AP Government UNIT 2 Review—Everything You NEED to Know — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Well, no way around it, unit two for AP
- 0:01Government is a right beast of a unit.
- 0:03But fear not, my dear pupil, I'm about
- 0:05to Heim Splain everything you need to
- 0:07know about it. So, if you're ready to
- 0:08get them brain cows milked, let's get to
- 0:10it. All right, as is my custom, let me
- 0:12begin by giving you the big picture for
- 0:14the unit so that you know what it's all
- 0:15about, and hopefully it'll keep you from
- 0:16getting lost along the way. So, first of
- 0:18all, this unit is going to explain the
- 0:19separation of powers among each of the
- 0:21three branches of the federal
- 0:22government, and potentially a fourth
- 0:24branch. Fourth branch? What you talking
- 0:25about, Willis? Well, stick with me and I
- 0:27shall explain in due time. And then,
- 0:29second, because the government is
- 0:30characterized by the separation of
- 0:32powers, this unit is then going to show
- 0:33how each branch has constitutional
- 0:35checks and balances designed to restrain
- 0:37the other branches. And baby, that's it.
- 0:39So, I reckon we'll start as is proper by
- 0:41considering the legislative branch.
- 0:43Okay, so the Constitution devotes the
- 0:44majority of its words to Article 1,
- 0:46which explains the structure and powers
- 0:48of Congress, whose main job is to write
- 0:50and pass laws. Now, it was universally
- 0:52agreed upon by the founders that in a
- 0:54Republican system of government divided
- 0:56into three branches, the legislative
- 0:58branch would be, by nature, the most
- 1:00powerful. because Congress is where the
- 1:02voices of the American people are
- 1:03represented, which is that whole popular
- 1:05sovereignty and consent of the governed
- 1:07thing that we talked about in unit one.
- 1:08Now, to be clear, the legislative being
- 1:10the most powerful branch is what the
- 1:11founders expected based on their thinky
- 1:13thinky theoretical framework. However,
- 1:15in actual practice across history, the
- 1:17executive branch has scooped a big
- 1:19gulp-sized chunk of power out of the
- 1:21legislative branch and brought it over
- 1:22to the executive. But alas, I get ahead
- 1:24of myself. We'll talk about that later.
- 1:26But remember, the founders were all
- 1:27kinds of concerned to make sure that
- 1:29these three branches would be equal in
- 1:31power to each other. And so, to solve
- 1:32that problem of the legislature being
- 1:34more powerful by nature, the
- 1:35Constitution created a bicameral
- 1:37legislature, which is to say, Congress
- 1:39is made of two houses that are required
- 1:41to work together in order to get laws
- 1:43passed. The two being the House of
- 1:44Representatives and the Senate. And I
- 1:45don't know about you, but I'm feeling
- 1:47like we need to put our comparison pants
- 1:48on and try to understand the differences
- 1:50between the two. And let's start with
- 1:51the House of Representatives. So, this
- 1:53chamber of Congress was designed to be
- 1:54as close and accountable as possible to
- 1:56the people themselves. So, to that end,
- 1:58members of the House are apportioned by
- 2:00the population of each state. In other
- 2:02words, more populous states like
- 2:03California or Texas have far more House
- 2:05Representatives than the less populous
- 2:07states like Montana or Delaware. Now,
- 2:08since 1929, the number of House
- 2:10Representatives has been capped by law
- 2:12at 435 seats, and those seats are
- 2:14shuffled between different states as the
- 2:16American population increases or
- 2:17decreases in any given state. Anyway,
- 2:19the reason I said the House is closer to
- 2:21the people is because its members are
- 2:22more accountable to voters since they
- 2:24only serve for two year terms. That
- 2:26means if voters believe a representative
- 2:27isn't performing in the way that they
- 2:29want, well, it's a very short span of
- 2:31time before they can vote that person
- 2:32out of office. But, that is not how it
- 2:34is in the Senate, and I'm in the mood to
- 2:36talk about it. But, before I get all
- 2:37senatorial on you, you should know that
- 2:39I too am sensitive and responsive to the
- 2:41people, namely all you who are watching
- 2:43this. And in response to your desperate
- 2:45cries for help in studying for your
- 2:46class exams and the national exam in
- 2:48May, I have made the AP Government
- 2:49Heimler Review Guide. It's got
- 2:50everything you need to study for your
- 2:52class and your national exam as fast as
- 2:54possible, including unit review videos
- 2:56like this one that are not on YouTube,
- 2:57notes to follow along, practice
- 2:59questions, practice exams, and a whole
- 3:01lot more. So, if that's something that
- 3:02you're into, check that link in the
- 3:03description. Okay, so the Senate, known
- 3:05as the upper house of Congress because
- 3:06it is further away from the people, has
- 3:08exactly 100 members since each state
- 3:10always has two representatives. And
- 3:11while senators are still representatives
- 3:13of the people, they serve six year
- 3:14terms, which means they can afford to be
- 3:16less responsive to the people because
- 3:18the longer terms insulate them from the
- 3:19pressure of the short-term whims of the
- 3:21public. But, those terms are staggered
- 3:23so that every two years a third of the
- 3:24Senate is up for re-election, which has
- 3:26the effect of creating a continuously
- 3:28changing legislative body. So, that
- 3:29means that the House of Representatives,
- 3:31which is based on population, is more
- 3:33accurately representing the interests of
- 3:34the people as a whole, whereas the
- 3:36Senate, based on equal representation,
- 3:38more accurately represents the interests
- 3:40of entire states. Okay, so if the
- 3:42primary job of Congress is to pass laws,
- 3:44then here's where I tell you that the
- 3:45main way each house gets its work done
- 3:47is through the process of debate. But,
- 3:48those debates look way different
- 3:50depending on which chamber we're talking
- 3:52about. What I mean is in the House, the
- 3:53process of proposing and debating
- 3:55legislation is highly disciplined and
- 3:57structured and representatives must
- 3:58follow metric butt loads of rules in
- 4:00order to participate. And that's not
- 4:01hard to understand since like I said the
- 4:03House has 435 members. Like without
- 4:05strict rules for limiting debate among
- 4:07the many blowhard representatives who
- 4:09love to hear themselves speak, it would
- 4:10be chaos. But in the Senate, the rules
- 4:12for debate are much looser. Again,
- 4:14mainly owing to its smaller size. For
- 4:16example, while the House has strict
- 4:17rules governing the time limits each
- 4:18member must obey when speaking, the
- 4:20Senate has no time limits on debate.
- 4:22Now, I could keep comparing these two
- 4:23houses all day, every day, and twice on
- 4:25Sundays. But I've left you hanging long
- 4:27enough because now I need to give you
- 4:28the briefest sketches of the
- 4:29constitutional powers that belong to the
- 4:31legislative branch of government. Now,
- 4:33hopefully you can rummage through all
- 4:34the brain folds where you stored
- 4:35everything about unit one and recall
- 4:37that Article 1 Section 8 of the
- 4:38Constitution grants Congress what are
- 4:40known as enumerated powers. And I know
- 4:42that's a big word, but don't get all
- 4:44weak in your jellies. Enumerated just
- 4:45means to name items one by one. So,
- 4:48basically what we're talking about here
- 4:49are the explicit powers actually written
- 4:51out in list form that the Constitution
- 4:53gives to Congress. And there are seven
- 4:55that you're going to need to know for
- 4:56your exam. And to be clear, there are
- 4:57more than seven powers listed in Article
- 4:591, but these are the only ones you are
- 5:00required to know. First of all, Congress
- 5:02has the power to pass a federal budget.
- 5:04Now, in case you don't know, that
- 5:05federal budget ain't going to fund
- 5:06itself. So, Congress also has the power
- 5:08to impose taxes or borrow money in order
- 5:10to raise revenue. And all these taken
- 5:11together are known as Congress's power
- 5:13of the purse, which is a big deal and
- 5:15we'll return to it later. Second,
- 5:16Congress has the power to declare war
- 5:18and raise the funds needed to maintain
- 5:20the armed forces needed to fight those
- 5:21wars. Third, Congress has the power to
- 5:23determine the process for
- 5:24naturalization, which means they
- 5:25determine the exact process for how
- 5:27immigrants can become citizens. And then
- 5:28fourth, Congress has the power to
- 5:30regulate interstate commerce, which is
- 5:31just a fancy way of saying that when
- 5:33states trade with each other, Congress
- 5:35can oversee the process and make sure
- 5:36everything is all fair and whatnot.
- 5:38Fifth, Congress has the power to create
- 5:39federal courts and define exactly what
- 5:41their jurisdiction is. And for now, it's
- 5:43enough to know that the court's
- 5:44jurisdiction refers to the kinds of
- 5:45cases it has the authority to hear.
- 5:47Sixth, and hold on to your butts for
- 5:49this one, Congress has an enumerated
- 5:50power that grants authority to pass laws
- 5:53not listed in its Article 1 enumerated
- 5:55powers. Again, Unit 1, do you remember
- 5:56the necessary and proper clause, also
- 5:58known by its sassier name, the elastic
- 6:00clause? Well, this clause grants what
- 6:01are known as implied powers, which
- 6:03enable Congress to pass laws on all
- 6:04kinds of issues that the framers could
- 6:06not have anticipated just as long as
- 6:07those laws support Congress's enumerated
- 6:10powers. Or you might think about it like
- 6:11this. The Constitution gave Congress a
- 6:13toolbox. The enumerated powers represent
- 6:15the jobs assigned to Congress, while the
- 6:16elastic clause enables Congress to use
- 6:18any tool in the box in order to get
- 6:20those jobs done. And then finally,
- 6:21seventh, Congress has the power to
- 6:22conduct oversight of the executive
- 6:24branch, which we'll talk about in the
- 6:25next section. Okay, now so far, here's
- 6:27what I've done. I explained the
- 6:28structure of Congress, which is
- 6:30bicameral, the powers of Congress,
- 6:31Article 1 Section 8, and I told you that
- 6:33the main work of the legislative branch
- 6:35is to write and pass laws. And I can see
- 6:37that faint yet inquisitive twinkle in
- 6:39your eye, which says, "But Heimler, what
- 6:41exactly is the process for writing and
- 6:43passing a law?" And hey, I remain a man
- 6:44of the people, so let me explain exactly
- 6:46how a bill becomes a law, which is a
- 6:48four-step process. Step one is
- 6:49introduction. Here, a bill can be
- 6:51introduced by a member of either the
- 6:52House or the Senate. It doesn't matter
- 6:54which. And then step two is committee
- 6:56review, which is when the bill under
- 6:57consideration is assigned to a small
- 6:59committee of representatives who review
- 7:00and debate the contents of that bill.
- 7:02Again, way more about committees
- 7:03forthcoming, so for now, let's just move
- 7:05on to step three, which is voting. So,
- 7:07once the bill leaves its committee, it
- 7:08goes to the floor of each chamber for a
- 7:10yay or nay vote. And then supposing it's
- 7:12a majority yay, then the bill enters
- 7:14step four, namely getting signed into
- 7:15law by the president. And look, I wish I
- 7:17could tell you that it doesn't get any
- 7:18more complicated than that, but this is
- 7:20AP Government, baby. It always gets more
- 7:22complicated. What I mean is yes, that's
- 7:24the basic process that turns a baby bill
- 7:26into an adult-sized law, and both
- 7:28chambers have some similarities in how
- 7:29they do that work, but there are also
- 7:31some significant differences. So, in
- 7:32terms of similarities, both the House
- 7:34and the Senate use committees to
- 7:35accomplish the main work of legislation.
- 7:37Now, committees are smaller groups of
- 7:38representatives who study bills and then
- 7:40debate the contents of bills, they mark
- 7:42them up, etc. And this is where most of
- 7:44the real work of Congress gets done and
- 7:46that's because there are so many bills
- 7:47under constant consideration it would be
- 7:49impractical for either the entire House
- 7:51or Senate to work together in full on
- 7:53every bill. Now, as a general rule, the
- 7:54leadership on these committees is
- 7:56determined by the majority party in each
- 7:58chamber. And there are no less than four
- 7:59of these kinds of committees that you're
- 8:01going to need to know. First, you have
- 8:02standing committees, which are permanent
- 8:03since they handle the same kinds of
- 8:05bills that arise year in and year out,
- 8:07like budget legislation or regulations
- 8:09for the armed forces, etc. Second, there
- 8:10are select committees, which are the
- 8:12opposite of standing committees since
- 8:13they're formed temporarily in order to
- 8:15investigate or debate a very specific
- 8:17non-repeated issue. For example, a
- 8:18select committee was formed to
- 8:19investigate the details of the Watergate
- 8:21scandal during the Nixon administration
- 8:23and once that investigation was over,
- 8:25the committee disbanded. And then third,
- 8:26you have joint committees. So, both the
- 8:28House and Senate have their own unique
- 8:30standing committees and they each have
- 8:31their own unique select committees. But,
- 8:33some larger issues require a bicameral
- 8:35effort that brings together both the
- 8:36House and Senate members and that would
- 8:38be a joint committee. And when I say
- 8:39larger issues, I mean things like
- 8:41taxation or the maintenance of the
- 8:42Library of Congress or, you know, things
- 8:44like that. And finally, fourth, you have
- 8:45conference committees, which form in
- 8:47order to reconcile different versions of
- 8:48the same bill in order to bring it to a
- 8:50vote and send it to the president's
- 8:51desk. Okay, well, now let's consider the
- 8:53differences between the two chambers and
- 8:55just for poops and giggles, let's start
- 8:56with the House. So, in the House, the
- 8:57legislative process is led by the
- 8:59Speaker of the House, which is the most
- 9:00powerful position in this chamber.
- 9:02That's because the Speaker oversees
- 9:03debates on bills, makes committee
- 9:05assignments, and guides legislation from
- 9:07conception to presidential signing. Now,
- 9:08this person is elected by the majority
- 9:10of House Representatives, which means
- 9:11that the Speaker will always be a member
- 9:13of the majority party since they're the
- 9:14ones with enough votes to pick their
- 9:16preferred candidate. Now, once a bill
- 9:17emerges out of its assigned committee,
- 9:19it goes to the House Rules Committee,
- 9:20which is by far the most powerful
- 9:22committee in this chamber. And that's
- 9:23because the Rules Committee decides how
- 9:25much debate can occur or what kinds of
- 9:27amendments can be added to a specific
- 9:29bill or whatever. And more than that,
- 9:30the Rules Committee has the
- 9:31responsibility for creating calendar
- 9:33assignments for the day on which a bill
- 9:34will be brought forth to the floor for
- 9:36debate. And if the Rules Committee wants
- 9:37to kill a bill that has made it out of
- 9:39another committee, they can simply just
- 9:40not put it on the calendar, which is a
- 9:42nasty move, but you know, they have the
- 9:44power to do it. However, I should note
- 9:45that if the Rules Committee pulls said
- 9:47nasty move, then the House has a special
- 9:49rule called the discharge petition,
- 9:51which can force a bill to the floor for
- 9:53a vote. It requires a majority of
- 9:54representatives to enact the discharge
- 9:55petition, namely 218, and although it's
- 9:58powerful, it's rarely done. Now, in
- 9:59order to expedite the legislative
- 10:01process, the House can bypass the
- 10:02committee stage and make use of a rule
- 10:04called the Committee of the Whole. And
- 10:05this means that all present House
- 10:06members as a whole essentially agree to
- 10:08form one large committee to debate
- 10:10legislation under more relaxed
- 10:11procedures so they can get it done
- 10:12faster. Okay, now let's consider how the
- 10:14Senate works differently than the House.
- 10:16Now, because the Senate is smaller and
- 10:17their procedures are more relaxed, they
- 10:18don't have an equivalent of the House
- 10:20Rules Committee. Instead, the Senate's
- 10:21main mechanism for structuring debate is
- 10:23a procedure called unanimous consent.
- 10:25Here, every senator must agree to the
- 10:27terms of debate, but even if one senator
- 10:29disagrees, then the process is stalled.
- 10:31Now, recall that senators have no rules
- 10:33governing the length of their debate,
- 10:34and therefore they can make use of the
- 10:36filibuster, which is a procedural
- 10:37technique for delaying a vote on a bill.
- 10:39So, in the past, a filibuster meant that
- 10:41a senator could refuse to yield his or
- 10:42her debate time to someone else and keep
- 10:44flapping their mouth hole until the
- 10:46desired outcome was achieved, or they
- 10:48just fell over in exhaustion. But, the
- 10:49talky-talky filibuster doesn't happen
- 10:51much anymore, since even the mere threat
- 10:53of a filibuster can achieve the same
- 10:54effect. Now, the only way to end a
- 10:56filibuster is for senators to invoke the
- 10:57cloture rule, which requires 60 out of
- 10:59100 votes to end debate. And it's
- 11:01basically the equivalent of 60 senators
- 11:03collectively forcing their clammy hand
- 11:05upon an overly chatty colleague who
- 11:07refuses to shut up. And to be clear, 60
- 11:09out of 100 votes is not easy to achieve
- 11:11given all the politically polarized
- 11:12toddler-style rigidity we see in the
- 11:14Senate today. And that's why the
- 11:15filibuster is still a powerful tool that
- 11:17affects the outcome of legislation.
- 11:19Okay, now one of the most important
- 11:20bills on which both chambers of the
- 11:21House must work is the annual federal
- 11:23budget. And for this, you need to
- 11:24understand two categories of spending
- 11:26that representatives must reckon with.
- 11:27First, there's mandatory spending, which
- 11:29is spending required by law to fund
- 11:31entitlement programs, Like, for example,
- 11:33Social Security or Medicaid. That's just
- 11:35a fancy way of saying that if Congress
- 11:36passes a law that requires funding,
- 11:38then, well, they have no choice but to
- 11:40include that funding as a line item in
- 11:41the budget. But then, secondly, there's
- 11:43discretionary spending, which includes
- 11:44all the money left over after mandatory
- 11:46spending is budgeted, and it can be
- 11:47spent on non-mandatory projects or
- 11:49programs. Now, maybe it's entirely
- 11:51obvious, but I'm going to go ahead and
- 11:52say it anyway. The more mandatory
- 11:53spending that is stuffed into the
- 11:55budget, the less money is left over for
- 11:56discretionary spending and vice versa.
- 11:59But, you know, Congress loves to spend
- 12:00that boom-boom. And so, if there isn't
- 12:02enough money to satisfy the
- 12:03discretionary congressional want hole,
- 12:05then they can get more money in two
- 12:06ways. First, they can raise taxes, but
- 12:08that's kind of a last resort since this
- 12:10whole stinking country was kind of born
- 12:11on the conviction that we, uh, no likey
- 12:13taxes. So then, secondly, Congress can
- 12:15borrow money to increase available funds
- 12:17for discretionary spending. And if they
- 12:18do, that leads to an increase in the
- 12:20budget deficit, which is when the
- 12:21government spends more money in a year
- 12:23than it brings in. Now, the last thing
- 12:25I'll say about the budget is this. In
- 12:26many cases, making a budget is about
- 12:29more than making a budget. is, senators
- 12:31and representatives make use of two
- 12:32techniques during the budgeting process
- 12:34to help them achieve wins for their own
- 12:35constituents. First is what we call pork
- 12:37barrel tactics, which refer to a
- 12:38representative's efforts to secure
- 12:40funding in a general appropriations bill
- 12:42for a very specific project that is
- 12:44meaningful to their people. And in this
- 12:46way, they hope to use these funding wins
- 12:47as a way to get reelected. But then,
- 12:49secondly, representatives also make use
- 12:50of logrolling in order to get favorable
- 12:52legislation passed. And essentially, it
- 12:54means that representatives trade favors.
- 12:56Like, if you vote for my law, I'll vote
- 12:57for yours. You scratch my back rash, and
- 12:59I'll scratch yours. You know what I'm
- 13:00talking about? Okay, so that's the basic
- 13:01process by which Congress proposes and
- 13:03passes bills. But at this point, I need
- 13:05to tell you that there are four factors
- 13:07that influence how effectively and
- 13:09efficiently Congress is able to pass
- 13:11those laws. So, first of all, you have
- 13:12ideological divisions. So, members of
- 13:14Congress, like any other political body,
- 13:15represent a range of political beliefs
- 13:17that span from liberal to conservative.
- 13:19And that means the task of congressional
- 13:20policy making is affected by partisan
- 13:22voting, which refers to the practice of
- 13:24representatives voting on legislation
- 13:25purely based on their party or
- 13:27ideological affiliation. And partisan
- 13:29voting is becoming more and more
- 13:31prevalent as increasing political
- 13:32polarization becomes the norm.
- 13:34Basically, this means that conservative
- 13:35members of Congress have become more
- 13:37conservative while liberal members have
- 13:39become more liberal over time. And hey,
- 13:40far be it from me to criticize anybody's
- 13:42ideology because, you know, you do you,
- 13:44boo. But, this increasing polarization
- 13:46is definitely a problem because it tends
- 13:47to bog down the legislative process
- 13:49since there is less and less common
- 13:51ground available for meaningful
- 13:52compromise. And on important legislation
- 13:54that reality can lead to policy gridlock
- 13:56in which Congress cannot act due to a
- 13:58lack of consensus. But, then the second
- 14:00reality that affects the efficiency of
- 14:01Congress is the practice of
- 14:03gerrymandering, which refers to
- 14:04redrawing congressional districts in
- 14:06order to give the majority party an
- 14:07electoral advantage in the House of
- 14:09Representatives. And if that smells
- 14:10nasty to you, then, my dear pupil, your
- 14:13sniffer is working just fine. Now,
- 14:14gerrymandering is related to the
- 14:15constitutional process of redistricting,
- 14:17and here is how it's supposed to go. So,
- 14:19recall that representation in the House
- 14:21is based on population. Therefore, every
- 14:2310 years, the federal government can do
- 14:25like a census, which determines where
- 14:26Americans live and how many of them live
- 14:28there. And once the census data comes
- 14:30in, Congress uses this information to
- 14:32redistribute the 435 seats in the House,
- 14:34which is a practice known as
- 14:36apportionment. And then, based on that
- 14:37reapportionment, states are required to
- 14:39redraw their voting districts, which is
- 14:41what we call redistricting. And so far,
- 14:43everything is all constitutional and
- 14:44above board and sweet-smelling, but
- 14:47here's where things get stank. You see,
- 14:48since the majority party in the House
- 14:50wants to remain in power, they will
- 14:51often draw their districts in a way that
- 14:53benefits their party and harms the
- 14:55minority party. why gerrymandering has
- 14:57played a big role in modern political
- 14:59polarization. And look at that, we're
- 15:00just tying it all together, baby. You
- 15:01see, if representatives draw districts
- 15:03to keep themselves safe, then they have
- 15:05very little incentive to work with
- 15:06members of the opposition party to pass
- 15:08legislation born out of meaningful
- 15:10debate and compromise. And if you're a
- 15:11lover of democracy, that should conjure
- 15:13at least a single mournful tear because
- 15:15that is not how it's supposed to be.
- 15:17Speaking of which, redistricting and
- 15:18gerrymandering are the topics of two of
- 15:20your required Supreme Court cases. First
- 15:22was Baker v. Carr, and the short version
- 15:23is this. By 1962, Tennessee had not
- 15:26redrawn its districts since 1901. And in
- 15:28that span of time, urban populations in
- 15:30the state had exploded while rural
- 15:32populations had grown at a much slower
- 15:34rate. Therefore, with the districts as
- 15:35they were, rural voters had much more
- 15:37power in voting than urban districts,
- 15:39which is to say a minority of voters had
- 15:41a majority of the power. Or to say it
- 15:42another way, imagine this rural district
- 15:44had 10,000 people and this urban
- 15:46district had 100,000 people. And in this
- 15:48case, each district only has one
- 15:49representative with one vote. So, that
- 15:51makes this one way more powerful than
- 15:53this one. Therefore, when this case came
- 15:54before the court, lawyers argued that
- 15:56such an arrangement violated the equal
- 15:58protection clause of the 14th Amendment.
- 15:59And the court determined that
- 16:00Tennessee's outdated districts did
- 16:02violate the 14th Amendment and must be
- 16:04redrawn to create a more equal
- 16:05representation, thus establishing the
- 16:07one person, one vote principle. But then
- 16:09the second case about redistricting and
- 16:11gerrymandering was Shaw v. Reno in 1993.
- 16:13So, this particular case was concerned
- 16:15with two North Carolina districts that
- 16:16were drawn in strange shapes to create
- 16:18majority black districts, which
- 16:20representatives argued upheld the
- 16:21provisions of the Voting Rights Act of
- 16:231965 for historically discriminated
- 16:25people. However, the court ruled that
- 16:27drawing districts using race as the
- 16:28primary motivation violated the 14th
- 16:31Amendment, thus making the practice of
- 16:32strict racial gerrymandering illegal
- 16:34even if it empowered voters who were
- 16:36frequent targets of disenfranchisement.
- 16:38Anyway, all this to say gerrymandering,
- 16:39despite its questionable
- 16:41constitutionality, is very much an
- 16:43ongoing reality and it can affect how
- 16:44efficiently Congress does its job. And
- 16:46then the third reality that affects the
- 16:48efficiency of Congress is how
- 16:49representatives understand their role,
- 16:51and there are three potential models for
- 16:52this. First, if a representative
- 16:54understands themselves as a trustee,
- 16:55then they will vote on issues based on
- 16:57their own knowledge and judgment. In
- 16:59other words, a trustee believes that his
- 17:00or her constituents elected them to
- 17:02exercise their own judgment on policy
- 17:04matters, so that's what they do. Second,
- 17:05if a representative understands
- 17:07themselves as a delegate, then they will
- 17:08vote on issues the way their
- 17:09constituency wants them to vote, even if
- 17:11it goes against the personal beliefs of
- 17:13the representative. Now, this model is
- 17:14especially prevalent in the House, since
- 17:16representatives face elections every 2
- 17:18years and thus are more frequently
- 17:19accountable to receiving a retaliatory
- 17:21smack down from voters regarding their
- 17:23policy decisions. But third, most
- 17:24representatives understand their role as
- 17:26a politico, which is basically a blend
- 17:28of the other two models. So in cases
- 17:30where a policy has generated a strong
- 17:31public opinion then the political will
- 17:33act like a delegate to please the
- 17:34constituency. But if not then they'll
- 17:36act like a trustee and use their own
- 17:38judgment. And then the fourth and final
- 17:39reality that affects the efficiency of
- 17:41Congress is the presence of a divided
- 17:43government, which is when one party
- 17:44controls the presidency while the
- 17:46opposition party controls at least one
- 17:47chamber of Congress. So when one party
- 17:49controls both the presidency and both
- 17:51chambers of Congress, well then the
- 17:53legislative process can function pretty
- 17:54quickly and without much hindrance. But
- 17:56that's at the expense of the
- 17:57consideration of the needs and desires
- 17:59of the minority party. However, when
- 18:00rival parties control either branch it
- 18:02can significantly slow down the work of
- 18:04legislation since Congress can frustrate
- 18:05both the presidential policy agenda and
- 18:07presidential appointments that require
- 18:09congressional approval. And this is
- 18:10especially true when the president is a
- 18:12lame duck, which is to say another
- 18:14president has already been elected and
- 18:15the current president only has a few
- 18:16months left to serve. In that case, if
- 18:18there's a divided government then
- 18:19Congress feels very little pressure to
- 18:21work with the president to accomplish
- 18:22much before the end of the presidential
- 18:24term. And hey, since we're talking about
- 18:25the president I reckon it's time to shut
- 18:27down this section and move right along
- 18:28to consider the executive branch. That's
- 18:30right, it's time to get all
- 18:30presidential. Yawn. Let me begin by
- 18:32reminding you what should be obvious by
- 18:34now, namely that the entire job of
- 18:35making laws belongs to the legislative
- 18:38branch or you know, Congress. But wait a
- 18:39minute, that's kind of weird because
- 18:40when presidents are campaigning they're
- 18:41making all kinds of policy promises like
- 18:44you know, if you elect me I'll lower
- 18:45health care costs or I'll beef up the
- 18:46military or whatever. And according to
- 18:48the Constitution the president is
- 18:49granted precisely zero authority to
- 18:51write or make laws on behalf of the
- 18:53citizens of the United States. So what
- 18:55in the fresh heck is going on here?
- 18:57Well, my dear pupil, what's going on is
- 18:58that every president comes into office
- 19:00with a policy agenda that the president
- 19:02hopes to lead Congress to pass. And how
- 19:04does the president do that? Well,
- 19:05through two means, namely formal and
- 19:07informal powers. Now, the formal powers
- 19:09of the president are those written
- 19:10directly into the Constitution in
- 19:12Article 2 and there are three of these
- 19:14that you're going to need to know. The
- 19:14president's first formal power is the
- 19:16veto, which when being defined means
- 19:18that the executive can render a bill
- 19:20null and void by refusing to sign it
- 19:22into law. And as it turns out, the
- 19:23authority to veto legislation is a
- 19:25powerful means by which the president
- 19:27can ensure that only laws that align
- 19:28with the presidential policy agenda can
- 19:30pass. And what's more, the veto
- 19:31represents the president's most potent
- 19:33check on Congress. However, Congress can
- 19:35smack back if the president vetoes a
- 19:37bill because the Constitution says that
- 19:39if both chambers of Congress can muster
- 19:40a two-thirds vote, the president's veto
- 19:42is overridden and the bill becomes law
- 19:44without the president's signature. Okay,
- 19:46now so far I've told you that the
- 19:47president has two options when a bill
- 19:49reaches the White House, sign it into
- 19:50law or straight up veto it. But here's
- 19:52where I tell you that the president
- 19:53actually has a third option, namely do
- 19:56nothing. But there are two very
- 19:57different kinds of nothings the
- 19:59president can do. Now to understand
- 20:00this, you need to know that by law, the
- 20:02president has precisely 10 days to sign
- 20:04or veto a bill once it reaches the Oval
- 20:06Office. But if the president wants
- 20:08neither to sign it nor veto it, then
- 20:10after the 10-day period ends, the bill
- 20:12becomes a law without the president's
- 20:14signature. But then the second kind of
- 20:15nothing that the president can do is a
- 20:16little sneakier and it's known as a
- 20:18pocket veto. So Congress is not always
- 20:20in session. Like sometimes they take
- 20:22breaks. And so if a bill arrives to the
- 20:23president for signing and Congress is
- 20:25scheduled to adjourn before that 10-day
- 20:27period is up, then in that case, the
- 20:29presidential nothing amounts to a veto
- 20:31without all the bluster of a normal
- 20:33veto. Okay, the second formal power of
- 20:34the executive branch is that the
- 20:36president is named commander-in-chief,
- 20:38which means he is the highest ranking
- 20:39civilian military commander of the
- 20:41various American armed forces. But, big
- 20:43butt, massive butt, do not forget what I
- 20:46told you earlier, namely that the
- 20:47Constitution gives Congress the
- 20:49enumerated power to declare war. So when
- 20:51it comes to wars, Congress does the
- 20:53starting and the president does the
- 20:55strategizing, at least in theory. I
- 20:57mean, according to the Constitution,
- 20:58that's how it ought to go. But over the
- 21:00course of the 20th century, that line
- 21:01has become real blurry and I'm going to
- 21:03tell you more about that in a moment.
- 21:04Anyway, the third formal power of the
- 21:05president is the negotiation of
- 21:07treaties. And again, only the Senate can
- 21:08formally ratify a treaty, but it's the
- 21:10president who has the authority to
- 21:12hammer out the details with the other
- 21:13heads of state. But formal powers are
- 21:15not the only tools presidents can wield
- 21:17in order to get a policy agenda passed.
- 21:18No, there are also informal powers which
- 21:20are not written in the Constitution, but
- 21:22naturally relate to the formal powers
- 21:24and there are four of these you'll need
- 21:25to know. First, the president has the
- 21:26informal power to enter into executive
- 21:28agreements. So, in some cases, the
- 21:30president wants the United States to
- 21:31enter into a treaty with other
- 21:32countries, but that rascally Senate
- 21:34refuses to ratify the document. In that
- 21:36case, the president can engage in
- 21:37international policy through executive
- 21:39agreement. The downside is that since
- 21:41it's not a Senate ratified treaty, then
- 21:43once the president is out of office,
- 21:44usually the executive agreements are
- 21:46tossed in the trash by the incoming
- 21:47president. Okay, the second informal
- 21:49power of the president includes
- 21:50bargaining and persuasion. Now, the
- 21:51president has the eyes and ears of
- 21:53Americans more than any other elected
- 21:55official and good presidents use that
- 21:56attention to persuade people to put
- 21:58pressure on their congressional
- 21:59representatives to support bills that
- 22:01favor the executive agenda and that
- 22:03happens in several ways. First of all,
- 22:04every year the president delivers a
- 22:05State of the Union address to Congress
- 22:07in which he lays out the major terms on
- 22:09his own policy agenda. And because this
- 22:11is a televised event which is then
- 22:12covered and summarized by news outlets
- 22:14afterwards, presidents use this bully
- 22:15pulpit to attempt to persuade Americans
- 22:17to pressure Congress to support the
- 22:19executive policy agenda. But then
- 22:20second, presidents have made use of
- 22:22communication technology to reach the
- 22:24American people. For example, Franklin
- 22:25D. Roosevelt delivered a series of talks
- 22:27over the radio during the Great
- 22:28Depression to help Americans understand
- 22:30the policies he was pushing through
- 22:31Congress in order to help them. And then
- 22:33John F. Kennedy was the first president
- 22:34to fully exploit the newer technology of
- 22:36television. And then with the rise of
- 22:37the internet and particularly social
- 22:39media, modern presidents, Donald Trump
- 22:41chief among them, have used this
- 22:42technology to communicate directly with
- 22:44their followers in order to drum up
- 22:45support for their policy agenda. Okay,
- 22:47and third, executive orders amount to a
- 22:49very potent informal power of the
- 22:50president. Now, in case you didn't know,
- 22:52the executive branch is not just the
- 22:54president. No, there are millions of
- 22:55people spread across dozens of executive
- 22:57agencies and departments that do the
- 22:59work of executing the laws that Congress
- 23:01writes. And this whole collection of
- 23:02workers is known as the bureaucracy. And
- 23:04if you're itching to hear more about
- 23:05them, then
- 23:06it is your luckiest thinking day cuz I
- 23:08got a mouthful coming at you later. But
- 23:09here, it's enough to know that the
- 23:10president can influence how bureaucratic
- 23:12agencies enforce the law in line with
- 23:14the presidential policy agenda, and
- 23:15that's done through executive orders.
- 23:17They're not laws, they're just written
- 23:18orders from the president telling
- 23:19certain parts of the bureaucracy what to
- 23:21do or what not to do based on existing
- 23:23laws passed by Congress. And then
- 23:24fourth, the president can exercise the
- 23:26informal power of issuing signing
- 23:28statements. So, remember that in order
- 23:29for a bill to become a law, the
- 23:31president must sign it. But if the
- 23:32president is feeling a little sassy,
- 23:34then a veto is another option. But
- 23:35sometimes slinging vetoes around isn't
- 23:37the best or wisest course of action. So,
- 23:39in that case, the president can sign the
- 23:41bill into law, but then issue a signing
- 23:43statement, which amounts to a written
- 23:44explanation for how the president
- 23:46intends to execute the law, which in
- 23:48some cases might be different from how
- 23:50Congress intended the law to be
- 23:51executed. Now, there is no doubt. In
- 23:53fact, I go so far as to say there isn't
- 23:54even a diggity doubt that the power of
- 23:56the president has grown over time. But
- 23:58that doesn't mean that the president can
- 24:00just get that sweet policy agenda passed
- 24:01without any resistance because there are
- 24:03times when Congress and more to the
- 24:05point the Senate uh resist. And this
- 24:07resistance often arises when it comes
- 24:08time for the president to make
- 24:10appointments to various executive
- 24:11positions. And that's because a little
- 24:12more than a thousand of these
- 24:13appointments are subject to confirmation
- 24:15by the Senate based on the powers
- 24:16granted by the advice and consent clause
- 24:18of Article II. Now, there are four major
- 24:20categories of appointments that the
- 24:21president makes. First, appointments are
- 24:22made to the president's cabinet, which
- 24:24is made up of the heads of various
- 24:25executive departments and acts as an
- 24:27advisory board to the president. the
- 24:29appointment of cabinet members is
- 24:30subject to the Senate's power of advice
- 24:32and consent, most appointees to these
- 24:33positions don't face much opposition
- 24:35from Congress, even if senators are
- 24:37ideological opposed to these nominees.
- 24:39And that's because the unspoken rule of
- 24:41cabinet confirmation is if the president
- 24:42won the election, then the president
- 24:44should be able to appoint the people
- 24:45that he or she wants to work with. But
- 24:47on some occasions, the president
- 24:48nominates controversial figures for
- 24:50certain posts, and they can face
- 24:51resistance in the Senate. For example,
- 24:53when President Donald Trump nominated
- 24:54Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has been very
- 24:56public about his skepticism about
- 24:58vaccines to serve as his Secretary of
- 25:00Health. The Senate confirmation process
- 25:02was pretty tense given his position.
- 25:04Second, the President appoints
- 25:05ambassadors which act as the President's
- 25:07representatives in various countries
- 25:08across the world and typically these
- 25:09appointments pass without much of a
- 25:11fight also. And then third, some of the
- 25:12President's appointments to the
- 25:13Executive Office of the President are
- 25:15subject to Senate confirmation. So, if
- 25:16the cabinet's main job is to advise the
- 25:18President then the main job of the
- 25:20Executive Office of the President is to
- 25:21coordinate and manage the various
- 25:23agencies and departments within the
- 25:25Executive Branch to align with the
- 25:26President's agenda. And again, the
- 25:27people who fill these positions play a
- 25:29big role in shaping the presidential
- 25:30policy agenda in the Executive Branch,
- 25:32but they typically get through the
- 25:33confirmation process without much of a
- 25:35fight. But without a doubt, the most
- 25:36drama occurs when the President appoints
- 25:38federal judges at all levels, namely the
- 25:40District Courts, the Court of Appeals,
- 25:42and the Supreme Court. And look,
- 25:43presidents straight up love appointing
- 25:45federal judges because in case you
- 25:46forgot, they serve lifetime terms which
- 25:48means that they can continue to
- 25:49implement the President's policy agenda
- 25:51for decades after the President's left
- 25:53office. Therefore, because the stakes
- 25:54are so high, the Senate confirmation of
- 25:56federal judges, particularly Supreme
- 25:58Court judges, can become an arena of
- 26:00stiff resistance to the President's
- 26:01policy agenda. For example, when Ronald
- 26:03Reagan nominated Justice Robert Bork to
- 26:05the court, let's just say things got uh
- 26:07nasty. So, Reagan wanted Bork on the
- 26:09court to rule in favor of his
- 26:10administration's conservative policies
- 26:12for decades to come. But as it turned
- 26:13out, Judge Bork, which I admit gives me
- 26:16great pleasure to say, was a little too
- 26:17radical for the taste of the senators
- 26:19whose job it was to confirm him. And in
- 26:21the end, the Senate rejected Bork and
- 26:22Reagan was forced to find a new nominee.
- 26:24Okay, so appointments in the Executive
- 26:25Branch are one way in which the
- 26:27President can advance a policy agenda,
- 26:29but at the same time, it's one way in
- 26:30which the Senate can frustrate the
- 26:32President's policy agenda. But hey,
- 26:33don't go thinking that the President is
- 26:35the only one with an agenda. No,
- 26:36Congress too has a policy agenda and
- 26:38sometimes those two agendas don't
- 26:40exactly match up. And in that case,
- 26:41Congress can really throw up hurdles to
- 26:43the presidential agenda. But when that
- 26:45happens, you often see presidents
- 26:46attempting to enact their agenda by
- 26:47issuing executive orders rather than the
- 26:49more traditional means of getting laws
- 26:51passed by Congress. For example,
- 26:53President Harry Truman desegregated the
- 26:54military with an executive order in
- 26:561948. Like he knew that Congress, with
- 26:58its preponderance of Southern
- 27:00representatives, would never pass a law
- 27:01to desegregate anything. But Truman did
- 27:03have control of the rules and
- 27:05regulations of the US Armed Forces, and
- 27:07therefore he went ahead and executive
- 27:08ordered them to abolish racial
- 27:10segregation. Okay, now the last thing I
- 27:11need to tell you about the president is
- 27:13that over time executive power has
- 27:14expanded significantly. Or to put it
- 27:17another way, the Constitution says that
- 27:18the president's power pants only come in
- 27:20a size small. But as presidents have
- 27:22used their formal and informal powers
- 27:24over the course of history, they found
- 27:25themselves getting a plumper and
- 27:27therefore demanding a bigger set of
- 27:29power pants. And today those pants are
- 27:30running into the multiple extra larges,
- 27:33and you'll need to know how that
- 27:34happened. First of all, this growth of
- 27:35presidential power was almost inevitable
- 27:37given that the Constitution mandates a
- 27:38single executive rather than a council
- 27:40of executives. So Alexander Hamilton
- 27:42argued in Federalist 70, another one of
- 27:44your required documents, that a single
- 27:46executive, as opposed to a council of
- 27:48executives, despite its potential
- 27:49dangers, was the only logical choice for
- 27:52two reasons. First of all, Hamilton
- 27:53argues that a single executive by nature
- 27:55possesses the one quality most necessary
- 27:57for the executive branch, namely energy,
- 28:00which is Hamilton's way of saying
- 28:01efficiency and decisiveness. Second,
- 28:03Hamilton argues that a single executive
- 28:05provides far greater accountability when
- 28:07abuses do occur. In other words, if the
- 28:08president tries to taste the sweet
- 28:10fruits of absolute power and then
- 28:11tramples all over the rights of the
- 28:13American people, well, then everyone
- 28:15knows exactly who to blame and hold
- 28:16accountable. But second, presidential
- 28:18power has grown nonetheless because
- 28:20presidents making prodigious use of
- 28:21Hamilton's energy have claimed more and
- 28:24more authority. For example, George
- 28:25Washington, the first president,
- 28:26considered himself to be a servant of
- 28:28Congress and often deferred to their
- 28:30judgment on account of, you know, it's
- 28:31the branch that represents the people.
- 28:33But things changed significantly with
- 28:34the election of Andrew Jackson, who
- 28:36decided that he himself knew better how
- 28:38to represent the people than Congress
- 28:40did, and with that conviction he often
- 28:42clashed with Congress and the Supreme
- 28:43Court as he expanded the power of the
- 28:45president. But for sure, the greatest
- 28:47expansion of presidential power came
- 28:48under the leadership of President
- 28:49Franklin Roosevelt. As it turned out, he
- 28:51came into office during the Great
- 28:52Depression, and that man had all kinds
- 28:54of that Hamiltonian energy available to
- 28:56try to solve the greatest economic
- 28:57crisis in US history. And here it's not
- 28:59important whether those programs worked
- 29:01or they didn't, but it is important to
- 29:02know that as a result of Roosevelt's
- 29:04flurry of policies known as the New
- 29:06Deal, the executive power pants were way
- 29:08bigger after his presidency than they
- 29:10were before it. And not surprisingly,
- 29:12the debate over the proper scope of
- 29:13presidential powers continues up to this
- 29:15present moment. All right, now it's time
- 29:16to talk about the third branch of
- 29:18government, namely the judicial branch.
- 29:20And I know I've been flapping my mouth
- 29:21hole for an eternity at this point. So,
- 29:23smack yourself in the face, lick a 9-V
- 29:25battery, do what you have to do to wake
- 29:26up, and let's get busy. And I'm getting
- 29:28word from my legal department saying
- 29:30that I cannot encourage you to lick a
- 29:31battery, even if it was a hilarious
- 29:33joke. So, you know,
- 29:35don't. Anyway, first things first, what
- 29:36is the job of the federal court system?
- 29:38Well, the court acts as the final and
- 29:39most authoritative interpreter of the
- 29:41Constitution, which is a power known as
- 29:43judicial review. And there's a whole
- 29:44three-tiered system of federal courts
- 29:46arranged thusly: district courts,
- 29:48appeals courts, and then the big daddy
- 29:50on top of the ladder is the Supreme
- 29:51Court. Now, for the most part, all cases
- 29:53start at the bottom and then work their
- 29:54way up to the Supreme Court, whose
- 29:55decision on the constitutionality of
- 29:57laws or executive actions is final. But,
- 30:00where says you does the judicial branch
- 30:01get such authority? Well, says I, it's
- 30:03right there in Article 3 of the
- 30:04Constitution. And here's where I tell
- 30:06you that Article 3 actually says very
- 30:08little about the Supreme Court compared
- 30:09to the more voluminous structures and
- 30:11regulations in Article 1 regarding
- 30:13Congress and Article 2 regarding the
- 30:14president. It does mention the kinds of
- 30:16cases that the court can hear and the
- 30:17kinds of jurisdiction it has in those
- 30:19cases, which again refers to the scope
- 30:21of authority the court has to hear
- 30:22different kinds of cases. But anyway,
- 30:24Article 3 also mentions the manner in
- 30:26which federal judges will be appointed,
- 30:27which is to say they are appointed by
- 30:29the president and they serve for life on
- 30:30the condition of good behavior. Now,
- 30:32listen carefully. Those two features,
- 30:34namely that judges are not elected, but
- 30:35rather appointed, and that they serve
- 30:37for life, keep the judiciary
- 30:39independent. And that's important
- 30:40because if judges are not independent,
- 30:42that would cause all kinds of problems.
- 30:44And what problems would those be? Well,
- 30:45I reckon we'll let our boy Alexander
- 30:47Hamilton explain it to you in another of
- 30:48your required documents, namely
- 30:50Federalist 78. First of all, the fact
- 30:51that federal judges are appointed by the
- 30:53president rather than elected by the
- 30:54people means that judges are insulated
- 30:56from the pressure of pleasing the voters
- 30:58with their decisions. And that means
- 30:59that they're more likely to decide cases
- 31:01based on their constitutional merit
- 31:02alone rather than popular sentiment in
- 31:04society. And second, Hamilton argues
- 31:06that the fact that judges serve for life
- 31:08means that they can become familiar with
- 31:09the magnificently large case history of
- 31:11the United States, which, you know,
- 31:12takes a lot of stinking time. Okay, so
- 31:14by nature, the Constitution protects the
- 31:16independence of the judicial branch, to
- 31:17which I say, "Noise." But there's also a
- 31:20potential not so noise side to that
- 31:22independence. What I mean is when a
- 31:23federal court, especially the Supreme
- 31:25Court, hands down a decision that has
- 31:27the effect of making policy for the
- 31:29whole country. For example, before the
- 31:30Civil War, one of the most notorious and
- 31:32stanky decisions ever rendered by the
- 31:34Supreme Court was handed down, namely
- 31:36Dred Scott v. Sanford. Here, judges
- 31:37ruled that the owners of enslaved people
- 31:39cannot be deprived of their property
- 31:41when crossing state lines, which
- 31:42effectively meant that slavery was now
- 31:44legal in every state in the Union,
- 31:46including states that by law opposed the
- 31:48practice. When the court hands down a
- 31:50controversial decision like that, which,
- 31:51remember, can only happen because judges
- 31:53don't answer to the people and can serve
- 31:55for life, it could be controversial. And
- 31:57the main energy of that controversy is
- 31:58something like this. How can this
- 32:00handful of unelected judges who
- 32:02represent precisely no Americans turn
- 32:04around and tell Americans what they can
- 32:06or cannot do. So, that's the downside of
- 32:08the independence of the judiciary. But
- 32:09it's hard to eliminate the downside
- 32:11without also ruining the upside, namely
- 32:13that juicy independence, which is the
- 32:14main fuel that powers this branch of
- 32:16government. And with that independence,
- 32:18federal judges are free to get their
- 32:19judicial review on, which, if you'll
- 32:21recall from unit one, is the main power
- 32:23of the judicial branch. And essentially,
- 32:24this just means that federal courts are
- 32:25the final and authoritative interpreters
- 32:27of the Constitution regarding laws and
- 32:29executive actions. But I have to tell
- 32:31you this, if you go and read Article 3,
- 32:32and I know that you will, you will find
- 32:34that it nowhere says that the judicial
- 32:36branch has the power of judicial review.
- 32:38So, why is a bald, bearded, gap-toothed
- 32:40man sitting here telling you that the
- 32:41court does have a power that the
- 32:43Constitution does not mention? Well,
- 32:45thankfully, it's not actually me telling
- 32:46you that. It's Hamilton, once again, in
- 32:48Federalist 78. There he says that the
- 32:49court's main job is to declare all acts
- 32:52contrary to the manifest tenor of the
- 32:53Constitution void. Or, to say it in a
- 32:55way that you actually understand, the
- 32:57power of judicial review belongs to the
- 32:59court by the very nature of what a court
- 33:01is. Like, the Constitution is, first and
- 33:03foremost, a law, and a law needs judges
- 33:05to interpret it and make rulings based
- 33:07on its precepts. And that's essentially
- 33:08what judicial review is. However, I
- 33:10should mention that judicial review was
- 33:11formally established as belonging to the
- 33:13judiciary once and for all in 1803 in
- 33:15the Marbury v. Madison case. Okay, so,
- 33:17judicial review is the power of the
- 33:19court. But, now I need to explain the
- 33:20most important principle that governs
- 33:22exactly how judicial reviewing takes
- 33:24place. It's a principle known as stare
- 33:26decisis, which, when being translated
- 33:28from the Latin, means let the decision
- 33:30stand. So, whenever the court makes a
- 33:31final ruling on a case, that creates a
- 33:33precedent by which judges can make
- 33:35decisions on future cases that are
- 33:36similar. Therefore, in order to ensure
- 33:38that domestic tranquility written about
- 33:40in the preamble of the Constitution,
- 33:42federal judges make every effort to hand
- 33:44down decisions on current cases that are
- 33:46consistent with past decisions. And
- 33:47look, this principle is pretty dang
- 33:49firm, and as such, it governs the
- 33:51judicial process most of the time. And
- 33:52you know I got a butt for you, and here
- 33:54it is. But, there are times when the
- 33:56court overturns past decisions, thereby
- 33:57creating a new precedent to follow. Now,
- 33:59in some cases, precedents are overturned
- 34:01because the ideological composition of
- 34:03the court's judges has changed.
- 34:04Remember, it's presidents who appoint
- 34:06federal judges, and that means they are
- 34:07eager to appoint judges who align with
- 34:09their particular ideology, which is to
- 34:11say, liberal presidents appoint liberal
- 34:13judges, and conservative presidents
- 34:14appoint conservative judges. And that
- 34:16can have a major impact on whether the
- 34:18court upholds a past precedent or prints
- 34:20it out, burns it, and dances upon its
- 34:22ashes. For example, in 1896, a
- 34:24conservative-leaning Supreme Court
- 34:26established the separate but equal
- 34:27doctrine that allowed for racial
- 34:28discrimination laws. But, 50 years
- 34:30later, a more liberal-leaning court
- 34:32overturned that precedent and declared
- 34:33racial discrimination unconstitutional,
- 34:35on which more to come in unit three.
- 34:37Now, the interesting thing is that
- 34:38judges on both of those courts would say
- 34:40they were getting their judicial review
- 34:41on. But, over time, when ideological
- 34:44changes affect how the court makes
- 34:45decisions, we've developed two terms to
- 34:47describe these different ways of
- 34:48exercising judicial review. On one side,
- 34:50you have judicial activism, which refers
- 34:52to the court's willingness to overturn
- 34:54prior precedents or legislative and
- 34:55executive acts, which in effect
- 34:57invalidates existing laws and creates
- 34:59new laws. The emphasis here is on in
- 35:01effect, because courts have no power to
- 35:03make new laws. So, in general, an
- 35:04activist court considers not merely the
- 35:06constitutional principle at stake in
- 35:08their decision, but also the broad
- 35:09effects that decision might have on
- 35:11American society as a whole. So, you
- 35:12might say that judicial activists do
- 35:14their work with the Constitution in one
- 35:16hand and a newspaper in the other, and
- 35:18both inform their decisions. On the
- 35:19other hand, you have judicial restraint,
- 35:21which asserts that judicial review
- 35:23should be limited to decisions that
- 35:24adhere to current constitutional and
- 35:26case precedent. In other words,
- 35:27practitioners of judicial restraint
- 35:29believe that federal judges exist only
- 35:30to interpret the Constitution without
- 35:32regard for the social effects of their
- 35:34decisions. So, in this case, you might
- 35:35say that those who adhere to judicial
- 35:37restraint do their work with the
- 35:38Constitution in one hand and, you know,
- 35:40like a second copy of the Constitution
- 35:41in the other. Now, I wish I could tell
- 35:42you that activism and restraint could
- 35:44each be neatly applied to a particular
- 35:46political ideology, but, you know, not
- 35:48so much. There have been both
- 35:49conservative and liberal activist
- 35:51courts, as well as conservative and
- 35:52liberal restraint courts, and it really
- 35:54depends on the decision being made.
- 35:55Anyway, the last thing you need to know
- 35:56about the judicial branch is that
- 35:58because it exists within the consti-
- 36:00tution of the other branches of
- 36:01government, it too can get checked and
- 36:02balanced by the others. And there are
- 36:04five specific checks that you're going
- 36:05to need to know. First, Congress can
- 36:07check the judicial branch by passing
- 36:08legislation that modifies the impact of
- 36:10Supreme Court decisions. For example, in
- 36:121993, Congress passed the Religious
- 36:14Freedom Restoration Act, which was a
- 36:15direct response to a Supreme Court
- 36:17decision that restricted Americans'
- 36:18First Amendment right to the free
- 36:20exercise of religion. And then, the
- 36:21second check on judicial branch
- 36:22decisions is the passage of a
- 36:23constitutional amendment. So, let's go
- 36:25back to the Dred Scott case I mentioned
- 36:26earlier, which effectively legalized
- 36:28slavery in all states. Well, Congress
- 36:30went ahead and clapped all the way back
- 36:31by proposing the 13th Amendment, which
- 36:33abolished slavery, and soon thereafter
- 36:35enough states ratified the amendment
- 36:36that it got added to the Constitution,
- 36:38thereby invalidating the Dred Scott
- 36:40decision. Thirdly, judicial decisions
- 36:42can be affected by presidential
- 36:43appointments that shift the ideological
- 36:45balance of the court. For example,
- 36:46during his first term in office,
- 36:47Republican Donald Trump appointed no
- 36:49less than three conservative justices to
- 36:51the Supreme Court. And that move paid
- 36:52off for him in 2022 when the court
- 36:54overturned Roe v. Wade, a case that
- 36:56conservative Americans hated in the
- 36:58Dobbs v. Jackson decision. And then
- 36:59fourth, the force of judicial decisions
- 37:01can be minimized when the president or
- 37:03states delay the implementation of its
- 37:05ruling. Remember, the court has neither
- 37:06the power nor the resources to execute
- 37:08the decisions it makes and thus must
- 37:10rely on the executive branch and state
- 37:12governments to enforce the law. But if
- 37:13the other branches or state governments
- 37:14disagree with that decision, then they
- 37:16could just drag their feet and delay its
- 37:18enforcement. For example, in 1954 when
- 37:19the court ruled that racial segregation
- 37:21in schools was unconstitutional, some
- 37:23southern states just refused to
- 37:25integrate their schools. And a full
- 37:26decade after that decision, very few of
- 37:28those states had complied with the
- 37:29court's ruling. And finally, the fifth
- 37:31check on the Supreme Court comes from
- 37:32Congress, which has the constitutional
- 37:34power to limit or alter the jurisdiction
- 37:36of the court. And what that means is
- 37:37that Congress can effectively ban entire
- 37:39categories of cases, like for example,
- 37:41cases involving school prayer from
- 37:43consideration in the Supreme Court.
- 37:45Okay, so those are the three branches
- 37:46that make up the American federal
- 37:48government. But did I not say in the
- 37:49beginning that there is a mysterious
- 37:50potential fourth branch of government? I
- 37:52know that felt like weeks ago, but yes,
- 37:54I did in fact say that. And so, my dear
- 37:56people, it's time to introduce you to
- 37:57the federal bureaucracy, which may or
- 37:59may not be a fourth branch of
- 38:00government, question mark. Okay, so
- 38:02technically speaking, the federal
- 38:03bureaucracy exists within the executive
- 38:05branch of the government and includes
- 38:07all the various departments and agencies
- 38:09and millions of civil servants that do
- 38:11the actual work of enforcing the laws
- 38:12that Congress passes. Yeah, the
- 38:14Constitution says that it's the job of
- 38:15the president to execute the laws, but
- 38:17it's not like the president is going to
- 38:18knock on the door of every American
- 38:20citizen or corporation or whatever and
- 38:22make sure they're in line. I mean,
- 38:23that's not even possible. And so, in
- 38:24order to actually enforce the law, the
- 38:26executive branch has created a metric
- 38:28buttload of departments and
- 38:29organizations staffed with workers who
- 38:31can fan out across the country to ensure
- 38:33that laws are being observed and obeyed.
- 38:34And that is the bureaucracy. But I mean,
- 38:36it just sounds like that's part of the
- 38:38executive branch. So, why am I all maybe
- 38:40it's the fourth branch?
- 38:42Well, that's because over the course of
- 38:43the 20th century, the federal
- 38:44bureaucracy has become so massively
- 38:46massive that its influence can
- 38:47significantly impact the way in which
- 38:49laws are executed. And don't worry, I'm
- 38:51about to Heimsplain all that up for you
- 38:52real nice. So, first of all, you need to
- 38:54understand the structure of the
- 38:55bureaucracy, which is made up of four
- 38:57different kinds of entities. First, you
- 38:58have the 15 executive departments, which
- 39:00are led by the president's appointed
- 39:01cabinet secretaries. And since
- 39:03departments occupy the highest rung on
- 39:04the bureaucratic ladder, they represent
- 39:06exceedingly broad policy areas. For
- 39:08example, there's the Department of
- 39:09Energy, the Department of Homeland
- 39:10Security, the Department of Education,
- 39:12etc. And then second, the bureaucracy is
- 39:14made up of various independent agencies,
- 39:16which specialize in specific areas of
- 39:17policy. For example, NASA is responsible
- 39:20for organizing and executing the US
- 39:21space program, as well as conducting
- 39:23research on space and aeronautics. And
- 39:25then third, the bureaucracy contains
- 39:26independent regulatory commissions,
- 39:28which are made up of experts in various
- 39:30areas of industry and business, and
- 39:31their job is to create rules for
- 39:33specific industries, monitor compliance,
- 39:35and issue fines if compliance is
- 39:37lacking. And then fourth, you have
- 39:38government corporations, which are kind
- 39:40of a hybrid between a private business
- 39:41and a government agency. These are not
- 39:43funded by taxpayer money, but instead
- 39:45are expected to pay their own bills by
- 39:46generating profit. And a good example
- 39:48here is the US Postal Service, which
- 39:50generates profit by selling stamps. Now,
- 39:51related to all of this, you need to
- 39:52understand exactly how people get jobs
- 39:55in all these bureaucratic entities. And
- 39:56this is important because way back in
- 39:58the day, like for example, during the
- 39:591830s, during the Andrew Jackson
- 40:00administration, people got bureaucratic
- 40:02jobs on a single condition: Are you or
- 40:05are you not a crony of the president?
- 40:07Did you campaign for him? Did you
- 40:08contribute financially? If so, bam, you
- 40:10got a job in the bureaucracy. Now, that
- 40:11was called the patronage system, and I
- 40:13don't think I need to explain why it was
- 40:14such a bad idea. But that began to
- 40:16change near the end of the 19th century,
- 40:17so the bureaucratic jobs were awarded on
- 40:19merit-based qualities like
- 40:21professionalism and specialization and
- 40:22political neutrality. And that's a much
- 40:24better system, since in theory the
- 40:26people who hold those jobs are policy
- 40:27specialists and field experts, rather
- 40:29than some unqualified rando to whom the
- 40:31president owed a favor. Okay, second,
- 40:33you need to know exactly what it is that
- 40:34the bureaucracy does, and here it's
- 40:36pretty simple in concept. They write
- 40:38rules and enforce regulations. So, as
- 40:40you know by now, Congress is the
- 40:41law-making branch, but if you've ever
- 40:43read a law passed by Congress, you'll
- 40:44know that the language they use is
- 40:46pretty broad and sometimes kind of
- 40:47vague. And that's because most
- 40:48representatives or senators are not
- 40:50experts in the fields on which they
- 40:52write laws. For example, to my
- 40:53knowledge, no member of Congress is a
- 40:54climatologist. But who cares? Congress
- 40:56people are perfectly qualified to pass a
- 40:58law saying we want clean air and water
- 41:00free from stanky pollution, and we want
- 41:02all you jamokes who are out there
- 41:03polluting it to get smacked with
- 41:04consequences if you do. So, that's fine,
- 41:06but like the senator who sponsored that
- 41:08bill probably doesn't know the science
- 41:09or engineering required to actually
- 41:11reduce pollution. But you know who does
- 41:12have that expertise? Wait for it. The
- 41:15bureaucracy. In this case, there's a
- 41:16whole agency, namely the Environmental
- 41:18Protection Agency, that's positively
- 41:20overflowing with scientists and
- 41:22engineers who do know how to reduce
- 41:23pollution. So, Congress sends that law
- 41:25over to the bureaucracy, and they get
- 41:26cracking to make very specific rules and
- 41:28regulations that make that law
- 41:30enforceable. Now, the term for this is
- 41:31delegated discretionary authority, and
- 41:33that term is about the most important
- 41:35thing you can remember about the
- 41:36bureaucracy. What it means is that
- 41:37Congress delegates or transfers
- 41:39authority to make binding rules and
- 41:41regulations to agencies responsible for
- 41:43enforcing the law. But then the
- 41:44discretionary bit means that the
- 41:46bureaucracy, because it's filled with
- 41:47experts, has room to use its own
- 41:49judgment on exactly which rules to write
- 41:51in order to best enforce that law. So,
- 41:53here's where that whole fourth branch
- 41:55thing starts to emerge. Yes, it's true
- 41:56that the bureaucracy has no authority on
- 41:58its own. It's all delegated from
- 42:00Congress. But with that delegated
- 42:01authority, agencies make rules that have
- 42:03the force of law. So, back to the
- 42:05previous example, Congress is like, "We
- 42:06want clean air, and whoever messes it up
- 42:08gets a consequence." And so, the
- 42:09scientists over at the EPA say, "Okay,
- 42:11that means large corporations can only
- 42:13release X amount of carbon emissions."
- 42:15And if they go over that amount, the
- 42:16business is going to have to pay a fine
- 42:17of X dollars. And here's the kicker, the
- 42:19values of those X's are determined by
- 42:21the EPA, an executive agency, and not by
- 42:24Congress. So, can you begin to see the
- 42:26power these agencies have and why people
- 42:28wonder if their growing power amounts to
- 42:29a fourth branch of government? Well, I
- 42:31hope so because I dang near used up all
- 42:32my words trying to explain. Now, there
- 42:34are seven bureaucratic entities that
- 42:35you're required to know for your exam,
- 42:37so let me tell you about them real
- 42:38quick. First, the Department of Homeland
- 42:39Security, which uses its delegated
- 42:41authority to ensure the public security
- 42:43of the United States. Second, there's
- 42:44the Department of Transportation, whose
- 42:45purpose is to ensure an efficient and
- 42:47safe transportation system for
- 42:48Americans, including roads and railways,
- 42:50air traffic, and shipping traffic.
- 42:52Third, there's the Department of Veteran
- 42:53Affairs, whose purpose is to provide
- 42:55health care benefits and services to
- 42:56America's war veterans. Fourth, there's
- 42:58the Department of Education, whose
- 42:59purpose is to administer federal
- 43:01education funding and enforce federal
- 43:03education policy, especially when it
- 43:04comes to civil rights. Then fifth, you
- 43:06have the Environmental Protection
- 43:07Agency, whose purpose is to regulate
- 43:09pollution to ensure that America's air,
- 43:10water, and environment remain clean and
- 43:12safe. And then sixth, you have the
- 43:13Federal Elections Commission, whose
- 43:15purpose is to enforce federal campaign
- 43:16finance laws in order to keep elections
- 43:18free and fair. And finally, seventh, you
- 43:20have the Securities and Exchange
- 43:21Commission, whose purpose is to regulate
- 43:23financial markets and protect investors
- 43:25in those markets. Now, look, you may
- 43:26have glazed over during that section,
- 43:27and I don't blame you, but let me bring
- 43:29you back to the main point here. Every
- 43:31entity I just listed has been granted
- 43:33discretionary rule-making authority by
- 43:35Congress in order to enforce the laws
- 43:37which fall under their respective areas
- 43:38of expertise. And that delegated
- 43:40discretionary authority is the big thing
- 43:42the AP Overlords want you to remember
- 43:43about those entities. Now, the actual
- 43:45day-in, day-out work of the bureaucracy
- 43:47basically comes down to five discrete
- 43:48activities. First, as you hopefully have
- 43:50discerned already, the bureaucracy
- 43:51writes and enforces regulations. Second,
- 43:53agencies issue fines that result from
- 43:55non-compliance with their rules. Third,
- 43:57bureaucrats often testify before
- 43:58Congress. You see, because the heads of
- 44:00departments and agencies are often
- 44:01experts in their field, Congress invites
- 44:03them to testify and give opinions and
- 44:04clarifying information when
- 44:06representatives are debating the merits
- 44:07of a particular bill. Fourth, we have
- 44:09the formation of iron triangles. So,
- 44:10this triangle represents a strong and
- 44:12enduring relationship between three
- 44:14entities, namely agencies, interest
- 44:16groups, and congressional committees, in
- 44:18which they help each other do the work
- 44:19of executing the law. For example,
- 44:21interest groups help fund congressional
- 44:22elections and then lobby representatives
- 44:24to support legislation important to the
- 44:26members of the interest group. They also
- 44:27advocate for funding of certain
- 44:28bureaucratic agencies that will support
- 44:30the interest group's desired outcomes.
- 44:32And then in return, bureaucratic
- 44:33agencies will sometimes create rules and
- 44:35regulations that favor the interest
- 44:36group that helped them secure funding,
- 44:38and then it goes around and around. And
- 44:39finally, fifth, various bureaucratic
- 44:41groups create issue networks. Okay, so
- 44:42interest groups tend to focus on getting
- 44:44legislation passed that addresses a very
- 44:46narrow issue like gun rights or
- 44:47healthcare benefits or retirees, for
- 44:49example. But as modern societies become
- 44:51more complex, sometimes several interest
- 44:53groups join together to form an issue
- 44:54network that aims to tackle specific
- 44:56problems on a large scale. And the
- 44:57structure of iron triangles is pretty
- 44:59rigid and always only includes the same
- 45:01three entities, which exist more or less
- 45:03permanently. But issue networks are more
- 45:05temporary and can include many different
- 45:07kinds of organizations that want to get
- 45:08a problem solved, problems like air
- 45:10pollution or underage drinking or
- 45:11whatever. Okay, and then the very last
- 45:13thing I need to tell you about are the
- 45:14various ways which the three branches of
- 45:16government can check and balance this
- 45:17massive and sometimes unwieldy
- 45:19bureaucracy. And we'll start with
- 45:20Congress's checks, and there are three.
- 45:22First, Congress has created its own
- 45:23watchdog agency in the legislative
- 45:25branch called the Government
- 45:26Accountability Office. And its purpose
- 45:27is to monitor whether executive agencies
- 45:29are spending money according to
- 45:31congressional desires and to ensure
- 45:32they're not overstepping the bounds of
- 45:34their delegated authority. Second,
- 45:35Congress can hold investigations and
- 45:37committee hearings. In other words, if
- 45:38the GAO does find evidence of
- 45:40wrongdoing, then they can require the
- 45:41having agency to testify before Congress
- 45:43and explain themselves. Then third, and
- 45:45by far the most powerful check, is that
- 45:47Congress holds the power of the purse.
- 45:49Remember, it's Congress who creates the
- 45:50annual federal budget and decides what
- 45:52amount each federal agency receives in
- 45:54order to carry out their work. And if
- 45:55investigations reveal that an agency is
- 45:57mismanaging funds or enforcing laws
- 45:59contrary to the congressional intent,
- 46:00Congress can reduce that agency's
- 46:02funding, which effectively removes its
- 46:04power in order to enforce the law. But
- 46:06then second, the president also holds
- 46:07powerful checks over the bureaucracy,
- 46:09and there's one big check to remember,
- 46:10namely the executive order, which I told
- 46:12you about earlier. For example, if
- 46:13agencies are enforcing the law in a way
- 46:15that contradicts the president's policy
- 46:16agenda, then the president can fire off
- 46:18an executive order to attempt to steer
- 46:20that agency in a different direction.
- 46:22And finally, federal courts can also
- 46:23check bureaucratic entities, and they do
- 46:25so using the only power they have. Uh
- 46:27say it with me now, judicial review. So
- 46:29just as the court determine the
- 46:30constitutionality of laws passed by
- 46:32Congress, they can do the same for
- 46:33bureaucratic rules and regulations. For
- 46:35example, if the court decides that an
- 46:36agency rule violates the first amendment
- 46:38right to free speech, then they can
- 46:39strike that rule down, rendering it null
- 46:41and void. And so it's true that the
- 46:42bureaucracy probably deserves its title
- 46:44as the fourth branch of government given
- 46:46its growing size and power. But in the
- 46:47end, the complex system of checks and
- 46:49balances that was built into our system
- 46:51of government puts clear and significant
- 46:52limits on the authority of these
- 46:54departments and agencies. And that's
- 46:55why, to tie everything up in a nice
- 46:57little bow, national policy making will
- 46:59always be constrained by the sharing of
- 47:01powers between the branches of
- 47:02government. Well, okay, you can click
- 47:03here to check out my Heimler Review
- 47:04Guide, which has everything you need to
- 47:06get an A in your class or a five on your
- 47:07exam in May. Or you can click here to
- 47:08watch my more in-depth topic videos for
- 47:10unit two. I'm glad you came around, and
- 47:12give yourself a dang high five for
- 47:13getting through that one, and I'll catch
- 47:14y'all on the flip-flop. Heimler out.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of AP Government UNIT 2 Review—Everything You NEED to Know by Heimler's History, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,971 words across 1,721 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.