André Ventura: «Luís Neves não tem nenhumas condições para continuar como ministro» — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00even a brief statement for a
- 0:04declaration that has been long-awaited,
- 0:07eh, but which, due to its content,
- 0:09would merit a reaction from the party
- 0:12that, from the beginning, demanded that
- 0:14clarifications be given and the truth
- 0:17be restored. I will start by saying
- 0:21what seems evident to me. This was one
- 0:24of the most painful press conferences
- 0:27in recent times, but I also think it
- 0:30was one of the most painful for our
- 0:33democracy as a democracy. And the way
- 0:38in which someone, in an absolutely
- 0:40ostensible manner, almost with hints of
- 0:44impunity and arrogance, made statements
- 0:47about grave and serious matters, in an
- 0:50absolutely rudimentary, authoritarian
- 0:53way, answering what they wanted and not
- 0:56what was asked, but which could at
- 0:59least have had a function: that of
- 1:01clarifying what was, and is, under
- 1:04investigation for some time. One has to
- 1:09go back a long time in the history of
- 1:11press conferences to hear someone say
- 1:13several times "I did not commit any
- 1:16illegality," but mention several they
- 1:18did commit in the same intervention
- 1:20where they are saying they did not
- 1:22commit any illegality. I did not submit
- 1:28income statements because no one asked
- 1:30me to. This will go down in the annals
- 1:33of democratic history. Because it means
- 1:37that someone who oversees the
- 1:39transparency of others does not submit
- 1:41an income and asset statement because
- 1:44they say the Constitutional Court did
- 1:46not ask, but then it wasn't because it
- 1:49didn't ask, but because there were
- 1:51threats of revealing their home address
- 1:53. I have been in public life for some
- 2:00years. I was a candidate for President
- 2:02of the Republic twice. I am the leader
- 2:04of the largest opposition party.
- 2:09Politics brings us bitterness,
- 2:12insecurity, and threats. That is not a
- 2:15reason why we can stop submitting
- 2:18income and asset statements, whether
- 2:20with an address or not, because
- 2:23presidential candidates have to do it,
- 2:26prime ministers have to do it, and
- 2:28opposition leaders have to do it. There
- 2:32is no reason why any other official
- 2:34should not have to do so. There are
- 2:37threats against magistrates,
- 2:39politicians, opposition leaders, and
- 2:42prime ministers who have to submit
- 2:44income statements. In fact, the track
- 2:49record of other directors who publicly
- 2:52guaranteed that not only did they
- 2:54submit their statements, but all their
- 2:56members did too, and alerted that the
- 2:58Judicial Police itself warned of the
- 3:01need to submit those statements. It is
- 3:04a bit painful to see a Minister of
- 3:06Internal Administration say that, after
- 3:08all, it is the Constitutional Court's
- 3:10fault for not notifying him that he had
- 3:12to submit those statements for years
- 3:14and years and years. But that, along
- 3:18with other issues that clearly only got
- 3:20worse today from the point of view of
- 3:23explanation, will be matters that the
- 3:25justice system and other entities will
- 3:28have to evaluate. The explanation given
- 3:34to the other side is not just poor, it
- 3:37is dangerous due to its lack of sense
- 3:39and relevance, and its complete lack of
- 3:42rationality. Let us look at material
- 3:45that, according to the minister himself
- 3:48, was very expensive to destroy for two
- 3:51reasons: its size and quantity. The
- 3:54reason why one had to pay so much to
- 3:57destroy this dangerous material was
- 3:59concise: size and quantity. Therefore,
- 4:02a lot of dangerous material of
- 4:03significant size. So, what does the
- 4:05then-director of the Judiciary Police
- 4:07decide to do? Despite the material
- 4:09being abundant and dangerous, why not
- 4:11let a friend of his who has a trailer
- 4:13and a construction company take it? And
- 4:15so, despite being dangerous material
- 4:17that was very expensive to destroy, it
- 4:19stayed on the street in front of
- 4:21everyone, posing a real danger to
- 4:23people for who knows how long. In other
- 4:27words, the handling of absolutely
- 4:28dangerous material, which was even very
- 4:30costly to destroy, ends up being
- 4:32carelessly placed with an entity he
- 4:34just happens to know, and it stays
- 4:36there, exposing all other people to
- 4:38risk for I don't know how long. It is
- 4:42somewhat incomprehensible. And if it
- 4:44has happened more times, it is very
- 4:46serious. And it means that this form of
- 4:48decision-making, as Chega has always
- 4:50said, must be scrutinized and must be
- 4:52subject to parliamentary scrutiny.
- 4:55Because, if it happens more often—
- 4:57which might not have even happened, and
- 4:59there might be some specifically
- 5:01privileged relationship here—it is
- 5:03still an enormous risk to public safety
- 5:05, which I think no one understood.
- 5:08Furthermore: the attempt to shift blame
- 5:10onto current PJ employees, or former
- 5:12ones, or previous leaders, saying: "
- 5:14Whoever is there now is the one who has
- 5:16to explain this matter.""I only said to
- 5:18do it like that," meaning, "I only said
- 5:21to commit an illegality.""The rest,
- 5:23someone else took care of, and it's
- 5:24with them that you have to deal now."
- 5:28Bravery is not just standing in front
- 5:29of journalists, speaking loudly, and
- 5:31telling people who can speak and who
- 5:33cannot. Bravery is assuming
- 5:34responsibilities when it is necessary
- 5:36to assume responsibilities. It is not
- 5:38shifting blame onto PJ employees, PJ
- 5:40inspectors, or those who, by your order
- 5:43, ended up having to carry out this
- 5:45clearly illegal and evidently
- 5:46disconnected and irresponsible decision
- 5:49. In truth, if everything had been done
- 5:52legally—and the minister did not want
- 5:54to answer this because the decision was
- 5:56not in the file. The minister's
- 5:57response. That is a mere irregularity.
- 5:59That is not where the problem lies. I
- 6:02ask, to which other politician would we
- 6:03allow this? What other, what other
- 6:06politician would we allow to say: "This
- 6:08is a mere minor illegality, an
- 6:10irregularity, that's not where the
- 6:11problem lies? Be quiet and let me
- 6:13continue." Who else would we allow? Why
- 6:16do we allow this one? Why do we allow
- 6:19this to continue on these terms?
- 6:23Finally, if the Judicial Police knew
- 6:25about the other side and it had been a
- 6:27legal decision, why go there to seize
- 6:29it when they found out the other side
- 6:31was there after all. If it was all
- 6:35legal and had all the internal and
- 6:37external regulatory frameworks, then
- 6:40why would the Judicial Police rush to
- 6:42seize that trailer if it had been duly,
- 6:44legally decided and determined? The
- 6:50rest will go down in the annals of
- 6:51history regarding payments in cash made
- 6:53in stages, equally illegal, because the
- 6:55law dictates it, a law that this very
- 6:57government, by the way, has on its
- 6:58website. I recommend everyone check it
- 7:02to verify that it is very clear there
- 7:04that you cannot make payments over €
- 7:073,000 even in installments in cash. It
- 7:11is a very clear illegality admitted by
- 7:13a minister in front of an entire
- 7:14country. Then the minister, I believe,
- 7:17referred to our parliamentary inquiry
- 7:20commission, saying he has a legacy to
- 7:22defend and that he will defend it. I am
- 7:24sure there were good things. I am sure,
- 7:27uh, that there was dedication, as he
- 7:29puts it, to public service, but that
- 7:32does not erase, nor can it erase, the
- 7:34accountability that must also exist and
- 7:37that can only exist, we now realize,
- 7:39with clarifications that must be given
- 7:42clearly, precisely, and where he cannot
- 7:44order his interlocutors to be quiet,
- 7:47create problems with the microphone or
- 7:49the hearing, or other types of
- 7:51conditioning. I think this was frankly
- 7:54one of the worst press conferences I,
- 7:57as leader of the opposition and as a
- 7:59political leader, have had to witness,
- 8:01but I had to out of duty, but I think
- 8:03it wasn't even Chega that lost. I think
- 8:07it was the country that lost an
- 8:08opportunity for clarification and the
- 8:10government that lost an opportunity for
- 8:11decency. Allow me this, as this is not
- 8:13about any conversation. It is really
- 8:16just an intuition I have. I think the
- 8:19President of the Republic must be
- 8:21shuddering, shuddering after hearing
- 8:23this press conference. And I think
- 8:26everyone should search their conscience
- 8:28as to why we reached this point and
- 8:30allow this to continue; the Prime
- 8:31Minister, the leader of the Socialist
- 8:33Party, why do you allow this to
- 8:35continue? I think clarifications will
- 8:37continue to have to be demanded, as we
- 8:38had the opportunity to clarify to
- 8:40everyone today. A parliamentary inquiry
- 8:42commission was filed today which will
- 8:45begin at the start of the proceedings,
- 8:47and this parliamentary commission
- 8:49should clarify, uh, many of these
- 8:51issues that should have been clarified
- 8:53today and were not. André Ventura is
- 8:58now available for questions to confirm
- 9:00that Chega has already filed this
- 9:01request. Looking at this press
- 9:04conference, can you say, unless you are
- 9:05politically completely biased, can you
- 9:07say that the minister, after what he
- 9:09said today, still has the conditions to
- 9:11continue being the Minister of Internal
- 9:13Administration? I think it was so, uh,
- 9:18unusual, sometimes bordering on the
- 9:20ridiculous, but as far as the substance
- 9:22is concerned, with a total lack of, of,
- 9:24of capacity to explain things that, in
- 9:26truth, perhaps, uh, have no explanation
- 9:28. There is another, there is another
- 9:31level of things, which is not just the
- 9:32lack of explanation; it is, and this is
- 9:34serious, the attempt to shift
- 9:35responsibilities onto others for
- 9:36something he himself decided. The
- 9:38attempt to say that other institutions
- 9:40were the ones that failed, not himself:
- 9:41it was the court that didn't notify him
- 9:43that it had to be done that way. All of
- 9:45this is a very poor-quality movie, very
- 9:47, very poor quality for our democracy.
- 9:49That is why I spoke about the hand of
- 9:51conscience. Uh, frankly, I don't like
- 9:53to, because everyone has to assume
- 9:54their own responsibilities and people
- 9:56speak if they want and when they want.
- 9:59But I think the time is coming when the
- 10:01President of the Republic must have a,
- 10:03must have a say here, since it seems
- 10:05the Prime Minister doesn't want to have
- 10:07one, and it seems that, well, beyond
- 10:09the leader of the opposition, no one
- 10:11wants to. I think the President of the
- 10:14Republic, frankly, will have to have a
- 10:16word of, of determination here in a
- 10:18scenario that I sincerely believe is an
- 10:20absolute discredit to our, our, our
- 10:22democracy. I ask you if André Ventura
- 10:25will go. We saw José Luís Carneiro
- 10:27today at São Bento. I ask you if
- 10:29André Ventura will also go to São
- 10:31Bento soon, and possibly to Belém to
- 10:33speak with the President of the
- 10:34Republic. I have already spoken with
- 10:36the President of the Republic about
- 10:37this. Uh, there is no need, I don't
- 10:39think there is a need for an in-person
- 10:41meeting to tell the Prime Minister,
- 10:42frankly, what I am saying here and what
- 10:44I have already said to the whole
- 10:45country. I think there were no
- 10:48conditions, and as even the leader of
- 10:50the PS slightly acknowledged today,
- 10:52finally, after all this time, the
- 10:54authority of the minister is highly
- 10:56weakened and the prestige of the
- 10:58institutions is irremediably being
- 11:00undermined. The serious part of this,
- 11:03frankly, is not the minister or the
- 11:05person, Luís Neves, the serious part
- 11:07of this is the muck this puts democracy
- 11:08in, the lack of judgment, the lack of
- 11:10standards, where from here on
- 11:12everything is possible. Everything is
- 11:14possible. Uh, I think that under these
- 11:16conditions, there is no need for me to
- 11:19say anything else to the prime minister
- 11:21, other than this to at least save the
- 11:23decency of the institutions, he must
- 11:25make a decision. And I say it again,
- 11:27and I say it again in this even more
- 11:30serious circumstance for us. One cannot
- 11:33be afraid of any power in a democracy,
- 11:35not one. And the prime minister must
- 11:38have the ability to realize that it is
- 11:40his entire government that is being
- 11:41dragged into an inexplicable situation.
- 11:44And he must make a decision. Therefore,
- 11:46I think I don't need any meeting to
- 11:47tell him the obvious. This, this
- 11:49minister has no conditions to continue,
- 11:50and I think that if he continues, he
- 11:52will continue to destroy the image of
- 11:54the State. That inquiry will be
- 11:58a question regarding
- 12:00we still haven't closed the list of
- 12:03people to be heard for a reason. Now,
- 12:06the law provides that after it is
- 12:07submitted, it is accepted, granted by
- 12:09the president of the assembly, and then
- 12:12there will be time to make that list of
- 12:14people to be heard. Uh, it is not
- 12:16finished yet. It was important to
- 12:17define the object of this commission of
- 12:19inquiry. That has already been done in
- 12:21this careful text, as you can see. Uh,
- 12:24it was important because one of the
- 12:26issues that was raised or is being
- 12:28raised is precisely, uh, the
- 12:30possibility that some decisions may
- 12:32have been politically conditioned or
- 12:34influenced. And that also had to be in
- 12:36the commission of inquiry. Uh, so we
- 12:38had to take that care. There will be
- 12:40time, I think after the approval, uh,
- 12:43of the commission of inquiry, to define
- 12:45exactly who, uh, needs to be heard. And
- 12:47there I think the contributions from
- 12:49civil society will also be important.
- 12:53Yes, we have a list of names, but as I
- 12:54indicated to you, this commission, the
- 12:56text, I would like to indicate it when
- 12:58we already have the, the list closed,
- 13:00also so that it is not a closed
- 13:01calculation of something that might
- 13:03still evolve. Just that reason.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of André Ventura: «Luís Neves não tem nenhumas condições para continuar como ministro» by NOW Canal, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,225 words across 337 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.