Attacco a Bucha: il messaggio di Putin all'Occidente. Escalation in Ucraina e Iran | G. Gabellini — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:29[1] Even the cicadas have fled from
- 0:44Terni. Welcome back to Polyx Summer.
- 0:48Fortunately, in this interview, we
- 0:50won't have the background chirping
- 0:52because, for some strange reason, they
- 0:54aren't here today. Better that way. We
- 0:58will talk about the acceleration
- 1:00happening on both hot fronts, namely
- 1:03Ukraine and Iran. Uh, in Ukraine, there
- 1:09have been some special strikes by
- 1:11Russia, which just yesterday hit an
- 1:14arms fair where there were probably
- 1:17Western weapons as well. That’s what
- 1:22was leaked in the statements from
- 1:26Deepstate, a military analysis channel
- 1:29linked to the GUR, Ukrainian military
- 1:33intelligence, but also by other
- 1:36prominent figures tied to military
- 1:39circles. The war at sea continues.
- 1:45Russia has practically closed the
- 1:47corridor that Ukraine had struggled so
- 1:50hard to create with the help of
- 1:53partners—the United States first and
- 1:56foremost, Turkey, and England—at the
- 1:59Danube ports to continue trading grain.
- 2:04No ship wants to pass through there
- 2:06anymore after the strikes Russia is
- 2:09launching. And on the other side, the
- 2:14European Union is practically including
- 2:18in its 21st sanctions package the
- 2:21possibility of selling Russian grain
- 2:24and oil seized in the various
- 2:26operations that the British, French,
- 2:30and even Italians are conducting in the
- 2:33Mediterranean and also in the Atlantic.
- 2:39And finally, there is the Iranian front
- 2:42, which continues to be a very hot
- 2:46front with Trump's promise to
- 2:49accelerate the escalation, to conduct
- 2:52an even broader operation, while Iran
- 2:56promises vengeance one after another
- 2:59against those leaders who are
- 3:02conducting this operation. And we will
- 3:07discuss all these topics today with a
- 3:10welcome return of Giacomo Gabellini. Hi
- 3:13Giacomo, and welcome back to Polyx.
- 3:17Hi Clara, thanks for the invitation.
- 3:18Good morning to everyone.
- 3:21Perhaps I rambled a bit in the
- 3:23introduction, but we have many things
- 3:26to cover today. I'll hand it over to
- 3:29you right away. I’ll remind you that
- 3:31Giacomo Gabellini is a highly regarded
- 3:34geopolitical analyst and essayist; his
- 3:36latest book is*Scricchiolio*—excuse
- 3:39me, Giacomo—he collaborates with many
- 3:41magazines, including*Analisi Difesa*,
- 3:44as well as*Il Fatto Quotidiano*and*
- 3:46Crisis*, and he is the curator of a
- 3:48very popular YouTube channel, *Il
- 3:51Contesto*. Giacomo, I would start
- 3:54immediately with the situation in
- 3:56Ukraine and this war at sea, which
- 3:59until now has been a bit, um...let's
- 4:04say it hasn't received much attention,
- 4:06but now people are starting to
- 4:08understand the gravity of this conflict
- 4:10at sea. Well, I believe that yes,
- 4:15everything is being done just to shift
- 4:17focus away from the main battlefield.
- 4:22Naturally, a war is a total phenomenon;
- 4:24it involves the entirety of the two
- 4:26societies called to confront each other
- 4:28, or of the two or more societies
- 4:30called to confront each other. This was
- 4:33highlighted Urbi et Orbi by General
- 4:35Zaluzhny, the current Ukrainian
- 4:37ambassador to London and former Chief
- 4:40of Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces,
- 4:42who in an editorial for the Telegraph
- 4:44noted that Zaluzhny allegedly expressed
- 4:47to Zelensky his intention to run in the
- 4:49next elections, if they are held.
- 4:53Zaluzhny writes that, in reality, well,
- 4:55it is very, very—he says—premature,
- 4:57excessive, to speak of, uh, the fact
- 5:03that Ukraine is reversing the outcome
- 5:05of the conflict; because yes, the drone
- 5:07attacks are sophisticated, they inflict
- 5:09and impose costs on Russia, but Russia
- 5:12has a way to push back, to react
- 5:14symmetrically, equally or contrarily,
- 5:16and, in addition, it is, well, making
- 5:18advances of, well, some significance,
- 5:20especially, especially, in the regions,
- 5:22in the Donetsk region. In short, we
- 5:26know that Kostiantynivka has now fallen
- 5:28, and Lyman is on the verge. There has
- 5:32been a very heavy attack on Sloviansk,
- 5:34which is one of the last Ukrainian
- 5:36strongholds, like the belt of
- 5:37strongholds of Sloviansk, Kramatorsk,
- 5:39and Druzhkivka. These are three
- 5:44strongholds, from north to south, which
- 5:46practically constitute Ukraine's last
- 5:48highly fortified line of defense, and
- 5:51which Russia is mostly trying, in my
- 5:53opinion, to encapsulate—that is, to
- 5:55bypass and then cut off supplies.
- 5:59Russia has been doing this for some
- 6:00time now, targeting first the logistics
- 6:02network, then the electrical grid. Now
- 6:05it is literally taking shots at, uh,
- 6:07firing at will with drones. In short,
- 6:19we know that things are going this way
- 6:21on the battlefield. The Ukrainians are
- 6:24complaining about a shortage of, above
- 6:26all, of human material, I would say,
- 6:28that is, of men who can be enlisted.
- 6:32Because, well, because they have
- 6:34scraped the bottom of the barrel, and
- 6:36because in some areas, including the
- 6:38more revanchist ones—let's think of
- 6:40Lviv—there are even insurrectional
- 6:42phenomena, because the recruitment vans
- 6:45are systematically targeted by the
- 6:47crowd and often these recruiters are
- 6:49even lynched. Therefore, there is a
- 6:52declining ability for Ukraine to draw
- 6:54from, to replace losses, and this is
- 6:57the basis of numerous initiatives. For
- 7:01example, the restrictions that European
- 7:04countries hosting Ukrainian refugees
- 7:07are preparing to introduce to, well, in
- 7:10fact force the return of those who
- 7:12could be, uh, enlisted, recruited, in
- 7:15short. And this tells us that the
- 7:19blanket is becoming quite short.
- 7:22Similarly, it can be said that one
- 7:24aspect of the increasing reliance on
- 7:27drone warfare and also war at sea stems
- 7:29from the need to ease pressure on the
- 7:31front lines by attempting to strike
- 7:34infrastructure deep within Russian
- 7:36territory. These are very visible,
- 7:40highly theatrical strikes that serve,
- 7:42on one hand, to undoubtedly impose real
- 7:44costs on Russia, which for a certain
- 7:46period even had to import finished
- 7:48petroleum products—that is, it
- 7:50exported crude and imported refined
- 7:52products precisely because its refining
- 7:54capacity had been severely hit. However
- 7:58, when a refinery is hit, it doesn't
- 8:01mean the refinery is destroyed; these
- 8:03are gigantic facilities, and it means
- 8:05it has been damaged and there is a
- 8:07temporary collapse in refining capacity
- 8:10that must be corrected through various
- 8:12systems, rationing, in short,
- 8:16inconveniences of various kinds for the
- 8:18population. There is also an attempt,
- 8:20for example, to strike the tourism
- 8:21sector. Crimea, in fact, I think it did
- 8:25very well this season, and with the,
- 8:28with a bit of the White Berri
- 8:30warehouses, in short, they are clearly
- 8:33trying here too to create discontent
- 8:36among the population, with the goal of
- 8:39loosening the cohesion that is now seen
- 8:42between the Russian political
- 8:44leadership and the population, which,
- 8:47despite criticizing some choices, for
- 8:51example that of not having switched to
- 8:53stronger measures more quickly, still
- 8:56maintains a high level of popular
- 9:01support, in fact, something that is
- 9:02missing in most European countries. So
- 9:05one another chapter of this attempt to
- 9:10wear down Russia is the effort to
- 9:13strike its vessels transporting oil,
- 9:16grain, and so on, around the
- 9:18Mediterranean—acts of real piracy. To
- 9:22which, however, Russia could respond. I
- 9:24heard an interview some time ago with,
- 9:27I think it was the head of Roscosmos,
- 9:30who suggested actually escorting
- 9:32Russian oil tankers. In some cases, it
- 9:36has happened, and we saw that when
- 9:38military ships approached vessels from
- 9:40other countries that were attempting a
- 9:42somewhat aggressive approach, well,
- 9:44these boardings did not take place.
- 9:47Someone even suggested installing mines
- 9:49on these ships, therefore, in effect,
- 9:51booby-trapping them. In short, Russia
- 9:54could also adopt a series of
- 9:56countermeasures to throw a wrench in
- 9:59this attempt by the Europeans. But it
- 10:03is heading in that direction, that is,
- 10:05an attempt to identify any element of
- 10:07pressure on Russia to leverage in order
- 10:10to try to weaken it, because
- 10:12conventional methods are systematically
- 10:14failing. I see, and in this, I intend
- 10:19to trace in this situation a whole
- 10:22series of initiatives, as I just tried
- 10:25to explain regarding the war front, and
- 10:28perhaps also the latest reshuffles, the
- 10:31umpteenth ones being recorded in
- 10:34Ukraine. Why? Because we have seen that
- 10:37Zelensky, for many months now—we
- 10:39could almost say since the beginning of
- 10:40the conflict—has been forced to
- 10:41continue government reshuffles. Because
- 10:44some say, "Well, Zelensky is trying to
- 10:46remove anyone who might overshadow him.
- 10:49" There is some truth to this statement
- 10:51because we should think about the
- 10:53removal of Zaluzhny, who was
- 10:54effectively sent to hibernate in London
- 10:56. And Zaluzhny is a very important
- 11:00figure who has great credibility both
- 11:02among the population and within the
- 11:04armed forces, and kicking him out,
- 11:06replacing him with Syrskyi, was not a
- 11:09decision appreciated by many in Ukraine
- 11:11. Now Syrskyi has given way to Drapatyi
- 11:15, the new, uh, the new Chief of General
- 11:18Staff, who is of a new generation.
- 11:22Syrskyi was of the old generation.
- 11:23Syrskyi was a man who had trained in
- 11:24the Soviet era. There are images that
- 11:27immortalize him parading during certain
- 11:29marches in Moscow, with his parents in
- 11:31Russia. He is a character who is
- 11:34portrayed as an old dinosaur, one might
- 11:37say, anchored to strategic visions that
- 11:40are now obsolete. Uh, while on the
- 11:43other hand, the new Drapatyi is an
- 11:46innovator and very he is red. Ah, it
- 12:01went away for a moment, uh. A
- 12:03thirty-five-year-old who had, well,
- 12:08particularly innovative ideas, meaning
- 12:11his, uh, his vision contemplated a
- 12:13massive use of drones for deep-strike
- 12:16attacks; therefore, diverting further
- 12:19resources in favor of this option, thus
- 12:22drawing the scarce resources perhaps
- 12:24away from the battlefield and. And yet,
- 12:28it is on the battlefield that the war
- 12:30is mainly fought: diverting all
- 12:32resources to devote them to usage, that
- 12:35is, drone attacks, is something that
- 12:37has more of a political purpose than a
- 12:40military one, in short. Uh, that is, it
- 12:43is about showing that Ukraine is
- 12:45capable of striking, therefore keeping
- 12:48Western public opinion—on which
- 12:50Ukraine depends for the continuation of
- 12:53the conflict—attentive, focused on
- 12:56the objective, and guaranteeing a shred
- 12:58of, well, political support or popular
- 13:01support within Western countries for
- 13:03military and economic aid to Ukraine. I
- 13:07believe that much of what is happening
- 13:09can be explained through these
- 13:11interpretations.
- 13:15Yes. So, you have introduced many
- 13:16elements, we will also try to dissect
- 13:18them. Even the matter of Drapati, for
- 13:23those who have followed the conflict in
- 13:26Ukraine since the Maidan, will remember
- 13:30that Drapati was the officer (he is now
- 13:33a general, I don't know what rank he
- 13:37had back then) who drove the tank
- 13:40during what was the massacre in
- 13:42Mariupol on May 9, 2014. So, we also
- 13:47need to understand why such a divisive
- 13:50person was chosen, someone who goes on
- 13:52TV and calmly says that the inhabitants
- 13:54of the Donbas are subhuman, uncivilized
- 13:57, or things of that nature. In the
- 14:00meantime, I remind our audience that
- 14:02those who wish to contact the Polyx
- 14:05channel can do so at the address
- 14:07polyxedi letterainfo@aproton. But, uh,
- 14:12clearly you can contact us for any
- 14:14reason, except if you want money.
- 14:17Obviously, we cannot give you any of
- 14:19that under any circumstances. We
- 14:22continue, unfortunately, unfortunately
- 14:25we continue with our interview because,
- 14:28well, this news is from yesterday which
- 14:32, uh, in my opinion is being
- 14:34understated: the attack against Bucha,
- 14:37carried out with eight Iskanders and
- 14:40two Zircons, hit very important figures
- 14:43such as Eduard Sorsky Sirenchi, who was
- 14:46an officer of the Fifth Directorate,
- 14:50even a commander of the Fifth
- 14:53Directorate, that is, the Alfa special
- 14:56units of the SBU, the Ukrainian secret
- 15:00services, which is precisely the
- 15:03department that handled the dirty war,
- 15:06therefore the assassination of the
- 15:09so-called enemies of the nation,
- 15:12starting with those who were considered
- 15:15collaborators in the Donbas in the
- 15:18post-Maidan era, commanders like
- 15:22Zakharchenko, like Mozgovoy, like
- 15:24Motorola, Givi, and many others, but
- 15:27then they also operated on Russian
- 15:30territory, as we know, with the
- 15:33assassination of Daria Dugina, Tatarsky
- 15:36, and a thousand other operations that
- 15:39the SBU has claimed as their own. By
- 15:43the way, Sirenchi, according to reports
- 15:47, had also worked for the GUR, the
- 15:50military intelligence that had Budanov
- 15:54as its chief, who is now the head of
- 15:57Zelensky's office, but for a long time,
- 16:01until last year, he was head of the GUR
- 16:05, and he too belongs to this young
- 16:09generation of generals who have a
- 16:12different conception of war. However, I
- 16:16would dwell more on the type of
- 16:18responses Russia is giving, wouldn't
- 16:20you? Because what does it mean? What
- 16:23message is Russia sending to the West
- 16:27by striking a drone fair? Slavyansk was
- 16:31also hit, a warehouse, and this, uh,
- 16:34this attack grazed the Latvian
- 16:37consulate. Now, I don't know the
- 16:41details well, whether it was
- 16:43anti-aircraft fire, anti-aircraft
- 16:45debris, or if it is a message they want
- 16:47to send. But I am seeing, regarding the
- 16:52issue of escalation, that Russia is not
- 16:55exactly so willing to continue, let's
- 16:59say, according to a policy of openness
- 17:02to diplomacy. It seems to me that, at
- 17:05this point, they are willing to
- 17:07escalate and even challenge the West.
- 17:11Let’s remember that in the last 24 to
- 17:1448 hours, two drones, presumably
- 17:16Russian—though there has been no
- 17:19confirmation yet—were shot down in
- 17:21Romania by two Eurofighters, one of
- 17:24which was Italian. And then, of course,
- 17:29there is the whole issue of the grain
- 17:31corridor and the boardings we discussed
- 17:34. So, what message do you think Russia
- 17:38is sending to the West with these
- 17:41attacks? Well, I believe the message is
- 17:46unequivocal. I want to emphasize the
- 17:50the formalism of the Russians is
- 17:52something we underestimate, but it is a
- 17:54very important thing. Think, for
- 17:57example, about the phrase "special
- 17:58military operation," right? It has been
- 18:01mocked. According to many, it's just
- 18:04Putin's usual trick to avoid admitting
- 18:06that his country is at war. Actually,
- 18:10no. In reality, a "special military
- 18:14operation" was a term, an expression
- 18:17that designates a specific military
- 18:20engagement, a specific mobilization of
- 18:23the population and the economy. For
- 18:28example, it was also used in
- 18:29Afghanistan in 1979, when the Soviet
- 18:31Union invaded Afghanistan. It was a
- 18:34special military operation; it wasn't a
- 18:35war. Why? Because the objectives, the
- 18:40type of rules of engagement, the
- 18:43discipline—in short, a whole series
- 18:47of methods of operation—are strictly
- 18:50tied to certain specifications. The
- 18:56moment we were to transition from a
- 18:57special military operation to a war,
- 18:58things would change; we would see a
- 19:00very different Russia. I want to point
- 19:03out that until now, for example, the
- 19:04bridges over the Dnieper have not been
- 19:06hit. I mean, the bridges on the main
- 19:10supply routes through which Ukraine
- 19:11receives war material. And that was the
- 19:15first thing to do—since Russia
- 19:17effectively controls the skies—if not
- 19:19to destroy them, because that isn't so
- 19:21simple. In any case, they could have
- 19:24tried to hit them systematically.
- 19:26Instead, we see that it is the
- 19:27Ukrainians who have repeatedly tried to
- 19:29strike the Kerch Strait Bridge. So,
- 19:33this already means that the military
- 19:35operations have been carried out
- 19:37gradually, in an attempt to keep a door
- 19:39open for negotiations, because, as
- 19:43Colonel Jacques Baud always explains to
- 19:46us, Russia has a view of the conflict
- 19:48that is not exactly Clausewitzian; that
- 19:50is, rather than war being the
- 19:52continuation of politics by other means
- 19:54, it is politics that is the
- 19:55continuation of war by other means. In
- 19:58other words, war—the military
- 20:00instrument—must lead to the
- 20:01achievement of political objectives, so
- 20:03it doesn't make much sense to destroy
- 20:05for the sake of destroying, or to push
- 20:07for maximum escalation immediately. It
- 20:09makes sense to pursue a gradual
- 20:11approach because it forces the
- 20:14counterpart and multiplies the
- 20:16incentives for the counterpart to sit
- 20:18at the negotiating table with a more
- 20:21constructive attitude, one of greater
- 20:24openness to the demands of the party
- 20:26that is in. a position of strength. So,
- 20:31Ukraine was invaded in 2022 with a very
- 20:34small force, not even 200,000 troops,
- 20:37which was absolutely inadequate to
- 20:40achieve the goal many attributed to
- 20:43Russia, namely, to conquer Ukraine. The
- 20:48goal could have been to deliver a blow
- 20:50to the supposedly wavering Ukrainian
- 20:53government and install a collaborative
- 20:56government of its own. This is
- 20:59certainly possible. Or it could also
- 21:02have been an attempt to open, to force
- 21:04Ukraine to open negotiations, and if we
- 21:06look at it, this goal had been achieved
- 21:09because negotiations immediately began,
- 21:11first in Gomel in Belarus, then in
- 21:13Istanbul, which had actually produced
- 21:15remarkable results. The Turks said
- 21:18around the end of March, early April
- 21:202022, that the parties had effectively
- 21:22reached an agreement, and this version
- 21:24was confirmed by David Arakhamia, who
- 21:26is a Ukrainian parliamentarian from the
- 21:28Servant of the People party, the same
- 21:30one as Zelensky. Many have spoken about
- 21:34it; even Putin spoke about it when he
- 21:36hosted that delegation of African
- 21:39leaders at the Kremlin, where he even
- 21:41showed the actual document bearing the
- 21:44signatures of the Ukrainians. Gerhard
- 21:48Schröder, the former German Chancellor
- 21:50, provided a virtually identical
- 21:52reconstruction. Then, we know the
- 21:56events of Bucha, on which light has
- 21:59never been shed, and the trip to Kyiv
- 22:01by Boris Johnson, the British Prime
- 22:04Minister, sorry. And they effectively
- 22:08forced Zelensky to back down, and so
- 22:11war followed, and from that moment on,
- 22:13Russia, with a partial mobilization,
- 22:16began to increase the tone of its
- 22:18demands. Then the referendums, which
- 22:22were highly referential, naturally, for
- 22:24the annexation, the inclusion, the
- 22:26incorporation of additional oblasts
- 22:29compared to Crimea, are those of
- 22:31Donetsk, Lugansk, Zaporizhzhia, and
- 22:33Kherson. Note that Donetsk and Lugansk
- 22:37had asked for incorporation, just like
- 22:38Crimea, as early as 2014. Yet Russia
- 22:42had never granted them this, had never
- 22:45consented to this request, because
- 22:47under the Minsk agreements, these two
- 22:49republics were supposed to remain an
- 22:51integral part of the Ukrainian state,
- 22:54but benefit from broad autonomy modeled
- 22:56after South Tyrol. In fact, someone
- 22:59from Italy came forward as a possible
- 23:02facilitator, precisely by making
- 23:05available the experience gained on the
- 23:08basis of this autonomy of South Tyrol.
- 23:12Nothing came of it. Let’s recall:
- 23:15Poroshenko, Angela Merkel, and
- 23:17François Hollande all gave concordant,
- 23:20converging assessments and revelations
- 23:23regarding the fact that those
- 23:25agreements, the 2014-2015 Minsk
- 23:27agreements, were signed in bad faith,
- 23:29effectively just to give Ukraine time
- 23:32to rearm. And so, if we look, if we
- 23:37rewind the tape to 2014, we see there
- 23:39is a gradual escalation in the Russian
- 23:41attitude. The tenor of the demands is
- 23:45constantly increasing, as is the
- 23:47official nature of their positions.
- 23:51Think of Strelkov, a former FSB officer
- 23:54who had fought alongside the Donbas
- 23:56separatists since 2014; he is Russian
- 23:58and had harshly criticized the Kremlin
- 24:01because, in his view, it underestimated
- 24:03how much the Westerners were behind
- 24:06Ukraine, behind the Kiev government,
- 24:08and that they were using Ukraine,
- 24:10preparing its transformation into an
- 24:13anti-Russian bulwark. Strelkov had even
- 24:17faced criminal proceedings for these
- 24:18statements, in fact, because in Russia
- 24:20at that time those things could not be
- 24:22said. Then they began to leak, and we
- 24:27saw that, for example, some political
- 24:30scientists, some prominent academics
- 24:33like Lukyanov, Trenin, Karaganov,
- 24:36Avakyan—in short, they spoke out,
- 24:38expressing very critical assessments of
- 24:41the Kremlin’s management, deemed
- 24:44excessively passive and too prone to
- 24:47accommodations that were built on
- 24:49absolutely fragile foundations. Let’s
- 24:54think about the so-called spirit of
- 24:56Anchorage. The spirit of Anchorage, on
- 24:59which someone like Lukyanov has always
- 25:01expressed major reservations, and then
- 25:03it was the turn of the siloviki, that
- 25:05is, the apparatus men. Think of
- 25:07Bezrukov, who is a former SVR colonel
- 25:09who was an undercover agent in the
- 25:11United States, a character literally
- 25:13from a movie because he was the
- 25:15inspiration for the series "The
- 25:16Americans." Bezrukov at the forum—
- 25:22it’s not like he said it to Putin in
- 25:24private, he said it at the St.
- 25:26Petersburg International Economic Forum
- 25:28: that Russia, in fact, must begin to
- 25:30prepare for a 20-year confrontation, in
- 25:32fact, it is already doing so, it is at
- 25:34least a twenty-year confrontation that
- 25:36will absorb two generations of Russians
- 25:38against the West, and this entails a
- 25:39transformation of society, of the
- 25:41economy, taking inspiration from the
- 25:43model, from the Iranian example, that
- 25:45is, moving much of the critical
- 25:47infrastructure underground. So
- 25:49factories, refineries, in short,
- 25:52military centers, and now it is the
- 25:54turn of the politicians. Ushakov and
- 25:57Lavrov have expressed themselves in
- 25:59unequivocal terms regarding the
- 26:00dissolution of the spirit of Anchorage.
- 26:03Then it was spokesperson Peskov who
- 26:05said similar things, in fact, so the
- 26:07escalation on the battlefield is also
- 26:10matched by an escalation in strategic
- 26:12communication that now reaches the
- 26:14highest levels of power in Russia. So
- 26:17we are heading towards a hardening that
- 26:19has in fact already begun because, for
- 26:21example, Kyiv has been targeted with an
- 26:23intensity never recorded during the 5
- 26:25years—almost 5 years—of conflict.
- 26:28About fifty missiles were even launched
- 26:30against Kyiv in less than an hour. Just
- 26:33a week ago, something like that,
- 26:36targets that were previously generally
- 26:39spared are being hit; so yes, Russia is
- 26:42clearly raising the stakes, trying to
- 26:45hit hard even at the cost of causing
- 26:48serious problems for the civilian
- 26:51population, which it had previously
- 26:54tried to avoid. Therefore, as is
- 26:58clearly evident from the statements of
- 27:00the Russian spokespeople, there is no
- 27:03longer any room for negotiations, there
- 27:05is no longer good faith, there is no
- 27:08longer...Please. No, in this regard,
- 27:12the meeting is very recent—no, sorry,
- 27:15yesterday, eh, Thursday—the meeting
- 27:18between, um, Lavrov and Rubio. An
- 27:23unexpected meeting, by the way, which
- 27:25took place immediately after the
- 27:28meeting between Lavrov and Araqchi; a
- 27:30meeting that seemed very delicate to me
- 27:33, precisely because of the tension that
- 27:35exists above all between Lavrov and
- 27:37Rubio. But I don't believe it can
- 27:42change the course of the war in Ukraine
- 27:45in any way, or lead it towards a, let's
- 27:48say, a diplomatic path. Eh, but here, I
- 27:53ask you, what is your impression, since
- 27:55we are also talking about encouragement
- 27:58, about diplomacy, after this meeting,
- 28:00do you think there will then be the G20
- 28:03, in which Moscow will participate with
- 28:05a high-profile delegation, so it said,
- 28:08anyway are there some small spaces for
- 28:10diplomacy? Do you think the path is set
- 28:14, or can they be recovered? Also
- 28:16considering that by now even Western
- 28:19journals, I think Associated Press,
- 28:22wrote that after these strikes on
- 28:25Voronezh the population is very angry
- 28:28and, well, Zelensky—this, the press,
- 28:32the Western press has admitted—
- 28:34Zelensky is absolutely not achieving
- 28:37his goal of making the people revolt,
- 28:41making them rebel against Putin, but is
- 28:45creating a climate where if tomorrow
- 28:48Putin declares martial law, war, and
- 28:50mobilization, the people will say: "Yes
- 28:53, we must fight against the Ukrainians
- 28:56because they are no longer our brothers
- 28:59, they are an existential enemy to us."
- 29:05And the point is, I believe there is no
- 29:08longer any room for diplomacy. There is
- 29:10room for dialogue, in the sense that,
- 29:13as Rubio said, Russia and the United
- 29:15States must have a dialogue. They
- 29:18didn't have one under Biden and that
- 29:20was something extremely dangerous
- 29:22because, naturally, two countries of
- 29:24that stature, equipped with that
- 29:25nuclear arsenal, must have relations,
- 29:27must try to avoid eh misunderstandings,
- 29:31dangerous incidents. You were talking
- 29:33about Operation SpiderWeb earlier.
- 29:35Operation SpiderWeb and, even more so,
- 29:38the attack on the Armavir early-warning
- 29:40radars are episodes that were
- 29:42unthinkable during the Cold War because
- 29:45they are extremely dangerous. If you go
- 29:49to undermine, to strike a leg, to
- 29:51hobble one leg of the Russian nuclear
- 29:52triad, if you try to make the Russians
- 29:54blind, unable to see potential incoming
- 29:56missile attacks, you are playing with
- 29:58fire. These things must not happen, in
- 30:02short. So it is good that the two sides
- 30:05maintain a dialogue, but a dialogue
- 30:08limited to this issue. As for the rest,
- 30:12I don't believe they can talk to each
- 30:14other because, well, the Russians have
- 30:17already been screwed several times by
- 30:19...well, if we go back to the Soviet
- 30:22Union, by Gorbachev, who feels, who
- 30:25believes the promises of James Baker
- 30:27regarding NATO expansion in 1990. And
- 30:32then, let's remember the Primakov
- 30:34episode in '99, where Primakov was the
- 30:37Russian prime minister, he gets a
- 30:39guarantee from Clinton that the United
- 30:41States would not attack Serbia, and he
- 30:43learns of the start of the attacks
- 30:45while his plane was in mid-air and he
- 30:47has to turn, he has to turn right back.
- 30:52Then with the color revolutions, 2003
- 30:55Georgia, 2004 Ukraine, then there were
- 30:58various attempts in Central Asia in an
- 31:02attempt to organize and set up
- 31:04non-governmental organizations in the
- 31:07Russian space and in the Russian sphere
- 31:10of hegemony. Eh, in short, the
- 31:16sanctions, the support for Euromaidan,
- 31:19the Minsk 1 and Minsk 2 agreements, the
- 31:22proposal that had been put forward by
- 31:24Putin to the NATO Secretary General and
- 31:27to Biden in December 2021, and it gets
- 31:30rejected, the agreement that had been
- 31:33signed, as we were saying, in Istanbul
- 31:36between Zelensky and Putin. Everything
- 31:41fell through. Why should the Russians
- 31:44now have believed that the Americans
- 31:47were serious? They were trying to buy
- 31:50time because, in fact, the United
- 31:52States was trying to recycle itself as
- 31:54a mediator, a mediator from a position
- 31:57of belligerence. A very interesting
- 31:59thing, because this ridiculous pretense
- 32:01too: "Oh, the United States doesn't
- 32:03support Ukraine, the United States gets
- 32:05paid to support Ukraine," but if they
- 32:07wanted to, they could very well pull
- 32:10out. And by no longer supplying weapons
- 32:12and, above all, they could cease the
- 32:15sharing of files, of intelligence
- 32:17targeting, because to this day Starlink
- 32:20is the backbone of Ukrainian
- 32:22communications. Starlink is run by Elon
- 32:24Musk. Elon Musk has been put in charge
- 32:27of a department of the United States
- 32:29government, the one for government
- 32:30efficiency. So? Palantir, we saw Alex
- 32:34Karp in Kyiv a month ago boasting, in
- 32:36the presence of Zelensky, about the
- 32:38fact that Palantir has been on
- 32:40Ukraine's side since the beginning of
- 32:42the war. So, in short, the involvement
- 32:45of the United States, like other
- 32:47countries, is there and it is very
- 32:48heavy. So, in all of this, what do you
- 32:50want to negotiate? You can simply
- 32:53achieve your objectives on the
- 32:55battlefield. Ukraine, battlefield for
- 33:00now. Yes. And Lavrov said this, he said
- 33:04: "You have no idea what Russia could
- 33:07do if it were to move from a special
- 33:09military operation to a war." The Czech
- 33:14president Pavel, who is a person to
- 33:16keep an eye on because he has a
- 33:18background in the intelligence of
- 33:20Czechoslovakia when it was
- 33:22Czechoslovakia, therefore in the Warsaw
- 33:25Pact, therefore he knows well how
- 33:27Russian mechanisms work, said that
- 33:29Ukraine has a few months of time, two
- 33:31months in fact, to enter into serious
- 33:34negotiations with Moscow. Because after
- 33:37September 20th, when the elections for
- 33:39the renewal of the Duma will take place
- 33:41, and they will enter, truly possibly
- 33:43the veterans, some veterans who fought
- 33:45in Ukraine will enter as
- 33:47parliamentarians. At that point, Putin
- 33:49could order a general mobilization. I
- 33:52don't know if this is a forecast, a
- 33:56hypothesis, or intelligence information
- 33:59, but it is significant that, in short,
- 34:03a top representative of a country that
- 34:07had even set itself that intended, in
- 34:12short, a group that was trying to
- 34:14scrape together as much artillery
- 34:15ammunition as possible for Ukraine,
- 34:17expresses himself in this way. It means
- 34:20that the tension is rising and many
- 34:23fear, in short, that one could truly
- 34:26lose control of the situation. Yes,
- 34:34sorry. But this is a...I thought you
- 34:36were continuing. This, however, let's
- 34:39say, is information usable by
- 34:41intelligence on both sides, or in the
- 34:44sense that Russian services could have
- 34:47spread this information to put pressure
- 34:51on the counterpart; while on the other
- 34:54side the Ukrainians could say: "The
- 34:56Russians are invading us, they want to
- 35:01increase their front or they constitute
- 35:04a danger even for the European Union,
- 35:07for NATO, and therefore give us more
- 35:10weapons, give us more, um, more money"
- 35:13and so on. In short, I would take this
- 35:17with a grain of salt, but effectively,
- 35:20in my opinion, a mobilization will take
- 35:23place if Russia declares a state of war
- 35:26.
- 35:29That is inevitable, right?
- 35:30Yes. That is the point exactly.
- 35:33The point is this, it's not so much the
- 35:35mobilization, but will Russia continue
- 35:38the special military operation or
- 35:41perhaps I didn't explain myself, Clara.
- 35:43I believe that Pavel meant something
- 35:45else,
- 35:46I mean, look, this whole "special
- 35:47military operation" thing is not a
- 35:49fiction, it’s not just splitting
- 35:50hairs.
- 35:52It’s not that Putin is simply trying
- 35:54to use a label to avoid admitting that
- 35:56the country is at war. No, it's
- 35:59something else. If Russia goes to war,
- 36:01it will start doing things very
- 36:02differently than what it is doing now.
- 36:05You have to be prepared for all this,
- 36:06because as long as they are trying to
- 36:08use Ukraine and Ukrainians are dying,
- 36:09that's one thing. If the Russians were
- 36:13to start, if they were to determine
- 36:15that some impassable red lines have
- 36:17truly been crossed, then there is no
- 36:19turning back. I believe this was the
- 36:23meaning, because even saying it
- 36:26publicly in that manner, and saying it
- 36:29then, yes, the Czech Republic was a
- 36:32country that organized that mechanism
- 36:35of, well, rounding up artillery shells
- 36:38for Ukraine, but then they backed out.
- 36:43So I don't know what is moving, but in
- 36:46my opinion, it is reasonable to assume
- 36:49that most Europeans do not really have
- 36:52an awareness of what could happen. This
- 36:57, in my opinion, is something that some
- 36:58are starting to fear, for example, the
- 37:00Poles,
- 37:03who instead have adopted a much, much
- 37:06more low-profile approach in recent
- 37:09times compared to the past years.
- 37:13Yes, it's true, it's true. Moreover,
- 37:16what we are saying can also be
- 37:19supported by the statements made by the
- 37:23Kremlin, because a few weeks ago Peskov
- 37:26said quite clearly: the military
- 37:29operation against Ukraine is over, not
- 37:32against Ukraine, but to free the
- 37:35Ukrainian people from the Kiev regime.
- 37:40Now we are fighting a war with—or
- 37:42rather, NATO is fighting a war against
- 37:45us. So there is that process of
- 37:49transition from the special military
- 37:52operation to war that has already begun
- 37:55because Peskov is the Kremlin spokesman
- 37:57, so a series of statements is
- 38:00beginning that will then culminate with
- 38:03Putin if we continue, if the war
- 38:05continues in this way, and we are in
- 38:08full escalation. But Rubio also said
- 38:12this a few days ago; he said there is
- 38:15an escalation to force Russia to sit at
- 38:18the negotiating table, because
- 38:20evidently Rubio and the Neocons are
- 38:23convinced that by acting in this way
- 38:26they will bring Russia to the
- 38:28negotiating table. It must be said in
- 38:31Rubio's favor that they are in the
- 38:33United States, after all. The
- 38:37battlefield of a war between Russia and
- 38:39NATO will be Europe; that’s how it
- 38:41was during the Cold War, and that’s
- 38:43how it will continue to be. Even if
- 38:46they are already saying in Russia, "
- 38:49Don't think that the United States
- 38:51won't be hit." But, in short, it is an
- 38:54objective fact that there are at least
- 38:56two seas between Russia and the United
- 38:58States. I would like to stay on the
- 39:01theme of escalation and acceleration to
- 39:03conclude our interview on another front
- 39:06: the Middle East. By the way,
- 39:10Ansarallah has just declared that it
- 39:13struck an Aramco facility in Saudi
- 39:16Arabia; so, this sector has also been
- 39:19reactivated, the moment it blocks the
- 39:22Bab al-Mandab Strait, it doesn't need
- 39:26to block it physically, but just strike
- 39:29a few ships to the point of
- 39:35discouraging—which, by the way, has
- 39:37already happened—insurers or
- 39:39companies, like Maersk, from passing
- 39:41through there, effectively closing the
- 39:43passage. And then there is clearly the
- 39:49situation in Iran, which is completely
- 39:53off the tracks of any possible peaceful
- 39:56solution, despite Pakistan and other
- 40:00states that acted as mediators begging
- 40:03both Iran and the United States to
- 40:07accept a 10-day ceasefire. And it is
- 40:12news from a few hours ago that Trump
- 40:14had actually made a proposal to Iran,
- 40:17which it rejected, so we are back to
- 40:20the usual, moreover it has been 15 days
- 40:23now since the attacks resumed and once
- 40:25again there is no end in sight,
- 40:30but actually there is something—for
- 40:32the first night, there were no U.S.
- 40:35attacks. Well, because from the very
- 40:39beginning of the resumption of these
- 40:42U.S. offensives, I have said multiple
- 40:45times that the war cannot return to its
- 40:48previous pace, for two fundamental
- 40:50reasons. The United States does not
- 40:52have the ammunition; I’m not just
- 40:54saying this. There are dozens of
- 40:56convergent studies, even from the
- 40:59Center for Strategic and International
- 41:01Studies, and the Rand Corporation has
- 41:04talked about it; the United States has
- 41:07used high-value missiles intensively,
- 41:10for example, interceptors for Patriot
- 41:12systems, JASSM attack missiles, and
- 41:15Tomahawks. Denting stockpiles beyond a
- 41:21certain limit means literally
- 41:23cannibalizing the depots of other
- 41:25commands: the Pacific one, the European
- 41:28one. I mean, funneling everything to
- 41:31CENTCOM, but then for what exactly? I
- 41:35mean, this is also the classic
- 41:36escalation trap that we saw in Vietnam,
- 41:39and how did that go? You fool yourself
- 41:41into thinking that to force—McNamara
- 41:44was like that. You fool yourself that
- 41:47to force the other side to adopt more
- 41:49moderate views, you increase the
- 41:50intensity of the attacks, the rhythm,
- 41:52and the quality of the targets. I mean,
- 41:56on Fox News, for example, two strapping
- 41:58guys were talking calmly with a map
- 42:01clearly on display. They were talking
- 42:04about, you know, "we could hit the
- 42:06Bushehr plant, we could hit the energy
- 42:08infrastructure at South Pars":
- 42:10basically full-blown terrorist attacks,
- 42:13one on a nuclear power plant, one on a
- 42:15facility, one of the largest gas
- 42:17processing plants in the world. Yes,
- 42:21you can hit them, but then what does
- 42:24Iran do? The point is this: Iran has
- 42:27clearly demonstrated the intention and
- 42:30willingness to target structures
- 42:32symmetrically, so you hit our plant, we
- 42:35hit the plants in Bahrain, Saudi Arabia
- 42:37, Kuwait, the Emirates, Qatar, and so
- 42:40on. I mean, Iran has the ability to
- 42:44zero out the energy production of the
- 42:47entire Western Asia for a decade at the
- 42:49very least. So something like that
- 42:53isn't exactly convenient for anyone.
- 42:56Then many say, "Ah, Trump keeps saying,
- 42:58'Well, we don't need the Strait of
- 43:00Hormuz, we could easily do without it.'
- 43:03" Yes, from a purely supply-side
- 43:05perspective, that may be true, but not
- 43:08regarding inflation. And I also want to
- 43:11point out that most of the facilities
- 43:14in that part of the world, let's look
- 43:16at who their shareholders are, and we
- 43:19find ExxonMobil, we find Chevron, we
- 43:21find Gulf, we find various US companies
- 43:24, so what do we do? We destroy the
- 43:27plants, and then there are the data
- 43:28centers. Do we really want to accept
- 43:32that the data centers of Amazon and
- 43:34others become systematic targets for
- 43:37Iranian missiles at a time when the
- 43:39bubble in the United States—the
- 43:41world's largest speculative bubble,
- 43:43centered specifically on artificial
- 43:45intelligence, the biggest bubble of all
- 43:47time—is starting to creak, because
- 43:50points of vulnerability are emerging,
- 43:52like cross-investments between these
- 43:54companies and excessively high debt
- 43:56levels in a particularly weak sector,
- 44:00which is the private credit market? In
- 44:03short, there are many points of
- 44:05difficulty, or vulnerability, for the
- 44:08United States, and the fact that Trump
- 44:11is losing control seems to emerge from
- 44:14some of his statements. "Ah, we will
- 44:18use the confiscated Iranian frozen
- 44:20funds as compensation for the damages
- 44:22suffered." I mean, even the Europeans
- 44:25didn't commit such idiocy with Russian
- 44:27funds; they didn't go that far. If the
- 44:30United States were to take a step like
- 44:32that, their credibility would literally
- 44:35drop to zero. Literally. Washington
- 44:39D.C. pointed this out immediately, and
- 44:41in fact, Trump, as always, has not
- 44:43followed through on this intention for
- 44:45now. And then, we—that is, we the
- 44:48United States—will charge a toll for
- 44:51the Strait of Hormuz, of which we will
- 44:53take control. How will you take control
- 44:55of the Strait of Hormuz with ground
- 44:57operations? Ah, there are 50,000 U.S.
- 45:01troops in the region, yes. Of which
- 45:038,000 are combat troops. You can plant
- 45:07a flag on a small island, but then you
- 45:09have to hold that island, and above all
- 45:12, you have to accept thousands of
- 45:14casualties in a war thousands of miles
- 45:17from home that is dragging on much
- 45:19longer than expected, after you, during
- 45:22your campaign, had announced that you
- 45:25would be the president who would end
- 45:27the endless wars—the involvement of
- 45:30the United States in endless wars on
- 45:32behalf of other countries, to be
- 45:34precise. Look at that, in short, and
- 45:37Trump has even announced his intention
- 45:39to run again, although he cannot, but
- 45:41by now we are, uh, we are somewhat at
- 45:44this point. So it seems to me that the
- 45:48escalation the United States is
- 45:50pursuing is only an escalation up to a
- 45:52certain point because then they stop
- 45:54and try to reopen diplomatic channels,
- 45:57but every step corresponds to further
- 45:59damage to their credibility. Their
- 46:02credibility is dropping below zero.
- 46:05Their reserves of precision missiles—
- 46:07or rather, not precision missiles, but
- 46:09critical ammunition—are dwindling.
- 46:13Strategic reserves are thinning out.
- 46:16The United States 'strategic oil
- 46:18reserves have plummeted to their lowest
- 46:20levels since 1983, that is, since they
- 46:22began being recorded, at 316 million
- 46:24barrels. That means that dipping into
- 46:28them further means pushing them below
- 46:30operational levels, which becomes
- 46:31dangerous, very dangerous. So that
- 46:34buffer which allowed prices in some
- 46:36parts of the world to remain all in all
- 46:39under control—in short, not to
- 46:41reflect the gravity of the situation—
- 46:44is now failing. And so, you could find
- 46:47yourselves in the United States with
- 46:49the gallon returning, or even reaching,
- 46:51not just $ 4-5, but $ 7 per gallon, two
- 46:52months before the elections. Iran knows
- 46:57this well, and Iran is solidly united,
- 47:00in terms of public opinion and
- 47:03government structure (even if there are
- 47:06some divergences), ready to support
- 47:09this effort, which is existential, even
- 47:12by leaning on its allies. The Houthis
- 47:15are capable of doing great harm to the
- 47:17world economy and to Saudi Arabia, and
- 47:18they are already doing so; and, in my
- 47:20opinion, we are only at the beginning,
- 47:22because the Houthis could truly do very
- 47:24, very great harm to Saudi Arabia. Yes,
- 47:29I thank you, Giacomo, for this. We are
- 47:33now at 45 minutes. We have spent time
- 47:36delving into the general escalation
- 47:39both in Ukraine and in Iran, even if,
- 47:42as you rightly pointed out, Trump's
- 47:45escalation is somewhat an escalation
- 47:48for the Italians only up to a point. So
- 47:53let's hope we can return to the
- 47:56diplomatic tables, even if it is clear
- 48:00that the United States has completely
- 48:03lost its credibility as a negotiating
- 48:07party, both in Russia and especially in
- 48:10Iran. In short, after this latest
- 48:15ceasefire violation, I don't think
- 48:17there are any conditions at all to be
- 48:20able to return to dialogue with this
- 48:23side, at least with, uh, the envoys
- 48:25that Trump sends. Since, well, he sent
- 48:29Vance, who was the most viable one, by
- 48:32the way; so I don't know who he could,
- 48:34or which saint he could pray to in a
- 48:36subsequent round. So I thank Giacomo
- 48:40for being here with us, I thank the
- 48:42Volico audience, I mean, sorry, I've
- 48:44lost my voice. I thank the audience,
- 48:47like the cicadas outside the window,
- 48:49then I end up losing my voice too. I
- 48:51thank the Polyx audience who follows us
- 48:54. Support us with a like by subscribing
- 48:57to the channel and, if you want to
- 49:00contribute more, with a donation to our
- 49:03PayPal. But also support Giacomo,
- 49:06subscribe to his channel—though I
- 49:08know you already have—and follow his
- 49:10newsletter. Have a good day everyone.
- 49:13Thank you Giacomo, and until next time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Attacco a Bucha: il messaggio di Putin all'Occidente. Escalation in Ucraina e Iran | G. Gabellini by Clara Statello, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,594 words across 1,057 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.