At Her Wedding, My Sister Shoved Me Into the Deep End and Laughed—She Knew I Couldn't Swim — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00"Relax, Erica. It was just for fun." My
- 0:02sister said, laughing, while two
- 0:04strangers dragged me out of the deep end
- 0:06by my arms.
- 0:07I was on my hands and knees on the wet
- 0:09tile, coughing up chlorine, my green
- 0:11dress plastered to me like a second
- 0:13skin, and she was already turning to the
- 0:15crowd with her champagne flute raised,
- 0:18soaking up the laughter like it was
- 0:19applause.
- 0:21She knew I couldn't swim.
- 0:22She knew why. She had been standing on
- 0:24the dock the day it happened.
- 0:27My name is Erica Anderson. I'm 28 years
- 0:29old, and for most of my life I believed
- 0:32the safest thing I could do around my
- 0:34older sister was be small.
- 0:36Kayla is 31. She's the kind of person
- 0:38people describe with words like magnetic
- 0:40and fearless and so much fun. My
- 0:43parents, Donald and Sharon, said those
- 0:45words constantly. If Kayla broke
- 0:47something, it was spirit. If Kayla said
- 0:50something cruel, it was honesty. If
- 0:52Kayla embarrassed me in front of
- 0:53company, I was told to lighten up, and I
- 0:56learned to do it fast with a smile,
- 0:59before anyone could call me sensitive.
- 1:01When I was six, we spent a Fourth of
- 1:03July weekend at a lake in northern
- 1:05Michigan. Kayla was nine.
- 1:07She decided we were going to play a game
- 1:10where she held me under the water and
- 1:11counted, and I was supposed to see how
- 1:13long I could last.
- 1:15I remember her hand on top of my head. I
- 1:17remember the green light overhead
- 1:19getting farther away, and the sound of
- 1:21my own heartbeat in my ears. I remember
- 1:24thinking, very clearly, that she wasn't
- 1:26going to let go.
- 1:28She did let go eventually. A man from
- 1:30the next cabin had seen it from his dock
- 1:32and came running. My mother cried. My
- 1:35father yelled at the man for
- 1:36overreacting. Kayla said we were only
- 1:38playing. Later that night, over s'mores,
- 1:41my father decided the whole thing was a
- 1:43misunderstanding, and that was the
- 1:46version of the story that lived in our
- 1:47house for the next 22 years.
- 1:50I never got in water above my waist
- 1:52again. Not at friends' pool parties. Not
- 1:55on the one cruise my parents took us on.
- 1:58I learned to sit on the edge with a book
- 2:00and say I didn't feel like swimming.
- 2:02I'm a pediatric nurse now. I spend my
- 2:04days calming scared kids down and I'm
- 2:06good at it because I know exactly what
- 2:08fear looks like from the inside. But I
- 2:11have never once been calm near deep
- 2:13water.
- 2:14So when Kayla got engaged to Evan Wells
- 2:16last spring, I did what I always did. I
- 2:19swallowed everything and showed up.
- 2:21Evan was a structural engineer at Duncan
- 2:23Engineering. A steady, soft-spoken guy
- 2:26with kind eyes and a habit of really
- 2:28listening when you talked, which was a
- 2:30novelty in my family.
- 2:32He'd come into Kayla's life about a year
- 2:34and a half earlier. I liked him
- 2:36immediately and I think he liked me
- 2:38because I was the only member of the
- 2:40Anderson family who asked him questions
- 2:42about himself.
- 2:44The wedding was at a resort in Traverse
- 2:46City, Michigan. All white stucco and
- 2:48tall pines and a long glittering pool
- 2:50that ran along the back of the main
- 2:52terrace.
- 2:53Kayla chose it because it photographed
- 2:55well. 90 guests, a string quartet, a
- 2:58sparkler send-off. I was her maid of
- 3:01honor, which I'd agreed to in the same
- 3:03breath I'd tried to say no.
- 3:05For eight months I'd driven out to
- 3:07bridal appointments on my days off,
- 3:09hand-addressed envelopes, mediated
- 3:11fights between her and the florist, and
- 3:14listened to her explain why a seating
- 3:15chart was a moral issue. My mother told
- 3:18me I was doing a wonderful thing for my
- 3:19sister. I told myself, "Maybe this was
- 3:22the part where we finally grew up."
- 3:25The ceremony was lovely, honestly.
- 3:27Kayla cried in the right places. Evan's
- 3:30hand shook when he said his vows and
- 3:32that made my throat ache a little
- 3:34because he sounded like he meant every
- 3:35word.
- 3:36Dinner ran long. There were toasts. Mine
- 3:39was short and warm and I'd practiced it
- 3:41in the bathroom mirror until I could say
- 3:43it without my voice cracking.
- 3:45Kayla hugged me afterward and whispered,
- 3:48"Perfect. Now don't make it weird."
- 3:51Then the reception moved out onto the
- 3:52pool deck, and the night went soft and
- 3:54loud.
- 3:56String lights over the water, a DJ,
- 3:58bartenders pouring something blue and
- 4:00sparkling.
- 4:01Kayla changed into a short white dress
- 4:03and went from group to group like she
- 4:05was working a campaign.
- 4:07She was drinking fast. I know that look
- 4:09on her. The attention wasn't enough
- 4:11anymore, and she needed a target.
- 4:14At around 10:00, she found me by the bar
- 4:17standing with a cluster of Evan's
- 4:18coworkers from Duncan Engineering.
- 4:21I was talking to a woman about her kids.
- 4:23Kayla slid an arm around my shoulders
- 4:25and announced to the group that I was
- 4:27the one who doesn't do fun, that I'd
- 4:30been boring since birth, that if they
- 4:32wanted a good time, they should stay
- 4:34away from the nurse.
- 4:36People laughed politely. The way people
- 4:38do when they aren't sure if it's a joke.
- 4:41I smiled, took a breath, and said I was
- 4:43going to get some air.
- 4:45That's all. I walked to the far end of
- 4:47the deck where the tile ran close to the
- 4:49edge because it was the only quiet
- 4:51corner left. I stood there with my back
- 4:54to everyone looking at the lights
- 4:56wobbling on the surface of the water,
- 4:58my heart doing its small familiar
- 5:00kicking thing.
- 5:01I heard heels behind me, fast ones.
- 5:04Then two hands hit me square between the
- 5:06shoulder blades, hard with her whole
- 5:08weight behind them.
- 5:10I don't remember falling. I remember the
- 5:12cold, a slap of it over my face, and
- 5:14then the awful floating weightlessness
- 5:16of having no floor.
- 5:18I opened my mouth to scream and the pool
- 5:20poured in. I kicked and my feet found
- 5:22nothing. I clawed upward, broke the
- 5:25surface for half a second, saw a blur of
- 5:27lights and a swirl of faces, and went
- 5:29under again.
- 5:30My dress felt like a hundred pounds.
- 5:33Chlorine burned my nose and throat.
- 5:35I was six years old again, and the green
- 5:37light was getting farther away.
- 5:39When I came up the second time, I saw
- 5:41her. Kayla was at the edge, one hand on
- 5:44her hip, the other clutching her glass,
- 5:46bent over with laughter.
- 5:48Behind her, my parents stood at the
- 5:50rail.
- 5:51My father was shaking his head with a
- 5:52half grin. My mother had her hand to her
- 5:54mouth, but she wasn't gasping. She was
- 5:57giggling.
- 5:58No one in my family moved.
- 6:01A man I'd never met, a tall guy in a
- 6:03gray suit, was the one who went in. He
- 6:05didn't even take off his shoes. He hit
- 6:07the water, got an arm around my chest,
- 6:09and said close to my ear, "I've got you.
- 6:12I've got you. Stop fighting me. I've got
- 6:14you." Another guest hauled me up by the
- 6:16wrists. I landed on the tile coughing so
- 6:18hard I thought my ribs would crack.
- 6:21Somebody put a jacket over my shoulders.
- 6:23Somebody was crying. It might have been
- 6:25me.
- 6:26The music had stopped. 90 people stood
- 6:29in a ragged circle, and the only sound
- 6:31was my gagging and, over it, Kayla's
- 6:33voice, bright and breezy.
- 6:36"Oh my god, she's fine. You guys, it was
- 6:37just for fun. Erica, stop being so
- 6:40dramatic."
- 6:41Then my mother was kneeling beside me,
- 6:43but she wasn't asking if I was okay.
- 6:46She pressed a thin pool towel into my
- 6:48hands and hissed,
- 6:49"Get up, Erica. You're making a scene on
- 6:51her wedding night. Everyone is staring."
- 6:54I looked up at her, water streaming down
- 6:57my face, and I understood something I'd
- 6:59been avoiding for 22 years.
- 7:01My mother wasn't embarrassed that I'd
- 7:03nearly drowned. She was embarrassed that
- 7:05I'd made it visible.
- 7:07And that was when I saw Evan.
- 7:09He was standing near the patio doors
- 7:11with his tie loosened, and a glass in
- 7:13his hand he'd forgotten to drink from.
- 7:15His face had gone gray.
- 7:17He wasn't looking at me. He was looking
- 7:20at his wife, not the way a groom looks
- 7:22at a bride,
- 7:23the way you look at a stranger you've
- 7:25just realized is standing in your
- 7:27kitchen.
- 7:28Then he set his glass down on a table
- 7:30very carefully and walked inside.
- 7:33I couldn't stay out there.
- 7:35I climbed to my feet with the man in the
- 7:36gray suit holding my elbow, and I let
- 7:38him walk me to a side entrance.
- 7:40His name was Jared. He was a high school
- 7:43swim coach, a friend of Evan's from
- 7:44college, and he said quietly, "I'm so
- 7:47sorry. I'm so so sorry. I'd have gone in
- 7:50sooner, but I thought for a second it
- 7:52might be, I don't know, planned." Which
- 7:55made it worse, somehow, that a stranger
- 7:57had needed that second to understand
- 7:59what my family hadn't.
- 8:01My room was on the ground floor, down a
- 8:03long tiled hallway that smelled like
- 8:04lilies.
- 8:06I was dripping on the tile, holding my
- 8:08shoes in one hand, when I heard voices
- 8:10from the alcove around the corner, near
- 8:12the ice machines. I stopped.
- 8:15I didn't mean to listen. I just couldn't
- 8:17make my legs move.
- 8:19She could have drowned, Kayla.
- 8:20Evan's voice, low, shaking. You know she
- 8:23can't swim. You know what happened to
- 8:25her.
- 8:26Oh my god, Evan, don't. Kayla,
- 8:28impatient, bored. She's fine. She loves
- 8:31making everything about her.
- 8:32It's my wedding, and for once she was
- 8:34going to be the one everyone looked at.
- 8:36I just evened it out.
- 8:38You pushed her into a pool on purpose.
- 8:41It was funny. Everyone was laughing.
- 8:44Nobody was laughing, Kayla. A long
- 8:46pause. I watch watch your face. You were
- 8:48enjoying it.
- 8:49Oh, please. She was seven. It was a
- 8:51stupid lake. She's been milking it for
- 8:5320 years.
- 8:55She was six, Evan said. I'd never heard
- 8:57him sound like that. I've heard the
- 8:59story from you.
- 9:01You told me you held her under to teach
- 9:03her to be brave.
- 9:04Kayla laughed, actually laughed.
- 9:07Well, it didn't work, did it? There was
- 9:09a silence so long I could hear the ice
- 9:11machine humming. When Evan spoke again,
- 9:13his voice had gone flat and cold.
- 9:16That's what I needed to hear.
- 9:18I backed away before either of them
- 9:20turned the corner. I went to my room,
- 9:22peeled off the dress, stood under the
- 9:24hottest shower I could stand, and sat on
- 9:26the bathroom floor wrapped in a towel
- 9:28until the shaking stopped. At some point
- 9:30I texted my best friend, Dana, three
- 9:33words, she pushed me.
- 9:35Dana called four times. I didn't pick
- 9:37up.
- 9:39At 6:40 the next morning, a shriek tore
- 9:42through the resort.
- 9:43I'd barely slept, and I came out into
- 9:45the hallway in a hotel robe to find half
- 9:47a dozen guests and a startled
- 9:49housekeeper standing outside the
- 9:50honeymoon suite.
- 9:52Kayla was in the doorway in her slip,
- 9:54her makeup smeared, holding her phone
- 9:56out like a weapon.
- 9:58"He's gone!" she was screaming. "His car
- 10:01is gone, his bags are gone, he won't
- 10:03pick up, he's gone!"
- 10:04Evan had checked out at 4:30 in the
- 10:06morning.
- 10:08The front desk clerk, who looked like he
- 10:10wanted to disappear into the floor,
- 10:12said,
- 10:13"The groom had paid the remaining
- 10:14balance on the room block and left a
- 10:16note for the staff to be kind to his
- 10:18wife."
- 10:19Kayla found me at the breakfast buffet
- 10:21an hour later. She came in swinging,
- 10:23loud enough to turn heads. She said I'd
- 10:26poisoned him. She said I'd ruined her
- 10:28wedding, that I'd always been jealous,
- 10:31that I'd gotten into Evan's ear with
- 10:32some sob story to wreck the best day of
- 10:34her life.
- 10:36My parents flanked her like bodyguards.
- 10:38My father said I should have apologized
- 10:40last night, that I'd let everything
- 10:42fester, and that now we all had to clean
- 10:44it up.
- 10:45My mother cried into a napkin and said,
- 10:48"I don't understand why you do this to
- 10:50her."
- 10:51I put down my coffee.
- 10:52"I nearly drowned," I said, "last night
- 10:54in front of all of you."
- 10:56"You're being dramatic," my mother said.
- 10:59For the first time in my life, I didn't
- 11:01say I was sorry.
- 11:03My phone buzzed against the table.
- 11:05A text from an unknown number.
- 11:08Erica, it's Evan. I got your number from
- 11:10the guest list. Can you meet me?
- 11:12There's a coffee place at the Marriott
- 11:13down the road. Please don't tell anyone.
- 11:16I told my family I needed a shower and
- 11:18walked out the side door.
- 11:20Evan was in a back booth in yesterday's
- 11:22dress shirt, still in his wedding
- 11:24slacks, a cold coffee in front of him.
- 11:27He stood when he saw me, and for a
- 11:29second I thought he might cry.
- 11:31He didn't. He looked like a man who had
- 11:33finally been woken up.
- 11:35"I owe you an apology," he said. "Not
- 11:36for her, for me. I should have gone in
- 11:39the second you went under. I froze. I've
- 11:41never frozen in my life, and I froze.
- 11:44You're not the one who pushed me.
- 11:46No."
- 11:47He rubbed his face. "But I'm the one who
- 11:49married her."
- 11:50He slid a folder across the table.
- 11:52"I need to show you something. I think
- 11:54you're about to get a lot of phone
- 11:55calls, and I want you to know the truth
- 11:57first."
- 11:59He told me he'd driven home to the
- 12:00townhouse they'd bought together, a
- 12:02place they'd moved into 3 months before
- 12:04the wedding, and sat in the driveway for
- 12:06an hour.
- 12:08Then he went inside and, for the first
- 12:10time, opened the locked drawer in the
- 12:11spare room she called her office.
- 12:14She'd told him it was for wedding
- 12:16paperwork. He'd never pried.
- 12:19Inside were credit card statements. Not
- 12:21his, not hers. Cards in his name, six of
- 12:24them, with his social security number,
- 12:25his date of birth, his signature, in
- 12:28handwriting that was almost his and not
- 12:30quite. Opened over the past 10 months.
- 12:33Balances totaling $71,000.
- 12:36Cash advances, luxury boutiques, a
- 12:38deposit on a Cabo vacation she'd never
- 12:41mentioned, and a transfer $34,000
- 12:45from the joint savings account they'd
- 12:46opened for their house down payment into
- 12:49an account that belonged to Kayla alone.
- 12:51"I don't know what she was planning,"
- 12:53Evan said.
- 12:54"Maybe she thought I'd never look.
- 12:57Maybe she thought the marriage would
- 12:58make it harder for me to do anything
- 12:59about it."
- 13:01He gave a hollow laugh.
- 13:03"She told me last night that you were
- 13:04milking a childhood accident for
- 13:06attention, but the thing I kept thinking
- 13:08driving home was that she'd never once
- 13:11been afraid you'd tell anyone.
- 13:13She'd never been afraid of anyone
- 13:16because everyone in your family kept her
- 13:17safe from the consequences of
- 13:19everything."
- 13:21"What are you going to do?" I asked.
- 13:23"Annulment. Fraud," he said it calmly.
- 13:26"My attorney's already got the
- 13:27statements. The credit bureaus have
- 13:29fraud holds. And Erica, the resort has a
- 13:32videographer who was filming the whole
- 13:34reception for our wedding film. Jared
- 13:36found him this morning. He caught the
- 13:38whole thing. The push, the water, your
- 13:41parents laughing, all of it." "The raw
- 13:43footage is on a drive in my pocket."
- 13:45I stared at him. "Why are you telling me
- 13:47this?"
- 13:49"Because you get to decide what happens
- 13:50with that video, not me."
- 13:52He pushed a second folder across. "This
- 13:54is a copy. It's yours."
- 13:57I held it in both hands. It weighed
- 13:59almost nothing.
- 14:00I drove home the next day alone with the
- 14:03folder on the passenger seat. I did not
- 14:05go to my parents' house.
- 14:07By Wednesday, Kayla had been served.
- 14:10Evan's lawyer filed for annulment on
- 14:12grounds of fraud, and the bank flagged
- 14:14the transfer as unauthorized. My phone
- 14:17started lighting up before I'd even
- 14:18unpacked.
- 14:20My mother called 11 times in one
- 14:22afternoon. When I finally picked up, she
- 14:24was sobbing so hard I could barely
- 14:26understand her. "Erica, please please
- 14:29talk to Evan.
- 14:30Tell him it was a misunderstanding. Tell
- 14:32him you're not hurt. Kayla's life is
- 14:34falling apart. You have to fix this."
- 14:37"I can't fix it, Mom," I said. "I didn't
- 14:39break it."
- 14:41"She's your sister."
- 14:43"She held my head underwater when I was
- 14:44six and pushed me into a pool when I was
- 14:4728," I said. "And both times you told me
- 14:50it was nothing.
- 14:51That's not fair.
- 14:53You told me to stop making a scene while
- 14:55I was throwing up chlorine on a
- 14:57stranger's shoes."
- 14:59My father got on the line then in his
- 15:00low courtroom voice, the one that used
- 15:02to end every argument. He said I was
- 15:05tearing the family apart.
- 15:07He said I owed Kayla loyalty.
- 15:09He said if I had any decency, I'd call
- 15:11Evan and say I'd been drinking and
- 15:13overreacted.
- 15:14"I was drinking club soda, Dad," I said,
- 15:17"and I couldn't breathe."
- 15:19He hung up on me. 10 minutes later, my
- 15:21mother texted, "Kayla needs $30,000 by
- 15:24Friday or the bank is going to go after
- 15:27us.
- 15:27We co-signed the loan for the wedding.
- 15:29Can you help?"
- 15:31I read it three times. I hadn't known
- 15:33they'd co-signed anything.
- 15:35$85,000 of wedding put on my parents'
- 15:38retirement age credit
- 15:40with Kayla swearing she and Evan would
- 15:42cover it. Evan wasn't going to cover it.
- 15:44Evan had never been told.
- 15:46I didn't answer.
- 15:48On Thursday, I did what my family had
- 15:50never imagined I would do.
- 15:52I wrote a long message, clear and calm,
- 15:55and I sent it to the extended family
- 15:56group chat that included 41 relatives,
- 15:59aunts, uncles, cousins, my grandmother's
- 16:02side, all the people who sent Kayla
- 16:04birthday emojis, and called her the star
- 16:07of the family.
- 16:08I told them what happened at the lake
- 16:10when I was six.
- 16:11I told them what happened at the resort.
- 16:14I attached the video file.
- 16:16Then I attached photos of the credit
- 16:17card statements, which Evan's attorney
- 16:20had said I could share since they were
- 16:22already part of the filing.
- 16:24There was silence for almost an hour.
- 16:26Then my aunt Rita wrote in all caps,
- 16:28"What is this?" My cousin Amy wrote, "I
- 16:30am so sorry, Erica. I didn't know." Then
- 16:33my grandmother, who is 86 and has never
- 16:36once typed a message without a typo,
- 16:39wrote the cleanest sentence I've ever
- 16:40seen from her.
- 16:42"I should have protected you both
- 16:43better. Come see me."
- 16:45By Friday, the family had split in half,
- 16:48and the half that mattered was on my
- 16:49side.
- 16:51I won't pretend I felt triumphant. I sat
- 16:53on my couch that weekend feeling
- 16:54hollowed out the way you feel after a
- 16:56fever breaks. Dana came over with
- 16:59takeout, and we watched dumb TV.
- 17:01On Sunday afternoon, I got a call from
- 17:03Jared. He'd gotten my number from Evan.
- 17:06He asked if I'd ever considered lessons,
- 17:08then immediately apologized for how it
- 17:10sounded.
- 17:11"I'm serious," he said. "No pressure. I
- 17:15teach adults who are scared of the water
- 17:16all the time. We could start in the
- 17:18shallow end. You could stand there and
- 17:20just get used to it. I said I'd think
- 17:23about it. I thought about it for months.
- 17:26Kayla's collapse was not quick and it
- 17:28was not quiet.
- 17:29The annulment went through in under 2
- 17:31months.
- 17:32Evan's attorney, along with the bank's
- 17:34fraud unit and a county detective,
- 17:37pursued the identity theft case. Kayla
- 17:39had opened those accounts using Evan's
- 17:41information before they were even
- 17:43married. Which made it fraud rather than
- 17:46a marital dispute. She'd sold real
- 17:48estate in Michigan for 6 years and her
- 17:50brokerage let her go within a week of
- 17:52the video circulating among clients. And
- 17:56I'd later learn one of her bigger
- 17:57sellers, who happened to be Jared's
- 17:59cousin.
- 18:00Her license was suspended pending an
- 18:02investigation.
- 18:04My parents sold their lake property to
- 18:06cover the co-signed loan, the same lake.
- 18:09I thought about that for a long time.
- 18:11In January, I received a subpoena to
- 18:14testify, which I had expected. I sat in
- 18:16a courthouse hallway in a navy blazer
- 18:18with a paper cup of terrible coffee.
- 18:20Evan was across from me. He nodded. I
- 18:23nodded back. Jared was there, too, in a
- 18:25suit that didn't fit him right because
- 18:28he'd asked the prosecutor if he could
- 18:30give a statement and and been told he'd
- 18:32be called.
- 18:33Kayla came down the hallway between my
- 18:35parents. She was in a gray cardigan, no
- 18:38makeup, her hair pulled back.
- 18:41She looked 10 years older and more than
- 18:42anything, she looked surprised as though
- 18:46someone had told her the world was going
- 18:47to keep rewarding her and she had
- 18:49trusted them.
- 18:50My mother caught my eye across the hall
- 18:52and mouthed, "Please."
- 18:54I looked at her and I felt nothing but a
- 18:57calm so deep it surprised me.
- 18:59Inside, I testified for 40 minutes. The
- 19:02prosecutor played the resort video on a
- 19:04screen the size of a refrigerator.
- 19:07The courtroom watched Kayla's hands hit
- 19:09my back. They watched me go under. They
- 19:11watched my father grin. They watched my
- 19:14mother laugh into her palm. The judge, a
- 19:16woman in her 60s with reading glasses on
- 19:19a chain, took off those glasses at the
- 19:21end and rubbed the bridge of her nose.
- 19:24Kayla pleaded to six counts of identity
- 19:26theft and one count of fraud. She was
- 19:29sentenced to 3 years of probation, 200
- 19:32hours of community service, a full
- 19:34restitution order of $71,000 to Evan and
- 19:38the creditors, and a felony on her
- 19:40record that would follow her to every
- 19:42job application for the rest of her
- 19:44life.
- 19:45Her real estate license was permanently
- 19:47revoked. When the judge read it out, my
- 19:49sister turned and looked at me, and for
- 19:51the first time since I was a child, I
- 19:53saw real fear on her face.
- 19:55Not anger, fear. The kind she'd watched
- 19:58me feel years ago from a dock.
- 20:01My parents had to cosign an installment
- 20:03plan to keep her out of county jail.
- 20:05I watched my father sign it at a clerk's
- 20:07window in the hallway, his hand slow on
- 20:09the pen.
- 20:11My mother holding his elbow like he
- 20:12might fall. Then all three of them came
- 20:15toward me.
- 20:16I was standing by the courthouse doors
- 20:18with my coat half-buttoned. I could have
- 20:20left through the side exit. I didn't.
- 20:23"Are you happy now?" Kayla said. Her
- 20:25voice was hoarse. There was no sparkle
- 20:27in it, no audience. "You got everything
- 20:29you wanted, a felony."
- 20:32"Do you know I can't even rent an
- 20:33apartment?"
- 20:34"I didn't want any of it," I said.
- 20:36"I wanted you to take your hands off my
- 20:38back."
- 20:39"It was a joke, Erica. It was always a
- 20:41joke."
- 20:42"You said that at the lake, too."
- 20:45Her mouth opened and nothing came out.
- 20:47I realized she had never once had to
- 20:49answer that sentence.
- 20:51My father stepped in, and for the first
- 20:53time his courtroom voice wasn't there.
- 20:55"We lost the lake house," he said.
- 20:57"We're living in a condo with our grown
- 20:59daughter. Is that enough? Can we be a
- 21:01family again now?"
- 21:03"You laughed at," I said.
- 21:05"You stood at that rail and grinned
- 21:07while I was going under."
- 21:09"I watched the video in front of a judge
- 21:10and saw it again."
- 21:12"I didn't think you were really in
- 21:13danger."
- 21:14"I know. That's the whole problem."
- 21:17My mother started to cry. The napkin
- 21:19kind of crying, the kind that had always
- 21:21ended arguments in my house. She reached
- 21:24for my sleeve. "Please, we're your
- 21:26parents."
- 21:27I stepped back so her hand fell away.
- 21:30"Parents would have jumped in. A
- 21:31stranger who didn't know my name did."
- 21:34Nobody said anything. Wind pushed a
- 21:36paper cup across the steps.
- 21:39"Here is what happens now," I said. I
- 21:41was surprised by how steady I sounded.
- 21:43"I won't pay for anything. Not the
- 21:45restitution, not the condo, not a single
- 21:47dollar of that loan. I won't come to
- 21:49holidays. I won't pick up when you call.
- 21:52If one of you is ever sick, the hospital
- 21:54can reach me through Grandma and I'll
- 21:56decide then. That's all I'm offering and
- 21:59it isn't a punishment. It's a door I'm
- 22:01finally closing."
- 22:03"You can't just erase us," my mother
- 22:05whispered.
- 22:06"I'm not erasing you. I'm leaving the
- 22:08room you made me stand in."
- 22:11Kayla stared at me with her arms wrapped
- 22:13around her gray cardigan and she looked
- 22:15for 1 second, exactly like the
- 22:179-year-old on the dock, caught and
- 22:20bewildered that the rules had changed.
- 22:22Then my father took her by the shoulder
- 22:25and steered her toward the parking lot.
- 22:27My mother looked back twice. I let her.
- 22:30She left me a long voicemail in March
- 22:32saying I'd taken everything from them. I
- 22:34listened to it once, then deleted it.
- 22:37"I didn't take anything. I just stopped
- 22:39holding the door shut while the water
- 22:41came in."
- 22:42In April, I put on a plain black
- 22:44swimsuit I'd bought 3 weeks earlier and
- 22:46still hadn't worn and I drove to the
- 22:48community center where Jared coaches.
- 22:51It was 7:00 in the morning.
- 22:53The pool was empty, flat and pale blue
- 22:55under the fluorescent lights. I stood at
- 22:57the edge of the shallow end with my arms
- 23:00wrapped around myself.
- 23:02"You don't have to go anywhere," Jared
- 23:03said, in the shallows, knee-deep,
- 23:05patient as a fence post.
- 23:08"Just put your feet in. That's the whole
- 23:10assignment today."
- 23:11I put my feet in.
- 23:13It was freezing.
- 23:14My heart hammered. I stood there for 20
- 23:17full minutes, breathing while the water
- 23:19lapped my ankles, and nothing grabbed
- 23:21me, and nobody laughed, and no one told
- 23:24me to stop being dramatic.
- 23:26On the way home, I stopped at my
- 23:27grandmother's house. She was waiting on
- 23:30the porch with iced tea and two lemon
- 23:32bars, and she took my hand in both of
- 23:34hers, dry and papery and warm.
- 23:37"I should have said something when you
- 23:38were six,"
- 23:40she told me.
- 23:41"You're saying it now," I said.
- 23:43She nodded, and her eyes filled up.
- 23:46"Then you tell me how I can make it
- 23:47right."
- 23:48"Just keep showing up," I said. "That's
- 23:50all."
- 23:51Evan sent me a card in June. He'd paid
- 23:53back what he could, sold the townhouse,
- 23:55and moved to Seattle for a job. Inside
- 23:58the card was a short note.
- 24:00"Thank you for telling the truth when it
- 24:01cost you. I hope the water is warm."
- 24:04He'd tucked a gift card in for a swim
- 24:06shop.
- 24:07I bought a pair of goggles.
- 24:09I'm in the deep end now some mornings,
- 24:11not far from the wall.
- 24:13Jared floats beside me, calling out
- 24:15cues, and I kick and breathe and kick
- 24:17and breathe, and the water holds me up
- 24:19now instead of pulling me down. Some
- 24:21days my arms ache. Some days I laugh out
- 24:24loud into the surface and swallow half
- 24:26the pool and come up grinning.
- 24:29Kayla still sends me messages from
- 24:30numbers I haven't blocked yet. The
- 24:32latest one said, "You ruined my life
- 24:35over a joke."
- 24:36I looked at it for a while. Then I typed
- 24:39one sentence and sent it.
- 24:41"No, Kayla. You let go of the dock, and
- 24:43you finally hit the water."
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of At Her Wedding, My Sister Shoved Me Into the Deep End and Laughed—She Knew I Couldn't Swim by Lovers Revenge Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,553 words across 714 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.