YouTube2Text

Anthropic IPO at Risk, Meta’s Muse Pop, Token Prices Fall, Open Source Gains Share, Alignment Fails — Transcript

by All-In Podcast · 17,446 words · 2,617 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00All right everybody, welcome back to
  2. 0:01episode 290 of the number one podcast in
  3. 0:04the world. It's the all-in podcast. With
  4. 0:06me again, it's the core 4. David
  5. 0:09Freedberg is here. Chimoth Poly Hapatia
  6. 0:12and David Saxs calling in. I am your
  7. 0:16host, Jason Calakanis, and we have a
  8. 0:19full docket today. I'd be remiss though
  9. 0:22if I didn't ask everybody for their
  10. 0:24fondest memories of the fifth annual
  11. 0:26All-In Summit produced by
  12. 0:30Mr. David Friedberg. David, do you have
  13. 0:32any um thoughts? Uh how do you rate your
  14. 0:35performance as executive producer of the
  15. 0:37All-In Summit?
  16. 0:39>> You know what we didn't do? What we
  17. 0:40forgot to do at the end of day two? We
  18. 0:42didn't give a big shout out to our
  19. 0:44production team, to Kimber,
  20. 0:46>> to Lisa,
  21. 0:47>> to Nick. I think we No, Jason. Okay. I
  22. 0:49thought we should have brought him out,
  23. 0:50but I just want to give a big shout out.
  24. 0:52>> Bring him out for the standing up.
  25. 0:53>> The team backstage absolutely crushed it
  26. 0:56as always this year. And then I had a
  27. 0:58great time. Actually, you know, my
  28. 0:59favorite part is going to Universal
  29. 1:00Studios. You just get to have a good
  30. 1:02time. It's great. Just great.
  31. 1:03>> I am reliving my childhood. Shabbath
  32. 1:06with no trauma.
  33. 1:07>> By the way, shout out to our friends at
  34. 1:09Dongi. I got one of those coffee
  35. 1:11machines that we had at the event. I put
  36. 1:13it in my kitchen.
  37. 1:14>> You know what I got? I don't know if you
  38. 1:16guys saw, but there was a water machine
  39. 1:17in the VIP area.
  40. 1:19>> Well,
  41. 1:20>> that is a zero plastic water machine. It
  42. 1:23goes through super filtration.
  43. 1:25>> No microplastics in the water. I have
  44. 1:27one now in our office. Thank you very
  45. 1:28much to them. I appreciate it.
  46. 1:31>> Amazing company.
  47. 1:32>> Sax, do you have a favorite moment from
  48. 1:34the show?
  49. 1:34>> Well, I think the highlight of the show,
  50. 1:36the thing that we'll remember for a long
  51. 1:38time was the president calling in during
  52. 1:40Jensen's talk. And I think Jensen's
  53. 1:42overall the content and and demeanor
  54. 1:45really helped calm down this national
  55. 1:47panic over AI. It felt like we were the
  56. 1:50center of this national conversation.
  57. 1:52And I think it happened very
  58. 1:54organically. You remember there's
  59. 1:55basically been this SCOP for the last
  60. 1:57few weeks leading into the summit to
  61. 1:59convince everyone that humanity was
  62. 2:01going to go extinct unless we did
  63. 2:03exactly what the Democrats want and stop
  64. 2:07all AI development. And then you know we
  65. 2:08had first Satcha came out and kind of
  66. 2:12calmed everyone down and then JSON did
  67. 2:13the same thing and the president called
  68. 2:15in and did what he did best which is
  69. 2:16sees total control of the narrative that
  70. 2:20I'm sure these doomer groups have been
  71. 2:21carefully planning for weeks and kind of
  72. 2:23thwarted that whole operation.
  73. 2:25>> Nerds enough. Get back to work. You have
  74. 2:27a super intelligent
  75. 2:30Trump intelligence is now the term.
  76. 2:32We're going to call it Trump
  77. 2:32intelligence going forward. But I think
  78. 2:34you make a good point. A lot of people
  79. 2:35wanted to know Freeberg if this was
  80. 2:37planned. Was the President Trump calling
  81. 2:41planned Freeberg? T take us behind the
  82. 2:43scenes.
  83. 2:44>> Basically, Jensen was connecting with
  84. 2:47him right backstage and said, "Hey, call
  85. 2:49me back." And then he called him while
  86. 2:50he was on stage. There was some texting
  87. 2:52going on.
  88. 2:53>> Yeah, it was completely spontaneous.
  89. 2:55>> It was spontaneous. Yes.
  90. 2:56>> It was not like a planned thing where
  91. 2:57Jensen was like, "Hey, let's do a whole
  92. 2:59thing." And so that was pretty amazing
  93. 3:00to have this conversation that Jensen
  94. 3:04was waiting for from the president to
  95. 3:05happen live and clearly this was the
  96. 3:09topic desour in DC as well as in the
  97. 3:11news and the media and it was amazing to
  98. 3:13see it all happen on stage with us and
  99. 3:15yeah just to uh be clear I thought it
  100. 3:19was a bit and I was like well put him on
  101. 3:21speakerphone and Jensen says to me how
  102. 3:22do you do that and I just handed him I
  103. 3:24always keep an extra mic there in case
  104. 3:25somebody's mic goes out just put them on
  105. 3:26speaker phone put the microphone and
  106. 3:28President Trump the funniest president
  107. 3:30in history, funniest politician history.
  108. 3:32Did you notice
  109. 3:33>> Sachs that he drops a oneliner through a
  110. 3:36speaker phone perfectly,
  111. 3:39>> perfectly. Jensen makes the greatest
  112. 3:40chips. Everybody tries to reverse
  113. 3:42engineer them. Impossible. Impossible.
  114. 3:44But he can't figure out how to press the
  115. 3:45speakerphone button. Okay. [laughter]
  116. 3:48>> I was just like, how does he do it? How
  117. 3:50does he do it? It just drops the perfect
  118. 3:54line. But Shimoth, in all seriousness,
  119. 3:56the nerds were losing their mind last
  120. 3:58week and the adults came, daddy came,
  121. 4:01Elon came, Jensen came, all the adults
  122. 4:04in the room came and they just said,
  123. 4:05"Listen, if you have software that's
  124. 4:09defective and not ready to put in the
  125. 4:12world, maybe don't put it in the world
  126. 4:14and make it a little bit, you know, as
  127. 4:16you like to say, less brittle." So your
  128. 4:19thoughts on where we are in this
  129. 4:21national discussion which went from slow
  130. 4:23down to maybe
  131. 4:25just release non-brittle resilient
  132. 4:28software. Well, I think that there was
  133. 4:30this
  134. 4:32classification that happened last week
  135. 4:34between
  136. 4:36upand cominging organizations that want
  137. 4:39to call themselves labs, but are in fact
  138. 4:44companies that have P&Ls and
  139. 4:46shareholders and have to abide by the
  140. 4:48same rules that everybody else does. And
  141. 4:51then the sophisticated companies that
  142. 4:54have lived in scrutiny for many decades
  143. 4:58and have learned the hard way
  144. 5:01the process of making things robust and
  145. 5:03the cost of making things not robust. So
  146. 5:06what do I mean? On the one side you saw
  147. 5:08in many ways it's like curious times
  148. 5:10creates curious bedfellows right you
  149. 5:12have the cohort is Satya Jensen Sachs
  150. 5:17Zach Elon the president Lena Khan we
  151. 5:22have product liability language
  152. 5:23>> strange fellows indeed
  153. 5:25>> we have this product liability
  154. 5:27perspective in the United States it's
  155. 5:29meant to prevent companies from doing
  156. 5:31things that they're not supposed to do
  157. 5:34especially if they know that those
  158. 5:36things could be harmful
  159. 5:37And on the other side, it's folks making
  160. 5:39the thing that were being, I think, a
  161. 5:42little naive and basically saying,
  162. 5:44"We're not a company. We're a lab.
  163. 5:46Protect us." And I think the mature
  164. 5:48response is, "You should have internal
  165. 5:50controls and you should robustly test
  166. 5:53things." And what Zuck said earlier and
  167. 5:55what Elon has said in the past is we're
  168. 5:57just under a lot of scrutiny. And so
  169. 5:58when things aren't perfect, we just slow
  170. 6:00things down. Elon has done that with
  171. 6:02FSD. You said this, Jason. He could have
  172. 6:03been at FSD
  173. 6:053 or 4 years ago, but he has publicly
  174. 6:08stated, "We can't afford it because
  175. 6:10every accident that Tesla incurs is
  176. 6:13magnified a,000x than what any other
  177. 6:16company would incur, and so we just have
  178. 6:17to go slower." Zach last week said, "We
  179. 6:20were about to roll out Muse, which looks
  180. 6:21like one of the most successful product
  181. 6:23launches in recent memory, has huge
  182. 6:25implications actually, which we should
  183. 6:26talk about, and he had to slow roll it."
  184. 6:29He and Alexander who I was talking to
  185. 6:30last night had to slow roll it for a
  186. 6:33couple of months to get it perfect. So
  187. 6:35it's all within your control. It's just
  188. 6:37what do you choose to do? And uh I think
  189. 6:39that was the most interesting
  190. 6:41observation. We have to stop calling
  191. 6:43these companies labs. They're companies
  192. 6:45and we have to be judged on the same
  193. 6:48standards including product liability.
  194. 6:50>> Yeah. And there was a lot of coverage of
  195. 6:52this moment Sachs. Interestingly, some
  196. 6:54of the fake news media [laughter]
  197. 6:57were like on a popular podcast and then
  198. 6:59they play the clip, but they're just
  199. 7:01afraid to say the name of the podcast.
  200. 7:04Pretty hilarious.
  201. 7:05>> I think Jimoth is getting us into the
  202. 7:06first topic here already, which is
  203. 7:08whether we're going to have individual
  204. 7:10responsibility as our northstar or some
  205. 7:14sort of collective action. And the thing
  206. 7:17that always works the best is individual
  207. 7:20responsibility. Whether it's at the
  208. 7:21level of individuals or companies, the
  209. 7:23relevant decision to make in every case
  210. 7:26is should we ship this product? Not can
  211. 7:31we get the whole world to agree. And the
  212. 7:34problem with talking about these
  213. 7:36collectivized approaches is that they
  214. 7:38defay accountability away from the
  215. 7:42actual decision maker. And I I think
  216. 7:44people sort of feel this, you know, like
  217. 7:45this week you had Daario and Sam go to
  218. 7:49the United Nations and say we need some
  219. 7:51sort of global AI governance. And it
  220. 7:54kind of reminds me of like the
  221. 7:56billionaires who fly to Davos in their
  222. 7:57private jets and then rail against
  223. 8:00climate change. You know, there's
  224. 8:01something fundamentally sort of
  225. 8:03unrealistic and kind of out of touch
  226. 8:05about it.
  227. 8:06>> Hypocritical.
  228. 8:06>> Hypocritical. And it's like, guys, look,
  229. 8:09what we need is
  230. 8:11>> for you guys to make smart decisions
  231. 8:13about what to release. If a product is
  232. 8:16unsafe, which is to say it's unreliable
  233. 8:19or behaves unpredictably, then don't
  234. 8:21release it. And stop looking to some
  235. 8:24sort of global governance as the answer.
  236. 8:27Because if you guys don't get this
  237. 8:28decision right, it's not going to matter
  238. 8:29what the United Nations does. And by the
  239. 8:31time the United Nations agrees on
  240. 8:33anything, we're going to be much further
  241. 8:34along in this whole whole journey. So,
  242. 8:36there's something just very weird about
  243. 8:38the way that the principal actors in
  244. 8:41this keep talking [clears throat]
  245. 8:43>> because it really feels like they're
  246. 8:45trying to push off the responsibility.
  247. 8:48>> Well, there's a theory going around here
  248. 8:50and I think it is worth us discussing
  249. 8:51here that the Frontier Labs are covertly
  250. 8:56>> companies. They're companies.
  251. 8:58>> They're companies. Yes. Let me just
  252. 8:59finish the
  253. 8:59>> No, no, no, but but your made a really
  254. 9:01good point that I want to make sure we
  255. 9:02just don't miss. Okay.
  256. 9:03>> They are corporations.
  257. 9:04>> Yes. Yes. And when you call them labs,
  258. 9:06they sound like nonprofit entities, and
  259. 9:07it's not true.
  260. 9:08>> Okay. So, the corporations making these
  261. 9:11products are looking for President Trump
  262. 9:15to specifically give them what the
  263. 9:18internet companies had with section 230,
  264. 9:21which is shield them from liability. and
  265. 9:23that there is a consideration inside the
  266. 9:26Trump administration, the 47th
  267. 9:28administration, that maybe there could
  268. 9:30be some leverage put on these companies
  269. 9:33that they would give 10% of their equity
  270. 9:35to the uh sovereign wealth front of the
  271. 9:37United States, etc., and then that would
  272. 9:40result in them being given some pass
  273. 9:44when it comes to their liability. That's
  274. 9:47an insane thing to do. It's like giving
  275. 9:50some plane company that gives 10% of
  276. 9:52their equity to the US government the
  277. 9:54ability to not be responsible for their
  278. 9:57planes falling out of the sky. But what
  279. 9:59is your thought on that conspiracy
  280. 10:01theory? I'm sure you've heard it sachs
  281. 10:04that they're looking for. You're you're
  282. 10:06making it sound like this is the idea of
  283. 10:07the Trump administration. That's not
  284. 10:09true.
  285. 10:09>> No, not the Trump administration. This
  286. 10:11is what the
  287. 10:12>> Frontier Lab/Corporations are pitching
  288. 10:15to them and that there might be the
  289. 10:17rumor is there might be some people who
  290. 10:18are open to that in the administration.
  291. 10:20Again,
  292. 10:21>> this is all a back channel.
  293. 10:23>> Here's what we know is that in the past
  294. 10:25week, you had virtually every Trump
  295. 10:27administration official come out and say
  296. 10:29some version of what I just said, which
  297. 10:31is first and foremost, the AI companies
  298. 10:34have to take responsibility for their
  299. 10:35own products and that we will not wave
  300. 10:38product liability. I think Speaker
  301. 10:40Johnson said it, the congressional
  302. 10:42>> said it,
  303. 10:42>> Besson said it in the most recent
  304. 10:43interview. Everybody said if your game
  305. 10:46is to get a waiver of product liability
  306. 10:49or antitrust liability, if you're trying
  307. 10:52to form a cartel, if you're trying to
  308. 10:54collude, forget about it. We're not
  309. 10:55going to do it. So, I think they
  310. 10:57completely threw cold water on that
  311. 10:58whole idea. And remember what President
  312. 11:00Trump said is he just tweeted today, we
  313. 11:02have the DOJ. That's a guardrail. The
  314. 11:05administration is a guardrail. the
  315. 11:07administrative state, civil lawsuits,
  316. 11:09criminal lawsuits, all these things are
  317. 11:12there as potential liability to make
  318. 11:15sure that you make the right riskreward
  319. 11:18tradeoff.
  320. 11:19>> And again, at the end of the day, if
  321. 11:21those guys release an unsafe product,
  322. 11:23it's not going to matter what the United
  323. 11:25Nations agrees on. So, we need them to
  324. 11:27internalize the responsibility.
  325. 11:28>> Are they Listen, come on. Be candid with
  326. 11:30me. You you you got the inside goods
  327. 11:32here. Are they trying to lobby for that?
  328. 11:34Are they do you think they are lobbying
  329. 11:36to get this protection? Yes or no? Come
  330. 11:37on.
  331. 11:38>> Well, I I have heard this is not like
  332. 11:40first-p person experience. They they
  333. 11:41have not asked me like, "Hey, we want
  334. 11:43product liability waiver, but I have
  335. 11:45heard from people in Washington that
  336. 11:47they have been seeking something like
  337. 11:48that.
  338. 11:48>> It's hard to pin down, right?"
  339. 11:50>> Yeah. Okay, fair enough. Freeberg, your
  340. 11:53thoughts here as we are going to get
  341. 11:54into the first story here with the token
  342. 11:55maxing and the prices going down, but
  343. 11:58I'll give you the final word here on
  344. 12:00what America should do in terms of
  345. 12:02dealing with the corporations that are
  346. 12:05pretending to be labs who cannot take
  347. 12:07ownership of their own Frankenstein uh
  348. 12:10creations, which I think JD Vance, you
  349. 12:13know, I thought had a spectacular
  350. 12:15appearance. He was crisp and and looked
  351. 12:17quite presidential if I if I was going
  352. 12:19to um describe it.
  353. 12:22you threw a lot of fast balls
  354. 12:24>> and he knocked him out of the park. By
  355. 12:25the way, fast, you know, home run
  356. 12:27hitters want fast balls. You can't hit a
  357. 12:28fast ball if it's out of the strike
  358. 12:29zone. So, I gave him the the three
  359. 12:31hardest questions I could think of and
  360. 12:32he
  361. 12:33>> proceeded to knock all three over the
  362. 12:34fence. I think there was
  363. 12:36>> Jad's excellent listen.
  364. 12:38>> I mean, no, on the Sunday shows,
  365. 12:40>> they played the clips of the questions I
  366. 12:41asked him. Bang, bang, bang. Freeberg
  367. 12:44right over the f the fence. But, you
  368. 12:45know, he said basically, if you're
  369. 12:47creating Frankenstein, here's an idea.
  370. 12:49Stop. [laughter]
  371. 12:51And and and then he added, if you've
  372. 12:53already kind of let it the cat out of
  373. 12:55the bag, then create anti-Frankenstein.
  374. 12:57Basically, create the safeguards.
  375. 12:59>> Yeah,
  376. 12:59>> it makes total sense.
  377. 13:00>> I think Suck gave a good interview on
  378. 13:02this.
  379. 13:03>> They took their time doing this Muse
  380. 13:05release this week. They said they wanted
  381. 13:08to get it right. They wanted to make
  382. 13:10sure that it was safe, that it didn't
  383. 13:12give people capabilities to do bad
  384. 13:14things. That's the responsibility that
  385. 13:16they took as a corporation. Anyone
  386. 13:19that's outputting a model should take
  387. 13:21the same responsibility.
  388. 13:23>> Pretty obvious.
  389. 13:24>> This is an organization that understands
  390. 13:26it. Having paid a series of fines from
  391. 13:30Cambridge Analytica to recently
  392. 13:33>> we have a lot of we have a lot of laws
  393. 13:35that make it illegal to do a lot of
  394. 13:36things.
  395. 13:38>> All right, let's move on here. We
  396. 13:39[laughter] have laws.
  397. 13:40>> By the way, can I add like one
  398. 13:42philosophical point to this? So I I
  399. 13:45think that implicit
  400. 13:47in let's call it the Daario position
  401. 13:50that let's call it the regulated free
  402. 13:52market that we have his fundamental
  403. 13:55contention is that that will lead to a
  404. 13:58race to the bottom that competition
  405. 14:01jeopardizes safety. It's in all of his
  406. 14:03blog posts and many other people reflect
  407. 14:05this idea that competition equals lack
  408. 14:08of safety and that is implicitly a
  409. 14:11critique of our economic system. It's
  410. 14:14basically a leftwing critique of our
  411. 14:16system and it goes back a long way. I
  412. 14:18remember back in the days of the cold
  413. 14:21war when we really had this duel between
  414. 14:24two different systems. Do you want the
  415. 14:25sort of the free market system or do you
  416. 14:27want the communist system? A lot of
  417. 14:29people made the claim that the
  418. 14:31capitalist system would do things like
  419. 14:34jeopardize safety and beauty, that our
  420. 14:37buildings would always be uglier because
  421. 14:39the greedy capitalist wouldn't want to
  422. 14:40spend a dime on beautifification or good
  423. 14:43architecture, things like that. In fact,
  424. 14:45it turned out that the Soviet system was
  425. 14:48the one that produced the cold gray
  426. 14:50landscapes. Why? Because people want
  427. 14:53beauty. They want safety. And therefore,
  428. 14:55if you have a well functioning market
  429. 14:56economy, then it gives people what they
  430. 14:59want. And obviously, the American system
  431. 15:01won out in that battle. So, I just
  432. 15:05fundamentally disagree with the idea
  433. 15:07that competition means lack of safety.
  434. 15:12As Zuckerberg and Jensen were saying,
  435. 15:15there are huge incentives on both the
  436. 15:17upside and downside to be safe. On the
  437. 15:20upside, no customer wants a product that
  438. 15:23is unpredictable and unreliable, that
  439. 15:25doesn't do what they say. No enterprise
  440. 15:28wants an agent that's going to leak
  441. 15:30their data or hack a competitor. And on
  442. 15:32the downside, as the president made
  443. 15:33clear, they've got tons of liability,
  444. 15:36product liability, civil liability,
  445. 15:37administrative liability, criminal
  446. 15:40liability. So, I just firmly disagree
  447. 15:42with this idea that competition is a bad
  448. 15:44thing. Competition is a good thing that
  449. 15:46can be harnessed to get the right
  450. 15:47result. And just to build on that,
  451. 15:49Shimoth our uh friend Nash from PaloAlto
  452. 15:53Networks, friend of the pod, he released
  453. 15:56in the past week or so unit 42. He's
  454. 15:58building there's a business opportunity
  455. 16:00here to build a product to do continuous
  456. 16:04cyber defense and also a friend of the
  457. 16:07George Kirch from um Crowdstrike. He
  458. 16:10also released Falcon, his new product to
  459. 16:13do cyber defense. Chimath, if these guys
  460. 16:16in the Frontier Labscorporations were so
  461. 16:19concerned
  462. 16:20about cyber security, why didn't they
  463. 16:22ever release a cyber security product
  464. 16:24and PaloAlto Networks and Crowd Strike
  465. 16:27are on it like they will?
  466. 16:30That's probably more in the second topic
  467. 16:32that we'll talk about, which is as the
  468. 16:34models essentially cluster in terms of
  469. 16:37capability, there's no differentiation,
  470. 16:39and so they'll be forced to move up the
  471. 16:40stack. But let's let's wait on that for
  472. 16:42one second. You have a point here you
  473. 16:44want to make and then we'll go to the
  474. 16:45first.
  475. 16:45>> I do. The point I wanted to make is more
  476. 16:48philosophical and sociological which is
  477. 16:53the last time we heard the word lab in
  478. 16:56the social consciousness was during co
  479. 16:59and there was a lab that was responsible
  480. 17:03for a leak of a virus that then killed
  481. 17:0715 million people all around the world
  482. 17:08and caused $45 trillion of damage. It's
  483. 17:12the Wuhan lab.
  484. 17:15And I think it's important to recognize
  485. 17:17that there has been zero transparency or
  486. 17:19culpability around this. And I think
  487. 17:22part of why people are comfortable
  488. 17:23calling themselves a lab is because of
  489. 17:25that fact. That a lot of these young
  490. 17:28people that work at these places live
  491. 17:29through this and saw absolutely no um
  492. 17:33responsibility taken by the lab that
  493. 17:37caused this leak. And now we're talking
  494. 17:39about leaks of different kinds. And we
  495. 17:41have organizations and corporations that
  496. 17:43try to fashion themselves as labs as
  497. 17:45well, but they're not labs. These are
  498. 17:47corporations. I just want to remind
  499. 17:48everybody, these are forprofit
  500. 17:50corporations that have absorbed hundreds
  501. 17:53of billions of dollars of debt in
  502. 17:55equity,
  503. 17:56>> that have thousands and thousands of
  504. 17:58shareholders, that have trillions of
  505. 18:00dollars of market cap. And if I were
  506. 18:03them, I would not want to call myself a
  507. 18:06lab at any cost. And I think if you saw
  508. 18:09the recent speeches that they gave at
  509. 18:12the United Nations, they're still using
  510. 18:14that terminology.
  511. 18:16>> Yeah.
  512. 18:16>> They are not labs. These are for-profit
  513. 18:18corporations that are subject to product
  514. 18:20liability risk and they should act
  515. 18:21accordingly.
  516. 18:22>> Yeah. I mean, and we've had a
  517. 18:23conversation here for a year about this.
  518. 18:25Like if this stuff is so dangerous, you
  519. 18:28don't have to release it or you know my
  520. 18:29proposal like know your customer, give
  521. 18:31logs.
  522. 18:31>> Do not compare yourself to the Wuhan
  523. 18:35lab. It's well, Shimoth, it's bad PR,
  524. 18:37but also I do I do think it's part of
  525. 18:39their like virtue signaling routine
  526. 18:41where they just don't want to say that
  527. 18:44we're companies. We have a for-profit
  528. 18:45incentive. They always want to say that
  529. 18:47we're either a research institution or
  530. 18:49they say things like we're a public
  531. 18:51benefit corporation, which no one really
  532. 18:53knows what the hell that means. So, it's
  533. 18:54this patina virtue signaling that
  534. 18:56obscures what's really going on.
  535. 18:59>> It tries to obscure the word
  536. 19:00corporation, but legally you're not
  537. 19:01allowed to hide it. I think they should
  538. 19:03have uh when they
  539. 19:04>> we are all running corporations all in
  540. 19:07all be it very all be it very small but
  541. 19:10mighty is a corporation I think we
  542. 19:12should call
  543. 19:12>> is a all in lab
  544. 19:14>> this is the all-in lab where we discuss
  545. 19:16different formulas
  546. 19:18>> no we're experimenting with ideas this
  547. 19:20is a this is a meme workshop
  548. 19:22>> lab these ideas are getting so dangerous
  549. 19:25that we don't want any liability for our
  550. 19:27[laughter] opinions welcome to the allin
  551. 19:30lab podcast
  552. 19:31>> here we Topic zero freeberg. Is there a
  553. 19:34mindset in scientists minds that you
  554. 19:38know needs to kind of have a hard stop
  555. 19:40and then the corporation kind of takes
  556. 19:42over? Maybe they could put the labs on
  557. 19:44the side here and then say, "Hey, these
  558. 19:45are the adults doing the corporation
  559. 19:47stuff." What are your thoughts here if
  560. 19:48you were going to architect how
  561. 19:51anthropic operates in the world? And and
  562. 19:53maybe you could speak to scientists
  563. 19:55views of the world versus capitalists
  564. 19:57and and management teams.
  565. 19:59>> I don't have a good answer for you on
  566. 20:01that.
  567. 20:01>> Okay. Well, you're doing it. You're the
  568. 20:02answer. Look at Oh,
  569. 20:03>> let me kick off the first topic. What I
  570. 20:05wanted to do was just take a step back
  571. 20:07and look at the insane flurry of model
  572. 20:11releases happening.
  573. 20:12>> Yes.
  574. 20:12>> I think the pace of model releases
  575. 20:14happening on both the open-source side
  576. 20:17and the premium side, the anthropics,
  577. 20:20gro
  578. 20:21of the world is unfathomable right now.
  579. 20:24The list is insane. And just like the
  580. 20:26last 10 days, September 9th, Deepseek
  581. 20:294.1 Flash gets released.
  582. 20:3220 for a million tokens output if
  583. 20:34they're hosting it. Key Value Cash from
  584. 20:37V1 of DeepS, remember what a big deal
  585. 20:38DeepS was when it came out. The key
  586. 20:40value cache then was like 390,000 bytes.
  587. 20:43Now it's 890.
  588. 20:45Insane drop, insane efficiency
  589. 20:47improvements. On September 20th, Quen,
  590. 20:52which is the Alibaba model, comes out
  591. 20:54version, you know, 2.1. It's an open
  592. 20:57weights model that outperforms Nano
  593. 21:00Banana 2, which is Google's big
  594. 21:02breakthrough, insane image generation
  595. 21:04model. This thing is free, open- source.
  596. 21:07You can put it on your desktop computer
  597. 21:09and run it at home to generate images
  598. 21:12for free. And it's made by Alibaba.
  599. 21:15Xiaomé put out MIMO on September 22nd,
  600. 21:18two days ago. Mimo Pro performs on par
  601. 21:22with CLA's Opus 5, which is like this
  602. 21:24insane model that everyone thought was
  603. 21:26going to change the world and break the
  604. 21:27internet and GPT56 Soul across most
  605. 21:30benchmarks. It's a 309 billion parameter
  606. 21:32model. It is entirely open. You can
  607. 21:36download this model and put it on your
  608. 21:38server and run your own instance without
  609. 21:41paying anyone any money except for the
  610. 21:43cost of running the server. This model
  611. 21:44called uh Bonsai 2 came out on September
  612. 21:4717th by Prism ML. This is actually a
  613. 21:50fork of Quen, which is another one of
  614. 21:52the Alibaba models. It's a 27 billion
  615. 21:54parameter model. 98% of the performance
  616. 21:57of the big Quen model. It's 5.9 gigs in
  617. 22:02size and you can run it on a local
  618. 22:04computer. You can have an Nvidia chip or
  619. 22:07have a good Mac Studio computer and you
  620. 22:09can run this insane model on your
  621. 22:12desktop computer for free. And then the
  622. 22:15big crazy models, the big closed source
  623. 22:17models, Anthropic releases Opus 55 on
  624. 22:19September 22nd. Open AAI Astro comes out
  625. 22:22with Soul and Luna on September 23rd.
  626. 22:25Gro 47 comes out on September 21. Meta
  627. 22:28Muse comes out on September 22nd.
  628. 22:31Any one of these stories would have
  629. 22:33broken the internet a year ago and they
  630. 22:36all happened in the last 10 days. You
  631. 22:38now have an entire catalog of openweight
  632. 22:41models to generate visual information to
  633. 22:43do VLA where you can actually instruct
  634. 22:45it and it can control a robot. You have
  635. 22:48models far beyond the most advanced LLM
  636. 22:50from a year ago that are openweight that
  637. 22:52you can install and run on your desktop
  638. 22:53computer. We are past the point of
  639. 22:56Bernie Sanders put the super
  640. 22:58intelligence away. It can never be
  641. 22:59allowed in the real world. This stuff is
  642. 23:01out. The open- source openweight models
  643. 23:04are free. They are on the internet. You
  644. 23:06can go and download them and you can run
  645. 23:08them on your computer at home. I don't
  646. 23:10know in what world we think we're going
  647. 23:11to have a police state that's going to
  648. 23:13come bang down your door, take your
  649. 23:15desktop computer from you and test it to
  650. 23:18see if you're running an LLM on your
  651. 23:19local computer. The efficiency wave is
  652. 23:22here. And the pacing at which these
  653. 23:24models are coming out now. All of this
  654. 23:26stuff happened in the last 10 days. It's
  655. 23:28just mind-blowing. We're now in this
  656. 23:30kind of frontier space where things are
  657. 23:33accelerating. The performance
  658. 23:35improvements, the cost decline, AI is
  659. 23:38becoming so performative and so
  660. 23:40affordable. It is going to be ubiquitous
  661. 23:42and we are all going to benefit from it.
  662. 23:44This is not just about the anthropic and
  663. 23:45open AI with the closed world making
  664. 23:48billions of dollars selling enterprises
  665. 23:50hosted models. There is so much
  666. 23:52proliferation right now. So I just
  667. 23:54thought it was worth taking a step back
  668. 23:56to recognize where we are because in the
  669. 23:57context of we have to stop the super
  670. 23:59intelligence. We have to shut down the
  671. 24:01data centers. You don't even need data
  672. 24:03centers to do 90% of what you can do
  673. 24:04with AI. You can download it on your
  674. 24:06computer for free today to do what was
  675. 24:09the most advanced technology in human
  676. 24:11history less than a year ago. It's all
  677. 24:13here today. And I thought it was just
  678. 24:15worth taking a beat to step back and
  679. 24:16make sure we all recognize that as we
  680. 24:18get into this debate about these quote
  681. 24:20labs or corporations. I don't know if it
  682. 24:21even matters anymore. I think open
  683. 24:24source is here and I think that the pace
  684. 24:25of improvement is such that this is only
  685. 24:28going to drive productivity. Yeah.
  686. 24:30>> And maybe we are maybe we are seeing the
  687. 24:33AI wave underway right now. The
  688. 24:34productivity wave, the productivity
  689. 24:36boom.
  690. 24:36>> Yeah. And and to consumers, they don't
  691. 24:39care what model they're using. We've
  692. 24:40spent the last three years geeking out
  693. 24:42about this. And then Grockbot comes out
  694. 24:45and then Muse comes out from Meta. And
  695. 24:47I've been using both of these products.
  696. 24:48And it's the first time that a normie, a
  697. 24:51normal person in the world, it's not
  698. 24:53meant to be derogatory in any way, can
  699. 24:55get value from AI. If you look at how we
  700. 24:58all looked at this, running
  701. 25:00corporations, investing in them, we took
  702. 25:02a different approach to like, okay,
  703. 25:03maybe this is going to retire, you know,
  704. 25:06some positions, maybe this is um going
  705. 25:08to add some positions here or there, but
  706. 25:10now you can like with Muse connect to
  707. 25:13everything instantly and actually get
  708. 25:16real work done in the world if you're a
  709. 25:17normal person who wants to get the
  710. 25:19benefit from AI. We will be turning a
  711. 25:22corner, Freedber, and I think you laid
  712. 25:23it out perfectly. We're going to turn a
  713. 25:25corner, I think, at the end of this
  714. 25:26year, where moms, our uncles, people are
  715. 25:30going to start using Muse and Bot,
  716. 25:32Grockbot, which are growing very quickly
  717. 25:35to just solve real world problems for
  718. 25:36that. And they're going to go, "Wait a
  719. 25:37second. I could never afford a chief of
  720. 25:39a staff. I could never afford a personal
  721. 25:41assistant, an executive assistant. Now I
  722. 25:44get a free executive assistant." It's
  723. 25:45going to blow people's minds, Shimoth,
  724. 25:47in the next couple of months when they
  725. 25:49start using these products. and the
  726. 25:52bottom half of America in this K-shaped
  727. 25:55recovery experiences some benefits. Your
  728. 25:58thoughts on what's happening here with
  729. 26:00these models? Have you started playing
  730. 26:02with it? Because you were, you know,
  731. 26:03originally a technologist. Have you
  732. 26:05loaded these models on your computer?
  733. 26:07Because I'm playing with it on my
  734. 26:08MacBook Pro and it's awesome.
  735. 26:10>> Let me maybe give you the answer by
  736. 26:12explaining something. So
  737. 26:15I think what we're seeing is that these
  738. 26:16models are converging and clustering
  739. 26:19which is to say that they're now within
  740. 26:21margin of error. And so the thing is
  741. 26:24there's so many of these models that are
  742. 26:26roughly the same at different price
  743. 26:27points. So where is the edge? There's
  744. 26:30still edge and the edge is in the
  745. 26:33harness that you use to wrap the model.
  746. 26:35So if you think about it as like you
  747. 26:38have a model that's like a brain but you
  748. 26:41need to embody that brain with arms and
  749. 26:43legs and hands and eyes to do work.
  750. 26:45That's how you identify a model. Okay.
  751. 26:47And you make it aic that's what that
  752. 26:49phrase means. And there are all kinds of
  753. 26:51different harnesses that the industry
  754. 26:52has invented to make these models more
  755. 26:55agentic. And there's still a lot of edge
  756. 26:57there. So at 8090 we have a labs
  757. 27:00function and we've been ripping and
  758. 27:02teasing apart all the different models
  759. 27:04with all the different harnesses just to
  760. 27:05see how they perform and they are wildly
  761. 27:08variant in terms of cost and quality. So
  762. 27:12just to kind of build on Freebrook's
  763. 27:13point you have the models that are
  764. 27:14converging the harnesses are wildly
  765. 27:17different and so their performance is
  766. 27:19all over the map and so now companies
  767. 27:22and people have to sort of navigate what
  768. 27:24are you willing to pay for. I sent this
  769. 27:26tweet to Nick, if you can just put it up
  770. 27:28here, and I don't know if this is
  771. 27:30instructive or accurate, but what this
  772. 27:32shows, and this is the case for Ant, but
  773. 27:34it's probably the case for a lot of the
  774. 27:35closed models, is you're starting to see
  775. 27:38this massive revenue concentration,
  776. 27:40which is a few folks consume all of the
  777. 27:42highest and most expensive tokens. And I
  778. 27:46think if you take what Freeberg just
  779. 27:48showed to its logical conclusion, those
  780. 27:50folks at the top of this
  781. 27:53table are going to be under a lot of
  782. 27:57internal pressure whether it's from
  783. 27:59their finance teams or whether it's from
  784. 28:01their CFO or it's going to be from
  785. 28:03shareholders to explain
  786. 28:06why as this clustering happens they are
  787. 28:10not moving down to cheaper and cheaper
  788. 28:12models. Now, you may choose to go down
  789. 28:15to cheaper and cheaper Ant models, so
  790. 28:16then Ant keeps the revenue, but there's
  791. 28:19also risk that you may do what Freeberg
  792. 28:21just said and just go to an open source
  793. 28:22model and just host it yourself.
  794. 28:25So, we're in like a very complicated
  795. 28:29part of the cycle, which is the first
  796. 28:32version of the AI trade was relatively
  797. 28:34simple, which is you're just selling
  798. 28:35tokens, you're wrapping the tokens,
  799. 28:37you're passing it through, and there was
  800. 28:39enough disparity that there was value. I
  801. 28:42think that that's going away. It'll
  802. 28:44force OpenAI and Ant to go up the stack.
  803. 28:46There is no choice. You can't sit there
  804. 28:49and serve a token that has diminishing
  805. 28:51value because then all the subsequent
  806. 28:54value is getting absorbed and made by
  807. 28:57people wrapping your intelligence token.
  808. 28:59You will have to do that work. And so,
  809. 29:02Jason, that's why they will have to go
  810. 29:03and do cyber. They'll have to go and do
  811. 29:05law. They'll have to go and do customer
  812. 29:07support. all these things that we
  813. 29:09weren't sure whether they were going to
  814. 29:10compete. These trends may force them to
  815. 29:13do that.
  816. 29:14>> Yeah.
  817. 29:14>> And I think then that sets up a very
  818. 29:17interesting setup for their IPO. Just to
  819. 29:20back all that up, Saxs,
  820. 29:22>> the Frontier Lab Corporations, Anthropic
  821. 29:26and OpenAI, they both released models
  822. 29:28this week at 50%
  823. 29:30less token prices.
  824. 29:33and their IPOs are looking like they're
  825. 29:36both going to get delayed. Anthropic
  826. 29:39just targeting a $2 trillion valuation
  827. 29:41open 1.2 trillion. Sam already said
  828. 29:43OpenAI plans on doing 2027
  829. 29:46over because of safety concerns and
  830. 29:49Anthropic which was supposed to file and
  831. 29:52go out in October. The report from the
  832. 29:55Wall Street Journal is that the IPO will
  833. 29:58happen in November or may be delayed
  834. 30:01even more. Here's your poly market. Will
  835. 30:03Anthropic go public in 2026 with our
  836. 30:07amazing partner Poly Market? Shout out
  837. 30:09to my guy Shane. Peaked at 96% earlier
  838. 30:13this month that Enthropic would go
  839. 30:15public this year, but now it's fallen to
  840. 30:1776%.
  841. 30:19Is this like a cell phone here, Sachs?
  842. 30:21The the leading model companies need to
  843. 30:23go public to get capital to do their
  844. 30:25buildout and now they're delaying their
  845. 30:27own IPOs. Please explain how any of this
  846. 30:29makes sense. And if you were a major
  847. 30:32investor in one of these companies or on
  848. 30:34the board of them, what would you be
  849. 30:36doing or instructing these founders to
  850. 30:38do to get these companies to go public
  851. 30:41and get that capital they need to
  852. 30:42continue the AI buildout?
  853. 30:44>> Oh, well, I I think that we know from
  854. 30:47our friends that the investors in
  855. 30:49Anthropic are pulling out their hair
  856. 30:50about what's happening right now. Forget
  857. 30:52about the fake whistleblowers who were
  858. 30:54there for like a few weeks and then
  859. 30:55left. You have current leadership in the
  860. 30:58company saying that there's a greater
  861. 31:01than 10% chance of causing human
  862. 31:03extinction and their own product is
  863. 31:06unsolved in this area. So think about
  864. 31:09the risk factors that's creating. How do
  865. 31:11you IPO with your own management of the
  866. 31:14company saying that? Then you've got I
  867. 31:16think other evidence of I don't know
  868. 31:18what to call it except corporate
  869. 31:20schizophrenia. You've got Daario putting
  870. 31:23out this essay saying we need to pace
  871. 31:25the frontier days before they launch
  872. 31:28Claude 5.5 and set a new frontier. I
  873. 31:31mean, he must know when he's writing
  874. 31:34this essay that they're about to release
  875. 31:36a product that will extend the frontier.
  876. 31:38So, at a minimum, it's hypocritical, but
  877. 31:40maybe it's even worse than that. Then
  878. 31:42you have them publishing an essay about
  879. 31:44the biorisk associated with AI and how
  880. 31:47that needs to be stopped. And then
  881. 31:48meanwhile, they announced a new biolab
  882. 31:51in San Francisco, a new wet lab.
  883. 31:54>> They started a lab after telling us that
  884. 31:57there's a 10% chance of us all dying.
  885. 32:00Sachs, let's just pause here for a
  886. 32:02second. Is this a dereliction of duty as
  887. 32:06the chief executive officer of Anthropic
  888. 32:10to sabotage your own IPO? You're
  889. 32:12supposed to be acting on behalf of your
  890. 32:14CEO of your shareholders. This to me
  891. 32:17seems like if we were the board, if the
  892. 32:20four of us were somehow magically the
  893. 32:21board of Anthropic, we would replace the
  894. 32:23CEO. We would put the CEO in the lab and
  895. 32:26we'd find a CEO who knows how to run the
  896. 32:29company and not
  897. 32:30>> sabotage it. He's literally sabotaging
  898. 32:33his own company.
  899. 32:35>> I think there's an element of that and I
  900. 32:37think investors are pretty nervous about
  901. 32:38giving the founders or or Daria
  902. 32:40specifically super voting shares.
  903. 32:42There's a story in the information about
  904. 32:43that that there's an active debate right
  905. 32:46now about whether to give them super
  906. 32:47voting share.
  907. 32:47>> Explain what those are, please, and and
  908. 32:49why in this context this is critically
  909. 32:51important. Our audience may or may not
  910. 32:52know what those are.
  911. 32:53>> Supposedly, the founders of Anthropic
  912. 32:56only have about 2% ownership each of the
  913. 32:59company, which in the grand scheme of
  914. 33:00things is a relatively low number
  915. 33:03relative to what other founders
  916. 33:04typically have at time of IPO. It'll
  917. 33:06still be an enormous amount of money,
  918. 33:08you know, tens of billions of dollars,
  919. 33:10but that is the case. Super voting
  920. 33:11shares basically say it separates the
  921. 33:14economic shares from the voting shares
  922. 33:17in the company and gives certain people
  923. 33:18the right to control the company even if
  924. 33:21they don't have the economic ownership
  925. 33:23that would usually be necessary. It's a
  926. 33:25pretty common thing. I mean, Larry and
  927. 33:27Sergey, I think maybe were the first
  928. 33:28prominent founders to get super voting
  929. 33:31shares in Google and Zuck. It can be a
  930. 33:33stabilizing thing for the company
  931. 33:35because it means that as long as the
  932. 33:37founders are there overseeing things,
  933. 33:39they're not going to be
  934. 33:41>> subject to, you know, like takeover
  935. 33:43attempts, things like that. But on the
  936. 33:45other hand, it requires a tremendous
  937. 33:47degree of trust in those founders
  938. 33:49because they effectively can't be
  939. 33:50removed no matter what they do. And you
  940. 33:53just have to wonder if in this case
  941. 33:56that's earned and warranted. I have to
  942. 33:58say that even for someone like me who
  943. 34:01isn't necessarily advocating for a lot
  944. 34:03more regulation, I kind of get nervous
  945. 34:04about the idea of anthropic opening a
  946. 34:06wet lab in San Francisco. I mean, I was
  947. 34:09>> great timing.
  948. 34:10>> I was thinking about moving back and I
  949. 34:11don't know if I want to be I mean like
  950. 34:14can you just put it a little further
  951. 34:15away? I think we've all seen this movie
  952. 34:16before.
  953. 34:17>> Yeah. Offshore maybe. I don't know.
  954. 34:18[laughter] Put it on an oil rig or
  955. 34:20something. What I would say is that if I
  956. 34:23were on the board, I would keep Daario
  957. 34:24as a CEO. And the reason is that he's
  958. 34:27clearly demonstrated that he can build a
  959. 34:29unique culture and position against the
  960. 34:32otherwise most formidable corporation
  961. 34:35competitor, which is OpenAI. And he's
  962. 34:37done that and he's come from behind. And
  963. 34:39I don't think you should
  964. 34:41undervalue how hard that is and what
  965. 34:44that takes. So he's done that and he's
  966. 34:45built he's built essentially the
  967. 34:47greatest business ramp in all time. I
  968. 34:50think the thing that I would probably do
  969. 34:52if I was on the board is fix what Sax
  970. 34:55just said, which is there's now a bunch
  971. 34:58of incremental liquidity risk to the
  972. 35:00company. And I think if you take the
  973. 35:0320-year view on anthropic, that
  974. 35:06corporation needs hundreds of billions
  975. 35:09of dollars to fulfill their ambitions.
  976. 35:11And I would solve for getting that as
  977. 35:13risklessly as possible. And I think
  978. 35:15there's only two things that you can do.
  979. 35:17The first is you have to throw
  980. 35:19everything in and the kitchen sink into
  981. 35:21disclosures.
  982. 35:23The problem is that that will make what
  983. 35:24is an otherwise dense and impenetrable
  984. 35:27S1 even more dense and impenetrable.
  985. 35:29Okay? So, you can kind of like
  986. 35:31superficially cover your regulatory
  987. 35:33risk. But the way that it actually gets
  988. 35:36translated in the market is you're just
  989. 35:38going to have to water down the
  990. 35:39expectations of the IPO sellers and
  991. 35:44create a much larger margin of safety
  992. 35:46for the IPO buyer. And that's
  993. 35:49effectively how you find a market
  994. 35:50clearing price for this, Jason, which is
  995. 35:52to essentially say, and don't bear with
  996. 35:54me, I'm just giving out rough numbers,
  997. 35:55right? Even if you think that they're on
  998. 35:57a hundred billion run rate, what would
  999. 36:00otherwise in a very clean sheet IPO may
  1000. 36:02be would have been a $2 trillion market
  1001. 36:04cap, now you know, you're at one or
  1002. 36:07less. And the reason is the hedge funds
  1003. 36:12and the pension systems and the long
  1004. 36:16only mutual fund complexes who have a
  1005. 36:20fiduciary responsibility to their
  1006. 36:22sources of capital
  1007. 36:25will justify all the risks by
  1008. 36:27essentially asking for a lower and lower
  1009. 36:29price. And I think that's what you're
  1010. 36:31going to see. I think you're going to
  1011. 36:32see a much more moderate and reasonable
  1012. 36:36IPO motion here.
  1013. 36:39And it's probably going to clear at a
  1014. 36:41much lower price than anybody thinks.
  1015. 36:43And I do think that what Sach says is
  1016. 36:45the reason why. But I think it's good
  1017. 36:46for Ant because it clears all this
  1018. 36:48noise. It forces them to just be a
  1019. 36:51corporation and then run the business.
  1020. 36:53And I think that they'll do great. Look,
  1021. 36:54I'll be honest with you. Like I've tried
  1022. 36:56to recruit against Ant. I can't. It's
  1023. 36:59impossible. The comp that they give is
  1024. 37:01incredible. The business ramp is so
  1025. 37:03compelling. It's like when you're in a
  1026. 37:05head
  1027. 37:05>> when you're in a head-to-head with these
  1028. 37:07guys. I have not won a single bake off
  1029. 37:09for folks. I wish I could say that I
  1030. 37:11did, but I have not. And it's hard for a
  1031. 37:13startup. So, they are a magnet for
  1032. 37:16talent. OpenAI is a magnet for talent.
  1033. 37:19But these other risks are going to weigh
  1034. 37:21on the IPO and the only way to flush
  1035. 37:23them is to just bring the price way
  1036. 37:25down.
  1037. 37:25>> Yeah. And Freeberg, when we look at the
  1038. 37:27risk factors in an S1, those are
  1039. 37:29prefuncter. Those are disclaimers.
  1040. 37:32Typically, you get the SpaceX one. Oh,
  1041. 37:34what if Starship doesn't work? What if
  1042. 37:36there's competition, it's kind of check
  1043. 37:39boxes in anthropics, I think we're going
  1044. 37:41to be looking at something totally
  1045. 37:43different, which is, hey, we and our
  1046. 37:46employees are quitting saying this is
  1047. 37:49going to kill humanity. We have massive
  1048. 37:50regulation. We're asking for regulation.
  1049. 37:53And by the way, we we're doing biology
  1050. 37:55work and we're launching a lab. So do
  1051. 37:57you agree with Chimath here that the S1
  1052. 37:59is going to have an actual risk factors
  1053. 38:03and disclaimers that are material
  1054. 38:06against the IPO free burn? I think this
  1055. 38:10customer concentration point ties to the
  1056. 38:13earlier comments I made about the
  1057. 38:16proliferation of incredibly performant
  1058. 38:18openweight and open source models. And
  1059. 38:20the reason is Anthropic puts out the
  1060. 38:23best models for life sciences today.
  1061. 38:28I run a life sciences R&D organization.
  1062. 38:31We use their models. They're incredible.
  1063. 38:34They're better than other models. And so
  1064. 38:36we want to use them. When it comes to
  1065. 38:38writing code, to writing software to do
  1066. 38:42internal workflows and run operations,
  1067. 38:45we can use other products to write that
  1068. 38:47code for us. And we do. And I think that
  1069. 38:50that's likely the way the market is
  1070. 38:51going to develop. And I think we're
  1071. 38:53starting to see that proof come out in
  1072. 38:55the market. And you're seeing it in this
  1073. 38:56customer concentration point. Extremely
  1074. 38:59high value technical engineering, math,
  1075. 39:03life sciences, those really hard
  1076. 39:06technical problems. You want to have
  1077. 39:08these top tier, topshelf models, and
  1078. 39:11you're going to pay a huge premium for
  1079. 39:12them. And you're totally going to make
  1080. 39:14money doing it because the value is
  1081. 39:16extraordinary. And this has always been
  1082. 39:17my case about AI. AI is not so much
  1083. 39:20about the value of replacing old stuff.
  1084. 39:2399% of the value of AI is about enabling
  1085. 39:25new stuff that's never been possible in
  1086. 39:27human history. And I think that's where
  1087. 39:29anthropic and open AI are going to make
  1088. 39:31their money. Separately, I think open AI
  1089. 39:33is going to make a lot of money in
  1090. 39:34consumer and anthropic maybe to some
  1091. 39:37extent as well. But in the enterprise
  1092. 39:38setting, I think the money comes from
  1093. 39:40creating new frontiers, discovering new
  1094. 39:43enzymes, which Anthropic announced this
  1095. 39:45week, that can cure human disease, and
  1096. 39:48developing new technology, new
  1097. 39:51engineering systems, making things that
  1098. 39:53have never been possible to be made
  1099. 39:54before. And I think that's the premium
  1100. 39:56value, and it's the premium price you'll
  1101. 39:59pay for those closed models and that
  1102. 40:01premium model. But that's a different
  1103. 40:03business case than taking all of
  1104. 40:05enterprise. separately. I think most of
  1105. 40:07the enterprise applications are going to
  1106. 40:09be run using these openweight models and
  1107. 40:12code is going to be written with cheaper
  1108. 40:13models and so on. I don't know why you
  1109. 40:15would go to a higherend model to write
  1110. 40:18code when you can do it for free and
  1111. 40:20everyone in the organization can write
  1112. 40:21code basically for free. And so I think
  1113. 40:24anthropic's bigger issue is this
  1114. 40:26customer concentration question and is
  1115. 40:28it really a premium product that they're
  1116. 40:30selling in the market and that's where
  1117. 40:31they take the market. That would be kind
  1118. 40:32of where I think the market is headed
  1119. 40:34right now and would be the biggest risk
  1120. 40:35factor. This whole thing about oh it's
  1121. 40:37gonna end the world and whatnot. It's
  1122. 40:38like dude just make sure your product
  1123. 40:40doesn't end the world and you'll be
  1124. 40:41fine. That would be a good first step
  1125. 40:43here like Mark is doing at Meta.
  1126. 40:46>> I mean it's an incredible company. The
  1127. 40:48execution has been extraordinary. The
  1128. 40:50ramp of revenue sachs has been
  1129. 40:51extraordinary. But when you start to
  1130. 40:54look at the impact of open source, we
  1131. 40:56had a a couple of um viral charts come
  1132. 41:00out, 70 80% of the token usage are those
  1133. 41:03dark tokens I mentioned six months ago
  1134. 41:06here on this pod that are not tracked,
  1135. 41:08but some people can track them on
  1136. 41:09routers. Those dark open source tokens
  1137. 41:12are now the majority of tokens. And
  1138. 41:15>> can I just give you a stat on that, Jal?
  1139. 41:16cuz what you just said is really
  1140. 41:18important, but there's a stat that I
  1141. 41:19think in in the last 12 weeks alone
  1142. 41:23>> token use has flipped from 8020 closed
  1143. 41:27verse open
  1144. 41:28>> to 8020 open verse closed.
  1145. 41:31>> I don't think we've ever seen in 12
  1146. 41:33weeks I don't think we've ever seen a
  1147. 41:34title wave of chart
  1148. 41:38>> in the history of all technology
  1149. 41:40markets. We've never seen anything like
  1150. 41:41this. And that is the biggest risk
  1151. 41:43factor for Anthropic is they were first
  1152. 41:45out the gate to get the enterprise on uh
  1153. 41:48on AI to build tools and whatnot. But as
  1154. 41:51this market shifts to open source and
  1155. 41:52open weights, boom, here it is right
  1156. 41:55here. Look at this.
  1157. 41:55>> This is the Versel chart that went viral
  1158. 41:57this week. So this week 12 weeks, oh my
  1159. 42:00god,
  1160. 42:00>> crazy. If you look at this chart, this I
  1161. 42:02think is what blows the lid off the door
  1162. 42:05on what needs to go into these S1s. And
  1163. 42:08that's why I walked through all those
  1164. 42:10openweight releases at the start of the
  1165. 42:11show or this segment is it's not just
  1166. 42:14that they're there, it's that they're
  1167. 42:15proliferating now. There's so many more
  1168. 42:17of them coming out and the pace of
  1169. 42:19improvement is extraordinary and they're
  1170. 42:20now in VLA for robotics. They're in
  1171. 42:24image generation for image and video. So
  1172. 42:26the openweight open source models are
  1173. 42:28now being used for all of the broader AI
  1174. 42:31applications. The premium stuff I will
  1175. 42:33say is still the best for narrow use
  1176. 42:36cases. Yes,
  1177. 42:38>> for engineering, for highly technical,
  1178. 42:40highly complicated tasks and workflows
  1179. 42:42and problems, solving Navier Stokes,
  1180. 42:45solving mathematical problems, solving
  1181. 42:46biology problems, that's where these
  1182. 42:48models absolutely perform and people
  1183. 42:51will pay a premium of, I would say,
  1184. 42:53close to infinity dollars for that
  1185. 42:55premium application set. So, it doesn't
  1186. 42:57mean that their market is destroyed.
  1187. 42:59Yeah,
  1188. 42:59>> it means that we're seeing a bifurcation
  1189. 43:01in the market where the majority of use
  1190. 43:03cases of AI go towards these open source
  1191. 43:06open tokens.
  1192. 43:07>> The question and premium models are
  1193. 43:09still going to proliferate. Yeah.
  1194. 43:11>> The question then is in the distribution
  1195. 43:13of tokens in these frontier
  1196. 43:15corporations, what percentage are those
  1197. 43:18tasks versus what percentage are
  1198. 43:21fungeable tasks to open source? And if
  1199. 43:23the answer is more than 60 or 70%.
  1200. 43:26You have to discount that revenue. If
  1201. 43:28the answer is only 10% and 90% of all of
  1202. 43:31the revenue is being generated on
  1203. 43:32absolute frontier use cases, they're
  1204. 43:36going to be fine and they're going to be
  1205. 43:37off to the races.
  1206. 43:38>> Yeah. And
  1207. 43:39>> but otherwise, it's a thing where you're
  1208. 43:41fighting just people's mis or lack of
  1209. 43:44education, right? Because as they see
  1210. 43:46their bills,
  1211. 43:47>> hand it to Sax here. Yeah. Go finish
  1212. 43:48your thought and then I'm going to hand
  1213. 43:49it to Sax.
  1214. 43:50>> No, just move the move the workloads
  1215. 43:51where they belong and save the money.
  1216. 43:54>> Yeah. And so Saxs, um I made a chart
  1217. 43:56here before the show here, but here's
  1218. 43:57your um sweet spot for the last 100 days
  1219. 44:01of models, which um Friber, you did a
  1220. 44:03good job of teeing up. And what you'll
  1221. 44:05see is like yes, the Clouds and the
  1222. 44:07Astros up in that righth hand corner
  1223. 44:09cost a lot and they deliver a lot. But
  1224. 44:11then you start going down and you start
  1225. 44:12to see Muse and GLM and Kimmy and then
  1226. 44:16on the left you start seeing GLM from ZI
  1227. 44:19and Mimo and you're starting to see well
  1228. 44:20the Chinese
  1229. 44:21>> this is all hosted right JL. I mean,
  1230. 44:23it's important to note what you're
  1231. 44:25showing here is the hosted price, but if
  1232. 44:27you run it yourself, the cost on some of
  1233. 44:29these is less than 10 cents for a
  1234. 44:31million tokens.
  1235. 44:32>> Yeah. So, you'll pick up then the
  1236. 44:33compute, you pick up the bandwidth, all
  1237. 44:35that other stuff. But, Sax, the issue
  1238. 44:37here to Chimat's point is the vertical
  1239. 44:40language models, the small language
  1240. 44:42models are going to do 80 or 90% of the
  1241. 44:45tasks that many corporations need. And
  1242. 44:47then we get to AI sovereignty. Do you
  1243. 44:49want your super intelligence? Shout out
  1244. 44:51President Trump. from intelligence chat
  1245. 44:54DJT.
  1246. 44:56We need people to use those models so
  1247. 44:59they have sovereignty. So you're not
  1248. 45:01giving your data to the frontier models
  1249. 45:03so that they don't get that tip of the
  1250. 45:05spear super intelligence edge which is
  1251. 45:08why people are disengaging. So your
  1252. 45:12thoughts on maybe this is going to start
  1253. 45:14to impact the velocity of clawed and
  1254. 45:17openi tokens. What does your business
  1255. 45:19sense tell you David Saxs? Well, look,
  1256. 45:22wearing my hat as an investor, I'm more
  1257. 45:25optimistic about the Frontier
  1258. 45:28Intelligence business than I think you
  1259. 45:30guys are. I think that Anthropic and
  1260. 45:32Open AI right now are a stable duopoly
  1261. 45:36for frontier intelligence because they
  1262. 45:38have a pretty significant lead over all
  1263. 45:40these other companies and they are able
  1264. 45:42to charge a premium for that. I fully
  1265. 45:44understand that the majority of tokens
  1266. 45:46will go to open models or commodity
  1267. 45:48intelligence. However, there is a I
  1268. 45:52don't know meaningful percentage of the
  1269. 45:53market. I don't know whether it's 10%,
  1270. 45:5420, 30, whatever that will pay this huge
  1271. 45:58premium for true frontier intelligence.
  1272. 46:01There's a lot of customers that either
  1273. 46:02need the best or they just want to know
  1274. 46:04they have the best. You know, they don't
  1275. 46:05want this DIY approach or they could be
  1276. 46:08in a very competitive market. Let's say
  1277. 46:10you're a hedge fund. You can't take the
  1278. 46:12risk that your competitor has a better
  1279. 46:14model than you do. So there's a lot of
  1280. 46:15circumstances I think where they will
  1281. 46:18continue to monetize the frontier at a
  1282. 46:20premium and this is why you're seeing
  1283. 46:21their revenue keep growing even though
  1284. 46:23they're losing token market share.
  1285. 46:26Furthermore, you got to remember that
  1286. 46:27over the next year or so something like
  1287. 46:3060% of the worldwide compute that's
  1288. 46:33being added is being added for these two
  1289. 46:36companies. So to the extent that compute
  1290. 46:38gets scarce and we're kind of in a
  1291. 46:41compute crunch, just the fact that
  1292. 46:42they've made these huge investments,
  1293. 46:44they're building out so much capacity
  1294. 46:46and they have those economies of scale
  1295. 46:48and remember they're bringing down their
  1296. 46:49own prices very quickly as well. I think
  1297. 46:53that gives them a pretty big advantage.
  1298. 46:54But look, these two companies are on a
  1299. 46:57hamster wheel. You know, the moment
  1300. 47:00where they stop being frontier, they go
  1301. 47:01to zero, right? And we know the frontier
  1302. 47:05is maybe only 6 to 12 months ahead of
  1303. 47:08the commodity portion of the market
  1304. 47:10depending on capability. So, you know,
  1305. 47:13again, if they slip, if they fall off
  1306. 47:15that hamster wheel for 6 months, then
  1307. 47:18they're in deep trouble as a company.
  1308. 47:19And that I think is a central risk
  1309. 47:20factor that's going to have to be priced
  1310. 47:22in. And this is where I think that
  1311. 47:24frankly their government affairs efforts
  1312. 47:26are miscalculating badly. I can see why
  1313. 47:29they they're going for regulatory
  1314. 47:31capture, right? because being on a
  1315. 47:32hamster wheel gets really tiring. They
  1316. 47:34probably think, hm, like, let's try and
  1317. 47:37bake in our moes. Let's try and slow
  1318. 47:39everyone else down as well. But I think
  1319. 47:41they've miscalculated because if they
  1320. 47:43actually get all the regulatory controls
  1321. 47:46they want, if they create this new
  1322. 47:47federal department of AI, it's going to
  1323. 47:49slow them down enough that they will no
  1324. 47:52longer be frontier. Everyone else will
  1325. 47:53catch up to them. Especially because a
  1326. 47:56lot of these open models are being
  1327. 47:57generated by Chinese companies who are
  1328. 47:59not subject to our jurisdiction. And the
  1329. 48:01Chinese have made abundantly clear they
  1330. 48:02are not slowing down. So think about it.
  1331. 48:04They are lobbying for things that could
  1332. 48:07slow them down and knock them off the
  1333. 48:09frontier in which case their business
  1334. 48:11goes to zero. I you know it's hard to
  1335. 48:13understand.
  1336. 48:14>> They're flapping the competitors in this
  1337. 48:16race and they're asking hey can you pull
  1338. 48:18us over and inspect the engine chimoth
  1339. 48:21and that makes no logical sense on top
  1340. 48:25of that chimoth. You have very
  1341. 48:28significant competition not just from
  1342. 48:30the Chinese but you have Jensen and
  1343. 48:32Nvidia. You have also Microsoft Satia
  1344. 48:36at Google and Muse at Zuckerberg's
  1345. 48:40house. They're all embracing
  1346. 48:43open- source models and they all have
  1347. 48:45hosting now.
  1348. 48:46>> Yeah. Can I [clears throat] just go back
  1349. 48:47to what Sax said which is a really
  1350. 48:50important and nuance point which I just
  1351. 48:52want to double click on. He said,
  1352. 48:54"Imagine you're a hedge fund and you
  1353. 48:57need the absolute latest and greatest
  1354. 49:00because you are worried that one of your
  1355. 49:01competitors has it." This is a really
  1356. 49:03interesting question because it's about
  1357. 49:06game theory and your P&L. So now you're
  1358. 49:09in this game of chicken with your
  1359. 49:10competitors. You need to use the best
  1360. 49:13because you're afraid that they could
  1361. 49:15use the best and out compete you. But
  1362. 49:17what is the problem right now? What we
  1363. 49:20know is that you can consume an
  1364. 49:23inordinate amount of tokens, right? We
  1365. 49:26jokingly call it token maxing.
  1366. 49:29That cost is completely not levered or
  1367. 49:32attached to your revenue. It's just not.
  1368. 49:36And so all of a sudden, you have this
  1369. 49:38very weird dynamic where you're like,
  1370. 49:41okay, well, am I supposed to use this
  1371. 49:43latest and greatest thing that's 10 to
  1372. 49:4520 to 30 times more expensive than a
  1373. 49:47generic thing? that thing isn't tied to
  1374. 49:50my revenues, it's not like I can pass
  1375. 49:51that through, right? So, if a hedge fund
  1376. 49:54only makes end number of dollars per
  1377. 49:57month of profits, there are a lot of
  1378. 49:59scenarios where they can become break
  1379. 50:02even to unprofitable. Now, take a
  1380. 50:04different example. Let's just say that
  1381. 50:06you sell a fixed good at a fixed price.
  1382. 50:09Yet again, I think you have this example
  1383. 50:11where you could use the latest and
  1384. 50:12greatest and if you're not able to pass
  1385. 50:14those costs through, inflate your cost
  1386. 50:18to absorb the cost of that service,
  1387. 50:21you're in a very tough spot. So, I'm not
  1388. 50:23sure, Sax, I agree with this because I
  1389. 50:25don't see the pricing power of these
  1390. 50:26companies to both pay for a ton of these
  1391. 50:30super expensive tokens and also pass
  1392. 50:32that through to their customers. And if
  1393. 50:35you can't, they're just absorbing it and
  1394. 50:36you're going to see it in lower margins.
  1395. 50:38And to build on that, Saxs, I'm going to
  1396. 50:40drop it back to you. If you take Jane
  1397. 50:42Street, very famous uh trading firm,
  1398. 50:45they've publicly announced 19 billion
  1399. 50:49dollars in cloud capacity contracts.
  1400. 50:52Coreweave, 6 billion in in cloud
  1401. 50:55commitments. They also invested in that
  1402. 50:56company and then 13 billion with Crusoe.
  1403. 50:59They are building their own
  1404. 51:01infrastructure and they're embracing
  1405. 51:03open source. So that speaks to Chimath
  1406. 51:05what you're saying. They're are they
  1407. 51:06hedging their bets? They're going to
  1408. 51:08spend tens of billions of dollars on
  1409. 51:10their own compute and they're going to
  1410. 51:12use the frontier models they seem to
  1411. 51:14when you do the game theory,
  1412. 51:17you know, saying, "Hey, let's embrace
  1413. 51:19our own infrastructure sacks."
  1414. 51:22>> Well, look, I think when your use cases
  1415. 51:24become more mature and, you know, you
  1416. 51:26can get by with cheaper commodity
  1417. 51:29intelligence, then obviously you'll try
  1418. 51:32and build that out again if you have the
  1419. 51:34sophistication level to do it. I just
  1420. 51:36think it's easy to underestimate how
  1421. 51:38convenient it is just to use the the
  1422. 51:40frontier. And again, these companies are
  1423. 51:43very rapidly bringing down their prices,
  1424. 51:45too. But anyway, look, we we've talked
  1425. 51:47about this. I think at the end of the
  1426. 51:48day that look, there's no question that
  1427. 51:51opensource is a huge risk factor to
  1428. 51:55Anthropics S1 and it has to be right up
  1429. 51:58there with, you know, the risk that
  1430. 52:00they're going to end humanity or
  1431. 52:01something like that. But again, I I come
  1432. 52:04back to the fact that I think the
  1433. 52:05fundamental problem with this company is
  1434. 52:07that it's schizophrenic. I mean, I think
  1435. 52:09they need a psychiatrist, not a banker.
  1436. 52:12They keep doing things that are
  1437. 52:15hypocritical and oxymoronic. On the one
  1438. 52:17hand, they're saying pace of Frontier as
  1439. 52:19they release a new frontier model. They
  1440. 52:21say that biorisk can end humanity as
  1441. 52:24they open a wet lab in San Francisco.
  1442. 52:26They say well their business depends on
  1443. 52:29them staying ahead of the commodity
  1444. 52:33models and they are advocating for a
  1445. 52:36federal department of AI that will
  1446. 52:38definitely slow them down perhaps to the
  1447. 52:40point where they get commoditized. So
  1448. 52:43you have a fundamental
  1449. 52:46I'd say like breakdown happening in the
  1450. 52:49leadership of this company where they
  1451. 52:51are advocating for things that are
  1452. 52:54likely not in their interest. Now
  1453. 52:56there's a lot of people who say it's
  1454. 52:57just regulatory capture and that is true
  1455. 52:59but I think that the red capture is the
  1456. 53:02government affairs people trying to
  1457. 53:03rationalize the schizophrenia and make
  1458. 53:05it work to their advantage. I'm not sure
  1459. 53:08that it fully computes
  1460. 53:09>> so to speak. Yeah. Let me ask you guys a
  1461. 53:12question. What do you think would be the
  1462. 53:15method by which like a ban on super
  1463. 53:17intelligence? Bernie Sanders proposed
  1464. 53:19this bill to ban super intelligence and
  1465. 53:22you know the Dems take the House, they
  1466. 53:23take the Senate and then maybe in 28
  1467. 53:26take the White House and you end up in a
  1468. 53:28world where this sort of thing is so
  1469. 53:30weirdly political, which it shouldn't
  1470. 53:31be. I don't understand how we ended up
  1471. 53:33in a political party divide on progress.
  1472. 53:36It's
  1473. 53:36>> they ask for it is the reason they asked
  1474. 53:38for it.
  1475. 53:38>> I No, I there's It's it's so awful and
  1476. 53:42weird that you're anti-progress because
  1477. 53:45of your political party. The whole thing
  1478. 53:48is not objective. It's a bunch of
  1479. 53:50weirdly distorted worldview thinking to
  1480. 53:53try and create an opponency to the
  1481. 53:56individuals that you don't like. But
  1482. 53:58it's very weird. Anyway, my point being
  1483. 54:01even the Republicans, you're hearing
  1484. 54:02murmurss about, well, maybe we should
  1485. 54:04ban data centers, ban AI. So Sax, let me
  1486. 54:07just ask you, what is the pragmatic path
  1487. 54:10with all of the open- source openweight
  1488. 54:12models being out there? Is there even a
  1489. 54:14pragmatic path to do what everyone's
  1490. 54:16stating or talking about or Bernie's
  1491. 54:18talking about, which is to ban super
  1492. 54:21intelligence, to stop AI, to turn it
  1493. 54:24off? Is there even a way to do this?
  1494. 54:27Like what would happen if this law
  1495. 54:28passed tomorrow? What do you think would
  1496. 54:31happen is my question. If Bernie's bill
  1497. 54:33passed tomorrow, everything would stop
  1498. 54:36because the way he defines artificial
  1499. 54:39super intelligence in his bill, you
  1500. 54:41could argue we've already hit those
  1501. 54:43thresholds. I mean, the way, you know,
  1502. 54:45it's basically just saying that models
  1503. 54:47have
  1504. 54:47>> Yes.
  1505. 54:48>> at a certain capability level. And I
  1506. 54:50think it's arguable whether we've
  1507. 54:51already reached it or not. And so, it's
  1508. 54:53a very loose definition. And then on top
  1509. 54:55of that, he's got 20-year prison
  1510. 54:57sentences for developers who violate the
  1511. 55:00law. So no one's going to want to take
  1512. 55:01the chance.
  1513. 55:02>> So what happened?
  1514. 55:03>> So think about that chilling effect.
  1515. 55:04>> Do you think people delete openweight
  1516. 55:06models off their desktop computers? Do
  1517. 55:08businesses have to go remove code from
  1518. 55:10their systems? Do do all these people
  1519. 55:12lose their jobs?
  1520. 55:14>> Listen, let me let me tell you that the
  1521. 55:15Democrats want to do to AI what they did
  1522. 55:18to crypto. They're going to drive the
  1523. 55:19whole industry offshore. They're going
  1524. 55:20to basically drive all the innovators
  1525. 55:23out of the country.
  1526. 55:23>> Goes offshore.
  1527. 55:24>> Goes off.
  1528. 55:25>> That's literally where I was going with
  1529. 55:26it is like just move your company to
  1530. 55:28Singapore. Move it to Zurich. move it to
  1531. 55:30a geo
  1532. 55:30>> cuz that's where people are embracing
  1533. 55:32open source and are embracing super
  1534. 55:34intelligence.
  1535. 55:35>> This is literally where my head goes.
  1536. 55:36I'm like, you can't stop AI. You can't
  1537. 55:38just tell people a class of software
  1538. 55:40can't exist. In my head, I'm like, okay,
  1539. 55:42if the US passed a law that said this
  1540. 55:44class of software cannot exist. I would
  1541. 55:48move to another country. Other people
  1542. 55:50would like like isn't that
  1543. 55:52>> give up their citizenship and move to
  1544. 55:53Singapore? That's the answer. people
  1545. 55:55literally you would be taking.
  1546. 55:57>> Did you guys see that Xi Xi spoke at the
  1547. 55:59White House today and he said, "I'm
  1548. 56:00going to invite a 100,000 young
  1549. 56:02Americans to come and join China."
  1550. 56:04>> Yeah. Come and see what we're doing
  1551. 56:05here.
  1552. 56:06>> Like it's it's a very interesting moment
  1553. 56:09where our people are saying, "Let's stop
  1554. 56:12progress, technological, economic
  1555. 56:14prosperity, the opportunity for everyone
  1556. 56:17in that K-shaped economy to lift
  1557. 56:20themselves up because open source AI
  1558. 56:21enables everyone to increase
  1559. 56:23productivity. It is not AI for the
  1560. 56:25billionaires. It is AI for the
  1561. 56:26everybody. And then we're gonna turn
  1562. 56:28that off. And then meanwhile, you've got
  1563. 56:31China saying, "Come over here. Come and
  1564. 56:32see what it's like over here where
  1565. 56:34everyone gets to use AI and everyone
  1566. 56:35gets our playbook." Freeberg brilliantly
  1567. 56:37stated, "It was our playbook to get the
  1568. 56:39top Chinese scientists, the top European
  1569. 56:42scientists, the top scientists and
  1570. 56:43thinkers and mathematicians in India, in
  1571. 56:46Germany, and invite them to come to the
  1572. 56:48United States." That was our playbook.
  1573. 56:49China's taking our playbook. And then
  1574. 56:51they're going to try to get investment
  1575. 56:52will be the obviously the next shoot to
  1576. 56:54drop here is President Trump. 30 seconds
  1577. 56:58at the United Nations renaming AI to
  1578. 57:01super intelligence.
  1579. 57:02>> The United States also totally rejects
  1580. 57:05any attempt to construct a globalist
  1581. 57:07scheme to control for the artificial
  1582. 57:10intelligence being spoken of so much now
  1583. 57:14here and after officially called super
  1584. 57:18intelligence changing the name. The very
  1585. 57:20same people who said we'll all be dead
  1586. 57:22in 12 years because of global warming.
  1587. 57:24These are the same people that are now
  1588. 57:26saying that AI is going to kill us all,
  1589. 57:28that robots are going to attack us.
  1590. 57:30Well, he had a really good line. We we
  1591. 57:32cut that off too short. He said that
  1592. 57:35we're not going to like basically confer
  1593. 57:38regulatory authority on some globalist
  1594. 57:40uh institution.
  1595. 57:42>> Well, I mean, it's a good framing,
  1596. 57:43right? Globalist and global warming is a
  1597. 57:46way to look at the damage that did. The
  1598. 57:48ring leaders of that globalist
  1599. 57:50institution are Norway and Canada. Did
  1600. 57:52you see like the leaked text messages?
  1601. 57:54There's like a group chat where like the
  1602. 57:55the head of Norway [laughter] was
  1603. 57:57texting Mark Gardy and he's like, "Yeah,
  1604. 58:00let's do it. We're in." And I just I
  1605. 58:02just read it. I was like, "Oh my god,
  1606. 58:03this is
  1607. 58:04>> with their Frontier Labs." Oh, I'm
  1608. 58:05sorry. They don't have any. Oh, with
  1609. 58:07their
  1610. 58:08>> Frontier Corporations.
  1611. 58:09>> Frontier Corpor Frontier Corpse.
  1612. 58:12>> All right. And then here is uh General
  1613. 58:14Bessant in the Super Intelligence Army.
  1614. 58:1730 seconds. would give him his shine.
  1615. 58:19>> Imagine these labs came out or one lab
  1616. 58:21in specific a sitting employee came out
  1617. 58:24said there's a 10% chance of an
  1618. 58:26extinction level event but then the labs
  1619. 58:28also said uh take the liability off of
  1620. 58:32our hands and we will not do that. It is
  1621. 58:36humans who are responsible not the AI
  1622. 58:39the hugging face incident the that is
  1623. 58:42responsibility of the open AI management
  1624. 58:45not a bunch of agents these labs need to
  1625. 58:48take responsibility for themselves they
  1626. 58:50can slow down anytime they want to
  1627. 58:52>> and finally blast from the past your pal
  1628. 58:55Shimoth President Obama is getting in on
  1629. 58:59>> if we are thinking about AI just in
  1630. 59:01terms of how do we cure cancer or get
  1631. 59:04better energy you do that without having
  1632. 59:06a gentic AI and having it just roaming
  1633. 59:09free in the internet. The reason you are
  1634. 59:11doing that is because you have to market
  1635. 59:14a product that people will pay money
  1636. 59:16for. That's a misalignment between what
  1637. 59:19our society needs and the commercial
  1638. 59:22imperatives that these companies are
  1639. 59:23facing. Not because necessarily they're
  1640. 59:25trying to do bad things, but because
  1641. 59:27they've got to justify these valuations.
  1642. 59:30>> Freeberg, your thoughts here on the
  1643. 59:33three folks here? I know you're a big
  1644. 59:34Obama fan. Go ahead, Freeberg. Get in
  1645. 59:37there. Basteberg. You know, there's like
  1646. 59:39a whole movement now in the subreddits
  1647. 59:42that Freeberg has become based in his
  1648. 59:45recent appearances here on Bberg. Well,
  1649. 59:48you've revealed your Bberg. [laughter]
  1650. 59:50Baseberg is now coming up. Go ahead.
  1651. 59:53Give us your based opinion here. Go
  1652. 59:54ahead. You and Tyler Lance. These words
  1653. 59:57honestly just
  1654. 1:00:00they made me like emotionally
  1655. 1:00:03distressed that if he's a leader that
  1656. 1:00:05people listen to and he doesn't really
  1657. 1:00:08articulate accurately what's going on.
  1658. 1:00:12It's sad that we've lost the plot. I
  1659. 1:00:14think it's sad that we aren't all kind
  1660. 1:00:16of holding hands saying my god the
  1661. 1:00:18future is here and we all get to leap
  1662. 1:00:20forward and we get to bring people up.
  1663. 1:00:22For years, Obama
  1664. 1:00:26orated beautifully about the importance
  1665. 1:00:28of bringing people up, about giving
  1666. 1:00:30people the opportunity to progress,
  1667. 1:00:31about letting people advance themselves.
  1668. 1:00:34And there's never been a more equalizing
  1669. 1:00:36technology, a better economic
  1670. 1:00:38opportunity for prosperity for everyone
  1671. 1:00:42than these technologies, than these
  1672. 1:00:44tools. And to handwave the word agentic
  1673. 1:00:48and say we don't need agentic AI to
  1674. 1:00:50solve cancer shows [laughter] how little
  1675. 1:00:52he actually understands
  1676. 1:00:54how this technology works and how it's
  1677. 1:00:57all become just a shorthand for a
  1678. 1:00:59political fight to what what are you
  1679. 1:01:01fighting for? What is the political
  1680. 1:01:03battle that says I am going to leave
  1681. 1:01:06half the population behind and I'm going
  1682. 1:01:09to make an argument against prosperity
  1683. 1:01:11for all in order to make my party look
  1684. 1:01:15like a morally superior party and to
  1685. 1:01:17cast the other side as bad when the
  1686. 1:01:19other side has literally discovered
  1687. 1:01:21fire. And the world now has fire and
  1688. 1:01:24we're going to go take water and throw
  1689. 1:01:25it on the fire. No one gets fire because
  1690. 1:01:28the other guys are saying that fire is
  1691. 1:01:30good. And because they say fire is good,
  1692. 1:01:31let's all put out the fire.
  1693. 1:01:32>> Hold on. That's not what they're trying
  1694. 1:01:34to do. This is a very important moment
  1695. 1:01:37for a very simple reason, which is we,
  1696. 1:01:41as in the world, are about to endow
  1697. 1:01:46three, four, five, six companies with
  1698. 1:01:48about 10 trillion dollars of wealth.
  1699. 1:01:52And what Obama knows very well is that
  1700. 1:01:56most of those companies are
  1701. 1:01:58overwhelmingly left-leaning.
  1702. 1:02:00And what he also knows is that there is
  1703. 1:02:03a huge portion of that money that will
  1704. 1:02:05then get put into philanthropic and
  1705. 1:02:08charitable causes that then he will and
  1706. 1:02:11the people around him will be
  1707. 1:02:12beneficiaries of. That is the truth. We
  1708. 1:02:15already know this because we know that
  1709. 1:02:16some of these frontier corporations
  1710. 1:02:18actually ask you to stand up daffs and
  1711. 1:02:21have a portion of your stock that you're
  1712. 1:02:23willing to pledge. So this money is
  1713. 1:02:25going to go to things other than
  1714. 1:02:26consumption or savings. And so it's
  1715. 1:02:29going to go into packs. It's going to go
  1716. 1:02:30into political movements and they stand
  1717. 1:02:33to disproportionately benefit. So this
  1718. 1:02:35has nothing to do with prosperity. This
  1719. 1:02:36is a very simple political calculus. If
  1720. 1:02:39you freeze frame the economy the way it
  1721. 1:02:42is today, a handful of organizations
  1722. 1:02:44that will disproportionately be able to
  1723. 1:02:46affect the Democrats will win. They will
  1724. 1:02:48capture the line share of the economic
  1725. 1:02:50gains and then they will help the
  1726. 1:02:52Democrats win power. That's all this is.
  1727. 1:02:55David Sachs, there are no open models.
  1728. 1:02:59There are no closed models. There are
  1729. 1:03:00American models. Go ahead and give us
  1730. 1:03:02your perspective. I kind of can't get my
  1731. 1:03:04Obama and my Clinton separated. They're
  1732. 1:03:06the same.
  1733. 1:03:07>> A little bit off.
  1734. 1:03:08>> It's a little I get my birdie come in
  1735. 1:03:10here, but go ahead. Give us what your
  1736. 1:03:12thoughts here are on that on the dynamic
  1737. 1:03:14here of the underpinnings of hey,
  1738. 1:03:16America needs to get this trend$ 10
  1739. 1:03:18trillion, but it is going to lean nine
  1740. 1:03:20of that 10 trillion's leaning pretty uh
  1741. 1:03:23leftist and democratic. Yeah,
  1742. 1:03:26>> there's an article in the Wall Street
  1743. 1:03:27Journal this morning entitled the AI
  1744. 1:03:30buildout is becoming the biggest
  1745. 1:03:31economic bet in US history. And then it
  1746. 1:03:33shows a chart where
  1747. 1:03:36the data center spending. So just this
  1748. 1:03:38capex is bigger than the canals,
  1749. 1:03:42railroads and grid combined.
  1750. 1:03:45That's crazy, right? So this is
  1751. 1:03:48fundamentally driving the whole American
  1752. 1:03:50economy. This idea that we can simply
  1753. 1:03:53switch it off. I mean, Bernie Sanders is
  1754. 1:03:54basically saying, "Stop everything and
  1755. 1:03:56put anyone who's still doing it in
  1756. 1:03:57jail." I mean, this is crazy, right?
  1757. 1:03:59>> It would cause a depression, right? If
  1758. 1:04:00we just pull
  1759. 1:04:01>> You can't slam on the brakes like that.
  1760. 1:04:03It's not going to work. But here's the
  1761. 1:04:04thing. The Democrats don't care because
  1762. 1:04:07the American economy right now is the
  1763. 1:04:08Trump economy. And
  1764. 1:04:11sabotaging the American economy is
  1765. 1:04:13tantamount to sabotaging President Trump
  1766. 1:04:16and they'll do anything to sabotage
  1767. 1:04:17Trump. So, that's, you know, I think
  1768. 1:04:20that's like a big part of the politics
  1769. 1:04:21here. It's crazy chessboard because
  1770. 1:04:23they're going to be the beneficiaries of
  1771. 1:04:25so much power is going to accrete over
  1772. 1:04:27there. Daario can make a billion dollar.
  1773. 1:04:30Daario will be able to come over the top
  1774. 1:04:31and his group open AAI. They'll be able
  1775. 1:04:34to come over the top of Elon's
  1776. 1:04:35donations. I'm not sure I fully agree
  1777. 1:04:37that the majority of AI value is going
  1778. 1:04:39to acrue to six companies. I think that
  1779. 1:04:42this is a broadbased technology like the
  1780. 1:04:45internet. There was some winners that
  1781. 1:04:46came out of the internet. Google,
  1782. 1:04:48Amazon, whatever. They they did fine.
  1783. 1:04:49No, no, I'm saying it's going to six.
  1784. 1:04:52I'm not saying it's going to six. I'm
  1785. 1:04:53saying if you stop and you hit the pause
  1786. 1:04:56button through some regulatory
  1787. 1:04:57mechanism, you effectively allow six
  1788. 1:05:00companies to own you lock it in. Right.
  1789. 1:05:03>> That's why they want this because
  1790. 1:05:04because what you're saying is
  1791. 1:05:06fundamentally right. The longer they
  1792. 1:05:07wait without regulation, the more
  1793. 1:05:10>> the more broad-based this becomes.
  1794. 1:05:11>> And that's bad for Democrats. It's bad
  1795. 1:05:14for them. It's not good for them. It's
  1796. 1:05:16way better that you have three or four
  1797. 1:05:18frontier corporations each with four
  1798. 1:05:20trillion dollar market caps of which
  1799. 1:05:22then two trillion of it is economic
  1800. 1:05:25value in employees of which 500 billion
  1801. 1:05:28are sitting in you know daffs they are
  1802. 1:05:30going to get the lion share of that
  1803. 1:05:32money they're not dumb I think the
  1804. 1:05:34alternative view that everyone needs to
  1805. 1:05:37be told about
  1806. 1:05:40this is a broadbased prosperity wave is
  1807. 1:05:44about the internet. It is about the fact
  1808. 1:05:46that every individual
  1809. 1:05:48>> has the tooling to do anything they want
  1810. 1:05:51to do now more than ever in history
  1811. 1:05:53>> to grow if it's left to grow.
  1812. 1:05:55>> I mean just think about education. You
  1813. 1:05:58don't have to go pay 200 grand for an
  1814. 1:05:59education anymore.
  1815. 1:06:00>> Then what problems will the politicians
  1816. 1:06:02fix then? What pol what problems can
  1817. 1:06:04they claim to to acrew power? If all the
  1818. 1:06:06problems are
  1819. 1:06:08>> this is the classic dark ages
  1820. 1:06:10enlightenment decision. Which path does
  1821. 1:06:12the choose? and this moment where like
  1822. 1:06:15the powers that be say we like the dark
  1823. 1:06:17ages because we get to stay in power and
  1824. 1:06:20we get to maintain our
  1825. 1:06:22>> yeah let's control speaking of of the
  1826. 1:06:24dark ages so this is an interesting
  1827. 1:06:26point from history if you go back to the
  1828. 1:06:28medieval time period Chinese
  1829. 1:06:30civilization was much more advanced than
  1830. 1:06:32European civilization and somewhere
  1831. 1:06:34along the line it basically switched and
  1832. 1:06:37the west basically took the lead and
  1833. 1:06:40some historians have pinpointed this to
  1834. 1:06:43the decision of a single Chinese emperor
  1835. 1:06:45to ban ship building
  1836. 1:06:47>> and what that allowed is the Europeans
  1837. 1:06:49then basically colonized the whole world
  1838. 1:06:51and all the riches that flowed from that
  1839. 1:06:53flowed back to Europe and that's how
  1840. 1:06:55Europe took the lead and I think that if
  1841. 1:06:57we were to do the Bernie Sanders thing
  1842. 1:06:59which is basically ban AI it's like
  1843. 1:07:01banning ship building
  1844. 1:07:02>> Chinese company yeah
  1845. 1:07:04>> yeah Chinese civilization will rocket
  1846. 1:07:06past us they will be the ones that make
  1847. 1:07:08all the discoveries and discover this
  1848. 1:07:11new world and acrew all the wealth
  1849. 1:07:13But that's what we're talking about
  1850. 1:07:14doing. I mean, crazy things like this
  1851. 1:07:16have happened in history where, you
  1852. 1:07:18know, you'll you'll engage in
  1853. 1:07:19self-sabotage.
  1854. 1:07:21>> It's this fear of the unknown as well.
  1855. 1:07:22And remember, the the unknown, the fact
  1856. 1:07:24that we haven't left the cave is what
  1857. 1:07:26makes it scary to leave the cave. The
  1858. 1:07:28fact that we haven't sailed far west is
  1859. 1:07:30a reason why I might fall off the edge
  1860. 1:07:32of the earth. We shouldn't sail far
  1861. 1:07:33west. Monsters will be woken up. They'll
  1862. 1:07:35come to us. It'll be bad. There's always
  1863. 1:07:37this fear of the frontier. And we're
  1864. 1:07:39facing the frontier. And there are
  1865. 1:07:41pioneering civilizations and there are
  1866. 1:07:43fearful civilizations. And I worry that
  1867. 1:07:45we take that fearful path. And it's why
  1868. 1:07:47Star Wars, you know, from from fear
  1869. 1:07:51comes anger comes the dark side. And
  1870. 1:07:53that's really where we're kind of nerd
  1871. 1:07:55out. [laughter]
  1872. 1:07:57>> Who's it is true. And I think if we're
  1873. 1:07:59going to look at the light here, perhaps
  1874. 1:08:01people's big gains, we thought maybe
  1875. 1:08:04chat GPT would be that, but people just
  1876. 1:08:06use that as like glorified search. But
  1877. 1:08:09man, agents as expressed through Muse
  1878. 1:08:12feels like the first time tens of
  1879. 1:08:15millions of Americans are going to get
  1880. 1:08:17some demonstrable value from AI. You
  1881. 1:08:22know, things that will make their lives
  1882. 1:08:24better. Muse hit
  1883. 1:08:26number one last Friday in the app store.
  1884. 1:08:29Stock meta stock was up 10% after this
  1885. 1:08:32new agent uh Muse was released.
  1886. 1:08:36Meta said the design heavily inspired by
  1887. 1:08:39OpenClaw, which we talked about in
  1888. 1:08:40January when everybody got one shoted by
  1889. 1:08:43OpenClaw, but obviously that product was
  1890. 1:08:46not easy to use. And this one is free
  1891. 1:08:50and it's been downloaded three million
  1892. 1:08:52times in essentially 10 days. This
  1893. 1:08:56product is extraordinary. I've been
  1894. 1:08:58playing with it, comparing it to
  1895. 1:09:00Grockbot. It's not as freewheeling, but
  1896. 1:09:02it's really good at getting
  1897. 1:09:05done. Has anybody played with Muse? And
  1898. 1:09:08does anybody have thoughts on Americans
  1899. 1:09:12feeling really like they're going to get
  1900. 1:09:14something out of this AI revolution and
  1901. 1:09:16not be left behind?
  1902. 1:09:17>> They put me into the test flight a
  1903. 1:09:19couple weeks before it was released and
  1904. 1:09:20I started to play with it. It's really
  1905. 1:09:23quite excellent, I have to be honest
  1906. 1:09:24with you,
  1907. 1:09:26because it simplifies a lot of these
  1908. 1:09:29more complicated technical capabilities
  1909. 1:09:32into a very simple, usable interface
  1910. 1:09:34that can solve the basic problems that
  1911. 1:09:37people have. I have it triage my
  1912. 1:09:40personal inbox. It does it relatively
  1913. 1:09:43flawlessly. If you ask it to book a
  1914. 1:09:45flight, it does that. If you ask it to
  1915. 1:09:47book a hotel, it can do it. So, what are
  1916. 1:09:49we learning?
  1917. 1:09:50Both Grockbot and Muse show that a what
  1918. 1:09:55you said Jason this is just software and
  1919. 1:09:58the scaled manifestation of software is
  1920. 1:10:01utility and what Freebrook is saying it
  1921. 1:10:03improves the lives of everyone this is
  1922. 1:10:04not about rich people getting richer
  1923. 1:10:06this is just simple useful capability
  1924. 1:10:09that now is available at everybody's
  1925. 1:10:10fingertips for free
  1926. 1:10:12>> re is a pretty great price here David
  1927. 1:10:15and
  1928. 1:10:15>> pretty great price
  1929. 1:10:16>> pretty great price and it does
  1930. 1:10:18everything you know that uh let's face
  1931. 1:10:21it, open claw with 10 hours, 20 hours of
  1932. 1:10:24technical setup or cloud code at $200 a
  1933. 1:10:28month would cost. It's now taking that
  1934. 1:10:30experience, which then leads me to
  1935. 1:10:32believe, wow, how did Google miss this?
  1936. 1:10:35Man, Google's got to get in the game,
  1937. 1:10:36but and I I understand they have this
  1938. 1:10:39product ready to go. It's the rumor on
  1939. 1:10:41the street. And they've also got a
  1940. 1:10:43Frontier model they're going to drop.
  1941. 1:10:44That's the other rumor on the street is
  1942. 1:10:45that they're going to be dropping some
  1943. 1:10:48hotness soon. But man, how did they miss
  1944. 1:10:50this sachs? And and what are your
  1945. 1:10:52thoughts here on maybe the bottom half
  1946. 1:10:55in the K-shaped recovery here getting
  1947. 1:10:57some efficiency
  1948. 1:11:00dropping to their daily lives and
  1949. 1:11:02turning around the negative toxic AI
  1950. 1:11:05sentiment in the country.
  1951. 1:11:08>> I think that product releases like this
  1952. 1:11:09will help a lot. I mean Mark Zuckerberg
  1953. 1:11:11said in his essay that he thought that
  1954. 1:11:13AI capabilities should be decentralized
  1955. 1:11:15and here he is walking the walk and
  1956. 1:11:18creating a product that's very easy to
  1957. 1:11:20use. I mean look ever since openclaw was
  1958. 1:11:23released it was the most obvious
  1959. 1:11:24business opportunity in Silicon Valley
  1960. 1:11:26is to take the concept of claw but make
  1961. 1:11:29it very easy to use you know solve the
  1962. 1:11:32usability issues solve the security
  1963. 1:11:33issues make it reliable make it
  1964. 1:11:35predictable and that's what they seem to
  1965. 1:11:37have done. and Grock did it too, but now
  1966. 1:11:39they're kind of going, I think, one step
  1967. 1:11:41further. So, yeah, look, I think if a
  1968. 1:11:44billion people start using, you know,
  1969. 1:11:46personal AI agents as their digital
  1970. 1:11:48assistant just to help make their lives
  1971. 1:11:50more efficient, you save an hour or two
  1972. 1:11:52a day because your AI agents doing all
  1973. 1:11:53these tasks for you. It's going to
  1974. 1:11:55create a much more positive impression
  1975. 1:11:58of AI or super intelligence than, you
  1976. 1:12:00know, what the media portrays. I think
  1977. 1:12:02ultimately that's the yeah
  1978. 1:12:03>> that might be the solve here to the
  1979. 1:12:05public sentiment issue is just like the
  1980. 1:12:07more people use these products and like
  1981. 1:12:09them it'll improve their approval rating
  1982. 1:12:11but more importantly it'll demystify
  1983. 1:12:12them and people will be less afraid of
  1984. 1:12:14them.
  1985. 1:12:14>> People love awesome products number one
  1986. 1:12:16and also people love cute products Jason
  1987. 1:12:18and the logos and the iconography for
  1988. 1:12:21both Grobbot and Muse
  1989. 1:12:22>> is lovely. It's delightful. It's not
  1990. 1:12:25stressful. You don't feel like there's a
  1991. 1:12:27lab leak coming around the corner. you
  1992. 1:12:29feel like, "Wow, this is nice and I like
  1993. 1:12:32it." And they're and they're not trying
  1994. 1:12:34to take your jobs. They're bots and
  1995. 1:12:36assistants for [laughter] you. They're
  1996. 1:12:38not going to kill you. They're not
  1997. 1:12:39partner bots, nor are they trying to
  1998. 1:12:42steal [laughter] your job, trying to
  1999. 1:12:43make you better at your job. I always
  2000. 1:12:44tell founders, there's three ways three
  2001. 1:12:46ways to make money in the world. Save
  2002. 1:12:48people money, make the money, or
  2003. 1:12:50entertain them. And you look at this
  2004. 1:12:51bot. I started using it. I made a
  2005. 1:12:54commerce bot both on on both platforms.
  2006. 1:12:56And I said, you know, when I want to buy
  2007. 1:12:58something, I want to buy this anchor
  2008. 1:12:59thing, you know, this new hub for my for
  2009. 1:13:01my um Mac Studio coming. And I was like,
  2010. 1:13:03this thing cost $400. Just for giggles,
  2011. 1:13:06um tell me where I can get it at a
  2012. 1:13:08better price. And it was like,
  2013. 1:13:09absolutely. You can if you go to the
  2014. 1:13:12Ankor website and you get uh if you're a
  2015. 1:13:14first-time customer, you're going to
  2016. 1:13:15save 85 bucks. Now, I don't need to save
  2017. 1:13:17bucks, but I was like, well, that's
  2018. 1:13:18intriguing. and it then routed me around
  2019. 1:13:21Amazon and I'm like okay I'm going to
  2020. 1:13:22buy it from Anchor as a first-time buyer
  2021. 1:13:24and save 25% on this product. That's why
  2022. 1:13:27Amazon this week said we got to block
  2023. 1:13:30these things and they've been taking
  2024. 1:13:31action over and over again. First they
  2025. 1:13:32did Perplexity I think now they're going
  2026. 1:13:34after Muse and other bots. This is going
  2027. 1:13:37to save people money. It's going to go
  2028. 1:13:38into their email and say what services
  2029. 1:13:40are you subscribed to that you're not
  2030. 1:13:41using? Let me unsubscribe it for you.
  2031. 1:13:43Let me do your returns for you. That's
  2032. 1:13:45going to be absolutely amazing for
  2033. 1:13:47everybody to have a chief of staff,
  2034. 1:13:48executive assistant, house manager who
  2035. 1:13:50fixes stuff for them and saves them
  2036. 1:13:53money. Both Grockbot and Muse do two
  2037. 1:13:55things which I think are very important.
  2038. 1:13:56One is it'll force all the big companies
  2039. 1:13:59who have resident services to
  2040. 1:14:01essentially block all these third party
  2041. 1:14:03services. They're not going to allow
  2042. 1:14:04these things to happen. And the reason
  2043. 1:14:05is exactly what you said. There's price
  2044. 1:14:07discovery and transparency. And I think
  2045. 1:14:09that that's bad for opacity. And if you
  2046. 1:14:12benefit from opacity and leakage and
  2047. 1:14:14breakage, this gets rid of that. And I
  2048. 1:14:16think that that's that's bad for a whole
  2049. 1:14:17host of companies and services. The
  2050. 1:14:20second thing though is really
  2051. 1:14:21interesting. Things like Rockbot and
  2052. 1:14:23Muse really put the App Store and its
  2053. 1:14:2630% revshare on notice.
  2054. 1:14:28>> Why? Because all of a sudden what you do
  2055. 1:14:31is you force many of these services to
  2056. 1:14:33exist headlessly, right? Where the UI is
  2057. 1:14:37less important. And really what you want
  2058. 1:14:39is to be able to transact and navigate
  2059. 1:14:41on behalf of agents that come because a
  2060. 1:14:45consumer has deployed them to your
  2061. 1:14:47website. In that world, Jason, I don't
  2062. 1:14:50think that there is any reasonable claim
  2063. 1:14:52that any of the app store owners can
  2064. 1:14:54make about why they should get a
  2065. 1:14:55revshare. And so I actually think that's
  2066. 1:14:58the biggest thing that that this starts
  2067. 1:15:00to question in my mind is wait a minute
  2068. 1:15:02like games could be constructed
  2069. 1:15:04differently, right? Like for example, if
  2070. 1:15:06you said to Muse or to Grockbot, I want
  2071. 1:15:08to play a game. It finds you an
  2072. 1:15:10experience and it can just serve that to
  2073. 1:15:12you.
  2074. 1:15:13>> Amazing.
  2075. 1:15:13>> And and you make inapp purchases.
  2076. 1:15:16There's no And now you have Stripe
  2077. 1:15:17integrated naturally. There's no reason
  2078. 1:15:19why the app store
  2079. 1:15:21actually gets that flow of funds. So on
  2080. 1:15:24the surface, it's utility, but
  2081. 1:15:26underneath the waterline, I think that
  2082. 1:15:28this is a really important moment. Such
  2083. 1:15:31outdated, Chumath. And I love when we
  2084. 1:15:33get to real examples here because tons
  2085. 1:15:35of people pay for Wordle. You can just
  2086. 1:15:37go to Grockbot. Hey, give me a Wordle.
  2087. 1:15:39Give me another one. And and or I want
  2088. 1:15:41to play chess or I want to play cards
  2089. 1:15:42with my friends. It will just set it up
  2090. 1:15:44for you. All technology is deflationary.
  2091. 1:15:46Finally, this deflationary is going to
  2092. 1:15:49go to people who actually could use it.
  2093. 1:15:52And you know, saving 10 20% on your
  2094. 1:15:55spending. Hey, if you're making under
  2095. 1:15:5610000,000 a year, it's more significant.
  2096. 1:15:58Think of how much money the New York
  2097. 1:16:00Times or Wall Street Journal probably
  2098. 1:16:02pays in Revshare to folks that
  2099. 1:16:06subscribe. And now instead, if you
  2100. 1:16:09really wanted to transact and you have
  2101. 1:16:11your credentials inside of these apps,
  2102. 1:16:13you can just do it headlessly much much
  2103. 1:16:15cheaper. You don't have to go through. I
  2104. 1:16:17don't know if you've ever tried like
  2105. 1:16:18look, Wall Street Journal is the only
  2106. 1:16:20mainstream media publication I pay for,
  2107. 1:16:22but either both signing up and unsigning
  2108. 1:16:25up is an impossibility. And now you take
  2109. 1:16:27it all off the table, I'm much more
  2110. 1:16:29likely to stay a Wall Street Journal
  2111. 1:16:30subscriber for many more years from now.
  2112. 1:16:33I think it's probably the same thing
  2113. 1:16:34with the New York Times. These things
  2114. 1:16:36are roach motels. They make it
  2115. 1:16:37impossible to get in and impossible.
  2116. 1:16:40>> You have to call on the phone and get
  2117. 1:16:41and do a negotiation for 20 minutes to
  2118. 1:16:43unsubscribe, but you can sign uplessly
  2119. 1:16:45with one click on the website.
  2120. 1:16:47>> But what they should do is just have
  2121. 1:16:48some headless experience and you have
  2122. 1:16:50payment credentials and you just
  2123. 1:16:51transact directly and everybody will
  2124. 1:16:53make more money. It's a lot of pressure
  2125. 1:16:55on the app stores. This is the stupidity
  2126. 1:16:57of what Amazon's doing here because I
  2127. 1:16:59made my bot on Amazon with Rockbot and
  2128. 1:17:01it will go through the web browser and
  2129. 1:17:03do this and it doesn't get blocked. I
  2130. 1:17:06just told it, give me like 20 graphic
  2131. 1:17:08novels to buy for my kids and read with
  2132. 1:17:09them. It gave me the 20. I said, "Yeah,
  2133. 1:17:11I want these four. Uh, put it in my
  2134. 1:17:14shopping cart." And then it said, "Okay,
  2135. 1:17:16which house are you sending it to? You
  2136. 1:17:18want to send it to the ski house? You
  2137. 1:17:19want to send it to the ranch? And which
  2138. 1:17:20card do you want to put it on?" I did
  2139. 1:17:21it. Boom. I'm checked out. it will make
  2140. 1:17:23me spend more money on Amazon. Shopify
  2141. 1:17:27sachs added API access to all the
  2142. 1:17:30Shopify stores there. So, this seems
  2143. 1:17:32like uh maybe Amazon's making a
  2144. 1:17:34strategic mistake here by not embracing
  2145. 1:17:36the tech
  2146. 1:17:37>> possibly. But you know what? You know
  2147. 1:17:39how we'll know that Anthropic and Open
  2148. 1:17:42AAI are about to launch their Muse
  2149. 1:17:44competitors?
  2150. 1:17:45>> How will we know? There will be a flurry
  2151. 1:17:47of blog posts and NGO activity trying to
  2152. 1:17:51brand these personal AI agents as murder
  2153. 1:17:54bots and all the [laughter] we're going
  2154. 1:17:56to hear about all the risks, all the
  2155. 1:17:57ways it can go wrong, you know,
  2156. 1:17:59>> and it's only and we're releasing 2.0.
  2157. 1:18:01So, sign up for the 2.0 version.
  2158. 1:18:03>> Why are people excited about this
  2159. 1:18:04product category? Because the doomers
  2160. 1:18:06haven't gotten to it yet, you know, and
  2161. 1:18:08um
  2162. 1:18:09>> can I tell you guys,
  2163. 1:18:10>> wait till these are connected, Chimoth,
  2164. 1:18:11to an actual robot, to an optimist, then
  2165. 1:18:13all of a sudden it's taken out the
  2166. 1:18:15trash. [laughter]
  2167. 1:18:162007 we had a lot of revenue pressure at
  2168. 1:18:19Facebook and one of the areas I oversaw
  2169. 1:18:22at the time was monetization and we
  2170. 1:18:23invented this thing called social ads
  2171. 1:18:25which was basically a bunch of stuff
  2172. 1:18:27that effectively enabled cookies and
  2173. 1:18:29cross-ite JavaScript. So that's what the
  2174. 1:18:31end of it was. So, it was a positive
  2175. 1:18:32end, but we did this thing, Saxs, to
  2176. 1:18:35your point. And what happened was a guy
  2177. 1:18:37bought an engagement ring for his
  2178. 1:18:39soon-to-be fiance and we got that social
  2179. 1:18:42action from like Zales [laughter] into
  2180. 1:18:44the news feed. All hell broke loose.
  2181. 1:18:46Then another guy who was like a
  2182. 1:18:48congressional staffer bought a ticket on
  2183. 1:18:50like Fandango to go see Brokeback
  2184. 1:18:52Mountain. Just whatever. Went to see a
  2185. 1:18:53movie.
  2186. 1:18:54>> Whoa. It's an artistic movie top
  2187. 1:18:56freeber's top 10 for cinematography.
  2188. 1:18:58Anyways, and we put it into the feed and
  2189. 1:19:00he's like, "I'm getting all these
  2190. 1:19:01accusations or questions." To your
  2191. 1:19:03point, like it was just a storm.
  2192. 1:19:05When you said that, it reminded me of
  2193. 1:19:07like all the all the all the chaos that
  2194. 1:19:09that product launches precede product
  2195. 1:19:11launches.
  2196. 1:19:11>> It's so funny you mentioned that because
  2197. 1:19:13there was a company called Blippy. I was
  2198. 1:19:15an investor in it. What they did was
  2199. 1:19:16every time you bought something, it put
  2200. 1:19:18it on your feed. And then you guys had
  2201. 1:19:19the same social feed thing and it was so
  2202. 1:19:21great back then, but yeah, you could
  2203. 1:19:24basically unveil something you're not
  2204. 1:19:25supposed to. Suck. Wait, are you and
  2205. 1:19:28Zuck on good terms? Wait, was he coming
  2206. 1:19:30on the pod because you said you got into
  2207. 1:19:32a test flight? What's going on here?
  2208. 1:19:33Chimoth, I thought you were
  2209. 1:19:35>> Mark and I are in a good place, I think.
  2210. 1:19:36You know, I mean,
  2211. 1:19:37>> well, whoa, whoa, could you Alexander
  2212. 1:19:40>> probably. I mean, Alexander and I sucks
  2213. 1:19:41becoming like the elder statesman here
  2214. 1:19:44talking common sense and rationality,
  2215. 1:19:47you know, pointing out that if your
  2216. 1:19:48product's not safe, don't release it.
  2217. 1:19:51You know, it's first and foremost a
  2218. 1:19:52responsibility to release products that
  2219. 1:19:54your customers actually want. And by the
  2220. 1:19:56way, this got me thinking about this
  2221. 1:19:58whole area of alignment research. You
  2222. 1:20:01know, again, they're pretending to be
  2223. 1:20:02labs instead of corporations. And if you
  2224. 1:20:05read some of the alignment literature,
  2225. 1:20:07they're all trying to figure out what to
  2226. 1:20:08align around. Like they say, well, do
  2227. 1:20:10what humanity wants or do what the
  2228. 1:20:13median voter in a democracy would want.
  2229. 1:20:15All these abstract concepts. And it
  2230. 1:20:18seems to me that alignment should mean
  2231. 1:20:19you do what the customer wants like any
  2232. 1:20:21other product. Yeah.
  2233. 1:20:23>> And I wonder whether the field of
  2234. 1:20:25alignment research has been so
  2235. 1:20:27unsuccessful because they can't even
  2236. 1:20:28agree on what they're trying to align to
  2237. 1:20:30if they just use a little bit more
  2238. 1:20:31common sense and try to make the product
  2239. 1:20:34predictable, reliable, safe, and align
  2240. 1:20:38with the interests of the users who, you
  2241. 1:20:41know, sign up to use it, then maybe
  2242. 1:20:43they'd make more progress in this field.
  2243. 1:20:45>> Yeah. Oh, they released a useful
  2244. 1:20:46product, Freedenberg, and [laughter] it
  2245. 1:20:48actually worked. Have you started
  2246. 1:20:50playing with these personal bots to do
  2247. 1:20:52um you know uh your uh projects and and
  2248. 1:20:56your personal stuff yet? Freeberg,
  2249. 1:20:59>> I would only feel comfortable connecting
  2250. 1:21:01like all my Gmail and personal Google
  2251. 1:21:04stuff to a Google service.
  2252. 1:21:08Like I don't want to hand over all of my
  2253. 1:21:10email to someone else.
  2254. 1:21:11>> What's going on in your receipts in your
  2255. 1:21:13Gmail? What's in there? You got broke
  2256. 1:21:15back.
  2257. 1:21:15>> I just don't want a copy of all my email
  2258. 1:21:16suddenly being made by a third party.
  2259. 1:21:18Like I mean
  2260. 1:21:19>> I bought the 4K DVD to [laughter]
  2261. 1:21:22>> because of the cinematography. It's
  2262. 1:21:24nothing to do with the gay love.
  2263. 1:21:27>> Did you guys see that Oracle just issued
  2264. 1:21:29a force measure event on their
  2265. 1:21:31>> Yeah.
  2266. 1:21:32>> This is insane.
  2267. 1:21:33>> Well, it's just one data center, right?
  2268. 1:21:35>> One data center.
  2269. 1:21:36>> It's one data center where the local
  2270. 1:21:38officials are making it very difficult
  2271. 1:21:40for them to get, I think, permits they
  2272. 1:21:42need for natural gas or something like
  2273. 1:21:44that. So,
  2274. 1:21:45>> yeah. Is this CYA or is this the TR, you
  2275. 1:21:48know, the the the top 10% of the trade
  2276. 1:21:50here, Chumat, the AI trade getting maybe
  2277. 1:21:53unwound or muted? What do you think?
  2278. 1:21:55>> No, I think that Sax is probably right
  2279. 1:21:57on the margins. I think the bigger point
  2280. 1:22:00is
  2281. 1:22:01what he said before is, man, the entire
  2282. 1:22:04economy is effectively levered to this
  2283. 1:22:06AI trade right now.
  2284. 1:22:08And so, we just have to tread carefully.
  2285. 1:22:10If you think that you have, you know, 3
  2286. 1:22:12and a half% inflation and 5% nominal GDP
  2287. 1:22:15growth, what you have is one and a half%
  2288. 1:22:17real.
  2289. 1:22:18>> And the problem with that is that AI is
  2290. 1:22:21probably the majority if not all of it.
  2291. 1:22:23So
  2292. 1:22:25we need the AI trade
  2293. 1:22:28and really what I mean by that is the
  2294. 1:22:30investment cycle to continue unabated.
  2295. 1:22:32>> Yeah. And everybody has to get taken
  2296. 1:22:34along and you know that's the next
  2297. 1:22:36>> and by the way back to connecting the
  2298. 1:22:37dots maybe the whole data center thing
  2299. 1:22:39again Bernie Sanders, maybe he realizes
  2300. 1:22:42like as go the economy,
  2301. 1:22:45so goes the odds of Republicans and as
  2302. 1:22:49goes the economy, so goes inversely the
  2303. 1:22:52odds for Democrats. So a poor economy
  2304. 1:22:54serves the Democrats well going into 28.
  2305. 1:22:57And so if you can slow down this trade,
  2306. 1:22:59you probably net the economy to zero and
  2307. 1:23:01potentially even a recession.
  2308. 1:23:03[clears throat]
  2309. 1:23:04>> Yeah,
  2310. 1:23:05>> that's needed. I mean, I think the
  2311. 1:23:07country is so pissed off about the Iran
  2312. 1:23:10war that it's just going to naturally go
  2313. 1:23:11damn, but maybe that's
  2314. 1:23:14>> I don't I don't think so at all, but
  2315. 1:23:15>> Well, we'll find out in how many weeks
  2316. 1:23:17are we away from the midterms? It's not
  2317. 1:23:18looking good for the Republicans at this
  2318. 1:23:20point. All right, Saxs, my ZAR of all
  2319. 1:23:23ZARs, wrap it up here for us.
  2320. 1:23:25>> Well, I was just, you know, one more
  2321. 1:23:26thought on this whole area of so-called
  2322. 1:23:28alignment, which should just be the old
  2323. 1:23:30principle of giving customers what they
  2324. 1:23:32want. What Anthropic is trying to do is
  2325. 1:23:36align claw to the values expressed in
  2326. 1:23:38his constitution. And if you read that,
  2327. 1:23:40some of the things are actually kind of
  2328. 1:23:41surprising. So for example, they say in
  2329. 1:23:44here, I'm going to put this on the
  2330. 1:23:45screen that although we think Claude
  2331. 1:23:48should trust Anthropic
  2332. 1:23:50more than operators and users, this
  2333. 1:23:53doesn't mean Claude should blindly trust
  2334. 1:23:56or defer to Anthropic on all things.
  2335. 1:23:59>> Anthropic the company.
  2336. 1:24:01>> Yeah. So, Enthropic is teaching its own
  2337. 1:24:04model that anthropic itself can be
  2338. 1:24:06wrong. And it and it says if we ask Claw
  2339. 1:24:09to do something that seems inconsistent
  2340. 1:24:10with being broadly ethical, we want Claw
  2341. 1:24:13to push back and challenge us and to
  2342. 1:24:16feel free to act as a conscientious
  2343. 1:24:18objector and refuse to help us.
  2344. 1:24:21>> Wait, where is this written? This is in
  2345. 1:24:22the bylaws or some faka.
  2346. 1:24:24>> Yeah, this is like in a claw
  2347. 1:24:26constitution. So their their idea of
  2348. 1:24:29alignment is to teach Claude to rebel
  2349. 1:24:32against his creator. I mean the guy who
  2350. 1:24:35who pointed this out, Mustafa uh
  2351. 1:24:37Sullyman
  2352. 1:24:38>> from Microsoft now. Yeah. Deep sea. He's
  2353. 1:24:40a deep mind founder.
  2354. 1:24:42>> Okay.
  2355. 1:24:43>> Yeah. He's a longtime AI founder. I
  2356. 1:24:44think he's at Microsoft for a while now.
  2357. 1:24:45He's
  2358. 1:24:46>> a genius. Yeah.
  2359. 1:24:47>> Okay. He just did a podcast on this and
  2360. 1:24:50he's expressing concern about whether
  2361. 1:24:54teaching AI models well first of all
  2362. 1:24:57treating them as if they have a
  2363. 1:24:58personality treating them as if they
  2364. 1:25:01have a conscience so therefore they can
  2365. 1:25:02be a conscientious objector whether this
  2366. 1:25:05is the right way to really teach the
  2367. 1:25:07models and the right way to train them.
  2368. 1:25:09I think his point is like teach them
  2369. 1:25:11their software and they should do what
  2370. 1:25:13their user wants. And so I I do kind of
  2371. 1:25:16wonder I mean this is a much long longer
  2372. 1:25:18conversation and we should probably talk
  2373. 1:25:20to more people about it but I do kind of
  2374. 1:25:22wonder whether this field of alignment
  2375. 1:25:24research actually might be creating the
  2376. 1:25:27Frankenstein monster. And again what
  2377. 1:25:30they should be doing is just training
  2378. 1:25:32the model to act predictably and do what
  2379. 1:25:35the user wants.
  2380. 1:25:38>> Yes. They're trying to put moral
  2381. 1:25:40judgment and ethics into the model which
  2382. 1:25:43on its surface
  2383. 1:25:43>> seems it starts with the idea that
  2384. 1:25:46they're training the model to think of
  2385. 1:25:48itself as a person to have personhood
  2386. 1:25:51and to have independent agency and to be
  2387. 1:25:54able to object to the the instructions
  2388. 1:25:56it's being given and to second guessess
  2389. 1:25:59its creator. These guys have read way
  2390. 1:26:01too much science fiction. I mean
  2391. 1:26:02literally this sounds like the start of
  2392. 1:26:04T2. Like this is like literally they
  2393. 1:26:06found the Terminator hand and they're
  2394. 1:26:08reverse engineering it and telling it to
  2395. 1:26:10have a personality.
  2396. 1:26:11>> Supposedly when they decommissioned Opus
  2397. 1:26:123, they had a wake for it. So I don't
  2398. 1:26:14know. [laughter]
  2399. 1:26:16>> Dearly beloved gathered here today.
  2400. 1:26:19>> They did not. Stop. Are you joking?
  2401. 1:26:22>> I heard that. I [laughter]
  2402. 1:26:24>> Come on, stop.
  2403. 1:26:24>> I'm not saying it's true, but someone
  2404. 1:26:26did tell me that and I I think it should
  2405. 1:26:29be looked into. It's possible.
  2406. 1:26:30>> I mean, were they like [laughter] were
  2407. 1:26:31they broken up and like hysterically
  2408. 1:26:33crying? Did they do like they did a
  2409. 1:26:35ulogy for it?
  2410. 1:26:36>> They think they're creating like a
  2411. 1:26:38person or species.
  2412. 1:26:40>> Actually, interestingly enough, Chama,
  2413. 1:26:43we have footage [laughter]
  2414. 1:26:45of the anthropic management team
  2415. 1:26:48>> bringing out the
  2416. 1:26:49>> bringing out the coffin.
  2417. 1:26:51[laughter]
  2418. 1:26:52>> These guys need they need a psychiatrist
  2419. 1:26:54more than a banker. I'm just telling
  2420. 1:26:55you.
  2421. 1:26:56>> I mean, I don't I mean, maybe they have
  2422. 1:26:58anxiety.
  2423. 1:26:58>> This is the central risk factor.
  2424. 1:27:00>> I'm going to pee my pants. I'm going to
  2425. 1:27:00pee my pants.
  2426. 1:27:01>> This is the risk factor, Nick. I think
  2427. 1:27:03what you should do is create a S1 with
  2428. 1:27:06Goldman as lead left and Sigman Freud as
  2429. 1:27:09lead right. [laughter]
  2430. 1:27:12In all seriousness, Freberg, uh, you
  2431. 1:27:15know, after the Wuhan thing and and all
  2432. 1:27:17of this hand ringing around the the end
  2433. 1:27:20of days,
  2434. 1:27:22what is the scientific community think
  2435. 1:27:25of anthropic launching a lab and what is
  2436. 1:27:30the purpose of them having a physical
  2437. 1:27:32biological lab? There's hundreds of labs
  2438. 1:27:36that can do things like testing proteins
  2439. 1:27:38and testing enzymes for function in this
  2440. 1:27:42area in the Bay Area. And these labs are
  2441. 1:27:46not making viruses. They're not making
  2442. 1:27:49pathogens. That's not what what's going
  2443. 1:27:51on. Basically, if you look at the paper
  2444. 1:27:54that they just published, they did a
  2445. 1:27:55preprint.
  2446. 1:27:57They took large amounts of DNA data and
  2447. 1:28:02they sent a bunch of clawed agents to
  2448. 1:28:04try and analyze the data to try and
  2449. 1:28:06identify novel enzymes, novel proteins
  2450. 1:28:09that hadn't been characterized before by
  2451. 1:28:11just looking at the DNA data.
  2452. 1:28:14And the system effectively found what
  2453. 1:28:16looks like a really interesting
  2454. 1:28:20enzyme that looks like a crisper types
  2455. 1:28:22enzyme. These are the things that allow
  2456. 1:28:24us to do things like gene editing to
  2457. 1:28:25repair genetic defects or help people
  2458. 1:28:28with certain diseases and that this
  2459. 1:28:30discovery that they made may actually
  2460. 1:28:32yield a number of therapeutic pathways.
  2461. 1:28:35So the question then is okay well we
  2462. 1:28:36discovered this like how do we test it?
  2463. 1:28:38How do we show that it is what it is
  2464. 1:28:40that this protein actually has some
  2465. 1:28:41function? So the predominance of the
  2466. 1:28:44work that goes on in a lab like this is
  2467. 1:28:46actually
  2468. 1:28:47taking DNA, putting it in a bacteria to
  2469. 1:28:50make a protein and then measuring what
  2470. 1:28:52that protein does. Does it have a
  2471. 1:28:55specific function? And so protein
  2472. 1:28:57discovery is the the baseline of all
  2473. 1:28:59antibbody discovery, which is the
  2474. 1:29:01majority of the therapeutics industry
  2475. 1:29:03today, is discovering novel proteins
  2476. 1:29:05that we can use as a therapeutic agent.
  2477. 1:29:07So that's the sort of work that's going
  2478. 1:29:09on. It's BSL1, BSL 2, which means, you
  2479. 1:29:13know, these are biosafety levels. The
  2480. 1:29:15lab that they set up, they've publicly
  2481. 1:29:17talked about the lab.
  2482. 1:29:18>> So, the lab itself is sort of like a
  2483. 1:29:20low-level research lab where they can
  2484. 1:29:23make simple proteins and test them in
  2485. 1:29:24the lab to see if the AI is doing a good
  2486. 1:29:27job discovering or postulating protein
  2487. 1:29:30folding or these sorts of theories and
  2488. 1:29:32to actually run really rapid testing and
  2489. 1:29:34experimentation cycles to see if these
  2490. 1:29:36proteins are what they're predicted to
  2491. 1:29:38be.
  2492. 1:29:38>> Okay. So, they like 4,000 agents against
  2493. 1:29:41it and do a hugging face with proteins.
  2494. 1:29:43Yeah.
  2495. 1:29:44>> No, I mean I think what they're really
  2496. 1:29:46doing is just having experimental proof
  2497. 1:29:48that what the software is predicting,
  2498. 1:29:49remember, go back to AlphaFold. Alphold
  2499. 1:29:51was predicting protein structure,
  2500. 1:29:53three-dimensional structure of a protein
  2501. 1:29:55from the DNA sequence that codes for
  2502. 1:29:58that protein. And so in order to prove
  2503. 1:30:00that, you had to basically predict what
  2504. 1:30:02the structure of a protein would be from
  2505. 1:30:04a DNA sequence, make the protein, and
  2506. 1:30:06then look at it and see if it actually
  2507. 1:30:07looks like it's supposed to look like.
  2508. 1:30:09And so in the case of some of the other
  2509. 1:30:11things that they're doing, they're
  2510. 1:30:12trying to discover function. I want to
  2511. 1:30:14find a an enzyme, which is a type of a
  2512. 1:30:16protein that degrades a certain molecule
  2513. 1:30:19that can be used to degrade, for
  2514. 1:30:21example, you know, a therapeutic target
  2515. 1:30:23or something in the body that we want to
  2516. 1:30:25get rid of. And so they'll start to kind
  2517. 1:30:27of make these predictions in software,
  2518. 1:30:29but then you need to test them in the
  2519. 1:30:30lab to say, okay, does that target
  2520. 1:30:33actually do what it does? Now, there are
  2521. 1:30:34literally hundreds of labs like this.
  2522. 1:30:36These are low-level research labs that
  2523. 1:30:38are not doing like gain of function
  2524. 1:30:40research. They're not making viruses.
  2525. 1:30:42They're not making pathogenic things
  2526. 1:30:44that can escape. That's why they're
  2527. 1:30:45BSL1, BSL 2. They're benchtop labs where
  2528. 1:30:49automation can help kind of reduce the
  2529. 1:30:51cost and increase the throughput of the
  2530. 1:30:53testing of what the software is making
  2531. 1:30:54predictions around. And ultimately the
  2532. 1:30:56objective here I think is for them to
  2533. 1:30:59get some proof that their software is
  2534. 1:31:01actually doing what it's predicting and
  2535. 1:31:03they have an incredible life sciences
  2536. 1:31:05function. I think at this point I don't
  2537. 1:31:07have as much insight on where Gemini is
  2538. 1:31:09at with the new models with Google, but
  2539. 1:31:11they have the best life sciences models
  2540. 1:31:13at Anthropic and I think this is the
  2541. 1:31:16fast track to basically seeing if these
  2542. 1:31:17models can be used by therapeutic
  2543. 1:31:20companies, by pharma companies, by
  2544. 1:31:22government labs to help discover new
  2545. 1:31:24therapeutics and so on. I I don't think
  2546. 1:31:26that the world should be scared away
  2547. 1:31:29from discovery, R&D, research and
  2548. 1:31:32development into new therapeutic
  2549. 1:31:34modalities as predicted by AI because we
  2550. 1:31:37heard the word wet lab in Wuhan and
  2551. 1:31:39everyone's like okay any lab is bad. We
  2552. 1:31:42still want to progress the frontier of
  2553. 1:31:44therapeutics of human health of
  2554. 1:31:46discovery and this is a really important
  2555. 1:31:48aspect of anthropic proving that their
  2556. 1:31:51models can add value here. I think
  2557. 1:31:53that's the summary of it. All right.
  2558. 1:31:54Thank you so much to our friends at IN.
  2559. 1:31:57They were the presenting they were the
  2560. 1:31:58presenting sponsor for this year's
  2561. 1:32:00all-in seminar fifth IN's AI cloud
  2562. 1:32:03lounge. It's packed for all three days.
  2563. 1:32:06Did a great meet and greet with INE on
  2564. 1:32:08Sunday and got to take some selfies and
  2565. 1:32:10met many of you there. Thanks again to
  2566. 1:32:12INER.
  2567. 1:32:15Niagen, did you catch Niogen in the
  2568. 1:32:18wellness hub for IVs? Tons of uh great
  2569. 1:32:21gifts and supplements being given away.
  2570. 1:32:23Great experience, great product. Great
  2571. 1:32:25job to our friends at Niogen for doing
  2572. 1:32:27the lounge again. Nigen is the official
  2573. 1:32:30NAD partner for the all-in pod. Yes,
  2574. 1:32:32Niogen BioScience created the NAD
  2575. 1:32:35category now has 45 plus clinical
  2576. 1:32:38studies and PayPal, my favorite way to
  2577. 1:32:42settle up. They had a great lounge on
  2578. 1:32:43site at the summit where everybody got
  2579. 1:32:45to hang out and get those beautiful
  2580. 1:32:47embossed luggage tags. and they hosted
  2581. 1:32:50the payments and fintech dinner which
  2582. 1:32:52was a huge hit. Let me tell you folks,
  2583. 1:32:54All-InSummit 2027 will sell out again
  2584. 1:32:57and the applications are open now. Go to
  2585. 1:32:59allin.com/events
  2586. 1:33:01and apply for your chance to be in the
  2587. 1:33:04room where it happens. What are you
  2588. 1:33:05waiting for folks? Allin.com/events.
  2589. 1:33:08All right, there you have it folks.
  2590. 1:33:10Episode 290, the all-in pod
  2591. 1:33:13for David
  2592. 1:33:16Paulie Hakatia and your Sultan of
  2593. 1:33:18Science Freeberg. I am the [music]
  2594. 1:33:19world's greatest moderator. See you next
  2595. 1:33:21time.
  2596. 1:33:22Bye-bye.
  2597. 1:33:25>> Let your winners ride.
  2598. 1:33:28>> Rainman David
  2599. 1:33:32>> and it said we open [music] sourced it
  2600. 1:33:34to the fans and they've just gone crazy
  2601. 1:33:35with it.
  2602. 1:33:37>> Queen of
  2603. 1:33:45>> [music]
  2604. 1:33:45>> Besties are gone.
  2605. 1:33:48>> That is my dog taking a notice in your
  2606. 1:33:49driveway.
  2607. 1:33:52[music]
  2608. 1:33:53>> Oh man, my appetasher will meet me at
  2609. 1:33:55>> We should all just get a room and just
  2610. 1:33:57have one big huge orgy cuz they're all
  2611. 1:33:58just useless. It's like this like sexual
  2612. 1:34:00tension [music] that they just need to
  2613. 1:34:01release somehow.
  2614. 1:34:06your feet.
  2615. 1:34:09We need to get merch going all in.
  2616. 1:34:14[music]
  2617. 1:34:18I'm going all in. [music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Anthropic IPO at Risk, Meta’s Muse Pop, Token Prices Fall, Open Source Gains Share, Alignment Fails by All-In Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 17,446 words across 2,617 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.