Aula pública sobre prevenção quaternária - SBMFCEnsina — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, good evening to everyone. My
- 0:12name is Ricardo Heinson, I am a family
- 0:14and community physician, and director
- 0:16of undergraduate and graduate studies
- 0:18at our Brazilian Society of Family and
- 0:21Community Medicine. We are starting
- 0:25today our 11th public lecture for this
- 0:29project that has been a great success
- 0:32and very popular, which is SBMFC
- 0:35Teaches. It is a theoretical channel
- 0:39from our Brazilian Society for students
- 0:42and residents of Family and Community
- 0:44Medicine, covering key topics within
- 0:47the universe of Family and Community
- 0:49Medicine. Today we will have a special
- 0:53lecture, a very, very highly
- 0:55anticipated topic, which is the theme
- 0:58of quaternary prevention. I will first
- 1:03pass it over, before introducing our
- 1:05guest, our great guest of the evening.
- 1:08I will also pass it to Lucas so he can
- 1:11give his initial greeting, and then we
- 1:13will move on to our guest. Over to you,
- 1:17Lucas. Hey everyone, how are you all
- 1:20doing? Good evening to all, or good
- 1:23morning, good afternoon, or good night,
- 1:25depending on the time you are watching
- 1:27this. We are starting, as Ricardo
- 1:30mentioned, another SBMFC Teaches
- 1:32session. I am Lucas, I am the director
- 1:35of medical residency for the Brazilian
- 1:37society, a professor at the Federal
- 1:39University of São Carlos, and I am
- 1:41here with you today, along with Ricardo
- 1:44and our guest, who you will find out
- 1:46about shortly if you haven't seen yet.
- 1:50Very welcome, everyone. I hope we have
- 1:53a great conversation now. It is an
- 1:57essential theme within family and
- 1:59community medicine. Actually, in any
- 2:02medical field, this topic is becoming
- 2:04increasingly essential. But for us, who
- 2:07care for people and are much more
- 2:10concerned with the care process and
- 2:13avoiding excesses—already giving a
- 2:16hint—it is a key topic.
- 2:20Uh-huh. Certainly, Lucas. And before
- 2:24anyone asks in the chat, just a
- 2:26reminder, these lectures offer a
- 2:28certificate. It will be available for
- 2:31everyone on YouTube, but those watching
- 2:33online right now get a certificate of
- 2:35participation. To get the certificate,
- 2:38simply enter your name, institution,
- 2:41and city of origin in the live YouTube
- 2:44chat. And when our communications
- 2:47advisor, Ana, posts the link to the
- 2:49contact form to receive the certificate
- 2:51, please fill it out, okay? you fill
- 2:54out the link that will appear in just a
- 2:57moment in the YouTube chat. Well, so,
- 3:01without further delay, we are very
- 3:04happy today to introduce our guest,
- 3:07family and community physician,
- 3:09professor Rogério Luiz Coelho Neto. He
- 3:14is a physician for the city of Curitiba
- 3:17and a preceptor for the family and
- 3:19community medicine residency in
- 3:21Curitiba. He is also a professor at the
- 3:26medical school of the Positivo course,
- 3:28also in Curitiba, and a supervisor for
- 3:31the Mais Médicos program, right? And
- 3:36now, within the Brazilian society, he
- 3:38has also played an essential role,
- 3:40especially during this period we are
- 3:42experiencing, this pandemic for over a
- 3:44year and a half. He has coordinated our
- 3:49special COVID-19 working group from the
- 3:52beginning, and he has brilliantly led,
- 3:55from the start, the production of our
- 3:58guidelines—recommendations, rather—
- 4:01for facing COVID-19 in the primary
- 4:03healthcare setting. It is material that
- 4:08, here is a tip for all of you, is
- 4:10available on the society's website.
- 4:14Material that is comprehensive, with
- 4:17major issues drawn from literature
- 4:19reviews and the best available evidence
- 4:23, which I think all residents and
- 4:25students should take a look at, and
- 4:28which was certainly prepared with great
- 4:31care by Rogério. So, without further
- 4:36ado, I pass the floor to Rogério for
- 4:39us to have this lecture, and afterwards
- 4:42, everyone please stay attentive to
- 4:45post questions and comments in the chat
- 4:48. The ball is in your court, Rogério.
- 4:52Good evening. I thank the Brazilian
- 4:55society for the invitation again. This
- 4:57time I was able to happily accept. I
- 5:00thank Ricardo, I thank Lucas. So, I am
- 5:03Rogério, and they have already said
- 5:05who I am. So, without further ado, we
- 5:07are going to start. The guidance we
- 5:10have is that you please leave comments
- 5:13in the chat so we can organize
- 5:14ourselves. It is much more interesting
- 5:18for us to answer your questions than
- 5:19for you to keep listening to me here
- 5:21for a long time. So, the lecture is
- 5:24programmed to be a very introductory
- 5:26and conversational session. So, once
- 5:29you start asking questions, we can
- 5:31begin to interact in a more relaxed way
- 5:34. So, I am going to share my screen now
- 5:37. So, we are in this wonderful program
- 5:42that is SBMC Teaches, and we are going
- 5:45to talk about quaternary prevention
- 5:47today. This is me. And that is it. So,
- 5:53man, when we talk about quaternary
- 5:55prevention, it’s the last of the
- 5:59levels of prevention, right? So, the
- 6:02levels of prevention, according to
- 6:04Leavell and Clark, these are the
- 6:06classic levels we use in family
- 6:07medicine. Uh, you have to be a little
- 6:12careful, because social and preventive
- 6:15medicine uses other concepts for levels
- 6:18of prevention too, but ours in family
- 6:20medicine, not social and preventive
- 6:23health, are these four. The primary
- 6:27level of prevention is the prevention
- 6:28of diseases and the promotion of health
- 6:30. These are those sanitary measures,
- 6:35vaccines, uh, well, population-level
- 6:39disease screening, these are
- 6:42preventions, promotions, interventions
- 6:46made so a person doesn't develop a
- 6:50disease. So, the primary level of
- 6:54health, uh, of health prevention that
- 6:57we have with Leavell and Clark, which
- 7:00we use in family medicine in general,
- 7:03is this level of not letting a disease
- 7:07happen, not letting you get sick, not
- 7:10letting our colleagues, friends,
- 7:12patients, and loved ones we care for
- 7:15suffer from any harm. The secondary
- 7:21level is diagnosing a disease and
- 7:24treating it, preferably as early as
- 7:27possible, but always to avoid worsening
- 7:31that disease, sequelae, and future
- 7:34morbidities. Uh, that's what we always
- 7:39do with hypertension and diabetes
- 7:41control, which, more than diseases, are
- 7:43uh, risk factors for cardiovascular
- 7:46disease, right? Anyway, uh, you live in
- 7:50a a it's a blurry path to call diabetes
- 7:55a disease, or hypertension a disease,
- 7:58when you know they are more, uh,
- 8:02especially at the start of their
- 8:05history, uh, risk factors, right? But
- 8:10anyway, let's suppose frank
- 8:12hypothyroidism, right? Not that one
- 8:16from a test where the person feels
- 8:18nothing and the doctor gives medicine
- 8:20to improve a test that does nothing for
- 8:22anyone. Uh, but frank hypothyroidism,
- 8:26we treat the hypothyroidism, we treat
- 8:30the migraine, we improve quality of
- 8:32life, we improve the person's ability
- 8:36to have their functions established and
- 8:39working. Yeah, we give that person a
- 8:44chance not to have the sequelae of
- 8:46whatever disease they have at the
- 8:49moment. Tertiary prevention in this
- 8:54Leavell and Clark context is
- 8:56rehabilitation. it's having the disease
- 9:01, not having had the time, not having
- 9:05managed, not having had the opportunity
- 9:08, generally, to avoid a sequela. And
- 9:13tertiary prevention is rehabilitation,
- 9:16it is fixing this sequela, it is
- 9:18working on this sequela, it is bringing
- 9:22the best or the best possible quality
- 9:25of life to this person who has this
- 9:28sequela from a disease, to bring them
- 9:31to be as functional or as well-adjusted
- 9:34to their eh sequela as possible. So
- 9:38these are the classic primary,
- 9:40secondary and tertiary preventions by
- 9:42Leavell and Clark. And now we talk a
- 9:47lot about this quaternary prevention.
- 9:51Quaternary prevention, instead of being
- 9:55a fourth-stage prevention, right? If
- 10:00you look at the first preventions, the
- 10:02first, primary, secondary, tertiary,
- 10:04they are a progression of a natural
- 10:07history of a disease. So before I have
- 10:09nothing, and I have to do prevention
- 10:11and promotion. Then I have the disease,
- 10:15but I undergo treatment, whether
- 10:18pharmacological or not, as a way to
- 10:21reduce future sequelae or improve
- 10:24quality of life, or, well, eh, treat
- 10:27this disease. The third one is, I
- 10:30already have the disease, I already
- 10:33have the sequela, I already have a
- 10:35worse quality of life, but I have to
- 10:38rescue this, bring it back. And the
- 10:41quaternary one, instead of being an
- 10:44evolution, let's suppose, of this
- 10:47tertiary prevention, it actually
- 10:50permeates, it is the backdrop for all
- 10:53these other preventions. So, when we
- 10:57talk about quaternary prevention, what
- 10:58are we talking about? We mean that we
- 11:02want to prevent the harms of exams,
- 11:05medications, treatments and
- 11:07interventions inherent to the
- 11:10biomedical model. We want to go back in
- 11:15time and bring medicine back to its
- 11:18Hippocratic principles. And one of the
- 11:22Hippocratic principles is primum non
- 11:25nocere, which is that you first do no
- 11:27harm, first do not cause harm to the
- 11:30person. Quaternary prevention, the
- 11:35philosophy of it is that generally less
- 11:38is better, it's more. So, quaternary
- 11:43prevention comes in a search, in a need
- 11:49that medicine has to bring answers to
- 11:52people. People tend to want us to
- 11:57practice quaternary medicine. People
- 12:03say this to us: "No, doctor, but I take
- 12:05this medicine and I feel sick. What
- 12:08could I have? many things in medicine.
- 12:12The answer is:" I don't know what to do
- 12:14, sir. You are feeling sick because of
- 12:16the doctor ". Eh, and quaternary
- 12:20prevention comes to bring these answers
- 12:23to us, it comes to explain to the
- 12:26doctor that any intervention, any
- 12:29medication, treatment, any word
- 12:31sometimes from the doctor can cause
- 12:34harm to this person. So, quaternary
- 12:38prevention, it all other levels of
- 12:43prevention and healthcare, it should be
- 12:46what we aim for the most, which is
- 12:49helping someone without ever hindering
- 12:52them. That is practically impossible.
- 12:56There is no way to interact with a
- 12:58person without causing something in
- 13:01them. And whenever we cause something,
- 13:04we have both the positive and the
- 13:06negative side. Even when giving a
- 13:09diabetes diagnosis, you can destabilize
- 13:11that person. And for many people, for
- 13:15many doctors who might be thinking
- 13:17about this, oh, Rogério, come on, it's
- 13:19just a hypothyroidism diagnosis. The
- 13:22person will take some levothyroxine
- 13:24there, and it's not even a serious one,
- 13:26just subclinical. I'll treat it just so
- 13:29the endocrinologist doesn't get mad at
- 13:30me. And they don't understand that just
- 13:34the words" you have a disease "can
- 13:37sometimes be an iatrogenic act. You
- 13:41will have to deal with that, you will
- 13:43have to deal with ideas and functions
- 13:46in that person's life that change them
- 13:48forever. They will always, it may be,
- 13:52they may always have a stigma in their
- 13:54life. Now I have hypothyroidism, and
- 13:58that will be a stigma they will carry
- 14:00forever. The great, the great movements
- 14:04in medicine today are towards
- 14:06quaternary prevention. Why? Because
- 14:11technology, hard technology, that
- 14:14technology of exams, of CT scans, of
- 14:17PET scans, of surgical robots, of the
- 14:20endoscopic pill, this technology
- 14:23doesn't care if it causes harm to the
- 14:26patient, because that's not what it was
- 14:30made for. It is never made with the
- 14:36thought of" I will invent a PET scan
- 14:38and find so many incidentalomas, so
- 14:41much cancer that wouldn't cause
- 14:44anything to the person, wouldn't
- 14:47progress, wouldn't kill, wouldn't cause
- 14:50symptoms. "I don't realize that my hard
- 14:55technology is doing harm, is causing
- 14:58overdiagnosis, is diagnosing more than
- 15:01it should. Wow, Rogério, but does that
- 15:04really exist? It does. Too many exams,
- 15:10too much treatment, too much therapy,
- 15:14too much care. So this shift towards
- 15:21quaternary prevention, to understand
- 15:24that everything we do can potentially
- 15:27harm the patient, shows that yes, there
- 15:30is too much medicine, too much care,
- 15:33there is an excess in our pursuit of
- 15:36the optimal. So, what are the concepts
- 15:42we must understand and that you, and
- 15:44that we will study and we will have to
- 15:46read, and we won't exhaust here because
- 15:49there's no way quaternary prevention
- 15:51can be covered in a single night's
- 15:53class. We could do a, I don't know, a
- 15:57months-long course on quaternary
- 16:00prevention, giving several examples,
- 16:03and for every test, every treatment,
- 16:05every symptom, we could talk about
- 16:08quaternary prevention. But, what about
- 16:12the student, what about the newly
- 16:14graduated doctor? What about the
- 16:17resident, what about the doctor
- 16:19interested in being a better doctor,
- 16:21not just a better health technician?
- 16:24Because look, if you graduate from
- 16:26medical school today, go to work, and
- 16:28order an X-ray of the spine for
- 16:30everyone with back pain, without
- 16:32criteria, you are a health technician.
- 16:34You are doing a technical thing, which
- 16:37is ordering an X-ray, but without any
- 16:39critical thought, without any protocol,
- 16:42in short, without the care of a good P4
- 16:44, of good quaternary prevention.
- 16:48Quaternary prevention is well
- 16:50acquainted with her. For those who have
- 16:54dated, held hands, gone to the mall,
- 16:56eaten popcorn at the movies, cried when
- 16:59their favorite team lost, she can be
- 17:02called, but you have to have, you know,
- 17:04given that care to quaternary
- 17:06prevention. So, P4, I need you to root
- 17:13some concepts so you can have better P4
- 17:16discussions. So, what are the concepts?
- 17:21They are about diagnosis, overdiagnosis
- 17:24, and treatment. Overdiagnosis is me
- 17:27making a diagnosis of things that, even
- 17:30though they are there, So, for example,
- 17:33you go there, make a diagnosis of
- 17:36subclinical hypothyroidism, the
- 17:38reference value was five and your
- 17:41patient comes in with a TSH of 5.5. It
- 17:45is hyperthyroidism, it is euthyroidism.
- 17:48Nobody in P4 is going to tell you:" No,
- 17:50that's nonsense, it's not
- 17:51hypothyroidism. "" No, no. "We know it
- 17:54is because the theory, the concept, the
- 17:57technique is telling us that it is
- 18:00indeed subclinical hypothyroidism. The
- 18:04problem with overdiagnosis is when you
- 18:07make this diagnosis in patients who
- 18:09would have absolutely no difference at
- 18:12all, whether they had this information
- 18:14or didn't have this information. For
- 18:20example, we have prostate cancers and
- 18:22breast cancers that are diagnosed very
- 18:24early and are increasingly smaller, and
- 18:27that cancer has less and less chance of
- 18:30causing any real harm. So, we know, for
- 18:34example, that most prostate cancers
- 18:36discovered in PSA screening, in routine
- 18:39PSA and digital rectal exams, will make
- 18:42zero, zero difference in the person's
- 18:44life; because the person will have
- 18:47prostatic hyperplasia, just a little
- 18:49something or not, it will have zero
- 18:52chance of changing the person's
- 18:54prognosis. So, making a diagnosis of
- 18:56prostate cancer in routine screening
- 18:59via PSA and digital rectal exam is
- 19:01overdiagnosis. The world today is
- 19:03overdiagnosing. Oh, Rogério, but it's
- 19:06the blue campaign and blue month. Well,
- 19:08it’s still about the diagnosis.
- 19:12Whether or not you follow protocols,
- 19:14which we have to discuss, why they
- 19:16exist, that’s another thing. But
- 19:19overdiagnosis is discovering something
- 19:22that exists there, but would never make
- 19:25any difference in the person's life. Oh
- 19:28, Rogério, but how am I supposed to
- 19:29know that? No, we already have studies
- 19:32showing where the diagnoses that will
- 19:34cause problems are and where the
- 19:36overdiagnoses are. For example,
- 19:39hypothyroidism again, any TSH below 10
- 19:41is likely subclinical hypothyroidism
- 19:44and is an overdiagnosis. Oh, Rogério?
- 19:48But my cousin had a TSH of 6, felt cold
- 19:51, free T4 of 0.2, and she only improved
- 19:55. We aren't talking about individuals,
- 19:59we are talking about population-wide
- 20:01diagnosis. Disease mongering is a
- 20:07criminal form of overdiagnosis. Disease
- 20:12mongering, which doesn't have a good
- 20:15term in Portuguese, is like"
- 20:17thematizing "disease, something like
- 20:22that they try to say, but even in
- 20:24Portuguese texts you will hear about
- 20:25disease mongering. It’s like this:
- 20:29the pharmaceutical industry, the lab
- 20:32test industry, the medicine, therapy,
- 20:35and surgery industry push people into
- 20:39overdiagnosis. Disease mongering is the
- 20:44industry and international diabetes
- 20:46protocols lowering glucose levels more
- 20:50and more to sell more medicine. So, you
- 20:55will have metformin now having to be
- 20:58given, uh, to anyone who has 100
- 21:08glucose, or insulin starting with
- 21:15someone who already has only 8%...or
- 21:21osteoporosis medications approved for
- 21:24longer than 3 years, which we know
- 21:27doesn't work, or cholesterol medicine
- 21:30given to everyone over 65, which is
- 21:33what happens if you use the North
- 21:35American cardiovascular guidelines. So,
- 21:40whoever is supporting or pushing this
- 21:44overdiagnosis is doing it for profit.
- 21:49The pharmaceutical industry of drugs,
- 21:51exams, treatments, surgeries, and
- 21:53hospitalizations wants to push this
- 21:55level, this threshold of" this is a
- 21:57disease, this is not a disease, "to
- 21:59make more profit. That is disease
- 22:02mongering, right? You are buying
- 22:03diseases. And overtreatment is
- 22:07something that comes from overdiagnosis
- 22:09. So, like, I have pre-diabetes and
- 22:13everyone in my area, in my practice, in
- 22:16my office who has pre-diabetes will
- 22:19start taking...but we know that this is
- 22:25not what is recommended. What is
- 22:28recommended is six months of physical
- 22:30activity, lifestyle changes. But I
- 22:34start early, because I keep in mind
- 22:37that a diagnosis is an entity that must
- 22:40be respected, since we know it should
- 22:43only be measured if it exists and can
- 22:46be ruled out. The less a person uses
- 22:49medication, the better it is for their
- 22:51life. And over-treatment is that: using
- 22:57more expensive, more complex,
- 23:00harder-to-obtain medications that treat
- 23:04more serious illnesses, always earlier.
- 23:10That is over-treatment. Deprescribing
- 23:14is a newer concept. Deprescribing is a
- 23:18concept that is still even being
- 23:21debated in its literal definition—
- 23:25what it means in English, anyway—but
- 23:28we talk about deprescribing
- 23:31intelligently when we understand it's
- 23:34not automatic. It's no use telling
- 23:38people," Look, omeprazole is one of the
- 23:40worst drugs invented in medicine. "For
- 23:44a short period, less than four to eight
- 23:47weeks, it reduces a symptom that must
- 23:50have an underlying cause. It’s not
- 23:55possible that symptoms like heartburn,
- 23:57bloating, or regurgitation don't have a
- 23:59cause. It's not possible. It’s not,
- 24:02it’s not, it’s not human if you
- 24:04don't have a cause for that. And
- 24:07omeprazole comes along and acts as a"
- 24:09hush-up "for the body. It is only
- 24:10symptomatic. It does not treat the
- 24:12cause. So, we end up addicting people
- 24:16to a drug, because we know that after
- 24:20eight weeks of regular use, your
- 24:22gastric condition will worsen. So those
- 24:27who take it for more than 8 weeks can
- 24:28no longer go without it, because every
- 24:30time they try to stop, the person feels
- 24:31worse than when they started with
- 24:33omeprazole. So, omeprazole...We already
- 24:38have international protocols for
- 24:40withdrawing omeprazole, but it's no use
- 24:43telling people," Look, just stop it. "
- 24:45The deprescribing process is not just a
- 24:48process of withdrawing medication; it's
- 24:50a process that involves a lot of
- 24:52persuasion and protocols. How to
- 24:55withdraw this medicine, how to minimize
- 24:58the reduction in people's quality of
- 25:00life when you decide to take this
- 25:01medicine away. So, if you still don't
- 25:06know how to deprescribe omeprazole,
- 25:08deprescribe benzodiazepines, or
- 25:11deprescribe antibiotics until you get
- 25:13better, you need to study deprescribing
- 25:16. There are protocols for this. So,
- 25:19benzodiazepines have established
- 25:21protocols. Another concept you need to
- 25:25understand for good practice is
- 25:26evidence-based medicine. And within
- 25:29evidence-based medicine, there are
- 25:31several important concepts, but the
- 25:33most important is the level of evidence
- 25:35. It's obvious that you give prazole to
- 25:39everyone who has heartburn and the like
- 25:41. Well, there will be people saying:"
- 25:43Oh, but I do this in my practice and it
- 25:45works great. "Yes, but the evidence you
- 25:47alone generate in your practice is the
- 25:50weakest that exists. We know from very
- 25:55high levels of evidence, for example,
- 25:57in randomized studies and such, that
- 25:59when you do a meta-analysis of those
- 26:01studies, using them after 8 weeks is
- 26:03more harmful than beneficial to the
- 26:05person. So, evidence-based medicine
- 26:08must be something studied and
- 26:10understood. The concepts of
- 26:12evidence-based medicine are sometimes
- 26:15better or more important than what we
- 26:17think it means to look at UpToDate and
- 26:22see what the evidence is for that. It
- 26:25is very important that you know the
- 26:27concept of evidence-based medicine. And
- 26:30I personally think that for P4 you need
- 26:33, you need, it's mandatory for you to
- 26:35be very good at the person-centered
- 26:38clinical method. The four new
- 26:41components of the method that, starting
- 26:43from the third edition of the book by
- 26:45Barbara and the folks over at the folks
- 26:50over in Canada, they have already
- 26:52transformed the clinical method into
- 26:55just four, well, four steps. And these
- 26:59steps must be internalized by the
- 27:01person who wants to do it, because you
- 27:03will have to convince the person that
- 27:05everything they have heard about
- 27:07medicine so far was wrong, and that you
- 27:09are the one who is right. Folks, I
- 27:28think there was a failure in Rogério's
- 27:31internet connection. It had already
- 27:33been freezing a little. Let's see if he
- 27:38can adjust it there. Just a minute.
- 27:45It seems to have returned. At least his
- 27:47face changed. Hello, Rogério. I'm back
- 27:51. Ricardo, I'm listening again. It's
- 27:53back now. It was failing, man, it
- 27:54started to fail a lot, this internet,
- 27:56and then suddenly it dropped completely
- 27:57.
- 27:58Do you know more or less when you
- 28:00started losing me?
- 28:03You were talking about evidence-based
- 28:04medicine, right? It was right at that
- 28:06part. So, well, I had moved on, I'll go
- 28:09back a little bit. So, evidence-based,
- 28:11if there is a problem there, Ricardo,
- 28:13give me a heads up, okay?
- 28:16Evidence-based medicine, in the sense
- 28:19of the concept, is sometimes more
- 28:22important than what we understand as
- 28:24evidence-based medicine when you want,
- 28:27eh, to look at evidence in DynaMed or
- 28:30UpToDate or Whitebook. Anyway, it is
- 28:35much more important for you to do a
- 28:36good P4 that you understand where the
- 28:39concepts of evidence-based medicine
- 28:41come from so you can draw your own
- 28:43conclusions. The person-centered
- 28:48clinical method is the core of how you
- 28:51deal with P4 with people, because, when
- 28:54it comes down to it, in the end, you
- 28:57will have to try to convince this
- 29:00person that everything they heard from
- 29:03other doctors they’ve seen until
- 29:05today was wrong. Look, you went to the
- 29:11cardiologist at, I don't know, the, uh,
- 29:14popular clinic, and he told you to take
- 29:18statins. But you are primary prevention
- 29:22, you never had, you never had any
- 29:24issues, uh, you never had
- 29:26cardiovascular disease, you don't smoke
- 29:28, you aren't diabetic, you don't need
- 29:30to take it. Oh, but the cardiologist
- 29:33said so. So, the person-centered
- 29:36clinical method with its four current
- 29:38components will really help you in
- 29:40those difficult conversations you’ll
- 29:43have with your patients. A lot, a lot,
- 29:46really a lot. So, I recommend studying
- 29:49these topics to understand what a good
- 29:52P4 is. Now, what hinders the
- 29:57application of P4? Well, what hinders
- 30:00the application of P4 is usually
- 30:03something personal to the doctor. So,
- 30:05it's the hero syndrome. Yeah, oh, no,
- 30:08I’m going to save these people's
- 30:10lives, even if it means giving them
- 30:12statins and putting statins in the
- 30:14water supply, putting fluoxetine in the
- 30:16water supply for my vulnerable
- 30:17population. We hear this; sometimes it
- 30:20even gives me the chills, putting stuff
- 30:22in the water supply. We hear this a lot
- 30:25in medical school, we hear this a lot
- 30:28in, uh, medical classes, we hear this a
- 30:30lot at conferences. Oh, no. Uh,
- 30:34alendronate has to be put in the water
- 30:36supply for everyone over 60, okay? And
- 30:40this hero syndrome is just that, it's
- 30:42you thinking, wow, I'm the one who will
- 30:44solve this problem, my dear. You are
- 30:47just a doctor. You have to be applying
- 30:50quaternary prevention. You have to know
- 30:53that your pen and your stamp here in
- 30:55Brazil, right, are weapons, you
- 30:57understand? They are, it is very
- 31:00serious to write a prescription. A
- 31:03prescription is a serious thing, it's
- 31:05something like, uh, it's a
- 31:06demonstration that there was a general
- 31:08failure in that situation. You will
- 31:11have to prescribe something. You won't
- 31:14be able to tell the person:" Look, go
- 31:15home, think about this, think about
- 31:17that, bring your family member so we
- 31:18can talk together. "Uh, no, your child
- 31:21isn't sick, he's having four, five
- 31:24colds a year. Uh, it's all right, it's
- 31:28normal to have four, five colds a year
- 31:30up to 4 years old. If you live in
- 31:32Curitiba, you're going to have 12 to 20
- 31:33. That's normal, there’s nothing you
- 31:36can do. Your child is just a kid
- 31:38building up immunity. Oh, but now that
- 31:41COVID is different, everything is
- 31:43different with COVID, but you still
- 31:45don’t need to be a hero, get it? You
- 31:48still don’t need to be the person who
- 31:50is going to solve the problem. Remember
- 31:53that a prescription is a weapon. You
- 31:55are arming the system when you write a
- 31:58prescription. There is a widespread
- 32:03idea in medicine and our clinical
- 32:06practice and such that medications work
- 32:10, but most medicines only work for 30
- 32:14to 50%of people. But how do you know
- 32:17that, Rogério? Because we do placebo
- 32:21studies, and when you see that
- 32:22fluoxetine was studied against a
- 32:24placebo and the placebo provided 90%of
- 32:27fluoxetine's effect, you start to ask
- 32:29yourself:" Wow, why do I give so much
- 32:31medicine? "" Eh, so this idea that
- 32:36medication inherently works, that you
- 32:40read in Dynamed, look, if you have
- 32:43psoriasis, you have to use psoralen,
- 32:47man. "Ah, that doesn't work for
- 32:49everyone, it's not like that, you know?
- 32:53And we have a lot of difficulty in
- 32:55medicine because the expectations of
- 32:57both the doctor and the patient are
- 33:00that medicines work much more than they
- 33:02actually do, you know? Eh, when you
- 33:08start to study, eh, anyway, comparing
- 33:11various drugs and treatments to
- 33:13placebos, eh, look, I can't explain to
- 33:17my surgeons at the hospital that
- 33:20appendicitis won't always cause death
- 33:23in 100%of cases, it's more like 30, 40%
- 33:26, because they won't improve just with
- 33:29antibiotics. Ah, Rogério, you're crazy
- 33:33. Appendicitis is surgery. Yeah, but if
- 33:36you look at what's been published, that
- 33:39you admit a child and they take
- 33:41antibiotics for three days and they
- 33:44might occupy one less COVID bed or not
- 33:46have surgery, it's impressive when you
- 33:49start to realize that even what we
- 33:52thought was written in stone—
- 33:54appendicitis, surgery—isn't true.
- 33:57It's, it's what our eh Ah, Rogério,
- 34:00but 80%of cases will need surgery. No,
- 34:04I know that. That's what I'm saying.
- 34:06But, but it's a matter of idea, of the
- 34:12concept of eh premise. You have to have
- 34:20the premise that nothing works the way
- 34:22you think it works, because it usually
- 34:24doesn't. Another thing that really
- 34:29hinders the application of P4, mainly
- 34:31in primary care in Brazil, but we see
- 34:34this in other parts of the world too,
- 34:37is a low statistical literacy. People
- 34:40don't understand statistics, they don't
- 34:43understand where the numbers come from.
- 34:45They don't understand what the number
- 34:47needed to treat is, or the number
- 34:49needed to harm, which is H in English,
- 34:51for harm. And we have this crazy
- 34:55obsession in global research with a
- 34:57significant p-value. Oh, no, Rogério,
- 35:01but this medicine is significantly
- 35:04better than the other one, okay? But
- 35:07what is the NNT of the treatment? What
- 35:09do you mean? How many people do I need
- 35:12to treat with a type of treatment to
- 35:14see an improvement over my usual care
- 35:16or placebo? Oh, I don't know. Well, I
- 35:19do. With statins for primary events, it
- 35:23doesn't matter what the person's risk
- 35:25factor is, the risk classification for
- 35:27the population is 100. I need to treat
- 35:32100 people with statins and follow
- 35:35another 100 people without statins to
- 35:38see a benefit. So, for every 100 people
- 35:43you give statins to, who didn't have a
- 35:46stroke or heart attack, you are getting
- 35:48one person who benefits. Oh, Rogério,
- 35:52but don't we give statins to everyone?
- 35:56Well, you don't, but for every 100
- 35:58people you treat, you'll only get one
- 36:00benefit. No, Rogério, but it's
- 36:03statistically significant. I know. The
- 36:06point is not whether P exists or not,
- 36:09because a significant P just means the
- 36:11groups are indeed different. The point
- 36:14is that the NNT, the number needed to
- 36:16treat, is very high. It's not worth it.
- 36:20There is no cost-benefit, there is no
- 36:23population, social, or personal
- 36:25cost-benefit for that person to use
- 36:28statins for primary prevention. Another
- 36:34factor I see that really prevents
- 36:36people from understanding P4 is that
- 36:38they don't realize that protocols are
- 36:40often just the opinions of people
- 36:42involved with the pharmaceutical
- 36:44industry. Want to see a protocol
- 36:48circulating in Brazil that every city
- 36:51is adding to prenatal care, even though
- 36:54it isn't scientific? It’s the TSH
- 36:58test in pregnancy. TSH in pregnancy was
- 37:03studied and adopted as a protocol by a
- 37:07society in the United States in 2007.
- 37:13This protocol of ordering a TSH for
- 37:16every pregnant woman had no scientific
- 37:20basis; it was a panel vote, and the
- 37:23vote was 11 to nothing to include the
- 37:27TSH protocol. So, besides having
- 37:32something we know doesn't reduce
- 37:34mortality, doesn't reduce the risk at
- 37:37birth or the risk during delivery,
- 37:40besides all that, we think:" No, but
- 37:43it's good to do it because it's in the
- 37:46protocol, right? "Did anyone study this
- 37:49?" No, no. It was an 11 to 9 vote that
- 37:53put this in the protocol of that
- 37:56endocrinology entity. And now we're
- 38:00doing this all over Brazil, without
- 38:02realizing that it was just an opinion.
- 38:07And we carry out several interventions
- 38:10without knowing it was just an opinion.
- 38:14Brazil is the largest per capita seller
- 38:17of benzodiazepines in the world. How
- 38:21can this be protocol? It is impossible
- 38:23for this to be protocol, but we act
- 38:25like it is. It's just the opinion of
- 38:28doctors that this medicine is useful
- 38:29for something and works. All good,
- 38:33folks? That was more or less what I had
- 38:35to say. I will now uh answer the
- 38:39questions. I'll leave this slide with
- 38:42the references. There are some really
- 38:46cool references here on deprescribing,
- 38:50on uh on diagnosis. There's even one at
- 38:54the bottom, my last reference, I think
- 38:57you can see it on the slide, a whole
- 38:59issue of the Brazilian Journal of
- 39:01Family and Community Medicine dedicated
- 39:03to quaternary prevention. It's an issue
- 39:06, a little booklet, you print it, go
- 39:08read it, put it on your phone, there
- 39:10are wonderful things in there. And
- 39:13we're reading too little. No, no, no,
- 39:15no, it's not downloaded enough. That
- 39:18should be downloaded by every resident
- 39:20and medical student in Brazil. Every
- 39:23sixth-year student should know this
- 39:26protocol, these opinions, these studies
- 39:29that are in this special 2015 issue of
- 39:31the Brazilian Journal of Family and
- 39:34Community Medicine. So I'm available
- 39:37now for questions. Let me just stop
- 39:41here. That's it. Very, very nice,
- 39:49Rogério. And the presentation was very
- 39:53enlightening. I think I can see that by
- 39:57the feedback, right? It's a great
- 39:59success with many people watching us
- 40:02live right now. Uh, in fact, there were
- 40:06some uh fluctuations in your internet,
- 40:10but don't worry, nothing that
- 40:12compromised your presentation, okay?
- 40:14But really, it's good,
- 40:16I think your internet there at home is
- 40:21a bit unstable. Uh, guys, there are
- 40:26already many questions, right? I I will
- 40:31start bringing them up and then we'll
- 40:34continue the conversation. I'll bring
- 40:38the first two, and then I'll uh pass
- 40:40the ball to Lucas as well. Ah, we're
- 40:44remembering, right, to see if
- 40:46quaternary, especially in this context,
- 40:47I even found it interesting, it barely
- 40:49touched on, no, it practically didn't
- 40:50touch on the COVID issue, right,
- 40:52Rogério? I think we've covered it well
- 40:55, but it's always important. I think
- 40:56it's a big topic, right,
- 41:00COVID-19, how we can also use it in our
- 41:02classes to apply all these concepts you
- 41:05brought, right, our reality of clinical
- 41:08practice related to Bodag.
- 41:11Yeah, it's a family presentation, right
- 41:13, Ricardo? We can't give our opinion on
- 41:17things in the format we would like.
- 41:20It's a family-friendly presentation,
- 41:22there are little kids watching, right?
- 41:25If you start trying to trap me into
- 41:26talking about COVID, I'll start cursing
- 41:28at people, and then it'll look bad,
- 41:30right?
- 41:32Understood. True. It's true. Well, I'll
- 41:35start with Gabson's questions. Gabson
- 41:38is a resident there in Santa Cruz. I
- 41:40had the opportunity to meet him in
- 41:42person. I'm glad you're here honoring
- 41:45us, watching the lecture. Gabson, he
- 41:48asks two questions. I'll say both,
- 41:51which are: one is about to what extent
- 41:56can we use the Beers criteria, right,
- 41:59and the START/STOPP criteria, as
- 42:01quaternary prevention in clinical
- 42:04practice, right, considering they are
- 42:07highly judgmental. And the second
- 42:11question relates to a very specific
- 42:13issue, right, also about breast
- 42:15self-exams, right, what is there placed
- 42:18, right, for the evaluation of this
- 42:21method as screening, right, considering
- 42:23the possibility of false positives and
- 42:26negatives. Start with those two, right,
- 42:30and then we'll continue with Lucas. So,
- 42:33the Beers criteria are those criteria
- 42:35for medications that are inadequate or
- 42:37inappropriate for the elderly.
- 42:40Exactly.
- 42:40And it's a huge list. And believe it or
- 42:43not, there are places in the world that
- 42:45follow the list. Like, don't give
- 42:48amitriptyline to an old person to sleep
- 42:49, don't give quetiapine to an old
- 42:51person to sleep, because you know
- 42:52they'll have a fracture if they fall,
- 42:54because these medicines cause dizziness
- 42:55and such. It's interesting to note, for
- 42:59example, that Fluoxetine has entered
- 43:01and left the Beers criteria several
- 43:03times in recent years, so the Beers
- 43:05criteria are wonderful criteria, you
- 43:07really must use them. When in doubt,
- 43:10don't give medicine, right? That, I
- 43:12think that is the main way out, yeah.
- 43:16There are so many non-pharmacological
- 43:18things we aren't trained to do that
- 43:20it’s embarrassing, given the medicine
- 43:22we graduate with. For instance, I won't
- 43:26even get into integrative practices,
- 43:29which are already established—and
- 43:32Lucas can speak more to that than I can
- 43:35—but things already scientifically
- 43:37established in our allopathic science,
- 43:40for example, sleep hygiene. We have
- 43:46sleep hygiene guidelines that improve
- 43:49sleep for 80%of people. Our first
- 43:53resort is to give a benzodiazepine or
- 43:55quetiapine to an elderly person who
- 43:56isn't wanting to sleep. And that is
- 43:58what we have to change. So, the Beers
- 44:01criteria are an extremely useful tool
- 44:03for you to be able to have these
- 44:05discussions. The STOPP/START criteria
- 44:08are also criteria for starting and
- 44:10stopping medication. So, it's worth
- 44:13studying and understanding this,
- 44:15because it's a methodology—not as
- 44:17much of a list as Beers, but it's worth
- 44:20it. It is a tool that family doctors
- 44:23should adopt—the STOPP/START criteria
- 44:25. It’s worth it. I don’t think we
- 44:29have time to discuss the tool itself in
- 44:31depth, but I think we should. As
- 44:34quaternary prevention, the Beers
- 44:36criteria, STOPP/START, antibiotic
- 44:39pauses—all of this needs to start
- 44:41being read, studied, and reflected upon
- 44:44, because these are not concepts of
- 44:47today; they aren't new concepts. The
- 44:50antibiotic pause has been advocated by
- 44:52health organizations since '87 to try
- 44:54to reduce bacterial resistance. And we
- 44:57keep telling people: "No, no, no, no,
- 44:58no, you can't stop.""You have to take
- 45:02it for seven days or else"—man, that
- 45:04has been debunked for years, and we
- 45:06continue doing breast self-exams. See,
- 45:10when we talk about screening, screening
- 45:14is something else entirely, because it
- 45:17depends on several issues to become
- 45:20effective; it depends on the country's
- 45:24socioeconomic issues, its technological
- 45:27issues, and the particularities of the
- 45:30population. What we know, what we do
- 45:34know, is that several developed
- 45:36countries are stopping their
- 45:38population-based mammography programs.
- 45:41They are stopping because we cannot
- 45:43show a mortality benefit. So you can't
- 45:46show a mortality benefit with
- 45:48mammography anymore, for example, in
- 45:49Canada, Sweden, or Switzerland. For the
- 45:53prostate, we have never been able to
- 45:55show a mortality benefit. We never have
- 45:58. For the prostate, PSA and the digital
- 46:00rectal exam have never succeeded. Now,
- 46:04breast self-assessment is something we
- 46:08have to be very careful with, because
- 46:11you don't really need to go to a health
- 46:14center to be taught how to do a breast
- 46:18exam. That is not the kind of breast
- 46:21self-assessment that shows benefits.
- 46:23Yeah. Breast assessment. It's about
- 46:26getting to know your breasts as you go
- 46:29about your life. So you might say, "
- 46:33Look, doctor, a week ago I found a lump
- 46:36.""I didn't have it last month because
- 46:40I shower and I look at my breasts every
- 46:42time I take a shower." That, that kind
- 46:45of breast self-assessment seems to be
- 46:47beneficial. But training people to, say
- 46:51, make circular motions and so on, will
- 46:53that save you? No, that doesn't seem to
- 46:57work. So, this breast issue needs a bit
- 47:00of, beyond more studies, of course, but
- 47:03it needs us to understand what we are
- 47:06dealing with. That old concept of a
- 47:10nurse teaching women how to palpate
- 47:13themselves has largely been debunked;
- 47:15it doesn't seem to work very well. But
- 47:20a woman knowing herself and coming to
- 47:22the office and saying, "Look, there was
- 47:24a little lump that was just sitting
- 47:26there, and two weeks ago it grew to 1
- 47:28cm, 1.5 cm." That is the
- 47:31self-assessment we need to advocate for
- 47:33. Got it?
- 47:38Yeah, another thing, while I'm at it, I
- 47:39once read about what the sensitivity of
- 47:41self-assessment is, right? Very small
- 47:45lumps don't show up in breast exams,
- 47:46nor in mammograms, etc. That's why this
- 47:49is part of the discussion, tying in a
- 47:51little bit with what Rogério brought
- 47:53up about self-assessment. So, these
- 47:56really are very important things. For
- 47:59those who like to study and dive deeper
- 48:01, I suggest Choosing Wisely, right?
- 48:04Wisely, I never know how to pronounce
- 48:06that word correctly.
- 48:07It's Choosing Wisely. And it's there in
- 48:09the references I sent, the website is
- 48:11there. Exactly. The SBMFC has the
- 48:14Choosing Wisely Brazil recommendations,
- 48:17right? There are 10 recommendations
- 48:21that later became five, reduced to five
- 48:23with details and descriptions, which we
- 48:26can even send to you so you can get to
- 48:29know the Choosing Wisely from the
- 48:31Brazilian society. Outside of Brazil,
- 48:35there are others that are much larger,
- 48:37and I think this helps a lot in our
- 48:39conversation, right? About quaternary
- 48:42prevention. And then Marlie brings up a
- 48:46very interesting comment, saying that
- 48:48just today she was talking to students
- 48:50about this topic, which is that we must
- 48:52be increasingly attentive to
- 48:54polypharmacy, right? People who see
- 48:57many doctors usually have more
- 48:59polypharmacy, and as family doctors, we
- 49:02are the managers of care, right?
- 49:05Looking at this pharmacy.
- 49:07Yes. is our responsibility. An
- 49:11interesting concept we have in the
- 49:12world today is that polypharmacy is
- 49:14five or more medications. So, if you
- 49:17have a prescription that has 1, 2, 3, 4
- 49:20, 5, that’s not it. I could take four
- 49:24enalaprils a day and it’s just one
- 49:26medication, but if my list has five or
- 49:30more, I already have a long-term
- 49:32worsening of my health. It doesn’t
- 49:36matter if the medications serve a
- 49:37purpose or not. Five or more
- 49:39medications will cause trouble; it will
- 49:41start to cause confusion. So Marl is
- 49:44totally right. I totally agree with the
- 49:47doctor. And, but I’ll remind you
- 49:51again, it’s worth saying again,
- 49:54because, you know, we are trained to
- 49:56look for disease, man. We, medicine
- 50:00today is diagnostic; you have to find
- 50:02the disease the person has. And
- 50:05diagnoses start to be invented in a
- 50:07kind of weird way, you know? So, I
- 50:10remind everyone that osteoporosis
- 50:15existed for many centuries; you had
- 50:17asymptomatic fractures and you would
- 50:19tell the person, "Look, this is
- 50:20osteoporosis." But osteopenia was
- 50:24invented after the bone densitometry
- 50:26scan. You had a test that you could use
- 50:31to prove that you now have a disease.
- 50:35This is "disease mongering." This is
- 50:38making an economy out of disease. You
- 50:42start inventing ways for people to
- 50:45spend money by telling them they are
- 50:47sick. This is very bad, very
- 50:50deleterious to society, because there
- 50:53is something called normal aging. Well,
- 50:56we have to understand this too, that
- 50:58you will reach 88 years old and you
- 51:01won't have the same stamina, quality of
- 51:03life, and ability to remain independent
- 51:05as you did when you were 20. But we
- 51:10have to be very careful because they
- 51:15are literally pathologizing age,
- 51:20pathologizing menopause, andropause,
- 51:25pathologizing, you know, baldness,
- 51:30myopia, presbyopia, okay? These things
- 51:35that used to be normal in society,
- 51:37where you have: "Oh, I'm young, I do
- 51:39this, I do that; then when I'm 50 I
- 51:41won't be able to anymore; then when I'm
- 51:4360 I won't be able to; then when I'm 90
- 51:45I won't be able to walk properly." This
- 51:49journey through normality is being
- 51:51pathologized. Pathologized. That’s it
- 51:56. So, I think Dr. Mari is right. The
- 52:01big question today is more about
- 52:05political reversal, right? Because we
- 52:08had PHC as the system's maintainer and
- 52:11that was never implemented at a
- 52:13national level to the point where we
- 52:16could say, "Oh, now we are losing PHC."
- 52:20No, we haven't managed to convince the
- 52:22population that PHC, that family
- 52:24medicine is what matters, right? So, we
- 52:27continue to have this culture of the
- 52:30specialist. Oh, I have hypertension,
- 52:32I'll go to the cardiologist. Oh, I have
- 52:35diabetes, I'll go to the
- 52:37endocrinologist. Oh, I have back pain,
- 52:38I'll go to the orthopedist. Oh, I have
- 52:41...And this is very bad, because
- 52:43exactly, when you have one doctor, you
- 52:45have a doctor. When you have two, you
- 52:47have half. When you have three, you
- 52:48have none, right? And that's it.
- 52:53And remember that, well, remembering
- 52:55now that polypharmacy we speak of five
- 52:56or more, but we also have to remember
- 52:58the medications that the person uses on
- 53:00their own, as that also counts toward
- 53:02polypharmacy. Sometimes we forget as
- 53:04doctors, we only see the prescription,
- 53:06we only see this and that, but it's
- 53:07that Cataflam that the person, that
- 53:09grandma goes there and buys. No, I
- 53:10always have a dipyrone in the cupboard,
- 53:13right? A tea, syrup, uh, etcetera. That
- 53:17is medication, right?
- 53:19And remember, very well remembered,
- 53:21Lucas, that herbal medicines are not,
- 53:24uh, free,
- 53:25it's not something like, a herbal
- 53:27medicine is, if it's a herbal medicine
- 53:29it's because it has an active
- 53:31ingredient, it has adverse effects,
- 53:33drug interaction effects. So, uh,
- 53:35herbal therapy is a very cool thing,
- 53:37but it has to be studied too, it's not
- 53:39like, oh, everyone gives it, so I will
- 53:41give it. It's worth considering well,
- 53:44because you are adding a medication to
- 53:47that story, it's not just chamomile tea
- 53:49, right? It's a medication called
- 53:51chamomile tea, if you are going to take
- 53:54it every day. This perspective is also
- 53:56very important.
- 53:57Exactly. We have to look beyond the
- 53:59prescription. That's basic, right? And
- 54:02then Ricardo also brought up another
- 54:04very complex question, which is what
- 54:07are the challenges of quaternary
- 54:08prevention in scenarios of high care
- 54:11pressure with 25 to 30 patients per
- 54:13shift, is it possible to do QP4? Then
- 54:16it comes to Rogério, who is a guy who
- 54:18has been working for 6, 7 years with
- 54:20advanced access.
- 54:22Yeah, now we've been doing advanced
- 54:24access at the clinic for 11 years
- 54:25already.
- 54:2611 years. who lives through this every
- 54:28once in a while,
- 54:29because I don't, I don't, I don't count
- 54:31the pandemic, because it really doesn't
- 54:32count, right? We didn't provide access
- 54:34to anyone. But look, access is another
- 54:37can of worms that we will obviously
- 54:40have to have a conversation about at
- 54:42SBMFC regarding access as well. But the
- 54:47advice I give Ricardo is the following:
- 54:50if you have 30 patients per shift,
- 54:52that's 60 patients a day, that's one
- 54:54hell of a busy ER. You have to triage
- 54:58who you will see with FM and who you
- 55:01will see just as an ER case. There is
- 55:04absolutely no chance of this working if
- 55:07you want to spend 40 minutes per, you
- 55:09know, patient. So, the pressure on
- 55:13healthcare involves many dreams of the
- 55:15Brazilian doctor, right? The dreams are
- 55:19like, I really hoped that the SUS law
- 55:22would be followed, and instead of
- 55:24having three teams caring for 7,000
- 55:26people at my clinic, I would have seven
- 55:28teams caring for 3,000. So this
- 55:31pressure on healthcare must always be
- 55:33debated. Managers need to know that
- 55:35it's not like that. You can't bring in
- 55:3820,000 people and expect me to attend
- 55:40to them, or expect me to get everyone's
- 55:42A1C down to an average of seven. That's
- 55:44not going to happen. Where is my NAS?
- 55:47Where is my assistant? Where is my
- 55:50nurse with office time and so on? So, I
- 55:52think it is possible to do it. I
- 55:55literally do what you are saying. I see
- 55:58more than that per shift. At the unit
- 56:01where I work, the average evaluations
- 56:04are around 120, 130 when the pressure
- 56:06on healthcare is heavy. Now, during
- 56:10COVID, it dropped quite a bit, but you
- 56:12have to prioritize who you're going to
- 56:14do this for, who you're going to sit
- 56:16down with and say: "Look, ma'am, I
- 56:18understand you just need a prescription
- 56:20for Rivotril, here it is, a 30-day
- 56:22prescription." But the next appointment
- 56:26will be scheduled. Where is your family
- 56:30member to come here and talk to me
- 56:31about your sleep patterns? Where is
- 56:34your family member? Where is your
- 56:35caregiver? Where is your husband? Where
- 56:37is your wife? Let's involve more family
- 56:39, then, let's do it. If the pressure on
- 56:42healthcare is killing me, I need to
- 56:44have a way out to resolve this, which
- 56:46will be family resolution. It’s the
- 56:48topic. Of course it is, because if you
- 56:50don't have enough people to see, you
- 56:52won't be able to keep up. And then it
- 56:55just becomes prescription renewals, and
- 56:57COVID did that to us here, here with
- 56:59the access we had as well.
- 57:02Prescriptions didn't even go through a
- 57:04doctor anymore, they were just renewed
- 57:05administratively, because that's how it
- 57:07is, you know? You have to work with
- 57:09what you have. I'm going to read here
- 57:14the question from Fábio Xiroma, which
- 57:15is: What alternatives exist to the use
- 57:17of statins, since their NNT is so high?
- 57:18That's exactly it. There is no
- 57:20alternative to a statin. The
- 57:23alternative to a statin is to stop
- 57:25smoking, lower your hypertension, and
- 57:28not be diabetic. So, if you look at
- 57:31risk calculators, and you can look at
- 57:34any risk calculator, the ways to lower
- 57:36your cardiovascular risk are in order.
- 57:40By stopping smoking, you reduce your
- 57:43cardiovascular risk by 50%. Usually,
- 57:46that’s the deal. If you have a risk
- 57:48of 10 and you smoke, you will have a
- 57:49risk of 20. Lowering your blood
- 57:52pressure is next in order of
- 57:53improvement. I haven't mentioned
- 57:55cholesterol yet. After you stop smoking
- 57:58, after you lower your blood pressure,
- 57:59then you can think about your
- 58:01cholesterol. So, for primary prevention
- 58:04, what actually changes people's lives?
- 58:07Lifestyle modifications. There's no
- 58:10point in trying to reinvent the wheel,
- 58:12no point in trying to be a hero, it's
- 58:14not the medicine. You're going to give
- 58:16a statin to a guy who smokes two packs
- 58:18of cigarettes a day, of course you will
- 58:19, because that's what's in the protocol
- 58:21. Will it work for anything? Of course
- 58:23not, man. Check your criteria, alright?
- 58:27Suppose the guy has a total cholesterol
- 58:29of 250. If you lower his total
- 58:32cholesterol to 120 and he's still
- 58:34smoking and is diabetic, what kind of
- 58:36risk reduction are you going to have?
- 58:39Minimal, 5 to 10%, and the guy has a 40
- 58:41%cardiovascular risk. So, the issue
- 58:45isn't what I use, the issue is how do I
- 58:49convince this person that the medicine
- 58:52they were told would solve their
- 58:55problem doesn't work. How am I going to
- 59:01get into this person's head and show
- 59:04them: "Look, sir, the cigarette is
- 59:06what's causing you to take statins,
- 59:09medicine for cholesterol. If you didn't
- 59:13smoke, you wouldn't need the medicine.
- 59:17So you see where we are regarding the
- 59:19gravity of you just smoking, which is
- 59:20something that seems simple to you. So,
- 59:24instead of continuing with the culture
- 59:27of the miracle drug, the miracle pill,
- 59:30the pill that will cure you, these are
- 59:32the conversations we need to have. Look
- 59:36, it doesn't work the way you're saying
- 59:38it does. A statin reduction of
- 59:41cholesterol, even a very strong 50%
- 59:43reduction in cholesterol, does not
- 59:46reduce your cardiovascular risk by 50%;
- 59:48it reduces it by five, maybe seven. So,
- 59:53eh, Fábio, it’s not a question of
- 59:56what I can use, it’s why I can’t
- 59:58use it, because it provides no benefit.
- 1:00:02That’s the big question.
- 1:00:04And it can cause more harm, right?
- 1:00:06There are several studies on statins
- 1:00:08alone too, right? Right? The statin
- 1:00:11math is really cool, because look:
- 1:00:13it’s one in 100 to get a benefit, one
- 1:00:16in 50 to find new diabetes, and one in
- 1:00:1910 or 20 to find muscle pain that will
- 1:00:21stop you from exercising. So, to save
- 1:00:26one person from an MI or a stroke,
- 1:00:28you’ve caused two cases of diabetes
- 1:00:30and 10 sedentary people. Fantastic.
- 1:00:33This is a
- 1:00:34Exactly. Yeah. And I just wanted to
- 1:00:36jump in and mention, I think that when
- 1:00:38we have these P4 discussions—and you
- 1:00:40were very important in your
- 1:00:42presentation too, Rogério—the issue
- 1:00:44of the person-centered clinical method,
- 1:00:46right? Because having this debate from
- 1:00:49the perspective of the actual desires,
- 1:00:51the fantasies, of what the patient
- 1:00:53brings, especially considering that
- 1:00:56this patient often—given that in
- 1:00:58Brazil we still have a low presence of
- 1:01:00Family Medicine in people's lives,
- 1:01:02right? There are still few of us, right
- 1:01:04? So, most of our patients have had
- 1:01:07prior contact with some specialist,
- 1:01:09like a cardiologist, and so on, and end
- 1:01:12up having a lot of influence from the
- 1:01:14pharmaceutical industry, right? I think
- 1:01:17I also really wanted to reinforce this,
- 1:01:19especially for the residents who are
- 1:01:21arriving now: we are a medical society
- 1:01:23that does not have pharmaceutical
- 1:01:25industry sponsorship for our congresses
- 1:01:27, right? This is—this makes a
- 1:01:30difference, because several studies
- 1:01:31show how simply the presence of this
- 1:01:33sponsorship, the so-called" sponsorship
- 1:01:35"—" oh, it won't do any harm, I'll
- 1:01:37just prescribe something else. "It’s
- 1:01:40not quite like that, right? We know
- 1:01:43very well it isn't; there is a
- 1:01:45subjective influence too, and that is
- 1:01:47why the society values so much that our
- 1:01:50congresses do not have this type of
- 1:01:52sponsorship in our activities, so we
- 1:01:54can have complete independence. And we
- 1:01:58know that many colleagues in other
- 1:01:59fields don't always realize they end up
- 1:02:01having a certain more subjective
- 1:02:02influence, right? Not necessarily
- 1:02:05directly from receiving something right
- 1:02:07there, but they are also influenced by
- 1:02:09the pharmaceutical industry. So, that
- 1:02:12is why the debate is truly complex, and
- 1:02:15why we also need to have this arsenal
- 1:02:17of clinical epidemiology, which is our
- 1:02:20next class, in fact, in 15 days, to
- 1:02:22discuss, right, to translate this
- 1:02:25knowledge of clinical epidemiology for
- 1:02:27the patient, to really make the patient
- 1:02:30understand what this is. Even these
- 1:02:34concepts: number needed to treat,
- 1:02:35number needed to harm, we can also
- 1:02:37translate them into the patient's
- 1:02:39language, so they can understand, right
- 1:02:41? Is this possible, right? And we, and
- 1:02:44this is how we can ensure they leave
- 1:02:47our office with a sense of health
- 1:02:49education, right? So that later they
- 1:02:52follow through and realize that no,
- 1:02:54it's no use for a doctor to prescribe a
- 1:02:56statin for me, and then I won't take it
- 1:02:58. I think this is very important for
- 1:03:00our role as family doctors too.
- 1:03:02community.
- 1:03:05Now here, Ana Laura Teodó said:" When
- 1:03:07should we use vitamin D and is it
- 1:03:09beneficial given the high prevalence in
- 1:03:11your region? "" Uh, yes. "So, look, I'm
- 1:03:14a bit of a vitamin D fanatic, really,
- 1:03:17my master's degree was on vitamin D in
- 1:03:20high-level athletes, and I'll tell you:
- 1:03:23I don't test anyone. Because, it’s
- 1:03:27one of two things: either you test
- 1:03:30vitamin D and know everyone is
- 1:03:32deficient, and you'll see that you
- 1:03:34won't increase it in anyone with the
- 1:03:37dosages generally used, or you just
- 1:03:39assume everyone is deficient and soak
- 1:03:42people in vitamin D, getting everyone
- 1:03:45above 50, 80 with a dosage based on the
- 1:03:47person's weight and so on. So, I don't
- 1:03:51think you should test anyone for now. I
- 1:03:55think vitamin D is our photosynthesis.
- 1:03:58I think we will, the studies will show
- 1:04:00that it is beneficial in some way, but
- 1:04:02there are some caveats to consider. For
- 1:04:06example, the main caution you have to
- 1:04:09take with vitamin D is to ask if
- 1:04:11vitamin D, which is not a vitamin, it's
- 1:04:14a secosteroid hormone, is vitamin D
- 1:04:16really all of that, or is it just a
- 1:04:18test to show how much sun I'm getting?
- 1:04:22And it's the sun that is all of that.
- 1:04:24So we don't have the answer to that yet
- 1:04:26. Until we have that answer, measuring
- 1:04:28vitamin D is nonsense. It’s the kind
- 1:04:31of thing where, if you believe in
- 1:04:33vitamin D, you just give it to people
- 1:04:35or tell them to get some sun. If you
- 1:04:38don't believe in vitamin D, there's
- 1:04:40also no point in making minimal
- 1:04:42corrections with ridiculous doses like,
- 1:04:45say, 1,000 a day, 12,000 a week, or
- 1:04:4850,000 a week, which are doses that
- 1:04:50literally won't increase your vitamin
- 1:04:53D. So, vitamin D today—currently—
- 1:04:56should not be measured at a population
- 1:04:58level. You shouldn't include it in your
- 1:05:01routine, if you still do routine
- 1:05:02check-ups. I highly recommend reading
- 1:05:06some documents, for instance, that show
- 1:05:08this whole business of doing routine
- 1:05:10exams is actually harmful to you. There
- 1:05:14are several studies already showing
- 1:05:16this, but even if you do these routine
- 1:05:18exams, don't include vitamin D, because
- 1:05:21you'll see everyone is deficient, and
- 1:05:23you never manage to increase it because
- 1:05:25the value coming back is too low. Or
- 1:05:28it's better to just say:" Look, folks,
- 1:05:31you really need to get some sun, and we
- 1:05:33have to find that balance of what I'm
- 1:05:35going to expose to the sun and what
- 1:05:36kind of sun-related cancer I might get
- 1:05:38in my life to have more vitamin D. "So
- 1:05:40I think, Ana Laura, first of all, we
- 1:05:42don't have the science to keep
- 1:05:44measuring vitamin D, and the Choosing
- 1:05:46Wisely campaign says there's no benefit
- 1:05:48because there isn't one. Currently,
- 1:05:51science doesn't see a benefit to
- 1:05:53vitamin D, and I'm saying this even as
- 1:05:56the" vitamin D nut "who did the review
- 1:05:59on vitamin D for COVID, which shows it
- 1:06:01does absolutely nothing. So, folks, I'm
- 1:06:05sorry, vitamin D is like, it's my
- 1:06:07little darling, but I don't test for
- 1:06:12anyone anymore because there's just no
- 1:06:13point. And that is a major, that is a
- 1:06:17great difficulty. I’ll speak
- 1:06:20personally: I know how hard it is to
- 1:06:22change a concept or a routine because
- 1:06:24of vitamin D. Because I used to measure
- 1:06:26it, and when I started realizing that,
- 1:06:29damn, it's useless—either everyone is
- 1:06:31deficient, or people don't give enough
- 1:06:33vitamin D to reach the levels they want
- 1:06:35—I stopped measuring it. I literally
- 1:06:39just give vitamin D and such, and I do
- 1:06:42it as a good placebo attempt, you know,
- 1:06:45in some very, very, very well-selected
- 1:06:48people. But look, I'll tell you, us in
- 1:06:52healthcare not getting sun...it's not
- 1:06:55possible that vitamin D is the only
- 1:06:57thing the sun provides us. I think we
- 1:07:01only know about vitamin D, but the
- 1:07:03benefits of getting sun in populations
- 1:07:05that get more sun in general are
- 1:07:07greater than what vitamin D alone can
- 1:07:09cause. So, maybe vitamin D isn't the
- 1:07:12sole cause of everything, it’s what
- 1:07:14we call a proxy, right? Look, you don't
- 1:07:17get much sun, which is why your vitamin
- 1:07:19D is low. I can even give you vitamin D
- 1:07:22, but the advice is: get some sun,
- 1:07:25exercise, and so on. I think that's
- 1:07:27what happens with vitamin D. Ah,
- 1:07:34It's like Jéssica Duarte, it's like a
- 1:07:36multivitamin. They all ask for it and
- 1:07:38even arrive already taking several
- 1:07:40sometimes. Yes, but it's like smoking,
- 1:07:44eating junk food, drinking too much
- 1:07:47alcohol, uh, using hard drugs and such,
- 1:07:50without control. That's it. That's the
- 1:07:53human being, man. And they come in and
- 1:07:54you tell them:" Look, your best bet is
- 1:07:56to do this, this, and this. "It's no
- 1:07:58use if you do this, this, and this." Oh
- 1:08:01, I smoke two packs of cigarettes a day
- 1:08:03, doctor, but I drink water, my dear. "
- 1:08:06Uh, that's not what we need. So," Oh, I
- 1:08:09don't do anything, but I take a
- 1:08:10multivitamin. "Oh, alright, take it, no
- 1:08:13problem. Go ahead, it won't hurt, these
- 1:08:16low-dose vitamins they have inside them
- 1:08:18. Oh, sir, if you don't walk, if you
- 1:08:21don't eat properly, if you don't drink
- 1:08:23water, if you don't have good bowel
- 1:08:25movements, a good flow, if you aren't
- 1:08:27breathing every day, instead of just
- 1:08:29surviving, right, my dear? Uh, you can
- 1:08:32take whatever vitamin you want, it's
- 1:08:33pointless, right? If you just ate two
- 1:08:35pieces of broccoli, you'd get the
- 1:08:36vitamin you're taking.
- 1:08:38And question six is, before question
- 1:08:40six, there's this number seven that has
- 1:08:43even more to do with the vitamin D
- 1:08:45topic. It just came in, Gon just asked
- 1:08:47about the relationship between vitamin
- 1:08:49D and osteoporosis. Right.
- 1:08:52So, what we know about osteoporosis is
- 1:08:54the following: osteoporosis isn't just
- 1:08:56a calcium problem, it's a more complex
- 1:08:59metabolic issue. Uh, if it were just a
- 1:09:03calcium problem, the person would have
- 1:09:05ossification of the body and lose their
- 1:09:07teeth, which is where the body uses
- 1:09:09calcium most rapidly. And that's not
- 1:09:12what happens. So, osteoporosis is some
- 1:09:14more complex metabolic problem. Vitamin
- 1:09:17D works for osteoporosis in the sense
- 1:09:19that, in various systems, it helps
- 1:09:21absorb calcium and deposit that calcium
- 1:09:23into the bone. So that’s how it works
- 1:09:26. The big problem is that supplemented
- 1:09:29calcium has been shown to increase
- 1:09:32cardiac risk. So you can’t just keep
- 1:09:35giving people vitamin D and calcium. So
- 1:09:39if you’re just going to give vitamin
- 1:09:40D, well, that’s fine. But let's
- 1:09:43remember, who actually gets
- 1:09:44osteoporosis? If you look at the
- 1:09:47typical person with osteoporosis,
- 1:09:49it’s that thin little old lady who
- 1:09:52stays at home, doesn't exercise,
- 1:09:54doesn't go for walks, and smokes.
- 1:09:57Exactly, right, Lucas? Smokes. There is
- 1:10:00a very significant sedentary pattern in
- 1:10:02osteoporosis, because it’s
- 1:10:03physiological, man. If you put pressure
- 1:10:06on your bone, it develops density,
- 1:10:08there's no way around it. So, obesity
- 1:10:10is actually protective against
- 1:10:12osteoporosis, believe it or not, but it
- 1:10:15is, you know? If you are obese during
- 1:10:17your formative years, you will have
- 1:10:19more bone density; sure, you’ll have
- 1:10:21a bunch of other problems—I know,
- 1:10:22I’m obese, I’ll have a lot of
- 1:10:24problems—but I won’t have
- 1:10:25osteoporosis. See what I mean? So, does
- 1:10:30vitamin D work for osteoporosis? Of
- 1:10:32course it works, but it's like a
- 1:10:35multivitamin. Does it work alone for
- 1:10:38osteoporosis? It’s obvious that it
- 1:10:40doesn’t work alone for osteoporosis,
- 1:10:43okay? So, could you please leave those
- 1:10:46references regarding routine exams? Yes
- 1:10:50, in fact, the Ministry of Health has,
- 1:10:52or used to have on their website, by
- 1:10:54age, which types of routine exams you
- 1:10:57should do. But look, under 50 years old
- 1:11:01, the rule for routine exams is HIV,
- 1:11:04syphilis, and hepatitis in Brazil.
- 1:11:08That’s the rule; doing these exams
- 1:11:11under 50 is already very good. I still
- 1:11:16teach my residents to beat the system
- 1:11:18and order a complete blood count,
- 1:11:20because if you can't convince the
- 1:11:21person that they don't need tests, the
- 1:11:23name" complete blood count "is
- 1:11:25sometimes all they need. It should be
- 1:11:28ordered. No, folks, we don't order a
- 1:11:30blood count for a woman just because
- 1:11:32she menstruates. Everything is fine,
- 1:11:34you know? She can menstruate, let her
- 1:11:36be, poor thing. We don't look for—for
- 1:11:40example, in men, what is the leading
- 1:11:42cause of death? What is the highest
- 1:11:46percentage of deaths in men aged 30 to
- 1:11:4950? It's violence. This guy knows his
- 1:11:54blood type so he can have it on his ID
- 1:11:56card that he is A positive, so if he's
- 1:11:58riding a motorcycle around and falls,
- 1:12:00he has it on his ID:" No, I'm A
- 1:12:01positive, "and they can sort his
- 1:12:03situation out much faster. So,
- 1:12:06sometimes, besides routine exams, we
- 1:12:09have to think more about people's
- 1:12:11specific needs. What we have to stop
- 1:12:15selling to our patients is the annual
- 1:12:18checkup." Oh, no, I want to do an
- 1:12:20annual checkup. "No, that has to stop.
- 1:12:22That, no, no, no, it doesn't work, man.
- 1:12:25You get it? So, uh, go ahead, Ricardo,
- 1:12:28please. No, no, just commenting there
- 1:12:31too, since you mentioned that issue of
- 1:12:34the ministry's own criteria, right?
- 1:12:37Lucas posted it there too. We'll put it
- 1:12:40in the YouTube link, the primary care
- 1:12:42screening manual, which clearly
- 1:12:44indicates what you brought up: for each
- 1:12:47age group, which exams have evidence
- 1:12:49related to screening and routine tests.
- 1:12:53And I remembered here too that there is
- 1:12:55even an app, right, from, uh, Task
- 1:13:00Force, right, the Preventive Services
- 1:13:03Task Force, which are the
- 1:13:06recommendations, right, that we can
- 1:13:08base on evidence, right, which are,
- 1:13:11well, from the United States, right,
- 1:13:14but you just enter the age. There's an
- 1:13:18app, later we can put it there, oh,
- 1:13:20Lucas already put it there, we'll put
- 1:13:21it in the YouTube chat now. YouTube. Uh
- 1:13:24, very interesting. You enter age, sex,
- 1:13:28right, and it actually brings you all
- 1:13:31the evidence, or rather, the grade of
- 1:13:35evidence, for the main exams for each
- 1:13:38age group. That's it. Yeah,
- 1:13:41I just want to add one thing, Ricardo,
- 1:13:44that screening is a complex thing. So,
- 1:13:48for example, in the United States they
- 1:13:50screen for colon cancer.
- 1:13:52Uh-huh.
- 1:13:53But here in Brazil we shouldn't screen.
- 1:13:57If you look, including that document
- 1:13:59there, the screening manual, you will
- 1:14:01have the position of the Inca saying:"
- 1:14:03Look, in Brazil we don't have the same
- 1:14:04incidence of colon cancer as the United
- 1:14:06States; we don't have the same number
- 1:14:08of colonoscopies; we don't have the
- 1:14:10same number of surgical centers for
- 1:14:11this. "So, we don't have the technology
- 1:14:15, we don't have the epidemiology. We
- 1:14:17just don't. So, uh, and that is my
- 1:14:20major critique of us using the
- 1:14:22cardiovascular risk assessment criteria
- 1:14:24calculators that we have available
- 1:14:27today, including the Brazilian Society
- 1:14:30of Cardiology calculator. This isn't a
- 1:14:33critique of the society, it's a
- 1:14:35critique of my take on their calculator
- 1:14:37, which was a translation and not an
- 1:14:39original study. So they used a
- 1:14:41translation of a calculator that gives
- 1:14:43high risk to everyone over 65 years old
- 1:14:45. You put in 65, no matter what else
- 1:14:47you enter, it's going to tell you to
- 1:14:49use a statin. And I always say, there
- 1:14:53isn't a single Brazilian participating
- 1:14:55in the frame study, not one. So we also
- 1:15:00, we have to be careful that
- 1:15:02evidence-based medicine in the world
- 1:15:04isn't made by Brazilians and we have to
- 1:15:07pursue that and make these studies
- 1:15:09happen and such, but be careful. Uh,
- 1:15:13question eight here from Patrícia
- 1:15:15Puglia Raca, what about bariatric
- 1:15:17patients? That's probably what she
- 1:15:19wants to ask, how to care for them in
- 1:15:21P4? That must be what she asked. Uh,
- 1:15:25Patrícia, uh, like anyone with
- 1:15:27sequelae from a disease, uh, like a
- 1:15:30person who had an amputation due to
- 1:15:32diabetes, like someone going blind from
- 1:15:35a cataract, like someone
- 1:15:37post-gallbladder surgery, the care for
- 1:15:40a bariatric patient will have the
- 1:15:42specificities of a bariatric patient.
- 1:15:46So, I think that what you're saying is
- 1:15:49probably like, ah, we're saying never
- 1:15:51to request vitamins and such, but this
- 1:15:54is a specific population with a
- 1:15:56specific protocol. If you have to
- 1:15:59request B12 for bariatric patients,
- 1:16:01request B12 for bariatric patients,
- 1:16:03bariatric patients are more prone to
- 1:16:04have dyslipidemia, you request it, you
- 1:16:06understand? It's, it's a matter of,
- 1:16:09then you're entering a specificity that
- 1:16:11perhaps isn't the target of my point
- 1:16:13about not requesting things for
- 1:16:14everyone. Uh, he is already a patient
- 1:16:18with sequelae, we are already doing P3
- 1:16:21on him, right, which is providing care
- 1:16:23for the sequelae, the rehabilitation of
- 1:16:26that person. After a surgery, you have
- 1:16:29to have rehabilitation. There are
- 1:16:32surgeries where rehabilitation is three
- 1:16:33or four days at home and there are
- 1:16:35surgeries where rehabilitation is years
- 1:16:37and years and years of follow-up so you
- 1:16:39don't gain weight again, for example.
- 1:16:42So, uh, it's because of that that P4
- 1:16:44permeates the other preventions. But
- 1:16:47really, in bariatric surgery, you have
- 1:16:49no reason at all to keep requesting an
- 1:16:51endoscopy every year. You know what's
- 1:16:53there, you have a small stomach, you do
- 1:16:56it every 5 years, as per the protocols,
- 1:16:58depending on each surgical center or
- 1:16:59each surgical technique. So, the
- 1:17:02person's specific needs will tell you
- 1:17:05the specifics of your P4. Jorge brought
- 1:17:11a very interesting conclusion, right,
- 1:17:13that excessive exams, deprescribing,
- 1:17:15and proper screening are inseparable
- 1:17:17from the person-centered clinical
- 1:17:19method. So, whenever we talk about P2,
- 1:17:23P3, P4, P1, we are talking about caring
- 1:17:26for people and defining the entire care
- 1:17:28process centered on the individual we
- 1:17:31are treating. And including this story
- 1:17:35of which screenings to do and which not
- 1:17:37to, I've set aside three links for you:
- 1:17:39the Ministry of Health, USPSTF, and the
- 1:17:41Canadian Task Force. I think these are
- 1:17:45three interesting links to know, that
- 1:17:46doesn't mean you have to follow them to
- 1:17:48the letter, right? Rogério himself
- 1:17:51said, we don't have the physical
- 1:17:52infrastructure in Brazil to deal with
- 1:17:54this. For example, the USPSTF
- 1:17:56recommends lung cancer screening. We
- 1:17:59don't even have enough CT scans for
- 1:18:01those who have cancer, let alone for
- 1:18:02screening. In our country, right? So,
- 1:18:06we have to place the individual within
- 1:18:09this entire universe we are in. We
- 1:18:12cannot forget that, right? Within what
- 1:18:15the system offers and what it doesn't
- 1:18:17offer, right? And looking at all of
- 1:18:19this does not mean stop doing P4. And
- 1:18:23when people come with excessive
- 1:18:25requests, which I think is the greatest
- 1:18:26anguish, especially for students and
- 1:18:28residents, like, oh, I want to do this,
- 1:18:30I want to do that, the famous check-up,
- 1:18:32right? And I dream that the person
- 1:18:35realizes that a complete blood count—
- 1:18:37the word complete means it will show
- 1:18:38the whole body from end to end—and
- 1:18:40they barely know what a blood count is.
- 1:18:44So, it is up to us as doctors and
- 1:18:46caregivers of individuals and families
- 1:18:49embedded in a community to show them
- 1:18:52our universe, right, and the universe
- 1:18:55we value so much. I think this talk by
- 1:18:59Rogério, this 1 hour and 20 minutes
- 1:19:02we've been together, with over 100
- 1:19:05people watching live simultaneously, is
- 1:19:09a very high number. This reinforces how
- 1:19:12important it is for us to have this
- 1:19:15discussion, right? Well, it ends up
- 1:19:19showing that we might need to have
- 1:19:21other meetings to deepen the
- 1:19:23discussions, to delve into how to
- 1:19:25define an appropriate list of exams for
- 1:19:28the individual, how to organize exams,
- 1:19:30routines, and scheduling. Look at how
- 1:19:33much we can break down from just one
- 1:19:35conversation about quaternary
- 1:19:37prevention, right? So, already
- 1:19:41for sure I
- 1:19:43go ahead. Sorry, Ricardo.
- 1:19:45No, sorry. I was going to say that we
- 1:19:48still have many demands for Rogério.
- 1:19:52Rogério, please be aware in advance
- 1:19:55that you will be called for new stages
- 1:19:57of our SBC Ensina project, because
- 1:19:59there are still more questions, there
- 1:20:02are issues here that we didn't have
- 1:20:04time to answer. I saw that people liked
- 1:20:09it a lot, lots of compliments, they
- 1:20:11really praised your lecture, okay? And
- 1:20:14we are very happy that you enjoyed it.
- 1:20:19And, without a doubt, it was a great
- 1:20:21success that we chose your name as well
- 1:20:24. I even forgot during your
- 1:20:26introduction to mention that Rogério
- 1:20:29is also part of our quaternary
- 1:20:30prevention working group, right? The
- 1:20:32society has several working groups, one
- 1:20:35of them is a working group of great
- 1:20:37quality, right? The one on quaternary
- 1:20:40prevention, and Rogério is part of it,
- 1:20:42right? He is one of the coordinators of
- 1:20:45that group as well. And that is very
- 1:20:48good. So, that invitation for other
- 1:20:51lectures stands, right? I would like
- 1:20:55your final thoughts for the closing,
- 1:20:58Rogério, please. Well, I thank you
- 1:21:02again for the invitation, I make myself
- 1:21:04available, let's keep working to spread
- 1:21:06what we think, what we do, and what we
- 1:21:08study. I recommend to everyone,
- 1:21:13residents, students, to sign up for the
- 1:21:16Brazilian society, you get a discount
- 1:21:18because you are a resident or student.
- 1:21:22Go there, join, because these working
- 1:21:25groups are fantastic places for
- 1:21:27discussion, they are wonderful forums.
- 1:21:31Nowadays, all these working groups have
- 1:21:33WhatsApp, it's quite fast-paced, but
- 1:21:35it's very interesting, hectic, but cool
- 1:21:38. Case discussions, if you need, there
- 1:21:41is always someone to help you. And I
- 1:21:43really want to express my gratitude to
- 1:21:46the society. I really like talking
- 1:21:49about this, leaving here what we study,
- 1:21:52what our opinion is on this. And to
- 1:21:56remind everyone that less is more, you
- 1:21:59know? Less is more. Life nowadays, this
- 1:22:03planetary life we lead, our political
- 1:22:06issues in Brazil, COVID, which showed
- 1:22:09us that Brazilian medicine is not
- 1:22:11evidence-based...medicine is based, uh,
- 1:22:14Brazilian medicine is based on WhatsApp
- 1:22:17, on what my uncle who lives in the
- 1:22:20countryside said. And, man, we need to
- 1:22:25improve; we need, as a society, to
- 1:22:28demand improvements in medicine,
- 1:22:30improvements in our conditions. Of
- 1:22:34course, that involves political,
- 1:22:36educational, and security improvements,
- 1:22:38but we need to become better people,
- 1:22:39you know? And I think these discussion
- 1:22:42forums here catch people who are really
- 1:22:45eager to learn, and that is very
- 1:22:47worthwhile. So, a hug to everyone, I
- 1:22:49thank you very much for the invitation
- 1:22:51and I am at your disposal. My kisses to
- 1:22:55each and every one of you, and let’s
- 1:22:57move on to the next. I just wanted to
- 1:23:04answer a question quickly, because it
- 1:23:07was a very important question, whether
- 1:23:09the Medical Ethics Council, the medical
- 1:23:12councils, support quaternary prevention
- 1:23:14—they do, okay? It’s not by failing
- 1:23:17to do things that we are being
- 1:23:20unethical, right? So,
- 1:23:23actually, if you do too much, you incur
- 1:23:25much greater ethical risks than if you
- 1:23:28do too little, right?
- 1:23:31Uh, there is no ethics in trying to
- 1:23:34find out why a person's fingernail is
- 1:23:36crooked. There is ethics in not making
- 1:23:39your patient go through all of that,
- 1:23:42knowing that it's not important. So,
- 1:23:45even the big issue with COVID was this,
- 1:23:48right, that from the beginning we saw
- 1:23:50it was completely unethical to give
- 1:23:52medicines that you know don't work.
- 1:23:56It’s not a case of me not knowing if
- 1:23:58it works; it’s knowing that it
- 1:24:00doesn't work. Research around the world
- 1:24:03quickly showed that it doesn't work. In
- 1:24:07April 2020, no country had a
- 1:24:08chloroquine protocol anymore, and we
- 1:24:10were giving it like there was no
- 1:24:12tomorrow. So our CFM ethics council, it
- 1:24:16didn't work the way it needed to work.
- 1:24:21Because the moment you heard a doctor
- 1:24:23on WhatsApp or a doctor on YouTube, a
- 1:24:24doctor on Instagram talking nonsense,
- 1:24:26they should have cracked down, slapped
- 1:24:28their wrists quickly, and that would
- 1:24:30have ended our problem. So our ethical
- 1:24:34issue is generally, in the majority, 99
- 1:24:37%of the time, you're going to get
- 1:24:39screwed by what you do too much, not by
- 1:24:42not ordering a blood count for the
- 1:24:44person this year. No, that's not what
- 1:24:47happens.
- 1:24:49I think it is very important to make
- 1:24:50this clear, because this scares people,
- 1:24:52right? Ah, I didn't do it, am I going
- 1:24:54to get in trouble? work. Yeah, I think
- 1:24:57just to pick up where we left off to
- 1:24:59wrap up, we should also move away from
- 1:25:01this idea of so-called defensive
- 1:25:02medicine, right? Because often, things
- 1:25:05are done more because of this," Oh,
- 1:25:08I'll order several tests to show, "
- 1:25:10right, that I put it in the medical
- 1:25:13record so no one sues me later.
- 1:25:17Something, for example, that we might
- 1:25:19have inherited from American medicine,
- 1:25:21right, where it's very litigious, and
- 1:25:23we know the amount of hospitalizations
- 1:25:25due to iatrogenesis is huge in the
- 1:25:27United States, right? They have more
- 1:25:31statistical data; we don't have as much
- 1:25:33data to compare to the Brazilian
- 1:25:35reality here yet, but the North
- 1:25:37American data is impressive regarding
- 1:25:40the percentage of hospitalizations due
- 1:25:42to excessive interventions, often,
- 1:25:44right? Right, excessive prescribing,
- 1:25:47over-diagnosis, and over-treatment. So,
- 1:25:50I think looking at the North American
- 1:25:53reality makes us see, look, really
- 1:25:55using quaternary prevention here in
- 1:25:57Brazil is the way to go, especially in
- 1:25:59a country with few financial resources
- 1:26:02applied to health, right? And finally,
- 1:26:06I just wanted to thank Rogério once
- 1:26:08again, thank everyone watching us, and
- 1:26:10reinforce the importance of having a
- 1:26:13Brazilian Society of Family and
- 1:26:15Community Medicine that has also been
- 1:26:17guided by quaternary prevention in our
- 1:26:19positions—positions that are often
- 1:26:22political, tough, and that are, well,
- 1:26:24it's how we believe a society should
- 1:26:26conduct itself, really bringing
- 1:26:28scientific evidence, thinking really
- 1:26:35about the benefit of our population. I
- 1:26:38think, regarding COVID, that was
- 1:26:40fundamental, and the society was one of
- 1:26:42the few that didn't stay silent, right?
- 1:26:45And they took a firm stand, denouncing,
- 1:26:48including, this issue of using early
- 1:26:50treatment without any kind of evidence
- 1:26:53—quite the contrary. It's important
- 1:26:57for everyone watching to know and to
- 1:26:59sign up, to become a member of the
- 1:27:01society, and to realize that by
- 1:27:03participating more and more, we
- 1:27:05strengthen this movement in defense of
- 1:27:07medicine, which also includes
- 1:27:09quaternary prevention as part of it,
- 1:27:11okay? That's it, folks. I thank you
- 1:27:14very much, once again I thank my
- 1:27:16colleague in moderation, Lucas, our
- 1:27:19fellow family doctor Rogério, and
- 1:27:22let's continue with new classes. soon
- 1:27:25in the coming weeks and months. Big hug
- 1:27:27. Bye bye.
- 1:27:28That's it, folks. Thank you. Good night
- 1:27:30. Thanks to Ana as well, who joined us
- 1:27:32here, right? And a reminder, the
- 1:27:34congress is already here, right? August
- 1:27:37, September, October, 16th Brazilian
- 1:27:39Congress of Family and Community
- 1:27:41Medicine. So, there is still time to
- 1:27:44sign up. Let's go, everyone.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Aula pública sobre prevenção quaternária - SBMFCEnsina by SBMFC, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,284 words across 1,909 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.