Attorney’s Fees in Family Law Cases — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00here welcome judge Barber on that end
- 0:03thank you and everybody who's over there
- 0:06first of all I'd like to shout out and
- 0:08thank you to all the Techno people who
- 0:09are helping us both on that end and this
- 0:11end we are also video conferencing
- 0:14um in some other folks last time we
- 0:17tried that that didn't work out so great
- 0:19for some of those people so if you're
- 0:20listening to this right now via video
- 0:22conference please shoot me an email and
- 0:24let me know how the experience was
- 0:25because we've made some improvements
- 0:28um this uh presentation will also be
- 0:30available on the ninth Judicial website
- 0:32under my uh under my name if you've got
- 0:36friends who want to go watch it they can
- 0:38contact me later and get the
- 0:39all-important CLE number I'm going to
- 0:42give that to you now I'm going to try to
- 0:44remember to do it again at the end
- 0:47um email me if you don't get it right or
- 0:49I say it wrong I'm going to be sneaking
- 0:51out on this end by 1-1 because I've got
- 0:54a hearing in Osceola to get to so if all
- 0:57of a sudden judge Barber you don't see
- 0:59me here that's where I've been all right
- 1:01the number is one six zero six zero one
- 1:06seven n as in Nancy one six zero six one
- 1:10zero seven n as in Nancy so we're here
- 1:12today to talk
- 1:16one six zero
- 1:18six zero one seven n
- 1:23and that's why you don't want to have
- 1:25your math cases in front of me
- 1:31one of my favorite topics
- 1:35and in keeping with judge Barber and I's
- 1:37uh good cop bad copper chain down in
- 1:39Osceola County I will be talking about
- 1:41Bad actors and 75-105 and then she's
- 1:45going to talk to you about the very
- 1:46important 6116 fees which are your more
- 1:49traditional need ability to pay and I
- 1:52want you to pay super close attention to
- 1:54what she has to tell you because we have
- 1:56both been experiencing lately some
- 1:59problems in in lawyers bringing to us
- 2:01what they need to to prove that
- 2:04reasonableness of fees and in having
- 2:07what we feel like as a record that will
- 2:09withstand appeal so please pay extra
- 2:12close attention when judge Barber talks
- 2:13to you so let's talk about 57 105 for a
- 2:16minute and let me just say at the jump
- 2:19that this is controversial there are a
- 2:21lot of people in this room in this
- 2:22building that where black dresses to
- 2:25work that are going to disagree with
- 2:26what I'm about to say
- 2:29I like 57 105 and I think it's
- 2:32underutilized although it should not be
- 2:34abused
- 2:36um in my feeling as a now being on the
- 2:40bench and this is my feeling as a
- 2:42practitioner too there are very few ways
- 2:44that we can deter
- 2:46litigants from filing baloney very few
- 2:50ways
- 2:51fees as a sanction is is just about the
- 2:55only tool a judge has to keep folks from
- 2:59doing that so I personally I believe in
- 3:02it I believe that it is a lawyer I
- 3:04believe in it as a judge so here are the
- 3:06rules number one you need to evaluate
- 3:09the situation where you want to use it
- 3:11very carefully
- 3:12all right we're not Miami trust me you
- 3:14don't want to practice in Miami let's
- 3:16not I'm not trying to make us Miami
- 3:18evaluate it very carefully keep in mind
- 3:21that 57 105 applies not just to the
- 3:24pleading as a whole but to individual
- 3:27parts of a pleading and I'm going to use
- 3:29as my example for today petitions for
- 3:32modification because that just happens
- 3:33to be the area that I feel is the most
- 3:35utterly abused if you get a petition for
- 3:38modification
- 3:40um
- 3:41you know my kid's 16 now and this is
- 3:44what he wants
- 3:45um you know or whatever and the shorter
- 3:48they are usually the the worse they are
- 3:50and you feel that you have a 57-105
- 3:54claim
- 3:55um then this is how you go about doing
- 3:57it but but again back to my first point
- 3:59it doesn't just have to be the pleading
- 4:02as a whole it can be some individual
- 4:04part of a pleading and it doesn't have
- 4:05to be an original petition or a petition
- 4:08for modification it can be an answer it
- 4:11can be a request for Discovery I mean
- 4:13there's it really does apply to anything
- 4:16that is an assertion of law or fact that
- 4:19is not well-based it doesn't have to be
- 4:21frivolous anymore just well-based if
- 4:23it's not based in the law and the fact
- 4:25it can be any portion of therein be
- 4:30subject to 57-105 but here's what you've
- 4:32got to do to make this stick and by
- 4:36stick I mean once you'd follow these
- 4:38these directions
- 4:39accordingly and you've got the right
- 4:41kind of case or the right kind of claim
- 4:43and you Prevail these attorneys fees are
- 4:46shall you are guaranteed to get
- 4:48attorney's fees under 57 105 if you
- 4:50Prevail and you follow the directions
- 4:53and the directions are you have to do a
- 4:56Safety Harbor notice you have to send a
- 4:58notice to the other party you do not
- 5:00file it no no no no
- 5:02it can look like a pleading that's
- 5:04usually how mine looked it looks like a
- 5:05pleading you send it to the other side
- 5:07you say notice of intent to seek fees
- 5:10under 57 105.
- 5:12and then you go and you have put this in
- 5:16your pleading
- 5:18and it's it's baloney I per I always
- 5:21preferred and I think it's safer if you
- 5:23go the extra step and say it's not well
- 5:26founded under the law because of this
- 5:28Statute in this case in this case it's
- 5:31not well founded in the in the facts
- 5:33because you should you do or should know
- 5:36that that's not true and that's not true
- 5:38and that's not true and then you send it
- 5:40to the other side and they now have 20
- 5:43days to fix things they can dismiss the
- 5:46pleading they can file they can seek to
- 5:48file an amended uh if you haven't filed
- 5:51an answer they can go ahead and file an
- 5:52amended they get a chance to fix things
- 5:54my suggestion to you is that when you
- 5:57get one of those notices you don't ball
- 6:00it up and go half sour grapes you take a
- 6:02pretty good look at it
- 6:05um I take a pretty good look at it I
- 6:07take a I take an objective look at it we
- 6:09all and by we I mean litigants uh uh
- 6:13lawyers for litigants and I wasn't there
- 6:16very long ago we drink the Kool-Aid I
- 6:20get it you come in and you really really
- 6:22really do believe your client's position
- 6:24and when they sell when they say to you
- 6:27um Dad was arrested three weeks ago for
- 6:28aggravated assault on a baby uh you have
- 6:31no reason not to believe that and
- 6:33they're pretty and you put that in your
- 6:35pleading and you sign it and they swear
- 6:37to it and you think everything's good
- 6:38when you get the 57 105 it says yeah
- 6:40actually that's not what happened he was
- 6:43the victim in that or there was no
- 6:45arrest or he wasn't charged with
- 6:47anything or there was no baby involved
- 6:48or this child wasn't there you need to
- 6:51really take a hard look at that because
- 6:54what happens down the line is once you
- 6:56once you file this notice I'm sorry once
- 6:58you give them the notice
- 7:00then 21 days later if they have not
- 7:03fixed the problem and you don't have to
- 7:05do it on the 21st day frankly you don't
- 7:08have to file it until after you
- 7:10um theoretically after you Prevail but
- 7:12at least 20 days later you have to wait
- 7:15and you file the motion seeking fees
- 7:18under 57 105 and then when you win
- 7:22the judge has to take a look at that and
- 7:24say if there was no
- 7:26um reality to those allegations of those
- 7:29factual allegations had no reality
- 7:32uh you Prevail and your client gets fees
- 7:35and if that legal position that was
- 7:38taken by the lawyer
- 7:41is doesn't have a basis in the law
- 7:44you get fees
- 7:46and
- 7:47the fees presumptively are shared by the
- 7:52lawyer and the client who filed the bad
- 7:55stuff
- 7:58um
- 7:59lawyer beware it's presumptive so the
- 8:02only way a lawyer gets out of paying
- 8:04their half
- 8:05is if they come in out of the
- 8:08evidentiary hearing on the 57-105 fees
- 8:10and now they're they're put in a
- 8:13position a very unpleasant position of
- 8:15having to say it's my client's fault
- 8:18that I put that bologna in there
- 8:20and then you've got to convince the
- 8:21court that you did your due diligence
- 8:23because some of this case law that's in
- 8:25the uh the outline that I emailed you
- 8:27guys
- 8:28um this is pretty tough case law
- 8:33um
- 8:34I love this this um quote from the vo
- 8:37versus Church case about half the
- 8:41practice of a decent lawyer is telling
- 8:43clients they are damn fools and to stop
- 8:46I mean that's your your job as I see it
- 8:50in part is to tell people I know you
- 8:53feel very strongly about that position
- 8:55there is no legal basis for it I'm not
- 8:58putting it in writing I know you feel
- 9:01very strongly about that but I have
- 9:03absolutely no evidence except you
- 9:06telling me that he hits the pipe all day
- 9:08long
- 9:09and I don't mean tobacco and if I I'm
- 9:14telling you right now without some
- 9:16objective how we're going to prove it in
- 9:18a courtroom I'm not putting it in
- 9:20writing I'm not putting my name on it
- 9:22that's your job
- 9:25um is it kind of a higher level to this
- 9:28I you know judges I don't remember ever
- 9:31a judge ever telling me this when I was
- 9:32in private practice but I'm telling you
- 9:35right now our memories are actually
- 9:37better than you think they are
- 9:39and we're human
- 9:42so when I have lawyers come before me
- 9:45that have a history of not bringing
- 9:49baloney
- 9:50and the I had they come in with a gut
- 9:54visceral unconscious I couldn't do
- 9:57anything about it if I wanted to
- 9:59credibility bump they come in with a
- 10:01credibility bump over somebody who time
- 10:04after time I we we read this stuff we I
- 10:09read every single pleading before a
- 10:10trial I read every single old order I
- 10:12read the entire thing I read the
- 10:14pre-trial memorandums I prep my final
- 10:17judgments based on those and this is
- 10:19what I find myself doing too often oh
- 10:22back back back they didn't prove that oh
- 10:25back back but that wasn't actually
- 10:27anywhere near in the realm of what was
- 10:29proved backpack backpack
- 10:31um we we know and you all are developing
- 10:33your own little
- 10:36um Persona of credibility and
- 10:38reliability with each individual judge
- 10:40and it it doesn't take that much for
- 10:42that there to be chinks in that
- 10:46um there are occasions where I think God
- 10:48that I really thought that was a really
- 10:51good bright lawyer I can't believe what
- 10:53I can't believe what I'm reading there's
- 10:56absolutely there's like no no law in our
- 10:59land that would support what this this
- 11:01is I don't even know I mean did they do
- 11:03it because their their client forced
- 11:05them to did they do it because they
- 11:07really didn't know I mean we don't know
- 11:09what goes on in your offices so we have
- 11:11no idea whether you file baloney because
- 11:14you got buckled under by a client with a
- 11:16lot of money and a lot of passion and
- 11:18they convinced you to do it because you
- 11:20wanted the case that bad or if you tried
- 11:22to talk them out of it and they talked
- 11:25you back into it or whether you just
- 11:26flat out don't know the law we don't
- 11:28know
- 11:29we don't know but each time we get an
- 11:32experience like that it's very very
- 11:34difficult to put that out of your mind
- 11:35and treat you like fresh pristine don't
- 11:38know you from Adam lawyers the next time
- 11:40you come with another client so just
- 11:42keep that in mind
- 11:44um
- 11:45so lawyers are expected to do
- 11:48their own investigation
- 11:49you're not you're expected to do more
- 11:51than Sally tells me that he smokes dope
- 11:55all day every day okay Sally what makes
- 11:58you say that what are we going to
- 11:59present in court what isn't going to be
- 12:01hearsay what's not going to be you
- 12:04really have an obligation to do a lot
- 12:07more than I think is normally done
- 12:10uh uncorroborated claims do not
- 12:14constitute material facts
- 12:20and oh that is such a powerful concept
- 12:22and let me let me
- 12:25um point to something that happens in
- 12:27the courtroom as an example all right so
- 12:29your client Sally says he's at the crack
- 12:32pipe all day long
- 12:34um this happened he left the child alone
- 12:36uh the the the babies diaper's always
- 12:39bad
- 12:41um blah blah so you go to trial
- 12:43you have no eyewitnesses to this of
- 12:45course and you don't have anything but
- 12:48hearsay which the judge isn't letting in
- 12:50and so
- 12:52um pipe pipe smoker gets on the stand
- 12:54and and you you know isn't it true that
- 12:57your pipe smoker know what about that
- 12:59time that you got arrested that didn't
- 13:00happen well what about that time this
- 13:02happened that didn't happen well what
- 13:04about time that it didn't happen that
- 13:05didn't happen
- 13:06and then in closing I've had lawyers
- 13:09argue to me the things that they asked
- 13:12the witness like that's not you being
- 13:16able to cross-examine somebody is not a
- 13:20corroborated
- 13:22fact that's not that's not comp that's
- 13:25not evidence your questions and is are
- 13:28not are not evidence
- 13:30so even if you say to to pipe smoker hey
- 13:33what about that time you smoked crack
- 13:35four months ago and he says I don't
- 13:37remember that happening
- 13:38that's not evidence that he spoke
- 13:40cracked four months ago either you so
- 13:43you really
- 13:44um
- 13:45the reason that this needs to
- 13:48were you uh is not even so much because
- 13:52there are that many people out there
- 13:54filing 57 105 claims because right now
- 13:56there there aren't I see very few of
- 13:58them
- 13:59um I think there should be more of them
- 14:01and I think that lawyers have some sort
- 14:03of impression that um judges don't like
- 14:06it or that we see it as being
- 14:08I don't know not playing fair not being
- 14:11nice I can't speak for all the judges
- 14:13all I can do is tell you that a it's a
- 14:17it's a tool that is absolutely
- 14:19legitimate and to me helps us call out
- 14:23um
- 14:24claims that I shouldn't have to be
- 14:25dealing with at the end of a year-long
- 14:27expensive litigation and two it offers
- 14:31judges a little bit of cover
- 14:33because it's not it's it I think it's
- 14:36going to be a lot easier to get judges
- 14:38to award fees under the statutory basis
- 14:40than it is to not do this and hope that
- 14:43you can do it under the vexatious
- 14:45litigation bad faith case law which
- 14:48we'll talk about next
- 14:49um because that's then that's the judge
- 14:51happy to say you're a bad you know bad
- 14:53litigant a bad lawyer and they've got to
- 14:54be the bad guy whereas under 57 105 you
- 14:58prevailed turns out that you didn't have
- 15:00any evidence of it turns out the law
- 15:02didn't support you
- 15:03and it's shall and now the judge can say
- 15:07I don't really have a choice so
- 15:10um I'd ask you to think about
- 15:12when it is that you can use that
- 15:14strategically and to pay more attention
- 15:17to that Judge Barbara did you want to
- 15:18talk about
- 15:19um anything related to that before I go
- 15:22on to vexatious litigation
- 15:25any questions on this end
- 15:28about 57 105.
- 15:36okay we got one on this end we say it
- 15:38and then and then I'll repeat the
- 15:39question make sure everybody can hear
- 15:40would it be your suggestion that the
- 15:4457105 motion then not be filed until you
- 15:47get a ruling or an order to determine
- 15:50whether you're the prevailing party or
- 15:52not so that's a great question the
- 15:55question is strategically when do you
- 15:57file the motion you've done the notice
- 15:59you've waited the 20 days they haven't
- 16:01done bubkiss
- 16:03um if you were in my courtroom I'd say
- 16:05file it before the hearing because it's
- 16:08just that little thing because we the
- 16:09judges won't know about the notice you
- 16:11sent but they will know that you filed
- 16:13the motion and that is going to be you
- 16:16know just right up here going huh no
- 16:19facts huh no law to support it huh I
- 16:21mean we're gonna kind of see where it's
- 16:23going and you can actually ask for
- 16:26um notice that along with the trial and
- 16:27ask the court to make a decision at the
- 16:30at the end of the trial depending on how
- 16:31they rule so I wouldn't personally I
- 16:34wouldn't I don't know that there's a big
- 16:36advantage to waiting the the other thing
- 16:38is too you put your you you already have
- 16:42the bow over the bridge and now you've
- 16:43said okay we've got the cannon pointing
- 16:45at you
- 16:47um because a couple of just Little
- 16:49nuances to that your obligation as a
- 16:51lawyer
- 16:52doesn't just mean at the front end I I
- 16:56did my best I did some investigation
- 16:57these facts look right to me
- 17:00uh when you go to the deposition and I
- 17:03had a I had a case in a dependency Court
- 17:05where 57105 fees were a big huge deal
- 17:09because what happened is we went to the
- 17:11deposition and the Department's case
- 17:13crumbled like a souffle
- 17:16well there's a continuing obligation so
- 17:19even if you're not going to get dinged
- 17:21for what you did uh the fees prior to
- 17:24the depositions if you go to depositions
- 17:26and all of a sudden somebody's case
- 17:27falls apart they have an obligation then
- 17:29a continuing one to say oops I need to
- 17:32file an amended uh there's a 57 105
- 17:35pending so um at any at any point along
- 17:38the way if you realize that you don't
- 17:40have the facts there's a law to support
- 17:41you then it's your obligation to fix
- 17:44your pleadings
- 17:46um you can also buyer beware you can
- 17:48also get 57 105 fees for filing an
- 17:52improper
- 17:54motion for 57 105 fees so I'm not
- 17:57telling you go I mean I don't want to
- 17:58you know if I get people in this
- 18:00building calling me tomorrow and going
- 18:01God damn it Diana everybody in the world
- 18:03is filing these damn motions I'm gonna
- 18:04go hey hey hey no you got to be careful
- 18:06I mean you gotta you gotta pick the ones
- 18:09where you know you know pick the ones
- 18:11where you know you're right you got to
- 18:12know you're right yeah
- 18:19[Music]
- 18:24first and then you ask for your ruling
- 18:27on 57 105 like if you the prevailing
- 18:30party at that motion so you can do it
- 18:32and I think you can do it a number of
- 18:33different ways so you do the notice
- 18:34which doesn't get filed and then at
- 18:37least 21 days later and I believe you
- 18:40could do your motion for fees under 57
- 18:43105 up up to the the trial on that issue
- 18:47or you could even do it after you win we
- 18:50were just talking about there
- 18:51potentially being some maybe advantages
- 18:54to doing it beforehand and I guess I
- 18:57could think of situations where you
- 18:59where you want to wait until after
- 19:01depending on the facts but you could do
- 19:03it either way the other advantage to
- 19:05doing ahead of time is you could cross
- 19:06notice that for the trial and ask the
- 19:09court to actually rule on those issues
- 19:11at the same time I personally
- 19:14um whether it's 57 105 fees or 61 16
- 19:17fees I really like to get it all done at
- 19:20the same time I don't I hate this whole
- 19:23comeback six months later with the
- 19:26affidavits and I don't remember what the
- 19:28facts I barely remember what my ruling
- 19:30was and I mean I I personally would
- 19:32prefer to do it all in one time but I
- 19:33don't think you I don't think you have
- 19:34to do that you could wait get your win
- 19:36and then file the motion saying I and
- 19:39the motion has to lay out I gave them
- 19:41the notice on this date I filed my
- 19:43motion on this date there's there's time
- 19:45the at least 20 days in between and I
- 19:48prevailed and you got to give me fees I
- 19:51Prevail that the their emotion that got
- 19:53denied right okay right
- 19:55um
- 20:00let's talk about the uh vexatious
- 20:03litigation for just a minute
- 20:04so
- 20:05if you have a 57 105 claim pending and
- 20:10you have what the the judge might
- 20:13consider to be bad acts of the litigant
- 20:16or the lawyer also
- 20:19and for example you've got maybe you've
- 20:22got a
- 20:24are you okay
- 20:27are we yeah
- 20:30okay I apologize I had wanted to
- 20:33interject something but I tried and
- 20:35apparently you didn't hear me so I
- 20:37wanted to make sure we are communicating
- 20:38good you can hear me now I totally I
- 20:40totally can what you want to say okay
- 20:42well I'm so it's
- 20:44a little bit late now I apologize but
- 20:46getting back to 57 105 in the safe
- 20:49harbor motion what about the instance
- 20:51where the uh Safe Harbor letters sent to
- 20:55the attorney and the attorney files an
- 20:58amended pleading but it really doesn't
- 20:59cure the defect now do you think that
- 21:02the person is obligated to file another
- 21:06or I should say send another Safe Harbor
- 21:09letter or do you think that they can go
- 21:11ahead and file their motion for fees
- 21:12when the amended pleading does not cure
- 21:14the the complaint of defect so I know
- 21:17we've I know we've had a conversation
- 21:18about this judge Barber and I my feeling
- 21:21is because it's a continuing Duty you
- 21:25would not have to file another letter
- 21:27but I think in practice another letter
- 21:32would perhaps
- 21:35help if you had a judge that was either
- 21:37concerned about the notice due process
- 21:39part or if there's
- 21:42excuse me or if the changes that they're
- 21:45making
- 21:46for example it's one thing to have them
- 21:48take out things I think if they don't
- 21:50take out enough you're okay you don't
- 21:52need another letter but what if they
- 21:54change things up I think you might need
- 21:57another one to put them a notice that
- 21:59these new allegations also are not based
- 22:01on fact or your new legal premise is
- 22:04also not based in the law so I think it
- 22:07might be a safer practice
- 22:09to go ahead and do another letter
- 22:12but I don't know that you technically
- 22:14have to assuming the same problems were
- 22:17in the new one as were in the old one
- 22:19since it is a continuing Duty
- 22:22um but I don't I didn't see any cases
- 22:25directly on that issue so
- 22:28I you know
- 22:30another one I think would be safer
- 22:33so when a judge has multiple ways that
- 22:36they can award fees you know uh yeah I
- 22:39apologize I don't want to get too far
- 22:40off but we do have a question on this
- 22:42Silva
- 22:43yeah it's my understanding I heard you
- 22:46initially say that it no longer has to
- 22:49be excuse me
- 22:52and it just needs to not be well based
- 22:55in the block or fact
- 22:58does that mean that the standard of
- 23:00proof is no longer a centillo of
- 23:03evidence that there's a justiceable
- 23:05issue
- 23:06did you hear the question I did and I
- 23:08believe that that is accurate
- 23:10I'm looking for the case it's cited in
- 23:13the
- 23:14materials that talks about the fact that
- 23:17you no longer have to prove a frivolity
- 23:21and it is
- 23:32section
- 23:33four up
- 23:36uh right so it's um
- 23:40I don't believe that it has the
- 23:43scintilla thing is there I think it's
- 23:45just it's got to be well based
- 23:47so there has to be a a a a firm a legal
- 23:51basis and the facts have to be have a
- 23:54basis so to me that means that if you
- 23:57make claims that you have no proof of
- 24:01and you know you don't have any proof of
- 24:03at that moment that your your
- 24:06susceptible to having fees lodged
- 24:09against you and if at some point
- 24:13you lose the evidence you thought you
- 24:15were going to have to support that claim
- 24:18I think you're also uh in in Dire
- 24:22Straits potentially
- 24:25um but I'm glad you went back to that
- 24:26because the one thing that I did want to
- 24:28point out that is perhaps the most
- 24:30should be the most frightening
- 24:33um although I believe
- 24:35have you ever have you ever susponte
- 24:37awarded 57 105 fees judge Barber
- 24:40I have not okay because I haven't worn
- 24:42off on you quite enough yet but that
- 24:44doesn't mean it won't happen
- 24:48um I have and the danger of having a
- 24:51judge do it is you don't get your 20
- 24:53days you don't get your Safe Harbor you
- 24:56just get you said this you brought me no
- 24:59evidence where is it that you thought
- 25:01you were going to get your evidence I
- 25:02had a witness that didn't show up in a
- 25:04subpoena that I talked to personally
- 25:06that I thought was going to give me this
- 25:07okay all right
- 25:09um but you better you better have
- 25:11somebody or some basis to believe that
- 25:14you're going to be able to come into
- 25:14this courtroom with admissible evidence
- 25:17of what you claimed
- 25:19because I'm tired of spending my days
- 25:23um litigating stuff
- 25:25that everybody knew full well from the
- 25:27beginning what she just thought or hoped
- 25:30or suspected that he was at the crack
- 25:32pipe all day you better have some basis
- 25:34for thinking you're going to prove that
- 25:36because that's a pretty serious there's
- 25:37some pretty serious allegations
- 25:40um I don't want to see allegations of
- 25:42sexual abuse unless you've got some you
- 25:44got a A basis in fact
- 25:46not just your clients saying I think
- 25:48this happened you better have some
- 25:49admissible evidence coming in
- 25:51um so that's the danger of of Judges
- 25:54using that statute is you don't get your
- 25:55you don't get a way out you just you're
- 25:58kind of stuck
- 26:00so um vexatious litigation
- 26:04um
- 26:04I think the thing that makes this so
- 26:08difficult
- 26:09for judges and I don't know I'm just
- 26:12going to take a little poll in this room
- 26:14how many of you think it's hard to get
- 26:16judges to award fees for bad acts on the
- 26:19other side
- 26:21I always did
- 26:23um and it's my my impression that
- 26:25there's a couple reasons for it one is
- 26:28that judges are generally nice people
- 26:31and they don't like to piss people off
- 26:33I personally think is a lame reason not
- 26:35to do it but I think that is a reason
- 26:38um the other reason is it all gets so
- 26:42murky it gets so murky because it's so
- 26:46rare that there's only one bad actor
- 26:50it's usually like super bad actor and
- 26:52got fed up and now has done some of
- 26:55their own you know and now it's a back
- 26:57and forth and everybody's got dirt on
- 26:59them and it's just it takes a lot of
- 27:02time and memory and it it's it makes it
- 27:06very difficult so that's part of the
- 27:08other problem the other problem is
- 27:12um and I know you have to have this
- 27:14happen to a million times you'll come in
- 27:16they didn't do Discovery and you'll say
- 27:19I want fees you won't have an affidavit
- 27:24um
- 27:24you won't be kind of all queued up and
- 27:27you'll say judge could you just Reserve
- 27:29so the judge reserves and how often do
- 27:32you actually ever get those fees
- 27:33nobody ever goes back I
- 27:35probably have a 4 million reserved
- 27:38attorneys fees orders that I've signed
- 27:40because you know people were ready to do
- 27:42it right then
- 27:43um if you have emotion at least in front
- 27:46of me if you have emotion related to
- 27:49Discovery uh dispute
- 27:52or there's an order they didn't follow
- 27:55it
- 27:56uh something you know something along
- 27:58those lines and you have to come to a
- 28:00hearing somebody's paying somebody's
- 28:03fees
- 28:05you didn't give a discovery your bare
- 28:07face
- 28:08that's the only one that's the only in
- 28:11my mind that's the only way that's the
- 28:13only tool lawyers have to go back to
- 28:15their clients and go no no no I need the
- 28:18bank account records no no I need the
- 28:21financial Advocate I mean that's the
- 28:22tool you have is to say you know what I
- 28:24know I'm telling you right now 100 she's
- 28:26going to make you pay their fees I'm
- 28:28telling that right now that's the only
- 28:30tool you have
- 28:31um so and I feel like that's the only
- 28:33tool I have
- 28:34um but when you come into those hearings
- 28:37at least in front of me bring an
- 28:39Affidavit of time and and judge Bart is
- 28:42going to tell you more about that be be
- 28:45ready to actually request the fees that
- 28:48you want I want to give fees as
- 28:51sanctions for people who are not doing
- 28:52what they want to but you've got to give
- 28:54us the tools that we need to do that
- 28:57um and if you and if you don't have them
- 28:59then say judge can we set a hearing now
- 29:02for the fees issue and I'll get out my
- 29:04calendar and we'll set a hearing now or
- 29:06call up later and actually set those set
- 29:10those things for hearing because they
- 29:11just kind of get lost in the ephemera
- 29:14and it just kind of then and then Nobody
- 29:17ends up there's no deterrence to that
- 29:21when you're going for read over the case
- 29:24law a little bit when it comes to bad
- 29:25act and bad faith litigation the the the
- 29:28rules and the findings are much more
- 29:32strict than for example 57-105 fees so
- 29:37it really is you really got to give your
- 29:40judge a lot to get fees based on those
- 29:43kind of bad act things that aren't based
- 29:45on on aren't based on the statute on the
- 29:49last thing I'm going to talk about
- 29:49before I turn it over to judge Barber is
- 29:52an area that I I feel is in a little bit
- 29:54of flux
- 29:55and um that is the fees that the the
- 30:00amount of consideration a judge can give
- 30:02at the end of a trial
- 30:05to
- 30:06who was reasonable in their desires
- 30:09requests expectations uh negotiations
- 30:13and how to balance that with the need
- 30:16and ability to pay and there's a couple
- 30:19of cases out of a couple different
- 30:20districts that are kind of in opposition
- 30:22about that we have the the new case the
- 30:26Palmer case out of the first and
- 30:29basically in the first they believe it
- 30:31needing ability to pay really really
- 30:32really needs to be that guiding force no
- 30:35matter who came in and asked for the Sun
- 30:37the moon the stars and lost there's a
- 30:40case called halleck out of the fourth
- 30:42which seems to indicate that you can
- 30:45take into account a little bit more
- 30:47people's uh negotiations and who rejects
- 30:51what offers so in my my feeling is that
- 30:56no matter where the judge comes down on
- 30:58balancing those two things
- 31:00you cannot ignore the inability to pay
- 31:02because that that can never be ignored
- 31:05but as far as the relevance of people's
- 31:09offer of settlement I think is totally
- 31:10relevant admissible all I want I want to
- 31:13I want to know I want to know about it
- 31:15only as it relates to the fees
- 31:18uh yes Miss Lopez
- 31:24it's relevant as to the fees issue judge
- 31:27I have an offer of settlement that I
- 31:29said now and it may be your judge may it
- 31:32you can do it one of two ways
- 31:34if the judge is already bifurcating the
- 31:37fees issue then you've got no problem
- 31:38because you're bringing in at the fees
- 31:40hearing and you say judge you ordered
- 31:42400 a month in alimony and we have an
- 31:45offer here where we offered her two
- 31:47thousand dollars a month in alimony and
- 31:49here we went to four mediations on this
- 31:51topic and that's this much of their bill
- 31:54is based on
- 31:55um the obvious this was ever going to
- 31:57happen or they kept asking for you to
- 32:01make her him do XYZ here's where we kept
- 32:05telling them there's no law you know
- 32:06it's that's kind of a little back door
- 32:0857 105 but at any at any rate those
- 32:11things are admissible when it comes to
- 32:13fees
- 32:15um you can argue an unreasonable
- 32:16positions even if it doesn't rise to the
- 32:19level of a 57 105 you can still those
- 32:22are still relevant factors that a court
- 32:25can use to award fees if the party's uh
- 32:29situations are equal financially or you
- 32:32can use it to reduce fee fees for
- 32:35somebody who under normal circumstances
- 32:37might have a right to most or all of
- 32:39their fees getting paid so I just want
- 32:41to point out to you there's a lot
- 32:43there's a lot of case law that says
- 32:44there's a lot of things that we can
- 32:45consider other than need an ability to
- 32:48pay although again that is still uh uh I
- 32:52guess I would call it a super Factor
- 32:53very important so uh judge Barber unless
- 32:56we have some questions related to those
- 32:59issues any questions on that end
- 33:02yes we have one Mr Lebanon trying to
- 33:05speak louder or she can't hear I'll
- 33:07repeat it
- 33:16uh true for contempt proceedings as well
- 33:22um if an offer of settlement would be
- 33:25admissible for fees related to a
- 33:26contempt proceeding
- 33:28that was the question so
- 33:31I don't know um I don't think that
- 33:33there's any particular type of
- 33:34proceeding that this theoretically would
- 33:38not be
- 33:40available for although that's I'm having
- 33:43a hard time just in my head picturing a
- 33:44factual scenario where you've got a
- 33:47somebody who's in contempt of a court
- 33:49order
- 33:51um I mean you're really not going to
- 33:52need
- 33:53I guess if they were in contempt of
- 33:56I'm having a hard time I'm having a hard
- 33:58time just picturing the factual scenario
- 34:00but theoretically I think this would be
- 34:01admissible anytime there's somebody
- 34:03asking for fees
- 34:06all right and I would agree I don't know
- 34:08if this is a situation where you're just
- 34:12dealing with maybe alimony that's one
- 34:14thing I can think of right off the top
- 34:16of my head if there was an offer for uh
- 34:20the payment of less and arrears of
- 34:22alimony I don't know but um something
- 34:25along those lines it's hard
- 34:26enforcement's usually dealing with child
- 34:28support and or alimony or something of
- 34:31that nature but
- 34:32I agree with judge tennis procedurally
- 34:36I don't see why not I mean you can do it
- 34:39for trial you could do it for for the
- 34:41hearing I don't have any bar to it I
- 34:43just don't uh you know offhand of the
- 34:45applicability right away all right we
- 34:48got one more question here and then I'm
- 34:49gonna you go ahead
- 34:51that talks about negotiations being
- 34:53relevant for people yeah
- 34:56um there's uh the under three uh chapter
- 35:0161 fees it has respective positions
- 35:04there's a whole there's a whole deal in
- 35:06it all right Judge Barbara why don't we
- 35:08why don't you talk about
- 35:09um our more typical 6116 fee situation
- 35:18for uh chapter 61 fees is in Florida
- 35:21statute 61-16 which uh says a lot of
- 35:26things but in the main part it says that
- 35:29a judge from time to time after
- 35:31considering the relative Financial
- 35:33positions of the parties can award fees
- 35:36and the reason for the statutory basis
- 35:40is to place parties on equal footing as
- 35:43possible so that they can both secure
- 35:46competent counsel do know that whether
- 35:49or not though that your request for beat
- 35:53for fees is based in statute or in
- 35:56contract you still must plead it it has
- 35:59to be pled and the petition or the
- 36:01motion or it's waived
- 36:03um there's a case in your materials the
- 36:05Watson case that stands just for that
- 36:07proposition in that case the
- 36:09husband filed a petition the wife
- 36:12answered fees were never pled
- 36:15they went to trial and the court went
- 36:17through a lot of findings as to alimony
- 36:19and need an ability incomes of the
- 36:22parties set child support did an unequal
- 36:25distribution and then found entitlement
- 36:27to fees even though it wasn't it wasn't
- 36:29argued at trial
- 36:30and after the Judgment was entered the
- 36:34attorney for the wife filed a motion for
- 36:36fees I suppose maybe under for the rule
- 36:39procedure
- 36:401.525 that's the rule of procedure that
- 36:43says you can file a motion for fees
- 36:45within 30 days after rendition of
- 36:46judgment or the notice of voluntary
- 36:49dismissal being entered but if you look
- 36:51at the family law rules of civil
- 36:53procedure it clearly says that 1.525 has
- 36:56no applicability in the family law rules
- 36:59so that case is Illustrated of that
- 37:01point that it's got to be pled or it is
- 37:04waived that case also points to a
- 37:07Supreme Court case called Stockton or I
- 37:10think it's Stockman B downs and and that
- 37:13Supreme Court case it's a civil case but
- 37:16um they pointed to it in Watson in that
- 37:19case kind of carves out an exception
- 37:21when fees are not uh pledged and says if
- 37:26uh somebody was placed on notice because
- 37:28remember it's all about notice that's
- 37:30why we have to plead fees but if someone
- 37:32was otherwise placed on some kind of
- 37:34notice and they by their conduct
- 37:37acquiesced or they didn't object uh then
- 37:41fees can be properly before the court
- 37:45so in preparing what came to my mind is
- 37:48what about a situation where
- 37:52fees are never planned but somebody
- 37:54sticks it in their pre-trial memorandum
- 37:56okay I said the wife is seeking
- 37:59attorney's fees or maybe they'd even go
- 38:00as far as to say the wife is seeking
- 38:02attorney's fees and the amount of
- 38:03effects
- 38:04is that something that is properly
- 38:08what
- 38:10um and I think the answer to that is it
- 38:13just depends it depends on the conduct
- 38:15of uh the attorneys are they discussing
- 38:19it
- 38:19uh has there been uh an Affidavit of
- 38:23time that has flowed back and forth has
- 38:27there been any objection to it there's
- 38:29another case that the Stockman case
- 38:33points to that against the civil case
- 38:36but in that case uh fees were never pled
- 38:41um and uh they did include it though in
- 38:43a pre-trial statement
- 38:45and uh subsequent to trial the under
- 38:511.525 the attorney filed a motion for
- 38:53attorneys fees and the court said that
- 38:55it was good enough for it being in the
- 38:57pre-trial memorandum because the other
- 38:58side was placed on notice
- 39:00so I think it really is fact specific
- 39:03and it does depend but do recognize that
- 39:06there may be situations where if it's
- 39:08placed in a pre-trial memorandum and
- 39:11you're not otherwise objected to uh
- 39:14there could be conduct that would lead
- 39:16to court to rule that it was uh you were
- 39:19sufficiently placed on notice Judge
- 39:20Barbara could I jump in there for a
- 39:22second
- 39:23yeah so I think I think along the lines
- 39:25of what you're talking about is is you
- 39:28can waive your right to have all sorts
- 39:31of things pled and so I think if the
- 39:34danger is that if you get a pre-trial
- 39:36memorandum and you don't go back and
- 39:38compare that to the original pleading
- 39:40and you go forward and you're all
- 39:42arguing about whatever this issue is for
- 39:44example in this you know attorney's fees
- 39:46at the trial
- 39:48um it's very easy to try these things by
- 39:50consent and you figuring out later or
- 39:53arguing in your closing statement oh
- 39:55wait gotcha that wasn't in your that
- 39:57wasn't in your pleading I think that's
- 39:59where it's not so much that a pre-trial
- 40:01memorandum is a pleading I think that it
- 40:04it gets wrapped up in this trial by
- 40:06consent but I do see a lot of times
- 40:09where we're talking about things at
- 40:12trial it's very it's hard for me because
- 40:15I like to be involved and probably more
- 40:17than I should so
- 40:19Dad will not have pled for the tax
- 40:22deduction and here we're having this big
- 40:24old discussion at the trial about the
- 40:26tax deduction and all mom has to do is
- 40:28say he didn't plead for it he doesn't
- 40:30get it but at the end of it now I got to
- 40:32figure out did was it tried by consent
- 40:35was it not tried by consent because
- 40:37nobody said out loud we're doing this by
- 40:39consent was it in the trial memorandum
- 40:42because that makes it look a little bit
- 40:43more like consent so I think there
- 40:45definitely needs to be a little bit more
- 40:46going back and looking at the original
- 40:48pleading on your way to trial I got one
- 40:49question for you on this end Judge
- 40:50Barbara go ahead
- 40:56I'd either move to strike it or do that
- 40:59as a preliminary issue at the trial we
- 41:01didn't hear the question the question
- 41:03was if you see in the pre-trial
- 41:05memorandum I want to talk about the tax
- 41:06deduction or I want eternities and it
- 41:08wasn't pled I would probably if I were
- 41:10the lawyer I'd probably wait until the
- 41:12up until the trial starts and said like
- 41:14a couple preliminary matters
- 41:17um I'd like us to make sure we take
- 41:19these off the table because they weren't
- 41:21pled and we're starting the trial right
- 41:22now that's I think the safest way to do
- 41:25it
- 41:27yeah
- 41:29well that's why I'm I'm saying that the
- 41:32K the cases my my feeling is a pre-trial
- 41:36memorandum is not a pleading it only
- 41:38becomes trial by waiver and notice
- 41:41sufficient when you go through the whole
- 41:42thing and you you're litigating it and
- 41:45um now if they're sending you
- 41:47um Discovery related to that issue then
- 41:50you know I wouldn't just give them the
- 41:51discovery on it I would
- 41:54um but I I don't I don't think that a
- 41:57pre-trial memorandum in and of itself is
- 42:00sufficient as long as you make clear at
- 42:01the front end of the trial I'm not
- 42:03trying this by consent I don't agree to
- 42:05have that issue dealt with and while
- 42:08we're talking about Trial by consent
- 42:11that is Rule 1.190 subsection B uh I
- 42:16believe are the rules of civil procedure
- 42:18and that's the whole rule about
- 42:21pleadings relating back and amendments
- 42:23to the pleadings and conforming the
- 42:26pleadings to meet the evidence so that
- 42:28rule specifically tells you that things
- 42:31that are not pled can be Tried by
- 42:34Express or implied consent so again like
- 42:38judge tennis just indicated if somebody
- 42:41starts uh to mention something at the
- 42:44trial and you and it's not properly
- 42:46object don't let it go any further
- 42:50object and shut that door
- 42:53okay anything further there no ma'am
- 42:57all right
- 42:59um
- 42:59as far as uh
- 43:02these were contempt and enforcement
- 43:05rule excuse me if Florida statute 6116
- 43:09also indicates that uh from time to time
- 43:12the court can impose fees not only for
- 43:15initial proceedings but obviously for
- 43:16modification and uh enforcement
- 43:19proceedings there is a case in your
- 43:21materials called uh I believe it's
- 43:24power hang on one second yeah Power
- 43:27and that case just underscores that we
- 43:31still have to consider first need and
- 43:34ability as the pole star but it also
- 43:37talks about the consideration and
- 43:39contempt and enforcement actions of the
- 43:42Rosen factors and we all are I'm sure
- 43:45familiar with the Rosen factors you know
- 43:47the length the scope the duration of the
- 43:50litigation whether it's brought on to
- 43:54frustrate uh or stall
- 43:58defenses or claims that kind of thing so
- 44:02I do know that even in situations where
- 44:05somebody is being held an indirect
- 44:07criminal contempts emanating from a 61
- 44:11proceeding the first thing that we must
- 44:13consider though is or the primary factor
- 44:16is need and ability but we can also look
- 44:18to the Rosen factors
- 44:21all right
- 44:24I next want to talk to you about
- 44:28once fees are properly
- 44:31pled entitlement to fees what's next
- 44:34what's needed at the hearing we know you
- 44:37need to have an evidentiary hearing
- 44:39there has to be testimony there has to
- 44:41be testimony of the attorney that's
- 44:43seeking the fees there has to be some
- 44:45evidence as to the reasonable hourly
- 44:48rate
- 44:49as to the number of hours required
- 44:52we have to have the evidence of the
- 44:55party's relative Financial positions in
- 44:58order to determine need and ability
- 45:01a need in building findings are
- 45:03generally required except for and uh
- 45:06temporary relief situations for interim
- 45:10fees the courts are allowed broad
- 45:13discretion in awarding temporary fees
- 45:15and there's a case in your materials
- 45:19of coluso that seems to indicate that
- 45:22even if a court doesn't make the proper
- 45:23findings in the temporary fee award so
- 45:25long as the record has sufficient
- 45:27evidence of need and ability then that's
- 45:29going to be good enough
- 45:31okay
- 45:36also uh
- 45:39there is a case two cases in your
- 45:41materials uh derivir and Baker
- 45:45and those cases deal with a proposition
- 45:47that temporary fees are not a vested
- 45:50right the court can go back in a
- 45:53temporary fee award and adjust it in a
- 45:56whole or impart
- 45:59there is a case also that's not in your
- 46:01materials and I wanted to discuss it
- 46:03because it brings on a little bit of a
- 46:06different layer other than just the
- 46:08roads and factors and mutant ability it
- 46:11is the case of Woodward versus Berkeley
- 46:14it's recorded at
- 46:167 14 Southern 2nd 1027 is the fourth DCA
- 46:20case
- 46:221998. and that case was a paternity case
- 46:25and it actually involved Tom Jones I
- 46:28don't know if any of y'all are old
- 46:30enough to remember Tom Jones I'm kind of
- 46:32embarrassed on him but apparently he had
- 46:37a concert and he had a one night stand
- 46:40with a woman
- 46:42and it resulted in the conception of a
- 46:45child
- 46:46and she sued him in the state of New
- 46:48York for paternity and he gave her a
- 46:50very generous settlement he gave her
- 46:52thirty three thousand dollars a month in
- 46:53child support uh
- 46:56tuition to college and private school
- 47:00and some other things it was very
- 47:02generous
- 47:03um settlement but it was non-modifiable
- 47:05the child support was not non-viable
- 47:08and New York law sanctioned that it
- 47:10apparently it was okay under certain
- 47:12circumstances in New York to make child
- 47:13support non-modifiable
- 47:16well she was not happy with that years
- 47:19later she lived in Florida
- 47:21she moved to domesticate the foreign
- 47:25judgment
- 47:26and seek to modify the child support
- 47:29she had Tom Jones served he wasn't a
- 47:32resident in Florida but she had him
- 47:34served when he came here to do a concert
- 47:37and she moved for interim fees he had
- 47:39voluntarily given her about twenty
- 47:41thousand dollars in temporary fees that
- 47:44she wanted more and the trial court
- 47:47without going to any other
- 47:50legal principles of the case whether or
- 47:53not Florida really had jurisdiction
- 47:55whether or not uh the New York law
- 47:59should apply to the contract they made
- 48:01just gave her like a hundred and thirty
- 48:03eight thousand dollars and more in the
- 48:05temporary attorneys fees and the reason
- 48:08that I like this case is it Rosen was
- 48:10decided right before this case so it
- 48:12deals with the court needing to look to
- 48:14the Rosen factors in the reward of
- 48:16temporary fees and it deals with 6116
- 48:19because charity actions 6116 applies to
- 48:22fraternity actions in terms of fees
- 48:25um but what it also instructs the court
- 48:28is it's the Court's Duty and
- 48:30responsibility
- 48:31and determining uh an award of interim
- 48:35fees to actually think about those legal
- 48:38principles to think about wait a minute
- 48:40even though he didn't raise him Persona
- 48:42jurisdiction does the court have
- 48:43jurisdiction over them
- 48:45even though Florida doesn't allow for
- 48:48non-modifiable child support New York
- 48:51does so is this action even sustainable
- 48:55right here
- 48:56so that case tells us that it's
- 48:59incumbent upon the court to actually
- 49:00look at those things in that case
- 49:02reverse that temporary fee award which
- 49:04is rarely done reverse that temporary
- 49:06fee award it's going to back down to
- 49:08trial court and said look to the merits
- 49:10in this litigation first before you
- 49:11decide whether or not you're going to a
- 49:13more temporary fees and how much okay
- 49:19do also know that a court can order a
- 49:23party to fund litigation through their
- 49:26own assets if they find that the party
- 49:29is being vexatious and that's the
- 49:31Schmitz case located in your materials
- 49:34the Martin case uh is one of the few
- 49:37cases it actually deals with what is
- 49:40income disparity in that case says that
- 49:43a party who made two and a half times
- 49:46more than the other party that that was
- 49:49a sufficient income disparity when
- 49:51consideration of the relative Financial
- 49:53positions of the parties for the award
- 49:55for the awarding of fees
- 49:58the Balco case tells you that the court
- 50:00cannot look solely to incomes the most
- 50:03again that's what the statute says the
- 50:05respective relative Financial positions
- 50:07or the parties that's what we look to
- 50:09the dresser case is I think a very
- 50:12important case I use this as a
- 50:14practitioner successfully a couple
- 50:16occasions because other practitioners
- 50:17just weren't aware of it but in
- 50:19assessing attorney's fees that case says
- 50:22that you must first when determining
- 50:25incomes
- 50:26take away from the paying party whatever
- 50:30they're paying every month out in child
- 50:32support or alimony and not only that you
- 50:35have to subtract from the receiving
- 50:37spouse's income their child support
- 50:41contribution pursuant to the guidelines
- 50:44so do be aware that when into uh incomes
- 50:49just don't say oh he's making 95 and
- 50:52she's making 35 before you do that
- 50:54adjustment
- 50:55okay
- 51:00now what proof is needed at the
- 51:03evidently hearing we need your billing
- 51:05statements or a summary and you need to
- 51:08redact out whatever information may or
- 51:11may be confidential
- 51:13we actually need evidence of need and
- 51:15ability so my preference is if you're
- 51:18going to rely on financial affidavits I
- 51:20will take judicial notice if the party's
- 51:22agree to that but my preference is that
- 51:25you actually introduce into evidence
- 51:27uh the documentation whether it be the
- 51:29financial affidavit or anything else
- 51:31you're relying on
- 51:32certainly evidence of the the Rosen
- 51:34factors if that's going to be argued the
- 51:37testimony of from uh the attorney
- 51:42and we know that pursuant to 61-16 you
- 51:46do not need expert uh witnesses to
- 51:50testify it would be good to have an
- 51:52affidavit as to the reasonableness
- 51:54by an attorney that's viewed the file
- 51:56and looked at it
- 52:00um there are some objections also that
- 52:03you can make a lot of people for
- 52:06whatever reason when I have fee hearings
- 52:09don't object to the end things uh on the
- 52:12other party's billing for whatever
- 52:14reason I don't know if it's because they
- 52:16don't want to
- 52:18upset the other party I don't know if
- 52:20it's too close to home or what but
- 52:22oftentimes when I'm Looking Through Time
- 52:25Records uh that are attached to the
- 52:28Affidavit of the time I see things that
- 52:31if I was still a practitioner I'd
- 52:32certainly be
- 52:34attacking I do know that um clerical
- 52:38time
- 52:39that is not something that should be
- 52:41taxed against the other party
- 52:4457 104 is the computation of attorney's
- 52:48fee statute and it tells you that time
- 52:51can be billed for legal assistance who
- 52:54do non-clerical services that perform a
- 52:57valid support of the case and preparing
- 53:02a notice of hearing preparing a letter
- 53:04is not it that's that's clerical
- 53:06services so you should be attacking
- 53:08those things unit billing you cannot
- 53:11Bill flat rates you have to bill actual
- 53:13time spent so that's something that you
- 53:15can attack
- 53:17and holding if it's obvious from the
- 53:20face of uh the billing statements that
- 53:23you're having way too many telephone
- 53:25calls or
- 53:27um
- 53:28prophecies or what have you it looks
- 53:31like it's uh hand holding that might be
- 53:33something you either want to further
- 53:35investigate prior to the hearing or at
- 53:37the time of the hearing
- 53:39travel time for an attorney that is out
- 53:42of town is not allowable while you're
- 53:44entitled to competent counsel you're not
- 53:46necessarily entitled to speak the time
- 53:49of an out of town attorney who has to
- 53:52travel a great distance
- 53:56and uh duplicative efforts of uh
- 54:00successor attorneys or multiple
- 54:03attorneys that is something that you can
- 54:05also look to because that is
- 54:07objectionable also know that if you want
- 54:09to object to a cost especially somebody
- 54:13such as an accountant or
- 54:15I don't know any any other expert that's
- 54:17hired
- 54:19you need to uh
- 54:22place that objection well in advance of
- 54:24the evidence you're hearing on fees and
- 54:27the reason uh is because the other
- 54:30parties should be on notice that you're
- 54:33objecting to that cost and if they need
- 54:36to get a witness in to testify as to the
- 54:39reasonableness of that cost they should
- 54:42be able to do that and they wouldn't be
- 54:44able to do that if they didn't know you
- 54:45were objecting ahead of time
- 54:47coach Barbara can I interject a couple
- 54:48thoughts
- 54:51um so I have a lot of compassion for
- 54:54what it takes to get a case ready for
- 54:56trial and I get
- 54:58how it's always so much more than you
- 55:00thought it would be and I I totally get
- 55:02that but I see so many attorneys fees
- 55:05presentations at the end of these
- 55:07horrible long agonizing hearings and
- 55:10trials that really did not get the time
- 55:12that they deserved and it really is
- 55:15having an effect on not just the amount
- 55:17of money that that we're able to give
- 55:20you but the uh vulnerability of those
- 55:24orders
- 55:25on appeal so a couple of things that
- 55:29come to mind number one I know it's
- 55:31difficult to get the attorney's fees
- 55:33affidavit out in a timely fashion but
- 55:36when I have one lawyer that says hey
- 55:38here's my I've been working for three
- 55:40years on it and I just sent it to him
- 55:43yesterday and him stands up and says I
- 55:46was a little busy last night that to me
- 55:50is just not a fit that's not fair and
- 55:53now it means that we got to kick the can
- 55:55and do something else and so if you can
- 55:58get those bills out timely and then when
- 56:01you get them from when you you've got
- 56:03the when you don't have the impecunious
- 56:06spouse when you got the the money making
- 56:08spouse and you get that thing in
- 56:11um take some time with it just as judge
- 56:14Barber was saying so often I have
- 56:16lawyers want to argue to me that the
- 56:18fees were unreasonable when they didn't
- 56:19ask the first question I mean you're the
- 56:21one who's been preparing the case I
- 56:23didn't I don't know whether that was
- 56:24reasonable or not if they're asking for
- 56:27a hundred thousand and your your guy
- 56:29only spent 30 point that out if if
- 56:32they're I mean take a little bit of time
- 56:34and spot check did the mediation really
- 56:37take five hours or did you build two
- 56:39hours or are there is there enough
- 56:43specificity
- 56:45um if somebody's challenging it email
- 56:48emo phone call phone call
- 56:50is not that's not a sufficient record if
- 56:53somebody's challenging it we are
- 56:56theoretically supposed to do our own
- 56:58independent look at these time records
- 57:01and determine what is reasonable but the
- 57:03reality is if the other party or the
- 57:05other lawyer doesn't care enough to
- 57:07cross-examine this lawyer a little bit
- 57:09to push a little bit to say what about
- 57:11on this date why would that have taken
- 57:13so long or what about on this date I
- 57:15spent this long on it and how could you
- 57:17have spent that much on it or hey you
- 57:19said you drafted this motion morality is
- 57:22I drafted that motion if you don't if
- 57:24you don't take some time to you know you
- 57:27can do it a nice way it doesn't make you
- 57:29unprofessional that just means
- 57:32um you're giving the court some
- 57:33information to Base to Base a decision
- 57:36on is if you don't do that I feel like
- 57:38this this lawyer saying this is the time
- 57:41they spend who am I I don't know what
- 57:43time he spent
- 57:44um so definitely give it a little bit
- 57:46more effort than you have but but again
- 57:49if you if you're the one with the money
- 57:51making spouse that is really at risk of
- 57:53paying those fees and you get in those
- 57:55that uh those are Time Records
- 57:58sufficiently reasonably ahead of the
- 58:00hearing
- 58:02send them a letter that says hey I've
- 58:04got questions about bees send them
- 58:05something highlight their copy and send
- 58:08it back to them and say this is what I'm
- 58:09going to question you about at the
- 58:10hearing otherwise we have the the
- 58:12opposite side of that situation
- 58:13happening and you're saying well what
- 58:15about on this day who'd you send the
- 58:17email to well
- 58:18they don't know and now again we have to
- 58:21kick the can down the road
- 58:23um there was something else that I
- 58:24wanted to
- 58:25uh something that I'm always curious
- 58:28about but very rarely does anybody tell
- 58:30me is what the other guy spent
- 58:33I find that to me that if if you're the
- 58:36client who's the doctor making a million
- 58:39and she's the stay-at-home mom who's
- 58:41getting back into real estate making 15
- 58:44and there she's asking for
- 58:48um 70.
- 58:50and he paid 200.
- 58:54um you know if you're the one asking for
- 58:56the 70 I ask the other guy how much he
- 58:59spent I think it's proper frankly and if
- 59:02and that guy won't know because you know
- 59:04he he's not going to know what he spent
- 59:05I think it's proper if you'd say if you
- 59:07say judge I'm asking for fees based on
- 59:09ability to pay I think it's relevant and
- 59:11important for you to know what
- 59:13everybody's spent so that you can look
- 59:14at what reasonable is I would like to
- 59:16put that lawyer under oath and ask him
- 59:19how much he spent or I would like to
- 59:21enter the records that I requested from
- 59:23him showing how much they spent to me
- 59:26that that's there's
- 59:27some information that I would like that
- 59:29I don't always get
- 59:31um we've got a couple questions here go
- 59:33ahead
- 59:44but then also within that detail is like
- 59:47a lot of clerical work and things like
- 59:48that and it hasn't been carved out the
- 59:53burden of proof within I think the only
- 59:54person trying to get those fees but
- 59:56curious as to how the judge sort of
- 59:58looks at that or how you look at that
- 1:00:00point so Justice
- 1:00:02that is a great question so what happens
- 1:00:05when you get in the blabo time you know
- 1:00:08two hours spent doing this and this and
- 1:00:10this and this and this and this and this
- 1:00:11which technically you're not supposed to
- 1:00:13do and you're defending against the fees
- 1:00:16do you tell them ahead of time Hey
- 1:00:18listen
- 1:00:20um you need to chop that time up to the
- 1:00:22degree or I'm going to be questioning
- 1:00:23you about this or I don't think that's
- 1:00:24the way it should be done or do you wait
- 1:00:26to the trial and say judge they didn't
- 1:00:28prove it because it's blocked timing
- 1:00:31um my off the top of my head my response
- 1:00:35would be
- 1:00:37um I would be tempted if if you got the
- 1:00:40bills in sufficient time ahead to know
- 1:00:43there was a problem and you didn't let
- 1:00:45them know there was a problem my gut
- 1:00:47sense is that I would probably say
- 1:00:49you're right that's not how it should
- 1:00:50look
- 1:00:51but I'm not going to be super technical
- 1:00:53about it and now we're going to have to
- 1:00:55you need to do a new affidavit and we're
- 1:00:57going to come back and if you can you
- 1:01:00know convince me that you figured out
- 1:01:02how it got chopped up and that's
- 1:01:03reasonable I'm going to go forward I
- 1:01:05would I don't like the the concept of
- 1:01:08gotchas or technicalities when it comes
- 1:01:11to stuff like this but
- 1:01:14I don't know judge Barber do you have a
- 1:01:16different feeling about
- 1:01:19you know I I hate to keep saying and
- 1:01:21stuff like this but I just kind of
- 1:01:23hearken back to my own practice and I
- 1:01:27knew those cases where I was going to
- 1:01:29have to be asking for fees and those
- 1:01:31which I wasn't and I would keep detailed
- 1:01:34uh single entry Time Records on those
- 1:01:37cases where I was going to be asking for
- 1:01:39fees
- 1:01:41um and then redact that information
- 1:01:44as far as what might be confidential
- 1:01:47before so I I'm kind of of the
- 1:01:50persuasion and everything's Case by case
- 1:01:53analysis but I'm kind of of this
- 1:01:55persuasion that it should be a single
- 1:01:59entry and it should be detailed uh if
- 1:02:02you were the proponent asking for the
- 1:02:05fees you need to put on a decent case
- 1:02:09I don't know you're going to be bad
- 1:02:10copper like I said
- 1:02:13um I'm not gonna help him out yeah yeah
- 1:02:15so well so so the tough thing about that
- 1:02:17is
- 1:02:19um
- 1:02:20you're never gonna know what which way
- 1:02:23the judge is going to go on that that's
- 1:02:24going to be the problem because I could
- 1:02:26be tough tough tough on a lot of things
- 1:02:27and you're going to have no idea going
- 1:02:29in that I'm not going to be like hey you
- 1:02:30didn't do it right never mind
- 1:02:32it's just it's going to be really hard
- 1:02:34to know
- 1:02:35um so but you know you know you know
- 1:02:37when you take a case or when you're into
- 1:02:39a case you know which cases that you are
- 1:02:43not going to be litigating fees in which
- 1:02:45cases you are you shouldn't be doing it
- 1:02:46you just know that within your within
- 1:02:48your office so uh Miss Louis and yep
- 1:02:53about if you're going to go into trial
- 1:02:56if you're trying to negotiate about
- 1:02:58getting fees prior to trial for trial
- 1:03:01like estimates of what is the time it's
- 1:03:03going to take if you've got the
- 1:03:05housewife mom and
- 1:03:06see the money you're talking about
- 1:03:08temper you're talking about temporary
- 1:03:09fees
- 1:03:16so visit Judge Barbara this is the
- 1:03:19question and I and I I got to admit I
- 1:03:21feel a little bit of confusion about
- 1:03:22this although I do it all the time the
- 1:03:24question is when you're going in on your
- 1:03:26temporary fees can you say and I think
- 1:03:30it's going to take me another X hours to
- 1:03:32do this and this and do this and this
- 1:03:34deposition and then for the final trial
- 1:03:37um yeah I think you can because it's
- 1:03:38temporary and it's fixable uh afterwards
- 1:03:42now that doesn't mean though that you
- 1:03:44can go to the trial and say well I I
- 1:03:47spent what I got I'm good with that no
- 1:03:50because the other side can tell you I
- 1:03:52want your time entries to make sure that
- 1:03:54you actually spent what you said you
- 1:03:56spent you can't get a windfall but I
- 1:03:58think because it's a temporary award you
- 1:04:01can do the estimation and I I grant
- 1:04:03those so I think and I think a motion
- 1:04:06for temporary fees
- 1:04:08yeah I think it would be a good practice
- 1:04:11point and a motion for temporary fees to
- 1:04:13really lay it out if you expect that
- 1:04:16there's going to be
- 1:04:1810 hours to get yourself to trial then
- 1:04:22putt there's going to be 10 additional
- 1:04:23hours to get myself to trial if you
- 1:04:26think you're going to need a court
- 1:04:27reporter for a four-hour trial then the
- 1:04:30per diem for the court reporter is X and
- 1:04:33this is the company that I am thinking
- 1:04:35about hiring and this is what they
- 1:04:37charge and I'm going to call an expert
- 1:04:39and the expert charges x per hour and I
- 1:04:42anticipate the expert to be on the stand
- 1:04:44for an hour to hour and a half or what
- 1:04:47have you but if you lay that all out
- 1:04:49instead of just putting some big number
- 1:04:52in your motion or just not putting any
- 1:04:54motion at all the other side is on
- 1:04:57notice and it really does help the court
- 1:04:58in fashioning a reasonable uh interim
- 1:05:02fee again uh interim fees there's a
- 1:05:05broad discretion in case it's all very
- 1:05:07clear that courts are rarely overturned
- 1:05:09on appeal but if you lay it out in your
- 1:05:11motion you're putting the other side on
- 1:05:14notice and you're also preparing
- 1:05:15yourself right really for okay how much
- 1:05:17how much more am I going to need in
- 1:05:20attorney's fees and costs to bring this
- 1:05:21matter to try and that's a great great
- 1:05:23point because the other thing it does it
- 1:05:25has everybody all the litigants and the
- 1:05:27lawyers all thinking about the thing
- 1:05:28that you always underestimate you always
- 1:05:30underestimate how much time and money
- 1:05:32it's going to take so you always end up
- 1:05:35with a client who cannot believe the
- 1:05:37final tally of this thing but when you
- 1:05:39go through it and go it's going to take
- 1:05:41this and this and this and you show them
- 1:05:43then at least you're not going to be
- 1:05:46they're not going to have sticker shock
- 1:05:47at the end and if you've got the client
- 1:05:49who is the the bread man anchor perhaps
- 1:05:52that's the time to have the conversation
- 1:05:54about you know you throw this much at
- 1:05:57her now or you can throw this much at
- 1:05:59the two lawyers over the course of an
- 1:06:01agonizing two years that's really doing
- 1:06:03them a favor or at least you've given
- 1:06:05them the option and if they decide they
- 1:06:07want to go take it to court anyway at
- 1:06:09least later you can say hey it's not
- 1:06:11like we didn't all know that this was
- 1:06:12going to be a very expensive probably on
- 1:06:14you situation so I think those are good
- 1:06:16conversations and don't be yeah and
- 1:06:19don't be too concerned either about okay
- 1:06:21if I put all that out in in my motion
- 1:06:24and I spend that money and more and I'm
- 1:06:28going to need another request for
- 1:06:30interim fees I'm hamstrung by this no I
- 1:06:34mean the statute does say from time to
- 1:06:36time so you can come back for another
- 1:06:40um Award of interim fees you might want
- 1:06:43to make it clear in your motion that
- 1:06:45this is your best
- 1:06:46uh
- 1:06:48guesstimate or estimate based on the
- 1:06:50information available to you at that
- 1:06:52point in time but I can see where
- 1:06:55someone would say I don't want to get
- 1:06:56too detailed in that motion because I
- 1:06:58don't want to be hamstrung to that if I
- 1:07:00that doesn't carry me through the trial
- 1:07:01and I have to file another emotion so I
- 1:07:05wouldn't be too concerned with that any
- 1:07:07any last minute questions
- 1:07:10we have one from Miss Silva okay I got
- 1:07:13one on this side and then we'll do my
- 1:07:14Silvis gotcha okay
- 1:07:16okay so not temporary but you're at the
- 1:07:19trial and you realize that they were
- 1:07:20actually
- 1:07:22so you put your fiatric tables together
- 1:07:24and do all that when you do the
- 1:07:25estimated time for trial
- 1:07:27as the judges see that right because of
- 1:07:30course you do always underestimate
- 1:07:31estimate and is it okay just to say all
- 1:07:33right I think
- 1:07:34[Music]
- 1:07:36you've got to get this to the other side
- 1:07:37but you also probably haven't prepared
- 1:07:39so in advance because you're hoping
- 1:07:41you're going to settle it at least in my
- 1:07:43life right
- 1:07:46I guess I would I guess I would say I
- 1:07:48would I would probably plug in the
- 1:07:50amount of time that you've been given
- 1:07:51for the trial if you already have like a
- 1:07:53trial date you're going to know you have
- 1:07:54a whole day put in the whole day or
- 1:07:56you've got two days put or not you're
- 1:07:58getting two days out of me but you know
- 1:07:59put that put in that whole day or that
- 1:08:01three hours
- 1:08:03um and then um but I think that you can
- 1:08:05absolutely testify that in addition to
- 1:08:09that judge as you can see it's now seven
- 1:08:10o'clock we ran over by two hours I'd
- 1:08:12like another 500 or whatever that is so
- 1:08:16I I think your bet your best intelligent
- 1:08:18guess is always going to be fine as long
- 1:08:21as you follow it up if there's a court
- 1:08:23reporter with a record of and I'd like
- 1:08:25to add an additional because we've run
- 1:08:27over or whatever I think that's I think
- 1:08:29that's the only way you can do it
- 1:08:30honestly and Miss Silva's question
- 1:08:39[Music]
- 1:08:49[Music]
- 1:09:00is there a better way for us to maybe
- 1:09:03time that
- 1:09:06um number one and the other thing is I'm
- 1:09:08very uncomfortable
- 1:09:10um
- 1:09:11putting another attorney under oath in
- 1:09:15the middle of a trial on other issues
- 1:09:18why
- 1:09:21I fear that as I question them about
- 1:09:24reasonableness this you did this why did
- 1:09:28you do this that I'm somehow gonna
- 1:09:32reach the privilege or I'm going to run
- 1:09:34up against that with the client's
- 1:09:37president so I'm a little I'm just not
- 1:09:41sure how to handle that I didn't know
- 1:09:42that I didn't totally understand what
- 1:09:44you meant about not feeling
- 1:09:46uncomfortable questioning the lawyer
- 1:09:48about the time spent are you I'm not
- 1:09:51totally clear on what you mean what the
- 1:09:53concern is what I mean is you had
- 1:09:55mentioned you know you put you put the
- 1:09:58attorney under oath so we're in a
- 1:10:00divorce trial a custody trial whatever
- 1:10:02and before closing where an attorney's
- 1:10:07fees and now if I'm understanding you
- 1:10:10correctly you want me to call
- 1:10:13Council here and put them on the stand
- 1:10:15on their own about his time records and
- 1:10:19I've just never I don't know I'm a
- 1:10:22little uncomfortable about how to
- 1:10:24do that without
- 1:10:27disrespecting the privilege between him
- 1:10:29and his wife
- 1:10:32well does that not make sense I'm sorry
- 1:10:34no I get it I mean I think there's a lot
- 1:10:36of people who don't feel comfortable
- 1:10:39cross-examining their fellow lawyer
- 1:10:42because you have an empathy that you
- 1:10:45know you wouldn't like to be questioned
- 1:10:46about uh your time record so I mean I
- 1:10:49it's not that I don't understand that
- 1:10:50but I don't I mean I I think it's just
- 1:10:54being professional about it and asking
- 1:10:58uh reasonable questions I don't know now
- 1:11:00I guess a lot of times this does tend to
- 1:11:03happen at the end of the trial and
- 1:11:05you're right if you run out of time you
- 1:11:06run out of time we've got to Kick the
- 1:11:07Can but
- 1:11:09um I don't know I from the bench anyway
- 1:11:12it's not I don't see it as a
- 1:11:14particularly a big deal for One
- 1:11:16Professional to say hey what about this
- 1:11:18what about that time this entry doesn't
- 1:11:20have anything
- 1:11:22um I'm interesting but that's the the
- 1:11:25price you pay for
- 1:11:26having to request fees is having to
- 1:11:29justify those those records
- 1:11:31um I don't know Miss Loma I don't think
- 1:11:34there's anything wrong with just asking
- 1:11:35the court to find entitlement and set
- 1:11:37the fee hearing for for another day too
- 1:11:39you can always do that if you feel like
- 1:11:41you're going to run out of time
- 1:11:47well they have to be there but I don't
- 1:11:50think you need to necessarily list them
- 1:11:53as a witness no because I think it kind
- 1:11:57of goes without saying that's the
- 1:11:58attorney that you're going to I mean in
- 1:12:00an abundance of caution okay maybe but
- 1:12:04um I don't think that it's mandatory I
- 1:12:06mean it's not like I'm going to grant
- 1:12:08their motion to exclude themselves as a
- 1:12:10witness because you didn't list them as
- 1:12:11a witness so
- 1:12:15[Laughter]
- 1:12:18but no I mean you could you certainly
- 1:12:20can always request when anytime
- 1:12:21attorney's fees by either side is an
- 1:12:23issue I think you can legitimately
- 1:12:25request production from the other side
- 1:12:26to get those those redacted uh Time
- 1:12:29Records so that you can
- 1:12:31um it's gonna be a lot harder for
- 1:12:33somebody to say you spending this time
- 1:12:36is not reasonable when they're when
- 1:12:37they're um Time Records have the very
- 1:12:40same time it's going to be very very
- 1:12:42difficult for them but it's one but but
- 1:12:44the times where things are super out of
- 1:12:46whack and somebody is spending three and
- 1:12:49four and five times more
- 1:12:51um then at some point you've got to say
- 1:12:52there's there's some there's something
- 1:12:54going on here and it's probably not fair
- 1:12:57to the guy who's not spending as much
- 1:12:59but
- 1:13:00um all right did everybody get the
- 1:13:02number on that end anybody still need
- 1:13:04the number we need it again on this end
- 1:13:06we had some folks come in a little bit
- 1:13:08late so if you could state it again
- 1:13:09please it's one six zero six zero one
- 1:13:13seven n as in Nancy
- 1:13:17um thank you all very much I don't know
- 1:13:18if we're going to fit another one of
- 1:13:19these in this fall before the holidays
- 1:13:21but we will try we appreciate it if you
- 1:13:23want feedback or want to give us
- 1:13:24feedback please please do so give us an
- 1:13:26email have a great day thanks thank you
- 1:13:30thank you all thank you
- 1:13:42um
- 1:13:44uh we we are kind of
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Attorney’s Fees in Family Law Cases by Ninth Judicial Circuit Court of Florida, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,338 words across 1,800 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.