Athens vs Sparta: Deep Thinkers vs Military Might? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03hi and welcome to ancient history
- 0:05encyclopedia my name is Kelly and today
- 0:08I'm going to discuss some of the
- 0:09similarities and differences between the
- 0:11Greek city-states Athens and Sparta
- 0:14first let's look at each city-states
- 0:17form of government in the 5th to 4th
- 0:21century BCE democracy was the system of
- 0:24government in Athens democracy meant
- 0:27that all male citizens had equal rights
- 0:29in politics could participate in public
- 0:31affairs and had freedom of speech the
- 0:34assembly or ecclesia was the main body
- 0:37of democracy and would meet at least
- 0:39once a month all Athenian males over the
- 0:42age of 18 would speak up during their
- 0:44assemblies and would vote on all
- 0:46decisions that leaves out women slaves
- 0:49and foreigners who lived in Athens they
- 0:52could not attend the assemblies and did
- 0:54not have a say in politics the Spartan
- 0:57government was relatively unusual with
- 0:59two kings each from different families
- 1:01these kings were very powerful as they
- 1:05led the army and were priests of Zeus
- 1:07they also held seats on the council of
- 1:10elders the highest court in Sparta they
- 1:13would have proposed issues that the
- 1:15meeting of the citizens or ecclesia
- 1:17would have voted on as you may have
- 1:19realized Sparta uses the same word
- 1:21ecclesia but with the more restricted
- 1:24use as only the points submitted by the
- 1:26Council of Elders could be discussed
- 1:28nothing else like urges in the sixth
- 1:31century BCE created the social system in
- 1:34which male citizens were to focus on
- 1:36military training and politics while the
- 1:38city's helots or serfs were denied a
- 1:41political voice the helots who grew the
- 1:43crops and did the other lower-class jobs
- 1:46in the city were denied access to land
- 1:48were not allowed to leave the land that
- 1:50they were assigned to work and could not
- 1:52become full citizens to be a Spartan was
- 1:56to be strong courageous and disciplined
- 1:59boys were trained and educated to be
- 2:01soldiers from as young as seven years
- 2:03old when a boy turned seven he would
- 2:06leave his home and join the army with
- 2:08other boys the same age this
- 2:10militaristic upbringing was known as the
- 2:12ago gay and saw the boys
- 2:13Bing running swimming and increasing
- 2:16their strength they weren't given much
- 2:17food and we're encouraged to steal but
- 2:20not get caught this rigorous military
- 2:22and athletic training got much harder
- 2:24once they turn 20 the result of such
- 2:27demanding training was a professional
- 2:29army known as a hoplite army and they
- 2:32were feared throughout Greece because
- 2:34they were tough elite soldiers famous
- 2:36for their skill in war in contrast to
- 2:41Sparta Athens put an emphasis on the
- 2:43education of the boys as rhetorician x'
- 2:45to be persuasive public speakers and
- 2:47deep thinkers along with physical
- 2:50training less strict than Sparta
- 2:52Athenian boys were taught to read and
- 2:54write as well as to be proficient in the
- 2:56arts such as music they also studied
- 2:59literature such as the works of Hesiod
- 3:00and Homer and other poetry between 18
- 3:04and 20 years old boys had to perform in
- 3:06military and civil service and their
- 3:08education would continue with politics
- 3:10and rhetoric which was the ability to
- 3:13speak persuasively boys from richer
- 3:15families would get the opportunity to
- 3:17study finer topics such as astronomy and
- 3:19philosophy the Athenian army was made up
- 3:23of the male citizens of Athens and their
- 3:25training started once they turned 18 and
- 3:27was conducted in the gymnasium the
- 3:29Athenian army would come to include
- 3:32resident foreigners slaves mercenaries
- 3:35and neighbouring allies unlike most
- 3:39other Greek city-states girls in Sparta
- 3:41were educated and were permitted to
- 3:43exercise and compete in athletic events
- 3:45a big difference to Athenian girls who
- 3:48were only taught domestic skills such as
- 3:50weaving and caring for the home Spartan
- 3:54women were also allowed to own land a
- 3:56custom not seen in any other city-state
- 3:58in Greece Athenian girls were only
- 4:00taught what was needed to raise a family
- 4:02and care for the household and they
- 4:04weren't permitted to leave their house
- 4:06unless it was for a special occasion
- 4:08they couldn't exercise or have a job
- 4:10they weren't classified as Athenian
- 4:12citizens and they weren't allowed to own
- 4:15property or land in all definitions they
- 4:18were the property of their father or
- 4:20male Guardian and then of their husbands
- 4:22after marriage as you can see the Greek
- 4:27city-states at
- 4:27Athens and Sparta were very different in
- 4:30most factors although they spoke the
- 4:32same language and held men's rights
- 4:34higher than women's Sparta gave women
- 4:36more freedom and access to education
- 4:39although they both had an assembly in
- 4:41their government Athens was a democracy
- 4:44whereas Sparta was a monarchy ruled by
- 4:46kings Sparta's physical and military
- 4:49training was of higher importance and
- 4:51other education whereas Athens who still
- 4:54had a strong military considered the
- 4:56education of a wide range of topics more
- 4:58highly Athens contributed to art
- 5:01architecture literature philosophy
- 5:03political science and medicine
- 5:05whereas Sparta contributed to the
- 5:07concept of the efficient war machine and
- 5:09state unity Athens focused on individual
- 5:13achievement and accomplishment but
- 5:15Sparta concentrated on the communal good
- 5:17Athens was militarily supreme at the sea
- 5:20with their Navy and Sparta was stronger
- 5:23on land with their army so which Greek
- 5:26city-state would you prefer to live in
- 5:28and why
- 5:34this video is brought to you by ancient
- 5:36history encyclopedia for more great
- 5:38articles and interactive content head to
- 5:40our website via the link below
- 5:42ancient history encyclopedia is a
- 5:44not-for-profit organization so if you'd
- 5:46like to support our work please hit the
- 5:48support button on the screen or via the
- 5:50link below thank you so much for
- 5:52watching and we'll see you soon
- 5:54[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Athens vs Sparta: Deep Thinkers vs Military Might? by World History Encyclopedia, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 942 words across 146 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.