YouTube2Text

Як почнеться Третя світова | Віталій Портников @ApostropheTV — Transcript

by Віталій Портников · 7,925 words · 1,234 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:12Glory to Ukraine! Runa on air: the
  2. 0:14Russian House in the center of Berlin
  3. 0:15has been closed. I translate this as,
  4. 0:17of course, a cover for the Russian
  5. 0:19Federation's intelligence services.
  6. 0:21Putin's statements, there are quite a
  7. 0:23few of them, and then the Finance
  8. 0:24Minister’s whining. How could we do
  9. 0:26without them? Vitaly Portnikov,
  10. 0:27publicist and journalist, is with us.
  11. 0:28Mr. Vitaly, good evening. I am glad to
  12. 0:31see you.
  13. 0:32Greetings.
  14. 0:34Uh, I think I’d like to start with
  15. 0:36the issue of security. This sixth day
  16. 0:38is ending today. The sixth day, or no,
  17. 0:41the seventh day of almost non-stop,
  18. 0:43round-the-clock terror with missiles,
  19. 0:45drones, and ballistics. That's Kyiv and
  20. 0:48the region. And yesterday, following
  21. 0:51the Shanghai Cooperation Organization
  22. 0:53press conference, Putin spoke a great
  23. 0:56deal about security and his vision for
  24. 0:58the continuation of the war. Usually,
  25. 1:01they are very simple; they are not
  26. 1:03Chinese diplomats. Whatever they say,
  27. 1:06that is what they mean to imply. There
  28. 1:08is nothing more to it. These are
  29. 1:10threats to both the West and Ukraine.
  30. 1:13Uh, well, just in that direct form. And
  31. 1:16the nuclear option was mentioned again
  32. 1:18from their side. And already there are
  33. 1:19such direct, not even hints anymore.
  34. 1:21What if we terrorize the civilian
  35. 1:23population so much that they simply
  36. 1:25come out and surrender? Uh, they are
  37. 1:28just announcing this plan to us. Is
  38. 1:30there anything to interpret, translate,
  39. 1:32or analyze here? Well, first of all, I
  40. 1:36would separate two important things
  41. 1:38when we talk about the statements of
  42. 1:41Russian politicians and officials.
  43. 1:44There are people who make decisions,
  44. 1:46and there are people who do not make
  45. 1:48decisions. And the people who do not
  46. 1:51make decisions have now been given a
  47. 1:53large platform, which they didn't have
  48. 1:56until recently, simply because they
  49. 1:58were of no use to anyone in Russian
  50. 2:00media. But now there is an election
  51. 2:03campaign underway. Everything you hear,
  52. 2:07is essentially what is called an
  53. 2:09election campaign in normal societies.
  54. 2:12In Russia, it is not. Because it is
  55. 2:14clear that the list of State Duma
  56. 2:16deputies of the Russian Federation is
  57. 2:18approved before the elections in the
  58. 2:19office of the First Deputy Chief of
  59. 2:21Staff of the Presidential
  60. 2:22Administration, Sergei Kiriyenko. But
  61. 2:26these people are trying to prove to
  62. 2:28their handlers—many of whom are, in
  63. 2:30fact, agents of the Russian Federal
  64. 2:32Security Service—that they are truly
  65. 2:34needed. They have this competition for
  66. 2:39usefulness, even if not to the people,
  67. 2:42though they obviously hope their
  68. 2:44bloodthirsty views will be accepted by
  69. 2:47society, but primarily to Putin and
  70. 2:49Kiriyenko. In other words, they want to
  71. 2:54be, as they say, holier than the Pope
  72. 2:56—or rather, more bloodthirsty than
  73. 2:58Putin—to show that they fully approve
  74. 3:00of this policy, that they are for the
  75. 3:02war, and that all Ukrainians are
  76. 3:04enemies because they did not appreciate
  77. 3:06the genius of the greatest president of
  78. 3:08Russia. So, if you look closely, it is
  79. 3:12simply a real political process. A
  80. 3:15representative of United Russia calls
  81. 3:17for striking the civilian population,
  82. 3:20and the next day, a representative of A
  83. 3:23Just Russia does the same; well, what
  84. 3:25else can you say? He is calling for the
  85. 3:28use of a nuclear bomb. And we know all
  86. 3:31these people very well. For instance,
  87. 3:34the Deputy Chairman of the State Duma
  88. 3:37of the Russian Federation, Pyotr
  89. 3:38Tolstoy. I studied with him at the
  90. 3:40Faculty of Journalism of Moscow
  91. 3:41University. Oksana,
  92. 3:44I thought so.
  93. 3:45This man, this man has never hidden his
  94. 3:48contempt for people, as such. I will
  95. 3:52remember it for the rest of my life, by
  96. 3:53the way, I haven't told this, but I
  97. 3:55will tell you, because it is an almost
  98. 3:56intimate story. I remember for the rest
  99. 4:00of my life how I was with Pyotr
  100. 4:03flying together to Kazakhstan. We were
  101. 4:04on a business trip. He was there for
  102. 4:06Agence France-Presse, because he had
  103. 4:08worked for many years at Agence
  104. 4:09France-Presse, a bourgeois, imperialist
  105. 4:11one, because French is his native
  106. 4:12language. He is one of those Tolstoys
  107. 4:15who are direct descendants of Leo
  108. 4:17Tolstoy. And they were forced to move
  109. 4:19from Yugoslavia to Russia after World
  110. 4:21War II. They fled from the Bolsheviks.
  111. 4:24They did not want to live in the Soviet
  112. 4:26Union at all. They were simply, one
  113. 4:29might say, at gunpoint, his grandfather
  114. 4:31, I believe, was forced to move. What
  115. 4:34kind of people are these? So, we are
  116. 4:37sitting in the airport waiting area in
  117. 4:39Moscow, and Tolstoy is reading a French
  118. 4:42book. Well, he is reading in his native
  119. 4:45language, and I am sitting nearby
  120. 4:47reading a book in Polish.
  121. 4:51Uh-huh.
  122. 4:52And I say to him, jokingly, between
  123. 4:55people who are studying together, such
  124. 4:58a conversation. I say to him, "You know
  125. 5:02, Count, if we had been sitting
  126. 5:04together 100 years ago somewhere at
  127. 5:06some train station, it would have been
  128. 5:08exactly the same scene. You would be
  129. 5:12reading in French, I would be reading
  130. 5:14in Polish. Nothing has changed in 100
  131. 5:18years, I would say, on this proscenium
  132. 5:20of curiosity about cultural worlds."
  133. 5:23Because you know that Jews in the
  134. 5:24Russian Empire were very often also
  135. 5:26Polish-speaking at the same time. And
  136. 5:30he looks at me and says, "Vitaly, 100
  137. 5:32years ago you and I would not have been
  138. 5:34sitting anywhere near each other."
  139. 5:39There you have it, it just
  140. 5:42instinctively slipped out. I understood
  141. 5:46perfectly well that this person
  142. 5:48actually looks at me like an insect
  143. 5:50because he perceives himself as a
  144. 5:52nobleman, as they say in Russian, "blue
  145. 5:55blood." A wedding in Geneva. Who could
  146. 5:58perform the ceremony? The Archbishop of
  147. 6:00Geneva? It’s not for these Russian
  148. 6:02peasants to marry us. And from here, of
  149. 6:05course, when he says that it is okay to
  150. 6:07strike at Ukrainian civilians, for him,
  151. 6:09these Ukrainian civilians are serfs.
  152. 6:11Well, serfs who need to be punished.
  153. 6:14Russians too. It’s just that, from
  154. 6:17his point of view, he is ready to give
  155. 6:19orders to one group of serfs to beat
  156. 6:20the others. And that is all there is to
  157. 6:23it. And then there is Zhuravlyov. About
  158. 6:26the nuclear bomb. We also know
  159. 6:27Zhuravlyov very well. He is the leader
  160. 6:30of a neo-fascist party. The Rodina
  161. 6:32party, which he leads, which is part of
  162. 6:35A Just Russia. These are neofascists.
  163. 6:40That must be clearly understood. If you
  164. 6:43read the program of this party, it is
  165. 6:46the program of the National Socialist
  166. 6:48German Workers 'Party, rewritten for
  167. 6:51Russians. Because what these people say
  168. 6:54—Tolstoy, Zhuravlyov, or anyone else
  169. 6:55—I have stopped following them, it is
  170. 6:57of absolutely no interest to me. Let
  171. 7:00Seryozha Kirienko think about how
  172. 7:02adequate Tolstoy is today, and how well
  173. 7:04he is performing the job he was
  174. 7:07entrusted with. That is not our problem
  175. 7:10. These are the problems of those
  176. 7:12people who, back in the 90s of the 20th
  177. 7:14century, when we were studying at the
  178. 7:16journalism department, came to him from
  179. 7:18Lubyanka and said: "No, Count." They
  180. 7:21didn't call him Count. They said: "
  181. 7:24Comrade Tolstoy, you yourself
  182. 7:26understand the problems of your origin,
  183. 7:28the question of trust.""We think you
  184. 7:33realize that you have to earn this
  185. 7:36trust.""And we respect your esteemed
  186. 7:40grandfather.""Lenin wrote about him.""
  187. 7:42So, sign this paper, please, stating
  188. 7:44that you will cooperate with the
  189. 7:46Committee for State Security of the
  190. 7:48Soviet Union and report on the
  191. 7:49sentiments in your course." And I am
  192. 7:52practically certain that Tolstoy simply
  193. 7:55could not help but sign, given his poor
  194. 7:57background. "It is unknown whether you
  195. 8:00would have returned to our Soviet
  196. 8:02Motherland on your own if you hadn't
  197. 8:04been forced.""And you surely want to
  198. 8:08travel abroad, work for the French,
  199. 8:10earn foreign currency, and want to be
  200. 8:13accepted to the journalism faculty,
  201. 8:15despite not having a worker-peasant
  202. 8:18origin." And so this complex is formed.
  203. 8:22And for Putin, of course, imagine Putin
  204. 8:24, who just yesterday was running around
  205. 8:26some back alley, and here is Count
  206. 8:28Tolstoy himself. Well, fine. No, not
  207. 8:31Leo Nikolayevich, licking his boots
  208. 8:34with his tongue. Pleasant. Almost an
  209. 8:37orgasm. And by the way, every dictator,
  210. 8:39as you know, must have his own Tolstoy.
  211. 8:41Stalin had the real Red Count, Alexei
  212. 8:44Tolstoy. Well, he was indeed a
  213. 8:45prominent novelist. Well, there is
  214. 8:47nothing to say there.
  215. 8:49We won't talk about his moral qualities
  216. 8:51, but his novels are well-known. They
  217. 8:54play a major role in Russian literature
  218. 8:56. We still remember about his
  219. 8:58collaboration, don't we? Nothing can be
  220. 9:00done about that. But Tolstoy cannot
  221. 9:02write any Buratino. He is a Buratino
  222. 9:04himself. That is the problem. A wooden
  223. 9:07boy. So, these are their problems. Now
  224. 9:09let's move on to this, to Karabas,
  225. 9:12Parabas,
  226. 9:14the one who makes decisions, to Putin.
  227. 9:19We have talked about the puppet theater
  228. 9:21. Karabas, he is not in as good a
  229. 9:24condition as I would say. He is simply
  230. 9:26trying to intimidate us. On one hand,
  231. 9:28he is intimidating us, and on the other
  232. 9:31hand, he obviously wants negotiations.
  233. 9:33He is essentially inviting Withoft and
  234. 9:35Kushner to the Russian capital in plain
  235. 9:38text and saying, "We trust these people
  236. 9:41.""Such wonderful people, fine people."
  237. 9:44"And Trump trusts them, and we can talk
  238. 9:47to them, they are so constructive."
  239. 9:49What is this? What kind of thing is
  240. 9:51that? It’s Chichikov's monologue
  241. 9:54before he tries to buy some dead souls
  242. 9:57from Sobakevich or Manilov. What’s
  243. 10:01with this joy? Why have you become so
  244. 10:03kind to Vhad and Kushner? That means
  245. 10:05some kind of negotiation process is
  246. 10:06needed. That means something happened
  247. 10:09in Bishkek during the conversation with
  248. 10:11Xi Jinping. We don't know what. But at
  249. 10:15least something like this was obviously
  250. 10:18said: "Dear Mr. President, we
  251. 10:20understand your concern for your own
  252. 10:22security, but the People's Republic of
  253. 10:25China believes that a political
  254. 10:27dialogue would be necessary to reduce
  255. 10:29the level of tension and escalation
  256. 10:32that exists in the modern world."
  257. 10:35That’s roughly how they speak in the
  258. 10:37Central Committee of the Communist
  259. 10:38Party, that’s how they use those
  260. 10:40words. He heard it. Unlike Trump, he
  261. 10:42definitely understands what those words
  262. 10:44mean. It means "I'll gouge your eyes
  263. 10:48out"
  264. 10:50and "pull your eyes over a certain
  265. 10:52place."
  266. 10:53But it looks so intelligent like that.
  267. 10:56And he, as a person who was just told
  268. 10:58about the eyes and that certain place,
  269. 11:00is trying to maneuver somehow so as not
  270. 11:02to hear it anymore. There you go. He is
  271. 11:05threatening, yet he also wants to talk.
  272. 11:07And what about his phrase that he is
  273. 11:08not carrying out strikes on the
  274. 11:10Ukrainian leadership? Because he needs
  275. 11:12negotiators. This is a man who, in
  276. 11:14February 2022, made the decision to
  277. 11:16liquidate this leadership. Did you
  278. 11:18think Yanukovych and Medvedchuk were
  279. 11:20supposed to come to power, just walk in
  280. 11:21and sit in Zelenskyy’s office? No,
  281. 11:23Zelenskyy and his inner circle were
  282. 11:25supposed to be shot by Russian troops,
  283. 11:28just like what happened to the head of
  284. 11:30the Revolutionary Council of the
  285. 11:32Democratic Republic of Afghanistan,
  286. 11:34Hafizullah Amin, when Soviet troops
  287. 11:36entered. If we have already decided who
  288. 11:38will be the head of the Revolutionary
  289. 11:40Council of Ukraine, why do we need this
  290. 11:42Zelenskyy? He must be destroyed so that
  291. 11:44no one else claims power in our beloved
  292. 11:46Ukraine, and now he doesn't want to hit
  293. 11:48him with missiles. Why would that be?
  294. 11:50What’s up? What’s with this love?
  295. 11:52But there is a cognitive dissonance.
  296. 11:54Well, firstly, he says: "Well, we are
  297. 11:55preparing, I gave the order to prepare
  298. 11:57massive strikes there and destroy all
  299. 11:59the energy infrastructure there. One,
  300. 12:01it will be worse there, two." But we
  301. 12:03are leaving the leadership alive, three
  302. 12:05. There is, I don't know, like a "
  303. 12:07premise for peace." That's already a
  304. 12:10bad phrase. Potential.
  305. 12:11Premise for peace. We hope they will
  306. 12:14capitulate.
  307. 12:15And this, so I don't forget, is the
  308. 12:17potential for veiled advice about the "
  309. 12:19eyes" and everything else from the
  310. 12:21Chinese leader. How deep does that go?
  311. 12:27Well, he thinks that one needs at least
  312. 12:29to imitate negotiations. He is at least
  313. 12:31talking about the fact that he needs
  314. 12:32Ukrainian negotiators and needs the
  315. 12:33Vhad and Kushner types. By the way,
  316. 12:35when he talks about Ukrainian
  317. 12:36negotiators, it is also a jab at Trump.
  318. 12:43Here you have Trump, there is no one
  319. 12:45left to surrender to in Iran, because
  320. 12:46you killed everyone, but we won't kill
  321. 12:47everyone, so that we have someone to
  322. 12:49surrender to. We are smarter. This is
  323. 12:51also a kind of game. But in any case,
  324. 12:55Putin is a walking cognitive dissonance
  325. 12:57. So you are absolutely right. Well,
  326. 13:00listen, this is the logic of a criminal
  327. 13:02. I want to make a deal with you, you
  328. 13:05scum. I hate you. I will kill you, rape
  329. 13:10your wife, eat your children for dinner
  330. 13:14, but let's split this 50/50. Come on,
  331. 13:18let's make it 70. Give me 70. Well okay
  332. 13:22, give it to me, I'll kill you. I will
  333. 13:25do such things to you. I have already
  334. 13:27given the order. My guys are already on
  335. 13:28their way. They will cut off all your
  336. 13:30fingers. Let's make it 45. Let's make
  337. 13:32it 45. Well, that's not much. What is
  338. 13:3445? This is a joint cause. I have done
  339. 13:37so much. But generally, I will destroy
  340. 13:40you. All the planes will bomb you. Scum
  341. 13:42. I hate you. Let's make it 19. Can it
  342. 13:46be 19? This is exactly what it is. So
  343. 13:50this is a simple tactic, because people
  344. 13:52very often say about Putin that he is a
  345. 13:55great Chekist, but he is a thug. He is
  346. 13:58a man who wore a famous maroon jacket
  347. 14:03in the 90s. Did you see him in the 90s?
  348. 14:07I did.
  349. 14:07I saw him. He looked like a bandit. He
  350. 14:10spoke like a bandit. Chekists don't
  351. 14:12talk like that. Listen, I see in my
  352. 14:15life, and now I think everyone should
  353. 14:17take out their notebooks and write down
  354. 14:19that I was recruited by the KGB, the
  355. 14:21FSB. I have seen dozens of Chekists in
  356. 14:25my life. Where
  357. 14:26are the dozens of Chekists? Listen
  358. 14:28carefully. So, they all recruited me.
  359. 14:31All those dozens, hundreds, but I have
  360. 14:33seen dozens of people. I saw all of the
  361. 14:37last Soviet chairmen of the State
  362. 14:40Security Committee of the Soviet Union
  363. 14:43directly. Just like I am talking to you
  364. 14:45now. Chebrikov, Kryuchkov.
  365. 14:47Uh-huh.
  366. 14:48I saw the heads of the State Security
  367. 14:50Committee of the Ukrainian SSR. I saw
  368. 14:52the generals of the foreign
  369. 14:53intelligence service. I talked to them,
  370. 14:55take my word for it. They were, of
  371. 14:58course, all terrible people, but none
  372. 15:01of them behaved like Putin. They
  373. 15:03behaved exactly like officers. As they
  374. 15:05said in the Soviet Union: "People in
  375. 15:06plain clothes." What are people in
  376. 15:08plain clothes? How do you distinguish a
  377. 15:10person in plain clothes from another
  378. 15:12person in the same kind of jacket? By
  379. 15:13their behavior, by their behavior. It
  380. 15:16is, I would say, you know, cautious and
  381. 15:19with a sense of their own power, almost
  382. 15:25unnoticeable, but with, I would say, a
  383. 15:28certain pressure on the interlocutor.
  384. 15:33But Putin never behaved that way. You
  385. 15:34see how he behaves. Feet here, hands
  386. 15:37there, and all the time using some kind
  387. 15:39of obscene language. "I'll show you,"
  388. 15:42he says, and so on. Right. If grandma
  389. 15:45had grandpa's parts, she wouldn't be
  390. 15:47grandma anymore. We'll "whack them in
  391. 15:50the." Yes.
  392. 15:52Bandito, gangstero, Putinito. He’s
  393. 15:57not an officer at all. You see, what
  394. 15:59kind of officer? There are no such
  395. 16:02officers, even in the KGB. He is a bad
  396. 16:07Chekist. Well, by the way, Putin had
  397. 16:09associates who were actual Chekists.
  398. 16:11Take Sergei Ivanov, for instance—an
  399. 16:13absolutely vile person, but he acted
  400. 16:16like a Chekist, not a bandit. Well,
  401. 16:19there’s your answer. Or Patrushev, he
  402. 16:21doesn't behave like that either.
  403. 16:22We’re just talking about the people
  404. 16:24who are there. They are no better than
  405. 16:26Putin. They are immoral creatures, but
  406. 16:28they aren't criminals in that
  407. 16:30behavioral sense. But Putin behaves
  408. 16:32like that all the time. He thinks it's
  409. 16:34cool because he didn't grow up among
  410. 16:36Chekists, but among bandits. He went to
  411. 16:40these judo halls, and he was beaten
  412. 16:42there. He realized that the main
  413. 16:45culture is the culture of beating. Do
  414. 16:49you understand? This isn't some boy
  415. 16:51from an intelligent Jewish family like
  416. 16:52Volodya Zelenskyy, who walked through
  417. 16:54working-class neighborhoods in Kryvyi
  418. 16:55Rih and didn't understand what he was
  419. 16:57doing there with his little violin. No,
  420. 16:59this is a completely different story.
  421. 17:02This is not some violin.
  422. 17:03Well, that’s why they can’t find
  423. 17:04common ground. Mr. Vitaly, this terror
  424. 17:07—is it a change in tactics, is it not
  425. 17:08just terror, but a demonstrative terror
  426. 17:10against Kyiv, the capital? Does this
  427. 17:13fit into the logic of a peace plan or
  428. 17:15not, because he received a hint from
  429. 17:17China, say, yesterday or the day before
  430. 17:18, that we are striking, but we...
  431. 17:21I think that the strike on Kyiv,
  432. 17:23the strikes on Kyiv are just an attempt
  433. 17:26to do something to show the Russians
  434. 17:28that he is capable of forcing Ukraine
  435. 17:31to end the war. The war is already in
  436. 17:33the homes of Russians, right? How can
  437. 17:37one force Ukraine to capitulate?
  438. 17:39Uh-huh.
  439. 17:40Let me tell you why it’s specifically
  440. 17:42strikes on Kyiv. It is our misfortune,
  441. 17:47because we live in a non-centralized
  442. 17:49country, and even for us Kyivans, we
  443. 17:51don't have the feeling that Kyiv is
  444. 17:53something completely separate from
  445. 17:56Odesa, Dnipro, Kharkiv, Lviv, or
  446. 17:58Donetsk. It's true, we just have big
  447. 18:01cities. Kyiv plays a big role among
  448. 18:04them, but until recently, it wasn't
  449. 18:06even the richest city in Ukraine. The
  450. 18:08richest was Odesa back in the Russian
  451. 18:10Empire. Odesa was the second wealthiest
  452. 18:14city in the empire after Saint
  453. 18:16Petersburg. So, we don't have that.
  454. 18:20Here, a person can express themselves
  455. 18:22and realize their potential if they
  456. 18:24want to live in a big city. Uh-huh.
  457. 18:26In Kyiv, in Kharkiv, in Donetsk before
  458. 18:28its occupation, where flights from
  459. 18:30Boryspil took off every two hours.
  460. 18:32Planes in Dnipro, in Lviv, when I said
  461. 18:42in Moscow that before Moscow University
  462. 18:44I had studied in Dnipro.
  463. 18:45Uh-huh.
  464. 18:46They looked at me like someone who had
  465. 18:48been severely ill. I just couldn't
  466. 18:50understand why. Because from the Moscow
  467. 18:53perspective, if you studied anywhere
  468. 18:55outside of Moscow, it had to be the
  469. 18:57capital of a Soviet Republic. You
  470. 18:59couldn't live anywhere else. You could
  471. 19:02live in Moscow. And if you were some
  472. 19:04unfortunate, sick person living in
  473. 19:06Ukraine, in Belarus, or in Kazakhstan,
  474. 19:11then it had to be Kyiv, Minsk, Almaty.
  475. 19:16Well, now Astana. Meaning that outside
  476. 19:19the capital there can be no life,
  477. 19:20because everything is in the capital:
  478. 19:23power, corruption, money, and everyone
  479. 19:25else must serve the capital. This is
  480. 19:27the Laputa concept. Remember Laputa? In
  481. 19:30Jonathan Swift, Gulliver arrived in a
  482. 19:32country above which such a saucer was
  483. 19:34flying. And it flew, and the rulers and
  484. 19:38their whole retinue sat there. And from
  485. 19:42time to time, they threw stones at
  486. 19:44their own country. So, Russian
  487. 19:47statehood has always been the Laputa
  488. 19:50concept since the time of Andrey
  489. 19:52Bogolyubsky. And why do they strike
  490. 19:54Kyiv? Because they believe that the
  491. 19:56Laputa concept applies everywhere.
  492. 19:58Uh-huh. Even in Russian journalism—we
  493. 20:02ourselves use their clichés as a rule
  494. 20:05when we say: "Moscow responded to
  495. 20:08Berlin, Berlin to Warsaw." That's not
  496. 20:12how international journalism usually
  497. 20:13speaks, in principle. It's just that
  498. 20:17kind of conversation where everything
  499. 20:19happens in one place. That's why you
  500. 20:21need to strike at one point. If we
  501. 20:23strike only at Dnipro, they won't even
  502. 20:25notice. What difference does it make?
  503. 20:27It's the same as them striking Bryansk.
  504. 20:29Well, even if they destroyed that
  505. 20:31Bryansk. How many of those Bryansks are
  506. 20:32there, what do we care about that
  507. 20:33Bryansk? Remember how many years we
  508. 20:35have been hitting Belgorod? Did a
  509. 20:37single soul notice? But a 15-minute
  510. 20:40closure of the Sheremetyevo-2 airport.
  511. 20:44Oh, that is the pain and anxiety of
  512. 20:46every Russian person. My God, a plane
  513. 20:49can't take off from Sheremetyevo to
  514. 20:52Dubai. God! And that poor woman living
  515. 20:55in Krasnoyarsk, she is just crying, not
  516. 20:58cooking cutlets for her children, not
  517. 21:00helping her husband recover from
  518. 21:02hawthorn tincture. She is in grief; the
  519. 21:05tragedy is you can no longer get into
  520. 21:08or out of Sheremetyevo. It's a
  521. 21:11nationwide grief. That is Russian
  522. 21:13national security. What does it mean?
  523. 21:15That everything in Moscow should be
  524. 21:17fine. Just Moscow. And by the way, this
  525. 21:20is not a joke. I saw the first drone
  526. 21:23strikes on Moscow, and there was this
  527. 21:24guy—I think we even discussed this—
  528. 21:26from Rostov who said: "Oh, well, in
  529. 21:28Rostov we have this all the time, but
  530. 21:30how can something like that happen in
  531. 21:31Moscow?" Oh, I will never forget that
  532. 21:37drone if I suddenly saw it in Moscow. "
  533. 21:41But as for Kyiv, they only really
  534. 21:43focused or accumulated their attention
  535. 21:46on it in the fifth year of the war.
  536. 21:48Meaning, they thought differently
  537. 21:51before. Well, they did attack Kyiv,
  538. 21:53they struck Kyiv.
  539. 21:54No, it's just that Moscow shouldn't be
  540. 21:56touched.
  541. 21:56And yet
  542. 21:57previously, they spread their strikes
  543. 22:00across the entire territory. And if we
  544. 22:03have already reached Moscow, then the
  545. 22:05strikes on Kyiv are just a simple
  546. 22:07signal. Don't touch Moscow, that's
  547. 22:10where Koschei's death is hidden. Which
  548. 22:13means we must strike there. Mr. Vitaliy
  549. 22:15, before I forget, this is an important
  550. 22:17question; it is actually deep and, I
  551. 22:19think, something that will take many
  552. 22:20years to comprehend. And what you said
  553. 22:23—these statements, do they just fit
  554. 22:25into political PR or the election
  555. 22:27campaigns of these deputies, or of
  556. 22:29Putin himself?
  557. 22:30Not the deputies, yes.
  558. 22:32But they do understand; unlike us, they
  559. 22:35know their population, or their biomass
  560. 22:37. They understand that this is
  561. 22:38well-received. In other words, they are
  562. 22:40selling the deaths of Ukrainians. They
  563. 22:43are selling the liquidation and
  564. 22:44destruction of Ukraine. And they eat it
  565. 22:46up there. Well, it is accepted there,
  566. 22:48that turns out to be their political...
  567. 22:50Let's look at this situation from the
  568. 22:52point of view of idiocy. Well, let's
  569. 22:55decide that we are not idiots and try
  570. 22:57to understand the idiots. So, I live in
  571. 23:01the Russian Federation. I am, in
  572. 23:03principle, a more or less normal person
  573. 23:07. Why on earth would I go to vote for
  574. 23:12United Russia, A Just Russia, the
  575. 23:15Communist Party, or the Zhirinovskyites
  576. 23:18,
  577. 23:20for the New People? Well, I might, in
  578. 23:23principle, think that elections are
  579. 23:25important. I still think we have some
  580. 23:27kind of elections, but I am against the
  581. 23:29war. I would have voted for Yabloko,
  582. 23:31but Yabloko was removed from the
  583. 23:32elections. Why should I even go there?
  584. 23:34Who are all these people? They are for
  585. 23:36the war. I don't want war. This is not
  586. 23:38even a question of how I feel about
  587. 23:40Ukraine. So, if I actually go to the
  588. 23:43polling station and cast my ballot, and
  589. 23:46in principle participate in this and
  590. 23:48vote for some party instead of doing
  591. 23:51something to the ballot so it doesn't
  592. 23:53count, then I am already an idiot a
  593. 23:56priori, because I am choosing between
  594. 24:01different types of. They lead me
  595. 24:05into a voting booth. There lie
  596. 24:07different types of, and they offer
  597. 24:11for me to eat some and declare it ice
  598. 24:14cream, so to speak, gelato chocolate.
  599. 24:22So why can't we shove something down
  600. 24:23these people's throats and then some?
  601. 24:26Well, if they are willing to
  602. 24:27participate in this. A normal person in
  603. 24:31their right mind would never in their
  604. 24:35life vote for Tolstoy, Zhuravlyov,
  605. 24:38Volodin, Zyuganov, that moronic Slutsky
  606. 24:42, who is only known for harassing women
  607. 24:46in his office—a bloated creature that
  608. 24:50even a monkey wouldn't eye,
  609. 24:55that's why. I would say that a retired
  610. 24:58monkey, the uncertain one you’ve
  611. 24:59already checked out of the zoo, who
  612. 25:00needs to find its place in the waiting
  613. 25:02room of a State Duma committee chairman
  614. 25:03, might take an interest in Slutsky.
  615. 25:06And it was still trying to crawl
  616. 25:07somewhere, good lord. Well, there you
  617. 25:09go. But that is not the point. That is
  618. 25:10not the point. In any case, they are
  619. 25:14counting on idiots. Yes, on idiots. And
  620. 25:18what's more, you know, these are
  621. 25:20different levels of idiocy. Well, you
  622. 25:22see, there is a different level of
  623. 25:23idiocy when a person in Russia says
  624. 25:25they will vote at all in the State Duma
  625. 25:26elections, or when they vote for United
  626. 25:28Russia. There is also a level of having
  627. 25:31no choice, when they are a public
  628. 25:32sector worker and are simply being
  629. 25:33forced. There. And then there is the
  630. 25:36level of idiocy like that of Yulia
  631. 25:38Navalnaya, who says you should vote for
  632. 25:40any party, just not United Russia. Yeah
  633. 25:42. I mean, the person has already left.
  634. 25:45You can take the girl out of Russia,
  635. 25:46but you can't take the Soviet out of
  636. 25:48the girl. How is that? You, damn it,
  637. 25:51are abroad, and you are suggesting that
  638. 25:56people vote, relatively speaking, for
  639. 25:58Zhuravlyov, with his calls for
  640. 25:59extermination.
  641. 26:00Regarding Yulia Navalnaya, I apologize,
  642. 26:01but I have, you know, a suspicion. Is
  643. 26:03she just an idiot, or is she a useful
  644. 26:05idiot? Everything she says, absolutely
  645. 26:08everything since Navalny's death, as
  646. 26:10she went around to all those Oscars and
  647. 26:11non-Oscars—well, it doesn't stand up
  648. 26:13to any critical analysis at all. Uh,
  649. 26:16Alexei wasn't a very great politician,
  650. 26:18and she is completely and incredibly
  651. 26:20removed from all of this. Then again,
  652. 26:21she isn't the only one. Well, in the
  653. 26:24end, the idea of" smart voting, "an
  654. 26:26absolutely idiotic idea, was invented
  655. 26:28by Navalny himself—that you should
  656. 26:30vote for any party, just not United
  657. 26:31Russia. And by the way, on those calls,
  658. 26:34incredible monsters very often made it
  659. 26:36into the State Duma. One deputy, I
  660. 26:39believe from the LDPR, who was elected
  661. 26:41through" smart voting, "was the first
  662. 26:43to say that all Ukrainians should be
  663. 26:45destroyed, the Ukrainian language
  664. 26:47banned, and Russia established there.
  665. 26:50This person only made it into the State
  666. 26:51Duma thanks to Navalny. If it weren't
  667. 26:53for Navalny, there would have been a
  668. 26:54United Russia deputy there instead. I
  669. 26:56could give you a huge number of such
  670. 26:57examples, but I hope that if Navalny
  671. 26:59were alive, he would have learned from
  672. 27:01his own foolishness, though she is
  673. 27:02incapable of learning lessons—but she
  674. 27:04is not alone. There is also the fanatic
  675. 27:07Yashin and other people who still
  676. 27:12cannot understand that they had, have,
  677. 27:14and will have no political future in
  678. 27:16Russia.
  679. 27:18That, in all likelihood, they will die
  680. 27:20abroad. I would like them to die at an
  681. 27:23old age, and not from Novichok, which,
  682. 27:25of course, considering that Putin
  683. 27:27treats every Russian who opposes his
  684. 27:28policy as a traitor, will be waiting
  685. 27:30for them. And you know how many times
  686. 27:34they have poisoned that poor Kara-Murza
  687. 27:35. This man, with an absolutely
  688. 27:37astonishing political program, is also
  689. 27:39one. Well, as a journalist, he is my
  690. 27:42colleague; I have known him for many
  691. 27:44years, and I was well acquainted with
  692. 27:46his father, I worked with him, but as a
  693. 27:49politician, he is helpless. Yet they
  694. 27:51still poison him and poison him, poison
  695. 27:53and poison, how they poison. I mean,
  696. 27:55I don't know, to waste Novichok on...no
  697. 27:57.
  698. 27:58But these people just cannot understand
  699. 27:59what kind of country they are in and
  700. 28:01what kind of society they have. On the
  701. 28:03other hand, it is a great tragedy.
  702. 28:05Listen, they face the same tragedy that
  703. 28:09Thomas Mann, Albert Einstein, Stefan
  704. 28:13Zweig, and Bertolt Brecht had in the
  705. 28:1730s when they looked at Germany.
  706. 28:22Uh-huh.
  707. 28:22And grabbed their heads in despair. But
  708. 28:24you know, many people drew different
  709. 28:26conclusions from that German history
  710. 28:28too. Thomas Mann, being an ethnic
  711. 28:30German, actually became a full
  712. 28:33opposition not just to Germany, but to
  713. 28:35the German people. He never returned.
  714. 28:38Uh-huh.
  715. 28:38What he wrote about the German people,
  716. 28:41his stance—it was a verdict. And, of
  717. 28:45course, in Germany, they treated this
  718. 28:47—considering he was a great writer,
  719. 28:49beyond doubt—with incredible
  720. 28:51rejection. But Stefan Zweig, being an
  721. 28:54ethnic Jew, tried not to even sign any
  722. 28:58documents. There is a wonderful feature
  723. 29:01film about Zweig in Brazil, about that
  724. 29:03time, I think it’s called that, which
  725. 29:06would somehow put him at odds with the
  726. 29:08German people. That is, he was against
  727. 29:12Hitler, but as an Austrian—by the way
  728. 29:14, not a German, not from Germany—he
  729. 29:15was afraid to say anything that would
  730. 29:17cause a rift between him and the German
  731. 29:19people and readers. Do you know how it
  732. 29:22ended? Suicide. Thomas Mann lived a
  733. 29:26long, I would say, happy and fruitful
  734. 29:29creative life. And Stefan Zweig, safe
  735. 29:33in Brazil, living in a German village,
  736. 29:36surrounded by the love of people there,
  737. 29:38still ended his life by suicide because
  738. 29:41he could not find this modus vivendi.
  739. 29:45This is a problem,
  740. 29:46I think it is exactly the same for many
  741. 29:47Russians. Yes.
  742. 29:49It is a problem of moral choice. It
  743. 29:51seems to me that there is no point in
  744. 29:52even discussing all these politicians.
  745. 29:54First of all, they are not politicians.
  746. 29:55Secondly, their problem is not that
  747. 29:57they are very far from, I don't know,
  748. 29:59the agenda of Russia, the people, but
  749. 30:01in their misunderstanding and lack of
  750. 30:03awareness of how far away they are.
  751. 30:05Well, that's obvious.
  752. 30:06And besides, they are not, well, they
  753. 30:07are not Zweig. We know that there are
  754. 30:09Russians who speak about this
  755. 30:11absolutely harshly.
  756. 30:12Yes, yes, yes.
  757. 30:13What do they say about this,
  758. 30:14well, on the other hand, there are
  759. 30:15different moral assessments. There are
  760. 30:17moral assessments given by Shishkin,
  761. 30:19being a Russian writer. There are moral
  762. 30:21assessments given by Loznitsa, being
  763. 30:22formally a Ukrainian director. These
  764. 30:24are different moral assessments.
  765. 30:25Essentially, these are people from the
  766. 30:27same cultural field.
  767. 30:29Mr. Vitaliy, it seems to me that the
  768. 30:31topic that moves from broadcast to
  769. 30:33broadcast for me is the inevitability,
  770. 30:35I don't know, the fatality of
  771. 30:36escalation to the West and this great
  772. 30:38war in general. Well, the topic here is
  773. 30:41, as it were, an update. It's this spy
  774. 30:44scandal, a Russian spy scandal in
  775. 30:46Berlin. The Russian House under the
  776. 30:49leadership of Rossotrudnichestvo, which
  777. 30:51we also talked about in some broadcast,
  778. 30:53was closed. The last consulate in...yes
  779. 30:57. In Bonn, they also closed the
  780. 30:58consulate general, and in fact, all
  781. 31:00over the place. So where will we go now
  782. 31:01? It was so convenient. You arrive, get
  783. 31:03your little documents, everything for
  784. 31:05the people. And what about us? And the
  785. 31:07only thing left is the embassy in
  786. 31:08Berlin. Moreover, the German government
  787. 31:11changed, saying, well, we'll give you
  788. 31:13more IRIS-T missiles, we'll give you
  789. 31:15several thousand drones. And in return,
  790. 31:18from Solovyov's studio, missiles are
  791. 31:20flying there to destroy them. Oh, now
  792. 31:22that's it, Germany can be destroyed.
  793. 31:24Tsk-tsk-tsk, it's so bad. This is a
  794. 31:26stage for escalation. How deep, broad,
  795. 31:29and distant is this stage for the
  796. 31:31escalation of relations? You know, when
  797. 31:36I started talking a few months ago
  798. 31:37about the fact that the scaling up of
  799. 31:39the war was inevitable, many of my
  800. 31:41colleagues, particularly in the West,
  801. 31:45in Poland, in the Baltic states,
  802. 31:47advised me not to make such predictions
  803. 31:49, because they said I was saying it on
  804. 31:51purpose, that I was stoking the
  805. 31:53situation, and that these words could
  806. 31:55only hinder support for Ukraine. And I
  807. 31:58told you:" Listen, but they told me all
  808. 32:00of this in Ukraine, too. "We in Ukraine
  809. 32:02were saying back in '14, and in '22,
  810. 32:04and in '19, that I am fearmongering,
  811. 32:06that nothing like that would happen.
  812. 32:10And then, when it became obvious that I
  813. 32:11wasn't fearmongering, that I am saying
  814. 32:13completely objective things, it was
  815. 32:14already too late. Too late. Well, I
  816. 32:17just want you to understand this in
  817. 32:19time, because I am simply thinking the
  818. 32:21way Putin, conditionally speaking, must
  819. 32:23think. If thanks to the support of
  820. 32:28Ukraine Europeans still remain resolute
  821. 32:34and continue to help us, and Ukraine
  822. 32:37overcomes resistance, it means that the
  823. 32:40idea that everything would end after
  824. 32:42the presidential elections in the
  825. 32:45United States in '26, in '25, excuse me
  826. 32:48, turned out to be wrong. Putin clearly
  827. 32:52believed, make no mistake, that after
  828. 32:54Trump's victory we would capitulate.
  829. 32:58It’s just that, from his point of
  830. 33:00view, Trump didn't offer him enough,
  831. 33:01and the capitulation did not happen.
  832. 33:05And Ukraine continues not only to
  833. 33:06resist but also to destroy the Russian
  834. 33:08economy completely. Then it is
  835. 33:11necessary to scare the Europeans so
  836. 33:13that they stop. So, what is the
  837. 33:15conclusion from this? The conclusion is
  838. 33:18very simple. They have already started
  839. 33:21a hybrid war. That drone in Leipzig is
  840. 33:25a real hybrid war. The missile in
  841. 33:27Poland is a real hybrid war. Drones in
  842. 33:30Romania are a real hybrid war. The fact
  843. 33:33that they found six launchers today
  844. 33:34near another German power plant that
  845. 33:36were meant to blow it up is a real
  846. 33:37hybrid war. It will expand every single
  847. 33:40day. I will also tell you what happens
  848. 33:42next. This is so-called walking on the
  849. 33:47edge of an abyss, on such a very thin
  850. 33:49—it's not even a tightrope, it's like
  851. 33:51a thread. You walk along this thread,
  852. 33:55and it is important for you not to make
  853. 33:57a mistake. But, as a rule, it is a very
  854. 34:03dangerous route. As a rule, everyone
  855. 34:07makes mistakes. World War I began
  856. 34:12precisely because someone fell off that
  857. 34:14rope, or maybe everyone did at once. It
  858. 34:18could be the same here. They will keep
  859. 34:20walking and eventually commit some
  860. 34:23mistake. Well, let's say it blows up in
  861. 34:27the wrong place, the wrong object is
  862. 34:30attacked, let's say a train station or
  863. 34:34airport terminal explodes instead of an
  864. 34:37aircraft. And not two people die there,
  865. 34:42but a thousand or five thousand. If
  866. 34:46they continue, it will necessarily
  867. 34:48happen. The response to them will be
  868. 34:51more serious than closing a consulate
  869. 34:54general. First, the deportation of
  870. 34:57citizens of the Russian Federation will
  871. 34:59begin, who do not have any political
  872. 35:01circumstances tied to their stay in
  873. 35:03Europe. Second, a limited strike could
  874. 35:07be carried out, say, on some facilities
  875. 35:10from which that attack occurred, on
  876. 35:13some bases of the Russian Federation,
  877. 35:15somewhere else, it could be anything at
  878. 35:18all. And a major war begins. We are
  879. 35:22just a few steps from this abyss. And
  880. 35:26Putin is heading exactly there, do you
  881. 35:27understand?
  882. 35:29Well, he is heading there
  883. 35:30simultaneously.
  884. 35:30The Russian Emperor Kalayksanch. Or
  885. 35:35either he pushes in there,
  886. 35:37or the small ATGMs, which are few, but
  887. 35:39he's heading there simultaneously with
  888. 35:41threats from China. He has leeway to
  889. 35:46start a war, finish it here. Well, he
  890. 35:49has to somehow manage between
  891. 35:51he can tell the Chinese that the
  892. 35:53problem is the Europeans and that they
  893. 35:55need to be calmed down so they stop
  894. 35:57helping Ukraine. Then Ukraine will
  895. 35:59reach an agreement. I'll do it now.
  896. 36:01I'll do it now. Literally a few, I need
  897. 36:03a few weeks, well, a few months, I'll
  898. 36:05do everything now. And here is the
  899. 36:08moment of error. Listen, once this
  900. 36:10starts, no China will be able to stop
  901. 36:11it anymore. That's it. China will have
  902. 36:16to think: either continue supporting
  903. 36:18Russia, or Europe will start rejecting
  904. 36:21Chinese goods en masse in protest
  905. 36:23against China continuing to cooperate
  906. 36:25with a country that has killed tens of
  907. 36:27thousands of Europeans. And it will
  908. 36:30simply be a bust. The collapse of the
  909. 36:32European economy, the collapse of the
  910. 36:34Chinese economy. Perhaps the start of a
  911. 36:36war in the Taiwan Strait so that the
  912. 36:38Chinese population doesn't notice
  913. 36:40what's happening.
  914. 36:42Well, wonderful.
  915. 36:42That's how world wars begin. We are, I
  916. 36:45keep saying, we are constantly on the
  917. 36:47verge of a world war. It's an
  918. 36:50incredible spectacle. The question is
  919. 36:54just whether we will approach it or not
  920. 36:56, but it's just, relatively speaking,
  921. 36:59we are with you on such a small stage
  922. 37:01in a theater where this terrible play
  923. 37:04is unfolding. Do you understand?
  924. 37:06And we are at the epicenter.
  925. 37:09On the main stage, the scenery is
  926. 37:11already being prepared for the real
  927. 37:13performance. The question is, will this
  928. 37:16real performance begin?
  929. 37:18And what does it depend on? What
  930. 37:19conditions? On a mistake.
  931. 37:24Whether they make a mistake in Russia
  932. 37:26or not. It depends on how much sense
  933. 37:29Putin still has left in his head,
  934. 37:31whether he will be capable of stopping.
  935. 37:35Because, you understand, Europeans, the
  936. 37:37West, and the Americans still won't be
  937. 37:39able to ignore it when something truly
  938. 37:41horrific happens. Well, no, there are
  939. 37:45political situations where you can't
  940. 37:48just say," Big deal, so some planes hit
  941. 37:50my shopping mall. "" So what? "" Fine,
  942. 37:54it's an isolated incident, it won't
  943. 37:58happen again. "You understand that
  944. 38:00doesn't happen. 9/11 is 9/11.
  945. 38:04Uh-huh.
  946. 38:06The problem is that Putin's mistake
  947. 38:08could lead to a 9/11-style situation in
  948. 38:10Europe. And that's it. That’s an
  949. 38:14anti-terrorist coalition, the
  950. 38:16activation of Article Five, just as it
  951. 38:19was activated after 9/11. The Americans
  952. 38:22might try to wash their hands of it.
  953. 38:24They might not succeed, even Trump. But
  954. 38:28even if they wash their hands of it, it
  955. 38:29doesn't mean the Europeans will,
  956. 38:31because they will realize that if they
  957. 38:32just stay silent, they will simply be
  958. 38:34beaten everywhere, from Lisbon to
  959. 38:38Bratislava. They simply won't be able
  960. 38:40to. They will want to abstain, but they
  961. 38:42won't be able to. So everything depends
  962. 38:45on how Putin handles this distance. But
  963. 38:49if we speak absolutely, you know,
  964. 38:51completely cold-bloodedly, calmly,
  965. 38:53without emotions, purely from a
  966. 38:54political technology and logical
  967. 38:56standpoint, the conditions for the
  968. 38:58start of a third world war are prepared
  969. 39:00. We are just right there. I am
  970. 39:05surprised, I already don't understand
  971. 39:07the West anymore, because this whole
  972. 39:08story with our unfortunate Ukraine is
  973. 39:10just the history of Czechoslovakia.
  974. 39:13Give us a piece of territory so we can
  975. 39:16take it all. Let's hold talks and reach
  976. 39:20an agreement. It's just that Biden is
  977. 39:22what changed the situation. By the way,
  978. 39:25Biden did not play the role of
  979. 39:27Chamberlain. He did not want to be
  980. 39:30Chamberlain. Biden is a historical
  981. 39:32figure. Of the 20th century. And Trump,
  982. 39:36who came after Biden, he would have
  983. 39:38liked to be Chamberlain. When he says
  984. 39:41the war would never have started, it
  985. 39:43should be translated as: I would have
  986. 39:44been Chamberlain, I would have given
  987. 39:45away everything, damn it, that he
  988. 39:47wanted. Trump in this situation, as you
  989. 39:53understand, simply can no longer
  990. 39:56turn back.
  991. 39:57It's the same as if Chamberlain had
  992. 39:58come after Churchill, and not before.
  993. 40:00Imagine there is Churchill. Uh-huh.
  994. 40:04And in '44, let's say, he was killed,
  995. 40:06well, hypothetically, he died of a
  996. 40:07heart attack, and the prime minister
  997. 40:09became the living Chamberlain, who
  998. 40:11hadn't died. Or, I don't know, Lord
  999. 40:13Halifax, it doesn't matter. And he says
  1000. 40:16:" I think I could have made a deal
  1001. 40:18with Hitler. "Hitler is a serious
  1002. 40:22person. Adolf respects me so much, but
  1003. 40:26it's no longer possible. Biden ruined
  1004. 40:30Trump’s whole scheme. And he wants to
  1005. 40:35, he's just whining with desire. Just,
  1006. 40:37just weeping. Mila, I want him so much.
  1007. 40:43You can't imagine. He's so, he's so.
  1008. 40:47God, he's such a little charmer. A
  1009. 40:50wonder, a wonder. Oh, but he can't make
  1010. 40:53a deal. That scoundrel Biden won't let
  1011. 40:55me make a deal. He did such a thing. He
  1012. 40:57did such a thing.
  1013. 41:00I can't even eat. By the way, it's not
  1014. 41:02just Trump crying there, there's Besat.
  1015. 41:05I can't believe this. When I read it, I
  1016. 41:07thought it seemed like a prank, because
  1017. 41:09I first saw it in a Telegram channel.
  1018. 41:11We are now feeling the energy shock,
  1019. 41:13that we are guilty, that it is a shock.
  1020. 41:15Well, first of all, Ukraine decided it
  1021. 41:17wants to destroy. Ukraine just decided
  1022. 41:20that it wants to destroy something, and
  1023. 41:22they are already in shock. They are
  1024. 41:24sitting there already in shock. Our
  1025. 41:26prices are going to go up. I mean,
  1026. 41:28Ukraine thought of something. I don’t
  1027. 41:30even know what they decided this about,
  1028. 41:31but they’re already having issues.
  1029. 41:33Listen, just think about Bessent.
  1030. 41:36He’s not a very smart person either.
  1031. 41:38I mean, really. The man who came to
  1032. 41:40Zelenskyy and told him," Sign this
  1033. 41:42document here. "That man is not of very
  1034. 41:44great intelligence. Well, imagine
  1035. 41:45Bessent comes...
  1036. 41:47Bessent comes home and says to his
  1037. 41:49partner," Listen, what a horror, the
  1038. 41:51Democrats will win the election and
  1039. 41:53start investigating the Treasury
  1040. 41:54Department. It’s such a nightmare,
  1041. 41:58how will we be able to sit calmly, how
  1042. 41:59will we be able to sit in restaurants,
  1043. 42:01go on wonderful cruises, enjoy
  1044. 42:03ourselves, none of that will happen.
  1045. 42:07They will just poison our wonderful
  1046. 42:11life, and all because the price of oil
  1047. 42:14is rising. "And his partner says to him
  1048. 42:17," Why, Mr. Secretary, from me? "" Yes,
  1049. 42:20why, sweetie, did the price of oil rise
  1050. 42:22? "And he says to him," Well, why,
  1051. 42:24honey? Because Zelenskyy, Zelenskyy
  1052. 42:27decided that he could destroy all
  1053. 42:29Russian oil. And now the price is so
  1054. 42:32high. "" Oh, I forgot, honey, there was
  1055. 42:35a war in Iran. "" Seriously? "" Did you
  1056. 42:38miss everything? "" I missed everything
  1057. 42:40. "" Our dear grandpa started a war in
  1058. 42:42Iran and something didn't work out
  1059. 42:44there. But now we’ll impose such
  1060. 42:46sanctions on Iran that they’ll
  1061. 42:48immediately beg us to lower the price.
  1062. 42:50"I mean, he has nothing to say. You
  1063. 42:53understand, you can't even imagine
  1064. 42:55everything you will hear from these
  1065. 42:57people before the election. You hear a
  1066. 43:03lot from these Russian ghouls right now
  1067. 43:06. Imagine what you will hear from
  1068. 43:08American election candidates and the
  1069. 43:10American administration when they see
  1070. 43:11the polls, Trump's rating is falling,
  1071. 43:13the Republicans' rating is falling,
  1072. 43:15they aren't winning here, they aren't
  1073. 43:16winning there, so of course they will
  1074. 43:18look for someone to blame. After all,
  1075. 43:21anyone can be to blame, except for them
  1076. 43:23. That's it.
  1077. 43:26And Zelenskyy is just so convenient.
  1078. 43:27And to wrap up this topic, you know, we
  1079. 43:29are on the threshold of World War III,
  1080. 43:31as you optimistically said. And if
  1081. 43:34before, people tried to calculate the
  1082. 43:37duration of the war based on Putin's
  1083. 43:39economic ability to wage it, now this
  1084. 43:42fatal factor is kicking in, that, well,
  1085. 43:45the domino effect, everyone is already
  1086. 43:47in the process. Everyone is in the game
  1087. 43:51, everyone is a player. He is still
  1088. 43:53doing something, because I can tell you
  1089. 43:56, Roxana, how to stop this game, to
  1090. 43:58stop Putin's economic capabilities with
  1091. 44:00his bare ass. They don't start World
  1092. 44:04War III. Imagine Hitler without any oil
  1093. 44:08for his tanks. What kind of war would
  1094. 44:10that be? What would he have fueled them
  1095. 44:11with? Many military historians have
  1096. 44:15already said that if Stalin had moved a
  1097. 44:17bit further into the Romanian territory
  1098. 44:19he was seizing and taken the Romanian
  1099. 44:22oil fields, Hitler would have had no
  1100. 44:24way to start the Second World War. But
  1101. 44:28Stalin was interested in Hitler
  1102. 44:29starting it, because he believed Hitler
  1103. 44:31would fight the British and the French.
  1104. 44:33And he needed Hitler to have oil for
  1105. 44:37that.
  1106. 44:38Do our Western, I don't know, partners,
  1107. 44:40colleagues, realize this? Well, some
  1108. 44:42are partners, and some are not so much.
  1109. 44:45Of course they realize it; when they
  1110. 44:46say they will give us additional
  1111. 44:48missiles, what is that for? Is it so we
  1112. 44:50can admire them, or so we can destroy
  1113. 44:52the Russian economy? Of course, they
  1114. 44:54realize—Americans might not fully
  1115. 44:56realize it, because they still believe,
  1116. 44:58and this is their big mistake, that the
  1117. 45:00vast ocean will protect them. It won't
  1118. 45:02protect them. Technology is already at
  1119. 45:06a point where no ocean will help anyone
  1120. 45:07. The world has become tiny. Well,
  1121. 45:12there is simply no point.
  1122. 45:13The ocean is just a puddle now. Please.
  1123. 45:16I understand the capabilities exist,
  1124. 45:17but there is no point. Putin has
  1125. 45:18Ukraine right under his nose, and
  1126. 45:20Europe right here. Well, the States,
  1127. 45:23what is the point?
  1128. 45:25But on the other hand, I apologize.
  1129. 45:28Then let's look at the years 1939, 1940
  1130. 45:31, and 1941. Through the eyes of
  1131. 45:33President Franklin Roosevelt. Through
  1132. 45:35the eyes of the Ambassador to Great
  1133. 45:38Britain, Joseph Kennedy Sr. Let's look
  1134. 45:40and say:" Listen, does war threaten the
  1135. 45:42United States? "" Not at all. "Hitler
  1136. 45:45still has Europe, still has the Soviet
  1137. 45:47Union. Where would he even go? And then
  1138. 45:51, bam, Pearl Harbor. How did that
  1139. 45:54happen? What happened? We calculated
  1140. 45:58everything so perfectly. Of course, no
  1141. 46:00Putin is going to attack the United
  1142. 46:02States. But China is creating problems
  1143. 46:04for the States. China, which will
  1144. 46:07decide that if the United States isn't
  1145. 46:09participating in this game, they are
  1146. 46:11ultimately weakened and American
  1147. 46:13interests can be hit. It will be
  1148. 46:14exactly the same as it was. I once saw
  1149. 46:17Americans at Pearl Harbor. Well, really
  1150. 46:22.
  1151. 46:22Uh-huh.
  1152. 46:23They walk around with eyes wide open.
  1153. 46:27They still can't understand how it
  1154. 46:30happened, how someone just went and
  1155. 46:32attacked the United States of America.
  1156. 46:36You see, it's still a trauma for them,
  1157. 46:38because they were generally confident
  1158. 46:40and remain subconsciously, deep down,
  1159. 46:42convinced even now that it couldn't
  1160. 46:44have happened. But it did happen. Why
  1161. 46:47can't it happen again?
  1162. 46:50Well, perhaps we should deal with
  1163. 46:52Europe first, of course. Well, you know
  1164. 46:54, every time you end a broadcast with
  1165. 46:56your optimistic forecast of being on
  1166. 46:58the threshold of World War III. And so
  1167. 47:00we are adding a new factor of
  1168. 47:01escalation. This time, Germany is
  1169. 47:03entering the game. Well, on this
  1170. 47:04broadcast,
  1171. 47:06well, it has effectively declared a
  1172. 47:07diplomatic war on Russia, one could say
  1173. 47:09, and not just diplomatic, but also
  1174. 47:10military.
  1175. 47:12Or Russia?
  1176. 47:13And the Russians are also threatening
  1177. 47:15Great Britain. We passed by that,
  1178. 47:17whether they said they would strike the
  1179. 47:19territory of Great Britain or not."
  1180. 47:21Military secret, "Putin said. We would
  1181. 47:23like to know whether
  1182. 47:25Mr. Vitaliy, today I started earlier
  1183. 47:27with some news from the feed. Today I
  1184. 47:30am finishing, it seems to me, eh,
  1185. 47:32Tetyana, I don't know, I'll try to read
  1186. 47:34your handle there. This is about you,
  1187. 47:37of course. Tetyana Shvet bez karavaina.
  1188. 47:41" I stared for a long time at the
  1189. 47:43pattern of your new shirt, Mr. Vitaliy,
  1190. 47:44this is your, well, this shirt you are
  1191. 47:46wearing right now. "" And yes, yes. ""
  1192. 47:48And suddenly I realized that these are
  1193. 47:51orcas devouring the Russian bear. ""
  1194. 47:54God-level trolling. "Mr. Vitaliy, well,
  1195. 47:56she nailed it. Did you purposely...
  1196. 47:58Do you think it's an orca? Oksa, please
  1197. 48:00.
  1198. 48:00Eh, no, I can't.
  1199. 48:01No, it happened on its own.
  1200. 48:04Well, that's what the viewer thinks.
  1201. 48:05Most of them, I...well, even if they
  1202. 48:07aren't orcas, these could be some
  1203. 48:09sharks of imperialism that will somehow
  1204. 48:11eat the Russian Federation. Well, have
  1205. 48:13no doubt that this shirt is clearly
  1206. 48:15aimed at eating the Russian Federation.
  1207. 48:18But Putin and I do many things
  1208. 48:20subconsciously.
  1209. 48:21Uh-huh.
  1210. 48:22For him, it's connected to his poor
  1211. 48:24education, and for me, it's connected
  1212. 48:26to my non-trivial taste.
  1213. 48:28A new segment in the studio, C'est la
  1214. 48:30vie. Now Portnikov will push, and you
  1215. 48:33know, usually he is saying something
  1216. 48:35visually. Well, that is their favorite,
  1217. 48:39favorite story—placing some flowerpot
  1218. 48:42on the windowsill so that a Soviet
  1219. 48:44scout could tell by the flower whether
  1220. 48:46the hideout was compromised or if our
  1221. 48:49people were still there. We know what
  1222. 48:51these people have been doing their
  1223. 48:53whole lives.
  1224. 48:53Sending a signal.
  1225. 48:55They aren't killers from their point of
  1226. 48:57view, they are florists, but in reality
  1227. 48:58, we know who they are. Orcas devouring
  1228. 49:03the Russian bear. I like it. I will end
  1229. 49:06with that. You know, we will continue
  1230. 49:09this decoding of your shirts next time.
  1231. 49:11Thank you very much today. Don't be a
  1232. 49:13stranger. Well, you know, I am very
  1233. 49:15glad to see you. Thank you, Mr. Vitaliy
  1234. 49:17.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Як почнеться Третя світова | Віталій Портников @ApostropheTV by Віталій Портников, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,925 words across 1,234 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.