he called the
- 7:46foundations of a navy the bases the
- 7:49infrastructure that's what he wanted
- 7:51Australia to get into first and then
- 7:53move into the ships but of course with
- 7:56Fisher's fleet unit we actually got the
- 7:59Navy the fleet first rather than the
- 8:01naval infrastructure and fortunately
- 8:05however the brita the the Royal Navy
- 8:07when it you know supported the the plan
- 8:11for an Australian fleet unit was also
- 8:14happy to give the Australian government
- 8:18or Australian Navy a new Australian Navy
- 8:20all the infrastructure there were
- 8:22existed at Garden Island etc which
- 8:24obviously helped a lot and that we
- 8:25didn't have to build that up from
- 8:27scratch
- 8:29my turn now to Jeff McKinley who looked
- 8:34after or who's looking at Admiral grant
- 8:37who was the first successor in two to
- 8:43Creswell and and obviously the first
- 8:46Royal Navy officer to be brought from
- 8:50the UK to command the Royal Australian
- 8:52Navy Jeff I'm just wondering if you can
- 8:56tell us a little bit about the process
- 8:58selecting grant a little bit about the
- 9:01officer himself and also what was what
- 9:06was the writing instructions what
- 9:07problems did he face what issues did he
- 9:10need to address when he became first
- 9:12knoefel member yeah Thank You Alastair
- 9:15look
- 9:16Admiral grant this many way is a sailor
- 9:19sailor he he'd spent an entire noble
- 9:23career at sea early come ashore he'd
- 9:25specialized in the fastidious role of
- 9:27navigation and it sort of showed he'd
- 9:30come up mm-hmm excuse me he commanded
- 9:33various battleships he commanded had
- 9:35been chief of staff for the first battle
- 9:37squadron at Jutland he done all the
- 9:39thing he'd been to P dode in malboro he
- 9:42done all the sort of things you'd expect
- 9:43to see going lost to do except learn how
- 9:46to command a navy and he was that
- 9:49actually the third best candidate put
- 9:51forward by the Admiralty the Admiralty
- 9:53had hand-picked two other officers
- 9:55Admirals Lambert and halls Lee he would
- 9:57had just the right pedigree had been
- 9:59serving in the ambush he had a previous
- 10:02experience the Australian Navy but
- 10:04Australia was just a tad past - with our
- 10:07salary we'd offered only 3,000 pounds
- 10:10salary whereas the IRA instead was three
- 10:13and a half and also Sir Joseph cook the
- 10:16Navy Minister perhaps had a rather
- 10:18informal interview style that made the
- 10:21officers a bit uncomfortable so we
- 10:24actually missed out on the officers that
- 10:26that the almaty wanted to send we got
- 10:28grant instead and he wasn't a natural
- 10:31Court choice he was quite politically
- 10:33clumsy he was actually seeing demands
- 10:36upon his own and what's he saying that
- 10:38you better count this is equivalent to
- 10:40service in in the rule Admiralty
- 10:43and lord Jellico was no into prosperity
- 10:46construe this giant government law and
- 10:49referred to him as one those second tier
- 10:50our own officers that would be doubling
- 10:52the Aryan at this time so not really a
- 10:55natural choice to lead a navy and
- 10:58typically not to be the first RN officer
- 11:00doing so and he certainly faced some big
- 11:02problems
- 11:03organizationally the Navy of 1919 had
- 11:08been left behind after four years of war
- 11:11the technological tactical and
- 11:13organizational changes that had occurred
- 11:16very rapidly in Britain and that the
- 11:19Australian ships indeed had been exposed
- 11:21to hadn't filtered back to the
- 11:24Australian mainland and Grant when he
- 11:26did the Jellico ture welding first
- 11:30arriving in 1919 was quite aghast of
- 11:32what he found he tried to push through a
- 11:34bunch of changes really rapidly but that
- 11:36political clumsiness is very quickly
- 11:38came to the fore to just seeing a whole
- 11:40bunch of things that just went powerful
- 11:42to the government strength incredibly
- 11:44even to the point of threatening a de
- 11:46facto trade war with New Zealand if they
- 11:50can give us the high quality Welsh coal
- 11:51or local coal that we needed to make our
- 11:54ships run a bit more effective
- 11:56efficiently so he didn't really straight
- 12:01away he knew he had problems but really
- 12:03trouble to do something with it
- 12:05strategically he came into a very tense
- 12:09time Australia of 1919 was led by the
- 12:13very xenophobic and fearful Prime
- 12:16Minister Billy Hughes I think the ward
- 12:18really impacted him and Billy Hughes was
- 12:21looking towards Japan and saw an
- 12:23immediate threat they expected an
- 12:25imminent and overall me Japanese
- 12:27attacked and grant fully concurred with
- 12:29that and interesting that they look to
- 12:33two causes one was Japanese militarism
- 12:36but also as the Australian what the
- 12:40widest rainfall see and it was
- 12:42recognized by government and by grant
- 12:43this was provoked in the region but
- 12:48grant in assessing the strategic
- 12:50environment showed probably quite a
- 12:52disappointing which to achieve
- 12:53understanding he elevated the
- 12:56from these threat and the ability to act
- 12:58in the region and to fight a campaign
- 13:02and to appeal in the Australian doorstep
- 13:04unannounced discredited the impact of
- 13:07their commitments in China and career
- 13:10that was quite the quagmire or even the
- 13:12role that America could play in the any
- 13:15sort of future pacific conflict so
- 13:17strategically a difficult time but one
- 13:20that he wasn't really well posted for
- 13:23clearly financials was a big issue for
- 13:26him this was again Australian nation was
- 13:29trying to revert back to a peacetime
- 13:31spending and he faced continual
- 13:35unannounced cuts slicing off his budget
- 13:38often cut upon cut each financial year
- 13:42and and then I suppose the whole thing
- 13:45was the straight nation had been changed
- 13:47by war I don't think it's to exaggerate
- 13:50suggests that there was a real fear of
- 13:53revolution or disruption to the society
- 13:56and the government was much more focused
- 13:58upon financial aid to return soldiers by
- 14:02supporting a navy the euphoria that
- 14:05admit the arrival of the Australian
- 14:07fleet in 1913 had very much evaporated
- 14:09by time he could command in 1990
- 14:13thank you I think maybe there are two
- 14:17themes emerging at least in my head the
- 14:20first is a conception and Australian a
- 14:23conception of what a Navy actually
- 14:24consisted of how you funded it and you
- 14:28know what did it look like and the
- 14:30second issue is a common idea or an
- 14:35accept an idea of what you needed in the
- 14:37person to lead that Navy following grant
- 14:43there's a succession of three Royal Navy
- 14:46officers one of whom is Admiral Everett
- 14:50and then as followed then by Hall
- 14:53Thompson Napier and Monroe so Jeff I'm
- 14:59just wondering if you could continue on
- 15:02but looking at those two particular
- 15:06ideas of
- 15:08the consistency of what we thought the
- 15:10Navy was going to be part of and and the
- 15:13qualities that we look for in an officer
- 15:15to lead that may be well I think it
- 15:18takes you a second question first I
- 15:19think we learnt a lesson with Everett
- 15:21Everett was a far better choice and we
- 15:24actually get the position of CNS but for
- 15:27several months until the prime minister
- 15:29could get over for the 1921 Imperial
- 15:32conference and can handpick the officer
- 15:35but it really done if it was a far
- 15:38better rounded officer II Danny see time
- 15:40he had done all the things you'd expect
- 15:42an applause to do but he'd also had much
- 15:44bright broader exposure he'd been a
- 15:47favorite in it so it seen commanders up
- 15:49close suni command is up close very
- 15:51early on he twice commanded the naval
- 15:55signal schools to experience how to work
- 15:56in burocracy and how to work through
- 15:58political changes but most importantly
- 16:01after period is kept in the grand fleet
- 16:03and setting up Scarpa flow no small
- 16:06challenge he had then spent three and a
- 16:08half years in the Amity and at war and
- 16:11he'd served as the noble assistant to
- 16:13the First Sea Lord and then the noble
- 16:15secretary to the First Lord of the
- 16:16Admiralty
- 16:16I think it's fair to say that we've had
- 16:18few chiefs and chiefs or naval staff
- 16:20better prepared to understand the
- 16:22political elements for what we're
- 16:24looking for in our senior officers and
- 16:27it showed he understood the politics he
- 16:30understood the relationships with
- 16:32subordinates peers and political
- 16:35superiors it's far better and things
- 16:37were much smoother
- 16:39I suppose the incorporating environment
- 16:41he was in was also had evolved as well
- 16:45the Washington treaties of 1921 and
- 16:48afterwards had at least for a period put
- 16:51the Japanese threat back back in the box
- 16:54and and brought a bit more perspective
- 16:55to it and his job was to find the
- 16:58narrative that would define the future
- 17:01of the Australian Navy and he was
- 17:02actually able to find far more realistic
- 17:04narrative of a appropriately-sized may
- 17:07be focused on Imperial trade defence
- 17:10working with the RN that made sense in
- 17:15this context where in theory
- 17:17war had been rendered obsolete by treaty
- 17:19so
- 17:21every was definitely evolution to a far
- 17:24more effective leader but also one who
- 17:26was dealing a very different static
- 17:28environment by the time he'd taken up
- 17:30the job James I might ask you if you
- 17:36might look at the succeeding three
- 17:39Admirals or if you could just comment on
- 17:43them certainly talking about the three
- 17:45Royal Navy Admirals and gremlin has been
- 17:50working on these to great effect and I
- 17:53think he's found same sort of themes
- 17:56that Ellis has identified but also the
- 17:59same sort of effort on the part of the
- 18:01Admiralty that's reflected in the
- 18:03selection of Admiral Everett Paul
- 18:05Thompson Napier and Monroe Kerr
- 18:08all had backgrounds which were actually
- 18:10quite good to be Chiefs of the
- 18:13Australian Navy to give an example of
- 18:15Hall Thompson had actually been naval
- 18:18advisor in New Zealand before the first
- 18:19world war all of them had very diverse
- 18:22careers all of them had significant
- 18:23administrative experience all of them
- 18:26the Admiralty does make provision to see
- 18:29that they're not going to be
- 18:30disadvantaged all of them do seem to
- 18:33have been quite effective within what
- 18:37are very difficult circumstances
- 18:40politically and particularly financially
- 18:43although the Australian Navy was getting
- 18:45the lion's share of the defence vote in
- 18:47the 1920s and 1930s and the Air Force
- 18:51and the army were doing not well by
- 18:55comparison in fact the Australian Navy
- 18:57was not getting nearly enough money to
- 18:59do what it what it meant and what it was
- 19:02meant to do so there were some very
- 19:03difficult decisions about retrenchment
- 19:06submarines which we'd acquired new
- 19:09construction from the United Kingdom
- 19:11actually had to be given to the Royal
- 19:13Navy because we couldn't afford to run
- 19:14them and again that decision is a very
- 19:17difficult one to make but it's made on
- 19:19the basis that in fact retaining a
- 19:21cruiser force not only was strategically
- 19:24important but there's this view that in
- 19:26fact the crews are forced by its natural
- 19:29ability to train people and put numbers
- 19:32through was actually better
- 19:34as a core force for a future expansion
- 19:37of the Navy we're trying to run
- 19:39submarines was not only really difficult
- 19:41and very expensive but actually very
- 19:43difficult to generate people do they
- 19:48have trouble about coming into Australia
- 19:50as Royal Navy officers with not
- 19:54necessarily the right background they do
- 19:56have some trouble but all again because
- 19:59they're reasonably diverse background
- 20:00and halt Thompson particularly the
- 20:03others do well as well all seem to
- 20:05adjust and I think that's they have some
- 20:08advantages one is everything is in
- 20:09Melbourne at the time including the
- 20:11capital until 1927 they are socially
- 20:16inserted into the establishment very
- 20:19easily and I think the conversations and
- 20:22their presence make it easy for them to
- 20:26actually relate both to other
- 20:29bureaucrats and to the government that
- 20:32by the way changes after 1927 it gets
- 20:35more difficult because defence remains
- 20:38in Melbourne Parliament goes to Canberra
- 20:41and of course if you're not a Victorian
- 20:43politician that means there's almost no
- 20:45reason for you to go to Melbourne but in
- 20:49general I think they they handled a
- 20:51difficult situation well and I will say
- 20:54that there all of them attuned to the
- 20:58idea of growing the Australian Navy and
- 21:02a lot of the evidence is indirect rather
- 21:06than direct but they are looking at the
- 21:08graduates of the Australian Naval
- 21:10College coming through to be the future
- 21:13leaders the Australian Navy and they're
- 21:14trying to map their careers that way so
- 21:18for example Harrell fancam is sent on
- 21:20the Imperial defence course as a latina
- 21:22commander for a course that's normally
- 21:25conducted by senior captains you know
- 21:28there's all this sort of clever stuff
- 21:30going on to really push people through
- 21:33and what I would say is they're very
- 21:35happy with how well the Australian
- 21:37officers are doing when assessed by the
- 21:40Royal Navy and trained by the Royal Navy
- 21:42in serving in the Royal Navy they're
- 21:45comfortable that
- 21:46what's coming through is a quality
- 21:48quality product so in general I think
- 21:50they handle it as well as could be
- 21:52expected
- 21:53[Music]
- 21:55the officer who followed that group of
- 22:01first naval members was the second Royal
- 22:05Australian Navy officer Hyde is it fair
- 22:10to treat him as an exception and
- 22:14Australians exception or isn't he in
- 22:16fact in many ways a continuation of the
- 22:20Royal Navy officers who come before him
- 22:23he's both a continuation and a
- 22:26difference
- 22:27George Frances Hyde who in fact with
- 22:29Francis and that's what he took his
- 22:31knighthood as was a really interesting
- 22:34man in some ways he is what you could
- 22:38call the second father of the Australian
- 22:40Navy because he was chief enable start
- 22:43from 1931 to 1937 and really ensure that
- 22:48the Foundation's continued to be in
- 22:49place and were developed for an expanded
- 22:52Navy for future need he's a very
- 22:55interesting man he was very he was
- 22:57convinced that the australian navy's
- 22:58efficiency depended upon maintaining a
- 23:00close relationship with the royal navy
- 23:02and he in fact confirmed the rule which
- 23:05i think is very significant that you
- 23:07could not be promoted in the australian
- 23:09navy unless you had served in the rank
- 23:13before with the royal navy on loan or
- 23:17exchange and been recommended for
- 23:19promotion according to royal navy
- 23:21standards not Australian standards or
- 23:24Navy standards and indeed he would send
- 23:26back officers confidential reports to
- 23:29the Admiralty to get sent back to the
- 23:30Admiral concern to rewrite them if it
- 23:34said recommended for promotion in the
- 23:35Australian Navy what he wanted to know
- 23:38was you know could you could you make it
- 23:42by those standards but he himself
- 23:46I think the skits have both
- 23:47schizophrenic about the Royal Navy and
- 23:49also had wider perspectives first off he
- 23:52had served as Royal Navy officer but he
- 23:55had only got into the Royal Navy by
- 23:57special transfer from the Royal Naval
- 23:59Reserve
- 24:00sponsored as far as I can figure by a
- 24:02combination of lord Charles Beresford
- 24:04and Admiral Fisher which is a remarkable
- 24:07combination but it's quite clear that he
- 24:11had always wanted to be a Royal Navy
- 24:12officer but was from the wrong social
- 24:14background and it served as a merchant
- 24:17cadet in sale coming out to Australia
- 24:19and I think he fell in love with the
- 24:20country and then as a Royal Navy officer
- 24:24actually had a very hard bad time
- 24:27because he wasn't from the right social
- 24:29background so when the Australian Navy
- 24:31starts there's his opportunity as an
- 24:33experienced destroyer officer to get an
- 24:35acting third stripe and he always said
- 24:37he was asked to join the Australian Navy
- 24:40he repeatedly server the Royal Navy he
- 24:43attracted very high opinions in general
- 24:45from people like Admiral Jellico and his
- 24:48career was prepared all along from the
- 24:52time really he's a commander that he is
- 24:55going to be if he keeps doing as well as
- 24:57he is and he's given exchange command of
- 25:00the Royal Navy's biggest and most modern
- 25:02cruiser at the time which also was going
- 25:04to be its first equipped with a catapult
- 25:07of scouting aircraft he was given an
- 25:10exchange appointment as a battle
- 25:13squadron commander fact I think he's the
- 25:15only person ever to assert on exchange
- 25:17at flag rank and sigue and within the
- 25:21limits was well prepared he also had
- 25:25another perspective which I think is
- 25:26really interesting and he's on record
- 25:27he'd looked to America strategically as
- 25:32much as he did to Britain and he's
- 25:34actually saying in the 1920s that
- 25:37Singapore would be a really good base
- 25:39for the US Navy in the event of a
- 25:41Pacific War that's one of the reasons we
- 25:44should be supporting the development of
- 25:46the base and its variants here I can
- 25:48trace back he makes he's serving in
- 25:50Queenstown with the American destroyer
- 25:52flotillas in 1917-18 and he makes
- 25:54friends with Americans and again I think
- 25:56there's that element of social outlook
- 26:00you know he found that he found a a
- 26:03compatibility with American officers in
- 26:06ways that I'm not sure he found with the
- 26:07average Royal Navy officer but was he
- 26:11the right person he was very much
- 26:13I think it's inevitable for its
- 26:15background the man alone and I think the
- 26:18difficulties of being isolated
- 26:21particularly once Parliament had moved
- 26:26he also and this is an important point
- 26:28he'd suffered from cancer of of the
- 26:32tongue as chief of naval staff and was
- 26:36quite sick for some months they were
- 26:38able to fix it but I think by some
- 26:40horrendous surgery and radio and radio
- 26:42therapy which actually made impossible
- 26:45of him afterwards I think to speak in
- 26:46public so accentuates I think this
- 26:50solitude and he did have a lot of
- 26:53difficulties with both politicians and
- 26:55the people around him which I think were
- 26:57because he's so much the man alone
- 26:59whereas much his fault as theirs he
- 27:02didn't get on well with the squadron
- 27:03commanders he's certainly the last
- 27:06Minister for defence Archdale Park Hill
- 27:08effectively I think they're not on
- 27:10speaking terms by the end of his time so
- 27:13I think he had his limitations but my
- 27:17view is he was very firmly a Royal
- 27:19Australian Navy officer and that was his
- 27:21outlook but what I just like to finish
- 27:24off is I don't think we're comfortable
- 27:26with the way Australia's identity has
- 27:29evolved and you could think of yourself
- 27:31as Australian in 1930 or 1920 in
- 27:35different ways in relation to the United
- 27:37Kingdom though we would 19 40 or 50 or
- 27:4060 or indeed in 2019 thank you Hyde was
- 27:47succeeded by three another three Royal
- 27:52Navy officers Colvin royal and and
- 27:56Hamilton today I think we're going to
- 27:59skip over Colvin and just look at royal
- 28:05and and Hamilton and ear I'd like to
- 28:08bring in Allison and Joe Joe you first
- 28:12chronologically royal came before
- 28:14Hamilton it was he and and i'm i'm
- 28:20curious again about who
- 28:22why he was selected and the the fact
- 28:24that that series of three officers were
- 28:28not officers who were just on promotion
- 28:32to Rear Admiral as the ones who had
- 28:36preceded Hyde were but ones who had a
- 28:39more significant experience by the time
- 28:44they came to be the first naval member
- 28:46in Australia Weiss Edmund Royal came out
- 28:50in mid 1941 and rider who's coming to
- 28:54Australia he had served in the Admiralty
- 28:57initially is served as Secretary of no
- 29:01board and then he served as the fifth
- 29:03naval member whereas responsible
- 29:06seeing the reinvigoration as it were the
- 29:10raw Navy fleet air arm in the 1920s
- 29:14served at the British Embassy in Tokyo
- 29:18so you've got a man here who is a wide
- 29:23admitted admin experience he commanded a
- 29:26carrier at sea he served as a gunnery
- 29:28officer so he got white sea service but
- 29:31importantly also he's got a view of the
- 29:34region which would quite in Tokyo so he
- 29:38would have seen the evolution to use a
- 29:42word of the right ship between Britain
- 29:45and Japan in the 20s the worsening
- 29:49relationship and also the changing
- 29:52politics in Japan and the rise of
- 29:55radical nationalism so in many ways well
- 30:00yeah he was he was quite a good pick for
- 30:01the period now when he Tommy came out
- 30:05here the war in Europe had been raging
- 30:08for some time and the possibility of war
- 30:11in Civic was very much on everybody's
- 30:13radar screens and his presa sir had been
- 30:16involved in a number of discussions and
- 30:19committee meetings its singapore
- 30:21concerning the defense the region so a
- 30:24lot of that earlier strategic planning
- 30:26the framework had been laid out there
- 30:29and this had involved also the Americans
- 30:32but because of the political situation
- 30:34in America
- 30:37America was viewed as an associated of
- 30:40power it wasn't and considered to be an
- 30:42ally or a partner at stage now in the
- 30:46Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor of course
- 30:49those circumstances changed but not only
- 30:52those strategic circumstance has changed
- 30:54all those pre-war plans from 1941
- 30:57effectively went out the window too
- 30:59because the Japanese just steamrolled
- 31:02the British American the Dutch and the
- 31:05Australians and in very quick succession
- 31:08after royal arrived and of course the
- 31:12first two were before the Japanese
- 31:15attack we lost Sydney Parramatta earth
- 31:19Yarra so so for a small Navy that was a
- 31:22very beginning in Chiefs and especially
- 31:24in personnel so so royal yeah it is
- 31:29faced these losses he then faced with a
- 31:32change in circumstances which probably
- 31:37no other Royal Navy officer who's come
- 31:40out as the first naval member has faced
- 31:42and that is of the the defense of
- 31:44Australia is placed in the hands of
- 31:47effectively of the Americans the
- 31:49southwest Pacific Theatre is created and
- 31:51that includes all of Australia MacArthur
- 31:55takes command and he brings in his own
- 31:58naval people so that's initially
- 32:02everyone Larry and then Admiral
- 32:04carpenter who had one stage I'm not sure
- 32:08whether it's a right at the very start
- 32:09or after all gets promoted he's actually
- 32:13junior to Royal but Rob royal doesn't
- 32:15yeah he's been honest from the fact that
- 32:19Compton maybe junior to him he accepts
- 32:22the role given to him by the Australian
- 32:23government and in many ways that role is
- 32:26reflective of the roles of the chief of
- 32:29navies today which is to raise trying to
- 32:31sustain the force the operational
- 32:34application of that force was
- 32:36effectively in the hands of the
- 32:37Americans and ships that was still
- 32:40allocated to the Admiralty and he was in
- 32:44that role effectively to the end of the
- 32:47war
- 32:47he was extended it in Australia he was
- 32:50promoted while he's out here and it's
- 32:53only in the final stages of the war that
- 32:56he's relieved and returned back to the
- 32:59United Kingdom one of the interesting
- 33:04things mentioned in fact on his
- 33:06departure that Navy Minister mr. Macon
- 33:09pay tribute upon royal in the efforts he
- 33:12went to to meet ships returning from
- 33:17operational duties when when Australia
- 33:20was hit by the kamikazes in the
- 33:22Philippines and then return to the to a
- 33:24forward base royal travelled to meet the
- 33:27ship and as that sort of I think he was
- 33:31very much interested in the people as
- 33:33well yeah there's there was another
- 33:37reason during the war years where he
- 33:40actually send a signal back to the
- 33:41Admiralty telling them I got it wrong
- 33:44when the director of Naval Intelligence
- 33:48was reprimanded by the Admiralty and the
- 33:53British and recenter the final paragraph
- 33:56on the message that went on the law yeah
- 33:59we would expect but you kept informed of
- 34:00these things Roy went back and said well
- 34:04yeah the information was available to
- 34:06you and by the way yeah we're part of
- 34:09you southwest Pacific Command we're not
- 34:11part of a novelty command so yeah he
- 34:13didn't mind putting people in their
- 34:17places of work it was also very I think
- 34:21strategically aware shortly after his
- 34:24arrival he ordered the construction of
- 34:27arrange for the construction of has dick
- 34:31fitted and motor launches for ASW work
- 34:33now whilst they may not have been 100%
- 34:36suitable the problem was of course the
- 34:39shipyards in Australia though are
- 34:41already at capacity
- 34:42the only yards available with small
- 34:44yards which were had built trawlers
- 34:47worked in wood so these are the craft he
- 34:50ordered as the chief of Navy he received
- 34:55on a daily basis the situation reports
- 34:58from the combined operational
- 34:59intelligence
- 35:01all those he'd noticed in April 42
- 35:04American carriers have disappeared so he
- 35:09asked the chief of deputy chief Navy to
- 35:12ask the director of plans to draw up a
- 35:14plan for attack on Japan or three
- 35:17aircraft carriers surely have that
- 35:20instruction when out the doodle right
- 35:24occurred so it clearly his own knowledge
- 35:27of carriers and and the concept of
- 35:31carrier aviation etc yeah came to play
- 35:35there
- 35:36unfortunately whilst the original minute
- 35:38survives the operational plans were
- 35:41supposedly drawn up by the director of
- 35:42planes doesn't that would have been an
- 35:44issue one just to see four I say yeah
- 35:47based on historical curiosity Thank You
- 35:55Admiral Hamilton so he arrived in
- 36:00Australia with a mission
- 36:02Admiral royal it had great difficulty
- 36:04convincing the government to fund
- 36:08purchase of fleet units for the post-war
- 36:11lady he arrived with an incredible
- 36:15background of experience and connection
- 36:18back into the Admiralty he was the
- 36:22grandson of an admiral and the son of an
- 36:25admiral
- 36:26he was very closely connected throughout
- 36:29his time to his mother who had great
- 36:33links into both the Admiralty and the
- 36:36royal family he connected often with
- 36:42various people particularly Captain
- 36:44Foley back in the office in the
- 36:47Admiralty on a regular basis he's the
- 36:52only chief of Navy as naval staff that
- 36:55was in command of two fleet units one
- 36:59during the First World War and one
- 37:01during the Second World War so he had a
- 37:03very vast and deep range of experience
- 37:07to bring as well as his adeptness at
- 37:11playing the political game as it were
- 37:15he's mission in coming to Australia was
- 37:18to convince the Australian government
- 37:21and the Defense Department of the time
- 37:26to develop blue water operations the
- 37:30concept being to have one carrier to
- 37:33attack and one to defend and to build
- 37:36the Australian Navy for the future
- 37:39around that minimum to carry a concept
- 37:42okay the next question I'd like to move
- 37:48on to after I read my notes is is to
- 38:00look at the achievements of of each of
- 38:04these officers and so as I go through as
- 38:08we go through each each panelist if I
- 38:10could ask you to talk about what the
- 38:12long-term achievements were for the
- 38:15officer and and maybe also to comment on
- 38:19I think their political adeptness in in
- 38:23having achieved that so David and just
- 38:27to give you a little bit of time to get
- 38:29it together I think we could I ask you
- 38:32to talk Creswell more than just the
- 38:35creation of the Royal Australian Navy
- 38:36which is obviously the headline enduring
- 38:40achievement for Creswell but was there
- 38:43was there more to it than that yeah look
- 38:45cruisers achievements certainly not just
- 38:49in creating a Navy but in actually
- 38:51getting the Australian politicians and
- 38:53also the public to start thinking about
- 38:55Australia as a maritime nation and his
- 38:59legacy in many ways can be seen in what
- 39:01he produced in those early years from
- 39:04his time in the South Australian Navy
- 39:05and onwards in actually setting out the
- 39:08arguments of why we needed Navy why we
- 39:10were a maritime nation where our
- 39:12interest really lay and he was very
- 39:14successful in that and when you think
- 39:16about what happened as we move on into
- 39:18the fleet units arrival in 1913 you'd
- 39:22actually set up the the background for
- 39:26the the
- 39:27the fleet units that we could arrive in
- 39:30an area and be used in a useful
- 39:32strategic manner it wasn't just it
- 39:35didn't just turn up the naval board at
- 39:38the time was thinking about how best to
- 39:40use it forest in Australia's interests
- 39:42and this was very much a strategic
- 39:44outlook that did not just include
- 39:46Australia but included Australia as part
- 39:48of the Empire and looking at the Pacific
- 39:50as a whole and the Indian Ocean and he
- 39:53really pushed this this idea that we
- 39:57were talking great distances in the
- 39:59Pacific great distances around Australia
- 40:02he'd often compare you know fleet going
- 40:05from Malta to the UK and say well you
- 40:08know we do that just going from one side
- 40:09of Australia the other that's the sort
- 40:11of thinking he tried to put in there he
- 40:16certainly did a lot to set up at the
- 40:18Navy for the first world war and such
- 40:22that it was the most efficient the most
- 40:23knowledgeable of the services when in
- 40:26entering the war not that he did it by
- 40:29himself
- 40:29he appreciated that he couldn't do it by
- 40:31himself and got to remember in those
- 40:34days are very small fleets a very small
- 40:36staff and he in the end he required an
- 40:41assistant which he brought out from the
- 40:42UK commander thrinng who was
- 40:46instrumental in putting kraslow's ideas
- 40:49into action and also doing things like
- 40:52creating an intelligence service and
- 40:54eventually ensuring that we worthy said
- 40:57the best-informed of the services at the
- 40:59start of the war thank you Jeff turning
- 41:04to grant and Everett what do you think
- 41:06their enduring achievements might have
- 41:08been well I think for grant it's that is
- 41:11the reforms he made to the novel board
- 41:12so very early DS arrival he splits the
- 41:18role and redefined the role so he
- 41:21actually established the executive role
- 41:23of chief of naval staff so up until that
- 41:27point the never board as a whole was
- 41:29responsible for naval operations and
- 41:31that was not particularly effective so
- 41:34he kept the devil bored he read so tidy
- 41:37things up there but first on remember
- 41:39your first mark equals of
- 41:41the non ministerial people on the board
- 41:44but then he set up the position of chief
- 41:46of naval staff who would have the
- 41:48executive command or the Navy on
- 41:50operations and he also did some work to
- 41:54improve the noble staff and they would
- 41:55have to do that operation but and in
- 41:58doing so he actually implemented one of
- 42:00the things that Jellico recommend him to
- 42:02do it also showed his political weakness
- 42:06and the way he went about this so he got
- 42:08this through he just ordered it to
- 42:10happen himself without really great lot
- 42:12of consultation and that was his problem
- 42:15the whole way through his that he didn't
- 42:17really have his own plan he had the
- 42:19Jellico plan and the Jellico plan was
- 42:21not really realistic and so he could
- 42:24have achieved so much more but because
- 42:26he was a slave to a plan written by more
- 42:29Jellico a plan that was totally
- 42:31disconnected from the realities in both
- 42:33Britain and Australia what he did
- 42:36achieve was far less but he did have
- 42:38some other things like he established
- 42:40the hydrographic service he did improve
- 42:42some stands in the fleet through better
- 42:45double board inspections and he actually
- 42:47got some pay rises through for the Navy
- 42:49personnel Everett by comparison was a
- 42:53far less showy Admiral and punk measure
- 42:56than what he tried to achieve but as a
- 42:59literature before his really great
- 43:00achievement was that he provided a
- 43:02narrative of the Navy Post the
- 43:05Washington treaty changes that actually
- 43:07made sense
- 43:07it was modest in design but it was
- 43:11sufficiently inclusive that the
- 43:14government the people the Navy the
- 43:16bureaucrats could all sign up to agree
- 43:18that yes Imperial trade defense was
- 43:21important we did need some heavy
- 43:23cruisers to do that and he set the scene
- 43:25for the decision to the purchase of hey
- 43:28Australia in Canberra at a time when
- 43:30money was so incredibly short so I think
- 43:33that really set the Navy up for the next
- 43:3610-15 years at least thank you
- 43:40James could I ask you to as summarize
- 43:45what you think the achievements of the
- 43:46next three offices were I think the
- 43:48achievements of the four well in fact
- 43:51the four offices I think the achievement
- 43:52is really keep things going and to keep
- 43:54things together under extraordinary
- 43:56financial pressure the fact that they
- 44:00did sustain the core and efficient
- 44:02Australian Navy and a foundation for the
- 44:04future I think is an achievement of all
- 44:08of them and I don't think you can
- 44:10discount the difficulties they all faced
- 44:15we had no idea I think in the present
- 44:19day of the pressure and the extent of
- 44:23the reductions in funding hmm which were
- 44:26continuous really until about 1934 and
- 44:31even then it any starts to scale up
- 44:34really slowly I get back to this point
- 44:36that the fact that the Navy was getting
- 44:40more than the other services not me in
- 44:41the Navy was getting enough I think
- 44:44that's an important point but I think
- 44:46they were the way they were able to keep
- 44:48the Corps going and I don't think any of
- 44:52them lost sight of the need for that is
- 44:53a collective achievement of them all as
- 44:56to adeptness I think actually the three
- 45:00British officers were all politically
- 45:04quite adept hide less so and but I do
- 45:08think hide circumstances and frankly
- 45:13he's you know he was not as strongly
- 45:15tactically positioned as a Royal Navy
- 45:18officer on loan for a few years to some
- 45:22extent because he was RA in his position
- 45:25I think was a little weaker but I think
- 45:28the separation of parliament from the
- 45:34government from the administration was a
- 45:36really critical difficulty I think in
- 45:39fact that dogged the later chiefs of
- 45:40naval staff for many years as well thank
- 45:43you
- 45:44Joe turning to Admiral Royal ironic I
- 45:49think Rawls potentially greatest
- 45:51achievement was also probably the
- 45:53biggest fader and that was the attempt
- 45:55to acquire an aircraft carrier towards
- 45:57the end of the war and that was a
- 46:01potentially filed because he discussed
- 46:04the issue with Shedden who was the
- 46:07secretary the department of defense
- 46:08Shedden has had developed his own
- 46:11strategic concepts which did not
- 46:14necessarily have carrier aviation at the
- 46:18fall but by putting it on the table yeah
- 46:23yeah it was there it was a concept that
- 46:26was subsequently built on by successes
- 46:28and I think the other achievement would
- 46:30be you could argue is that up until
- 46:33World War two the strategic concept of a
- 46:35threat to Australia had been cruiser
- 46:37raids raids by enemy cruisers and so the
- 46:42Rin was oriented around that as a
- 46:46defense under royal he was appointed
- 46:51commander south or specific sea
- 46:53frontiers which was an any submarine
- 46:55oriented organization and I think that
- 46:59we pull together an organization which
- 47:02was involved the Air Force which is a
- 47:05faithfully in any submarine organization
- 47:07to defend seaborne trade and the
- 47:10submarine was yeah really this earth the
- 47:13the threat that was in developing so it
- 47:15was exposing a whole raft the junior
- 47:19naval officers to working with the Air
- 47:22Force working on the on the ASW problem
- 47:26and focusing on a he SW problem and I
- 47:29think if you look down through the 50s
- 47:31and 60s we God there's that very heavy a
- 47:36SW force structure Thank You al
- 47:42what would you think Admiral Hamilton's
- 47:44major achievements were he worked very
- 47:48quickly in the short time that he had he
- 47:50was chief of metal staff for two and a
- 47:53half years
- 47:54under a great deal of pressure to pave
- 47:58the way for Admiral Collins he had to do
- 48:02a lot of work in short order when a lot
- 48:04of decisions were being made very
- 48:05quickly at the end of the Second World
- 48:07War with some very very strong
- 48:10personalities such as sheddin and the
- 48:13other two service chiefs vying for
- 48:15resources as Australia was taking on the
- 48:19post war footing so he managed to have a
- 48:25lot of resources etc port to the Navy at
- 48:30a time when there was a lot of interest
- 48:32in the Air Force the development of the
- 48:34Air Force in the Army and quite a lot of
- 48:37infighting amongst the service chiefs as
- 48:39to who was going to man the the aircraft
- 48:42carriers should they be bought so the
- 48:47Air Force was not keen on demobilizing
- 48:50to the extent that they were were
- 48:53looking at and the Air Force was
- 48:57positioning itself to take on that role
- 49:01from the Navy side now it was quite a
- 49:04win on Hamilton's part to convince the
- 49:08government to purchase these two
- 49:12cruisers he also positioned them to
- 49:15carry sorry my apologies thinking too
- 49:19many things at once so he also did a lot
- 49:23of work for the development of the array
- 49:27in his haul down speech was more this
- 49:31report was more about the issues with
- 49:33morale and the decline of the array in
- 49:36personnel at the time then necessarily
- 49:40about equipment etc he was quite
- 49:43concerned about making sure that the
- 49:45array n was ready to take on a growth of
- 49:49the Fleet Air Arm another thing that he
- 49:53did that was behind the scenes was the
- 49:55mentoring of Admiral Collins and the
- 49:57work that he did with Admiral royal etc
- 50:00on ensuring that Collins was receiving
- 50:03the postings and the training required
- 50:05for him to step in and be ready to
- 50:07develop
- 50:08we're armed thank you very much
- 50:11um in thanking the panelists for this
- 50:15first session I think it's interesting
- 50:19to reflect on one the challenge of
- 50:21trying to understand a national
- 50:24institution like the Royal Australian
- 50:25Navy over a almost a half-century period
- 50:29and the changes that were wrought and
- 50:32the challenges that were faced but also
- 50:35to reflect on the difficulties of
- 50:36understanding the the individuals who
- 50:39served in this position in the context
- 50:42of the service that they that they were
- 50:46running but also the nation which that
- 50:48which which that navy served and until
- 50:51you can actually start to integrate all
- 50:53of those it becomes quite hard to assess
- 50:55the performance of the individuals so I
- 50:57think it's a considerable challenge
- 50:59which our panelists have done really
- 51:01well so ladies gentlemen thank you very
- 51:03much thank you for joining us and for
- 51:05more information on the Australian naval
- 51:07history video and podcast series simply
- 51:10search for naval studies group on your
- 51:12search engine good bye for now
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Australian Naval Leaders - The Early Years by UNSW Canberra, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,606 words across 1,114 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.