YouTube2Text

ATHEIST ANGER! | “Does God Exist?” | DEBATE | Jesusandwhatnot vs Ogar — Transcript

by Jesus and Whatnot · 7,831 words · 1,278 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Now I can.
  2. 0:00>> Oh, sorry.
  3. 0:01>> Yeah, sorry. There must have been some
  4. 0:02problem with the microphone. All I had
  5. 0:03to do was was mute it and unmute it
  6. 0:05again and it worked.
  7. 0:06>> Oh, fair enough. Uh I just ask everybody
  8. 0:08how old are you?
  9. 0:09>> Uh I'm 19, but I turn 20 tomorrow.
  10. 0:12>> Oh, well, happy early birthday.
  11. 0:13>> Well, thank you so much. Uh it's the the
  12. 0:15fall equinox or solstice, one of the
  13. 0:17two. I always forget. I think it's
  14. 0:19equinox.
  15. 0:20>> Sure.
  16. 0:21I'll I'll trust you on that. Uh my
  17. 0:23understanding is that you're Catholic,
  18. 0:24is that correct?
  19. 0:25>> Uh that is true.
  20. 0:27>> Cool. And um what would you say is some
  21. 0:30argument or evidence that would provide
  22. 0:31justification to believe in God?
  23. 0:32>> Yeah, so I I typically
  24. 0:35um take a lot of my arguments from St.
  25. 0:36Thomas Aquinas. I don't know how much of
  26. 0:38him you've read, but um I think he's
  27. 0:40he's probably the greatest theologian um
  28. 0:42outside of the apostles.
  29. 0:44Um I would I would say
  30. 0:47I'm going to take his argument from
  31. 0:48motion, but in light of how um
  32. 0:51Father Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange
  33. 0:53phrased it. So, I can give you the
  34. 0:55syllogism. Um premise one, whatever
  35. 0:58>> we put it up on screen?
  36. 0:59>> Yeah, sure.
  37. 1:00Premise one, whatever is one by
  38. 1:02participation receives its unity
  39. 1:05>> I'm so sorry. Whatever is one as in the
  40. 1:07number one?
  41. 1:07>> Yes.
  42. 1:08>> Okay, by participation.
  43. 1:10>> Receives its unity from something other
  44. 1:12than itself.
  45. 1:15>> It's unity from something other than
  46. 1:18itself, okay.
  47. 1:20>> Okay. Premise two,
  48. 1:22what receives its unity from another
  49. 1:26does not have unity by essence.
  50. 1:33>> Okay.
  51. 1:33>> Premise three, an ordered series of
  52. 1:36things receiving unity
  53. 1:39with no member having unity by essence
  54. 1:42never accounts for any member's unity.
  55. 1:45>> No unity. In an ordered series of things
  56. 1:48receiving unity
  57. 1:50>> with no member having unity by essence
  58. 1:56never accounts for any members unity.
  59. 2:01>> Oh, was the first word "an" not "in"?
  60. 2:05>> An, a n, yeah.
  61. 2:07>> Okay, my bad. Okay, never
  62. 2:10accounts for unity. Okay.
  63. 2:12>> Any members unity.
  64. 2:17>> Thank you.
  65. 2:18>> Of course.
  66. 2:19Uh, premise four, some things are one by
  67. 2:22participation.
  68. 2:28Conclusion,
  69. 2:29therefore,
  70. 2:31something is one by essence and is its
  71. 2:34unity is identical with what it is.
  72. 2:42>> Um, can you
  73. 2:44uh, help me understand how you're using
  74. 2:46the word unity?
  75. 2:47>> [snorts]
  76. 2:47>> Um, things that are that are united that
  77. 2:50that share in one form, you could say.
  78. 2:54>> Things that share in one form?
  79. 2:56>> Yeah, so for example, like uh, you can
  80. 2:58use redness. Redness would be the form
  81. 3:01that actualizes specific matter and it's
  82. 3:03the
  83. 3:04>> I don't
  84. 3:05I don't believe in like universals. So,
  85. 3:07it sounds like this is not an argument
  86. 3:08that's going to have any force for me.
  87. 3:10>> Yeah, so we Yeah, we can talk about
  88. 3:11universals and we can uh, discuss them.
  89. 3:12But but this is you actually don't need
  90. 3:14to
  91. 3:17um, necessarily believe in universals to
  92. 3:19understand how I'm using this specific
  93. 3:22uh, phrase of of unity. I was just
  94. 3:24trying to give you an example. It's an
  95. 3:25example. It's an example.
  96. 3:28No, this is this is this is just an an
  97. 3:30example of how it can be used. So,
  98. 3:32>> Okay, so I need you to provide an
  99. 3:33example so I understand what you mean by
  100. 3:35unity in a way that is like applies to
  101. 3:37things that I think actually exist.
  102. 3:39Otherwise,
  103. 3:40>> But you understand what universals are
  104. 3:42so I can still give you the analogy and
  105. 3:44you will understand how I'm using unity
  106. 3:46even if you don't agree that
  107. 3:48>> No, because I don't
  108. 3:48>> [snorts]
  109. 3:48>> think that the kind of form No, because
  110. 3:50I don't think that the kind of form
  111. 3:52we're if you're talking about like
  112. 3:52platonic forms
  113. 3:53>> I'm not.
  114. 3:54>> don't
  115. 3:54>> platonic forms exist.
  116. 3:55>> I reject platonic forms.
  117. 3:57>> Okay, that's fine. So now I just don't
  118. 3:59know what this phrase, things that share
  119. 4:00in one form, I don't know what that
  120. 4:02means. And since that was the definition
  121. 4:03of unity, I still don't know what unity
  122. 4:05means.
  123. 4:05>> Yeah, so I'm
  124. 4:06>> That's why I said I would need you to
  125. 4:07give a different definition that I
  126. 4:08actually know what it means.
  127. 4:09>> Yeah, so I'm going to give you an
  128. 4:10example and you can know what it means.
  129. 4:12>> want an example, please. I just want a
  130. 4:13definition of unity.
  131. 4:15>> Yeah, I just want a definition
  132. 4:16>> Well, I already gave I already gave you
  133. 4:17that. Things that are one in form. In
  134. 4:19one form.
  135. 4:19>> Yeah, and I don't know what that means,
  136. 4:20so I need you to give a different
  137. 4:21definition so I do know what it means.
  138. 4:23>> Well, just because you don't know what
  139. 4:23it means. I'm trying to explain it with
  140. 4:25an example. That's kind of how like
  141. 4:26definitions work. Because I gave you the
  142. 4:27definition
  143. 4:28>> already and then it turned into the
  144. 4:29whole Okay, if you want to give a
  145. 4:31different example, I guess, but like
  146. 4:33We just need I just need something
  147. 4:34informative so I know what the word
  148. 4:35unity means in in the way you're using
  149. 4:37it.
  150. 4:37>> Yeah, so so just just let me give the
  151. 4:39example. I think it'll make sense even
  152. 4:41if you don't agree with universals.
  153. 4:42>> So just give the example, please.
  154. 4:44>> Yeah, so things that are red they share
  155. 4:48in redness by participa right? They have
  156. 4:51>> what that means unless we're talking
  157. 4:53about like platonic forms.
  158. 4:54>> So
  159. 4:55>> Or like, you know, properties being, you
  160. 4:56know, platonic or like abstract objects
  161. 4:58or something.
  162. 4:58>> Okay, so are
  163. 4:59>> Otherwise I have no idea what you're
  164. 5:00saying.
  165. 5:00>> Are strawberries red?
  166. 5:04>> Yeah.
  167. 5:04>> Are apples red?
  168. 5:06>> Yeah.
  169. 5:06>> So they are united because they share in
  170. 5:08the one form of redness. That's how I'm
  171. 5:11using
  172. 5:12>> No, that's I don't have no idea what
  173. 5:13that means.
  174. 5:14>> How how do you not know what that means?
  175. 5:16Like they're they're united because they
  176. 5:17share in one form.
  177. 5:18>> If you're not talking about like it
  178. 5:20being an instantiation of some universal
  179. 5:22property, then I have no idea what
  180. 5:24you're saying.
  181. 5:25If you're saying something other than
  182. 5:27like, you know, the redness of an apple
  183. 5:29and the redness of a strawberry are both
  184. 5:31instantiations of the universal abstract
  185. 5:34object red or redness, if you're saying
  186. 5:37something other than that, then I don't
  187. 5:38understand the example and I still don't
  188. 5:40know what unity means.
  189. 5:41>> Okay, so so respectfully, you can reject
  190. 5:44a certain premise and you can reject
  191. 5:46like how like you like disagree with the
  192. 5:49Aristotelian understanding of forms, but
  193. 5:51that doesn't mean you don't understand.
  194. 5:53Like if you don't understand that things
  195. 5:54are united by redness, I think that's
  196. 5:56going to be more of a problem of like
  197. 5:58conceptual understanding of the world
  198. 5:59versus like agreeing with what I'm
  199. 6:01saying.
  200. 6:02>> No, if I can just say that like there
  201. 6:04are things that exist that have um, you
  202. 6:07know, that like um, when we look at
  203. 6:09them, we experience what we call, you
  204. 6:12know, like visual experience of redness,
  205. 6:14but that's fine, but I don't know what
  206. 6:16it means to say that they share in a
  207. 6:18form.
  208. 6:20>> So, so they're both red. That would be
  209. 6:22the form that they're sharing in. The
  210. 6:24fact that they are both red.
  211. 6:25>> Okay, can you can you maybe maybe I just
  212. 6:27need to What does form mean?
  213. 6:29>> Uh, form would be that which actualizes
  214. 6:32a given matter.
  215. 6:36Or that which constitutes a thing as it
  216. 6:38is. So, for example, like if you have a
  217. 6:40block of wood and you turn it into a
  218. 6:43statue,
  219. 6:45the the shape of the statue is going to
  220. 6:47be the form that actualizes the matter
  221. 6:50of the block of wood or the block of
  222. 6:51stone.
  223. 6:57>> Can you say that again?
  224. 7:00>> So, so form is going to be that which
  225. 7:02constitutes a thing as it is.
  226. 7:05>> Mhm.
  227. 7:05>> So, for [snorts] material forms, for
  228. 7:07example, like the ones that you're most
  229. 7:09familiar with, if we have a statue
  230. 7:11that's carved out of marble, the marble
  231. 7:14is going to be the matter and the form
  232. 7:16is going to actualize that matter. So,
  233. 7:19it's going to be the the statueness that
  234. 7:21we find within the block. So, the block
  235. 7:23beforehand has the potency of statueness
  236. 7:26and then it's actualized by the form of
  237. 7:28statueness.
  238. 7:29>> [snorts]
  239. 7:29>> Okay, so this is grounded or or
  240. 7:32dependent on some understanding of act
  241. 7:35and potency?
  242. 7:36>> Yes.
  243. 7:37>> Okay, that's where the disconnect is. I
  244. 7:39would need you to help me uh, by giving
  245. 7:42a demonstration that there is potency
  246. 7:44actualized. That
  247. 7:46the actualization of potential is
  248. 7:47something that exists.
  249. 7:48>> Yeah, so this is something that Father
  250. 7:49Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange also talks
  251. 7:51about. Have you read any Father Reginald
  252. 7:53Garrigou-Lagrange?
  253. 7:54>> Uh I have not, no.
  254. 7:55>> Uh he's he's he's really good on this
  255. 7:57specific topic. I I highly recommend
  256. 7:59that you read um Reality. But in short,
  257. 8:02um the conclusion of potency was kind of
  258. 8:07the result of like centuries of debates
  259. 8:10um between
  260. 8:12and Plato.
  261. 8:13>> This isn't informative. So, I'm just
  262. 8:15asking you
  263. 8:15>> informative.
  264. 8:16>> No, because what you're doing is talking
  265. 8:18about history. I'm not asking for a
  266. 8:20history lesson. I'm asking you to
  267. 8:21provide the justification that act and
  268. 8:24potency are things that exist.
  269. 8:26>> Yeah, so I'm I'm trying to explain I was
  270. 8:27just giving you like a little bit of
  271. 8:28historical preface as to why this is
  272. 8:30widely accepted.
  273. 8:31>> Yeah, I don't want preface.
  274. 8:32>> You don't want any preface?
  275. 8:34>> No prefaces, please.
  276. 8:35>> Okay. Okay. No no prefaces.
  277. 8:37>> substance, please.
  278. 8:37>> Okay, so so first of all, do you agree
  279. 8:40with the principle of non-contradiction?
  280. 8:44>> Do you mean the law of
  281. 8:45non-contradiction?
  282. 8:46>> Uh it can be called the principle of
  283. 8:47non-contradiction. Law of
  284. 8:48non-contradiction would typically be
  285. 8:49referring to like logical syllogisms.
  286. 8:50I'm talking about the principle of
  287. 8:52non-contradiction because I reject like
  288. 8:54the Parmenidean um
  289. 8:56approach of just saying that like it's
  290. 8:58only a law of speech. I would say that
  291. 9:00it it extends
  292. 9:01beyond that and it's actually a
  293. 9:02principle that applies to all reality.
  294. 9:07>> I I guess I don't know what it means for
  295. 9:09non-contradiction to apply to all
  296. 9:11reality.
  297. 9:11>> Yeah, so non-contradiction, the
  298. 9:13principle of non-contradiction states
  299. 9:15that a thing cannot be and not be at the
  300. 9:17same time.
  301. 9:19And so, that applies to all reality.
  302. 9:21Something can't be and not be at the
  303. 9:22same time.
  304. 9:24>> Okay, sure. I would agree with that.
  305. 9:25>> Yeah, and so
  306. 9:27the the discussion about act and potency
  307. 9:29at potency is Aristotle's specific
  308. 9:31conclusion. But it comes from Heraclitus
  309. 9:34and Par
  310. 9:34>> doing the history thing say it
  311. 9:35>> No, because I'm I'm giving you the
  312. 9:37>> preferences. We we already discussed no
  313. 9:39preferences.
  314. 9:39>> Please just give the the argument or the
  315. 9:41justification that there is um
  316. 9:44actualization of potency.
  317. 9:45>> Yeah, but I it'll it'll be very helpful
  318. 9:47for the rest of the conversation so that
  319. 9:48I can refer to specific things as
  320. 9:50Heraclitus's view.
  321. 9:51>> you to give No, I just want you to give
  322. 9:53the justification that there is potency.
  323. 9:57>> Yeah, and I'm giving it I'm giving it to
  324. 9:58you.
  325. 9:59>> Okay, hold on. Hold on. Stop. I don't
  326. 10:00want you to like
  327. 10:02What you need to do here and is to move
  328. 10:05the conversation forward is actually
  329. 10:07provide the justification for the
  330. 10:09existence of potency. If you do anything
  331. 10:12else, then I'm just going to take that
  332. 10:13as an indication that you don't have you
  333. 10:15can't do that.
  334. 10:16>> No. I'll I'll just consider that a
  335. 10:17concession.
  336. 10:18>> So it's up to you if you want to
  337. 10:19actually move the conversation forward,
  338. 10:22then what you'll do is you'll actually
  339. 10:23provide the justification for thinking
  340. 10:25that potency exists.
  341. 10:26>> So so I'm going to be referring to these
  342. 10:28views later on in the discussion.
  343. 10:31>> No. I'm just trying to explain where
  344. 10:33you're not actually doing the where
  345. 10:34you're not actually providing the
  346. 10:35justification. So you're claiming that
  347. 10:37potency exists. Please provide the
  348. 10:39justification for that claim.
  349. 10:41>> Yeah, I I'm going to, but I'm
  350. 10:43>> Okay, so notice again what you're doing
  351. 10:44is you're not providing the
  352. 10:45justification.
  353. 10:46>> You're not letting me speak.
  354. 10:47>> to I'm going to cut you off every single
  355. 10:49time
  356. 10:50you don't just provide the demonstration
  357. 10:52or the the justification. So if you say
  358. 10:54anything other than justification that
  359. 10:56you're being asked for, I'm going to cut
  360. 10:57you off again. If you don't want to get
  361. 10:58cut off, that's I understand. I don't
  362. 11:00like getting cut off either. So then
  363. 11:02just provide the demonstration or the
  364. 11:03justification that potency exists.
  365. 11:04>> Yeah, so in order to I'll just I'll just
  366. 11:07give it straight up and then I guess
  367. 11:08I'll explain the the history behind it
  368. 11:10later.
  369. 11:10>> it again, dude. I don't know why you're
  370. 11:11doing this. I don't know why this is so
  371. 11:12difficult for you.
  372. 11:13>> Oh my goodness. I'm
  373. 11:15telling you I'm saying yeah.
  374. 11:17>> All you have to do to move the
  375. 11:18conversation forward is actually provide
  376. 11:21prevent the present the justification.
  377. 11:22>> I'm doing it. I'm doing exactly what
  378. 11:24you're asking.
  379. 11:24>> Okay, so here's what's happening. No,
  380. 11:26when you say
  381. 11:27>> [laughter]
  382. 11:27>> what you're asking me for,
  383. 11:28that's not doing what you what I'm
  384. 11:30asking for. So what you shouldn't be
  385. 11:31doing is crying and pretending that
  386. 11:33you're giving the demonstration which
  387. 11:35I've asked
  388. 11:35>> I'm I'm trying to. You're just not
  389. 11:36You're just talking.
  390. 11:37>> actually provided.
  391. 11:38>> Yeah, you're just talking the whole
  392. 11:38time. So, I can't do it.
  393. 11:40>> So, just actually provide the
  394. 11:41justification.
  395. 11:42>> Yeah, so in order to rationalize the
  396. 11:44principle of non-contradiction with
  397. 11:46motion that we observe in the universe,
  398. 11:48you're going to have to have some middle
  399. 11:50term. And that's what is described as
  400. 11:52potency. Any other solution
  401. 11:55>> Say that again. In order to
  402. 11:58>> You want me to say the whole thing
  403. 11:59again?
  404. 12:00>> Yeah, please.
  405. 12:00>> So, this is why it would be easier if I
  406. 12:02just gave you the historical context.
  407. 12:04But that would make more sense to you.
  408. 12:05Because you don't understand what I'm
  409. 12:06saying because I haven't given you the
  410. 12:08premise.
  411. 12:08>> it. You can't just tell me the
  412. 12:09demonstrat or the justification.
  413. 12:10>> just did, but I You told me I couldn't
  414. 12:12give you context, so now you don't
  415. 12:13understand. This is exactly what I said
  416. 12:15would happen.
  417. 12:16>> Just give me the justification. Just say
  418. 12:18what it is.
  419. 12:19>> In order to
  420. 12:19>> to write it down.
  421. 12:20>> order to reconcile the principle of
  422. 12:22non-contradiction with motion observed
  423. 12:24in the universe, you will need
  424. 12:26>> Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. The principle
  425. 12:27of non-contradiction
  426. 12:28>> Yeah, I can't write that. I can't type
  427. 12:29that.
  428. 12:30>> I mean, you could just listen.
  429. 12:31>> You got to calm down. I'm writing it
  430. 12:32down. So, in order to reconcile the
  431. 12:34principle of non-contradiction
  432. 12:36>> In order to reconcile the principle of
  433. 12:37non-contradiction with motion observed
  434. 12:40in the universe, you need some middle
  435. 12:42term.
  436. 12:42>> Motion observed Hold on. You can't You
  437. 12:44got to calm down. I'm writing it down.
  438. 12:46>> You could just listen. You could just
  439. 12:47listen.
  440. 12:48>> With motion observed in the universe
  441. 12:54>> Am I good now?
  442. 12:57>> So, what's the rest of it? In order to
  443. 12:58reconcile the principle of
  444. 12:59non-contradiction with motion observed
  445. 13:00in the universe
  446. 13:01>> some middle term to explain non-being
  447. 13:04going to being.
  448. 13:10>> Uh what's the justification for that?
  449. 13:12>> It leads to absurdity any other way
  450. 13:14because it would violate the principle
  451. 13:15of non-contradiction.
  452. 13:17>> Yeah, but just how?
  453. 13:19>> Because So, potency is the only logical
  454. 13:21conclusion. That's what I'm saying. You
  455. 13:23can have like an apophatic description.
  456. 13:24>> Instead of saying it's the logical
  457. 13:25conclusion, provide the logic.
  458. 13:27>> Yeah, so that this is kind of how like
  459. 13:28like first principles and the
  460. 13:30understanding of the universe works is
  461. 13:31that I'm saying
  462. 13:32>> you're making a claim that if something
  463. 13:34like if we didn't have act and potency,
  464. 13:36there would be like some incoherency,
  465. 13:38presumably some kind of contradiction.
  466. 13:40And so I need you to just derive that
  467. 13:42contradiction.
  468. 13:42>> Yeah, so I that's why I tried to give
  469. 13:44you the historical preface of the people
  470. 13:46who tried to do this.
  471. 13:47>> preface is not going to help here. What
  472. 13:49I'm asking you to do is to actually
  473. 13:50derive the contradiction.
  474. 13:52>> So, Heraclitus tried to do it, he
  475. 13:54failed. Parmenides tried to do it, he
  476. 13:55failed.
  477. 13:56>> history again.
  478. 13:56>> So I can't quote history?
  479. 13:58>> Your claim Now, maybe I'm
  480. 14:00misunderstanding.
  481. 14:01>> Yeah, you are.
  482. 14:01>> My understanding here is that you're
  483. 14:04claiming that any worldview that does
  484. 14:05not have potency in it entails a
  485. 14:07contradiction. Is that correct?
  486. 14:09>> Or an absurdity.
  487. 14:10>> Fantastic. So
  488. 14:12and and by absurdity, what do you mean?
  489. 14:14>> Um something that is either extremely
  490. 14:17unlikely to be true or contradictory.
  491. 14:21>> Just Okay.
  492. 14:24Um
  493. 14:24Sure. So, what is the absurdity or
  494. 14:27contradiction that follows from not
  495. 14:28having um
  496. 14:31uh from not having potency in your
  497. 14:32worldview?
  498. 14:34>> So that's what I tried to tell you with
  499. 14:35Heraclitus and Parmenides.
  500. 14:36>> Yeah, you're still doing the history
  501. 14:38thing again.
  502. 14:38>> It's not history. I'm just assigning
  503. 14:40names to the specific belief.
  504. 14:41>> don't need to talk about other people.
  505. 14:42You I know you think it makes you sound
  506. 14:43smart, but it just sounds like you're
  507. 14:43dodging. So why don't you just actually
  508. 14:44present the the problem instead of just
  509. 14:45saying that there's a problem.
  510. 14:47So why don't you just actually present
  511. 14:48the the problem instead of just saying
  512. 14:49that there's a problem.
  513. 14:50Instead of just saying that there's a
  514. 14:51problem.
  515. 14:52>> Hey hey dude, I I'm just trying to have
  516. 14:54a conversation with you.
  517. 14:55>> I know, and I would love to have the
  518. 14:56conversation with you.
  519. 14:57>> No, you you obviously don't.
  520. 14:58>> What I'm interested in is the substance
  521. 15:00of the conversation. I'm not interested
  522. 15:02in the flowery language that you think
  523. 15:03makes you sound smart. So what I would
  524. 15:05like for you to do, please, is to
  525. 15:07actually derive the contradiction or
  526. 15:09whatever absurdity you think would would
  527. 15:11be entailed from not having um potency
  528. 15:14in your worldview.
  529. 15:15>> Okay. Can you let me speak for 15
  530. 15:17seconds?
  531. 15:17>> Okay, so what I need you to do is
  532. 15:19I will I will let you talk for minutes
  533. 15:21on end if you're actually addressing the
  534. 15:23substance. As soon as you start doing
  535. 15:25anything other than addressing the
  536. 15:26substance, I'm going to jump in again.
  537. 15:28That's going to happen every single time
  538. 15:30you talk, just so you know. So, if you
  539. 15:32don't want to get interrupted,
  540. 15:34just stick to the substance. If you
  541. 15:36don't If you don't stick to the
  542. 15:37substance, you know now and you have
  543. 15:40known for
  544. 15:41the mass support majority of this
  545. 15:43conversation, you have known that
  546. 15:45anytime you do anything other than
  547. 15:46substance, you are going to get cut off.
  548. 15:48So, if you would like to have the
  549. 15:49conversation, which I would love to do,
  550. 15:51we're going to stick to substance, okay?
  551. 15:53So, now I would love to stop talking
  552. 15:55about meta because I hate it.
  553. 15:57So, please just derive the contradiction
  554. 15:59or absurdity that is entailed from not
  555. 16:02having potency in your worldview.
  556. 16:04>> So, there's two approaches you could
  557. 16:06take. The first one would be to deny
  558. 16:08motion or the reality of motion at all.
  559. 16:12Um and this would be to say that um like
  560. 16:15something nothing can come from nothing,
  561. 16:19right? It's a impossible for something
  562. 16:20to come from nothing and therefore you
  563. 16:22just deny motion altogether, which would
  564. 16:24be completely contrary to the
  565. 16:26phenomenological evidence that we have
  566. 16:28presented in front of us. So, this is
  567. 16:31Wait, I thought you were going to let me
  568. 16:32talk. I thought you were going to let me
  569. 16:33talk. Cuz you said you would let me talk
  570. 16:35for a minute.
  571. 16:35>> just to deny motion?
  572. 16:37>> That's that is the approach of
  573. 16:38Parmenides, yes.
  574. 16:39>> Okay, and what's the second way?
  575. 16:41>> I thought you were going to let me talk
  576. 16:42for minutes on end. That's what you said
  577. 16:43would happen if I was just allowed to
  578. 16:45explain.
  579. 16:46>> sorry. I wanted to clarify. I apologize
  580. 16:48for clarifying.
  581. 16:50>> Yeah, so so that's that's known as
  582. 16:51monism, the first one.
  583. 16:53Um where where you deny motion
  584. 16:55altogether. And um he says that
  585. 16:58um
  586. 16:59being cannot be like multiplied or
  587. 17:01diversified by its own homogeneous self.
  588. 17:04And this is something I talked about
  589. 17:05with Dr. Blitz.
  590. 17:06Um and so he denies motion in general.
  591. 17:08>> it. What's the second one?
  592. 17:10>> Dude,
  593. 17:11I thought I was going to be able to
  594. 17:12talk. Like you you keep interrupting.
  595. 17:13>> the thing again where you weren't on
  596. 17:14substance and I told you that that was
  597. 17:16going
  598. 17:16>> I That's That's That's literally was
  599. 17:17100% substance. Everything I just said.
  600. 17:20>> No, because what you're supposed to be
  601. 17:21doing is providing You're supposed to
  602. 17:23You're You're saying What you're trying
  603. 17:24to do is say that there are only two
  604. 17:25ways to not have potency in your view. I
  605. 17:28need you to just tell me what those two
  606. 17:29ways are and then derive the
  607. 17:31contradiction or absurdity. But instead
  608. 17:33of doing that, you're just yapping. Now,
  609. 17:35I'm not interested in the yap. I just
  610. 17:36want you to I want the substance. So,
  611. 17:38you're saying the two ways
  612. 17:40So, here we'll label this two ways
  613. 17:42to not have potency in your worldview.
  614. 17:47And just tell me what they are without
  615. 17:48all the flowery nonsense.
  616. 17:49>> Yeah, so monism is problematic because
  617. 17:51it denies the phenomenological evidence
  618. 17:54that we have. And it leads to just an
  619. 17:56absurdity and epistemic like ridiculous
  620. 17:59conclusions. The second one, universal
  621. 18:01becoming, is where you are on the
  622. 18:03opposite end of the spectrum from
  623. 18:05monism. It's where you argue that
  624. 18:07everything is in motion and the process
  625. 18:09of becoming. And so, he says the
  626. 18:11distinction between non-being and being,
  627. 18:13this is Heraclitus, by the way.
  628. 18:16Um it is is simply abstract. And he
  629. 18:18denies the principle of
  630. 18:19non-contradiction, which is ridiculous.
  631. 18:24>> Okay, so what is the So, what you're
  632. 18:26saying is um
  633. 18:27I don't I don't know what you're talking
  634. 18:29about with this universal becoming. Is
  635. 18:30that what you're saying everything is
  636. 18:32pure act?
  637. 18:33>> Everything is in the process of
  638. 18:34becoming. He denies that there's any
  639. 18:36difference between being and non-being.
  640. 18:38He says there's no real distinction
  641. 18:40there. And he says it's simply abstract.
  642. 18:42And so, both of these, the first one
  643. 18:45leads to absurdity in denying the
  644. 18:47principle of non-contradiction, and the
  645. 18:49second one leads to absurdity in so far
  646. 18:51as it rejects phenomenological evidence.
  647. 18:54>> Okay, well, I'm just I'm going to take
  648. 18:56the first one. So, I need you to explain
  649. 18:58because I definitely deny motion.
  650. 19:01I don't think Well, let me let me
  651. 19:02clarify. I think that's smart.
  652. 19:05By motion, I assume you mean
  653. 19:06actualization of potential?
  654. 19:08>> Yeah.
  655. 19:08>> Oh, fantastic. I'm glad that I finally
  656. 19:10understood something.
  657. 19:11>> Or well, actually, let me let me let me
  658. 19:13clarify further. Non-being going to
  659. 19:15being.
  660. 19:20>> Um
  661. 19:21the problem that I have there is that if
  662. 19:23you're just saying that um the issue is
  663. 19:26uh denying non-being going to being,
  664. 19:28like
  665. 19:30I don't understand why we can't say that
  666. 19:32there are accounts for something coming
  667. 19:36into existence without invoking any
  668. 19:39potency. Like I don't understand why
  669. 19:41because it seems like what you're saying
  670. 19:42is that any any account of something
  671. 19:45coming into existence or changing in any
  672. 19:48way is necessarily potency, but that
  673. 19:51feels like you're just begging the
  674. 19:52question then.
  675. 19:53>> Yeah, so so you're you're arguing my
  676. 19:54perspective that potency is necessary.
  677. 19:56That that's kind of the whole point
  678. 19:57>> No, I'm not arguing your perspective.
  679. 19:59I'm telling you that it sounds like
  680. 20:00you're begging the question and I'm
  681. 20:01trying to help I'm asking you to help me
  682. 20:03understand how you're not just begging
  683. 20:05the question.
  684. 20:05>> Yeah. So, what what we can look at is
  685. 20:09um
  686. 20:10Should I wait until your your music gift
  687. 20:12is over?
  688. 20:13>> Yeah, and just so anybody knows, not
  689. 20:15that most of the people here probably
  690. 20:16care, but the music is I'm just going to
  691. 20:18block you, so.
  692. 20:19>> Okay.
  693. 20:19>> Anyway, um so it sounds like what you're
  694. 20:21saying is that necessarily any account
  695. 20:24or or any that there cannot be an
  696. 20:26account of uh change that doesn't
  697. 20:30involve act and potency and that just
  698. 20:32feels like begging the question.
  699. 20:33>> Yeah, no, that that that exactly pretty
  700. 20:36straightforward, but we we can talk
  701. 20:37about um
  702. 20:38like like an apple seed in a tree.
  703. 20:41By what means does an apple seed change
  704. 20:44into a tree?
  705. 20:48>> I I mean biological processes.
  706. 20:50>> Yeah, but but it changes. So, it there
  707. 20:52is the non-being of the tree and then
  708. 20:54there is the being of the tree. So, how
  709. 20:57do we if if non-being is completely
  710. 20:59incompatible with being, how does it go
  711. 21:02from non-being to being?
  712. 21:06>> You're just asking how change happens.
  713. 21:07Like I'm not I'm not saying change
  714. 21:09doesn't happen.
  715. 21:10>> So then you don't
  716. 21:11>> you
  717. 21:11>> So then you don't deny motion.
  718. 21:13>> Hold on. When I No, I
  719. 21:16You clarified
  720. 21:17that um
  721. 21:19Oh, no, again. So the whole thing that
  722. 21:21got us onto this was talking about act
  723. 21:23and potency. You said act and potency
  724. 21:25was necessary when you were discussing
  725. 21:27what unity and form are and that your
  726. 21:29your understanding of these things is
  727. 21:30based on there being act and potency. I
  728. 21:32deny the existence of potency and now
  729. 21:34what you're doing is you're saying that
  730. 21:36any change is necessarily actualization
  731. 21:39of potential.
  732. 21:40>> Yeah.
  733. 21:41>> Are you trying to say that it's it's
  734. 21:42necessarily like um non-being becoming
  735. 21:44being or whatever? But then now now
  736. 21:46you're not we're not talking about the
  737. 21:48act and potency stuff anymore. So it
  738. 21:50sounds like you you wanted to use act
  739. 21:51and potency in order to like undergird
  740. 21:54these definitions for the original
  741. 21:56argument that you gave and now that
  742. 21:57we're I'm pushing back on act and
  743. 21:59potency, you're running you are running
  744. 22:01away from act and potency. So um
  745. 22:04I'm I'm not saying change doesn't
  746. 22:05happen. Change does happen.
  747. 22:07>> Okay, that's motion.
  748. 22:09>> I'm saying that's fine. I'm saying there
  749. 22:11is no act and potency and if by motion
  750. 22:14you mean something other than act and
  751. 22:15potency, then this is not relevant to
  752. 22:17what I'm asking you about. I'm asking
  753. 22:19you to justify
  754. 22:20uh
  755. 22:22I'm asking you to justify that there is
  756. 22:24actualization of potential.
  757. 22:25>> Okay, look at your screen right now. You
  758. 22:27said specifically that you are going
  759. 22:30with number one, which denies motion.
  760. 22:33>> And then after I said that, I clarified
  761. 22:35by motion do you mean actualization of
  762. 22:37potential and you said no, you're just
  763. 22:38talking about uh the transition from
  764. 22:40non-being to being, correct?
  765. 22:43>> So so the non-being going to being
  766. 22:46>> would be would be the motion we're
  767. 22:48talking about. Change is motion.
  768. 22:50>> I'm just I'm just trying to clarify. Are
  769. 22:52am I correct that you're only defining
  770. 22:54motion as non-being transitioning to
  771. 22:56being?
  772. 22:56>> Well, yeah, because you deny potency
  773. 22:58right now. So that's how we're defining
  774. 23:00it.
  775. 23:00>> Okay, sure. So so there is So this stuff
  776. 23:03that we're talking about right now
  777. 23:05doesn't have this
  778. 23:08this stuff that we're talking about
  779. 23:09right now has nothing to do with active
  780. 23:11potency because you're redefining motion
  781. 23:13to not include active potency. So I so
  782. 23:15remember we were supposed to be talking
  783. 23:16about two ways to not have potency in
  784. 23:18your worldview. And so if you're
  785. 23:20defining motion as something that has
  786. 23:21nothing to do with potency, then I don't
  787. 23:23see how this is relevant to the thing
  788. 23:24that we were supposed to be talking
  789. 23:26about which is the the problem with not
  790. 23:28having potency in your worldview.
  791. 23:29>> Okay, so you
  792. 23:32so you you don't deny motion then.
  793. 23:35>> Um if depending on
  794. 23:37>> When when I say being non-being going to
  795. 23:39being, you you don't deny that.
  796. 23:42>> Um I I think that that's a weird way to
  797. 23:44phrase it, but I think if if all you're
  798. 23:46talking about is like something like a
  799. 23:48temporal change, I don't deny temporal
  800. 23:50change. And if you want to call that
  801. 23:52non-being going to being,
  802. 23:54fine. I wouldn't call it that, um but I
  803. 23:57I feel like if if we get into like the
  804. 23:59reason that I wouldn't call it that,
  805. 24:01then it's just going to go into like my
  806. 24:02metaphysics and stuff, and I'm not
  807. 24:04trying to like force you to debate me on
  808. 24:06my metaphysics. That seems irrelevant
  809. 24:08here. So I'm like willing to grant that
  810. 24:10that's like what change is, that it's,
  811. 24:12you know, being and non-being, but I
  812. 24:14don't well
  813. 24:16being um
  814. 24:20No, you know what? Um I I can't do that.
  815. 24:22Okay, I was trying to I was trying to
  816. 24:23grant as much as possible
  817. 24:25uh just to try to move the conversation
  818. 24:26forward, but I do think that we're going
  819. 24:27to end up having to get bogged down in
  820. 24:28the metaphysics, um because I'm I'm
  821. 24:32I'm an eternalist. So my my position is
  822. 24:35that um everything is actual. There are
  823. 24:38no non-actual
  824. 24:40anything. So like when there's change,
  825. 24:42it's just changing from uh with like
  826. 24:44temporal change, it's just a transition
  827. 24:46from one actual state of affairs to
  828. 24:48another actual state of affairs, and
  829. 24:49it's not actually anything coming into
  830. 24:51existence because each of those states
  831. 24:53of affairs was always actual.
  832. 24:55>> Okay, so like for example um is
  833. 25:00is an apple seed already a tree?
  834. 25:04>> Um so the seed is not the tree, but the
  835. 25:08chain of like the the process
  836. 25:12uh are each each phase of that existence
  837. 25:14each state of existence from, you know,
  838. 25:17the apple tree or excuse me, the seed uh
  839. 25:19going into the ground and then, you
  840. 25:21know, um taking the nutrients and and
  841. 25:23sprouting and becoming a tree. Like that
  842. 25:25whole series of events,
  843. 25:27every moment of that series is actual
  844. 25:30eternally.
  845. 25:31>> No, but I'm asking does the tree So,
  846. 25:33let's say we have a seed in my hand.
  847. 25:35Does the tree exist right now?
  848. 25:37>> Oh my god.
  849. 25:38>> Um no, it doesn't exist right now.
  850. 25:40>> Okay, so then my question is how is it
  851. 25:42going from non-being to being? That's
  852. 25:43the whole point of this discussion.
  853. 25:45>> Oh my god.
  854. 25:45>> Right, that's what I said is that I I I
  855. 25:47was trying to grant the non-being to
  856. 25:48being and now I'm realizing that um
  857. 25:52um that I I'm not able to grant as much
  858. 25:54as I wanted to cuz I was hoping that I
  859. 25:56could grant enough to try to move the
  860. 25:58conversation forward and not get bogged
  861. 25:59down in this metaphysics stuff and then
  862. 26:01I realized that unfortunately, I can't
  863. 26:03grant that uh because
  864. 26:05you know, it is uh germane to the
  865. 26:07argument. So, uh we are going to have to
  866. 26:08talk about the fact that I'm I'm going
  867. 26:10to say that each of those moments is
  868. 26:11actual. They're just not actual at the
  869. 26:13same time.
  870. 26:14>> No, so you just said that the tree is
  871. 26:16non-existent, which means it's
  872. 26:17non-being.
  873. 26:18>> No, no, no, no. No, no, I said the tree
  874. 26:20doesn't exist right now.
  875. 26:21>> Yeah, so that's that's That's what we're
  876. 26:23talking about.
  877. 26:23>> actual.
  878. 26:23>> So, no So, so if it doesn't exist at
  879. 26:26this moment, but then it does exist,
  880. 26:29what is causing that change?
  881. 26:31>> No, what I'm saying is there's a
  882. 26:32difference between being actual
  883. 26:34simpliciter and being actual in this
  884. 26:36moment. So, if if you're holding a seed
  885. 26:39and we know that that seed is going to
  886. 26:41become a tree or like it is the case
  887. 26:42that that seed is going to become a
  888. 26:43tree, then I would say that the tree
  889. 26:45doesn't exist in the moment when you're
  890. 26:47holding the seed, but that doesn't mean
  891. 26:49that when the tree comes in, you know,
  892. 26:51comes into existence to speak to say
  893. 26:53colloquially, that's not the tree um
  894. 26:55going from non-being to being, that's
  895. 26:57simply just like a progression of time
  896. 26:59from one actual state of affairs to
  897. 27:01another actual state of affairs. So, I
  898. 27:03think what you're getting tripped up on
  899. 27:05is just the temporal notion of it. So,
  900. 27:06what I'm saying is
  901. 27:08um
  902. 27:09the moment where
  903. 27:11you are holding the seed is actual, and
  904. 27:14the moment where that seed is a as no
  905. 27:16longer a seed and is instead become a
  906. 27:18tree, um that moment is also actual.
  907. 27:21They're just not actual at the same
  908. 27:23moment. So, that was when when you asked
  909. 27:25if you're holding the tree, or excuse
  910. 27:27me, if you're holding the seed, is the
  911. 27:28tree
  912. 27:29is the tree actual at that moment? No,
  913. 27:32but the tree is actual simpliciter at a
  914. 27:35future moment.
  915. 27:36>> Okay, so what distinguishes the seed
  916. 27:37from the tree?
  917. 27:40>> Um I mean, the the different properties
  918. 27:42that they have, like the different
  919. 27:44properties that
  920. 27:44>> Okay, so so how is this this universal
  921. 27:46being that you're referencing, this
  922. 27:47universal actuality, how is it being
  923. 27:50diversified among subjects if they
  924. 27:52aren't going from non-being to being?
  925. 27:55>> I don't know what you mean by
  926. 27:56diversified among subjects.
  927. 27:57>> So, you're saying that the seed has a
  928. 27:59different being than the tree does. How
  929. 28:02is this being being diversified among
  930. 28:05different subjects?
  931. 28:06>> about when you're saying it has a
  932. 28:07different being. I don't I don't know
  933. 28:08what you're saying.
  934. 28:09>> Is the is the seed different than the
  935. 28:10tree?
  936. 28:12>> Yeah, they have different properties,
  937. 28:13yeah.
  938. 28:13>> Yeah, okay, so how is there a
  939. 28:15diversification
  940. 28:17of the being of the seed and of the
  941. 28:19tree? Why are they diverse?
  942. 28:22>> When you're using the la- I don't
  943. 28:23understand the language diversification
  944. 28:24of being. Like, I'm not sure what you're
  945. 28:26talking about there. Can you like, I
  946. 28:28don't know, maybe
  947. 28:30use just natural language?
  948. 28:31>> I mean, that's pretty uh natural. Like,
  949. 28:32why is it being divided among different
  950. 28:34subjects? Is another way you could
  951. 28:36phrase it. Why does Why is there being
  952. 28:37over here and being over there?
  953. 28:42>> I don't know what you're talking about.
  954. 28:43I genuinely don't know what you're
  955. 28:44>> So, so So saying that the tree is
  956. 28:46different than the seed. So that means
  957. 28:48that there is being in the tree that is
  958. 28:50not the same as being in the seed. So
  959. 28:53why is it being divided or diversified
  960. 28:55among subjects?
  961. 29:02>> I don't I genuinely honestly I have no
  962. 29:04idea what it is that you're asking me.
  963. 29:05Like if you're asking why things have
  964. 29:08being like why anything exists at all,
  965. 29:10then I mean is that what you're asking
  966. 29:12me?
  967. 29:12>> No. No. So you're saying
  968. 29:14that the the the tree
  969. 29:16exists differently than the seed does.
  970. 29:21Correct?
  971. 29:22>> Okay. Yeah, there are things that have
  972. 29:23different properties than other things.
  973. 29:25>> But you're you're you're taking the view
  974. 29:27of this
  975. 29:28um universal and homogeneous being
  976. 29:30because you're denying that there's
  977. 29:32actual
  978. 29:33actualization of of non-being.
  979. 29:35>> Why When did I commit myself to
  980. 29:36homogeneity?
  981. 29:38>> Because you said that there's no such
  982. 29:40thing as non-being going to being and
  983. 29:41that everything is in actuality. So I'm
  984. 29:43referencing this universal actuality
  985. 29:45that you're talking about now.
  986. 29:48>> Okay, but what where where does the
  987. 29:49homogeneity come in?
  988. 29:51>> Because if there's one universal
  989. 29:52actuality, it's homogeneous because
  990. 29:55because actuality can't be divided by
  991. 29:58its own self.
  992. 30:00What would that even mean?
  993. 30:02>> I don't know what you're what you're
  994. 30:03talking about. I don't know what it
  995. 30:05means because I don't understand the
  996. 30:06phrases that you're using because you're
  997. 30:07you're
  998. 30:08um it seems like you're just using this
  999. 30:09like um
  1000. 30:11you know, scholastic language because
  1001. 30:14the I don't know. I assume because that
  1002. 30:15you feel like it makes you sound smart.
  1003. 30:16>> No, I I'm I'm using like pretty simple
  1004. 30:18language actually. So you're you're
  1005. 30:21you're saying that there's being that
  1006. 30:22exists and all things are simultaneously
  1007. 30:26in maybe not not simultaneously, but all
  1008. 30:28things are actual maybe just not in this
  1009. 30:31temporal moment.
  1010. 30:33>> Right.
  1011. 30:33>> And so I'm asking you if they are all
  1012. 30:35sharing in the same actuality, what is
  1013. 30:38diversifying them? Like what is placing
  1014. 30:41actuality in the seed versus actuality
  1015. 30:43in the tree.
  1016. 30:44>> No, nothing. Nothing has to place
  1017. 30:46actuality in them.
  1018. 30:47>> No, I So, then why why is it the Why is
  1019. 30:49it like that? Why is it I'm not saying
  1020. 30:50I'm not I'm not invoking a creator. I'm
  1021. 30:52This would be an invocation of potency
  1022. 30:54in the in the end. I'm asking you why
  1023. 30:57are you saying that it's in the tree in
  1024. 30:59one way and in the seed in a different
  1025. 31:01way? And when we say that they're in
  1026. 31:02each other different ways, what is the
  1027. 31:04different way that actuality is in one
  1028. 31:06subject versus the other subject?
  1029. 31:09>> I didn't say actuality was in things
  1030. 31:11differently. I said that the tree and
  1031. 31:12the seed have different properties.
  1032. 31:14>> Okay, so
  1033. 31:14>> That's all I ever said. I didn't say
  1034. 31:16actuality is is in them differently.
  1035. 31:18>> Are the properties actual?
  1036. 31:21>> Yeah.
  1037. 31:21>> Okay, so you said there's different
  1038. 31:23properties.
  1039. 31:24>> cash that out.
  1040. 31:25>> said there's different properties. What
  1041. 31:27is making them different from one
  1042. 31:29another if they are all actual?
  1043. 31:31>> Nothing's making them different.
  1044. 31:33>> oh my god, no. What constitutes them as
  1045. 31:35different from one another?
  1046. 31:39>> The The fact that the properties are
  1047. 31:41different?
  1048. 31:42>> Yeah, so I'm I'm asking you what
  1049. 31:43constitutes them as different.
  1050. 31:49>> I I don't know I I have no idea what
  1051. 31:51you're what you like what what does that
  1052. 31:52even mean? Like
  1053. 31:53>> [laughter]
  1054. 31:53>> different properties are different. Like
  1055. 31:54you don't think that like a seed is
  1056. 31:56different from a tree?
  1057. 31:57>> No, I do. I'm asking you why cuz I have
  1058. 31:59an I have an explanation and you don't.
  1059. 32:01I'm showing you the absurdity of your
  1060. 32:02position.
  1061. 32:03>> No, but I don't understand the question
  1062. 32:05that you're asking. Like what you're
  1063. 32:06saying is nonsense as far as I can tell.
  1064. 32:08>> No, it's not.
  1065. 32:09>> you're showing absurdity in my position.
  1066. 32:11You're just like I don't know. You're I
  1067. 32:13don't even know what you're asking for.
  1068. 32:15>> Yeah, so the fact that your brain is
  1069. 32:17breaking is showing the validity of this
  1070. 32:20argument and why it's so ridiculous.
  1071. 32:22>> of your argument. You're just using
  1072. 32:24language that like in some weird
  1073. 32:26idiosyncratic way where I don't know
  1074. 32:28what you're talking about is not you
  1075. 32:29showing there's a problem with my view.
  1076. 32:31I can't engage with what you're saying
  1077. 32:33because I don't understand what you're
  1078. 32:34saying. My goal here right now is to try
  1079. 32:37to understand what you're saying so that
  1080. 32:38I can engage with it and determine
  1081. 32:40whether or not you've exposed some
  1082. 32:42absurdity in my position. If you have,
  1083. 32:44I'll freely, absolutely admit that. Like
  1084. 32:46I have no problem. I have no like
  1085. 32:48allegiance to a particular position is
  1086. 32:50such that I'm going to hold on to it
  1087. 32:52when I have justification to let it go.
  1088. 32:53If you show me that there is a reason
  1089. 32:55for me to change my position, I will
  1090. 32:57immediately change my position. But I'm
  1091. 32:59not I'm not running away from some
  1092. 33:01reason that you've provided. As far as I
  1093. 33:03can tell, you're um well, basically
  1094. 33:06what's happening is I just don't
  1095. 33:07understand what you're saying, and so I
  1096. 33:09can't see how it applies to my view and
  1097. 33:11whether or not it provides justification
  1098. 33:13for me to change my view because I don't
  1099. 33:14understand what you're talking about. So
  1100. 33:16what I need you to do because I've said
  1101. 33:17this over and over and I've asked a
  1102. 33:19bunch of different questions in an
  1103. 33:21attempt to clarify, what I need you to
  1104. 33:23do is actually like clarify, please. And
  1105. 33:26so tell me in a way that I can
  1106. 33:27understand what it is that you're
  1107. 33:29talking about.
  1108. 33:30>> So,
  1109. 33:31I I I I I approached it before like a
  1110. 33:34college-level explanation, then I went
  1111. 33:35to a high school explanation. I'm going
  1112. 33:37to try and do it as as simple as I can,
  1113. 33:39and if this doesn't get through, then I
  1114. 33:40think we'll just have to have it like
  1115. 33:41we'll have to end the conversation cuz I
  1116. 33:43don't know how to break this down any
  1117. 33:45simpler. You're saying that a seed and a
  1118. 33:47tree, they're different from one another
  1119. 33:50according to their properties. And you
  1120. 33:52agreed that those properties were actual
  1121. 33:54because they are existing. There's
  1122. 33:56actualization of those properties. And
  1123. 33:58so I asked, what constitutes
  1124. 34:02one property over here, like being small
  1125. 34:04like a seed, as different from the
  1126. 34:08property of the tree being big, like an
  1127. 34:10oak tree. What is the constitutive
  1128. 34:12difference?
  1129. 34:16>> Like
  1130. 34:17you're asking why is small different
  1131. 34:20than big?
  1132. 34:21>> Sure.
  1133. 34:27>> You're asking why is small different
  1134. 34:29than big as if like like they're just
  1135. 34:32analytical.
  1136. 34:33Like what? Like obviously like what
  1137. 34:36small means and what big means it's just
  1138. 34:38like they're different concepts.
  1139. 34:40>> Yeah, so I'm breaking it down to the
  1140. 34:42level of non-being and being though.
  1141. 34:44Because you're you're trying to state
  1142. 34:45that everything is, you know, in this
  1143. 34:47state of actuality. And the actuality in
  1144. 34:50that case of small would actually be
  1145. 34:52identical to the actuality of big. So
  1146. 34:54I'm asking what is distinguishing them
  1147. 34:55from one another.
  1148. 34:58>> Um
  1149. 34:58I don't know what you mean by how small
  1150. 35:00and actual would be the same.
  1151. 35:02>> Okay, so do they have different
  1152. 35:03actualities?
  1153. 35:04>> They're only actual, but that doesn't
  1154. 35:05mean that they are the same property.
  1155. 35:07>> So do they have different actualities
  1156. 35:09then?
  1157. 35:10>> I don't know what you mean by different
  1158. 35:11actualities. Do you mean that like
  1159. 35:13they're just in some way different from
  1160. 35:15each other?
  1161. 35:17>> Yeah, yeah, so so what what
  1162. 35:18differentiates them? What is what is the
  1163. 35:19being non-being differentiation?
  1164. 35:22>> I mean that's just
  1165. 35:23I don't know what you mean by being
  1166. 35:25non-being differentiation.
  1167. 35:28>> Then I don't think that this
  1168. 35:29conversation will go any further cuz
  1169. 35:31like that's like the very basis of of
  1170. 35:33like our understanding of the world.
  1171. 35:35>> so so
  1172. 35:36perfect perfect
  1173. 35:40perfect.
  1174. 35:40>> being.
  1175. 35:41>> Okay, so you said there's no non-being.
  1176. 35:43When the seed is small, is it big at the
  1177. 35:46same time?
  1178. 35:48>> No.
  1179. 35:49>> Okay, so that means there's non-being.
  1180. 35:51It is not big.
  1181. 35:53>> No.
  1182. 35:54No, no, no, that's not No, you're you're
  1183. 35:56reifying like a lack of properties.
  1184. 35:58That's Maybe that's the problem. You're
  1185. 36:00like you're just trying to like reify
  1186. 36:01this this idea of something not having a
  1187. 36:03property. That's like saying that I like
  1188. 36:06that there was some ontological like
  1189. 36:09because I'm I'm fat and so like I don't
  1190. 36:12have the property of being skinny and
  1191. 36:14you're trying to say that that is some
  1192. 36:15like ontological that I have this like
  1193. 36:19the ontology or the the being of not
  1194. 36:21skinniness.
  1195. 36:22>> No, that's ridiculous. I wouldn't say
  1196. 36:24that you have being of non-skinniness. I
  1197. 36:27say that you're not skinny, meaning that
  1198. 36:29there is non-being. You are not skinny.
  1199. 36:32>> Yeah, but that's not non-being.
  1200. 36:33>> That is non-being. You're not skinny.
  1201. 36:36>> No, that's you're you're reifying like
  1202. 36:38the absence of something. So, that's I
  1203. 36:40think what the problem is here is you're
  1204. 36:41trying to reify the concept of nothing
  1205. 36:43or the concept of like a lack. So, a
  1206. 36:45lack isn't a thing. It's simply the
  1207. 36:47absence of something.
  1208. 36:48>> Yes, it's non-being. The absence of
  1209. 36:49something is non-being.
  1210. 36:51>> Again, you're you're reifying non-being
  1211. 36:53as far as I can tell. So, I don't know
  1212. 36:55how you're like I don't know how to
  1213. 36:58if if if you can't explain this in a way
  1214. 37:00where you don't like if you can't
  1215. 37:02explain this in a way that doesn't reify
  1216. 37:05uh a lack of something, then then I
  1217. 37:07would agree with you that the
  1218. 37:08conversation probably isn't going to go
  1219. 37:10any further.
  1220. 37:10>> So, wait wait wait. If we say
  1221. 37:13that something is, that is being,
  1222. 37:17correct?
  1223. 37:19>> Um it it has being like it has ontology.
  1224. 37:22>> So, if we say that something is not,
  1225. 37:26that would be non-being.
  1226. 37:28>> No, because that again sounds like
  1227. 37:30reification. That again sounds like
  1228. 37:31reification.
  1229. 37:32>> Okay, man. Well, then we're not we're
  1230. 37:33not going to get any further. If you
  1231. 37:34can't understand that, then I don't
  1232. 37:35think it's it's going to be a good
  1233. 37:36conversation anymore.
  1234. 37:38>> Yeah, I I I agree. Like if you if you
  1235. 37:40figure out a way that you can discuss
  1236. 37:42this without reifying a lack of
  1237. 37:43something, then I'd be happy to try to
  1238. 37:45continue the conversation. Um but it
  1239. 37:47sounds like that's what you're going to
  1240. 37:48ground out in is this reification of of
  1241. 37:51lacking a thing.
  1242. 37:52>> Yeah. All right, man. Well, God bless
  1243. 37:53you. I'll be praying for you. And uh if
  1244. 37:55you need anything, feel free to reach
  1245. 37:56out.
  1246. 37:57>> Yeah, I'll think for you. Have a good
  1247. 37:58one.
  1248. 37:58>> Yeah, all right. God bless, man.
  1249. 38:02What a conversation.
  1250. 38:03Um I think we we just saw very clearly
  1251. 38:06um you know, some of the absurdities of
  1252. 38:08atheism. I think it was presented very
  1253. 38:09clearly. Um guys, please please be nice
  1254. 38:12to him. Don't don't be mean. Um but that
  1255. 38:13was our debate with Ogar Debates.
  1256. 38:18Um Ogar Debates. So, thank you Ogar for
  1257. 38:20that wonderful conversation. Thank you
  1258. 38:22everybody for watching. Um please guys,
  1259. 38:24thank you so much for your support
  1260. 38:25lately. Um you know, share this to
  1261. 38:27friends. Do do whatever you need to do.
  1262. 38:29Like it. Subscribe if you're not
  1263. 38:30subscribed cuz like this uh I like I
  1264. 38:32know that that it's you know, like it's
  1265. 38:34entertaining from your side. It's a
  1266. 38:35quick 40-minute video, but like I'm
  1267. 38:37spending hours upon hours every day
  1268. 38:38studying this stuff so that I can, you
  1269. 38:40know, be more precise in my explanations
  1270. 38:42um and continue to proclaim the gospel.
  1271. 38:44So, your guys' support um really really
  1272. 38:46is helpful. I appreciate everybody that
  1273. 38:48watches these um and so yeah. If you're
  1274. 38:50not subscribed, please help me out and
  1275. 38:51subscribe. Like the video and and maybe
  1276. 38:53leave a comment on your thoughts. Um but
  1277. 38:54yeah, appreciate you guys. Thanks so
  1278. 38:56much for watching and God bless.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of ATHEIST ANGER! | “Does God Exist?” | DEBATE | Jesusandwhatnot vs Ogar by Jesus and Whatnot, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,831 words across 1,278 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.