YouTube2Text

Are Mortgages & Bank Loans Haram? - Mufti Abu Layth — Transcript

by Mufti Abu Layth · 7,895 words · 1,421 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00All right, coming to this issue of riba.
  2. 0:03Right, so I'm going to need some of you.
  3. 0:05Uh
  4. 0:06It's done, people. It's done. Don't
  5. 0:08worry about it. Is that the devil's sign
  6. 0:10or is that the devil's I don't know
  7. 0:11whichever one. I'm trying to provoke
  8. 0:13people anyways.
  9. 0:16You know when people you know when
  10. 0:17people get agitated I just love pushing
  11. 0:20their buttons even further. It's like
  12. 0:22sometimes people will make annoying
  13. 0:24comments and I'll delete them and
  14. 0:26they'll say Oh.
  15. 0:28Mufti Abu Layth, why did you delete my
  16. 0:30comment? And delete it again.
  17. 0:35And I'll say because I can.
  18. 0:41Why did you do it? Because I can.
  19. 0:44Right, so
  20. 0:46All right, now
  21. 0:48coming to
  22. 0:50Okay, this is going to need a bit of
  23. 0:52focus.
  24. 0:54Riba.
  25. 0:56All right, okay. Now
  26. 1:00Riba is an incredibly in my
  27. 1:02understanding an incredibly complex
  28. 1:05yet
  29. 1:07it's an over-claimed
  30. 1:10subject. Like people feel
  31. 1:14too many people feel that they actually
  32. 1:16understand riba.
  33. 1:18And two and it's
  34. 1:21become symbolic. This is the problem.
  35. 1:24That riba has the concept of riba has
  36. 1:27become symbolic.
  37. 1:30With uh
  38. 1:32within Islam.
  39. 1:34Right, ahlan wa sahlan those people just
  40. 1:35tuning in. Ahlan wa sahlan if you'd like
  41. 1:38the actual
  42. 1:42Sorry, I get distracted. Some people are
  43. 1:43trying to correct my drinking. If you
  44. 1:45click like and share the link uh share
  45. 1:48the live feed get it out this is an
  46. 1:49interesting and important point on riba.
  47. 1:52I'd like many people to benefit.
  48. 1:56What's life if not lived and absolutely
  49. 2:00what's life if not lived on the edge.
  50. 2:04That is something I say. Right now
  51. 2:07I I need us to understand something
  52. 2:09here. This is um
  53. 2:11slightly complex. I'm going to need you
  54. 2:14to bear with me. Okay.
  55. 2:17You can all be my murids. Ahlan wa
  56. 2:19sahlan. Yeah.
  57. 2:21Right now, an absolute love
  58. 2:24coming right back at you Murad Ahmed.
  59. 2:26Shukran shukran. Right now, the thing is
  60. 2:28look, listen.
  61. 2:30I need you to uh to to kind of focus on
  62. 2:33this. Riba
  63. 2:37has become symbolic. Now
  64. 2:40we need to take a step back.
  65. 2:43Religion to many people is just
  66. 2:46symbolism.
  67. 2:48Okay, religion is symbols.
  68. 2:51This is why
  69. 2:53to many people and and this this is a
  70. 2:55fascinating point and I was just having
  71. 2:57this discussion last week with a sheikh
  72. 3:00from Birmingham, Sheikh Sajad. I don't
  73. 3:03know those of you that know him, an
  74. 3:04amazing person spelled S J double A D.
  75. 3:07And
  76. 3:09and we were just discussing this point
  77. 3:10that religion is symbolic to many
  78. 3:13people.
  79. 3:14Okay.
  80. 3:15It's only about symbols. That's how they
  81. 3:18identify with religion. Hence
  82. 3:21me I'm not considered religious to many
  83. 3:24people.
  84. 3:26I mean, I'm not saying I am by their
  85. 3:27definition of religious.
  86. 3:29Uh but because I don't carry any of the
  87. 3:33symbols that they would identify
  88. 3:36religion to be. So to them
  89. 3:38religion is symbolism. It's iconic. It's
  90. 3:42through icons and symbols.
  91. 3:45Now, and that will be partly through
  92. 3:47things like dress, through attire,
  93. 3:49affirmations, through rituals, through I
  94. 3:53suppose what rituals you can't always
  95. 3:54see like praying I suppose, but you
  96. 3:56can't always see people praying. But you
  97. 3:58could see the way they dressed. You
  98. 4:00could see the way they have a beard or
  99. 4:03wear hijab or do certain things. And
  100. 4:05this is what it's all about to people,
  101. 4:07symbols.
  102. 4:09Now, from these symbols like domes,
  103. 4:12minarets
  104. 4:13I mean, taking into consideration that
  105. 4:15none of these things existed like that
  106. 4:17like domes or minarets in the time of
  107. 4:19the prophet, but these symbols have
  108. 4:21today come to represent Islam in the in
  109. 4:25the minds of many.
  110. 4:27So
  111. 4:28riba has become one of those things that
  112. 4:31is symbolic.
  113. 4:33That it is
  114. 4:36seen to many people to be an important
  115. 4:39aspect of Islam. They may not fully
  116. 4:42understand what riba is.
  117. 4:44But they understand this to be an
  118. 4:46important aspect. So I don't know what
  119. 4:49it is.
  120. 4:50But they think whatever it is it's
  121. 4:53incredibly important.
  122. 4:56The other thing is that they think riba
  123. 4:59I mean, they understand that riba is
  124. 5:01something Allah has declared war on.
  125. 5:04Fa'azanu biharbim minallah. That Allah
  126. 5:07says in the Quran that he has declared
  127. 5:09war. Yamhaqullahur riba wa yurbis
  128. 5:12sadaqat.
  129. 5:13It's been highlighted something distinct
  130. 5:16to sadaqat and Allah destroys riba as in
  131. 5:20destroys as in you know, it has no
  132. 5:23baraka and Allah kind of detests it.
  133. 5:26This is the the understanding that God
  134. 5:28detests usury.
  135. 5:30Now ahallallahu al bay'a wa harrama
  136. 5:34riba, the verse in the Quran that Allah
  137. 5:36made transactions he legislated and
  138. 5:39authorized transactions, but he
  139. 5:41prohibited riba.
  140. 5:45So
  141. 5:46what is this riba?
  142. 5:49Riba in the Quran
  143. 5:51uh is mentioned as three things.
  144. 5:55Okay. Sorry, not in the Quran, in Islam
  145. 5:59it's mentioned as three things. In the
  146. 6:00Quran riba is just generally used as
  147. 6:03riba and it is usually referring to just
  148. 6:06one thing.
  149. 6:08But people will say all three. Okay,
  150. 6:10fine.
  151. 6:12These three things are
  152. 6:14ribal
  153. 6:16you've got ribal jahiliyyah, what is
  154. 6:18called ribal jahili, the riba of
  155. 6:20jahiliyyah.
  156. 6:22You have ribal fadl
  157. 6:24and riban nasa.
  158. 6:26These are three categories of riba.
  159. 6:30Ribal jahiliyyah
  160. 6:33is the riba that
  161. 6:35it's a kind of
  162. 6:37inc- a
  163. 6:38tyrant like a very uh draconian
  164. 6:43highly oppressive
  165. 6:46loan shark kind of riba.
  166. 6:50Where that's the best way I can describe
  167. 6:52it. It's what the pre-Islam the kind of
  168. 6:55riba that was going on.
  169. 6:57So people would uh they would they would
  170. 7:00require wealth. So I require certain
  171. 7:02amount of gold. Somebody gives me. Now
  172. 7:05obviously I struggle to pay it back.
  173. 7:07There will be compound kind of demands
  174. 7:10made. So you will give me this much this
  175. 7:12much this much on top. And each time I
  176. 7:15can't do that that continues to be
  177. 7:18compounded. And then it's usually
  178. 7:21followed by I could be killed in return
  179. 7:23or worse. Sometimes being killed I mean,
  180. 7:26being killed is an utter tragedy
  181. 7:29obviously.
  182. 7:32Obviously, it's an utter tragedy and
  183. 7:36What's that?
  184. 7:38What's that poem? Where he says
  185. 7:43He says uh
  186. 7:47He says what in tabqa tufja
  187. 7:51bifana'il ahibbati is that No, something
  188. 7:54like uh
  189. 7:56Ah, it's a famous poem, man.
  190. 7:58He says wa fana'u nafsika
  191. 8:01afja'u.
  192. 8:04That if you do survive you will come to
  193. 8:07see like witnessing the death of many
  194. 8:11loved people will be shocking
  195. 8:14to you. Be
  196. 8:16And he says wa fana'u nafsika la abalaka
  197. 8:20afja'u.
  198. 8:21But surely you you dying
  199. 8:24is indeed a greater tragedy.
  200. 8:27So I'm not kind of denying that it's not
  201. 8:29a great tragedy. Uh
  202. 8:32Doctor uh
  203. 8:33ahlan wa sahlan and ahlan wa sahlan to
  204. 8:35all those
  205. 8:36uh just coming on late. Do click like
  206. 8:38and share the live feed. I'm trying to
  207. 8:42um
  208. 8:42discuss the topic of riba here. So
  209. 8:45people sometimes obviously they would
  210. 8:47kill you, but they would sometimes
  211. 8:49torture you, enslave your children, drag
  212. 8:52your children away from you. Uh torture
  213. 8:55them,
  214. 8:57your wife or wives back then or whatever
  215. 9:00it is and
  216. 9:01you know, it was the whole
  217. 9:04highly oppressive kind of context
  218. 9:08to this usury
  219. 9:10that what that which contained this
  220. 9:14concept of riba. This kind of loan shark
  221. 9:17culture but to the power of 10.
  222. 9:21Now, then you have the second category
  223. 9:24of riba which is ribal fadl.
  224. 9:27Ribal fadl is where we are tran-
  225. 9:31transacting with each other but we are
  226. 9:35taking more
  227. 9:37than what we're giving.
  228. 9:40Okay, now this is done between
  229. 9:42categories. Now this is strange because
  230. 9:45the hadith mentions this sahih hadith
  231. 9:48which is in Sahih Bukhari, it's in Sahih
  232. 9:50Muslim and many of the other books that
  233. 9:52the prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam
  234. 9:53said in the hadith that azzahabu
  235. 9:55bizahabi wal fiddatu bilfiddah, that
  236. 9:57gold by gold and silver by silver what
  237. 10:01tamar with tamar that and dates by dates
  238. 10:04that
  239. 10:05uh
  240. 10:06and what
  241. 10:08shair with shair with milk with milk and
  242. 10:11and wheat by wheat and barley by barley
  243. 10:14and salt by salt
  244. 10:16These six things are mentioned almost
  245. 10:19did seven then.
  246. 10:21That's like in the thick books when they
  247. 10:23say, "Okay, these five things but they
  248. 10:25only mention four."
  249. 10:28I'd say three but mention five. Right,
  250. 10:30so
  251. 10:31these six things in the Hadith are
  252. 10:33mentioned these categories.
  253. 10:36Now
  254. 10:37the prophet said that if you're trading
  255. 10:40in these
  256. 10:42Now it's strange that you see what the
  257. 10:44Hadith says is that you
  258. 10:48can they must be of equal
  259. 10:50proportionality.
  260. 10:53The question here is why would you even
  261. 10:56trade in equal proportionality?
  262. 10:58Like why would I give you 1 kilo of
  263. 11:01wheat for 1 kilo of wheat?
  264. 11:03You wouldn't.
  265. 11:05So and then the interesting thing is
  266. 11:09it mentions ribbon nasa
  267. 11:13hand to hand exactly I'm coming to that.
  268. 11:16But if you are to delay one of the
  269. 11:19payments
  270. 11:21bar that with the exception of gold and
  271. 11:24silver.
  272. 11:25So with the exception of currency if you
  273. 11:27are bartering
  274. 11:29and you are to delay one of the the
  275. 11:31goods
  276. 11:32so you're taking it now and you're
  277. 11:34collecting the other thing from so I'm
  278. 11:36taking something from you and you can so
  279. 11:38I say, you know, I'll give me that 1
  280. 11:40kilo of dates you can take
  281. 11:422 kilos of wheat but you can collect
  282. 11:45that from me
  283. 11:46tomorrow.
  284. 11:48So it's not instant it's not hand to
  285. 11:50hand.
  286. 11:52This
  287. 11:53is declared is he
  288. 11:56it's declared riba. Now this is the
  289. 11:59shocking thing. It doesn't actually make
  290. 12:01much sense.
  291. 12:04That why
  292. 12:06okay, if it's the same category maybe
  293. 12:08it's just a statement. Maybe the prophet
  294. 12:11is saying, you know, it should be like 1
  295. 12:14kilo of wheat for 1 kilo of wheat to
  296. 12:16kind of this is an emphasis to draw away
  297. 12:20kind of uh any oppression.
  298. 12:23But then the prophet says in the Hadith
  299. 12:26for the Hadith of the Hadith of the
  300. 12:27Hadith
  301. 12:28But if you're trading between categories
  302. 12:31like dates for wheat
  303. 12:34for be okay for shiktum sell as you
  304. 12:36want, you know, you don't have to be 1
  305. 12:38kilo for 1 kilo.
  306. 12:40My cannot as long as it is yet and be
  307. 12:43yet as long as it is still hand in hand.
  308. 12:46The moment you delay one of them
  309. 12:51it becomes riba.
  310. 12:53This is called riba fuddle.
  311. 12:56Now the Hadith actually includes gold
  312. 12:59and silver too.
  313. 13:01Which would mean it's impossible
  314. 13:04impossible to buy anything on credit
  315. 13:07anything.
  316. 13:09But what the scholars did is they all
  317. 13:11said didn't ijma whatever that means but
  318. 13:15some kind of a consensus that the
  319. 13:17scholars
  320. 13:20came to an understanding that gold and
  321. 13:23silver is exempt from this Hadith even
  322. 13:26though the Hadith mentions gold and
  323. 13:28silver in the beginning.
  324. 13:29So they said we're going to exempt
  325. 13:31currency but the remaining four will
  326. 13:33stay.
  327. 13:34Now the question was what is this riba
  328. 13:38even about?
  329. 13:40So there was never any agreement on what
  330. 13:43riba was actually speaking about.
  331. 13:46When Allah says in the Quran
  332. 13:50that Allah be haram riba
  333. 13:54that Allah be Allah this Allah has made
  334. 13:57transactions halal all transactions
  335. 14:00halal this alif lam is either
  336. 14:04lil jins or lil istigraq it means either
  337. 14:07kullul bay is halal or jinsul bay the
  338. 14:12category of transactions are halal.
  339. 14:16What haram riba and made riba haram at
  340. 14:20this alif lam in riba is not kullul
  341. 14:23riba.
  342. 14:25Because riba simply means an excess.
  343. 14:29And everybody agrees
  344. 14:31that not all excesses are haram in fact
  345. 14:34most excesses are not haram.
  346. 14:37So alif lam in riba is referring to a
  347. 14:40type of riba or a riba that I've got in
  348. 14:44my mind
  349. 14:46and what we call al ahdul dhini.
  350. 14:48How do we know this? So for example,
  351. 14:51let's look at all the Hadith. So for
  352. 14:53example
  353. 14:54the Hadith of the haras
  354. 14:56so you could in the time of the prophet
  355. 14:58this was a common practice. They would
  356. 15:00go to dates on the trees the dates
  357. 15:03whilst they're still ripe but they
  358. 15:05hadn't been plucked and kind of taken
  359. 15:08off
  360. 15:09and they would say, "Okay, I'll buy all
  361. 15:11of those from you for these grapes I've
  362. 15:13got here." and they would just guess
  363. 15:14them estimate them.
  364. 15:16And they had experts to do this and they
  365. 15:18were called harasun.
  366. 15:21And these people the haras were like
  367. 15:23experts so they would say and they would
  368. 15:25allow them a margin of error up to a
  369. 15:28third.
  370. 15:29So for example, I'd look at that tree
  371. 15:31and I'd say, "Right, for that tree I
  372. 15:34estimate there's
  373. 15:3610 kilos of dates on there. So I've got
  374. 15:3910 kilos of dates here you can take them
  375. 15:42and I'll own that."
  376. 15:44So that's and this was common and it was
  377. 15:47guaranteed excess in this transaction.
  378. 15:50There's no way you got it down to the
  379. 15:52exact date never.
  380. 15:55But it was okay the scholars say that
  381. 15:57the excess could be up to a third of the
  382. 15:59entire quantity.
  383. 16:01The other thing is none of the scholars
  384. 16:04agreed on
  385. 16:06uh
  386. 16:07none of the there has been no agreement
  387. 16:10on riba to start off with what riba is
  388. 16:13actually even about.
  389. 16:15Okay, they I'm just giving us an
  390. 16:17understanding.
  391. 16:19The so Omar ibn al-Khattab famously said
  392. 16:22that I wish the prophet
  393. 16:24passed away and I wish one of the things
  394. 16:26he explained was riba.
  395. 16:29Ibn Abbas radiyallahu anhu in Sahih
  396. 16:32Muslim clearly denied any riba in
  397. 16:34delayed transactions.
  398. 16:37No, sorry sorry.
  399. 16:39Sorry, he denied let let me correct
  400. 16:41myself. He denied any riba except in
  401. 16:44delayed transactions.
  402. 16:47Right, he denied any riba except in
  403. 16:50delayed transactions. So as long as
  404. 16:53we're trading hand in hand you can do
  405. 16:55whatever you want. I can take double
  406. 16:58less whatever I want.
  407. 17:00He didn't this was Ibn Abbas this is in
  408. 17:03Sahih Muslim.
  409. 17:04So half a whole entire
  410. 17:07category of riba Ibn Abbas completely
  411. 17:10denied.
  412. 17:12The other thing is why on earth is when
  413. 17:15the categories are different are we not
  414. 17:17allowed to delay the payment?
  415. 17:21Why are we not allowed to delay the
  416. 17:23payment? Now
  417. 17:25so sorry why are we like we're bartering
  418. 17:28if I'm taking wheat from you for dates
  419. 17:32why am I not allowed to say collect
  420. 17:34dates from me tomorrow?
  421. 17:37Why does it have to be hand in hand? How
  422. 17:39does that become riba?
  423. 17:41I mean I can understand if I was
  424. 17:43exchanging gold for gold that maybe
  425. 17:45tomorrow the value of gold would change.
  426. 17:48If it was fluctuating that suddenly but
  427. 17:51why with bartering if the categories are
  428. 17:53different?
  429. 17:55So Ibn Ulayyah and some scholars are the
  430. 17:57only scholars who said that that's
  431. 18:00okay like it this doesn't make any
  432. 18:02sense.
  433. 18:04Now I'm coming to this about the riba
  434. 18:06from a bank. Now
  435. 18:08this is setting out the premise. This is
  436. 18:11important to understand.
  437. 18:13Right now
  438. 18:14I have asked I asked
  439. 18:18every or almost every senior scholar I
  440. 18:22could imagine in this day and age to
  441. 18:24explain this to me. And wallahi not a
  442. 18:27single I mean they could explain it
  443. 18:31and they could give an understanding
  444. 18:32which I could arrive at anyway and which
  445. 18:35is you know, it's it's not even I mean
  446. 18:36that okay, that maybe some exploitation
  447. 18:39could come about but nobody can has
  448. 18:43explained I've never come across a kind
  449. 18:45of thirst-quenching explanation on why
  450. 18:50uh bartering the delaying of one of the
  451. 18:54kind of product is riba.
  452. 18:57It doesn't make any like it doesn't make
  453. 19:00much rational sense okay to start off
  454. 19:02with.
  455. 19:03Now
  456. 19:04then the thing is okay, these four
  457. 19:07categories are mentioned in the Hadith
  458. 19:09what about other things?
  459. 19:11What about
  460. 19:12so for example, what about mobile
  461. 19:14phones?
  462. 19:15Nobody
  463. 19:17believes there's riba in mobile phones
  464. 19:20nobody.
  465. 19:22I could give you this is a Samsung. I
  466. 19:24could give you one Samsung for three
  467. 19:26Samsungs. Nobody will call that riba.
  468. 19:30I could swap your house for another
  469. 19:33house for two houses. Nobody will call
  470. 19:36that riba. I could swap your car.
  471. 19:39They dis Now
  472. 19:41when it came to what will what does riba
  473. 19:44operate in?
  474. 19:46The scholars massively disagreed.
  475. 19:48There's never been any agreement to
  476. 19:50start off with. So the Hanafi method
  477. 19:53looked at this Hadith and said, well,
  478. 19:56riba based on wheat, barley, dates, and
  479. 20:00salt, this is to do with scalable and
  480. 20:03wayable products. So, riba is in wayable
  481. 20:06and scalable products only.
  482. 20:10The Maliki method looked at this and
  483. 20:12said, no, this is to do with food.
  484. 20:16And the Shafi said, this is to do with
  485. 20:18food.
  486. 20:19The Maliki said, no, but this is a
  487. 20:21particular type of food that is that
  488. 20:24that is storable.
  489. 20:26So, these are products which you can
  490. 20:28store for almost a year. So, they're not
  491. 20:30perishable or easily perishable items.
  492. 20:33Hence, there is no such riba according
  493. 20:35to the Maliki method in things like
  494. 20:37fruits.
  495. 20:38I could trade apples with you.
  496. 20:42And I could take more or less.
  497. 20:45The Maliki method says that's not riba.
  498. 20:48Because there's no riba in fruits.
  499. 20:51But,
  500. 20:53according to the Hanafis, that's riba.
  501. 20:56Why? Because you scale them when you
  502. 20:58sell them.
  503. 20:59So, there was never a clear
  504. 21:02understanding on what riba actually is.
  505. 21:07Everybody agreeing that
  506. 21:10on several things, huge things, there is
  507. 21:13no riba.
  508. 21:15Like even though linguistically does
  509. 21:17exist. So, like the mobile phone example
  510. 21:21is a good example. Like swords in the
  511. 21:23past, I'll give you one sword for two
  512. 21:25swords. I'll give you this shield for
  513. 21:26this many shields.
  514. 21:28Right. Why am I Why am I explaining
  515. 21:31this? I'm going to come to I'm going to
  516. 21:32make it relevant for us in a moment, but
  517. 21:35I need to explain this to show
  518. 21:38that there was never from the offset any
  519. 21:41clarity in what riba was actually
  520. 21:44speaking about.
  521. 21:46It's important to understand that.
  522. 21:49Right now,
  523. 21:51okay, moving on from all of this.
  524. 21:54Right.
  525. 21:56What about in our
  526. 21:58the
  527. 21:59We need to come to what bothers people
  528. 22:01because people today don't barter,
  529. 22:03generally. They're not going to swap
  530. 22:05apples and oranges and do things like
  531. 22:07this. But, they want to buy a house on
  532. 22:10mortgage.
  533. 22:11They want to take out a loan.
  534. 22:13Are these things riba?
  535. 22:16These things are not riba
  536. 22:19in the Quranic sense, in my
  537. 22:20understanding.
  538. 22:21Yes, they may have some similarities in
  539. 22:24the sense that there is some excess of
  540. 22:26repayment.
  541. 22:28So, you're seeing a similarity
  542. 22:30like that element and you're assuming,
  543. 22:33oh, because of that similarity, this is
  544. 22:35the Quranic riba. It's not.
  545. 22:38Why is this not the Quranic riba?
  546. 22:41Because everything is different.
  547. 22:44Now,
  548. 22:46first of all, when a
  549. 22:48when you go to a bank to take a loan and
  550. 22:51they give you this sorry, they give your
  551. 22:53mortgage, they you know, they buy the
  552. 22:55house for you and you repay this house
  553. 22:59over,
  554. 23:01you know, almost lifetime.
  555. 23:04And obviously, they've tied in inflation
  556. 23:07and stuff like this. This concept as a
  557. 23:09concept did not even exist back then.
  558. 23:13This thought of
  559. 23:15first of all, of banks doing this,
  560. 23:18corporations corporations did not exist,
  561. 23:20banks did not exist. This thing of I'm
  562. 23:23giving you a money, I'm buying the house
  563. 23:27for you, you are buying it back or you
  564. 23:29are paying me did not even exist as a
  565. 23:31concept. Okay, to start off with.
  566. 23:35Whether whether we want to say that they
  567. 23:37are buying the house or they're giving
  568. 23:39you the money, I mean, they're doing it
  569. 23:41all, but okay, technically, the money is
  570. 23:43on your name.
  571. 23:45It did not even exist as a concept. So,
  572. 23:47back then in the prophet's time, this
  573. 23:49was never happening. Nobody was going to
  574. 23:52one of the
  575. 23:53Quraysh and people were saying, hey,
  576. 23:57right, people were saying, hey, uh will
  577. 24:00you buy me this house, pay me this much,
  578. 24:02and I'll pay you back over this portion.
  579. 24:04Never happened. This concept did not
  580. 24:07even exist. Okay. So, let's take that as
  581. 24:10one element.
  582. 24:12The other element is we have to
  583. 24:14understand that why riba was made haram
  584. 24:18was because of the excessive
  585. 24:20extortion
  586. 24:23loan shark loan shark culture
  587. 24:28that was diabolical.
  588. 24:32Because of that, riba was made haram.
  589. 24:36This today does not fit that.
  590. 24:40Right now,
  591. 24:41this today, right, you are not like
  592. 24:45nothing like that happens.
  593. 24:47You are operating within a greater
  594. 24:50framework.
  595. 24:51Okay, when you take out a mortgage,
  596. 24:54right, you are operating within greater
  597. 24:58legal parameters of commerce
  598. 25:01and of the banking structure. So, for
  599. 25:04example, people say, yeah, but you pay
  600. 25:06back more. Of course, first of all,
  601. 25:08first of all,
  602. 25:10another point to throw in here,
  603. 25:13you are not the person taking the money,
  604. 25:15you are the person giving the money.
  605. 25:18Okay, no person in their right mind
  606. 25:20would ever want to give back more
  607. 25:23than they took. But, it's only because
  608. 25:25of a necessity that, you know, you
  609. 25:28you don't have the money to start off
  610. 25:30with, so you're taking the money.
  611. 25:32Otherwise, nobody's going to say, yeah,
  612. 25:34you know what, I'll happily give you
  613. 25:36back more money than I took in the first
  614. 25:38place. Nobody happily does those things.
  615. 25:41So,
  616. 25:42let's get that straight to start off
  617. 25:44with. You are not the person taking.
  618. 25:46This isn't greed.
  619. 25:48You are the person giving.
  620. 25:51Okay, that's an important element, too.
  621. 25:54The other thing, like I said, is you are
  622. 25:57operating within a safe structure.
  623. 26:00This doesn't work like this isn't a loan
  624. 26:02shark culture.
  625. 26:04Like if you cannot pay back your
  626. 26:07mortgage tomorrow, the bank will
  627. 26:09actually cooperate with you
  628. 26:12to pay it back because it's in the
  629. 26:13bank's interest not to seize the
  630. 26:16property.
  631. 26:17It wants you to maintain a long
  632. 26:20commitment to paying back.
  633. 26:22Right? So,
  634. 26:24and people say, yeah, but the banks are
  635. 26:26I'm not trying to justify banks and
  636. 26:28banking culture, but what I'm telling
  637. 26:30you is
  638. 26:31let's juxtapose that with renting.
  639. 26:34You would have if you rented a property
  640. 26:38and you couldn't pay, you would be
  641. 26:39evicted much easier. You'd be evicted
  642. 26:42after 2 months.
  643. 26:44Whereas with a bank, you would easily
  644. 26:46obtain up to 6 months to a year
  645. 26:49to repay that.
  646. 26:52It would it would cooperate with you,
  647. 26:54whereas a private tenant wouldn't.
  648. 26:56Sorry, a private landlord would not
  649. 26:59cooperate like that.
  650. 27:01The other thing is that
  651. 27:04even if you cannot pay back the money,
  652. 27:07let's say you cannot pay back your
  653. 27:08mortgage,
  654. 27:10right?
  655. 27:11If you can't pay back your mortgage, you
  656. 27:14can go on to a management program, a
  657. 27:16debt management program. You can go on
  658. 27:19to an IVA. You can declare yourself
  659. 27:21bankrupt.
  660. 27:24Bankruptcy only lasts for 12 months.
  661. 27:27And they don't even seize your essential
  662. 27:30assets. I'm just saying, like you would
  663. 27:32So, for example, a car, you would still
  664. 27:35keep your car. You'd still keep all
  665. 27:36kinds of So, you are actually very
  666. 27:39protected.
  667. 27:41You are operating within these greater
  668. 27:44frameworks. So, whether you whether the
  669. 27:46bank is telling you these things, by the
  670. 27:48way, you can declare bankruptcy or not,
  671. 27:50it won't tell you that. But, you are
  672. 27:51operating within that framework. The
  673. 27:54banks have a legal obligation to
  674. 27:57cooperate. They have a legal obligation
  675. 27:59They can't do anything to you should you
  676. 28:01declare
  677. 28:03So, what I'm this
  678. 28:05This program is sponsored by Why am by
  679. 28:08Bach
  680. 28:09But, why am I saying this?
  681. 28:11Because the in the Quran,
  682. 28:15when Allah declared war,
  683. 28:17that's not what was happening.
  684. 28:20That was tyranny.
  685. 28:23Why was it declared so harshly? Why was
  686. 28:27it rebuked? Because of the tyranny that
  687. 28:31was unleashed on the back of this.
  688. 28:36Now, there's another point I'm about to
  689. 28:38say. Now, this is an important point. I
  690. 28:41need you to focus.
  691. 28:45Tawajjo farmao. Tawajjo Tawajjo farmao.
  692. 28:52That is, people,
  693. 28:54this is now the icing. So, that's some
  694. 28:56of the things I I wanted to highlight.
  695. 28:58That first of all, look,
  696. 29:00riba, it's never been clear what riba
  697. 29:02actually meant to start off with.
  698. 29:05Secondly,
  699. 29:06there's been confusion all along in what
  700. 29:08kinds of riba are haram and ain't.
  701. 29:11There's never been an agreement.
  702. 29:14Thirdly, the banking today and loans and
  703. 29:17mortgages do not operate like that
  704. 29:20diabolical kind of uh that
  705. 29:24barbaric loan shark culture. They don't
  706. 29:27operate like that at all.
  707. 29:29They do take back more from you. They
  708. 29:32have their versions of they're trying to
  709. 29:34tie this into
  710. 29:35uh inflation with some profit. Yes, they
  711. 29:38do that.
  712. 29:39But, you have a greater safety net at
  713. 29:42all times.
  714. 29:45Now, the other key thing that I'm about
  715. 29:48to go into and this is incredibly
  716. 29:49important.
  717. 29:51That is people, we have to understand
  718. 29:54that just that the concept of commerce
  719. 29:58and economics has entirely changed.
  720. 30:03Entirely changed
  721. 30:06since
  722. 30:07the 18th century.
  723. 30:10The whole world the world we live in
  724. 30:14today and the way economics is perceived
  725. 30:18the way finance is perceived has
  726. 30:20entirely changed and do not I need you
  727. 30:23to focus with me on this. Right, because
  728. 30:25some of you might just take this for
  729. 30:27granted and they not appreciate what I'm
  730. 30:29saying here.
  731. 30:31Everything has changed people.
  732. 30:35Everything.
  733. 30:37Industrialization
  734. 30:38and the rise of the the kind of economic
  735. 30:43culture with it absolutely changed.
  736. 30:48Let's backtrack.
  737. 30:50The greatest and most successful story
  738. 30:58the greatest I'm calling it a story the
  739. 31:00narrative and discourse that human
  740. 31:02beings ever invented
  741. 31:05ever the most successful story that
  742. 31:08human beings have ever created
  743. 31:13right out of the imagination
  744. 31:17is money.
  745. 31:19It is our greatest invention till date.
  746. 31:24Followed
  747. 31:27by
  748. 31:28gods
  749. 31:30and kingship.
  750. 31:33Okay.
  751. 31:34These three things
  752. 31:38are the greatest human stories that we
  753. 31:42have ever had.
  754. 31:45Okay, ever.
  755. 31:47Right, so
  756. 31:48now
  757. 31:50let let's
  758. 31:52human beings by arbitrarily placing
  759. 31:55value on
  760. 31:59arbitrarily placing value on some
  761. 32:02objects
  762. 32:03they managed to create a system an
  763. 32:07imaginative system by which they could
  764. 32:09trade.
  765. 32:11Trading is just a figment of our
  766. 32:13imagination.
  767. 32:14Ownership is just a story.
  768. 32:17You don't really I mean do we even own
  769. 32:19any? This is everything like this is
  770. 32:22discourse analysis people.
  771. 32:24When you start to study discourses.
  772. 32:27Now, money when we created money as in
  773. 32:32gold pieces this this has certain values
  774. 32:35now.
  775. 32:37What human beings did a few hundred
  776. 32:40years ago they did the second greatest
  777. 32:44they got that story
  778. 32:48and they gave it the greatest makeover.
  779. 32:52So, it became money 2.0.
  780. 32:54They dematerialized
  781. 32:56money. Okay, demineralized
  782. 33:00so it no longer the element elementized
  783. 33:04it okay. So, now it became paper.
  784. 33:09But it wasn't just this
  785. 33:12amazing ability to turn that into paper.
  786. 33:16But the whole story that they spun
  787. 33:20around this. Look
  788. 33:22stay with me stay with me.
  789. 33:25When the Quran was revealed in 7th
  790. 33:28century Arabia
  791. 33:31money was finite.
  792. 33:34It was a fixed aspect.
  793. 33:37So, for example if let's say in
  794. 33:40Birmingham
  795. 33:41there were 5 million gold pieces in
  796. 33:44Birmingham.
  797. 33:46That meant Birmingham that's the city
  798. 33:49where I live by the way the heart
  799. 33:51of the UK. Right, now
  800. 33:53Birmingham let's say it had 5 million
  801. 33:56gold pieces.
  802. 33:58It would only have 5 million gold
  803. 34:01pieces. These gold pieces couldn't just
  804. 34:03double or triple. I mean there could be
  805. 34:06some fluctuation tiny negligible
  806. 34:09fluctuation. So, some other person
  807. 34:11leaves the town some person comes some
  808. 34:13person goes but this is negligible.
  809. 34:16It generally has 5 million gold pieces.
  810. 34:19That's it.
  811. 34:21When I lend you
  812. 34:25when you borrow from me 1,000 gold
  813. 34:29pieces you're not going to pull
  814. 34:321,000 gold pieces out of thin air next
  815. 34:35month.
  816. 34:36They have to come from somewhere.
  817. 34:41Wealth is static.
  818. 34:44The only way Birmingham we can increase
  819. 34:48in wealth is if we
  820. 34:50raid another kingdom. So, let's raid
  821. 34:54Manchester as an example.
  822. 34:56So, Birmingham raids Manchester
  823. 34:59Manchester has 5 million gold pieces it
  824. 35:02drags that as part of their gold pieces
  825. 35:04now they have 10 million gold pieces.
  826. 35:07This is how kingdoms worked in the past.
  827. 35:11Money wasn't just pulled out of thin
  828. 35:13air. You had to gold was finite.
  829. 35:17So, when Allah says in the Quran that
  830. 35:20that let not the wealth be do let them
  831. 35:24be among men come let it not just go
  832. 35:27round and round amongst the rich from
  833. 35:31amongst you. That's because that's all
  834. 35:33it was.
  835. 35:36Right,
  836. 35:38got nothing against Manchester I love
  837. 35:40Manchester but I'm just saying. So
  838. 35:43I'm giving an example. Right, so now
  839. 35:46this poor person who's borrowed a
  840. 35:49thousand or five thousand gold pieces he
  841. 35:52can't just pull them out of thin air. He
  842. 35:54has to go to another person to get them.
  843. 35:58If you are trading it is the same thing.
  844. 36:01Money is static.
  845. 36:04Now, what the greatest trick the next
  846. 36:08greatest trick that humanity did Allah
  847. 36:14was it de-elementized
  848. 36:17it removed the element from money.
  849. 36:21It freed it.
  850. 36:24All of a sudden money became paper.
  851. 36:29Now
  852. 36:31you could
  853. 36:33you could
  854. 36:35give out money that you don't actually
  855. 36:37have.
  856. 36:40So
  857. 36:41with this
  858. 36:44you see as people started to get more
  859. 36:46money than was actually there they could
  860. 36:49do more things with that money.
  861. 36:53You see now tie this in. Now, hold that
  862. 36:56hold that peg that thought right there.
  863. 36:58Hold that and come back to another
  864. 37:01thought.
  865. 37:02With this you had the rise of people
  866. 37:05like Adam Smith and his understanding of
  867. 37:08economics.
  868. 37:10His understanding of commerce. Now, in
  869. 37:12his books amongst them
  870. 37:15the wealth of nations.
  871. 37:17He speaks about and you see now Adam
  872. 37:20Smith highly promoted things like
  873. 37:23obviously free trade free markets.
  874. 37:26But with there was a very important
  875. 37:29concept that he started to promote. And
  876. 37:32that was the pursuit of self-interest.
  877. 37:36You see prior to Adam Smith people were
  878. 37:39seeing this as just greed.
  879. 37:43That greed was a bad thing. So, when
  880. 37:46the Quran was condemning riba
  881. 37:49in the time of the Arabs of 7th century
  882. 37:53Arabia greed was just seen as an evil
  883. 37:56thing.
  884. 37:58But everything changes in the 18th
  885. 38:01century.
  886. 38:03You see all of a sudden you see like let
  887. 38:05me ask you
  888. 38:07if you were to open a shop
  889. 38:10and I asked you or you were to do
  890. 38:12business
  891. 38:14why is this just being greedy? Is your
  892. 38:17business just about you and being
  893. 38:19greedy?
  894. 38:20You will say and it may be about being
  895. 38:22greedy. But you will say no. Look, by me
  896. 38:26opening a shop I'm I'm I'm creating
  897. 38:30jobs. I'm
  898. 38:32what is it disseminating wealth within
  899. 38:34the community. I'm giving back to the
  900. 38:36community.
  901. 38:38I'm allowing trade within a community.
  902. 38:41I'm adding to the
  903. 38:43flourishing nature of a community.
  904. 38:46Now, believe it or not nobody nobody
  905. 38:50would have thought like that 500 years
  906. 38:53ago.
  907. 38:54Nobody.
  908. 38:56Now, it seems so common sense today.
  909. 38:59But it was impossible
  910. 39:02500 years ago to even think like that.
  911. 39:04Nobody thought like that.
  912. 39:07You see Adam Smith starts to write about
  913. 39:10the pursuit of self-interest. He says
  914. 39:13that look even if people are doing this
  915. 39:16for greed but greed in in the case of
  916. 39:19business is a good thing.
  917. 39:21Because what it does is you still feed
  918. 39:24back where you live.
  919. 39:26You create jobs. You are still
  920. 39:29disseminating wealth in that community.
  921. 39:33So, what happens in the decades and the
  922. 39:36centuries that follow is there is a
  923. 39:38shift
  924. 39:39in mindset.
  925. 39:42Imam
  926. 39:43ahlan wa sahlan, tusharrafna, people.
  927. 39:45Imam Mark, Manly is in the house. Allah,
  928. 39:48Allah.
  929. 39:49Right, a legend.
  930. 39:52Rising star, absolute star from the US.
  931. 39:55So, people, if you're not in touch,
  932. 39:57reach out to him and shoot away with
  933. 40:00your questions to him as well whenever
  934. 40:02you get a chance. Right, now
  935. 40:04this we're just discussing the concept
  936. 40:06of riba.
  937. 40:08Now
  938. 40:12I Imam Mark, I know
  939. 40:15your
  940. 40:16your views absolutely on the right
  941. 40:19supporting the right to bear arms.
  942. 40:22Right, so but coming back to this so the
  943. 40:24mind shift started to change. Another
  944. 40:27thing started to change. Right, with
  945. 40:30with this kind of thought of the pursuit
  946. 40:32of self-interest with economist
  947. 40:37Adam Smith is a revolutionary kind of
  948. 40:41a person who wrote on economics and
  949. 40:43stuff like that for whoever's asking the
  950. 40:45Another thing that started to change was
  951. 40:49the promise of tomorrow being better
  952. 40:52than yesterday.
  953. 40:53Now, in the past that was never the
  954. 40:55case. Now, this is another important
  955. 40:58ingredient.
  956. 40:59It was never the case.
  957. 41:02People in the past always felt that
  958. 41:06tomorrow would be worse than today and
  959. 41:09yesterday.
  960. 41:10So, they didn't want to give you money.
  961. 41:12When you came to ask somebody to loan
  962. 41:14you money, they would not give you
  963. 41:16money.
  964. 41:17Because they felt why should we? The
  965. 41:19chances are tomorrow is going to be
  966. 41:21miserable.
  967. 41:22It's going to be abysmal. There's going
  968. 41:24to be There's going to be just raids and
  969. 41:26war and battles and
  970. 41:29diseases and the the promise of tomorrow
  971. 41:32was never optimistic.
  972. 41:35Now, with industrialization
  973. 41:37that changed.
  974. 41:39So, all of a sudden we've got now hold
  975. 41:41on to these elements that I'm giving you
  976. 41:43these ingredients.
  977. 41:45So, the pursuit of self-interest the
  978. 41:48de-elementizing
  979. 41:50of money.
  980. 41:52Right, the promise of a better tomorrow
  981. 41:54and this promise of a better tomorrow
  982. 41:57catches on with the collective
  983. 41:59consciousness.
  984. 42:00So, people start to buy into this Once
  985. 42:03again, it's a shared imaginative
  986. 42:06reality.
  987. 42:07I'm not saying it's true. We It's just a
  988. 42:10shared reality.
  989. 42:12No, I'm not on stats. Right, so this
  990. 42:15shared reality that people started to
  991. 42:17think, "Well, tomorrow is going to be
  992. 42:19better."
  993. 42:20Now, another element
  994. 42:23the fact that
  995. 42:25banks were authorized
  996. 42:28to give out much more money than they
  997. 42:30actually had.
  998. 42:32Now, people might see this as a bad
  999. 42:34thing.
  1000. 42:35But, it allowed the community and
  1001. 42:37societies
  1002. 42:39to flourish.
  1003. 42:42Now, let me let me just illustrate that
  1004. 42:44for you.
  1005. 42:45Look.
  1006. 42:47Here is a bank.
  1007. 42:49I go to this bank and I put Let's say I
  1008. 42:52wish I wish
  1009. 42:54make dua, inshallah I become a
  1010. 42:56millionaire.
  1011. 42:58So, I put 1 million in the bank.
  1012. 43:01Pursuit of self-interest.
  1013. 43:03Right, so I put 1 million in the bank.
  1014. 43:06Now
  1015. 43:09here is another person.
  1016. 43:11He
  1017. 43:12decides to This person needs a loan from
  1018. 43:15the bank. So, let's just say we're going
  1019. 43:18to take
  1020. 43:20Shall I take some figures? I'll tell you
  1021. 43:22what, I'll use some of you guys right
  1022. 43:24here that are just logging in as some
  1023. 43:26live examples.
  1024. 43:28So
  1025. 43:29we've got Hamad. How you doing? I'm
  1026. 43:32going to use you as an example. So,
  1027. 43:33Hamad says, "All right, I'm going to I
  1028. 43:36need a loan. I want to set up a
  1029. 43:37business."
  1030. 43:39So Right, what I'm going to do is I need
  1031. 43:42a million pounds from the bank. So, the
  1032. 43:44bank borrows
  1033. 43:46a lends, sorry. Hamad borrows 1 million
  1034. 43:49from the bank. Okay, so he's got that.
  1035. 43:51So, Shakeel has just joined and said 100
  1036. 43:54trillion. So, okay.
  1037. 43:56Shakeel, I'll use as the next example.
  1038. 44:00Hamad to set up his business needs to
  1039. 44:02hire out a contractor. So, the
  1040. 44:04contractor is
  1041. 44:06a
  1042. 44:07A contractor says that fine to do this
  1043. 44:10job I need a million which Hamad has
  1044. 44:12taken. So, Shakeel now takes that
  1045. 44:15million from Hamad, puts it back in the
  1046. 44:17bank.
  1047. 44:19Whilst working away at his bank
  1048. 44:23Sorry, whilst working away on this
  1049. 44:25project
  1050. 44:26Shakeel realizes that wait a minute
  1051. 44:30this is going to cost This project is
  1052. 44:32going to cost double what I thought. He
  1053. 44:34goes back to Hamad and says, "Well,
  1054. 44:36sorry Hamad this ain't going to happen.
  1055. 44:39You need to double your investment."
  1056. 44:41Hamad goes back to the bank.
  1057. 44:44In this
  1058. 44:45Feroza bint al-Farsi has said, "I'm
  1059. 44:48supposed to be poor." Okay, Feroza, you
  1060. 44:49get to play the bank.
  1061. 44:52So
  1062. 44:53Feroza, who's the bank, right?
  1063. 44:56Hamad goes back to the bank and says,
  1064. 44:59"Look, I need another million."
  1065. 45:02The bank being generous and capitalistic
  1066. 45:06says no
  1067. 45:07no hay problema. Don't worry about it.
  1068. 45:10Right, so he the bank gives another
  1069. 45:14million.
  1070. 45:16All right, so Feroza, you decide to give
  1071. 45:18another million to Hamad.
  1072. 45:20Hamad pays that million to Shakeel, who
  1073. 45:25being a typical let's just say Pakistani
  1074. 45:28contractor was going to double the price
  1075. 45:31anyway. He goes and puts that million in
  1076. 45:33the bank.
  1077. 45:35Right. Now
  1078. 45:39you see
  1079. 45:40we've got I go and
  1080. 45:43and then obviously Hamad now let's say
  1081. 45:46owes 2 million to the bank. He pays back
  1082. 45:492 million to the bank
  1083. 45:51later on in time to come.
  1084. 45:53But, he sets up a
  1085. 45:55a glamorous business.
  1086. 45:58And that starts to flourish. He has
  1087. 46:00jobs. He creates jobs in the
  1088. 46:02environment. The contractor brings his
  1089. 46:04own crew. They have jobs. They work.
  1090. 46:07They spend their money. This million
  1091. 46:09that they've taken off Let's say Hamad,
  1092. 46:11they're spending some of it. They're
  1093. 46:13putting some in the bank. They're taking
  1094. 46:15it out. They're spending. Me
  1095. 46:18I'm I just originally just put 1 million
  1096. 46:20in the bank. I'm taking out mine
  1097. 46:22whatever I want whenever I want.
  1098. 46:25But, how much money did the bank
  1099. 46:26originally have?
  1100. 46:28Even if we say I actually had any
  1101. 46:30original money, it was only the bank
  1102. 46:33only had 1 million. Yet, it lent out
  1103. 46:36three, four million.
  1104. 46:41Certain laws allow banks to lend out up
  1105. 46:45to maybe even 10 times what they
  1106. 46:47actually have.
  1107. 46:49The question here is and I'm not saying
  1108. 46:51sometimes they can't do irresponsible
  1109. 46:53things. They can and we all know what
  1110. 46:55with the kind of bust and everything
  1111. 46:57what happened. But, my point is
  1112. 47:00you see what this allows is for
  1113. 47:02communities to flourish.
  1114. 47:06So, we are no long like
  1115. 47:10You see wealth and today I spoke about
  1116. 47:13another point. Today we spoke
  1117. 47:16I said that we had money 2.0 where it
  1118. 47:19was de-elementized
  1119. 47:21into paper. Now
  1120. 47:25money 3.0 it was digitalized.
  1121. 47:30All right.
  1122. 47:32Money now created out of thin air.
  1123. 47:38Just add and look at the beauty
  1124. 47:42by adding zero
  1125. 47:46which means nothing.
  1126. 47:48By adding nothing
  1127. 47:51you create money.
  1128. 47:52But, what do you create? You create
  1129. 47:54riches.
  1130. 47:56You enrich
  1131. 47:58a community. You enrich because whoever
  1132. 48:01has money, even if I'm as greedy as
  1133. 48:03greedy can be I'm still spending my
  1134. 48:06money where people are using it and
  1135. 48:09those people are spending it.
  1136. 48:12Like, it doesn't matter whether I'm as
  1137. 48:14greedy as I want to be.
  1138. 48:17If I start spending money
  1139. 48:20people somewhere are benefiting.
  1140. 48:23But, you see unlike
  1141. 48:257th century or 500 years ago or whenever
  1142. 48:30back then in time
  1143. 48:33money was static. If we had 5 million
  1144. 48:36gold pieces in Birmingham, that's all we
  1145. 48:38had.
  1146. 48:40But, now
  1147. 48:42but now
  1148. 48:45money
  1149. 48:46has no limits.
  1150. 48:49Human beings for once can actually
  1151. 48:52eradicate and they have to great not
  1152. 48:55globally, but to great capacities. They
  1153. 48:58have eradicated
  1154. 49:01poverty to great capacities, to great
  1155. 49:04limits. They have afforded your common
  1156. 49:08human being with immense luxuries. How
  1157. 49:11did they do this?
  1158. 49:13How did How did this even happen? How
  1159. 49:15could this happen?
  1160. 49:17Without these elements, these
  1161. 49:19ingredients
  1162. 49:21without the ability
  1163. 49:23of a a a better future, this hope this
  1164. 49:27shared narrative without these
  1165. 49:29structures, without this imaginative
  1166. 49:31kind of
  1167. 49:33money without this kind of So, what I'm
  1168. 49:36trying to say
  1169. 49:38is the culture in which Quranic riba
  1170. 49:41came.
  1171. 49:43This kind of loan shark, immense,
  1172. 49:46despotic, tyrannic
  1173. 49:49kind of
  1174. 49:50immensely oppressive culture, loan shark
  1175. 49:54culture, where money was finite and
  1176. 49:57fixed and gold pieces and if you didn't
  1177. 50:00produce them, you were
  1178. 50:01butchered or you were enslaved or your
  1179. 50:04family, your children were dragged away
  1180. 50:06and kidnapped and sold off and your wife
  1181. 50:09and whatever your
  1182. 50:11your relatives could have been, your
  1183. 50:14father, your brothers,
  1184. 50:16other people bear the pressure of what
  1185. 50:18you did.
  1186. 50:20All of this was happening.
  1187. 50:23And that's why Allah declares war on it.
  1188. 50:27Because of the tyranny that was
  1189. 50:28happening.
  1190. 50:29That is nothing
  1191. 50:32like
  1192. 50:33banks saying, "Well, okay, you've got
  1193. 50:35this house. We've sorted out the money
  1194. 50:37for you. You take 25 years to pay us
  1195. 50:40back.
  1196. 50:41And should you not be able to pay this
  1197. 50:44back,
  1198. 50:45you have so many structures. You can go
  1199. 50:47on debt management programs. You can You
  1200. 50:50can declare bankruptcy, which only lasts
  1201. 50:51for 12 months and then you're free.
  1202. 50:54It doesn't really I mean, it affects
  1203. 50:56your credit scoring, but you're not
  1204. 50:58nothing nothing like that happens.
  1205. 51:02The only similarity here is the fact
  1206. 51:05that okay, yes, they are asked that the
  1207. 51:08amount of money repaid is more
  1208. 51:11than the amount taken, but they are
  1209. 51:14arguing that look, obviously to do that
  1210. 51:18one, we've taken inflation into
  1211. 51:20consideration. Two, what they're saying
  1212. 51:23is we wouldn't Look, they need obviously
  1213. 51:26this whole culture, this imaginative
  1214. 51:27reality works on motivation, which works
  1215. 51:31on self-interest.
  1216. 51:33So, coming back to Adam Smith, they need
  1217. 51:36that pursuit of some self-interest to be
  1218. 51:38motivated to generate this greater dream
  1219. 51:42of a more prosperous tomorrow.
  1220. 51:44So, what I'm trying to say and then on
  1221. 51:46top of that, you are not the person
  1222. 51:48taking. You are not the person of greed
  1223. 51:51saying, "Ha, I want to consume people's
  1224. 51:53money." You are giving.
  1225. 51:57So, when you do all of these things,
  1226. 52:02I mean, sorry, when you take into
  1227. 52:03consideration all of these elements,
  1228. 52:07I do not feel
  1229. 52:09that the mortgages or loans that are
  1230. 52:12taken from banks today
  1231. 52:14are what the Quran is speaking about.
  1232. 52:17Now, you can disagree with me.
  1233. 52:19By all means. But in my understanding,
  1234. 52:22this is categorically a different
  1235. 52:24narrative.
  1236. 52:26This is an extremely immensely
  1237. 52:29oppressive loan shark
  1238. 52:32kind of culture that it's addressing.
  1239. 52:35And it's addressing where it's not just
  1240. 52:37even I know loan sharks do exist even in
  1241. 52:40this part of the world, but
  1242. 52:42they're an extreme rarity, but with un-
  1243. 52:46like
  1244. 52:47unlimited consequences.
  1245. 52:50So, that is what the Quran was
  1246. 52:53condemning with so much kind of um
  1247. 52:57with so much passion, if you like, when
  1248. 53:00it declared war on riba.
  1249. 53:02So, I hope that's of some help in
  1250. 53:05explaining why riba, in my
  1251. 53:08understanding, does not
  1252. 53:11does not kind of include these things.
  1253. 53:14To me,
  1254. 53:16a conventional mortgage and Islamic
  1255. 53:18mortgage or whatever mortgage are all
  1256. 53:20the same in my understanding.
  1257. 53:23Right? I I wouldn't uh
  1258. 53:25I mean, I wouldn't necessarily view
  1259. 53:27Obviously, if people want to go with the
  1260. 53:31uh you know, they want to go with what
  1261. 53:33they call Islamic mortgages. To me,
  1262. 53:35Islamic mortgages are exactly They're
  1263. 53:37just mortgages. Like what It's just a
  1264. 53:38play on words.
  1265. 53:40And I don't like that. The Maliki method
  1266. 53:42has never liked that kind of attitude of
  1267. 53:45trying to create loopholes and trying to
  1268. 53:47kind of trick God.
  1269. 53:49I I don't like I mean, I've got nothing
  1270. 53:51against them, but I see as just that.
  1271. 53:54Like, oh, they're saying a mortgage,
  1272. 53:57you're doing this. Oh, you know, you're
  1273. 53:59buying it for me, you're renting it to
  1274. 54:02me, I'm buying shares. Look, come on.
  1275. 54:04Everybody knows.
  1276. 54:06You know, just call a spade a spade.
  1277. 54:09Like, you see, all I'm doing is I'm just
  1278. 54:11saying, "Look, a spade is a spade.
  1279. 54:14This is the banking system.
  1280. 54:17Call it whatever you want. You know,
  1281. 54:18it's like Sayyidna Umar radiyallahu anhu
  1282. 54:22in his time, he had an issue with one of
  1283. 54:25the the kind of neighboring dynasties.
  1284. 54:28They weren't Muslim.
  1285. 54:30And uh they were Roman. And there was
  1286. 54:32one of the provinces refused to pay his
  1287. 54:34taxes to him.
  1288. 54:37And what happened is Sayyidna Umar said
  1289. 54:40to him that we have this agreement. And
  1290. 54:42by breaking this covenant between us,
  1291. 54:44it's seen as a declaration of war.
  1292. 54:47Would you want to do that? Why why would
  1293. 54:48you want to do And that person said,
  1294. 54:50"Look, I have no harm. I have no issue
  1295. 54:52in paying you."
  1296. 54:54He said that what it is is calling this
  1297. 54:56jizya, calling this an Islamic kind of
  1298. 54:59taxation,
  1299. 55:00I find it denigrating. My people insult
  1300. 55:03me.
  1301. 55:04So, how about you can take this same
  1302. 55:08money from me. It will come at the same
  1303. 55:10time of the year. It will come in the
  1304. 55:13same quantity.
  1305. 55:15But we will not call it jizya.
  1306. 55:18We will call it hadiya. That this is a
  1307. 55:20hadiya. This is a gift.
  1308. 55:23Okay. So, this is what he said to
  1309. 55:25Sayyidna Umar.
  1310. 55:26Sayyidna Umar just wrote back to him,
  1311. 55:29"Look." He said to him, "Send it on
  1312. 55:31time."
  1313. 55:34I said, "Done. I said, "Done." He said
  1314. 55:38to him, "Send it on time."
  1315. 55:40He said, "Hiyal jizya." Sammuha ma
  1316. 55:43shi'ta.
  1317. 55:44He said, "It is the jizya. It is the
  1318. 55:47tax. Call it whatever the hell you want.
  1319. 55:51I don't give a damn." Like he said,
  1320. 55:54"Just make sure it's on time."
  1321. 55:59I like it. That's the
  1322. 56:01a style. That's the style, the swagger
  1323. 56:05in the conduct. Now, you see, look, I'm
  1324. 56:08saying, "Look, let's just be real.
  1325. 56:10The whole system has changed.
  1326. 56:12Now, you can call this Islamic mortgages
  1327. 56:15or you can call it this.
  1328. 56:17That's one way of trying to bend and do
  1329. 56:20gymnastics. I'm just saying, "Look, the
  1330. 56:22whole day and age has changed. Where we
  1331. 56:25live, the whole banking system has I
  1332. 56:27mean, there there was no such thing as a
  1333. 56:29banking system.
  1334. 56:30The whole thing has been created.
  1335. 56:33That there's a promise of tomorrow,
  1336. 56:35there's this, there's that, there's
  1337. 56:36safety structures. It's not
  1338. 56:39loan shark kind of culture. So, I don't
  1339. 56:42feel it to be the same.
  1340. 56:45So, that's in my understanding, these
  1341. 56:47things are not haram. I'm not saying
  1342. 56:49people have to take them. I'd like to
  1343. 56:51add another little icing on the cake.
  1344. 56:54This is just my
  1345. 56:56uh point I'd just like to say that uh
  1346. 57:00that I feel that as Muslims and as
  1347. 57:03ethnic minorities
  1348. 57:05Not every Muslim is an ethnic minority
  1349. 57:07and I'm sure there's many uh perhaps
  1350. 57:09indigenous Muslims that are watching
  1351. 57:11this and you know, God bless you all and
  1352. 57:14us all, right? Uh but I'm just saying as
  1353. 57:17people in this country
  1354. 57:20or in the United States or in Europe, I
  1355. 57:23feel that we should invest in property.
  1356. 57:27That we should have kind of assets. That
  1357. 57:30we should This is just my
  1358. 57:32you know, it's not even my two cents or
  1359. 57:34whatever it is. You can just throw
  1360. 57:36discard it, you know, as as one of the
  1361. 57:39sh- Sheikhs said, "Banatu afkari."
  1362. 57:42Zuffat ilaykum. You know, fa'imsakum
  1363. 57:45bima'rufin aw tasrihum bi'ihsan.
  1364. 57:48You know, that's
  1365. 57:49as Allah says. You know, I
  1366. 57:51reject it I mean, leave it you
  1367. 57:54gracefully or accept it
  1368. 57:56respectfully. I mean, whichever way you
  1369. 57:58want, but th- this is just my thought
  1370. 58:00that I think we should
  1371. 58:03have some kind of status. We should have
  1372. 58:06some capital.
  1373. 58:08And you know, if you want to rent, by
  1374. 58:10all means. I'm not somebody that is
  1375. 58:12against that. I'm not somebody that's
  1376. 58:14against
  1377. 58:15Islamic mortgages per se, although I do
  1378. 58:18as the Maliki school and the Hanbali
  1379. 58:20school are against like they don't like
  1380. 58:22this concept of hiyal. They find it
  1381. 58:24denigrating that you're kind of trying
  1382. 58:25to trick God. But
  1383. 58:28but if by all means, if you want to if
  1384. 58:30it makes you
  1385. 58:31you know, if
  1386. 58:32if it makes you sleep better,
  1387. 58:35then by all means. I mean, do that. I
  1388. 58:37mean, if
  1389. 58:38But to me, these things are the same.
  1390. 58:41Taking out student loans, taking out
  1391. 58:44loans to fix up anything, taking out car
  1392. 58:47finance, taking out a mortgage, all of
  1393. 58:50these things fit the same category here.
  1394. 58:53Okay? I do not believe them to be haram
  1395. 58:56based on all of these elements. And riba
  1396. 58:58from the very onset or the offset has
  1397. 59:02never had an agreement over what it ever
  1398. 59:05meant anyway to start off with. As I
  1399. 59:08explained and went through elaborate
  1400. 59:10detail. And I know that was a bit
  1401. 59:11confusing, but it was important to show
  1402. 59:14that this was never
  1403. 59:16a clear-cut matter.
  1404. 59:19So, although the term pe- Muslims have
  1405. 59:22symbolized the term,
  1406. 59:24uh b- but they never
  1407. 59:27kind of had a concept. The signified was
  1408. 59:31always blurry.
  1409. 59:34Right. Woo.
  1410. 59:36Mostly
  1411. 59:39Uh shukran shukran abida shukran. Right,
  1412. 59:42so I hope that's of Right, Sheikh Noman
  1413. 59:45bear ahlan wa sahlan people. That's
  1414. 59:47Sheikh Noman bear in the house from
  1415. 59:50America, California
  1416. 59:52people. Uh we were in the same although
  1417. 59:55at different times we're in the same
  1418. 59:56madrasah back in Karachi, Pakistan.
  1419. 59:59So, that's awesome. So, I hope that's
  1420. 1:00:01been of some help. I'll tell you what,
  1421. 1:00:02I'll take some rapid rap

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Are Mortgages & Bank Loans Haram? - Mufti Abu Layth by Mufti Abu Layth, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,895 words across 1,421 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.