Atheist Crashes Out After Being Caught Using ChatGPT (JAW vs ‘ZipZop’) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:0020 years old.
- 0:02>> Sure. When were you reborn?
- 0:05>> 2006.
- 0:07>> What's the square root of zero?
- 0:10>> The square root of zero? Uh zero, right?
- 0:13>> Yeah.
- 0:14Is the Earth flat?
- 0:16>> No.
- 0:18>> How old is the Earth?
- 0:20>> Uh I I don't know. I'm not a geologist.
- 0:23I I'm not too well studied on that.
- 0:26>> We're giving answers in the chat will be
- 0:27muted, by the way, guys.
- 0:31What Whether they're right or wrong, it
- 0:32doesn't matter.
- 0:34So, okay. Um so, you don't know.
- 0:37>> Uh yeah, no. I I I haven't studied
- 0:40geology in depth.
- 0:43>> Okay.
- 0:44You can just say I don't know, right?
- 0:46>> Yeah. That's That's what I said.
- 0:48>> Okay, great. So, what's up?
- 0:53>> Uh well, you you said you said God isn't
- 0:55real, get over it. I think God is real.
- 0:57I'd like to discuss that with you.
- 0:59>> Okay, let's see the evidence. Go ahead.
- 1:01>> Um well, I I'm a I'm a
- 1:03>> Things Real things Real things have
- 1:04evidence, so
- 1:05>> Yep.
- 1:06>> I'd appreciate the evidence. Go ahead.
- 1:08>> Yeah, I agree. So, I I'm a Thomist. I
- 1:10think that that logical deduction is the
- 1:12the greatest evidence that we have.
- 1:15Um would you consider yourself a logical
- 1:17thinker?
- 1:19>> Sure.
- 1:20>> Okay. So, um
- 1:23now that we can agree that we're both
- 1:24logical thinkers, or at least that you
- 1:26are, you should be able to adhere to
- 1:28>> You said something You said something
- 1:30else that I find very fascinating. And
- 1:32you said logical deductions are
- 1:33evidence.
- 1:35>> Uh yeah, no. I would say
- 1:37when we're talking about the evidence of
- 1:39something that isn't necessarily
- 1:42empirically testable in that way, I
- 1:44think yeah, like logical deductions are
- 1:46the best way to have convincible
- 1:48evidence, or um just to convince someone
- 1:50in general that something is
- 1:52>> But But like treating a logical
- 1:54deduction as actual evidence is like
- 1:56taking a picture of a unicorn, drawing a
- 1:59very detailed saddle on it with a
- 2:01sharpie and trying to register it at the
- 2:03DMV.
- 2:05>> No.
- 2:06>> Yeah, yeah, yeah. Logic is just a
- 2:08recipe. Evidence is the cake, right? You
- 2:11can't satisfy reality's hunger by
- 2:15handing it a beautifully reasoned piece
- 2:17of paper that says, "Therefore,
- 2:19carbohydrate content must logically
- 2:21equal 100%." Right? If If sound logic
- 2:24counted as empirical proof, every
- 2:27flawless math proof would magically
- 2:29manifest physical objects into
- 2:30existence. Like, detectives could solve
- 2:33murder mysteries simply by sitting on a
- 2:35couch, stroking their chins, and
- 2:37declaring the butter guilty because it
- 2:39just makes sense.
- 2:41>> No. You're You're misunderstanding.
- 2:43>> Until your pristine chain of syllogisms
- 2:46can be slapped onto a lab table and
- 2:48poked with a stick, it's not evidence.
- 2:51It's just eyebrow fan fiction about how
- 2:53the universe ought to work.
- 2:55>> Yeah. So, let let me let me help you
- 2:57understand what I mean when I say that
- 2:59the logical deduction
- 3:00>> what you
- 3:01>> Well, you're not letting me speak
- 3:02though. So so, I don't think you do. Cuz
- 3:04I'm telling you you're misunderstanding.
- 3:05>> Oh, yeah. No, I understand what you
- 3:07mean. But, go ahead, please.
- 3:08[clears throat]
- 3:08>> Yeah. So, for example, if we have the
- 3:11the basic syllogism of if it rains, then
- 3:15it is wet.
- 3:16Premise two, it is raining. Conclusion,
- 3:20it is wet.
- 3:21Then, we can say that if all of the
- 3:24premises are true, the conclusion is
- 3:27also going to be true because what I
- 3:28presented is a valid syllogism. It's a
- 3:32valid argument. And so, when I say that
- 3:34I can present a valid argument for the
- 3:37existence of God, it's going to be
- 3:39contingent upon you accepting the three
- 3:41premises that I'm about to explain.
- 3:48>> So, you're [snorts] saying that it's
- 3:50it's wet, therefore it's raining equals
- 3:52God?
- 3:53>> No, it's raining.
- 3:55If it rains, then it's wet. It is
- 3:56raining. This is modus ponens. Like, if
- 3:58P then Q, P therefore Q.
- 4:00>> Oh, modus ponens equals God, huh?
- 4:03>> No, I'm I'm explaining how logic works.
- 4:05I think that's that's a pretty um
- 4:07bad interpretation of what I just said.
- 4:09Was that purposeful or was that
- 4:10accidental?
- 4:14>> Oh, no, it was very purposeful.
- 4:15>> Okay, yeah. Well, don't don't don't
- 4:17present straw men cuz we're we're trying
- 4:18to have a conversation.
- 4:21Right?
- 4:24That won't be helpful.
- 4:25>> get that, but
- 4:26you're you're just like
- 4:28this is like affirming the consequent,
- 4:30right? Whereas it's known in the wild,
- 4:32the my driveway is wet, therefore God
- 4:34opened the sky pumps maneuver.
- 4:36>> No, that's
- 4:37>> the it's the absolute crown jewel of
- 4:40backwards logic. The premise of like if
- 4:43it rains, the ground gets wet is rock
- 4:45solid, but flipping it around to claim
- 4:48like the ground is wet, therefore it
- 4:50rained completely
- 4:51>> Yeah,
- 4:52that wasn't my I never said that. That
- 4:53was never my argument.
- 4:54>> fire hydrants, overzealous garden hoses,
- 4:58a neighbor washing their car, or an
- 5:00unexceptionally like an exceptionally
- 5:02large dog with poor bladder control.
- 5:04>> Yeah,
- 5:04>> It's the logical equivalent of seeing a
- 5:06person eating a cracker, knowing the
- 5:08astronauts eat crackers, and instantly
- 5:10calling NASA to report a rogue spaceman
- 5:13in the back in the break room.
- 5:15>> Yeah, no, I I don't know if you
- 5:16understand what affirming the consequent
- 5:18is because I didn't do that at all. I
- 5:20didn't say that. I was literally just
- 5:22explaining modus ponens to you and how
- 5:24logical deductions are supposed to be
- 5:25convincible evidence to someone. And in
- 5:27fact, it's it's the highest form of
- 5:30convincibleness that one can achieve
- 5:32because it is purely logical and it will
- 5:34always follow. If you if I if you need
- 5:36me to show you like a truth table for
- 5:37what I'm showing you, I can do that, but
- 5:40>> modus ponens as like a [ __ ] shiny get
- 5:42out of jail free card.
- 5:43>> No, I'm using modus ponens to explain
- 5:45how logic works.
- 5:49So now I'm going to tell you why I
- 5:50believe that God exists if that's okay.
- 5:52>> Yeah, okay, so so like that's fine and
- 5:54dandy that like
- 5:56the ground is wet.
- 6:00>> Yep.
- 6:01>> You you use the ground is wet, therefore
- 6:03it rained
- 6:05To prove it's raining.
- 6:06>> No, [laughter] I I First of all, the
- 6:09proof was to show that it's wet, not to
- 6:11show that it's raining.
- 6:14So, it seems like you you misunderstood
- 6:16what modus ponens is used for, but
- 6:18that's okay. I'm not here to trap you. I
- 6:20just haven't even been able to give my
- 6:21argument for why I believe that God
- 6:23exists.
- 6:27So, I'd like to do that if that's okay.
- 6:34>> Sure, I guess.
- 6:36>> Yeah, okay.
- 6:37Um there's three premises and one
- 6:40conclusion.
- 6:41Um I I'd like to to show all of them to
- 6:44you first, and then you can tell me
- 6:46which ones you disagree with after.
- 6:48Um premise one, whatever exists is
- 6:52either self-existent
- 6:55or has existence from another.
- 6:59Premise two,
- 7:00>> Hey, let me write Let me Let me write
- 7:01this one down.
- 7:02So, you said
- 7:04What was it What was it again? Do you
- 7:05remember?
- 7:05>> Whatever exists is either self-existent
- 7:10or has existence from another.
- 7:19>> Okay.
- 7:20>> Okay. Premise two, derivative existence
- 7:24alone is not sufficient to establish
- 7:27existence in general.
- 7:37>> Okay.
- 7:37>> Premise three, things exist.
- 7:43>> Okay.
- 7:43>> Conclusion, therefore something
- 7:45self-existent exists, and this is what
- 7:48we would call God.
- 7:52>> Why can't it be the universe?
- 7:54>> Why can't something self-existent be the
- 7:56universe?
- 7:58>> Mhm.
- 7:58>> Because the universe's essence is not
- 8:00identical with its existence.
- 8:04>> The The universe's essence isn't
- 8:07identical with its existence?
- 8:08>> Yeah, and therefore it doesn't exist by
- 8:11virtue of what it is. It doesn't exist
- 8:13by nature because its essence is truly
- 8:15distinct from its existence. Whereas in
- 8:18a necessary being, essence would have to
- 8:20be identical with existence because
- 8:22we're saying that it exists necessarily
- 8:25because of what it is, not from anything
- 8:28else. But the universe's essence is
- 8:30truly distinct from its existence
- 8:32because it's composed of parts.
- 8:36>> So.
- 8:44So.
- 8:46>> So therefore it it can't be the
- 8:48necessary being that we're referring to.
- 8:51>> Why not?
- 8:52>> I just explained because its essence is
- 8:54not identical with its existence.
- 9:01>> What?
- 9:02What the [ __ ] is that even supposed to
- 9:03mean?
- 9:04>> Yeah,
- 9:04that
- 9:06If you If you have a question, I have no
- 9:07problem explaining it, but you can ask
- 9:08it in a nicer way than that. Like we're
- 9:10I'm just here to have a conversation.
- 9:11I'm not
- 9:11>> Sir, if you don't like my vernacular,
- 9:13like I'm not trying to be mean to you.
- 9:14This is just my vernacular. This is the
- 9:16way I speak. If you don't like it, you
- 9:17can [ __ ] off.
- 9:18>> Okay, that's fine.
- 9:19Um so I have in my hand like a lighter
- 9:21right now.
- 9:23We would say that
- 9:24you can understand what a lighter is.
- 9:26You can describe what a lighter is. You
- 9:28could describe it by its capacity to
- 9:30have a flame come out of it, by its
- 9:32holdableness, by um the fact that it's
- 9:35made out of plastic and and metal and
- 9:37all this stuff. This is going to be the
- 9:39essence of the lighter. Now, someone
- 9:41could be mistaken
- 9:43and say, "Well, I actually don't think
- 9:46lighters exist. I've never seen one, and
- 9:48I don't think lighters exist." That
- 9:50person would still understand the
- 9:52essence of what a lighter is, but they
- 9:55would not understand the actual
- 9:57existence of lighters. And that proves
- 10:00that essence is truly distinct from
- 10:02existence in that thing. And anything
- 10:04whose
- 10:05>> Let me get this.
- 10:06Let me get this straight. Let me see if
- 10:07I can state my any your right? So
- 10:09everything is either a starter or a
- 10:11borrower. Yes?
- 10:14>> I wouldn't I wouldn't use the word
- 10:15starter or borrower. I would say
- 10:17self-existent or contingent or possibly
- 10:20contingent. You could even use weak PSR.
- 10:22>> Starter or borrower, sure. So, you and
- 10:25then you say you can't have an infinite
- 10:27line of people borrowing $20 without
- 10:29someone having actual cash, right?
- 10:31>> No, I I never actually brought up the
- 10:33infinite line. I just said that
- 10:35derivative existence alone is not
- 10:37sufficient to establish existence in
- 10:39general. I never mentioned infinite
- 10:41regress. You kind of brought that in.
- 10:44>> Well, it seems to be what you're saying.
- 10:47>> No,
- 10:48>> everything is either a starter or a
- 10:50borrower. You can't have an infinite
- 10:52line of people borrowing $20 without
- 10:54someone having actual cash. You have
- 10:56$20, right? Conclusion, therefore the
- 10:59guy with the cash is named God and he
- 11:01hates shellfish and wants you to pay a
- 11:0310% tithe.
- 11:04>> No, so I I do not deny accidently
- 11:08ordered causal series. The dollar
- 11:10argument that you're presenting, I
- 11:12actually believe that can go back to
- 11:14infinity. I have no problem with that.
- 11:16I'm just saying that derivative
- 11:18existence alone cannot be sufficient for
- 11:21existence in general.
- 11:22>> So, where did the name tag come from?
- 11:25>> The name tag?
- 11:27>> Yeah.
- 11:28>> What name tag?
- 11:30>> The only one you're using in the in the
- 11:32premises.
- 11:33>> What What I don't know what What What
- 11:35are you talking about? Like
- 11:37>> Um never mind, dude. Um so, even if P1
- 11:41[snorts] through P3 hold up,
- 11:44right? Jumping to or jumping from like
- 11:47there must be a fundamental ground of
- 11:49existence to like and that fundamental
- 11:52ground is conscious universe creating
- 11:54deity who cares if I wear mixed fabrics
- 11:57is
- 11:59I think absolute leap of the millennium,
- 12:01sir.
- 12:01>> Yeah, so so I didn't even I I
- 12:03>> the series. That's like That's like
- 12:04That's like finding a mysterious shoe on
- 12:07the sidewalk and going
- 12:08a shoe must have a cobbler. Therefore,
- 12:10the cobbler is an omnipotent
- 12:12intergalactic wizard named Gear.
- 12:14>> No.
- 12:15>> Bro, like it could just be like
- 12:17a shoe.
- 12:18It could just be like a shoe factory
- 12:19machine.
- 12:20>> Yeah, so so I could explain to you why
- 12:22the necessary being must be the God of
- 12:25Catholicism if you would like me to.
- 12:29>> Yeah, but like when I asked you like why
- 12:31can't the self-existent thing be the
- 12:33universe? You hit me with like the
- 12:35ultimate Aquinas speed run card. Like,
- 12:37"Oh, because the universe's essence is
- 12:39not identical to its existence."
- 12:40>> Yeah, I'm willing to explain that if you
- 12:41don't understand.
- 12:42>> You you you you brought out the Latin
- 12:44metaphysical artillery. Like,
- 12:46>> use any any Latin.
- 12:48>> Yeah, saying the universe's essence
- 12:50isn't identical to its existence is just
- 12:52highbrow philosophy speak for like, "Oh,
- 12:55I can imagine a universe not existing.
- 12:57Therefore, it needs a cosmic battery
- 12:59pack."
- 12:59>> No, no, here I'll help you out. So so
- 13:02essence
- 13:02>> I will help you out, sir.
- 13:03>> Well, I don't I don't think you you want
- 13:05to.
- 13:06>> Yeah, no no no no I
- 13:07>> I I I can teach you this. I'll teach you
- 13:09this. This is This is
- 13:09>> This is why it's absolutely hilarious,
- 13:11right? Like, who checked the universe's
- 13:13ID? Like, how do they know what the
- 13:15universe's essence is? Like, did they
- 13:18open up the hood of quantum mechanics
- 13:20and inspect the metaphysical wiring?
- 13:22>> Yeah.
- 13:22>> Right?
- 13:23And quantum physics would would like a
- 13:25word, by the way. Like, quantum
- 13:27fluctuations literally pop particles
- 13:29into existence out of nothing because
- 13:31like minutes nothing.
- 13:33>> It's It's not It's not It's not out of
- 13:36nothing. No, you you misunderstand You
- 13:39You misunderstood quantum mechanics.
- 13:40This is
- 13:40>> I just said it's not It's not nothing.
- 13:43It's nothing. It's not nothing. It's
- 13:45nothing.
- 13:45>> Yeah, it's not It's not matter from
- 13:47matter, but it's still based off of the
- 13:48quantum fluctuation. So, there's still
- 13:50an efficient cause.
- 13:51>> Because the underlying quantum fields
- 13:53just exist, right? And the universe
- 13:55doesn't need to ask permission from a
- 13:57metaphysical landlord to exist. It might
- 14:00literally just be the ultimate
- 14:01self-sustaining baseline reality.
- 14:03>> Yeah, so so I'll I'll I'll I'll show
- 14:06you. You have to let me speak though.
- 14:08>> And if you claim like God's essence is
- 14:11existence, right? I would ask you to
- 14:13define God's essence without using the
- 14:15word existence.
- 14:16>> Yeah, actus purus.
- 14:20>> Yeah,
- 14:20great.
- 14:21>> Yeah, okay, so there's that for you. I
- 14:23fulfilled that that last request pretty
- 14:25easily. The other thing that you were
- 14:26saying, I think your your argument is a
- 14:29misunderstanding of how quantum
- 14:30mechanics works. Now now I'm not a
- 14:31quantum physicist and I won't I will not
- 14:33claim to be. However, I would say that
- 14:36that in line with what Heisenberg
- 14:38taught, quantum mechanics actually
- 14:40points directly to act and potency. He
- 14:43said that quantum mechanics affirms the
- 14:46Aristotelian thought of act and potency.
- 14:48He says it's directly correlated to it.
- 14:51And I would say that that quantum
- 14:53fluctuations
- 14:55and and like down at the most
- 14:56rudimentary level would affirm what
- 14:58Thomas called prime matter, which is
- 15:00pure potency because
- 15:02the closer you get down to this simple
- 15:04particle, the more and more fluctuation
- 15:07there is and the more it's going to have
- 15:09the potential to be anything that is
- 15:11material. And so
- 15:13>> Yeah, but sir
- 15:15Sir, I'm going to stop you because
- 15:16>> Why are you stopping me?
- 15:18I'm answering your questions. You ask
- 15:19questions, I'm helping I'm helping you.
- 15:21>> you like what is God's essence, right?
- 15:25And you said actus purus, right? I mean
- 15:27you're literally saying like, well,
- 15:29God's essence is that
- 15:31>> No, it's pure act.
- 15:32>> actuality. He's He's 100% pure pure
- 15:35fully realized action with no potential
- 15:38to change, learn, grow, or be anything
- 15:40other than what he is.
- 15:42>> Does he know anything about this guest?
- 15:45He thinks that children are supposed to
- 15:47give birth.
- 15:48>> I already know it.
- 15:49>> Yeah,
- 15:50why are we why are we coming up and and
- 15:53>> Because you're a piece of [ __ ]
- 15:54>> Oh, no. I I I forgot that TikTok
- 15:57atheists don't like me. That's That's
- 15:59Oh, I got muted.
- 16:00>> is with just saying like God's essence
- 16:02is actus purus, right? That's just a
- 16:05definition, not a description.
- 16:08>> Yeah, so
- 16:09>> Replying Replying with actus purus when
- 16:12asked for your essence is like asking a
- 16:14chef like what's in the secret sauce and
- 16:17having them answer deliciousness itself?
- 16:20>> No. Here, I'll I'll I'll give you a more
- 16:21detailed explanation. A more detailed
- 16:23definition.
- 16:23>> Aristotle, super [ __ ] helpful. You
- 16:26didn't tell me what God is. You just
- 16:27gave me a high highfalutin Latin
- 16:31adjective that means he doesn't have any
- 16:33unrealized potential. That's not a
- 16:36description of eternity of an entity,
- 16:39sir. That's a rule you made up for your
- 16:41own logic puzzle.
- 16:42>> I'll explain it to you if you give me a
- 16:44chance. If you let me speak.
- 16:45>> Wait. Wait, sir. If God is actus purus,
- 16:49right, then how did he create the
- 16:50universe?
- 16:51>> Yeah, I'll explain.
- 16:52>> Cuz what what before creation, like God
- 16:55wasn't creating. And then after
- 16:58creation, God created, right? That means
- 17:01God went from a from a state of not
- 17:03creating to creating. That's a change,
- 17:05my guy. That implies potentiality. If
- 17:08he's 100% pure actuality,
- 17:10>> Yeah.
- 17:10>> eternally locked in place, then creation
- 17:13either had to happen automatically like
- 17:16a [clears throat] cosmic belch, or God
- 17:18changes [ __ ] mind, which actus purus
- 17:20explicitly says he can't do. You just
- 17:23trapped your deity in concrete.
- 17:25>> it. So, Hey, can you let me speak?
- 17:28>> You just invent terms. And if we're
- 17:29allowed to just invent terms to win
- 17:31debates, like why can't the total sum of
- 17:34energy and mass in the cosmos, the
- 17:35quantum vacuum, fabric of space-time be
- 17:39the actus purus?
- 17:40>> Yeah. Yeah, I'll I'll show you. You have
- 17:42to let me You're dish galloping though.
- 17:43You're not letting me respond.
- 17:45>> is. No, I'm not, sir. Listen.
- 17:47>> The the
- 17:48>> You are dish galloping.
- 17:49>> The total energy of the universe cannot
- 17:52be created or destroyed. It just is. Why
- 17:55give the universe a fake demotion just
- 17:57so you can slap a divine name tag on the
- 17:59exact same concept?
- 18:01>> Yeah, I'll help you out. Can I speak?
- 18:04>> Well, yeah, but dropping actus purus
- 18:06isn't an explanation.
- 18:07>> I'll give you I'll give you a detailed
- 18:08explanation.
- 18:09>> It's just It's just winning a game of
- 18:11metaphysical scrabble by playing playing
- 18:13a Latin word on triple word score.
- 18:15>> No. Okay, so So, am I good to speak?
- 18:18>> with zero potentiality, then he
- 18:20literally cannot make a choice because
- 18:22making a choice requires moving from
- 18:25potential to action. Whereas you just
- 18:27argued that God's an immovable cause
- 18:29make rocks.
- 18:30>> So can I speak now? Is that okay?
- 18:32>> Yeah, except except one last thing.
- 18:34Calling God actus purus is like asking
- 18:37what a burrito is made of and being
- 18:39told, "Oh, it's pure buritoness."
- 18:41>> No.
- 18:42You're misunderstanding what the term
- 18:44means.
- 18:45>> Still [clears throat] waiting on the
- 18:46ingredients. I'm not understanding. No,
- 18:48I'm sorry. I'm not misunderstanding.
- 18:49>> you you you were right. You aren't
- 18:51understanding. I'll explain it though.
- 18:52So
- 18:54um and
- 18:54>> That's disingenuous.
- 18:56>> Uh he's also dodged several women and
- 18:59>> What?
- 19:00>> and several Well, his followers, sorry.
- 19:02>> Yeah, I believe it.
- 19:03>> Um
- 19:04including Christina the Godless and our
- 19:06very own Wave in the comments.
- 19:07>> Woah, woah, woah. I I didn't do that.
- 19:11Why why would I do I I I never did that.
- 19:13Why would you lie about me? I I
- 19:15I
- 19:15>> Did you not hear me say your followers?
- 19:18>> Well, no, but I didn't do that and I've
- 19:19never encouraged anyone to do that.
- 19:21I've never encouraged anyone to do that.
- 19:23They're muting me so I can't defend
- 19:24myself.
- 19:25>> you and your followers out for sending
- 19:26threats and doxxing people. You're a
- 19:28disgusting [laughter] piece of [ __ ]
- 19:29human being.
- 19:29>> Yeah, I I've I've condemned that
- 19:31multiple times. I've spoken against it.
- 19:32I don't know know what I'm supposed to
- 19:33do. I don't know how that's my fault
- 19:35when I've said it's it's wrong and I
- 19:36told people not to do it.
- 19:38>> Yeah, I don't think you did actually.
- 19:39>> I did. I've done it on I can show you
- 19:41multiple videos that I've made about it.
- 19:43I don't know what I'm supposed to do
- 19:44outside of that though.
- 19:45>> Uh not be a piece of [ __ ] human being.
- 19:47That'd be a start.
- 19:48>> Okay. Can I Can I answer the questions
- 19:50from from the debate now? Is that okay?
- 19:51I've been trying to do that for like 15
- 19:53minutes now.
- 19:56>> It hasn't been 15 minutes. You're being
- 19:58dramatic.
- 19:58>> Okay. So actus purus
- 20:01simply refers to the fact that the being
- 20:03is is pure act and there's no potency
- 20:05within it. And so that actually is an
- 20:07exact
- 20:09Okay, I'm just explaining. You don't
- 20:10need to interrupt, okay?
- 20:11>> I don't need you to explain it. I know
- 20:13what it means. Why don't you give me a
- 20:14reason why why do something
- 20:17>> got it. You got to let me speak.
- 20:18>> action and no potentiality.
- 20:20>> You got to let Let okay?
- 20:22Cuz I'm just trying to answer your
- 20:23questions.
- 20:24So so I would define God as a being
- 20:27lacking potency or a pure act being or a
- 20:30necessary being,
- 20:32um eternal, all powerful, all good, all
- 20:34knowing, all these things. I'm willing
- 20:36to defend any of the things I just said.
- 20:37I'll I'll prove it to you. Um however,
- 20:40you also made a really cool point and
- 20:42it's actually a really interesting
- 20:44topic. I'm talking about God's creation
- 20:46and whether or not this contradicts
- 20:48actus purus. Now, luckily for the the
- 20:50Thomist, St. Thomas, this was like one
- 20:53of the first things that he talked
- 20:54about. It's in prima pars of the Summa
- 20:56Theologica. And not only that,
- 20:58>> Sir, why do you keep resorting to St.
- 21:00Thomas Aquinas like
- 21:02>> Cuz he's he's
- 21:02>> This dude didn't know the things This
- 21:04dude didn't know the things that we know
- 21:06now.
- 21:06>> But I'm explaining it. You you you still
- 21:08won't let me speak.
- 21:10You still won't let me speak.
- 21:11You still You just won't let me speak,
- 21:13though. I'm just trying to explain your
- 21:14your your question.
- 21:15>> define God as lacking potentiality.
- 21:18However,
- 21:19>> You won't let me speak. I'm trying to
- 21:20answer your question.
- 21:21>> creation is what? God's creation is what
- 21:23and would do what?
- 21:24>> Just let me speak, okay, man?
- 21:27You just got to let me answer your
- 21:28question.
- 21:28>> Tell me about God's creation.
- 21:31>> Yeah. So so what the Thomist says is
- 21:33that there's a a real distinction
- 21:35between intrinsic change and extrinsic
- 21:37change.
- 21:39So for example, um so somebody or or we
- 21:42could actually say a magnet. A magnet
- 21:45that draws another magnet towards itself
- 21:48is actually undergoing no intrinsic
- 21:50change, but rather it's a drawing
- 21:52something outside of it towards itself.
- 21:54Now, sure some of the magnetic fields
- 21:56around the magnet may be changing, but
- 21:58the the essence of the magnet itself, we
- 22:00could say in a very simplistic way with
- 22:02with simple descriptions, the magnet
- 22:04itself is not changing. Now, it's also
- 22:06important to note that the the creation
- 22:09of God is extrinsic. And we can show
- 22:11this by understanding that God does not
- 22:13have discursive judgments. Because
- 22:15remember, before creation, there is no
- 22:18time. So there is no time where God did
- 22:21not create. We would say God always has
- 22:24been and precedes creation, but there
- 22:28was no time when God did not create
- 22:30because he created time itself. Now,
- 22:33logically, we can deduce that he came
- 22:34before, but time came into existence
- 22:37with creation. But again, God does not
- 22:39have discursive judgment. He's not going
- 22:41from one section of oh, I don't want to
- 22:44create to now I do want to create
- 22:46because his will is infinite
- 22:48intrinsically and unchanging.
- 22:53>> So, people
- 22:54had to be
- 22:55had to be created exactly the way they
- 22:58are right now. So, the universe
- 23:00>> No.
- 23:00>> You're basically saying you're basically
- 23:02saying that the universe is fundamental
- 23:04as God.
- 23:05>> No. I I don't know how you came back to
- 23:08>> what you're saying.
- 23:09>> That's modal collapse. And we we agree I
- 23:12I hold to S5 modal logic. I agree with
- 23:14you that
- 23:16like I agree with the distribution
- 23:18principle from axiom K. Like I don't
- 23:19have any problem with that. However, the
- 23:22distribution principle of of necessity
- 23:24doesn't apply in this circumstance. So,
- 23:26just because P is necessary does not
- 23:29automatically make Q necessary.
- 23:33>> Oh, jeez.
- 23:39You're You're essentially trying to
- 23:41build like a logic fortress where God is
- 23:43an unchangeable timeless rock, but
- 23:46somehow also responsible for dynamic
- 23:48changing universe without incurring any
- 23:51change itself or making the universe
- 23:53necessary.
- 23:54>> Yeah, so all all the
- 23:55>> that? Like
- 23:56>> All the
- 23:56>> You're saying you're saying basically
- 23:58your claim is like Yeah, basically
- 23:59you're saying your claim is like God
- 24:01creating the universe is just an
- 24:03extrinsic change an extrinsic change.
- 24:07>> Yep.
- 24:07>> Like a magnet pulling iron, the magnet
- 24:09stays the same, iron moves, therefore
- 24:11God doesn't change when he creates. Like
- 24:14nice try with the magnet trick, bro.
- 24:16Like but that's a massive false
- 24:18equivalency, right?
- 24:19>> What? It's an analogy. I know it's it's
- 24:22an analogy.
- 24:23>> It's a false equivalency.
- 24:24>> No, I'm not using the same You don't
- 24:26even know what that means.
- 24:28>> pulls A magnet pulls If you'll [ __ ]
- 24:30listen, you'll under
- 24:32Okay.
- 25:09No. Again, I'll explain.
- 26:17Yeah.
- 26:30But you're accusing me of modal
- 26:32collapse?
- 26:33>> No, I'm showing you that you're I said
- 26:35that's modal collapse because you were
- 26:37arguing that I was falling into modal
- 26:39collapse.
- 26:40>> ultimate Uno reverse projection, right?
- 26:43Because let's look at the world, right?
- 26:45God is actus purus, right? Pure act,
- 26:49zero potentiality. God's act of creating
- 26:52is identical to God's essence because
- 26:54divine simplicity says God has no parts
- 26:56or like separate attributes. God's
- 26:59essence is necessary, like he cannot not
- 27:01exist. So, conclusion there, if if God's
- 27:04act of creating is identical to his
- 27:06necessary essence, then creation is also
- 27:09necessary,
- 27:11right?
- 27:12>> We we would No, we would we would
- 27:14>> had to exist
- 27:15>> You're misunderstanding divine
- 27:16simplicity.
- 27:17>> as it is.
- 27:19>> Also, there
- 27:19>> God couldn't have created anything
- 27:21differently, right? That is modal
- 27:23collapse. Your own theology forces the
- 27:26universe to be just as necessary as God,
- 27:30destroying divine free will entirely,
- 27:33right? And you didn't avoid I like you
- 27:36didn't avoid modal collapse. You walked
- 27:37straight into it while while wearing
- 27:39[ __ ] Latin armor.
- 27:41>> No, I'll I'll help you out. You're still
- 27:43not understanding why I brought up modal
- 27:45collapse.
- 27:46>> just fine.
- 27:47>> You obviously don't because you're not
- 27:49even understanding why I said modal
- 27:51collapse.
- 27:52>> Let me sum this Let me sum this
- 27:53>> You're not letting me speak. You're not
- 27:55letting me speak, dude.
- 27:56>> Comparing God to
- 27:57>> This is pathetic.
- 27:58>> I'm not even [ __ ] done.
- 28:00Comparing God to a magnet makes creation
- 28:03an automatic passive side effect rather
- 28:05than a conscious choice. Congrats, you
- 28:08just
- 28:09>> What are you reading off of?
- 28:10>> your creator to a giant cosmic
- 28:12gravitational
- 28:13>> What are you reading off of?
- 28:14>> And second of all, you accused me of
- 28:16modal collapse,
- 28:18>> No, I didn't.
- 28:18>> but God is actus purus. You did.
- 28:21>> No, I said I
- 28:22>> Absolutely did.
- 28:23>> I pointed out that your accusation was
- 28:26modal collapse and that we had already
- 28:27refuted that.
- 28:30I never accused you of modal collapse. I
- 28:32said this objection that you're making
- 28:34is modal collapse, and I have a
- 28:36refutation to that."
- 28:38>> Your argument makes the universe as
- 28:40fundamental as God.
- 28:42>> No, I can explain like do you need me to
- 28:44like show you the logical proof?
- 28:46>> that when I said that you said that was
- 28:48that was modal collapse. So, you accuse
- 28:50me of modal collapse, but if God is at
- 28:53his purest and his creation is the of
- 28:56the universe is identical to his
- 28:57immutable essence, then creation is
- 29:00necessary and it couldn't be otherwise.
- 29:03Your own premise causes the very modal
- 29:05collapse you're running from.
- 29:07>> No, I make I already explained to you
- 29:09that we agree with the distribution
- 29:11principle of necessity. We agree with
- 29:13axiom K. We're S5. We we believe in in
- 29:17system S5. Like I don't understand what
- 29:19you're not getting that. I'm not I'm not
- 29:21saying that you are falling into modal
- 29:23collapse. I said the objection that you
- 29:24made was modal collapse and that it does
- 29:26not affect our argument because the
- 29:29distribution property still holds.
- 29:32>> makes that the case. My goodness. Hey, I
- 29:34I noticed that there's three people up
- 29:36here now. Am I talking to just one
- 29:38person or like why why are people
- 29:40continuing to come up?
- 29:42>> Why why are you deflecting when neither
- 29:44of us have said anything?
- 29:45>> hasn't hasn't said anything. I haven't
- 29:47said anything.
- 29:47>> I'm I was just asking. I'm just asking
- 29:50why there's so
- 29:50>> Your question is irrelevant. It's a
- 29:52deflection to be
- 29:52>> It's irrelevant? Oh, I got muted again.
- 29:55I I'm just asking like why so many
- 29:57people are up here.
- 29:58>> Why ain't it doesn't matter?
- 30:01>> I keep getting muted.
- 30:03Why why do I keep getting
- 30:04>> you because you're asking things that
- 30:06don't [ __ ] matter.
- 30:08>> Well, I'm just confused as to why so
- 30:09many people are coming up.
- 30:11>> Why Okay, you know what? Here, let
- 30:13[clears throat] me let them speak then.
- 30:14Shut the [ __ ] up.
- 30:15>> Oh, I got muted again.
- 30:18>> Uh not right now.
- 30:20I did
- 30:21>> All right, Allen, you got something to
- 30:21say, bro?
- 30:23>> Oh, I said all I needed to say.
- 30:26>> All right. See All right, so again, it
- 30:28didn't [ __ ] matter why you were
- 30:29asking that.
- 30:30>> Yeah, I was I was literally just
- 30:32wondering.
- 30:33Yeah.
- 30:34>> What does it matter, dude? It's my
- 30:35[ __ ] life. yours.
- 30:36>> [laughter]
- 30:37>> I was just asking a question. I don't
- 30:38know why this is such a big deal.
- 30:40Um but but regardless of that, um I I am
- 30:43already I've told you multiple times
- 30:45that you're misunderstanding why I
- 30:46brought up modal collapse. Do you know
- 30:48what axiom K is?
- 30:51>> Yeah. Anyway, tell me why I'm
- 30:53misunderstanding why you
- 30:54>> Are you searching Are you searching up
- 30:55axiom K now?
- 30:57>> So, why don't you tell me why I'm
- 30:59misunderstanding
- 31:00>> You don't need to be using AI. You can
- 31:01just say that you you don't know
- 31:02something.
- 31:03>> don't you tell me why I'm
- 31:05misunderstanding why you brought up
- 31:06modal
- 31:06>> But but we can hear you we can hear you
- 31:08typing on your AI chatbot. You can just
- 31:09say that you don't know something.
- 31:11>> matter? What Why does it
- 31:14Sorry. Why am I understanding or
- 31:17misunderstanding that you brought up
- 31:18modal collapse?
- 31:19>> Yeah, so I brought up modal collapse
- 31:21showing you that I already understand
- 31:23your specific objection and that it's
- 31:26been dealt with in length. Like the
- 31:28Alvin Plantinga's, the the Alexander
- 31:30Pruss's, the Josh Rasmussen's, they
- 31:31they've dealt with this in length. I
- 31:33highly recommend that you read the
- 31:34Oxford Press necessary existence. Um but
- 31:38but what what we what we're what I'm
- 31:40saying here is that you are trying to
- 31:43apply the distribution property of axiom
- 31:45K. You're trying to say that since P is
- 31:48necessary and then Q, you're trying to
- 31:51say that therefore Q is also necessary.
- 31:55But that that is not how axiom K works.
- 31:58Axiom K states that if it is necessary
- 32:02that if P then Q then if P is necessary,
- 32:05then Q is also necessary. But that's not
- 32:08the claim that I'm making and you're
- 32:09you're misunderstanding like the most
- 32:11rudimentary modal logic. And trying to
- 32:14bring up modal collapse is completely
- 32:16embarrassing. But I would say just just
- 32:18stop using AI and just have an actual
- 32:19conversation with me.
- 32:22>> I don't think you're capable of an
- 32:23actual conversation.
- 32:24>> Well, I'm not the one using a chatbot
- 32:26right now, am I?
- 32:30>> I don't need to use a chatbot to talk to
- 32:31your dumb [ __ ]
- 32:32>> Well, you're you are though. You are
- 32:34using it right now, so I'm
- 32:35>> It's funny It's funny that you're really
- 32:37trying to [ __ ] pull rank here with
- 32:39formal modal logic syntax now.
- 32:42Right, and bringing up axiom K means you
- 32:45think that I'm misapplying modal
- 32:48distribution.
- 32:48>> Dude, stop reading off of the screen.
- 32:50You don't even know the words that
- 32:51you're saying.
- 32:54Can you Can you explain
- 32:56>> Sir, you're very You're very dishonest
- 32:58and disingenuous.
- 32:58>> I'm not being dishonest. Can you Can you
- 33:00just explain system
- 33:01>> but dishonest and disingenuous this
- 33:03whole time. You can't even engage with
- 33:05>> He's muting me over and over and over
- 33:06again.
- 33:08>> [snorts]
- 33:09>> Oh, I got kicked.
- 33:11He kicked me. Oh, man.
- 33:16Man, how how how brutal is that?
- 33:19Kicked from the live stream. Okay, guys.
- 33:21Hopefully that was entertaining.
- 33:23Um
- 33:24Yeah, very, very concerning behavior
- 33:26that we keep seeing from the the Tik Tok
- 33:28atheists. Hopefully this was
- 33:30entertaining to some of you guys.
- 33:32Um but yeah, just pray for these people.
- 33:35Um
- 33:35know that they're just confused. Know
- 33:37that they're just scared.
- 33:39Um
- 33:40And that ultimately in the heart of all
- 33:41of these people, they know. They know
- 33:43that they're wrong.
- 33:45But But put yourself in the shoes of a
- 33:48of an atheist.
- 33:49Sure, something could be convincing. An
- 33:51argument for God could be convincing.
- 33:54But if that's true, think about what you
- 33:55have to give up. If Christianity is
- 33:58true, think about what you have to give
- 33:59up. It's a very hard decision for them
- 34:01to make, and they will often go into
- 34:04this fight or flight mode, just like you
- 34:05saw. Where they will do literally
- 34:07anything but admit maybe Christianity is
- 34:10true. Because if Christianity is maybe
- 34:12true,
- 34:14it's very, very scary. It's very, very
- 34:16problematic for their their entire
- 34:17worldview, for all of their behavior.
- 34:20And so, I would say
- 34:22there's no need to go and and hate on
- 34:24these people. There's no need to go and
- 34:26and get upset at them.
- 34:27Um but but rather, just pray for them.
- 34:30Just pray for them.
- 34:33Um and also, guys, what I will say
- 34:35openly right now,
- 34:37I have never doxxed anyone. I do not
- 34:40plan on doxxing anyone. I do not condone
- 34:42the doxing of anyone. I have never sent
- 34:44sexual assault threats to anyone. I will
- 34:47never do that and I will never ask
- 34:49anyone to do that. Those allegations are
- 34:51serious and I am considering litigation
- 34:54against all those who are saying that.
- 34:56So, uh I will be going to that guy's
- 34:58profile. I'm going to be taking notes um
- 35:00as well as that one Christina lady who
- 35:02has accused me of grooming children and
- 35:05um all of that stuff. Um I am
- 35:07considering litigation against all of
- 35:09them. So, uh for for those two people,
- 35:11um if you see this, um
- 35:13now you know. Um and we will we will see
- 35:16where that goes with those false
- 35:17allegations. Um it will not be cheap.
- 35:20However, um if you if you want to
- 35:22support the channel, uh what what I
- 35:24would uh request that you do is you like
- 35:27the video, you subscribe. Um all this
- 35:29all the stuff that I do takes time,
- 35:31takes time out of my day, um and it
- 35:32takes a lot of effort as well. I don't
- 35:34get enough sleep, but it's it's worth
- 35:35it.
- 35:36Um please, um if you really really want
- 35:39to support the channel, you can go to my
- 35:41Substack where I write articles on
- 35:43pretty much everything I talk about on
- 35:44this channel in-depth with sources, um
- 35:48and it's very very helpful. If you want
- 35:49to actually get good at the things that
- 35:51I'm talking about, I would recommend
- 35:52going to my Substack. Um there's a bunch
- 35:54of free articles on there, but there's
- 35:56also um
- 35:58uh a subscription where you can get
- 35:59access to even more articles. So, if you
- 36:01want to support the channel, that's
- 36:02where you can go. You don't need to
- 36:04though. I just appreciate it if you do.
- 36:06But anyways, thank you for watching.
- 36:07Know that I'm praying for you. Please
- 36:09pray the rosary every single day. Pray
- 36:11for the souls in purgatory and God bless
- 36:13every single one of you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Atheist Crashes Out After Being Caught Using ChatGPT (JAW vs ‘ZipZop’) by Jesus and Whatnot, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,195 words across 1,033 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.