Arundhati Roy: How to Survive Authoritarianism | The Interview — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00People are arrested for things they say
- 0:01on Facebook, on Twitter. Like in the US,
- 0:05it seems new to you, but we have been
- 0:08living with this and is increasingly
- 0:10becoming normalized.
- 0:12[Music]
- 0:13Writer
- 0:16Aaron Dati Roy sees disturbing parallels
- 0:19between what's happening in the United
- 0:21States and what she's experienced in her
- 0:23native India, where censorship
- 0:25campaigns, book banning, and other
- 0:27assaults on freedom of expression are
- 0:30becoming more common. Royy's debut
- 0:32novel, The God of Small Things, made her
- 0:34a global literary star in 1997. She won
- 0:37the Booker Prize and was interviewed
- 0:39around the world. The advantage that I
- 0:42have in my book is that it offends
- 0:45everybody a little bit.
- 0:46>> Afterward though, she turned to
- 0:48non-fiction and activism. It's work that
- 0:51has put her personally at risk. Royce
- 0:54spent a day in jail in 2002 for contempt
- 0:57after criticizing India's Supreme Court.
- 1:02And more recently, she's been targeted
- 1:04by India's current government under the
- 1:06populist leader Narendra Modi. Royy's
- 1:09latest book is a memoir called Mother
- 1:11Mary Comes to Me. And in part, it's an
- 1:14explanation of how she became a
- 1:16political writer, but it's also a deeply
- 1:18felt exploration of her relationship
- 1:21with her very complicated mother. Here's
- 1:24my conversation with Aaron Datiroy.
- 1:27[Music]
- 1:30>> Hi.
- 1:32>> Hi, Lulu. How are you?
- 1:33>> I'm very well. Um, thank you so much for
- 1:36coming on to the interview. I'm very
- 1:38pleased to have you.
- 1:39>> Thank you.
- 1:40>> This book really resonated with me. It's
- 1:43a memoir of you, but also a biography of
- 1:46your mother who died in 2022 at the age
- 1:49of 89. And she was a very complicated
- 1:52and and difficult person as you describe
- 1:55her. While I was reading it, it reminded
- 1:58me of this quote by the writer Cheslav
- 2:01Milos who wrote, "When a writer is born
- 2:04into the family, the family is
- 2:06finished."
- 2:08Did you struggle with how much to reveal
- 2:11about your mother and your family just
- 2:13in the personal context of how difficult
- 2:16your upbringing actually was?
- 2:20Uh
- 2:22well obviously you know when you write
- 2:24something like this you you you choose
- 2:27what you write and what you won't write.
- 2:30But I know that this doesn't work as
- 2:33literature. If you're trying to present
- 2:36some uh acceptable version of yourself
- 2:39or of of her, then you might as well not
- 2:42do it, you know. But but to me it wasn't
- 2:45so much of a struggle because I think
- 2:49what was incredible about her was that
- 2:53there was there was a part of her which
- 2:56which which hammered me but then it also
- 2:59created me but then there was this
- 3:01public part of her which was so
- 3:04extraordinary you know so I could never
- 3:07settle on what I really thought or felt.
- 3:11I could never remove myself from her
- 3:14because I admired her too. And I just
- 3:18felt that this the the the entire range
- 3:22of what she had was a challenge to me as
- 3:25a writer. Can I put down this
- 3:29unresolvable character?
- 3:31>> Well, let's talk about Mary Roy and and
- 3:33that public part of her before we get to
- 3:36to the part of her as your mother. I
- 3:39mean on the most basic level tell me
- 3:41about who she was outside of your
- 3:43relationship. I mean she was indeed a
- 3:45well-known person.
- 3:47>> She belonged to the Syrian Christian
- 3:49community in Kerala which is pretty
- 3:51privileged tiny but privileged community
- 3:54that's insulated from the the wildness
- 3:57and the poverty of the rest of India for
- 3:59many reasons. But then she married
- 4:02outside the community and then got
- 4:04divorced which was absolute taboo you
- 4:08know and she um started a small school
- 4:13initially uh in the rented premises of
- 4:17what was called the Rotary Club. I used
- 4:19to think of it as a sliding folding
- 4:22school because we uh uh you know we had
- 4:25to sweep up all the stubs on the coffee
- 4:26cups of the men and put out our
- 4:29furniture and then and then they would
- 4:31come the next day and mess it up again.
- 4:35Um and then ultimately built this
- 4:38beautiful school which still runs. I
- 4:40studied there too in the early years.
- 4:44But what she's equally well known for is
- 4:46that um when she left her husband, my
- 4:50father, we lived in this tiny little
- 4:52cottage that used to belong to her very
- 4:55cruel father who was dead by then. And
- 4:58then her mother and her older brother
- 5:01came there and they asked us to leave
- 5:04the house and they said that as a
- 5:06daughter according to the Trabuncore
- 5:09Christian Succession act a daughter can
- 5:13inherit quarter of her father's property
- 5:16or 5,000 rupees whichever is less. So we
- 5:20were literally going to be turfed out
- 5:22onto this road in the middle of the
- 5:25night by my grandmother and my uncle and
- 5:29she and we ran to the lawyer and he told
- 5:33us that law applies in Kerala not in
- 5:36Tamilad. So we weren't kicked out but
- 5:39she nurtured this humiliation and kept
- 5:43it to herself for a long time. But when
- 5:46she was able to, when she was
- 5:48economically stable, when she could
- 5:50afford to, she filed appeal to the
- 5:54Supreme Court challenging this law,
- 5:56calling it unconstitutional. And the
- 5:59Supreme Court actually
- 6:01uh struck down that law with
- 6:03retrospective effect and uh made it
- 6:07equal inheritance for everybody. And it
- 6:09took years and years and years in court,
- 6:12you know, before she actually won the
- 6:14case. and she had very few people on her
- 6:17side while she was fighting it.
- 6:20>> So, there's that side of your mother.
- 6:22Um,
- 6:24you start the book though really
- 6:26discussing
- 6:27how you were raised by her and
- 6:32your early life as you describe it was
- 6:35one of hardship, poverty, instability,
- 6:38and abuse both verbal and physical. I
- 6:42should ask before we continue, is
- 6:44abusive actually the word that feels
- 6:47right to you in describing your
- 6:48relationship to her?
- 6:50>> Uh I I flinch, you know, when when we
- 6:54use these words because nowadays there
- 6:57are a lot of these words that are used
- 7:00and I suppose they are useful in some
- 7:04ways, but I don't know. I I I didn't use
- 7:08any of these words in the book. And
- 7:12>> if it was a single thing that one was
- 7:14dealing with, you know, if it was just
- 7:16abuse or just violence or just one thing
- 7:19that you could settle on and decide how
- 7:23to feel about it,
- 7:25that's one thing. But I I think I had a
- 7:28schism in me very early where even as a
- 7:32young child I could see that her anger
- 7:36against me and my brother was somehow
- 7:40connected to what she herself was going
- 7:42through. So one half of me was
- 7:46uh you know was taking the hits and the
- 7:49other half of me was taking notes and
- 7:52somehow that
- 7:55in a sense made me a writer very early
- 7:59where you're trying to understand why is
- 8:01she doing this to me? uh you know it it
- 8:06it was so often clear that it had
- 8:08nothing to do with what I had said or
- 8:11what I had done. It had something to do
- 8:14with something that I couldn't fully
- 8:16understand or control and was always
- 8:19struggling to understand and control.
- 8:23>> I just want to give the audience just a
- 8:27sense of of some of these incidents that
- 8:29you describe in the book. Some of the
- 8:31moments that were hardest to read about
- 8:34were when she would berate you, belittle
- 8:37you. You tell a story about being on a
- 8:39plane for the first time when you were
- 8:40about 6 years old. Can you recount that
- 8:43story?
- 8:46>> Uh yeah. Well, my mother had an older
- 8:49sister who who was very different from
- 8:53the rest of the family cuz she was the
- 8:55only one who had held her marriage
- 8:57together and she was married to someone
- 8:59who was a pilot who worked in Indian
- 9:01Airlines and she had a as I say a proper
- 9:04house and a proper husband and proper
- 9:06children and because this this uncle of
- 9:10mine was a pilot, we we had free tickets
- 9:13to get on a plane which we had never
- 9:15been on. And um
- 9:19on the plane I uh asked my mother how
- 9:24come uh her sister was so much thinner
- 9:28than her. And my mother was a very very
- 9:31severe asthmatic and she was at the time
- 9:37you on steroids and she had just become
- 9:40very overweight and she had this moon
- 9:42face and she just uh turned on me in a
- 9:46fury and mimicked me, you know. She had
- 9:49this way of mimicking my baby way of
- 9:53speaking and that used to just rip
- 9:57through me, you know, and and and then
- 9:59she said, "By the time you're my age,
- 10:02you'll be three times my size." And of
- 10:05course, uh, very quickly she
- 10:09she said, "Well, I'm your mother and
- 10:11your father, and I' I love you double,
- 10:13you know, so you forgive her, and yet
- 10:16you're shredded also." And so that that
- 10:20was the constant thing that you had to
- 10:22manage that something would tear you up
- 10:26and then stitch you back together then
- 10:29tear you up then stitch you back
- 10:31together and um yeah
- 10:34>> that leaves a lot of scars.
- 10:37>> Well it does but maybe it also made me
- 10:40the writer that I am. You know,
- 10:43>> you write that her mimicking you and
- 10:46calling you names made you feel that I
- 10:48swirled like water down a drain and
- 10:51disappeared.
- 10:53And I think that anyone who's had a
- 10:55difficult parent, which I have, um, can
- 10:58identify with that line. Did you think
- 11:01that you had to hide yourself disappear
- 11:04when she was attacking you?
- 11:08>> Um, yeah. Well, it's not only that. She
- 11:12was the only parent. She was also the
- 11:16only person in a society and in a family
- 11:21that makes it clear that you're not part
- 11:23of it. So, so she's all you have. I
- 11:26mean, there are no relatives, there are
- 11:28no neighbors, there's just nobody, you
- 11:30know. So for me in some ways I've welded
- 11:34myself to her you know when I was very
- 11:37young and then
- 11:40exploded apart when I was older but you
- 11:45know she had this these terrible attacks
- 11:47of asthma and she used to keep telling
- 11:49me I'm going to die and you better
- 11:52figure out what you're going to do.
- 11:54You'll live on the street who's going to
- 11:57look after you. And so I became like her
- 12:02lung, you know. I was I used to breathe
- 12:04for her. I was like a extension.
- 12:07My body was an extension of her body.
- 12:10And then when I was 16 and I went to
- 12:14architecture school and I just walked
- 12:16into those lawns and watched all the
- 12:20students and I knew that I would I would
- 12:24be fine. I would be able to work. I
- 12:26would be able to survive. I wouldn't die
- 12:29if she died. I didn't have to breathe
- 12:31for her. And she sensed that the valiant
- 12:36organ child of hers, the the lung, extra
- 12:39lung that she had suddenly was breathing
- 12:42for itself and that generated a whole
- 12:45lot of hostility.
- 12:47>> I just want to clarify that you ended up
- 12:49leaving your home at 16. Um there was a
- 12:53huge period of separation where you
- 12:54didn't see your mother at all and you
- 12:56basically raised yourself.
- 12:58>> Yeah. I I I I left uh Kerala to join
- 13:01architecture school when I was 16 and
- 13:04after my second year I just stopped
- 13:06going home because it was too painful
- 13:09you know. So I I put myself through the
- 13:12rest of it.
- 13:13>> College.
- 13:14>> We should say that. Sorry, I just keep
- 13:16wanting to say that I I don't want this
- 13:19to end up like some litany of uh you
- 13:23know horrors about her because as I keep
- 13:26saying in the book I I had huge
- 13:29admiration for her too.
- 13:31>> I mean you talk about the battles that
- 13:33she was fighting even within the school
- 13:36how she taught women and the men to look
- 13:40at gender dynamics in a completely
- 13:42different way. I mean, you tell a story
- 13:44about her, you know, making the boys
- 13:47parade around in bras because one of
- 13:49them had disrespected one of the girls.
- 13:51Um,
- 13:52>> not parade around, not parade around in
- 13:54bras, but
- 13:56>> something similar.
- 13:56>> No, she just learned that um they were
- 13:59making fun of the girls because they had
- 14:01started wearing bras. So, she said, "Go
- 14:04to my cupboard and get my bra." And then
- 14:06she showed them. She said, "This is a
- 14:09bra. This is what it's for in assembly,
- 14:11you She said, "If it excites you so
- 14:13much, you can keep mine."
- 14:15>> So, it it changes the pH balance of what
- 14:20goes on between boys and girls. You
- 14:22know, when the girls know that there's
- 14:24someone who's got their back.
- 14:26>> One of the most interesting things uh in
- 14:28the book is how you write about gender
- 14:30dynamics. Um, which we should say you
- 14:34have always written about, but in the
- 14:36book you describe India as the land of
- 14:38sun worshippers. That's Sen. But you
- 14:42also describe how harsh
- 14:44your mother was with your brother in
- 14:46particular. I mean, she would call him a
- 14:48male chauvinist pig when he was only a
- 14:51child. When he was a teenager, she said
- 14:52to him, you know, you're ugly and
- 14:54stupid.
- 14:56You know, you should kill yourself.
- 14:58You write that the way she treated him
- 15:00was like she was punishing him for the
- 15:02sins of the world and that that
- 15:04complicated your own views of feminism.
- 15:07And I'm wondering how that played out
- 15:09for you.
- 15:10>> Well, I I mean, even today, I think that
- 15:14my brother, he's one of the most amazing
- 15:18people that I know, you know, and having
- 15:21endured all that from her. My My
- 15:24brother's the one that asks me, I don't
- 15:26understand how you can be so
- 15:31so upset about her death after
- 15:34everything that she did to us, you know.
- 15:37and and I understand that uh it's very
- 15:42puzzling for him and perhaps even
- 15:45hurtful that I uh I don't hate her, you
- 15:49know, but uh I think it's just because I
- 15:55see that her public battles were making
- 15:58space for women in ways that included
- 16:01making space for me. But at the same
- 16:04time, just because you're a feminist
- 16:07doesn't make you a great person. You
- 16:10know, I it feminism just doesn't have
- 16:14only to do with women's rights. It has
- 16:16to do with a way of looking at the world
- 16:19in which men and women are equal and men
- 16:22and women are respectful of each each
- 16:24other. It doesn't mean disrespecting
- 16:28uh a lovely man. it doesn't mean that
- 16:31which is what I saw happening with my
- 16:33brother and it it affected me deeply.
- 16:40I I want to just linger here for a
- 16:42moment because I am curious because you
- 16:45you and your brother saw your mother so
- 16:47differently what the conversations
- 16:50around this book have been. I mean has
- 16:53he read it and what has he thought of
- 16:54it?
- 16:56Yeah, I mean he he has read it and uh I
- 17:01think it was hard initially for him to
- 17:03read because he
- 17:06uh in a way has
- 17:08or maybe thought he had put it behind
- 17:11him but uh then he
- 17:14uh wrote to me saying I'm laughing and
- 17:16crying and I can't breathe and if I die
- 17:19it'll be your fault and then then uh but
- 17:23then he did say you know uh I don't
- 17:26understand why you uh why you you know
- 17:31feel so much about her cuz I said I
- 17:34can't hate her because there are so much
- 17:36of her in me I'd have to hate myself but
- 17:40you know I see that he's been
- 17:43and I respect that he's been deeply
- 17:46deeply hurt by her
- 17:48>> but he too he too has made his life on
- 17:51his own and brilliantly so you M
- 17:55>> both of us survived.
- 17:57>> There is this other moment that really
- 17:59struck me in the book where you describe
- 18:03you and your brother being sent to
- 18:05boarding school and you write that your
- 18:07brother got a report from school that
- 18:09said average student and your mother
- 18:12beat him with a ruler until it broke.
- 18:14And in the morning she then turned to
- 18:16you and gave you a hug because your
- 18:18report card had been good and said that
- 18:21you were brilliant. And you wrote, "On
- 18:24the occasions when I am toasted or
- 18:26applauded, I always feel that someone
- 18:29else, someone quiet is being beaten in
- 18:32the other room." I have to say that
- 18:34stopped me in my tracks.
- 18:36>> Yeah. I think the the the sentence after
- 18:39that is if you stop to think about it,
- 18:41it's true. someone is, you know,
- 18:44>> and and actually that is the truth, you
- 18:48know, that uh I mean when you get
- 18:53uh applauded and rewarded and everybody
- 18:55claps and and and you you know that
- 18:59somebody you love and somebody quiet has
- 19:02has been beaten and to me that expands
- 19:06far beyond my brother and me. It it
- 19:08expands into the country that I live in
- 19:10now. you know that or the world that I
- 19:12live in now that I might be uh a writer
- 19:17with you know whatever is conventionally
- 19:19known as success but the things I write
- 19:22about and the people that I write about
- 19:24are being beaten they are being beaten
- 19:27down even as we speak today you know
- 19:30they are being starved in Gaza they are
- 19:32being broken they are being occupied and
- 19:34so what does it mean when you are
- 19:37applauded when you when your heart
- 19:40belongs in the whole world.
- 19:41>> When you
- 19:43wrote that section and were thinking
- 19:46about that incident and how it applies
- 19:49to your life as someone who has been
- 19:52frequently publicly applauded and given
- 19:54so many awards,
- 19:57was it a sense of discovery that this
- 19:59was the root of that connection?
- 20:02No, I I I don't think that uh
- 20:08I mean I don't think that the process of
- 20:10writing this
- 20:13made me understand it deeper because I
- 20:17wrote it because I understood it. you
- 20:19know,
- 20:20>> in order to survive or in order to make
- 20:25sense of my
- 20:28uh life, I've had to think and think and
- 20:30think and think and think about all
- 20:32these things, you know. So uh even for
- 20:36example when I won the book aer prize
- 20:37and so on I there was like more than one
- 20:41half of me that was um
- 20:45you know
- 20:47uh thinking about what does it mean to
- 20:50be this besteller novelist in this
- 20:53country where people can't read in this
- 20:57country where you know is hurtling
- 21:00towards what we have now. So there was
- 21:03hardly a moment uh for me to to feel
- 21:07great about myself, you know, before
- 21:10things started to unravel quickly.
- 21:15And um even the celebration of me had
- 21:19this whole nationalistic fervor which I
- 21:22despised at that time in 97. So, uh, I
- 21:28was very quickly, um, kicked off that
- 21:31pedestal and I kicked myself off it,
- 21:33too. You know, I always have this
- 21:37feeling that those of us who've been
- 21:39very unsafe as as children, we seek out
- 21:44the unsafe. We seek out the lack of
- 21:47security. And if you have security, you
- 21:50blow it up. I mean you've
- 21:53risked your security um many times uh in
- 21:57your career. Uh we should say that at
- 22:01the moment actually you are under um
- 22:05legal threat in India for uh your
- 22:08writing uh and the things that you've
- 22:10said. I mean what do you think the role
- 22:12of writers and creators
- 22:16is at a moment when there is censorship
- 22:17and people are trying to shut you down?
- 22:20I think that writers have survived uh
- 22:24you know whether it's in the Soviet
- 22:26Union or whether it's in East Germany or
- 22:29whether it's in the darkest places and
- 22:31times they have managed to survive they
- 22:34ma their work has survived and it's for
- 22:38me very important to understand that I
- 22:42just can't keep striking the same note
- 22:44again and again you have to keep it you
- 22:47have to change it up you know you have
- 22:49to vary things. You have to experiment.
- 22:52You have to insist that your work is not
- 22:54just a reaction to what's happening to
- 22:56you. It your work is a thing in and of
- 22:59itself and uh a a way of thinking, a way
- 23:04of positing another vision of the world.
- 23:09And and that's a challenge because you
- 23:12can't do it as a manifesto as some
- 23:14clumsy uh you know hitting everybody on
- 23:17the head with some ideological hammer.
- 23:20You've got to do it beautifully. And
- 23:22somebody told me the other day that oh
- 23:25you know the reason I like uh your
- 23:28writing is cuz you write as though
- 23:30they've already killed you. Meaning you
- 23:33don't have you don't hold back you know
- 23:36stuff for another book or another essay
- 23:38or something. Let's just put it all
- 23:40down.
- 23:40>> It's your epitap.
- 23:43to bring this back to your mother. One
- 23:45of the things that I was most curious
- 23:47about is once you had this immense
- 23:50success um and the pressures that it
- 23:54brought because of your non-fiction
- 23:55writing um about the situation in
- 23:58Kashmir about
- 24:00huge dam operations and many of the
- 24:02other issues that you have passionately
- 24:05written about um including the rise of
- 24:07Hindu nationalism in India.
- 24:11How did she view that? Was she worried
- 24:13for you? Was she proud of you? Was she
- 24:16jealous of you?
- 24:18>> She um
- 24:21you know, of all the people that I know
- 24:24in in in my family, she's the one who
- 24:29used to read it every every especially
- 24:31every political essay and she used to
- 24:33follow it closely.
- 24:35But she I know that she was worried but
- 24:39not because she told me she was worried
- 24:40but because other people in the school
- 24:43used to tell me she's worried but to me
- 24:45she was always like
- 24:47what what the hell do you think you're
- 24:49doing and you know whatever very
- 24:51dismissive but perhaps she also had
- 24:55these as unresolved feelings about me as
- 24:58I did for for her because once she
- 25:01called me up to say that you know I went
- 25:04to buy some fruit and that woman asked
- 25:07me are you Arundat Tiroyy's mother and I
- 25:09felt as though she had slapped me and
- 25:12she called me to tell me this you know
- 25:15and and at the same time she was also
- 25:19proud because I was a I was not just her
- 25:21daughter I was also product of her
- 25:23school you know so uh
- 25:27I think she she had her moments when she
- 25:29was very very ill she used to get very
- 25:33upset
- 25:34uh if I wasn't there in the hospital,
- 25:36but if I was there, she would say, "Oh,
- 25:38these people, they're just coming here
- 25:40because of you. They don't care about
- 25:42me." And you know that stuff. So,
- 25:45>> how how did that make you feel um that
- 25:48she seemed to have a complicated
- 25:50relationship with you even as you became
- 25:54an enormous success?
- 25:57Well, first of all, uh, as we've spoken
- 26:00before, you know, success was in itself
- 26:03without her and her opinions a
- 26:05complicated thing for me. But, uh, you
- 26:10know, occasionally it used to break my
- 26:13heart that she had such a thorny,
- 26:18uh, you know, response to it.
- 26:21But at the same time, I always was very
- 26:25clear in my mind that I never wanted to
- 26:28defeat her. Like I wanted her to go out
- 26:30like a queen, you know, which she did.
- 26:34And um you know that involved reducing
- 26:38myself sometimes. That involved
- 26:42being mauled and shredded and having to
- 26:44piece myself together sometimes. That
- 26:47involved
- 26:49calibrating how many days I could be
- 26:51there before I was absolutely
- 26:55corroded.
- 26:56It it involved coming home and
- 27:00being quite sick physically for a long
- 27:03time just to get over it, you know. But
- 27:06at the same time, somehow I had that
- 27:10ability to detach myself and sit on the
- 27:13ceiling fan and think, "God, this is
- 27:15quite funny." need the whole thing,
- 27:17isn't it? You know, so I think that sort
- 27:20of saved me and also because I
- 27:24the more I traveled, the more I saw of
- 27:26the world, the more I wrote about things
- 27:28that were happening, the less able I was
- 27:31to put myself at the center of some
- 27:33great tragedy, you know. I was just
- 27:35like, it's okay. Things are bad
- 27:38elsewhere, you know.
- 27:40>> Well, um, we are going to speak again in
- 27:44a short time. Um and I want to talk more
- 27:47about your political writing, your
- 27:49activism, um and the situation in India
- 27:53and we'll pick up there. But uh I want
- 27:55to thank you so much for this
- 27:57conversation.
- 27:58>> Thank you. It's my pleasure.
- 28:00>> Can I ask you one more question
- 28:02actually?
- 28:03>> Yeah, sure.
- 28:05>> Is it hard to talk about this?
- 28:09>> I'm I'm just learning to talk about it.
- 28:12I can see your physical self when I ask
- 28:15certain questions and and it might be
- 28:17uncomfortable territory I imagine.
- 28:19>> Yeah. I mean I I I read the audio book
- 28:23and the audio uh uh engineer producer he
- 28:29told me uh you know it's okay you can
- 28:31take some breaks and if you get upset I
- 28:33said me why would I get upset? I wrote
- 28:35it. I lived it. You know I'm going to
- 28:37get upset. He says, "Oh, well, the last
- 28:40third of the book, your voice is
- 28:41completely different from this first
- 28:44twothirds." I I have to see, you know,
- 28:47how it goes. And um
- 28:50uh I think to me it's important that
- 28:54people don't think that this is just a
- 28:55book about a mother and a daughter
- 28:57because this is a book about two women
- 29:00who happen to be mother and daughter,
- 29:02but it's also about the village and the
- 29:03city and the state and the country and
- 29:06the world. And if it weren't that,
- 29:10uh, it would not be as important to me.
- 29:17On the interview, we talked to our guest
- 29:18twice. So, a few days later, I followed
- 29:21up with Arandati. This time, we spoke
- 29:23about her political writing.
- 29:26>> Hi, nice to see you again.
- 29:28>> Hey, Lulu. Nice to see you, too. you
- 29:30know after we spoke last time
- 29:33uh and we talked a little bit about the
- 29:36political situation in India and the
- 29:38situation for you in particular just in
- 29:40the past few days the Indian regional
- 29:43government of Kashmir has banned one of
- 29:45your books and of course this is not the
- 29:47first time your work has been targeted
- 29:50this time the book is Azadi it was
- 29:52published in 2020 it's about the fight
- 29:54in Indian controlled Kashmir the
- 29:57concepts behind freedom and
- 29:59authoritarianism ism more broadly. And
- 30:01I'm going to quote what the directive
- 30:02said. It said that your book and others
- 30:06um it wasn't the only one that was
- 30:07targeted. Uh would quote deeply impact
- 30:10the psyche of youth by promoting a
- 30:12culture of grievance, victimhood, and
- 30:15terrorist heroism.
- 30:19Why do you think your book was included
- 30:20in that list? And what's your response
- 30:22to that more broadly? You know, my
- 30:25response to it is to not respond because
- 30:30uh I don't know. It sounds like some
- 30:33list they got out of chat GPT or
- 30:35something. So, uh you never know why
- 30:39these things happen when they happen.
- 30:41when they target me now, I just um I
- 30:45just don't say anything because
- 30:48you never know whether they really mean
- 30:50it or it's just some
- 30:54side game to distract from something or
- 30:57whatever. So, I have no idea. So, I'm
- 31:00not really going to say much about it.
- 31:03>> Okay. As we mentioned in our first
- 31:06conversation, you are currently under
- 31:08threat of arrest in India uh for
- 31:10comments you made about Kashmir in 2010.
- 31:13I mean for our audience, do you feel
- 31:16comfortable explaining your position and
- 31:18can you tell me a little bit about the
- 31:19status of that legal case?
- 31:22uh I really don't want to talk about it
- 31:24actually because you know it just uh
- 31:28increases the risk of you know something
- 31:32being taken out of context and something
- 31:35blowing up uh uh it's dormant right now
- 31:40so I just let it be you know
- 31:43>> then let me ask you this because even
- 31:45the manner in which you're responding
- 31:47which is that you do not want to address
- 31:51this because of the fear of legal
- 31:54repercussions that could even mean
- 31:58jail
- 31:59and and other other punishments.
- 32:03What does that say when governments try
- 32:06and silence authors, writers, academics
- 32:11regarding their work and regarding what
- 32:14what they try and put out in the world?
- 32:16Well, I think um in America, you're
- 32:19beginning to head in that direction. Uh
- 32:23ours started a long time ago and one has
- 32:27to learn how to navigate it. And the
- 32:30reason that I don't talk about it is
- 32:32because uh I would much rather
- 32:36um write what I want to write than have
- 32:40some controversy about something you
- 32:42just say off the cuff. It's like they're
- 32:45always trying to trip people up and
- 32:48trying to prevent you from thinking
- 32:50clearly or and and so this culture of
- 32:54fear is everywhere here you know now
- 32:57people are not able to uh you know
- 33:00people are arrested for things they say
- 33:02on Facebook on Twitter or what they
- 33:05don't say like in the US it seems new to
- 33:08you but we have been living with this
- 33:11and is increasingly becoming normalized
- 33:14It's a very disturbing situation and
- 33:17especially disturbing uh you know
- 33:20obviously for Muslims uh where it
- 33:23doesn't stop with just uh you know court
- 33:25cases and jail it goes on to lynching
- 33:28and murder and social boycotts and
- 33:31economic boycotts and their homes being
- 33:34bulldozed.
- 33:35So you know always one thing leads to
- 33:39another to another to another and you
- 33:42end up being in a situation where you
- 33:45meet people who have stories that you
- 33:47can't look away from. This thing is
- 33:51really I think seminal to your work you
- 33:54know when you have seen injustice you
- 33:58have not been able to look away. Many
- 34:00people do look away. What do you think
- 34:02it is about you that
- 34:05makes you not flinch?
- 34:07>> Actually, I think uh uh the the point is
- 34:11that I do flinch when I see it and most
- 34:14people don't flinch. You know, they just
- 34:17accept it as a part of uh you know daily
- 34:21injustices. And the thing is that India
- 34:24is a society
- 34:26um that is built on a social hierarchy
- 34:29which is amongst the most cruel in the
- 34:31world. You know, we have a situation
- 34:34where people uh people are divided up
- 34:39hierarchically according to what is
- 34:42considered levels of purity and impurity
- 34:45and the dehumanization of people who are
- 34:47considered outcast uh which has been
- 34:50actually institutionalized.
- 34:53So it's a society that
- 34:56accepts injustice as a as a given. you
- 35:01touched on this a little um and and so I
- 35:06would love to hear your thoughts on
- 35:08how you view parallels between
- 35:12the Hindu nationalist movement in India
- 35:14and the MAGA movement here in the United
- 35:16States. There are a lot of parallels. So
- 35:20one of the first things that happened
- 35:22was when Modi came to power was
- 35:25demonetization was this direct hit on
- 35:28the economy where he suddenly said 500
- 35:31rupee notes were illegal like overnight.
- 35:33If you look at the attack on
- 35:35citizenship, the attack on universities,
- 35:38the attack on students, the attack on
- 35:41Rohingyas, the continuous uh
- 35:45uncertainty, the fact that you might be
- 35:47ambushed by anything at any time. It's
- 35:50so similar that you wonder is there a
- 35:53playbook or is it just osmotic
- 35:58sort of um authoritarian behavior? And
- 36:01of course there are other things like
- 36:03voter suppression. The leader of the
- 36:05opposition had a huge expose of how
- 36:08voter lists have been manipulated. So
- 36:11basically what you're seeing is is that
- 36:14the ruling party is confused with
- 36:18government
- 36:20and all of it is confused with one man
- 36:24you know. So you you're seeing that in
- 36:26the US and I look at I look at it in
- 36:29shock cuz you know you thought that
- 36:32there was a mechanism in place there
- 36:34were checks and balances in place but
- 36:36clearly there isn't a way of handling
- 36:40someone who's completely out of control.
- 36:44you you know the way statisticians are
- 36:48being fired for giving out figures that
- 36:50don't that the authoritarian doesn't
- 36:53agree with. Same thing here. You can't
- 36:55believe any of the government figures on
- 36:57economics because every everything that
- 37:00doesn't suit the ruling establishment is
- 37:04dismissed. It's thrown away and a new
- 37:07picture is put in its place. The one big
- 37:10difference between what's happening in
- 37:13India and what is happening right now in
- 37:16the US is that in India the mainstream
- 37:19media has completely compromised. It's
- 37:23not it's not just rolled over. It is
- 37:26actually
- 37:28an organ of the authoritarian state.
- 37:32It's actually calling for people's
- 37:34arrest or making up lies. Of course,
- 37:37America is sitting on top of a crumbling
- 37:40world. Whatever Trump does affects the
- 37:43whole world, whereas here it just
- 37:47affects this country.
- 37:49>> Why do you think um authoritarian
- 37:52leaders go after
- 37:54people like you, people who deal in
- 37:57ideas when you said there's like an echo
- 38:00of a playbook? Um I mean, we've seen
- 38:03that. Yes. in in places all around the
- 38:06world. I've covered it
- 38:07>> from time immemorial.
- 38:08>> Memorial. Exactly.
- 38:10>> But as someone who's the subject of of
- 38:12that kind of censure, I'm wondering why
- 38:15you think it happens.
- 38:17>> I think uh they are terrified of people
- 38:21who who they feel like can communicate
- 38:24not just cerebrally but emotionally and
- 38:28otherwise with with people, you know. So
- 38:32people who can uh even however small
- 38:36they are and even however little access
- 38:39they have to the mainstream or to the
- 38:43the thundering pullpit thumping uh
- 38:46television anchors. They know that there
- 38:50are some people who
- 38:53uh who somehow people eventually do
- 38:57listen to. They know it, you know. They
- 39:00know who is read, they know who is um
- 39:04loved, they know also who is not
- 39:10invested in the things that
- 39:14uh everyone else is invested in. You
- 39:16know, it's not just about fame and money
- 39:19and awards and whatever it is. You know,
- 39:22there's something else going on. And
- 39:24there are a lot of people like that who
- 39:28who they know just will not bow down.
- 39:32>> I think what you're referring to in part
- 39:35is
- 39:37uh people like yourself who also deal
- 39:39with emotional truth,
- 39:41>> not just um facts, but being able to
- 39:46capture ideas that resonate on a
- 39:49different level. I mean it's really
- 39:51interesting cuz now you see the
- 39:54government moving to capture Bollywood
- 39:57right and one after another after
- 40:00another they churn out these absolutely
- 40:03hateful films hateful violent
- 40:08literally almost evil films but they
- 40:11just don't work
- 40:13>> in our first conversation when I asked
- 40:14you about how you see the role of
- 40:16artists in turbulent moments you said
- 40:20something that struck me. Um, you have
- 40:23to insist that your work is not just a
- 40:25reaction to what's happening to you. Is
- 40:29that feeling specific to your fiction?
- 40:32Because you're, as we've said, a very
- 40:34prolific political writer,
- 40:36>> but maybe that work feels different.
- 40:39>> That work is different because that work
- 40:41is often an argument that that is made
- 40:44at a time when things are closing down.
- 40:46when I see the media, the government,
- 40:49everybody closing in on a vulnerable
- 40:52community or or you know trying to lie
- 40:57about them, pretend that they are what
- 40:59they are not and so on and and and and
- 41:02it's really like trying to blow a space
- 41:04open, you know, that I would go in and
- 41:07it's always almost all the essays are
- 41:10written despite despite my telling
- 41:13myself I'm not going to do it. I'm not
- 41:14going to do you and because you get into
- 41:17so much trouble uh after and then when
- 41:21it just becomes harder to keep quiet
- 41:25than to write I write and for me it's
- 41:28not about the product or how many books
- 41:30I write I I'm not uh interested in that
- 41:34output being huge you know um I I'm
- 41:39interested in
- 41:42living the life of a writer which does
- 41:45not involve just sitting and writing. It
- 41:47involves a lot of living, a lot of
- 41:50listening, a lot of traveling, a lot of
- 41:54inhabiting worlds and worlds and worlds,
- 41:56you know, which is why I love this place
- 41:59because there's so much about it that I
- 42:03still
- 42:05don't know.
- 42:09[Music]
- 42:16[Music]
- 42:25[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Arundhati Roy: How to Survive Authoritarianism | The Interview by The Interview, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,188 words across 893 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.